betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Periodic implementation of the random phase approximation with numerical atomic orbitals and dual reciprocal space grids

Abstract

The random phase approximation (RPA) has emerged as a prominent first-principles method in material science, particularly to study the adsorption and chemisorption of small molecules on surfaces. However, its widespread application is hampered by its relatively high computational cost. Here, we present a well-parallelised implementation of the RPA with localised atomic orbitals and pair-atomic density fitting, which is especially suitable for studying two-dimensional systems. Through a dual k\textbf{k}-grid scheme, we achieve fast and reliable convergence of RPA correlation energies to the thermodynamic limit. We demonstrate the efficacy of our implementation through an application to the adsorption of CO on MgO(001) using PBE input orbitals (RPA@PBE) Our calculated adsorption energy is in good agreement with previously published RPA@PBE studies, but, as expected, overestimates the experimentally available adsorption energies as well as recent CCSD(T) results.

Introduction

The Random Phase Approximation (RPA) is a well-established method in quantum chemistry and solid-state physics.[1] Originally developed by Bohm and Pines while working on plasmonic oscillation in the jellium model,[2, 3, 4] it is equivalent to approximating the correlation energy through a summation of ring diagrams within diagrammatic perturbation theory.[5, 6, 7] Equivalently, it can be derived from the Klein functional[8] using a non-interacting single particle Green function[8, 9, 10] or within the Adiabatic-Connection (AC) Fluctuation Dissipation theorem (ACFDT).[11, 12] Ring diagrams describe one of the most important signatures of electron correlation,[13] the screening of electron-electron interactions at large interelectronic distances. Therefore, the RPA is especially accurate for reactions dominated by the difference in the long-range correlation energies of the reactants, as caused, for instance, by non-covalent interactions.[14, 15, 16]

The RPA exchange-correlation (xc) energy is fully non-local and depends on virtual orbitals, placing itself at the top of Perdew’s Jacob’s ladder[17] of density functional theory (DFT).[18, 19] Therefore, it is computationally more involved than generalized gradient approximations (GGA). While density functionals including empirical dispersion corrections[20, 21] are cheaper options for treating non-covalent interactions and give accurate results in many scenarios, they may break down in highly anisotropic or highly polarizable systems.[22] Non-local dispersion corrections are more advanced alternatives but are also computationally more involved.[23]

Compared to wave-function-based methods, the RPA includes interactions present both in second-order Møller–Plesset perturbation theory (MP2) and Coupled Cluster (CC) theory.[24, 25, 26, 27] The development of CC implementations for periodic systems is a relatively recent development[28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33] and applications of these methods to the adsorption of CO on the MgO(001) surface[34, 35] demonstrate their immense potential in applications to molecule-surface interactions. As shown by Scuseria, Henderson, and coworkers,[36, 37] RPA can be seen as a simplification of coupled cluster with single and double excitations (CCSD), including fewer interaction channels but having the advantage of much lower computational cost.

RPA and MP2 both share the second-order ring diagram, but this term diverges in strongly polarizable[38] small band gap systems or metals in the thermodynamic limit.[39] While MP2 is increasingly applied to solids[39, 40, 41] and these shortcomings might be alleviated using regularization techniques,[42] the RPA is widely applicable without such corrections.[6, 7, 39]

To combine the benefits of MP2 and RPA, the addition of second-order screened exchange (SOX) corrections has also been explored extensively for molecules[43, 44, 45, 46] and homogeneous electron gases.[47, 48] SOX corrections come however with increased computational cost and tend to deteriorate the good description of stretched bonds within the RPA,[43, 44, 45, 49] which is important to describe transition states.

The many beneficial characteristics of RPA are key factors behind the increasing popularity of the RPA for applications in heterogeneous catalysis. Here, the rate-determining step is the chemisorption (involving an effective chemical bond between the surface and the reactant) of a reactant (typically small molecules) followed by their dissociation into reactive fragments.[50] Modelling such molecule-surface interactions accurately requires a reliable description of long-range dispersion forces and reaction barrier heights.[50] In many instances, GGAs are not suitable to study these processes,[50, 51] and the RPA promises much higher accuracy.[52, 53] For this reason the RPA has been applied to model a wide array of molecule-surface interactions[53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62] and is predicted to play an increasingly prominent role in computational catalysis in the future.[64] [63] More advanced ACFDT methods like adiabatic xc kernel methods[65, 66, 67] or σ\sigma-functionals[68, 69, 70] can boost the accuracy of the RPA at similar computational cost and their implementations can be realized through minor modifications of the underlying RPA algorithms. We focus here on the efficient implementation of the RPA, which is an important stepping stone to these more advanced methods.

While being significantly cheaper than wave-function-based methods, RPA calculations are computationally much more demanding than conventional DFT. In their canonical formulations [71, 72] RPA calculations scale as NA4Nk2N_A^4N_k^2 with NAN_A being the number of atoms in the unit cell and NkN_k being the number of kk-points. [14] Applications of the RPA and other post-SCF methods to heterogeneous catalysis therefore often rely on embedding approaches [73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79] and further algorithmic developments are needed to make full RPA calculations routine for molecule-surface interactions. Algorithms based on the space-time formulation [80, 81] of the GWGW approximations [82] lower the scaling of RPA calculations to formally NA3NkN_A^3N_k. [83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90]

In practice, the time-determining step of these calculations is the calculation of the RPA polarizability, which can be done with sub-quadratic scaling, and therefore the scaling is sub-quadratic for practical system sizes. [88, 89, 90] These algorithms come with a higher prefactor than canonical implementations, and for this reason, they are useful for large kk-grids and large unit cells. Important potential use-cases include Moiré superlattices, [88] point-defects, or molecule-surface interactions with low coverages. [91]

Many molecule-surface interactions can however be modelled with relatively small unit cells for which canonical RPA implementations are more suitable. Here, it is important to account for the reduced 2-dimensional (2D) periodicity of the system. In plane-wave-based implementations, the 2D geometry is replicated periodically along the non-periodic spatial direction, and large replica separations are required to prevent unphysical interactions between them. [92, 93, 94, 95, 96] The number of plane waves required to reach a given energy cut-off increases significantly with the lattice constant, making such calculations computationally demanding. [97] To address this, plane-wave simulations of molecule–surface interactions often employ truncated Coulomb potentials. [98, 99] Despite these techniques, relatively large replica separations of 10–20 Å are still necessary. [100] This approach also introduces challenges in Brillouin zone integration, necessitating even denser kk-point grids. [101, 102]

For these low-dimensional systems, atomic orbital-based implementations are more suitable since they can naturally describe the non-periodic behavior of the wave function. [103] The most commonly employed localized basis sets for post-self-consistent field (SCF) calculations in periodic systems are Gaussian-type orbitals (GTO) [104, 105, 106, 107, 108] as implemented for instance in pySCF[31, 32, 109, 110, 111] or CP2K[40, 112, 113, 114, 115] and numerical atomic orbitals (NAO) as implemented in FHI-AIMS[72, 89, 116, 117] or ABACUS.[118, 119, 120, 121] NAO basis sets are both compact and highly flexible and can be used to numerically represent GTOs, Slater-type orbitals (STO), or molecular DFT orbitals. Choosing STOs as their functional form, the exponential decay of the wave function far from a finite system can be better represented.[122] This property is important when modeling 2D systems, and is difficult to achieve with plane waves.[97] In practice, this enables energies closer to the infinite basis set limit for the same number of basis functions.[123]

This work reports a novel NAO-based RPA implementation in the BAND[124] module of the Amsterdam modeling suite (AMS).[125] Our implementation relies on the pair-atomic density fitting (PADF) approximation[123, 126] (also known as local RI[89, 90, 118, 119] or concentric atomic density fitting[127, 128, 129]) which expands products of atomic basis functions in an additional fit set of functions which are centered only on the same atoms from which a specific basis set product originates.[126, 130, 131, 132] PADF has been used extensively within the space-time method to realise low-scaling implementations of RPA and GW for finite[126, 133] and periodic systems,[89, 90] and for periodic Hartree-Fock.[118, 119, 121] Here, we use it only to reduce the size of involved tensors and consequently memory demands.

Inspired by the HF implementation of Irmler et al.[134], we introduce a scheme to dampen the Coulomb potential at long distances depending on the size of the employed kk-grid. Using mono- and bilayer hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN) as well as the adsorption of CO on monolayer MgO(001) as test systems, we demonstrate this method to be numerically stable and leading to a rapid convergence to the thermodynamic limit in combination with a dual kk-grid scheme (inspired by the staggered-mesh method[135, 136]) which we introduce here as well. We also describe a parallelisation scheme, which handles reciprocal space and frequency grid integration, achieving near-perfect parallel efficiency for thousands of cores on multiple nodes. Finally, as a practical application for our implementation, we calculate the adsorption energy of CO on the MgO(001) surface and demonstrate good agreement of our result to previous periodic RPA calculations. [137]

Theory

RPA correlation energy from Adiabatic connection

From the ACFDT, the RPA Correlation energy can be written as [1, 11]

EcorrRPA=−12π∫0∞dωTr⁡[∑n=1∞1n[Z(r,r′,iω)]n−Z(r,r′,iω)],(1)E^{RPA}_{corr}=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{0}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}\omega\operatorname{Tr}\left[\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n}[Z(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r}',i\omega)]^{n}-Z(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r}',i\omega)\right], \tag*{(1)}

with

Z(r,r′,iω)=∫dr′′P(0)(r,r′′,iω)v(r′′,r′),(2)Z(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r}',i\omega)=\int\mathrm{d}\mathbf{r}''P^{(0)}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r}'',i\omega)v(\mathbf{r}'',\mathbf{r}'), \tag*{(2)}

and the trace operator for a generic two variable function A(r,r′)A(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r}') defined as

Tr⁡[A(r,r′)]=∫drdr′A(r,r′)δ(r−r′).(3)\operatorname{Tr}[A(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r}')]=\int\mathrm{d}\mathbf{r}\mathrm{d}\mathbf{r}'A(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r}')\delta(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}'). \tag*{(3)}

Here, P(0)(r,r′,iω)P^{(0)}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r}',i\omega) is the irreducible RPA polarizability, and v(r,r′)=1∣r−r′∣v(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r}')=\frac{1}{|\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}'|} is the Coulomb potential. By following the derivation given in the appendix, we can expand this equation in a basis F={f(r,q)}F=\{f(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{q})\} with q\mathbf{q} being differences between points in the first Brillouin zone (1BZ). We obtain

EcorrRPA=−12π∑q∈1BZ∫0∞dω[log⁡{det⁡[1−Z(q,iω)]}−Tr⁡[Z(q,iω)]],(4)E^{RPA}_{corr}=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\sum_{\mathbf{q}\in1\mathrm{BZ}}\int_{0}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}\omega\left[\log\{\det[1-\mathbf{Z}(\mathbf{q},i\omega)]\}-\operatorname{Tr}[\mathbf{Z}(\mathbf{q},i\omega)]\right], \tag*{(4)}

where Z=v1/2P(0)v1/2\mathbf{Z}=\mathbf{v}^{1/2}\mathbf{P}^{(0)}\mathbf{v}^{1/2}, and the matrix elements of P(0)\mathbf{P}^{(0)} are

Pαβ(0)(q,iω)=⟨fα(r,q)∣P(0)(r,r′,iω)∣fβ(r′,q)⟩.(5)P^{(0)}_{\alpha\beta}(\mathbf{q},i\omega)=\langle f_{\alpha}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{q})|P^{(0)}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r}',i\omega)|f_{\beta}(\mathbf{r}',\mathbf{q})\rangle. \tag*{(5)}

The matrix v1/2(q)\mathbf{v}^{1/2}(\mathbf{q}) is the square root of the Coulomb potential with matrix elements

vαβ(q)=⟨fα(r,q)∣1∣r−r′∣∣fβ(r′,q)⟩.(6)v_{\alpha\beta}(\mathbf{q}) = \langle f_{\alpha}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{q}) \mid\frac{1}{\lvert\mathbf{r} - \mathbf{r}' \rvert} \mid f_{\beta}(\mathbf{r}',\mathbf{q}) \rangle. \tag*{(6)}

In general, for both 5 and 6, matrix elements between fit functions from different q\mathbf{q} and q′\mathbf{q}' points can be defined. However these off-diagonal elements are zero, making Pαβ(0)(q,ω)P_{\alpha\beta}^{(0)}(\mathbf{q},\omega) and vαβ(q)v_{\alpha\beta}(\mathbf{q}) diagonal in q\mathbf{q}. We therefore have simplified the notation and use only one q\mathbf{q} value to index these matrix elements.

Bloch summation functions RI

After having summarized the key relations to obtain EcorrRPAE_{\mathrm{corr}}^{RPA}, we will show in the following how the matrix elements of P(0)P^{(0)} can be calculated. We will refer to the basis FF as fit set, to distinguish it from the primary basis set that is used to expand the orbitals in and which is labelled as XX. We define X={χμ(r,kn)}X = \{\chi_{\mu}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k}_{n})\} where the kn\mathbf{k}_{n} vector defines the basis functions at its specific reciprocal point in the first Brillouin zone. The set of all k\mathbf{k}-points will be called KGK_{G}. Similarly, the fit set FF includes functions {fα(r,qn)}\{f_{\alpha}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{q}_{n})\} which depend on all the reciprocal vectors qn≡km−kl\mathbf{q}_{n} \equiv\mathbf{k}_{m} - \mathbf{k}_{l}, obtained as differences between all pairs km,kl∈KG\mathbf{k}_{m},\mathbf{k}_{l} \in K_{G}. The set of all q\mathbf{q}-vectors defines another grid QGQ_{G}. Both types of basis functions are related to their real-space analogues via Fourier transforms,

χμ(r,k)=∑Rχμ(r−R)eik⋅R(7)\chi_{\mu}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k}) = \sum_{\mathbf{R}} \chi_{\mu}(\mathbf{r} - \mathbf{R}) e^{i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{R}} \tag*{(7)}

and

fα(r,q)=∑Rfα(r−R)eiq⋅R,(8)f_{\alpha}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{q}) = \sum_{\mathbf{R}} f_{\alpha}(\mathbf{r} - \mathbf{R}) e^{i\mathbf{q}\cdot\mathbf{R}}, \tag*{(8)}

where the vectors R\mathbf{R} enumerate the unit cells. The fit set is related to the primary basis through the PADF equations[123] (also known as local RI[89, 90, 118, 119]) as

χμ∈A(r−R)χν∈B(r−R′)≈∑α∈ACνμαR′,Rfα(r−R)+∑β∈BCμνβR,R′fβ(r−R′).(9)\chi_{\mu\in A}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R})\chi_{\nu\in B}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R}') \approx\sum_{\alpha\in A} C_{\nu\mu\alpha}^{\mathbf{R}',\mathbf{R}} f_{\alpha}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R})+\sum_{\beta\in B} C_{\mu\nu\beta}^{\mathbf{R},\mathbf{R}'} f_{\beta}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R}'). \tag*{(9)}

The fit functions on the r.h.s. are thus centred on the same two atoms with indices AA and BB as the two primary basis functions. Utilising this definition, we next consider this product in reciprocal space

χμ∗(r,k)χν(r,k+q)=∑Rχμ(r−R)e−ik⋅R∑R′χν(r−R′)ei(k+q)⋅R′=∑RR′ei(k+q)⋅R′e−ik⋅Rχμ(r−R)χν(r−R′)≈∑RR′ei(k+q)⋅R′e−ik⋅R[∑α∈ACνμαR′,Rfα(r−R)+∑β∈BCμνβR,R′fβ(r−R′)].(10)\begin{aligned} \chi_{\mu}^{*}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k})\chi_{\nu}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q}) &= \sum_{\mathbf{R}}\chi_{\mu}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R})e^{-i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{R}}\sum_{\mathbf{R}'}\chi_{\nu}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R}')e^{i(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q})\cdot\mathbf{R}'} \\ &= \sum_{\mathbf{R}\mathbf{R}'}e^{i(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q})\cdot\mathbf{R}'}e^{-i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{R}}\chi_{\mu}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R})\chi_{\nu}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R}') \\ &\approx\sum_{\mathbf{R}\mathbf{R}'}e^{i(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q})\cdot\mathbf{R}'}e^{-i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{R}}\left[\sum_{\alpha\in A}C_{\nu\mu\alpha}^{\mathbf{R}',\mathbf{R}}f_{\alpha}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R})+\sum_{\beta\in B}C_{\mu\nu\beta}^{\mathbf{R},\mathbf{R}'}f_{\beta}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R}')\right]. \tag*{(10)} \end{aligned}

By grouping the phase factors on both the atomic summations and by employing translational symmetry of fit coefficients, we obtain

χμ∗(r,k)χν(r,k+q)≈∑α∈A∑RR′ei(k+q)⋅R′e−ik⋅RCνμαR′,Rfα(r−R)+∑β∈B∑RR′ei(k+q)⋅R′e−ik⋅RCμνβR,R′fβ(r−R′)=∑α∈A∑R′ei(k+q)⋅(R−R′)Cνμα0,(R′−R)∑Reiq⋅Rfα(r−R)+∑β∈B∑RCμνβ0,(R′−R)e−ik⋅(R−R′)∑R′eiq⋅R′fβ(r−R′).(11)\begin{aligned} \chi_{\mu}^{*}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k})\chi_{\nu}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q}) &\approx\sum_{\alpha\in A}\sum_{\mathbf{R}\mathbf{R}'}e^{i(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q})\cdot\mathbf{R}'}e^{-i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{R}}C_{\nu\mu\alpha}^{\mathbf{R}',\mathbf{R}}f_{\alpha}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R})+ \\ &\quad\sum_{\beta\in B}\sum_{\mathbf{R}\mathbf{R}'}e^{i(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q})\cdot\mathbf{R}'}e^{-i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{R}}C_{\mu\nu\beta}^{\mathbf{R},\mathbf{R}'}f_{\beta}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R}') \\ &= \sum_{\alpha\in A}\sum_{\mathbf{R}'}e^{i(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q})\cdot(\mathbf{R}-\mathbf{R}')}C_{\nu\mu\alpha}^{0,(\mathbf{R}'-\mathbf{R})}\sum_{\mathbf{R}}e^{i\mathbf{q}\cdot\mathbf{R}}f_{\alpha}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R})+ \\ &\quad\sum_{\beta\in B}\sum_{\mathbf{R}}C_{\mu\nu\beta}^{0,(\mathbf{R}'-\mathbf{R})}e^{-i\mathbf{k}\cdot(\mathbf{R}-\mathbf{R}')}\sum_{\mathbf{R}'}e^{i\mathbf{q}\cdot\mathbf{R}'}f_{\beta}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R}'). \tag*{(11)} \end{aligned}

and further, by defining ΔR=R−R′\Delta\mathbf{R}=\mathbf{R}-\mathbf{R}', we get

χμ∗(r,k)χν(r,k+q)≈∑α∈A∑ΔRei(k+q)⋅ΔRCνμα0,ΔR∑Reiq⋅Rfα(r−R)+∑β∈B∑ΔRe−ik⋅ΔRCμνβ0,−ΔR∑R′eiq⋅R′fβ(r−R′).(12)\begin{aligned} \chi_{\mu}^{*}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k})\chi_{\nu}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q}) &\approx\sum_{\alpha\in A}\sum_{\Delta\mathbf{R}}e^{i(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q})\cdot\Delta\mathbf{R}}C_{\nu\mu\alpha}^{0,\Delta\mathbf{R}}\sum_{\mathbf{R}}e^{i\mathbf{q}\cdot\mathbf{R}}f_{\alpha}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R})+ \\ &\quad\sum_{\beta\in B}\sum_{\Delta\mathbf{R}}e^{-i\mathbf{k}\cdot\Delta\mathbf{R}}C_{\mu\nu\beta}^{0,-\Delta\mathbf{R}}\sum_{\mathbf{R}'}e^{i\mathbf{q}\cdot\mathbf{R}'}f_{\beta}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R}'). \tag*{(12)} \end{aligned}

Defining

Cνμα(k)=∑ΔRCνμα0,ΔReik⋅ΔR(13)C_{\nu\mu\alpha}(\mathbf{k}) = \sum_{\Delta R} C_{\nu\mu\alpha}^{0,\Delta R} e^{i\mathbf{k}\cdot\Delta R} \tag*{(13)}

the periodic k\mathbf{k}-dependent PADF equations read

χμ∗(r,k)χν(r,k+q)≈∑α∈ACνμα(k+q)fα(q,r)+∑β∈BCμνβ∗(k)fβ(q,r)=∑γCγμν(k+q,k)fγ(q,r),(14)\chi_{\mu}^{*}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k})\chi_{\nu}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q}) \approx\sum_{\alpha\in A} C_{\nu\mu\alpha}(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q})f_{\alpha}(\mathbf{q},\mathbf{r}) + \sum_{\beta\in B} C_{\mu\nu\beta}^{*}(\mathbf{k})f_{\beta}(\mathbf{q},\mathbf{r}) = \sum_{\gamma} C_{\gamma}^{\mu\nu}(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q},\mathbf{k})f_{\gamma}(\mathbf{q},\mathbf{r}) , \tag*{(14)}

where we have combined the separate summations over α\alpha and β\beta for notational convenience. In eq. (14), the structure of pair fitting is maintained: fit functions are still located on the same atoms as the basis set products. The notion of ’same atoms’ implies that two atoms are considered equivalent as long as they are invariant by a direct lattice vector translation.

P(0)P^{(0)} can be expressed in terms of Kohn–Sham (KS) states ψ\psi and KS eigenvalues ϵ\epsilon as

P(0)(r,r′,iω)=∑n,m∑k+q,kζkζq(omk+q−onk)ψm∗(r,k+q)ψn(r,k)ψn∗(r′,k)ψm(r′,k+q)ϵm(k+q)−ϵn(k)−iω(15)P^{(0)}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{r}',i\omega) = \sum_{n,m}\sum_{\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q},\mathbf{k}} \zeta_{\mathbf{k}}\zeta_{\mathbf{q}} \frac{\left(o_{m}^{\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q}}-o_{n}^{\mathbf{k}}\right)\psi_{m}^{*}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q})\psi_{n}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k})\psi_{n}^{*}(\mathbf{r}',\mathbf{k})\psi_{m}(\mathbf{r}',\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q})}{\epsilon_{m}(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q})-\epsilon_{n}(\mathbf{k})-i\omega} \tag*{(15)}

where mm and nn denote band indices. We do not consider the case of partially filled bands and assume spin-compensation in this work. Therefore, the occupation factors oo are either 2 for valence, and 0 for conduction bands. The weights ζk\zeta_{\mathbf{k}} and ζq\zeta_{\mathbf{q}} account for the sampling of KK and QQ spaces over all Born–von Karman states in the first Brillouin zone and include the normalization factors of the Bloch summation functions. Transforming eq. (14) into the basis of KS states and adopting the usual convention of denoting virtual orbitals with the index aa and occupied ones with ii,

ψa∗(r,k)ψi(r,k+q)≈∑γCγai(k+q,k)fγ(q,r),(16)\psi_{a}^{*}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k})\psi_{i}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q}) \approx\sum_{\gamma} C_{\gamma}^{ai}(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q},\mathbf{k})f_{\gamma}(\mathbf{q},\mathbf{r}) , \tag*{(16)}

and substituting eq (16) in eq (5) we finally obtain the expression

Pγγ′(0)(q,iω)=−2∑kζkζq∑i,aCγai(k+q,k)Cγ′ai∗(k+q,k)ϵa,σ(k)−ϵi,σ(k+q)−iω+c.c.(17)P_{\gamma\gamma'}^{(0)}(\mathbf{q},i\omega)=-2\sum_{\mathbf{k}}\zeta_{\mathbf{k}}\zeta_{\mathbf{q}}\sum_{i,a}\frac{\mathcal{C}_{\gamma}^{ai}(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q},\mathbf{k})\mathcal{C}_{\gamma'}^{ai*}(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q},\mathbf{k})}{\epsilon_{a,\sigma}(\mathbf{k})-\epsilon_{i,\sigma}(\mathbf{k}+\mathbf{q})-i\omega}+c.c. \tag*{(17)}

Additionally, the Coulomb potential can be obtained as follows

v~γγ′(q,q′)=∫drdr′fγ∗(q′,r′)fγ′(q,r)∣r−r′∣=∫drdr′∑R,R′fγ(r′−R′)e−iq′⋅R′fγ′(r−R)eiq⋅R∣r−r′∣=∑ΔR∫drdr′fγ(r′−R−ΔR)fγ′(r−R)e−iq′⋅ΔR∣r−r′∣∑Rei(q−q′)⋅R=NR⋅δq,q′⋅∑ΔR⟨fγ(r−ΔR)|1∣r−r′∣|fγ′(r′)⟩e−iq′⋅ΔR,(18)\begin{aligned} \widetilde{v}_{\gamma\gamma'}(\mathbf{q},\mathbf{q}')&=\int d\mathbf{r}d\mathbf{r}'\frac{f_{\gamma}^{*}(\mathbf{q}',\mathbf{r}')f_{\gamma'}(\mathbf{q},\mathbf{r})}{\lvert\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}'\rvert}\\ &=\int d\mathbf{r}d\mathbf{r}'\sum_{\mathbf{R},\mathbf{R}'}\frac{f_{\gamma}(\mathbf{r}'-\mathbf{R}')e^{-i\mathbf{q}'\cdot\mathbf{R}'}f_{\gamma'}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R})e^{i\mathbf{q}\cdot\mathbf{R}}}{\lvert\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}'\rvert}\\ &=\sum_{\Delta\mathbf{R}}\int d\mathbf{r}d\mathbf{r}'\frac{f_{\gamma}(\mathbf{r}'-\mathbf{R}-\Delta\mathbf{R})f_{\gamma'}(\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{R})e^{-i\mathbf{q}'\cdot\Delta\mathbf{R}}}{\lvert\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}'\rvert}\sum_{\mathbf{R}}e^{i(\mathbf{q}-\mathbf{q}')\cdot\mathbf{R}}\\ &=N_{\mathbf{R}}\cdot\delta_{\mathbf{q},\mathbf{q}'}\cdot\sum_{\Delta\mathbf{R}}\left\langle f_{\gamma}(\mathbf{r}-\Delta\mathbf{R})\middle|\frac{1}{\lvert\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}'\rvert}\middle|f_{\gamma'}(\mathbf{r}')\right\rangle e^{-i\mathbf{q}'\cdot\Delta\mathbf{R}}, \tag*{(18)} \end{aligned}

where the NRN_{\mathbf{R}}-factor can be set to one to yield the RPA correlation energy per unit cell.

Periodic Projector Method

When the PADF expansion is used, perturbation-theoretical methods relying on virtual orbitals often suffer from stronger numerical instabilities than methods utilising only occupied orbitals.[123] To overcome this issue which arises from linear dependencies in the primary basis, we generalized the projector method of Ref. 123 to periodic systems. Starting from the k\mathbf{k}-point specific overlap matrix Sμν(k)=⟨χμ(r,k)∣χν(r,k)⟩S_{\mu\nu}(\mathbf{k})=\langle\chi_{\mu}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k})\mid\chi_{\nu}(\mathbf{r},\mathbf{k})\rangle we build a projector T(k)T(\mathbf{k}) by diagonalizing SS

S(k)=U(k)D(k)U†(k)(19)S(\mathbf{k})=U(\mathbf{k})D(\mathbf{k})U^{\dagger}(\mathbf{k}) \tag*{(19)}

and subsequently removing the subspace spanned by eigenvectors corresponding to eigenvalues smaller than a user-specified threshold ϵd\epsilon_d,

Rij(k)=δijΘ(Dii(k)−ϵd)(20)R_{ij}(\mathbf{k}) = \delta_{ij}\Theta(D_{ii}(\mathbf{k})-\epsilon_d) \tag*{(20)}
R~ij=∏kRij(k)(21)\tilde{R}_{ij} = \prod_{\mathbf{k}} R_{ij}(\mathbf{k}) \tag*{(21)}
T(k)=U(k)R~U†(k)(22)T(\mathbf{k}) = U(\mathbf{k})\tilde{R}U^{\dagger}(\mathbf{k}) \tag*{(22)}

where Θ\Theta is the Heaviside function. The R(k)R(\mathbf{k}) matrices are combined via matrix multiplication, hence, whenever a matrix element from any R(k)R(\mathbf{k}) is zero, it will be zero for the cumulative projector. This allows removing the same atomic specific linear combinations from every k\mathbf{k} point. Eventually T(k)T(\mathbf{k}) is then used to regularize the KS orbital coefficients as

c~μi(k)=∑νTμν(k)cνi(k).(23)\tilde{c}_{\mu}^{i}(\mathbf{k}) = \sum_{\nu} T_{\mu\nu}(\mathbf{k})c_{\nu}^{i}(\mathbf{k}) . \tag*{(23)}

These coefficients are then used to transform eq. (14) to eq. (16). Numerical issues can become more pronounced with increasing system and basis set size, necessitating the use of this projector method. Of course, this issue is strongly related to the quality of the auxiliary fit set. When large fit sets are used, a small ϵd\epsilon_d will suffice, while a smaller fit set necessitates a larger value of ϵd\epsilon_d.[123]

Implementation

Restricted Bloch summation

The periodic RI-RPA equations eqs. (7), (13) and (14) but also the qq-dependent Coulomb overlap integrals eq. (18), formally rely on Bloch summations to obtain a mapping between two infinite spaces. In practice, the reciprocal space grid will however be a finite sampling of the infinite number of k\mathbf{k}-points in the first Brillouin zone prescribed by the Born–von Karman boundary conditions. This unavoidable limitation demands additional considerations on the representation of such quantities. Since the set of Bloch states is obtained from its real-space analog via a discrete Fourier transform of the unit cell coordinate R\mathbf{R}, a finite k\mathbf{k}-grid implies that only a limited amount of unit cells can be considered. In other words, for a regular k\mathbf{k}-sampling along the reciprocal lattice vectors, there will be a maximum representable distance in real space. Starting from the minimum increment between k\mathbf{k}-points min⁡[klx−knx]=qmin⁡x\min[k_l^x-k_n^x]=q_{\min}^x along each reciprocal lattice vector direction ii, the ’Nyquist’ distance Rmax⁡iR_{\max}^i, on the corresponding real lattice vector direction, is defined by

qmin⁡i⋅Rmax⁡i=2π.(24)q_{\min}^i \cdot R_{\max}^i = 2\pi. \tag*{(24)}

Rmax⁡iR_{\max}^i defines an nn-dimensional parallelepiped (n=3n=3 for bulk). Within this parallelepiped, a new real space grid is defined, containing as many unit cells as the number of k\mathbf{k}-points with coordinates Rx\mathbf{R}_x. To ensure that the Fourier transform is invertible, it is necessary to restrict every Bloch summation to cells lying only within the grid induced by the Nyquist vectors Rmax⁡iR_{\max}^i. Beyond Rmax⁡iR_{\max}^i, every function represented through QGQ_G is not properly defined, unless it reaches zero within the limits of Rmax⁡iR_{\max}^i. If not, trying to represent them with a unsuitable QGQ_G would introduce spurious long-range effects. On the other hand, due to the non-invertibility of the Fourier transform, functions that do not decay to zero within Rmax⁡iR_{\max}^i would artificially repeat if transformed back to real space beyond Rmax⁡iR_{\max}^i. This induces undesirable boundary effects for non-converged k\mathbf{k}-grids. To ensure a proper decay within Rmax⁡iR_{\max}^i, Spencer and Alavi suggested to attenuate the Coulomb potential by setting v(r1,r2)v(\mathbf{r}_1,\mathbf{r}_2) to zero beyond Rmax⁡iR_{\max}^i.[138] Here, we instead introduce a spherical Fermi-Dirac function,

θ(∣r2−r1∣,r0,β)=11+eβ(∣r2−r1∣+r0)(25)\theta(|\mathbf{r}_2-\mathbf{r}_1|,r_0,\beta)=\frac{1}{1+e^{\beta(|\mathbf{r}_2-\mathbf{r}_1|+r_0)}} \tag*{(25)}

and damp the Coulomb potential according to

vθ(r1,r2)=v(r1,r2)θ(∣r2−r1∣,r0,β).(26)v_{\theta}(\mathbf{r}_1,\mathbf{r}_2) = v(\mathbf{r}_1,\mathbf{r}_2)\theta(\lvert\mathbf{r}_2-\mathbf{r}_1\rvert,r_0,\beta). \tag*{(26)}

Similar schemes to damp the Coulomb potential have previously been used in periodic HF calculations.[139]

As illustrated in Figure 1, the parameters of θ\theta directly depend on the chosen k\mathbf{k}-grid. If not specified otherwise, we choose the damping radius r0r_0 as 50% of RcR_c, the radius of the largest circle which fits the parallelepiped defined by Rmax⁡iR^i_{\max}. The decay parameter β\beta is chosen to reduce the damping function to 0.1% within a distance of 1.4 r01.4\,r_0. In general, we will refer to the practice of damping the Coulomb potential depending on the k\mathbf{k}-grid as AUTO damping. In this way, increasing the k\mathbf{k}-grid will increase r0r_0 and β\beta. In the limit of an infinite k\mathbf{k}-grid, we would sample the infinite number of unit cells.

Pictorial representation of the $R^x$ grid and damping function

Figure 1. Pictorial representation of the RxR^x grid. Each grey cell represents a primitive cell. The whole grid contains 15×1515 \times15 unit cells, which can be represented by 15×1515 \times15 points in the k\mathbf{k} grid. The red circle represents the maximum circle that can fit in this grid and the blue shadow is the damping function for the Coulomb potential.

Dual grids for enhanced sampling around the Γ\Gamma-point

Due to the slow convergence of RPA correlation energies, regular sampling of the first Brillouin zone often requires unpractically large k\mathbf{k}-grids to reach satisfactory accuracy. [140, 141, 142] This is caused by the divergence of the Coulomb potential at the Γ\Gamma-point and can be mitigated by truncating the Coulomb interaction as described in the previous section. For a non-converged k\mathbf{k}-grid, such a truncation would however be artificial and undesirable. To overcome this issue, we enhance the sampling of QGQ_G around q≡Γq \equiv\Gamma by generating a regular grid in qq, removing q≡Γq \equiv\Gamma, and adding additional points in the vicinity of Γ\Gamma as can be seen Figure 2A. This approach is inspired by the staggered mesh method of Lin and coworkers. [135, 136]

Figure 2. In (A) we show the QGQ_G grid. The additional sampling near Γ\Gamma is represented in blue, the neglected Γ\Gamma point with a red cross, and the other regular points in black. In (B) we show the KGK_G grid. The regular set KregK_{\mathrm{reg}}, which is sampled at first is represented in green, in black all the other points which are added accordingly to QGQ_G. Using (27) from green points in (B) with black points in (A) will transform to a green point kj\mathbf{k}_j. The additional blue points in QGQ_G create the surrounding black points in (B).

Differences lie in the fact that while we are using the same grids for occupied and virtual orbitals, we have an independent q\mathbf{q}-grid augmenting our regular k\mathbf{k}-grid. This allows for introducing a flexible displacement parameter in q\mathbf{q} to treat the integrable divergence at the Γ\Gamma-point.

Considering the reciprocal lattice vectors bi\mathbf{b}_i as basis for the reciprocal space, these additional points have coordinates x=∑i±dbi\mathbf{x} = \sum_i \pm d\mathbf{b}_i, where x\mathbf{x} is position of the additional point in QGQ_G. According to the dimension of the system, we add 2, 4, and 8 points for respectively 1D, 2D and 3D systems. With this procedure, we sample k\mathbf{k}-space, by generating a regular k\mathbf{k}-grid KregK_{\mathrm{reg}} first and then combining it with the increments QGQ_G as

kj+q=ki.(27)\mathbf{k}_j + \mathbf{q} = \mathbf{k}_i . \tag*{(27)}

In this way, all ki\mathbf{k}_i which augment KregK_{\mathrm{reg}}, will be used to generate the final KGK_G, which is schematically presented in Figure 2B.

With the right choice of QGQ_G, the size of KGK_G increases linearly with QGQ_G, because many target points kik_i will already be part of the regular set KregK_{reg}. The additional sampling increases the size of the KregK_{reg} grid exactly by a multiplicative factor of Nadd+1N_{add}+1. For instance, for a 2D system, where 4 additional points are added in QGQ_G around Γ\Gamma, a regular grid KregK_{reg} of 10×1010 \times10 kk-points, results in a KGK_G of (10×10)×5(10 \times10) \times5. This scaling however only affects the memory demands of the calculations. As can be seen from eq. (15), the computational effort to evaluate the polarizability in reciprocal space scales as the product of the kk and qq integration grids, which is Kreg×QGK_{reg} \times Q_G.

In the worst-case scenario, using other choices of QGQ_G, such as generic non-regular grids, can make the size of KGK_G scale quadratically with respect to QGQ_G. From eq. (27), it is evident that this occurs when none of the kjk_j points belong to the previous KregK_{reg} sampling. Other samplings around Γ\Gamma, improving on a regular grid, also make the size of KGK_G scale linearly with respect to QGQ_G, but the number of additional points influences the prefactor of the memory scaling. Since now the minimum increment between two kk-points is determined by the distance of the additional sampling around q=Γq=\Gamma, also the radius of the Coulomb potential damping increases. In particular, for the results that will be presented further in this article, the distance dx=110dregxd^x=\frac{1}{10}d^x_{reg} where dregxd^x_{reg} is the directional increment between the initial regular grid in q\mathbf{q}.

RPA Algorithm

Here, we discuss the design of our RPA algorithm which is summarized in algorithm 1. The decisive part is the calculation of the RPA integrand εω,q\varepsilon_{\omega,q} for all q\mathbf{q} and ω\omega in their respective grids which enters eq. (4) through

EcorrRPA≈∑ω∑q∈QGεω,qζqζω,(28)E^{RPA}_{corr} \approx\sum_{\omega}\sum_{q\in Q_G} \varepsilon_{\omega,q}\zeta_q\zeta_\omega, \tag*{(28)}

Algorithm 1 Algorithm for the evaluation of the RPA correlation energy

Input: CαiaC_{\alpha}^{ia}, ϵn\epsilon_n

  1. for q←q1q \leftarrow q_1 to qMq_M (subdivide in Ng.qN_{g.q} groups) do

  2.     eval. V0.5(q)V^{0.5}(q)

  3.     for ω←ω1\omega\leftarrow\omega_1 to ωN\omega_N (subdivide in Ng.ωN_{g.\omega} groups) do

  4.         for k1k_1 and k2k_2 if k1−k2≡qk_1-k_2 \equiv q do

  5.             eval. Cα,i,β∗k1k2C_{\alpha,i,\beta}^{*k_1k_2}

  6.             eval. Pk1,k2(iω)P_{k_1,k_2}(i\omega)

  7.             eval. Cα,i,β∗k2k1C_{\alpha,i,\beta}^{*k_2k_1}

  8.             eval. Pk2,k1†(ω)P_{k_2,k_1}^{\dagger}(\omega)

  9.             Pq(iω)=Pq(iω)+ζk[Pk1,k2(ω)+Pk2,k1†(iω)]P_q(i\omega)=P_q(i\omega)+\zeta_k\left[P_{k_1,k_2}(\omega)+P_{k_2,k_1}^{\dagger}(i\omega)\right]

  10.         end for

  11.         Zω,q=Vq0.5Pq(iω)Vq0.5Z_{\omega,q}=V_q^{0.5}P_q(i\omega)V_q^{0.5}

  12.         ϵω,q=[log⁡(det⁡(1−Zω,q))−Tr⁡(Zω,q)]\epsilon_{\omega,q}=\left[\log\left(\det(1-Z_{\omega,q})\right)-\operatorname{Tr}(Z_{\omega,q})\right]

  13.         eω=eω+2ζqϵω,qe_\omega=e_\omega+2\zeta_q\epsilon_{\omega,q}

  14.     end for

  15. end for

  16. ERPA=∑ωeωζωE_{RPA}=\sum_\omega e_\omega\zeta_\omega

where ζq\zeta_q and ζω\zeta_\omega denote the integration weights for q\mathbf{q} and ω\omega-integration, respectively. In our implementation, the q\mathbf{q}-integration for a specific ω\omega is achieved through subsequent summations at every cycle, obtaining in the end the intermediate eωe_\omega. The integration of eωe_\omega is performed at the end of both loops.

To parallelise (28) efficiently, the loops over ω\omega and q\mathbf{q} group all the concurring processes NpN_p in smaller ScaLapack contexts. This technique allows each ScaLapack context to be composed of nq,ω=Np/Ng,ωNg,qn_{q,\omega}=N_p/N_{g,\omega}N_{g,q} processes where each handles a portion of the whole workload, consisting of couples of q\mathbf{q} and ω\omega. Each group will have a separate ScaLapack context to enable distributed algebra. In practice, considering sequential routines proportionally more efficient than their distributed version, one would prefer to have only one single process per group, without actually adopting any parallelisation in the algebra. However, this is not always achievable due to memory constraints, since storing all the intermediate matrices at the same time can become prohibitive. Apart from the communication that occurs within ScaLapack, the only communication that is needed consists in gathering eωe_\omega, which later is integrated only in the main node with the respective weights. The procedure is illustrated in Figure 3.

Figure 3. Schematic overview of the parallelization strategy adopted in our implementation.

The fit coefficients are transformed to the MO basis on the fly when needed for the corresponding polarizability terms. Therefore, some of these transformations have to be performed multiple times. However, the alternative of storing them all, even on disk, is prohibitive due to memory constraints. Nevertheless, for some architectures with faster read and write to disk, or for small calculations in which the memory is not a constraint, these become viable options. For larger systems, storing the PADF fit coefficients becomes the memory bottleneck.

Results

In the following, we report tests of several aspects of our RPA implementation. In all calculations, we employ STO-type basis sets represented in the NAO-form. These range from double-ζ\zeta (DZ) to quadruple-ζ\zeta quality (QZ), referred to as DZP, TZ2P, and QZ4P, respectively, [143] where the suffix xP indicates the number of polarization functions. We note that some integrals, such as kinetic energy integrals or overlap integrals, could in principle be evaluated analytically for STOs. However, the computational overhead of evaluating them numerically when they are represented as NAOs is completely negligible. All calculations used a modified Gauss–Legendre frequency grid of 32 points, according to the prescription of Ref. 69. All other computational details are provided in connection with the rest of the results.

Coulomb potential truncation

As a first test of our implementation, we assess how the damping of the Coulomb potential affects the accuracy of our results, and how it influences convergence of the RPA correlation energies with respect to the size of the kk-grid for two-dimensional hexagonal boron nitride (h-BN). Figure 4 shows the absolute errors of the RPA correlation energy for different r0r_0 in the Fermi-Dirac damping function for different regular k\mathbf{k}-grids, distinguished by different colours. We have chosen the infinite k\mathbf{k}-grid limit, obtained from fitting the AUTO damping scheme with an inverse linear fit with respect to the number of k\mathbf{k}-points as reference value. We have used a constant decay parameter β\beta, obtained according to the rules depicted in § 3.1 in all calculations. The error in the RPA correlation energy decreases with the number of k\mathbf{k}-points, as long as the damping radius r0r_0 is smaller than the radius of the circle confined by the parallelogram defined by Rmax⁡R^{\max}. Larger values of r0r_0 lead to uncontrolled errors in the correlation energy.

Figure 4. Effect of Fermi–Dirac damping on RPA@PBE correlation energy convergence for hexagonal boron nitride (STO-DZ basis) The y-axis shows the absolute deviation from a reference RPA energy, extrapolated via an inverse-linear fit in the infinite QGQ_G limit using the AUTO damping scheme. The x-axis varies the Fermi–Dirac damping parameter r0r_0. Colors denote different QGQ_G grids, with vertical lines indicating the largest inscribed circle radius in the corresponding RxR_x grids. All curves use the same β\beta parameter, as defined along with the AUTO damping settings in § 3.1.

Moreover, as long as r0r_0 is smaller than Rmax⁡R^{\max}, we observe convergence of the RPA correlation energy to a short-range separated value. For instance, choosing a fixed damping radius of r0=40r_0 = 40 Bohr, we obtain almost the same RPA correlation energy with the 30×3030 \times30 and 50×5050 \times50 k\mathbf{k}-grids. A fixed damping radius would correspond to a fixed short-range separated RPA calculation. This is not desirable, since RPA correlation is important in the long range.[144] Moreover, the artificial convergence comes from restricting the RPA correlation energy to the short range, leading to potentially large errors in absolute correlation energies.

The automatic damping we use in this work avoids such an artificial truncation of the Coulomb potential outside the finite resolution prescribed by the finite k\mathbf{k}-grid. The stars in Figure 4 show the convergence of the RPA correlation energy with respect to the k\mathbf{k}-grid and associated damping distance to the true undamped result. For this test, we used a damping distance r0r_0 equal to 75% of RcR_{\mathrm{c}}, with a decay speed that reached a damping factor of 0.1% at a distance of 1.3r01.3r_0. Lastly, we bring to the attention the large deviations from the fully converged result, which in the best cases is of the order of 1 kcal mol−1^{-1}. Leaving out that we are looking at an absolute energy and that energy differences will be subjected to error cancellation, the root cause is the difficulty of regular grids to treat the integration at the Γ\Gamma point. In § 4.3, we will show how the use of dual grids, described in section 3.2 improves the k\mathbf{k}-point convergence.

Damping distance effects on fluoro-polyacetylene

To further study the effects of the damping of the Coulomb potential on RPA correlation energies we analyzed the RPA integrand εω,q\varepsilon_{\omega,q} of fluoro-polyacetylene (whose structure is shown in Figure 5) for different Fermi-Dirac damping distances r0r_0 using a decay parameter β\beta reaching a damping of 0.1% at distance of 1.3 r0r_0 using regular 1D grids KGK_G and QGQ_G of 128 kk-points. The results, displayed in Figure 5, demonstrate that the damping of the Coulomb potential, or, more generally, the effect of a finite grid of unit cells in real space, do not solely affect the integrand at the Γ\Gamma-point (q≡0q \equiv0) but modifies εω,q\varepsilon_{\omega,q} globally.

Figure 5. in (A) Fluoro-polyacetylene geometry with its RPA correlation energy integrand εω,q\varepsilon_{\omega,q} for a specific imaginary frequency, iω=8i\omega= 8 Hartree, using the DZ basis set of Band. The different numbers in the legend denote the different values of r0r_0 in Bohr. In (B) Its Fourier analysis for the same frequency and same basis. The black line represents a calculation performed with 1000 kk-points and AUTO range separation

We notice that εω,q\varepsilon_{\omega,q} tends to converge to a definite value at the Γ\Gamma-point for increasing damping distances, while the behaviour away from q≡Γq \equiv\Gamma point is more subtle. Guided by the oscillating trend of the curves in the left panel of Figure 5, we performed a Fourier analysis of the same function presented in the right panel of Figure 5, where, given the parity of the function, only the positive axis is shown. The different lines exhibit unique spikes in increasing order, according to the respective damping radii.

Even though the functions εω,q\varepsilon_{\omega,q} are very different for different damping distances, the

RPA results reported in Table 1 remain stable. This suggests that for this system, to some extent, the effect of the damping cancels out in the oscillations shown in Figure 5. It is clear that the damping, which undoubtedly guarantees a regular convergence to the fully periodic RPA Correlation energy, affects the RPA integrand. As shown by the Fourier analysis, this is mitigated only when the damping parameter goes to infinity, which then comes with the known problem of the Γ\Gamma-point divergence of the Coulomb potential. [72] Damping of the Coulomb potential facilitates convergence to the limit of infinite kk-grid sampling, but it does not necessarily guarantee fast convergence. As shown in the next section, the combination with the dual grid approach leads to fast kk-grid convergence.

r0r_0ERPA(2.47 A˚)E_{RPA}(2.47\text{ Å})ERPA(2.67 A˚)E_{RPA}(2.67\text{ Å})Δ\Delta
10-333.408-339.461-6.052
20-331.902-338.277-6.374
30-331.731-338.145-6.414
40-331.694-338.113-6.418
50-331.683-338.100-6.417

Table 1. RPA correlation energies for fluoro-polyacetylene (kcal mol−1^{-1}) using different bond lengths between the two carbon atoms (indicated in the parentheses), and different damping distances r0r_0 (first column, in Bohr) The RPA contribution to the energy difference between the equilibrium and stretched geometries (kcal mol−1^{-1}) is reported in the last column, using the DZ basis set.

Validation of damping approach and the reciprocal space convergence

To validate the combined use of damping and dual-grid techniques, we calculate the MgO–CO adsorption energy for a single MgO layer at 100 % coverage with a Mg–C distance of 2.479 Å, as well as the interaction energy of an AA′-stacked h-BN bilayer at an interlayer distance of 3.45 Å.[145] Enhanced grids were used, adding sampling at 1/101/10 of the regular kk-grid step.

Figure 6a shows the CO adsorption energy on the MgO monolayer for different kk-meshes relative to its value calculated with a 17 × 17 kk-mesh. The data demonstrates that kk-point convergence is both rapid and that the rate of convergence is independent of the basis set: lines of the same color (DZP vs. TZ2P) for the same decay parameter r0r_0 nearly overlap. This observation is consistent with previous plane-wave results. [146] Figure 6b shows again the RPA contribution to the CO adsorption energy on the MgO monolayer for all different kk-meshes.

Figure 6. Absolute deviation of the RPA contribution to the adsorption energy with respect to tst_s values calculated with a 17×1717 \times17 kk-mesh, for different decay parameters and basis sets. b) RPA contributions to the interaction energy for different decay parameters. In all calculations, we set a damping factor of 0.1% at 1.4r01.4r_0

The data clearly shows that the same thermodynamic limit is reached, independent of the precise value of r0r_0. The convergence rate is excellent, and independent of r0r_0, already a 9×99 \times9 kk-mesh is sufficient to converge the RPA contribution to the adsorption energy with 0.05 kcal/mol. Convergence becomes faster when r0r_0 is chosen as a larger fraction of RcR_c, since more and more of the Coulomb potential is accounted for for a given kk-grid (r0=Rcr_0 = R_c would correspond to zero damping). Tables S4 and S6 in the supporting information demonstrate that absolute correlation energies converge equally fast.

For the h-BN bilayer, Figure 7 shows the differences in RPA adsorption energies (DZP vs. TZ2P) at various kk-grids relative to a 15×1515 \times15 reference. All values are very close to zero, demonstrating that convergence is independent of the basis set. In all of the following calculations, we use a damping of r0=0.5Rcr_0 = 0.5R_c, since it seems to guarantee both a rapid and smooth convergence to the thermodynamic limit.

Figure 7. Differences between the RPA contributions to the adsorption energy for the h-BN bilayer for different kk-point meshes relative to the values obtained with a 15×1515 \times15 grid calculated with the DZP and TZ2P basis sets for different Coulomb damping parameters. The tt parameter prescribes a damping factor of 0.1%0.1\% at r0+0.5tr_0 + 0.5t.

Parallel performance

In this section, we discuss the parallel efficiency of our algorithm. All calculations discussed here have been performed on AMD Genoa 9654 nodes with 192 cores, 2GB of DRAM per core, and 2.4GHz clock speed.

In Figure 8, we report the strong scaling of the algorithm through a test on a 1D fluoro-polyacetylene chain. It can be seen that the algorithm scales almost perfectly with the number of nodes. The timings for the computationally most intensive part of the algorithm, involving loops over qq and ω\omega, are in almost perfect agreement with the theoretical speedup, represented through the dashed line. Nevertheless, we find a small deviation of increasing relative magnitude. This is likely due to a non-perfect balance with respect to the qq variable, which involves evaluating the Coulomb potential. In practice, if a specific qq point is duplicated over different nodes, multiple evaluations of the potential for the same point are performed. For the overall speedup of the algorithm, the considerations made for the qq, ω\omega loop apply as well, but the deviations discussed before are larger. This is due to the necessary preparation steps before the start of the main RPA loop. These steps are carried out separately on each node to avoid the transfer of very large tensors.

Figure 8. Percentage speed up of RPA correlation energy calculation for fluoro-polyacetylene.

As a second test, we show in Figure 9 the scaling for different sizes of QGQ_G and KGK_G for h-BN using regular kk-grids. Absolute timings are shown in Table 2. Here, the scaling is again very close to the theoretical limit. The deviation of the 8 × 8 cases showing a super-perfect scaling likely derives from an artefact in the reference 2 × 192 cores case, normalised to 100%. This is due to some operations that are independent of the kk-grid size and therefore are more relevant for the smallest grid. These deviations are practically negligible and do not affect our conclusions.

Figure 9. Percentage speed up of RPA correlation energy calculation by reducing the KGK_G size h-BN.

# nodesKG\sqrt{K_G}q,ωq,\omega-loop [s]RPA[s]RPA + SCF [s]
283545115
216478491577
232742274567698
481723102
416244254336
432375337894019
8881595
816121136216
832189119322053

Table 2. RPA calculation timings for different parts of the code: the innermost q,ωq,\omega loop, the total RPA routine time, and the one of the total calculation including the DFT reference. Results have been evaluated on hBN for different regular QG/KGQ_G/K_G sizes.

Adsorption CO on MgO

As a practical application of our algorithm, we calculate the adsorption energy of CO on a MgO(001) surface at the RPA@PBE level of theory. Also known as the ’hydrogen molecule of surface science, [147] the adsorption of CO on MgO(001) is one of the most widely studied molecule-surface interactions. [34, 35, 73, 74, 79, 148, 149, 150, 151] While MgO is relevant as a catalyst for a wide variety of applications, [152, 153, 154, 155, 156] the adsorption of a small molecule on metal oxide surfaces is prototypical for many problems in heterogeneous catalysis and surface science. [157, 158, 159] Also RPA@PBE results have been reported previously, both using a fully periodic implementation[137] as well as in a finite cluster approach. [160] The RPA@PBE adsorption energy reported by Bajdich et al. [137] is with -1.65 kcal mol−1\mathrm{mol}^{-1} significantly higher (less negative) than experimental and recent embedded CCSD(T) results[34, 35, 79] which all agree on an adsorption energy of around -4.5 kcal mol−1\mathrm{mol}^{-1}.

Here, we focus on the convergence with respect to KgK_g and QGQ_G sampling, basis set convergence, the convergence with respect to the coverage θ\theta, and convergence with the number of MgO layers. As commonly done in the calculation of adsorption energies, [79, 90] all calculations are counterpoise-corrected to account for basis set superposition errors (BSSE), as this is crucial to obtain reliable adsorption energies. We do so by using the full basis of the dimer also when computing the energy for the non-interacting systems, yielding:

Ecads=Ecfull basis(MgO+CO)−Ecfull basis(CO)−Ecfull basis(MgO).(29)E_c^{\mathrm{ads}} = E_c^{\mathrm{full\ basis}}(\mathrm{MgO+CO}) - E_c^{\mathrm{full\ basis}}(\mathrm{CO}) - E_c^{\mathrm{full\ basis}}(\mathrm{MgO}) . \tag*{(29)}

Analysing the BSSE explicitly via the evaluation of

BSSE=Ecfull basis(MgO)+Ecfull basis(CO)−Ec(MgO)−Ec(CO),(30)\mathrm{BSSE} = E_c^{\mathrm{full\ basis}}(\mathrm{MgO}) + E_c^{\mathrm{full\ basis}}(\mathrm{CO}) - E_c(\mathrm{MgO}) - E_c(\mathrm{CO}) , \tag*{(30)}

is, however, complicated. Using the projector method, the number of functions projected out from the primary basis set of each subsystem does depend on the basis functions present on other subsystems. This gives an additional effect beyond the traditional definition of BSSE,[161] which, for larger basis sets, where more functions are projected out, can be rather pronounced.

The system we study is shown in Figure 10. It involves a slab composed of a variable number of MgO layers, and another slab consisting of a single layer of CO molecules of variable density. The MgO surface is modelled through a rock-salt lattice with a lattice constant of 2.105 Å, and the distance between the C and O atoms in the CO molecule is 1.134 Å. The distance between the surface and the CO molecule is the experimental distance of 2.479 Å, and the molecule is oriented perpendicular to the slab.[151] All calculations employ dual grids, with an enhancement factor of 0.1. The KgK_g grid consists of a regular number of kk-points, and the total number of kk-points is 5 times larger than the size of KGK_G.

Geometry of Carbon Oxide on MgO adsorption for 100% coverage case

Figure 10. Geometry of Carbon Oxide on MgO adsorption for 100% coverage case

Convergence with the size of primary and auxiliary basis

Using PADF, the auxiliary basis used to expand the AO products in eq. (14) significantly affects the accuracy of correlation energies, especially for larger molecules and basis sets, [123] and their convergence with respect to this parameter is decisive for reliable results. In Table 3, we show the RPA contribution to the counterpoise-corrected adsorption energy of CO on a 2-layer MgO slab at 100 % coverage for the DZP, TZ2P, and QZ4P basis sets for auxiliary fit sets of variable size. For this test, we employ a 9x9 kk-grid. The threshold parameter for the projector method eq. (20) is ϵd=10−3\epsilon_d = 10^{-3}.

NbasN_{\mathrm{bas}}NauxN_{\mathrm{aux}}Ec(MgO−CO)E_c(MgO - CO)Ec(CO)E_c(CO)Ec(MgO)E_c(MgO)ΔEc\Delta E_c
DZP100T1873-1033.20-316.23-710.36-6.61
T21477-1033.21-316.23-710.38-6.60
TZ2P172T1873-1219.42-374.14-837.54-7.75
T21477-1218.62-374.07-836.87-7.67
T32956-1217.88-374.06-836.29-7.53
T44070-1220.08-374.19-838.31-7.53
QZ4P273T1873-1439.00-439.05-988.74-11.22
T21477-1431.92-438.39-983.11-10.42
T32956-1419.13-437.99-972.57-8.56
T44070-1418.40-437.98-972.01-8.36

Table 3. Total RPA@PBE correlation energies per unit cell and contributions to Adsorption energy in kcal mol−1^{-1} for 2 MgO layers and 100 % coverage for different basis sets and auxiliary basis sets using a 9x9 kk-grid. NbasN_{\mathrm{bas}} denotes the number of primary basis functions remaining after applying the projector method.

Different auxiliary basis sets are denoted as T1 to T4. Their generation has been described in Ref. 126. Importantly, they are not automatically generated from the primary basis. T1 contains auxiliary basis functions up to lmax⁡=4l_{\max} = 4, T2 and T3 contain auxiliary basis functions up to lmax⁡=6l_{\max} = 6 (As also reflected by the numbers of auxiliary basis functions in each system shown in Table 3, T3 is composed of a much larger number of fit functions for each angular momentum), and T4 contains additional basis functions with lmax⁡=7l_{\max} = 7. Even though the maximum angular momentum in our primary basis sets is lmax⁡=3l_{\max} = 3, angular momenta larger than 2lmax⁡2l_{\max} in the auxiliary basis can be important. [123, 162] For the DZP basis set, even absolute correlation energies are already converged with the T1 auxiliary basis. The TZ2P calculations show a larger dependence on the auxiliary basis, and the T3 set is necessary for the convergence of the correlation energy difference. For the QZ4P basis set, correlation energies are not converged with T1 and T2, and even the T4 auxiliary basis changes the relative correlation energy by 0.2 kcal/mol compared to T3. The following DZP and TZ2P calculations are all performed with the T2 fit set, and the TZ2P results are adjusted for the resulting fit error of 0.14 kcal/mol in the RPA contribution to the adsorption energy.

After assessing the influence of the auxiliary basis, we also quantify the impact of the threshold for the projector method. We do this here for the TZ2P basis set and the T3 auxiliary basis. The results in Table 4 reveal a pronounced sensitivity of absolute RPA correlation energies to this value. This is expected, since a smaller number of NmodN_{\mathrm{mod}} translates into a larger primary basis. The contribution to the adsorption energy is relatively stable with respect to this parameter, but increases for ϵd=1e−4\epsilon_d = 1e^{-4}. This can be fixed using a larger auxiliary basis set. Repeating the same calculation with the T4 auxiliary basis set again reduces ΔEc\Delta E_c to -7.50 kcal/mol. This demonstrates that the convergence of a calculation with respect to the size of the auxiliary basis is heavily influenced by the threshold used for the projector method. In all of the following calculations, we will use ϵd=1e−3\epsilon_d = 1e^{-3}.

ϵd\epsilon_dNmodN_{\mathrm{mod}}Ec(MgO−CO)E_c(\mathrm{MgO}-\mathrm{CO})Ec(CO)E_c(\mathrm{CO})Ec(MgO)E_c(\mathrm{MgO})ΔEc\Delta E_c
1e−31e^{-3}12-1217.88-374.06-836.29-7.53
5e−45e^{-4}8-1227.49-375.01-844.97-7.51
1e−41e^{-4}4-1234.80-377.40-850.05-7.35

Table 4. Total RPA@PBE correlation energies per unit cell and contributions to Adsorption energy in kcal mol−1^{-1} for 2 MgO layers and 100 % coverage calculated with the TZ2P basis set and T3 auxiliary basis set. NmodN_{\mathrm{mod}} denotes the number of primary basis functions that have been projected out, and ϵd\epsilon_d is the value of the threshold for the projector method.

Using the numbers that are converged with respect to the auxiliary basis set, we extrapolate the RPA contribution to the adsorption energy to the complete basis set (CBS) limit. We assume a linear dependence of the basis set error on the inverse number of basis functions, as often done in plane wave calculations. [14] As shown in Figure 11, the linear fit including all three basis sets (DTQ) captures the trend in the calculated values quite well. From this fit, we obtain an extrapolated RPA contribution to the adsorption energy of −9.25 ± 0.29 kcal/mol, which is about 1 kcal/mol lower than the QZ result. We assume the standard fit error (intercept) of 0.29 kcal/mol to represent the uncertainty of our extrapolation.

Figure 11. Inverse linear fit of the RPA contribution to the adsorption energy in kcal/mol of CO on a 2-layer MgO slab against the size of the single particle basis. The red area is the confidence interval of the fit.

KG/QGK_{\mathrm{G}}/Q_{\mathrm{G}} convergence

Figure 12 shows the convergence with respect to the number of kk-points of the RPA contribution to the adsorption energy of CO on a 2-layer MgO slab at 100 % coverage for the DZP and TZ2P basis sets. As for the previous calculations involving the monolayer MgO slab, the convergence with the size of the kk-grid is rapid, and independent of the employed basis set. For both basis sets, convergence within 0.02 kcal/mol is reached already for the 9×99 \times9 grid. In practical calculations, the independence of the convergence rate with respect to the thermodynamic limit is particularly useful, as it allows for converging the RPA correlation energies with respect to the kk-grid in a small basis set, and subsequently to converge them with respect to the single-particle basis size using a coarser kk-grid.

Figure 12. RPA@PBE contribution to adsorption energy in kcal mol−1^{-1} for 2 MgO layers and 100% coverage for the DZP and TZ2P basis sets with different kk-grids. The shaded areas highlight the regions where the correlation energy is converged within 0.05 kcal/mol.

Number of layers

Next, we evaluate the RPA contribution to the adsorption energy as a function of the number of MgO layers, using both the DZP basis set. As shown in Table S13 in the supporting information, this contribution consistently remains at –6.60 kcal/mol, regardless of the number of layers, with the same behavior observed for the TZ2P basis set. This is in agreement with previous correlated calculations for the same system,[34] where convergence of the MP2 contribution to the adsorption energy has been obtained already with 2 MgO layers as well.

Convergence with respect to coverage

Finally, we investigate the convergence of the adsorption energy with respect to the coverage of the Mg atoms, using a slab geometry with two layers. To this end, we calculate the CO-MgO adsorption energies for the cases of 100 %, 50 %, and 25 % coverage, and show the results in Table 5. We obtain an adsorption energy of -0.84 kcal mol−1^{-1} at 100 % coverage. In the supporting information (S.3.2.2), we also show that the differences between the 100 % and 50 % coverage cases are exactly the same for the DZP and TZ2P basis sets, from which we conclude that the change of the adsorption energy with respect to the coverage is basis set independent. We therefore apply a correction evaluated with the DZP basis set to the TZ2P result at 50 % coverage to extrapolate it to the 25 % coverage case. The adsorption energies for the 25 % and 50 % cases are relatively close, suggesting that the convergence with respect to the CO saturation is achieved already at the 50 % case. For this reason, we decided to use the average between the interaction energies obtained for the 50 % and 25 % coverages as the error bar for the low coverage limit, amounting to

Coveragedim⁡nk\dim\sqrt{n_k}: 57911
100-1.10-0.90-0.85-0.84
500.330.32
25*0.070.08

Table 5. RPA@PBE interaction energies of CO with a 2-layer MgO slab for different kk meshes and coverages in kcal/mol using TZ2P and DZP basis sets. The TZ2P result for 25 % coverage has been extrapolated by adding the difference between the TZ2P and DZP result for 50 % and 25 % coverage to the TZ2P result at 25 % coverage, as shown in the supporting information in section S.3.2.2.

ϵcov=E50%−E25%2=0.12 kcal mol−1,(31)\epsilon_{\mathrm{cov}} = \frac{E_{50\%} - E_{25\%}}{2} = 0.12\ \mathrm{kcal\ mol}^{-1}, \tag*{(31)}

while the low-coverage limit is assumed to be reached at 25 % coverage, obtaining the coverage correction as

Δcov=E100%2l−E25%2l=0.92 kcal mol−1(32)\Delta_{cov} = E_{100\%}^{2l} - E_{25\%}^{2l} = 0.92\ \mathrm{kcal}\ \mathrm{mol}^{-1} \tag*{(32)}

Final estimate and discussion

To obtain the final adsorption energy, we combine the CBS-limit extrapolated RPA contribution from Figure 11 with the PBE and the HF@PBE contributions. We calculated these numbers using 4 MgO layers and the QZ4P basis set, which ensures convergence with respect to both parameters, and we obtain (See Table S14 for the raw data)

Eads100%=ERPACBS+EHFQZ4P+EPBEQZ4P−EXC@PBEQZ4P=−9.25 kcal mol−1−3.01 kcal mol−1−3.49 kcal mol−1+13.16 kcal mol−1=−2.59 kcal mol−1.(33)E_{ads}^{100\%} = E_{RPA}^{\mathrm{CBS}} + E_{HF}^{\mathrm{QZ4P}} + E_{PBE}^{\mathrm{QZ4P}} - E_{XC@PBE}^{\mathrm{QZ4P}} \\ = -9.25\ \mathrm{kcal}\ \mathrm{mol}^{-1} - 3.01\ \mathrm{kcal}\ \mathrm{mol}^{-1} - 3.49\ \mathrm{kcal}\ \mathrm{mol}^{-1} + 13.16\ \mathrm{kcal}\ \mathrm{mol}^{-1} \\ = -2.59\ \mathrm{kcal}\ \mathrm{mol}^{-1}. \tag*{(33)}

The only source of error in this number stems from the basis set extrapolation, which we estimated above to be 0.29 kcal/mol. To give the final estimate of the MgO(001)-CO adsorption energy, we use as a reference the RPA@PBE/BSSE adsorption energy at 100% coverage. As mentioned, we apply the constant shift evaluated in eq. (32) to correct for the low coverage limit. Since we consider errors arising from the number of layers and the reciprocal space convergence negligible, we combine the uncertainties from the extrapolation to the CBS error and of the coverage correction to estimate the total uncertainty as e=ϵbas2+ϵcov2=0.31 kcal mol−1e = \sqrt{\epsilon_{bas}^{2} + \epsilon_{cov}^{2}} = 0.31\ \mathrm{kcal}\ \mathrm{mol}^{-1}. The final estimate for the RPA@PBE adsorption energy of CO on the MgO surface in the low coverage limit becomes

EadsCO−MgO≈Eads100%+Δcov±e=−1.67±0.31 kcal mol−1.(34)E_{ads}^{\mathrm{CO-MgO}} \approx E_{ads}^{100\%} + \Delta_{cov} \pm e = -1.67 \pm0.31\ \mathrm{kcal}\ \mathrm{mol}^{-1}. \tag*{(34)}

This result is in excellent agreement with the periodic RPA@PBE calculations by Bajdich [137] who obtained an adsorption energy of -1.64 kcal mol−1^{-1} for the same system. Our calculations confirm that RPA@PBE underestimates both the experimental adsorption energy of -4.57 kcal mol−1^{-1} [35], and recent (embedded) CCSD(T) results obtained by different authors.[34, 35, 79] This is expected since RPA@PBE is known to underestimate the magnitude of non-covalent binding energies.[1, 38, 46] We assume that better agreement with these values can be reached by evaluating the RPA adsorption energy with orbitals obtained from a hybrid DFT calculation. Using a hybrid scheme[163] where the RPA correlation energy is obtained with exact Fock exchange from a self-consistent HF calculation, Bajdich et al.[137] obtained an adsorption energy of -7.14 kcal mol−1^{-1}. It is further known that RPA@PBE0 gives more negative non-covalent molecular interaction energies than RPA@PBE.[46] Both findings suggest that RPA@PBE0 will yield more negative energies for the adsorption of small molecules on transition metal surfaces than RPA@PBE. Such calculations require the fully self-consistent evaluation of periodic HF exchange. We are planning to report the results of such calculations shortly.

Conclusions

In this work, we reported the implementation of the RPA correlation with localised atomic orbitals and pair-atomic density fitting[123] in the BAND module[124] of AMS.[125] We have introduced an algorithm, inspired by the staggered mesh method of Lin and coworkers[135, 136] which improves the treatment of the Γ\Gamma-point divergence. This allowed us to achieve fast and reliable convergence to the infinite kk-grid limit. A complete account of this algorithm and a detailed benchmarks will be presented in future work. By distributing the evaluation of the most computationally involved steps of the RPA energy evaluation over multiple ScaLapack contexts for all possible pairs of q\mathbf{q} and ω\omega, our code achieves almost perfect parallel efficiency.

We have demonstrated the efficacy of our implementation through an application to the adsorption of CO on MgO(001). After careful extrapolation to the complete basis set and infinite kk-grid limit we obtain a final adsorption energy of −1.67±0.31-1.67 \pm0.31 kcal mol−1^{-1} in the low-coverage limit, in excellent agreement with a previous calculation. [137] As could be expected,[1, 38, 46] this value underestimates both the experimental adsorption energy of −4.57-4.57 kcal mol−1^{-1},[35] and recent (embedded) CCSD(T) results.[34, 35, 79] The remaining observed discrepancies could possibly be addressed by evaluating the RPA correlation energies with orbitals obtained from a hybrid DFT calculation.[46] Another promising option to improve over the RPA would be to extend our current algorithm to σ\sigma-functionals,[68, 69, 70] which can be achieved through minor modifications of the RPA algorithm at the same computational cost.[164] Also renormalised adiabatic xc kernel methods have been shown to provide more accurate results than the RPA at comparable computational cost.[65, 66, 67]

The developments presented here lay the groundwork for further extensions of our algorithm. In particular, we currently focus on extending our algorithm to metallic systems, which would enable the calculation of accurate energy profiles for the dissociative chemisorption of small molecules on transition metal surfaces. This process is decisive in heterogenous catalysis,[50] but difficult to model with (semi-)local density functionals [51] or even advanced embedded wave function methods.[75, 165] On the other hand, the RPA has recently been shown to give accurate reaction barrier heights within chemical accuracy for the challenging cases [51] of H2_2+Cu(111)[53, 76] and H2_2+Al(110).[53] The widespread availability of efficient RPA implementations with localised AOs could pave the way for more applications of the RPA to such systems in the future.[64] [63] Another important application would be the calculation of potential energy surfaces for the adsorption of graphene on metal surfaces, which allows for the tuning of its band gap[166] with potential applications in catalysis.[167] The competition between chemi- and physisorption induced by the interplay of covalent and dispersive interactions between both surfaces is well described by the RPA[166, 168, 169] but less so by most van der Waals density functionals.[170]

Furthermore, we are currently working on evaluating the RPA polarizability in imaginary time.[89, 90] Combined with PADF, this should lead to an RPA algorithm that scales cubically in the number of atoms[89, 90, 123, 133] and only linearly in the number of kk-points.[89, 90] This could be important for applications in heterogeneous catalysis requiring large unit cells. Together, these advancements should position the RPA as a versatile and accurate tool for computational materials science, offering a pathway for tackling increasingly challenging problems in heterogeneous catalysis.

RPA Equations in a basis

In this appendix, we discuss how the expression for the RPA correlation energy can be expressed in a non-orthogonal auxiliary basis set. Given an operator A(r,r′)A(r,r') in a L2L^2-Hilbert space, we may write

A(r,r′)=∑αβγδSαγ−1⟨fγ(r)∣A^∣fδ(r)⟩Sδβ−1fα(r)fβ∗(r′)(35)A(r,r') = \sum_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta} S^{-1}_{\alpha\gamma} \langle f_\gamma(r)|\hat{A}|f_\delta(r)\rangle S^{-1}_{\delta\beta} f_\alpha(r) f_\beta^*(r') \tag*{(35)}
=∑αβAαβfα(r)fβ∗(r′)(36)= \sum_{\alpha\beta} A_{\alpha\beta} f_\alpha(r) f_\beta^*(r') \tag*{(36)}

Where we have defined

Sαγ=∫R3fα∗(r)fγ(r) dr(37)S_{\alpha\gamma} = \int_{\mathbb{R}^3} f_\alpha^*(r) f_\gamma(r)\,\mathrm{d}r \tag*{(37)}

and

A~αγ=⟨fα∣A^∣fγ⟩=∫R3fα∗(r)A(r,r′)fγ(r′) drdr′(38)\widetilde{A}_{\alpha\gamma} = \langle f_\alpha|\hat{A}|f_\gamma\rangle= \int_{\mathbb{R}^3} f_\alpha^*(r) A(r,r') f_\gamma(r')\,\mathrm{d}r\mathrm{d}r' \tag*{(38)}

The set of functions fα∈Ff_\alpha\in F is assumed to be a basis of the Hilbert space in which $A(r,r') is defined. We then obtain

Z(r,r′′,ω)=∫R3P0(r,r′,ω)v(r′,r′′) dr′=∫R3dr′∑αγPαγ0(ω)fα(r)fγ∗(r′)∑δβvδβfδ(r′)fβ∗(r′′)=∑αγ∑δβPαγ0(ω)Sγδvδβfα(r)fβ∗(r′′)=∑αβ[P0(ω)Sv]αβfα(r)fβ∗(r′′)=∑αβ[P0(ω)SS−1v~S−1]αβfα(r)fβ∗(r′′)=∑αβ[P0(ω)v~S−1]αβfα(r)fβ∗(r′′)(39)\begin{aligned} Z(r,r^{\prime\prime},\omega) &= \int_{\mathbb{R}^{3}} P^{0}(r,r^{\prime},\omega)v(r^{\prime},r^{\prime\prime})\,dr^{\prime} \\ &= \int_{\mathbb{R}^{3}} dr^{\prime} \sum_{\alpha\gamma} P^{0}_{\alpha\gamma}(\omega)f_{\alpha}(r)f_{\gamma}^{*}(r^{\prime}) \sum_{\delta\beta}v_{\delta\beta}f_{\delta}(r^{\prime})f_{\beta}^{*}(r^{\prime\prime}) \\ &= \sum_{\alpha\gamma}\sum_{\delta\beta}P^{0}_{\alpha\gamma}(\omega)S_{\gamma\delta}v_{\delta\beta}f_{\alpha}(r)f_{\beta}^{*}(r^{\prime\prime}) \\ &= \sum_{\alpha\beta}\left[P^{0}(\omega)S v\right]_{\alpha\beta}f_{\alpha}(r)f_{\beta}^{*}(r^{\prime\prime}) \\ &= \sum_{\alpha\beta}\left[P^{0}(\omega)SS^{-1}\widetilde{v}S^{-1}\right]_{\alpha\beta}f_{\alpha}(r)f_{\beta}^{*}(r^{\prime\prime}) \\ &= \sum_{\alpha\beta}\left[P^{0}(\omega)\widetilde{v}S^{-1}\right]_{\alpha\beta}f_{\alpha}(r)f_{\beta}^{*}(r^{\prime\prime}) \tag*{(39)} \end{aligned}

for the product of polarizability and Coulomb potential. The trace becomes

Tr⁡[Z(r,r′,ω)]=∫R3∫R3dr′dr∑αβZαβfβ∗(r′)fα(r)δ(r,r′)=∫R3∫R3dr′dr∑αβ[P0v~S−1]αβfβ∗(r′)fα(r)δ(r,r′)=∑αβ[P0v~S−1]αβSβα=Tr⁡[P0v~]=Tr⁡[v~1/2P0v~1/2](40)\begin{aligned} \operatorname{Tr}[Z(r,r^{\prime},\omega)] &= \int_{\mathbb{R}^{3}}\int_{\mathbb{R}^{3}}dr^{\prime}dr\sum_{\alpha\beta}Z_{\alpha\beta}f_{\beta}^{*}(r^{\prime})f_{\alpha}(r)\delta(r,r^{\prime}) \\ &= \int_{\mathbb{R}^{3}}\int_{\mathbb{R}^{3}}dr^{\prime}dr\sum_{\alpha\beta}\left[P^{0}\widetilde{v}S^{-1}\right]_{\alpha\beta}f_{\beta}^{*}(r^{\prime})f_{\alpha}(r)\delta(r,r^{\prime}) \\ &= \sum_{\alpha\beta}\left[P^{0}\widetilde{v}S^{-1}\right]_{\alpha\beta}S_{\beta\alpha} \\ &= \operatorname{Tr}[P^{0}\widetilde{v}] \\ &= \operatorname{Tr}[\widetilde{v}^{1/2}P^{0}\widetilde{v}^{1/2}] \tag*{(40)} \end{aligned}

We can notice that a similar cancellation of the overlap matrix SS also occurs in the power series term,

1nTr⁡(Z(r,r′,ω)n)=1nTr⁡([P0v~]n).(41)\frac{1}{n}\operatorname{Tr}(Z(r,r^{\prime},\omega)^{n})=\frac{1}{n}\operatorname{Tr}([P^{0}\widetilde{v}]^{n}) . \tag*{(41)}

The RPA equation then becomes

EcorrRPA=−12π∫0∞dωTr⁡[∑n=1∞1n[Z(r,r′)]n−Z(r,r′)]=−12π∫0∞dω[∑n=1∞1nTr⁡([P0v~]n)−Tr⁡(P0v)]=−12π∫0∞dω[log⁡(det⁡(1−Z))−Tr⁡(Z)](42)\begin{aligned} E_{\mathrm{corr}}^{\mathrm{RPA}} &= -\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{0}^{\infty} d\omega\operatorname{Tr}\left[\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n} [Z(r,r')]^{n} - Z(r,r')\right] \\ &= -\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{0}^{\infty} d\omega\left[\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n}\operatorname{Tr}\left([\mathbf{P}^{0}\tilde{\mathbf{v}}]^{n}\right) - \operatorname{Tr}(\mathbf{P}^{0}\mathbf{v})\right] \\ &= -\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{0}^{\infty} d\omega\left[\log\left(\det(1-\mathbf{Z})\right) - \operatorname{Tr}(\mathbf{Z})\right] \tag*{(42)} \end{aligned}

where the matrix Z\mathbf{Z}, by using the cyclic property of the trace operation is defined as Z=v~1/2P0v~1/2\mathbf{Z} = \tilde{\mathbf{v}}^{1/2}\mathbf{P}^{0}\tilde{\mathbf{v}}^{1/2}. We remark that the discussion presented here assumes the basis FF to be complete when representing both the Coulomb potential and the polarizability. In practice, however, this can not be achieved and an error deriving from the incompleteness will always be present.

Acknowledgement

We acknowledge the use of supercomputer facilities at SURFsara sponsored by NWO Physical Sciences, with financial support from The Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO). E.S. acknowledges funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under grant agreement No 956813 (2Exciting), private funding from SCM - Software for Chemistry and Materials, and funding from ChemistryNL under grant agreement CHEMIE.PGT.2024.032. A.F. acknowledges funding through a VENI grant from NWO under grant agreement VI.Veni.232.013.

TOC Graphic

Figure 13 (PDF p. 59).

