The spin alignment of J/ψ with respect to event plane in relativistic heavy ion collisions exhibits a significant signal. We propose a possible mechanism for spin alignment through spin dependent dissociation of quarkonia in a vortical quark-gluon plasma. The spin dependent dissociation is realized through inelastic scattering between constituents of quarkonium and those of quark-gluon plasma polarized by the vorticity. The spin dependent dissociation rate is found to depend on the directions of vorticity, quantization axis, and quark momentum. We implement our results in a dissociation dominated evolution model for quarkonia in the Bjorken flow, finding the spin 0 state is slightly suppressed compared to the average of the other two, which is consistent with the sign found in experiments. We also find absence of logarithmic enhancement in binding energy in the vortical correction to dissociation rate, which is understood from the requirement that a spin dependent dissociation can only come from quark coupling to a pair of chromomagnetic and chromoelectric field.
Introduction
The spin physics in relativistic heavy ion collisions (HIC) has become an emergent field under intensive studies recently. It was first realized that the final particles in off-central heavy ion collisions should be spin polarized [1]. The first measurement was made in global polarization of Λ hyperons [2], which has been nicely understood from the coupling of Λ hyperons spin with vorticity of quark-gluon plasma (QGP) [3, 4, 5]. Further measurement of local polarization has further revealed more refined structure of spin interaction [6], allowing us to characterize the spin response to more general hydrodynamic gradients [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14].
A closely related phenomenon is the spin alignment of vector meson, originally proposed from polarization of the two constituent quarks based on quark model [15, 16]. In HIC, the spin alignment is measured with a quantization axis chosen to be perpendicular to the event plane. The spin component along the axis defines 1, −1, 0 states. With the polarization of quarks from spin-vorticity coupling, we would have a spin alignment quadratic in vorticity. However, the measurement of spin alignment of ϕ meson has revealed significantly large signal, with the probability of finding 0 state significantly larger than the other two state. A variety of mechanisms have been explored to understand the large signal [17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26].3 See [27] for a recent review. More recently there has been a proposal on constraining the mechanisms experimentally [28].
A second vector meson observed with spin alignment is the J/ψ. The measurement has found a spin alignment different from the counterpart of ϕ meson in sign [29]. This might not be a surprise as the production mechanism of J/ψ is completely different from that of ϕ, which comes mainly from thermal production. Since the charm quark is much larger than the temperature of QGP, thermal production is negligible. J/ψ can be produced either directly in initial hard scatterings or from recombination of charm and anti-charm quarks, which are also produced by initial hard scatterings. Both sources are subject to significant medium modification. The early produced J/ψ partly dissociate due to interaction with the medium and the charm quarks evolving with the medium also carries information about the medium before they recombine to form J/ψ. We shall refer to the two cases loosely as dissociation and recombination production respectively. The dissociation and recombination production are known to dominate in low and high energy collisions respectively [30, 31, 32].
While the vorticity coupling to spin of constituent quarks does give the correct sign for spin alignment of J/ψ, the overall magnitude is expected to be much smaller than what has been observed in experiments [15, 16]. This is because the spin alignment is quadratic in the phenomenologically small vorticity. In fact, this is not the only effect of vorticity on spin alignment. In this paper, we will propose another possible mechanism through spin dependent dissociation in a QGP with vorticity. Since dissociation occurs throughout evolution of the QGP, the small vorticity can be compensated by long evolution time. For simplicity, we focus on dissociation production in medium-high energy collisions. We consider dissociation rate of quarkonia in a spinning QGP characterized by vorticity ω. For quarkonia in the vortical QGP, we expect by rotational symmetry that the vortical contribution to dissociation rate for quarkonia in spin s state can be parameterized by Γs=Γ1sp^⋅ω(n^⋅p^)+Γ2sn^⋅ω+O(ω2), with n^ and p^ being the direction of quantization axis and quarkonium momentum. s=1,−1,0 labels the spin states of the quarkonia. The survival probability of the initially produced quarkonia is given by exponential decay as exp(−∫Γsdt). Since exponential decay is a concave function, the splitting in the dissociation rate above leads to a suppressed rate of 0 state compared to the average of the other two. This is independent on the sign of Γ1 and Γ2 in the parameterization above. The goal of this paper is to work out the spin dependent part of the dissociation rate and study its impact on spin alignment of J/ψ.
The paper is structured as follows: in § 2 we first review the spin independent dissociation of quarkonia in QGP in the quasi-free picture, and then calculate spin dependent vortical correction to dissociation rate of quarkonia. Apart from dependence on spin component s, the correction is also found to depend on quantization axis and momentum of quarkonia; in § 3, we apply the results to calculate the spin alignment of J/ψ in medium-high energy collisions and discuss the phenomenological implications; § 4 is devoted to conclusion and outlook. Details of calculations are reserved to three appendices.
Quarkonia dissociation in vortical QGP
With application to J/ψ in mind, we consider dissociation of spin-triplet S-wave quarkonium states (to be referred to as quarkonium state in short) in vortical QGP. Since magnitude of vorticity produced in HIC is ∼10 MeV still much smaller than typical temperature of QGP ∼200 MeV, we may treat vorticity dependent part of dissociation rate as a perturbation. The dissociation rate of quarkonium state in the absence of vorticity has been well understood, which we briefly review below.
Quarkonia dissociation rate in equilibrium QGP
The dissociation of an unthermalized quarkonia arise from two types of processes: gluo-dissociation and inelastic scattering. In the former, the color singlet quarkonium dissolves into a color octet by absorbing a gluon from QGP [33, 34, 35, 36]. This process is leading order in coupling constant. In the latter, one of the heavy (anti-)quark constituents scatters with light quark or gluon in the QGP, converting the color singlet quarkonium into color octet. It is next to leading order in coupling constant and formally suppressed. However, the naive power counting ignores the bound state nature of quarkonium. In fact the gluo-dissociation process is only possible for bound state: in the limit of vanishing binding energy, the gluo-dissociation cross section simply vanishes by vanishing phase space. Therefore it is crucial to take into account the effect of finite binding energy. Indeed it has been realized that the cross section for gluo-dissociation is rather small as quarkonium is loosely bounded at high temperature [37]. It follows that the dominant process for dissociation is the inelastic scattering. A quasi-free picture has been proposed for quarkonium, in which the two constituents of quarkonium scatter with light quarks and gluons in QGP independently [38, 39], see also [40, 41]. The validity of the scenario is studied in framework of potential non-relativistic QCD [42, 43, 44, 45, 46], which treats bound state effect more systematically.
In fact, binding energy also play a crucial role in the inelastic scattering process, which includes Coulomb scattering and Compton scattering. It is well known that the perturbative damping rate for heavy quark suffers from infrared (IR) divergence when the exchanged gluon carries very soft momenta [47, 48]. Fortunately the finite binding energy to be denoted as ϵb sets a threshold for the energy of exchanged gluon to dissolve the quarkonium, thus the binding energy effectively cuts off the IR divergence, leading to a logarithmic enhancement in the binding energy. Similar IR divergence does not occur in Compton scattering as the exchanged particle is the heavy constituent [47]. At sufficient small binding energy, the Coulomb scattering process is logarithmically enhanced giving the dominant contribution to the cross section. Such an enhancement of the form lnϵbT has been found in [44], with T being temperature of the QGP T. Focusing on the logarithmically enhanced contribution allows one to consider Coulomb scattering only.
With Coulomb scattering, the evaluation of dissociation rate can be reduced to the effective one-loop self-energy diagram for heavy quark shown in Figure 1. The gluon propagator running in the loop is the hard thermal loop (HTL) resummed one, which screens the IR divergence of Coulomb scattering. The remaining logarithmic divergence is cut off by ϵb as we already discussed.
Figure 1. The self-energy diagrams for heavy quark. The cutted propagators can be put on-shell. The left/right diagram corresponds to Coulomb scattering off light quarks/gluons. The logarithmic enhancement comes from exchange of gluons with soft momenta, so that we need to use HTL resummed propagators for them, indicated by blobs.
Vorticity correction to dissociation rate
The question we now ask is how the vorticity enters the diagram above. We still assume the quarkonium to be unthermalized so that the vorticity only affects the light quarks and gluons. The modifications are known from quantum kinetic theories, see [49] for a recent review. Crucially the vorticity modifies only the on-shell light quarks and gluons but not their off-shell counterparts.
Aiming at vortical correction to dissociation rate to leading logarithmic order lnϵbT, we will also restrict ourselves to Coulomb scattering process. The role played by the vorticity is to affect the distribution and polarization of light degrees of freedom in the initial and final states.
With the light degrees of freedom polarized by vorticity, we expect a spin-dependent damping rate of heavy quarks inside the quarkonium though collisions with polarized light degrees of freedom. The spin-dependent damping rate for the constituent can further lead to spin-dependent dissociation rate for the bound state. The spin averaged damping rate can be related to self-energy as [50]
To derive damping rate for a particular spin state, we need to project the self-energy into a spin state. To find the appropriate spin projection operator, we first recall the following representation of free retarded propagator for particle state
where us(P) is the eigenspinor solution to the free Dirac equation normalized as ur†us=2Epδrs. In fact, this is general eigenstate representation of retarded function in quantum mechanics applied to Dirac theory with labels of eigenstates being spin. We readily identify 2Epus(P)us†(P) as the projection operator onto a specific spin state and 2Ep∑sus(P)us†(P) is the identity operator in Dirac space. With the same logic, we can rewrite the spin average in (1) more explicitly as
Γ=21tr[2Ep∑sus(P)us†(P)γ0Σ>(P)].(3)
This suggests the following damping rate for specific spin state
Let us comment on the validity of this representation: (4) implicitly assumes Ep to be degenerate and free eigenspinors to be used. In principle, both come from solution to the following Dirac equation in the presence of self-energy
(\slashed{P}-m-\Sigma_R)u_s(P)=0, \tag*{(5)}
with ΣR being retarded self-energy. However in perturbation theory the ΣR∼Σ> is small and consists leading order contribution to Γs, so that we may ignore modifications to energy and eigenspinor in (4), which are higher order effect.
The case of anti-particle can be worked out similarly. Since the vorticity effect in a charge neutral QGP is expected to be identical for particle and anti-particle, we will focus on damping rate for particle below.
Now we are ready to calculate self-energy of heavy quark in a vortical QGP. As argued in the previous subsection, to the leading logarithmic order in ϵb, only Coulomb scattering contributes, corresponding to the self-energy diagrams in Figure 1.
The vorticity corrections to the diagrams enter through modifications of propagators for light quarks and gluons. The explicit forms are known from quantum kinetic theories. The gluon lesser propagator in the Coulomb gauge is given by [51, 52, 53]
where X is a coarse-grained coordinate labeling fluid elements. We assume uniform temperature and slow-varying fluid velocity uμ(X). The vorticity is defined as ωμ=21ϵμνρσuν∂ρuσ. PρTμ=−ημρ+Q⋅uQμuρ+Qρuμ−(Q⋅u)2QμQρ and Pμν=uμuν−ημν are transverse and spatial projectors respectively. ϵ is the sign function, f is the Bose-Einstein distribution function. The superscripts (0) and (1) indicate the order in vorticity. Dμρ<(1) can be further simplified. In the fluid rest frame with uμ=(1,0,0,0), only spatial components of Dμρ<(1) are nonvanishing and read
References
[1]Z.T. Liang and X.N. Wang, Globally polarized quark-gluon plasma in non-central A + A colli- sions, Phys. Rev. Lett, 94:102301,(2005)DOI
[2]L. Adamczyk et al,Global Λ hyperon polarization in nuclear collisions: evidence for the most vortical fluid, Nature, 548:62-65, (2017)
[3]F. Becattini, V. Chandra, L. D. Zanna et al, Relativistic distribution function for particles with spin at local thermodynamical equilibrium, Annals Phys, 338:32-49, (2013)
[4]R.H. Fang, L.G. Pang, Q. Wang et al,Polarization of massive fermions in a vortical fluid, Phys. Rev. C, 94(2):024904, (2016)DOI
[5]H. Li, L.G. Pang, Q. Wang et al, Global Λ polarization in heavy-ion collisions from a transport model, Phys. Rev. C, 96(5):054908, (2017)DOI
[6]J. Adam et al, Polarization of Λ (Λ̄) hyperons along the beam direction in Au+Au collisions at √sNN = 200 GeV, Phys. Rev. Lett, 123(13):132301, (2019)DOI
[7]B. Fu, S.Y.F. Liu, L. Pang et al, Shear-Induced Spin Polarization in Heavy-Ion Collisions, Phys. Rev. Lett, 127(14):142301, (2021)DOI
[8]F. Becattini, M. Buzzegoli, G. Inghirami et al., Local Polarization and Isothermal Local Equi- librium in Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions, Phys. Rev. Lett, 127(27):272302, (2021)
[9]C. Yi, S. Pu , D.L. Yang, Reexamination of local spin polarization beyond global equilibrium in relativistic heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C, 104(6):064901, (2021)DOI
[10]X.Y. Wu, C. Yi, G.Y. Qin et al, Local and global polarization of Λ hyperons across RHIC-BES energies: The roles of spin hall effect, initial condition, and baryon diffusion, Phys. Rev. C, 105(6):064909, (2022)DOI
[12]S. Lin , Z.Y. Wang, Steady state, displacement current, and spin polarization for massless fermion in a shear flow, Phys. Rev. D, 111(3):034032, (2025)arxiv.org/abs/2406.10003
[13]Z.Y. Wang , S. Lin, Spin polarization for massive fermion in a shear flow: Complete results at O(∂), Phys. Rev. D, 111(5):056023, (2025)arxiv.org/abs/2411.19550
[14]S. Fang , S. Pu, Collisional corrections to spin polarization from quantum kinetic theory using Chapman-Enskog expansion, Phys. Rev. D, 111(3):034015, (2025)DOI
[15]Z.T. Liang , X.N. Wang, Spin alignment of vector mesons in non-central A+A collisions, Phys. Lett. B, 629:20–26, (2005)DOI
[16]Y.G. Yang, R.H. Fang, Q. Wang et al., Quark coalescence model for polarized vector mesons and baryons, Phys. Rev. C, 97(3):034917, (2018)DOI
[17]X.L. Sheng, L. Oliva, Z.T. Liang et al., Spin Alignment of Vector Mesons in Heavy-Ion Collisions, Phys. Rev. Lett, 131(4):042304, (2023)DOI
[18]X.L. Sheng, S. Pu , Q. Wang, Momentum dependence of the spin alignment of the ϕ meson, Phys. Rev. C, 108(5):054902, (2023)DOI
[19]A. Kumar, B. Müller , D.L. Yang, Spin alignment of vector mesons by plasma fields, Phys. Rev. D, 108(1):016020, (2023)DOI
[20]D.L. Yang, Transverse and longitudinal spin alignment from color fields in heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rev. D, 111(5):056005, (2025)DOI
[21]D. Wagner, N. Weickgenannt , E. Speranza, Generating tensor polarization from shear stress, Phys. Rev. Res, 5(1):013187, (2023)arxiv.org/abs/2207.01111
[22]P.H. De Moura, K.J. Goncalves , G. Torrieri, Quarkonium spin alignment in a vortical medium, Phys. Rev. D, 108(3):034032, (2023)arxiv.org/abs/2305.02985
[23]K. Xu , M. Huang, Spin alignment of vector mesons induced by local spin density fluctuations, Phys. Rev. D, 110(9):094034, (2024)arxiv.org/abs/2408.06581
[24]X.L. Sheng, Y.Q. Zhao, S.W. Li et al., Holographic spin alignment for vector mesons, Phys. Rev. D, 110(5):056047, (2024)arxiv.org/abs/2403.07522
[25]B. Fu, F. Gao, Y.X. Liu et al., The spin alignment of vector mesons with light front quarks, Phys. Lett. B, 855:138821, (2024)DOI
[26]Y.Q. Zhao, X.L. Sheng, S.W. Li et al, Holographic spin alignment of J/ψ meson in magnetized plasma, JHEP, 08:070, (2024)arxiv.org/abs/2403.07468
[27]J.H. Chen, Z.T. Liang, Y.G. Ma et al, Vector meson’s spin alignments in high energy reactions, Sci. China Phys. Mech. Astron, 68(1):211001, (2025)DOI
[28]J.P. Lv, Z.H. Yu, Z.T. Liang et al, Global quark spin correlations in relativistic heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rev. D, 109(11):114003, (2024)arxiv.org/abs/2402.13721
[29]M.S. Abdallah et al, Pattern of global spin alignment of φ and K*0 mesons in heavy-ion collisions, Nature, 614(7947):244–248, (2023)DOI
[30]P. Braun-Munzinger , J. Stachel, (Non)thermal aspects of charmonium production and a new look at J/ψ suppression, Phys. Lett. B, 490:196–202, (2000)
[31]X.B. Zhao , R. Rapp, Transverse Momentum Spectra of J/ψ in Heavy-Ion Collisions, Phys. Lett. B, 664:253–257, (2008)DOI
[32]K. Zhou, N. Xu, Z. Xu et al, Medium effects on charmonium production at ultrarelativistic energies available at the CERN Large Hadron Collider, Phys. Rev. C, 89(5):054911, (2014)DOI
[33]G. Bhanot , M.E. Peskin, Short Distance Analysis for Heavy Quark Systems. 2. Applications, Nucl. Phys. B, 156:391–416, (1979)
[34]M.E. Peskin, Short Distance Analysis for Heavy Quark Systems. 1. Diagrammatics. Nucl. Phys. B, 156:365–390, (1979)
[35]T. Song , S.H. Lee, Quarkonium-hadron interactions in perturbative QCD, Phys. Rev. D, 72:034002, (2005)DOI
[36]S.L. Chen , M. He, Gluo-dissociation of heavy quarkonium in the quark-gluon plasma reexamined, Phys. Rev. C, 96(3):034901, (2017)DOI
[37]F. Karsch, M.T. Mehr , H. Satz, Color Screening and Deconfinement for Bound States of Heavy Quarks, Z. Phys. C, 37:617, (1988)DOI
[38]L. Grandchamp , R. Rapp, Thermal versus direct J/ψ production in ultrarelativistic heavy ion collisions, Phys. Lett. B, 523:60–66, (2001)DOI
[39]L. Grandchamp , R. Rapp, Charmonium suppression and regeneration from SPS to RHIC, Nucl. Phys. A, 709:415–439, (2002)
[40]S.L. Chen , M. He, Heavy quarkonium dissociation by thermal gluons at next-to-leading order in the Quark-Gluon Plasma, Phys. Lett. B, 786:260–267, (2018)DOI
[41]S.X. Zhao, M. He, Second-order dissociation and transition of heavy quarkonia in the quark-gluon plasma, Phys. Rev. D, 110(7):074040, (2024)arxiv.org/abs/2405.07025
[42]N. Brambilla, M.A. Escobedo, J. Ghiglieri et al, Thermal width and gluo-dissociation of quarkonium in pNRQCD, JHEP, 12:116, (2011)DOI
[43]N. Brambilla, M.A. Escobedo, J. Ghiglieri et al, Thermal width and quarkonium dissociation by inelastic parton scattering, JHEP, 05:130, (2013)DOI
[44]N. Brambilla, M.A. Escobedo, J. Ghiglieri et al, Heavy Quarkonium in a weakly-coupled quark-gluon plasma below the melting temperature, JHEP, 09:038, (2010)DOI
[45]X.J. Yao , B. Müller, Quarkonium inside the quark-gluon plasma: Diffusion, dissociation, recombination, and energy loss, Phys. Rev. D, 100(1):014008, (2019)DOI
[46]Z.S. Chen , S. Lin, Polarized dissociation and spin alignment of moving quarkonia in a quark-gluon plasma, Phys. Rev. D, 111(7):074002, (2025)DOI
[47]S. Peigne , A. Peshier, Collisional energy loss of a fast heavy quark in a quark-gluon plasma, Phys. Rev. D, 77:114017, (2008)DOI
[48]E. Braaten , M.H. Thoma, Energy loss of a heavy quark in the quark-gluon plasma, Phys. Rev. D, 44(9):R2625, (1991)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10014185
[49]Y. Hidaka, S. Pu, Q. Wang et al, Foundations and applications of quantum kinetic theory, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys, 127:103989, (2022)DOI
[50]M.L. Bellac, Thermal Field Theory, First edition(Cambridge University Press,1996), p.129,194
[51]X.G. Huang, P. Mitkin, A. Sadofyev et al, Zilch Vortical Effect, Berry Phase, and Kinetic Theory, JHEP, 10:117, (2020)DOI
[52]K. Hattori, Y. Hidaka, N. Yamamoto et al, Wigner functions and quantum kinetic theory of polarized photons, JHEP, 02:001, (2021)
[53]S. Lin, Quantum kinetic theory for quantum electrodynamics, Phys. Rev. D, 105(7):076017, (2022)DOI
[54]Y. Hidaka, S. Pu , D.L. Yang, Nonlinear Responses of Chiral Fluids from Kinetic Theory. Phys. Rev. D, 97(1):016004, (2018)DOI
[55]J.H. Gao, J.Y. Pang , Q. Wang, Chiral vortical effect in Wigner function approach, Phys. Rev. D, 100(1):016008, (2019)DOI
[56]D.F. Hou , S. Lin, Polarization Rotation of Chiral Fermions in Vortical Fluid, Phys. Lett. B, 818:136386, (2021)DOI
[57]X.B. Zhao , R. Rapp, Charmonium in Medium: From Correlators to Experiment, Phys. Rev. C, 82:064905, (2010)DOI
[58]G.T. Bodwin, E. Braaten , G.P. Lepage, Rigorous QCD analysis of inclusive annihilation and production of heavy quarkonium, Phys. Rev. D, 51:1125–1171, (1995)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10018572
[59]Y. Jiang, Z.W. Lin , J.F. Liao, Rotating quark-gluon plasma in relativistic heavy ion collisions, Phys. Rev. C, 94(4):044910, (2016)DOI
[60]W.T. Deng , X.G. Huang, Vorticity in Heavy-Ion Collisions, Phys. Rev. C, 93(6):064907, (2016)DOI