WorksPhysics and Astronomy
1D Poiseuille Plane Channel Flow by Second Order Response Matrix
Abstract
With increasing miniaturization of diagnostic devices for more effective detection of blood-borne pathogens for example, Poiseuille molecular flow in micro channels has become increasingly relevant. Since continuum mechanics no longer applies for Poiseuille flow when the Knudson number is near or larger than unity, kinetic theory is required to capture the microscopic molecular scattering responsible for channel molecular flow and the velocity profile across a channel. Here, we apply a response matrix solution to the 1D Poiseuille flow with a BGK approximation featuring simplicity with precision by following a consistent numerical formulation leading to high precision, 8-place benchmarks.
Introduction
1D plane channel Poiseuille molecular flow, shown in Figure 1, occurs in a micro channel of sufficient width so quantum effects are not relevant but molecular collisions are. The flowing molecules of a gas, driven by a pressure gradient, scatter from the upper and lower walls of the

Figure 1. Poiseuille micro channel flow.
channel whose influence is simulated by , the accommodation coefficient in , representing diffuse reflection. The fundamental assumptions are a transversely infinite channel with laminar mass molecular flow in the -direction as described by the BGK [1] scattering approximation. Wall specular and diffuse reflection and subsequent molecular scattering within the channel enable a steady state density profile across the channel width (-coordinate) in the -direction. The simplification of the BGK model features local conservation of number density, momentum and energy as well as a non-decreasing variable proportional to entropy. Our goal is to determine the microscopic density perturbation profile from a Maxwellian in order to estimate the macroscopic velocity profile and total channel flow rate in the -direction. In addition to solving the Poiseuille BGK equation, we do so with emphasis on simplicity with precision. This becomes apparent in the analytical form of the solution found in terms of common trigonometric and hyperbolic functions. By generating a sequence of solutions in quadrature order, we estimate the solution for the microscopic velocity profiles at the centerline and exiting the wall, the macroscopic mass velocity and flow rate to be at least eight digits of precision, which is uncommon in the published literature.
In the next section, we begin with a review of the derivation of the flow equation followed by the corresponding discrete ordinates balance equation. First order forward and backward streams of ODEs appear and couple into a single second order ODE. We choose conveniently normalized hyperbolic solutions for the solution to the diagonalized homogeneous second order form. Finally, a MATLAB program requiring only common matrix inversion and diagonalization provides high-precision numerical results. Where possible, comparison of the response matrix results with literature confirms 5- to 7-place precision.
BGK Equation for 1D Poiseuille Plane Channel Flow
In the following section, we present the derivation of Poiseuille BGK equation. It is brief since an excellent derivation appears in Ref [2]. When linearized, the solution of the nonlinear Boltzmann equation deviates about the Maxwellian equilibrium distribution by
where the density perturbation satisfies the following linearized Boltzmann equation:
is the BGK operator [1] and
is the non-dimensional pressure gradient driving the flow. is the microscopic molecular velocity (aka speed). To specify the perturbed Maxwellian averaged gas velocity in the -direction, we form the following velocity moment by integrating over the - and - directions weighted by all molecular flow velocities in the -direction:
One interprets as the perturbed microscopic velocity profile in the -direction of a gas travelling in the -direction. Similarly, integrating Eq(2a) gives
for , where is the scattering mean free path. Boundary conditions at the walls giving symmetry in are
where is the accommodation coefficient specifying the degree of wall diffuse and specular scattering. If , and , then Eq(3b) is
with , and boundary conditions
where the inverse Knudsen number is
Elimination of the inhomogeneous term in Eq(4a) comes after substitution of
to give
with
By taking advantage of symmetry about the channel centerline and redefining, from the centerline
and retaining the lower wall boundary condition for , gives
with
for . Eq(6a) is a typical transport equation for the “flux distribution” similar to neutron transport in a slab except the “angular variable”, , is not in , which is a matter of scaling.
Theory of Second Order Matrix solution
There have been many solutions to Eqs(6). Some of the most successful solutions are found in Refs [2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9], including vibrational methods, elementary singular eigenfunction solutions, Fourier transforms, the FN method and more. Indeed, nearly any method of solving the linear transport equation is feasible including adding and doubling as recently shown [8]. Moreover, the author has developed two response matrix formulations, which are generally more straightforward than previous methods. The first is a first order parity approach that considers the discrete ordinate balance equation as a set of first order ODEs with linearly independent exponential solutions. Decaying exponentials stabilized the solution through an interpretation of the identity [11]. The second casts the solution in a second order The solution form by combining the two directional streams through differentiation similarly found in Ref [12]. This opens up a host of solutions. It is the second order form we pursue here. As will be shown, the second order form provides highly precise benchmarks in contrast to most previous methods cited.
Discrete Ordinates Balance Equation
First Order Form
The fundamental discrete order equations that provide the basis for the solution to the second order form are now derived making liberal use of Ref [8]. By writing Eqs(6) in terms of the new variable such that , and partitioning the scattering integral into forward and backward contributions, Eq(6a) becomes
where the scattering integral splits into two improper integrals. Note the explicit dependence on the new variables and , and that is an even function. With the change of variable, there results
by transforming to . Reference [3] suggests an appropriate choice of from an infinite number of possibilities as
to give
Therefore, the scattering integral is
enabling approximate half-range integration by Gauss quadrature of order
where
with the velocity directions shown in Figure 2. is the local quadrature error in and is the local quadrature error in the solution. Positive (+) and negative (−) directions are shown in

Figure 2. Molecular directions: + top to bottom/− Bottom to top.
Figure 2. Now the similarity to discrete ordinates neutron transport in a slab is clear. The channel represents a transmitting and scattering medium, where, molecular density perturbations (particles) enter in discretized directions through the boundaries at the channel centerline and lower wall and exit out the same boundaries. The discretized directions, , come from the zeros of the half-range Legendre polynomial of degree
giving the two half-range discrete ordinates for and
with weights [13]
Introducing Eq(10b) into the RHS of Eq (18), evaluating the equation at and dropping the error term gives the following discrete ordinates approximation in the positive (+) and negative (−) half-ranges:
A more compact form results by defining vectors in the half-ranges
for which Eqs(12) become the following first order vector ODEs:
with
Note that the unity-vector makes the RHS a vector of uniform elements. From Eqs(6c,d,e), the boundary conditions are
for or as vectors
and more conveniently in vector form to be used later
where is the matrix identity of size .
Equivalent Second Order Form
It is at this point, where the expression of the solution could vary. One has to make a choice on how to solve the set of homogeneous ODEs of Eqs(14a,b). Our choice specifies a unique form of solution with special features. The choice covers any functions that solve a first order vector ODE with constant or variable coefficients. The most notable previous choices have been exponential solutions [3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9], or Fourier transform [10], or others not tried like the Matrix- Raccati formulation [14]-- or the interaction principal [15] to give an invariant embedding solution-- or numerically solving the ODEs by spatial discretization with diamond difference and matrix iteration [16]-- or reforming as the double PN (DPN) moments approximation [17]. All of the methods noted could lead to the response matrix, which we seek here, but we follow a different path.
A second order ODE emerges from adding and subtracting Eqs(14a,b)
which become
when
If one differentiates Eq(16d)
and introduces Eq(16c) as
then a second order ODE emerges
The scattering integral will now be expressed in terms of the vector . Since the discretized integral is a dot product on the vector
there results
with
or
where
and therefore
Introducing Eq(18f) into Eq(17c) gives the explicit second order homogeneous equation
with
squared for convenience. Note that , the uniform one-matrix, is
and the elements of are any real numbers if the quadrature weights are positive.
Once is known from the solution to Eq(19a), Eq(16d) gives as
The solution found here for is but one of many possibilities. For example, a second form comes from differentiating Eq(16c) and then substituting Eq(16d) and the derivative of from Eq(19f). We would then have another second order ODE but for . This will be the subject of further research.
Solution of Second Order Form
There are many expressions for the solutions to Eqs(19a) depending on one’s knowledge of solutions to ODEs, analytical elegance and computational efficiency. When first encountering a homogeneous vector or scalar second order ODE with constant coefficients, it is most natural to consider exponential solutions or equivalent sines and cosines. These solutions lead to a linear equation for the coefficients of the linear combination of independent solutions after application of boundary conditions. Here, we take a more direct approach.
One anticipates matrix to have linearly independent eigenvectors; therefore, is diagonalizable. Thus,
or more conveniently by suppressing the list and letting brackets define a diagonal matrix of eigenvalues
where is the matrix of the eigenvectors. The independence of the eigenvectors guarantees the inverse of the matrix. In addition, since the elements of are all real, the eigenvalues may be imaginary. Since, , on substitution into Eq(19a), there results
with multiplication of the first term by the identity. On defining the reduced vector
Eq(23) becomes
which alternatively is a diagonal matrix of scalar ODEs, where the second order ODE is
with
The novelty of our approach is rather than assume exponential solutions to the homogeneous ODE, we specify the following linearly independent solutions
which are naturally normalization such that
To check linear independence, the Wronskian is
and does not vanish for any eigenvalue including zero, which is not true for simple exponential solutions. The set of solutions of Eqs(25a,b) is particularly convenient since the analytical solution results without the need to solve an additional linear system for the coefficients of the linear combination of the independent solutions as will be shown.
Thus, the general solution to Eq(24b) is
and from Eq(24a),
and substituting Eq(27a)
Since, for and $a
respectively,
and the solution from Eq(27c) is
where the matrix function is
Because of the imposed structure of the matrix function satisfies
the boundary conditions immediately determine constants without additional linear algebra, which is a significant advantage of the chosen solutions of Eqs(24c).
In addition, with
the solution for is
In principle, with known, one could find the solution to the first order ODE from Eq(16e); but before we do so, we find the response matrix next.
The Response Matrix
The response matrix is the matrix, which, when multiplied by the incoming density distributions from the channel centerline, , and from accommodation at the bottom wall, , (see Fig.2) into the channel, gives the distributions exiting the channel through the centerline, , and from the wall, . When viewing the solution of Eq(28c) at the boundaries, identities result by construction. Thus, no new information results. However, Eq(30c) for does give new information such as
where
Do not confuse the in Eqs(31d,e) with the in Eqs(19). With Eqs(31e-f), Eqs(31a,b) are
With the following definitions:
Eqs(32a,b) become
which, on gathering terms, are
for
A more convenient form of Eqs(33e,f) is the vector equation
The response matrix (RM) is therefore
where
Note that the vector of entering densities on the RHS of Eq(35a), when multiplied by the response matrix, yields the vector of exiting densities on the left explicitly.
To finish, from the symmetry and boundary conditions given by Eq(15g), Eq(35a) becomes
and solving for the exiting distribution
From the exiting densities, we infer the interior densities in the next section.
Solution to Original First Order Form
To convert to the solutions of the original first order ODE of Eqs(14a,b), substitute Eq(16e) into Eqs(28c) and (30c) for
then add and subtract Eqs(37a,b) to give the channel interior microscopic profiles
Next, introduce the boundary conditions from Eqs(15d,e) to give for
and finally introduce and from Eq(36b) in the form
to arrive at the channel interior microscopic velocity distributions in the positive and negative directions
with from Eq(14e), from Eq(28d), from Eq(30a), from Eq(35b) and from Eq(15f). Thus, in the limit as approaches infinity, the solution is two infinite dimensional vectors of microscopic velocity profiles specified at , where are the zeros of a half-range Legendre polynomial as its degree approaches infinity.
Eqs(39a,b) are new explicit analytical solutions to the discrete ordinates balance equations [Eqs(14a)]. The only numerical requirements are mapping to the interval [-1,1], matrix diagonalization and matrix inversion. In the next section, we evaluate the macroscopic velocity profile, flow rate and the microscopic velocity profile.
Macroscopic Velocity Profile, Flow Rate and Microscopic Velocity Profile
Expressions for the velocity profile and total flow rate appear in this section. The velocity profile is the Maxwellian weighted moment of the microscopic velocities of Eqs(39); and the flow rate is the integration of the velocity profile over the channel width. The velocity profile is also the RHS (or scattering integral) in Eq(4a).
Velocity Profile
The velocity profile is
for and with Eq (12) inserted becomes
Introducing from Eq. (18f) yields
and including symmetry and wall conditions from Eq. (15d,e) in Eq. (28c)
to give
where and come from Eqs. (38c,d).
Flow Rate
The flow rate is
and with Eq. (40b) becomes
An analytical result for the integral follows the procedure found in Ref [7]. If we define moments
when the transport equation [Eq. (6a)] is multiplied by and integrated over , there results
and upon integration
Now multiply the transport equation [Eq(6a)] again by , integrate over to give
and multiply by and integrate over
which simplifies by integration by parts to
From symmetry about the centerline,
therefore,
Multiply the transport equation [Eq(6a)] by and integrate over
and integrate over over
Since, from symmetry
we find
Finally, substituting into Eq(42b) and remembering Eqs(15d,e)
with
giving
when Eqs(48b,c) are introduced into Eq(48a). Numerically integrating by Gauss quadrature gives
Benchmark Demonstration
With the analytical solution to the discrete ordinates equations now complete, we turn our attention to the numerical precision of the response matrix method. First, we summarize the response matrix solution and briefly compare its mathematical simplicity to a few previous methods.
The response matrix method based on discrete ordinates discretization of the microscopic molecular velocity profile (direction in neutron transport theory) is a general method of solving transport equations [Eqs(6)] for intensity, flux or density perturbation. After mapping the molecular velocity into the standard interval [-1,1], one solves the resulting set of discretized ODEs [Eqs(14)] over Gauss quadrature by common ODE solution techniques. To the author’s knowledge, all previous ODE solutions originating from discrete ordinates assume exponential solutions. In his recent publications [11, 12] on response matrix solutions however, the author has changed the paradigm. Instead of solving the first order form [Eqs(14)], we construct a second order solution through differentiation [Eq(19a)]. The second order form supports solutions via trigonometric or hyperbolic functions [Eqs(28d)] depending upon whether an eigenvalue of the associated matrix [Eq(19b)] is real or imaginary both of which occur. Two linearly independent solutions exist even for the zero eigenvalue [Eqs(25a,b)]. With particular construction of the diagonalized solution [Eqs(28d) and (29)], the incoming distribution generates the outgoing distribution through the response matrix [Eqs(35a,b)]. The construction of independent solutions enables a closed form representation of the exiting distributions in terms of density distributions at the boundaries [Eq(36b)]. One finds the final solution when the second order form is algebraically transformed into the first order [Eqs(39)]. The response matrix representation also enables alternative solution representations, which deserve further exploration.
The response matrix solution is a straightforward and readily implemented method of the solution of Poiseuille flow and additional transport equations. Besides round off error from the determination of eigenvalues and eigenvectors, which is probably the most precise of all known numerical methods, the only approximation is the finite number of discrete ordinates (microscopic velocities). Unlike invariant embedding solutions, there are no X or Y functions requiring iterative solutions. Other methods like Fourier transforms and the FN method require expansion or collocation and integrations for the expansion coefficients. Finally, integral equation solutions require evaluation of the Abramowitz function. In addition, the response matrix applies to heterogeneous channels of separated laminar flow through the multiregion version of the response matrix formulation [8, 12].
Velocity Profile
A MATLAB program evaluates the velocity profile and flow rate, Eqs(41c) and (48d) respectively. Starting with the velocity profile, Table 1a shows the variation across a channel of half width for quadrature order . To compensate for the finite number of microscopic velocities allowed, we converge the velocity profile and flow rate in quadrature order . For example, the analytical solution, say for the velocity profile, is actually a limit as the number of discretizations approaches infinity,
| 0.5 | 0.8 | 0.88 | 0.96 | 1.0 | |
| 0.0000e+00 | -3.65222151e+00 | -2.31961581e+00 | -2.11740958e+00 | -1.94880072e+00 | -1.87457690e+00 |
| 1.0000e-01 | -3.64483644e+00 | -2.31214766e+00 | -2.10992110e+00 | -1.94129259e+00 | -1.86705918e+00 |
| 2.0000e-01 | -3.62257740e+00 | -2.28963849e+00 | -2.08735075e+00 | -1.91866310e+00 | -1.84440085e+00 |
| 3.0000e-01 | -3.58511714e+00 | -2.25175862e+00 | -2.04936834e+00 | -1.88058161e+00 | -1.80627105e+00 |
| 4.0000e-01 | -3.53185187e+00 | -2.19790110e+00 | -1.99536633e+00 | -1.82644008e+00 | -1.75206153e+00 |
| 5.0000e-01 | -3.46178918e+00 | -2.12707160e+00 | -1.92435031e+00 | -1.75524419e+00 | -1.68077806e+00 |
| 6.0000e-01 | -3.37332081e+00 | -2.03766632e+00 | -1.83471834e+00 | -1.66539407e+00 | -1.59082192e+00 |
| 7.0000e-01 | -3.26372789e+00 | -1.92699094e+00 | -1.72378372e+00 | -1.55421110e+00 | -1.47951862e+00 |
| 8.0000e-01 | -3.12791673e+00 | -1.79003943e+00 | -1.58656589e+00 | -1.41674086e+00 | -1.34192713e+00 |
| 9.0000e-01 | -2.95401978e+00 | -1.61528082e+00 | -1.41162825e+00 | -1.24164283e+00 | -1.16675552e+00 |
| 1.0000e+00 | -2.67640744e+00 | -1.34037200e+00 | -1.13752739e+00 | -9.68381321e-01 | -8.93924720e-01 |
Table 1a. Velocity Profile for (CPU= 0.75s)
Since exists analytically, we are free to evaluate it at any quadrature order. In this way, one makes a sequence, say in the interval by increments of 5, and estimates sequence convergence as approaches infinity. There are many effective choices for assessing sequence convergence. The most common and simplest is element-by-element or sequential convergence
where, when the “engineering estimate” of the relative error
is less that a prescribe error (say ) the sequence is considered converged. Another effective convergence procedure is non-linear Wynn-epsilon (W-e) convergence acceleration [18]. W-e convergence extrapolates a known sequence to give the next sequence element (estimation of the limit) from previous elements. For our purpose, we use a five-element window passing through the sequence to continually approximate the limit from the last five elements. The algorithm after elements
is recursive, where
giving following tableau:
where the last value in only the even columns [see arrow] forms the extrapolated sequence giving the relative error
A hybrid form of convergence now applies, where if
then is the most precise value; otherwise, is the precise value when the inequality is reversed. The values in Table 1a, which is the last element of the iteration sequence 5(5)100, are expected to be precise to better than one unit in the 8th place. This is consistent with the relative errors between the last two iterates given in Table 1b. 38% of the tabular values converged by We acceleration.
| 0.5 | 0.8 | 0.88 | 0.96 | 1.0 | |
| 0.0000e+00 | 1.2479e-11 | 7.8180e-12 | 7.1166e-12 | 6.5351e-12 | 6.2800e-12 |
| 1.0000e-01 | 1.1563e-11 | 1.7938e-11 | 1.9106e-11 | 2.0159e-11 | 2.0650e-11 |
| 2.0000e-01 | 2.3087e-11 | 1.9220e-11 | 1.8736e-11 | 1.8374e-11 | 1.8229e-11 |
| 3.0000e-01 | 1.5359e-11 | 1.0928e-11 | 1.0290e-11 | 9.7721e-12 | 9.5498e-12 |
| 4.0000e-01 | 2.9635e-12 | 2.5846e-12 | 3.5318e-12 | 4.3625e-12 | 4.7438e-12 |
| 5.0000e-01 | 3.8193e-11 | 3.6237e-11 | 3.6299e-11 | 3.6496e-11 | 3.6637e-11 |
| 6.0000e-01 | 2.4855e-12 | 3.4526e-12 | 4.5183e-12 | 5.4750e-12 | 5.9215e-12 |
| 7.0000e-01 | 1.5580e-11 | 1.1348e-11 | 1.0775e-11 | 1.0329e-11 | 1.0144e-11 |
| 8.0000e-01 | 2.4666e-11 | 2.2236e-11 | 2.2220e-11 | 2.2367e-11 | 2.2495e-11 |
| 9.0000e-01 | 1.7267e-11 | 2.9194e-11 | 3.2238e-11 | 3.5376e-11 | 3.6997e-11 |
| 1.0000e+00 | 1.2712e-11 | 2.5634e-12 | 7.0920e-12 | 6.4186e-12 | 6.1137e-12 |
Table 1b. Relative error between iterates for
Curiously, the first eigenvalue is imaginary for the quadrature orders shown in Table 1c. Furthermore, there is no indication in the numerical results of the existence of an imaginary eigenvalue, which previous works did not detected. Table 1c also lists the number of places in agreement for the macroscopic velocities for the quadrature orders.
| Places | |||
| 5 | 0.0000000000e+00 | 4.8253512854e-02 | 0 |
| 10 | 0.0000000000e+00 | 3.5835002846e-03 | 4-5 |
| 25 | 0.0000000000e+00 | 1.9729463267e-05 | 7 |
| 30 | 0.0000000000e+00 | 5.4354269127e-07 | 7-8 |
| 50 | 0.0000000000e+00 | 8.2103403882e-07 | 8 |
| 90 | 0.0000000000e+00 | 1.0041471930e-06 | 8 |
Table 1c. Occurrence of imaginary eigenvalues ().
Flow Rate
Figure 2a displays the flow rate to 8 places for two different methods of calculation over a range of channel widths and accommodation coefficients. The first is for where 93% of the values converged for the sequence 5(5)100 by W-e acceleration. We find identical values from the adding and doubling (A&D) method of solution [8]. The methods could not be more different, but nevertheless give identical results. While the response matrix relies on eigenvalues and eigenvectors, A&D does not. A&D solves the first order set of ODEs with a Crank-Nicholson approximation in contrast to the response matrix, which is analytic.
Channel widths () range from 0.05 to 100. Table 2b shows the corresponding relative error between the two orders and 100. According to the relative error, the flow rate should be precise to one digit in the last place since the relative error is or less, confirmed in comparison with A&D.
| 0.5 | 0.8 | 0.88 | 0.96 | 1.0 | |
| 5.000E-02 | 5.22329643E+00 | 3.08971134E+00 | 2.73834029E+00 | 2.43735442E+00 | 2.30225642E+00 |
| 1.000E-01 | 4.55640624E+00 | 2.70774075E+00 | 2.40604565E+00 | 2.14824142E+00 | 2.03271429E+00 |
| 3.000E-01 | 3.77847230E+00 | 2.24477079E+00 | 2.00106748E+00 | 1.79450880E+00 | 1.70247402E+00 |
| 5.000E-01 | 3.54437089E+00 | 2.10226566E+00 | 1.87662020E+00 | 1.68634239E+00 | 1.60187423E+00 |
| 7.000E-01 | 3.43766932E+00 | 2.03876698E+00 | 1.82201088E+00 | 1.63984952E+00 | 1.55918596E+00 |
| 9.000E-01 | 3.38388693E+00 | 2.00924078E+00 | 1.79763600E+00 | 1.62022302E+00 | 1.54179963E+00 |
| 1.000E+00 | 3.36821820E+00 | 2.00186689E+00 | 1.79205901E+00 | 1.61631243E+00 | 1.53867845E+00 |
| 2.000E+00 | 3.37657376E+00 | 2.04138518E+00 | 1.83856321E+00 | 1.66936555E+00 | 1.59485690E+00 |
| 5.000E+00 | 3.77440185E+00 | 2.43823390E+00 | 2.23505907E+00 | 2.06547805E+00 | 1.99076737E+00 |
| 7.000E+00 | 4.08810781E+00 | 2.74611243E+00 | 2.54143624E+00 | 2.37037511E+00 | 2.29493220E+00 |
| 9.000E+00 | 4.41019024E+00 | 3.06346434E+00 | 2.85756452E+00 | 2.68529504E+00 | 2.60925361E+00 |
| 1.000E+01 | 4.57278306E+00 | 3.22410732E+00 | 3.01770233E+00 | 2.84493372E+00 | 2.76864494E+00 |
| 2.000E+01 | 6.21934716E+00 | 4.85986623E+00 | 4.65065850E+00 | 4.47511900E+00 | 4.39745649E+00 |
| 3.000E+01 | 7.87834275E+00 | 6.51452799E+00 | 6.30419513E+00 | 6.12754285E+00 | 6.04932852E+00 |
| 4.000E+01 | 9.54094965E+00 | 8.17483582E+00 | 7.96390587E+00 | 7.78666297E+00 | 7.70815570E+00 |
| 1.000E+02 | 1.95332586E+01 | 1.81627859E+01 | 1.79507236E+01 | 1.77723604E+01 | 1.76932974E+01 |
Table 2a. Adding and Doubling and Response Matrix /CPU = 39s\1.9s
Choice between linear and Wynn-epsilon convergence
| 0.5 | 0.8 | 0.88 | 0.96 | 1.0 | |
| 5.000e-02 | 2.283e-12 | 3.467e-12 | 2.151e-11 | 2.519e-11 | 2.607e-11 |
| 1.000e-01 | 7.913e-12 | 1.281e-12 | 6.296e-13 | 3.890e-12 | 4.586e-12 |
| 3.000e-01 | 5.827e-12 | 1.122e-12 | 4.209e-12 | 6.358e-12 | 6.881e-12 |
| 5.000e-01 | 9.330e-12 | 5.038e-13 | 4.331e-14 | 3.480e-13 | 5.162e-13 |
| 7.000e-01 | 1.582e-12 | 9.273e-12 | 1.517e-13 | 1.850e-12 | 4.409e-13 |
| 9.000e-01 | 1.362e-12 | 9.816e-13 | 2.832e-12 | 7.509e-12 | 6.364e-12 |
| 1.000e+00 | 3.191e-14 | 5.528e-12 | 2.686e-12 | 8.805e-13 | 2.957e-12 |
| 2.000e+00 | 1.255e-13 | 8.223e-14 | 5.217e-12 | 2.658e-12 | 2.564e-12 |
| 5.000e+00 | 8.518e-12 | 4.471e-12 | 6.088e-12 | 7.248e-12 | 7.644e-12 |
| 7.000e+00 | 4.141e-12 | 3.839e-12 | 2.209e-12 | 2.737e-13 | 6.701e-13 |
| 9.000e+00 | 1.610e-12 | 6.941e-12 | 7.240e-12 | 7.310e-12 | 7.291e-12 |
| 1.000e+01 | 5.442e-13 | 5.890e-12 | 6.134e-12 | 6.132e-12 | 6.062e-12 |
| 2.000e+01 | 9.673e-12 | 9.518e-13 | 1.422e-12 | 1.633e-12 | 1.676e-12 |
| 3.000e+01 | 1.049e-12 | 1.644e-12 | 5.702e-13 | 3.856e-14 | 2.048e-13 |
| 4.000e+01 | 1.704e-13 | 5.580e-12 | 2.697e-12 | 1.262e-12 | 8.489e-13 |
| 1.000e+02 | 6.177e-12 | 2.026e-13 | 3.958e-14 | 1.421e-13 | 1.586e-13 |
Table 2b. Relative Error between and 200
If we consider smaller channels such as and 0.0001, shown in Table 2c and as the error observed in Table 2d, the error is of a larger order than for widths above or equal to 0.05. For width 0.001, the flow rate does match four places of the method [7] and the error is acceptable, but for width 0.0001, it is not. Below width 0.001; therefore, we conclude the response matrix solution is no longer valid and requires a change in solution strategy, which is the subject of a future investigation. Otherwise, the results of Table 2a agree to all 5 places of Ref [3] with rounding, to all four places of Refs [6 and 7] and to all 7 places of Ref [9] representing some of the most precise values of Poiseuille flow rates found in today’s literature.
| 0.5 | 0.8 | 0.88 | 0.96 | 1.0 | |
| 1.0000e-04 | 1.449009e+01 | 7.896153e+00 | 6.844253e+00 | 5.95324e+00 | 5.55660e+00 |
| 1.0000e-03 | 1.068924e+01 | 5.978254e+00 | 5.214431e+00 | 4.56414e+00 | 4.27360e+00 |
Table 2c. Convergence of Flow Rate for , CPU = 23s
| 0.5 | 0.8 | 0.88 | 0.96 | 1.0 | |
| 1.000e-04 | 1.719e-04 | 3.136e-04 | 3.608e-04 | 4.133e-04 | 4.417e-04 |
| 1.000e-03 | 7.824e-07 | 1.399e-06 | 1.605e-06 | 1.832e-06 | 1.957e-06 |
Table 2d. Relative Error Relative Error
For further confirmation, we refer to the interaction principle. The interaction principle considers the channel a homogeneous scattering medium that scatters molecules into and out of the channel boundaries (centerline and wall). The medium equally reflects and transmits molecules entering the channel from either boundary. Thus, if and are the overall reflectance and transmittance matrix coefficients for the channel depending upon only the thickness and scattering properties, one can write from physical reasoning, the exiting density distributions are
or in vector form
which is the interaction principle. Thus, the density exiting the wall results from that reflected from the incoming at the wall through the accommodation coefficient and the contribution transmitted from the centerline. Likewise, the exiting density at the centerline results from reflection of the incoming molecules at the centerline and transmission from the wall to the centerline. In comparing Eq(54c) with Eq(35a), we find
Thus, the response matrix should be block symmetric, which we indeed observed in our calculation.
Exiting Microscopic Velocity Profile
The final calculation is for the exiting microscopic velocity profiles from Eqs(38a,b). Our objective is to find the exiting densities for an arbitrary series of microscopic velocities . There are several ways of proceeding. One could solve Eqs(12) with replaced by for
requiring additional solutions to ODEs, which are straightforward since we know analytically for each quadrature order and all . The simplest approach however is to first note is independent of the microscopic velocity. In this case, one can simply add edits (called faux quadrature edits) to the quadrature list as if they were quadratures but have a zero weight [12, 19]. In this way, the response matrix formulation interpolates to give the additional edits in the output list, but does not change the scattering integral since the edits enter with zero weight. Faux quadratures are also a way to measure the precision of the calculation since they exist in each quadrature order and therefore provide a relative error as the order increases.
The converged exiting distributions, shown in Table 3, are for the following chosen set of faux edits
| 1.31325920e-02 | 1.87449029e+00 | 1.43220923e+00 |
| 6.98521513e-02 | 1.87207461e+00 | 1.51665953e+00 |
| 1.74704896e-01 | 1.85316653e+00 | 1.60291016e+00 |
| 3.33101149e-01 | 1.76408706e+00 | 1.67031959e+00 |
| 5.54364553e-01 | 1.65453384e+00 | 1.69443054e+00 |
| 8.54342679e-01 | 1.72997909e+00 | 1.72528197e+00 |
| 1.26124074e+00 | 2.26800624e+00 | 1.97660821e+00 |
| 1.83073806e+00 | 3.74963767e+00 | 2.90547577e+00 |
| 2.69609717e+00 | 7.42638684e+00 | 5.66720498e+00 |
| 4.33921731e+00 | 1.87634259e+01 | 1.52624303e+01 |
| 8.51719319e+00 | 7.22755937e+01 | 6.44636970e+01 |
Table 3. Edit exiting microscopic velocity distribution
and for
For only linear convergence, the relative error between quadratures of all orders is and at the centerline and wall respectively. The faux quadrature edits, plotted on the converged solution in Figure 2, show perfect agreement.

Figure 1 (PDF p. 26). Faux edits imposed on converged analytical solution.
Conclusion
Poiseuille flow is a fundamental flow of rarefied gas dynamics. Over the years, many excellent solutions have appeared in the literature that are mathematically elegant, but are also mathematically sophisticated and numerically challenging and lack precision. Some give analytical representations at the cost of possibly several time-consuming iterative procedures. However, at the turn of the century, it was the genius of C.E. Siewert and co-workers who revived Chandrasekhar’s discrete ordinates method of radiative transfer. It again has became fashionable to solve discretized transport equations, like for Poiseuille flow [3], in terms of practical exponential eigenfunctions and eigenvalues expansions with diagonalization, one of the most developed of all numerical algorithms. These solutions, however, while straightforward, were limited to the set of order first order discrete ordinates ODEs.
In this presentation, we approach the transport solution as second order ODEs. The admitted solutions are trigonometric and hyperbolic functions depending on whether the eigenvalues are real or imaginary. After diagonalization and forming a customized solution, the boundary conditions immediately appear into the general solution without further matrix inversion since there is no need to solve a separate set of linear equations to incorporate boundary conditions. This is but one of many possible solutions representations. As a result, an analytical solution emerges to give the microscopic velocity distribution. By integrating, we specify the macroscopic velocity and the flow rate, which are the common quantities of interest.
By solving the second order form for a series of quadrature orders , one converges the resulting sequence for any dependent variable as become large. Convergence is either linear element by element or through the Wynn-epsilon algorithm. With a converged solution, three benchmarks to 8 places have been established for the macroscopic velocity, flow rate and the microscopic velocity.
References
- [1]P. L. Bhatnagar, E. P. Gross and M. Krook, A Model for Collision Processes in Gases. I. Small Amplitude Processes in Charged and Neutral One-Component Systems, Phys. Rev. 94, 511-524, (1954).DOI
- [2]M.M.R. Williams, A review of the Rarefied Gas Dynamics Theory Associated with some Classical Problems in Flow and Heat Transfer, Z. Angew. Math. Phys. 52, 500-516, (2001).DOI
- [3]L.B. Barichello and C.E. Siewert, A Discrete-ordinates Solution for Poiseuille Flow in a Plane Channel, Z. Angew. Math. Phys. 50, 972-981, (1999).DOI
- [4]C. Cercignani and A. Daneri, Flow of a Rarefied Gas Between Two Parallel Plates, J. Appl. Phys. 34, 3509-3513, (1963).DOI
- [5]C. Cercignani, Plane Poiseuille Flow According to the Method of Elementary Solutions, J. Math. Anal. Appl. 12, 254-262, (1965).DOI
- [6]S. K. Loyalka, N. Petrellis and T. S. Storvick, Some Exact Numerical Results for the BGK Model: Couette, Poiseuille and Thermal Creep Flow between Parallel Plates, Z. Angew. Math. Phys. 30, 514-521, (1979).DOI
- [7]C. E. Siewert, R. D. M. Garcia and P. Grandjean, A Concise and Accurate Solution for Poiseuille Flow in a Plane Channel, J. Math. Phys. 21, 2760-2763, (1980).DOI
- [8]B.D. Ganapol, Poiseuille Channel Flow by Adding and Doubling, 30ᵗʰ International Symposium on Rarefied Gas Dynamics, 1786-1793, (2016).DOI
- [9]Mario De Florio, Enrico Schiassi, B.D. Ganapol and Roberto Furfaro, Physics-Informed Neural Networks for Rarefied-gas Dynamics: Poiseuille flow in the BGK Approximation, Z. Angew. Math. Phys. 73:126, (2022).DOI
- [10]V. Boffi, L. De Socio, G. Gauri and C. Pescatore, Rigorous Constructive Solution to Monodimensional Poiseuille and Thermal Creep Flows, Meccanica 11, 183-190, (1976).DOI
- [11]B.D. Ganapol and J.K. Patel, Response Matrix Benchmark for the 1D Transport Equation with Matrix Scaling, in press, PHYSOR, (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2407.07905
- [12]B.D, Ganapol, The Response Matrix Discrete-ordinates Solution to the 1D Radiative Transfer Equation, JQSRT, 154, 72–90, (2015).DOI
- [13]I. Stegun, M. Abramowitz Handbook of Mathematical Functions, (1965).
- [14]B.D. Ganapol and J.K. Patel, Matrix Riccati Equation Solution of the Radiative Transfer Equation, JCTT, v50, 297-327, (2021).
- [15]I.P. Grant and G.E. Hunt, Discrete Space Theory of Radiative Transfer I. Fundamentals. ProcRSocA, 313:183–97, (1969).DOI
- [16]K. Lathrop and B. Carlson, Discrete-ordinates Angular Quadrature of the Neutron Transport Equation, LASL Report, LA-3186, (1964).
- [17]B.D. Ganapol and J.K. Patel, DPN Solution of the 1D Monoenergetic Neutron Transport Equation with Benchmarking, ANS Trans, Washington DC, (2018).
- [18]A. Sidi, Practical Extrapolations Methods, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, (2003).
- [19]E.S. Chalhoub and R.D.M. Garcia, The Equivalence Between Two Techniques of Angular Interpolation for the Discrete-ordinates Method, JQSRT, 64, 517–35, (2000).DOI