WorksMathematics
On the ring of bounded functions on the character variety
Abstract
Let denote the character variety associated to the group , where is the ring of integers in a finite extension . is a rigid analytic variety parametrizing locally -analytic characters. Let denote the global sections bounded by . In this paper we prove that , answering the question posed in [AB24].
Introduction
Let be a finite extension of with completed algebraic closure . The character variety was first defined by Schneider and Teitelbaum [8] in the context of -adic Fourier theory. is a rigid analytic variety defined over whose set of -points , for complete, is the set of locally -analytic characters .
The character variety appears in the approach of Berger, Schneider and Xie to the Lubin-Tate generalization of cyclotomic -modules in [5]. This approach is motivated by the possibility of generalizing the -adic local Langlands correspondence from to . One of the reasons that appears is that the ring of global bounded functions, denoted , has a natural action of the monoid analogous to that in the classical setting. Lubin-Tate analogues of cyclotomic -modules are defined over the rings that we get by localizing and completing .
In this paper we consider the subring consisting of global functions bounded by on the character variety. Ardakov and Berger in [1] study, among other things, the question whether every distribution bounded by comes from an integral measure, or equivalently, whether , see [1 Question 1.1.1]. Here denotes the completed group ring and the map is given by integration against the measure.
In [1] several different criteria that imply are proved. The question was further studied in the quadratic unramified case by Berger and Sprang in [4]. In this paper we prove
Theorem 1.1. It holds that .
In independent work, Berger, Sprang and Steingart prove the same result for quadratic extensions of using different methods.
The starting point of the proof of Theorem 1.1 is a reduction to the integrality of a trace operator by using [1 Theorem 3.1.9], see Lemma 3.1. We prove the integrality of this operator using a version of analytic boundary results from [2] in combination with a modification of Tate’s classical result on absolute values of traces in deeply ramified field extensions given in Lemma 3.6. A key step in the proof is the connection between partial trace operators, which are used to factorize the trace operator from [1 Theorem 3.1.9], and a normalized arithmetic trace, see Proposition 3.4. For more details, see the sketch of the proof of Theorem 1.1 in § 2.6.
Theorem 1.1 has the following interesting corollary for integer valued polynomials, see [1 Theorem 4.2.21]. Let denote the ring of integer valued polynomials on . Denote the formal Lubin-Tate action1 by . Recall from [1 Section 1.5] the definition where . Here .
Corollary 1.2. The following equality holds: .
Related results were studied in [7 Tat99], where it was proven that the space of coefficients generates as an algebra over . Theorem B from [4] implies that is -adically dense in . Corollary 1.2 strengthens these results by showing that generate all integer valued polynomials as an -module.
Note that when , the Lubin-Tate formal group can be taken to be the formal multiplicative group . In this case Corollary 1.2 recovers the classical fact that all integer valued polynomials over are -linear combinations of binomial coefficients . In this regard, Corollary 1.2 can be interpreted as a statement that the “generalized” binomial coefficients span all integer valued polynomials.
Remark 1.3. In [6 Remark 2.5], Colmez showed that a locally -analytic -valued distribution on with bounded Fourier transform has order at most , where . If such a distribution is defined over , Theorem 1.1 implies that has order .
Structure of the paper
1.1. Structure of the paper. Section 2 collects the necessary background and provides a sketch of the proof of Theorem 1.1. Section 3 contains the proof of Theorem 1.1. Section 4 contains the proof of a result about unions of fibers being an analytic boundary. Section 5 contains the proof of our reformulation of a classical result of Tate about the behaviour of normalised traces in deeply ramified extensions.
Acknowledgements
I want to thank Konstantin Ardakov for many valuable discussions, interesting insights and invaluable guidance and support. I want to thank Laurent Berger and Andrew Graham for the discussion related to the question. I want to thank Konstantin Ardakov, Laurent Berger, James Newton, Branislav Prvulović and Vukašin Stojisavljević for reading the first draft of the paper.
AI Declaration
AI assistance consisted of suggesting the relation with the arithmetic trace and pointing to the operators . No AI was used during the writing of the paper, but it was used to check the proofs and review the literature.
Notation and background
Fix a prime . Let denote the completed algebraic closure of . Let the norm on be normalized such that . Let be a finite extension of degree with ramification index and a uniformizer . Denote by the cardinality of the residue field. Let be a system of primitive -th roots of unity and denote , , .
The character variety
The character variety is a rigid analytic variety defined over whose set of -points , for complete, is the set of locally -analytic characters . Denote the global sections on by , the bounded global sections by , and the power-bounded global sections by . For the precise definition of the character variety see [8 Section 2].
The set is a group under pointwise multiplication of characters and we denote this multiplication by for . For we will use additive notation to mean . There is an action of on defined by . Let and denote the -torsion under this action by . Define and let denote the set of characters in whose -order is bigger than .
Remark 2.1. There exists a noncanonical isomorphism as -modules. One can use [5 Lemma 2.13], or argue directly as follows. Take a family of characters such that and has -order equal to , and consider the family of -module isomorphisms defined by sending . These maps are compatible, so we can take the inductive limit to get an -module isomorphism . Note that we view where the transition maps are given by multiplication by .
p-adic Fourier theory and Lubin-Tate isomorphism
Let denote the set of locally -analytic distributions on the additive group . These carry an action of defined by . One of the main results of [8 Theorem 2.3] is an isomorphism
This enables us to work with distributions, and we will be using this isomorphism implicitly2. Note that if , we can evaluate at a locally -analytic -valued function on .
Let denote the distributions corresponding to under this isomorphism. We call these bounded distributions. There is a multiplicative norm on given by
Distributions that have norm at most one under the isomorphism (1) correspond to . For more details see [5 p. 3 Remark, Corollary 1.23].
Let denote a Lubin-Tate group associated to , and let denote the open unit ball over . Denote the base change of the character variety to by . In [8 Theorem 3.6] it is proved that
Operators and
We recall the operators used in [1], and transport them to distributions via -adic Fourier theory and the LT isomorphism. Define the operator by , where denotes the Lubin-Tate action. This is a finite locally free map of constant rank, so we can define the normalized trace as the unique map such that
From now on, by transport and descent, we view these two operators as acting on distributions. We call them . After transport and descent, we get that acts on distributions as multiplication by , or in other words . The action of is given by
where is defined as on and as otherwise. For the proof of these claims see [9 Remark 4.1.4, Section 4.1.4].
Analytic boundary
We slightly modify the definition of an analytic boundary from [2] by restricting the family of distributions to -valued ones. We fix the norm on by the LT isomorphism from Section 2.2.
Definition 2.2. A subset of that satisfies with is called an analytic boundary if for all we have
The following result will play an important role.
Theorem 2.3 (Berger). Let be a nonnegative integer. Then is an analytic boundary. In particular, for we have .
The proof follows by combining [2 Theorem D] and [2 Lemma 1.1.3]. We record one useful lemma here.
Lemma 2.4. Let and with . Then if and only if . Furthermore, if , then
Specifically, if then .
Proof. The proof is immediate since multiplication by is surjective on by [9 Lemma 4.1.10].
Partial trace operators
Here we define partial trace operators that will be used to factorize . Since is a -module of rank , there exist elements such that they form a -basis of . Let .
Definition 2.5. For define
by $\psi_i(\lambda)=\lambda(1_{K_i}).
Sketch of the proof
Recall that is a system of primitive -th roots of unity.
We want to prove that , i.e. that the normalized trace operator is integral, see [1 Theorem 3.1.9]. The reduction to the integrality of the partial trace operators is formal, see Lemma 3.1.
Fix from now on one index and a distribution . To prove the integrality of the operator , i.e. that , we can use the theorem of Berger [2 Theorem D] that says that the norm of can be seen as the supremum of over all .
The main idea of the proof is that for sufficiently large integers and characters satisfying , , we have that the value can be seen as the normalized arithmetic trace for the totally ramified field extension , see Proposition 3.4 (compare to [3 p. 1023]). There are good estimates for these traces due to Tate, see [10 3.1, Corollary 2], which allow us to bound giving us the integrality of the operators .
Two issues remain. The first one is that extensions for small need not satisfy the hypothesis of Tate’s theorem (for example, these fields could be equal), so we need to be able to take large enough. The second issue is that for the trace formula to hold we need to restrict to characters satisfying . This is where Proposition 3.7 comes in, which is a version of [2 Theorem D] that restricts to the family of characters such that for large enough .
The geometric interpretation of the equality between the evaluation of at a torsion point and the normalized arithmetic trace is that the trace operator for finite étale (or finite locally free) maps commutes with base change. We apply this to the following unramified cover of degree , where is the character variety associated to the subgroup and the vertical arrow on the right is the restriction.
To elaborate further, take a large enough integer and take a character of order such that . Then has values in , and has values in . The fiber of the image of in is equal to . But this set is exactly the set of Galois conjugates of under the action of . Now the partial trace operator is equal to averaging over the fiber, see Lemma 3.2. However, the fiber consists of Galois conjugates as noted, so the averaging over the fiber is actually the normalized arithmetic trace.
The idea to connect arithmetic trace to evaluation at torsion points is already in the literature, see for example [3 p. 1023].
Proof of Theorem 1.1
We start the proof of Theorem 1.1 by reducing the statement to the integrality of the partial trace operators .
Lemma 3.1. To prove Theorem 1.1 it suffices to prove that for every .
Proof. We have
where the product means composition of operators. Indeed, we have that , and therefore
By [1 Theorem 3.1.9], to prove Theorem 1.1 it suffices to prove . By the assumption we have
which, combined with (2), gives us that
Lemma 2.4 gives us that
Since again by Lemma 2.4, we get that
Since , this finishes the proof. □
Now we study partial trace operators further. First we give a different interpretation of as an average over the fiber under restriction .
Lemma 3.2. For and we have
Proof. The lemma is equivalent to the statement that
which follows because is a character of order and this implies
Remark 3.3. In the Lubin-Tate coordinate, is given by .
As a consequence of Lemma 3.2 we have that preserves bounded distributions
and that these operators are bounded on .
The idea for proving the integrality of the operators is testing their values against by using Theorem 2.3. Since such are torsion, their values lie in cyclotomic extensions and hence they inherit a natural Galois action which we inspect. To bound the norm of , for , we will interpret the value as the value of the normalized trace of the cyclotomic extension. This equality is the key step in the entire proof. Recall that is a system of primitive -th roots of unity and , .
Proposition 3.4. Let and let be an integer. Suppose that and that is cyclic of degree . For we have and
Proof. Note that , and hence takes values in . Since torsion characters are locally constant, there exists a decomposition
But because is defined over , this shows that .
The group acts on , and we are interested in the orbit of . First we prove that the orbit of has cardinality . To do this, it is enough to prove that the stabilizer of has cardinality 1. Therefore let be such that . Note that since has exact order , there exists an such that . But we have that , which implies that .
We claim that for all . To prove this, it suffices to prove that acts trivially on . From the assumption that , we get that . This implies that , and so acts trivially on .
We have proved that the set gives us different elements of . On the other hand, since is cyclic of order , we have that . This shows that .
Note that because is defined over and is torsion and hence locally constant. Therefore
Applying Lemma 3.2 finishes the proof. □
Remark 3.5. Proposition 3.4 can also be deduced from the cyclotomic case of the trace formula in [3 p. 1023] by passing to the finite cyclic quotient defined by and extending scalars. The proof we give is direct.
The next step is to bound this trace. It turns out this is a direct corollary of the classic result by Tate [10 Section 3.1, Corollary 2]. We prove it in Section 5.
Lemma 3.6. For any there exists an integer such that for every we have that is Galois cyclic totally ramified of degree and
for all .
Recall that we want to prove that for . At this point we would like to apply a description of the norm as a supremum of over , as given in Theorem 2.3, and then apply Proposition 3.4 and Lemma 3.6 to bound these values. However, in order to apply Proposition 3.4 and Lemma 3.6, we need to restrict to the family of such that for large enough . To this end, we prove the following strengthening of Theorem 2.3.
Proposition 3.7. Let and let be a positive integer. The set
is an analytic boundary. In particular, for we have .
The proof of this proposition uses Theorem 2.3 and is given in Section 4.
We can now prove that the operators are integral by combining Proposition 3.4, Lemma 3.6 and Proposition 3.7.
Theorem 3.8. The operators are integral. In other words, .
Proof. For it suffices to prove that for every . Therefore, fix a nonzero and , and take to be large enough such that Lemma 3.6 holds. By Proposition 3.7 we have
and therefore it is enough to prove that
for every . In this regard, take and a positive integer such that we have . By the definition of , we have that .
By Proposition 3.4
and . Note also that since it follows that . Now, by the way we chose to satisfy Lemma 3.6, and because we have
This finishes the proof. □
Remark 3.9. The fact that is totally ramified is important only for Tate’s bound.
The proof of Theorem 1.1 follows by combining Theorem 3.8 and Lemma 3.1.
A union of fibers in is an analytic boundary
In this section we prove Proposition 3.7. Fix a positive integer throughout this section.
Let be an element of -order equal to and define
Let be the set of elements of whose -order is bigger than . The following lemma is just a linear algebra fact about the -module .
Lemma 4.1. There exists a finite set and an integer such that for every there exists such that .
Proof. For the proof is trivial, so we assume that . Let be a finite set such that every element of has a lift in , and take
We can take large enough, and we will see that it suffices to take . We take , and note that, because of our choice of , there exists a unique pair of integers , with and , such that has -order equal to . Since the action of on elements of -order in is transitive, we can find an element such that . Therefore , which implies that . □
Remark 4.2. The set works for any and only depends on the -order of .
Proof of Proposition 3.7. For we have , so by Theorem 2.3 we are done. Henceforth assume that . By Remark 2.1 we have an isomorphism as -modules, so we can take and as in Lemma 4.1, where is the -order of . By Theorem 2.3, for any , we have
Let and
Take some . Then from Lemma 4.1 it follows that there exists some such that . We have
Taking the supremum over and noting that by multiplicativity of the norm (§ 2.2) and Lemma 2.4, we get
Therefore we get . The reverse inequality is obvious, showing that . Finally, if has -order , by the proof of [1 Theorem 3.5.4] we have that
and the left-hand side tends to as tends to infinity, finishing the proof. □
Remark 4.3. For the argument in Theorem 3.8 we do not need that has points whose norm is tending to .
Normalized trace estimates for totally ramified -extensions
In this section we prove Lemma 3.6. Recall the following result of Tate [10 Section 3.1, Corollary 2]. Here is a complete discretely valued field of characteristic , with a perfect residue field of characteristic .
Theorem 5.1 (Tate). Let be a totally ramified Galois extension with Galois group . Let correspond to the subgroup . Then for every integer , is cyclic of degree and there exists a constant , independent of , such that for any
Recall that is a system of primitive -th roots of unity and that , , .
Proof of Lemma 3.6. Denote the residue fields of by , and note that the sequence is bounded and nondecreasing, and hence it stabilises. The sequence of numbers is nonincreasing and hence it stabilises. Take a large such that both of the sequences stabilise. Then we have for and these extensions are totally ramified. Next we prove that is totally ramified Galois with Galois group for all .
We have and this extension is totally ramified. Since , this is also Galois. Take . Then fixes and is determined by what it does to . This proves that the natural restriction map
is an injection. Since both groups have cardinality , this has to be an isomorphism. Finally we get
and note that since . This shows that is a totally ramified Galois extension with Galois group for all .
Finally let and and apply Tate’s theorem to get
for all and all . Now take large enough such that . Taking finishes the proof.
Uroš A. Colović, Mathematical Institute, University of Oxford
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]Konstantin Ardakov and Laurent Berger. “Bounded functions on the character variety”. In: Münster J. Math. 17.1 (2024), pp. 1–83. ISSN: 1867-5778,1867-5786. DOI: 10.17879/51958619387.DOI
- [2]Laurent Berger. “Lubin-Tate generalizations of the p-adic Fourier transform”. In: Bull. Soc. Math. France 153.2 (2025), pp. 559–573. ISSN: 0037-9484,2102-622X. DOI: 10.24033/bsmf.2906.DOI
- [3]Laurent Berger and Lionel Fourquaux. “Iwasawa theory and F-analytic Lubin-Tate (φ, Γ)-modules”. In: Doc. Math. 22 (2017), pp. 999–1030. ISSN: 1431-0635,1431-0643.DOI
- [4]Laurent Berger and Johannes Sprang. “Integer-valued polynomials and p-adic Fourier theory”. In: Rendiconti del Seminario Matematico della Università di Padova (2026). DOI: 10.4171/RSMUP/204.DOI
- [5]Laurent Berger, Peter Schneider, and Bingyong Xie. “Rigid character groups, Lubin–Tate theory, and (φ, Γ)-modules”. In: Mem. Amer. Math. Soc. 263.1275 (2020), pp. v+79. ISSN: 0065-9266,1947-6221. DOI: 10.1090/memo/1275.DOI
- [6]Pierre Colmez. “Représentations localement analytiques de GL₂(Qₚ) et (φ, Γ)-modules”. In: Representation Theory 20 (July 2016), pp. 187–248. DOI: 10.1090/ert/484.
- [7]Ehud de Shalit and Eran Iceland. “Integer valued polynomials and Lubin–Tate formal groups”. In: Journal of Number Theory 129.3 (2009), pp. 632–639.DOI
- [8]P. Schneider and J. Teitelbaum. “p-adic Fourier theory”. In: Doc. Math. 6 (2001), pp. 447–481. ISSN: 1431-0635,1431-0643.
- [9]Peter Schneider and Otmar Venjakob. Reciprocity laws for (φ_L, Γ_L)-modules over Lubin-Tate extensions. Vol. 24. Memoirs of the European Mathematical Society. EMS Press, Berlin, 2026. ISBN: 978-3-98547-100-3; 978-3-98547-600-8.DOI
- [10]J. T. Tate. “p-divisible groups”. In: Proc. Conf. Local Fields (Driebergen, 1966). Springer, Berlin-New York, 1967, pp. 158–183.DOI