betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Analysis of SS-wave ωπωπ dynamics behavior in multi-body Bℓ4B_{\ell4} and Bℓ6B_{\ell6} decays

Abstract

The b1(1235)b_1(1235) state has a sizable decay width, which have longstanding puzzle in treating as a final state in theoretical calculations may lead to systematic deviations in the predicted observables. To address this issue and further explore the internal structure of this resonance, we study the multi-body semileptonic decays Bℓ4B_{\ell4} and Bℓ6B_{\ell6}. Within the approximation where the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance dominates, we study the Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB\to b_1(1235)(\toωπ)\ell^+ν_\ell in the QCD light-cone sum rules framework. The corresponding transition form factors (TFFs) are calculated by constructing a correlation function with a right-handed chiral current. As the main nonperturbative input for the TFFs calculation, the transverse twist-2 light-cone distribution amplitude (LCDA) of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance is constructed using the light-cone harmonic oscillator model, and the resulting LCDA exhibits a single-peak behavior. At the large-recoil region, we obtain the TFFs V0,1,2(0)V_{0, 1, 2}(0) and A(0)A(0), together with the corresponding TFFs ratios rV=1.530−0.016+0.013r_V = 1.530_{-0.016}^{+0.013} and r2=0.553−0.015+0.012r_2 = 0.553_{-0.015}^{+0.012}. We then further study the complete Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay by incorporating the b1(1235)→ωπb_1(1235)\toωπ resonant line shape and obtain the corresponding observables. The results show that the branching ratio of the Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay is about 1/31/3 of that obtained when b1(1235)b_1(1235) is treated as a final state. We also account for the subsequent decay ω→π+π−π0ω\to π^+π^-π^0 and further predicted the branching ratio of the Bℓ6B_{\ell6} decay B→b1(1235)(→ω(→π+π−π0)π)ℓ+νℓB\to b_1(1235)(\toω(\to π^+π^-π^0)π)\ell^+ν_\ell. These results may provide useful references for future experimental measurements and further theoretical studies.

Introduction

In the low-energy region of strong interactions, information about the internal structure of excited hadronic states is often difficult to extract directly from their complex invariant-mass and angular distributions. This is particularly relevant for axial-vector states, which may have rich internal configurations and sizable finite-width effects. Identifying these effects through experimentally accessible observables is therefore important for understanding the structure of light hadrons. Semileptonic decays of heavy-flavor BB-mesons provide a useful platform for studying weak transitions and hadronic transition dynamics [1]. In such processes, the resonance of interest can be produced through a relatively clean short-distance weak transition, while its properties are subsequently encoded in the experimentally measurable multi-body final states through its strong decay.

At present, several axial-vector states are known to have sizable decay widths. Both experimental and theoretical studies of these states therefore often rely on the multi-body final states formed by their decay products. Semileptonic decays provide a relatively clean environment for such investigations. Since the final-state lepton does not participate in strong interactions, the hadronic dynamics is mainly governed by the weak-current-induced transition and the subsequent strong interactions among the final-state hadrons. Compared with purely hadronic decays, semileptonic processes generally suffer from reduced hadronic backgrounds and are therefore better suited for studying the spectroscopic properties and internal structure of axial-vector resonances [2, 3]. Experimentally, in 2024, the BESIII Collaboration reported the first observation of D0→b1(1235)−e+νeD^0 \to b_1(1235)^{-}e^+\nu_e with a statistical significance of 5.2σ5.2\sigma, and also found evidence for D+→b1(1235)0e+νeD^+ \to b_1(1235)^0e^+\nu_e with a significance of 3.1σ3.1\sigma [5]. In both decay channels, the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance was reconstructed through the ωπ\omega\pi final state. These measurements provide direct experimental motivation for further studies of semileptonic decays involving the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance. On the theoretical side, the theoretical side, the Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decays D→M(M→VP)ℓ+νℓD \to M(M \to VP)\ell^+\nu_\ell were systematically studied within SU(3)(3) flavor symmetry, where M=A/TM=A/T and AA, TT, VV, and PP denote axial-vector, tensor, vector, and pseudoscalar states, respectively [4]. It was shown that both axial-vector and tensor resonances can contribute to such decay modes, indicating that multi-body semileptonic decays provide a useful approach for studying resonance structures in hadronic final states. In addition, lattice QCD studies indicate a strong coupling of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance to the SS-wave ωπ\omega\pi channel [6], further supporting studies of this resonance through the ωπ\omega\pi final state. According to the PDG [1], the ω\omega-meson decays predominantly through ω→π+π−π0\omega\to\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0, with a branching fraction of B(ω→π+π−π0)=89.2±0.7%\mathcal{B}(\omega\to\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0) = 89.2 \pm0.7\%. Moreover, its natural width of Γω=8.68±0.13\Gamma_\omega= 8.68 \pm0.13 MeV, is much smaller than that of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance, Γb1=142±9\Gamma_{b_1} = 142 \pm9 MeV. Therefore, the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance can be experimentally reconstructed through the corresponding four-pion final state, and the complete decay chain can be written as B→b1(1235)(→ω(→π+π−π0)π)ℓ+νℓB \to b_1(1235)(\to\omega(\to\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0)\pi)\ell^+\nu_\ell. Despite these experimental and theoretical developments, systematic studies of the Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB \to b_1(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^+\nu_\ell remain limited. A detailed investigation of this process is therefore worthwhile for studying the B→b1(1235)B \to b_1(1235) transition dynamics, the finite-width effect of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance, and the resonance structure of the ωπ\omega\pi final state. Axial-vector states possess a rich internal structure. They have the same total angular momentum and parity, but different states show different properties because of differences in symmetry, composition, and dominant decay channel. For non-strange systems, b1(1235)b_1(1235) and h1(1170)h_1(1170) are classified as 1+−1^{+-}-states, whereas a1(1260)a_1(1260), f1(1285)f_1(1285) and f1(1420)f_1(1420) are classified as 1++1^{++}-states. The strange states K1(1270)K_1(1270) and K1(1400)K_1(1400) have no definite CC or GG-parity, they involve mixing between the 1P1{}^{1}P_1 and 3P1{}^{3}P_1 basis states. According to the latest PDG compilation [1], The mass of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) state is mb1(1235)=1229.5±3.2m_{b_1(1235)} = 1229.5 \pm3.2 MeV, its average width is Γb1(1235)=142±9\Gamma_{b_1(1235)} = 142 \pm9 MeV and its main decay channels are ωπ\omega\pi [7]. Which compared with other axial-vector states, The mass and width of a1(1260)a_1(1260) are 375±35375 \pm35 MeV and 250−600250-600 MeV, respectively. The dominant decay channel for both h1(1170)h_1(1170) and a1(1260)a_1(1260) is ρπ\rho\pi[8, 9, 10, 11], and both states have relatively large decay widths. The widths of f1(1285)f_1(1285) (23.0±1.123.0 \pm1.1 MeV) and f1(1420)f_1(1420) (56.7±3.356.7 \pm3.3 MeV) are relatively narrow, and they mainly decay into ηππ\eta\pi\pi [12, 13, 14] and KKˉπK\bar{K}\pi [12, 13, 15, 16, 17]. Although b1(1235)b_1(1235) and a1(1260)a_1(1260) have similar masses, they differ in their internal quantum numbers and GG-parities. The considerable width of b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance makes it an important tool for studying the multi-body dynamics of axial-vector resonances.

Currently, the internal structure of axial-vector states is still not fully understood. In particular, the internal structure of b1(1235)b_1(1235) state has not yet been completely determined. The b1(1235)b_1(1235) state was first observed by the HBC in 1963 [18]. Before 1994, studies on the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance mainly focused on processes such as ppˉp\bar{p} [19, 20], γp\gamma p [21], and pπp\pi [22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30], with the main goal of measuring its mass and width. In the processes ppˉ→ω0π+π−p\bar{p} \to\omega^0\pi^+\pi^- at rest, the b1(1235)b_1(1235) (then called the BB) was clearly observed. Its mass, width, and spin-parity were determined to be approximately 1200 MeV, 100–130 MeV, and JP=1+J^P = 1^+, respectively [19, 20]. For the π+p\pi^+p collision experiment in 1974, the ωπ\omega\pi decay channel was analyzed at 5 GeV/c, and the mass and width of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance were measured, yielding values similar to those obtained in ppˉ→ω0π+π−p\bar{p} \to\omega^0\pi^+\pi^- [24, 26]. It is indicated by these results that the b1(1235)b_1(1235) is a resonance with a significant width. In the traditional quark model, b1(1235)b_1(1235) is often described as a quark-antiquark pair in the 1P1{}^{1}P_1 state [31, 32]. Lattice QCD calculations show that the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance can be effectively produced by an operator composed of a quark and an antiquark. This indicates that it has a significant qqˉq\bar{q} component [33]. The calculations also show that the interaction between b1(1235)b_1(1235) and the ωπ\omega\pi system is also important [6]. Some theoretical studies have proposed different explanations. For example, in the diquark-antidiquark color-spin model, b1(1235)b_1(1235) can be regarded as a candidate state of the JPC=1+−J^{PC}=1^{+-} tetraquark state [34]. Based on the above discussion, more theoretical support is given to b1(1235)b_1(1235) as a qqˉq\bar{q} state, and the subsequent study in this paper is carried out on this basis.

For the Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB \to b_1(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^+\nu_\ell, the decay dynamics involves both the weak transition B→b1(1235)B \to b_1(1235) and the subsequent strong decay b1(1235)→ωπb_1(1235) \to\omega\pi. These two parts are connected through the b1(1235)b_1(1235) propagator. To describe the resonance line shape and the finite-width effect near the ωπ\omega\pi threshold, we adopt a Breit-Wigner form with a mass-dependent width [35]. The nonperturbative dynamics of the weak transition is encoded in the B→b1(1235)B \to b_1(1235) transition

ϕ2∥\phi_2^{\parallel}ϕ2⊥\phi_2^{\perp}
Vector statesymmetricsymmetric
Axial-vector state (3P1{}^{3}P_1)symmetricantisymmetric
Axial-vector state (1P1{}^{1}P_1)antisymmetricsymmetric

Table 1. The LCDAs of vector and axial-vector states exhibit symmetric or antisymmetric behavior under the exchange of quark and antiquark momentum fractions [44].

form factors (TFFs), which therefore serve as key hadronic inputs for calculating the differential decay rates and other physical observables. A reliable determination of these TFFs is essential for a quantitative description of the four-body decay. In particular, precise knowledge of the B→b1(1235)B \to b_1(1235) TFFs provides an important theoretical basis for studying various observables of this Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay and for assessing the finite-width effect of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance.

Theoretically, many methods are available for studying heavy BB-meson to the light axial-vector b1(1235)b_1(1235) TFFs, including perturbative QCD (pQCD) [36], QCD light-cone sum rules (LCSRs) [37, 38], and the covariant light-front quark model (CLFQM) [39, 40]. For pQCD approach in 2009, the factorization scheme which retains the transverse momentum kTk_T is adopted where the TFFs were calculated TFFs at large-recoil region and whole physical region directly. Branching ratios for BB-meson decays to different axial-vector states is also given, most of them are at the 10−410^{-4} level. It was also pointed out that the sizes of the TFFs and different helicity components are very sensitive to the distribution amplitudes of the axial-vector state [36]. Implementation of the CLFQM method, a scheme was adopted in which the calculations were carried out in the spacelike region and then extended to the timelike region through a parametrization. Within this scheme, the TFFs were treated separately for the spacelike and timelike regions. It was also pointed out that the internal structure of axial-vector states could significantly affect the related TFFs predictions [40]. For the LCSR method in 2008, the vector and axial-vector TFFs were calculated for Bu,d,sB_{u,d,s} decays to PP-wave axial-vector states, with mA/mbm_A/m_b order corrections included. The differential decay widths and branching ratios for the subsequent Bu,d,s→AℓνB_{u,d,s} \to A\ell\nu were measured [37]. A basis for evaluating the reliability of TFFs predictions can be provided by comparing different results [41]. In this work, we use the LCSR method, it is suitable for the low to mid q2q^2-region required for this process, the LCDA of b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance can be used to describe the relevant nonperturbative effects. The uncertainties of nonperturbative input can also be evaluated. This method was developed from 1980s. It can be regarded as an extension of the SVZ sum rules to the light cone [42, 43].

To accurately determine the behavior and precision of the TFFs in the B→b1(1235)B \to b_1(1235) transition, the leading-twist LCDAs of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) state play a key role, which contain information about the momentum distribution of quarks inside the hadron, Therefore, we also pay close attention to the behavior of its twist-2 LCDA amplitude. Within the LCSR framework, for axial-vector state, the LCDAs include both longitudinal and transverse polarization states, which are described by chiral-even and chiral-odd operators, respectively. Regarding LCDAs, opposite symmetry properties are exhibited by the chiral-even and chiral-odd cases under quark-antiquark momentum exchange [44]. From the QCDSR [44] sum rules, it can be known that the chiral-even two-particle LCDAs of axial-vector state are antisymmetric, while the opposite holds for the chiral-odd LCDAs. The symmetric and antisymmetric properties of the twist-2 LCDAs of axial-vector states under the exchange of the quark momentum fractions are listed in Table I. For the longitudinally polarized one couples through the axial-vector current uˉγμγ5b\bar{u}\gamma_{\mu}\gamma_{5}b, while the transversely polarized b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) state is described by the tensor current uˉσμνb\bar{u}\sigma_{\mu\nu}b. We use the right-handed chiral current to construct the correlation function and obtain the TFFs. We choose the chiral current over the conventional current to construct the correlation function. Within the present QCD light-cone sum rule framework, this choice helps suppress unwanted resonance contributions, allows some strong interaction corrections to cancel, and reduces the sensitivity of the results to higher-twist distribution amplitudes [45, 46, 47, 48], These features can improve the stability of the calculation and the precision of theoretical predictions [47, 48]. For the transverse leading-twist distribution amplitude ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)\phi^{\perp}_{2;b_{1}(1235)}(x,\mu), which gives the dominant contribution, the light-cone harmonic oscillator (LCHO) model is adopted to construct it. This model is based on the Brodsky-Huang-Lepage (BHL) prescription, which connects the equal-time wave function of the meson in its rest frame to the light-cone wave function in the infinite momentum frame [49, 50, 51], it provides an intuitive and effective framework for modeling the internal structure of mesons. This model has been successfully applied to pseudoscalar mesons π\pi, KK, η′\eta' [52, 53, 54], scalar states a0(980)a_{0}(980), K0∗(1430)K_{0}^{*}(1430) [55, 56, 57] and vector states ρ\rho, K∗K^{*}, ϕ\phi [58, 59, 60]. At the same time, for axial-vector states, the LCHO model has also been successfully used to construct the longitudinal twist-2 LCDA of a1(1260)a_{1}(1260). It has also been applied to study the D→a1(1260)D \to a_{1}(1260) TFFs and semileptonic decays [61]. This shows that the LCHO model can provide an effective parametrization for the nonperturbative structure of axial-vector states. Based on this, in this work, we adopt the LCHO model to construct the transverse twist-2 LCDA ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)\phi^{\perp}_{2;b_{1}(1235)}(x,\mu) of b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) as an input parameter. Then, we use LCSR to study the semileptonic decay process with a four-body final state.

The structure of this paper is organized as follows: In Section II, the decay width of the Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB \to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} and the theoretical framework for the calculation of the TFFs by means of the LCSR method are first briefly introduced. This includes the detailed procedure for the construction of ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)\phi^{\perp}_{2;b_{1}(1235)}(x,\mu) in the LCHO model, the method by which the correlation functions are built with the right-handed chiral current, and the expressions for the TFFs. Section III presents the numerical results and analysis, covering the behavior of the LCDAs, the shapes of the TFFs, the differential decay width, the branching fraction, Finally, the paper concludes with a summary and outlook.

Theoretical Framework

A general expression for the differential decay width of Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decays has been derived in Ref. [62]. It is formulated in terms of the five-variable Cabibbo-Maksymowicz parametrization [63] and has been widely used in theoretical studies of Bℓ4B_{\ell4} processes. In this work, we adopt this general formalism to describe the decay B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB \to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell}. The effective weak interaction amplitude for the B→b1(1235)ℓ+νℓB \to b_{1}(1235)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} transition can be written as

Mweak=GF2VubLμHμ,(1)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{weak}} = \frac{G_{F}}{\sqrt{2}}V_{ub}L^{\mu}H_{\mu}, \tag*{(1)}

where GF=1.166×10−5 GeV−2G_{F}=1.166\times10^{-5}\ \mathrm{GeV}^{-2} is the Fermi coupling constant. For a positively charged final-state lepton, the leptonic current is defined as Lμ=uˉ(pν)γμ(1−γ5)v(pℓ)L^{\mu}=\bar{u}(p_{\nu})\gamma^{\mu}(1-\gamma_{5})v(p_{\ell}), which can be calculated perturbatively. The hadronic current HμH_{\mu} describes the charged-current matrix element of the B→b1(1235)B \to b_{1}(1235) transition. Its nonperturbative dynamics is parametrized in terms of a finite set of independent TFFs through a Lorentz-covariant decomposition of the matrix element. For the Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay, the weak production of the b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) resonance is followed by the strong decay b1(1235)→ωπb_{1}(1235) \to\omega\pi. These two parts are connected through the b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) propagator. The corresponding resonance line shape is described by a Breit-Wigner form with a mass-dependent width, which allows the finite-width effect of the b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) resonance to be incorporated. The differential decay width is given by dΓ=∣M∣2dΦ4/(2mB)d\Gamma= |\mathcal{M}|^{2}d\Phi_{4}/(2m_{B}), where dΦ4d\Phi_{4} denotes the four-body Lorentz-invariant phase space. For the process B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB \to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell}, the phase space can be factorized into the successive two-body phase spaces B→(ωπ)W∗B \to(\omega\pi)W^{*}, (ωπ)→ωπ(\omega\pi) \to\omega\pi, W∗→ℓ+νℓW^{*} \to\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell}. After integrating over the overall orientation of the spinless initial BB meson and neglecting the charged-lepton mass, the final-state kinematics can be completely described by five variables, as shown in Figure 1. The five variables are the invariant mass squared of the ωπ\omega\pi system, s≡mωπ2=(pω+pπ)2s \equiv m_{\omega\pi}^{2} = (p_{\omega} + p_{\pi})^{2}; the invariant mass squared of the ℓ+νℓ\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} system, q2≡(pℓ+pν)2q^{2} \equiv(p_{\ell} + p_{\nu})^{2}; the polar angles θω\theta_{\omega} and θℓ\theta_{\ell} defined in the ωπ\omega\pi and ℓ+νℓ\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} rest frames, respectively; and the azimuthal angle χ\chi between the two decay planes. Here, pωp_{\omega}, pπp_{\pi}, pℓp_{\ell} and pνp_{\nu} denote the four-momenta of the ω\omega meson, the pion, the charged lepton, and the neutrino, respectively. In terms of these five variables, the differential decay width can be written as

Definition of angular variable

Figure 1. Definition of angular variable, among them, the three-momenta of ℓ+\ell^{+} in the rest frame of the virtual W+W^{+} and of ωπ\omega\pi rest frame are denoted by Kℓ+K_{\ell^{+}} and KωK_{\omega}, respectively. The unit vector along the ωπ\omega\pi direction in the BB rest frame is set as v^\hat{v}, and the unit vectors along the components of KωK_{\omega} and Kℓ+K_{\ell^{+}} that are perpendicular to v^\hat{v} are defined as c^\hat{c} and d^\hat{d}, respectively.

d5Γdsdq2dcos⁡θωdcos⁡θℓdχ=GF2∣Vub∣2(4π)6mB3X(s,q2)β(s)I,(2)\frac{d^{5}\Gamma}{dsdq^{2}d\cos\theta_{\omega}d\cos\theta_{\ell}d\chi} = \frac{G_{F}^{2}|V_{ub}|^{2}}{(4\pi)^{6}m_{B}^{3}}X(s,q^{2})\beta(s)\mathcal{I}, \tag*{(2)}

where X(s,q2)=mB∣pωπ(s,q2)∣X(s,q^{2}) = m_{B}|\mathbf{p}_{\omega\pi}(s,q^{2})| and β(s)=2∣p∗(s)∣/s\beta(s) = 2|\mathbf{p}^{*}(s)|/\sqrt{s}. Here, ∣pωπ∣|\mathbf{p}_{\omega\pi}| denotes the magnitude of the three-momentum of the ωπ\omega\pi system in the BB-meson rest frame, while ∣p∗(s)∣|\mathbf{p}^{*}(s)| denotes the magnitude of the three-momentum of the ω\omega (or equivalently the π\pi) in the ωπ\omega\pi rest frame. The angular function I\mathcal{I} can be decomposed into nine angular terms, I1\mathcal{I}_{1}–I9\mathcal{I}_{9}, which depend on ss, q2q^{2}, and θω\theta_{\omega} [62]. The physical phase-space region for the Bℓ4B\ell_{4} decay B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB \to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} is determined by energy-momentum conservation. The allowed kinematic ranges are (mω+mπ)2≤s≤(mB−mℓ)2(m_{\omega} + m_{\pi})^{2} \leq s \leq(m_{B} - m_{\ell})^{2} and mℓ2≤q2≤(mB−s)2m_{\ell}^{2} \leq q^{2} \leq(m_{B} - \sqrt{s})^{2}. For a fixed invariant mass squared ss of the ωπ\omega\pi system, the maximum value of the dilepton invariant mass squared is therefore determined by qmax⁡2=(mB−s)2q_{\max}^{2} = (m_{B} - \sqrt{s})^{2}. To obtain the double differential decay width with respect to the hadronic invariant mass squared ss and the dilepton invariant mass squared q2q^{2}, the angular variables appearing in Eq. (2) need to be integrated over. Upon integration over the full angular phase space, only terms with nonvanishing angular integrals survive, while the remaining interference terms vanish. Thus, the double differential decay width is obtained as:

dΓ(B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+ν)dsdq2=29GF2∣Vub∣2∣pωπ∣1024π5mB2β(s)[∣F11(s,q2)∣2+∣F21(s,q2)∣2+∣F31(s,q2)∣2],(3)\frac{d\Gamma(B \to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu)}{dsdq^{2}} = \frac{2}{9}\frac{G_{F}^{2}|V_{ub}|^{2}|\mathbf{p}_{\omega\pi}|}{1024\pi^{5}m_{B}^{2}\beta(s)} \left[|\mathcal{F}_{11}(s,q^{2})|^{2}+|\mathcal{F}_{21}(s,q^{2})|^{2}+|\mathcal{F}_{31}(s,q^{2})|^{2}\right], \tag*{(3)}

Here, F11(s,q2)\mathcal{F}_{11}(s,q^{2}), F21(s,q2)\mathcal{F}_{21}(s,q^{2}), and F31(s,q2)\mathcal{F}_{31}(s,q^{2}) denote the corresponding P-wave amplitudes. In the quark model, the b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) resonance is classified as a 1P1^{1}P_{1} state, corresponding to a P-wave axial-vector state [1, 31]. Therefore, only the P-wave contribution is retained. According to previous studies, P-wave amplitudes entering the angular distribution can be directly related to the helicity amplitudes describing the weak B→b1(1235)B \to b_{1}(1235) transition [62, 64]. Therefore, the partial-wave amplitudes Fi1(s,q2)\mathcal{F}_{i1}(s,q^{2}) (i=1,2,3i = 1, 2, 3) can be expressed in terms of the helicity amplitudes as follows:

F11(s,q2)=22αqH0(s,q2)A(s),\mathcal{F}_{11}(s,q^{2}) = 2\sqrt{2}\alpha q H_{0}(s,q^{2})A(s),
F21(s,q2)=2αq(H+(s,q2)+H−(s,q2))A(s),\mathcal{F}_{21}(s,q^{2}) = 2\alpha q\left(H_{+}(s,q^{2}) + H_{-}(s,q^{2})\right)A(s),
F31(s,q2)=2αq(H+(s,q2)−H−(s,q2))A(s).(4)\mathcal{F}_{31}(s,q^{2}) = 2\alpha q\left(H_{+}(s,q^{2}) - H_{-}(s,q^{2})\right)A(s). \tag*{(4)}

Here, α=[3πBω/(p0∗Γb1(1235)0)]1/2\alpha= [3\pi B_{\omega}/(p_{0}^{*}\Gamma_{b_{1}(1235)}^{0})]^{1/2}. We take the total decay width Γb1(1235)0=0.142\Gamma_{b_{1}(1235)}^{0} = 0.142 GeV and the branching fraction Bω=B(b1(1235)→ωπ)=1B_{\omega} = \mathcal{B}(b_{1}(1235) \to\omega\pi) = 1 [5]. The quantity p0∗p_{0}^{*} denotes the magnitude of the three-momentum of the ω\omega meson in the b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) resonance rest frame, evaluated at the resonance pole mass. In addition, the line shape of the b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) resonance can be described by a Breit-Wigner parametrization with a mass-dependent width [35]. The corresponding line-shape amplitude is given by [35, 65]:

A(s)=mb1(1235)Γb1(1235)0mb1(1235)2−s−imb1(1235)Γb1(1235)(s)B(p∗)B(p0∗).(5)A(s) = \frac{m_{b_{1}(1235)}\Gamma_{b_{1}(1235)}^{0}}{m_{b_{1}(1235)}^{2}-s-im_{b_{1}(1235)}\Gamma_{b_{1}(1235)}(s)}\frac{B(p^{*})}{B(p_{0}^{*})}. \tag*{(5)}

The Γb1(1235)(s)\Gamma_{b_{1}(1235)}(s) denote the mass dependence width have the following form

Γb1(1235)(s)=Γb1(1235)0(p∗p0∗)3mb1(1235)s[B(p∗)B(p0∗)]2.(6)\Gamma_{b_{1}(1235)}(s) = \Gamma_{b_{1}(1235)}^{0}\left(\frac{p^{*}}{p_{0}^{*}}\right)^{3}\frac{m_{b_{1}(1235)}}{\sqrt{s}}\left[\frac{B(p^{*})}{B(p_{0}^{*})}\right]^{2}. \tag*{(6)}

The B(p)=1/(1+rBW2p∗2)1/2B(p) = 1/(1 + r_{\mathrm{BW}}^{2}p^{*2})^{1/2} is the Blatt-Weisskopf damping factor. The three helicity amplitudes can then be related to the axial-vector and vector TFFs V1,2(q2)V_{1,2}(q^{2}) and A(q2)A(q^{2}),

H±(s,q2)=(mB+s)V1(q2)∓2mBpωπmB+sA(q2),H_{\pm}(s,q^{2}) = (m_{B} + \sqrt{s})V_{1}(q^{2}) \mp\frac{2m_{B}p_{\omega\pi}}{m_{B}+\sqrt{s}}A(q^{2}),
H0(s,q2)=12sq2[(mB2−s−q2)(mB+s)V1(q2)−4mB2pωπ2mB+sV2(q2)].(7)H_{0}(s,q^{2}) = \frac{1}{2\sqrt{s}\sqrt{q^{2}}}\left[(m_{B}^{2}-s-q^{2})(m_{B}+\sqrt{s})V_{1}(q^{2}) - \frac{4m_{B}^{2}p_{\omega\pi}^{2}}{m_{B}+\sqrt{s}}V_{2}(q^{2})\right]. \tag*{(7)}

where the TFFs are evaluated at the pole mass of the b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) resonance and have no explicit dependence on ss. We find that V2(q2)V_{2}(q^{2}) contributes only to H0(q2)H_{0}(q^{2}), whereas A(q2)A(q^{2}) contributes only to H±(q2)H_{\pm}(q^{2}). By contrast, V1(q2)V_{1}(q^{2}) contributes to all three helicity amplitudes, H±(q2)H_{\pm}(q^{2}) and H0(q2)H_{0}(q^{2}). At large values of q2q^{2}, the contribution from V1(q2)V_{1}(q^{2}) becomes increasingly important.

Based on the above theoretical analysis, the three TFFs serve as the main nonperturbative inputs for the calculation. A precise understanding of the behavior of these TFFs is essential for two reasons: it enables accurate predictions of the decay branching fraction and provides a theoretical basis for extracting the CKM matrix element ∣Vub∣|V_{ub}| from experimental measurements. The TFFs are indispensable for calculating the above observable physical quantities. Under the LCSR framework, the TFFs are derived from the vacuum-to-meson correlation function, and their dominant form is given as:

Πμ(p,q)=i∫d4xeiq⋅x⟨b1(1235)(p,λ)∣T{jμ(x),jB†(0)}∣0⟩,(8)\Pi_{\mu}(p,q) = i\int d^{4}x e^{iq\cdot x}\langle b_{1}(1235)(p,\lambda)|T\{j_{\mu}(x),j_{B}^{\dagger}(0)\}|0\rangle, \tag*{(8)}

where jμ(x)=uˉ(x)γμ(1−γ5)b(x)j_{\mu}(x) = \bar{u}(x)\gamma_{\mu}(1-\gamma_{5})b(x) and jB†(x)=ibˉ(x)(1+γ5)q2(x)j_{B}^{\dagger}(x) = i\bar{b}(x)(1+\gamma_{5})q_{2}(x). This choice removes contributions from chiral-odd LCDAs, so that the non-perturbative inputs in the TFFs are mainly determined by the chiral-even LCDAs. Following the standard QCDSR, we insert a complete set of states with the same quantum numbers as the BB meson into the correlation function defined in Eq. (8). In this step, we use the matrix element ⟨B(p+q)∣jB†∣0⟩=mB2fB/mb\langle B(p+q)|j_{B}^{\dagger}|0\rangle= m_{B}^{2}f_{B}/m_{b}, where fBf_{B} is the BB-meson decay constant, together with the Lorentz-invariant TFFs. After isolating the pole term of the lowest pseudoscalar BB-meson and using a dispersion relation to model the contributions from higher resonances and the continuum, we obtain the hadronic representation of the correlation function. In the spacelike q2q^{2}-region, the correlation function defined in Eq. (8) can be calculated using QCD. Specifically, we perform an operator product expansion (OPE) near the light cone, where x2∼0x^{2}\sim0. This expansion is valid when (p+q)2−mb2≪0(p+q)^{2}-m_{b}^{2}\ll0 and the momentum transfer satisfies q2∼O(1 GeV2)≪mb2q^{2}\sim O(1\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2})\ll m_{b}^{2}. We then apply a Borel transformation with respect to (p+q)2(p+q)^{2} to enhance the ground-state contribution relative to higher resonances. The continuum contribution is treated using quark-hadron duality, allowing the OPE representation to be matched to the hadronic representation. Within the LCSR framework, this procedure gives the following general expressions for the TFFs:

Ri(q2)=Ni[Aiϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(u,μ)+Biψ3;b1(1235)∥(u)−Ciϕ4;b1(1235)⊥(u)−DiIL(u)−EiH3(u)+GiΦ3;b1(1235)⊥(α)+JiΨ4;b1(1235)⊥(α)+QiΨ4;b1(1235)⊥(α)],(9)R_i(q^2)=\mathcal{N}_i\left[A_i\phi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(u,\mu)+B_i\psi^\parallel_{3;b_1(1235)}(u)-C_i\phi^\perp_{4;b_1(1235)}(u)-D_iI_L(u)-E_iH_3(u)+G_i\Phi^\perp_{3;b_1(1235)}(\alpha)+J_i\Psi^\perp_{4;b_1(1235)}(\alpha)+Q_i\Psi^{\perp}_{4;b_1(1235)}(\alpha)\right], \tag*{(9)}

where i=1,2,3i=1,2,3 corresponding to V1(q2)V_1(q^2), V2(q2)V_2(q^2) and A(q2)A(q^2) in the axial-vector and vector TFFs. For i=0i=0, V0(q2)V_0(q^2) in the axial-vector TFFs satisfies R0(q2)=V3(q2)−V0(q2)R_0(q^2)=V_3(q^2)-V_0(q^2), where V3(q2)V_3(q^2) is an auxiliary TFF. The explicit expressions for all parameters appearing in the analytical formulas for the TFFs are presented in Appendix Appendix A.

For the two-particle twist-3 LCDAs ψ3;b1(1235)∥(x,μ)\psi^\parallel_{3;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu) and ϕ3;b1(1235)∥(x,μ)\phi^\parallel_{3;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu), the analysis is more complicated than that for pseudoscalar states. This is because axial-vector states have different polarization states and their mass cannot be ignored. As a result, handling these functions becomes more difficult. In 2007, the twist-3 LCDAs of axial-vector states were systematically studied [44]. Using a conformal partial-wave expansion and the QCD equations of motion, which showed that ψ3;b1(1235)∥(x,μ)\psi^\parallel_{3;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu) and ϕ3;b1(1235)∥(x,μ)\phi^\parallel_{3;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu) are not independent. Instead, they can be expressed in terms of simpler quantities: the Wandzura-Wilczek (WW) part derived from the twist-2 LCDA, the three-particle LCDAs, and the terms from quark mass corrections. Among them, the contribution from the three-particle LCDAs is very small, we can safely ignore it. The quark mass correction terms involve a factor δ±\delta_{\pm}, which depends on the quark mass inside the meson. For the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance, this factor is basically zero [66]. As a result, the WW approximation is adopted in this paper. Under this approximation, the two-particle twist-3 LCDAs ψ3;b1(1235)∥(x,μ)\psi^\parallel_{3;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu) and ϕ3;b1(1235)∥(x,μ)\phi^\parallel_{3;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu) can be approximately expressed as convolution integrals of the transverse twist-2 LCDA ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)\phi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu). The explicit expressions are given in Ref. [44]. Therefore, the twist-3 two-particle LCDAs required in the subsequent calculations can all be determined from ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)\phi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu) under the WW approximation. Using the higher-twist LCDAs given in Ref. [67] within the simplest self-consistent approximation satisfying the QCD equations of motion, we obtain the expressions for Φ3;b1(1235)⊥(αi)\Phi^\perp_{3;b_1(1235)}(\alpha_i), ψ4;b1(1235)⊥(x)\psi^\perp_{4;b_1(1235)}(x) and ϕ4;b1(1235)⊥(x)\phi^\perp_{4;b_1(1235)}(x). The values of the coefficients entering these expressions are given in Ref. [68].

The correlation functions in Eq. (9), together with the WW approximation, indicate that the dominant contributions to the TFFs arise from the transverse twist-2 LCDA of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance. We therefore employ the light-cone harmonic oscillator (LCHO) model to construct this LCDA. The twist-2 LCDA ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ0)\phi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu_0) can be obtained from the corresponding light-cone wave function (LCWF) ψ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,k⊥)\psi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{k}_{\perp}) by integrating over the transverse momentum. The relation between the LCDA and LCWF is given by:

ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)=23f~b1(1235)⊥∫∣k⊥∣≤μdk⊥16π3ψ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,k⊥),(10)\phi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu)=\frac{2\sqrt{3}}{\widetilde{f}^{\perp}_{b_1(1235)}}\int_{\lvert\mathbf{k}_{\perp}\rvert\leq\mu}\frac{d\mathbf{k}_{\perp}}{16\pi^{3}}\psi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mathbf{k}_{\perp}), \tag*{(10)}

where f~b1(1235)⊥=fb1(1235)⊥/3\widetilde{f}_{b_1(1235)}^{\perp}=f_{b_1(1235)}^{\perp}/\sqrt{3} and k⊥\mathbf{k}_{\perp} represents the transverse momentum of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance. Following the Brodsky-Huang-Lepage (BHL) description [49, 50, 51], the light meson wave function ψ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,k⊥)\psi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mathbf{k}_{\perp}) can be broken down into a spin wave function χb1(1235)h1h2(x,k⊥)\chi_{b_1(1235)}^{h_1h_2}(x,\mathbf{k}_{\perp}) and a spatial wave function Ψ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,k⊥)\Psi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mathbf{k}_{\perp}), which can be written as

ψ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,k⊥)=∑h1h2χb1(1235)h1h2(x,k⊥)Ψ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,k⊥),(11)\psi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(\mathbf{x},\mathbf{k}_{\perp})=\sum_{h_1h_2}\chi_{b_1(1235)}^{h_1h_2}(x,\mathbf{k}_{\perp})\Psi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mathbf{k}_{\perp}), \tag*{(11)}

In this expression, the correct relativistic spin structure is provided by χb1(1235)h1h2(x,k⊥)\chi_{b_1(1235)}^{h_1h_2}(x,\mathbf{k}_{\perp}), and the longitudinal and transverse momentum distributions of the quark-antiquark pair are described by Ψ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,k⊥)\Psi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mathbf{k}_{\perp}). The symbols h1h_1 and h2h_2 refer to the helicities of the quark and antiquark, respectively. The function χb1(1235)h1h2(x,k⊥)\chi_{b_1(1235)}^{h_1h_2}(x,\mathbf{k}_{\perp}) describes the coupling structure of the quark and antiquark spins, and it is determined by the Wigner Melosh rotation [51, 69, 70]. The spin-orbit coupling information is incorporated into the corresponding projection factors and wave-function definitions through the Wigner-Melosh rotation. For convenience, then, takes the simplified form χb1(1235)h1h2(k⊥)=m^q/(k⊥2+m^q2)1/2\chi_{b_1(1235)}^{h_1h_2}(\mathbf{k}_{\perp})=\widehat{m}_q/(\mathbf{k}_{\perp}^{2}+\widehat{m}_q^{2})^{1/2}, where m^q=300 MeV\widehat{m}_q=300\ \mathrm{MeV} is the constituent quark mass. Brodsky-Huang-Lepage (BHL) established a scheme by comparing the off-shell propagators in the rest frame and the light-front representation. In this scheme, the harmonic oscillator wave function in the rest frame is mapped to the light-front momentum space [71]. Therefore, the spatial wave function Ψ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,k⊥)\Psi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mathbf{k}_{\perp}) can be split into two parts. The first depends only on the longitudinal momentum fraction xx and is written as φ(x)\varphi(x). The second depends on k⊥k_{\perp} and comes from the harmonic oscillator solution that describes the meson in its rest frame Ψ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,k⊥)=A2;b1(1235)⊥φ(x)exp⁡[−b2;b1(1235)⊥(k⊥2+m^q2)/(xxˉ)]\Psi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mathbf{k}_{\perp})=A^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}\varphi(x)\exp[-b^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(\mathbf{k}_{\perp}^{2}+\widehat{m}_q^{2})/(x\bar{x})] with xˉ=(1−x)\bar{x}=(1-x), where A2;b1(1235)⊥A^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)} is the normalization constant, b2;b1(1235)⊥b^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)} is the harmonic parameter. When quark-spin effects are taken into account, the Lorentz boost induces an additional longitudinal correction to the LCDA, which is incorporated through the function φ(x)\varphi(x). This function can be expanded in terms of Gegenbauer polynomials as φ(x)=1+B2;b1(1235)⊥C23/2(ξ)\varphi(x)=1+B^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}C_2^{3/2}(\xi) with ξ=(2x−1)\xi=(2x-1), where C23/2(ξ)C_2^{3/2}(\xi) is a Gegenbauer polynomial and B2;b1(1235)⊥B^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)} plays an important role in determining the longitudinal part of the distribution. Finally, by integrating over the transverse momentum using Eq. (10), we can determine the twist-2 LCDA ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)\phi^\perp_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu) within the LCHO model. result is

ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)=A2;b1(1235)⊥3xxˉmq8π3/2fb1(1235)⊥b2;b1(1235)2[1+B2;b1(1235)⊥C23/2(ξ)][Erf⁡(b2;b1(1235)⊥μ2+m^q2xxˉ)−Erf⁡(b2;b1(1235)⊥m^q2xxˉ)](12)\phi^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu)=\frac{A^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}\sqrt{3x\bar{x}m_q}}{8\pi^{3/2}f^{\perp}_{b_1(1235)}b^{2}_{2;b_1(1235)}}\left[1+B^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}C^{3/2}_2(\xi)\right] \left[\operatorname{Erf}\left(b^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}\sqrt{\frac{\mu^2+\hat{m}_q^2}{x\bar{x}}}\right)-\operatorname{Erf}\left(b^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}\sqrt{\frac{\hat{m}_q^2}{x\bar{x}}}\right)\right] \tag*{(12)}

where Erf⁡(x)=2∫0xe−t2 dt/π\operatorname{Erf}(x)=2\int_0^x e^{-t^2}\,\mathrm{d}t/\sqrt{\pi} denotes the error function, it is obtained by integrating over the transverse momentum and rewriting the integral in Gaussian form. The integral result can be expressed as the difference between two error functions, with the first evaluated at the upper limit of the transverse-momentum integral ∣k⊥∣=μ|\mathbf{k}_{\perp}|=\mu, and the second at the lower limit ∣k⊥∣=0|\mathbf{k}_{\perp}|=0. The difference between these two error functions represents the contribution to the twist-2 LCDA from transverse momentum below the factorization scale μ\mu. This form in Eq. (12) has two useful features. First, it approaches the asymptotic form ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,∞)=6xxˉ\phi^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\infty)=6x\bar{x} in the limit of large μ\mu. Second, it is exponentially suppressed near the endpoints, thereby suppressing endpoint singularities in convolution integrals. In addition, three model parameters remain to be determined A2;b1(1235)⊥A^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}, b2;b1(1235)⊥b^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}, and B2;b1(1235)⊥B^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}. To do that, we use some extra conditions: (i) The normalization condition of the twist-2 LCDA for the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance; (ii) The average value of the transverse momentum squared ⟨k⊥2⟩2;b1(1235)1/2=0.37\langle k^2_{\perp}\rangle^{1/2}_{2;b_1(1235)}=0.37 GeV [72]; (iii) The first Gegenbauer moments of the twist-2 LCDA. For this purpose, we adopt the value a2;b1(1235)⊥(μ0)=0.03±0.19a^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}(\mu_0)=0.03\pm0.19 at the initial scale μ0=1\mu_0=1 GeV [44]. The above theoretical framework lays the foundation for calculating the physical observables considered in this work.

Numerical Analysis

Before performing the numerical analysis, we adopt the following input parameters from PDG[1]. The masses of charged and neutral BB-mesons and b1(1235)b_1(1235)-resonance are taken as mB+=5279.42±0.08m_{B^+}=5279.42\pm0.08 MeV, mB0=5279.72±0.08m_{B^0}=5279.72\pm0.08 MeV and mb1(1235)=1229.5±3.2m_{b_1(1235)}=1229.5\pm3.2 MeV, respectively. For the quark masses, we use mb=4.18−0.03+0.04m_b=4.18^{+0.04}_{-0.03} GeV, md=4.76±0.07m_d=4.76\pm0.07 MeV and mu=2.16±0.07m_u=2.16\pm0.07 MeV. The masses of the ω\omega and π\pi mesons are taken as mω=782.66±0.13m_\omega=782.66\pm0.13 MeV and mπ=139.57±0.00018m_\pi=139.57\pm0.00018 MeV. The decay constant fB+=fB0=0.160±0.019f_{B^+}=f_{B^0}=0.160\pm0.019 GeV [48], and fb1(1235)⊥=0.180±0.0008f^{\perp}_{b_1(1235)}=0.180\pm0.0008 GeV [44]. For B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)B\to b_1(1235)(\to\omega\pi) transition, we take the typical process scale μk=(mB2−mb12)1/2≃3.2\mu_k=(m_B^2-m_{b_1}^2)^{1/2}\simeq3.2 GeV. The transverse twist-2 LCDA ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)\phi^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu) plays a key role in determining the TFFs, both directly and indirectly. We therefore investigate the behavior of the transverse twist-2 LCDA ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)\phi^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu) firstly. Using the three conditions mentioned before: normalization, average transverse momentum squared, and Gegenbauer moment, we can fix the unknown parameters for ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)\phi^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu). To obtain the LCDA parameters at any scale, the Gegenbauer moment a2;b1(1235)⊥(μ)a^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}(\mu) can be evolved from initial scale μ0\mu_0 to typical process scale μk\mu_k by

A2;b1(1235)⊥A^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}B2;b1(1235)⊥B^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}b2;b1(1235)⊥b^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}
+25.877+0.182−0.574
+29.671+0.012−0.626
+32.401−0.175−0.662
+24.703+0.152−0.584
+27.604+0.022−0.623
+29.910−0.118+0.653

Table 2. The three model parameters of b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance transverse twist-2 LCDA, i.e. A2;b1(1235)⊥A^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}, B2;b1(1235)⊥B^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}, and b2;b1(1235)⊥b^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)} at initial and typical scale μ0\mu_0. From which the upper limits, central values, lower limits are present, respectively.

using the renormalization group equation

an;b1(1235)⊥(μ)=an;b1(1235)⊥(μ0)[αs(μ0)αs(μk)]−γn2β0.(13)a^{\perp}_{n;b_1(1235)}(\mu)=a^{\perp}_{n;b_1(1235)}(\mu_0)\left[\frac{\alpha_s(\mu_0)}{\alpha_s(\mu_k)}\right]^{-\frac{\gamma_n}{2\beta_0}}. \tag*{(13)}

The one-loop anomalous dimensions are given by [73, 74]:

γn=CF(1−2(n+1)(n+2)+4∑j=2n+11j).(14)\gamma_n=C_F\left(1-\frac{2}{(n+1)(n+2)}+4\sum_{j=2}^{n+1}\frac{1}{j}\right). \tag*{(14)}

Here, β0=11−2/3nf\beta_0=11-2/3n_f, where nfn_f denotes the number of active quark flavors. The resulting numerical values are listed in Table II. The resulting behavior of ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)\phi^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu) is shown in Figure 2, where the uncertainty comes from the error in a2;b1(1235)⊥(μ0)a^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}(\mu_0). The transverse twist-2 LCDA ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ0)\phi^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu_0) obtained in this work is presented in Figure 2, with the solid curve representing the central value and the shaded band indicating the corresponding uncertainty. For comparison, the QCDSR prediction based on the truncated Gegenbauer expansion is also included [44]. Our result is in good agreement with the QCDSR [44] prediction, with both exhibiting a single-peak structure symmetric about x=0.5x=0.5, and agreement with the theoretical expectation. Our numerical result is slightly higher than the QCDSR [44] prediction, but it is still within the error range. This discrepancy may arise from differences in model construction, the choice of input parameters, and uncertainty propagation. Overall, the results presented in Figure 2 support the applicability of the LCHO model in constructing the transverse twist-2 LCDA of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance and provide a useful theoretical input for the subsequent calculation of the TFFs. In addition, the calculation of the TFFs for the B→b1(1235)B \to b_1(1235) transition requires two important input parameters: the continuum threshold s0s_0 and the Borel parameter M2M^2. In the QCD sum rule approach [76, 77, 78], we use the following criteria to determine them:

The behavior of the transverse twist-2 LCDA

Figure 2. The behavior of ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ0)\phi^{\perp}_{2;b_1(1235)}(x,\mu_0) in LCHO model within uncertainties. The dashed line represents the previous QCDSR [44] prediction.

  • The contribution from the continuum is less than 35%.

  • The contribution from higher-twist LCDAs does not exceed 5%.

  • The value of the TFFs remains stable within the Borel window.

Based on the constraints mentioned above, we choose the continuum thresholds as s0V0,1,2=30.0(1) GeV2s_0^{V_{0,1,2}} = 30.0(1)\ \mathrm{GeV}^2 and s0A=32.0(1) GeV2s_0^A = 32.0(1)\ \mathrm{GeV}^2. The corresponding Borel parameters are chosen as MV12=5.6(1) GeV2M_{V_1}^2 = 5.6(1)\ \mathrm{GeV}^2, MV22=11.0(1) GeV2M_{V_2}^2 = 11.0(1)\ \mathrm{GeV}^2, MV02=7.8(1) GeV2M_{V_0}^2 = 7.8(1)\ \mathrm{GeV}^2, and MA2=6.0(1) GeV2M_A^2 = 6.0(1)\ \mathrm{GeV}^2. Using the above parameters and Eq. (9), we can determine the TFFs for B→b1(1235)B \to b_1(1235) at large recoil. The results are presented in Table III and compared with the theoretical predictions from pQCD [36], LCSR(I) [75], and LCSR(II) [38]. The uncertainties in our predicted TFFs are controlled within the range of 10% − 15%. Our results for V1(0)V_1(0) agrees well with the pQCD prediction [36], while our result for V2(0)V_2(0) is close to the LCSR(I) prediction [75]. For the remaining TFFs, our predictions have some differences compared to LCSR(I) [75] and LCSR(II) [38]. These discrepancies may arise from differences in the choices of chiral currents and the input distribution amplitudes adopted in the respective approaches. Additionally, we can define two particularly interesting ratios in the large-recoil region, rV=A(0)/V1(0)r_V = A(0)/V_1(0) and r2=V2(0)/V1(0)r_2 = V_2(0)/V_1(0). These ratios can be obtained without relying on the total decay width or the CKM matrix elements, and they effectively remove common uncertainties from the overall normalization of the TFFs. This makes them more sensitive to differences in how various models describe the internal dynamics of hadrons. These ratios are listed in Table IV, together with other theoretical predictions. Different theoretical approaches employ different methods and input parameters. In this work, we obtain the central values rV=1.530−0.352+0.332r_V = 1.530^{+0.332}_{-0.352} and

V1(0)V_1(0)V2(0)V_2(0)V0(0)V_0(0)A(0)A(0)
This work+0.338−0.052+0.055+0.338^{+0.055}_{-0.052}+0.187−0.034+0.035+0.187^{+0.035}_{-0.034}+0.563−0.070+0.082+0.563^{+0.082}_{-0.070}+0.517−0.084+0.079+0.517^{+0.079}_{-0.084}
pQCD [36]+0.330−0.060−0.020+0.070+0.010(50)+0.330^{+0.070+0.010}_{-0.060-0.020}(50)+0.030(10)(0)(20)+0.030(10)(0)(20)+0.450−0.090+0.100(10)(40)+0.450^{+0.100}_{-0.090}(10)(40)+0.190(40)(10)(30)+0.190(40)(10)(30)
LCSR(I) [75]−0.096−0.017+0.014-0.096^{+0.014}_{-0.017}+0.166−0.023+0.024+0.166^{+0.024}_{-0.023}−0.597−0.070+0.065-0.597^{+0.065}_{-0.070}−0.189−0.068+0.055-0.189^{+0.055}_{-0.068}
LCSR(II) [38]−0.290(90)(60)-0.290(90)(60)−0.170(60)(40)-0.170(60)(40)−0.050(50)(50)-0.050(50)(50)−0.17(6)(4)-0.17(6)(4)
LCSR(III) [37]−0.200(40)-0.200(40)−0.090(20)-0.090(20)−0.390(70)-0.390(70)−0.250(50)-0.250(50)
LFQM [40]+0.180+0.180−0.030-0.030+0.390+0.390+0.100+0.100

Table III. The B→b1(1235)B \to b_1(1235) TFFs V1(0)V_1(0), V2(0)V_2(0) and A(0)A(0) at the large recoil . The predictions of other theories are used for comparison.

rVr_Vr2r_2
This work+1.530−0.016+0.013+1.530^{+0.013}_{-0.016}+0.553−0.015+0.012+0.553^{+0.012}_{-0.015}
pQCD [36]+0.576−0.020−0.001−0.005+0.005+0.012+0.003+0.576^{+0.005+0.012+0.003}_{-0.020-0.001-0.005}+0.091−0.016−0.058+0.010+0.057+0.091^{+0.010+0.057}_{-0.016-0.058}
LCSR(I) [75]+1.969−0.335+0.305+1.969^{+0.305}_{-0.335}−1.729−0.588+0.464-1.729^{+0.464}_{-0.588}
LCSR(II) [38]+0.586−0.036−0.021+0.019+0.014+0.586^{+0.019+0.014}_{-0.036-0.021}+0.586−0.036−0.021+0.019+0.014+0.586^{+0.019+0.014}_{-0.036-0.021}
LCSR(III) [37]+1.250−0.000+0.000+1.250^{+0.000}_{-0.000}+0.450−0.012+0.008+0.450^{+0.008}_{-0.012}
LFQM [40]+0.556+0.556−0.167-0.167

Table IV. The ratio rVr_V and r2r_2 of B→b1(1235)B \to b_1(1235) TFFs. For comparison, other theoretical results are also included.

r2=0.553−0.135+0.134r_2 = 0.553^{+0.134}_{-0.135}. In particular, our prediction for rVr_V differs appreciably from those of pQCD [36], LCSR (II) [38], and LFQM [40]. In general, these approaches predict smaller values of rVr_V than our result. The predictions for r2r_2 also differ to varying degrees among different theoretical approaches, indicating that the relative magnitudes of the TFFs in the B→b1(1235)B \to b_1(1235) transition remain somewhat model-dependent. To facilitate the comparison of theoretical predictions for rVr_V and r2r_2, we present the corresponding confidence ellipse in Figure 3, which illustrates the joint probability distribution of

The $1\sigma$ confidence ellipses for the TFF ratios $r_V$ and $r_2$

Figure 3. The 1σ1\sigma confidence ellipses for the TFFs ratios rVr_V and r2r_2 in the decay B→b1(1235)B \to b_1(1235) are shown. The empirical value rho=−0.57rho = -0.57 is adopted from Ref. [35] to determine the tilt of the ellipses. We also compare our results with predictions from other theoretical approaches.

the two ratios obtained in this work. The comparison reveals differences among theoretical predictions for the three TFFs at the large recoil point. To assess the reliability of these results, one can examine the overall behavior of the TFFs across the full kinematic range.

The LCSR method used to calculate the B→b1(1235)B \to b_{1}(1235) TFFs is reliable mainly in the low and intermediate q2q^{2} regions, but the decay width and branching fraction require knowledge of how the TFFs behave across the entire physical q2q^{2}. To analytically continue the TFFs to the full allowed physical region, we employ the simplified series expansion (SSE) [79], given by

Fi(q2)=11−q2/mR,i2∑k=0,1,2βk,izk(q2,t0).F_{i}(q^{2}) = \frac{1}{1-q^{2}/m_{R,i}^{2}}\sum_{k=0,1,2}\beta_{k,i}z^{k}(q^{2},t_{0}).

Where βk,i\beta_{k,i} is a coefficients, the conformal variable z(q2,t0)z(q^{2},t_{0}) and the reference point t0t_{0} follow the standard definitions given in Ref. [79]. This parametrization provides a systematic and largely model-independent description of the semileptonic TFFs. It allows the near-threshold behavior of the form factors to constrain the expansion coefficients while preserving their analytic structure.

Additionally, the real coefficients βk,i\beta_{k,i} are determined by requiring the quality of extrapolation Δ\Delta to be less than 1%. Using the input values reported in Ref. [80] and by the PDG [1], we obtain the fit parameters mR,im_{R,i} and the fit quality Δ\Delta for each form factor, as listed in Table V. In this case, all LCSR parameters are set to their central values. From the table, the values of Δ\Delta corresponding to the four TFFs are found to be 0.030%, 0.806%, 0.007% and 0.145%, respectively, all of which are less than 1%. Among them, A(0)A(0) has the best fit quality. Although the Δ\Delta value for V2(0)V_{2}(0) is relatively large, it is still significantly lower than 1%. This indicates that adopted parametrization accurately reproduces the LCSR results for the TFFs within the fitting interval, providing a reliable basis for further investigating their behavior over the full kinematic region. Using the parametrization described above, we obtain the q2q^2 dependence of the TFFs over the full physical kinematic range, as shown in Figure 4. In Figure 4, the solid curves represent the central values, while the shaded bands indicate the corresponding uncertainties. We also compare our results with the predictions from LCSR (I) [75], LCSR (II) [38], and pQCD [36]. The different theoretical approaches exhibit noticeable differences in the extrapolation behavior of the TFFs. Our extrapolated TFFs show varying degrees of agreement with predictions from different theoretical approaches. In the low and intermediate q2q^2 regions, our result for V1(q2)V_1(q^2) agrees well with the pQCD prediction [36]. Similarly, our result for V2(q2)V_2(q^2) is close to the LCSR (I) prediction [75] in these regions, although the discrepancy gradually increases with q2q^2. In our predictions, both V0(q2)V_0(q^2) and A(q2)A(q^2) remain positive and increase monotonically with q2q^2. This behavior differs markedly from the predictions of LCSR (I) [75] and LCSR (II) [38]. In contrast, the pQCD predictions [36] exhibit a similar q2q^2 dependence to that obtained in this work, although their overall magnitudes are smaller. These differences provide important clues for future experimental tests.

Extrapolated TFFs $V_{0,1,2}(q^{2})$ and $A(q^{2})$ versus $q^{2}$

Figure 4. The extrapolated TFFs V0,1,2(q2)V_{0,1,2}(q^{2}) and A(q2)A(q^{2}) versus q2q^{2}, where the solid line represents the central value and the shaded bands represent the corresponding uncertainties. In addition, the results are also compared with the predictions from LCSR(I) [75], LCSR(II) [38] and pQCD [36] in the figure.

V1(0)V_{1}(0)V2(0)V_{2}(0)A(0)A(0)V0(0)V_{0}(0)
mR,im_{R,i}5.7265.7265.3245.279
β0,i\beta_{0,i}0.3380.1880.5180.560
β1,i\beta_{1,i}0.4600.519−1.981-1.981−2.843-2.843
β2,i\beta_{2,i}1.781−1.034-1.0340.74555.865
Δ\Delta0.030%0.806%0.007%0.145%

Table V. The fitted parameters mR,im_{R,i} (GeV), βk,i\beta_{k,i} (k=0,1,2k = 0, 1, 2) and quality of extrapolation Δ\Delta for B→b1(1235)B \to b_{1}(1235) TFFs V0,1,2(0)V_{0,1,2}(0) and A(0)A(0). All LCSR parameters are set to be their central values.

The differential decay widths are calculated using these TFFs, with ∣Vub∣=(3.82±0.20)×10−3|V_{ub}| = (3.82 \pm0.20) \times10^{-3} adopted [1]. Detailed behavior is shown in Figure 5. To calculate the total decay width of B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓνℓB \to b_1(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell\nu_\ell, the integration range over the invariant mass ss corresponding to Eq. (3) is (mω+mπ)2≤s≤(mB−mℓ)2(m_\omega+ m_\pi)^2 \le s \le(m_B - m_\ell)^2. The maximum value of q2q^2 given by qmax⁡2=(mB−(mω+mπ))2q^2_{\max} = (m_B - (m_\omega+ m_\pi))^2. Overall, the peak in the differential decay-width distribution for B→b1(1235)ℓνℓB \to b_1(1235)\ell\nu_\ell is relatively mild. This behavior can be attributed in part to the Breit-Wigner line shape of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance, which redistributes the available phase space and, through the kinematic correlations between ss and q2q^2, shifts the q2q^2 distribution toward lower values. In addition, a faster decline is observed in B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓνℓB \to b_1(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell\nu_\ell near the endpoint, this is because the phase space of the ωπ\omega\pi system is suppressed near the endpoint. To further illustrate the finite-width effects, the double-differential decay width d2Γ/(dsdq2)\mathrm{d}^2\Gamma/(\mathrm{d}s\mathrm{d}q^2) is displayed in the (s,q2)(s,q^2) plane in Figure 6. The distribution is mainly concentrated near the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance region, and the global maximum is found at q2≃10.1 GeV2q^2 \simeq10.1\ \mathrm{GeV}^2. As is seen in the figure, when ss increases from 1.08 GeV21.08\ \mathrm{GeV}^2 to 1.98 GeV21.98\ \mathrm{GeV}^2, the peak position of the q2q^2 distribution is shifted from about 11.40 GeV211.40\ \mathrm{GeV}^2 to about 9.00 GeV29.00\ \mathrm{GeV}^2, indicating that the shape of the q2q^2 distribution is changed with ss. This behavior arises from the explicit dependence of the kinematic upper limit qmax⁡2=(mB−s)2q^2_{\max} = (m_B - \sqrt{s})^2 on ss: as ss increases, the kinematically allowed q2q^2 region shrinks. In the finite-width treatment, the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance is not approximated as a state with a fixed invariant mass; instead, its invariant mass ss varies across the ωπ\omega\pi spectrum. Accounting for the finite width of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance is essential for a reliable description of the Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay. Our results demonstrate that the finite-width effects of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance cannot be neglected in the four-body decay B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓνℓB \to b_1(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell\nu_\ell. After integrating over q2q^2 in the whole physical region, the corresponding decay widths can be obtained,

Differential decay widths of $B \to b_{1}(1235)(\to \omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell}$

Figure 5. The differential decay widths dΓ/dq2\mathrm{d}\Gamma/\mathrm{d}q^{2} of B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB \to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} are plotted as functions of q2q^{2}, the shaded area represents the uncertainty band of dΓ(B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓ)/dq2\mathrm{d}\Gamma(B \to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell})/\mathrm{d}q^{2} for the corresponding channel.

Three-dimensional distribution of the double differential decay width

Figure 6. For the process B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)e+νeB \to b_1(1235)(\to\omega\pi)e^+\nu_e, a three-dimensional distribution of the double differential width d2Γ/dsdq2\mathrm{d}^2\Gamma/\mathrm{d}s\mathrm{d}q^2 as a function of ss and q2q^2 is presented, where the height of the surface corresponds to the value of the differential decay width.

Γ(B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)e+νe)=(0.531−0.149+0.181)×10−16 GeV,Γ(B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)μ+νμ)=(0.530−0.148+0.181)×10−16 GeV,Γ(B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)τ+ντ)=(0.478−0.096+0.112)×10−16 GeV.(15)\begin{aligned} \Gamma(B \to b_1(1235)(\to\omega\pi)e^+\nu_e) &= (0.531^{+0.181}_{-0.149}) \times10^{-16}\ \mathrm{GeV},\\ \Gamma(B \to b_1(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\mu^+\nu_\mu) &= (0.530^{+0.181}_{-0.148}) \times10^{-16}\ \mathrm{GeV},\\ \Gamma(B \to b_1(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\tau^+\nu_\tau) &= (0.478^{+0.112}_{-0.096}) \times10^{-16}\ \mathrm{GeV}. \tag*{(15)} \end{aligned}

Finally, using the lifetime τB+=(1.638±0.004) ps\tau_{B^+} = (1.638 \pm0.004)\ \mathrm{ps} and τB0=(1.512±0.003) ps\tau_{B^0} = (1.512 \pm0.003)\ \mathrm{ps} provided by the PDG [1], we have calculated the branching ratio of the Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB \to b_1(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^+\nu_\ell. To assess the impact of the finite-width effects, we also present the branching fraction for the three-body semileptonic decay B→b1(1235)ℓ+νℓB \to b_1(1235)\ell^+\nu_\ell in Table VI. For comparison, we include the corresponding theoretical predictions from LCSR (I) [75], LCSR (II) [38], and CLFQM [39]. In Table VI, the branching ratios of B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB \to b_1(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^+\nu_\ell in the ee and μ\mu channels are almost the same. This indicates that the lepton mass effect effects are negligible, consistent with the expectation of lepton-flavor universality. The branching ratios of the three-body semileptonic decay B→b1(1235)ℓ+νℓB \to b_1(1235)\ell^+\nu_\ell in the ee and μ\mu channels are close to those from LCSR [75]. For the τ\tau channel, the branching ratio is somewhat smaller than those in the other two channels. This is mainly because the larger τ\tau mass reduces the available phase space. It is worth noting that, in both the electron and muon channels, the branching fractions for the four-body and three-body semileptonic decays differ by nearly a factor of three. This difference may partly arise from the finite width of the b1(1235)b_1(1235) resonance. In the finite-width treatment, the ωπ\omega\pi invariant mass squared ss is integrated over its kinematically allowed range, leading to a four-body decay width that can differ from the result obtained in the narrow-width approximation (NWA) [81]. Currently, no direct experimental measurement of this four-body process is available yet. Our results can provide a reference for future experimental studies.

Decay channelsThis workLCSR(I) [75]LCSR(II) [38]pQCD [36]CLFQM [39]
B(B+→b10(1235)(→ωπ0)e+νe)\mathcal{B}(B^{+}\to b_{1}^{0}(1235)(\to\omega\pi^{0})e^{+}\nu_{e})1.322−0.370+0.4501.322^{+0.450}_{-0.370}––––
B(B+→b10(1235)(→ωπ0)μ+νμ)\mathcal{B}(B^{+}\to b_{1}^{0}(1235)(\to\omega\pi^{0})\mu^{+}\nu_{\mu})1.321−0.370+0.4511.321^{+0.451}_{-0.370}––––
B(B+→b10(1235)(→ωπ0)τ+ντ)\mathcal{B}(B^{+}\to b_{1}^{0}(1235)(\to\omega\pi^{0})\tau^{+}\nu_{\tau})1.190−0.338+0.4091.190^{+0.409}_{-0.338}––––
B(B0→b1−(1235)(→ωπ−)e+νe)\mathcal{B}(B^{0}\to b_{1}^{-}(1235)(\to\omega\pi^{-})e^{+}\nu_{e})1.220−0.342+0.4171.220^{+0.417}_{-0.342}––––
B(B0→b1−(1235)(→ωπ−)μ+νμ)\mathcal{B}(B^{0}\to b_{1}^{-}(1235)(\to\omega\pi^{-})\mu^{+}\nu_{\mu})1.219−0.341+0.4161.219^{+0.416}_{-0.341}––––
B(B0→b1−(1235)(→ωπ−)τ+ντ)\mathcal{B}(B^{0}\to b_{1}^{-}(1235)(\to\omega\pi^{-})\tau^{+}\nu_{\tau})1.099−0.312+0.3771.099^{+0.377}_{-0.312}––––
B(B+→b10(1235)e+νe)\mathcal{B}(B^{+}\to b_{1}^{0}(1235)e^{+}\nu_{e})3.613−1.045+1.2013.613^{+1.201}_{-1.045}2.353−0.456+0.5972.353^{+0.597}_{-0.456}2.070−0.730+0.9002.070^{+0.900}_{-0.730}–0.770±0.1700.770\pm0.170
B(B+→b10(1235)μ+νμ)\mathcal{B}(B^{+}\to b_{1}^{0}(1235)\mu^{+}\nu_{\mu})3.604−1.043+1.1983.604^{+1.198}_{-1.043}2.339−0.448+0.5872.339^{+0.587}_{-0.448}–––
B(B+→b10(1235)τ+ντ)\mathcal{B}(B^{+}\to b_{1}^{0}(1235)\tau^{+}\nu_{\tau})2.463−0.705+0.8352.463^{+0.835}_{-0.705}–––0.300±0.0700.300\pm0.070
B(B0→b1−(1235)e+νe)\mathcal{B}(B^{0}\to b_{1}^{-}(1235)e^{+}\nu_{e})3.332−0.940+1.1083.332^{+1.108}_{-0.940}––––
B(B0→b1−(1235)μ+νμ)\mathcal{B}(B^{0}\to b_{1}^{-}(1235)\mu^{+}\nu_{\mu})3.353−0.965+1.1153.353^{+1.115}_{-0.965}2.166−0.415+0.5442.166^{+0.544}_{-0.415}1.260−0.540+0.6601.260^{+0.660}_{-0.540}––
B(B0→b1−(1235)τ+ντ)\mathcal{B}(B^{0}\to b_{1}^{-}(1235)\tau^{+}\nu_{\tau})2.248−0.640+0.7622.248^{+0.762}_{-0.640}––––

Table VI. TABLE VI: Predictions for the branching ratios of the Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB\to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} with ℓ=(e,μ,τ)\ell=(e,\mu,\tau) and the three-body semileptonic decay B→b1(1235)ℓ+νℓB\to b_{1}(1235)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} are given within the uncertainties (in unit: 10−410^{-4}).

For multibody decays, a cascade description in terms of sequential decay processes is commonly adopted within the factorization approximation [82, 83, 84]. We include the decay ω→π+π−π0\omega\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}. Under the NWA for the ω\omega meson, the branching fraction for B→b1(1235)(→ω(→π+π−π0)π)ℓ+νℓB\to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega(\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0})\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} can then be predicted,

B(B→b1(1235)(→ω(→π+π−π0)π)ℓ+νℓ)=B(B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓ)×B(ω→π+π−π0),(16)\mathcal{B}(B\to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega(\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0})\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell})=\mathcal{B}(B\to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell})\times\mathcal{B}(\omega\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}), \tag*{(16)}

where the B(ω→π+π−π0)=0.892±0.007\mathcal{B}(\omega\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0})=0.892\pm0.007 [1] and

B(B+→b1(1235)0(→ω(→π+π−π0)π0)e+νe)=1.179−0.337+0.415×10−4,\mathcal{B}(B^{+}\to b_{1}(1235)^{0}(\to\omega(\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0})\pi^{0})e^{+}\nu_{e})=1.179^{+0.415}_{-0.337}\times10^{-4},
B(B+→b1(1235)0(→ω(→π+π−π0)π0)μ+νμ)=1.178−0.337+0.414×10−4,\mathcal{B}(B^{+}\to b_{1}(1235)^{0}(\to\omega(\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0})\pi^{0})\mu^{+}\nu_{\mu})=1.178^{+0.414}_{-0.337}\times10^{-4},
B(B+→b1(1235)0(→ω(→π+π−π0)π0)τ+ντ)=1.062−0.307+0.376×10−4,\mathcal{B}(B^{+}\to b_{1}(1235)^{0}(\to\omega(\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0})\pi^{0})\tau^{+}\nu_{\tau})=1.062^{+0.376}_{-0.307}\times10^{-4},
B(B0→b1(1235)−(→ω(→π+π−π0)π−)e+νe)=1.088−0.311+0.382×10−4,\mathcal{B}(B^{0}\to b_{1}(1235)^{-}(\to\omega(\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0})\pi^{-})e^{+}\nu_{e})=1.088^{+0.382}_{-0.311}\times10^{-4},
B(B0→b1(1235)−(→ω(→π+π−π0)π−)μ+νμ)=1.087−0.311+0.383×10−4,\mathcal{B}(B^{0}\to b_{1}(1235)^{-}(\to\omega(\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0})\pi^{-})\mu^{+}\nu_{\mu})=1.087^{+0.383}_{-0.311}\times10^{-4},
B(B0→b1(1235)−(→ω(→π+π−π0)π−)τ+ντ)=0.980−0.284+0.347×10−4(17)\mathcal{B}(B^{0}\to b_{1}(1235)^{-}(\to\omega(\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0})\pi^{-})\tau^{+}\nu_{\tau})=0.980^{+0.347}_{-0.284}\times10^{-4} \tag*{(17)}

The above results give the branching fractions for six six-body BB-meson decay channels arising from the cascade decay involving b1(1235)→ωπb_{1}(1235)\to\omega\pi and ω→π+π−π0\omega\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}. These predictions provide a more complete description of the experimentally accessible final states and extend the phenomenological study of the corresponding multi-body semileptonic decays. They also provide useful theoretical benchmarks for future experimental searches and measurements. Future comparisons between these predictions and experimental data may help test the underlying weak transition dynamics and improve our understanding of the resonance effects in such multi-body decay processes.

Summary

In this paper, we study the Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB\to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} using the QCD sum rules method. We treat the b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) state as an intermediate resonance in this process and construct its transverse LCDA ϕ2;b1(1235)⊥(x,μ)\phi_{2;b_{1}(1235)}^{\perp}(x,\mu) of the b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) resonance using the LCHO model. The model parameters are then determined by three additional constraints, its behavior is shown in Figure 2. Our model exhibits an asymmetric distribution, which is consistent with the QCDSR [44] predictions. These results can be used as nonperturbative inputs for studying the B→b1(1235)ℓ+νℓB\to b_{1}(1235)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} transition. Using the LCDA determined above, we calculate the TFFs at the maximum-recoil point q2=0q^{2}=0 within the LCSR framework, with the results presented in Table III. We then extrapolate the TFFs over the full physical q2q^{2} range to obtain their q2q^{2} dependence, as shown in Figure 4. In particular, our prediction for the overall q2q^{2} dependence of V1(q2)V_{1}(q^{2}) agrees well with the LCSR(I) predictions [75]. Using the TFFs obtained above, we calculate the differential and total decay widths, as well as the branching fractions, for the Bℓ4B_{\ell4} decay B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB\to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell}. The q2q^{2} dependence of the differential decay widths is shown in Figure 5. In addition, Figure 6 presents the three-dimensional distribution of the double-differential decay width d2Γ/dsdq2\mathrm{d}^{2}\Gamma/\mathrm{d}s\mathrm{d}q^{2} for B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)e+νeB\to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)e^{+}\nu_{e} as a function of ss and q2q^{2}. The total decay width is obtained by integrating the differential decay width over the full physical q2q^{2} range. Meanwhile, using the B+B^{+} and B0B^{0} lifetimes reported by the PDG [1], we further predict the branching fractions for the four-body decay. To assess the impact of the finite width of the b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) resonance, we also present the branching fractions for the three-body decay B→b1(1235)ℓ+νℓB\to b_{1}(1235)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} within the NWA. The results are summarised in marized in Table VI. As shown in the table, the branching fractions for the four-body decay in the electron and muon channels are approximately 1/3 times of those for the corresponding three-body decay. This indicates that finite-width effects have a substantial impact on the integrated decay rates. Since the ω\omega can further decay into π+π−π0\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0}, the branching ratio of B→b1(1235)(→ω(→π+π−π0)π)ℓ+νℓB \to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega(\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0})\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} is calculated under the NWA. This provides a theoretical reference for future experiments that observe the decay B→b1(1235)(→ω(→π+π−π0)π)ℓ+νℓB \to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega(\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-}\pi^{0})\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell}. Currently, no direct experimental measurement of this Bℓ4B_{\ell4} process has been reported. It is hoped that in the near future, the results of this work can provide a theoretical reference for future experimental analyses of the B→b1(1235)(→ωπ)ℓ+νℓB \to b_{1}(1235)(\to\omega\pi)\ell^{+}\nu_{\ell} final state. They can also provide a theoretical basis for further determining the internal structure of the b1(1235)b_{1}(1235) resonance.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant No.12665017, No.12265010, the Project of Guizhou Provincial Department of Science and Technology under Grants No.MS[2025]219 and No.CXTD[2025]030.

Appendix A

The general analytic expression for the TFFs obtained by the LCSR method is given below:

Ri(q2)=Ni[AiΦ2;b1(1235)⊥(u,μ)+Biψ3;b1(1235)∥(u)−Ciϕ4;b1(1235)⊥(u)−DiIL(u)−EiH3(u)+GiΦ3;b1(1235)∥(α)+JiΨ4;b1(1235)⊥(α)+QiΨ4;b1(1235)⊥(α)](18)R_i(q^2)=\mathcal{N}_i\left[A_i\Phi_{2;b_1(1235)}^{\perp}(u,\mu)+B_i\psi_{3;b_1(1235)}^{\parallel}(u)-C_i\phi_{4;b_1(1235)}^{\perp}(u)-D_iI_L(u)-E_iH_3(u)+G_i\Phi_{3;b_1(1235)}^{\parallel}(\alpha)+J_i\Psi_{4;b_1(1235)}^{\perp}(\alpha)+Q_i\Psi_{4;b_1(1235)}^{\perp}(\alpha)\right] \tag*{(18)}

where i=1,2,3i=1,2,3, corresponding to R1(q2)=V1(q2)R_1(q^2)=V_1(q^2), R2(q2)=V2(q2)R_2(q^2)=V_2(q^2) and R3(q2)=A(q2)R_3(q^2)=A(q^2). Whereas the function with i=0i=0 gives the combination R0(q2)=V3(q2)−V0(q2)R_0(q^2)=V_3(q^2)-V_0(q^2). The auxiliary TFF V3(q2)V_3(q^2) is defined as:

V3(q2)=mB+mb1(1235)2mb1(1235)V1(q2)−mB−mb1(1235)2mb1(1235)V2(q2).(19)V_3(q^2)=\frac{m_B+m_{b_1(1235)}}{2m_{b_1(1235)}}V_1(q^2)-\frac{m_B-m_{b_1(1235)}}{2m_{b_1(1235)}}V_2(q^2). \tag*{(19)}

Where V3(q2)V_3(q^2) is defined as a linear combination of V1(q2)V_1(q^2) and V1(q2)V_1(q^2), it is not an independent physical TFF. To ensure that the hadronic matrix element has no unphysical kinematic singularity at q2=0q^2=0, the condition V0(0)=V3(0)V_0(0)=V_3(0) must be satisfied. Thus, from the relation among V0(q2)V_0(q^2), V3(q2)V_3(q^2) and R0(q2)R_0(q^2), we have V0(q2)=V3(q2)−R0(q2)V_0(q^2)=V_3(q^2)-R_0(q^2). The individual coefficients for the two-particle and three-particle distribution amplitudes are given below:

N0=mbmb1(1235)fb1(1235)⊥q22fBmB2,N1=mbmb1(1235)2fb1(1235)⊥fBmB2(mB+mb1(1235)),N2=mb(mB+mb1(1235))mb1(1235)2fb1(1235)⊥fBmB2.(20)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{N}_0&=\frac{m_bm_{b_1(1235)}f_{b_1(1235)}^\perp q^2}{2f_Bm_B^2},\\ \mathcal{N}_1&=\frac{m_bm_{b_1(1235)}^2f_{b_1(1235)}^\perp}{f_Bm_B^2(m_B+m_{b_1(1235)})},\\ \mathcal{N}_2&=\frac{m_b(m_B+m_{b_1(1235)})m_{b_1(1235)}^2f_{b_1(1235)}^\perp}{f_Bm_B^2}. \tag*{(20)} \end{aligned}
A0=−∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[1mb1(1235)2Θ(c(u,s0))],A1=Cu∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[1mb1(1235)2Θ(c(u,s0))],A2=∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[1mb1(1235)2Θ(c(u,s0))].(21)\begin{aligned} A_0&=-\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{1}{m_{b_1(1235)}^2}\Theta(c(u,s_0))\right],\\ A_1&=\frac{\mathcal{C}}{u}\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{1}{m_{b_1(1235)}^2}\Theta(c(u,s_0))\right],\\ A_2&=\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{1}{m_{b_1(1235)}^2}\Theta(c(u,s_0))\right]. \tag*{(21)} \end{aligned}
B0=−∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[2−uuM2Θ~(c(u,s0))],B1=mb12∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[1mb1(1235)2Θ(c(u,s0))],B2=−∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[1M2Θ~(c(u,s0))].(22)\begin{aligned} B_0&=-\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{2-u}{uM^2}\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))\right],\\ B_1&=m_{b_1}^2\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{1}{m_{b_1(1235)}^2}\Theta(c(u,s_0))\right],\\ B_2&=-\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{1}{M^2}\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))\right]. \tag*{(22)} \end{aligned}
C0=−14∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[mb2u2M4Θ~(c(u,s0))+Θ~(c(u,s0))uM2],C1=14∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[mb2Cu3M4Θ~(c(u,s0))+C−2mb2u2M2Θ~(c(u,s0))−1uΘ(c(u,s0))],C2=14∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[mb2u2M4Θ~(c(u,s0))+Θ~(c(u,s0))uM2].(23)\begin{aligned} C_0&=-\frac{1}{4}\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{m_b^2}{u^2M^4}\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))+\frac{\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))}{uM^2}\right],\\ C_1&=\frac{1}{4}\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{m_b^2\mathcal{C}}{u^3M^4}\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))+\frac{\mathcal{C}-2m_b^2}{u^2M^2}\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))-\frac{1}{u}\Theta(c(u,s_0))\right],\\ C_2&=\frac{1}{4}\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{m_b^2}{u^2M^4}\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))+\frac{\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))}{uM^2}\right]. \tag*{(23)} \end{aligned}
D0=−∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[(4−2u)Cu3M4Θ~(c(u,s0))−2Θ~(c(u,s0))u2M2+2(2mb2Θ~(c(u,s0))u2M4+1uM2Θ~(c(u,s0)))],D1=2∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[Cu2M2Θ~(c(u,s0))−Θ(c(u,s0))u],D2=2∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[C−2mb2u2M4Θ~(c(u,s0))−Θ~(c(u,s0))uM2].(24)\begin{aligned} D_0&=-\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[(4-2u)\frac{\mathcal{C}}{u^3M^4}\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))-\frac{2\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))}{u^2M^2}+2\left(\frac{2m_b^2\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))}{u^2M^4}+\frac{1}{uM^2}\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))\right)\right],\\ D_1&=2\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{\mathcal{C}}{u^2M^2}\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))-\frac{\Theta(c(u,s_0))}{u}\right],\\ D_2&=2\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{\mathcal{C}-2m_b^2}{u^2M^4}\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))-\frac{\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))}{uM^2}\right]. \tag*{(24)} \end{aligned}
E0=∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[2−uuM2Θ~(c(u,s0))],E1=∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[2mb2uM4Θ(c(u,s0))+Θ(c(u,s0))],E2=∫01duuemB2−s(u)M2[1M2Θ~(c(u,s0))].(25)\begin{aligned} E_0&=\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{2-u}{uM^2}\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))\right],\\ E_1&=\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{2m_b^2}{uM^4}\Theta(c(u,s_0))+\Theta(c(u,s_0))\right],\\ E_2&=\int_0^1\frac{du}{u}e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(u)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{1}{M^2}\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0))\right]. \tag*{(25)} \end{aligned}
G0=−∫Dαi∫01dv emB2−s(X)M212X2M2Θ(c(X,s0)) 4v,(26)G_0=-\int D\alpha_i\int_0^1dv\,e^{\frac{m_B^2-s(X)}{M^2}}\frac{1}{2X^2M^2}\Theta(c(X,s_0))\,4v, \tag*{(26)}
G2=∫Dαi∫01dvemb12−s(X)M212X2M2Θ(c(X,s0)) 4v,(27)G_2=\int\mathcal{D}\alpha_i\int_0^1 dv e^{\frac{m_{b_1}^2-s(X)}{M^2}}\frac{1}{2X^2M^2}\Theta(c(X,s_0))\,4v, \tag*{(27)}
J0=∫Dαi∫01dvemb12−s(X)M212X2M2Θ(c(X,s0))(4v−1),J_0=\int\mathcal{D}\alpha_i\int_0^1 dv e^{\frac{m_{b_1}^2-s(X)}{M^2}}\frac{1}{2X^2M^2}\Theta(c(X,s_0))(4v-1),
J1=∫Dαi∫01dvemb12−s(X)M2[C2X3M2−12X2]Θ(c(X,s0))(4v−1),J_1=\int\mathcal{D}\alpha_i\int_0^1 dv e^{\frac{m_{b_1}^2-s(X)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{C}{2X^3M^2}-\frac{1}{2X^2}\right]\Theta(c(X,s_0))(4v-1),
J2=∫Dαi∫01dvemb12−s(X)M212X2M2Θ(c(X,s0))(4v−1),(28)J_2=\int\mathcal{D}\alpha_i\int_0^1 dv e^{\frac{m_{b_1}^2-s(X)}{M^2}}\frac{1}{2X^2M^2}\Theta(c(X,s_0))(4v-1), \tag*{(28)}
Q0=−∫Dαi∫01dvemb12−s(X)M212X2M2Θ(c(X,s0)),Q_0=-\int\mathcal{D}\alpha_i\int_0^1 dv e^{\frac{m_{b_1}^2-s(X)}{M^2}}\frac{1}{2X^2M^2}\Theta(c(X,s_0)),
Q1=∫Dαi∫01dvemb12−s(X)M2[C2X3M2−12X2]Θ(c(X,s0)),Q_1=\int\mathcal{D}\alpha_i\int_0^1 dv e^{\frac{m_{b_1}^2-s(X)}{M^2}}\left[\frac{C}{2X^3M^2}-\frac{1}{2X^2}\right]\Theta(c(X,s_0)),
Q2=∫Dαi∫01dvemb12−s(X)M212X2M2Θ(c(X,s0)).(29)Q_2=\int\mathcal{D}\alpha_i\int_0^1 dv e^{\frac{m_{b_1}^2-s(X)}{M^2}}\frac{1}{2X^2M^2}\Theta(c(X,s_0)). \tag*{(29)}

Here N3=N2N_3=N_2, A3=A2A_3=A_2, C3=C2C_3=C_2, and B3=D3=E3=G1=G3=J3=Q3=0B_3=D_3=E_3=G_1=G_3=J_3=Q_3=0, C=mb12+u2mb1(1235)2C=m_{b_1}^2+u^2m_{b_1(1235)}^2, s(u)=[mb12−uˉ(q2−umb1(1235)2)]/us(u)=[m_{b_1}^2-\bar{u}(q^2-um_{b_1(1235)}^2)]/u with uˉ=1−u\bar{u}=1-u. We further introduce X=a1−a3X=a_1-a_3, and c(u,s0)=us0−mb12+uuˉq2−uuˉmb1(1235)2c(u,s_0)=us_0-m_{b_1}^2+u\bar{u}q^2-u\bar{u}m_{b_1(1235)}^2. Θ(c(u,s0))\Theta(c(u,s_0)) is the usual step function. Θ~(c(u,s0))\widetilde{\Theta}(c(u,s_0)) and Θ~~(c(u,s0))\widetilde{\widetilde{\Theta}}(c(u,s_0)) are generalized step functions arising from partial integration, their explicit definitions can be found in [60]. The simplified functions IL(u)I_L(u) and H3(u)H_3(u) are defined to [85].

References

References

  1. [1]F. Takahashi et al. [Particle Data Group], Review of Particle Physics, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 41 (2026) 2630011.
  2. [2]S. Cheng, A. Khodjamirian and J. Virto, B → ππ Form Factors from Light-Cone Sum Rules with B-meson Distribution Amplitudes, JHEP 05 (2017) 157. [arXiv:1701.01633]
  3. [3]K. C. Yang, Light-cone distribution amplitudes for the light P-wave singlet state-1 mesons, JHEP 10 (2005) 108. [arXiv:0509337]
  4. [4]Y. Qiao, Y. X. Liu, Y. G. Xu and R. M. Wang, Study of the axial-vector and tensor resonant contributions to the D → VPℓ+νℓ decays based on SU(3) flavor analysis, Eur. Phys. J. C 84 (2024) 1110. [arXiv:2404.03857]
  5. [5]M. Ablikim et al. [BESIII Collaboration], Observation of D0 → b1(1235)−e+νe and evidence for D+ → b1(1235)0e+νe, Phys. Rev. Lett. 136 (2026) 021801. [arXiv:2407.20551]
  6. [6]C. B. Lang, L. Leskovec, D. Mohler and S. Prelovsek, Axial Resonances a1(1260), b1(1235) and Their Decays from the Lattice, JHEP 04 (2014) 162. [arXiv:1401.2088]
  7. [7]K. Chen, C. Q. Pang, X. Liu and T. Matsuki, Light axial vector mesons, Phys. Rev. D 91 (2015) 074025. [arXiv:1501.07766]
  8. [8]J. A. Dankowych, P. Brockman, K. W. Edwards, J. Gandsman, D. Legacy, R. S. Longacre, J. F. Martin, P. M. Patel, A. J. Pawlicki and J. D. Prentice, et al. Evidence for I = 1(A1) and I = 0(H) Axial Vector Resonances in Charge Exchange, Phys. Rev. Lett. 46 (1981) 580.
  9. [9]M. Atkinson et al. [Omega Photon and Bonn-CERN-Glasgow-Lancaster-Manchester-Paris-Rutherford-Sheffield], Photoproduction of π+π−π0 on Hydrogen With Linearly Polarized Photons of Energy 20GeV − 70GeV, Nucl. Phys. B 231 (1984) 15.
  10. [10]A. Ando, K. Imai, S. Inaba, T. Inagaki, Y. Inagaki, A. Itano, S. Kobayashi, A. Murakami, T. Nakamura and K. Ohmi, et al. Experimental study of the axial vector resonances of a1 and h1 in the π−p charge exchange reaction, Phys. Lett. B 291 (1992) 496.
  11. [11]D. M. Asner et al. [CLEO Collaboration], Hadronic structure in the decay τ−→π−π−π+π0 and the sign of the Tau Neutrino Helicity, Phys. Rev. D 61 (2000) 012002. [hep-ex/9902022]
  12. [12]V. Dorofeev, A. Ekimov, Y. Gouz, A. Ivashin, I. Kachaev, A. Karyukhin, Y. Khokhlov, V. Konstantinov, V. Matveev and V. Nikolaenko, et al. Measurement of the f(1)(1285) → π+π−π0 decay, Eur. Phys. J. A 47 (2011) 68.
  13. [13]M. J. Corden, J. D. Dowell, J. Garvey, M. Jobes, I. R. Kenyon, J. Mawson, T. J. McMahon, I. F. Corbett, R. J. Esterling and N. H. Lipman, et al. Observation of the D0 and Delta Mesons in π−p Interactions at 12GeV/c and 15GeV/c, Nucl. Phys. B 144 (1978) 253.
  14. [14]A. Gurtu et al. [Amsterdam-CERN-Nijmegen-Oxford], Production and Decay Properties of the D(1285) Meson in K−p Interactions at 4.2GeV/c, Nucl. Phys. B 151 (1979) 181.
  15. [15]D. Barberis et al. [WA102 Collaboration], A Measurement of the branching fractions of f1(1285) and f1(1420) produced in central pp interactions at 450GeV/c, Phys. Lett. B 440 (1998) 225. [hep-ex/9810003]
  16. [16]C. Bromberg, J. Dickey, G. Fox, R. Gomez, W. Kropac, J. Pine, S. Stampke, H. Haggerty, E. Malamud and R. Abrams, et al. Observations of the D and E Mesons and Possible Three Kaon Enhancements in π−p → K0K±π∓X, K0K+K−X at 50GeV/c and 100GeV/c, Phys. Rev. D 22 (1980) 1513.
  17. [17]C. Dionisi et al. [CERN-College de France-Madrid-Stockholm], Observation and Quantum Numbers Determination of the E(1420) Meson in π−p Interactions at 3.95GeV/c, Nucl. Phys. B 169 (1980) 1.
  18. [18]M. A. Abolins, R. L. Lander, W. A. W. Melhhop, N. huu Xuong and P. M. Yager, Production of Multimeson Resonances via π+p Interaction and Evidence for a πω Resonance, Phys. Rev. Lett. 11 (1963) 381.
  19. [19]R. Bizzarri, M. Foster, P. Gavillet, G. Labrosse, L. Montanet, R. Salmeron, P. Villemoes, C. Ghesquiere and E. Lillestol, Experimental results on the ωπ and ππ systems as observed in the pp annihilations at rest pp → ω0π+π−, Nucl. Phys. B 14 (1969) 169.
  20. [20]C. Baltay, J. C. Severiens, N. Yeh and D. Zanello, Observation of the B-meson in the Reaction p̄p → ω0 + π+ + π−, Phys. Rev. Lett. 18 (1967) 93.
  21. [21]M. Atkinson et al. [Omega Photon Collaboration], Inclusive Photoproduction of Δ(980) and B(1235) at High X(f), Phys. Lett. B 138 (1984) 459.
  22. [22]P. Weidenauer et al. [ASTERIX Collaboration], N anti-N annihilation at rest into five pions, Z. Phys. C 59 (1993) 387.
  23. [23]S. Fukui, N. Horikawa, S. Inaba, T. Inagaki, Y. Inagaki, Y. Ishizaki, T. Iwata, T. Kinashi, M. Kurashina and I. Maeda, et al. Study of ω system in the π⁻p charge exchange reaction at 8.95GeV/c, Phys. Lett. B 257 (1991) 241.
  24. [24]U. Karshon, G. Mikenberg, Y. Eisenberg, S. Pitluck, E. E. Ronat, A. Shapira and G. Yekutieli, Production and Decay Mechanism of the B-meson and the ωπ System in π + p Interactions at 5GeV, Phys. Rev. D 10 (1974) 3608.DOI
  25. [25]P. Fayet and J. Iliopoulos, Spontaneously Broken Supergauge Symmetries and Goldstone Spinors, Phys. Lett. B 51 (1974) 461.DOI
  26. [26]R. Gessaroli, A. Quareni-Vignudelli, S. Berti, A. M. Cartacci, C. Caso, F. Fontanelli, S. Squarcia, U. Trevisan, A. Boldetti and G. Costa, et al. Analysis of the ωπ- System Produced in the Reaction π⁻p → π⁻π⁺π⁰p at 11.2GeV/c, Nucl. Phys. B 126 (1977) 382.DOI
  27. [27]C. Evangelista, B. Ghidini, A. Palano, V. Picciarelli, G. Zito, J. Broring, K. Muller, E. Paul, W. Renneberg and W. Ruhmer, et al. Results From a π⁻p Slow Proton Trigger Experiment at 12 GeV/c, Nucl. Phys. B 178 (1981) 197.DOI
  28. [28]M. Atkinson et al. [Omega Photon Collaboration], A Spin Parity Analysis of the ωπ⁰ Enhancement Photoproduced in the Energy Range 20GeV to 70GeV, Nucl. Phys. B 243 (1984) 1.DOI
  29. [29]B. Collick, S. Heppelmann, T. Joyce, Y. Makdisi, M. L. Marshak, E. A. Peterson, K. Ruddick, D. Berg, C. Chandlee and S. Cihangir, et al. PRIMAKOFF PRODUCTION OF THE B+(1235) MESON, Phys. Rev. Lett. 53 (1984) 2374.
  30. [30]A. Alde et al. [IHEP-IISN-LANL-LAPP-KEK], Study of the omega pi0 system, Z. Phys. C 54 (1992) 553.
  31. [31]S. Godfrey and N. Isgur, Mesons in a Relativized Quark Model with Chromodynamics, Phys. Rev. D 32 (1985) 189.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9955999
  32. [32]D. Ebert, R. N. Faustov and V. O. Galkin, Mass spectra and Regge trajectories of light mesons in the relativistic quark model, Phys. Rev. D 79 (2009) 114029. [arXiv:0903.5183]DOI
  33. [33]K. Jansen et al. [ETM Collaboration], A Lattice QCD calculation of the transverse decay constant of the b(1)(1235) meson, Phys. Lett. B 690 (2010) 491. [arXiv:0910.5883]DOI
  34. [34]H. Kim, M. K. Cheoun and K. S. Kim, Spin-1 diquark contributing to the formation of tetraquarks in light mesons, Eur. Phys. J. C 77 (2017) 173. [arXiv:1611.05502]DOI
  35. [35]P. del Amo Sanchez et al. [BaBar Collaboration], Analysis of the D+ → K−π+e+νe decay channel, Phys. Rev. D 83 (2011) 072001. [arXiv:1201.2180]
  36. [36]R. H. Li, C. D. Lu and W. Wang, Transition form factors of B decays into P-wave axial-vector mesons in the perturbative QCD approach, Phys. Rev. D 79 (2009) 034014. [arXiv:0901.0307]DOI
  37. [37]K. C. Yang, Form-Factors of B(u,d,s) Decays into P-Wave Axial-Vector Mesons in the Light-Cone Sum Rule Approach, Phys. Rev. D 78 (2008) 034018. [arXiv:0807.1171]DOI
  38. [38]Y. J. Sun, Z. G. Wang and T. Huang, B → A Transitions in the Light-Cone QCD Sum Rules with the Chiral current, Chin. Phys. C 36 (2012) 1046.DOI
  39. [39]X. W. Kang, T. Luo, Y. Zhang, L. Y. Dai and C. Wang, Semileptonic B and B_s decays involving scalar and axial-vector mesons, Eur. Phys. J. C 78 (2018) 909. [arXiv:1808.02432]DOI
  40. [40]H. Y. Cheng, C. K. Chua and C. W. Hwang, Covariant light front approach for S-wave and P-wave mesons: Its application to decay constants and form-factors, Phys. Rev. D 69 (2004) 074025. [hep-ph/0310359]DOI
  41. [41]D. Melikhov and B. Stech, Weak form-factors for heavy meson decays: An Update, Phys. Rev. D 62 (2000) 014006. [hep-ph/0001113]DOI
  42. [42]I. I. Balitsky, V. M. Braun and A. V. Kolesnichenko, Radiative Decay Σ+ → pγ in Quantum Chromodynamics, Nucl. Phys. B 312 (1989) 509-550.DOI
  43. [43]V. L. Chernyak and I. R. Zhitnitsky, B meson exclusive decays into baryons, Nucl. Phys. B 345 (1990) 137.DOI
  44. [44]K. C. Yang, Light-cone distribution amplitudes of axial-vector mesons, Nucl. Phys. B 776 (2007) 187-257. [arXiv:0705.0692]DOI
  45. [45]T. Huang and Z. H. Li, B → K*γ in the light cone QCD sum rule, Phys. Rev. D 57 (1998) 1993.DOI
  46. [46]T. Huang, Z. H. Li and X. Y. Wu, Improved approach to the heavy to light form-factors in the light cone QCD sum rules, Phys. Rev. D 63 (2001) 094001.DOI
  47. [47]Z. G. Wang, M. Z. Zhou and T. Huang, B pi weak form-factor with chiral current in the light cone sum rules, Phys. Rev. D 67 (2003) 094006.DOI
  48. [48]H. B. Fu, X. G. Wu, Y. H. Han and Y. Ma, B → ρ transition form factors and the ρ-meson transverse leading-twist distribution amplitude, J. Phys. G 42 (2015) 055002. [arXiv:1406.3892]
  49. [49]T. Zhong, X. G. Wu, H. Y. Han, Q. L. Liao, H. B. Fu and Z. Y. Fang, Revisiting the Twist-3 Distribution Amplitudes of K Meson within the QCD Background Field Approach, Commun. Theor. Phys. 58 (2012) 261. [arXiv:1109.3127]DOI
  50. [50]X. G. Wu, T. Huang and Z. Y. Fang, B → K transition form-factor up to O (1/m_b²) within the k(T) factorization approach, Eur. Phys. J. C 52 (2007) 561. [arXiv:0707.2504]DOI
  51. [51]T. Huang and X. G. Wu, A Model for the twist-3 wave function of the pion and its contribution to the pion form-factor, Phys. Rev. D 70 (2004) 093013. [arXiv:0408252]DOI
  52. [52]T. Zhong, H. B. Fu and X. G. Wu, Investigating the ratio of CKM matrix elements |Vub|/|Vcb| from semileptonic decay B_s^0 → K−μ+νμ and kaon twist-2 distribution amplitude, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) 116020. [arXiv:2201.10820]
  53. [53]T. Zhong, Z. H. Zhu, H. B. Fu, X. G. Wu and T. Huang, Improved light-cone harmonic oscillator model for the pionic leading-twist distribution amplitude, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021) 016021. [arXiv:2102.03989]DOI
  54. [54]D. D. Hu, X. G. Wu, H. B. Fu, T. Zhong, Z. H. Wu and L. Zeng, Properties of the η_q leading-twist distribution amplitude and its effects to the B/D+ → η(′)ℓ+νℓ decays, Eur. Phys. J. C 84 (2024) 15. [arXiv:2307.04640]DOI
  55. [55]D. Huang, T. Zhong, H. B. Fu, Z. H. Wu, X. G. Wu and H. Tong, K*0(1430) twist-2 distribution amplitude and B_s, D_s → K*0(1430) transition form factors, Eur. Phys. J. C 83 (2023) 680. [arXiv:2211.06211]DOI
  56. [56]Y. L. Yang, H. J. Tian, Y. X. Wang, H. B. Fu, T. Zhong, S. Q. Wang and D. Huang, Probing |V_cs| and lepton flavor universality through D → K*0(1430)ℓνℓ decays, Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) 116030. [arXiv:2409.0512]DOI
  57. [57]Z. H. Wu, H. B. Fu, T. Zhong, D. Huang, D. D. Hu and X. G. Wu, ω0(980)-meson twist-2 distribution amplitude within the QCD sum rules and investigation of D → a0(980)(ηπ)ℓ+νe, Nucl. Phys. A 1036 (2023) 122671. [arXiv:2211.05390]
  58. [58]D. D. Hu, X. G. Wu, L. Zeng, H. B. Fu and T. Zhong, Improved light-cone harmonic oscillator model for the ϕ-meson longitudinal leading-twist light-cone distribution amplitude and its effects to D_s^+ → ϕℓ+νℓ, Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) 056017. [arXiv:2403.10003]
  59. [59]H. B. Fu, X. G. Wu, W. Cheng and T. Zhong, ρ-meson longitudinal leading-twist distribution amplitude within QCD background field theory, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 074004. [arXiv:1607.04937]DOI
  60. [60]H. B. Fu, X. G. Wu and Y. Ma, B → K* Transition Form Factors and the Semi-leptonic Decay B → K*μ+μ−, J. Phys. G 43 (2016) 015002. [arXiv:1411.16423]DOI
  61. [61]D. D. Hu, H. B. Fu, T. Zhong, Z. H. Wu and X. G. Wu, a1(1260)-meson longitudinal twist-2 distribution amplitude and the D → a₁(1260)ℓ⁺νₑ decay processes, Eur. Phys. J. C 82 (2022) 603. [arXiv:2107.02758]
  62. [62]C. L. Y. Lee, M. Lu and M. B. Wise, B(14) and D(14) decay, Phys. Rev. D 46 (1992) 5040.
  63. [63]N. Cabibbo and A. Maksymowicz, Angular Correlations in Ke − 4 Decays and Determination of Low-Energy π − π Phase Shifts Phys. Rev. 137 (1965) B438.
  64. [64]J. D. Richman and P. R. Burchat, Leptonic and semileptonic decays of charm and bottom hadrons, Rev. Mod. Phys. 67 (1995) 893. [hep-ph/9508250]
  65. [65]M. Ablikim et al. [BESIII Collaboration], Study of D⁺ → K⁻π⁺e⁺νₑ, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 032001. [arXiv:1512.08627]
  66. [66]P. Ball, V. M. Braun, Y. Koike and K. Tanaka, Higher twist distribution amplitudes of vector mesons in QCD: Formalism and twist - three distributions, Nucl. Phys. B 529 (1998) 323-382. [hep-ph/9802299]DOI
  67. [67]P. Ball and V. M. Braun, Handbook of higher twist distribution amplitudes of vector mesons in QCD, [hep-ph/9808229].DOI
  68. [68]P. Ball and G. W. Jones, Twist-3 distribution amplitudes of K* and ϕ mesons, JHEP 03 (2007) 069. [hep-ph/0702100]DOI
  69. [69]T. Huang, B. Q. Ma and Q. X. Shen, Analysis of the pion wave function in light cone formalism, Phys. Rev. D 49 (1994) 1490-1499. [hep-ph/9402285]DOI
  70. [70]X. G. Wu and T. Huang, Pion electromagnetic form-factor in the K_T factorization formulae, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 21 (2006) 901-904. [hep-ph/0507136]DOI
  71. [71]S. J. Brodsky, T. Huang and G. P. Lepage, The Hadronic Wave Function in Quantum Chromodynamics, SLAC-PUB-2540.
  72. [72]X. H. Guo and T. Huang, Wave functions in D and B decays, Phys. Rev. D 43 (1991) 2931.
  73. [73]P. Ball and R. Zwicky, New results on B → π,K,η decay formfactors from light-cone sum rules, Phys. Rev. D 71 (2005) 014015. [hep-ph/0406232]
  74. [74]V. M. Braun, G. P. Korchemsky and D. Müller, The Uses of conformal symmetry in QCD, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 51 (2003) 311. [hep-ph/0306057]DOI
  75. [75]L. Zeng, X. G. Wu, D. D. Hu, H. B. Fu and T. Zhong, Longitudinal leading-twist distribution amplitude of the P₁-state b₁(1235) meson and its implications on B → b₁(1235)ℓ⁺νₑ decays, Phys. Rev. D 111 (2025) 056030. [arXiv:2501.06737]DOI
  76. [76]T. Zhong, Y. H. Dai and H. B. Fu, ρ-meson longitudinal leading-twist distribution amplitude revisited and the D → ρ semileptonic decay, Chin. Phys. C 48 (2024) 063108. [arXiv:2308.14032]arxiv.org/abs/2308.14032
  77. [77]H. J. Tian, H. B. Fu, T. Zhong, Y. X. Wang and X. G. Wu, Rare decay B⁺ → K⁺ℓ⁺ℓ⁻(ν̄ν) under the QCD sum rules approach, Phys. Rev. D 111 (2025) 076013. [arXiv:2411.12141]arxiv.org/abs/2411.12141
  78. [78]Y. X. Wang, D. D. Hu, W. B. Luo, T. Zhong and H. B. Fu, Status of the Dₛ⁺ → ϕℓ⁺νₑ decay with a chiral-odd ϕ-meson light-cone distribution amplitude, Phys. Rev. D 112 (2025) 056008. [arXiv:2505.15014]
  79. [79]C. Bourrely, I. Caprini and L. Lellouch, Model-independent description of B → πℓν decays and determination of |Vᵤb|, Phys. Rev. D 79 (2009) 013008. [arXiv:0807.2722]
  80. [80]S. Momeni, Helicity form factors for D₍s₎ → Aℓν process in the light-cone QCD sum rules approach, Eur. Phys. J. C 80 (2020) 553. [arXiv:2004.02522]DOI
  81. [81]H. Y. Cheng, C. W. Chiang and C. K. Chua, Width effects in resonant three-body decays: B decay as an example, Phys. Lett. B 813 (2021) 136058. [arXiv:2011.03201]
  82. [82]H. Y. Cheng, C. W. Chiang and Z. Q. Zhang, Hadronic three-body D decays mediated by scalar resonances, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) 033006. [arXiv:2201.00460]DOI
  83. [83]J. Wu, N. Wang, G. Lü and X. H. Guo, Study of Kπ final states from four-body decay of B̄ₛ meson under perturbative QCD, Eur. Phys. J. C 85 (2025) 955. [arXiv:2504.18216]
  84. [84]H. Y. Cheng, C. W. Chiang and C. K. Chua, Finite-Width Effects in Three-Body B Decays, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 036017. [arXiv:2011.07468]DOI
  85. [85]W. Cheng, X. G. Wu and H. B. Fu, Reconsideration of the B → K* transition form factors within the QCD light-cone sum rules, Phys. Rev. D 95 (2017) 094023. [arXiv:1703.08677]DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_ym463dpu
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents