betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

A primer on the analogue black hole bomb with capillary-gravity waves

Abstract

Draining vortices with a free surface are frequently employed as rotating black hole simulators, both in theory and experiments. However, most theoretical work is restricted to the idealised regime, where wave dispersion and dissipation are neglected. We investigate the role of these effects on the analogue black hole bomb, an instability resulting from rotational superradiant amplification in confined systems. We reveal that the dispersion of deep water capillary-gravity waves significantly modifies the unstable mode eigenfrequencies, whereas viscosity only affects those with high frequencies. Furthermore, if the circulation is less than an order 1 multiple of the drain rate, superradiance does not occur and the vortex is stable. The instability is maximised in small systems with high flow velocities, provided there is sufficient space between the vortex and the outer boundary for the first excited state to lie inside the superradiant bandwidth. Implications for experiments on analogue black holes and free surface vortices are discussed.

Introduction

Draining vortices are the archetypal example of an analogue rotating black hole [1]. The basic idea is that the draining fluid speeds up as it impinges on the central outlet, and if the fluid velocity manages to surpass the speed of long wavelength excitations of the fluid, the system possess an analogue horizon. The presence of a horizon leads to the possibility of simulating Hawking radiation from a black hole [2, 3]. Extensive work on the analogue Hawking effect has been performed in one dimensional (1D) flows where the fluid accelerates linearly and the analysis is simpler. Detailed numerical [4, 5] and analytic [6–8] analyses have revealed the persistence of the effect in fluid-like systems and are supported by experimental measurements in both classical [9, 10] and quantum systems [11, 12]. These results are generally taken as an indication of the universality of the Hawking effect, that is, a robustness against modifications to the short wavelength part of the governing theory [13].

In two dimensions (2D), the analogy with black holes becomes much richer. In particular, rotating systems like the draining vortex can also possess an analogue ergosphere, the region of spacetime around a black hole where an observer would need to travel faster than the speed of light to remain at rest [14]. The existence of such a region implies the amplification of waves in a certain frequency band, i.e. rotational superradiance [15, 16], which causes an evaporating black hole to shed its angular momentum more rapidly than its mass [17, 18]. Many theoretical studies demonstrate the occurrence of analogue superradiance using a simple, shallow water model of a draining vortex [19–22]. The effect was first measured in a water tank [23] and subsequently in a (non-draining) photon superfluid [24].

Most experimental studies of the Hawking effect and superradiance to date have employed one of two types of simulator. The first involves excitations analogous to sound waves (density perturbations) in a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC), e.g. [11, 24]. The second employs a classical liquid, e.g. room temperature water, where the excitations are surface waves [9, 10, 23]. Since gravity and surface tension act as a restoring force, these are also known as capillary-gravity waves (where capillary is synonymous with surface tension). In both types of simulator, the dispersive nature of these waves complicates the analogy with black holes. In relativity, all massless particles propagate at the speed of light cc. Similarly, in fluids, it is often the case that long wavelength modes propagate at a constant (i.e. frequency independent) speed cc – the “analogue speed of light”. However, at short wavelengths, the waves probe the microscopic details of the fluid and the propagation speed becomes frequency dependent. If short wavelengths propagate slower than cc (e.g. deep water gravity waves) the theory is called sub-luminally dispersive, in analogy with relativity, whereas if they propagate faster than cc (e.g. capillary waves and Bogoliubov modes in a BEC) the theory is called super-luminally dispersive. In the case of capillary-gravity waves, the theory is a mixed type, containing a sub-luminal part at intermediate wavelengths (the deep water regime) and a super-luminal part as the wavelength goes to zero (the capillary regime). The effect of each type of dispersion relation on superradiance around a draining vortex was investigated in [25, 26]. The effect of mixed dispersion in rotating systems that superradiate has yet to be understood.

Through the analogy, many dynamical processes in supersonic fluid flows can be interpreted in terms of their black hole scattering counterparts. For instance, the Hawking effect in a trans-sonic BEC gives rise to the black hole laser instability [27–29]. The Hawking effect is also responsible for the phenomenon of the zero frequency undulation that appears when a fluid accelerates over a submerged obstacle [30]. In rotating systems, the relativistic phenomenon of rotational superradiance is analogous to the fluid mechanical notion of over-reflection in shear flows [31]. In quantum fluids, superradiance causes large vortices to decay into clusters of single vortex quanta [32–34] whilst in classical fluids, it is related to the rotating polygon instability of hollow core, free surface vortices [35].

