betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Constraining the Inner Dark Matter Profiles of Strong-Lensing Galaxy Clusters

Abstract

We present mass modeling of three strong lensing galaxy clusters found in the Dark Energy Survey utilizing Hubble Space Telescope imaging for lens modeling, and complementary constraints from Chandra X-ray observations. All three clusters are relaxed and have giant arc or ring lens structures ideal for constraints on the dark matter distribution. The strong lens modeling and X-ray temperatures yield consistent total cluster mass estimates. We find these clusters have best-fit X-ray temperatures of 2.7−6.22.7 - 6.2 keV and total masses of M200=(1−6)×1014M⊙_{200} = (1-6) \times 10^{14} M_{\odot}. Our lens models parameterize dark matter distribution with a generalized Navarro-Frenk-White (GNFW) density profile. While the GNFW profile allows the inner dark matter slope to vary, we find in all cases that the inner slopes are consistent with the standard NFW density profile γDM=1γ^{DM} = 1. The X-ray surface brightness distributions for all three clusters are generally symmetric with no significant substructure, supporting the conclusion that these are relaxed clusters. In addition, we find generally low values of the external shear magnitude with median values ranging ∣γext∣=0.04−0.09|γ^{ext}| = 0.04-0.09 and consistent with zero for two of the clusters.

Introduction

Strong gravitational lensing by galaxy clusters provides a powerful tool for studying the formation and evolution of large-scale structures, and strong lensing clusters are also powerful gravitational telescopes, allowing the study of the high-redshift universe. In particular, strong lensing offers a direct probe of the total mass distribution in the innermost region of the cluster. This allows the central mass distribution of the cluster to be well constrained, particularly when extended features such as giant arcs or partial Einstein rings are present (see e.g. Natarajan et al. 2024, for a recent review).

Strong lensing is thus a powerful tool, not only for cluster mass estimation, but also for testing the shape of the inner dark matter density profile where varying dark matter models make divergent predictions. In particular, cold dark matter (CDM) models predict cuspy inner density profiles while non-CDM models, including self-interacting dark matter (SIDM), warm dark matter (WDM), and fuzzy dark matter (FDM), generically predict shallower, cored profiles (e.g. Spergel & Steinhardt 2000; Hu et al. 2000; Schive et al. 2014; Kaplinghat et al. 2016; Hui et al. 2017; Tulin & Yu 2018; Despali et al. 2026). Because clusters are strongly dark matter dominated, and their strong lensing signal is generated on scales comparable to the core radii where these models diverge, cluster-scale strong lensing has emerged as a sensitive test for underlying dark matter properties (Newman et al. 2013; Sagunski et al. 2021; Andrade et al. 2022; O’Donnell et al. 2026).

Extracting robust constraints on the inner dark matter density profile from lensing alone is complicated by the need to separate the dark matter distribution from the baryonic mass contribution and by uncertainties in the cluster structure, e.g. substructure in merging clusters. Combining strong lens modeling with X-ray observations mitigates both issues. The X-ray surface brightness morphology serves as an established diagnostic of dynamical relaxation (e.g. Mohr et al. 1993; Buote & Tsai 1996; Jeltema et al. 2005; Poole et al. 2006; Yuan et al. 2022; Véliz Astudillo et al. 2025). A lack of substructure in X-ray with symmetric, centrally peaked emission indicates an undisturbed system, while the X-ray temperature provides a mass estimate that is independent of lensing, offering a valuable consistency check on the total mass (e.g. Sarazin 1986; Rosati et al. 2002; Voit 2005; Allen et al. 2011).

In this paper, we present strong lens models for three galaxy clusters identified in the Dark Energy Survey (DES), selected for their giant arc or ring-like lensing features that provide strong geometric constraints and indicate relaxed systems based on the symmetry of their arc systems. We combine Hubble Space Telescope (HST) imaging, for lens modeling, with Chandra X-ray observations, which we use to confirm the dynamical state and to obtain an independent temperature-based mass estimate. We model the dark matter distribution in each cluster with a generalized NFW profile that allows the inner slope to vary as a free parameter. By comparing the recovered inner slopes to the standard CDM prediction, we test whether these relaxed cluster cores favor the cuspy profiles expected under collisionless CDM or show evidence for the shallower cores predicted by non-CDM dark matter models.

In Section 2, we outline the properties of the strong lens clusters chosen and the optical and X-ray data sets used. Section 3 discusses the strong lens modeling and the model components, as well as the X-ray spectral extraction and modeling. In Section 4, we give our results, and Sections 5 and 6 present our discussion and conclusions.

Data Selection & System Characteristics

Description of Cluster Systems

Lens modeling and X-ray analysis is presented for three strong-lensing cluster systems: DESJ0424-3317, DESJ2349-5113, and DESJ2351-5452 (hereafter referred to as DESJ0424, DESJ2349, and DESJ2351) selected from cluster lenses in the Dark Energy Survey (DES) by O’Donnell et al. (2022). Basic properties of these systems, including source and lens redshifts, are listed in Table 1. We have chosen these specific systems for our modeling for several reasons, including their similar redshifts that range approximately z=0.4−0.6z = 0.4 - 0.6, and for the availability of HST imaging data for all systems, providing a high resolution data set for lens modeling. The lensed source galaxies range in redshift from z=0.9−1.4z = 0.9 - 1.4.

These systems were selected as likely relaxed clusters displaying symmetric lensing features and a dominant central galaxy, leading to a comparably simplified lens modeling. This is confirmed by our X-ray observations; they exhibit relatively round X-ray emission lacking significant substructure (see § 4.2, Figure 2), likewise indicating that they are relaxed clusters.

X-ray contours superimposed on Legacy Sky Surveys images of the three clusters

Figure 2. X-ray contours superimposed on Legacy Sky Surveys images of the three clusters. The X-ray emission does not show signs of substructure, is centered on the clusters, and is roughly spherical. In the case of DESJ2349, an X-ray point source can be seen to the southwest.

Additionally, each of these systems displays giant arcs and counter arcs. As seen in Figure 1, all three systems have near ring-like lens structures. This figure shows the HST imaging with both a zoom in on the lensing region (right panels) and the larger cluster field (left panels).

HST imaging of each cluster system with grid axes in degrees

Figure 1. HST imaging of each cluster system with grid axes in degrees. The right-hand panels show the features used to model each cluster in green, along with our chosen pivot galaxy in red, and the BCG in blue. The left-hand panels show the cluster member galaxies obtained from the DR10 catalogs. The selection of these objects are described in § 3 and further physical details on the used features are available in Table 2.

DESI Legacy Survey Imaging

We use the object catalogs for our cluster regions from Data Release 10 (DR10) of the DESI Legacy Imaging Surveys (hereafter referred to as the Legacy Surveys) (Dey et al. (2019)). Sky coordinates and magnitudes of each cluster’s member galaxies (shown in Figure 1) are obtained from the DR10 object catalogs. Specifically, we used the Legacy Surveys r- and i-band magnitudes to estimate cluster membership and to model the member galaxy mass contributions through the Faber-Jackson relation, as explained in further detail in § 3.1 and § 3.3.

Hubble Space Telescope Imaging

Additionally, this analysis relies on high-resolution imaging data provided by HST to extract lensed source positions. Our data covering systems DESJ0424 and DESJ2349 utilize both the IR and UVIS channels on the telescope’s Wide Field Camera 3 (WFC3) with the F140W wide-band filter and F200LP long-pass filter, respectively. The data for the aforementioned systems are available under program number 16773 (PI Karl Glazebrook). The data covering the DESJ2351 system use the now retired Wide-Field Planetary Camera 2 (WFPC2) with the wide-band filters F450W and F814W (McMaster, M. & Biretta, J. [47]). This data set is available under program number 11974 (PI Sahar Allam). While the wide-band filters onboard HST provide a wide coverage of wavelengths ranging from blue to near-IR, the long-pass filters provide the necessary depth on faint sources.

These data have a pixel scale of 0.05 – 0.1 arcsec, giving the resolution necessary to precisely locate features in the source galaxies and enabling strong-lens modeling.

Chandra X-ray Imaging

The three target clusters were observed by Chandra with the Advanced CCD Imaging Spectrometer (ACIS), specifically using the ACIS-I CCD array in FAINT mode. Observations were made for DESJ2351 in October 2023 for 15.57 ks (ObsID 6925); DESJ2349 was observed for 29.70 ks in September 2024 (ObsID 6924), and three combined observations were completed for DESJ0424 in November 2023 and March 2024 for a total of 54.56 ks (ObsIDs 26926, 27193, and 29343). The collected data were reduced using the Chandra Interactive Analysis for Observations (CIAO) 4.17 software package (Fruscione et al. 2006; Fruscione et al. 2026).

This reduction begins by first reprocessing the level-1 event files into level-2 event files using the chandra_repro script, automating the data processing procedure recommended in the CIAO analysis. Background flares were then detected and removed with the lc_sigma_clip script using the light curve extracted in the 0.5 – 5.0 keV energy range. Using CIAO’s dmstat, we checked whether the observations exhibited significant variation in focal-plane temperature, and if they did, the data were split into separate temperature ranges for calibration, which was necessary for DESJ2349 and DESJ0424 (ObsIDs 26926 and 27193).

Figure 2 shows contours of the Chandra X-ray emission overlaid on the Legacy Survey images.

Methodology

Member Galaxy Selection

Our lens modeling procedure can be divided into several stages, beginning first with a series of vetting procedures applied to the data to determine potential cluster member galaxies. We subject all astronomical objects within our catalogs to the following criteria, with objects satisfying these criteria retained as likely member galaxies. Member galaxies are limited by their proximity to the cluster center, specifically to a radial distance within 30 arcsec from the Brightest Cluster Galaxy (BCG), and by a threshold on their color, which we restrict to an r−ir-i color value below -0.5. Furthermore, we apply a threshold on absolute magnitude for potential members, which we have applied differently depending on the system. Objects in systems DESJ0424 and DESJ2349 are restricted to an absolute r-band magnitude less than 24.1, while objects in system DESJ2351 are limited to an absolute r-band magnitude less than 23.7. These various limits ensure our data sets contain only cluster member galaxies and limit the sample to galaxies close enough to the center and large enough to meaningfully impact the lens modeling.

The effect of these member galaxies on lensing is modeled following a scaling procedure defined in § 3.3 that is based on the physical properties of a reference galaxy, which we call the pivot galaxy. To provide a stable reference with which to relate the member galaxies, the most central and brightest galaxy (apart from the BCG) in the cluster is chosen to act as the pivot. This ensures high confidence in the physical properties we use

SystemRA (deg)Dec (deg)zlensz_{\mathrm{lens}}zsourcez_{\mathrm{source}}References
DESJ0424-331766.161-33.2950.5641.188(D)
DESJ2349-5113357.375-51.227-51.2270.4181.390(C), (D), (E)
DESJ2351-5452357.908-54.882-54.8820.3840.906(A), (B), (C)

caption: TABLE 1. A SUMMARY OF THE PHYSICAL ATTRIBUTES OF THE LENSING SYSTEMS USED IN THIS WORK. THIS INCLUDES THE SKY POSITION OF THE BCG OF EACH SYSTEM, THE REDSHIFTS OF THE LENS (zlensz_{\mathrm{lens}}) AND SOURCE (zsourcez_{\mathrm{source}}) PLANES, AND REFERENCES FOR THE REDSHIFT VALUES. References. (A) Menanteau et al. (2010), (B) Buckley-Geer et al. (2011), (C) Diehl et al. (2017), (D) Jacobs et al. (2019), (E) Rojas et al. (2022).

:::

in our scaling relations. The selected members and the pivot galaxy for each system are shown in Figure 1.

Source Feature Selection

Our strong lens models are constrained by the observed positions of multiply-imaged features of each lensed source. These features and their positions are derived from HST imaging and are listed in Table 2. We use the modified source-plane likelihood presented and used in O’Donnell et al. (2026) (see § 3.4), which incorporates the elliptical uncertainties of the observed feature positions.

