betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Propagation of Coupled Acoustic, Electromagnetic and Spin Waves in Saturated Ferromagnetoelastic Solids

Abstract

We study the propagation of plane waves in an unbounded body of a saturated ferromagnetoelastic solid. The equations by Tiersten for small fields superposed on finite initial fields in a saturated ferromagnetoelastic material are employed, with their quasistatic magnetic field extended to dynamic electric and magnetic fields for electromagnetic waves. Dispersion relations of the plane waves are obtained. The cutoff frequencies and long wave approximation of the dispersion curves are determined. Results show that acoustic, electromagnetic and magnetic spin waves are coupled in such a material. For YIG which is a cubic crystal without piezoelectric coupling, the acoustic and electromagnetic waves are not directly coupled but they can still interact indirectly through spin waves.

*E-mail: [email protected] (Jianke Du)

⊥E-mail: [email protected] (Jiashi Yang)

Conflict of interest statement: On behalf of all authors, the corresponding author states that there is no conflict of interest.

Data availability statement: The data that supports the findings of this study are available within the article.

Introduction

In saturated ferromagnetic solids, the magnetization vector has a fixed magnitude (saturation magnetization) and can change its direction only in a precessional motion. Below the Curie temperature, neighboring magnetization vectors align themselves in a certain direction called an easy axis of the material to form a distribution of spontaneous magnetization. A disturbance of the magnetization field propagates as spin waves with various applications [1]. Spin waves can interact with acoustic waves through magnetoelastic couplings such as piezomagnetic and magnetostrictive effects, which is called magnon-phonon interaction for which many references can be found in [2], a recent review article. Obviously, as a motion of magnetic moments, spin waves interact with electromagnetic waves directly as governed by Maxwell’s equations which is referred to as photon-magnon coupling (see [3] and the references therein). Thus, in deformable ferromagnetic solids, acoustic waves and electromagnetic waves can interact indirectly through spin waves. If the material is piezoelectric, acoustic waves and electromagnetic waves are also coupled piezoelectrically. It has been reported recently [4] that the couplings among surface acoustic waves (SAW), spin waves and electromagnetic waves can be used for making electromagnetic antenna at SAW frequencies (low-frequency antenna). This has motivated our study below on the propagation of coupled acoustic, electromagnetic and spin waves (phonon-photon-magnon interaction).

Governing Equations

Consider the widely-used Yttrium Iron Garnet (Y3_3Fe5_5O12_{12}) or YIG. In Gaussian units, the governing equations are [5, 6]

τij,j+Mi0h,jM=ρu¨j,(1)\tau_{ij,j}+M_i^0 h_{,j}^M=\rho\ddot{u}_j, \tag*{(1)}
∇⋅dM=0,(2)\nabla\cdot\mathbf{d}^M=0, \tag*{(2)}
∇⋅bM=0,(3)\nabla\cdot\mathbf{b}^M=0, \tag*{(3)}
∇×eM+1C∂bM∂t=0,(4)\nabla\times\mathbf{e}^M+\frac{1}{C}\frac{\partial\mathbf{b}^M}{\partial t}=0, \tag*{(4)}
∇×hM=1C∂dM∂t,(5)\nabla\times\mathbf{h}^M=\frac{1}{C}\frac{\partial\mathbf{d}^M}{\partial t}, \tag*{(5)}
εijkMj0(hkM−alk,l+hkL)+εijkmjHk0=1γm˙i,(6)\varepsilon_{ijk}M_j^0(h_k^M-a_{lk,l}+h_k^L)+\varepsilon_{ijk}m_jH_k^0=\frac{1}{\gamma}\dot{m}_i, \tag*{(6)}

where τ\boldsymbol{\tau} is the stress tensor. ρ\rho is the mass density. u\mathbf{u} is the displacement vector. eM\mathbf{e}^M, dM\mathbf{d}^M, bM\mathbf{b}^M and hM\mathbf{h}^M are the Maxwellian electric field, electric displacement, magnetic induction and magnetic field. CC is the speed of light in a vacuum. M0\mathbf{M}^0 and H0\mathbf{H}^0 are the initial magnetization and initial magnetic field which are static. The initial electric and polarization fields are assumed to be zero. hL\mathbf{h}^L is an effective local magnetic field which describes the interaction between the magnetic spin and the lattice [5]. a\mathbf{a} describes the exchange interaction between neighboring magnetic spins [5]. m\mathbf{m} is the incremental magnetization vector. γ\gamma is the gyromagnetic ratio which is a negative number. (1) is the linear momentum equation. (2)-(5) are Maxwell’s equations. (6) is the angular momentum equation of the magnetic spin. (2) and (3) are essentially implied by (4) and (5). We also have the following relationships:

diM=eiM+4πpi,(7)d_i^M=e_i^M+4\pi p_i, \tag*{(7)}
biM=hiM+4πmi−4πMi,j0u,j,b_i^M=h_i^M+4\pi m_i-4\pi M_{i,j}^0u_{,j},

where p\mathbf{p} is the electric polarization vector. Magnetoelectric coupling, if present, is not considered. YIG is a cubic crystal of class (m3m). Let the spontaneous magnetization M0\mathbf{M}^0 (and H0\mathbf{H}^0) be along the x3x_3 axis. In this case m3=0m_3=0 because of the saturation condition M⋅M=(M0)2\mathbf{M}\cdot\mathbf{M}=(\mathbf{M}^0)^2 which implies that M0⋅m=0\mathbf{M}^0\cdot\mathbf{m}=0 where M=M0+m\mathbf{M}=\mathbf{M}^0+\mathbf{m} and m\mathbf{m} is small. The constitutive relations are [6]

τ1=τ11=c11u1,1+c12u2,2+c12u3,3,τ2=τ22=c12u1,1+c11u2,2+c12u3,3,τ3=τ33=c12u1,1+c12u2,2+c11u3,3,(8)\begin{aligned} \tau_1&=\tau_{11}=c_{11}u_{1,1}+c_{12}u_{2,2}+c_{12}u_{3,3},\\ \tau_2&=\tau_{22}=c_{12}u_{1,1}+c_{11}u_{2,2}+c_{12}u_{3,3},\\ \tau_3&=\tau_{33}=c_{12}u_{1,1}+c_{12}u_{2,2}+c_{11}u_{3,3}, \tag*{(8)} \end{aligned}
τ4=τ23=c44(u2,3+u3,2)+2b44M20m2,τ5=τ31=c44(u1,3+u3,1)+2b44M10m1,τ6=τ12=c44(u1,2+u2,1),(9)\begin{aligned} \tau_4&=\tau_{23}=c_{44}(u_{2,3}+u_{3,2})+2b_{44}M_2^0m_2,\\ \tau_5&=\tau_{31}=c_{44}(u_{1,3}+u_{3,1})+2b_{44}M_1^0m_1,\\ \tau_6&=\tau_{12}=c_{44}(u_{1,2}+u_{2,1}), \tag*{(9)} \end{aligned}
pi=χeeiMordiM=εeiM,(10)p_i=\chi^e e_i^M\quad\text{or}\quad d_i^M=\varepsilon e_i^M, \tag*{(10)}
h1L=−χ(M0)2m1−2b44M0(u1,3+u3,1),h2L=−χ(M0)2m2−2b44M0(u2,3+u3,2),h3L=0,(11)\begin{aligned} h_1^L&=-\chi(M^0)^2m_1-2b_{44}M^0(u_{1,3}+u_{3,1}),\\ h_2^L&=-\chi(M^0)^2m_2-2b_{44}M^0(u_{2,3}+u_{3,2}),\\ h_3^L&=0, \tag*{(11)} \end{aligned}
h1L=−χ(M0)2m1−2b44M0(u1,3+u3,1),h2L=−χ(M0)2m2−2b44M0(u2,3+u3,2),h3L=0,(12)\begin{aligned} h_1^L &= -\chi(M^0)^2m_1-2b_{44}M^0(u_{1,3}+u_{3,1}),\\ h_2^L &= -\chi(M^0)^2m_2-2b_{44}M^0(u_{2,3}+u_{3,2}),\\ h_3^L &= 0, \tag*{(12)} \end{aligned}
aib=−2α11mb,i,(13)a_{ib}=-2\alpha_{11}m_{b,i}, \tag*{(13)}

where

ρ=5.172 g/cm3,c11=26.9×1011 dyn/cm2,c12=10.77×1011 dyn/cm2,c44=7.64×1011 dyn/cm2,b11−b12=1.66×102,b44=1.66×102,χ=3 4χ12−4χ11=3.36×10−5 Oe−2,α11=1.87×10−11 cm2,γ=−1.76×107 Oe-cm2/dyn-sec,M0=1750/4π G.(14)\begin{aligned} \rho&= 5.172\,\mathrm{g/cm^3},\quad c_{11}=26.9\times10^{11}\,\mathrm{dyn/cm^2},\\ c_{12} &= 10.77\times10^{11}\,\mathrm{dyn/cm^2},\quad c_{44}=7.64\times10^{11}\,\mathrm{dyn/cm^2},\\ b_{11}-b_{12} &= 1.66\times10^2,\quad b_{44}=1.66\times10^2,\\ \chi&= 3\,{}_{4}\chi_{12}-{}_{4}\chi_{11}=3.36\times10^{-5}\,\mathrm{Oe^{-2}},\quad\alpha_{11}=1.87\times10^{-11}\,\mathrm{cm^2},\\ \gamma&= -1.76\times10^7\,\mathrm{Oe\text{-}cm^2/dyn\text{-}sec},\quad M^0=1750/4\pi\,\mathrm{G}. \tag*{(14)} \end{aligned}

YIG is nonpiezoelectric and nonpiezomagnetic in its natural state without any fields. Due to the spontaneous magnetization and magnetostriction, it becomes effectively piezomagnetic.

Antiplane Motion

Consider cubic crystals of class (m3m) such as YIG in Gaussian units. With the initial magnetization M0M^0 and magnetic field H0H^0 along the x3x_3 axis, for antiplane problems [7] with u1=u2=0u_1=u_2=0 and ∂/∂x3=0\partial/\partial x_3=0, the relevant fields are

u1=u2=0,u3=u3(x1,x2,t),e1M=0,e2M=0,e3M=e3M(x1,x2,t),d1M=0,d2M=0,d3M=e3M(x1,x2,t),b1M=b1M(x1,x2,t),b2M=b2M(x1,x2,t),b3M=0,h1M=h1M(x1,x2,t),h2M=h2M(x1,x2,t),h3M=0.(15)\begin{aligned} u_1 &= u_2=0,\quad u_3=u_3(x_1,x_2,t),\\ e_1^M &= 0,\quad e_2^M=0,\quad e_3^M=e_3^M(x_1,x_2,t),\\ d_1^M &= 0,\quad d_2^M=0,\quad d_3^M=e_3^M(x_1,x_2,t),\\ b_1^M &= b_1^M(x_1,x_2,t),\quad b_2^M=b_2^M(x_1,x_2,t),\quad b_3^M=0,\\ h_1^M &= h_1^M(x_1,x_2,t),\quad h_2^M=h_2^M(x_1,x_2,t),\quad h_3^M=0. \tag*{(15)} \end{aligned}

In this case (2) is trivially satisfied. (4) and (5) reduce to

e3,2M+1C∂b1M∂t=0,−e3,1M+1C∂b2M∂t=0,(16)e_{3,2}^M+\frac{1}{C}\frac{\partial b_1^M}{\partial t}=0,\qquad-e_{3,1}^M+\frac{1}{C}\frac{\partial b_2^M}{\partial t}=0, \tag*{(16)}
h2,1M−h1,2M=1C∂d3M∂t.(17)h_{2,1}^M-h_{1,2}^M=\frac{1}{C}\frac{\partial d_3^M}{\partial t}. \tag*{(17)}

We also have:

c44(u3,11+u3,22)+2b44M0(m1,1+m2,2)=ρu¨3,−M0h2M−2α11M0(m2,11+m2,22)+χ(M0)3m2+2b44(M0)2u3,2+H0m2=1γm˙1,M0h1M+2α11M0(m1,11+m1,22)−χ(M0)3m1−2b44(M0)2u3,1−H0m1=1γm˙2,h1,1M+h2,2M+4π(m1,1+m2,2)=0.(18)\begin{aligned} c_{44}(u_{3,11}+u_{3,22})+2b_{44}M^0(m_{1,1}+m_{2,2}) &= \rho\ddot{u}_3,\\ -M^0h_2^M-2\alpha_{11}M^0(m_{2,11}+m_{2,22})+\chi(M^0)^3m_2+2b_{44}(M^0)^2u_{3,2}+H^0m_2 &= \frac{1}{\gamma}\dot{m}_1,\\ M^0h_1^M+2\alpha_{11}M^0(m_{1,11}+m_{1,22})-\chi(M^0)^3m_1-2b_{44}(M^0)^2u_{3,1}-H^0m_1 &= \frac{1}{\gamma}\dot{m}_2,\\ h_{1,1}^M+h_{2,2}^M+4\pi(m_{1,1}+m_{2,2}) &= 0. \tag*{(18)} \end{aligned}

where (18)₄ is essentially implied by (16). Then (16), (17) and (18)₁₋₃ can be written as six equations for u3u_3, e3Me_3^M, h1Mh_1^M, h2Mh_2^M, m1m_1 and m2m_2.

Propagation of Plane Waves

Let

u3=A1exp⁡[i(ξx1−ωt)],e3M=A2exp⁡[i(ξx1−ωt)],u_3=A_1\exp[i(\xi x_1-\omega t)],\qquad e_3^M=A_2\exp[i(\xi x_1-\omega t)],
h1M=A3exp⁡[i(ξx1−ωt)],h2M=A4exp⁡[i(ξx1−ωt)],h_1^M=A_3\exp[i(\xi x_1-\omega t)],\qquad h_2^M=A_4\exp[i(\xi x_1-\omega t)],
m1=A5exp⁡[i(ξx1−ωt)],m2=A6exp⁡[i(ξx1−ωt)].(19)m_1=A_5\exp[i(\xi x_1-\omega t)],\qquad m_2=A_6\exp[i(\xi x_1-\omega t)]. \tag*{(19)}

The substitution of (19) into (16), (17) and (18)1−3_{1-3} results in a system of six linear and homogeneous equations for A1A_1 through A6A_6. For nontrivial solutions, the determinant of the coefficient matrix has to vanish. This leads to the following equation that determines the dispersion relation of the wave:

−C2ξ2[α2c44ξ6−(α2ρω2−c44α(2P+4π)+αε2)ξ4-C^2\xi^2[\alpha^2c_{44}\xi^6-(\alpha^2\rho\omega^2-c_{44}\alpha(2P+4\pi)+\alpha\varepsilon^2)\xi^4
−(ε2P−c44P(P+4π)+ω2(c44γ2(M0)2+ρα(2P+4π)))ξ2-\left(\varepsilon^2P-c_{44}P(P+4\pi)+\omega^2\left(\frac{c_{44}}{\gamma^2(M^0)^2}+\rho\alpha(2P+4\pi)\right)\right)\xi^2
−ρP(P+4π)ω2+ργ2(M0)2ω4]+εω[c44α2ξ6−(α2ρω2−2c44α(P+4π)+αε)ξ4\begin{aligned} -\rho P(P+4\pi)\omega^2+\frac{\rho}{\gamma^2(M^0)^2}\omega^4] \\ &+\varepsilon\omega[c_{44}\alpha^2\xi^6-(\alpha^2\rho\omega^2-2c_{44}\alpha(P+4\pi)+\alpha\varepsilon)\xi^4 \end{aligned}
−(ε2(P+4π)−c44(P+4π)2+ω2(c44γ2(M0)2+2ρα(P+4π)))ξ2-\left(\varepsilon^2(P+4\pi)-c_{44}(P+4\pi)^2+\omega^2\left(\frac{c_{44}}{\gamma^2(M^0)^2}+2\rho\alpha(P+4\pi)\right)\right)\xi^2
−ρ(P+4π)2ω2+ργ2(M0)2ω4]=0,(20)-\rho(P+4\pi)^2\omega^2+\frac{\rho}{\gamma^2(M^0)^2}\omega^4]=0, \tag*{(20)}

where

e=2b44M0,α=2α11,P=H0/M0+K,K=χ(M0)2.(21)e=2b_{44}M^0,\qquad\alpha=2\alpha_{11},\qquad P=H^0/M^0+K,\qquad K=\chi(M^0)^2. \tag*{(21)}

In the special case of b44=0b_{44}=0, the magnetoelastic coupling disappears and (20) reduces to the product of two factors. One is for uncoupled acoustic waves:

ρω2−c44ξ2=0.(22)\rho\omega^2-c_{44}\xi^2=0. \tag*{(22)}

The other is for coupled electromagnetic and spin waves:

−C2ξ2[ω2γ2(M0)2−(αξ2+P)(αξ2+P+4π)]+εω2[ω2γ2(M0)2−(αξ2+P+4π)2]=0.(23)-C^2\xi^2\left[\frac{\omega^2}{\gamma^2(M^0)^2}-(\alpha\xi^2+P)(\alpha\xi^2+P+4\pi)\right] +\varepsilon\omega^2\left[\frac{\omega^2}{\gamma^2(M^0)^2}-(\alpha\xi^2+P+4\pi)^2\right]=0. \tag*{(23)}

When C→∞C\to\infty, (23) reduces to the following dispersion relation for uncoupled spin waves:

ω2γ2(M0)2=α2ξ4+α(2P+4π)ξ2+P(P+4π).(24)\frac{\omega^2}{\gamma^2(M^0)^2}=\alpha^2\xi^4+\alpha(2P+4\pi)\xi^2+P(P+4\pi). \tag*{(24)}

When α=0\alpha=0 and γ→∞\gamma\to\infty, (23) reduces to the following dispersion relation for uncoupled electromagnetic waves

ω2ξ2=C2Pε(P+4π).(25)\frac{\omega^2}{\xi^2}=\frac{C^2P}{\varepsilon(P+4\pi)}. \tag*{(25)}

When ε=1\varepsilon=1 and M0→0M^0\to0, we have P→∞P\to\infty and (25) reduces to ω/ξ=C\omega/\xi=C for electromagnetic waves in a vacuum.

When H0=1500H^0=1500 Oe and ε=14\varepsilon=14, the dispersion relations of the uncoupled waves in (22), (24) and (25) are shown in Figure 1 in logarithmic scales for both the coordinate and the abscissa. The acoustic and electromagnetic waves are represented by straight lines and are nondispersive, with the electromagnetic waves at higher frequencies. The spin wave is represented by a curve. Each straight line intersects with the curve at two points.

Uncoupled acoustic, electromagnetic and spin waves

Figure 1. Uncoupled acoustic, electromagnetic and spin waves.

When H0=1500H^{0}=1500 Oe and ε=14\varepsilon=14, the dispersion relations of the coupled waves determined by (20) are shown in Figure 2. Near B and C there are strong couplings between acoustic and spin waves. Near A and D there are strong couplings between electromagnetic and spin waves. Since the material is nonpiezoelectric, there is no direct coupling between acoustic and electromagnetic waves.

Dispersion curves of coupled waves

Figure 2. Dispersion curves of coupled waves when H0=1500H^{0}=1500 Oe and ε=14\varepsilon=14.

H0H^{0} is an independent parameter. If it is varied a little, its effects on the dispersion curves are shown in Figure 3. The spin waves are sensitive to H0H^{0} but the two other waves are not, which is reasonable.

Dispersion relations of coupled waves for different values of $H^{0}$

Figure 3. Effects of H0H^{0} (in Oe) on dispersion relations of coupled waves. ε=14\varepsilon=14.

The numerical value of ε\varepsilon for YIG in the literature ranges from 14 to 18. The effect of slightly different values of ε\varepsilon on the dispersion curves of the coupled waves is shown in Figure 4 where ε\varepsilon is denoted by εr\varepsilon_{r} which mainly affects the electromagnetic waves as expected.

Dispersion curves of coupled waves for different values of $\varepsilon_r$

Figure 4. Effects of εr=ε\varepsilon_{r}=\varepsilon on dispersion curves of coupled waves. H0=1500H^{0}=1500 Oe.

Conclusions

In saturated ferromagnetoelastic solids such as YIG, acoustic, electromagnetic and magnetic spin waves are coupled. Thus it is possible to manipulate one wave by another or design transducers using the couplings of these waves. This offers more possibilities for new devices. At present, the literature on the three-wave coupling of photons, phonons and magnons are limited, with an absence of the mechanics community. Since the equations of elasticity represent a major part of the coupled theory for these three waves, mechanics researchers can play an important role in this interdisciplinary area.

Acknowledgment

This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Nos. 12072167 and 11972199), the Zhejiang Provincial Natural Science Foundation of China (No. LR12A02001), and the K. C. Wong Magana Fund through Ningbo University.

References

  1. [1]D.D. Stancil, A. Prabhakar, Spin Waves: Theory and Applications, Springer, New York, 2009
  2. [2]D.A. Bozhko, V.I. Vasyuchka, A.V. Chumak, A.A. Serga, Magnon-phonon interactions in magnon spintronics (Review article), Low Temp. Phys., 46, 383-399, 2020.DOI
  3. [3]B. Bhoi, S.-K. Kim, Roadmap for photon-magnon coupling and its applications, Solid State Physics, Volume 71, Chapter 2, 39-71, Elsevier, 2020.DOI
  4. [4]R. Fabiha, J. Lundquist, S. Majumder, E. Topsakal, A. Barman, S. Bandyopadhyay, Spin wave electromagnetic nano-antenna enabled by tripartite phonon-magnon-photon coupling, Adv. Sci., 9, 2104644, 2022.DOI
  5. [5]H.F. Tiersten, Coupled magnetomechanical equation for magnetically saturated insulators, J. Math. Phys., 5, 1298-1318, 1964.DOI
  6. [6]H.F. Tiersten, Thickness vibrations of saturated magnetoelastic plates, J. Appl. Phys., 36, 2250-2259, 1965.DOI
  7. [7]Q.G. Xia, J.K. Du, J.S. Yang, Antiplane problems of saturated ferromagnetoelastic solids, Acta Mech., under review.

Paper details

vlnc:W_z8duwueh
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents