We prove that ellipsoids in Rn, n≥2, are uniquely determined by their intrinsic volumes up to congruence, resolving the conjecture posed by Gusakova and Zaporozhets in 2017.
Introduction
Let K be a convex body in Rn and denote by B2n the unit Euclidean ball in Rn. The Steiner formula asserts that for every t≥0 we have
Voln(K+tB2n)=k=0∑nκn−kVk(K)tn−k,
where
κk=Γ(k/2+1)πk/2
is the volume of B2k.
The coefficients Vk(K), k=0,1,…,n, are called the intrinsic volumes. Note that Vn(K) is equal to the volume of K, Vn−1(K) is a multiple of its surface area, V1(K) is a multiple of its mean width, and V0(K)=1 for any convex body.
Gusakova and Zaporozhets asked whether ellipsoids in Rn are uniquely determined (up to an isometry) by their intrinsic volumes. In the three-dimensional case, this question was answered affirmatively by Petrov and Tarasov [6]. We solve the problem in all dimensions.
Theorem 1.1. Two ellipsoids in Rn, n≥2, with the same intrinsic volumes V1,…,Vn are congruent.
The analogous result for dual volumes was obtained in [5].
Throughout the paper, we assume that all ellipsoids are full dimensional. The degenerate case can be reduced to subspaces of lower dimensions.
Preliminaries
To every ellipsoid E whose semiaxes squared are λ1,…,λn>0, we associate the polynomial
Q(u)=i=1∏n(1+λiu)=j=0∑nsj(Q)uj.(1)
Here sj=sj(Q) is the jth elementary symmetric polynomial in λi defined by
sj=1≤i1<⋯<ij≤n∑p=1∏jλip,if j≥1,
and s0=1. The following is a consequence of Newton’s inequalities (see [3 Theorem 53]):
sj2≥sj−1sj+1,1≤j<n.(2)
The coefficients s1,…,sn determine the semiaxes of E up to permutation. Our goal is to show that the intrinsic volumes determine these coefficients.
Throughout the paper, we will use the following rescaled version of intrinsic volumes:
vk(K)=κkVk(K),0≤k≤n.
Since an ellipsoid is uniquely determined (up to isometry) by the associated polynomial Q, it is enough to work with such polynomials and we will use the following notation:
vk(Q)=vk(E).
If the ellipsoid or its polynomial Q are clear from the context, we will just write vk.
It will often be convenient to work with a polynomial
Q(u)=1+s1u+⋯+sn−1un−1+snun,
whose coefficients are positive, but Q is not necessarily associated with an ellipsoid.
For such a polynomial and 0≤k≤n, we define
Tk(u)=p<k∑spup,
Ak(u)=p<k∑(k−p)spup,
Bk(u)=p>k∑(p−k)spup.
In particular, A0=Bn=0. Note that
Ak(u)=kTk(u)−uTk′(u)
and
Ak+1=Ak+Tk+1.
Similarly,
Bk(u)=u(Q−Tk)′−k(Q−Tk).
Whenever we need to emphasize that Ak and Bk are associated with a given polynomial Q, we will write AkQ and BkQ.
Auxiliary lemmas
First we derive a formula for vk using an existing formula for intrinsic volumes of ellipsoids proved in [2].
Lemma 3.1. Let E be an ellipsoid with the corresponding polynomials Q and Tk. Then
where sk−1(i) is the (k−1)st elementary symmetric function of λ1,…,λn with λi omitted. Set u=t2. Then tk−1dt=21uk/2−1du and ∏ℓ=1n1+λℓt2=Q(u). Bringing the sum inside the integral yields
is a polynomial with positive coefficients, not necessarily associated with an ellipsoid, we use the right-hand side of (3) as the definition of vk(Q). The identity
TkQ′−Tk′Q=p<k≤q∑(q−p)spsqup+q−1
shows positivity and convergence. The integrand is O(uk/2−1) at zero and O(u(k−n)/2−2) at infinity.
The following lemma is a version of the Alexandrov-Fenchel inequalities for vk.
Lemma 3.3. Let K⊂Rn be a convex body. Then
vk(K)2≥vk−1(K)vk+1(K),1≤k<n.
Proof. For any convex body K⊂Rn, the intrinsic volumes can be written as
Vk(K)=κn−k1(kn)V(K[k],B2n[n−k]).
where V(K[k],B2n[n−k]) is the corresponding mixed volume (see, for example, [1 (A.26)]). Thus
vk(K)=κkκn−k(kn)V(K[k],B2n[n−k]).
Dividing by vk(B2n) and using V(B2n[k],B2n[n−k])=κn gives
vk(B2n)vk(K)=κnV(K[k],B2n[n−k]).
Formula (7.66) in [7] shows that this ratio is log-concave as a sequence in k. Finally observe that the sequence
is also log-concave. Indeed, this follows from the convexity of logΓ, since both arguments of Γ in the denominator are affine functions of k. Thus, the sequence vk(K) is log-concave as the product of two positive log-concave sequences.
In the next lemma, we will derive an alternative representation for vk and use it in conjunction with the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality to obtain a bound on the ratio of two consecutive intrinsic volumes of ellipsoids.
Lemma 3.4. For any ellipsoid in Rn we have
vkvk+1<sk−1sk,1≤k<n.(6)
Proof. Let λ1,…,λn>0 be the squared semiaxes, and write
The last inequality follows from (2) for the tuple λ1,…,λn with λi removed. Since s−1(i)=0 by convention, the inequality also holds for k=1. Multiplying by λi/(1+λiu) and summing over i, we obtain (8).
where we used (5), uλi2/(1+λiu)=λi−λi/(1+λiu) and ∑i=1nλisk−1(i)=ksk. After multiplication by dμ, the last expression can be written as a total derivative:
sk(QuQ′−k)2Quk/2−1du=−sk(Quk/2)′du.
Since 0<k<n, uk/2/Q vanishes at the endpoints of (0,∞). Thus, integrating the preceding equality yields (9).
The Cauchy-Schwarz inequality is strict because Hk+1dμ has positive density on (0,∞), where u is not constant. This proves (6).
All integrals above are finite. Indeed, Hj(u)=O(1) at zero and Hj(u)=O(u−1) at infinity. The density of Hk+1dμ is therefore O(uk/2−1) at zero and O(u(k−n)/2−2) at infinity. Both its total integral and its first moment converge for 1≤k<n. □
We will also need the following elementary fact about matrix invertibility.
Lemma 3.5. Let M=(Mk,j) be an m×m matrix with positive entries. Suppose
Mk−1,j−2Mk,j+Mk+1,j≥0,for 1≤k=j≤m,
where M0,j=0=Mm+1,j by convention. Then M is invertible.
Proof. Consider an m×m matrix G=(Gk,j) such that
Gk,j=2Mk,j−Mk−1,j−Mk+1,j.
By assumption, Gk,j≤0 when k=j. Also, note that
k=1∑mGk,j=M1,j+Mm,j>0
where we used that M has positive entries. This implies that
Gj,j>−k=j∑Gk,j=k=j∑∣Gk,j∣≥0.(10)
We claim that G is invertible. Indeed, assume that there is x∈Rm, x=0 such that GTx=0, and choose j such that ∣xj∣=max1≤k≤m∣xk∣=0. Then, using (10), we have
which is impossible. Thus, G is invertible. Since the rows of G are linear combinations of the rows of M, Mx=0 implies Gx=0. Thus, M is also invertible. □
Main Lemmas
Consider the space of polynomials Q(u)=1+s1u+⋯+sn−1un−1+snun with positive coefficients, where the coefficient sn is fixed. This assumption comes from the fact that we are working with ellipsoids of fixed volume. Thus, this space of polynomials can be identified with (0,∞)n−1, and we can think of vk(Q), 1≤k≤n−1, as a function of (s1,…,sn−1)∈(0,∞)n−1. The lemma below gives the derivatives of this function.
The differentiation is justified since the integrand in (12) is of order O(uk/2−1) at zero and O(u(k−n)/2−2) at infinity, where the bounds in O are locally uniform in s1,…,sn−1.
The boundary values of uj−k/2TkQ−3/2 vanish at 0 and at ∞ since j−2k>0 and j+2k−1<23n. Subtracting this total derivative from the integrand in (12) yields
which gives (11) for j≥k. Now, let j<k. We can rewrite (3) as
vk=21∫0∞u−2kQ23(Q−Tk)′Q−(Q−Tk)Q′du
where Q−Tk does not depend on sj. Performing a similar computation as in (12) and adding the total derivative 21(uj−k/2(Q−Tk)Q−3/2)′ to the integrand gives
where in the last equality the boundary terms vanish at 0 and at ∞ since 0<k<n. Thus, when j=k, either expression in (11) can be used. The coefficients of Ak and Bk are positive, so ∂sj∂vk are also positive for any 1≤k,j<n.
To the integrands in (11), we associate the normalized functions
where we used Lemma 3.3 and the identities Ak+1=Ak+Tk+1 and Ak−1=Ak−Tk. Since the first term is nonnegative and the second is strictly positive by (13),
ak−1−2ak+ak+1>0.
We now prove the assertion for bk. Without loss of generality, assume that E is centered at the origin. Consider
where C(Qt) is either AkQt or BkQt, depending on whether j≥k or j<k. In both cases, C(Qt) depends linearly on the coefficients of Qt, and so C(Qt)=(1−t)C(P)+tC(Q). Thus, we can evaluate the following integral:
For j<k, the same formula holds with bk in place of ak. When j=k, either formula is valid by Lemma 4.1.
Fix a column j, and set M0,j=Mn,j=0. If k<j, we can express each of Mk−1,j, Mk,j, and Mk+1,j using formula (17) with the corresponding functions a. Thus
by Lemma 4.2. If k>j, we use the formula with bk−1, bk, bk+1 in the same way. The conventions M0,j=Mn,j=0 agree with a0=0 and bn=0. Therefore, by Lemma 3.5 the matrix M is invertible.
Now let
Δsj=sj(Q)−sj(P).
Observe that Δsn=0 due to sn(P)=sn(Q). Since
dtdvk(Qt)=j=1∑n−1∂sj∂vk(Qt)Δsj,
integrating this identity and using (14), we obtain
0=vkvk(Q)−vk(P)=j=1∑n−1Mk,jΔsj.
Since M is invertible, the last equality implies Δsj=0 for all 1≤j≤n−1. Recall also that Δsn=0. Thus P=Q, and their roots determine the same squared semiaxes, with multiplicities. □
AI Disclaimer. ChatGPT was used in exploratory discussions and in the preparation of this manuscript.
References
S. Myroshnychenko, Department of Mathematics and Statistics, University of the Fraser Valley, Abbotsford, BC V2S 7M8, Canada Email address:[email protected]
K. Tatarko, Department of Pure Mathematics, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, ON N2L 3G1, Canada Email address:[email protected]
V. Yaskin, Department of Mathematical and Statistical Sciences, University of Alberta, Edmonton, AB T6G 2N8, Canada Email address:[email protected]
References
[1]R. J. Gardner, Geometric tomography, 2nd edition, Encyclopedia Math. Appl., 58, Cambridge University Press, 2006.DOI
[2]A. G usakova, E. Spodarev and D. Zaporozhets, Intrinsic volumes of ellipsoids, Zap. Nauchn. Sem. POMI 515 (2022), 121–140.
[3]G. H. Hardy, J. E. Littlewood, and G. Pólya, Inequalities, 2nd ed., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1952.
[4]Z. Kabluchko, D. Zaporozhets, Intrinsic volumes of Sobolev balls with applications to Brownian convex hulls, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 368 (2016), 8873–8899.arxiv.org/abs/1404.6113
[5]S. Myroshnychenko, K. Tatarko, and V. Yaskin, Unique determination of ellipsoids by their dual volumes, International Mathematics Research Notices 2022, no. 17 (2022), 13569–13589.DOI
[6]F. Petrov and A. Tarasov, Uniqueness of a three-dimensional ellipsoid with given intrinsic volumes, Arnold Mathematical Journal 6 (2020), 163–171.DOI
[7]R. Schneider, Convex Bodies: The Brunn–Minkowski Theory, second expanded edition, Cambridge University Press, 2014.