Feature LabelRA (deg)Dec (deg)Semi-Major AxisSemi-Minor AxisRotation Angle
DESJ0424-3317
A166.16235-33.294310.10″0.17″45°
A266.15980-33.293840.21″0.11″315°
A366.16006-33.295470.12″0.09″0°
A466.16228-33.296420.33″0.09″155°
C166.16226-33.294590.17″0.12″350°
C266.15954-33.293850.11″0.21″20°
C366.16049-33.296010.14″0.25″300°
C466.16175-33.296380.28″0.13″355°
E166.16259-33.294020.09″0.11″120°
E266.16050-33.293490.18″0.06″340°
E366.16026-33.295380.07″0.06″0°
E466.16308-33.296060.13″0.08″340°
F166.16266-33.294120.08″0.12″45°
F266.16047-33.293460.16″0.05″340°
F366.16029-33.295400.05″0.08″20°
F466.16308-33.296010.11″0.06″340°
H166.16255-33.294460.06″0.10″45°
H266.15992-33.293580.05″0.09″45°
H366.16037-33.295740.07″0.08″330°
H466.16243-33.296190.11″0.07″340°
J166.16277-33.294410.18″0.28″340°
J266.16032-33.293380.17″0.13″0°
J366.16043-33.295580.12″0.16″150°
J466.16302-33.295880.22″0.12″330°
L166.16256-33.294610.19″0.41″320°
L466.16237-33.296060.41″0.14″325°
L266.15984-33.293510.42″0.14″125°
L366.16059-33.295870.35″0.17″10°
DESJ2349-5113
A1357.37395-51.227130.12″0.34″10°
A2357.37564-51.228980.26″0.08″355°
B1357.37337-51.227300.09″0.15″350°
B2357.37354-51.228510.19″0.14″35°
B3357.37643-51.227440.14″0.10″35°
C2357.37374-51.228540.30″0.11″45°
C3357.37656-51.227480.14″0.08″10°
D2357.37442-51.228910.19″0.08″25°
D3357.37661-51.227230.09″0.17″340°
H1357.37367-51.227150.24″0.45″20°
H2357.37452-51.228860.42″0.08″20°
H3357.37681-51.227350.37″0.15″135°
DESJ2351-5452
A1357.90670-54.880340.17″0.362″55°
A2357.90726-54.883950.17″0.418″100°
A3357.91183-54.882760.43″0.231″90°
A4357.91256-54.882040.32″0.236″100°
B1357.90714-54.880000.17″0.946″65°
B2357.90602-54.883580.67″0.210″30°
B3357.91136-54.882870.43″0.284″95°
B4357.91232-54.881680.37″0.263″25°

Table 2. Tabled details of the source features used in the modeling of each system. This includes the sky position in degrees, as well as the length of the axes and position angle of the elliptical regions for each feature used.

The source-plane positional reconstruction after applying our models is used to judge the performance of our lens models. These lensed features are chosen based on their visual identifiability compared to their surroundings (see Figure 1). The selection of lensed features also takes into account each feature’s potential to be related to one another by originating from the same source-plane feature, taking into account preliminary lens modeling. Observed lens-plane features are collected into groups of 2 to 4 corresponding to a single source-plane feature (e.g. “A”, “B”). The basic positional properties of the selected features for each cluster system are presented in Table 2.

The positions of each source-plane feature are estimated based on the attributes we define for our lens models and the observed positions of the lensed features. An initial prediction of coordinates on the source-plane is made for each lensed feature, from which a single best-fit position is calculated for each grouping, representing the likely position of the original source feature (see Figure A1 in Appendix A). We expect a well-defined model to trace all individual lensed features back to a common source-plane coordinate, implying the lensing properties of our chosen clusters have been accurately modeled.

Figure A1. Reconstructed source-plane positions of each of the features used in lens modeling (e.g. “a1”), of each system, as compared to the best-fit source-plane coordinate of that feature (e.g. “A”). Shaded regions represent the 1σ uncertainties on the source-plane feature positions and the best-fit coordinates.

It should be noted that the HST imaging for cluster DESJ2351 exhibits an astrometric offset relative to the Legacy Surveys imaging. To correct for this, a manual offset is roughly calculated and applied to align the HST astrometry with the DECam imaging using the skimage.transform package (van der Walt et al. [83]). We provide skimage.transform with two sets of coordinates corresponding to the same selection of prominent cluster members; one set of coordinates has been inaccurately recorded by HST, while the other set is given by the Legacy Surveys. skimage.transform estimates a translation of magnitude Δr=0.43\Delta r = 0.43 arcsec and a rotation angle of 0.17∘0.17^\circ between the source set and the destination set. We then applied these transformation values to the offset HST source feature coordinates, effectively realigning their positions with the Legacy Survey data.

Mass Model Components

Following the initial data selection and processing, we define a mass model for cluster member galaxies which groups member galaxy contributions together via a scaling relation, excluding the BCG, which is modeled independently. The model for the member galaxies follows a luminosity-dependent scaling law defined by the Faber-Jackson relation:

L∝σ1/αL \propto\sigma^{1/\alpha}

which describes an (elliptical) galaxy’s luminosity LL scaling with its central stellar velocity dispersion σ\sigma as σ1/α\sigma^{1/\alpha} (Faber & Jackson (1976)). We redefine this relation to express the velocity dispersion of each member galaxy in relation to that of the chosen pivot galaxy for each system. A similar scaling relation is also outlined relating the truncation or scale radius of member galaxies to that of the pivot. Both relations are motivated by the scaling relations for the central velocity dispersion and the truncation radius defined by Bergamini et al. (2019a), which are as follows:

σgal=σpiv(LgalLpiv)α(1)\sigma^{\mathrm{gal}} = \sigma^{\mathrm{piv}} \left(\frac{L_{\mathrm{gal}}}{L_{\mathrm{piv}}}\right)^\alpha \tag*{(1)}
rsgal=rspiv(LgalLpiv)β(2)r_s^{\mathrm{gal}} = r_s^{\mathrm{piv}} \left(\frac{L_{\mathrm{gal}}}{L_{\mathrm{piv}}}\right)^\beta \tag*{(2)}

Here, σ\sigma, LL and rsr_s refer to the velocity dispersion, luminosity, and scale radius of a given member galaxy or pivot galaxy denoted (gal) and (piv), respectively. Additionally, the slope β\beta is defined as:

β=1+γ−2α(3)\beta= 1 + \gamma- 2\alpha \tag*{(3)}

where we have set γ=0.2\gamma= 0.2 and take a Gaussian prior on α\alpha (with μα=0.27\mu_\alpha= 0.27 and $\sigma_\alpha = 0.03) based on the results of Bergamini et al. (2019a), who studied the Faber-Jackson relation for three strong lensing clusters.

The member galaxies of each lensing cluster were modeled with a dual Pseudo-Isothermal Elliptical (dPIE) mass profile (Eliášdóttir et al. (2007)) with parameters set by the above scaling relation. The introduction of core and scale radii (rar_a, rsr_s) to a traditional isothermal profile provides a physically reasonable finite mass distribution, with rar_a and rspivr_s^{\mathrm{piv}} set at 0.15 kpc and 10 kpc, respectively.

We next define the model representing the dark matter halo for each cluster. We parameterize this model with a GNFW mass density profile, a generalized adaptation of the Navarro-Frenk-White profile introduced by Navarro et al. (1996, 1997):

ρ(r)∝1(r/rs)(1+r/rs)2(4)\rho(r) \propto\frac{1}{(r/r_s)(1+r/r_s)^2} \tag*{(4)}

in which the mass density ρ(r)\rho(r) of a dark matter halo is related to scale radius rsr_s. The NFW profile has a logarithmic inner slope (Schmidt & Allen 2007):

γDM=−dlog⁡ρdlog⁡r∣r→0=1\gamma^{DM}=-\left.\frac{\mathrm{d}\log\rho}{\mathrm{d}\log r}\right|_{r\to0}=1

and provides a “universal” mass density profile for dark matter halos in a hierarchical clustering universe. To eliminate potential bias towards the slope of γDM=1\gamma^{DM}=1, we opt to use a GNFW profile in our modeling, where γDM\gamma^{DM} is allowed as a free variable (Schmidt & Allen 2007):

ρ(r)=ρs(r/rs)γDM(1+r/rs)3−γDM(5)\rho(r)=\frac{\rho_s}{(r/r_s)^{\gamma^{DM}}(1+r/r_s)^{3-\gamma^{DM}}} \tag*{(5)}

Variation from the CDM prediction of γDM=1\gamma^{DM}=1 may indicate potential physical attributes of the system, such as the presence of non-cold dark matter or baryonic feedback suggested by a shallow dark matter slope (γDM<1\gamma^{DM}<1) (e.g. (Spergel & Steinhardt 2000; Pontzen & Governato 2012; Tulin & Yu 2018)).

Central cluster galaxies are a distinct population from other cluster members, and their kinematic properties may not follow the same scaling Bianchetti et al. (2026). Accordingly, in each system we model the BCG independently of the Faber-Jackson relation linking the other cluster member galaxies. The core radius is set as raBCG=0.15r_a^{BCG}=0.15 kpc and a Uniform prior is applied to the scale radius rsBCGr_s^{BCG} with an interval dependent on the lensing system as shown in Table 4. Additionally, we include an external shear that models a warp factor that represents the cumulative gravitational influence of nearby structures on the cluster systems or complexities in the mass distribution not represented in the mass model (e.g. (Wong et al. 2011; Etherington et al. 2024)). For this, we utilize PyAutoGalaxy’s (Nightingale et al. 2023) External Shear mass profile, which is parameterized by cartesian and diagonal components γ1ext\gamma_1^{ext} and γ2ext\gamma_2^{ext}, describing xyxy directional shear and diagonal shear, respectively.

Prior ConfigurationPosterior
DESJ0424
σpiv\sigma^{piv} (km/s)N(200,20)\mathcal{N}(200, 20)177−16+15177^{+15}_{-16}
α\alpha (Faber-Jackson)N(0.27,0.03)\mathcal{N}(0.27, 0.03)0.28−0.026+0.0270.28^{+0.027}_{-0.026}
Halo Mass (log⁡10(M200mM⊙)\log_{10}(\frac{M_{200m}}{M_{\odot}}))U(14.5,16.0)\mathcal{U}(14.5, 16.0)14.77−0.12+0.1314.77^{+0.13}_{-0.12}
Halo Concentration (200m)U(5,12)\mathcal{U}(5, 12)8.0−1.5+1.48.0^{+1.4}_{-1.5}
γDM\gamma^{DM} (GNFW)N(1.0,0.2,0.0,2.0)\mathcal{N}(1.0, 0.2, 0.0, 2.0)0.85−0.08+0.090.85^{+0.09}_{-0.08}
σBCG\sigma^{BCG} (km/s)N(360,100,100,−)\mathcal{N}(360, 100, 100, -)309−39+42309^{+42}_{-39}
rsBCGr_s^{BCG} (kpc)U(10,50)\mathcal{U}(10, 50)14−3+1114^{+11}_{-3}
γ1ext\gamma_1^{ext}N(0.0,0.05,−0.2,0.2)\mathcal{N}(0.0, 0.05, -0.2, 0.2)0.077−0.011+0.0100.077^{+0.010}_{-0.011}
γ2ext\gamma_2^{ext}N(0.0,0.05,−0.2,0.2)\mathcal{N}(0.0, 0.05, -0.2, 0.2)0.030−0.031+0.0230.030^{+0.023}_{-0.031}
DESJ2349
σpiv\sigma^{piv} (km/s)N(200,20)\mathcal{N}(200, 20)196−17+16196^{+16}_{-17}
α\alpha (Faber-Jackson)N(0.27,0.03)\mathcal{N}(0.27, 0.03)0.27−0.029+0.0270.27^{+0.027}_{-0.029}
Halo Mass (log⁡10(M200mM⊙)\log_{10}(\frac{M_{200m}}{M_{\odot}}))U(13.5,15.5)\mathcal{U}(13.5, 15.5)14.02−0.28+0.3514.02^{+0.35}_{-0.28}
Halo Concentration (200m)U(5,15)\mathcal{U}(5, 15)8.6−2.6+4.08.6^{+4.0}_{-2.6}
γDM\gamma^{DM} (GNFW)N(1.0,0.2,0.0,2.0)\mathcal{N}(1.0, 0.2, 0.0, 2.0)0.89−0.17+0.160.89^{+0.16}_{-0.17}
σBCG\sigma^{BCG} (km/s)N(360,100,50,−)\mathcal{N}(360, 100, 50, -)305−60+43305^{+43}_{-60}
rsBCGr_s^{BCG} (kpc)U(10,100)\mathcal{U}(10, 100)64−31+2564^{+25}_{-31}
γ1ext\gamma_1^{ext}N(0.0,0.05,−0.2,0.2)\mathcal{N}(0.0, 0.05, -0.2, 0.2)−0.009−0.047+0.038-0.009^{+0.038}_{-0.047}
γ2ext\gamma_2^{ext}N(0.0,0.05,−0.2,0.2)\mathcal{N}(0.0, 0.05, -0.2, 0.2)−0.014−0.033+0.032-0.014^{+0.032}_{-0.033}
DESJ2351
σpiv\sigma^{piv} (km/s)N(200,20)\mathcal{N}(200, 20)197−19+22197^{+22}_{-19}
α\alpha (Faber-Jackson)N(0.27,0.03)\mathcal{N}(0.27, 0.03)0.27±0.030.27 \pm0.03
Halo Mass (log⁡10(M200mM⊙)\log_{10}(\frac{M_{200m}}{M_{\odot}}))U(13.5,15.5)\mathcal{U}(13.5, 15.5)14.44−0.25+0.2714.44^{+0.27}_{-0.25}
Halo Concentration (200m)U(5,15)\mathcal{U}(5, 15)10.0−3.1+3.210.0^{+3.2}_{-3.1}
γDM\gamma^{DM} (GNFW)N(1.0,0.2,0.0,2.0)\mathcal{N}(1.0, 0.2, 0.0, 2.0)1.05−0.19+0.181.05^{+0.18}_{-0.19}
σBCG\sigma^{BCG} (km/s)N(360,100,50,−)\mathcal{N}(360, 100, 50, -)382−103+106382^{+106}_{-103}
rsBCGr_s^{BCG} (kpc)U(10,100)\mathcal{U}(10, 100)62−32+2862^{+28}_{-32}
γ1ext\gamma_1^{ext}N(0.0,0.05,−0.2,0.2)\mathcal{N}(0.0, 0.05, -0.2, 0.2)0.004−0.034+0.0360.004^{+0.036}_{-0.034}
γ2ext\gamma_2^{ext}N(0.0,0.05,−0.2,0.2)\mathcal{N}(0.0, 0.05, -0.2, 0.2)0.005−0.033+0.0370.005^{+0.037}_{-0.033}

Table 4. Table of configured priors used for each lensing system. N(μ,σ,l,u)\mathcal{N}(\mu, \sigma, l, u) denotes the use of a Gaussian prior of mean μ\mu and variance σ2\sigma^2, with an optional lower or upper bound (l,u)(l, u). Similarly, U(l,u)\mathcal{U}(l, u) denotes a Uniform prior used within lower and upper bounds ll and uu. Results are reported as the posterior median with 16th and 84th percentile uncertainties.

Prior Configurations and Sampling

Our model setup and prior configuration was performed with the gravitational lensing framework provided by PyAutoLens (Nightingale et al. 2021b; Nightingale & Dye 2015; Nightingale et al. 2018). This software supplies analytic mass profiles, ray-tracing functions, and a model-fitting framework to compute lensing deflections and optimize model parameters. Table 4 lists the priors used for each sub-component of the model.

For our sampling process, we have chosen to use dynesty’s (Speagle 2020; Koposov et al. 2025; Skilling 2004; Skilling 2006; Higson et al. 2018; Feroz et al. 2009) dynamic nested sampling algorithm, which calculates both the Bayesian evidence and the Bayesian posterior distribution for the models we have defined. The nested sampling technique involves the exploration of the parameter space we have outlined for a model in which regions of low-likelihood are replaced with progressively higher-likelihood points, resulting in areas of best-fit at the conclusion of this process. We use the dynamic nested sampling method offered by dynesty, which allows the algorithm to adaptively allocate extra samples to regions of interest following an initial nested sampling run.

Our models are evaluated with the source-plane likelihood described in Section III.B.2 of Section III.B.2 of O’Donnell et al. (2026). Given a feature FF observed at a set of positions {θiF}\{\theta_i^F\} with uncertainties described by covariance matrices [ΣiF][\Sigma_i^F], the mass model is used to predict source-plane positions and uncertainties {(βiF, BiF)}\{(\beta_i^F,\ B_i^F)\} for each feature. The likelihood is the probability that all positions are consistent with the best-fit for the feature (β^F,B^F)(\hat{\beta}^F,\hat{B}^F):

log⁡LF=−log⁡∣B^F∣2π−12∑i(βiF−β^iF)T(B^F)−1(βiF−β^iF)(6)\log\mathcal{L}^F=-\log\sqrt{\frac{|\hat{B}^F|}{2\pi}}-\frac{1}{2}\sum_i(\beta_i^F-\hat{\beta}_i^F)^T(\hat{B}^F)^{-1}(\beta_i^F-\hat{\beta}_i^F) \tag*{(6)}

An ideal model correctly maps each observed feature to the same source-plane position, minimizing each βiF−β^F\beta_i^F-\hat{\beta}^F and maximizing log⁡LF\log\mathcal{L}^F.

Sampler Configuration

To begin the dynamic sampling process, we specify the initial number of live-points (nliveinitn_{\mathrm{live}}^{\mathrm{init}}) to be used in the first full nested sampling run. After this initial run, dynesty samples over the same parameter space again with a

specified number of batch live-points (nlivebatchn_{\mathrm{live}}^{\mathrm{batch}}), and continues these batch runs as many times as needed. The sampling process is completed when the effective sample count (neffn_{\mathrm{eff}}) is reached.

We start the sampler with nliveinit=5000n_{\mathrm{live}}^{\mathrm{init}} = 5000 points and allow dynesty to take additional nlivebatch=2000n_{\mathrm{live}}^{\mathrm{batch}} = 2000 points for each run they are needed for further expansion of the parameter space, before concluding the sampling process when neff=300,000n_{\mathrm{eff}} = 300{,}000 is reached. For each system, we executed and combined three independent sampling runs with identical configurations to produce our final results via dynesty’s merge_runs function, which effectively merges all samples into one run from which we can

extract our results as normal. These settings were chosen after some experimentation and independent runs were used to evaluate consistency and convergence.

It is also worth noting the changes that were made to the default dynesty configuration parameters, Fractional Acceptance (faccf_{\mathrm{acc}}) and Posterior Fraction (ffracf_{\mathrm{frac}}), to better accommodate the sampling behavior of our lens models. We chose to use a lower faccf_{\mathrm{acc}} value of 0.2, or 0.1 for system DESJ0424, which allows the sampler to adjust the sampler’s target acceptance rate. We do keep dynesty’s default ffracf_{\mathrm{frac}} value of 0.8, except for system DESJ0424, which uses a ffracf_{\mathrm{frac}} value of 0.5. These adjustments were made to improve sampling performance for the individual models. Additionally, we use the default stopping criterion for the initial run, dlogzinit=0.01\mathrm{dlogz}_{\mathrm{init}} = 0.01.

X-ray Spectral Fitting

In order to determine the X-ray temperature of each cluster, we extracted and modeled the Chandra spectrum after removing background point sources. First, we created images and exposure maps in the 0.5 − 7.0 keV energy range using CIAO’s fluximage tool. Point sources were detected in the images using wavdetect with a signal threshold of 2×10−72 \times10^{-7}. These point sources were then excluded from the source and background regions for the spectral fitting.

We initially defined the spectral extraction region as a 500 kpc aperture around the clusters’ centers, and defined the background as an annulus region spanning from 700 to 1000 kpc, also centered on the clusters. The cluster and background spectra were extracted in an energy range of 0.5 − 7.0 keV using the specextract function. For observations which had been divided based on focal-plane temperature (DESJ2349 and DESJ0424), a list of individually calibrated level-2 event files was used as the input, as opposed to a single event file. The resulting spectrum was produced by combining the individual spectra with the combined calibration files. Individual spectra were used for the separate observations of DESJ0424 and jointly fit in the modeling step described below for estimating the X-ray temperature of the cluster.

Using CIAO’s application for modeling and fitting X-ray data, Sherpa (Siemiginowska et al. (2024)), we fit models to the 500 kpc spectra to derive an initial estimate of the X-ray temperature of each cluster. We used Sherpa’s xsapecx\text{sapec} model to fit the emission spectrum, with an abundance of 0.3 and the known redshift of each cluster fixed, leaving the normalization and temperature to be determined by the model. xsapecx\text{sapec} was then multiplied by xsphabsx\text{sphabs} to account for photoelectric absorption, for which we used a fixed value for the HI column density (NHN_{\mathrm{H}}). We calculated NHN_{\mathrm{H}} at the RA and Dec of each lensing system using an NHN_{\mathrm{H}} calculator provided by NASA HEASARC ([28, 37] (Dickey & Lockman 1990)). Using xsapec∗xsphabsx\text{sapec}*x\text{sphabs} results in an absorbed, optically-thin, and collisionally-ionized plasma emission model. We fit our spectra using both a spectrum binned to give 15 counts per spectral bin with the chi2gehrels fit statistic, and the unbinned spectra with the wstat statistic. In general, we found consistent results between the two methods, and we present the final results with the wstat method.

Next, the cluster radius at 500 times the critical density of the universe, r500cr_{500\mathrm{c}}, was estimated based on the 500 kpc X-ray temperature using the radius-temperature scaling relation from Arnaud et al. (2005). Cluster spectra and background spectra were then extracted for the r500cr_{500\mathrm{c}} aperture; the background in this case was defined as an annulus spanning from 1.05r500c1.05r_{500\mathrm{c}} to 1.75r500c1.75r_{500\mathrm{c}}. The r500cr_{500\mathrm{c}} X-ray temperatures were fit using the same model as defined above. We also calculated luminosities in the 0.5-2 keV band from flux estimates (sample_flux) for each cluster given by Sherpa’s spectral fitting. Our derived X-ray temperatures allow us to estimate the total masses, M500cM_{500\mathrm{c}}, following the temperature-mass scaling relation defined by Mantz et al. (2016). With fixed values of h=0.7h = 0.7 and Ωm=0.3\Omega_{\mathrm{m}} = 0.3, we adopted the values of β0,t=2.16±0.06\beta_{0,t} = 2.16 \pm0.06, β1,t=0.63±0.03\beta_{1,t} = 0.63 \pm0.03, β0,l=1.65±0.14\beta_{0,l} = 1.65 \pm0.14, and β1,l=1.35±0.06\beta_{1,l} = 1.35 \pm0.06 from Table 3 of Mantz et al. (2016).

dynesty
DefaultDESJ0424-3317DESJ2349-5113DESJ2351-5452
facc0.50.10.20.2
pfrac0.80.50.80.8

Table 3. Table showing both the default values for dynesty’s configuration parameters, facc and pfrac, and our finalized settings for each lensing system.

DESJ2349 proved difficult to get a good spectral fit for, as the focal-plane temperature of Chandra’s CCD Imaging Spectrometer varied significantly during the observation. As a result, we elected to assume a temperature based on its known richness (λ\lambda) using the relations discussed in Kelly et al. (2024). By fixing this temperature, we were still able to derive a luminosity measurement for DESJ2349. Since the temperature was not derived from the spectra, but rather estimated from the richness, M500cM_{500\mathrm{c}} was instead determined using the luminosity-mass scaling relation from Mantz et al. (2016).

Results

Lens Modeling Results

Following the methodology discussed in § 3, we find the lens modeling results listed in Table 4. Figure A1 in Appendix A illustrates the goodness of fit by comparing the model-predicted source-plane features of our systems with their respective best-fit positions. Following the method described in § 3.2, source-plane positions are estimated by our lens modeling for each of our chosen features, given the observed lens-plane positions of the features. We overlay these predicted source-plane positions with their respective best-fit source-plane positions including 1σ1\sigma elliptical uncertainties, in Figure A1.

For each fit parameter, we report the median values with 1σ1\sigma uncertainties defined using the 16th and 84th percentiles of the posteriors. The parameter constraints and degeneracies are shown for the mass, concentration, and inner slope in corner plots in Figure 3. We find logarithmic halo mass values log⁡10(M200m/M⊙)\log_{10}(M_{200\mathrm{m}}/M_{\odot}) of ≈14.8±0.1\approx14.8 \pm0.1, 14.0−0.3+0.414.0^{+0.4}_{-0.3}, and 14.4±0.314.4 \pm0.3 for systems DESJ0424, DESJ2349, and DESJ2351 respectively. We find dark matter concentration values of c200m0424≈8.0−1.5+1.4c_{200\mathrm{m}}^{0424} \approx8.0^{+1.4}_{-1.5}, c200m2349≈9.0−3.0+4.0c_{200\mathrm{m}}^{2349} \approx9.0^{+4.0}_{-3.0}, and c200m2351≈10.0±3.0c_{200\mathrm{m}}^{2351} \approx10.0 \pm3.0, although the concentrations for DESJ2349 and DESJ2351 are poorly constrained within their prior ranges and therefore should not be considered reliable measurements. These best-fit concentrations are higher than cosmological mass-concentration relations (e.g. Ludlow et al. (2016)) but consistent with expectations given the large uncertainties. Furthermore, we find dark matter inner slope results that are consistent between clusters: γ0424DM≈0.85−0.08+0.09\gamma_{0424}^{\mathrm{DM}} \approx0.85^{+0.09}_{-0.08}, γ2349DM≈0.89−0.17+0.15\gamma_{2349}^{\mathrm{DM}} \approx0.89^{+0.15}_{-0.17}, γ2351DM≈1.05−0.19+0.18\gamma_{2351}^{\mathrm{DM}} \approx1.05^{+0.18}_{-0.19}. While the best fits for two of the clusters are slightly shallower than one, in all cases the inner slope is consistent with the NFW expectation of γDM=1\gamma^{\mathrm{DM}} = 1.

Figure 3. Corner plots showing the constraints on halo mass, concentration, and inner density slope. The median results and 16% and 84% quantiles are also shown. The red line represents both the NFW value of γ=1\gamma= 1 and the median value of the Gaussian prior used for our GNFW slope, while the shaded region represents the 1σ1\sigma width of this prior, γ=1±0.2\gamma= 1 \pm0.2.

For the external shear parameters, we find that both components of the shear are low for all three clusters. For DESJ0424 we find γ1ext0424=0.08±0.01\gamma_{1}^{\mathrm{ext}_{0424}} = 0.08 \pm0.01 and γ2ext0424=0.03−0.03+0.02\gamma_{2}^{\mathrm{ext}_{0424}} = 0.03^{+0.02}_{-0.03}. For DESJ2349, these values are γ1ext2349=−0.01−0.05+0.04\gamma_{1}^{\mathrm{ext}_{2349}} = -0.01^{+0.04}_{-0.05} and γ2ext2349=−0.01±0.03\gamma_{2}^{\mathrm{ext}_{2349}} = -0.01 \pm0.03, and we obtain γ1ext2351=0.004−0.03+0.04\gamma_{1}^{\mathrm{ext}_{2351}} = 0.004^{+0.04}_{-0.03} and γ2ext2351=0.005−0.03+0.04\gamma_{2}^{\mathrm{ext}_{2351}} = 0.005^{+0.04}_{-0.03} for DESJ2351. We find the overall magnitude of external shear to be ∣γext0424∣=0.09±0.01|\gamma^{\mathrm{ext}_{0424}}| = 0.09 \pm0.01, ∣γext2349∣=0.05−0.02+0.03|\gamma^{\mathrm{ext}_{2349}}| = 0.05^{+0.03}_{-0.02}, and ∣γext2351∣=0.04−0.02+0.03|\gamma^{\mathrm{ext}_{2351}}| = 0.04^{+0.03}_{-0.02}. The external shear values for DESJ2349 and DESJ2351 are low and consistent with zero. The external shear for DESJ0424 is consistent with typical values found in clusters.

X-ray Modeling Results

The X-ray surface brightness distributions as shown in Figure 2 indicate that all three clusters are relatively relaxed. The X-ray distributions, extending well beyond the strong lensing region, are generally symmetric with no indication of significant substructure.

We have measured the following X-ray temperatures from our Chandra data sets, which are consistent with expected values based on the richness of each galaxy cluster (Kelly et al. 2024): TX0424=2.7−0.5+0.7 keVT_{\mathrm{X}}^{0424}=2.7^{+0.7}_{-0.5}\ \mathrm{keV} and TX2351=6.2−2.0+3.4 keVT_{\mathrm{X}}^{2351}=6.2^{+3.4}_{-2.0}\ \mathrm{keV}. We also report X-ray luminosities of LX0424=6.0±0.6×1044 erg/sL_{\mathrm{X}}^{0424}=6.0\pm0.6\times10^{44}\ \mathrm{erg/s}, LX2349=7.3±1.7×1043 erg/sL_{\mathrm{X}}^{2349}=7.3\pm1.7\times10^{43}\ \mathrm{erg/s}, and LX2351=2.2±0.3×1044 erg/sL_{\mathrm{X}}^{2351}=2.2\pm0.3\times10^{44}\ \mathrm{erg/s}, with 1σ1\sigma errors determined from the uncertainty on the fit parameters for both our reported X-ray temperature and luminosity results. The M500cXrayM_{500c}^{Xray} masses estimated for the clusters DESJ0424, DESJ2349, and DESJ2351, respectively, are as follows: 4.2−0.8+0.9×1014M⊙4.2^{+0.9}_{-0.8}\times10^{14}M_{\odot}, 1.6±0.4×1014M⊙1.6\pm0.4\times10^{14}M_{\odot}, and 4.7−2.5+4.1×1014M⊙4.7^{+4.1}_{-2.5}\times10^{14}M_{\odot}. The uncertainty on the estimated mass includes the uncertainty in the temperature and luminosity values along with the uncertainties in the scaling relation parameters given by Mantz et al. (2016) as described in § 3.6. These results are listed in Table 5.

SystemTXT_X (keV)LXL_X (erg/s)λ\lambdaM500cxrayM^{xray}_{500c} (1014M⊙10^{14}M_\odot)M500clensM^{lens}_{500c} (1014M⊙10^{14}M_\odot)
DESJ0424-33172.7−0.5+0.72.7^{+0.7}_{-0.5}6.0±0.6×10446.0 \pm0.6 \times10^{44}544.2−0.8+0.94.2^{+0.9}_{-0.8}3.9−0.9+1.43.9^{+1.4}_{-0.9}
DESJ2349-51134.5†4.5^{\dagger}7.3±1.7×10437.3 \pm1.7 \times10^{43}651.6±0.41.6 \pm0.40.7−0.3+0.80.7^{+0.8}_{-0.3}
DESJ2351-54526.2−2.0+3.46.2^{+3.4}_{-2.0}2.2±0.3×10442.2 \pm0.3 \times10^{44}834.7−2.5+4.14.7^{+4.1}_{-2.5}1.8−0.8+1.61.8^{+1.6}_{-0.8}

Table 5. Table of derived x-ray temperatures, luminosities, and masses for each cluster, along with their redMaPPer richness λ\lambda. For comparison, this table also reports our lens-derived masses converted to M500cM_{500c}. †DESJ2349 had large focal-plane temperature variations during the observation and we were unable to robustly measure the temperature. We use a fixed 4.5 keV based on the known richness to estimate the luminosity and the mass is estimated from LXL_X.

Discussion

We chose to model the cluster mass distributions with a generalized-NFW mass density profile to test for potential flattening of the inner slope that might result from non-CDM dark matter scenarios. However, we find no indication of deviations of the inner slope from the NFW expectation. Our resulting inner slope values are well constrained, ranging from approximately 0.85±0.10.85\pm0.1 to 1.05±0.21.05\pm0.2, which are consistent with a slope of γNFW=1\gamma_{\mathrm{NFW}}=1.

This result is in contrast to several previous works which found shallow inner slopes or a preference for a core (Sand et al. 2004; Newman et al. 2013; Limousin et al. 2022; Cerny et al. 2025), though other works find inner slopes consistent with NFW (Sartoris et al. 2020; Biviano et al. 2023). Notably, the recent work of Cerny et al. (2025) finds an average inner slope of ∼0.66\sim0.66 for a sample of six strong lensing clusters, but these clusters are selected to have radial arcs, which preferentially appear in clusters with shallower density profiles.

As depicted in Figure 3, our median dark matter concentration results are fairly consistent between clusters within our data set, but with large errors indicating poor constraints on this parameter. Our c200mc_{200m} concentration values, approximately ranging from 8−1.5+1.48^{+1.4}_{-1.5} to 10±310\pm3, are consistent with the lensing-derived result of c200m≈10−3+2c_{200m}\approx10^{+2}_{-3} for the MACS J0138-2155 galaxy cluster modeled by O’Donnell et al. (2026). Although the best-fit concentration values are higher than expected for galaxy clusters in general, the uncertainties are large and strong lensing clusters tend to exhibit these higher concentrations (e.g. Comerford & Natarajan 2007), particularly relaxed strong lensing clusters (Giocoli et al. 2014).

Two of our three clusters (DESJ2349 and DESJ2351) are well described by a single, spherical halo model with external shear consistent with zero, and only DESJ0424 has a non-negligible γext\gamma^{\mathrm{ext}}. This suggests that the strong-lensing models of these clusters do not require additional substructure or ellipticity beyond that of a single, approximately symmetric halo. This is notable given that substantial external-shear terms (γext∼0.07−0.17\gamma^{\mathrm{ext}}\sim0.07-0.17) have been required in strong-lens models of several clusters (e.g. Mahler et al. 2018; Caminha et al. 2019; Lagattuta et al. 2019; Bergamini et al. 2019b; Acebron et al. 2022; O’Donnell et al. 2026). At galaxy scales, recent studies likewise find substantial fitted shear to be common (e.g. Hogg et al. 2026). While sometimes discussed as shear due to line of sight structure, the external shear values are high for this interpretation, and Etherington et al. (2024) show that external shear is generally due to a lack of complexity in the lens model. Likewise, Limousin et al. (2025) show for the case of the Abell 370 cluster that they can remove the need for an external shear term by adding additional cluster substructure. The negligible shear in our systems therefore indicates that they have unusually simple projected mass distributions and is consistent with their being relatively relaxed systems. For DESJ0424, the magnitude of the external shear (∣γ0424ext∣|\gamma^{\mathrm{ext}}_{0424}|) is 0.09±0.010.09\pm0.01; for this cluster, both the arc structure and X-ray show mild ellipticity, perhaps indicating the need for some elongation in the lens model. The structure of the source galaxy in this system is also particularly complex and could potentially benefit from a pixel-level modeling.

We can compare our independently estimated cluster masses based on our lensing results to those estimated from the X-ray temperatures. In order to compare to M500cXrayM_{500c}^{Xray}, which have been estimated as M500cM_{500c} masses, the lensing-derived masses MlensM^{lens} have been converted from M200mM_{200m} to M500cM_{500c} using the Colossus (Diemer 2018) toolkit, assuming Planck18 cosmology (Planck Collaboration et al. [61]) and given the zlensz_{\mathrm{lens}} of each cluster. The adjusted lensing masses are given in Table 5. The two methods of estimating the cluster masses generally agree well. The differences in mass between approaches are within 1σ1\sigma in all cases.

The slope of the Faber-Jackson relation α\alpha is nearly unconstrained by our data, with all three systems very nearly reproducing the prior of N(μ=0.3,σ=0.03)\mathcal{N}(\mu=0.3,\sigma=0.03). Since α\alpha exhibits very little degeneracy with other model parameters, its value is unlikely to affect our other results.

Conclusion

We used a combination of strong lens modeling and Chandra X-ray observations to model the structure and dark matter content of the three strong gravitational-lensing galaxy clusters, DESJ0424-3317, DESJ2349-5113, and DESJ2351-5452, found in the Dark Energy Survey (O’Donnell et al. 2022). Both the symmetric lensing giant arc structures and, on larger scales, the X-ray surface brightness distributions indicate that these are relaxed clusters ideal for strong lens modeling. In fact, two of the three clusters are well modeled by a single, spherical dark matter halo plus contributions from the BCG and member galaxies with low external shear, which might have indicated the need for additional complexity in the lens model.

We find cluster lensing estimated masses between 101410^{14} and 6×1014 M⊙6 \times10^{14}\ M_\odot. In all cases, the masses estimated from the X-ray temperature or luminosity are consistent with the lensing mass, and both the X-ray properties (TXT_X, LXL_X) and masses are consistent with the DES cluster richness.

In our lens models, the main dark matter halo is parameterized with a GNFW mass density profile allowing for a variable inner slope. While the best-fit inner slope is somewhat shallower than 1 for two of the clusters, we find inner slope consistent with 1 in all three clusters, as expected for an NFW profile. Thus we find no indication of a cored dark matter profile, as would be expected in non-CDM dark matter scenarios such as SIDM. Future Integral Field Unit (IFU) spectroscopy would allow us to more precisely constrain the inner density profile through the combination of resolved kinematics of the BCG with lensing, as was demonstrated in O’Donnell et al. (2026). The relaxed nature and large, symmetric giant arc systems make these ideal targets for constraints on SIDM.

Acknowledgments

Support for this work was provided by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration through Chandra Award Number GO3-24103X issued by the Chandra X-ray Center, which is operated by the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory for and on behalf of the National

Aeronautics Space Administration under contract NAS8-03060. This research is based on observations made with the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope obtained from the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS 5–26555. These observations are associated with programs 16773 and 11974. Additionally, we acknowledge that this research has made use of data obtained from the Chandra Data Archive provided by the Chandra X-ray Center (CXC).

In addition to the several open-source Python packages previously referenced throughout this work (PyAutoLens, PyAutoGalaxy, Colossus, skimage, dynesty, CIAO, and Sherpa), this research has also made use of additional Python packages including: PyAutoFit (Nightingale et al. 2021a), astropy (Astropy Collaboration et al. [5]; Price-Whelan et al. 2018; Astropy Collaboration et al. [6]), NumPy (Harris et al. 2020), and matplotlib (Hunter 2007).

Additionally, we acknowledge the use of the lux supercomputer at the University of California, Santa Cruz, funded by NSF MRI grant AST 1828315.

Appendix 1

Here we provide additional figures to further support our results. Figure A1 shows our selected lensed features at their estimated source-plane positions as compared to a best-fit position for each grouping. The visual overlap of a feature’s elliptical uncertainty (blue) with the best-fit ellipse (red) allows for an assessment of the goodness of fit of our models to these systems.

Figure A2, Figure A3, and Figure A4 expand upon Figure 3, showing the results of our full list of variables used.

Corner plot for system DESJ0424

Figure A2. Corner plot for system DESJ0424 showing the constraints on all parameters. The posterior medians and 16% & 84% quantiles are shown.

Corner plot for system DESJ2349 showing the constraints on all parameters

Figure A3. Corner plot for system DESJ2349 showing the constraints on all parameters. The posterior medians and 16% & 84% quantiles are shown.

Corner plot for system DESJ2351

Figure A4. Corner plot for system DESJ2351 showing the constraints on all parameters. The posterior medians and 16% & 84% quantiles are shown.

This paper was built using the Open Journal of Astrophysics LaTeX template. The OJA is a journal which provides fast and easy peer review for new papers in the astro-ph section of the arXiv, making the reviewing process simpler for authors and referees alike. Learn more at http://astro.theoj.org.

References

  1. [5]Astropy Collaboration et al., 2013, A&A, 558, A33
  2. [6]Astropy Collaboration et al., 2022, ApJ, 935, 167
  3. [28]HI4PI Collaboration et al., 2016, A&A, 594, A116
  4. [37]Kalberla P. M. W., Burton W. B., Hartmann D., Arnal E. M., Bajaja E., Morras R., Pöppel W. G. L., 2005, A&A, 440, 775
  5. [47]McMaster, M. Biretta, J. 2008, Wide Field and Planetary Camera 2 Instrument Handbook, Version 10.0. Space Telescope Science Institute, Baltimore, MD
  6. [61]Planck Collaboration et al., 2020, A&A, 641, A6
  7. [83]van der Walt S., Schönberger J. L., Nunez-Iglesias J., Boulogne F., Warner J. D., Yager N., Gouillart E., Yu T., 2014, PeerJ, 2, e453

Paper details

vlnc:W_yjkqrjkz
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents