betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

A marked tensor obstruction to four-dimensional disk embedding

Abstract

We disprove the unrestricted four-dimensional disk-embedding conjecture. We construct immersed disks in a compact oriented smooth four-manifold with framed algebraic dual spheres satisfying the usual equivariant intersection and reduced self-intersection conditions, but with no pairwise disjoint locally flat replacements that preserve the boundary maps and induced normal framings. The obstruction holds even when the replacement disks' relative homotopy classes are not prescribed.

Introduction

The disk-embedding problem asks when immersed disks in a four-manifold can be replaced by disjoint locally flat embedded disks with the same boundary data. Its role in four-dimensional topological surgery is to turn algebraic cancellation data into embedded disks. In dimension four, the auxiliary disks used to carry out cancellations can themselves intersect the original surfaces and one another. Dual spheres provide additional control. An algebraic dual records one intersection with its designated disk and zero with the others, counted with signs and fundamental-group labels; a geometric dual realizes these counts by meeting its designated disk once transversely and missing the other disks.

Casson’s construction replaces the finite task of removing intersections by an infinite tower of immersed disks. Freedman’s recognition theorem identifies the resulting Casson handle, relative to its attaching region, with the standard open topological two-handle. Together these results established the simply connected foundation of disk embedding [8] (Introduction and Theorem 1.1). Freedman and Quinn developed the capped-grope version of this method and organized the disk theorem and its surgery and cobordism applications [9] (Theorem 5.1A and Chapter 11). The group restriction enters through the double-point loops of the caps: their null-homotopies supply further stages of the construction. The class of good groups is defined by the availability of the required π1\pi_1-null disk operations [15] (Definition 3.2). Freedman and Teichner proved that groups of subexponential growth are good [10] (Theorem 0.1). Krushkal and Quinn supplied another proof [13] (Theorem, p. 408). Their paper also contains Freedman and Teichner’s correction of the earlier height-raising argument [13] (Appendix, pp. 424–430).

The modern formulation of Powell, Ray, and Teichner supplies framed geometric dual spheres as well as embedded disks, and preserves the homotopy classes of the input dual spheres [15] (Theorem A). Their modification supplies the geometric-dual step missing from the earlier argument; the disk conclusion without these output spheres was already proved [15] (Remark 1.3). For generally immersed input disks, their theorem preserves the induced boundary normal framings without prescribing relative homotopy classes for the replacement disks. The *unrestricted disk-embedding conjecture considered here is the extension of that theorem obtained by removing only the good-group hypothesis. It would in particular give framed disk replacements for compact oriented smooth input manifolds, even after the output-dual requirement is discarded. We resolve this geometric conjecture negatively by obstructing that disk conclusion.

We use the following intersection conventions in stating the result. After choosing basepoints and whiskers, λ\lambda denotes the equivariant intersection pairing with values in Z[π1M]\mathbb{Z}[\pi_1 M]. For an oriented four-manifold MM, the reduced self-intersection invariant μ~\widetilde{\mu} takes values in the additive quotient

Z[π1M]/⟨h−h−1 (h∈π1M), Z⋅1⟩.\mathbb{Z}[\pi_1 M]/\langle h-h^{-1}\ (h\in\pi_1 M),\ \mathbb{Z}\cdot1\rangle.

A framed immersed sphere has a trivialized normal bundle. A boundary normal framing is the framing induced by the normal bundle of the specified immersed disk.

Theorem 1.1. There exist a compact connected oriented smooth four-manifold MM with boundary, an integer k≥1k \ge1, generically immersed proper disks

f1,…,fk:(D2,S1)⟶(M,∂M)f_1,\ldots,f_k:(D^2,S^1)\longrightarrow(M,\partial M)

with disjoint embedded boundary circles, and generically immersed framed spheres g1,…,gk:S2⟶Mg_1,\ldots,g_k:S^2\longrightarrow M, such that

λ(fi,gj)=δij,λ(gi,gj)=0for all i,j,μ~(gi)=0for all i,\lambda(f_i,g_j)=\delta_{ij},\qquad\lambda(g_i,g_j)=0\quad\text{for all }i,j,\qquad\widetilde{\mu}(g_i)=0\quad\text{for all }i,

but there are no pairwise disjoint locally flat embedded disks in MM with the same boundary maps and the boundary normal framings induced by the fif_i.

The diagonal intersection equations are part of the statement. The conclusion of Theorem 1.1 requires no homotopy constraint on a hypothetical replacement disk. The markings used in the proof specify based curves and their paths in the fixed construction; they impose no further condition on hypothetical replacement disks. The result concerns geometric disk replacement. The relation to independently formulated surgery assertions is discussed after the proof in Section 7.

Idea of the proof

We first construct a fixed immersed disk problem in the exterior of a finite collection of capped gropes. A capped grope here is a surface tree with disks attached at its terminal curves; its boundary records an iterated commutator in the terminal curves. The construction installs finitely many such commutator relations, with independently chosen based conjugations, in a smooth plumbing model. It also supplies the algebraic dual spheres required in Theorem 1.1. These data are fixed before any hypothetical embedded replacements are chosen.

Suppose this particular disk problem has replacements with the required boundary maps and framings. They allow the plumbing model to be cut into two vertex pieces AA, BB, joined by compact three-manifolds Y1,…,Y2mY_1,\ldots,Y_{2m} with torus boundary, for an integer m≥5m\ge5 chosen in the construction. The cuts are smooth and miss the locally flat disks. The installed boundary words are now relations in the vertex groups, and restriction in cohomology gives complementary linear data on the two sides. Proposition 2.2 records this marked geometry; Lemma 2.4 verifies the equivariant disk-and-sphere input.

For each edge YiY_i, we study based flat SL2SL_2-connections with one torus holonomy fixed. Basing records holonomy as a matrix, with no quotient by simultaneous conjugation. A potential is a function in finitely many formal coordinates whose gradient equations describe these flat connections.

The central potential fixes this torus holonomy to the identity. Proposition 4.5 constructs it from the Chern–Simons functional, including a first-order variation of the fixed boundary holonomy. Theorem 5.1 then replaces the central potential by an algebraic function through a formal coordinate change. The comparison preserves based holonomy on the full critical scheme: its coordinate ring is the power-series ring modulo the actual gradient ideal, with its nilpotent elements retained. The geometric reduction selects mm edges for the first-order boundary variations; we call these edges active.

The two vertex pieces determine formal graphs in the product of the edge coordinate spaces. Their central tangent spaces are complementary, and suitable sums of the edge potentials vanish identically on the graphs. The boundary relations imply more than vanishing at common critical points: products associated to every three distinct active edges belong to the restricted gradient ideals. On one side these products are titjtkt_i t_j t_k, where each ti2=0t_i^2 = 0 and mixed products remain in the parameter ring. On the other they are products of three algebraic holonomy functions. Proposition 6.1 establishes the exact vanishing and ideal memberships. The graph parametrizations may mix all edge coordinates, while each fixed potential depends only on its own edge block.

Theorem 3.1 rules out precisely these algebraic data when at least five edges are active. Artin approximation and finite specialization first reduce them to large positive characteristic. Truncating each internal coordinate by its characteristic power makes the associated Koszul complexes finite. The two transverse graphs determine classes with nonzero pairing. The target triple relations, together with ordinary exterior differentiation, decompose one class into tensors admitting three independent first-order parameter lifts. The source triple relations force each resulting pairing to vanish, giving the contradiction.

Three features are useful beyond the final contradiction. First, the geometry imposes a finite family of independently conjugated laws before the cuts are chosen. Second, the algebraicity argument compares full relative closed shifted forms and preserves the marked holonomies; an algebraic model of the reduced representation locus would be insufficient. Third, the tensor argument uses actual gradient ideals over nonreduced parameter rings and makes no isolated-critical-point or regular-sequence assumption.

The geometric and algebraic antecedents

Capped-grope contraction and transverse grope constructions provide the local geometric operations [13], §§1.2 and 1.4. Their use to relate surface intersections and commutator words also appears in the work of Freedman and Krushkal. Using the repeated-variable 2-Engel relation, they constructed homotopy solutions to the A–B slice problem and new universal surgery models [6], Theorems 1 and 2; their later work established universality for half-π1\pi_1-null surgery models, with a capped grope on one side and a π1\pi_1-null sphere on the other [7], Theorem 1 and Section 3. These results concern particular surgery or slicing formulations, with their own embedding and complement conditions. They explain the value of commutator calculus in this setting without supplying the marked geometric reduction used here.

Our relations use three distinct group inputs and become trivial when any one is the identity. Their logarithmic expansion begins with the trilinear bracket [Z1,[Z2,Z3]][Z_1,[Z_2,Z_3]], where ZaZ_a is the logarithm of the aa-th input. The deletion property is the Brunnian property defined in Section 2. We install a finite family of such words with independently chosen conjugations, before knowing the cut pieces. The later argument uses those independent choices to recover every triple coefficient. It neither imposes a universal Engel relation nor requires the vertex groups to be nilpotent. The simultaneous placement, framing, and algebraic-dual calculations needed for this finite family are given in Section 2.

The deformation-theoretic part has a different origin. Goldman and Millson describe Artin-algebra families of flat connections by differential graded Lie algebras and identify their based holonomies with representation deformations [12] (Corollary 6.4 and Proposition 6.6). Their quadraticity results use additional formality hypotheses in the compact Kähler setting. The edge manifolds here are arbitrary compact three-manifolds, so higher deformation terms remain. Chern and Simons constructed the classical transgression form whose exterior derivative is the corresponding curvature characteristic form [4] (Section 3, especially Proposition 3.2). Section 4 uses this form to construct the potential, computes its boundary adjustment, and proves equality of its full curvature and gradient ideals.

The algebraic model comes from shifted symplectic geometry. The Betti transgression theorem of Pantev, Toën, Vaquié, and Vezzosi produces shifted symplectic forms on local-system stacks; their Lagrangian intersection theorem lowers the shift by one [14] (Theorems 2.5 and 2.9). Calaque’s relative orientation construction supplies the Lagrangian restriction map associated to an oriented manifold with boundary [3] (Theorem 2.9 and §3.1). After a punctured filling of the edge, these results put us in the setting of Brav, Bussi, and Joyce’s algebraic Darboux theorem in shift −1, which supplies an algebraic critical chart [2] (Example 5.15 and Theorem 5.18(i)).

To use that chart, we must identify its full relative closed form with the form underlying the particular Chern–Simons potential already constructed. Proposition 5.2, proved in Appendix A, carries out this comparison on derived coefficients and source cochain models. Its inputs include Getzler’s simplicial Maurer–Cartan comparison for nilpotent Lie algebras [11] (Theorem 5.4 and Corollary 5.11) and the simplicial de Rham contraction of Dupont [5]. Section 5 then turns the closed-form comparison into a coordinate change fixing the critical scheme and its based holonomies. Only after this step, and the polynomial replacement of the holonomy logarithms, do we apply ordinary Artin approximation [1] (Theorem 1.10). The approximation is applied to the final graph equations with their fixed, separately algebraic edge functions.

Conventions and organization

We assume familiarity with basic four-manifold topology, cohomology with local coefficients, and formal deformation theory. The algebraicity argument additionally uses derived mapping stacks and shifted symplectic forms; its required comparison is stated in the body and proved in full in Appendix A.

All manifolds and maps in the initial model are smooth, with corners rounded when necessary. Hypothetical output disks are only locally flat. The subsequent cuts are smooth hypersurfaces in the original smooth manifold and miss those disks. Thus the vertex and edge calculations use ordinary smooth forms and Stokes’ theorem.

Unless a field is specified, cohomology has characteristic-zero coefficients. We use g=sl2(C)\mathfrak{g}=\mathfrak{sl}_{2}(\mathbb{C}) and the pairing κ(X,Y)=tr⁡(XY)\kappa(X,Y)=\operatorname{tr}(XY). Connections and coordinate changes are formal power series, coefficient by coefficient. A statement about an ideal is a statement in the complete coordinate ring, including its nilpotents. In Sections 4–6, dd denotes the differential on source forms and δ\delta differentiation in formal coordinates. In the tensor argument of Section 3, dd is the coordinate de Rham differential and δ\delta its induced operator on Koszul homology. We specify total signs when using both differentials.

Section 2 proves the geometric reduction. Section 3 states and proves the finite obstruction before we construct its inputs, making the target algebraic interface explicit. Sections 4 and 5 construct the edge germs and their algebraic models. Section 6 constructs the vertex graphs and checks every hypothesis of the tensor obstruction. Section 7 completes the proof of Theorem 1.1.

The geometric reduction

We use the disk assertion only to compress a finite collection of surfaces. The following restricted version of its disk conclusion is therefore sufficient. All manifolds in the constructions before that application are smooth and oriented; corners are rounded when necessary. The output will be a fixed disk problem with algebraic duals, together with a description of the cut manifolds that its hypothetical embedded solutions would produce. The marked boundary words and their based paths are chosen as part of the initial disk problem.

Assumption 2.1 (Universal framed disk replacement). Let MM be a compact connected oriented smooth four-manifold with boundary. Suppose that a finite collection of proper generic immersions

fi ⁣:(D2,S1)⟶(M,∂M),1≤i≤k,f_i \colon(D^2,S^1) \longrightarrow(M,\partial M), \qquad1 \leq i \leq k,

has pairwise disjoint embedded boundary circles, and admits generically immersed framed spheres g1,…,gkg_1,\ldots,g_k such that

λ(fi,gj)=δij,λ(gi,gj)=0,μ~(gi)=0for all i,j.\lambda(f_i,g_j)=\delta_{ij}, \qquad\lambda(g_i,g_j)=0, \qquad\widetilde{\mu}(g_i)=0 \qquad\text{for all } i,j.

Here intersections are counted in Z[π1M]\mathbb{Z}[\pi_1M], with fixed whiskers, the diagonal equations are included, and

μ~(gi)∈Z[π1M]/⟨h−h−1,Z⋅1⟩\widetilde{\mu}(g_i)\in\mathbb{Z}[\pi_1M]/\langle h-h^{-1},\mathbb{Z}\cdot1\rangle

uses the additive quotient. Then the fif_i can be replaced by pairwise disjoint locally flat embedded disks with the same boundary maps and the same induced normal framings on those boundary circles.

No relative homotopy class for the replacement disks is prescribed in Assumption 2.1. Nor does it require output dual spheres. The unrestricted version of [15] would imply this assumption, including its framing clause. We will contradict the assumption itself. The capped-surface contractions used below are the usual one-sided contractions; see [13] and [15]. The relation between grope trees and commutator words is also used in [6, 7]. We give the particular finite construction needed here.

A finite list of relations

Our commutator convention is [a,b]=aba−1b−1[a,b]=aba^{-1}b^{-1}. A word RR in three free generators X1,X2,X3X_1,X_2,X_3 will be called a three-slot grope word if it is the boundary word of the rooted surface tree consisting of a punctured torus with a single tip on its first branch and a second punctured torus on its other branch. Paths to its three tips are part of its marking. Changing those paths inside the body can conjugate a tip by words in the three based tips, and can conjugate the inner commutator by such a word. Overall conjugation of the boundary word is irrelevant to its being a relation. In particular,

R∣Xa=1=1(a=1,2,3),R≡[X1,[X2,X3]](modΓ4F(X1,X2,X3)).(1)R\big|_{X_a=1}=1 \quad(a=1,2,3), \qquad R \equiv[X_1,[X_2,X_3]] \pmod{\Gamma_4F(X_1,X_2,X_3)}. \tag*{(1)}

Here ΓrF\Gamma_rF denotes the lower central series of the free group FF. The first property is the Brunnian property in the three slots: setting any one input equal to the identity trivializes the word. The orientations of the two surfaces can be fixed to give the displayed sign. Indeed a tip conjugation changes its image modulo Γ2\Gamma_2 by zero, and hence changes this weight-three commutator only modulo Γ4\Gamma_4. The first assertion follows directly by deleting a branch of the rooted tree. Equivalently, in the completed free associative algebra over Q\mathbb{Q},

log⁡R(eZ1,eZ2,eZ3)=[Z1,[Z2,Z3]]+terms of total degree at least four;\log R(e^{Z_1},e^{Z_2},e^{Z_3})=[Z_1,[Z_2,Z_3]]+\text{terms of total degree at least four};

each term contains a letter from every slot. These two properties, rather than a claim that an entire vertex group is nilpotent, will be used.

Fix m≥5m \ge5 and p≥9p \ge9. Each plumbing block will have 2m2m solid-torus boundary regions, called ports, through which it joins other blocks. Removing these regions leaves 2m2m boundary tori. Write x1,…,x2mx_1,\ldots,x_{2m} for their meridians and ℓ1,…,ℓp\ell_1,\ldots,\ell_p for the extra one-handle generators, and put

C={1,ℓ1,…,ℓp}.\mathcal{C} = \{1,\ell_1,\ldots,\ell_p\}.

Before making any cut, install one marked grope body for every ordered triple of distinct port indices, every independent choice c1,c2,c3∈Cc_1,c_2,c_3 \in\mathcal{C}, and every independent choice δ1,δ2,δ3∈{1,−1}\delta_1,\delta_2,\delta_3 \in\{1,-1\}. Its three based tips represent

Xa=caxraδaca−1,a=1,2,3.X_a = c_a x_{r_a}^{\delta_a} c_a^{-1}, \qquad a=1,2,3.

There are at most

8(2m)(2m−1)(2m−2)(p+1)38(2m)(2m-1)(2m-2)(p+1)^3

such bodies. Any additional fixed finite list of words in the extra letters could be included in C\mathcal{C} by the same construction. In particular, neither the list of bodies nor their markings depends on the slopes selected by the cuts below.

Proposition 2.2 (Geometric reduction). For the integers mm, pp and the finite list just specified, there is a compact connected oriented smooth four-manifold XX, constructed without Assumption 2.1, with the following properties.

It has a regular cover with deck group FmF_m, whose block graph is the Cayley tree of FmF_m. Each block is a four-dimensional one-handlebody on the pp extra letters. Its exposed boundary piece is

Kv≅(#p(S1×S2))∖int⁡ν(L2m),K_v \cong\left(\#^p(S^1 \times S^2)\right) \setminus\operatorname{int}\nu(L_{2m}),

where L2mL_{2m} is a 2m2m-component unlink in a ball. The port meridians and the extra letters freely generate π1Kv\pi_1 K_v. At every join, the meridian on one side is the longitude on the other. There is a finite family of framed grope bodies with boundary in these pieces, equivariant in the cover, realizing the list (2.3).

If Assumption 2.1 holds, there are equivariant cuts, with compact quotient, having connected vertex pieces VvV_v and connected edge three-manifolds YeY_e. Each YeY_e has as its entire boundary the prescribed join torus. Every corresponding three-slot grope word is trivial in π1Vv\pi_1 V_v.

In the index-two parity quotient, these cuts give two connected vertex pieces AA, BB and 2m2m connected oriented edge pieces Y1,…,Y2mY_1,\ldots,Y_{2m}. Their ambient manifold X2X_2 is homotopy equivalent to the graph with two vertices and 2m2m edges, with pp additional circles at each vertex. For any characteristic-zero field kk, difference of restrictions gives

H2(A;k)⊕H2(B;k)→≅⨁i=12mH2(Yi;k).H^2(A;k) \oplus H^2(B;k) \xrightarrow{\cong} \bigoplus_{i=1}^{2m} H^2(Y_i;k).

In degree one it is surjective, and restricts to an isomorphism on the kernel of evaluation on the pp extra loops at each vertex.

References

  1. [1]Michael Artin. Algebraic approximation of structures over complete local rings. Publications Mathématiques de l’IHÉS, 36:23–58, 1969. DOI.DOI
  2. [2]Christopher Brav, Vittoria Bussi, and Dominic Joyce. A Darboux theorem for derived schemes with shifted symplectic structure. Journal of the American Mathematical Society, 32(2):399–443, 2019. DOI. Theorem and Example locators refer to arXiv:1305.6302v4.
  3. [3]Damien Calaque. Lagrangian structures on mapping stacks and semi-classical TFTs. In Tony Pantev, Carlos Simpson, Bertrand Toën, Michel Vaquié, and Gabriele Vezzosi, editors, Stacks and Categories in Geometry, Topology, and Algebra, volume 643 of Contemporary Mathematics, pages 1–23. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2015. Theorem and Definition locators refer to arXiv:1306.3235v2.DOI
  4. [4]Shiing-Shen Chern and James Simons. Characteristic forms and geometric invariants. Annals of Mathematics. Second Series, 99(1):48–69, 1974.
  5. [5]Johan L. Dupont. Simplicial de Rham cohomology and characteristic classes of flat bundles. Topology, 15(3):233–245, 1976. DOI.DOI
  6. [6]Michael Freedman and Vyacheslav Krushkal. Engel relations in 4-manifold topology. Forum of Mathematics, Sigma, 4:e22, 2016. 57 pp. DOI.arxiv.org/abs/1412.5024
  7. [7]Michael Freedman and Vyacheslav Krushkal. Engel groups and universal surgery models. Journal of Topology, 13(3):1302–1316, 2020. DOI.DOI
  8. [8]Michael H. Freedman. The topology of four-dimensional manifolds. Journal of Differential Geometry, 17(3):357–453, 1982.DOI
  9. [9]Michael H. Freedman and Frank Quinn. Topology of 4-Manifolds, volume 39 of Princeton Mathematical Series. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 1990. DOI.
  10. [10]Michael H. Freedman and Peter Teichner. 4-manifold topology. I. Subexponential groups. Inventiones Mathematicae, 122:509–529, 1995.DOI
  11. [11]Ezra Getzler. Lie theory for nilpotent L∞-algebras. Annals of Mathematics. Second Series, 170(1):271–301, 2009. DOI.DOI
  12. [12]William M. Goldman and John J. Millson. The deformation theory of representations of fundamental groups of compact Kähler manifolds. Publications Mathématiques de l’IHÉS, 67:43–96, 1988. DOI.
  13. [13]Vyacheslav S. Krushkal and Frank Quinn. Subexponential groups in 4-manifold topology. Geometry & Topology, 4(1):407–430, 2000. DOI.DOI
  14. [14]Tony Pantev, Bertrand Toën, Michel Vaquié, and Gabriele Vezzosi. Shifted symplectic structures. Publications Mathématiques de l’IHÉS, 117:271–328, 2013. DOI.
  15. [15]Mark Powell, Arunima Ray, and Peter Teichner. The 4-dimensional disc embedding theorem and dual spheres. Selecta Mathematica. New Series, 31(4):80, 2025. 25 pp. DOI.arxiv.org/abs/2006.05209

Paper details

vlnc:W_yuf9ppyb
Version
v1 · latest
Published
License
LicenseRef-OpenAI-public
Usage

views · 22

downloads · 4

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

unreleased internal OpenAI model

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents