betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

String Model Predicts Relaxation in Sheared Glass-Forming Liquids

Abstract

Understanding how structural relaxation evolves from equilibrium to nonequilibrium conditions remains a central problem in glass physics. Using simulations of model glass formers under steady shear, we show that the String Model, which links stringlike cooperative rearrangements to relaxation in equilibrium glass-forming liquids, predicts the structural relaxation time across the full range of temperatures and shear rates investigated without additional nonequilibrium fitting parameters, when combined with a shear-dependent effective temperature that is captured by a generalized fluctuation-dissipation relation. These results indicate that equilibrium and nonequilibrium relaxation are governed by the same underlying cooperative mechanism, but they occur under different effective thermodynamic conditions under steady shear. More broadly, our study provides a unified microscopic description of thermal and mechanically driven dynamics in glass-forming liquids.

Introduction

The nature of glass formation remains one of the central unresolved problems in condensed matter physics [1]. Upon cooling molecular liquids or compressing colloidal suspensions, viscosity and structural relaxation times increase by many orders of magnitude, whereas static structural measures exhibit only modest changes and remain largely liquid-like [2]. Explaining this dramatic slowdown in the absence of obvious structural signatures lies at the heart of the glass problem [3]. The task becomes significantly more complex under nonequilibrium conditions, such as physical aging [4, 5, 6] or externally driven states [7, 8, 9, 10, 11].

Over the past few decades, growing evidence has linked the dramatic slowdown of glass-forming liquids to the emergence of collective particle motion [12, 13]. Among the various manifestations of dynamic heterogeneity [14], stringlike cooperative motion [15] has emerged as one of the most ubiquitous signatures of glass formation. Building on this observation, the String Model [16]—a microscopic realization of the Adam-Gibbs theory [17]—relates structural relaxation directly to the extent of stringlike cooperative rearrangements and quantitatively describes relaxation in a wide range of glass-forming materials, including polymers and metallic liquids [18]. Systematic studies have further connected stringlike cooperative motion to activation barriers, configurational entropy, and emergent rigidity [19, 20, 21, 22, 23]. Collectively, these findings establish stringlike cooperative motion as a unifying microscopic framework for understanding equilibrium glassy dynamics and the origin of characteristic glass anomalies, including the boson peak [24, 25].

Whether equilibrium and nonequilibrium relaxation are governed by the same microscopic mechanism remains unclear. Mechanical deformation can accelerate structural relaxation by many orders of magnitude, effectively reversing the dynamical slowdown associated with glass formation [26, 27]. Despite decades of study [28, 29], no predictive framework has successfully connected the cooperative motion that controls equilibrium relaxation to the strongly accelerated dynamics observed under external driving [30]. This raises a fundamental question: can the same microscopic mechanism that explains equilibrium relaxation also explain shear-driven relaxation?

In this Letter, we study relaxation in glass-forming liquids under steady shear, a typical nonequilibrium state having direct relevance for materials processing. We show that equilibrium and shear-driven relaxation originate from the same underlying cooperative mechanism. However, the suppression of stringlike cooperative motion alone is insufficient to account for the accelerated dynamics induced by external driving. To resolve this discrepancy, we combine collective motion with a nonequilibrium effective temperature captured by a generalized fluctuation-dissipation relation (FDR) framework [7]. Together, these two ingredients quantitatively predict the structural relaxation time across a broad range of temperatures and shear rates without additional nonequilibrium fitting parameters. More broadly, our results establish a unified microscopic description of equilibrium and nonequilibrium relaxation, in which external driving acts primarily by modifying the effective thermodynamic conditions governing activated dynamics.

Results — We study three representative glass-forming liquids: the Kob–Andersen binary Lennard–Jones model (KABLJ) [19, 20] and a coarse-grained bead-spring polymer melt [31, 32] under constant-volume (Poly-V) and constant-pressure (Poly-P) conditions. All quantities and results are expressed in standard reduced units; e.g., length, time, temperature, and pressure are measured in units of σ\sigma, τ=mσ2/ε\tau= \sqrt{m\sigma^{2}/\varepsilon}, ε/kB\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}, and ε/σ3\varepsilon/\sigma^{3}, respectively, where σ\sigma and ε\varepsilon are the length and energy parameters of the Lennard–Jones (LJ) potential, mm is the particle mass, and kBk_{\mathrm{B}} is Boltzmann’s constant. More simulation details are given in the Supplemental Material (SM).

We first investigate how steady shear modifies structural relaxation in glass-forming liquids, taking the KABLJ system as a benchmark system. As shown in Figure 1(a), increasing the shear rate γ˙\dot{\gamma} at a fixed temperature (TT) progressively shifts the decay of the self-intermediate scattering function Fs(q,t)F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t) to shorter times, indicating a dramatic enhancement of relaxation dynamics. This shear-induced acceleration of structural relaxation is consistent with previous simulations [7, 8, 9, 10, 11] and experiments [33]. We extract the structural relaxation time τα\tau_{\alpha} based on the definition of Fs(q,τα)=0.2F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,\tau_{\alpha}) = 0.2. Figure 1(b) shows the TT dependence of τα\tau_{\alpha} for different shear rates. As the shear rate increases at fixed TT, τα\tau_{\alpha} consistently decreases, revealing the profound acceleration of structural relaxation induced by steady shear. Consistent results are found also for the polymer systems and

Image not extracted

Figure 1. Accelerated structural relaxation under steady shear. (a) Self-intermediate scattering function, Fs(q,t)F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t), for the KABLJ system at a temperature of T=0.43 ε/kBT = 0.43\,\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}} and different shear rates γ˙\dot{\gamma}. Colored symbols indicate the condition Fs(q,t)=0.2F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t) = 0.2, which is used operationally to define the structural relaxation time, τα\tau_{\alpha}. (b) Logarithm of the structural relaxation time, log⁡(τα)\log(\tau_{\alpha}), as a function of ε/kBT\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}T for different γ˙\dot{\gamma}.

are presented in the SM.

We investigate the microscopic origin of shear-induced relaxation by examining the evolution of stringlike cooperative motion with increasing shear rate. Representative snapshots of the KABLJ system in equilibrium and under steady shear are shown in Figure 2(a,Figure 2b), where particles belonging to the same string are colored identically. The nonequilibrium state exhibits a marked reduction in both the size and prevalence of cooperative strings, indicating a strong suppression of collective motion by external driving. Previous studies have shown that the relaxation and transport properties of glass-forming liquids do not become appreciably anisotropic under steady shear [8, 9, 10], a finding corroborated by our own simulations (see the SM). Consequently, our treatment relies on an isotropic approximation of the dynamics.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Shear suppresses the collective motion underlying glassy relaxation. (a,b) Representative snapshots of stringlike cooperative motion in the KABLJ system at T=0.43 ε/kBT = 0.43\,\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}} for shear rates γ˙=0\dot{\gamma}=0 and γ˙=10−2τ−1\dot{\gamma}=10^{-2}\tau^{-1}, respectively. Particles belonging to the same string are shown in the same color. (c) Number-averaged string length, ⟨s(t)⟩\langle s(t)\rangle, as a function of time for different shear rates at T=0.43 ε/kBT = 0.43\,\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}. (d) Characteristic string length LL as a function of ε/kBT\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}T for different γ˙\dot{\gamma}.

A more quantitative picture emerges from Figure 2(c), which shows the number-averaged string length, ⟨s(t)⟩\langle s(t)\rangle, as a function of time for different γ˙\dot{\gamma}. Increasing shear rate strongly suppresses the population of cooperative strings. Moreover, both the height and position of the peak in ⟨s(t)⟩\langle s(t)\rangle decrease with increasing γ˙\dot{\gamma}, indicating that steady shear suppresses not only the characteristic size of cooperative rearrangements but also the timescale over which they develop. To characterize this behavior, we define the characteristic string length as L≡⟨s(tL)⟩L \equiv\langle s(t_{L})\rangle, where tLt_{L} is the time at which ⟨s(t)⟩\langle s(t)\rangle attains its maximum. Figure 2(d) shows the evolution of LL with shear rate. Below a characteristic temperature, LL decreases markedly with increasing shear, revealing a strong suppression of collective motion under nonequilibrium conditions. Evidently, the evolution of LL at least qualitatively follows the structural relaxation time τα\tau_\alpha shown in Figure 1(b), suggesting a direct connection between the reduction of cooperative motion and the acceleration of relaxation dynamics. Similar behavior is observed in the polymer systems (see the SM).

SystemTAT_A [ε/kB\varepsilon/k_B]ΔH0\Delta H_0 [ε\varepsilon]ΔS0\Delta S_0 [kBk_B]τA\tau_A [τ\tau]τ0\tau_0 [τ\tau]
KABLJ0.802.70-2.165.412.14×10−22.14 \times10^{-2}
Poly-V0.752.091.073.666.60×10−16.60 \times10^{-1}
Poly-P0.652.03-3.043.487.27×10−37.27 \times10^{-3}

Table 1. Basic properties of glass formation for the three systems at equilibrium. TAT_A is the onset temperature of glass formation. ΔH0\Delta H_0 and ΔS0\Delta S_0 are the enthalpy and entropy of high temperature activation. τA\tau_A is the relaxation time at TAT_A. τ0\tau_0 is the prefactor in the String Model.

The striking similarity between the shear dependence of LL in Figure 2(d) and that of τα\tau_\alpha in Figure 1(b) suggests that stringlike cooperative motion may provide the microscopic mechanism underlying relaxation in both equilibrium and nonequilibrium glass-forming liquids. To test this possibility, we turn to the String Model of glass formation [16, 18] [34]. Rooted in transition state theory [35, 36] and broadly consistent with entropy-based theories of glass formation [17], the String Model posits that, below the onset temperature TAT_A where the dynamics starts to deviate from Arrhenius behavior, the activation free energy for structural relaxation grows in proportion to the size of cooperative strings. Specifically, ΔG(T)=ΔG0z(T)\Delta G(T) = \Delta G_0 z(T), where ΔG0=ΔH0−TAΔS0\Delta G_0 = \Delta H_0 - T_A \Delta S_0 is the activation free energy at TAT_A, and z(T)=L(T)/LAz(T) = L(T)/L_A with LA≡L(TA)L_A \equiv L(T_A). This assumption leads directly to the String Model expression for τα\tau_\alpha,

τα=τ0exp⁡[ΔH0−TΔS0kBTz(T)].(1)\tau_\alpha= \tau_0 \exp\left[\frac{\Delta H_0 - T\Delta S_0}{k_B T}z(T)\right]. \tag*{(1)}

The prefactor τ0\tau_0 is fixed by the relaxation time at TAT_A, τA=τα(TA)\tau_A = \tau_\alpha(T_A), while the activation enthalpy ΔH0\Delta H_0 is independently determined from the Arrhenius regime at high temperatures above TAT_A. Consequently, ΔS0\Delta S_0 is the only fitting parameter. As shown in the SM, Eq. (1) quantitatively captures the equilibrium dynamics of all three systems considered here, with the relevant parameters summarized in Table I.

As a first minimal extension of the String Model, we assume that the sole effect of steady shear is to suppress the characteristic string length LL entering the parameter z(T)z(T) in Eq. (1), while all other quantities are retained at their equilibrium values determined from the equilibrium data. We test this hypothesis in Figure 3(a). Despite capturing the reduction of cooperative motion, the resulting predictions show evident systematic deviations from the simulation data. This demonstrates that the suppression of stringlike cooperative rearrangements alone is insufficient to account for the nonequilibrium acceleration of structural relaxation under steady shear.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Predicting nonequilibrium relaxation. (a) Logarithm of the structural relaxation time, ln⁡(τα/τ0)\ln(\tau_\alpha/\tau_0), is plotted against (ΔH0−TΔS0)z(T)/kBT(\Delta H_0-T\Delta S_0)z(T)/k_\mathrm{B}T for three glass-forming systems over a range of shear rates γ˙\dot{\gamma}. The parameters τ0\tau_0, ΔH0\Delta H_0, and ΔS0\Delta S_0 are obtained from equilibrium simulations and are reported in Table I. The black dashed line denotes the prediction of the String Model, corresponding to a one-to-one relation between the two quantities. (b) Schematic illustration of the effective temperature TmapT_\mathrm{map}. (c) Effective temperature TmapT_\mathrm{map} as a function of the bath temperature TT at different shear rates for the KABLJ system. (d) ln⁡(τα/τ0)\ln(\tau_\alpha/\tau_0) as a function of (ΔH0−TmapΔS0)z(T)/kBTmap(\Delta H_0-T_\mathrm{map}\Delta S_0)z(T)/k_\mathrm{B}T_\mathrm{map} for all three systems and a wide range of shear rates. The data collapse onto the predicted linear relation, shown by the black dashed line.

Because steady shear drives the system out of thermal equilibrium, the bath temperature TT is no longer sufficient to characterize the relaxation dynamics. It is then sensible to introduce an effective temperature for structural relaxation on the timescale used to define τα\tau_\alpha. In this picture, the driven relaxation at this timescale is mapped onto that of an equilibrium system at a higher temperature. Importantly, this choice preserves the equilibrium theoretical framework with minimal modification, requiring no additional nonequilibrium fitting parameters. It also avoids the need for ad hoc shear-dependent parametrizations of activation barriers, as commonly employed in phenomenological approaches such as the Eyring model [37–39].

More precisely, we define an effective temperature TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} as the equilibrium temperature for which the equilibrium structural relaxation time equals that of the driven system Figure 3(b),

τα(Tmap,γ˙=0)=τα(T,γ˙).(2)\tau_\alpha(T_{\mathrm{map}},\dot{\gamma}=0)=\tau_\alpha(T,\dot{\gamma}). \tag*{(2)}

As shown in Figure 3(c) for the KABLJ system, TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} is consistently larger than the bath temperature TT below TAT_A and increases monotonically with γ˙\dot{\gamma}. Thus, stronger driving effectively moves the system toward thermodynamic conditions associated with higher equilibrium temperatures.

We next hypothesize that structural relaxation under steady shear remains governed by the String Model, provided that the nonequilibrium driving is incorporated through two quantities: the shear-dependent cooperative motion encoded in z(T)z(T) and the effective temperature TmapT_{\mathrm{map}}. The relaxation time is therefore predicted to obey

τα=τ0exp⁡[ΔH0−TmapΔS0kBTmapz(T)].(3)\tau_\alpha= \tau_0 \exp\left[\frac{\Delta H_0-T_{\mathrm{map}}\Delta S_0}{k_B T_{\mathrm{map}}}z(T)\right]. \tag*{(3)}

In this description, shear affects relaxation in two ways: it suppresses stringlike cooperative motion, thereby modifying z(T)z(T), and it shifts the relaxation dynamics at the bath temperature TT to a higher effective temperature, Tmap>TT_{\mathrm{map}} > T. Importantly, after fixing the parameters from equilibrium simulations, the relaxation time under nonequilibrium conditions is predicted without introducing any additional fitting parameters.

The prediction of Eq. (3) is tested in Figure 3(d) over a broad range of temperatures and shear rates for three distinct glass-forming systems. The agreement is remarkable. Without introducing any additional nonequilibrium fitting parameters, the model quantitatively captures the relaxation dynamics across both equilibrium and driven conditions. These results provide strong evidence that stringlike cooperative motion remains the microscopic mechanism governing structural relaxation under steady shear, while the effects of driving are largely captured through TmapT_\mathrm{map}. To exclude the possibility that this success merely reflects the definition of TmapT_\mathrm{map} from τα\tau_\alpha, we show in the SM that TmapT_\mathrm{map} alone, without the cooperativity factor z(T,γ˙)z(T,\dot{\gamma}), fails to collapse data across different systems. The combination of both ingredients is therefore essential for a quantitative, system-independent description.

Despite the excellent agreement between Eq. (3) and the simulation data, the mapping temperature TmapT_\mathrm{map} is introduced phenomenologically. We therefore seek a microscopic interpretation in terms of nonequilibrium FDRs. As detailed in the End Matter, we construct an effective-temperature measure from the equilibrium states dynamically sampled by the driven liquid. We find that the resulting averaged temperature Tavg,cT_\mathrm{avg,c} coincides with TmapT_\mathrm{map}, whereas the conventional effective temperature Tslow,cT_\mathrm{slow,c}, extracted solely from the slow branch of the FDR, does not reproduce the shear-dependent structural relaxation time. Because Tavg,cT_\mathrm{avg,c} is determined independently from the fluctuation–dissipation construction, without using the value of τα\tau_\alpha, this agreement provides an independent determination of the temperature entering Eq. (3) and further resolves the apparent circularity associated with the determination of TmapT_\mathrm{map} through τα\tau_\alpha.

This distinction is physically significant. Previous work has shown that effective disorder temperatures can control the activation of particle rearrangements under driving [40]. Here, we find that Tavg,cT_\mathrm{avg,c} also provides the thermodynamic scale governing cooperative string-like motion and, consequently, the structural relaxation time. The failure of Tslow,cT_\mathrm{slow,c} suggests that steady shear destroys a clean separation between slow structural relaxation and faster cage-scale dynamics: the imposed advective timescale truncates cooperative rearrangements and mixes dynamical sectors that are more clearly separated near equilibrium. Because Tavg,cT_\mathrm{avg,c} incorporates the response across the full relaxation process rather than only its asymptotic slow sector, it naturally captures this mode mixing. The fluctuation–dissipation construction therefore provides a physical basis for TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} and identifies it as the effective thermodynamic variable required to extend the String Model to nonequilibrium steady states.

Discussion – In summary, we have investigated the microscopic origin of structural relaxation in glass-forming liquids under steady shear. Our simulations show that external driving progressively suppresses stringlike cooperative motion and dramatically accelerates relaxation. While the equilibrium String Model fails when applied directly under shear, introducing TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} as the effective control temperature restores its predictive power. The resulting nonequilibrium String Model quantitatively describes the relaxation time across different temperatures, shear rates, and glass-forming systems without introducing any additional nonequilibrium fitting parameters. These findings identify stringlike cooperative motion as the common microscopic mechanism governing relaxation in both equilibrium and driven glass-forming liquids, while revealing the effective temperature as the key quantity linking thermal and mechanical activation. More broadly, our results suggest that external driving acts primarily by modifying the effective thermodynamic conditions that control collective activated motion, providing a unified microscopic description of relaxation in equilibrium and nonequilibrium glass-forming liquids. Whether this effective-temperature description can be extended to other nonequilibrium conditions, including aging and oscillatory driving, remains an important question for future work.

Acknowledgments – This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos. 22573102 and 52293471) and the Jilin Provincial Science and Technology Development Program (Nos. SKL202602006JC and SKL202502004JC). Z.-Y.S. is grateful for the essential support of Jilin Provincial International Cooperation Key Laboratory for Polymer Processing Physics. M.B. acknowledges the support of the Foreign Young Scholars Research Fund Project (Grant No. 22Z033100604) and the sponsorship from the Yangyang Development Fund.

Data Availability

The data used to generate the figures presented in this manuscript are available from the Open Science Framework: https://osf.io/9fvdw.

* [email protected]

† [email protected]

‡ [email protected]

§ [email protected]

References

End Matter

Effective Temperature from Nonequilibrium Fluctuation–Dissipation Relation

To obtain a more grounded definition of TmapT_{\mathrm{map}}, we begin from the concept of an effective temperature TeffT_{\mathrm{eff}}, introduced through a nonequilibrium generalization of the fluctuation–dissipation relation (FDR) [41],

R(t)=−1kBTeff(C)dC(t)dt,(4)R(t)=-\frac{1}{k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{eff}}(C)}\frac{dC(t)}{dt}, \tag*{(4)}

where R(t)R(t) and C(t)C(t) denote the response and correlation functions, respectively. In equilibrium, the standard FDR is recovered with Teff(C)=TT_{\mathrm{eff}}(C)=T at all times.

Introducing the susceptibility χ(t)=∫0tR(t′) dt′\chi(t)=\int_{0}^{t}R(t')\,dt', (4) can be rewritten as

dχdC=−1kBTeff(C).(5)\frac{d\chi}{dC}=-\frac{1}{k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{eff}}(C)}. \tag*{(5)}

In this form, a parametric plot of χ\chi versus CC becomes piecewise linear, with each linear sector defining a distinct effective temperature.

In supercooled liquids driven out of equilibrium, two regimes are typically observed. Fast degrees of freedom obey the equilibrium FDR, yielding a slope −1/(kBT)-1/(k_{\mathrm{B}}T), while slow structural modes define a second linear sector associated with a higher effective temperature Tslow>TT_{\mathrm{slow}}>T [7] [42]. The former reflects short-time vibrational dynamics that remain equilibrated with the bath, whereas the latter encodes the long-time configurational response.

An alternative characterization is obtained by averaging over the full FDR curve [43, 44],

1kBTavg=χ(t→∞)=∫01dC′kBTeff(C′),(6)\frac{1}{k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{avg}}}=\chi(t\to\infty)=\int_{0}^{1}\frac{dC'}{k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{eff}}(C')}, \tag*{(6)}

which corresponds to a uniform-in-CC coarse-graining of the inverse effective temperature over the full relaxation process.

TavgT_{\mathrm{avg}} is often referred to as the effective disorder temperature [45, 46]. It has been widely used in driven amorphous materials and differs from TslowT_{\mathrm{slow}} defined above. Rather than probing only the asymptotic long-time sector, it provides a single measure of the full configurational response of the system.

Importantly, neither TslowT_{\mathrm{slow}} nor TavgT_{\mathrm{avg}} coincides with the phenomenological mapping temperature TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} (see the SM), and both fail to reproduce the structural relaxation time under steady shear.

To continue, we focus on the density–density response, where C(t)C(t) is identified with the intermediate scattering function Fs(q,t)F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t). Figure 4(a) compares Fs(q,t,T,γ˙)F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t,T,\dot{\gamma}) for a sheared fluid at T=0.43 ε/kBT=0.43\,\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}} and γ˙=10−2τ−1\dot{\gamma}=10^{-2}\tau^{-1} with equilibrium data at different temperatures. At short times, the decay of Fs(q,t)F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t) under shear closely follows the equilibrium curve at the bath temperature TT, indicating that fast, local dynamics remain effectively thermalized and only weakly affected by the imposed flow.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. Determination of the effective temperature from the fluctuation-dissipation relation. (a) Self-intermediate scattering function Fs(q,t,T,γ˙)F_s(q,t,T,\dot{\gamma}) at T=0.43 ε/kBT=0.43\,\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}} and γ˙=10−2 τ−1\dot{\gamma}=10^{-2}\,\tau^{-1}, compared with equilibrium results at different TT. Circles mark the intersections between the nonequilibrium and equilibrium curves used to define the crossing points at t≡tct\equiv t_c. (b) Parametric plot χc(q,tc)\chi_c(q,t_c) versus Fs,c(q,tc)F_{s,c}(q,t_c) constructed from the intersection points shown in (a). The slope of the slow-relaxation branch defines Tslow,cT_{\mathrm{slow},c}, while Tavg,cT_{\mathrm{avg},c} is determined from the long-time endpoint Fs,c→0F_{s,c}\to0; equivalently, −1/(kBTavg,c)-1/(k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{avg},c}) is the slope of the secant connecting (Fs,c,χc)=(1,0)(F_{s,c},\chi_c)=(1,0) to this endpoint. (c) Effective temperatures TmapT_{\mathrm{map}}, Tslow,cT_{\mathrm{slow},c}, and Tavg,cT_{\mathrm{avg},c} as a function of the bath temperature TT. The dash-dotted line indicates the equilibrium relation Teff=TT_{\mathrm{eff}}=T. Similar behavior is observed for the polymer systems (see the SM).

At longer times, however, Fs(q,t,T,γ˙)F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t,T,\dot{\gamma}) progressively deviates from the equilibrium bath-temperature curve. Crucially, this deviation cannot be captured by any single equilibrium curve at a higher temperature. Instead, the nonequilibrium correlator sequentially intersects a family of equilibrium curves corresponding to increasing temperatures, generating crossing points defined by

Fs,c(q,tc,Tc,0)=Fs(q,tc,T,γ˙).(7)F_{\mathrm{s,c}}(q,t_{\mathrm{c}},T_{\mathrm{c}},0)=F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t_{\mathrm{c}},T,\dot{\gamma}). \tag*{(7)}

Here, the left-hand side denotes the equilibrium intermediate scattering function evaluated at temperature TcT_{\mathrm{c}}, while the right-hand side corresponds to the driven system. This construction provides a dynamical mapping between the nonequilibrium system and a family of equilibrium states.

In the asymptotic limit Fs(q,t,T,γ˙)→0F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t,T,\dot{\gamma})\to0, the driven dynamics converge to a unique equilibrium curve. This highlights that any effective temperature extracted from the dynamics is inherently scale-dependent, interpolating from the bath temperature at short times to a larger asymptotic value associated with structural relaxation.

After identifying the crossing points in Eq. (7) [Figure 4(a)], we define the corresponding equilibrium susceptibility as

χc(q,tc)=1−Fs,c(q,tc)kBTc,(8)\chi_c(q,t_c)=\frac{1-F_{s,c}(q,t_c)}{k_{\mathrm{B}}T_c}, \tag*{(8)}

where Fs,c(q,tc)F_{s,c}(q,t_c) is evaluated at the crossing condition.

We then apply the fluctuation-dissipation relation of Eq. (5) to the pair (χc,Fs,c)(\chi_c,F_{s,c}), using tct_c as the parameter. A linear relation between χc(q,tc)\chi_c(q,t_c) and Fs,c(q,tc)F_{s,c}(q,t_c) identifies an effective temperature through its slope. Unlike conventional analyses, the temperature is extracted from the crossing points rather than directly from the nonequilibrium correlation functions.

Figure 4(b) shows the corresponding parametric plot for the KABLJ system. As in previous nonequilibrium fluctuation-dissipation analyses, two distinct linear regimes are observed. For Fs,c(q,tc)≳0.8F_{s,c}(q,t_c)\gtrsim0.8, the slope yields the bath temperature TT, indicating that fast vibrational modes remain effectively equilibrated and only weakly affected by shear, consistent with the short-time behavior of Fs(q,t,T,γ˙)F_s(q,t,T,\dot{\gamma}). For Fs,c(q,tc)≲0.8F_{s,c}(q,t_c)\lesssim0.8, a second linear regime emerges, defining an effective temperature associated with the slow structural dynamics, Tslow,c>TT_{\mathrm{slow},c}>T. This temperature increases monotonically with shear rate, reflecting the progressively stronger departure from equilibrium induced by the external driving.

However, Tslow,cT_{\mathrm{slow},c} does not exactly coincide with the phenomenological mapping temperature TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} introduced in the main text [Figure 4(c)], and it systematically deviates from TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} as the shear rate γ˙\dot{\gamma} increases. As a result, this definition fails to reproduce the shear-dependent structural relaxation time. This discrepancy is not specific to the KABLJ system, but persists across all three glass-forming systems considered in this work (see the SM).

We therefore turn to the alternative definition in Eq. (6), based on the asymptotic structure of the fluctuation-dissipation relation. In the long-time limit, where fast relaxation has fully decayed and Fs,c(q,tc)→0F_{s,c}(q,t_c)\to0, we define

kBTavg,c≡1χc(tc→∞),(9)k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{avg},c}\equiv\frac{1}{\chi_c(t_c\to\infty)}, \tag*{(9)}

which is determined by the long-time endpoint of the χc\chi_c–Fs,cF_{s,c} curve. Equivalently, −1/(kBTavg,c)-1/(k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{avg},c}) is the slope of the secant connecting the initial point (Fs,c,χc)=(1,0)(F_{s,c},\chi_c)=(1,0) to the endpoint Fs,c→0F_{s,c}\to0, as illustrated by the dashed green line in Figure 4(b).

As shown in Figure 4(c) for the KABLJ system, Tavg,cT_{\mathrm{avg},c} is in agreement with the phenomenological temperature TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} introduced in the main text. This establishes a direct link between TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} and a generalized fluctuation-dissipation construction, rather than a purely phenomenological mapping procedure. A similarly good agreement is observed in polymer glass-formers (see the SM), indicating that this correspondence is robust across a broad class of driven amorphous materials.

Supplemental Material for “String Model Predicts Relaxation in Sheared Glass-Forming Liquids”

Zi-Long Wang; Qi-Lu Yuan; Yun-Jiang Wang; Jack F. Douglas; Matteo Baggioli; Zhao-Yan Sun; Wen-Sheng Xu

supplemental.pdf

Supplemental Material for “String Model Predicts Relaxation in Sheared Glass-Forming Liquids”

Model Systems and Simulation Details

Kob-Andersen Glass-Forming Liquid

We consider a canonical model of glass-forming liquids, namely the Kob–Andersen (KA) binary Lennard–Jones (LJ) liquid [1, 2], which we denote as KABLJ throughout this work. The KA model consists of two particle species, AA and BB, of equal mass mm, with a composition ratio NA:NB=4:1N_A:N_B = 4:1. Particles interact via a truncated-and-shifted LJ potential,

ULJ,αβ(r)=4εαβ[(σαβr)12−(σαβr)6]+Cαβ(rcut),(10)U_{\mathrm{LJ},\alpha\beta}(r) = 4\varepsilon_{\alpha\beta}\left[\left(\frac{\sigma_{\alpha\beta}}{r}\right)^{12} - \left(\frac{\sigma_{\alpha\beta}}{r}\right)^6\right] + C_{\alpha\beta}(r_{\mathrm{cut}}), \tag*{(10)}

for r<rcutr < r_{\mathrm{cut}}, and zero otherwise. Here, α,β∈{A,B}\alpha, \beta\in\{A, B\}, rr denotes the distance between two particles, and σαβ\sigma_{\alpha\beta} and εαβ\varepsilon_{\alpha\beta} set the characteristic length and energy scales, respectively. The constant Cαβ(rcut)C_{\alpha\beta}(r_{\mathrm{cut}}) ensures that ULJ,αβ(r)U_{\mathrm{LJ},\alpha\beta}(r) vanishes continuously at the cutoff distance rcut=2.5σαβr_{\mathrm{cut}} = 2.5\sigma_{\alpha\beta}. The interaction parameters are εAB/εAA=1.5\varepsilon_{AB}/\varepsilon_{AA} = 1.5, εBB/εAA=0.5\varepsilon_{BB}/\varepsilon_{AA} = 0.5, σAB/σAA=0.8\sigma_{AB}/\sigma_{AA} = 0.8, and σBB/σAA=0.88\sigma_{BB}/\sigma_{AA} = 0.88.

Results are reported in standard reduced LJ units. Specifically, the units of length, time, and temperature are σ=σAA\sigma= \sigma_{AA}, τ=mσAA2/εAA\tau= \sqrt{m\sigma_{AA}^{2}/\varepsilon_{AA}}, and ε/kB=εAA/kB\varepsilon/k_B = \varepsilon_{AA}/k_B, respectively, where kBk_B is the Boltzmann constant. We introduce the symbols σ\sigma and ε\varepsilon as shorthand for the length and energy scales of the AA particles to maintain a common notation for both the KABLJ and polymer systems.

The total number of particles is N=NA+NB=4000N = N_A + N_B = 4000. Following the standard protocol for the KABLJ model [1, 2], we investigate glass formation under constant-volume conditions at a number density ρ=N/V=1.2 σ−3\rho= N/V = 1.2\ \sigma^{-3}.

Coarse-Grained Polymer Melt

We also consider a coarse-grained bead-spring model of polymer melts [3, 4]. Each polymer chain consists of a sequence of connected beads. Bond connectivity between neighboring beads is maintained by the finitely extensible nonlinear elastic (FENE) potential [3, 4],

UFENE(r)=−12kbR02ln⁡[1−(rR0)2]+4ε[(σr)12−(σr)6]+ε(11)U_{\mathrm{FENE}}(r) = -\frac{1}{2}k_b R_0^2 \ln\left[1-\left(\frac{r}{R_0}\right)^2\right] + 4\varepsilon\left[\left(\frac{\sigma}{r}\right)^{12}-\left(\frac{\sigma}{r}\right)^6\right] + \varepsilon \tag*{(11)}

where ε\varepsilon and σ\sigma are the characteristic energy and length scales of the LJ interaction. The first term in Eq. (11) is defined up to R0R_0, while the second term is truncated at 21/6 σ2^{1/6}\ \sigma. We adopt the standard parameter values kb=30 ε/σ2k_b = 30\ \varepsilon/\sigma^2 and R0=1.5 σR_0 = 1.5\ \sigma. Non-bonded interactions are described by Eq. (10), where the subscript αβ\alpha\beta is omitted for the one-component melt and the cutoff distance is rcut=2.5 σr_{\mathrm{cut}} = 2.5\ \sigma.

As for the KABLJ system, all quantities and results for the polymer melt are expressed in standard reduced LJ units. Specifically, length, time, temperature, and pressure are measured in units of σ\sigma, τ\tau, ε/kB\varepsilon/k_B, and ε/σ3\varepsilon/\sigma^3, respectively, where τ=mσ2/ε\tau= \sqrt{m\sigma^2/\varepsilon}. Each chain contains 20 beads of equal mass mm, and the melt consists of 400 chains, yielding a total bead number of N=8000N = 8000.

For the polymer melt system, we study glass formation under both constant-volume and constant-pressure conditions. The constant-volume system is simulated at a number density ρ=1.0 σ−3\rho= 1.0 \ \sigma^{-3}, whereas the constant-pressure system is simulated at P=0.0 ε/σ3P = 0.0 \ \varepsilon/\sigma^{3}. For convenience, we refer to these systems as Poly-V and Poly-P, respectively.

Simulation Details

Our simulations are carried out in three dimensions using the LAMMPS simulation package [5, 6]. The equations of motion are integrated with a time step of Δt=0.005 τ\Delta t = 0.005 \ \tau. We follow the protocol established in our previous studies [7, 8, 9] to investigate glass formation in the absence of shear. The system is first fully equilibrated at T=2.0 ε/kBT = 2.0 \ \varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}} for the KABLJ and Poly-V systems at the specified density, or for the Poly-P system at P=0.0 ε/σ3P = 0.0 \ \varepsilon/\sigma^{3}. The equilibrated liquid is then cooled at a rate of 10−4 ε/(kBτ)10^{-4} \ \varepsilon/(k_{\mathrm{B}}\tau) under periodic boundary conditions in either the NVTNVT or NPTNPT ensemble, depending on the thermodynamic conditions considered. Temperature and pressure are controlled using the Nosé–Hoover thermostat and barostat implemented in LAMMPS.

To obtain properties at a given temperature, configurations generated during the cooling process are further equilibrated for a duration typically 10–100 times longer than the segmental structural relaxation time in the NVTNVT ensemble, irrespective of the thermodynamic path used to generate the state point. We focus on temperatures well above the glass transition temperature TgT_{\mathrm{g}}, such that nonequilibrium effects associated with the glassy state are irrelevant to the present study.

After equilibration, shear deformation is applied at a constant shear rate γ˙\dot{\gamma} following standard procedures [10, 11, 12, 13]. Specifically, simple shear is imposed in the xyxy plane under constant-volume conditions using the SLLOD equations of motion [14, 15] in conjunction with Lees–Edwards boundary conditions. In this geometry, the xx, yy, and zz directions correspond to the flow, velocity-gradient, and vorticity directions, respectively. We vary γ˙\dot{\gamma} from 10−5 τ−110^{-5} \ \tau^{-1} to 10−2 τ−110^{-2} \ \tau^{-1} over a wide range of temperatures. To ensure that the steady state is reached, the system is deformed up to a total strain γ=γ˙t≈100\gamma= \dot{\gamma}t \approx100 for all state points studied, which is sufficient according to previous simulations of the same polymer model [10]. Static and dynamic properties are subsequently computed from trajectories collected in the steady-shear regime.

As an illustration, Figure S1 shows the shear stress σxy\sigma_{xy} as a function of shear strain γ\gamma for different shear rates γ˙\dot{\gamma} at T=0.32 ε/kBT = 0.32\ \varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}} in the Poly-V system. The stress initially increases with increasing strain and exhibits a characteristic overshoot before decreasing toward a steady-state value. At larger strains, the system reaches a stationary flowing state in which time-independent average properties are established. Evidently, the maximum strain of γ≈100\gamma\approx100 is sufficiently large to ensure that all simulations are performed in the steady-shear regime.

Image not extracted

Figure S1. Shear stress under steady shear in the Poly-V system. Shear stress σxy\sigma_{xy} as a function of shear strain γ\gamma for different shear rates γ˙\dot{\gamma} at T=0.32 ε/kBT = 0.32\ \varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}. Similar results are obtained for the KABLJ and Poly-P systems.

Definition of Basic Properties

Here we describe how structural relaxation and stringlike cooperative motion, the two central quantities considered in this study, are quantified. We determine the structural relaxation time τα\tau_{\alpha} from the self-part of the intermediate scattering function,

Fs(q,t)=1N⟨∑j=1Nexp⁡(−iq⋅[rj(t)−rj(0)])⟩(12)F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t) = \frac{1}{N}\left\langle\sum_{j=1}^{N} \exp\left(-i\mathbf{q}\cdot\left[\mathbf{r}_{j}(t)-\mathbf{r}_{j}(0)\right]\right) \right\rangle \tag*{(12)}

where ii is the imaginary unit, q=∣q∣q = \lvert\mathbf{q}\rvert is the wave number, rj\mathbf{r}_{j} is the position of particle jj, and ⟨⋯ ⟩\langle\cdots\rangle denotes the usual thermal average. For the KABLJ system, Fs(q,t)F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t) is computed using only the AA particles. The wave number is chosen as q=7.2 σ−1q = 7.2\ \sigma^{-1} for the KABLJ system and q=7.0 σ−1q = 7.0\ \sigma^{-1} for the polymer systems, corresponding approximately to the first peak of the static structure factor S(q)S(q). The structural relaxation time τα\tau_\alpha is then defined as the time at which Fs(q,t)F_s(q,t) decays to 0.2.

To quantify stringlike cooperative motion, we follow the established procedure of Refs. [16, 17]. Mobile particles are defined as a fraction f0f_0 of particles exhibiting the largest displacement over a chosen time interval, with f0=5.0%f_0 = 5.0\% and 6.5%6.5\% for the KABLJ and polymer systems, respectively. Two mobile particles jj and kk are considered to belong to the same string if the following condition holds,

min⁡[∣rj(t)−rk(0)∣,∣rk(t)−rj(0)∣]<δ,(13)\min\left[ \left|\mathbf{r}_j(t)-\mathbf{r}_k(0)\right|,\left|\mathbf{r}_k(t)-\mathbf{r}_j(0)\right| \right] < \delta, \tag*{(13)}

where δ\delta is a displacement threshold set to 0.6 σ0.6\ \sigma and 0.55 σ0.55\ \sigma for the KABLJ and polymer systems, respectively. The number-averaged string length is computed as ⟨s(t)⟩=⟨∑s=1∞sC(s)⟩/∑s=1∞C(s)\langle s(t)\rangle= \langle\sum_{s=1}^{\infty}sC(s)\rangle/\sum_{s=1}^{\infty}C(s), where C(s)C(s) is the probability of observing a string of length ss. The quantity ⟨s(t)⟩\langle s(t)\rangle exhibits a maximum L≡⟨s(tL)⟩L \equiv\langle s(t_L)\rangle at a characteristic time tLt_L, which defines the characteristic string length LL. Note that all particles are included in the calculation of LL, including both particle species in the KABLJ system.

In the presence of shear flow, the calculation of τα\tau_\alpha and LL is complicated by the need to subtract the affine deformation induced by the flow. Reference [18] showed that the displacement vector appearing in Eq. (12) should be replaced by

Δrj(t)=rj(t)−rj(0)−γ˙∫0tdt′ yj(t′)x,(14)\Delta\mathbf{r}_j(t)=\mathbf{r}_j(t)-\mathbf{r}_j(0)-\dot{\gamma}\int_0^t dt'\,y_j(t')\mathbf{x}, \tag*{(14)}

where yj(t′)y_j(t') is the yy component of the position of particle jj and x\mathbf{x} is a unit vector in the flow direction. Computing the full integral in Eq. (14) requires extensive bookkeeping of particle trajectories and is therefore computationally demanding. Fortunately, Tanaka and co-workers [13, 19] demonstrated that

γ˙∫0tdt′ yj(t′)≈γ˙tyj(0),(15)\dot{\gamma}\int_0^t dt'\,y_j(t') \approx\dot{\gamma}t y_j(0), \tag*{(15)}

provides an excellent approximation, which we adopt in the present work to compute both Fs(q,t)F_s(q,t) and ⟨s(t)⟩\langle s(t)\rangle.

Previous studies have also shown that Fs(q,t)F_s(q,t) exhibits only weak anisotropy under steady shear [18, 19]. We confirm this finding in our simulations (Figure S2). The small differences in the xx direction at high shear rates are expected since the approximation of Eq. (15) is less accurate under such conditions. For this reason, we consider only Fs,z(q,t)F_{s,z}(q,t) along the shear-free (zz) direction [10], i.e., Fs(q,t)=Fs,z(q,t)F_s(q,t)=F_{s,z}(q,t).

Image not extracted

Figure S2. Dynamics in different directions under steady shear. (a–c) Fs(q,t)F_s(q,t) in the xx, yy, and zz directions for the three systems at different γ˙\dot{\gamma} and a fixed TT indicated. (d–f) Logarithm of the structural relaxation time, log⁡(τα)\log(\tau_\alpha), in the xx, yy, and zz directions as a function of TT for the KABLJ system for the three systems at different γ˙\dot{\gamma}.

Results at Equilibrium

This section characterizes the equilibrium glass-forming behavior of the three systems studied in this work. We begin by examining the temperature dependence of the structural relaxation time τα\tau_\alpha and the characteristic string length LL. As shown in Figure S3, structural relaxation slows dramatically upon cooling, accompanied by a growth in the extent of string-like cooperative motion. Such behavior is characteristic of glass-forming liquids.

Image not extracted

Figure S3. Temperature dependence of the characteristic properties of glass formation. (a,b) Logarithm of the structural relaxation time log⁡(τα)\log(\tau_{\alpha}) and average string length LL versus inverse temperature ε/kBT\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}T for the three systems, respectively. The plus symbols indicate the positions of the onset temperature TAT_{\mathrm{A}} of glass formation.

The characteristic temperatures associated with glass formation are determined using established procedures. The onset temperature TAT_A of non-Arrhenius dynamics is estimated from the appearance of a minimum near t=2τt=2\tau in the logarithmic derivative of the mean-squared displacement [17]. Because the timescale defining TAT_A is closely related to particle localization, TAT_A is often referred to as the localization temperature. The resulting values of

TAT_{\mathrm{A}} are indicated by the plus symbols in Figure S3 and are listed in Table I of the main text.

An alternative estimate of the onset of non-Arrhenius relaxation can be obtained directly from the temperature dependence of τα\tau_{\alpha}. Figure S4 shows that our simulations cover a temperature range in which the high-temperature dynamics follow the Arrhenius form expected from transition state theory (TST) [20, 21],

Image not extracted

Figure S4. Analysis of the temperature dependence of the structural relaxation time. (a,b) Arrhenius dynamics (Eq. (16)) in the high-TT regime and Vogel–Fulcher–Tammann (VFT) equation (Eq. (17)) in the low-TT regime for the three systems, respectively, where dashed lines indicate ln⁡(τα/A0)=ΔH0/kBT\ln(\tau_{\alpha}/A_{0}) = \Delta H_{0}/k_{\mathrm{B}}T and ln⁡(τα/τ0,VFT)=DT0/(T−T0)\ln(\tau_{\alpha}/\tau_{0,\mathrm{VFT}}) = DT_{0}/(T-T_{0}). The meanings of A0A_{0}, ΔH0\Delta H_{0}, τ0,VFT\tau_{0,\mathrm{VFT}}, DD, and T0T_{0} are explained in the text.

τα=A0exp⁡(ΔH0kBT),(16)\tau_{\alpha}=A_0\exp\left(\frac{\Delta H_0}{k_{\mathrm{B}}T}\right), \tag*{(16)}

where A0A_0 is a prefactor and ΔH0\Delta H_0 is the activation energy. The prefactor A0A_0 contains both a vibrational attempt frequency and an entropic contribution proportional to exp⁡(−ΔS0/kB)\exp(-\Delta S_0/k_{\mathrm{B}}), where ΔS0\Delta S_0 is the activation entropy.

The crossover temperature TcT_c is obtained by fitting simulation data in the range 5τ<τα<5×103τ5\tau< \tau_{\alpha} < 5 \times10^{3}\tau to the power law τα∼(T−Tc)−γ\tau_{\alpha} \sim(T-T_c)^{-\gamma}, where γ\gamma is a fitting parameter. This scaling form was originally proposed within mode-coupling theory (MCT) [22], and the fitted parameter TcT_c is therefore commonly referred to as the mode-coupling temperature. The resulting values of TcT_c are listed in Table S1.

SystemTcT_c [ε/kB\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}]T0T_0 [ε/kB\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}]KVFTK_{\mathrm{VFT}}
KABLJ0.4240.3130.264
Poly-V0.2980.2130.224
Poly-P0.4130.3470.430

Table S1. Characteristic properties of glass formation for the three systems at equilibrium. TcT_c and T0T_0 are the crossover and ideal glass transition temperatures, respectively. KVFTK_{\mathrm{VFT}} is the VFT fragility parameter.

The ideal glass transition temperature T0T_0 is estimated using the Vogel–Fulcher–Tammann (VFT) equation [23, 24, 25],

τα=τ0,VFTexp⁡(DT0T−T0),(17)\tau_{\alpha}=\tau_{0,\mathrm{VFT}}\exp\left(\frac{D T_0}{T-T_0}\right), \tag*{(17)}

where τ0,VFT\tau_{0,\mathrm{VFT}} is a prefactor and DD is the fragility parameter that characterizes the temperature dependence of τα\tau_{\alpha}. As shown in Figure S4(b), the VFT expression provides an excellent description of the non-Arrhenius regime. We further define KVFT≡1/DK_{\mathrm{VFT}} \equiv1/D, such that larger values of KVFTK_{\mathrm{VFT}} correspond to more fragile glass-forming liquids. The fitted values of both T0T_0 and KVFTK_{\mathrm{VFT}} are reported in Table S1.

Finally, we show in Figure S5 that the String Model provides an excellent description of our simulation data at equilibrium for all the three systems. We note that ΔS0\Delta S_0 is a kinetic parameter describing barrier crossing events in an energy landscape so that it is not related in any obvious way to the equilibrium fluid entropy. Hence, it is understandable both from a theoretical standpoint and from measurements since the earliest formulations of transition state theory that ΔS0\Delta S_{0} can be either positive or negative. We also note that the String Model works well even when the entropic contribution to the activation free energy is neglected, as shown in a recent work [26].

Image not extracted

Figure S5. String Model description of glass formation at equilibrium. Logarithm of the structural relaxation time, ln⁡(τα/τ0)\ln(\tau_{\alpha}/\tau_{0}), as a function of (ΔH0−TΔS0)z(T)/kBT(\Delta H_{0}-T\Delta S_{0})z(T)/k_{\mathrm{B}}T for the three glass-forming systems. The parameters τ0\tau_{0}, ΔH0\Delta H_{0}, and ΔS0\Delta S_{0} are reported in Table 1 of the main text. The dashed line indicates the predicted one-to-one correspondence between the two quantities.

Results under Steady Shear

Characteristic Properties of Glass Formation

In the main text, we present the results for structural relaxation and stringlike cooperative motion in the KABLJ system under steady shear. For completeness, the corresponding results for the Poly-V and Poly-P systems are shown in Figure S6 and Figure S7, respectively. We find that all three systems exhibit qualitatively similar trends in both structural relaxation and stringlike cooperative motion as the shear rate is varied.

Image not extracted

Figure S6. Structural relaxation and stringlike cooperative motion in the Poly-V system under steady shear. (a,b) Self-intermediate scattering function Fs(q,t)F_s(q,t) and number-averaged string length ⟨s(t)⟩\langle s(t)\rangle as a function of time tt for different shear rates γ˙\dot{\gamma} at T=0.32 ε/kBT = 0.32\,\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}, respectively. (c,d) Structural relaxation time log⁡(τα)\log(\tau_{\alpha}) and characteristic string length LL as a function of inverse temperature ε/kBT\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}T, respectively.

Image not extracted

Figure S7. Structural relaxation and stringlike cooperative motion in the Poly-P system under steady shear. (a,b) Self-intermediate scattering function Fs(q,t)F_s(q,t) and number-averaged string length ⟨s(t)⟩\langle s(t)\rangle as a function of time tt for different shear rates γ˙\dot{\gamma} at T=0.42 ε/kBT=0.42\,\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}, respectively. (c,d) Structural relaxation time log⁡(τα)\log(\tau_\alpha) and characteristic string length LL as a function of inverse temperature ε/kBT\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}T, respectively.

For completeness, we also summarize the effective temperature TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} for the polymer systems in Figure S8, where we see that the results are similar to those for the KABLJ system.

Image not extracted

Figure S8. Summary of the effective temperature for the polymer systems. (a,b) Effective temperature TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} as a function of the bath temperature TT for the Poly-V and Poly-P systems over a wide range of shear rates γ˙\dot{\gamma}, respectively. The dashed line indicates Tmap=TT_{\mathrm{map}}=T.

To make our conclusion more robust, Figure S9 plots ln⁡(τα/τ0)\ln(\tau_{\alpha}/\tau_0) as a function of (ΔH0−TmapΔS0)/kBTmap(\Delta H_0 - T_{\mathrm{map}}\Delta S_0)/k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{map}}. For each system, we see that the data for different γ˙\dot{\gamma} collapse onto a single curve, which is expected since TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} is determined from the mapping of τα\tau_{\alpha}. Importantly, excluding the term z(T)z(T) in the String Model does not lead to a data collapse across different systems, indicating that TmapT_{\mathrm{map}} alone is inadequate to predict the relaxation time. As stated in the main text, the effective temperature and the shear-induced suppression of the string length are the two ingredients that lead to a quantitative prediction of the structural relaxation time across a broad range of temperatures and shear rates. Our analysis thus eliminates the circularity issue that may arise from the determination of TmapT_{\mathrm{map}}.

Image not extracted

Figure S9. Dependence of the structural relaxation time on the effective temperature. The plot shows ln⁡(τα/τ0)\ln(\tau_{\alpha}/\tau_{0}) as a function of (ΔH0−TmapΔS0)/kBTmap(\Delta H_{0}-T_{\mathrm{map}}\Delta S_{0})/k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{map}} for all three systems and a wide range of shear rates.

Effective Temperatures from Fluctuation-Dissipation Relation

We follow the established methodology to determine an effective temperature associated with the slow modes of a sheared fluid. This approach is based on a nonequilibrium generalization of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT). We refer the reader to Ref. [27] for a detailed discussion and summarize here only the essential steps required for its implementation.

We first define the following observables associated with density fluctuations,

A(q,t)=1N∑jξjexp⁡[i q⋅rj(t)],(18)A(q,t) = \frac{1}{N}\sum_{j}\xi_{j}\exp[\mathrm{i}\,\mathbf{q}\cdot\mathbf{r}_{j}(t)], \tag*{(18)}

and

B(q,t)=2∑jξjcos⁡[q⋅rj(t)],(19)B(q,t) = 2\sum_{j}\xi_{j}\cos[\mathbf{q}\cdot\mathbf{r}_{j}(t)], \tag*{(19)}

where ξj=±1\xi_j=\pm1 are random variables satisfying the constraint ∑jξj=0\sum_j \xi_j=0. The real part of the cross-correlation function of these observables is defined as

C(q,t)=⟨A(q,t+t0)B(q,t0)⟩−⟨A(q,t0)⟩⟨B(q,t0)⟩,(20)C(q,t) = \langle A(q,t+t_{0})B(q,t_{0})\rangle-\langle A(q,t_{0})\rangle\langle B(q,t_{0})\rangle, \tag*{(20)}

which can be shown to be equivalent to the real part of the self-intermediate scattering function,

C(q,t)=1N⟨∑jcos⁡[q⋅(rj(t)−rj(0))]⟩.(21)C(q,t)=\frac{1}{N}\left\langle\sum_j \cos\left[\mathbf{q}\cdot\left(\mathbf{r}_j(t)-\mathbf{r}_j(0)\right)\right]\right\rangle. \tag*{(21)}

To probe the linear response, we apply a weak external field hh conjugate to B(q,t)B(q,t) at time t0t_0, such that a perturbation ΔH=−hB(q,t)\Delta H=-hB(q,t) is added to the system Hamiltonian. The corresponding response function is

R(q,t)=δ⟨A(q,t+t0)⟩δh(t0)∣h=0,(22)R(q,t)=\left.\frac{\delta\langle A(q,t+t_0)\rangle}{\delta h(t_0)}\right|_{h=0}, \tag*{(22)}

and the integrated susceptibility is defined as

χ(q,t)=∫t0t+t0dt′′∂⟨A(t)⟩h∂h(t′′)∣h→0.(23)\chi(q,t)=\int_{t_0}^{t+t_0}dt^{\prime\prime}\left.\frac{\partial\langle A(t)\rangle_h}{\partial h(t^{\prime\prime})}\right|_{h\to0}. \tag*{(23)}

For a sufficiently small constant perturbation hh switched on at time t0t_0, χ(q,t)\chi(q,t) can be approximated by

χ(q,t)≈⟨Ah(q,t+t0)−Aref(q,t+t0)⟩h.(24)\chi(q,t)\approx\frac{\left\langle A_h(q,t+t_0)-A_{\mathrm{ref}}(q,t+t_0)\right\rangle}{h}. \tag*{(24)}

An effective temperature TslowT_{\mathrm{slow}} can then be introduced through the fluctuation-dissipation relation (FDR),

R(q,t)=−1kBTslow∂C(q,t)∂t,(25)R(q,t)=-\frac{1}{k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{slow}}}\frac{\partial C(q,t)}{\partial t}, \tag*{(25)}

or, equivalently, through its integrated form,

χ(q,t)=∫C(q,t)C(q,0)dxkBTslow(x).(26)\chi(q,t)=\int_{C(q,t)}^{C(q,0)}\frac{dx}{k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{slow}}(x)}. \tag*{(26)}

A constant TslowT_{\mathrm{slow}} therefore appears as a linear slope of −1/(kBTslow)-1/(k_{\mathrm{B}}T_{\mathrm{slow}}) in a parametric plot of χ(q,t)\chi(q,t) versus C(q,t)C(q,t).

In our simulations, the system is driven at a constant shear rate γ˙\dot{\gamma}. Particular care is required in choosing the perturbation strength hh used to compute the FDR. A series of benchmark calculations indicates that h=0.08 εh=0.08\,\varepsilon provides a suitable compromise between statistical accuracy and linear-response behavior (Figure S10), where ArefA_{\mathrm{ref}} in Eq. (24) denotes the unperturbed density fluctuation. This value is also consistent with the recommended range h=0.05h=0.05–0.2 ε0.2\,\varepsilon reported in [27]. To improve statistics, all results are averaged over more than 500 independent simulations.

Image not extracted

Figure S10. Influence of the perturbation strength hh on the fluctuation-dissipation relation (FDR). (a–c) Susceptibility χ(q,t)\chi(q,t) versus the correlation function C(q,t)C(q,t) over a range of hh at a fixed TT indicated for the three systems, respectively. The shear rate is fixed at γ˙=10−2τ−1\dot{\gamma}=10^{-2}\tau^{-1}. Here, our simulation data are obtained from 504 independent runs.

To validate our implementation, Figure S11 compares our results with those reported in Ref. [27] for the KABLJ system at T=0.5ϵ/kBT=0.5\epsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}} and 0.3ϵ/kB0.3\epsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}} under a shear rate of γ˙=10−2τ−1\dot{\gamma}=10^{-2}\tau^{-1}. The agreement is essentially perfect. Figure S12 further illustrates the temperature dependence of the FDR for all three systems. We find that TslowT_{\mathrm{slow}} closely follows the bath temperature TT at high temperatures but deviates significantly from it upon cooling. Notably, the FDR exhibits non-monotonic behavior in the Poly-P system, suggesting that the standard perturbation protocol, which neglects density fluctuations and their coupling to energy fluctuations, becomes problematic under isobaric conditions.

Image not extracted

Figure S11. Validation of the numerical calculation of the FDR. The plot shows Tχ(q,t)T\chi(q,t) versus C(q,t)C(q,t) at T=0.5ϵ/kBT=0.5\epsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}} and 0.3ϵ/kB0.3\epsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}} for the KABLJ system. The shear rate is fixed at γ˙=10−2τ−1\dot{\gamma}=10^{-2}\tau^{-1}. Symbols are data taken from Ref. [27] under the same conditions. The dash-dotted line shows the fluctuation-dissipation theorem (FDT) consistent with the bath temperature, as indicated. Here, our simulation data are obtained from 448 independent runs. Note that the wave number is chosen to be q=7.47σ−1q=7.47\sigma^{-1}, consistent with that in Ref. [27].

Image not extracted

Figure S12. Temperature dependence of the FDR. (a–c) show χ(q,t)\chi(q,t) versus C(q,t)C(q,t) at varying TT for the three systems, respectively. The shear rate is fixed at γ˙=10−2τ−1\dot{\gamma}=10^{-2}\tau^{-1}. Dash-dotted lines show the FDT consistent with the bath temperature. Solid lines indicate the identification of an effective temperature TX,slopeT_{\mathrm{X,slope}} associated with the slow modes of the sheared fluid. Here, our simulation data are obtained from 504 independent runs.

Comparison of Effective Temperatures from Different Methods

In the crossing-point construction, we identify effective temperatures from the self-intermediate scattering function. By linearly extrapolating the long-time portion of the parametric curve to Fs,c=0F_{s,c}=0, we extract the vertical-axis intercept χc,∞=lim⁡Fs,c→0χ(q,tc)\chi_{c,\infty}=\lim_{F_{s,c}\to0}\chi(q,t_c). The average effective temperature is then defined as Tavg,c=1/(kBχc,∞)T_{\mathrm{avg,c}}=1/(k_{\mathrm{B}}\chi_{c,\infty}). If expressed in terms of a slope, this definition uses the endpoint chord joining (Fs,c,χc)=(1,0)(F_{s,c},\chi_c)=(1,0) and (0,χc,∞)(0,\chi_{c,\infty}), whose slope is −χc,∞-\chi_{c,\infty}, while the slope of the long-time branch defines Tslow,cT_{\mathrm{slow,c}}. For completeness, Figure S13 and Figure S14 show the results associated with the FDR analysis based on Fs(q,t)F_s(q,t) for the polymer systems.

Image not extracted

(a)

Image not extracted

(b)

Image not extracted

(c)

Figure S13. Determination of the effective temperature from the fluctuation-dissipation relation in the Poly-V system under steady shear. (a) Self-intermediate scattering function Fs(q,t,T,γ˙)F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t,T,\dot{\gamma}) at T=0.32 ε/kBT = 0.32\,\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}} and γ˙=10−2 τ−1\dot{\gamma} = 10^{-2}\,\tau^{-1}, compared with equilibrium results at different temperatures TT. Circles mark the intersections between the nonequilibrium and equilibrium curves used to define the crossing points at t≡tct \equiv t_{\mathrm{c}}. (b) Parametric plot χc(q,tc)\chi_{\mathrm{c}}(q,t_{\mathrm{c}}) versus Fs,c(q,tc)F_{\mathrm{s,c}}(q,t_{\mathrm{c}}) constructed from the intersection points shown in (a). The long-time branch slope defines Tslow,cT_{\mathrm{slow,c}}, whereas the vertical-axis intercept χc,∞=lim⁡Fs,c→0χc\chi_{\mathrm{c},\infty} = \lim_{F_{\mathrm{s,c}}\to0}\chi_{\mathrm{c}} gives Tavg,c=1/(kBχc,∞)T_{\mathrm{avg,c}} = 1/(k_{\mathrm{B}}\chi_{\mathrm{c},\infty}). (c) Effective temperatures TmapT_{\mathrm{map}}, Tslow,cT_{\mathrm{slow,c}} and Tavg,cT_{\mathrm{avg,c}} as a function of the bath temperature TT. The dash-dotted line indicates the equilibrium relation Teff=TT_{\mathrm{eff}} = T.

Image not extracted

(a)

Image not extracted

(b)

Image not extracted

(c)

Figure S14. Determination of the effective temperature from the fluctuation-dissipation relation in the Poly-P system under steady shear. (a) Self-intermediate scattering function Fs(q,t,T,γ˙)F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t,T,\dot{\gamma}) at T=0.42 ε/kBT = 0.42\,\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}} and γ˙=10−2 τ−1\dot{\gamma} = 10^{-2}\,\tau^{-1}, compared with equilibrium results at different temperatures TT. Circles mark the intersections between the nonequilibrium and equilibrium curves used to define the crossing points at t≡tct \equiv t_{\mathrm{c}}. (b) Parametric plot χc(q,tc)\chi_{\mathrm{c}}(q,t_{\mathrm{c}}) versus Fs,c(q,tc)F_{\mathrm{s,c}}(q,t_{\mathrm{c}}) constructed from the intersection points shown in (a). The long-time branch slope defines Tslow,cT_{\mathrm{slow,c}}, whereas the vertical-axis intercept χc,∞=lim⁡Fs,c→0χc\chi_{\mathrm{c},\infty} = \lim_{F_{\mathrm{s,c}}\to0}\chi_{\mathrm{c}} gives Tavg,c=1/(kBχc,∞)T_{\mathrm{avg,c}} = 1/(k_{\mathrm{B}}\chi_{\mathrm{c},\infty}). (c) Effective temperatures TmapT_{\mathrm{map}}, Tslow,cT_{\mathrm{slow,c}} and Tavg,cT_{\mathrm{avg,c}} as a function of the bath temperature TT. The dash-dotted line indicates the equilibrium relation Teff=TT_{\mathrm{eff}} = T.

Figure S15 compares the decay rate, −∂Fs(q,t)/∂t-\partial F_s(q,t)/\partial t, of each sheared system with its equilibrium counterparts. As FsF_s decreases, the sheared decay rate progressively approaches the equilibrium rate at Tavg,cT_{\mathrm{avg,c}}. This convergence provides independent dynamical evidence that Tavg,cT_{\mathrm{avg,c}} governs long-time structural relaxation and supports the temperature selected by

Image not extracted

Figure S15. Decay rate of the self-intermediate scattering function as a function of FsF_s. (a–c) show the results for the three systems at a low temperature with shear rate γ˙=10−2τ−1\dot{\gamma}=10^{-2}\tau^{-1}. As FsF_s decreases beyond the cage regime, the sheared dynamics approach the equilibrium decay rate at Tavg,cT_{\mathrm{avg},c}, supporting both its long-time role and the asymptotic temperature selected by the Fs→0F_s\to0 extrapolation.

extrapolating the crossing-point construction to Fs,c=0F_{s,c}=0.

We now directly compare TmapT_{\rm map} with TslowT_{\rm slow} and TavgT_{\rm avg} determined from the FDR based on the perturbative method in Figure S16. We find that neither TslowT_{\rm slow} nor TavgT_{\rm avg} follows TmapT_{\rm map} as the bath temperature TT is varied. In particular, TslowT_{\rm slow} initially follows TT at high TT but increases upon further lowering TT, indicating that the standard FDR analysis does not provide a sensible effective temperature. We therefore conclude that the effective temperature defined through the average-mapping approach offers a more robust characterization of the nonequilibrium dynamics considered in our work.

Image not extracted

Figure S16. Determination of the effective temperature from the FDR in the three systems under steady shear. (a–c) Susceptibility χ(q,t)\chi(q,t) versus correlation C(q,t)C(q,t) at γ˙=10−2τ−1\dot{\gamma}=10^{-2}\tau^{-1} for KABLJ (T=0.43 ε/kBT=0.43\,\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}), Poly-V (T=0.32 ε/kBT=0.32\,\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}), and Poly-P (T=0.42 ε/kBT=0.42\,\varepsilon/k_{\mathrm{B}}) systems. The long-time branch slope defines TslowT_{\mathrm{slow}}, whereas the vertical-axis intercept χ∞=lim⁡C→0χ\chi_{\infty}=\lim_{C\to0}\chi gives Tavg=1/(kBχ∞)T_{\mathrm{avg}}=1/(k_{\mathrm{B}}\chi_{\infty}). (d–f) Effective temperatures (TmapT_{\mathrm{map}}, TslowT_{\mathrm{slow}}, and TavgT_{\mathrm{avg}}) as a function of the bath temperature TT for the corresponding systems. The dash-dotted line represents the equilibrium relation Teff=TT_{\mathrm{eff}}=T.

Comparison of Time Correlation Functions under Steady Shear and at Equilibrium

In the main text, we adopt the definition of an effective temperature TmapT_{\rm map} obtained from the mapping of τα\tau_\alpha indicated in Figure 3(b). Here, we directly compare the corresponding time-correlation functions under steady shear and at equilibrium. Figure S17 shows Fs(q,t)F_s(q,t) and ⟨s(t)⟩\langle s(t)\rangle for the sheared fluid at T=0.43 ε/kBT=0.43\,\varepsilon/k_{\rm B} and different shear rates γ˙\dot{\gamma}, together with the corresponding equilibrium results at TmapT_{\rm map}, where TmapT_{\rm map} is chosen as the closest available temperature in our simulations.

Figure S17. Comparison of time correlation functions under steady shear and at equilibrium in the KABLJ system. (a,b) Self-intermediate scattering function Fs(q,t)F_s(q,t) and number-averaged string length ⟨s(t)⟩\langle s(t)\rangle for the sheared fluid at T=0.43 ε/kBT=0.43\,\varepsilon/k_{\rm B} and different shear rates γ˙\dot{\gamma}, together with the corresponding equilibrium results at TmapT_{\rm map}. Circles in (a) and (b) indicate the positions of τα\tau_\alpha and LL, respectively. Similar results are obtained for the Poly-V and Poly-P systems.

Although the relaxation time τα\tau_{\alpha} of the sheared fluid at a given γ˙\dot{\gamma} closely matches that of the equilibrium fluid at the corresponding TmapT_{\mathrm{map}}, the full time dependence of Fs(q,t)F_{\mathrm{s}}(q,t) remains noticeably different [Figure S17(a)]. A similar observation applies to LL and ⟨s(t)⟩\langle s(t)\rangle in Figure S17(b). These results confirm that the concept of an effective temperature depends on the specific time and length scales used to characterize the dynamics, as discussed in the main text.

Code availability

The code and scripts used to compute the fluctuation-dissipation relation are available on GitHub: https://github.com/Zilong-Wang-2000/String-Model-Shear.

References

References

  1. [1]W. Kob and H. C. Andersen, Physical Review Letters 73, 1376 (1994).
  2. [2]W. Kob and H. C. Andersen, Physical Review E 51, 4626 (1995).
  3. [3]K. Kremer and G. S. Grest, The Journal of Chemical Physics 92, 5057 (1990).
  4. [4]G. S. Grest and K. Kremer, Physical Review A 33, 3628 (1986).
  5. [5]S. Plimpton, Journal of Computational Physics 117, 1 (1995).
  6. [6]LAMMPS (2018), available at http://lammps.sandia.gov. (Accessed July 9, 2026). The present work utilized the version released on 12/12/2018.
  7. [7]W.-S. Xu, J. F. Douglas, and X. Xu, Macromolecules 53, 4796 (2020).
  8. [8]W.-S. Xu, J. F. Douglas, and X. Xu, Macromolecules 53, 9678 (2020).
  9. [9]W.-S. Xu, J. F. Douglas, W. Xia, and X. Xu, Macromolecules 53, 6828 (2020).
  10. [10]A. Giuntoli, F. Puosi, D. Leporini, F. W. Starr, and J. F. Douglas, Science Advances 6, eaaz0777 (2020).
  11. [11]V. Jadhao and M. O. Robbins, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 114, 7952 (2017).
  12. [12]V. Jadhao and M. O. Robbins, Tribology Letters 67, 66 (2019).
  13. [13]T. S. Ingebrigtsen and H. Tanaka, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 115, 87 (2018).
  14. [14]D. J. Evans and G. P. Morriss, Physical Review A 30, 1528 (1984).
  15. [15]P. J. Davis and B. D. Todd, The Journal of Chemical Physics 124, 194103 (2006).
  16. [16]M. Aichele, Y. Gebremichael, F. W. Starr, J. Baschnagel, and S. C. Glotzer, The Journal of Chemical Physics 119, 5291 (2003).
  17. [17]F. W. Starr, J. F. Douglas, and S. Sastry, The Journal of Chemical Physics 138, 12A541 (2013).
  18. [18]R. Yamamoto and A. Onuki, Physical Review E 58, 3515 (1998).
  19. [19]A. Furukawa, K. Kim, S. Saito, and H. Tanaka, Physical Review Letters 102, 16001 (2009).
  20. [20]J. F. Kincaid, Henry. Eyring, and A. E. Stearn, Chemical Reviews 28, 301 (1941).
  21. [21]S. Glasstone, K. Laidler, and H. Eyring, The Theory of Rate Processes: The Kinetics of Chemical Reactions, Viscosity, Diffusion and Electrochemical Phenomena, International Chemical Series (McGraw-Hill Book Company, Incorporated, 1941).
  22. [22]W. Götze, Complex Dynamics of Glass-Forming Liquids: A Mode-Coupling Theory (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2008).DOI
  23. [23]H. Vogel, Physikalische Zeitschrift 22, 645 (1921).
  24. [24]G. S. Fulcher, Journal of the American Ceramic Society 8, 339 (1925).
  25. [25]G. Tammann and W. Hesse, Zeitschrift für anorganische und allgemeine Chemie 156, 245 (1926).
  26. [26]Q.-L. Yuan, Y.-T. Dong, Z. Yang, J. F. Douglas, F. W. Starr, Z.-Y. Sun, and W.-S. Xu, National Science Review 13, nwag366 (2026).
  27. [27]J.-L. Barrat and L. Berthier, Physical Review E 63, 12503 (2000).

Paper details

vlnc:W_yj3945qr
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents