betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Infinite Index Identities for Argyres-Douglas Theories and Graded Vector Space Isomorphisms for VOAs

Abstract

Supersymmetric indices provide stringent tests of dualities between superconformal field theories (SCFTs). We establish infinite families of Schur-index identities among four-dimensional N=2\mathcal N=2 Argyres-Douglas (AD) theories, with the logarithms of their fugacities related linearly. These identities connect theories with markedly different physical properties without requiring infrared duality, while still implying simple relations among their central charges and flavor levels. Through the SCFT/VOA correspondence, they become character identities for the associated affine and WW-algebras. One broad family relates Dp(G)D_p(G) and (A(h+1)(p−1),G)(A_{(h+1)(p-1)},G) theories, corresponding to affine and principal WW-algebras at boundary admissible levels. At the level of the underlying state spaces, these character identities suggest that the corresponding VOAs are related by graded vector space isomorphisms, which are weaker than full VOA isomorphisms. We explicitly construct such a graded isomorphism between the VOAs associated with (A1,A4p−3)(A_1,A_{4p-3}) and (A1,D2p)(A_1,D_{2p}). We also show the correspondence for universal affine and principal WW-algebras and test its compatibility with their simple quotients by matching the lowest-degree null states. We establish analogous character identities for certain non-vacuum modules in concrete examples and conjecture a broader extension. Finally, beyond the SCFT/VOA correspondence, we discover similar identities between level-one affine and Virasoro algebras, whose further generalizations point toward a new spectral level-rank duality in WZW models.

Introduction and summary

Superconformal indices play a central role in the study of supersymmetric quantum field theories. They encode infinitely many protected quantities and provide powerful tools for studying dualities, renormalization-group flows, moduli spaces, and, through the AdS/CFT correspondence, black-hole entropy. In particular, they furnish stringent tests of infrared (IR) dualities: distinct ultraviolet descriptions that flow to the same IR fixed point are expected to yield identical superconformal indices. Such agreement provides strong evidence for a proposed duality by matching an infinite collection of protected quantities. When the indices admit contour-integral or infinite sum representations, these equalities also yield highly nontrivial identities of independent mathematical interest.

In this paper, we investigate a weaker notion of index matching: indices of theories that need not be IR dual can coincide after simple but nontrivial redefinitions and specializations of fugacities. Focusing on the Schur indices of four-dimensional N=2\mathcal{N}=2 superconformal field theories (SCFTs), we systematically construct and prove infinitely many such identities. Through the SCFT/VOA correspondence, these results translate into identities among specialized characters of vertex operator algebras (VOAs).

Our primary examples are Argyres–Douglas (AD) theories with class S\mathcal{S} realizations involving an irregular puncture and, in some cases, an additional regular puncture [1]. In suitable cases, the associated VOAs are affine vertex algebras or WW-algebras at admissible levels [2]. These VOAs have a well-developed mathematical structure, including systematic constructions via Drinfeld–Sokolov (DS) reduction and uniform formulas for their characters [3, 4, 5]. They therefore provide a broad, mathematically tractable setting in which to identify and establish such relations.

A precursor to our construction is the identity I(A1,A6n)(q)=I(A1,D2n+1)(q3;q1/2)\mathcal{I}_{(A_{1},A_{6n})}(q)=\mathcal{I}_{(A_{1},D_{2n+1})}\left(q^{3};q^{1/2}\right) for n≥1n\ge1, established in [6]. The associated VOAs are Virasoro and affine vertex algebras, respectively. This identity was itself motivated by a relation between the indices of AD theories and N=4\mathcal{N}=4 super-Yang–Mills theories [7, 8]. Our construction extends these results to a broad range of SCFTs and VOAs.

For illustration, we present a few simple, representative examples:

I(AN−1,A(p−1)(N+1))(q)=IDp(SU(N))(qN+1;{qs−(N+1)/2}s=1N),gcd⁡(p,N)=1,\mathcal{I}_{(A_{N-1},A_{(p-1)(N+1)})}(q)=\mathcal{I}_{D_{p}(SU(N))}\left(q^{N+1};\left\{q^{s-(N+1)/2}\right\}_{s=1}^{N}\right),\qquad\gcd(p,N)=1,
I(A1,A4p−3)(q;w)=I(A1,D2p)(q2;y=q1/2,w),p≥2,\mathcal{I}_{(A_{1},A_{4p-3})}(q;w)=\mathcal{I}_{(A_{1},D_{2p})}\left(q^{2};y=q^{1/2},w\right),\qquad p\ge2,
I(A2,A4)(q)=I(A1,A5)(q2;1).\mathcal{I}_{(A_{2},A_{4})}(q)=\mathcal{I}_{(A_{1},A_{5})}(q^{2};1).

These examples illustrate different features of our construction. The first generalizes the identity of [6] to higher rank, relating affine vertex algebras to principal WW-algebras. The second retains nontrivial flavor dependence on both sides, whereas the third relates unflavored indices. Combining the second and third examples further shows that these identities can be composed into chains connecting more than two SCFTs.

The index identities also imply relations among the anomaly coefficients of the SCFTs, including their aa and cc central charges and flavor levels. These relations follow by comparing the high-temperature asymptotics of the indices. In particular, the effective central charges obey a universal rescaling relation, with the rescaling fixed by the power of qq appearing in the index identity.

These exact index identities also suggest structural connections between the underlying VOAs. More precisely, they imply graded vector space isomorphisms (GVISOs), with gradings defined by suitable combinations of conformal weights and flavor charges.1 This was first studied in [7]. Such isomorphisms are weaker than VOA isomorphisms, which must also preserve operator product expansions (OPEs) and normally ordered products. We seek a direct realization of these GVISOs in terms of VOA states and their relations. For a particular pair of VOAs, we explicitly construct the map and prove that it defines a GVISO. We also examine the obstacles to a general construction. For the universal affine and principal WW-algebras considered here, the correspondence follows from a one-to-one matching of modes. Passing to the simple quotients, however, requires compatibility with null relations, making the construction substantially more subtle. Nevertheless, we explicitly demonstrate the matching of the lowest-degree null states on the two sides.

We further extend our discussion to non-vacuum VOA modules and their interpretation in terms of surface-defect insertions in the SCFTs. Analogous character and index identities also arise in this setting. The problem is more intricate than for vacuum modules: VOA modules generally have complicated structures, simple character formulas are not always available, and the numbers of modules on the two sides can differ substantially. In an example involving three AD theories, we analyze these issues in detail and establish character identities relating selected modules of the corresponding VOAs. We conjecture a broader extension to suitable non-vacuum modules and outline its form for affine and principal WW-algebras at boundary admissible levels. In this setting, we express the module characters in plethystic exponential (PE) form, obtaining formulas useful for studying SCFTs with surface defects. A detailed treatment of the general extension, including its proof, is left to future work.

Finally, we extend the discussion beyond the SCFT/VOA correspondence. We establish a GVISO between a level-one affine VOA and the Ising VOA, together with explicit character identities that extend to non-vacuum modules. A free-field realization in terms of Majorana fermions provides a direct explanation of this correspondence. Generalizing further, this example leads us to character relations between pairs of affine VOAs whose ranks and levels are exchanged. We refer to these relations as spectral level-rank dualities, emphasizing the correspondence between graded state spaces under an exchange of rank and level. This terminology distinguishes them from the conventional topological level-rank dualities in Wess–Zumino–Witten (WZW) models, or Chern–Simons (CS) theories via the CS/WZW correspondence.

The paper is organized as follows. § 2 reviews the SCFT/VOA correspondence and the high-temperature asymptotics of Schur indices, and explains how index identities constrain anomaly coefficients. § 3 presents the basic family of index identities relating (AN−1,A(p−1)(N+1))(A_{N-1}, A_{(p-1)(N+1)}) and Dp(SU(N))D_p(SU(N)). § 4 further extends this construction to identities relating (A(p−1)(h+1),G)(A_{(p-1)(h+1)}, G) and Dp(G)D_p(G). § 5 develops the general construction and establishes further families of index identities for a broader class of AD theories. § 6 investigates explicit GVISOs between the underlying VOAs, going beyond character matching. § 7 explores extensions to non-vacuum modules. § 8 extends the analysis beyond the SCFT/VOA correspondence. § 9 concludes with a discussion of open questions. The appendices collect further technical details.

SCFT/VOA correspondence and index identity

Review of the SCFT/VOA correspondence

Every 4d N=2\mathcal{N}=2 SCFT can be associated with a vertex operator algebra or chiral algebra [9]

V:4d N=2 SCFT→VOA.(1)\mathbb{V}: 4\mathrm{d}\ \mathcal{N}=2\ \mathrm{SCFT} \to\mathrm{VOA}. \tag*{(1)}

The SCFT/VOA correspondence captures the Schur sector of the SCFTs.

Two important entries in the SCFT/VOA dictionary are

c2d=−12c4d,k2d=−12k4d.(2)c_{2d}=-12c_{4d}, \qquad k_{2d}=-\frac{1}{2}k_{4d}. \tag*{(2)}

The Schur index is defined as

I=Tr⁡(−1)FqE−RxxJ,q=e2πiτ,x=e2πiz,(3)\mathcal{I}=\operatorname{Tr}(-1)^Fq^{E-R_x}x^J,\qquad q=e^{2\pi i\tau},\qquad x=e^{2\pi iz}, \tag*{(3)}

where the trace is taken over all Schur operators, JJ is the flavor symmetry generator and xx is its fugacity. A generalization to multiple flavor fugacities is straightforward.

In particular, the SCFT/VOA correspondence implies that the Schur index of a 4d N=2\mathcal{N}=2 SCFT T\mathcal{T} is identified with the vacuum (super)character of the associated VOA [9]

IT=χV[T].(4)\mathcal{I}_{\mathcal{T}}=\chi_{\mathcal{V}[\mathcal{T}]}. \tag*{(4)}

In this paper, χ\chi denotes the normalized character, and χ^=q−c/24χ\widehat{\chi}=q^{-c/24}\chi denotes the full character. The former has the nice feature that it starts with 1 for the unique vacuum and coincides with the index, while the latter transforms covariantly under modular transformations.

Cardy limit of the Schur index

In this subsection, we would like to make full use of the modular property in order to study the high temperature or Cardy limit of the Schur index. See [10, 11] for previous discussions.

The VOAs associated with 4d SCFTs are expected to be quasi-lisse in general. For a quasi-lisse VOA, its full vacuum character satisfies an MLDE [10, 12]. The solution space of MLDE gives a vector valued modular form, which includes the vacuum and non-vacuum module characters. Note that the modular vector may also need logarithmic or pseudotrace solutions in addition to ordinary module characters.

As a result, under the SS transformation, the character vectors formed by the solutions of MLDEs transform as 2

χ^(−1/τ)=Sχ^(τ).(5)\widehat{\chi}(-1/\tau)=S\widehat{\chi}(\tau). \tag*{(5)}

Taking into account possible logarithmic solutions, each character can be chosen to admit an expansion of the following form 3

χ^i(τ)=qhi−c/24Ai(−log⁡q/(2π))di[1+O(qϵ)],di∈N,Ai≠0,ϵ>0.(6)\widehat{\chi}_i(\tau)=q^{h_i-c/24}A_i\left(-\log q/(2\pi)\right)^{d_i}\left[1+O\left(q^\epsilon\right)\right],\qquad d_i\in\mathbb{N},\qquad A_i\ne0,\qquad\epsilon>0. \tag*{(6)}

Taking the limit τ→+∞i\tau\to+\infty i, we learn from the SS transformation (5) that

χ^0(−1/τ)=∑iS0ie2πiτ(hi−c/24)[Ai(−log⁡q/(2π))di+O(e2πiϵτ)].(7)\widehat{\chi}_0(-1/\tau)=\sum_i S_{0i}e^{2\pi i\tau(h_i-c/24)}\left[A_i\left(-\log q/(2\pi)\right)^{d_i}+O\left(e^{2\pi i\epsilon\tau}\right)\right]. \tag*{(7)}

The dominant contribution comes from the one with the smallest hih_i and largest exponent did_i 4

hmin⁡=min⁡{hi∣S0i≠0},dmax⁡=max⁡{di∣hi=hmin⁡,S0i≠0}.(8)h_{\min}=\min\{h_i\mid S_{0i}\ne0\},\qquad d_{\max}=\max\{d_i\mid h_i=h_{\min},S_{0i}\ne0\}. \tag*{(8)}

We can then rewrite (7) and get the following asymptotic growth in the limit τ→i0+\tau\to i0^{+}

χ(τ)=e2πiτc2d/24e−2πi(hmin⁡−c2d/24)/τ(−iτ)−dmax⁡[∑i:hi=hmin⁡AiS0i(−iτ)dmax⁡−di+O(e−#/Im⁡τ)](9)\chi(\tau) = e^{2\pi i\tau c_{2d}/24}e^{-2\pi i(h_{\min}-c_{2d}/24)/\tau}(-i\tau)^{-d_{\max}}\left[\sum_{i:h_i=h_{\min}} A_iS_{0i}(-i\tau)^{d_{\max}-d_i}+O(e^{-\#/ \operatorname{Im}\tau})\right] \tag*{(9)}

where we omit the subscript 0 for the vacuum.

The universal expansion of the index is given by

log⁡I=log⁡χ=πi12τceff+γlog⁡(−iτ)+log⁡S+πiτC12+⋯ ,(10)\log\mathcal{I} = \log\chi= \frac{\pi i}{12\tau}c^{\mathrm{eff}}+\gamma\log(-i\tau)+\log S+\frac{\pi i\tau C}{12}+\cdots, \tag*{(10)}

where the dots represent the exponentially small terms. By comparison, we find

ceff=c2d−24hmin⁡,γ=−dmax⁡,S(τ)=∑i:hi=hmin⁡AiS0i(−iτ)dmax⁡−di,C=c2d,(11)c^{\mathrm{eff}}=c_{2d}-24h_{\min},\qquad\gamma=-d_{\max},\qquad S(\tau)=\sum_{i:h_i=h_{\min}}A_iS_{0i}(-i\tau)^{d_{\max}-d_i},\qquad C=c_{2d}, \tag*{(11)}

where SS is a finite polynomial of τ\tau, and only the minimal-exponent sector belongs in this polynomial.5

The logarithmic term γlog⁡(−iτ)\gamma\log(-i\tau) is absent if the MLDE has no logarithmic solution and the TT matrix is diagonalizable, which holds for rational VOAs. In such a case di=dmax⁡=0d_i=d_{\max}=0, and SS is just a constant, which is related to the modular SS-matrix.6

References

  1. [1]D. Xie, General Argyres-Douglas Theory, JHEP 01 (2013) 100 [1204.2270].
  2. [2]J. Song, D. Xie and W. Yan, Vertex operator algebras of Argyres-Douglas theories from M5-branes, JHEP 12 (2017) 123 [1706.01607].DOI
  3. [3]P. Bouwknegt and K. Schoutens, W symmetry in conformal field theory, Phys. Rept. 223 (1993) 183 [hep-th/9210010].DOI
  4. [4]E. Frenkel, V. G. Kac and M. Wakimoto, Characters and fusion rules for W-algebras via quantized Drinfeld-Sokolov reduction, Communications in Mathematical Physics 147 (1992) 295.
  5. [5]V. G. Kac and M. Wakimoto, A remark on boundary level admissible representations, 1612.07423.
  6. [6]D. Adamovic and S. Möller, Character identities between affine and Virasoro vertex operator algebra modules, Math. Z. 313 (2026) 87 [2511.2021].DOI
  7. [7]M. Buican and T. Nishinaka, N = 4 SYM, Argyres-Douglas theories, and an exact graded vector space isomorphism, JHEP 04 (2022) 028 [2012.13209].arxiv.org/abs/2012.13209
  8. [8]H. Jiang, Modularity in Argyres-Douglas theories with a = c, JHEP 06 (2024) 131 [2403.05223].arxiv.org/abs/2403.05323
  9. [9]C. Beem, M. Lemos, P. Liendo, W. Peelaers, L. Rastelli and B. C. van Rees, Infinite Chiral Symmetry in Four Dimensions, Commun. Math. Phys. 336 (2015) 1359 [1312.5844].DOI
  10. [10]C. Beem and L. Rastelli, Vertex operator algebras, Higgs branches, and modular differential equations, JHEP 08 (2018) 114 [1707.07679].DOI
  11. [11]A. Arabi Ardehali, M. Martone and M. Rosselló, High-temperature expansion of the Schur index and modularity, 2308.09738.
  12. [12]T. Arakawa and K. Kawasetsu, Quasi-lisse vertex algebras and modular linear differential equations, 1610.05865.arxiv.org/abs/1610.05865
  13. [13]P. C. Argyres and M. R. Douglas, New phenomena in SU(3) supersymmetric gauge theory, Nucl. Phys. B 448 (1995) 93 [hep-th/9505062].
  14. [14]Y. Wang and D. Xie, Codimension-two defects and Argyres-Douglas theories from outer-automorphism twist in 6d (2, 0) theories, Phys. Rev. D 100 (2019) 025001 [1805.08839].DOI
  15. [15]S. Cecotti, A. Neitzke and C. Vafa, R-Twisting and 4d/2d Correspondences, 1006.3435.
  16. [16]D. Xie, W. Yan and S.-T. Yau, Chiral algebra of the Argyres-Douglas theory from M5 branes, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 065003 [1604.02155].DOI
  17. [17]H. Jiang, An Infinite Family of Non-Rational VOAs from Strongly Coupled 4d Higgsless SCFTs, 2609.02437.arxiv.org/abs/2609.02437
  18. [18]Y. Yoshida, SCFT/VOA correspondence and R-twisted reductions of (A₂, D₃ₙ₋₂) Argyres–Douglas theories, 2609.04099.arxiv.org/abs/2609.04099
  19. [19]S. Cecotti, M. Del Zotto and S. Giacomelli, More on the N=2 superconformal systems of type Dₚ(G), JHEP 04 (2013) 153 [1303.3149].DOI
  20. [20]Y. Wang and D. Xie, Classification of argyres-douglas theories from m5 branes, Physical Review D 94 (2016) .DOI
  21. [22]T. Arakawa, Associated varieties of modules over Kac-Moody algebras and C(2)-cofiniteness of W-algebras, 1004.1554.
  22. [23]D. Xie and W. Yan, Schur sector of Argyres-Douglas theory and W-algebra, SciPost Phys. 10 (2021) 080 [1904.09094].DOI
  23. [24]T. Arakawa, J. Van Ekeren and A. Moreau, Singularities of nilpotent Slodowy slices and collapsing levels of W-algebras, Forum Math. Sigma 12 (2024) e95 [2102.13462].DOI
  24. [25]V. G. Kac and M. Wakimoto, Classification of modular invariant representations of affine algebras, in Infinite-Dimensional Lie Algebras and Groups, V. G. Kac, ed., vol. 7 of Advanced Series in Mathematical Physics, pp. 138–177, World Scientific, (1989), https://ncatlab.org/schreiber/files/KacWakimotoClassification.pdf.
  25. [26]T. Arakawa, Representation theory of superconformal algebras and the Kac–Roan–Wakimoto conjecture, Duke Mathematical Journal 130 (2005) 435 [math-ph/0405015].arxiv.org/abs/math-ph/0405015
  26. [27]T. Creutzig, W-algebras for Argyres-Douglas theories, 1701.05926.
  27. [28]D. Adamovic, T. Creutzig, N. Genra and J. Yang, The Vertex Algebras R^(p) and V^(p), Commun. Math. Phys. 383 (2021) 1207 [2001.08048].DOI
  28. [29]L. Benoit and Y. Saint-Aubin, Degenerate conformal field theories and explicit expressions for some null vectors, Physics Letters B 215 (1988) 517.DOI
  29. [30]T. Arakawa, Two-sided bgg resolutions of admissible representations, Representation Theory 18 (2014) 183.DOI
  30. [31]T. Creutzig and A. R. Linshaw, Trialities of W-algebras, Cambridge J. Math. 10 (2022) 69 [2005.10234].
  31. [32]C. Cordova, D. Gaiotto and S.-H. Shao, Surface Defects and Chiral Algebras, JHEP 05 (2017) 140 [1704.01955].DOI
  32. [33]Z. Fehily, K. Kawasetsu and D. Ridout, Classifying relaxed highest-weight modules for admissible-level Bershadsky–Polyakov algebras, Communications in Mathematical Physics 385 (2021) 859 [2007.03917].DOI
  33. [34]H. Jiang, Character identities for modules of affine vertex algebras and w-algebras, in preparation, .
  34. [35]P. H. Ginsparg, APPLIED CONFORMAL FIELD THEORY, in Les Houches Summer School in Theoretical Physics: Fields, Strings, Critical Phenomena, 9, 1988, hep-th/9108028.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9108028
  35. [36]J. Bockenhauer, An Algebraic formulation of level one Wess-Zumino-Witten models, Rev. Math. Phys. 8 (1996) 925 [hep-th/9507047].DOI
  36. [37]D. Delmastro, J. Gomis and M. Yu, Infrared phases of 2d QCD, JHEP 02 (2023) 157 [2108.02202].arxiv.org/abs/2108.02202
  37. [38]H. Jiang, Spectral level-rank duality, in preparation, .
  38. [39]M. Butorac, S. Kožić, A. Meurman and M. Primc, Lepowsky’s and wakimoto’s product formulas for the affine lie algebras C_l^(1), Journal of Algebra 660 (2024) 147 [2403.05456].
  39. [41]H. Jiang, Macdonald index from vertex-operator algebras and graded unitarity, Phys. Rev. D 114 (2026) 025022 [2603.29829].DOI
  40. [42]S. O. Warnaar, Ramanujan’s 1ψ1 summation, 2012.

Paper details

vlnc:W_yxr8pgdg
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

AI tools

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents