WorksPhysics and Astronomy
An Observable-Algebra Approach to Quantum Coherence in Anyonic Systems
Abstract
Physical restrictions on operations can make quantum coherence inaccessible. Quantifying off-diagonal density matrix elements in a chosen basis alone does not reveal which information is hidden by each restriction. To distinguish their effects, we describe physical restrictions through subalgebras of accessible observables. The associated trace-preserving conditional expectations unify two reconstruction principles: each gives both the maximum-entropy state compatible with the accessible data and the closest state in the corresponding subalgebra in relative entropy. We apply this framework to anyonic systems to separate the contributions from local-charge superselection and non-Abelian fusion rules. We prove that the charge-line severing map is the conditional expectation onto the local-product subalgebra. It is completely positive and quantum-trace-preserving, and uniquely reconstructs a state in this space from all local-product expectation values. The hierarchy of measurement restrictions then separates total bipartite coherence into three nonnegative contributions: coherence between local charges, inaccessible fusion information, and conventional coherence. The first two decompose the anyonic charge entanglement and distinguish the effects of local-charge superselection from the remaining fusion information. Finally, we relate basis-independent measures of anyonic coherence to entanglement. For pure anyonic states with vacuum total charge, the optimized total and correlated coherence equal the total and conventional relative-entropy entanglement, respectively.
Introduction
Quantum coherence [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6] is usually described by the off-diagonal elements of a density matrix in a chosen basis. In real constrained systems, however, not all of this coherence is accessible: physical restrictions limit the state transformations and measurements that can be performed. Superselection rules (SSRs) [7, 8], for example, forbid operations that connect different sectors. Coherence between these sectors can be inaccessible to observers whose operations obey the SSR. Off-diagonal elements alone therefore do not tell us which coherence is accessible under the allowed operations. Distinguishing the information hidden by different restrictions requires considering the allowed operations rather than the state alone.
Anyons are excitations in two-dimensional systems [9, 10]. Quantum information can be encoded in their fusion degrees of freedom [11, 12, 13]. Accessing this information through local measurements is subject to two restrictions. First, anyonic SSRs [14] require observables to preserve each subsystem’s total topological charge, making coherence between different local charges inaccessible. Second, non-Abelian fusion rules allow two given charges to combine in different ways. The resulting fusion information is not determined by the states of the two subsystems separately and can remain inaccessible even when all correlations between local measurements are recorded [15]. These restrictions call for a distinction between coherence across local-charge sectors and the information associated with their fusion.
Previous studies quantified information inaccessible to local observers through anyonic charge correlations. A probe of these correlations was defined through a charge-line severing map [16]. For full-rank states, a maximum-entropy approach identified this quantity with the information that cannot be recovered from local measurement data [15]. Relative-entropy entanglement measures further separated conventional entanglement from anyonic charge entanglement [17]. These results quantify the information inaccessible to local observers, but leave open how to distinguish the contributions from local-charge superselection rules and non-Abelian fusion rules. Our aim is to separate these two contributions and clarify how they combine with conventional coherence to give the total bipartite coherence.
We approach this problem through the algebra of accessible observables [18, 19, 20, 21, 22], rather than through the matrix elements of the state alone. The reconstruction framework depends on the accessible observables and does not require anyonic structure. We apply it here to distinguish the information hidden by superselection and fusion constraints. When these observables form a subalgebra, their trace-preserving conditional expectation defines a unique linear reconstruction that lies in the subalgebra and preserves all accessible expectation values. This reconstruction unifies two prescriptions: it is the maximum-entropy state compatible with the measurement data and the closest state in the subalgebra in relative entropy. For anyonic systems, we prove that the charge-line severing map is the conditional expectation onto the local-product subalgebra. It uniquely reconstructs a state in the local-product subalgebra while preserving all local-product expectation values, and it is completely positive and quantum-trace-preserving.
Figure Figure 1 summarizes the resulting decomposition. A local-charge projection first removes coherence between different local charge sectors. Reconstruction from local-product data then removes the remaining inaccessible fusion information. Finally, retaining only populations in fixed local bases removes conventional coherence. The corresponding subalgebras give an additive decomposition into three nonnegative contributions for both pure and mixed states. In particular, the first two contributions separate the entropy of anyonic charge entanglement according to the two restrictions above. We further divide conventional coherence into local and correlated parts. For pure states with vacuum total charge, optimized total and correlated coherence recover the total and conventional relative-entropy entanglement, respectively.

Figure 1. Reconstruction and coherence decomposition. From left to right, successive reconstructions remove charge-sector coherence, unresolved fusion information, and conventional coherence. Smaller frames indicate less retained information, with no quantitative size scale. Each contribution below is an entropy increase; the first two form , and all three sum to the total bipartite coherence. Diagrams represent operator components with coefficients and sums omitted. Internal fusion trees and multiplicity labels are suppressed; and label local basis states. Disconnected lines denote local operator products, not necessarily a product state.
Reconstructing a state from restricted measurements
A density matrix predicts the outcome of every measurement allowed by quantum mechanics. An observer with access to only some of those measurements generally cannot determine the full state. For example, measuring a spin along determines its populations in the basis, but gives no information about the coherence between them. The question is then not only how much coherence the state contains, but which information is missing from the observer’s description.
We approach this question in two ways. First, among all states that reproduce the same accessible measurement data, the maximum-entropy principle selects the state that adds the least information beyond those data [23, 24, 25, 26, 27]. Second, we ask how well the original state can be approximated by a state described entirely in terms of the accessible observables, using quantum relative entropy to quantify the difference [28, 29, 30]. These are two distinct optimization problems. Below we explain their physical meaning and the condition under which they give the same reconstructed state.
We begin with ordinary density matrices, and . Entropy and relative entropy are and . We set if . The anyonic version uses the quantum trace introduced in Sec. III.
Maximum-entropy inference from incomplete data
Suppose an observer knows the expectation values of the accessible observables . Denote their operator space by . The compatible states satisfy
Every state in this set gives the same accessible measurement statistics, although they may differ in information that the observer cannot measure. Maximum-entropy inference selects
This prescription does not claim that the actual state has maximum entropy. It assigns an effective state using only the accessible data, without retaining additional coherence or correlations that those data do not determine.
For example, if only the populations and of a qubit are known, its compatible density matrices have the form
The measured populations leave undetermined. Entropy is largest for , so the inferred state is , with entropy , which is the binary Shannon entropy. Its excess entropy over the actual state quantifies the information missing from population measurements.
The closest state in the accessible description
The second approach starts with the full state and compares it with states represented within the accessible operator space
The relative-entropy approximation is
Here the candidate states are restricted by their form, rather than by requiring them to reproduce the same measurement data. In the qubit example above, these candidates are all diagonal states , with arbitrary . Thus, , which is minimized at . Thus the closest diagonal state has the same populations as , even though that requirement was not imposed in Eq. (5).
The phrase “closest state” refers throughout to this minimization of . Relative entropy is not a metric: it is asymmetric and does not obey the usual triangle inequality. What matters here is that it is nonnegative and vanishes only when the two states coincide.
State reconstruction from accessible observables
The qubit example can be extended to a broad class of measurement restrictions. We assume that contains the identity and is closed under linear combinations, products, and Hermitian conjugation: it is an observable subalgebra. This condition is important. It lets us construct a reconstruction map that retains all expectation values available to the observer,
while producing a state within . The map is the trace-preserving conditional expectation onto [31, 32]. It is linear, completely positive, and leaves states already in unchanged. Requiring the output to lie in and preserve its expectation values determines the map uniquely. Appendix A gives the construction.
The state minimizes the relative entropy over states in [30]. As shown below, this relation also implies that has the largest entropy among all states consistent with the accessible measurement data.
Theorem 1 (State reconstruction). Let be a finite-dimensional observable subalgebra containing the identity, and let be its trace-preserving conditional expectation. For any density matrix , the maximum-entropy state compatible with its accessible measurement data and the state in that minimizes relative entropy from are both unique and satisfy
Moreover, the relative entropy between and its reconstructed state equals the increase in entropy under reconstruction,
A detailed proof of both statements, including the case of states with zero eigenvalues, is given in Appendix A.
We therefore use
as the information lost in this restricted description [33]. When consists of operators diagonal in a chosen basis, is dephasing and this quantity is the usual relative-entropy coherence [1]. For the qubit state , population measurements reconstruct and lose one bit of information. More general restrictions can also erase correlations. For instance, if only subsystem can be measured, the reconstructed state of a bipartite system is
Here denotes the algebra of all linear operators on the Hilbert space of subsystem , and is the identity operator on . The reconstruction preserves everything measurable on while discarding information about and its correlations with . Accordingly, we use “information loss” when the restriction is more general than basis dephasing. Appendix B gives familiar examples from ordinary coherence and discord.
Hierarchy of information loss
Now compare two observers. One has access to a larger set of observables , while the other can measure only a subset . Both sets are assumed to be subalgebras. Reconstructing from the larger set does not change any data needed for reconstruction from the smaller set. The corresponding maps therefore satisfy
The total information loss separates into two nonnegative parts,
The first term measures the information lost when the description is restricted to . The second term measures the further loss when the description is restricted from to . These reconstruction results apply to finite-dimensional quantum systems whenever the accessible observables form subalgebras containing the identity, with all reconstructions preserving the same trace. The information lost at each step depends on the physical meaning of the corresponding measurement restriction.
Anyonic constraints on local measurements
We now apply the framework developed above to anyonic systems. Superselection rules and fusion rules restrict the information accessible to local measurements. As a result, products of local observables generally do not span the full physical operator space. In this section, we introduce the anyonic state space and identify four observable algebras: the full physical algebra, the algebra preserving each local charge, the algebra generated by local products, and its diagonal subalgebra in chosen local bases. Their inclusion relations provide the basis for the coherence decomposition in Sec. IV.
Fibonacci anyons, fusion spaces, and anyonic states
We use Fibonacci anyons as a concrete example to introduce fusion spaces, fusion-tree bases, and the operator and state conventions needed below. More detailed introductions can be found in Refs. [11, 12, 34, 35].
The Fibonacci model has two topological charges, . Here denotes the vacuum and the Fibonacci anyon. Their fusion rules are
Thus, two anyons can have total charge or . Their quantum dimensions are and .
When charges and combine to give total charge , the possible fusion channels span a space denoted by . Its dimension is the fusion multiplicity , and a basis vector is written as , with . The Fibonacci model is multiplicity-free: every is either zero or one, so the label can be omitted. The two allowed fusion channels of two anyons are represented by
We use the standard graphical notation: world lines are oriented upward (arrows are omitted), a solid line represents , and vacuum lines are not drawn. The superselection rule forbids physical operations from changing the total charge. When the total charge is not fixed, the two-anyon Hilbert space is therefore .
For more than two anyons, the order of fusion is not unique. Each fusion order is represented by a fusion tree and defines a basis of the fusion space. Consider an ordered collection with charges and fixed total charge . We denote its fusion space by and, unless stated otherwise, use the left-associated fusion tree. A basis vector is
Here lists the intermediate charges. For models with fusion multiplicities, each vertex also carries a multiplicity label. Other fusion trees give other bases of the same fusion space.
Given two anyonic fusion spaces and , the space of anyonic operators from to can be represented as . Within a fixed total-charge sector, anyonic operators act as ordinary matrices on the corresponding fusion space. When several total-charge sectors are allowed, physical operators are block diagonal in the total charge. We use a tilde, , to denote an anyonic operator.
The trace operation appropriate for anyonic operators is the quantum trace, denoted by , defined as , where denotes the component of in charge sector , and is the ordinary matrix trace within that sector. An anyonic state is a positive anyonic operator normalized by the quantum trace. The corresponding anyonic entropy and anyonic relative entropy are defined as and , with the usual support convention. These are the usual definitions with the trace appropriate to the anyonic state space [16]. The reconstruction results of Sec. II also hold for this trace, which is explained in Appendix A.
Information accessible to local measurements
For an ordinary bipartite system, measuring a complete set of observables on each side, and recording their joint correlations, is sufficient to reconstruct the density matrix. This follows from
The analogous measurements can not determine an anyonic state in general: local observables preserve each subsystem’s total charge, and the way the two charges fuse is not an internal degree of freedom of either subsystem.
Consider a bipartite anyonic system with subsystems and . Let and be their total charges, and let be the total charge of . The state of specifies the internal fusion states in and , as well as how and fuse. Accordingly,
Here and contain the internal states, and describes the fusion space. Only charge pairs allowed by the fusion rules are included.
The global superselection rule requires physical operators to preserve the total charge . We denote the algebra of these operators by
Within the same sector, coherence between different local charge pairs is allowed. For example, a global vacuum state can superpose local charges and . Both pairs can fuse to the vacuum. However, such coherence is invisible to local observables that preserve the charge in each subsystem separately.
We assume access to all charge-preserving observables within each subsystem, including their joint measurement statistics. Their products generate , where
On a block with charges , an observable in acts as . Here acts on the internal states of and , while is the identity on their fusion space. Thus these measurements cannot detect coherence between different local charge pairs. They also can not determine the state in or distinguish the possible total charges at fixed . This remains true even when the observers record all correlations between their local measurements.
To separate these two restrictions, first consider a measurement of the total charge in each subsystem with its outcome discarded. If projects onto local charges , the state after this measurement is
This removes coherence between different local charge pairs and preserves their probabilities. It leaves all matrix elements within each fixed block unchanged, including the information in fusion space.
The operators left unchanged by form the subalgebra
Here we denote this block-diagonal algebra by , and denotes the set of outputs of . Sums, products, and Hermitian conjugates of operators that preserve still preserve . The map preserves the quantum trace and every expectation value in . It is thus the conditional expectation onto , so the reconstruction principle of Sec. II applies. Appendix A gives the proof.
The algebra includes joint observables that distinguish how and fuse. Such observables generally cannot be formed from local products, so
To retain only the information accessible to local products, let be the state reconstructed from all local-product expectation values. The reconstruction uses only local-product data, and a known global charge is not imposed as an additional constraint. Its defining property is
with . By Theorem 1, it is both the maximum-entropy state consistent with these data and the closest state in based on relative entropy.
For example, consider two Fibonacci anyons, with one in each region. The local charges are fixed, so leaves the state unchanged. Nevertheless, the pair can have total charge or . Neither local observer can determine which from measurements on a single . All mixtures of these two fusion outcomes give the same local data. Reconstruction from those data must therefore assign the same state to all of them. We calculate the resulting information loss in Sec. IV C.
More generally, for known local charges , the reconstructed probability of fusion outcome is
This distribution follows from maximizing the anyonic entropy. It is normalized because . For fixed , local-product measurements determine an averaged internal state of and . They cannot determine the fusion outcome , the state within , or correlations between the fusion and internal degrees of freedom. The reconstruction therefore uses the same reconstructed internal state for every allowed , assigns the probability , and assigns the maximally mixed state to . These changes remove the fusion information retained by . Since local products never detect coherence between different , applying first does not alter their data. Consequently,
The charge-line severing map , defined using an -loop, was introduced to quantify anyonic charge entanglement [15, 16, 17]. It removes nontrivial charge lines connecting and . In the multiplicity-free case, its action is
where the first step uses an move, a basis transformation between different fusion orders. The internal fusion trees in subsystems and are suppressed. The -loop projects the connecting charge onto the vacuum.
Theorem 2 (Reconstruction by charge-line severing). For the bipartite anyonic system considered here, the charge-line severing map is the quantum-trace-preserving conditional expectation onto the local-product algebra :
Consequently, for any state , is the unique maximum-entropy state consistent with all local-product expectation values. It is also the unique state in that minimizes the relative entropy from .
The identification is proved in Appendix A; the two reconstruction statements then follow from Theorem 1 with the quantum trace.
Finally, consider restricting measurements to a fixed local basis. Choose an orthonormal basis in each and in each . Fusion-tree bases are one such choice. Each basis state has a definite local charge. The observers now record only the joint probabilities of these basis states.
These data define the local diagonal subalgebra
where consists of operators diagonal in the chosen bases of , and similarly for . The tensor product acts in the global fusion space as described above. Its reconstruction map first retains the local-product data and then dephases the local internal states in the selected bases. We suppress the basis labels on this map when the bases are fixed.
The observable algebras satisfy
These inclusions describe successive restrictions on the measurements. The full algebra respects global anyonic superselection rules. The algebra also preserves each local charge, while contains only information accessible to local products. Finally, retains only populations in the chosen local bases. In the next section we quantify the information lost at these steps.
Decomposition of bipartite anyonic coherence
The observable restrictions identified in Sec. III allow us to distinguish different contributions to anyonic coherence. We begin with coherence in a global fusion basis. We then define bipartite coherence from local measurement data and separate it into three contributions: coherence between local charges, fusion information inaccessible to local measurements, and conventional coherence within local charge sectors.
Fusion-basis coherence and the local-measurement decomposition
We first consider coherence in a fixed global fusion basis. As in an ordinary quantum system, the diagonal entries specify populations, whereas the off-diagonal entries describe coherence between basis states.
We choose a fusion-tree basis because its charge labels correspond to outcomes of compatible measurements of the total charges of groups of anyons. These measurements involve anyons in both subsystems. For models with fusion multiplicities, charge measurements alone do not distinguish all basis states; additional measurements within the multiplicity spaces are required. We assume access to these measurements when defining coherence in a complete fusion-tree basis. No such additional measurements are needed for Fibonacci anyons.
Let be a complete fusion-tree basis, as introduced in Sec. III A, and let . Dephasing in this basis gives
It preserves every basis population and removes all off-diagonal entries. The resulting state is the maximum-entropy state compatible with those populations. Equivalently, it minimizes relative entropy over states diagonal in . The fusion-basis coherence is therefore
This definition extends ordinary relative-entropy coherence to a fusion-tree basis. Measurements in this basis can reveal how the charges of and fuse. Such information is generally unavailable from charge-preserving local measurements, even when their joint statistics are recorded. We next define coherence from the local measurement data specified in Sec. III.
We now consider measurements in fixed local bases, described by the algebra defined in Sec. III B. These measurements determine the joint basis populations, but leave three types of information inaccessible: coherence between different local charges, fusion information that local measurements cannot resolve, and coherence within each local-charge block. We define the total bipartite coherence as the information lost under this measurement restriction:
It quantifies the information lost when the state is described only by these joint local populations. For an ordinary bipartite system, the states form a complete basis of the joint Hilbert space, so this definition gives the usual coherence in that basis. However, for anyons, specifying the local basis states does not fully specify the joint fusion state. The total bipartite coherence therefore generally differs from the fusion-tree-basis coherence .
Applying Eq. (12) to gives
where
Both terms are nonnegative by the reconstruction result in Sec. II. The first is independent of the local basis: it measures information unavailable even to complete local measurements. The subscript “ntp” refers to the non-tensor-product operator structure: local products do not span the full physical operator space. The second is conventional coherence of the reconstructed state. It depends on which bases the observers choose.
Changing the local measurement bases can reveal the coherence measured by . It cannot reveal , because all such measurements still belong to . Access to that information requires observables beyond the local-product algebra. For an ordinary bipartite system without these restrictions, is the identity and .
The contribution has a direct connection to anyonic charge entanglement (ACE). The entropy of anyonic charge entanglement [15, 16, 17], denoted by , is defined as the entropy increase under charge-line severing: . Since , we obtain
Thus the total bipartite coherence contains an ACE contribution, , in addition to the conventional coherence . The ACE contribution is independent of the chosen local bases and cannot generally be identified with off-diagonal matrix elements alone. To clarify its physical content, we use to separate it into coherence between different local charges and the fusion information.
The first contribution is the entropy increase caused by ,
where the subscript “sec” stands for sector. It measures precisely the coherence between different local charge pairs. It vanishes when the state is already block diagonal in . The additional information lost on reconstructing from local products is
where “fus” stands for fusion. This term measures fusion information that survives the local-charge measurement but cannot be obtained from local products. It includes the fusion-outcome distribution and its correlations with the internal states of the subsystems. It can be nonzero even for a density matrix that is diagonal in a complete fusion basis. We therefore call it fusion information: it measures more than off-diagonal coherence.
We summarize these results in the following theorem.
Theorem 3 (Decomposition of anyonic coherence). For any physical anyonic state , choose orthonormal local bases and . The charge contributions satisfy
and the total bipartite coherence decomposes as
All three contributions are nonnegative. The quantities and are independent of the choice of bases within the local-charge sectors, whereas generally depends on this choice.
Abelian anyons and group superselection rules
For Abelian anyons, specifying and fixes their fusion outcome, and the fusion space is one-dimensional. Once coherence between local charges has been removed, no additional fusion information remains. Thus
This holds for both pure and mixed states. Conventional coherence can still be present if there are internal local degrees of freedom.
Group superselection rules provide another application of the reconstruction framework. Consider a finite-dimensional bipartite system whose state is globally invariant under a compact symmetry group [7, 8, 36, 37]. Charges are labeled by irreducible representations, and fusion corresponds to decomposing tensor products of these representations. Products of locally invariant observables form the accessible algebra. Averaging independently over the group transformations in each region is the trace-preserving conditional expectation onto this algebra. The projection removes coherence between different local representation labels; for non-Abelian , the subsequent local group average also removes information within the representation spaces. The same hierarchy and entropy decomposition apply, with representation dimensions playing the role of anyonic quantum dimensions.
Anyonic systems allow more general fusion rules and quantum dimensions. For example, the Fibonacci rule gives , with , whereas ordinary group representations have integer dimensions. Our framework uses the charge sectors, fusion rules, and accessible observables, and does not require braiding operations.
Fusion information in a diagonal Fibonacci state
Return to one Fibonacci anyon in each region. Both local charges are , so there are no distinct local-charge sectors to superpose and . Nevertheless, the pair can fuse to or . Consider
where is the probability of vacuum total charge. The factor ensures quantum-trace normalization. These states are all diagonal, so . There are no internal local fusion degrees of freedom, and hence as well.
A joint measurement of the pair can determine . Separate local measurements give the same data for every , namely a definite on each side. Their maximum-entropy reconstruction is
with and . The missing information is
where is the classical relative entropy. The fusion contribution vanishes only when the actual distribution equals the reconstructed distribution. A pair fusing to vacuum has , despite having no off-diagonal entries.
This example explains why a finer description is needed. A global basis measurement determines the fusion outcome; local measurements do not. The difference persists even after every off-diagonal entry has vanished.
Coherence and entanglement
In ordinary bipartite systems, coherence has been separated into local coherence and correlated coherence [38, 39, 40]. We apply this separation to the locally reconstructed state and divide into the same two contributions. We then examine how correlated coherence is related to entanglement in the anyonic system, complementing the relation established above.
Local coherence and correlated coherence
To obtain the correlated part of , we subtract the local coherence of the two subsystems. Let . Its marginals equal those of , since the reconstruction preserves all local expectation values. With and denoting dephasing in the selected local bases, define
The second quantity is correlated coherence. In terms of the anyonic mutual information [41], it is
Thus it measures how much correlation in the local-product description is lost when only the chosen local populations are retained. It is nonnegative: within this description, the problem is an ordinary bipartite state with locally distinguishable charge labels, and local dephasing cannot increase mutual information. The explicit reduction is given in Appendix A.
Substituting into Theorem 3 gives
The first two terms describe coherence within the locally reconstructed state. The last two describe information that cannot be determined by changing local measurement bases.
Optimized coherence and pure-state entanglement
For an ordinary bipartite pure state, the relative-entropy coherence in the Schmidt bases equals its entanglement entropy [42]. The local coherence vanishes in these bases, so the correlated coherence also equals .
We now examine this relation in anyonic systems, where the total coherence also contains charge-sector and fusion contributions. The optimization is over all orthonormal local bases within each fixed charge sector:
Equivalently, we allow all charge-preserving local unitaries, not just changes of fusion tree. By Eq. (44), minimizing correlated coherence maximizes the classical mutual information between the two local measurement outcomes.
The conventional and total relative-entropy entanglement are [17, 35]
where SEP consists of states in with separable internal states in each local-charge block. Thus measures entanglement in the locally reconstructed state, while compares the original state with the same separable states. Minimizing Eq. (63) over and using Theorem 3, we obtain
The first equality is the entanglement decomposition of Ref. [17]. The second follows from Theorem 3. For pure states with vacuum total charge, the optimized coherence recovers these entanglement measures as follows.
Theorem 4 (Optimized coherence and pure-state entanglement). Consider a pure anyonic state with vacuum total charge,
where is the dual charge, , and is a normalized state in . Let and . The charge contributions are
Optimization over local bases within each charge sector gives
and
Both minima are attained by choosing Schmidt bases for . These bases also give .
The proof is given in Appendix C. Reconstruction preserves the internal pure state in each charge sector. Measuring the local charges and then using Schmidt bases retains the classical correlation between and and maximizes the mutual information of the internal measurement outcomes. The remaining mutual-information loss is the average internal entanglement.
For comparison, the asymptotic entanglement entropy introduced in Ref. [43] gives
for the same vacuum pure state. The optimized total coherence therefore exceeds by . This difference is consistent with the asymptotic meaning of : for a finite number of copies, per copy need not equal , but it converges to in the asymptotic limit [35].
Summary and discussion
We have studied anyonic coherence through the information available to restricted measurements. When the accessible observables form a subalgebra, the trace-preserving conditional expectation gives both the maximum-entropy state consistent with the data and the closest state in that subalgebra in relative entropy. The construction also applies to other systems whose measurement restrictions are described by observable subalgebras. The physical meaning of each contribution is determined by which observables are retained at each step.
For a bipartite anyonic system, we distinguish three restrictions: preserving local charges, retaining only local-product observables, and measuring in fixed local bases. The corresponding subalgebras give a decomposition of total coherence into local-charge-sector coherence, fusion information, and conventional coherence. In particular, the entropy of anyonic charge entanglement is . The projection removes coherence between different local charges while preserving fusion information. The latter can be nonzero for states diagonal in a fusion-tree basis and vanishes for Abelian anyons. We further separate conventional coherence into local and correlated contributions. For vacuum pure states, optimizing the local bases gives the conventional relative-entropy entanglement from correlated coherence and the total relative-entropy entanglement from total coherence.
These results also suggest a connection to topological entanglement entropy (TEE) [44, 45]. Our main analysis concerns the effective anyonic degrees of freedom, whereas TEE characterizes entanglement in a microscopic ground state. Anyonic charge entanglement provides a bridge between these descriptions: Ref. [16] derives TEE using the anyonic correlations across a spatial boundary and the constraint on their total charge.
The anyons along the boundary must have total vacuum charge, so their charges are not independent. This constraint reduces the boundary entropy. Building on this connection, our framework offers two observations.
First, the decomposition of distinguishes the contribution associated with local-charge superselection from the additional information associated with non-Abelian fusion. For Abelian anyons, all quantum dimensions are trivial and , but local charge constraints remain. Thus non-Abelian fusion is not required for nonzero TEE: in the toric code [46], all anyons have unit quantum dimension, yet . Here TEE arises from the constraint that the boundary anyons have total vacuum charge.
Second, TEE can be written in terms of optimized coherence of the microscopic state. Let be a pure ground state of a spin or qubit system, and let be its relative-entropy coherence minimized over bases of the two regions. For a pure state, the minimum coherence equals the entanglement entropy [42]:
Each regional basis may involve all degrees of freedom within that region. This identity follows from optimization in Schmidt bases and does not require topological order. Using the annular partition of Ref. [45], the conditional mutual information can be written as
For the standard fixed-point ground states of quantum double and string-net models on the plane, this combination equals , where and , for regions sufficiently large compared with the microscopic length scales [45, 47, 48]. For more general ground states, spurious contributions can persist even in large regions and at zero correlation length [47, 49]; a choice of partition that excludes them for a class of stabilizer codes is given in Ref. [50]. Equation (55) expresses the conditional mutual information through independently optimized regional coherences. One half of this quantity gives the universal TEE when spurious contributions are absent. The basis optimization does not itself remove them.
Acknowledgments
C.-Q. Xu is supported by the National Key Research and Development Program of China (Grant No. 2025YFA1411600) and by NSFC (Grant No. 12405018). D. L. Zhou is supported by the Science Challenge Project (Grant No. TZ2025017) and the National Key Research and Development Program of China (Grants No. 2021YFA1402104).
Reconstruction maps
Trace-preserving conditional expectation
We first use the ordinary trace. Let be a finite-dimensional observable subalgebra of the allowed operator space . Orthogonal projection onto for the inner product defines a linear map satisfying Eq. (6). It fixes and preserves the trace, as follows by taking .
For , cyclicity of the trace gives
which implies
This is the bimodule property.
We next show that maps positive operators to positive operators. Since is closed under Hermitian conjugation, the orthogonal projection satisfies . Hence, if , then is Hermitian. Suppose that it has negative eigenvalues, and let be the projector onto the corresponding eigenspace. Because , its spectral projector also belongs to . The definition of the orthogonal projection then gives
The left-hand side is negative by the definition of , whereas the right-hand side is nonnegative because both and are positive. This contradiction proves that . The same argument after adjoining an arbitrary finite-dimensional auxiliary system proves complete positivity.
Finally, the bimodule property and trace preservation imply that preserves the expectation value of every observable :
The expectation-value condition determines the map uniquely: if two operators in give the same expectation value for every , their difference satisfies , so .
For anyonic states, the same construction uses the quantum trace in place of . The argument is unchanged. Trace preservation then means preservation of .
Maximum entropy and minimum relative entropy
We prove Theorem 1 using only preservation of measurement statistics and nonnegativity of relative entropy. Write . By construction, is a normalized positive operator in , and
Thus is an allowed candidate for both reconstruction problems: it belongs to the accessible subalgebra and reproduces all the measured expectation values. We now show that minimizes the relative entropy and maximizes the entropy.
a. Entropy increase under reconstruction. First suppose that has no zero eigenvalues. Since is closed under products and linear combinations, it also contains functions of its Hermitian operators, including . Equation (A5) therefore gives
Substitution into relative entropy yields
Thus, the reconstruction increases the entropy by .
b. Minimum relative entropy. Consider any state , initially with no zero eigenvalues. Its logarithm also belongs to , so . Using this equality to compare the two relative entropies gives
Consequently, no state in the accessible subalgebra is closer to than in relative entropy. Equality requires , which holds only for . This proves both optimality and uniqueness. The relative-entropy minimization and entropy-increase relation were established in Ref. [30].
c. Maximum entropy for fixed measurement data. Now let be any state compatible with the measured data. Unlike above, need not belong to : it may contain additional coherence or correlations invisible to the observer. Compatibility means
Taking and expanding the relative entropy, we have
Thus has at least as much entropy as every compatible state. Equality holds only when , proving the unique maximum. In fact, specifying the accessible data fixes all the information retained in ; any further information in a compatible state can only lower its uncertainty. This establishes the maximum-entropy statement as a consequence of the same trace identity, without a separate optimization calculation.
d. States with zero eigenvalues. Zero eigenvalues do not change these conclusions. Let project onto the eigenvectors of with nonzero eigenvalues. The projectors and belong to . The probability of the complementary subspace is therefore an accessible quantity:
A positive density matrix with zero probability in a subspace has neither population nor coherence connecting to that subspace. Indeed, positivity implies in any orthonormal basis. Thus . The same reasoning gives for every compatible state . We may consequently evaluate on the support , where all its eigenvalues are positive, and set its extension to zero outside that support. This extension belongs to and all the preceding traces remain valid, with .
For a singular candidate , let be its support projector. If , then , so it cannot improve on the finite value at . Otherwise, preservation of this expectation value gives as well. Both and are then supported inside , and the calculation in Eq. (63) applies with evaluated on . This covers every candidate, including singular states, and completes the proof.
e. Anyonic trace. For anyonic states, replace and by and , with states normalized by . The proof uses cyclicity, preservation of expectation values, and positivity of the trace, all of which hold for the quantum trace defined in the main text. Relative entropy is also nonnegative and vanishes only for identical states. Explicitly, for block states and , we can define the matrices and with ordinary trace, and
The factors cancel in the difference of logarithms. Since every is positive, zero quantum-trace weight in a subspace also means zero population there. The support arguments therefore apply unchanged. Both reconstruction statements hold.
The local-charge projection
The projectors describe mutually exclusive local-charge sectors and satisfy . Inserting this identity on both sides of an operator gives
The map retains the terms with and removes the terms connecting different local-charge sectors. Therefore, exactly when is block diagonal in . This proves that the range of is and that .
The map is the state transformation produced by measuring the local charges and discarding the outcome. Each term has Kraus form, so is completely positive. The completeness of the projectors also gives . Moreover, cyclicity of the quantum trace within each global-charge sector gives
Thus preserves the normalization of anyonic states. Finally, every is block diagonal and hence commutes with all . For ,
Thus fixes , preserves the quantum trace, and satisfies the bimodule property. It is therefore the quantum-trace-preserving conditional expectation onto .
To make the information loss explicit, choose bases of the local internal spaces and of the global fusion space. On a matrix unit with fixed global charge,
Charge-line severing as a conditional expectation
We prove that the charge-line severing map shown diagrammatically in Sec. III B has the conditional-expectation property stated in Theorem 2. The coefficient in that graphical expression uses the normalization of Ref. [16].
Proof of Theorem 2. After severing, each diagram is a product of an operator in and an operator in . Thus . Conversely, local-product diagrams have no nontrivial charge line between the two subsystems, so severing leaves every unchanged.
We next check the measurement data. The quantum trace closes an operator diagram, and is Hermitian. In the closed diagram for , the same projector can therefore be placed on the side of the contraction. This gives
Taking also proves quantum-trace preservation. Hence belongs to and has the required expectation values for every operator in that algebra. The uniqueness proved in this appendix implies .
The theorem allows us to apply the maximum-entropy and relative-entropy results directly to charge-line severing. It also clarifies the difference from : the projection removes coherence between local charges, while removes all nontrivial charge lines between the regions.
Dephasing the internal states of in the chosen local bases then gives . Since the local diagonal algebra is contained in , by Eq. (11). Both and satisfy for charge-preserving local unitaries . This follows from their bimodule property, since belongs to both algebras. Unitary invariance of relative entropy therefore proves that and are unchanged by these unitaries.
For completeness, the local-product data can be represented by an ordinary density matrix , where is the local-charge probability and is the normalized internal state determined by those data. This representation preserves every local-product expectation value. The anyonic entropy of the reconstructed state is
The marginal entropies have the corresponding terms and , with and . These terms cancel in mutual information, giving . Local dephasing cannot increase , which proves the nonnegativity of correlated coherence in Eq. (44).
Ordinary coherence and relative-entropy discord
With the ordinary trace, the same framework applies to conventional quantum systems. For an orthonormal basis , the diagonal algebra is , with conditional expectation
Equation (8) gives the relative-entropy coherence [1],
For a conventional bipartite system, choosing a product basis gives the conditional expectation onto its local diagonal algebra. Optimizing over both bases gives the two-sided relative-entropy discord [51],
where denotes the set of classical states defined in Ref. [52], namely, states diagonal in a local product basis.
If only is dephased, the relevant algebra is
which gives the one-sided relative-entropy discord.
The relative-entropy discord in Eq. (76) should be distinguished from the optimized mutual-information loss used in § 2 B. For a fixed basis, the latter subtracts the local coherence. These two optimizations agree on bipartite pure states but need not agree on mixed states.
Correlated coherence and conventional entanglement
In this appendix we prove that, for a pure anyonic state with vacuum total charge, the optimized correlated coherence equals the conventional entanglement contribution. Following Eq. (44), we calculate
where . The first term is independent of the local bases. The optimization therefore amounts to finding the largest mutual information that remains after local dephasing.
Consider the vacuum pure state in Eq. (49),
Here and are the local charges, describes their fusion to vacuum, and is a normalized ordinary bipartite pure state in . Removing coherence between local charges gives
Each block is pure and has vacuum total charge, so , where .
By Theorem 2, we have
Here is the identity on , including all allowed fusion outcomes . Its quantum trace is , so has unit quantum trace. The reconstruction preserves the internal pure state in each local-charge sector but replaces the known vacuum fusion outcome by this normalized identity.
The nonzero eigenvalue in every allowed fusion channel of sector is . Taking the quantum trace gives
Together with and , this proves the charge-sector and fusion contributions in Eq. (50).
Define the internal reduced states by
They have the same nonzero eigenvalues because is pure. The anyonic reduced states are
Taking the quantum trace in each local-charge sector gives
This proves Eq. (53). Subtracting Eq. (82) from the sum of the two reduced entropies, we obtain
The quantum dimension terms cancel.
Local dephasing preserves the charge labels and dephases the internal state within each sector. Choose bases and , and let
be the joint probability of their outcomes at fixed . Writing , the dephased reconstruction is
Let and . The classical mutual information within sector is
Evaluating the three entropies in the anyonic mutual information again cancels the quantum dimension terms, giving
For each sector, cannot exceed . To see why, first measure in its chosen basis. Since is pure and the measurement is rank one, each outcome prepares a pure conditional state on . Their average is . The Holevo quantity of this ensemble is therefore
By the Holevo bound [53], a measurement on can extract at most bits of information about . Consequently,
This bound is attained in Schmidt bases. In the decomposition
measuring both sides in these bases gives . Thus . The bases can be chosen independently in each local-charge sector, so all these bounds can be attained simultaneously:
Combining this result with Eqs. (78) and (86) gives
We now compare this optimized correlated coherence with the entanglement of the same state. For the vacuum pure state, , so Eq. (82) gives
For the entanglement measures defined in Eq. (47), the pure-state result of Ref. [35] and the decomposition in Eq. (48) give
The result above therefore establishes . Since and , we have . The Schmidt bases attain this bound: they minimize and also give . Thus . Because is basis independent, Theorem 3 yields
which proves Eq. (52).
References
- [1]T. Baumgratz, M. Cramer, and M. B. Plenio, Quantifying coherence, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 140401 (2014).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25325620
- [2]F. Levi and F. Mintert, A quantitative theory of coherent delocalization, New Journal of Physics 16, 033007 (2014).DOI
- [3]A. Streltsov, G. Adesso, and M. B. Plenio, Colloquium: Quantum coherence as a resource, Rev. Mod. Phys. 89, 041003 (2017).DOI
- [4]R. Lecamwasam, S. Assad, J. J. Hope, P. K. Lam, J. Thompson, and M. Gu, Relative entropy of coherence quantifies performance in bayesian metrology, PRX Quantum 5, 030303 (2024).DOI
- [5]A. Mani, F. Rezazadeh, and V. Karimipour, Quantum coherence between subspaces: State transformation, cohering power, k coherence, and other properties, Phys. Rev. A 109, 012435 (2024).DOI
- [6]F. Ahnefeld, T. Theurer, and M. B. Plenio, Coherence as a resource for phase estimation, Phys. Rev. Lett. 136, 180201 (2026).DOI
- [7]S. D. Bartlett and H. M. Wiseman, Entanglement constrained by superselection rules, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 097903 (2003).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14525211
- [8]S. D. Bartlett, T. Rudolph, and R. W. Spekkens, Reference frames, superselection rules, and quantum information, Rev. Mod. Phys. 79, 555 (2007).DOI
- [9]F. Wilczek, Quantum mechanics of fractional-spin particles, Phys. Rev. Lett. 49, 957 (1982).DOI
- [10]F. Wilczek, Magnetic flux, angular momentum, and statistics, Phys. Rev. Lett. 48, 1144 (1982).DOI
- [11]A. Kitaev, Anyons in an exactly solved model and beyond, Ann. Phys. (N.Y.) 321, 2 (2006).DOI
- [12]J. K. Pachos, Introduction to Topological Quantum Computation (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2012).
- [13]C. Nayak, S. H. Simon, A. Stern, M. Freedman, and S. Das Sarma, Non-Abelian anyons and topological quantum computation, Rev. Mod. Phys. 80, 1083 (2008).DOI
- [14]A. Kitaev, D. Mayers, and J. Preskill, Superselection rules and quantum protocols, Phys. Rev. A 69, 052326 (2004).DOI
- [15]C.-Q. Xu and D. L. Zhou, Topological correlation in anyonic states constrained by anyonic superselection rules, Phys. Rev. A 108, 052221 (2023).DOI
- [16]P. Bonderson, C. Knapp, and K. Patel, Anyonic entanglement and topological entanglement entropy, Ann. Phys. (N.Y.) 385, 399 (2017).
- [17]W. Ye, L. You, and C.-Q. Xu, Bipartite entanglement measures for anyonic systems, Phys. Rev. Res. 8, L022010 (2026).
- [18]K. Furuya, N. Lashkari, and S. Ouseph, Generalized entanglement entropy, charges, and intertwiners, Journal of High Energy Physics 2020, 046 (2020).DOI
- [19]C. Bertoni, Y. Yang, and J. M. Renes, Entropic time-energy uncertainty relations: an algebraic approach, New Journal of Physics 22, 083010 (2020).
- [20]H. Casini, M. Huerta, J. M. Magán, and D. Pontello, Entropic order parameters for the phases of QFT, Journal of High Energy Physics 2021, 277 (2021).
- [21]P. Zanardi, D. A. Lidar, and S. Lloyd, Quantum tensor product structures are observable induced, Physical Review Letters 92, 060402 (2004).DOI
- [22]A. P. Balachandran, T. R. Govindarajan, A. R. de Queiroz, and A. F. Reyes-Lega, Algebraic approach to entanglement and entropy, Physical Review A 88, 022301 (2013).DOI
- [23]E. T. Jaynes, Information theory and statistical mechanics, Phys. Rev. 106, 620 (1957).DOI
- [24]N. Linden, S. Popescu, and W. K. Wootters, Almost every pure state of three qubits is completely determined by its two-particle reduced density matrices, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 207901 (2002).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12443507
- [25]D. L. Zhou, Irreducible multipartity correlations in quantum states without maximal rank, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 180505 (2008).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18999807
- [26]Y. S. Teo, H. Zhu, B.-G. Englert, J. Řeháček, and Z. Hradil, Quantum-state reconstruction by maximizing likelihood and entropy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 020404 (2011).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21797584
- [27]R. Gupta, R. Xia, R. D. Levine, and S. Kais, Maximal entropy approach for quantum state tomography, PRX Quantum 2, 010318 (2021).DOI
- [28]S.-I. Amari, Information geometry on hierarchy of probability distributions, IEEE Transactions on Information Theory 47, 1701 (2001).DOI
- [29]D. L. Zhou, Irreducible multipartity correlations can be created by local operations, Phys. Rev. A 80, 022113 (2009).DOI
- [30]L. Gao, M. Junge, and N. LaRacuente, Relative entropy for von Neumann subalgebras, Int. J. Math. 31, 2050046 (2020).DOI
- [31]H. Umegaki, Conditional expectation in an operator algebra, Tohoku Mathematical Journal, Second Series 6, 177 (1954).
- [32]L. Gao and C. Rouzé, Complete entropic inequalities for quantum Markov chains, Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 245, 183 (2022).DOI
- [33]Z.-W. Liu, X. Hu, and S. Lloyd, Resource destroying maps, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 060502 (2017).DOI
- [34]S. Trebst, M. Troyer, Z. Wang, and A. W. Ludwig, A short introduction to fibonacci anyon models, Progress of Theoretical Physics Supplement 176, 384 (2008).DOI
- [35]C.-Q. Xu, W. Ye, and L. You, Superactivation of bell nonlocality in pure anyonic states, Phys. Rev. A 112, 062232 (2025).DOI
- [36]J. A. Vaccaro, F. Anselmi, H. M. Wiseman, and K. Jacobs, Tradeoff between extractable mechanical work, accessible entanglement, and ability to act as a reference system, under arbitrary superselection rules, Phys. Rev. A 77, 032114 (2008).DOI
- [37]G. Gour, I. Marvian, and R. W. Spekkens, Measuring the quality of a quantum reference frame: The relative entropy of frameness, Phys. Rev. A 80, 012307 (2009).DOI
- [38]K. C. Tan, H. Kwon, C.-Y. Park, and H. Jeong, Unified view of quantum correlations and quantum coherence, Phys. Rev. A 94, 022239 (2016).DOI
- [39]Y. Guo and S. Goswami, Discordlike correlation of bipartite coherence, Phys. Rev. A 95, 062340 (2017).DOI
- [40]T. Kraft and M. Piani, Genuine correlated coherence, Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical 51, 414013 (2018).DOI
- [41]C.-Q. Xu and D. L. Zhou, Deterministic quantum one-time pad via Fibonacci anyons, Phys. Rev. A 104, 022610 (2021).DOI
- [42]K. C. Tan and H. Jeong, Entanglement as the symmetric portion of correlated coherence, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 220401 (2018).DOI
- [43]K. Kato, F. Furrer, and M. Murao, Information-theoretical formulation of anyonic entanglement, Phys. Rev. A 90, 062325 (2014).DOI
- [44]A. Kitaev and J. Preskill, Topological entanglement entropy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 110404 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16605802
- [45]M. Levin and X.-G. Wen, Detecting topological order in a ground state wave function, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 110405 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16605803
- [46]A. Y. Kitaev, Fault-tolerant quantum computation by anyons, Annals of Physics 303, 2 (2003).DOI
- [47]I. H. Kim, M. Levin, T.-C. Lin, D. Ranard, and B. Shi, Universal lower bound on topological entanglement entropy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 131, 166601 (2023).
- [48]M. Levin, Physical proof of the topological entanglement entropy inequality, Phys. Rev. B 110, 165154 (2024).arxiv.org/abs/2408.04592
- [49]D. J. Williamson, A. Dua, and M. Cheng, Spurious topological entanglement entropy from subsystem symmetries, Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 140506 (2019).DOI
- [50]P. Han, Z. Liang, Y. Wang, B. Yang, Y. Gu, and Y.-A. Chen, Resolving spurious topological entanglement entropy in stabilizer codes (2026), arXiv:2604.27053 [quant-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2604.27053
- [51]Y. Yao, X. Xiao, L. Ge, and C. P. Sun, Quantum coherence in multipartite systems, Phys. Rev. A 92, 022112 (2015).DOI
- [52]K. Modi, T. Paterek, W. Son, V. Vedral, and M. Williamson, Unified view of quantum and classical correlations, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 080501 (2010).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20366919
- [53]M. A. Nielsen and I. L. Chuang, Quantum Computation and Quantum Information: 10th Anniversary Edition (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2010).