In this work, we investigate the occurrence of another well-known black hole instability in a draining water tank: the black hole bomb (BHB) [36]. This was first studied by Press and Teukolsky [37] and involved a black hole surrounded by an idealised spherical mirror. The essence of the BHB is that waves in a certain frequency range get (superradiantly) scattered outward near the boundary of the ergosphere then get partially or completely reflected back in at some location far away from the black hole. These two reflecting locations form a cavity which can trap the waves, and specific frequencies which fit inside the cavity (by satisfying the appropriate boundary conditions) will be resonances/bound states of the system. If the resonance lies within the superradiant bandwidth, it will be unstable and grow exponentially in time. Hence, the BHB is simply a superradiant bound state which occupies a region outside the black hole’s ergosphere.

In gravity, a natural reflection mechanism arises for light massive fields, which are prevented from propagating at infinity by the effect of their own mass. This has led to intense interest on ultralight axions, which are speculated to arise in various standard model extensions [38]. These fields can form clouds around black holes through the superradiant instability, sapping rotational energy from the system and dissipating into gravitational waves. This process leads to distinct observational signatures, raising the intriguing possibility of using black holes as observatories for axions [39–42]. However, it has been argued that nonlinear interactions could saturate growth of the cloud before it manages to spin down the black hole [43]. It is therefore pertinent to develop a more thorough understanding of nonlinear effects on BHB–type instabilities. In this regard, analogue models of the BHB in fluids (which possess their own unique nonlinearities) could help shed light on the influence of nonlinearities in a general sense, and can be implemented experimentally to test predictions.

BHBs in analogue systems have already been discussed, e.g. in [21, 44]. However, these works do not take the inherent dispersion or dissipation of the fluid into account, which will be present in any real experiment. For instance, the detection of superradiance in [23] was performed using deep water gravity waves, which are strongly dispersive. Subsequent theoretical analysis [25] demonstrated that the character of superradiance (i.e. the amount of amplification and the bandwidth of amplified frequencies) can differ significantly from the simple long wavelength systems studied by many authors. Furthermore, damping (e.g. due to viscosity) could significantly alter the instability timescales or, in the most extreme cases, fully quench the instability and stabilise the system. In view of this, our goal in this work will be to assess the impact of dispersion and dissipation on the BHB instability in analogue fluid systems. Using a simplified model of a draining vortex, we will develop a calculational tool for computing unstable mode frequencies in strongly dispersive settings, laying the theoretical groundwork for future experiments.

Method

To achieve this goal, the most suitable existing theory is the deep water theory of superradiance outlined in [25]. The theory is based on a Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin (WKB) approximation, which considers wavelengths shorter than the scale over which the background varies. The method reduces a complicated wave scattering problem governed by partial differential equations (PDEs) to a far simpler algebraic equation which governs the ray trajectories through phase space. The rays are the paths traced out by a collection of points along a wavefront of short wavelength (high frequency) waves and are analogous to spacetime geodesics in relativity. Since conventional relativistic theories are second order in space and time derivatives, the solution of the linearised theory at a given frequency will be a superposition of two waves, representing the two allowed directions of propagation (in-going and out-going). Hence, in the WKB theory, there will be two rays and intersections of the rays (caustics) are the locations where the wave scatters off the inhomogeneous background medium. Similarly, the long wavelength (or shallow water) limit of linear fluid dynamics is second order in space and time derivatives and the two solutions correspond to the in/out-going waves in the regions where the flow velocity is weak. For shorter wavelengths, however (which is the natural regime for WKB techniques), higher order spatial derivatives in the linear fluid equations become important and the general solution becomes a superposition of more than two waves. Correspondingly, the WKB theory contains more than two rays. One then has to consider all possible intersections between neighbouring rays to fully understand the scattering of waves off the inhomogeneous background. This was the approach taken in [25] (and subsequently [33, 45]) which introduced a method of schematically sketching the interactions between different rays to facilitate the computation of scattering coefficients. These scattering diagrams will be the principle tool used in this work as we attempt to understand the dispersive BHB around a draining vortex.

However, the deep water theory in [25] contains unphysical negative energy modes (with divergent wavenumber kk) asymptotically far from the vortex core and is therefore not suitable for an analysis of the BHB, which is dependent on the nature of reflections at the outer boundary. These unphysical modes arise when the (sub-luminal) deep water theory is applied beyond its regime of validity. Surface tension regulates the theory by making it super-luminal at large kk, so that in the weak field (i.e. slow flow) limit there are only two propagating modes outside the vortex corresponding to the usual in/out-going ones. It is these modes which get reflected at the (mirror) boundary and give rise to the BHB. Therefore, the primary aim of this work will be to establish the WKB theory of capillary-gravity waves around a draining vortex, and derive all the allowed scattering diagrams. Using the diagrams, we will identify the necessary conditions for superradiant amplification then apply these to the calculation of oscillation frequencies and growth rates of the BHB modes.

Outline and summary of results

In Section II, we start by reviewing the equations of fluid mechanics in the context of the draining vortex, before deriving the equations of motion for capillary-gravity waves. Then in Section III, we apply the WKB method to these equations and introduce the necessary concepts to study the scattering of rays in the inhomogeneous draining vortex background. Next, we illustrate how the framework can be applied to the simpler case of shallow water waves in Section IV. In this regime, the equations of motion can be cast in terms of an effective rotating black hole metric, allowing us to identify the superradiant instability as a BHB instability. The main result is that the oscillation frequency ωn\omega_n is determined by a resonance condition of the form,

Re⁡[Spath(ωn)]=π(2n+12),(1)\operatorname{Re}[S_{\mathrm{path}}(\omega_n)] = \pi\left(2n+\frac{1}{2}\right), \tag*{(1)}

where SpathS_{\mathrm{path}} is the phase integral for the radial part of the mode (which has to be evaluated numerically) along a trapped path consisting of a pair of rays, and n=0,1,…n = 0, 1, \ldots indexes the different possible bound states. We find an expression for the growth rate Γn\Gamma_n which has the intuitive interpretation that the exponential growth of the mode is equal to the amount of superradiant amplification i.e.

eΓnTpath(ωn)=∣R(ωn)∣,(2)e^{\Gamma_n T_{\mathrm{path}}(\omega_n)} = \lvert R(\omega_n)\rvert, \tag*{(2)}

where TpathT_{\mathrm{path}} is the time elapsed along the rays in the trapping region, and ∣R∣\lvert R\rvert is the magnitude of the reflection coefficient characterising the scattering of an in-going ray with the inhomogeneous draining vortex flow. When rotational superradiance occurs, we have ∣R∣>1\lvert R\rvert> 1 (i.e. amplification) and can immediately see that Γn>0\Gamma_n > 0 so that the eigenmode is unstable. Since the destabilising mechanism is superradiant scattering, we identify these modes as the BHB modes. We calculate the complex eigenfrequencies ωnC=ωn+iΓn\omega_n^{\mathrm{C}} = \omega_n + i\Gamma_n of the BHB modes for a range of parameters, comparing our WKB predictions with exact numerical calculations and finding excellent agreement. We then identify the key features of the instability, allowing us to generalise the BHB to the dispersive regime. In Section V, we analyse the scattering of capillary-gravity waves with the draining vortex, identifying all

possible scattering diagrams in the same vein as [25]. From the diagrams, we infer a condition for superradiant amplification of the form,

0<ω<ω∗,(3)0 < \omega< \omega_*, \tag*{(3)}

where ω∗\omega_* is a characteristic location on the dispersion relation (to be discussed in detail). We find in Figure 12 that this band opens at a critical rotation, hence, is a minimum required speed of rotation for superradiance to occur. With this information, we obtain a condition for the existence of BHB modes in the system, accounting for both the dispersion and dissipation of the fluid. The oscillation frequency is determined by a resonance condition which has the same form as the shallow water formula (1). Intuitively, one would expect the formula (2) for the growth rate to be modified by the amount of amplification on the right-hand side becoming suppressed. This can happen in two ways: firstly, amplification can be weakened by dissipation and secondly, scattering with the extra dispersive modes can lead to energy escaping the trapping region. We find that this expectation is indeed correct and that Γn\Gamma_n is governed by the relation,

Figure 12. The critical rotation is shown as a function of the dimensionless surface tension parameter. Superradiance cannot occur for rotations slower than this since modes propagating on ωD+\omega_D^{+} at infinity do not reach ωD−\omega_D^{-} in the vortex core.

eΓnTpath(ωn)=e−νRe⁡[Spath(ωn)]∏a∣Xa(ωn)∣,(4)e^{\Gamma_n T_{\mathrm{path}}(\omega_n)} = e^{-\nu\operatorname{Re}[S_{\mathrm{path}}(\omega_n)]}\prod_a \lvert X_a(\omega_n)\rvert, \tag*{(4)}

where the XaX_a are the different scattering coefficients along the trapped path consisting of a pair of two or more rays, and νΣpath\nu\Sigma_{\mathrm{path}} is the integral of the damping factor over the trapping region. The different terms in this expression will be explained in detail in the main text and the origin of the formula in Appendix F. We then calculate ωnC=ωn+iΓn\omega_n^{\mathrm{C}} = \omega_n + i\Gamma_n for some exemplary system parameters, finding in Figure 15 that generally instability is strongest in small systems (i.e. when the encircling mirror has a small radius) when the rotation speed is large and the drain is near the maximum allowed value that permits a trapping region outside the vortex. We conclude in Section VII by discussing future directions for our work.

Maximum growth rate in the $m=1$ mode as a function of $D$ and $C/D$ for various boundary locations

Figure 15. Maximum growth rate in the m=1m=1 mode as a function of DD and C/DC/D for various boundary locations. The color axis gives max⁡(Γn)\max(\Gamma_n) in s−1^{-1} on a logarithmic scale, with the lighter shade indicating a stronger instability. Hence, the dominant mode grows on a timescale which is between one and tens of seconds over the range of parameters probed. The striped curves in the colour scale result from the dominance of different nn, with n=0n=0 being the strongest in the top right corner. Black indicates that no BHB instability is found. The red dashed line is the location at which the trapping region outside the vortex closes up. The effect of viscosity is included in the growth rates. When viscosity is neglected (not shown) the plots become slightly brighter at low DD since the strongest instabilities there occur at higher frequency which are attenuated by viscosity (see panels (c2,c3) of Figure 14). The area of the plot where the ergosphere lies in a region of no water is delineated by a black dashed line, such that the plots only have meaning to its left. The line is plotted for h0=12h_0=12cm and moves to the right as h0h_0 increases.

The system

In this section, we present the stationary background flow for our draining vortex before deriving a set of linearised equations governing small amplitude capillary-gravity waves. The key equations are the draining vortex flow profile (11), the linear equations of motion (19) and statement of norm conservation in (30).

Basic equations

We consider a cylindrical tank of water with a hole of radius r=dr = d in the centre of the plane at z=0z = 0. Water drains toward the centre and is resupplied at the edge r=rBr = r_B of the cylindrical tank. The fluid has a free surface located at z=h(x,y)z=h(x,y). A schematic of the set-up is depicted on Figure 1.

Schematic illustration of the analogue black hole bomb set-up

Figure 1. A schematic illustration of our set-up. We display only a cross section in the (r,z)(r,z)–plane. There is a hard wall boundary situated at r=rBr=r_B. Water enters through a cylindrical inlet at the bottom of the container near the outer wall, then moves inward with velocity vr(r)v_r(r) and exits through a hole of radius dd in the centre. The velocity field also has a component in θ\theta–direction, not shown. The surface is given by the function h(r)h(r). In this work, we consider the dynamics of surface waves, also schematically depicted.

The incompressible Navier-Stokes equations in three spatial dimensions are,

(∂t+v⋅∇)v−ν∇2v=−∇Pρ+g,(5)(\partial_t+\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla)\mathbf{v}-\nu\nabla^2\mathbf{v}=-\frac{\nabla P}{\rho}+\mathbf{g}, \tag*{(5)}

where v\mathbf{v} is the fluid velocity, PP is the pressure and (for water) the density ρ≃997kg m−3\rho\simeq997\mathrm{kg\,m^{-3}} (which is taken to be constant at room temperature) and the kinematic viscosity ν≃8.93×10−7m2 s−1\nu\simeq8.93\times10^{-7}\mathrm{m^2\,s^{-1}}. The acceleration due to gravity is g=−ge^z\mathbf{g}=-g\hat{\mathbf{e}}_z (with g≃9.81m s−2g\simeq9.81\mathrm{m\,s^{-2}} at the surface of the earth) and we assume no other external forces. Since the fluid is incompressible, the velocity field satisfies,

∇⋅v=0.(6)\nabla\cdot\mathbf{v}=0. \tag*{(6)}

We further assume an irrotational fluid satisfying,

∇×v=0⇒v=∇Φ,(7)\nabla\times\mathbf{v}=0\quad\Rightarrow\quad\mathbf{v}=\nabla\Phi, \tag*{(7)}

where Φ\Phi is the velocity potential. Under these conditions, (5) and (6) can be reformulated as the Bernoulli and Laplace equations,

∂tΦ+12v2+Pρ+gz=const,∇2Φ=0,(8)\partial_t\Phi+\frac{1}{2}\mathbf{v}^2+\frac{P}{\rho}+gz=\mathrm{const},\qquad\nabla^2\Phi=0, \tag*{(8)}

where the relation ∇2v=∇(∇⋅v)−∇×∇×v\nabla^2\mathbf{v}=\nabla(\nabla\cdot\mathbf{v})-\nabla\times\nabla\times\mathbf{v} has been used to drop the term proportional to ν\nu and v⋅∇v=12∇(v2)−v×∇×v\mathbf{v}\cdot\nabla\mathbf{v}=\frac{1}{2}\nabla(\mathbf{v}^2)-\mathbf{v}\times\nabla\times\mathbf{v} to re-express the advective term.

The boundary condition at the free surface is [46, 47],

P(z=h)=Pa−σ∇∥⋅(∇∥h1+∣∇∥h∣2)+2ρν∂z2Φ(9)P(z=h)=P_a-\sigma\nabla_{\parallel}\cdot\left(\frac{\nabla_{\parallel}h}{\sqrt{1+|\nabla_{\parallel}h|^2}}\right)+2\rho\nu\partial_z^2\Phi \tag*{(9)}

where PaP_a is atmospheric pressure which we take to be zero, ∇∥\nabla_{\parallel} is the gradient operator parallel to the (x,y)(x,y) plane and σ≃7.2×10−2kg s−2\sigma\simeq7.2\times10^{-2}\mathrm{kg\,s^{-2}} is the surface tension. The second term on the right results from the curvature of the free surface and the final term encodes viscous friction within the fluid. Bernoulli’s equation at the free surface is then,

[∂tΦ+12v∥2+12vz2+gh−2ν∇∥2Φ−σρ∇∥⋅(∇∥h1+∣∇∥h∣2)]z=h=0,(10)\left[\partial_t\Phi+\frac{1}{2}\mathbf{v}_{\parallel}^2+\frac{1}{2}v_z^2+gh-2\nu\nabla_{\parallel}^2\Phi-\frac{\sigma}{\rho}\nabla_{\parallel}\cdot\left(\frac{\nabla_{\parallel}h}{\sqrt{1+|\nabla_{\parallel}h|^2}}\right)\right]_{z=h}=0, \tag*{(10)}

whilst Bernoulli’s equation in the bulk simply gives an expression for the pressure. Note, the assumption that the fluid motion is irrotational means that the boundary condition on the tangential stress has been dropped. This leads to an underestimation of dissipation since we are not accounting for losses into the rotational degrees of freedom in the fluid. A more thorough treatment for 1D deep water waves in a weakly viscous fluid leads to the replacement ν→2ν\nu\to2\nu in the results, e.g. [48]. Since we are only concerned with the generic effect of dissipation, we do not consider such losses here.

If the basic flow is assumed stationary and axisymmetric, it is natural to work in polar coordinates (r,θ)(r,\theta). In the region where the fluid height is approximately uniform, the basic flow is given by,

v=−Dre^r+Cre^θ,h≃h0=const,(11)\mathbf{v}=-\frac{D}{r}\hat{\mathbf{e}}_r+\frac{C}{r}\hat{\mathbf{e}}_\theta,\qquad h\simeq h_0=\mathrm{const}, \tag*{(11)}

which is valid in the region r≫ra≡(C2+D2)/(2gh0)r\gg r_a\equiv\sqrt{(C^2+D^2)/(2gh_0)}. We refer the reader to Appendix A for a thorough discussion of the approximations that lead to (11). Even working with these simplified profiles, solving the scattering problem over the full parameter space is a challenging task, especially with the inclusion of dispersive effects. Hence, order of magnitude estimates for the various parameters will be useful when it comes to computing bound state frequencies. We assume that dd and rBr_B are respectively on the order of centimeters and tens of centimeters. To get an estimate of the flow parameters achievable in such a set-up, we assume that (in practice) rar_a will be some significant fraction of the radius of the drain hole radius, say ra∼O(d)r_a\sim\mathcal{O}(d). Assuming h0h_0 in the range of millimeters to tens of centimeters, we find that CC and DD should roughly lie in the range 1010–100cm2 s−1100\mathrm{cm^2\,s^{-1}}, in accord with experimental realisations [23, 49].

Linear equations

To study perturbations of the basic flow, we work in the approximation that gradients of the free surface can be neglected, i.e. h′≃0h'\simeq0. This approximation is valid suitably far from the vortex axis, i.e. r≫rar\gg r_a. We now perturb the fluid variables as,

Φ→Φ+ϕ,h→h+η,(12)\Phi\to\Phi+\phi,\qquad h\to h+\eta, \tag*{(12)}

where ϕ\phi and η\eta are the velocity potential and height perturbations respectively. (10) gives the first equation,

(∂t+v∥⋅∇∥)ϕ+gη−σρ∇∥2η−2ν∇∥2ϕ∣z=h=0.(13)\left(\partial_t+\mathbf{v}_{\parallel}\cdot\nabla_{\parallel}\right)\phi+g\eta-\frac{\sigma}{\rho}\nabla_{\parallel}^{2}\eta-2\nu\nabla_{\parallel}^{2}\phi\big|_{z=h}=0. \tag*{(13)}

The second is obtained by solving Laplace’s equation ∇2ϕ=0\nabla^2\phi=0 in the bulk. In the region r>dr>d, we can write a solution in terms of Fourier modes,

References

  1. [59]Note that for vertices connected by more than one line (or not connected) the relative locations of the r_{tp} are not necessarily captured by the diagrams. In other words, the diagrams can be deformed within the same classification provided: 1) vertices are neither created nor destroyed, 2) the direction (right or left) of the arrows is unaltered and 3) the ordering of propagating modes from top to bottom is respected. For example, the turning point between the p^{±} modes on the Type II scattering schematic in Fig. 9 is not necessarily at larger r compared to the turning point involving the p^{u,t} modes (as can be seen by comparing with panel (c) of Fig. 10).
  2. [60]S. R. Dolan, Phys. Rev. D 87, 124026 (2013).
  3. [61]H. Yoshino and H. Kodama, Prog. Theor. Phys. 128, 153 (2012).
  4. [62]S. Mulligan, G. De Cesare, J. Casserly, and R. Sherlock, Sci. Rep. 8, 824 (2018).
  5. [63]A. Andersen, T. Bohr, B. Stenum, J. J. Rasmussen, and B. Lautrup, Journal of Fluid Mechanics 556, 121 (2006).
  6. [64]S. Yukimoto, H. Niino, T. Noguchi, R. Kimura, and F. Y. Moulin, Theoretical and Computational Fluid Dynamics 24, 323 (2010).
  7. [65]A. J. Odgaard, Journal of Hydraulic Engineering 112, 610 (1986).
  8. [66]J. E. Hite Jr and W. C. Mih, Journal of Hydraulic Engineering 120, 284 (1994).
  9. [67]S. Mulligan, J. Casserly, and R. Sherlock, J. Hydraul. Eng. 142, 04016051 (2016).
  10. [68]J. Mizushima, K. Abe, and N. Yokoyama, Phys. Rev. E 90, 041002 (2014).
  11. [69]Q. Zhou and W. P. Graebel, J. Fluid Mech. 221, 511 (1990).
  12. [70]V. A. Vladimirov, L. Y. Rybak, and V. F. Tarasov, J. Appl. Mech. Tech. Phys. 24, 337 (1983).
  13. [71]F. Gallaire and J. M. Chomaz, Phys. Fluids 15, 2622 (2003).

Paper details

vlnc:W_yszyxcxq
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents