WorksPhysics and Astronomy
The microscopic origin of droplet line tension
Abstract
The size dependence of the equilibrium droplet contact angle is governed by line tension. In this work, we identify a contribution to line tension arising from gravitational effects and pressure-induced changes in volume-fraction-dependent interfacial tensions within an adsorption layer. This mechanism addresses a multiscale problem of line tension in droplets ranging from nanometric to millimetric sizes that change sign and span several orders of magnitude, in agreement with experimental and simulation results. The sign of the apparent line tension is controlled by surface wettability, the initial volume fraction in the adsorption layer, and the droplet size, which also strongly influences its magnitude. Our results provide a unified physical interpretation of the experimentally observed variability in both the sign and magnitude of line tensions.
Introduction
It has been demonstrated through numerous experiments that the equilibrium contact angle depends on the droplet size. This phenomenon cannot be explained within the framework of Young’s law [1], thereby necessitating the introduction of line tension.
Line tension has been observed to not be a constant material parameter [2, 3, 4, 5, 6], but instead to span several orders of magnitude [7, 8], while exhibiting both positive and negative signs in experimental and simulation results [6]. The sign and magnitude of line tension are of particular relevance in the design and analysis of systems such as microfluidic devices, dropwise condensation [9] for heat transfer [7, 9], and heterogeneous nucleation [10, 11]. Despite extensive investigations into the physical origins of line tension, significant disagreement persists between existing theories and the line tension measured in experiments and simulations. A consensus on the physical origins underlying various signs and magnitudes of the measured line tension has, therefore, not yet been reached. Existing theories include several physical effects that are significant across different droplet sizes. At sub-nanometer atomic scales, line tension is attributed to poorly quantified direct atomic interactions [2]. At nanometric scales, the potential energy resulting from the attractive atomic forces between the liquid and the solid is modeled by the Lennard-Jones potential, with a liquid density that varies as a function of the distance from the surface, which requires a more complex numerical solution method [12]. In the case of millimetric droplets, the gravitational effect, which yields positive line tension, becomes predominant [2, 11, 12].
In this Letter, we present a unified theory across six orders of droplet size establishing a connection between line tension and the pressure effect on composition dependent interfacial tensions in an adsorption layer [13]. Our theory thus establishes a direct link between line tension and contact angle hysteresis on smooth substrates [14]. We show that two metastable adsorption states govern the sign and magnitude of the apparent line tension. When combined with gravitational effects, this approach enables the prediction of both the sign and the magnitude of line tension as functions of droplet size and surface wettability.
Model description — We consider a sessile droplet of volume on an ideally smooth and chemically homogeneous substrate, forming an apparent contact angle and a base radius (Figure 1 (A)). The interfacial tensions of the liquid-gas, solid-gas, and solid-liquid phases are denoted by , , and , respectively. According to Young’s law [1], the equilibrium contact angle satisfies , which expresses the mechanical balance of interfacial tensions at the three-phase contact line. In contrast, the modified Young’s equation [15] incorporates size-dependent corrections to the apparent contact angle,
Figure 1. (A) Schematic cross-sectional representation of the liquid droplet (L, blue) on a solid substrate (S, gray) in a gas phase (G, white), illustrating the contact angle , the base radius , the cap radius , and the interfacial tensions , , and . The colored layer represents the adsorption layer on the solid, which modifies the interfacial tensions. The wetted area, the local droplet penetration area and the exterior solid-gas interfacial area are represented by , , and , respectively. (B) Enlarged view at the triple line and the adsorption layer of thickness showing the liquid volume fraction and dependent interfacial tensions (green) and (pink) in the vicinity of the droplet, which are affected by the liquid pressure and the gas pressure , respectively. Outside the penetration area, the interfacial tension is considered to be constant (gray).
To elucidate the physical origin of the line tension , we characterize the partial penetration of the liquid phase into the adsorption layer, thereby determining the dependence of the interfacial tensions on the droplet radius arising from pressure differences and yielding line tension. In contrast to the common assumption of constant interfacial tensions, we treat and as functions of the average volume fractions of the liquid and gas species and () over the wetted area and the local penetration area (Figure 1 (B)), respectively. The local volume fractions of the liquid and gas species within the adsorption layer of thickness are denoted by and , respectively. In the exterior region , the solid-gas interfacial tension is assumed to be constant. The interfacial tension is modeled as
Here, , , and denote the internal, pressure, and van der Waals energy contributions, respectively (see end matter). Our wall free energy formulation circumvents the difficulty of directly measuring the solid–fluid interfacial energies in experiments. It is constructed in analogy with the classical Gibbs free energy, , incorporating contributions from internal energy, pressure energy, and the entropic term . In the present treatment, however, the entropy contribution is neglected. The wall free energy has units of J/m, in contrast to the bulk Gibbs free energy, which has units of J/m. This difference in dimensionality is reconciled, within the framework of mean-field theory, by introducing an average adsorption layer thickness , which transforms the bulk free energy density into an effective surface free energy density. As will be demonstrated later, inclusion of the pressure energy in the wall free energy is essential for correctly capturing both the magnitude and the sign of the line tension. This constitutes the central contribution of the present work toward elucidating the fundamental mechanism underlying line tension.
In accordance with the constraint of the volume fractions, namely, and , it can be concluded that only one independent variable remains. Consequently, the following simplified notation is employed: and .
The total free energy of the system is given by
Here, the first three terms represent the interfacial energies, denotes the gravitational energy, and is the area of the droplet cap. The difference in interfacial tensions is given by .
In this work, we use the spherical cap model for simplicity. For millimetric droplets, the Bond number is of order unity; consequently, the ellipsoidal cap model would provide a more accurate representation of the droplet shape here [13, 34, 35], but is not considered in the present study.
In the spherical cap model, the interfacial areas make (3) to
with and where , , and denote the radius of the spherical cap, the gravitational acceleration, and the height of the droplet centroid relative to the solid substrate, respectively. The density difference between the liquid and gas phases is denoted by .
We use the Young-Laplace equation to relate the pressure of the liquid phase to that of the gas phase ,
The pressure difference influence alters the composition of the adsorption layer, thereby inducing a size dependence of the surface tension and a corresponding modification of the energy function. By defining , we obtain a size-dependent expression
where . The intrinsic part includes all terms in (2) except the pressure term, leading to a reference Young’s contact angle , which is size independent. The second term in (6) captures the pressure-induced correction to the interfacial tension.
We identify the local energy minima [14, 36] of at minimizing the energy at each point, as defined by Eq. (4), over the domain (Figure 3 (A)). We refer to the local energy minimum at
Figure 3. (A) Energy landscape with local energy minima marked by crosses with . (B) Line tension as a function of the base radius: single pressure effect (dashed lines), single gravity effect (dotted lines), combined effect (solid lines; micro–Cassie–Baxter state: pink, micro–Wenzel: blue). (C) Apparent line tension as a function of the base radius for different (different materials) at (i) micro–Cassie–Baxter state and (ii) micro–Wenzel state.
as the micro–Cassie–Baxter state (CB), in which no liquid penetrates into the adsorption layer beneath the droplet. There is a second local energy minimum, the micro–Wenzel state (W), located at
where no gas penetrates into the adsorption layer beneath the liquid droplet. Here, the material parameters are fixed by Young’s contact angle,
The remaining local energy minima at and correspond to states with and thus exhibit no pressure-induced line tension. They are therefore excluded from the following analysis. The coexistence of two metastable minima separated by an energy barrier directly results in contact angle hysteresis, even on ideally smooth substrates.
By applying the volume constraint
to Eq. (6), we obtain that depends explicitly on and . This dependence leads to a modified energy function and a modified energy-minimizing contact angle, resulting in line tension. Young’s law is no longer applicable to these contact angles, as the additional term in Eq. (6) depends on . Here, the pressure acts not only as a global effect but also induces a localized response within the adsorption layer.
Substituting Eq. (6) and the volume constraint Eq. (10) into Eq. (4), and minimizing the energy yields
with , which is solved for at each droplet size. From this procedure, we obtain as a function of , a relationship that is frequently observed to deviate from linearity over several orders of magnitude in droplet size in experimental studies [2, 12, 23, 24, 31, 32, 37]. As a result, the line tension is typically determined by the local slope, .
Droplet size effect — Figure 2 shows the droplet size dependence of the apparent line tension at a constant Young’s contact angle as a function of the base radius for both local energy minima, obtained by varying the droplet volume. The good agreement of the theoretical curves with the experimental and simulation data points demonstrates the validity of the theory outlined above for predicting line tension. Experimental measurements agree with the line tension associated with both the micro–Wenzel and micro–Cassie–Baxter states, despite the lower energy of the latter. The resulting magnitudes span from pN to N. The magnitude of the line tension remains unaffected by the choice of adsorption thickness , which is measured in a few nanometers. The influence of different Young’s contact angles on line tension is discussed below.
Figure 2. Line tension [N] as a function of the base radius [m] with , , , , and , in comparison with previous experiments [6, 10, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29] and simulations [3, 5, 30, 31, 32, 33], where Young’s contact angle, , is indicated by the color of each point.
Figure 3 (B) shows the individual contributions to the line tension as a function of the base radius, namely the pressure effect and the gravity effect. This representation reveals the droplet-size ranges in which each contribution dominates. For small droplets (), the line tension is dominated by the pressure-induced contribution, while the gravitational effect on the line tension is negligible. For larger droplets (), the line tension is dominated by gravitational effects. An intermediate regime exhibits a continuous crossover between the two regimes. The pressure-induced line tension remains approximately constant at for , while the gravitational line tension increases strongly with .
The micro–Cassie–Baxter state and the micro–Wenzel state lead to opposite signs of in Eq. (6), and thus to opposite signs in the pressure-induced line tension (positive and negative, respectively). Because the gravitational line tension is always positive, the total line tension changes sign in the crossover regime for the micro–Wenzel state, while remaining strictly positive for the micro–Cassie–Baxter state.
Figure 4. Apparent line tension at the micro–Cassie–Baxter and the micro–Wenzel state as a function of the apparent contact angle in comparison with experimental measurements [6, 38].
Figure 3 (C) shows the line tension as a function of the base radius for different Young’s contact angles at (i) the micro–Cassie–Baxter state and (ii) the micro–Wenzel state. For nanometric and micrometric droplets, the sign of the line tension depends on Young’s contact angle. As illustrated in Figure 3 (C), the line tensions of the two states are either both positive or of opposite signs. In contrast, for millimeter-scale droplets, the line tension is dominated by gravitational effects and is invariably positive.
Origin of the sign for microscopic droplets
Having established the size dependence, the subsequent analysis focuses on the role of surface wettability. Figure 4 shows the line tension as a function of the apparent contact angle [8] at the micro–Cassie–Baxter and micro–Wenzel states, respectively. A linear regression of as a function of was performed over the range of , from which the line tension is obtained as times the slope of the fitted straight line. Within the range of droplet sizes considered, gravitational effects are negligible. The micro–Cassie–Baxter state exhibits a positive line tension at small contact angles and a negative line tension at large contact angles, with a sign change at , whereas the micro–Wenzel
state displays the opposite behavior, with the same transition angle. The dependence of on leads to a shift in the energy-minimizing contact angle due to the volume constraint. Neglecting bulk energy contributions, the displacement of the equilibrium angle with respect to follows from the equilibrium condition ,
with
Due to a crossover of the dominant contributions from to , changes sign with increasing , thereby reversing the displacement direction in Eq. (12) and the sign of the line tension. Zhao et al. [6] observed a sign change from positive to negative line tension at . The experimentally determined magnitude of approximately is in good agreement with the theoretical predictions. By comparing both local energy minima, we find that the micro–Cassie–Baxter state is energetically favored over the micro–Wenzel state for all hydrophilic contact angles. A possible cause for the deviations from the experimental data by Zhao et al. [6] may be the use of ionic liquids, for which electrostatic interactions [39] can contribute to both the contact angle and the line tension.
Macroscopic roughness effect
In the macroscopic Wenzel state [39, 40, 41, 42], fully wetted macroscopic surface roughness rescales the solid–liquid interfacial area in Eq. (4) by the Wenzel roughness factor . Eq. (12) then becomes
An analogous analysis for the macroscopic Cassie–Baxter state [39, 40, 41, 42], with a solid fraction , yields
For typical roughness factors () [43] and (), the macroscopic Wenzel and Cassie–Baxter states do not change the order of magnitude of the line tension. Tadmor [44, 45] associated line tension with chemical and topological surface defects and the resulting contact angle hysteresis. However, the classic Wenzel and Cassie–Baxter equations alone do not show size-dependent contact angles, and no defect-induced line tensions are observed, in contrast to the experimentally observed line tension at rough surfaces of order N [46]. Including microscopic roughness resolves this discrepancy. Consequently, macroscopic roughness contributes only a subleading effect to the observed line tension.
Conclusion — In summary, we present a theory for the apparent line tension that combines the effect of body energy and pressure-induced contributions to the interfacial tensions within an adsorption layer. The theory quantitatively reproduces experimental observations, including sign reversals and variations over several orders of magnitude, which cannot be captured by individual contributions alone. We identify the adopted metastable microscopic wetting state, the surface wettability, and droplet size as the key parameters controlling the sign of the apparent line tension, with droplet size also affecting its magnitude. Distinct physical mechanisms dominate in different droplet size regimes: pressure-induced effects at the adsorption layer for nanometric and micrometric droplets, and gravitational contributions for millimetric droplets. Our results indicate that the wide range of measured line tensions does not reflect inconsistencies among results but rather the diversity of the investigated systems [7]. This work provides a physical interpretation of the sign and magnitude of line tension across droplet sizes and experimental systems.
Acknowledgments
F.A. thanks the Gottfried-Wilhelm Leibniz prize NE 822/31-1 of the German Research Foundation (DFG) for funding this research. F.W. is grateful to the Virt-Mat project P09 of the Helmholtz Association (MSE-programme No. 43.31.01).
End Matter
Interfacial tensions — The liquid-solid and solid-gas interfacial tensions consist of three terms:
The volume fraction of the liquid and gas in the adsorption layer is denoted by and , respectively. The internal energy is represented by , where and are the internal energies of the liquid and gas phases, respectively. Furthermore, the van der Waals energy is denoted by , with the van der Waals interactions between the liquid-gas, solid-gas, and solid-liquid phases , , and , respectively. The pressure term is expressed as . Inserting the constraint yields a quadratic polynomial in
with , , , and .
Local droplet penetration area — The local droplet penetration area describes the area around the droplet at the solid-liquid interface, where the liquid penetrates into the solid at the adsorption layer and modifies the interfacial tension by the liquid volume fraction. It is considered to be a fraction of the wetted area ,
with . This factor influences the number and location of the local energy minima of (see Figure 3 (A)) [36].
References
- [1]T. Young, III. An essay on the cohesion of fluids, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. 95, 65 (1805).
- [2]M. Iwamatsu, A generalized Young’s equation to bridge a gap between the experimentally measured and theoretically calculated line tensions, Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology 32, 2305 (2018).
- [3]M. Kanduč, L. Eixeres, S. Liese, and R. R. Netz, Generalized line tension of water nanodroplets, Phys. Rev. E 98, 032804 (2018).DOI
- [4]W. Klauser, F. T. Von Kleist-Retzow, and S. Fatikow, Line Tension and Drop Size Dependence of Contact Angle at the Nanoscale, Nanomaterials 12, 369 (2022).DOI
- [5]J. Zhang, P. Wang, M. K. Borg, J. M. Reese, and D. Wen, A critical assessment of the line tension determined by the modified Young’s equation, Physics of Fluids 30, 082003 (2018).DOI
- [6]B. Zhao, S. Luo, E. Bonaccurso, G. K. Auernhammer, X. Deng, Z. Li, and L. Chen, Resolving the Apparent Line Tension of Sessile Droplets and Understanding its Sign Change at a Critical Wetting Angle, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 094501 (2019).DOI
- [7]A. Amirfazli and A. Neumann, Status of the three-phase line tension: A review, Advances in Colloid and Interface Science 110, 121 (2004).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15328061
- [8]A. Marmur, Line Tension and the Intrinsic Contact Angle in Solid–Liquid–Fluid Systems, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 186, 462 (1997).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9056376
- [9]A. Amirfazli, S. Hänig, A. Müller, and A. W. Neumann, Measurements of Line Tension for Solid–Liquid–Vapor Systems Using Drop Size Dependence of Contact Angles and Its Correlation with Solid–Liquid Interfacial Tension, Langmuir 16, 2024 (2000).
- [10]A. Amirfazli, D. Kwok, J. Gaydos, and A. Neumann, Line Tension Measurements through Drop Size Dependence of Contact Angle, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 205, 1 (1998).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9710494
- [11]B. M. Law, S. P. McBride, J. Y. Wang, H. S. Wi, G. Paneru, S. Betelu, B. Ushijima, Y. Takata, B. Flanders, F. Bresme, H. Matsubara, T. Takiue, and M. Aratono, Line tension and its influence on droplets and particles at surfaces, Progress in Surface Science 92, 1 (2017).DOI
- [12]B. H. Tan, H. An, and C.-D. Ohl, Body Forces Drive the Apparent Line Tension of Sessile Droplets, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 064003 (2023).DOI
- [13]F. Wang, H. Zhang, and B. Nestler, Wetting Phenomena: Line Tension and Gravitational Effect, Physical Review Letters 133, 246201 (2024).DOI
- [14]F. Wang and B. Nestler, Wetting and Contact-Angle Hysteresis: Density Asymmetry and van der Waals Force, Physical Review Letters 132, 126202 (2024).DOI
- [15]L. Boruvka and A. W. Neumann, Generalization of the classical theory of capillarity, The Journal of Chemical Physics 66, 5464 (1977).DOI
- [16]F. Mugele, T. Becker, R. Nikopoulos, M. Kohonen, and S. Herminghaus, Capillarity at the nanoscale: An AFM view, Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology 16, 951 (2002).DOI
- [17]J. Gaydos and A. Neumann, The dependence of contact angles on drop size and line tension, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 120, 76 (1987).
- [18]D. Duncan, D. Li, J. Gaydos, and A. W. Neumann, Correlation of Line Tension and Solid–Liquid Interfacial Tension from the Measurement of Drop Size Dependence of Contact Angles, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 169, 256 (1995).
- [19]J. A. Wallace and S. Schürch, Line tension of a sessile drop on a fluid–fluid interface modified by a phospholipid monolayer, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 124, 452 (1988).DOI
- [20]M. Munz and T. Mills, Size Dependence of Shape and Stiffness of Single Sessile Oil Nanodroplets As Measured by Atomic Force Microscopy, Langmuir 30, 4243 (2014).DOI
- [21]X. H. Zhang and W. Ducker, Interfacial Oil Droplets, Langmuir 24, 110 (2008).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18044934
- [22]J. K. Berg, C. M. Weber, and H. Riegler, Impact of Negative Line Tension on the Shape of Nanometer-Size Sessile Droplets, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 076103 (2010).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20868061
- [23]L.-O. Heim and E. Bonaccurso, Measurement of Line Tension on Droplets in the Submicrometer Range, Langmuir 29, 14147 (2013).DOI
- [24]A. Checco, P. Guenoun, and J. Daillant, Nonlinear Dependence of the Contact Angle of Nanodroplets on Contact Line Curvature, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 186101 (2003).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14611293
- [25]R. Seemann, K. Jacobs, and R. Blossey, Polystyrene nanodroplets*, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 13, 4915 (2001).DOI
- [26]J. Drelich and J. D. Miller, The effect of solid surface heterogeneity and roughness on the contact angle/drop (bubble) size relationship, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 164, 252 (1994).DOI
- [27]T. Werder, J. H. Walther, R. L. Jaffe, T. Halicioglu, and P. Koumoutsakos, On the Water-Carbon Interaction for Use in Molecular Dynamics Simulations of Graphite and Carbon Nanotubes, The Journal of Physical Chemistry B 107, 1345 (2003).
- [28]A. D. Dussaud and M. Vignes-Adler, Line tension effect on alkane droplets near the wetting transition, MRS Proceedings 464, 287 (1996).DOI
- [29]A. Amirfazli, A. Keshavarz, L. Zhang, and A. Neumann, Determination of line tension for systems near wetting, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 265, 152 (2003).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12927177
- [30]J. Wloch, A. P. Terzyk, and P. Kowalczyk, New forcefield for water nanodroplet on a graphene surface, Chemical Physics Letters 674, 98 (2017).DOI
- [31]G. Scocchi, D. Sergi, C. D’Angelo, and A. Ortona, Wetting and contact-line effects for spherical and cylindrical droplets on graphene layers: A comparative molecular-dynamics investigation, Phys. Rev. E 84, 061602 (2011).DOI
- [32]M. Khalkhali, N. Kazemi, H. Zhang, and Q. Liu, Wetting at the nanoscale: A molecular dynamics study, The Journal of Chemical Physics 146, 114704 (2017).DOI
- [33]M. Shintaku, H. Oga, H. Kusudo, E. R. Smith, T. Omori, and Y. Yamaguchi, Measuring line tension: Thermodynamic integration during detachment of a molecular dynamics droplet, The Journal of Chemical Physics 160, 224502 (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2402.06237
- [34]F. Aurbach, F. Wang, and B. Nestler, Gravitational effect on the equilibrium contact angles of sessile droplets: Theory and simulations, The Journal of Chemical Physics 163, 034706 (2025).DOI
- [35]G. Whyman and E. Bormashenko, Oblate spheroid model for calculation of the shape and contact angles of heavy droplets, Journal of Colloid and Interface Science 331, 174 (2009).DOI
- [36]F. Aurbach, F. Wang, and B. Nestler, Wetting phenomena of droplets and gas bubbles: Contact angle hysteresis based on varying liquid–solid and solid–gas interfacial tensions, The Journal of Chemical Physics 161, 164708 (2024).DOI
- [37]D. V. Tatyanenko and K. D. Apitsin, Line tension from dual-geometry sessile droplet measurements: Combining contact-angle size-dependence data for axisymmetric and cylindrical droplets to determine the line tension, Phys. Rev. E 111, 035503 (2025).DOI
- [38]T. Pompe, Line Tension Behavior of a First-Order Wetting System, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 076102 (2002).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12190534
- [39]H. Zhang, H. Zhang, F. Wang, and B. Nestler, Exploration of contact angle hysteresis mechanisms: From microscopic to macroscopic, The Journal of Chemical Physics 161, 194705 (2024).DOI
- [40]E. Bormashenko, Young, Boruvka–Neumann, Wenzel and Cassie–Baxter equations as the transversality conditions for the variational problem of wetting, Colloids and Surfaces A: Physicochemical and Engineering Aspects 345, 163 (2009).DOI
- [41]G. Whyman, E. Bormashenko, and T. Stein, The rigorous derivation of Young, Cassie–Baxter and Wenzel equations and the analysis of the contact angle hysteresis phenomenon, Chemical Physics Letters 450, 355 (2008).DOI
- [42]L. Bi, F. Wang, and B. Nestler, Wetting transition: Macroscopic roughness, static friction, and energy barrier, Phys. Rev. Res. 7, 043093 (2025).DOI
- [43]A. Hongru, L. Xiangqin, S. Shuyan, Z. Ying, and L. Tianqing, Measurement of wenzel roughness factor by laser scanning confocal microscopy, RSC Adv. 7, 7052 (2017).
- [44]R. Tadmor, Line Energy and the Relation between Advancing, Receding, and Young Contact Angles, Langmuir 20, 7659 (2004).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15323516
- [45]R. Tadmor, Line energy, line tension and drop size, Surface Science 602, L108 (2008).DOI
- [46]Z. Long, Z. Yuan, and H. Wang, Disentangle the intrinsic line tension from the nano-corrugations induced by surface lateral roughness, International Communications in Heat and Mass Transfer 164, 108957 (2025).DOI