betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Unrealistic assumptions may lead to unrealistic simulation results: Droplet nuclei are neglected in a COVID-19 transmission simulation (Comments)

Abstract

Bale et al. [1] perform a numerical study of droplet/aerosol transport in the air to assess the probability of airborne transmission of COVID-19 from an infected person to a nearby healthy person. In their numerical study, the air flow field is solved by an implicit large eddy simulation model, and the airborne transport of the droplets/aerosols exhaled from an infected person is solved by a Lagrangian particle model which considers droplet/aerosol evaporation. In the model used for droplets/aerosols, I found that an unrealistic assumption is used which may have a significant impact on the numerical accuracy: Droplet nuclei contained in real respiratory droplets/aerosols are neglected.

Bale et al. [1] perform a numerical study of droplet/aerosol transport in the air to assess the probability of airborne transmission of COVID-19 from an infected person to a nearby healthy person. In their numerical study, the air flow field is solved by an implicit large eddy simulation model, and the airborne transport of the droplets/aerosols exhaled from an infected person is solved by a Lagrangian particle model which considers droplet/aerosol evaporation. In the model used for droplets/aerosols, I found that an unrealistic assumption is used which may have a significant impact on the numerical accuracy: Droplet nuclei contained in real respiratory droplets/aerosols are neglected.

As is known, respiratory droplets/aerosols exhaled from the human mouth and nose contain nonvolatile components such as salt, protein, and lipid [2, 3, 4, 5]. These components remain as ``droplet nuclei’’ after the volatile components evaporate [3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15]: See Ref. [5] for photos of evaporating respiratory droplets and residual droplet nuclei taken using an acoustic levitation technique. The size (or equilibrium diameter) of the droplet nuclei is not negligibly small compared to the initial diameter of the droplets/aerosols, being estimated to be about 0.2∼0.40.2 \sim0.4 times the initial diameter at ∼50%\sim50\% relative humidity [16, 5]. The droplet nuclei are often considered to be the virus transmitter in airborne transmission of infectious diseases.

On the contrary, the model used by Bale et al. does not consider the droplet nuclei. Because the right-hand side of the model equation for the droplet mass (the lower equation in 17: See Ref. [17] for detailed review of this type of models) is negative for evaporation, the masses of the droplets/aerosols decrease without bound towards zero. This is due to the assumption that no, or negligibly small amount of, nonvolatile components are contained in the droplets/aerosols. Figure 4 of Bale et al.’s paper clearly demonstrates that the droplet diameter decreases without bound when the model equation in 17 is used.

This unrealistic assumption may lead to significant errors in the numerical simulations. First of all, the size of the droplets/aerosols is significantly underestimated particularly when the simulation time (up to 60 min in Bale et al.’s study) is much longer than the evaporation time of the droplets/aerosols (<1 μm<1\,\mu\mathrm{m} for 10 μm\mu\mathrm{m} droplets and about 10 s for 100 μm\mu\mathrm{m} droplets at 293 K ambient temperature and 50% relative humidity [18]). After a droplet with nonvolatile components evaporates and becomes a droplet nucleus, its size is fixed. If the nonvolatile components are neglected, however, the size of the droplet decreases without bound by continuous evaporation.

This underestimation of droplet/aerosol size would have a strong impact on Bale et al.’s numerical results. As is well known in many research fields including fluid dynamics and infectious diseases, the transport of droplets/aerosols in the air and in the human body is strongly dependent on the droplet/aerosol size among others [3, 4, 6, 7, 10, 11, 12, 14, 19]. Inaccurate estimation of droplet/aerosol size could thus result in a large error.

Since in the COVID-19 pandemic there has been much debate on the characteristics of respiratory droplets/aerosols [4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 14, 15, 18, 19], careful discussion is necessary. Bale et al. should clarify:

  • (a) why they used the model that does not consider the droplet nuclei even though more realistic models that consider the droplet nuclei have been used in previous works by other researchers [3, 12, 4], and

  • (b) how their numerical results (e.g., the transport dynamics of droplets/aerosols and the

resulting infection probability) change if the droplet nuclei are taken into account.

In addition, several important variables (e.g., NuNu, PrPr, and ScSc in Eq. 17) are not explained in Bale et al.’s paper. The authors must be more careful in writing a paper.

Additional Information

The author declares no competing interests.

References

  1. [1]Bale, R., Iida, A., Yamakawa, M., Li C.-G. & Tsubokura, M. Quantifying the COVID19 infection risk due to droplet/aerosol inhalation. Sci. Rep. 12, 11186 (2022).DOI
  2. [2]Effros, R. M., Hoagland, K. W., Bosbous, M., Castillo, D., Foss, B., Dunning, M., Gare, M., Lin, W., Sun. F. Dilution of respiratory solutes in exhaled condensates. Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med. 165, 663-669 (2002).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11874811
  3. [3]Redrow, J., Mao, S., Celik, I., Posada, J. A., Feng, Z.-G. Modeling the evaporation and dispersion of airborne sputum droplets expelled from a human cough. Building and Environment 46, 2042-2051 (2011).DOI
  4. [4]Pourfattah, F., Wang, L.-P., Deng, W., Ma, Y.-F., Hu, L. & Yang, B. Challenges in simulating and modeling the airborne virus transmission: A state-of-the-art review. Phys. Fluids 33, 101302 (2021).DOI
  5. [5]Stiti, M., Castanet, G., Corber, A., Alden, M., Berrocal, E. Transition from saliva droplets to solid aerosols in the context of COVID-19 spreading. Environmental Research 204, 112072 (2022).DOI
  6. [6]Wang, C. C., Prather, K. A., Sznitman, J., Jimenez, J. L., Lakdawala, S. S., Tufekci, Z. & Marr, L. C. Airborne transmission of respiratory viruses. Science 373, 981 (2021).DOI
  7. [7]Zuo, Y. Y., Uspal, W. E. & Wei, T. Airborne transmission of COVID-19: Aerosol dispersion, lung deposition, and virus-receptor interactions. ACS Nano 14, 16502-16524 (2020).DOI
  8. [8]Bourouiba, L. The fluid dynamics of disease transmission. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 53, 473-508 (2021).
  9. [9]Nicas, M., Nazaroff, W. W. & Hubbard, A., Toward understanding the risk of secondary airborne infection: Emission of respirable pathogens. J. Occup. Environ. Hyg. 2, 143-154 (2005).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15764538
  10. [10]Xie, X., Li, Y., Chwang, A. T. Y., Ho, P. L., Seto, W. H. How far droplets can move in indoor environments - Revisiting the Wells evaporation-falling curve. Indoor Air 17, 211-225 (2007).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17542834
  11. [11]Liu, L., Wei, J., Li, Y., Ooi, A. Evaporation and dispersion of respiratory droplets from coughing. Indoor Air 27, 179-190 (2016).DOI
  12. [12]Li, X., Shang, Y., Yan, Y., Yang, L., Tu, J. Modelling of evaporation of cough droplets in inhomogeneous humidity fields using the multi-component Eulerian-Lagrangian approach. Building and Environment 128, 68-76 (2018).DOI
  13. [13]Asadi, S., Wexler, A. S., Cappa, C. D., Barreda, S., Bouvier, N. M. & Ristenpart, W. D. Aerosol emission and superemission during human speech increase with voice loudness. Sci. Rep. 9, 2348 (2019).DOI
  14. [14]Li, H., Leong, F. Y., Xu, G., Ge, Z., Kang, C. W. & Lim, K. H. Dispersion of evaporating cough droplets in tropical outdoor environment. Phys. Fluids 32, 113301 (2020).DOI
  15. [15]Biswas, R., Pal, A., Pal, R., Sarkar, S. & Mukhopadhyay, A. Risk assessment of COVID infection by respiratory droplets from cough for various ventilation scenarios inside an elevator: An OpenFOAM-based computational fluid dynamics analysis. Phys. Fluids 34, 013318 (2022).DOI
  16. [16]Marr, L. C., Tang, J. W., Mullekom, J. V. & Lakdawala, S. S. Mechanistic insights into the effect of humidity on airborne influenza virus survival, transmission and incidence. J. R. Soc. Interface 16, 20180298 (2019).DOI
  17. [17]Miller, R. S., Harstad, K. & Bellan, J. Evaluation of equilibrium and non-equilibrium evaporation models for many-droplet gas-liquid flow simulations. Int. J. Multiph. Flow 24, 1025-1055 (1998).DOI
  18. [18]Walker, J. S., Archer, J., Gregson, F. K. A., Michel, S. E. S., Bzdek, B. R. & Reid, J. P. Accurate representations of the microphysical processes occurring during the transport of exhaled aerosols and droplets. ACS Cent. Sci 7, 200-209 (2021).DOI
  19. [19]Jayaweera, M., Perera, H., Gunawardana, B., Manatunge, J. Transmission of COVID-19 virus by droplets and aerosols: A critical review on the unresolved dichotomy. Environ. Res. 188, 109819 (2020).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_zcxyg67u
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents