betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

How pore-scale disorder controls fluid stretching in two-dimensional porous media

Abstract

Fluid stretching in porous media governs the mixing of reactants, contaminants, and nutrients, yet how the solid microstructure controls the stretching statistics remains poorly understood. We investigate how porous-medium heterogeneity controls stretching using (i) particle-tracking velocimetry experiments in 3D-printed millifluidic cells, (ii) numerical simulations of solute-plume deformation in the measured flow fields, and (iii) analytical calculations of fluid stretching. The cells contain arrays of cylindrical rods with systematically-varying disorder levels, from ordered to random. Velocity and shear-rate measurements reveal that fluid deformation is strongly localized near solid boundaries for all disorder levels, suggesting that near-wall flow is the main driver of stretching. The mean stretching grows linearly in time for ordered media and quadratically for disordered media, while the stretching distributions are approximately log-normal. We analytically describe the stretching produced by flow around an isolated cylinder and embed this description in a random-walk model that reproduces the observed stretching statistics in random media. These results provide the first quantitative connection between porous-medium structure and fluid-stretching statistics, revealing the extent to which disordered media accelerate mixing relative to ordered media and enabling progress beyond the common mean-field description of stretching in two-dimensional media as a simple shear flow.

Introduction

Solute mixing in porous media flows underlies numerous scientific applications, including contaminant transport and reactions in aquifers [43, 87, 72], microbial processes in the subsurface [10]; Turuban et al. 2025), and carbon dioxide sequestration in the subsurface [83, 77]. Mixing describes the process by which initially segregated chemicals diffuse toward uniformity due to the advective stirring of a flow field [65, 90]. Porous media flows provide complex velocity fields, which stretch solute fields into elongated filaments and sharpen transverse concentration gradients [47]. Because concentration gradients drive diffusion, predicting the evolution of concentration fields in porous media can be an intricate problem, even in non-turbulent flows [16]. Fluid deformation also couples to diverse phenomena of practical importance in addition to mixing, including the stability of viscoelastic fluids [61, 45], the transport of colloids and fibers [14, 22], and dynamics of immiscible droplets [81].

The lamellar theory provides a framework for relating mixing rates to flow-induced stretching [71, 66, 59, 20, 46, 80, 16]. This framework decomposes solute plumes into infinitesimal strips (the lamellae) and relates the evolution of solute concentrations to the stretching history of the individual lamellae [46, 90]. While fluid stretching has long been linked to the distributions of velocity and shear [64, 32, 19, 53], our understanding of how the interior structure of porous media controls the velocity and shear rate distributions remains limited [3, 18, 17, 2, 7]. Although solute mixing and chemical reactions have been quantified in a variety of laboratory and digital porous media [94, 80, 30, 15, 11] (Shafabakhsh et al. 2024; Shafabakhsh et al. 2025), there has been relatively little progress in connecting the underlying stretching statistics to the porous structure. Accordingly, we still lack the capability to explain mixing and reaction rates from the porous medium structure alone [47].

The statistics of fluid elongation scale differently with time in two- and three-dimensional steady flows [47]. In two-dimensional steady flows, the elongation moments grow algebraically with time (⟨qq⟩∼tα(q)\langle q^{q} \rangle\sim t^{\alpha(q)}), whether in open flows [80, 59] or in porous media [46, 19, 53]. The mean elongation exponent (q=1q = 1) ranges between α(1)=0.5\alpha(1) = 0.5 (sub-linear) and α(1)=2\alpha(1) = 2 (quadratic) in porous media [19, 47], with a higher exponent in more heterogeneous media, at least in random-permeability Darcy flows [46]. Earlier studies have assumed that linear mean elongation (α(1)=1\alpha(1) = 1) applies in disordered media to successfully explain some observed fluid-mixing properties [39, 11]. Understanding the limits of this linear-elongation assumption in two-dimensional porous media and relating the higher elongation moments to the medium structure remain significant open problems.

In three-dimensional porous media, the flow can be chaotic, with elongation moments growing exponentially with time [30, 78], unless additional symmetries are present in the medium structure [85, 84]. The mean elongation is characterized by a Lyapunov exponent, which has been quantitatively linked to the frequency of branch points in the flow (Lester et al. 2025). However, specific relations between the Lyapunov exponent and pore structure have only been established for monodisperse bead-packs [84, 47]. A clearer understanding of the two-dimensional case, where the pore structure can be carefully controlled, may provide insights for the three-dimensional problem.

Beyond the scaling of moments, the full elongation distribution P(ρ,t)P(\rho,t) is needed to predict solute concentrations from the lamellar theory Le Borgne et al. [46]. Whether in two or three dimensions, the overall elongation distribution is often considered to be log-normal, based on the reasoning that the coarse-grained stretching process is multiplicative with uncorrelated increments [46, 90, 78]. This idea has been carried over from the literature on turbulent flows [44, 21, 23]. Whether log-normal stretching is appropriate for two-dimensional steady porous media flows remains to be clarified, especially since the exact description of stretching in two-dimensional steady flows is inherently additive, not multiplicative [19]. With additive stretching, log-normal elongation distributions are unexpected; yet log-normal-like elongation distributions have been observed in some two-dimensional porous media flows Le Borgne et al. [46].

In the present study, we evaluate how fluid elongation depends on the medium structure in quasi two-dimensional porous models composed of cylinder arrays. Specifically, we combine particle tracking velocimetry experiments and numerical simulations to link the temporal scaling exponents of the lower elongation moments to the porous medium heterogeneity. We observe that the mean fluid elongation grows in time linearly along a symmetry direction of an ordered cylinder array, while it grows quadratically in disordered arrays with a growth rate that depends on the medium heterogeneity. By considering the frequency with which the plume encounters cylinders during transport, we relate the quadratic scaling to the progressive wrapping of the stretched plume over cylinders which increases the number of branches stretched by shear. To describe our observations, we analytically calculate the stretching produced by flow around an isolated cylinder, and we represent elongation in cylinder arrays as a stochastic exchange of individual lamellae between near-wall and bulk-flow regions. The isolated cylinder results are used to parameterize the near-wall stretching in the stochastic exchange model for elongation. The observed and modeled elongation statistics align with the Protean-frame theory of Dentz et al. [19], while also going further to link the elongation statistics observed in porous media to characteristics of the underlying solid structure. This work provides a framework to link pore-scale disorder to fluid elongation and mixing in steady flows through two-dimensional porous media.

Methods

Flow cell fabrication and structure

Transparent millifluidic porous flow cells were fabricated with 20 μm20\ \mu\mathrm{m} resolution using a stereolithographic 3D-printer (Formlabs 3B) and clear polyacrylate resin (Formlabs Clear V4). Models were designed using Autodesk Fusion CAD software as rectangular cavities with dimensions 60×45×1 mm360 \times45 \times1\ \mathrm{mm}^{3}, filled with vertical cylinders of diameter a=1 mma = 1\ \mathrm{mm} and average spacing 2a2a between centers. The vertical gap was set to be much smaller than the transverse size of the cell, which enables us to consider the flow as approximately two-dimensional [73, 38]. The Autodesk Fusion Python API was used to place the cylinders at specified locations in the domains. Models were printed with open tops for easy cleaning, and the top surfaces were painted black to contrast the solid. Models were sealed during experiments by pressing them between thick poly(methyl methacrylate) plates (PMMA) using thin polyvinyl chloride (PVC) sheets as gaskets.

Appendix B

Experimental setup, progressively disordered cells, zoomed-in experimental image, and particle streamlines

Figure 1. (A) Schematic of the experimental setup for particle-tracking velocimetry. (B) Detail of the progressively-disordered stereolithography-printed cells, with vertical rods of diameter aa arranged according to a disorder parameter ε\varepsilon. (C) Zoomed-in view of an experimental image, with fluorescent microspheres visible as white dots. (D) Overlay of successive zoomed-in images, showing particles tracing out streamlines.

Cylinders were placed at random sites rij′\mathbf{r}'_{ij} resulting from perturbations of a triangular lattice. The perturbation scheme is based on a dimensionless parameter ε\varepsilon that ranges between 0 and 1. Unperturbed sites are given by rij=ia1+ja2\mathbf{r}_{ij}=i\mathbf{a}_1+j\mathbf{a}_2, where i,ji,j are integers and ak\mathbf{a}_k are the primitive translation vectors of the triangular lattice. Perturbed sites are defined by

rij′=rij+aε2nij(cos⁡(θij)e^1+sin⁡(θij)e^2).(1)\mathbf{r}'_{ij}=\mathbf{r}_{ij}+\frac{a\varepsilon}{2}\sqrt{n_{ij}}\left(\cos(\theta_{ij})\hat{\mathbf{e}}_1+\sin(\theta_{ij})\hat{\mathbf{e}}_2\right). \tag*{(1)}

where 0≤nij≤10\leq n_{ij}\leq1 and 0≤θij≤2π0\leq\theta_{ij}\leq2\pi are uniform random variables and the e^i\hat{\mathbf{e}}_i are unit vectors parallel and perpendicular to the mean flow direction. This specification places the cylinders uniformly within disks of diameter a(1+ε)a(1+\varepsilon) centered on the unperturbed sites (random area sampling), so the models interpolate between ordered for ε=0\varepsilon=0 and disordered for ε=1\varepsilon=1. All models have porosity φ=1−π/(83)≈0.773\varphi=1-\pi/(8\sqrt{3})\approx0.773 and mean pore-throat size λˉ=a\bar{\lambda}=a, independent of ε\varepsilon. Fluctuations in the pore-throat sizes obey σλ≈0.182λˉε\sigma_{\lambda}\approx0.182\bar{\lambda}\varepsilon according to the approximate analytical throat-size probability density function derived in appendix § 9. We fabricated five different porous cells with ε∈{0.00,0.25,0.50,0.75,1.00}\varepsilon\in\{0.00, 0.25, 0.50, 0.75, 1.00\}, spanning a full range of heterogeneity parameters from completely ordered (ε=0\varepsilon= 0) to completely random (ε=1\varepsilon= 1). These cells have the same pore-space topology for all ε\varepsilon as characterized by the Euler characteristic [25]. Thus, the ε\varepsilon parameter modifies the pore-size heterogeneity without changing the pore-space topology.

Particle tracking velocimetry and velocity field preparation

Velocity fields were obtained in these models using particle tracking velocimetry (PTV), which reconstructs velocity fields from image sequences of tracer particles in the flow [62, 78]. Unlike particle image velocimetry (PIV), which correlates image windows to produce gridded fields [73, 55], PTV achieves sub-pixel resolution [40], making it well-suited to probe near-boundary velocities in porous media. Green fluorescent particles of emission wavelength ≈520\approx520 nm, diameter ≈20\approx20 μ\mum, and density 1.00 g cm−3^{-3} were dispersed in deionized water containing 0.01 % by mass of Tween 80 surfactant using an ultrasonic bath. The suspension was pumped through the porous model at flow rate q=0.5q = 0.5 mL min−1^{-1} with a syringe pump, which in the model geometries gave an average flow velocity uˉavg=0.1\bar{u}_{\mathrm{avg}} = 0.1 mm s−1^{-1} and a Reynolds number Re=5×10−4Re = 5 \times10^{-4}, low enough to neglect the inertia term in the Navier–Stokes equations. The Stokes number was St=6×10−6St = 6 \times10^{-6}, small enough to consider that the instantaneous particle velocities closely approximate the underlying flow velocities [55]. The cell was illuminated from below by a blue light-emitting diode (LED) panel with a wavelength range 450 ±\pm 30 nm, with long wavelengths screened by a short-pass filter gel (Lee 126). The fluorescence of moving particles was recorded through a bandpass filter (wavelength range 520 ±\pm 10 nm) with a 5-megapixel camera (Allied U511M) operating at 10 Hz, with 8-bit intensity resolution and 24 μ\mum/pixel.

For each porous model, a ten-minute-long image sequence ItI_t was obtained during fluid flow. A background image was formed by taking the minimum of each pixel across the sequence, B=min⁡(It)B = \min(I_t), and a foreground sequence showing only the moving particles was formed as Ft=It−BF_t = I_t - B. A solid mask MM was obtained by thresholding the background image to isolate the cylinders. PTV was conducted on the background-subtracted images (FtF_t) using the open-source software TracTrac [29]. TracTrac identifies particle centers with subpixel precision by thresholding the result of a difference-of-Gaussian filter, and it associates identified particles across temporal frames into trajectories using a Kalman-filtering approach. The analysis of each ten-minute image sequence provided around 10610^6 trajectories, and these were further filtered by their tortuosity and length, giving around 2×1052 \times10^5 cleaned particle trajectories per experiment.

The particle trajectories were binned into velocity fields u=(ux,uy)\boldsymbol{u} = (u_x, u_y) on the same 24 μ\mum grid as the original experimental images. For each pixel, all trajectories that crossed it at some time were identified, and the crossing velocities of these trajectories over the pixel were recorded. Note that our measurements sample tracers within a three-dimensional flow cell, whereas our target is the mid-plane velocity. The upper 75th percentile of crossing velocity observations was averaged, ensuring that the recorded velocity at each pixel approximates the channel mid-plane value, where the velocity is maximal. The 75th percentile was chosen as a compromise between data quantity and precision, and we found the overall structure of the velocity field was insensitive to the choice. The velocity components were set to zero on the solid mask MM. Pixels which had no velocity observations were interpolated from neighboring values using bi-harmonic inpainting from scikit-image [91].

The PTV-derived velocity fields were divergence corrected using a custom-built algorithm adapted from Wang et al. [92] for application to porous media flows. Divergence correction was found to be essential for the calculation of fluid stretching. From each field u\mathbf{u}, we find the divergence-corrected field u′\mathbf{u}' that minimizes ∫d2x∥u′−u∥2\int d^2x \lVert\mathbf{u}'-\mathbf{u}\rVert^2 subject to the constraint that ∇⋅u′=0\nabla\cdot\mathbf{u}'=0 on all fluid cells.

Wang et al. [92] provided an efficient solution of this constrained optimization problem, but their approach acts on both fluid and non-fluid cells, so it does not account for the no-slip condition on solid boundaries. Therefore, we implemented the constrained problem using a brute-force approach on a GPU using the Cooper package, built on PyTorch ([26, 67]). Our algorithm exactly enforces zero velocities on the solid mask MM. This means that the velocity field naturally adopts the appropriate near-boundary behavior required to satisfy both incompressibility and the no-slip condition, namely that the velocity component normal to the solid surface increases quadratically while the tangential component increases linearly with distance from the wall ([48]). Our porous media divergence-correction implementation is freely available on Github ([69]). We applied the algorithm until the divergence change per iteration fell below 10−4uˉ/a10^{-4}\bar{u}/a. We confirmed that the flow and elongation statistics of interest were insensitive to increases in the allowed divergence residual. The resulting divergence-free velocity fields u′=(ux′,uy′)\mathbf{u}'=(u'_x,u'_y) are used in the following, dropping the primes for convenience. To benchmark the PTV measurements, the flow was simulated using finite-volume method for the case ε=0.50\varepsilon=0.50 and compared with the divergence-corrected experimental flow field, showing qualitatively identical flow structure with errors less than 10% in the measured velocity components.

Elongation statistics of material lines

The stretching of infinitesimal fluid line segments in steady two-dimensional flows has been calculated in closed form by Dentz et al. [19]. Their solution relies on transforming the general formulation of fluid stretching (e.g., [13, 21]) into a Protean coordinate system, which is an evolving orthogonal basis that moves with the local flow velocity and rotates its basis vectors parallel and perpendicular to the local flow direction at all times ([1]). An infinitesimal filament (i.e., a lamella) in a two-dimensional steady flow is represented by the vector z=(z∥,z⊥)\mathbf{z}=(z_{\parallel},z_{\perp}), with components parallel and perpendicular to the streamline, respectively. This vector evolves according to

z∥(t)=u(t)u(0)[z∥(0)+z⊥(0)∫0tσ(t′)[u(t′)/u(0)]2 dt′](2)z_{\parallel}(t)=\frac{u(t)}{u(0)}\left[z_{\parallel}(0)+z_{\perp}(0)\int_{0}^{t}\frac{\sigma(t')}{[u(t')/u(0)]^2}\,dt'\right] \tag*{(2)}
z⊥(t)=u(0)u(t)z⊥(0),(3)z_{\perp}(t)=\frac{u(0)}{u(t)}z_{\perp}(0), \tag*{(3)}

where u(t)u(t) and σ(t)\sigma(t) are respectively the streamwise velocity and the streamwise shear rate (i.e., the shear acting across a streamline) along the segment’s trajectory. Note that a change of variables can also express these equations in terms of the streamline-arc length ss ([19]). The elongation is given by ρ(t)=∣z(t)∣/∣z(0)∣\rho(t)=|\mathbf{z}(t)|/|\mathbf{z}(0)|, which according to equation (2.2) originates from both velocity fluctuations and accumulated shear. The Protean-frame stretching theory of equation (2.2) has also been extended to three-dimensional steady flows ([53, 50]) and unsteady flows (Lester & Dentz 2026). We refer to K(t)=σ(t)/[u(t)/u(0)]2K(t)=\sigma(t)/[u(t)/u(0)]^2 as the deformation kernel and D(t)=∫0tK(t′) dt′D(t)=\int_{0}^{t}K(t')\,dt' as the deformation integral.

The deformation integral in equation (2.2) is the source of algebraic stretching in two-dimensional steady flows [19]. The integral kernel reveals a nonlinear coupling between the velocity and shear in determining fluid stretching. The deformation kernel weights the streamwise shear by two factors of inverse velocity, which can be understood as follows. The first factor of 1/u(t)1/u(t) represents the persistence of stretching, ensuring that streamwise shear produces additional deformation when sustained for longer. The second factor of 1/u(t)1/u(t) represents mass conservation: in the incompressible flow, deceleration compresses filaments in the streamwise direction and extends them transversely (equation 2.2b), so that shear acts on the extended transverse component z⊥(t′)=u(0)z⊥(0)/u(t′)z_{\perp}(t') = u(0)z_{\perp}(0)/u(t') [95]. Mass conservation similarly explains the u(t)/u(0)u(t)/u(0) pre-factors in equations (2.2).

The stretching theory of equations (2.2) is challenging to apply in practice, since the integrals involve velocities and velocity gradients along Lagrangian trajectories, and these quantities rarely have analytical solutions. However, in porous media, we can expect the ratio σ/u2\sigma/u^2 to peak near solid boundaries where the velocity is low and the shear is high. The ratio is comparatively negligible elsewhere, since shear decreases while velocity increases with distance from walls. Later, we will exploit this wall-localized character of σ/u2\sigma/u^2 in porous domains to explain stretching in porous media based on the frequency with which the solute plume encounters solid boundaries.

We calculate the elongation statistics of material lines using the strip method [60] applied to the measured flow fields. In each flow, we initialize a line of particles oriented approximately perpendicular to the mean flow and placed as far from nearby solid boundaries as possible. Neighboring particles on the line are initially separated by bonds of length δℓ(0)=0.05a\delta\ell(0)=0.05a carrying arbitrary mass 1. These particles are transported in the flow by solving dx(t)/dt=u[x(t)]\mathrm{d}\boldsymbol{x}(t)/\mathrm{d}t=\boldsymbol{u}[\boldsymbol{x}(t)] with an RK4 scheme and cubic interpolation on the velocity fields [27]. The bond lengths evolve through time to δℓ(t)\delta\ell(t)—generally different for each bond, and the elongation of each bond is calculated as ρ(t)=δℓ(t)/δℓ(0)\rho(t)=\delta\ell(t)/\delta\ell(0). Whenever neighboring particles become separated by more than 2δℓ(0)2\delta\ell(0), the bond is subdivided and another particle is inserted at its midpoint. Subdivided bonds inherit the elongation ρ\rho of their parent bond with half its mass, such that the mass carried by a bond is 2−n2^{-n}, with nn being the total number of subdivisions applied. Refinement conserves the overall mass and elongation of the line. The resulting elongation distribution P(ρ,t)P(\rho,t) and moments ⟨ρ(t)k⟩\langle\rho(t)^k\rangle are calculated by weighting the values of ρ\rho across all bonds by their masses.

Flow velocimetry and fluid elongation results

Velocity statistics for different solid heterogeneity

To evaluate fluid elongation as a function of medium heterogeneity, we first obtain the velocity and shear fields calculated from the particle-tracking velocimetry in the porous media cells. The PTV data provide the vector field u=(ux,uy)\boldsymbol{u}=(u_x,u_y), from which we calculate the streamwise velocity field u=∣u∣u=|\boldsymbol{u}| and the flow direction field u/u\boldsymbol{u}/u. To obtain the streamwise shear rate, we use a minimal approach based on rotating the velocity gradient tensor into the streamline frame rather than following the full Protean-frame transformation. We compute the velocity gradient tensor L=∇uT\boldsymbol{L}=\nabla\boldsymbol{u}^{\mathsf{T}} and assemble an orthogonal matrix R=[t^,u^]\boldsymbol{R}=[\hat{\boldsymbol{t}},\hat{\boldsymbol{u}}] that rotates this tensor into coordinates with one axis t^=(ur,uθ)/u\hat{\boldsymbol{t}}=(u_r,u_\theta)/u tangential to the flow and another axis n^=(−uθ,ur)/u\hat{\boldsymbol{n}}=(-u_\theta,u_r)/u normal to it. The velocity gradient tensor transforms into the streamline frame via L′=RTLR\boldsymbol{L}'=\boldsymbol{R}^{\mathsf{T}}\boldsymbol{L}\boldsymbol{R}. This transformation aligns the reference axes with the flow direction at each point, but it does not transport them along with the flow, so it is not a full Protean transformation. Still, L′\boldsymbol{L}' conveniently isolates the

Appendix C

streamwise shear as the sum of off-diagonal components, σ=L12′+L21′\sigma= L'_{12} + L'_{21} [19].

We scale the measured velocities by the imposed mean velocity uˉ=q/(Sφ)\bar{u} = q/(S\varphi), where S=2.25 cm2S = 2.25\ \mathrm{cm}^{2} is the cross-sectional area, and we scale the shear rates by the inverse of the advection time, σˉ=1/ta=uˉ/a\bar{\sigma} = 1/t_a = \bar{u}/a. The scaled streamwise velocity and shear-rate fields are displayed for a representative subset of the measured heterogeneity levels in Figure 2. Disorder increases the velocity variance in Figure 2A-C and organizes the flow structure into preferential paths that increasingly carry more of the total flux as ε\varepsilon increases. Two different fundamental flow structures are visible in the velocity fields, especially in the ordered case ε=0\varepsilon= 0. The first structure is the high velocity channel-like flows along the open flow pathways following symmetry directions of the underlying cylinder arrangement (typically in blue, see Figure 2A). The second structure is the obstructed flow pathways sheltered between cylinders (typically in white). Increasing disorder blends these two fundamental flow structures and diversifies the distribution of flow directions.

Figure 2. The streamwise velocity and shear rate fields are displayed for three of the observed heterogeneity levels. In (A), the ordered model displays two nonzero velocity modes, the channel-like pathways where the velocity is high, and the wake-like pathways behind the grains where the velocity is low. Comparison of the velocity fields in (A), (B), and (C) shows an increase in velocity heterogeneity with disorder that relates to a blending of the high and low-velocity pathways visible in (A). Likewise, the shear rate σ\sigma becomes more spatially heterogeneous with increasing disorder parameter ε\varepsilon. Shear magnitudes are typically large on the side walls of cylinders and drop to zero in the widest pores where the velocity is high.

The streamwise shear rate similarly shows two modes that blend together with increasing heterogeneity, see Figure 2D-F. The shear rate changes sign in the transverse direction across the widest flow pathways. Shear-rate magnitudes are typically highest along cylinder walls, especially near the sides of cylinders where the flow velocity is largest in the near-wall regions. Disorder increases the variability and range of shear-rate values. To quantify the

velocity and shear characteristics as a function of medium heterogeneity, we calculate the probability density functions of streamwise velocity and shear from the measured PTV data in Figure 3. Velocity statistics show a multimodal structure with two non-zero modes, coincident with the obstructed- and free-flow modes described above (Figure 3A). Heterogeneity blends these non-zero modes together as ε→1\varepsilon\to1. The velocity distributions are approximately flat for u→0u \to0 and have an exponential tail for large u>uˉu > \bar{u}, which becomes wider as medium heterogeneity increases, as shown in inset (i) of Figure 3A. A flat velocity distribution is anticipated for u→0u \to0 due to the no-slip condition on solid boundaries [4, 17]. The obstructed- and free-flow modes contributing to the distributions are visualized in inset (ii) of Figure 3A. The upper graphic is white where 0.1≤u/uˉ≤0.50.1 \le u/\bar{u} \le0.5, corresponding to the obstructed mode, while the lower graphic is white where 0.8≤u/uˉ≤1.20.8 \le u/\bar{u} \le1.2, corresponding to the free mode.

Figure 3. Panel (A) displays the velocity statistics for different model heterogeneities (denoted by colors). Ordered media display two peaks in the velocity probability density function associated with obstructed- and free-flow pathways. Inset (i) shows the exponential tail of P(u)P(u) that broadens with ε\varepsilon. Inset (ii) highlights the obstructed- and free-flow modes in the ε=0\varepsilon= 0 velocity distributions; these modes increasingly blend together as ε\varepsilon increases. Panel (B) shows the streamwise shear-rate statistics. The free-flow mode σ≈σˉ\sigma\approx\bar{\sigma}, visible for ε=0\varepsilon= 0, progressively transfers to low and high σ\sigma as disorder increases. Inset (i) displays the probability distribution of the dimensionless deformation kernel k=(∣σ∣uˉ2)/(u2σˉ)k = (|\sigma|\bar{u}^{2})/(u^{2}\bar{\sigma}) (equations (2.2)). The distribution of kk displays a power-law decay over more than three decades, regardless of the disorder level. This scaling is derived for the flow around an isolated cylinder in appendix § 10. Inset (ii) shows locations where k>50k > 50, indicating that stretching potential is concentrated in thin margins near solid boundaries. A more detailed image of the kk-field is available in Figure 7A.

The streamwise shear rate magnitude ∣σ∣|\sigma| follows a unimodal distribution as shown in Figure 3B. The most probable value for all media is near the value σˉ\bar{\sigma} defined by the mean velocity and grain size. Increasing heterogeneity broadens the shear variability and flattens the weak-shear component of the distribution (σ<σˉ\sigma< \bar{\sigma}), associated with high-velocity regions away from walls. The shear distribution shows an exponential-like tail for large values, associated with low-velocity regions near walls.

While the shear rate and velocity fields have a complicated spatial structure for all heterogeneity levels (Figure 2), it is the combination σ/u2\sigma/u^{2} which produces stretching in the deformation integral of equation (2.2a), and this quantity shows relatively simple behavior. Inset (i) of Figure 3B plots the probability density function of k=K/Kˉk = K/\bar{K}, where Kˉ=σˉ/uˉ2\bar{K} = \bar{\sigma}/\bar{u}^{2} is a characteristic deformation kernel value. We observe a similar P(k)P(k) for all heterogeneity levels, with a flat distribution for small values of k≲1k \lesssim1 and an identical power-law decay P(k)∼k−3/2P(k) \sim k^{-3/2} over more than three decades for the large values of kk associated with near-wall regions. These large-kk values are expected to dominate the deformation integral in equations (2.2). Inset (ii) of Figure 3B indicates the wall-localized character of these large deformation kernel values. Thresholding the fields where k>50k > 50 demonstrates that the power-law component of the deformation kernel distribution is exclusively located in thin shells around solid grains, suggesting that the near-wall flow will be primarily responsible for fluid stretching in our porous media.

Impact of heterogeneity on fluid stretching

The elongation of an initial material line from the advective strip calculations is displayed in Figure 4 for two representative solid geometries. The initial material line is displayed as a black line, while the stretched line at t≈3τat \approx3\tau_a is displayed with a color scale that represents the local elongation. We confirmed that stretching statistics were insensitive to the layout of the initial line by computing ⟨ρ⟩(t)\langle\rho\rangle(t) for five different initial lines at each ε\varepsilon. Averaging the standard deviation of ⟨ρ⟩(t)\langle\rho\rangle(t) over t/τa>5t/\tau_a > 5 provided a 1.3% uncertainty in the mean elongation due to the initial line placement. This insensitivity is expected since the line is generally aligned perpendicular to the local flow, while stretching is concentrated in the parallel direction (equation (2.2a)). Ordered porous media show relatively less diversity in the elongation distributions, and there is a clear spatial organization of the elongation from most-stretched on the left (near the initial configuration) to least-stretched on the right. The plume wraps around the first cylinders it encounters, near its initial position, then weaves through the widest pore throats and mainly avoids subsequent cylinder encounters. When additional wrapping events do occur, they appear to arise from asymmetries in the flow field from finite system size: one can observe a “fanning-out” of the flow from the inlet port (see Figure 4A). This influence persists for short distances around ∼3a\sim3a, consistent with the screening in porous media of the otherwise long-ranged 1/r1/r interactions in Stokes flows [24].

Material line elongation in ordered and disordered cylinder arrays

Figure 4. Material line elongation for completely ordered (ε=0\varepsilon= 0) and disordered (ε=1\varepsilon= 1) models. Each gray cylinder has diameter a=1a = 1 mm. The number of accumulated wraps of the plume over cylinders is a key control over the stretching statistics. Wraps are highlighted with the symbol (*). In ordered media, the number of wraps tends toward a constant (Panel A), whereas in disordered media, the number of wraps steadily accumulates with time (Panel B). In all cases, an overall spatial organization of the stretching is visible, with the earliest stagnation points to be wrapped originating the most highly-stretched sections of the plume.

In contrast, disordered porous media show more diversity in the elongation of material lines, and wrapping of cylinders is not limited to the first cylinders the plume encounters. The plume continually encounters new cylinders as it progresses downstream, and the most elongated areas exist just downstream of the earliest cylinders to be wrapped during transport. This organization of stretching around cylinder encounters likely relates to the localization of σ/u2\sigma/u^2 near solid boundaries. Material lines continuously accumulate contacts with wall regions in disordered porous media, whereas in ordered porous media, material lines only encounter wall regions early in transport and do not gain further contacts thereafter. This difference in the frequency of wall encounters coincides with the higher magnitude and diversity of elongation seen in the disordered media (Figure 4).

To quantify the elongation statistics, we calculate the first two moments of the elongation for all fabricated porous structures. Figure 5 displays the mean elongation ⟨ρ⟩\langle\rho\rangle and the relative variation of the elongation, σρ/⟨ρ⟩\sigma_\rho/\langle\rho\rangle for the studied media. The notation σρ2=⟨ρ2⟩−⟨ρ⟩2\sigma_\rho^2 = \langle\rho^2\rangle- \langle\rho\rangle^2 denotes the elongation variance. In ordered media, the mean elongation scales approximately linearly with time, whereas in disordered media, the mean elongation scales quadratically with time, with a pre-factor that increases with the disorder parameter ε\varepsilon. The distribution of log⁡ρ\log\rho is displayed in Figure 6 for three representative cases. With increasing time, the distribution broadens and its mode shifts to larger log⁡ρ\log\rho. The elongation distribution is more skewed for the ordered medium, whereas for the disordered medium, the distribution more resembles a log-normal distribution, although with additional frequency at small or compressive elongations when compared to log-normal.

First two moments of the elongation for all disorder levels

Figure 5. First two moments of the elongation for all disorder levels. In panel (A), the asymptotic mean elongation grows quadratically for disordered media, approaching linear for ordered media. The quadratic growth implies that the elongation process in disordered media cannot be approximated as a simple shear flow. In panel (B), the relative variation σρ/⟨ρ⟩\sigma_{\rho}/\langle\rho\rangle of the elongation is displayed. The scaling σρ/⟨ρ⟩∼t1/2\sigma_{\rho}/\langle\rho\rangle\sim t^{1/2} is superimposed for disordered media, while σρ/⟨ρ⟩∼t1\sigma_{\rho}/\langle\rho\rangle\sim t^{1} is superimposed for ordered media. The stretching model developed in § 6.5 predicts these scaling relations. The inset of panel (B) shows an increased density of neighboring filaments in disordered media, reflecting an increased propensity for lamella aggregation during mixing.

Figure 6. Probability density functions of log ρ\rho are displayed for times t/ta∈{1,5,25}t/t_a \in\{1,5,25\} and different heterogeneity levels: ε=0.00\varepsilon= 0.00 (A), ε=0.50\varepsilon= 0.50 (B), and ε=1.00\varepsilon= 1.00 (C). In all cases, the observed distributions deviate from a log-normal shape. Panel (C) displays a log-normal fit for comparison.

Random walk model for elongation in cylinder arrays

This section develops a quantitative description for the observed elongation statistics in Figure 5. In particular, the description aims to predict the asymptotic scaling of the elongation moments ⟨ρk⟩\langle\rho^k \rangle with time for the full range of cylinder array heterogeneities 0≤ε≤10 \le\varepsilon\le1. In addition to depending on the degree of heterogeneity ε\varepsilon, stretching characteristics in fully ordered arrays (ε=0\varepsilon= 0) are expected to depend on the flow orientation relative to the lattice structure; however, we only study flows aligned with the lattice here. To develop the description of elongation, we exploit the localization of the deformation kernel σ/u2\sigma/u^2 in the stretching equations 2.2 to the near-wall regions of individual cylinders as shown in the Figure 2B inset.

We decompose the initial line into infinitesimal lamellae and represent the transport of each lamella as a random exchange process between two states: (1) “inner regions” of cylinders where σ/u2\sigma/u^2 is large, corresponding to locations where the no-slip and incompressibility conditions constrain the flow-field (e.g., [33]); and (2) the “outer region” or bulk flow where σ/u2\sigma/u^2 can be considered negligible. Incorporating the transit time distributions through each of these two states will allow us to construct a multistate random-walk description (e.g., [93]) for the elongation statistics of lamellae. Figure 7 summarizes the conceptual basis of the model as random alternation between inner and outer regions; with transit time distributions ψI(tr)\psi_I(t_r) and ψO(tr)\psi_O(t_r), respectively, with stretching occurring only in the inner-region transits where the deformation kernel is large.

Figure 7. Proposed conceptual model for the transport of an infinitesimal lamella as random alternation between inner (near-wall) and outer (bulk flow) region flows. (A1) Scaled deformation kernel k=(∣σ∣/u2)/(∣σˉ∣/uˉ2)k = (|\sigma|/u^{2})/(|\bar{\sigma}|/\bar{u}^{2}) for ε=1\varepsilon= 1, showing close localization of this quantity to cylinder walls, implying the deformation integral in equation 2.2 grows mainly due to boundary encounters. Trajectories of two different lamellae in the flow are indicated. (A2) Scaled deformation kernel sampled by the indicated trajectories. Only close encounters with cylinders result in appreciable shear. Lamella 1 is strongly stretched by two inner-region transits, while lamella 2 accumulates negligible stretching by remaining in the outer region. (B) Alternation scheme of a lamella between inner- and outer-flow states, with the residence time distributions in each state given by equations (17) and 4.6, respectively.

We analytically study the elongation produced when a material line wraps over an isolated cylinder, and we assume this sufficiently represents the elongation produced by a cylinder within a larger array to parameterize the random-walk model. The single-cylinder analysis implies truncated power-law distributions for both the transit times and elongation increments through inner regions. We assess the rates at which the material line wraps over cylinders from the stretching simulations. This provides access to a medium-dependent wrap rate and suggests Poisson-distributed transit times through the outer region. When incorporated in a random exchange model as shown in Figure 7B, these distributions will be seen to produce anomalous scalings through time of the elongation moments which depend on medium disorder and nicely match our simulation results.

Quantification of cylinder wrapping events

Wrapping events would ideally be characterized as the bending of material lines over the no-slip stagnation points at the upstream sides of cylinders, but the detection of these events is challenging with discrete velocity fields and material lines represented as discrete points. Instead, to identify locations where the material line wraps over cylinders, we introduce an operational definition shown in Figure 8A1. The center points of all cylinders are identified with a Hough transform applied to the solid mask MM, and rays of length $2a$ are drawn transverse to the mean flow across each cylinder point. The material line is represented by a chain of points xi\boldsymbol{x}_i, i=1…N(t)i = 1 \ldots N(t), and a wrap is considered to occur over a cylinder at time tt if three conditions are met: (1) two bonds xi\boldsymbol{x}_i-to-xi+1\boldsymbol{x}_{i+1} and xj\boldsymbol{x}_j-to-xj+1\boldsymbol{x}_{j+1} on the line both cross the same ray; (2) the cumulative distance sij=∑k=ij∣xk∣s_{ij} = \sum_{k=i}^{j} |\boldsymbol{x}_k| between these segments satisfies sij<3πa/4s_{ij} < 3\pi a/4 (less than half of the cylinder circumference plus a 50% tolerance); and (3) the two (approximate) crossing points ci=(xi+xi+1)/2\boldsymbol{c}_i = (\boldsymbol{x}_i+\boldsymbol{x}_{i+1})/2 and cj=(xj+xj+1)/2areseparatedbymorethanadistance\boldsymbol{c}_j = (\boldsymbol{x}_j+\boldsymbol{x}_{j+1})/2 are separated by more than a distancea$. This definition successfully detects cylinder wraps over while avoiding false detections, as shown in Figure 8A2. Here, wrapped cylinders are highlighted with red dots for one timestep of the ε=1\varepsilon= 1 simulation.

Evaluation of cylinder-wrapping events from stretching simulations

Figure 8. Evaluation of cylinder-wrapping events from stretching simulations. A1 illustrates of the operational definition of wrapping. A2 displays an elongated line with wrapped cylinders highlighted by red dots. B1 shows the cumulative number of wraps versus time, suggesting a relationship nw∼νwt/tan_w \sim\nu_w t/t_a, generally increasing with medium disorder. Asymmetries in the flow field produce a finite-time departure of the ε=0\varepsilon= 0 case from νw∼const.⁡\nu_w \sim\operatorname{const.}. B2 shows the dimensionless wrap rate νw\nu_w scaled by the quantity 2a/ℓ02a/\ell_0 with initial filament length ℓ0\ell_0. Linear fits are developed to estimate νw\nu_w over 2≤t/ta≤102 \le t/t_a \le10, before finite-time effects become relevant. The departure of the ε=0\varepsilon= 0 case from νw∼0\nu_w \sim0 is used as an upper error bound for all cases. In B1, the data support a linear relation νw=(0.11±0.05)εa/ℓ0\nu_w = (0.11 \pm0.05)\varepsilon a/\ell_0, although with large uncertainty from the definition used to detect wraps, showing an increase in wrap rate with medium heterogeneity. An improved relation is obtained with other methods in § 6.

Applying the definition to quantify the number nw(t)n_w(t) of wrapping events versus time summarizes how the medium heterogeneity affects the frequency of encounters by the material line in Figure 8A3. To summarize how the wrap frequency νw/ta\nu_w/t_a depends on medium disorder ε\varepsilon, we establish a linear fit between the wrap frequency as νw=(0.11±0.05)εℓ0/a\nu_w = (0.11 \pm0.05)\varepsilon\ell_0/a, where ℓ0\ell_0 is the initial length of the material line (Figure 8B).

The case ε=0\varepsilon= 0 reveals a secondary late-time wrapping mechanism in the rear of the plume (see Figure 4A). The asymptotic wrap rate νw≈0\nu_w \approx0 is established after t≈2tat \approx2t_a, but this persists only up to t≈10tat \approx10t_a when secondary wraps develop. These additional wraps imply that the idealized ordered-lattice result only persists for a finite time, likely as a result of the fanning-out of the flow from the inlet port which breaks translation invariance in the ordered structure. We use the departure from a constant wrap number for ε=0\varepsilon= 0 as an upper-bound uncertainty measure for all wrap-rate observations in Figure 8B.

Stretching by an isolated cylinder

The observation that large deformation kernels are universally localized near solid boundaries (Figure 3B) suggests that encounters of lamellae with individual cylinders provide the key mechanism of stretching. Therefore, to describe stretching in cylinder arrays, we initially study the stretching produced by flow around an isolated cylinder.

To relate to our millifluidic cells, we start from the velocity field for creeping flow around a cylinder within a Hele-Shaw cell, and we expand it for small distances from the cylinder wall. For analytical tractability, we use the exact solution to the Brinkman equations for a cylinder in a thin gap between parallel plates ([70, 38]). This solution is known to provide an excellent approximation to the Stokes equations in cylinder-array geometries, where the Brinkman approximation gives maximal errors less than 2% when compared with Stokes-flow simulations ([38]).

Figure 9 displays a numerical simulation of material line stretching in the Brinkman flow around a cylinder embedded in a Hele-Shaw cell ([70, 38]). These results were obtained by simulating the transport of 5×1045 \times10^4 particles in the analytical Brinkman flow using the RK4 method ([27]). As the filament wraps the cylinder, the mean elongation scales asymptotically as tt, while the elongation variance scales like t4t^4.

Numerical simulation of a material line stretching around an isolated cylinder

Figure 9. Numerical simulation of a material line stretching around an isolated cylinder. In (A) the line (black at t=0t = 0 and colored by the elongation at t≈3tat \approx3t_a) is transported to the right and wraps around the cylinder. The line is parameterized by a coordinate η∈[−1,1]\eta\in[-1, 1] and an elongation ρ1(η,t)\rho_1(\eta,t). In (B), the mean elongation grows linearly, consistent with a concept of two branches moving past the cylinder, each with leading edge moving at velocity uˉ\bar{u}. In (C), the elongation variance grows as t4t^4. In (D), the elongation distribution P(ρ1,t)P(\rho_1,t) is shown evolving across evenly-spaced times (represented by the shift from gray to black), showing excellent correspondence to a truncated power-law scaling P(ρ1,t)∼ρ1−5/3P(\rho_1,t) \sim\rho_1^{-5/3} with a time-dependent maximal ρ1\rho_1. These distributions are vertically shifted for clarity. The upward hooks on these distributions at large ρ1\rho_1 originate from velocity variation near the downstream stagnation point. In all panels, red overlays show the predicted scalings from the analytical calculations in § 6.2.

Brinkman approximation and trajectories in the inner region

To describe the single-cylinder stretching analytically, we note the Brinkman flow has both inner and outer regions: there is a Stokes-like inner region where shear is significant, and there is a Darcy-like outer region where shear can be neglected [70]. We non-dimensionalize the flow with the cylinder diameter aa, the far-field velocity uˉ\bar{u}, and the advective time ta=a/uˉt_a = a/\bar{u}. To isolate the inner region, we expand the Brinkman flow near the cylinder wall, obtaining the velocity field

uδ=−Acos⁡(θ)δ2uθ=Asin⁡(θ)δ.(4)\begin{aligned} u_{\delta} &= -A\cos(\theta)\delta^2 \\ u_{\theta} &= A\sin(\theta)\delta. \tag*{(4)} \end{aligned}

The quantity δ=r/a−1/2\delta= r/a - 1/2 represents a small dimensionless distance from the cylinder wall, and θ\theta is the angle from the upstream stagnation point (see Figure 9A). Here, A=4sK1(s)/K0(s)≈8.8A = 4sK_1(s)/K_0(s) \approx8.8, where the K0(s)K_0(s) and K1(s)K_1(s) are modified Bessel functions, and s=3s = \sqrt{3} relates to the cylinder diameter and height through the permeability formula for a Hele-Shaw cell [38]. While this value of ss is specific to our geometry, changing the value of ss only modifies the pre-factors in the relations developed below.

Equation (4) is constrained by the simultaneous need to satisfy the no-slip and incompressibility conditions, so its functional form is insensitive to the method used to derive it [cf. 33]. Therefore, while we obtain this field using the Brinkman solution [70, 38], other methods provide the same velocity field with a modified pre-factor of less than 2%, including basis-function solutions of the Stokes equations in a gap [49] and Stokes-Oseen approximation of flow around an unconfined cylinder [48]. Because the pre-factors do not affect any conclusions derived here, we can safely ignore the small differences of equation (4) from the Stokes-flow result.

Equation (4) implies that a particle at initial location (δ0,θ0)(\delta_0,\theta_0) will move along the streamline given by δ(t)sin⁡θ(t)=δ0sin⁡θ0\delta(t)\sqrt{\sin\theta(t)} = \delta_0\sqrt{\sin\theta_0}. Since this relation holds for any tt, the quantity b0=δ0sin⁡θ0b_0 = \delta_0\sqrt{\sin\theta_0} is conserved along each streamline. Solving the system dδ/dt=uδd\delta/dt = u_{\delta} and (1/2+δ)−1dθ/dt=uθ(1/2+\delta)^{-1}d\theta/dt = u_{\theta} provides the trajectories

δ=b0sl⁡(b0At+sl⁡−1(b0/δ0)),sin⁡θ=sl⁡2(b0At+sl⁡−1(b0/δ0)).(5)\begin{aligned} \delta&= \frac{b_0}{\operatorname{sl}\left(b_0At+\operatorname{sl}^{-1}(b_0/\delta_0)\right)}, \\ \sin\theta&= \operatorname{sl}^2\left(b_0At+\operatorname{sl}^{-1}(b_0/\delta_0)\right). \tag*{(5)} \end{aligned}

The function sl⁡(⋅)\operatorname{sl}(\cdot) is the lemniscate sine, which is the Jacobi-elliptic generalization of the sine. The function sl⁡\operatorname{sl} is periodic with period 2ϖ≈5.2442\varpi\approx5.244, analogous to 2π2\pi for the trigonometric functions.

The trajectories of equation (5) break down when the particles enter the outer region near the downstream stagnation point, when δ\delta un-physically vanishes. This occurs for trt_r such that θ(tr)≈π−θ0\theta(t_r) \approx\pi-\theta_0 (for θ0>0\theta_0>0; the case θ0<0\theta_0<0 follows by symmetry), which for small values of the initial angle θ0\theta_0 becomes

tr≈πAδ0∣θ0∣.(6)t_r \approx\frac{\pi}{A\delta_0\sqrt{|\theta_0|}}. \tag*{(6)}

This relation implies that particles which started closer to the upstream stagnation point (i.e., with small δ0\delta_0 and θ0\theta_0) will reside longer in the inner region.

Elongation through an inner-region transit

We describe a material line in the inner region as a collection of infinitesimal lamellae at initial locations (δ0,ηθ0)(\delta_0,\eta\theta_0) indexed by η∈[−1,1]\eta\in[-1,1]. The line has initial length ℓ0=aθ0\ell_0 = a\theta_0, where θ0≪1\theta_0 \ll1, and the stretching vectors z(t∣η)\boldsymbol{z}(t \mid\eta) are conditional on η\eta. Each lamella has z∥(0∣η)=0z_{\parallel}(0 \mid\eta) = 0 and z⊥(0∣η)=δℓ0z_{\perp}(0 \mid\eta) = \delta\ell_0. Here and in the following equations, the units have been restored. Lamellae will accumulate elongation as they transit through the inner region of the cylinder, since σ/u2\sigma/u^2 is appreciable in the deformation integral of equation (2.2a). Eventually, the majority of lamellae will pass into the outer region, where σ/u2\sigma/u^2 is negligible and the deformation integral in equation (2.2a) no longer accumulates. Because most lamellae will eventually reside in the outer region of the cylinder, most of the mass eventually resides there, and the outer-region lamellae are expected to dominate the statistics. For this reason, we neglect lamellae still residing within the inner region to calculate elongation statistics in the following. This approach will be further justified later, since the derived results correspond nicely with the numerical simulations of stretching.

The flow in equation (4) produces the constant deformation kernel in the inner region, valid to lowest order in δ\delta:

K(t∣η)=u0δ0η.(7)K(t \mid\eta) = \frac{u_0}{\delta_0\eta}. \tag*{(7)}

Appendix § 10 describes the derivation based on the velocity gradient tensor in flow-aligned coordinates. Using equation (6), the lamella indexed by η\eta resides in the inner region for a timescale

tr(η)≈τ∣η∣−1/2,(8)t_r(\eta) \approx\tau|\eta|^{-1/2}, \tag*{(8)}

where τ=taϖ/(Aδ0θ0)\tau= t_a\varpi/(A\delta_0\sqrt{\theta_0}) is the time when the first lamellae break out of the inner region (those with η=±1\eta= \pm1). The distribution of times spent in the inner region follows by integrating over the uniform distribution of η\eta:

ψI(tr)=2τ2tr3I(τ≤tr),(9)\psi_I(t_r) = \frac{2\tau^2}{t_r^3}\mathcal{I}(\tau\le t_r), \tag*{(9)}

where I(⋅)\mathcal{I}(\cdot) is an indicator function. Lamellae in the outer region at time tt are those with tr(η)<tt_r(\eta) < t, or alternatively ηmin⁡<∣η∣≤1\eta_{\min} < |\eta| \le1, where

ηmin⁡=(τ/t)2.(10)\eta_{\min} = (\tau/t)^2. \tag*{(10)}

The deformation integral carried by outer-region lamellae is formed by multiplying the constant deformation kernel of equation (7) by the residence time over which shear was accumulated in the inner region:

D(η)=u0τℓ0∣η∣3/2sgn⁡(η).(11)D(\eta) = \frac{u_0\tau}{\ell_0|\eta|^{3/2}}\operatorname{sgn}(\eta). \tag*{(11)}

By assumption, all lamellae were initially perpendicular to the flow, so equations (2.2) provide the elongation ρ1(t∣η)=[u(t)/u0]∣D(tr)∣\rho_1(t \mid\eta) = [u(t)/u_0]|D(t_r)|, where the subscript “1” denotes stretching produced by an individual lamella. Once a lamella exits the inner region, its deformation integral DD is assumed frozen at the value accumulated during the inner-region transit, while its velocity u(t)u(t) fluctuates independently in the outer region. Therefore, the averages split as ⟨ρ1q⟩=⟨(u/u0)q⟩⟨∣D∣q⟩\langle\rho_1^q \rangle= \langle(u/u_0)^q\rangle\langle|D|^q\rangle. Assuming outer-region lamellae sample the mean flow velocity of the porous medium (uˉ)(\bar{u}) with narrow and symmetric fluctuations, one obtains ⟨(u/u0)q⟩≈(uˉ/u0)q\langle(u/u_0)^q\rangle\approx(\bar{u}/u_0)^q. Accordingly, the elongation carried by the lamellae in the outer region is

ρ1(tr)=ρ∗(tr/τ)3.(12)\rho_{1}(t_{r})=\rho_{*}\left(t_{r}/\tau\right)^{3}. \tag*{(12)}

Here, ρ∗=uˉτ/ℓ0\rho_{*}=\bar{u}\tau/\ell_{0} is the elongation of the first lamellae to exit the inner region (η=±1\eta=\pm1). Note that equation 4.5 relates η\eta and trt_{r}, so we can equivalently write ρ1\rho_{1} as a function of the lamella index η\eta. Equation 4.9 provides all elongation moments by integrating over the outer-region lamellae:

⟨ρ1(t)q⟩=∫τt[ρ∗(tr/τ)3]qp(tr) dtr≃2ρ∗q3q−2(tτ)3q−2.(13)\langle\rho_{1}(t)^{q}\rangle=\int_{\tau}^{t}\left[\rho_{*}(t_{r}/\tau)^{3}\right]^{q}p(t_{r})\,\mathrm{d}t_{r}\simeq\frac{2\rho_{*}^{q}}{3q-2}\left(\frac{t}{\tau}\right)^{3q-2}. \tag*{(13)}

This formula provides the mean elongation for q=1q=1:

⟨ρ1(t)⟩≃2uˉtℓ0.(14)\langle\rho_{1}(t)\rangle\simeq\frac{2\bar{u}t}{\ell_{0}}. \tag*{(14)}

This result describes two branches extending downstream from the cylinder, each moving with velocity uˉ\bar{u}, which matches the numerical simulations in figure 9B. Likewise, q=2q=2 provides the elongation variance (σρ12=⟨ρ12⟩−⟨ρ1⟩2\sigma_{\rho_{1}}^{2}=\langle\rho_{1}^{2}\rangle-\langle\rho_{1}\rangle^{2}):

σρ12≃12(uˉτℓ0)2(tτ)4,(15)\sigma_{\rho_{1}}^{2}\simeq\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{\bar{u}\tau}{\ell_{0}}\right)^{2}\left(\frac{t}{\tau}\right)^{4}, \tag*{(15)}

consistent with the numerical variance scaling in figure 9C. Under the same assumptions, we can compute the distribution of the elongation from a single cylinder at times large enough that most lamellae are in the outer region. The integral P(ρ1,t)=∫−11dη2δ(ρ1−ρ1(tr(η)))P(\rho_{1},t)=\int_{-1}^{1}\frac{\mathrm{d}\eta}{2}\delta(\rho_{1}-\rho_{1}(t_{r}(\eta))) provides

P(ρ1,t)≃23(uˉτℓ0)2/3ρ1−5/3,(16)P(\rho_{1},t)\simeq\frac{2}{3}\left(\frac{\bar{u}\tau}{\ell_{0}}\right)^{2/3}\rho_{1}^{-5/3}, \tag*{(16)}

over the domain ρ∗≤ρ1≤ρ∗(t/τ)3\rho_{*}\leq\rho_{1}\leq\rho_{*}(t/\tau)^{3}. This result is verified in figure 9D, where it is shown to correspond nicely to the numerical simulations. We also confirmed that the upper truncation values in the distributions of figure 9D increase as t3t^{3} in accord with the domain of equation 4.13. The distribution of equation 4.13 demonstrates that both the elongation and transit-time increments over an isolated cylinder follow truncated power-law distributions. The truncation arises because the maximum elongation at a given time is bounded by the maximum transit time, which is given by the observation time. Because of this truncation, all moments of equation 4.13 converge at any finite time, despite the heavy-tailed decay of the elongation distribution.

Stochastic representation of fluid stretching in porous media

We now formulate a stochastic model for fluid deformation that represents the successive deformation events produced by the encounters of the material line with cylinders. The key model concepts are illustrated in figure 7. A material line is divided into infinitesimal lamellae, and each lamella undergoes a random alternation between inner and outer regions. Transit time distributions ψI(tr)\psi_{I}(t_{r}) and ψO(tr)\psi_{O}(t_{r}) characterize the times lamellae spend in inner and outer regions, respectively. Elongation is considered to accumulate in inner regions only, since the deformation kernel is appreciable there and negligible elsewhere (see figure 7A,). The amount of elongation developed by an inner-region transit is considered as a non-linear function of the transit time, further specified below.

During flow through cylinder arrays, material lines wrap around cylinders as they stretch, and these wraps accumulate differently in ordered and disordered media (see figure 4).

Earlier we noted that the deformation kernel distribution has an identical (K−3/2K^{-3/2}) power-law tail for all heterogeneity levels (see inset (i) of Figure 3B). In Appendix § 10, flow around an isolated cylinder is shown to produce the same power-law scaling. Motivated by this observation, we assume any cylinder in the porous medium produces the same stretching as the isolated cylinder in § 6.2. This representation assumes that cylinders in an array all retain single-cylinder characteristics, so it may overlook some diversity in the stretching process. In particular, we should expect the single-cylinder approximation to break down when separations between cylinders become small compared with the typical size of regions where σ/u2\sigma/u^2 is appreciable. These regions are shown in Figure 7A1. We will show that this single-cylinder assumption successfully describes the asymptotic elongation statistics in the dilute cylinder arrays considered here, but the quality of the approximation may be worse in dense arrays.

In disordered media, material lines progressively wrap around cylinders during transport at a constant rate νw/t\nu_w/t which depends on medium heterogeneity (see Figure 8B). Since the porous structures considered here are without long-ranged correlations and wraps accumulate at a constant rate, a Poisson model is suggested for the outer-region transit time distribution:

ψO(tr)=νwtae−νwt/ta.(17)\psi_O(t_r) = \frac{\nu_w}{t_a}e^{-\nu_w t/t_a}. \tag*{(17)}

This equation contains an implicit dependence on medium heterogeneity, since νw\nu_w grows with ε\varepsilon as shown in Figure 8B.

Elongation in ordered media with flow along a symmetry axis

In ordered media with the flow oriented along a symmetry direction, material lines wrap around the first cylinders they encounter, but subsequent wraps occur only as a finite-time effect due to flow-field imperfections as shown in Figure 4A. The initial line wraps over a number ℓ0/a\ell_0/a of cylinders with line segments of size aa, so the overall elongation distribution is that of an isolated cylinder (§ 6.2) with ℓ0→a\ell_0 \to a, giving the mean ⟨ρ⟩≃2t/ta\langle\rho\rangle\simeq2t/t_a and variance σρ2≃12(τ/ta)2(t/τ)4∼(t/ta)4\sigma_\rho^2 \simeq\frac{1}{2}(\tau/t_a)^2(t/\tau)^4 \sim(t/t_a)^4. Accordingly, flow along a symmetry axis of ordered media produces mean elongation like a shear flow with an effective shear rate 2σˉ2\bar{\sigma}. The factor of 2 comes from the two branches formed when the material line wraps each cylinder. The case of flow not oriented along a symmetry axis of an ordered medium may produce quadratic elongation, similar to disordered media, although this case is not studied here.

Random-walk description of elongation in disordered media

To set up the random exchange process for elongation illustrated in Figure 7, we use a multi-state random walk approach Weiss [93]. In our case, the multiple “states” are the inner and outer regions which have distinct transit-time and deformation statistics (see Figure 7). Multi-state walks can be formulated using three main elements (Weiss [93]; Pierce & Hassan [68]; Zaburdaev et al. [96]):

  1. Propagators through states (denoted rir_i or RiR_i) are probability densities for the time and elongation increments produced by a transit through a state i∈{O,I}i \in\{O,I\}.

  2. Fluxes into states (denoted jij_i) represent transition probability densities between one state and another at each elongation and time.

  3. Probability densities in states (denoted pip_i) measure the likelihood of a lamella being found in state ii with a given elongation and time.

These quantities can be linked through renewal equations, which serve as a generalized Master equation, to describe the elongation dynamics as a stochastic process. This process turns out to be non-Markovian due to the truncated power-law transit-time distribution in inner-regions.

We now define the three elements of the model, starting with the propagators. The propagators have both “complete” and “incomplete” forms. The complete propagators (denoted RiR_i) describe the probability density that a lamella elongates by ρ\rho in a time tt when a transit ends. These involve the transit-time densities ψi(t)\psi_i(t) given in equations (9) and (17). Conversely, the incomplete propagators (rir_i) describe the probability density that a lamella elongates by ρ\rho in a time tt in a transit which is still ongoing. These involves the transit-time survival probabilities ∫t∞ψi(t′) dt′\int_t^\infty\psi_i(t')\,\mathrm{d}t'. For complete transits, we set

rO(ρ,t)=δ(ρ)exp⁡(−νwt/ta)νw/ta,r_O(\rho,t)=\delta(\rho)\exp(-\nu_w t/t_a)\nu_w/t_a,
rI(ρ,t)=I(t≥τ)δ(ρ−ρ∗(t/τ)3)2τ2/t3,(18)r_I(\rho,t)=\mathcal{I}(t\ge\tau)\delta\left(\rho-\rho_*(t/\tau)^3\right)2\tau^2/t^3, \tag*{(18)}

using the assumed exponential wrap-time distribution of equation (17) for OO and the single-cylinder equations (9) and (12) for II. For incomplete transits, we set

RO(ρ,t)=δ(ρ)e−νwt/ta,R_O(\rho,t)=\delta(\rho)e^{-\nu_w t/t_a},
RI(ρ,t)=[(τ/t)2I(t≥τ)+I(t<τ)]δ(ρ),(19)R_I(\rho,t)=\left[(\tau/t)^2\mathcal{I}(t\ge\tau)+\mathcal{I}(t<\tau)\right]\delta(\rho), \tag*{(19)}

using the survival probabilities at time tt, calculated from equations (9) and (17). The indicator functions in the second equation encodes the assumption that elongation accumulates exactly at the moment when lamellae exit the inner region.

The fluxes ji(ρ,t)j_i(\rho,t) represent the probability density that a transit through the state ii begins with elongation ρ\rho at time tt. Assuming that all lamellae initialize in cylinder inner regions at ρ=1\rho=1, these densities can be formulated with the renewal equations [93, 68, 96]:

jO(ρ,t)=∫0ρdρ′∫0tdt′ jI(ρ′,t′)rI(ρ−ρ′,t−t′),j_O(\rho,t)=\int_0^\rho\mathrm{d}\rho'\int_0^t \mathrm{d}t'\,j_I(\rho',t')r_I(\rho-\rho',t-t'),
jI(ρ,t)=δ(ρ−1)δ(t)+∫0ρdρ′∫0tdt′ jO(ρ′,t′)rO(ρ−ρ′,t−t′).(20)j_I(\rho,t)=\delta(\rho-1)\delta(t)+\int_0^\rho\mathrm{d}\rho'\int_0^t \mathrm{d}t'\,j_O(\rho',t')r_O(\rho-\rho',t-t'). \tag*{(20)}

Here, the δ\delta-function terms encode the initial condition, while the integrals represent all possible transitions between states. Specifically, the integral terms sum over all paths where a lamella evolves from (ρ′,t′)(\rho',t') in state jj as it transitions into state ii at (ρ,t)(\rho,t).

The probability densities of ρ\rho at time tt in each state can be written

pi(ρ,t)=∫0ρdρ′∫0tdt′ ji(ρ′,t′)Ri(ρ−ρ′,t−t′),i∈{I,O}.(21)p_i(\rho,t)=\int_0^\rho\mathrm{d}\rho'\int_0^t \mathrm{d}t'\,j_i(\rho',t')R_i(\rho-\rho',t-t'),\qquad i\in\{I,O\}. \tag*{(21)}

These equations describe a lamella that entered state ii at (ρ′,t′)(\rho',t') and remains in that state at (ρ,t)(\rho,t). Equations (20) and (22) constitute a generalized master equation for the multistate random walk in the phase space spanned by i∈{I,O}i\in\{I,O\} and ρ\rho. The elongation distribution is agnostic to which state lamellae exist in and is therefore given by the sum P(ρ,t)=pI(ρ,t)+pO(ρ,t)P(\rho,t)=p_I(\rho,t)+p_O(\rho,t) over both states, which with equation (22) can be written as

P(ρ,t)=∫0ρdρ′∫0tdt′{jI(ρ′,t′)rI(ρ−ρ′,t−t′)+jO(ρ′,t′)rO(ρ−ρ′,t−t′)}.(22)P(\rho,t)=\int_0^\rho\mathrm{d}\rho'\int_0^t \mathrm{d}t'\left\{j_I(\rho',t')r_I(\rho-\rho',t-t')+j_O(\rho',t')r_O(\rho-\rho',t-t')\right\}. \tag*{(22)}

To obtain the elongation moments, we now introduce the double Laplace transform of a function f(ρ,t)f(\rho,t) as

f~(g,s)=∫0∞dt′∫0∞dρ′exp⁡(−st′−gρ′)f(ρ′,t′),(23)\tilde{f}(g,s)=\int_{0}^{\infty}dt'\int_{0}^{\infty}d\rho'\exp(-st'-g\rho')f(\rho',t'), \tag*{(23)}

with Laplace variables gg and ss corresponding to ρ\rho and tt, respectively. Transforming the flux equations (20) provides

j~O=j~Ir~I,j~I=e−g+j~Oνwνw+tas,(24)\begin{aligned} \tilde{j}_{O}&=\tilde{j}_{I}\tilde{r}_{I},\\ \tilde{j}_{I}&=e^{-g}+\tilde{j}_{O}\frac{\nu_{w}}{\nu_{w}+t_{a}s}, \tag*{(24)} \end{aligned}

where we evaluated r~O(g,s)=νw/(νw+tas)\tilde{r}_{O}(g,s)=\nu_{w}/(\nu_{w}+t_{a}s) and r~I(g,s)=2τ2∫τ∞1t′3exp⁡(−st′−gρ∗τ3t′3)dt′\tilde{r}_{I}(g,s)=2\tau^{2}\int_{\tau}^{\infty}\frac{1}{t'^{3}}\exp\left(-st'-\frac{g\rho_{*}}{\tau^{3}}t'^{3}\right)dt'. Likewise, Laplace transforming equation (22) gives

P~=j~IR~I+j~Otaνw+tas,(25)\tilde{P}=\tilde{j}_{I}\tilde{R}_{I}+\tilde{j}_{O}\frac{t_{a}}{\nu_{w}+t_{a}s}, \tag*{(25)}

where we evaluated R~O(g,s)=ta/(νw+tas)\tilde{R}_{O}(g,s)=t_{a}/(\nu_{w}+t_{a}s) and R~I(g,s)=1−e−sτs+τ2∫τ∞e−st′t′2dt′\tilde{R}_{I}(g,s)=\frac{1-e^{-s\tau}}{s}+\tau^{2}\int_{\tau}^{\infty}\frac{e^{-st'}}{t'^{2}}dt'. Combining equations (24) and (25) thus provides the exact result

P~(g,s)=e−g(νw+tas)R~I+tar~Itas+νw(1−r~I)(26)\tilde{P}(g,s)=e^{-g}\frac{(\nu_{w}+t_{a}s)\tilde{R}_{I}+t_{a}\tilde{r}_{I}}{t_{a}s+\nu_{w}(1-\tilde{r}_{I})} \tag*{(26)}

for the Laplace-transformed elongation distribution. While in principle, Laplace inversion of this equation would provide the full elongation distribution P(ρ,t)P(\rho,t), the inversion is prohibitively difficult due to the integrals in r~I\tilde{r}_{I} and R~I\tilde{R}_{I} that encode the non-Markovian character of the elongation dynamics. Note that, while equation (26) was explicitly developed for disordered cylinder arrays, it also applies to ordered arrays along symmetry directions by setting νw=0\nu_{w}=0, meaning it contains the results of section 4.4 as a special case.

Moments of elongation in heterogeneous cylinder arrays

We calculate the elongation moments ⟨ρq⟩\langle\rho^{q}\rangle of order q=1,2,…q=1,2,\ldots in cylinder arrays by differentiating equation (26) with respect to gg. This yields the moments of ρ\rho via the relation ⟨ρq⟩=(−∂g)qP~(g,s)∣g=0\langle\rho^{q}\rangle=(-\partial_{g})^{q}\tilde{P}(g,s)|_{g=0}, an identity derived from equation (23). The t→∞t\to\infty moments are derived from this relation using an s→0s\to0 analysis of equation (26) in appendix C. This involves evaluating the integrals for r~I(g,s)\tilde{r}_{I}(g,s) and R~I(g,s)\tilde{R}_{I}(g,s) as s→0s\to0, incorporating these into equation (26), and evaluating derivatives with respect for gg of arbitrary order as s→0s\to0. The resulting formulas encompass both ordered (using νw=0\nu_{w}=0) and disordered (with νw≠0\nu_{w}\ne0) cylinder-array elongation moments by selecting the leading order of tt in equation (C4). From this process, we determine the mean elongation at large times:

⟨ρ⟩≃{2tta,ordered medium (symmetry axis);2νwaℓ0(tℓ0)2,disordered medium (all ε≠0).(27)\langle\rho\rangle\simeq \begin{cases} \frac{2t}{t_{a}}, & \text{ordered medium (symmetry axis);}\\ \frac{2\nu_{w}a}{\ell_{0}}\left(\frac{t}{\ell_{0}}\right)^{2}, & \text{disordered medium (all }\varepsilon\ne0\text{).} \end{cases} \tag*{(27)}

This result shows that stretching is linear in ordered cylinder arrays when the flow aligns with a symmetry axis (section 4.4), while it is quadratic in disordered arrays regardless of the amount of medium heterogeneity ε\varepsilon. The case of an ordered medium with flow not along a symmetry axis is expected to provide elongation like a disordered medium, although we do not analyze this here. For quadratic stretching, the pre-factor depends on the wrap rate νw\nu_w and therefore the medium heterogeneity through the observed relation between νw\nu_w and ε\varepsilon in Figure 8B. These scalings are overlaid on the simulated mean elongation in Figure 5A, where they closely correspond with the data at asymptotic times. The inset of Figure 5A plots the pre-factor of the quadratic mean elongation against the heterogeneity parameter ε\varepsilon, showing an increasing relation, similar to the direct wrap-counting in § 6.1.

A similar calculation gives the scaling of the elongation variance:

σρ2∼{t4,ordered medium (symmetry axis);t5,disordered medium (all ε≠0).(28)\sigma_{\rho}^{2} \sim\begin{cases} t^{4}, & \text{ordered medium (symmetry axis)}; \\ t^{5}, & \text{disordered medium (all } \varepsilon\ne0\text{).} \end{cases} \tag*{(28)}

Together, these results provide different scalings for the relative variation of the elongation in ordered and disordered cylinder arrays:

σρ⟨ρ⟩∼{t,ordered medium (symmetry axis);t1/2,disordered medium (all ε≠0).(29)\frac{\sigma_{\rho}}{\langle\rho\rangle} \sim\begin{cases} t, & \text{ordered medium (symmetry axis)}; \\ t^{1/2}, & \text{disordered medium (all } \varepsilon\ne0\text{).} \end{cases} \tag*{(29)}

These scalings are overlaid on the data in Figure 5B, showing a good match with the stretching simulations. Note that the disordered-media scalings also fit the ordered-media elongation statistics in Figure 5, likely because of the flow-field asymmetries we previously noted in Figure 2A, which eventually lead to additional cylinder wrapping events in ordered media, lending late-time nonlinearity to the elongation moments. However, the converse is not true, and the disordered-media elongation grows unambiguously as a nonlinear function of time. The progressive wrapping of cylinders during transport is the essential ingredient to capture the observed nonlinear elongation moments in disordered cylinder arrays.

The model developed in this section is a type of coupled continuous time random walk, similar to the deformation model developed by Dentz et al. [19]. Building on this paradigm, we have related both the temporal statistics (equation (9)) and the coupling between the timescales and elongation increments (equation (12)) to the flow around an isolated cylinder. Additionally, we extended the random walk to have multiple states, which allowed us to integrate the temporal frequency of cylinder encounters, νw/ta\nu_w/t_a, into the description. Since νw\nu_w has an increasing relation to ε\varepsilon (§ 6.1), the model developed in this section predicts faster elongation in more heterogeneous cylinder arrays, although with the same scaling exponent ⟨ρ⟩∝t2\langle\rho\rangle\propto t^2 for all disordered arrays (ε≠0\varepsilon\ne0). In the discussion, we will further study the dependence of elongation on medium heterogeneity by introducing theoretical arguments to connect νw\nu_w and ε\varepsilon.

Discussion

We have studied fluid stretching in porous media composed of heterogeneous cylinder arrays and identified different scaling relations for the elongation moments in ordered and disordered media. To explain the observed stretching statistics, we analytically studied the stretching of a material line wrapping over a solitary cylinder, and we developed a random walk model that builds on the solitary-cylinder stretching to quantify elongation across multiple cylinder encounters. Our approach successfully predicts the elongation moments at asymptotic times, demonstrating that the wrapping of the material line around cylinders provides the dominant mechanism of stretching in the considered porous media.

Relation of wrap-frequency to medium structure

Our stochastic description relates the pre-factor of the quadratic mean-stretching relation in disordered media (equation (27)) to the dimensionless frequency νw\nu_w of cylinder wrapping. Wrapping will occur when a streamline traced from the upstream stagnation point of a cylinder intersects the plume. In ordered cylinder arrays, these streamlines span between cylinders and do not cross the initial filament, so wraps do not accumulate. However, in disordered cylinder arrays, heterogeneity perturbs the streamlines and increases the likelihood of wrapping.

To relate the wrapping frequency to the medium structure, we assume that streamlines shift over a characteristic distance σλ\sigma_{\lambda}, the average deviation in throat size (see appendix § 9), which suggests a probability p=σλ/a≈0.182εp = \sigma_{\lambda}/a \approx0.182\varepsilon that a stagnation-point streamline shifts enough to intersect the initial plume. Noting that the plume sweeps out ϱℓ0\varrho\ell_0 cylinders in tat_a, with ϱ=1/(2a)\varrho= 1/(2a) the linear density of cylinders, we can model the dimensionless wrap rate as:

νw=ϱℓ0p≈0.09εℓ0/a.(30)\nu_w = \varrho\ell_0 p \approx0.09\varepsilon\ell_0/a. \tag*{(30)}

In the inset of Figure 5A, we fit a linear relation between νw\nu_w and ε\varepsilon from the pre-factors of the quadratic fit, and we determine that νw=(0.08±0.01)εℓ0/a\nu_w = (0.08 \pm0.01)\varepsilon\ell_0/a, which corresponds well to the model developed here. Using equation (27), this correspondence suggests that the simple relation

⟨ρ⟩=2ϱσλ(t/ta)2(31)\langle\rho\rangle= 2\varrho\sigma_{\lambda}(t/t_a)^2 \tag*{(31)}

can relate the quadratic mean elongation to the medium structure in different disordered media. In addition to inferring the wrap rate νw\nu_w from fitting the model to the elongation observations, we also measured the wrap rate directly from the simulated plumes and found νw=(0.11±0.05)ℓ0ε/a\nu_w = (0.11 \pm0.05)\ell_0\varepsilon/a in § 6.1. Although this result has large uncertainty due to the definition used to detect wrapping events, its consistency with equation (30) confers additional support to the model developed here.

Prediction of stretching in heterogeneous media

The presented stochastic framework shares some analogies with the Lévy-walk description developed by Dentz et al. [19] for stretching in heterogeneous porous media at Darcy scale. They introduced a power-law distribution p(t)∼t−1−βp(t) \sim t^{-1-\beta} of residence times and related the elongation increment and residence time as ρ∼tα\rho\sim t^{\alpha} by assuming a linear relationship between the velocity and shear. While the Lévy-walk description of Dentz et al. [19] proposed these scaling exponents phenomenologically, our framework explicitly relates them to the fluid mechanics of stretching around the isolated cylinder, evaluated in § 6.2. Additionally, our approach includes alternations between high- and low-velocity states to incorporate the effects of medium heterogeneity into the description. Using the theory by Dentz et al. [19], we find exponents β=2\beta= 2 from equation (9) and α=3\alpha= 3 from equation (14), which predicts mean elongation scaling as ⟨ρ⟩∼t1+α−β=t2\langle\rho\rangle\sim t^{1+\alpha-\beta} = t^2, exactly as observed in disordered media for all ε≠0\varepsilon\ne0 (Figure 5A). In contrast, the transit-time distribution is nonstationary along the symmetry directions of ordered media, so these are outside the scope of the Lévy-walk description.

In other quasi-two-dimensional porous structures besides cylinder arrays [e.g. 37], fluid stretching is likely medium-dependent, although the constrained flow properties near walls may offer a useful simplification. Near walls, velocity distributions are typically algebraic [8, 41, 4, 78], and the shear determines the velocity as follows: Using wall coordinates x=(x⊥,x∥)x = (x_{\perp},x_{\parallel}), the no-slip and incompressibility conditions yield velocities u=(−12(∂σ/∂x∥)x⊥2,σx⊥)\boldsymbol{u} = (-\frac{1}{2}(\partial\sigma/\partial x_{\parallel})x_{\perp}^{2},\sigma x_{\perp}) [48]. For motions predominantly along the wall, the streamwise velocity and shear thus become proportional, u≈σx⊥u \approx\sigma x_{\perp}, which satisfies a key assumption of the Lévy-walk description (Dentz et al. [19]) and provides a deformation kernel that localizes near walls as K=σ/u2∝x⊥−1K = \sigma/u^2 \propto x_{\perp}^{-1}. Away from walls, velocity distributions are typically thin-tailed [12, 74, 36, 57] (see also Figure 3A), and shear deformation may be negligible (see inset (ii) of Figure 3B). The model presented in § 6.5 alternates between near-wall and bulk flows to describe stretching, utilizing the constrained near-wall flow characteristics to calculate stretching (§ 6.2). A similar approach separating near-wall and bulk flow regions to evaluate deformation could be useful in other discrete structures, including three-dimensional media, where the coordination of near-wall shear and flow helicity density in the bulk can give rise to chaotic advection (Turuban et al. 2018; Lester et al. 2025).

Evaluation of the full elongation distribution

The early studies of fluid elongation were in turbulent flows [6], where the governing equation is z(t)=exp⁡T[∫0tdt′L(t′)]z(0)z(t) = \exp_{\mathrm{T}}\left[\int_{0}^{t} \mathrm{d}t'\mathbf{L}(t')\right]z(0), which involves the time-ordered exponential of the integrated velocity gradient tensor [13]. This equation is inherently multiplicative, since the exponential splits over weakly-correlated time intervals [21]. Accordingly, unsteady flows readily produce log-normal-like elongation distributions, as seen in a diversity of contexts (Kraichnan 1974; Khakhar & Ottino 1986; Drummond & Münch 1990; Girimaji & Pope 1990; Muzzio et al. 1992; Arratia & Gollub 2005; Subramanian et al. 2009; Souzy et al. 2017).

In steady flows, the Poincaré-Bendixson theorem ensures that streamlines cannot cross, which in the Protean-frame renders the velocity gradient tensor upper triangular; the constraint of non-crossing streamlines thereby simplifies the time-ordered exponential and modifies the multiplicative structure of the stretching equations [19, 53]. In two dimensions, the equations become additive (equations (2.2)), so there is no obvious reason to expect log-normal stretching. In three dimensions, the equations retain multiplicative structure as the transverse stretching remains multiplicative, while the longitudinal shear accumulates as a time integral over the transverse deformation components [53]. Accordingly, three-dimensional steady flows can still produce log-normal-like stretching (Lester & Dentz 2025), as observed both in porous media [78] and static mixers [34, 35]. The same conclusion of log-normal stretching can be inferred for two-dimensional unsteady flows (Lester & Dentz 2026).

The stochastic stretching model developed in § 6.5 represents the total elongation as the sum of independent, power-law-distributed stretching increments. According to the generalized central limit theorem, the sum of such heavy-tailed variables converges asymptotically to a Lévy-stable distribution [96], as recovered by the s→0s \to0 Laplace inversion of equation (26). However, the maximum elongation of lamellae is also bounded by the observation time, creating a time-dependent truncation in the elongation increments (equation (14)). Truncated Lévy processes have “ultra-slow” convergence to the asymptotic limit, with typically three orders of magnitude slower convergence compared to the case without truncation which requires typically ∼10\sim10 events [56], meaning times exceeding 103ta10^3 t_a could be required to observe the asymptotic elongation distribution. Consequently, a pre-asymptotic distribution likely dominates over the timescales examined here, explaining why the observed distributions lack the heavy power-law tails of the Lévy-stable form. Furthermore, our model assumes identical elongation statistics per cylinder encounter. This single-cylinder approximation suffices for predicting the asymptotic moments in our relatively-dilute cylinder arrays, which are largely controlled by the most-stretched lamellae in the tail of the stretching distribution [cf. 88].

Arrays with touching or near-touching inclusions will produce different elongation behavior. For pore throats much smaller than aa, the deformation kernel KK still localizes near solid boundaries (Figure 7), but the single-cylinder model becomes a crude approximation. This breakdown may explain the continuous scaling exponent ⟨ρ⟩∼tβ\langle\rho\rangle\sim t^\beta (0.5≤β≤20.5 \le\beta\le2) observed in random-permeability Darcy flows [46]. Accounting for more structural variability in stretching increments would likely broaden the core of the elongation distribution, further altering its pre-asymptotic shape. Analyzing the pre-asymptotic elongation distribution in additional detail remains as a subject for future work.

Implications for mixing in heterogeneous media

Studies of transport and reactions often use randomly-arranged cylinders as prototypical porous media [3, 39, 94, 58, 11]. Some of these studies have represented pore-scale elongation as simple shear flow [3, 39, 11], with a shear rate set by the pore size and mean flow velocity. In contrast to this linear-stretching assumption and in accord with Dentz et al. [19], we found quadratic-in-time scaling for the mean fluid elongation in disordered cylinder arrays (Figure 5), and we described this nonlinear elongation from the accumulated encounters of the plume with low-velocity regions near cylinder walls (§ 6.5). This quadratic stretching arises because each time the plume wraps a cylinder, two branches are generated, and each branch stretches as simple shear. The wrap rate (νw\nu_w) grows with medium heterogeneity (ε\varepsilon), so although quadratic scaling exists for all ε≠0\varepsilon\ne0, elongation grows with a larger pre-factor in more disordered cylinder arrays.

Nonlinear elongation in disordered media has important implications for relating the rate of mixing to the Péclet number characterizing the relative importance of advection and diffusion. According to the lamellar theory and neglecting lamella aggregation [46, 90], for algebraic mean elongation (⟨ρ⟩∼tα\langle\rho\rangle\sim t^\alpha), the time tmixt_{\mathrm{mix}} at which concentrations begin to decay obeys tmix∼Pe−2/3t_{\mathrm{mix}} \sim Pe^{-2/3} in ordered media (α=1\alpha= 1) and tmix∼Pe−4/5t_{\mathrm{mix}} \sim Pe^{-4/5} in disordered media (α=2\alpha= 2). Medium heterogeneity can therefore markedly speed up mixing, a characteristic not captured by the simple shear assumption. For example, by comparing tmixt_{\mathrm{mix}} between ordered and disordered media at Pe∼103Pe \sim10^3, which is a typical value in groundwater and laboratory settings [9], disorder shortens the mixing time by about 60 %. At the same time, additional elongation packs more lamellae into each pore (see inset of Figure 5B), increasing the chance of lamella aggregation [89, 31].

Conclusion

Fluid stretching in two-dimensional steady flows through porous media is governed by the ratio of shear and squared velocity, a quantity that localizes near solid boundaries. This localization enables an analytical representation of stretching through random cylinder arrays as a random alternation of lamellae into and out of near-wall regions, giving a mean elongation ⟨ρ⟩\langle\rho\rangle proportional to tt for flow along symmetry directions of ordered arrays and t2t^2 for flow through disordered arrays, regardless of the amount of medium heterogeneity. The rapidly-growing higher moments (⟨ρq⟩\langle\rho^q \rangle, of order q=1,2,…q = 1, 2, \ldots) scale as t3q−2t^{3q-2} (ordered) and t3q−1t^{3q-1} (disordered). We have described this nonlinear and microstructure-dependent fluid stretching using a random-walk framework, showing how near-wall shear and the frequency of wall encounters determine the bulk elongation statistics. This framework reveals that the common representation of stretching in disordered cylinder arrays as a simple shear flow is incorrect, instead showing a non-linear mean elongation growth in time consistent with the Protean-frame elongation theory developed by Dentz et al. [19]. The essential mechanism for quadratic elongation is that wraps over cylinders accumulate linearly in time and generate new branches, while each of these branches stretches as simple shear. By combining the statistics of single-cylinder stretching with a medium-dependent boundary-encounter frequency, our framework also opens pathways to describe the full distribution of elongations. The observed elongation distributions are not log-normal over the observed timescales, consistent with the additive stretching mechanisms in two-dimensional steady flows. Instead, the developed theory predicts an asymptotic Lévy stable distribution, although with an extremely slow convergence due to the time-dependent truncations of the underlying elongation-increment distributions.

Algebraic stretching ⟨ρ⟩∼tα\langle\rho\rangle\sim t^{\alpha} implies a mixing time tmix∼Pe−2α/(1+2α)t_{\mathrm{mix}} \sim Pe^{-2\alpha/(1+2\alpha)} in mean-field approximation when neglecting lamella aggregation, meaning tmix∼Pe−2/3t_{\mathrm{mix}} \sim Pe^{-2/3} for ordered media and tmix∼Pe−4/5t_{\mathrm{mix}} \sim Pe^{-4/5} for disordered media. The efficiency of mixing markedly differs between ordered and disordered media owing to the increased number of solid-boundary encounters in disordered media. For example, at Pe=103Pe = 10^3 and neglecting lamella aggregation, the mixing time is 2.5×2.5\times shorter in disordered media. At the same time, increased stretching packs more lamellae into the pores, which will increase the propensity for lamella aggregation [89, 31]. Whether these predicted differences in mixing from medium heterogeneity will survive lamella aggregation remains an important open prospect, as does the extension of our framework to other porous structures.

Acknowledgements KP and GL thank Tomás Aquino, Marco Dentz, Joachim Mathiesen, and Marcel Moura for valuable discussions, and the Centre for Advanced Study at the Norwegian Academy of Science and Letters for their hospitality.

Funding This work was funded by the Research Council of Norway from grants 325819 (FRINATEK—M4), 262644 (Center of Excellence—Porelab), and 353372 (FRIPRO—MinMix). The work was also supported by the Centre for Advanced Study in Oslo, through the Young CAS project Mixing by Interfaces to GL.

Declaration of interests The authors report no conflict of interest.

Data availability statement The divergence-corrected flow fields and simulation/analysis scripts used in this study are freely available at https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20027043. Our software for divergence correction of porous flow fields (Pierce et al. 2025) can be downloaded from https://github.com/jk pierce/deldotnot.

Author ORCIDs K. Pierce, https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3670-8636; T. Le Borgne, https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9266-9139; F. Renard, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5125-5930; G. Linga, https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0987-8704.

Characterization of porous structures

The coordinates of two neighboring cylinders in the medium (labeled 0 and 1) can be written as

x0=aε2r0(cos⁡θ0,sin⁡θ0),x1=(2a,0)+aε2r1(cos⁡θ1,sin⁡θ1),(32)\begin{aligned} x_0 &= \frac{a\varepsilon}{2}\sqrt{r_0}(\cos\theta_0,\sin\theta_0),\\ x_1 &= (2a,0)+\frac{a\varepsilon}{2}\sqrt{r_1}(\cos\theta_1,\sin\theta_1), \tag*{(32)} \end{aligned}

where r0r_0, r1r_1, θ0\theta_0, and θ1\theta_1 are all independent uniform random variables, with 0≤ri≤10 \le r_i \le1 and 0≤θi≤2π0 \le\theta_i \le2\pi. The square root appears for equation (A.1) to ensure uniform-area sampling in the perturbation of each lattice site. The pore-throat size can be computed as λ=∣x1−x0∣−a\lambda= \lvert x_1-x_0\rvert-a, which to lowest order in ε\varepsilon is

λa=1+εc2,(33)\frac{\lambda}{a}=1+\frac{\varepsilon c}{2}, \tag*{(33)}

where the random variable c=(r1cos⁡θ1−r0cos⁡θ0)/2c=(\sqrt{r_1}\cos\theta_1-\sqrt{r_0}\cos\theta_0)/2 combines the original four. This low-order expansion reliably approximates the nearest-neighbor distance. Note that −1≤c≤1-1\le c\le1. The distribution of cc can be evaluated by integrating out the four independent random variables involved in it, giving the exact result

P(c)=(4π)2∫max⁡(−1/2,−1/2+c)min⁡(1/2,1/2−c)1−4z21−4(z−c)2 dz.(34)P(c)=\left(\frac{4}{\pi}\right)^2\int_{\max(-1/2,-1/2+c)}^{\min(1/2,1/2-c)}\sqrt{1-4z^2}\sqrt{1-4(z-c)^2}\,\mathrm{d}z. \tag*{(34)}

The integral can be evaluated by steepest descent, giving the approximation:

P(c)≈(1−c2)21+c2.(35)P(c)\approx\frac{(1-c^2)^2}{\sqrt{1+c^2}}. \tag*{(35)}

This distribution can be transformed to the throat-size distribution through equation (A 2). In particular, the mean throat size can be computed as λˉ=a\bar{\lambda}=a, and its relative variation can calculated as σλ/λˉ≈0.182ε\sigma_\lambda/\bar{\lambda}\approx0.182\varepsilon, showing a linear relationship between the disorder parameter and the throat size fluctuations.

Deformation kernel in the inner region

For a particle started near a cylinder at initial coordinates (δ0,θ0)(\delta_0,\theta_0), the trajectories (equation (5)) show two short-lived durations (Ab0)−1(Ab_0)^{-1} near the stagnation points on the cylinder where the radial motion dominates (∣uδ∣≫∣uθ∣|u_\delta|\gg|u_\theta|). The first of these periods implies that the initial streamwise velocity is given by u(0)=∣ur(0)∣=Aδ02u(0)=|u_r(0)|=A\delta_0^2, independent of θ0\theta_0. Otherwise, for the majority of the time the particle spends in the inner region, the angular motion dominates, and the movement direction approximately aligns with increasing θ\theta, so that u≈∣uθ∣u\approx|u_\theta|. In this regime, the velocity gradient tensor can be computed to lowest order in δ\delta as:

L≈A(−2δcos⁡θ−2δsin⁡θsin⁡θ2δcos⁡θ).(36)L\approx A\begin{pmatrix}-2\delta\cos\theta& -2\delta\sin\theta\\ \sin\theta& 2\delta\cos\theta\end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(36)}

This tensor is already in a streamline frame to lowest order (L′≈LL'\approx L), since the flow is primarily tangential. Note that Tr⁡(L)=0\operatorname{Tr}(L)=0 as required by incompressibility. The non-dimensionalized streamwise shear to lowest order is therefore σ≈Asin⁡θ\sigma\approx A\sin\theta, which combines with u0≈Aδ02u_0\approx A\delta_0^2, δsin⁡θ=δ0sin⁡θ0\delta\sin\theta=\delta_0\sin\theta_0 (streamline constraint), and u(t)≈∣uθ(t)∣u(t)\approx|u_\theta(t)| to provide the constant deformation kernel equation (7) after restoring dimensions, valid throughout the tangential-motion regime.

We can also evaluate the deformation kernel distribution by calculating KK without the streamline constraint, obtaining K∼(δ2sin⁡θ)−1K\sim(\delta^2\sin\theta)^{-1}. With uniformly-distributed δ\delta and θ\theta, this gives P(K)∼K−3/2P(K)\sim K^{-3/2}, implying that isolated cylinders and porous models have identical large-deviation statistics (see inset (i) of Figure 3B).

Stretching statistics in cylinder arrays

To calculate the asymptotic elongation moments from the Laplace-transformed distribution of equation (26), we note that the large tt scaling of the moments relates to the s→0s\to0 scaling of the distribution via standard Tauberian theorems. The small-ss inner-region densities in equation (26) can be calculated as:

r~I(g,s)≃ψ~I(s)+2∑q=1∞(−gρ∗)qq!(sτ)2−3qΓ(3q−2),R~I(g,s)≃1−ψ~I(s)s.(37)\begin{aligned} \tilde r_I(g,s)&\simeq\tilde\psi_I(s)+2\sum_{q=1}^{\infty}\frac{(-g\rho_*)^q}{q!}(s\tau)^{2-3q}\Gamma(3q-2),\\ \tilde R_I(g,s)&\simeq\frac{1-\tilde\psi_I(s)}{s}. \tag*{(37)} \end{aligned}

where ψ~I\tilde\psi_I is the Laplace transform of equation (9). The result for r~I\tilde r_I can be obtained by Taylor expanding the integrands in its Laplace transforms and integrating term by term.

The Laplace-transformed elongation moments of order qq derive from ⟨ρ~(s)q⟩=lim⁡g→0(−∂g)qP~(g,s)\langle\tilde\rho(s)^q\rangle=\lim_{g\to0}(-\partial_g)^q\tilde P(g,s). Repeated application of −∂g-\partial_g to equation (26) provides the recursion relation

(−∂g)qP~(g,s)=e−g[(vw+tas)R~I+tar~I]+∑k=0q−1(qk)[tae−g+vw(−∂g)kP~](−∂g)q−kr~Itas+vw(1−r~I).(38)(-\partial_g)^q\tilde P(g,s)=\frac{e^{-g}\left[(v_w+t_as)\tilde R_I+t_a\tilde r_I\right]+\sum_{k=0}^{q-1}\binom{q}{k}\left[t_ae^{-g}+v_w(-\partial_g)^k\tilde P\right](-\partial_g)^{q-k}\tilde r_I}{t_as+v_w(1-\tilde r_I)}. \tag*{(38)}

For s→0s\to0 (long times), the k=0k=0 term dominates in the sum, and the Laplace-space moments become

⟨ρ~(s)q⟩≃1s+2τρ∗q[(sτ)1−3q+fI(sτ)−3q]Γ(3q−2).(39)\left\langle\tilde\rho(s)^q\right\rangle\simeq\frac{1}{s}+2\tau\rho_*^q\left[(s\tau)^{1-3q}+f_I(s\tau)^{-3q}\right]\Gamma(3q-2). \tag*{(39)}

where we have used R~I(s)∼2τ\tilde R_I(s)\sim2\tau, r~I(0,s)∼1−2τs\tilde r_I(0,s)\sim1-2\tau s, and P~(0,s)∼1/s\tilde P(0,s)\sim1/s. The mean residence time is 2τ2\tau in the inner region and ta/vwt_a/v_w in outer regions. We introduced the notation fI=2τ/[ta/vw+2τ]f_I=2\tau/[t_a/v_w+2\tau] for the expected fraction of time lamellae spend in inner regions. Because most lamellae have short residence times in the inner region, the mean time between subsequent wraps will be much larger than the average inner-region residence time (ta/νw≫2τt_a/\nu_w \gg2\tau), meaning fI≈2τνw/taf_I \approx2\tau\nu_w/t_a. The temporal moments follow from the inverse Laplace transform of equation (C3):

⟨ρ(t)q⟩≃1+2ρ∗q3q−2(tτ)3q−2+4τνwρ∗q(3q−1)(3q−2)ta(tτ)3q−1.(40)\langle\rho(t)^q \rangle\simeq1 + \frac{2\rho_*^q}{3q-2}\left(\frac{t}{\tau}\right)^{3q-2} + \frac{4\tau\nu_w\rho_*^q}{(3q-1)(3q-2)t_a}\left(\frac{t}{\tau}\right)^{3q-1}. \tag*{(40)}

Finally, equation (C4) provides equation (27) from q=1q = 1 and equation (28) from q=2q = 2. Significantly, equation (C4) applies regardless of medium heterogeneity by selecting the dominant-order term for the ordered case (νw=0\nu_w = 0) or the disordered case (νw>0\nu_w > 0).

References

  1. [1]Adachi, K. 1983 Calculation of strain histories in Protean coordinate systems. Rheologica Acta 22 (4), 326–335.DOI
  2. [2]Alim, Karen, Parsa, Shima, Weitz, David A. & Brenner, Michael P. 2017 Local pore size correlations determine flow distributions in porous media. Physical Review Letters 119 (14), 144501.DOI
  3. [3]de Anna, Pietro, Jimenez-Martinez, Joaquin, Taubeteau, Hervé, Turuban, Régis, Le Borgne, Tanguy, Derrien, Morgane & Méheust, Yves 2014 Mixing and reaction kinetics in porous media: An experimental pore scale quantification. Environmental Science & Technology 48 (1), 508–516.DOI
  4. [4]de Anna, Pietro, Quaife, Bryan, Biros, George & Juanes, Ruben 2017 Prediction of the low-velocity distribution from the pore structure in simple porous media. Physical Review Fluids 2 (12), 124103.DOI
  5. [6]Batchelor, George Keith 1952 The effect of homogeneous turbulence on material lines and surfaces. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A. Mathematical and Physical Sciences 213 (1114), 349–366.DOI
  6. [7]Ben-Noah, Ilan, Hidalgo, Juan J. & Dentz, Marco 2024 Pore network models to determine the flow statistics and structural controls for single-phase flow in partially saturated porous media. Advances in Water Resources 193, 104809.DOI
  7. [8]Berkowitz, Brian & Scher, Harvey 1997 Anomalous Transport in Random Fracture Networks. Physical Review Letters 79 (20), 4038–4041.DOI
  8. [9]Bijeljic, Branko & Blunt, Martin J. 2006 Pore-scale modeling and continuous time random walk analysis of dispersion in porous media. Water Resources Research 42 (1).DOI
  9. [10]Borer, Benedict, Tecon, Robin & Or, Dani 2018 Spatial organization of bacterial populations in response to oxygen and carbon counter-gradients in pore networks. Nature Communications 9 (1), 769.DOI
  10. [11]Borgman, Oshri, Turuban, Régis, Géraud, Baudouin, Le Borgne, Tanguy & Méheust, Yves 2023 Solute front shear and coalescence control concentration gradient dynamics in porous micromodel. Geophysical Research Letters 50 (5), e2022GL101407.DOI
  11. [12]Cenedese, Antonio & Viotti, Paolo 1996 Lagrangian analysis of nonreactive pollutant dispersion in porous media by means of the particle image velocimetry technique. Water Resources Research 32 (8), 2329–2343.DOI
  12. [13]Cocke, W. J. 1969 Turbulent hydrodynamic line stretching: Consequences of isotropy. The Physics of Fluids 12 (12), 2488–2492.DOI
  13. [14]Cunha, Lucas H. P., Zhao, Jingjing, MacKintosh, Fred C. & Biswal, Sibani Lisa 2022 Settling dynamics of Brownian chains in viscous fluids. Physical Review Fluids 7 (3), 034303.DOI
  14. [15]Dentz, M., De Barros, F. P. J., Le Borgne, T. & Lester, D. R. 2018a Evolution of solute blobs in heterogeneous porous media. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 853, 621–646.DOI
  15. [16]Dentz, Marco, Hidalgo, Juan J. & Lester, Daniel 2023 Mixing in porous media: Concepts and approaches across scales. Transport in Porous Media 146 (1), 5–53.DOI
  16. [17]Dentz, M., Icardi, M. & Hidalgo, J. J. 2018b Mechanisms of dispersion in a porous medium. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 841, 851–882.DOI
  17. [18]Dentz, Marco, Kang, Peter K., Comolli, Alessandro, Le Borgne, Tanguy & Lester, Daniel R. 2016a Continuous time random walks for the evolution of Lagrangian velocities. Physical Review Fluids 1 (7), 074004.DOI
  18. [19]Dentz, Marco, Lester, Daniel R., Le Borgne, Tanguy & De Barros, Felipe P. J. 2016b Coupled continuous-time random walks for fluid stretching in two-dimensional heterogeneous media. Physical Review E 94 (6), 061102.DOI
  19. [20]Dimotakis, Paul E. & Catrakis, Haris J. 1999 Turbulence, fractals, and mixing. In Mixing: Chaos and Turbulence (ed. H. Chaté, E. Villermaux & J.-M. Chomaz), pp. 59–143. Boston, MA: Springer US.
  20. [21]Drummond, I. T. & Münch, W. 1990 Turbulent stretching of line and surface elements. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 215, 45–59.DOI
  21. [22]Du Roure, Olivia, Lindner, Anke, Nazockdast, Ehssan N. & Shelley, Michael J. 2019 Dynamics of Flexible Fibers in Viscous Flows and Fluids. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 51 (1), 539–572.DOI
  22. [23]Duplat, J., Innocenti, C. & Villermaux, E. 2010 A nonsequential turbulent mixing process. Physics of Fluids 22 (3), 035104.DOI
  23. [24]Durlofsky, L. & Brady, J. F. 1987 Analysis of the Brinkman equation as a model for flow in porous media. The Physics of Fluids 30 (11), 3329–3341.DOI
  24. [25]Feder, Jens, Flekkøy, Eirik Grude & Hansen, Alex 2022 Physics of Flow in Porous Media. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.DOI
  25. [26]Gallego-Posada, Jose, Ramirez, Juan, Hashemizadeh, Meraj & Lacoste-Julien, Simon 2025 Cooper: A library for constrained optimization in deep learning, arXiv: 2504.01212.
  26. [27]Giordano, Nicholas J. 2006 Computational Physics. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
  27. [29]Heyman, Joris 2019 Trac: A fast multi-object tracking algorithm for motion estimation. Computers & Geosciences 128, 11–18.
  28. [30]Heyman, Joris, Lester, Daniel R., Turuban, Régis, Méheust, Yves & Le Borgne, Tanguy 2020 Stretching and folding sustain microscale chemical gradients in porous media. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117 (24), 13359–13365.
  29. [31]Heyman, J., Villermaux, E., Davy, P. & Le Borgne, T. 2024 Mixing as a correlated aggregation process. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 992, A6.
  30. [32]Hinch, E.J. 1999 Mixing: Turbulence and chaos - An introduction. In Mixing: Chaos and Turbulence (ed. E. Villermaux & J.-M. Chomaz), pp. 37–58. Boston, MA: Springer US.
  31. [33]Hinch, E. J. 1991 Perturbation Methods. Cambridge Texts in Applied Mathematics . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  32. [34]Hobbs, D.M & Muzzio, F.J 1997 The Kenics static mixer: A three-dimensional chaotic flow. Chemical Engineering Journal 67 (3), 153–166.
  33. [35]Hobbs, D. M., Alvarez, M. M. & Muzzio, F. J. 1997 Mixing in globally chaotic flows. Fractals 05 (03), 395–425.
  34. [36]Huang, Alice Y. L., Huang, Michelle Y. F., Capart, Hervé & Chen, Rong-Her 2008 Optical measurements of pore geometry and fluid velocity in a bed of irregularly packed spheres. Experiments in Fluids 45 (2), 309–321.
  35. [37]Hyman, Jeffrey D. & Winter, C. Larrabee 2014 Stochastic generation of explicit pore structures by thresholding Gaussian random fields. Journal of Computational Physics 277, 16–31.
  36. [38]Jasinski, Lukasz & Dabrowski, Marcin 2018 The effective transmissivity of a plane-walled fracture with circular cylindrical obstacles. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth 123 (1), 242–263.
  37. [39]Jiménez-Martínez, Joaquín, Le Borgne, Tanguy, Tabuteau, Hervé & Méheust, Yves 2017 Impact of saturation on dispersion and mixing in porous media: Photobleaching pulse injection experiments and shear-enhanced mixing model. Water Resources Research 53 (2), 1457–1472.
  38. [40]Kähler, Christian J., Scharnowski, Sven & Cierpka, Christian 2012 On the resolution limit of digital particle image velocimetry. Experiments in Fluids 52 (6), 1629–1639.
  39. [41]Kang, Peter K., Dentz, Marco, Le Borgne, Tanguy & Juanes, Ruben 2015 Anomalous transport on regular fracture networks: Impact of conductivity heterogeneity and mixing at fracture intersections. Physical Review E 92 (2), 022148.
  40. [43]Kitanidis, Peter K. & McCarty, Perry L., ed. 2012 Delivery and Mixing in the Subsurface, SERDP/ESTCP Environmental Remediation Technology, vol. 4. New York, NY: Springer.
  41. [44]Kraichnan, Robert H. 1974 Convection of a passive scalar by a quasi-uniform random straining field. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 64 (4), 737–762.
  42. [45]Kumar, Manish, Guasto, Jeffrey S. & Ardekani, Arezoo M. 2023 Lagrangian stretching reveals stress topology in viscoelastic flows. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 120 (5), e2211347120.
  43. [46]Le Borgne, T., Dentz, M. & Villermaux, E. 2015 The lamellar description of mixing in porous media. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 770, 458–498.
  44. [47]Le Borgne, Tanguy & Heyman, Joris 2026 Fluid deformation and mixing in porous media as drivers for chemical and biological processes. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 58, 443–471.
  45. [48]Leal, L. Gary 2007 Advanced Transport Phenomena: Fluid Mechanics and Convective Transport Processes. Cambridge Series in Chemical Engineering . Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  46. [49]Lee, J. S. & Fung, Y. C. 1969 Stokes flow around a circular cylindrical post confined between two parallel plates. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 37 (4), 657–670.
  47. [50]Lester, Daniel 2025 Mixing of Gaussian solute plumes, arXiv: 2506.20387.arxiv.org/abs/2506.20387
  48. [53]Lester, Daniel R., Dentz, Marco, Borgne, Tanguy Le & de Barros, Felipe P. J. 2018 Fluid deformation in random steady three-dimensional flow. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 855, 770–803.DOI
  49. [55]Lindken, Ralph, Rossi, Massimiliano, Gröbe, Sebastian & Westerweel, Jerry 2009 Micro-Particle Image Velocimetry (μPIV): Recent developments, applications, and guidelines. Lab on a Chip 9 (17), 2551–2567.DOI
  50. [56]Mantegna, Rosario N. & Stanley, H. Eugene 1994 Stochastic processes with ultraslow convergence to a Gaussian: The truncated Lévy flight. Physical Review Letters 73 (22), 2946–2949.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10057243
  51. [57]Matyka, Maciej, Gołembiewski, Jarosław & Koza, Zbigniew 2016 Power-exponential velocity distributions in disordered porous media. Physical Review E 93 (1), 013110.DOI
  52. [58]Meigel, Felix J., Darwent, Thomas, Bastin, Leonie, Goehring, Lucas & Alim, Karen 2022 Dispersive transport dynamics in porous media emerge from local correlations. Nature Communications 13 (1), 5885.DOI
  53. [59]Meunier, P. & Villermaux, E. 2003 How vortices mix. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 476, 213–222.
  54. [60]Meunier, P. & Villermaux, E. 2010 The diffusive strip method for scalar mixing in two dimensions. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 662, 134–172.DOI
  55. [61]Mokhtari, O., Latché, J.-C., Quintard, M. & Davit, Y. 2022 Birefringent strands drive the flow of viscoelastic fluids past obstacles. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 948, A2.DOI
  56. [62]Morales, V. L., Dentz, M., Willmann, M. & Holzner, M. 2017 Stochastic dynamics of intermittent pore-scale particle motion in three-dimensional porous media: Experiments and theory. Geophysical Research Letters 44 (18), 9361–9371.
  57. [64]Ottino, Julio M. 1989 The mixing of fluids. Scientific American 260 (1), 56–67.DOI
  58. [65]Ottino, Julio M. 2004 The Kinematics of Mixing: Stretching, Chaos, and Transport, 1st edn. Cambridge Texts in Applied Mathematics . Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Pr.
  59. [66]Ottino, J. M., Ranz, W. E. & Macosko, C. W. 1981 A framework for description of mechanical mixing of fluids. AIChE Journal 27 (4), 565–577.DOI
  60. [67]Paszke, Adam, Gross, Sam, Massa, Francisco, LeRer, Adam, Bradbury, James, Chanan, Gregory, Killeen, Trevor, Lin, Zeming, Gimelshein, Natalia, Antiga, Luca, Desmaison, Alban, Köpf, Andreas, Yang, Edward, DeVito, Zach, Raison, Martin, Tejani, Alykh an, Chilamkurthy, Sasank, Steiner, Benoit, Fang, Lu, Bai, Junjie & Chintala, Soumith 2019 PyTorch: An imperative style, high-performance deep learning library, arXiv: 1912.01703.arxiv.org/abs/1912.01703
  61. [68]Pierce, J. Kevin & Hassan, Marwan A. 2020 Back to Einstein: Burial-induced three-range diffusion in fluvial sediment transport. Geophysical Research Letters 47 (15), e2020GL087440.DOI
  62. [69]Pierce, J. Kevin, Le Borgne, Tanguy & Linga, Gaute 2025 Deldotnot: Divergence correction software for incompressible porous media flows.
  63. [70]Pop, I. & Cheng, P. 1992 Flow past a circular cylinder embedded in a porous medium based on the Brinkman model. International Journal of Engineering Science 30 (2), 257–262.DOI
  64. [71]Ranz, William E. 1979 Applications of a stretch model to mixing, diffusion, and reaction in laminar and turbulent flows. AIChE Journal 25 (1), 41–47.DOI
  65. [72]Rolle, Massimo & Le Borgne, Tanguy 2019 Mixing and reactive fronts in the subsurface. Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry 85 (1), 111–142.DOI
  66. [73]Roman, Sophie, Soulaine, Cyprien, Alsaud, Moataz Abu, Kovscek, Anthony & Tchelepi, Hamdi 2016 Particle velocimetry analysis of immiscible two-phase flow in micromodels. Advances in Water Resources 95, 199–211.DOI
  67. [74]Sederman, A.J & Gladden, L.F 2001 Magnetic resonance visualisation of single- and two-phase flow in porous media. Magnetic Resonance Imaging 19 (3-4), 339–343.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11445309
  68. [77]Snæbjörnsdóttir, Sandra Ó, Sigfússon, Bergur, Marieni, Chiara, Goldberg, David, Gislason, Sigurdur R. & Oelkers, Eric H. 2020 Carbon dioxide storage through mineral carbonation. Nature Reviews Earth & Environment 1 (2), 90–102.DOI
  69. [78]Souzy, M., Lhussier, H., Méheust, Y., Le Borgne, T. & Metzger, B. 2020 Velocity distributions, dispersion and stretching in three-dimensional porous media. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 891, A16.DOI
  70. [80]Souzy, Mathieu, Zaier, Imen, Lhussier, Henri, Le Borgne, Tanguy & Metzger, Bloen 2018 Mixing lamellae in a shear flow. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 838, R3.DOI
  71. [81]Stone, Howard A 1994 Dynamics of drop deformation and breakup in viscous fluids. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 26 (1), 65–102.
  72. [83]Szulczewski, Michael L., MacMinn, Christopher W., Herzog, Howard J. & Juanes, Ruben 2012 Lifetime of carbon capture and storage as a climate-change mitigation technology. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109 (14), 5185–5189.DOI
  73. [84]Turuban, Régis, Lester, Daniel R., Heyman, Joris, Borgne, Tanguy Le & Méheust, Yves 2019 Chaotic mixing in crystalline granular media. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 871, 562–594.DOI
  74. [85]Turuban, R., Lester, D. R., Le Borgne, T. & Méheust, Y. 2018 Space-group symmetries generate chaotic fluid advection in crystalline granular media. Physical Review Letters 120 (2), 024501.DOI
  75. [87]Valocchi, Albert J., Bolster, Diogo & Werth, Charles J. 2019 Mixing-limited reactions in porous media. Transport in Porous Media 130 (1), 157–182.DOI
  76. [88]Vezzani, Alessandro, Barkai, Eli & Burioni, Raffaella 2019 Single-big-jump principle in physical modeling. Physical Review E 100 (1), 012108.DOI
  77. [89]Villermaux, E. 2003 Mixing as an aggregation process. Physical Review Letters 91 (18).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14611286
  78. [90]Villermaux, Emmanuel 2019 Mixing versus stirring. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 51 (Volume 51, 2019), 245–273.DOI
  79. [91]van der Walt, Stefan, Schönberger, Johannes L., Nunez-Iglesias, Juan, Boulogne, François, Warner, Joshua D., Yager, Neil, Gouillart, Emmanuel & Yu, Tony 2014 Scikit-image: Image processing in Python. PeerJ 2, e453.DOI
  80. [92]Wang, ChengYue, Gao, Qi, Wei, RunJie, Li, Tian & Wang, JinJun 2017 Weighted divergence correction scheme and its fast implementation. Experiments in Fluids 58 (5), 44.DOI
  81. [93]Weiss, George 1994 Aspects and Applications of the Random Walk. Random Materials and Processes 1. Amsterdam: North-Holland.
  82. [94]Willingham, Thomas W., Werth, Charles J. & Valocchi, Albert J. 2008 Evaluation of the effects of porous media structure on mixing-controlled reactions using pore-scale modeling and micromodel experiments. Environmental Science & Technology 42 (9), 3185–3193.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18522092
  83. [95]Winter, H. H. 1982 Modelling of strain histories for memory integral fluids in steady axisymmetric flows. Journal of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics 10 (1), 157–167.DOI
  84. [96]Zaburdaev, V., Denisov, S. & Klafter, J. 2015 Lévy walks. Reviews of Modern Physics 87 (2), 483–530.

Paper details

vlnc:W_z53a99d3
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents