WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Efficient low temperature simulations for fermionic reservoirs with the hierarchical equations of motion method: Application to the Anderson impurity model
Abstract
The hierarchical equations of motion (HEOM) approach is an accurate method to simulate open system quantum dynamics, which allows for systematic convergence to numerically exact results. To represent the effects of the bath, the reservoir correlation functions are usually decomposed into the summation of multiple exponential terms in the HEOM method. Since the reservoir correlation functions become highly non-Markovian at low temperatures or when the bath has complex band structures, a present challenge is to obtain accurate exponential decompositions that allow efficient simulation with the HEOM. In this work, we employ the barycentric representation to approximate the Fermi function and hybridization functions in the frequency domain. The new method, by approximating these functions with optimized rational decomposition, greatly reduces the number of basis functions in decomposing the reservoir correlation functions, which further allows the HEOM method to be applied to ultra-low temperature and general bath structures. We demonstrate the efficiency, accuracy, and long-time stability of the new decomposition scheme by applying it to the Anderson impurity model (AIM) in the low-temperature regime with the Lorentzian and tight-binding hybridization functions.
Introduction
A paradigmatic setting in solid state physics is related to a quantum system coupled to a continuum of electronic states, where a typical example is the charge transport in single-molecule junctions or through quantum dots [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. Such systems usually consist of a molecule or quantum dot attached to two metal leads, forming an open quantum system where the molecule can exchange electrons and energy with the leads. Owing to the advances in experimental techniques [6, 7, 8, 9, 10], it is now possible to measure a variety of transport properties. The experimental observations, including Coulomb blockade [8], spin blockade [11], Kondo effect [12, 13], negative differential resistance [6, 14, 15, 16], switching [17, 18], and hysteresis [19], have shown the potential of molecular junctions in the field of molecular electronics and stimulated the development of transport theory and simulation techniques.
Different methods are now available to solve the transport problem in molecular junctions and likewise for arrays of quantum dots. Approximate methods such as the quantum master equations (QMEs) [20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26], although being able to provide many useful physical insights, introduce significant approximations and are often limited to certain parameter regimes. For example, in a previous study, we have shown that QMEs based on perturbation theory fail in the strong coupling regime [27]. Many numerically exact methods have also been developed, which include the numerical renormalization group (NRG) [28, 29, 30, 31, 32], density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) [33, 34, 35, 36], and multilayer multi-configuration time-dependent Hartree (ML-MCTDH) in the second quantization representation (SQR) [37, 38, 39]. These methods usually require discretization of the lead hybridization functions, such that special treatments are needed to avoid discretization artifacts at long simulation times [39, 40, 41].
Other approaches utilize the non-interacting nature of the leads and do not require discretization. These include the path integral (PI) [42, 43, 44], continuous-time quantum Monte-Carlo (CT-QMC) [45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50], Inchworm Monte Carlo [51, 52], and the hierarchical equations of motion (HEOM) approach [27, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59].
In this work, we focus on the HEOM method originally developed by Tanimura and Kubo [60, 61]. Jin et al. [53, 62] developed the HEOM method for the Fermionic bath problem, which has later been applied to the charge transport problem in molecular junctions [55, 56, 58, 63, 64, 65, 66]. Despite this popularity, it is known that the applicability of HEOM is often limited to moderate or high temperature regimes [56, 59]. The reason is that, in the HEOM, the reservoir correlation function that describes the fluctuation and dissipation effects of the environment, are represented using a finite set of basis functions to construct the hierarchical structures. In the literature, the most widely used scheme in the moderate to high temperature regime is based on exponential decomposition of the reservoir correlation function with the aid of Matsubara expansion of the Bose/Fermi function [53, 61, 67]. At low temperatures though, the long memory time of leads to rapid growth in the number of basis functions, rendering HEOM simulations very expensive and in many cases not feasible.
To resolve this problem, several methods have been developed based on more efficient decomposition schemes of , which include the Padé spectrum decomposition (PSD) [68, 69, 70], logarithmic discretization scheme [71], orthogonal functions decomposition based on Chebyshev polynomials [72, 73, 74, 75], Hermite polynomials [76], Bessel functions [74, 77], or product of oscillatory and exponential functions [77], re-summation over poles (RSHQME) [78], and more recently, the Fano spectrum decomposition (FSD) [59, 79], and the Prony fitting decomposition (PFD) [80] schemes. These important developments have now allowed the HEOM to reach the experimentally very low temperature regimes [59, 71, 80, 81, 82], and to deal with more complex band structures of the lead [78, 80, 83, 84, 85]. However, many of these new methods still have severe limitations. For example, the RSHQME approach becomes increasingly expensive with the simulation time [78], the FSD method may suffer from asymptotic instability problem in certain parameter regimes [59]. The time domain decomposition approaches also require a large number of basis functions when increasing the simulation time [72, 76, 86].
Recently, the free-pole HEOM (FP-HEOM) method was proposed by our groups [87] based on the barycentric representation [88] of the spectrum of the reservoir correlation function as a very efficient tool to cure the above deficiencies. It shows high accuracy and computational efficiency for a broad class of bosonic reservoirs including those with sub-ohmic and bandgap spectral densities. Further, it applies to the complete temperature range down to zero temperature. In this work, we extend this framework to the charge transport problem in molecular junctions or quantum dots, where the metal leads are described by non-interacting Fermionic baths. We name this scheme the barycentric spectrum decomposition (BSD) method henceforth. The BSD method is easy to implement with available packages and the accuracy of the decomposition can be controlled by a single predefined parameter [88]. To demonstrate the performance of the BSD scheme for fermionic baths, we apply it here to simulate charge transport in the Anderson impurity model (AIM), one of the benchmark models in solid state physics.
We first use the BSD scheme to decompose the Fermi distribution function. Compared with traditional methods such as PSD, the BSD scheme is more accurate in the full fitting range, with errors not exceeding a predefined precision criteria. Moreover, the BSD scheme is superior in the low temperature regime. It is found that, to achieve a given precision, the number of BSD basis functions increases only linearly when the temperature drops exponentially, compared to the exponential increase of the number of PSD basis functions.
To demonstrate the capability to perform simulations at low temperatures and the numerical stability of the new method, the voltage-driven dynamics and the Kondo resonance in the AIM with the Lorentzian hybridization function are simulated. The observed long time hysteresis behavior at low temperature shows the numerical stability of the BSD scheme. The Kondo resonance at low temperatures is investigated by calculating the retarded Green’s function directly using the HEOM, and the results show that the efficiency and accuracy are at least comparable with the most recent PFD method [80].
Previous frequency domain decomposition schemes usually depends on writing the hybridization functions into forms where the poles can be obtained analytically [59, 65, 70, 89]. The BSD scheme also has the advantage that it does not rely on these analytical forms, and is capable to treat general forms of spectral density or hybridization functions. In the last example showing its applicability to arbitrary band structures, the charge transport dynamics of the AIM with a tight-binding hybridization function are studied. It is shown that the BSD-based HEOM can produce reliable zero temperature dynamics, in agreement with previously results from the ML-MCTDH-SQR method [90]. Moreover, quantum dynamics at different temperatures can also be explored using the BSD scheme.
The outline of this paper is as follows. In Sec. II A, we introduce the model system and the HEOM method. In Sec. II B, we present how to use the HEOM to calculate the transport current and the impurity spectral function. In Sec. II C, we present details of the BSD scheme applied to the reservoir correlation function for the Fermionic bath. Numerical results are presented in § 1, where we analyze the efficiency of the BSD scheme in decomposing the Fermi distribution function, and show that the HEOM method combined with the BSD scheme can be efficiently applied to simulate charge transport in the AIM at very low temperature, and with general band structures. Conclusions and discussions are made in § 1.2.
theory
Model Hamiltonian and the HEOM method
Within the open quantum system framework, which consists of a molecule (referred to as the “system”) attached to two metal leads (representing the “bath”), the total Hamiltonian of the AIM can be written as:
where , , and correspond to the Hamiltonian of the system, the leads, and the coupling between them, respectively. Their explicit forms are given by:
Here, denotes the two spin states, which are degenerate when there is no external magnetic field. represents the left or right lead. and are the annihilation (creation) operators of the lead and molecule electrons, with the energy and , respectively. represents the repulsive Coulomb interaction when both spin states on the molecule are occupied. is the coupling between the molecule and the th lead. The molecule-lead coupling can be characterized by the hybridization function defined as:
The reservoir correlation functions are related to the corresponding hybridization function through [53, 56, 62]:
where , and is the Fermi function for the electrons/holes.
Qualitatively, at sufficiently elevated temperatures the correlation function decays exponentially while at very low temperatures algebraic decay gives rise to long time tails. The latter depends on the details of the hybridization and Fermi function in close proximity to the Fermi level, i.e. low-frequency properties. It is this behavior that renders any numerical simulation to be highly non-trivial for low temperature Fermionic reservoirs.
We may also encounter situations where a time-dependent bias voltage is applied to the leads. In such cases, for the time-dependent voltage applied on lead , the non-stationary reservoir correlation functions are described by [53, 59, 63]:
In the HEOM, the reservoir correlation function is represented by using a finite set of basis functions [78, 79, 80]. Usually, when applying a sum-over-poles expansion of , the basis is a set of exponential functions
The HEOM for the Fermionic bath is then given by [53, 55, 66]:
where the subscript denotes , denotes , and denotes , where the combined-label index , , . The reduced density operator (RDO) is , with means that does not contain any terms. When , s are the auxiliary density operators (ADOs) that contain the system-bath correlations. is the tier of , which is the total number of terms in . . , the only term that contains the effect of time-dependent bias voltage, is . The operators and couples the th tier to the th and the th tiers, respectively. Their actions on the RDO/ADOs are given by:
For , , with , representing the system annihilation (creation) operators. More details of the above HEOM for Fermionic bath can be referred to Refs. [53, 55, 91].
In practical calculations, except for the number of basis functions in Eq. (8), the number of tiers also needs to be truncated in conventional HEOM. We denote the terminal tier level as , i.e., we set for all ADOs with . The computational cost of the HEOM in Eq. (9) increases rapidly as increases, especially when is large. To solve this problem, we employ two different approaches: the first one is based on the on-the-fly filtering method [56, 92], and the second one is the matrix product state (MPS) method to propagate the HEOM [57, 93]. By using the MPS method, the computational and memory costs increase linearly as the number of basis functions increases. Moreover, the precision control parameter in the MPS method is the bond dimension, rather than truncation tier . For more details on the MPS-HEOM, we refer to the earlier work in Ref. [57]. In our later numerical simulations, the HEOM is propagated by using the on-the-fly filtering method unless the MPS method is explicitly mentioned.
Calculation of the physical quantities
To study the transport property of the AIM, we need to calculate the transport current which is defined as , with being the electron number operator on lead and being the elementary charge. In the HEOM, can be calculated from the first-tier ADOs as [53]:
where denotes the trace over system DOFs.
When the electron-electron interaction is strong in AIM, Kondo resonance arises at low-temperature, which can be quantitatively described by the Kondo peak of the spectral function near the Fermi energy [54, 94]. Thus to verify the efficiency of BSD at low temperatures, we are interested in calculating the spectral function given by the Fourier transform of the retarded Green’s function [36, 95]:
where with describing the thermal equilibrium of the total system, is the anti-commutator.
When using the HEOM to calculate , the equations of motion are slightly different due to the anti-commuting property of the Fermion operators. As an example, we first consider the correlation function :
In this work, the equilibrium density operator of the total system is represented by all the RDO/ADOs after propagating the initial state till equilibrium. We note that there are also other methods to obtain the equilibrium state, via the imaginary time propagation [96, 97, 98, 99], or iterative solver for linear equations [100, 101]. After obtaining the equilibrium RDO/ADOs, is obtained by multiplying on the left to all equilibrium RDO/ADOs. The resulted new RDO/ADOs are then propagated to time .
Due to the anti-commutation relation between and the RDO/ADOs, the resulting HEOM for the evolution of have the same form as Eq. (9), but with the operators and replaced by and :
The superscript in the above Eq. (13) indicates that the original equilibrium RDO/ADOs is multiplied by on the left (i.e., ). Note that the additional minus sign when acts on the left of , compared to Eq. (8). It comes from constructing the equation of motion of . After taking the derivative of , we obtain terms like and . To obtain the final equation of motion, should be switched to the left or right side of , such that the left acting term (i.e. ) in Eq. (13) has an additional minus sign due to the interchange of with in . Further details can be referred to Refs. [53, 54].
After propagating to time using the above equations, the term in Eq. (15) can be obtained by multiplying with the RDO at time (i.e. ), then taking the trace over the system DOFs. For , one needs to calculate . Similarly, is realized by multiplying to the right of the equilibrium RDO/ADOs. And the HEOM for the evolution of , following the same procedure as described above, is Eq. (9) with and replaced by and
Note that the minus sign appears when acts on the right of (), due to the same reason as in Eq. (13).
Barycentric spectrum decomposition
The sum-over-poles expansion method used in this work is based on the availability of high-precision rational approximations of general functions on the real axis. A particularly suitable representation for this purpose is the barycentric representation [87, 88]:
Here, is an integer that determines the order of the rational function. The function to be approximated by is , which takes the value for with as the sample points set. is a set of support points, chosen from the sample points set. is the value of at the support point . The barycentric approximation , which uses a rational function to interpolate at the support point , selects a support points set from the sample points set, and calculates the corresponding weight [88].
In this work, we employ the adaptive Antoulas-Anderson (AAA) algorithm to obtain the parameters and in Eq. (20), which is described in detail in Ref. [88]. The AAA algorithm uses a greedy strategy to select the support points, which can be obtained with a MATLAB code [88], and also from the baryrat Python package [102]. After the barycentric representation is obtained, the pole structure of the function can be obtained from the calculated support points and weights. Namely, , with the poles and associated residues . The poles and residues can also be obtained directly from the output of the MATLAB or Python packages. It can be shown that, is a rational function of type [88], so the total number of poles is .
BSD for the Bosonic reservoir case was reported previously in Ref. [87], where it is employed to approximate the spectrum of the harmonic bath correlation function. Significant improvements of the efficiency of the HEOM at low temperatures have been observed, and simulations can even be performed at zero temperature [87]. For the Fermionic bath considered in this work using the HEOM in Eq. (9) [53], the paths associated with and are combined to define the ADOs by utilizing the relation where is defined in Eq. (8). To maintain this conventional structure of the Fermionic HEOM in Eq. (9), expansion of and should be handled together to ensure that .
To this end, by utilizing the property , we define the symmetric Fermi distribution function as
Now, and , and the reservoir correlation functions can be expressed as:
From the above equations, we need the pole structures of and to do the sum-over-poles expansion. For the pole structure of , it is possible to use the BSD expansion in Eq. (20) to approximate directly as in Ref. [87], or to approximate the two functions and separately. In practice, the two different choices may result in slightly different pole structures for the same accuracy control parameter. It should be noted that, as long as the correlation functions are faithfully reproduced, the HEOM will give the same result, although the numerical cost could be different depending on the pole structure. In this work, we choose to approximate the hybridization functions and the symmetric Fermi functions separately. An advantage of this separate decomposition scheme is that, it allows us to discuss the contribution to basis functions from the Fermi function, which is critical for the low-temperature performance of the HEOM (see the discussions later in § 1 A).
To this end the pole structures of the hybridization and Fermi functions are:
where and denote the barycentric representation of and , respectively. and are the poles and residues, where and (we omit here the subscripts and for simplicity, same for and later) are the number of poles for each function.
It is noted that and are real, so except for those on the real axis, the poles and residues should consist of conjugate pairs. The sum-over-poles expansion of the reservoir correlation functions is then expressed as the combination of the pole structure of the two approximate functions:
where denotes + or −, and denote the number of basis functions that come from the poles of and , respectively. The frequency and coupling strength are
Here, the superscript in and distinguishes the poles or residues in the upper or lower half plane, with for the upper half plane, and for the lower half plane. Thus, all the constants in Eq. (26) can be obtained using the barycentric decomposition in Eq. (20), which is used later in the HEOM.
Depending on the choice of the sample points, sometimes there are poles on the real axis. They correspond to oscillating terms without decay () in the correlation function , and are unphysical for the two types of hybridization functions considered later in Eq. (29) and Eq. (22). Two types of spurious real poles are observed: poles away from the sample point domain and those at the sharp edge of the original function. The first type of real poles is due to incompletely chosen sample points and can be eliminated by choosing a larger sample point set. The second type is related to the property of the original function. When the function (e.g. the fermi function) or its first derivative is discontinuous (e.g. near the band edge) at a certain point, real poles may occur at the discontinuity point.
There are also some tricks to eliminate the second type of real poles, such as by defining for a discontinuous function at point . It is also noted that the residue of the second type of pole tends to zero when the resolution of the sample points near the discontinuity point becomes finer. So, throwing away the unphysical poles is another way to treat the above problem. In this case, we have checked carefully that neglecting the spurious poles would not affect the accuracy of the fitted function, and the final bath correlation functions . As a consequence, and . Since and are complex conjugates, the relation still holds in the BSD scheme. Hence, the structure of traditional HEOM will not change when applying the BSD scheme for the reservoir correlation functions.
The sample points do not need to be equally spaced. This allows us to choose a point set that can focus on the regime where the function changes rapidly. In this work, logarithmic discretization [30] is used for Fermi distributions to ensure that there are enough points near the Fermi level. A simple example is , which is discretized in the domain and concentrated at , with the minimum interval controlling the fineness of the discretization. For the hybridization functions, we choose uniform discretization. In both cases, the minimum interval should be chosen to achieve a good resolution at the Fermi level or the hard band edges (if any). As long as the domain is suitable and discrete points are dense enough, slight changes in the sample point set almost do not affect the BSD result.
In summary, application of the BSD scheme to obtain the sum-over-poles expansion of the reservoir correlation function can be achieved through the following steps:
Choose the sample points sets and to discretize the Fermi distribution and the hybridization functions, respectively. The point set is in the domain covering the main scope of the hybridization function. For simplicity, we use the same domain for point sets and . The sample points do not need to be equally spaced and should focus on the regime where the function changes rapidly. The minimum interval between adjacent sample points is denoted as and , which shows the fineness of the discretization.
(2): By using the sample point set , the value set as input, and with a predefined precision control parameter that measures the accuracy of the barycentric approximation and has been integrated into the AAA algorithm [88], obtain the barycentric representation of . The same procedure is applied to obtain .
(3): Calculate the poles and residues of and . Then use them to construct and in Eqs. (26) through (20), which are the and coefficients in the HEOM in Eq. (9).
Results
In this section, we apply the BSD method to simulate the charge transport of AIM at different temperatures with different band structures. To do this, we first use the AAA algorithm to approximate the Fermi function to show the low temperature performance of BSD. The real time dynamics and the Kondo resonance of AIM with the Lorentzian hybridization functions in the low temperature regime are then explored. In the end, we demonstrate the performance of the BSD scheme for arbitrary band structures by considering AIM with the tight-binding hybridization function.
Efficient decomposition of the Fermi function at low temperature
Fig. 1 shows the performance of the BSD scheme to decompose the Fermi function (here , ) at different temperatures, compared with the conventional PSD scheme. In Figure 1(a) at , the approximate function obtained from the PSD scheme shows high accuracy at small , but it deviates significantly from the exact curve at large . As the number of PSD basis functions increases, the accuracy improves and the deviation from the exact curve occurs at much larger . Since there is usually a finite range for the hybridization function , it is usually not a problem in decomposing the reservoir correlation functions, as the deviation of PSD approximation from becomes smaller and smaller with larger numbers of basis function. The corresponding reservoir correlation function obtained from the PSD scheme then approaches the exact result, allowing systematic convergence of the HEOM.
Figure 1. Performance of the BSD scheme to approximate the Fermi function (here , ), compared with the conventional PSD scheme. Panel (a) shows the approximate Fermi functions using different schemes at . The number in the parentheses is the number of basis functions . Panels (b) and (c) present the error defined as for different schemes, at and , respectively. Here, in the BSD using the AAA algorithm, the sample points are obtained in the domain with sufficiently dense discretization, the accuracy control parameter is given by .
The approximate distribution from the BSD scheme is more accurate than the PSD with the same number of basis functions. For , the deviation of the BSD curve from the exact curve is barely noticeable on the curves shown in Figure 1(a). Figure 1(b) shows the error at , the BSD errors oscillates at small , and the maximum error does not exceed . Figure 1(c) shows the error at low temperature . For the PSD scheme, the convergence slows down as the temperature decreases, and the PSD requires nearly 10 times as many basis functions as the case to reach similar accuracy. This severely limits the application of the PSD-based HEOM at low temperatures. However, for the BSD scheme, the number of required basis functions increases only slightly as the temperature decreases, with for and for , when . This behavior greatly reduces the number of basis functions required for low-temperature simulations, indicating the superiority of the BSD scheme at low temperatures. In addition, both the and cases show that the number of required basis functions only increases slightly as the accuracy increases (by decreasing ), thus allowing for systematic convergence to numerically exact results.
Figure 2 shows the performance of the BSD scheme when setting . In this case, the Fermi distribution becomes a step function. We present the BSD results for different minimum discretization intervals , where the discretization domain is with . It can be seen that, the BSD results are affected by the interval between the points where the Fermi function jumps. And increases when decreasing : , 23, 27 for , , , respectively. We find that the BSD approximate results can only reach the step function asymptotically, and correspond to a temperature approximately one-tenth of the discretization interval (see the comparison between the curve and the Fermi function at ).
Figure 2. Performance of the BSD scheme to approximate the Fermi function (here, , ) at . The BSD results are shown for different minimum discretization intervals . The exact and Fermi functions are also shown for comparison. The sample points are obtained by discretizing the domain , and the accuracy control parameters is . The number of basis functions is given in the parentheses.
Figure 3 shows distribution of the real and imaginary parts of the complex frequencies with different . It can be seen that, the largest frequency originates from the boundary of discretization, and the smallest frequency is on the same order of the minimum interval, which corresponds to an effective very small temperature. The frequencies are nearly uniformly distributed on the logarithmic scale, confirming the moderate increase of when decreasing .
Figure 3. Distribution of real and imaginary parts of the poles in the upper half plane, i.e., in Eq. (26) (we omit the or subscripts here), for the BSD results in Figure 2.
We further characterize this logarithmic distributed BSD pole structure by plotting in Figure 4, where is the spectrum of different BSD basis functions [note that with scripts and omitted]. By assuming that are arranged in ascending order, we show the results for the 1st, 3rd, 5th, 7th, 9th, and 11th poles, for and . The results show almost linearly distributed frequencies on the logarithmic scale. Compared with the nearly growth for Matsubara [i.e. ] or Padé basis functions, the number of basis functions from the BSD increases almost linearly as the temperature decreases exponentially. This makes the BSD scheme advantageous when performing very low temperature simulations. This behavior is also similar to the logarithmic discretization in the NRG framework [30], where s replaces the discrete states in the NRG. However, since each includes a distribution of frequencies, the long-time dynamics of HEOM do not suffer from the discretization effect in the NRG approach [28, 41].
Figure 4. The spectrum of BSD basis functions for and as in Figure 2. To calculate the coupling strength using Eq. (20b), an auxiliary Lorentzian type hybridization function is chosen, with parameters , , and (the and scripts are omitted). The basis functions are sorted in ascending order of , from to , the number in the legend indicates the th basis functions. For simplicity, only the spectra for six low-frequency basis functions are shown. The inset shows the spectra in linear scale for the -axis.
Though the analytic form of the Fermi function at cannot be obtained directly from the BSD, the approximate distribution function can approach the results as we decrease the discretization interval and introduce more low-frequency terms. It is found that the weights [ in Eq. (26)] associated with low-frequencies are also very small, so the low-frequency term will contribute to the dynamics only when for all the high-frequency terms . This is illustrated in Figure 5, where we show the corresponding for the approximate BSD Fermi functions in Figure 2. To draw the reservoir correlation function , a hybridization function with Lorentzian type [defined later in Eq. (29)] is chosen with , , (here we omit the lead label ). For this hybridization function and with the Fermi energy , the real part of shows single exponential decay and only the imaginary part is affected by the temperature [80]. For simplicity, we only show in Figure 5. It can be seen from Figure 5 that, in the short time region, all the curves are the same for different BSD discretization intervals . The deviation from the exact curve only occurs at longer times, which is shown in the inset. For minimum discretization intervals , , and , the deviation appears at approximately , , and , respectively.

Figure 5. The reservoir correlation function for the approximate BSD Fermi functions in Figure 2. An auxiliary Lorentzian type hybridization function is chosen, with parameters , , and (the and scripts are omitted). The other parameters are the same as in Figure 2. For simplicity only is shown.
From the above results, one can assume that the results can be obtained using the BSD scheme for a given accuracy. With the increase of the number of basis functions, we find that the weight of the introduced low-frequency mode gets very small, such that its effect on the dynamics is very small before reaching a very long simulation time. This observation can also be understood from a different perspective: From Figure 5, obtained from the BSD scheme is the same as the zero temperature result till a long time , so one can assume that the dynamics represent the “true” zero temperature result till this time. For short-time simulations, or if the dissipation is relatively fast such that the system reaches its steady state before , the simulated dynamics is essentially at . In practice, we will show later that, for the transport dynamics of the AIM, the result obtained from BSD with a small can converge and reproduce the correct zero temperature dynamics.
Low temperature dynamics with the Lorentzian hybridization function
We first consider the Lorentzian type hybridization function that has been employed in many recent studies [27, 53, 54, 56, 59, 91], where
Here, and denote the band center and width of the lead , and is the coupling strength between the molecule and the lead . This form of hybridization function only has two simple poles that are symmetric with respect to the real axis, leading to in Eq. (26). The majority of the exponential terms in Eq. (8) thus originates from the BSD decomposition of the Fermi function.
To illustrate the numerical stability of the HEOM combined with the BSD scheme, we first calculate the voltage-driven dynamics of the AIM. In the low-temperature regime, due to the interplay between the quantum coherence and the Kondo resonance, the real-time dynamics exhibit nontrivial memory effects [63]. As shown by Zheng et al. [63], driven by an external periodic voltage, the corresponding curve show hysteresis and self-crossing feature. In a later work, by using the FSD-based HEOM, it was shown that much stronger memory effects can be observed at even lower temperatures [59]. However, the FSD has an asymptotic instability problem [59], and the time-dependent current start to diverge after a certain time. It was also shown that the instability becomes more severe when increasing the truncation tier of HEOM [59].
Figure 6 shows the dynamic characteristics for the same parameter of Figure 3 in Ref. [59], where, in units of , , , , , , , , and the ac voltage is with , . Here, the truncation tier is set to that ensures convergence. At this temperature, the BSD scheme using the AAA algorithm gives , when discretizing the Fermi functions dense enough in the domain , and setting .
Figure 6. Dynamic – characteristics for the AIM with the Lorentzian hybridization function, with an ac driving voltage . The parameters are (in units of ), , , , , , , , , and . Here, the BSD scheme is used to obtain the optimized pole structure of the Fermi function, with discretization domain and the accuracy control parameter . basis functions are used to decompose the Fermi function at this temperature. The inset shows the corresponding transient current flow out of left lead . All simulations are performed using the on-the-fly filtering algorithm with the HEOM truncation level .
To obtain the transport current, we first propagate the total system without voltage () till equilibrium, then apply the voltage to the left and right leads and propagate the system using Eq. (9). Finally, the transient current is calculated by Eq. (12). It can be seen in Figure 6 that, the characteristics are in excellent agreement with the results in Ref. [59]. The inset shows the real-time current dynamics. For longer simulations, the hysteresis loop is almost unchanged, as the curve repeats the earlier cycles. It can be seen that the current has a phase shift relative to the driving voltage, and due to the Kondo resonance, there are also overtone responses. These two features manifest themselves in the hysteresis behavior with multiple self-crossing points of characteristics [63]. Moreover, the current dynamics obtained from BSD-based HEOM runs smoothly over , compared with the FSD-based HEOM that diverges at about for [59], showing the long-time stability of the BSD scheme. We further use this example to demonstrate the accuracy of the BSD scheme. In Figure 7, we show the convergence of the transient current with respect to the BSD tolerance parameter . The other parameters are the same as Figure 6. For , the number of basis functions to decompose the Fermi function is , 9, and 11, respectively (note that for the Lorentzian hybridization function, and the number in the figure legend denotes ). It can be seen that, even with a relatively rough precision control parameter , the dynamics are very close to convergence. This shows that the BSD scheme has high precision and in the AAA algorithm is an effective precision control parameter. For , the transient current is essentially indistinguishable from those with . Based on these observations, we choose in later simulations.
Figure 7. Transient current flow out of the left lead , with different BSD accuracy control parameter . All other parameters are the same as those in Figure 6. The number in the parentheses denotes the total number of basis functions used in the simulation. The inset shows the curves near the peak current.
Figure 8 shows the Green’s function in Eq. (14), due to the similar behavior of and , only [i.e., ] is shown for simplicity. We choose the same system parameters studied previously with the PSD- [54] and FSD-based HEOM [59]. That is, in units of , , , , , and , . The two spin states are now degenerate and we drop the subscript for the spin DOF. Since parameters for the left and right leads are the same, we can combine them into a single lead with , and the number of basis functions in the HEOM can be greatly reduced. Our data are calculated using HEOM truncated at to ensure convergence. In the BSD scheme using the AAA algorithm, the Fermi distribution is discretized in the range , and , which leads to the number of basis functions for , respectively.
Figure 8. Imaginary part of the retarded Green’s function for the AIM with Lorentzian hybridization function at different temperatures. The inset shows the long-time decay, where the imaginary parts of the reservoir correlation function (in units of ) at different temperatures are also shown for comparison. The parameters are, in units of , , , , , , and . The truncation tier of HEOM is set to , and the number of basis functions used in the simulations is 5, 9, 10, 11 for , 0.075, 0.01, and 0.001, respectively. These numbers are also shown in the parentheses of the legends. In performing the BSD, the discretization domain for the Fermi distribution is , and the accuracy control parameter is .
The retarded Green’s function is calculated after propagating the system to equilibrium, which oscillates over short period of time and shows exponential decay at longer times. This exponential decay is typical for Green’s function at longer times [103, 104, 105]. For comparison, we also plot the imaginary part of the reservoir correlation function (in units of ) in the inset. It can be seen that the long-time decay of the Green’s function is essentially determined by the low-frequency effective mode of the reservoir correlation function at this temperature, which is responsible for the sharp peak of near the Fermi energy as the indication of Kondo resonance (see Figure 9). As the temperature decreases, the slope of and becomes closer, and they decay slowly such that longer simulation is required. For , we simulate the Green’s function to the exponential decay regime (about in the inset) and then employ the “linear prediction” method [103, 106, 107] to extrapolate the simulation data to longer times.
Figure 9. The impurity spectral function calculated from in Figure 8 through Eq. (13) at different temperatures. All the parameters are the same as those in Figure 8.
Figure 9 shows the spectral functions at various temperatures. The spectral function is obtained from the imaginary part of the Fourier transform of , that is, Eq. (13). For , , and , respectively, the results are consistent with those in Ref. [59]. The spectral function shows two broad peaks at impurity level energies and , which do not change significantly with the temperature. This is because the broadening is caused by coupling to the leads, such that it is on the order of and is only slightly affected by temperature. On the other hand, the peak located at the Fermi energy is significantly affected by decreasing the temperature. A sharp peak at the Fermi energy appears at low temperature, and for , the amplitude of this peak is very close to 1, which agrees with the theoretical result at [108, 109].
We also compare our BSD-HEOM result to the analytic Friedel sum rule [108, 109] at zero temperature, which is given by , with . Figure 10 shows the calculated at different temperatures, with . The red circle in Figure 10 corresponds to a symmetric AIM case with a small Coulomb repulsive energy (in units of ), where the other parameters are the same as those in Figure 8. For this symmetric AIM, at equilibrium, , the transition temperature (here we define it as the temperature at which the Kondo peak changed significantly) is about . As the temperature decreases, the amplitude of the Kondo peak, approaches 1, which verifies the Friedel sum rule and indicates the accuracy of our BSD-based HEOM.
Figure 10. The calculated at various temperatures with . The black circles labeled with are obtained using the same parameters as those in Figure 8. The red circles labeled with assume a symmetric AIM (in units of , , with all other parameters the same as those in Figure 8). The Friedel sum rule predicts at for the symmetric AIM.
The black circles in Figure 10 show the result for the parameters in Figure 8 with a larger Coulomb repulsive energy . In this case, at equilibrium for is 0.4811, and the Friedel sum rule predicts a Kondo peak amplitude at very close to 1. The transition temperature now is very low at about . We can also see that approaches the analytic result as goes down. This indicates that the calculated data contains the correct long-time behavior and the extrapolation scheme works well in these cases.
It is also noted that the results below are obtained by combining the long-time simulation data with the “linear prediction” method [103, 106]. To make the extrapolation procedure work, the HEOM needs to capture the correct dynamics till the asymptotic region where the extrapolation ansatz works, which depends on the long-time convergence of HEOM. It has been found previously that, when the truncation tier is not sufficient, HEOM does not converge and may cause overshoots of the Kondo peak [110, 111]. In more complex cases or as temperature decreased even further, a larger might be needed for the convergence of HEOM.
Low temperature dynamics with the tight-binding hybridization function
To illustrate that the BSD scheme can handle general forms of hybridization function, in this section we choose a tight-binding hybridization function with given by:
This semi-elliptical form of hybridization function has been studied previously by Wang et al. [37, 90], Wolf et al. [104, 112], and other groups [36, 113, 114, 115]. Wang et al. have used the ML-MCTDH-SQR method to explore charge transport dynamics through single-molecule junctions at zero temperature. Here, we fix and which are the same as those in Ref. [90]. As in the previous section, we set the two spin states to be degenerate.
Figure 11 shows the performance of the BSD scheme for decomposing the tight-binding hybridization function defined in Eq. (22). In the BSD scheme using the AAA algorithm, we set and discretize the hybridization function on the domain , with the minimum discretization interval . This results in for the semi-elliptical hybridization function. It can be seen that the approximate hybridization function agrees very well with the exact one, even beyond the fitting range (see the inset). From the inset, we can also see that the approximate hybridization function deviates from the exact one mainly on the hard edges, and places beyond the fitting domain. But the overall errors are smaller than the given accuracy control parameter .
Figure 11. Performance of the BSD scheme for decomposing the tight-binding hybridization function defined in Eq. (22), with and . is discretized in the domain , with the minimum discretization interval near the band edge. The accuracy control parameter results in . The inset shows the error of the BSD scheme, for the range close to the band edge and beyond the discretization domain .
Figure 12 shows the corresponding reservoir correlation function, calculated from in Figure 11, at different temperatures , , and with the source-drain voltage applied symmetrically to the left and right lead . For simplicity, only the real part of is shown. The BSD scheme results in , , and for , , and , respectively. Compared with the Lorentzian hybridization function, the tight-binding hybridization function results in oscillating reservoir correlation functions with the frequency associated with bandwidth. The hard edge of the tight-binding hybridization function, like the Fermi function at shown in Figure 2, leads to many poles with small decay constants and weights . The minimum is found to be slightly smaller than .
Figure 12. The reservoir correlation function at different temperatures, for in Figure 11. For simplicity, only the real part is presented. Here, , , and the Fermi functions are discretized in the domain , with . For , the minimum discretization interval is . The number of basis functions used to decompose the Fermi function is for , and , respectively. The inset shows the long-time behavior.
When the minimum from the Fermi distribution is larger than the minimum , the decay of is controlled by temperature at short time, and is controlled by the basis functions obtained from the tight-binding hybridization function at longer time. This is shown in and curves. At short time, the decay of the high-temperature correlation function is faster than the low-temperature one at . But at longer times, the two curves almost coincide as shown in the inset of Figure 12. When the temperature is low enough, the decay of is mainly controlled by the temperature. Indeed, the approximate with obtained with shows rather different long-time behavior.
Although as discussed previously in § 1 A, the approximate corresponds to a very small effective temperature as shown in Figure 2, it can be seen from the inset of Figure 12 that, the approximate and exact correlation functions agree with each other over a very long time range. In this sense, we can conclude that within this time range, the dynamics obtained from the approximate should essentially be the same as the “true” zero temperature dynamics at . Moreover, though not shown in the figure, in the temperature-controlled decay regime, the decay rate of the reservoir correlation function is the same for different forms of hybridization functions, which will result in the same decay rate of the Green’s function as in Figure 8, such that the Kondo resonance of different types of hybridization functions at low temperature should not change significantly [80].
We then study the current dynamics of the AIM with the tight-binding hybridization function at different temperatures. Figure 13 shows the current dynamics for the non-interacting case . In this case, the HEOM with leads to exact results [53]. The energy of the system state is eV, eV such that the bias voltage is 0.1 V. This parameter corresponds to the so called off-resonant transport regime [90]. The other parameters for the hybridization or Fermi functions are the same as those in Figure 12. In the simulation, the initial system state is doubly occupied. In this case, the current shows transient oscillations at short time that decay due to the coupling to the leads. When the temperature is relatively high, we can see another high-frequency oscillation with frequency fs (2 eV) which corresponds to the band edge of the semi-elliptical hybridization function.
Figure 13. (a) The average current of the non-interacting AIM () with the tight-binding hybridization function at different temperatures. Here, , , , , and the bias voltage is symmetrically applied to two leads: . The BSD result is the same as in Figure 12, with , , , for , , , respectively. The case (), though at an unrealistic high temperature, is also shown for comparison. (b) The average steady state current at different bias voltage, the other parameters are same as those in panel (a).
At low temperatures, the lead states at the band edge do not contribute to the transport process. So as the temperature decreases, the high-frequency oscillation is suppressed. The steady state current is suppressed as the temperature decreases, since the conductive window is reduced. As can be seen from Figure 13(a), the eV result is already very close to that at , indicating that the system is already in the low temperature regime. Further lowering the temperature will only lead to very minor changes of the dynamics. Moreover, our results obtained from the BSD scheme agree well with the results in Ref. [90].
Figure 13(b) gives the steady state current as a function of the bias voltage, with all other parameters fixed. At high temperature eV, the characteristics at this bias range in almost linear. When lowering the temperature, the conductance increases after entering the resonant transport regime. The curve is almost unchanged for the eV and cases obtained from the BSD-based HEOM, which further shows that eV is already in the low temperature regime. It is noted that for the non-interacting case , the stationary current can be obtained exactly from the Landauer-Büttiker formula [27, 95]. As shown in Figure 13(b), the BSD-based HEOM results at agrees well with those from the Landauer-Büttiker formula, indicating that the results are converged.
We then study the current dynamics of AIM in the presence of electron-electron repulsive energy . This is much more challenging than the non-interacting case since the HEOM must be truncated at a higher tier. At low temperatures, the needed truncation tier for high accuracy is relatively high. Our traditional HEOM code based on the filtering approach can not handle the computational and memory costs to get converged results at (), for truncation tier higher than . In this case, we resort to the MPS-HEOM method [57] to reduce the computational costs.
Figure 14 shows the current dynamics of the AIM with , with all the other parameters being the same as those in Figure 13. Here the result is obtained using MPS-HEOM [57] with maximum bond dimension up to 500. Comparing to Figure 13(a), the case has a larger current. This is because that, the energy change from the single occupied state to the doubly occupied state, , moves close to the Fermi energy and provides a channel for resonant transport. In the case, the transport becomes incoherent for a short period of time. Moreover, the temperature dependence of the current is reversed, that is, decreasing the temperature results in an increase in the current. The reason is that, decreasing the temperature reduces the fluctuations, and increases the probability of resonant transport. It can be seen that, the high-frequency oscillation of the current which is the band edge effect appears even at low temperature. While in the case, this effect only appears at high temperatures. The case is found to be already in the low-temperature regime, where the dynamics are only slightly different from the result in the transient regime, and the steady-state currents are almost the same. Our results agree well with those in Ref. [90], which verifies the validity of the BSD scheme for zero temperature dynamics. The relaxation process of the current to stationary value is also slower at low temperatures, due to the long time memory effect.
Figure 14. Time evolution of the average transport current of the AIM with the tight-binding hybridization function at different temperatures. The electron-electron repulsive energy is , all the other parameters are the same as those in Figure 13(a). The result is obtained using MPS-HEOM with the maximum bond dimension up to 500.
Conclusion and Discussion
In this paper, we have proposed to use the BSD scheme for the sum-over-poles decomposition of the Fermionic reservoir correlation functions. The BSD scheme based on rational function approximation of barycentric form can be used to calculate optimized pole structure than the analytical Matsubara and PSD poles, thus is superior in low-temperature simulations. This decomposition scheme is easy to implement with existing software packages. By approximating the reservoir correlation functions and with the same set of poles, the traditional structure of the HEOM is also maintained. With the BSD scheme, we can apply the HEOM to the AIM in the low-temperature regime even at for dynamic simulation with high efficiency, accuracy, and long-time stability. The improvements of BSD over previous HEOM-based methods such as PSD [68, 69, 70] and FSD [59, 79] in efficiency and long-time stability, as well as the ability to deal with arbitrary band structures, offer new opportunities for applications in lower temperatures or more realistic systems.
To demonstrate the performance of the BSD scheme, we first apply it to approximate the Fermi function, the results show that the number of required basis functions grows almost linearly as the temperature decreases exponentially, compared to the exponential growth of the widely used PSD scheme. The low temperature performance is further demonstrated by calculating the Kondo peak of the impurity spectral function of the AIM with the Lorentzian hybridization function. The characteristics under an voltage have also been simulated, showing the accuracy and long-time stability of the HEOM combined with the BSD scheme. Furthermore, to illustrate the application to arbitrary band structures, we apply the BSD scheme to the AIM with a tight-binding band structure, where the hybridization function has no analytic poles. Combined with the MPS-HEOM [57], the current dynamics at different temperatures and even at have been explored.
We have also pointed out that the BSD scheme cannot really reach the Fermi function at which is discontinuous at the Fermi energy. The approximate function for based on BSD can be regarded as the Fermi function at a very small temperature related to the smallest discretizing interval . In the time domain, the simulated results based on BSD reflect the true dynamics within a time range determined by which in many cases can be chosen sufficiently large to approach the steady-state regime.
Compared to other widely used methods such as the QMC [45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52] and time-dependent NRG (TD-NRG) [28, 29, 30, 31], the long-time dynamics of HEOM do not suffer from discretization problems, and its computation cost grows linearly as time increases. The BSD scheme in this work also significantly increases the capability of HEOM in the low-temperature regime and for more complex band structures. Thus, we believe that BSD-based HEOM could become the method of choice for certain types of applications, especially in long-time simulations that may be difficult for the QMC and TD-NRG methods.
Recently, some of us have developed the generalized master equation (GME) method to calculate the exact memory kernel from physical quantities such as population and current [27]. The memory kernels, which usually decay within a short period of time, can be used to produce reliable long-time dynamics [116, 117]. Combining this method with the BSD scheme may allow us to calculate efficiently asymptotic long-time dynamics and stationary state properties at for even broader classes of hybridization functions.
With the development of the HEOM method and new algorithms including the MPS-HEOM [57] with efficient time evolution methods [118, 119], Tree-Tensor HEOM [120], and the hierarchical Schrödinger equations of motion (HSEOM) [74], the BSD scheme provides a new method for the simulation of realistic systems at low temperatures. Moreover, the methodology can be applied to other approaches based on an expansion of reservoir correlation functions or Green’s functions, such as the hierarchy of pure states (HOPS) [121], the non-equilibrium Green’s function (NEGF) [122, 123, 124] methods, and the nonequilibrium dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) [125].
Acknowledgments
X.D. and Q.S. thank the financial support from NSFC (Grant No. 21933011) and the K. C. Wong Education Foundation. M.X., J.T.S., and J.A. gratefully acknowledge financial support from the DFG via AN336/12-1 (FOR2724) and the BMBF through QCOMP within the Cluster4Future QSens.
References
References
- [1]M. Galperin, M. A. Ratner, A. Nitzan, and A. Troisi, Science 319, 1056 (2008).
- [2]N. A. Zimbovskaya, Transport Properties of Molecular Junctions, Vol. 254 (Springer, New York, 2013).DOI
- [3]M. Ratner, Nature Nanotech. 8, 378 (2013).
- [4]D. Xiang, X. Wang, C. Jia, T. Lee, and X. Guo, Chem. Rev. 116, 4318 (2016).
- [5]M. Thoss and F. Evers, J. Chem. Phys. 148, 030901 (2018).
- [6]J. Chen, M. Reed, A. Rawlett, and J. Tour, Science 286, 1550 (1999).
- [7]H. Park, J. Park, A. K. Lim, E. H. Anderson, A. P. Alivisatos, and P. L. McEuen, Nature 407, 57 (2000).
- [8]J. Park, A. N. Pasupathy, J. I. Goldsmith, C. Chang, Y. Yaish, J. R. Petta, M. Rinkoski, J. P. Sethna, H. D. Abruña, P. L. McEuen, et al., Nature 417, 722 (2002).
- [9]B. Xu and N. J. Tao, Science 301, 1221 (2003).
- [10]X. Qiu, G. V. Nazin, and W. Ho, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 206102 (2004).
- [11]H. B. Heersche, Z. De Groot, J. A. Folk, H. S. J. Van Der Zant, C. Romeike, M. R. Wegeweijs, L. Zobbi, D. Barreca, E. Tondello, and A. Cornia, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 206801 (2006).
- [12]W. Liang, M. P. Shores, M. Bockrath, J. R. Long, and H. Park, Nature 417, 725 (2002).
- [13]J. J. Parks, A. R. Champagne, T. A. Costi, W. W. Shum, A. N. Pasupathy, E. Neuscamman, S. Flores-Torres, P. S. Cornaglia, A. A. Aligia, C. A. Balseiro, et al., Science 328, 1370 (2010).
- [14]E. A. Osorio, M. Ruben, J. S. Seldenthuis, J. M. Lehn, and H. S. van der Zant, Small 6, 174 (2010).
- [15]J. Gaudioso, L. J. Lauhon, and W. Ho, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 1918 (2000).
- [16]B. Xu and Y. Dubi, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 27, 263202 (2015).
- [17]A. S. Blum, J. G. Kushmerick, D. P. Long, C. H. Patterson, J. C. Yang, J. C. Henderson, Y. Yao, J. M. Tour, R. Shashidhar, and B. R. Ratna, Nat. Mater. 4, 167 (2005).
- [18]B.-Y. Choi, S.-J. Kahng, S. Kim, H. Kim, H. W. Kim, Y. J. Song, J. Ihm, and Y. Kuk, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 156106 (2006).
- [19]S. Ballmann, R. Hartle, P. B. Coto, M. Elbing, M. Mayor, M. R. Bryce, M. Thoss, and H. B. Weber, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 056801 (2012).
- [20]A. Mitra, I. Aleiner, and A. Millis, Phys. Rev. B 69, 245302 (2004).
- [21]A. Donarini, M. Grifoni, and K. Richter, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 166801 (2006).
- [22]C. Timm, Phys. Rev. B 77, 195416 (2008).
- [23]M. Leijnse and M. R. Wegewijs, Phys. Rev. B 78, 235424 (2008).
- [24]M. Esposito and M. Galperin, Phys. Rev. B 79, 205303 (2009).
- [25]R. Hartle and M. Thoss, Phys. Rev. B 83, 115414 (2011).
- [26]A. Levy, L. Kidon, J. Batge, J. Okamoto, M. Thoss, D. T. Limmer, and E. Rabani, J. Phys. Chem. C 123, 13538 (2019).
- [27]X. Dan, M. Xu, Y. Yan, and Q. Shi, J. Chem. Phys. 156, 134114 (2022).
- [28]F. B. Anders and A. Schiller, Phys. Rev. Lett. 95, 196801 (2005).
- [29]F. B. Anders and A. Schiller, Phys. Rev. B 74, 245113 (2006).
- [30]R. Bulla, T. A. Costi, and T. Pruschke, Rev. Mod. Phys. 80, 395 (2008).
- [31]H. T. M. Nghiem and T. A. Costi, Phys. Rev. B 98, 155107 (2018).
- [32]B. M. de Souza Melo, L. G. G. V. D. da Silva, A. R. Rocha, and C. Lewenkopf, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 32, 095602 (2019).
- [33]U. Schollwöck, Rev. Mod. Phys. 77, 259 (2005).
- [34]F. Heidrich-Meisner, A. E. Feiguin, and E. Dagotto, Phys. Rev. B 79, 235336 (2009).
- [35]Z. He and A. J. Millis, Phys. Rev. B 99, 205138 (2019).
- [36]L. Kohn and G. E. Santoro, Phys. Rev. B 104, 014303 (2021).
- [37]H. Wang and M. Thoss, J. Chem. Phys. 131, 024114 (2009).
- [38]H. Wang, I. Pshenichnyuk, R. Haertle, and M. Thoss, J. Chem. Phys. 135, 244506 (2011).
- [39]H. Wang and M. Thoss, Chem. Phys. 509, 13 (2018).
- [40]S. Nishimoto and E. Jeckelmann, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 16, 613 (2004).
- [41]R. Žitko and T. Pruschke, Phys. Rev. B 79, 085106 (2009).
- [42]S. Weiss, J. Eckel, M. Thorwart, and R. Egger, Phys. Rev. B 77, 195316 (2008).
- [43]D. Segal, A. J. Millis, and D. R. Reichman, Phys. Rev. B 82, 205323 (2010).
- [44]S. Weiss, R. Hützen, D. Becker, J. Eckel, R. Egger, and M. Thorwart, Phys. Status Solidi B 250, 2298 (2013).
- [45]L. Mühlbacher and E. Rabani, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 176403 (2008).
- [46]P. Werner, T. Oka, and A. J. Millis, Phys. Rev. B 79, 035320 (2009).
- [47]M. Schiró and M. Fabrizio, Phys. Rev. B 79, 153302 (2009).
- [48]E. Gull, A. J. Millis, A. I. Lichtenstein, A. N. Rubtsov, M. Troyer, and P. Werner, Rev. Mod. Phys. 83, 349 (2011).
- [49]A. E. Antipov, Q. Dong, and E. Gull, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 036801 (2016).
- [50]I. Krivenko, J. Kleinhenz, G. Cohen, and E. Gull, Phys. Rev. B 100, 201104 (2019).
- [51]G. Cohen, E. Gull, D. R. Reichman, and A. J. Millis, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 266802 (2015).
- [52]A. E. Antipov, Q. Dong, J. Kleinhenz, G. Cohen, and E. Gull, Phys. Rev. B 95, 085144 (2017).
- [53]J.-S. Jin, X. Zheng, and Y.-J. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 128, 234703 (2008).
- [54]Z.-H. Li, N.-H. Tong, X. Zheng, D. Hou, J.-H. Wei, J. Hu, and Y.-J. Yan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 266403 (2012).
- [55]R. Härtle, G. Cohen, D. R. Reichman, and A. J. Millis, Phys. Rev. B 88, 235426 (2013).
- [56]R. Härtle, G. Cohen, D. Reichman, and A. Millis, Phys. Rev. B 92, 085430 (2015).
- [57]Q. Shi, Y. Xu, Y. Yan, and M. Xu, J. Chem. Phys. 148, 174102 (2018).
- [58]A. Erpenbeck, L. Götzendörfer, C. Schinabeck, and M. Thoss, Eur. Phys. J.-Spec. Top. 227, 1981 (2019).
- [59]H.-D. Zhang, L. Cui, H. Gong, R.-X. Xu, X. Zheng, and Y. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 152, 064107 (2020).
- [60]Y. Tanimura and R. Kubo, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 58, 101 (1989).
- [61]Y. Tanimura, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 75, 082001 (2006).
- [62]J.-S. Jin, S. Welack, J.-Y. Luo, X.-Q. Li, P. Cui, R.-X. Xu, and Y.-J. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 126, 134113 (2007).
- [63]X. Zheng, Y. Yan, and M. Di Ventra, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 086601 (2013).
- [64]X. Wang, D. Hou, X. Zheng, and Y. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 144, 034101 (2016).
- [65]Y. Wang, X. Zheng, and J. Yang, J. Chem. Phys. 145, 154301 (2016).
- [66]C. Schinabeck, A. Erpenbeck, R. Härtle, and M. Thoss, Phys. Rev. B 94, 201407 (2016).
- [67]Y. Tanimura, Phys. Rev. A 41, 6676 (1990).
- [68]T. Ozaki, Phys. Rev. B 75, 035123 (2007).
- [69]J. Hu, R.-X. Xu, and Y.-J. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 133, 101106 (2010).
- [70]J. Hu, M. Luo, F. Jiang, R.-X. Xu, and Y.-J. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 134, 244106 (2011).
- [71]L. Ye, H.-D. Zhang, Y. Wang, X. Zheng, and Y. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 147, 074111 (2017).
- [72]H. Tian and G.-H. Chen, J. Chem. Phys. 137, 204114 (2012).
- [73]B. Popescu, H. Rahman, and U. Kleinekathöfer, J. Chem. Phys. 142, 154103 (2015).
- [74]K. Nakamura and Y. Tanimura, Phys. Rev. A 98, 012109 (2018).
- [75]H. Rahman and U. Kleinekathöfer, J. Chem. Phys. 150, 244104 (2019).
- [76]Z. Tang, X. Ouyang, Z. Gong, H. Wang, and J. Wu, J. Chem. Phys. 143, 224112 (2015).
- [77]T. Ikeda and G. D. Scholes, J. Chem. Phys. 152, 204101 (2020).
- [78]A. Erpenbeck, C. Hertlein, C. Schinabeck, and M. Thoss, J. Chem. Phys. 149, 064106 (2018).
- [79]L. Cui, H.-D. Zhang, X. Zheng, R.-X. Xu, and Y. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 151, 024110 (2019).
- [80]Z.-H. Chen, Y. Wang, X. Zheng, R.-X. Xu, and Y. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 156, 221102 (2022).
- [81]Z. Li, J. Wei, X. Zheng, Y. Yan, and H.-G. Luo, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 29, 175601 (2017).
- [82]L. Han, H.-D. Zhang, X. Zheng, and Y. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 148, 234108 (2018).
- [83]X. Zheng, J.-S. Jin, S. Welack, M. Luo, and Y.-J. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 130, 164708 (2009).
- [84]H. Xie, Y. Kwok, Y. Zhang, F. Jiang, X. Zheng, Y. Yan, and G. Chen, Phys. Status Solidi B 250, 2481 (2013).
- [85]D. Hou, R. Wang, X. Zheng, N. Tong, J. Wei, and Y. Yan, Phys. Rev. B 90, 045141 (2014).
- [86]C. Duan, Z. Tang, J. Cao, and J. Wu, Phys. Rev. B 95, 214308 (2017).
- [87]M. Xu, Y. Yan, Q. Shi, J. Ankerhold, and J. T. Stockburger, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 230601 (2022).
- [88]Y. Nakatsukasa, O. Sète, and L. N. Trefethen, SIAM J SCI COMPUT 40, A1494 (2018).
- [89]H. Liu, L. Zhu, S. Bai, and Q. Shi, J. Chem. Phys. 140, 134106 (2014).
- [90]H. Wang and M. Thoss, J. Chem. Phys. 138, 134704 (2013).
- [91]M. Xu, L. Song, K. Song, and Q. Shi, J. Chem. Phys. 146, 064102 (2017).
- [92]Q. Shi, L.-P. Chen, G.-J. Nan, R.-X. Xu, and Y.-J. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 130, 084105 (2009).
- [93]Y. Ke, R. Borrelli, and M. Thoss, J. Chem. Phys. 156, 194102 (2022).
- [94]A. C. Hewson, The Kondo problem to heavy fermions (Cambridge university press, 1997).
- [95]G. D. Mahan, Many-Particle Physics (Kluwer Academic/Plenum, New York, 2000).
- [96]Y. Tanimura, J. Chem. Phys. 141, 044114 (2014).
- [97]L. Song and Q. Shi, J. Chem. Phys. 143, 194106 (2015).
- [98]T. Xing, T. Li, Y. Yan, S. Bai, and Q. Shi, J. Chem. Phys. 156, 244102 (2022).
- [99]Y. Ke, C. Kaspar, A. Erpenb ecka, U. Peskin, and M. Thoss, J. Chem. Phys. 157, 034103 (2022).
- [100]L. Ye, X. Wang, D. Hou, R.-X. Xu, X. Zheng, and Y. Yan, Wiley Interdiscip. Rev.: Comput. Mol. Sci. 6, 608 (2016).
- [101]C. Kaspar and M. Thoss, J. Phys. Chem. A 125, 5190 (2021).
- [102]C. Hofreither, Numer Algorithms 88, 365 (2021).
- [103]T. Barthel, U. Schollwöck, and S. R. White, Phys. Rev. B 79, 245101 (2009).
- [104]F. A. Wolf, A. Go, I. P. McCulloch, A. J. Millis, and U. Schollwöck, Phys. Rev. X 5, 041032 (2015).
- [105]F. A. Wolf, J. A. Justiniano, I. P. McCulloch, and U. Schollwöck, Phys. Rev. B 91, 115144 (2015).
- [106]S. R. White and I. Affleck, Phys. Rev. B 77, 134437 (2008).
- [107]M. Ganahl, M. Aichhorn, H. G. Evertz, P. Thunström, K. Held, and F. Verstraete, Phys. Rev. B 92, 155132 (2015).
- [108]D. C. Langreth, Phys. Rev. 150, 516 (1966).
- [109]J. Martinek, M. Sindel, L. Borda, J. Barnáš, J. König, G. Schön, and J. Von Delft, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 247202 (2003).
- [110]D. Zhang, X. Ding, H.-D. Zhang, X. Zheng, and Y. Yan, Chin. J. Chem. Phys. 34, 905 (2022).
- [111]X. Ding, D. Zhang, L. Ye, X. Zheng, and Y. Yan, J. Chem. Phys. 157, 224107 (2022).
- [112]F. A. Wolf, I. P. McCulloch, and U. Schollwöck, Phys. Rev. B 90, 235131 (2014).
- [113]M. Karski, C. Raas, and G. S. Uhrig, Phys. Rev. B 77, 075116 (2008).
- [114]A. Dorda, M. Nuss, W. von der Linden, and E. Arrigoni, Phys. Rev. B 89, 165105 (2014).
- [115]G. Wójtowicz, J. E. Elenewski, M. M. Rams, and M. Zwolak, Phys. Rev. B 104, 165131 (2021).
- [116]G. Cohen and E. Rabani, Phys. Rev. B 84, 075150 (2011).
- [117]G. Cohen, E. Y. Wilner, and E. Rabani, New. J. Phys. 15, 073018 (2013).
- [118]M. Yang and S. R. White, Phys. Rev. B 102, 094315 (2020).
- [119]R. Borrelli and S. Dolgov, J. Phys. Chem. B 125, 5397 (2021).
- [120]Y. Yan, Y. Liu, T. Xing, and Q. Shi, Wiley Interdiscip. Rev.: Comput. Mol. Sci. 11, e1498 (2021).
- [121]D. Suess, A. Eisfeld, and W. T. Strunz, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 150403 (2014).
- [122]K. Beach, R. Gooding, and F. Marsiglio, Phys. Rev. B 61, 5147 (2000).
- [123]A. Croy and U. Saalmann, Phys. Rev. B 80, 245311 (2009).
- [124]J. Gu, J. Chen, Y. Wang, and X.-G. Zhang, Comput. Phys. Commun. 253, 107178 (2020).
- [125]E. Arrigoni, M. Knap, and W. Von Der Linden, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 086403 (2013).