References

  1. [1]Ren, X.; Rinke, P.; Joas, C.; Scheffler, M. Random-phase approximation and its applications in computational chemistry and materials science. Journal of Materials Science 2012, 47, 7447–7471.DOI
  2. [2]Bohm, D.; Pines, D. A Collective Description of Electron Interactions. 1. Magnetic Interactions. Phys. Rev. 1951, 82, 625–634.
  3. [3]Pines, D.; Bohm, D. A Collective Description of Electron Interactions: II. Collective vs Individual Particle Aspects of the Interactions. Phys. Rev. 1952, 85, 338–353.DOI
  4. [4]Bohm, D.; Pines, D. A collective description of electron interactions: III. Coulomb interactions in a degenerate electron gas. Physical Review 1953, 92, 609–625.DOI
  5. [5]Hubbard, J. The description of collective motions in terms of many-body perturbation theory. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A. Mathematical and Physical Sciences 1957, 240, 539–560.DOI
  6. [6]Gell-Mann, M.; Brueckner, K. A. Correlation energy of an electron gas at high density. Physical Review 1957, 106, 364–368.
  7. [7]Mattuck, R. D. A Guide to Feynman Diagrams in the Many-body Problem, 2nd ed.; Dover Publications INC. New York, 1992.
  8. [8]Klein, A. Perturbation theory for an infinite medium of fermions. Physical Review 1961, 121, 950–956.
  9. [9]Klein, A.; Prange, R. Perturbation Theory for an Infinite Medium of Fermions. Phys. Rev. 1958, 112, 994–1007.DOI
  10. [10]Caruso, F.; Rohr, D. R.; Hellgren, M.; Ren, X.; Rinke, P.; Rubio, A.; Scheffler, M. Bond Breaking and Bond Formation: How Electron Correlation is Captured in Many-Body Perturbation Theory and Density-Functional Theory. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2013, 110, 146403.
  11. [11]Langreth, D. C.; Perdew, J. P. The Exchange-Correlation Energy of a metallic surface. Solid State Communications 1975, 17, 1425–1429.
  12. [12]Langreth, D. C.; Perdew, J. P. Exchange-correlation energy of a metallic surface: Wave-vector analysis. Physical Review B 1977, 15, 2884–2901.DOI
  13. [13]van Loon, E. G.; Rösner, M.; Katsnelson, M. I.; Wehling, T. O. Random phase approximation for gapped systems: Role of vertex corrections and applicability of the constrained random phase approximation. Physical Review B 2021, 104, 045134.DOI
  14. [14]Harl, J.; Kresse, G. Cohesive energy curves for noble gas solids calculated by adiabatic connection fluctuation-dissipation theory. Physical Review B 2008, 77, 045136.DOI
  15. [15]Kresse, G.; Harl, J. Accurate bulk properties from approximate many-body techniques. Physical Review Letters 2009, 103, 056401.
  16. [16]Lebègue, S.; Harl, J.; Gould, T.; Ángyán, J. G.; Kresse, G.; Dobson, J. F. Cohesive properties and asymptotics of the dispersion interaction in graphite by the random phase approximation. Physical Review Letters 2010, 105, 196401.
  17. [17]Perdew, J. P.; Schmidt, K. Jacob’s ladder of density functional approximations for the exchange-correlation energy. AIP Conference Proceedings 2001, 577, 1–20.DOI
  18. [18]Hohenberg, P.; Kohn, W. Inhomogeneous Electron Gas. Physical Review 1964, 136, 864–871.
  19. [19]Kohn, W.; J., S. L. Self-Consistent Equations Including Exchange and Correlation Effects. Physical Review 1965, 140, A1133.
  20. [20]Tkatchenko, A.; Scheffler, M. Accurate molecular van der Waals interactions from ground-state electron density and free-atom reference data. Physical Review Letters 2009, 102, 6–9.
  21. [21]Grimme, S.; Ehrlich, S.; Goerigk, L. Effect of the damping function in dispersion corrected density functional theory. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2011, 32, 1456–1465.
  22. [22]Dobson, J. F.; Gould, T. Calculation of dispersion energies. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 2012, 24, 073201.
  23. [23]Vydrov, O. A.; Voorhis, T. V. Nonlocal van der Waals density functional: The simpler the better. Journal of Chemical Physics 2010, 133, 244103.
  24. [24]Coester, F.; Kümmel, H. Short-range correlations in nuclear wave functions. Nuclear Physics 1960, 17, 477–485.
  25. [25]Bartlett, R. J.; Musial, M. Coupled-cluster theory in quantum chemistry. Rev. Mod. Phys. 2007, 79, 291–352.
  26. [26]Čížek, J. On the Correlation Problem in Atomic and Molecular Systems. Calculation of Wavefunction Components in Ursell-Type Expansion Using Quantum-Field Theoretical Methods. The Journal of Chemical Physics 1966, 45, 4256–4266.
  27. [27]Stanton, J. F.; Bartlett, R. J. The equation of motion coupled-cluster method. A systematic biorthogonal approach to molecular excitation energies, transition probabilities, and excited state properties. The Journal of Chemical Physics 1993, 98, 7029–7039.DOI
  28. [28]Zhang, I. Y.; Grü­neis, A. Coupled cluster theory in materials science. Frontiers in Materials 2019, 6, 00123.DOI
  29. [29]Schäfer, T.; Gallo, A.; Irmler, A.; Hummel, F.; Grü­neis, A. Surface science using coupled cluster theory via local Wannier functions and in-RPA-embedding: The case of water on graphitic carbon nitride. Journal of Chemical Physics 2021, 155, 244103.DOI
  30. [30]Gruber, T.; Liao, K.; Tsatsoulis, T.; Hummel, F.; Grü­neis, A. Applying the Coupled-Cluster Ansatz to Solids and Surfaces in the Thermodynamic Limit. Physical Review X 2018, 8, 21043.DOI
  31. [31]McClain, J.; Sun, Q.; Chan, G. K. L.; Berkelbach, T. C. Gaussian-Based Coupled-Cluster Theory for the Ground-State and Band Structure of Solids. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2017, 13, 1209–1218.DOI
  32. [32]Vo, E. A.; Wang, X.; Berkelbach, T. C. Performance of periodic EOM-CCSD for bandgaps of inorganic semiconductors and insulators. Journal of Chemical Physics 2024, 160, 044106.DOI
  33. [33]Ye, H.-Z.; Berkelbach, T. C. Periodic Local Coupled-Cluster Theory for Insulators and Metals. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2024, 20, 8948–8959.DOI
  34. [34]Ye, H.-Z.; Berkelbach, T. C. Adsorption and Vibrational Spectroscopy of CO on the Surface of MgO from Periodic Local Coupled-Cluster Theory. Faraday Discussions 2024,DOI
  35. [35]Shi, B. X.; Zen, A.; Kapil, V.; Nagy, P. R.; Grüneis, A.; Michaelides, A. Many-Body Methods for Surface Chemistry Come of Age: Achieving Consensus with Experiments. Journal of the American Chemical Society 2023, 145, 25372–25381.DOI
  36. [36]Scuseria, G. E.; Henderson, T. M.; Sorensen, D. C. The ground state correlation energy of the random phase approximation from a ring coupled cluster doubles approach. Journal of Chemical Physics 2008, 129.
  37. [37]Scuseria, G. E.; Henderson, T. M.; Bulik, I. W. Particle-particle and quasiparticle random phase approximations: Connections to coupled cluster theory. Journal of Chemical Physics 2013, 139, 104113.DOI
  38. [38]Nguyen, B. D.; Chen, G. P.; Agee, M. M.; Burow, A. M.; Tang, M. P.; Furche, F. Divergence of Many-Body Perturbation Theory for Noncovalent Interactions of Large Molecules. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2020, 16, 2258–2273.DOI
  39. [39]Grüneis, A.; Marsman, M.; Kresse, G. Second-order Møller-Plesset perturbation theory applied to extended systems. II. Structural and energetic properties. Journal of Chemical Physics 2010, 133, 074107.DOI
  40. [40]Ben, M. D.; Hutter, J.; Vandevondele, J. Second-order møller-plesset perturbation theory in the condensed phase: An efficient and massively parallel gaussian and plane waves approach. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2012, 8, 4177–4188.DOI
  41. [41]Schäfer, T.; Ramberger, B.; Kresse, G. Quartic scaling MP2 for solids: A highly parallelized algorithm in the plane wave basis. Journal of Chemical Physics 2017, 146, 104101.DOI
  42. [42]Keller, E.; Tsatsoulis, T.; Reuter, K.; Margraf, J. T. Regularized second-order correlation methods for extended systems. Journal of Chemical Physics 2022, 156, 024106.
  43. [43]Paier, J.; Ren, X.; Rinke, P.; Scuseria, G. E.; Grü­neis, A.; Kresse, G.; Scheffler, M. Assessment of correlation energies based on the random-phase approximation. New Journal of Physics 2012, 14, 043002.
  44. [44]Ren, X.; Rinke, P.; Scuseria, G. E.; Scheffler, M. Renormalized second-order perturbation theory for the electron correlation energy: Concept, implementation, and benchmarks. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2013, 88, 035120.
  45. [45]Bates, J. E.; Furche, F. Communication: Random phase approximation renormalized many-body perturbation theory. Journal of Chemical Physics 2013, 139, 171103.DOI
  46. [46]Förster, A. Assessment of the second-order statically screened exchange correction to the random phase approximation for correlation energies. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2022, 18, 5948–5965.DOI
  47. [47]Grüneis, A.; Marsman, M.; Harl, J.; Schimka, L.; Kresse, G. Making the random phase approximation to electronic correlation accurate. Journal of Chemical Physics 2009, 131, 154115.DOI
  48. [48]Hummel, F.; Grü​neis, A.; Kresse, G.; Ziesche, P. Screened Exchange Corrections to the Random Phase Approximation from Many-Body Perturbation Theory. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2019, 15, 3223–3236.
  49. [49]Henderson, T. M.; Scuseria, G. E. The connection between self-interaction and static correlation: A random phase approximation perspective. Molecular Physics 2010, 108, 2511–2517.DOI
  50. [50]Kroes, G. J. Computational approaches to dissociative chemisorption on metals: Towards chemical accuracy. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2021, 23, 8962–9048.DOI
  51. [51]Gerrits, N.; Smeets, E. W.; Vuckovic, S.; Powell, A. D.; Doblhoff-Dier, K.; Kroes, G. J. Density Functional Theory for Molecule-Metal Surface Reactions: When Does the Generalized Gradient Approximation Get It Right, and What to Do if It Does Not. Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 2020, 11, 10552–10560.DOI
  52. [52]Schmidt, P. S.; Thygesen, K. S. Benchmark Database of Transition Metal Surface and Adsorption Energies from Many-Body Perturbation Theory. Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2018, 122, 4381–4390.arxiv.org/abs/1801.10560
  53. [53]Oudot, B.; Doblhoff-Dier, K. Reaction barriers at metal surfaces computed using the random phase approximation: Can we beat DFT in the generalized gradient approximation? Journal of Chemical Physics 2024, 161, 054708.DOI
  54. [54]Rohlfing, M.; Bredow, T. Binding energy of adsorbates on a noble-metal surface: Exchange and correlation effects. Physical Review Letters 2008, 101, 1–4.
  55. [55]Ren, X.; Rinke, P.; Scheffler, M. Exploring the random phase approximation: Application to CO adsorbed on Cu(111). Physical Review B 2009, 80, 045402.DOI
  56. [56]Schimka, L.; Harl, J.; Stroppa, A.; Grüneis, A.; Marsman, M.; Mittendorfer, F.; Kresse, G. Accurate surface and adsorption energies from many-body perturbation theory. Nature Materials 2010, 9, 741–744.DOI
  57. [57]Torres, J. A. G.; Ramberger, B.; Früchtl, H. A.; Schaub, R.; Kresse, G. Adsorption energies of benzene on close packed transition metal surfaces using the random phase approximation. Physical Review Materials 2017, 1, 060803(R).DOI
  58. [58]Sheldon, C.; Paier, J.; Sauer, J. Adsorption of CH4 on the Pt(111) surface: Random phase approximation compared to density functional theory. Journal of Chemical Physics 2021, 155.DOI
  59. [59]Wei, Z.; Göltl, F.; Sautet, P. Diffusion Barriers for Carbon Monoxide on the Cu(001) Surface Using Many-Body Perturbation Theory and Various Density Functionals. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2021, 17, 7862–7872.DOI
  60. [60]Liu, P.; Wang, J.; Avargues, N.; Verdi, C.; Singraber, A.; Karsai, F.; Chen, X. Q.; Kresse, G. Combining Machine Learning and Many-Body Calculations: Coverage-Dependent Adsorption of CO on Rh(111). Physical Review Letters 2023, 130, 78001.DOI
  61. [61]Weinberg, D.; Hull, O. A.; Clary, J. M.; Sundararaman, R.; Vigil-Fowler, D.; Ben, M. D. Static Subspace Approximation for Random Phase Approximation Correlation Energies: Implementation and Performance. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2024, 20, 8237-8246.
  62. [62]Clary, J. M.; Hull, O. A.; Weinberg, D.; Sundararaman, R.; Ben, M. D.; Vigil-Fowler, D. Static Subspace Approximation for Random Phase Approximation Correlation Energies: Applications to Materials for Catalysis and Electrochemistry. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2025, Sauer, J. The future of computational catalysis. Journal of Catalysis 2024, 433, 115482.DOI
  63. [64]jan Kroes, G.; Meyer, J. Best-of-both-worlds computational approaches to difficult-to-model dissociation reactions on metal surfaces. Chemical Science 2025, 16, 480–506.DOI
  64. [65]Olsen, T.; Thygesen, K. S. Extending the random-phase approximation for electronic correlation energies: The renormalized adiabatic local density approximation. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2012, 86, 081103(R).DOI
  65. [66]Olsen, T.; Thygesen, K. S. Accurate ground-state energies of solids and molecules from time-dependent density-functional theory. Physical Review Letters 2014, 112, 203001.DOI
  66. [67]Olsen, T.; Patrick, C. E.; Bates, J. E.; Ruzsinszky, A.; Thygesen, K. S. Beyond the RPA and GW methods with adiabatic xc-kernels for accurate ground state and quasi-particle energies. nature Computational Materials 2019, 5, 106.
  67. [68]Trushin, E.; Thierbach, A.; Görling, A. Toward chemical accuracy at low computational cost: Density-functional theory with σ-functionals for the correlation energy. Journal of Chemical Physics 2021, 154, 014104.DOI
  68. [69]Fauser, S.; Trushin, E.; Neiss, C.; Görling, A. Chemical accuracy with σ-functionals for the Kohn-Sham correlation energy optimized for different input orbitals and eigenvalues. Journal of Chemical Physics 2021, 155, 134111.DOI
  69. [70]Erhard, J.; Fauser, S.; Trushin, E.; Görling, A. Scaled σ-functionals for the Kohn–Sham correlation energy with scaling functions from the homogeneous electron gas. Journal of Chemical Physics 2022, 157, 114105.DOI
  70. [71]Ren, X.; Rinke, P.; Blum, V.; Wieferink, J.; Tkatchenko, A.; Sanfilippo, A.; Reuter, K.; Scheffler, M. Resolution-of-identity approach to Hartree-Fock, hybrid density func- tionals, RPA, MP2 and GW with numeric atom-centered orbital basis functions. New Journal of Physics 2012, 14, 053020.
  71. [72]Ren, X.; Merz, F.; Jiang, H.; Yao, Y.; Rampp, M.; Lederer, H.; Blum, V.; Scheffler, M. All-electron periodic G0W0 implementation with numerical atomic orbital basis functions: Algorithm and benchmarks. Physical Review Materials 2021, 5, 013807.DOI
  72. [73]Boese, A. D.; Sauer, J. Accurate adsorption energies of small molecules on oxide surfaces: CO-MgO(001). Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2013, 15, 16481–16493.DOI
  73. [74]Alessio, M.; Usvyat, D.; Sauer, J. Chemically Accurate Adsorption Energies: CO and H2O on the MgO(001) Surface. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2019, 15, 1329–1344.
  74. [75]Yin, R.; Zhang, Y.; Libisch, F.; Carter, E. A.; Guo, H.; Jiang, B. Dissociative Chemisorption of O2 on Al(111): Dynamics on a Correlated Wave-Function-Based Potential Energy Surface. Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 2018, 9, 3271–3277.DOI
  75. [76]Wei, Z.; Martinez, J. M. P.; Carter, E. A. Introducing the embedded random phase approximation: H2 dissociative adsorption on Cu(111) as an exemplar. Journal of Chemical Physics 2023, 159, 194108.DOI
  76. [77]Gujarati, T. P.; Motta, M.; Friedhoff, T. N.; Rice, J. E.; Nguyen, N.; Barkoutsos, P. K.; Thompson, R. J.; Smith, T.; Kagele, M.; Brei, M.; Jones, B. A.; Williams, K. Quantum computation of reactions on surfaces using local embedding. npj Quantum Information 2023, 9, 88.DOI
  77. [78]Sheldon, C.; Paier, J.; Usvyat, D.; Sauer, J. Hybrid RPA : DFT Approach for Adsorption on Transition Metal Surfaces : Methane and Ethane on Platinum ( 111 ). Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2024, 20, 2219–2227.DOI
  78. [79]Huang, Z.; Guo, Z.; Cao, C.; Pham, H. Q.; Wen, X.; Booth, G. H.; Chen, J.; Lv, D. Advancing Surface Chemistry with Large-Scale Ab-Initio Quantum Many-Body Simulations. arXiv:2412.18553v2 2025,arxiv.org/abs/2412.18553
  79. [80]Rojas, H. N.; R.W.Godby; J.Needs, R. Space-Time Method for Ab Initio Calculations of Self-Energies and Dielectric Response Functions of Solids. Physical Review Letters 1995, 74, 1827–1831.
  80. [81]Rieger, M. M.; Steinbeck, L.; White, I. D.; Rojas, H. N.; Godby, R. W. GW space-time method for the self-energy of large systems. Computer Physics Communications 1999, 117, 211–228.DOI
  81. [82]Hedin, L. New method for calculating the one-particle Green’s function with application to the electron-gas problem. Physical Review 1965, 139, A796.
  82. [83]Kaltak, M.; Klimeš, J.; Kresse, G. Low scaling algorithms for the random phase approximation: Imaginary time and laplace transformations. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2014, 10, 2498–2507.DOI
  83. [84]Kaltak, M.; Klimeš, J.; Kresse, G. Cubic scaling algorithm for the random phase approximation: Self-interstitials and vacancies in Si. Physical Review B 2014, 90, 054115.DOI
  84. [85]Kutepov, A. L. Self-consistent GW method: O(N) algorithm for polarizability and self energy. Computer Physics Communications 2020, 257, 107502.DOI
  85. [86]Yeh, C. N.; Morales, M. A. Low-Scaling Algorithm for the Random Phase Approximation Using Tensor Hypercontraction with k-point Sampling. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2023, 19, 6197–6207.DOI
  86. [87]Yeh, C. N.; Morales, M. A. Low-Scaling Algorithms for GW and Constrained Ran- dom Phase Approximation Using Symmetry-Adapted Interpolative Separable Density Fitting. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2024, 20, 3184–3198.
  87. [88]Graml, M.; Zollner, K.; Hernang, D.; Junior, P. E. F.; Wilhelm, J. Low-Scaling GW Algorithm Applied to Twisted Transition-Metal Dichalcogenide Heterobilayers. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2024, 20, 2202–2208.
  88. [89]Shi, R.; Lin, P.; Zhang, M. Y.; He, L.; Ren, X. Subquadratic-scaling real-space random phase approximation correlation energy calculations for periodic systems with numerical atomic orbitals. Physical Review B 2024, 109, 035103.DOI
  89. [90]Shi, R.; Zhang, M.-Y.; Lin, P.; He, L.; Ren, X. LibRPA: A Software Package for Low-scaling First-principles Calculations of Random Phase Approximation Electron Correlation Energy Based on Numerical Atomic Orbitals. Computer Physics Communications 2025, 309, 109496.
  90. [91]Kelsall, J.; Townsend, P. S.; Ellis, J.; Jardine, A. P.; Avidor, N. Ultrafast Diffusion at the Onset of Growth: O/Ru (0001). Physical Review Letters 2021, 126, 155901.DOI
  91. [92]Neugebauer, J.; Scheffler, M. Adsorbate-substrate and adsorbate-adsorbate interactions of Na and K adlayers on Al(111). Phys. Rev. B 1992, 46, 16067–16080.
  92. [93]Martyna, G. J.; Tuckerman, M. E. A reciprocal space based method for treating long range interactions in ab initio and force-field-based calculations in clusters. The Journal of Chemical Physics 1999, 110, 2810–2821.
  93. [94]Jarvis, M. R.; White, I. D.; Godby, R. W.; Payne, M. C. Supercell technique for total-energy calculations of finite charged and polar systems. Phys. Rev. B 1997, 56, 14972–14978.
  94. [95]Rozzi, C. A.; Varsano, D.; Marini, A.; Gross, E. K. U.; Rubio, A. Exact Coulomb cutoff technique for supercell calculations. Phys. Rev. B 2006, 73, 205119.
  95. [96]Giannozzi, P.; Baroni, S.; Bonini, N.; Calandra, M.; Car, R.; Cavazzoni, C.; Ceresoli, D.; Chiarotti, G. L.; Cococcioni, M.; Dabo, I.; Dal Corso, A.; de Gironcoli, S.; Fabris, S.; Fratesi, G.; Gebauer, R.; Gerstmann, U.; Gougoussis, C.; Kokalj, A.; Lazzeri, M.; Martin-Samos, L.; Marzari, N.; Mauri, F.; Mazzarello, R.; Paolini, S.; Pasquarello, A.; Paulatto, L.; Sbraccia, C.; Scandolo, S.; Sclauzero, G.; Seitsonen, A. P.; Smogunov, A.; Umari, P.; Wentzcovitch, R. M. QUANTUM ESPRESSO: a modular and open-source software project for quantum simulations of materials. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter 2009, 21, 395502.
  96. [97]Engel, E. Exact exchange plane-wave-pseudopotential calculations for slabs. Journal of Chemical Physics 2014, 140, 18A505.
  97. [98]Rozzi, C. A.; Varsano, D.; Marini, A.; Gross, E. K.; Rubio, A. Exact Coulomb cutoff technique for supercell calculations. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2006, 73, 205119.
  98. [99]Castro, A.; Räsänen, E.; Rozzi, C. A. Exact Coulomb cutoff technique for supercell calculations in two dimensions. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2009, 80, 033102.
  99. [100]Guandalini, A.; Leon, D. A.; D’Amico, P.; Cardoso, C.; Ferretti, A.; Varsano, D. Efficient GW calculations via the interpolation of the screened interaction in momentum and frequency space: The case of graphene. Physical Review B 2024, 075120, 075120.
  100. [101]Hüser, F.; Olsen, T.; Thygesen, K. S. Quasiparticle GW calculations for solids, molecules, and two-dimensional materials. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2013, 87, 235132.
  101. [102]Qiu, D. Y.; Jornada, F. H. D.; Louie, S. G. Screening and many-body effects in two-dimensional crystals: Monolayer MoS2. Physical Review B 2016, 93, 235435.
  102. [103]Lehtola, S. A review on non-relativistic, fully numerical electronic structure calculations on atoms and diatomic molecules. International Journal of Quantum Chemistry 2019, 119, e25968.
  103. [104]Dovesi, R.; Pascale, F.; Civalleri, B.; Doll, K.; Harrison, N. M.; Bush, I.; D’Arco, P.; Noël, Y.; Rérat, M.; Carbonnière, P.; Causà, M.; Salustro, S.; Lacivita, V.; Kirtman, B.; Ferrari, A. M.; Gentile, F. S.; Baima, J.; Ferrero, M.; Demichelis, R.; De La Pierre, M. The CRYSTAL code, 1976–2020 and beyond, a long story. The Journal of Chemical Physics 2020, 152, 204111.
  104. [105]Boys, S. F. A General Method of Calculation for the Stationary States of Any Molecular System. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A, Mathematical and Physical Sciences 1950, 200, 542–554.
  105. [106]McMurchie, L. E.; Davidson, E. R. One- and two-electron integrals over cartesian gaussian functions. Journal of Computational Physics 1978, 26, 218–231.
  106. [107]Obara, S.; Saika, A. Efficient recursive computation of molecular integrals over Cartesian Gaussian functions. The Journal of Chemical Physics 1986, 84, 3963–3974.
  107. [108]Gill, P. M. W.; Pople, J. A. The prism algorithm for two-electron integrals. International Journal of Quantum Chemistry 1991, 40, 753–772.
  108. [109]Sun, Q.; Berkelbach, T. C.; McClain, J. D.; Chan, G. K. L. Gaussian and plane-wave mixed density fitting for periodic systems. Journal of Chemical Physics 2017, 147, 164119.
  109. [110]Sun, Q.; Zhang, X.; Banerjee, S.; Bao, P.; Barbry, M.; Blunt, N. S.; Bogdanov, N. A.; Booth, G. H.; Chen, J.; Cui, Z. H.; Eriksen, J. J.; Gao, Y.; Guo, S.; Hermann, J.; Hermes, M. R.; Koh, K.; Koval, P.; Lehtola, S.; Li, Z.; Liu, J.; Mardirossian, N.; McClain, J. D.; Motta, M.; Mussard, B.; Pham, H. Q.; Pulkin, A.; Purwanto, W.; Robinson, P. J.; Ronca, E.; Sayfutyarova, E. R.; Scheurer, M.; Schurkus, H. F.; Smith, J. E.; Sun, C.; Sun, S. N.; Upadhyay, S.; Wagner, L. K.; Wang, X.; White, A.; Whitfield, J. D.; Williamson, M. J.; Wouters, S.; Yang, J.; Yu, J. M.; Zhu, T.; Berkelbach, T. C.; Sharma, S.; Sokolov, A. Y.; Chan, G. K. L. Recent developments in the PySCF program package. Journal of Chemical Physics 2020, 153, 024109.
  110. [111]Ye, H. Z.; Berkelbach, T. C. Correlation-Consistent Gaussian Basis Sets for Solids Made Simple. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2022, 18, 1595–1606.
  111. [112]Ben, M. D.; Schütt, O.; Wentz, T.; Messmer, P.; Hutter, J.; Vandevondele, J. Enabling simulation at the fifth rung of DFT: Large scale RPA calculations with excellent time to solution. Computer Physics Communications 2015, 187, 120–129.
  112. [113]Wilhelm, J.; Hutter, J. Periodic GW calculations in the Gaussian and plane-waves scheme. Physical Review B 2017, 95, 1–9.
  113. [114]Kühne, T. D.; Iannuzzi, M.; Ben, M. D.; Rybkin, V. V.; Seewald, P.; Stein, F.; Laino, T.; Khaliullin, R. Z.; Schütt, O.; Schiffmann, F.; Golze, D.; Wilhelm, J.; Chulkov, S.; Bani-Hashemian, M. H.; Weber, V.; Bornstnik, U.; Taillefumier, M.; Jakobovits, A. S.; Lazzaro, A.; Pabst, H.; Müller, T.; Schade, R.; Guidon, M.; Andermatt, S.; Holmberg, N.; Schenter, G. K.; Hehn, A.; Bussy, A.; Belleflamme, F.; Tabacchi, G.; Glöß, A.; Lass, M.; Bethune, I.; Mundy, C. J.; Plessl, C.; Watkins, M.; VandeVondele, J.; Krack, M.; Hutter, J. CP2K: An Electronic Structure and Molecular Dynamics Software Package – Quickstep: Efficient and Accurate Electronic Structure Calculations. Journal of Chemical Physics 2020, 152, 194103.
  114. [115]Stein, F.; Hutter, J. Massively parallel implementation of gradients within the random phase approximation: Application to the polymorphs of benzene. Journal of Chemical Physics 2024, 160, 024120.
  115. [116]Blum, V.; Gehrke, R.; Hanke, F.; Havu, P.; Havu, V.; Ren, X.; Reuter, K.; Schef- fer, M. Ab initio molecular simulations with numeric atom-centered orbitals. Computer Physics Communications 2009, 180, 2175–2196.
  116. [117]Qu, X.; Xu, P.; Li, R.; Li, G.; He, L.; Ren, X. Density Functional Theory Plus Dynamical Mean Field Theory within the Framework of Linear Combination of Numerical Atomic Orbitals: Formulation and Benchmarks. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2022, 18, 5589–5606.
  117. [118]Lin, P.; Ren, X.; He, L. Accuracy of Localized Resolution of the Identity in Periodic Hybrid Functional Calculations with Numerical Atomic Orbitals. Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 2020, 11, 3082–3088.
  118. [119]Lin, P.; Ren, X.; He, L. Efficient Hybrid Density Functional Calculations for Large Periodic Systems Using Numerical Atomic Orbitals. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2021, 17, 222–239.
  119. [120]Li, P.; Liu, X.; Chen, M.; Lin, P.; Ren, X.; Lin, L.; Yang, C.; He, L. Large-scale ab initio simulations based on systematically improvable atomic basis. Computational Materials Science 2016, 112, 503–517.
  120. [121]Lin, P.; Ren, X.; Liu, X.; He, L. Ab initio electronic structure calculations based on numerical atomic orbitals: Basic formalisms and recent progresses. WIREs Computational Molecular Science 2024, 14:e1687.
  121. [122]Zhang, I. Y.; Ren, X.; Rinke, P.; Blum, V.; Scheffler, M. Numeric atom-centered-orbital basis sets with valence-correlation consistency from H to Ar. New Journal of Physics 2013, 15, 123033.
  122. [123]Spadetto, E.; Philipsen, P. H. T.; Förster, A.; Visscher, L. Toward Pair Atomic Density Fitting for Correlation Energies with Benchmark Accuracy. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2023, 19, 1499–1516.
  123. [124]Velde, G. T.; Baerends, E. J. Precise density-functional method for periodic structures. Physical Review B 1991, 44, 7888–7903.
  124. [125]Baerends, E. J.; Aguirre, N. F.; Austin, N. D.; Autschbach, J.; Bickelhaupt, F. M.; Bulo, R.; Cappelli, C.; Duin, A. C. T. V.; Egidi, F.; Guerra, C. F.; Förster, A.; Franchini, M.; Goumans, T. P.; Heine, T.; Hellström, M.; Jacob, C. R.; Jensen, L.; Krykunov, M.; Lenthe, E. V.; Michalak, A.; Mitoraj, M. M.; Neugebauer, J.; Nicu, V. P.; Philipsen, P.; Ramanantoanina, H.; Rüger, R.; Schreckenbach, G.; Stener, M.; Swart, M.; Thijssen, J. M.; Trnka, T.; Visscher, L.; Yakovlev, A.; Gisbergen, S. V. The Amsterdam Modeling Suite. Journal of Chemical Physics 2025, 162, 162501.
  125. [126]Förster, A.; Franchini, M.; van Lenthe, E.; Visscher, L. A Quadratic Pair Atomic Resolution of the Identity Based SOS-AO-MP2 Algorithm Using Slater Type Orbitals. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2020, 16, 875 – 891.
  126. [127]Hollman, D. S.; Schaefer, H. F.; Valeev, E. F. Semi-exact concentric atomic density fitting: Reduced cost and increased accuracy compared to standard density fitting. Journal of Chemical Physics 2014, 140, 064109.
  127. [128]Hollman, D. S.; Schaefer, H. F.; Valeev, E. F. Fast construction of the exchange operator in an atom-centred basis with concentric atomic density fitting. Molecular Physics 2017, 115, 2065–2076.
  128. [129]Wang, X.; Lewis, C. A.; Valeev, E. F. Efficient evaluation of exact exchange for periodic systems via concentric atomic density fitting. Journal of Chemical Physics 2020, 153, 124116.
  129. [130]Baerends, E. J.; Ellis, D. E.; Ros, P. Self-consistent molecular Hartree—Fock—Slater calculations I. The computational procedure. Chemical Physics 1973, 2, 41–51.
  130. [131]Watson, M. A.; Handy, N. C.; Cohen, A. J. Density functional calculations, using Slater basis sets, with exact exchange. Journal of Chemical Physics 2003, 119, 6475–6481.
  131. [132]Manzer, S. F.; Epifanovsky, E.; Head-Gordon, M. Efficient implementation of the pair atomic resolution of the identity approximation for exact exchange for hybrid and range-separated density functionals. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2015, 11, 518–527.
  132. [133]Förster, A.; Visscher, L. Low-Order Scaling G0W0 by Pair Atomic Density Fitting. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2020, 16, 7381–7399.
  133. [134]Irmler, A.; Burow, A. M.; Pauly, F. Robust Periodic Fock Exchange with Atom-Centered Gaussian Basis Sets. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2018, 14, 4567–4580.
  134. [135]Xing, X.; Li, X.; Lin, L. Staggered Mesh Method for Correlation Energy Calculations of Solids: Second-Order Møller-Plesset Perturbation Theory. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2021, 17, 4733–4745.
  135. [136]Xing, X.; Lin, L. Staggered Mesh Method for Correlation Energy Calculations of Solids: Random Phase Approximation in Direct Ring Coupled Cluster Doubles and Adiabatic Connection Formalisms. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2022, 18, 763–775.
  136. [137]Bajdich, M.; Nørskov, J. K.; Vojvodic, A. Surface energetics of alkaline-earth metal oxides: Trends in stability and adsorption of small molecules. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2015, 91, 155401.
  137. [138]Spencer, J.; Alavi, A. Efficient calculation of the exact exchange energy in periodic systems using a truncated Coulomb potential. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2008, 77, 193110.
  138. [139]Sundararaman, R.; Arias, T. A. Regularization of the Coulomb singularity in exact exchange by Wigner-Seitz truncated interactions: Towards chemical accuracy in non-trivial systems. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2013, 87.
  139. [140]Hüser, F.; Olsen, T.; Thygesen, K. S. How dielectric screening in two-dimensional crystals affects the convergence of excited-state calculations: Monolayer MoS2. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2013, 88, 245309.
  140. [141]Rodrigues Pela, R.; Vona, C.; Lubeck, S.; Alex, B.; Gonzalez Oliva, I.; Draxl, C. Critical assessment of G0W0 calculations for 2D materials: the example of monolayer MoS2. npj Computational Materials 2024, 10, 77.
  141. [142]Guandalini, A.; D’Amico, P.; Ferretti, A.; Varsano, D. Efficient GW calculations in two dimensional materials through a stochastic integration of the screened potential. npj Computational Materials 2023, 9, 44.
  142. [143]Lenthe, E. V.; Baerends, J. E. Optimized Slater-type basis sets for the elements 1–118. Journal of Computational Chemistry 2003, 24, 1142–1156.
  143. [144]Bruneval, F. Range-separated approach to the RPA correlation applied to the van der Waals bond and to diffusion of defects. Physical Review Letters 2012, 108, 256403.
  144. [145]Leconte, N.; Jung, J.; Lebègue, S.; Gould, T. Moiré-pattern interlayer potentials in van der Waals materials in the random-phase approximation. Physical Review B 2017, 96, 1–10.
  145. [146]Jauho, T. S.; Olsen, T.; Bligaard, T.; Thygesen, K. S. Improved description of metal oxide stability: Beyond the random phase approximation with renormalized kernels. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2015, 92, 115140.
  146. [147]Sauer, J. Ab Initio Calculations for Molecule-Surface Interactions with Chemical Accuracy. Accounts of Chemical Research 2019, 52, 3502–3510.
  147. [148]Ugliენgo, P.; Damin, A. Are dispersive forces relevant for CO adsorption on the MgO(001) surface? Chemical Physics Letters 2002, 366, 683–690.
  148. [149]Valero, R.; Gomes, J. R.; Truhlar, D. G.; Illas, F. Good performance of the M06 family of hybrid meta generalized gradient approximation density functionals on a difficult case: CO adsorption on MgO(001). Journal of Chemical Physics 2008, 129, 124710.
  149. [150]Valero, R.; Gomes, J. R.; Truhlar, D. G.; Illas, F. Density functional study of CO and NO adsorption on Ni-doped MgO(100). Journal of Chemical Physics 2010, 132, 104701.
  150. [151]Mitra, A.; Hermes, M. R.; Cho, M.; Agarawal, V.; Gagliardi, L. Periodic Density Matrix Embedding for CO Adsorption on the MgO(001) Surface. Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters 2022, 13, 7483–7489.
  151. [152]Smart, R. S. C.; Slager, T. L.; Little, L. H.; Greenler, R. G. Carbon monoxide adsorption on magnesium oxide. The Journal of Physical Chemistry 1973, 77, 1019–1023.
  152. [153]Ito, T.; Wang, J.; Lin, C. H.; Lunsford, J. H. Oxidative dimerization of methane over a lithium-promoted magnesium oxide catalyst. Journal of the American Chemical Society 1985, 107, 5062–5068.
  153. [154]Morales, E.; Lunsford, J. H. Oxidative dehydrogenation of ethane over a lithium-promoted magnesium oxide catalyst. Journal of Catalysis 1989, 118, 255–265.
  154. [155]Ueda, W.; Kuwabara, T.; Ohshida, T.; Morikawa, Y. A low-pressure guerbet reaction over magnesium oxide catalyst. J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun. 1990, 1558–1559.
  155. [156]Kumar, D.; Reddy, V. B.; Mishra, B. G.; Rana, R.; Nadagouda, M. N.; Varma, R. S. Nanosized magnesium oxide as catalyst for the rapid and green synthesis of substituted 2-amino-2-chromenes. Tetrahedron 2007, 63, 3093–3097.
  156. [157]Li, M.; Liu, J.; Xu, Y.; Qian, G. Phosphate adsorption on metal oxides and metal hydroxides: A comparative review. Environmental Reviews 2016, 24, 319–332.
  157. [158]Gui, Y.; Liu, Z.; Ji, C.; Xu, L.; Chen, X. Adsorption behavior of metal oxides (CuO, NiO, Ag2O) modified GeSe monolayer towards dissolved gases (CO, CH4, C2H2, C2H4) in transformer oil. Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry 2022, 112, 134–145.
  158. [159]Campbell, C. T.; Sauer, J. Introduction: Surface Chemistry of Oxides. Chemical Reviews 2013, 113, 3859–3862.
  159. [160]Mazheika, A.; Levchenko, S. V. Ni substitutional defects in bulk and at the (001) surface of MgO from first-principles calculations. Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2016, 120, 26934–26944.
  160. [161]Boys, S. F.; Bernardi, F. The calculation of small molecular interactions by the differences of separate total energies. Some procedures with reduced errors. Molecular Physics 1970, 19, 553–566.
  161. [162]Ihrig, A. C.; Wieferink, J.; Zhang, I. Y.; Ropo, M.; Ren, X.; Rinke, P.; Scheffler, M.; Blum, V. Accurate localized resolution of identity approach for linear-scaling hybrid density functionals and for many-body perturbation theory. New Journal of Physics 2015, 17, 093020.
  162. [163]Ren, X.; Tkatchenko, A.; Rinke, P.; Scheffler, M. Beyond the random-phase approximation for the electron correlation energy: The importance of single excitations. Physical Review Letters 2011, 106, 153003.
  163. [164]Fauser, S.; Förster, A.; Redecker, L.; Neiss, C.; Erhard, J.; Trushin, E.; Görling, A. Basis Set Requirements of σ-Functionals for Gaussian- and Slater-Type Basis Functions and Comparison with Range-Separated Hybrid and Double Hybrid Functionals. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2024, 20, 2404–2422.
  164. [165]Zhao, Q.; Zhang, X.; Martinez, J. M. P.; Carter, E. A. Benchmarking an Embedded Adaptive Sampling Configuration Interaction Method for Surface Reactions: H2 Desorption from and CH4 Dissociation on Cu(111). Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation 2020, 16, 7078–7088.
  165. [166]Olsen, T.; Thygesen, K. S. Random phase approximation applied to solids, molecules, and graphene-metal interfaces: From van der Waals to covalent bonding. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2013, 87, 075111.
  166. [167]Pykal, M.; Jurečka, P.; Karlický, F.; Otyepka, M. Modelling of graphene functionalization. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics 2016, 18, 6351–6372.
  167. [168]Olsen, T.; Yan, J.; Mortensen, J. J.; Thygesen, K. S. Dispersive and covalent interactions between graphene and metal surfaces from the random phase approximation. Physical Review Letters 2011, 107, 156401.
  168. [169]Mittendorfer, F.; Garhofer, A.; Redinger, J.; Kliめš, J.; Harl, J.; Kresse, G. Graphene on Ni(111): Strong interaction and weak adsorption. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2011, 84, 2–5.
  169. [170]Hamada, I.; Otani, M. Comparative van der Waals density-functional study of graphene on metal surfaces. Physical Review B - Condensed Matter and Materials Physics 2010, 82, 153412.

Paper details

vlnc:W_ynszfvrf
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents