betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Exoplanets are predominately aligned with exo-Kuiper Belts

Abstract

The architectures of planetary systems encode their formation and dynamical histories. In the Solar System, the near alignment of planetary orbits, the Kuiper Belt, and the Sun's equator supports planet formation in a rotating disk of gas and dust. However, some exoplanet systems show planets on orbits misaligned with their host stars or other planets, raising the question of whether misalignments are primordial or produced by post-formation dynamics. We present the first population-level constraints on the mutual inclinations of 32 planets in 16 systems relative to debris disks. We find that planets across orbital distances from 0.1 to 100 AU are predominantly aligned with the debris disks within 10 deg (30/32 planets). The alignment holds across systems spanning tens of million years to a few gigayears in age. These results indicate that the aligned architecture of the Solar System is representative of the birth conditions of exoplanet systems.

Introduction

The Kuiper Belt is a broad population of icy bodies beyond Neptune, with its main classical belt located around 40-48 AU from the Sun [1, 2, 3, 4]. It is the largest surviving remnant of the Solar System’s primordial planet-forming disk [5]. The Kuiper belt has a dynamically complex structure, consisting of a cold, primordial population and a hot population shaped by resonant and scattering perturbations from Neptune [6, 7, 8]. The mean plane of Kuiper Belt is mildly warped [9]. But across the classical belt, especially within the primordial cold population, it remains broadly aligned to within a few degrees of the Solar System’s invariable plane, the plane perpendicular to the planets’ combined orbital angular momentum vector [10, 11, 12]. The Solar System’s planets likewise show a similar degree of coplanarity, with their orbital planes lying within 7∘7^\circ of the invariable plane [13].

The near alignment between the Kuiper belt and the orbital planes of the planets is consistent with the nebular hypothesis [14, 15], in which planets form in an initially flattened accretion disk [16].

In extrasolar systems, the cold widely separated debris disks are the counterparts of the Kuiper belt, with dust continually replenished by collisions among larger planetesimals [17]. These disks can be resolved in scattered light at visible/near infrared wavelengths or in thermal emission at infrared and longer wavelengths. If exoplanetary systems form like the Solar System, it is expected that they are broadly coplanar, with planets approximately aligned with their exo-Kuiper belts. Recent observations, however, reveal a more diverse architecture, including planets in inclined orbits relative to their host stars’ spin axes [18, 19, 20, 21], and planets on mutually misaligned orbits [22, 23]. Observations of protoplanetary disks likewise show that modest warps are fairly common [24], while large inner-outer disk misalignments are less common but clearly present [25, 26]. These findings have motivated two leading hypotheses. First, misalignments among stars, planets and debris disks may result from post-formation dynamical interactions, such as planet-planet scattering [27], secular perturbations from planetary and stellar companions [28], or disturbances from stellar flybys [29]. Alternatively, they could be primordial, inherited from misaligned or warped natal disks [30].

One observable that can help distinguish between these two scenarios is the mutual inclination between planetary orbits and debris disks. To date, however, such measurements are available for only a handful of individual systems, predominantly those hosting directly imaged planets on wide orbits near the debris belt. Recently, the availability of calibrated astrometric accelerations from Hipparcos, Gaia DR2 and DR3 [31] now makes it possible to constrain the three-dimensional (3-D) orbits of giant planets detected by radial velocities (RVs) in debris disk systems. This approach can be applied to planets much closer to their host stars and around relatively older stars than those typically accessible to direct imaging observations. Thus, planet-disk alignment tests can be extended to a much wider range of orbital distances and system ages. In this study, we present the first population-level constraints on the mutual inclinations of 32 planets (in 16 systems) relative to their debris disks (exo-Kuiper belts).

Sample description

Figure 1A presents the radial architectures of the planetary systems in our sample. We construct the sample by cross-matching systems with confirmed planets from the NASA Exoplanet Archive with resolved debris disks listed in the Catalog of Circumstellar Disks and the Resolved Debris Disks Catalog. The initial cross-match yielded 24 systems containing 47 planets with both confirmed planets and resolved debris disks. Of these, 2 systems host transiting planets, 16 host planets detected with radial velocities (RVs), and 6 host directly imaged planets. We then excluded 8 systems that host only close-in, small planets (a<0.5a < 0.5 AU, M<0.1MJM < 0.1 M_{\mathrm{J}}) detected by RVs, for which the orbital inclination cannot be measured currently. We also excluded targets whose host stars are spectroscopic binaries. We include the Solar System in our sample. Our final sample consists of 32 planets in 16 systems.

Overview of the radial architectures and planet-disk alignments across the planetary systems in our sample

Figure 1. Overview of the radial architectures and planet-disk alignments across the planetary systems in our sample. A, Radial architecture of the planetary systems in our sample. Circles represent planets, with colors indicating their masses. Circle sizes scale with planet masses. Bars mark the locations of the debris disks observed at different wavelengths, denoted by colors. Panel A is intended to show the radial locations of the planets and debris disks, not the mutual inclinations between planets and disks. B, Minimum mutual inclination between planets and debris disks, Δip,d=∣ip−id∣\Delta i_{p,d} = \lvert i_p - i_d \rvert, as a function of planetary orbital distance. Violin plots show the full posterior distributions, while circles and error bars indicate the MAP and 1σ1\sigma credible intervals. C, The light blue shaded region shows the KDE of the pooled Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} distribution for the full sample. Each system, including the Solar System, is included only once. We present the hierarchical Bayesian models (HBMs) with a Rayleigh distribution and a truncated Gaussian distribution in purple and green, respectively, plotted as the posterior medians (dashed lines) with their 68% credible intervals (shaded regions).

The exoplanets in our sample span nearly three orders of magnitude in orbital distance, from 0.1 to 100 AU (see Figure 1A). At the smallest separations (0.1-1 AU) are two systems with transiting planets, including the three planets orbiting the 22-Myr-old star AU Mic [32], whose inclinations are tightly constrained by the transit observations. At intermediate separations (1-10 AU) are giant planets discovered through RVs, whose 3-D orbits can be constrained from orbit fits combining RVs and absolute astrometry from the calibrated Gaia DR3, DR2 and Hipparcos catalog (G32H) [31]. At the widest separations, typically at 10-100 AU, are directly imaged planets, including well-characterized systems such as β\beta Pic and HR 8799, whose orbits are constrained using relative imaging astrometry, absolute astrometry and, when available, RVs.

All debris disks in our sample are consistently located in outer system regions, from tens to hundreds of AU. These disks are either resolved in scattered light by Hubble Space Telescope (HST) [33], Gemini Planet Imager (GPI) [34] or Very Large Telescope/SPHERE [35], in thermal infrared (FIR) by Herschel Space Observatory [36], or in submillimeter continuum emission by Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) [37]. We list the stellar and disk parameters in Table S1 and Table S2.

Name (other identifiers)Spectral typeM∗M_{\ast} (M⊙M_{\odot})TeffT_{\mathrm{eff}} (K)age (Myr)Ref.
AU Mic (HD 197481, HIP 102409)M1V0.64−0.07+0.040.64^{+0.04}_{-0.07}3540−110+1203540^{+120}_{-110}19+1019^{+10}[112]
HD 38529 (HIP 2725)G4IV1.41−0.03+0.031.41^{+0.03}_{-0.03}5573−31+315573^{+31}_{-31}3090−170+1703090^{+170}_{-170}[61]
HD 114082 (HIP 64184)F3V1.47−0.07+0.071.47^{+0.07}_{-0.07}6651−35+356651^{+35}_{-35}15−6+615^{+6}_{-6}[118]
HD 82943 (HIP 47007)G2V1.04−0.02+0.021.04^{+0.02}_{-0.02}6011−70+706011^{+70}_{-70}2350−330+3302350^{+330}_{-330}[74]
HD 38858 (HIP 27435)G3V0.94−0.04+0.040.94^{+0.04}_{-0.04}5752−52+525752^{+52}_{-52}5400−3080+26805400^{+2680}_{-3080}[69]
HD 113337 (HIP 63584)F6V1.40−0.14+0.141.40^{+0.14}_{-0.14}6577−150+1536577^{+153}_{-150}150−50+100150^{+100}_{-50}[78]
HD 10647 (q1q^{1} Eri, HIP 7978)F9V1.11−0.02+0.021.11^{+0.02}_{-0.02}6218−20+206218^{+20}_{-20}1400−900+9001400^{+900}_{-900}[41]
κ\kappa CrB (HD 142091, HIP 77655)K0IV1.45−0.09+0.091.45^{+0.09}_{-0.09}4889−48+484889^{+48}_{-48}3286−554+5543286^{+554}_{-554}[42]
HD 216435 (τ1\tau^{1} Gruis, HIP 113044)G0V1.30−0.10+0.101.30^{+0.10}_{-0.10}5993−35+355993^{+35}_{-35}3500−500+15003500^{+1500}_{-500}[84]
β\beta Pic (HD 39060, HIP 2732)A5V1.76−0.17+0.181.76^{+0.18}_{-0.17}7099−250+2507099^{+250}_{-250}16.5−4.5+4.516.5^{+4.5}_{-4.5}[86]
ϵ\epsilon Eri (HD 22049, HIP 16537)K2V0.82−0.02+0.020.82^{+0.02}_{-0.02}5065−72+1315065^{+131}_{-72}600−200+200600^{+200}_{-200}[93]
HD 206893 ((HIP 107412)F5V1.32−0.05+0.071.32^{+0.07}_{-0.05}6500−100+1006500^{+100}_{-100}155−15+15155^{+15}_{-15}[101]
HR 8799 (HD 218396, HIP 11418)A5V1.50−0.05+0.051.50^{+0.05}_{-0.05}7204−123+847204^{+84}_{-123}60−30+10060^{+100}_{-30}[120]
HR 2562 (HD 50571, HIP 3277)F5V1.30−0.05+0.051.30^{+0.05}_{-0.05}6597−134+1466597^{+146}_{-134}600−300+300600^{+300}_{-300}[110]
HD 95086 (HIP 5352)A2V1.77−0.21+0.361.77^{+0.36}_{-0.21}7595−156+967595^{+96}_{-156}17−4+417^{+4}_{-4}[106]

Table S1. Summary of stellar parameters in our sample

Planet Nameipi_p (°)Ωp\Omega_p (°)idiski_{\mathrm{disk}} (°)Ωdisk\Omega_{\mathrm{disk}} (°)i∗i_* (°)Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} (°)Δip,∗\Delta i_{p,*} (°)
AU Mic b89.6−0.4+0.489.6^{+0.4}_{-0.4}–89.5−0.5+0.589.5^{+0.5}_{-0.5}128.4−0.1+0.1128.4^{+0.1}_{-0.1}88.1−7.7+1.688.1^{+1.6}_{-7.7}0.2−0.2+0.50.2^{+0.5}_{-0.2}1.4−1.4+7.61.4^{+7.6}_{-1.4}
AU Mic c89.3−1.1+1.189.3^{+1.1}_{-1.1}–89.5−0.5+0.589.5^{+0.5}_{-0.5}128.4−0.1+0.1128.4^{+0.1}_{-0.1}88.1−7.7+1.688.1^{+1.6}_{-7.7}0.3−0.3+1.00.3^{+1.0}_{-0.3}1.5−1.4+7.31.5^{+7.3}_{-1.4}
AU Mic d89.2−0.2+0.289.2^{+0.2}_{-0.2}–89.5−0.5+0.589.5^{+0.5}_{-0.5}128.4−0.1+0.1128.4^{+0.1}_{-0.1}88.1−7.7+1.688.1^{+1.6}_{-7.7}0.1−0.1+0.50.1^{+0.5}_{-0.1}1.1−1.1+7.61.1^{+7.6}_{-1.1}
HD 38529 c107.8−5.6+9.6107.8^{+9.6}_{-5.6}63.2−10.0+12.863.2^{+12.8}_{-10.0}109−7+10109^{+10}_{-7}48−5+548^{+5}_{-5}112.2−14.2+9.7112.2^{+9.7}_{-14.2}2.98−2.6+8.62.98^{+8.6}_{-2.6}3.9−3.9+9.63.9^{+9.6}_{-3.9}
HD 114082 b89.8−0.3+0.389.8^{+0.3}_{-0.3}–83.2−1.1+1.183.2^{+1.1}_{-1.1}105.7−1.4+1.4105.7^{+1.4}_{-1.4}–6.6−1.2+1.06.6^{+1.0}_{-1.2}–
HD 114082 c89.7−0.2+0.289.7^{+0.2}_{-0.2}–83.2−1.1+1.183.2^{+1.1}_{-1.1}105.7−1.4+1.4105.7^{+1.4}_{-1.4}–6.6−1.2+1.06.6^{+1.0}_{-1.2}–
HD 82943 b19.1−4.0+6.519.1^{+6.5}_{-4.0}39.9−25.3+19.939.9^{+19.9}_{-25.3}27−4+427^{+4}_{-4}152−8+8152^{+8}_{-8}19.9−3.7+3.719.9^{+3.7}_{-3.7}6.8−5.4+4.56.8^{+4.5}_{-5.4}1.9−1.8+4.91.9^{+4.9}_{-1.8}
HD 82943 c23.3−5.6+7.223.3^{+7.2}_{-5.6}27.1−21.7+27.127.1^{+27.1}_{-21.7}27−4+427^{+4}_{-4}152−8+8152^{+8}_{-8}19.9−3.7+3.719.9^{+3.7}_{-3.7}1.8−1.8+5.61.8^{+5.6}_{-1.8}2.3−2.3+6.42.3^{+6.4}_{-2.3}
HD 38858 b46.5−23.2+20.646.5^{+20.6}_{-23.2}41.6−32.6+296.641.6^{+296.6}_{-32.6}44−5+544^{+5}_{-5}67−5+567^{+5}_{-5}33.00−12.10+10.9633.00^{+10.96}_{-12.10}4.9−4.9+17.84.9^{+17.8}_{-4.9}8.5−8.4+18.38.5^{+18.3}_{-8.4}
HD 113337 c24.4−0.7+2.024.4^{+2.0}_{-0.7}224.1−3.5+5.8224.1^{+5.8}_{-3.5}13−9+1013^{+10}_{-9}160−38+63160^{+63}_{-38}25.5−3.6+4.825.5^{+4.8}_{-3.6}9.8−9.8+6.49.8^{+6.4}_{-9.8}1.1−1.1+3.51.1^{+3.5}_{-1.1}
HD 10647 b34.0−8.3+10.634.0^{+10.6}_{-8.3}281.2−20.6+19.2281.2^{+19.2}_{-20.6}77.8−0.1+0.177.8^{+0.1}_{-0.1}57.3−0.1+0.157.3^{+0.1}_{-0.1}68.1−8.8+13.568.1^{+13.5}_{-8.8}43.6−10.4+8.243.6^{+8.2}_{-10.4}37.0−17.4+11.637.0^{+11.6}_{-17.4}
κ\kappa CrB b16.2−2.9+1.716.2^{+1.7}_{-2.9}110.7−6.7+7.5110.7^{+7.5}_{-6.7}62.3−3.4+3.462.3^{+3.4}_{-3.4}148−5+5148^{+5}_{-5}–45.6−5.5+3.545.6^{+3.5}_{-5.5}–
HD 216435 b72.0−13.5+7.672.0^{+7.6}_{-13.5}259.5−21.0+18.5259.5^{+18.5}_{-21.0}68.5−5.5+3.668.5^{+3.6}_{-5.5}66.1−5+666.1^{+6}_{-5}–3.1−3.1+8.43.1^{+8.4}_{-3.1}–
β\beta Pic b89.1−0.1+0.189.1^{+0.1}_{-0.1}32.1−0.1+0.132.1^{+0.1}_{-0.1}85.3−0.2+0.285.3^{+0.2}_{-0.2}30.4−0.1+0.130.4^{+0.1}_{-0.1}87.8−1.6+1.687.8^{+1.6}_{-1.6}3.9−1.2+0.93.9^{+0.9}_{-1.2}2.1−1.8+1.62.1^{+1.6}_{-1.8}
β\beta Pic c89.0−0.6+0.589.0^{+0.5}_{-0.6}31.3−0.1+0.131.3^{+0.1}_{-0.1}85.3−0.2+0.285.3^{+0.2}_{-0.2}30.4−0.1+0.130.4^{+0.1}_{-0.1}87.8−1.6+1.687.8^{+1.6}_{-1.6}3.6−0.9+1.23.6^{+1.2}_{-0.9}2.3−2.1+1.42.3^{+1.4}_{-2.1}
ϵ\epsilon Eri b38.8−4.8+6.538.8^{+6.5}_{-4.8}185.4−7.5+9.7185.4^{+9.7}_{-7.5}33.7−0.5+0.533.7^{+0.5}_{-0.5}178.9−1.0+1.0178.9^{+1.0}_{-1.0}41.4−5.7+6.241.4^{+6.2}_{-5.7}3.7−3.7+6.63.7^{+6.6}_{-3.7}2.5−2.5+6.52.5^{+6.5}_{-2.5}
HD 206893 B149.9−2.7+2.2149.9^{+2.2}_{-2.7}79.0−2.4+6.379.0^{+6.3}_{-2.4}140−3+3140^{+3}_{-3}61−4+461^{+4}_{-4}151.6−3.2+1.7151.6^{+1.7}_{-3.2}9.8−4.2+3.69.8^{+3.6}_{-4.2}0.9−0.9+2.90.9^{+2.9}_{-0.9}
HD 206893 c146.0−1.7+2.2146.0^{+2.2}_{-1.7}73.1−4.6+1.773.1^{+1.7}_{-4.6}140−3+3140^{+3}_{-3}61−4+461^{+4}_{-4}151.6−3.2+1.7151.6^{+1.7}_{-3.2}5.8−3.7+3.45.8^{+3.4}_{-3.7}5.2−3.3+2.85.2^{+2.8}_{-3.3}
HR 8799 b26.9−0.2+0.226.9^{+0.2}_{-0.2}62.3−0.3+0.362.3^{+0.3}_{-0.3}30.8−3.2+2.830.8^{+2.8}_{-3.2}52.4−5.4+5.752.4^{+5.7}_{-5.4}26.8−1.9+2.026.8^{+2.0}_{-1.9}0.9−0.9+2.70.9^{+2.7}_{-0.9}3.4−3.4+2.43.4^{+2.4}_{-3.4}
HR 8799 c26.9−0.2+0.226.9^{+0.2}_{-0.2}62.3−0.3+0.362.3^{+0.3}_{-0.3}30.8−3.2+2.830.8^{+2.8}_{-3.2}52.4−5.4+5.752.4^{+5.7}_{-5.4}26.8−1.9+2.026.8^{+2.0}_{-1.9}0.9−0.9+2.70.9^{+2.7}_{-0.9}3.4−3.4+2.43.4^{+2.4}_{-3.4}
HR 8799 d26.9−0.2+0.226.9^{+0.2}_{-0.2}62.3−0.3+0.362.3^{+0.3}_{-0.3}30.8−3.2+2.830.8^{+2.8}_{-3.2}52.4−5.4+5.752.4^{+5.7}_{-5.4}26.8−1.9+2.026.8^{+2.0}_{-1.9}0.9−0.9+2.70.9^{+2.7}_{-0.9}3.4−3.4+2.43.4^{+2.4}_{-3.4}
HR 8799 e26.9−0.2+0.226.9^{+0.2}_{-0.2}62.3−0.3+0.362.3^{+0.3}_{-0.3}30.8−3.2+2.830.8^{+2.8}_{-3.2}52.4−5.4+5.752.4^{+5.7}_{-5.4}26.8−1.9+2.026.8^{+2.0}_{-1.9}0.9−0.9+2.70.9^{+2.7}_{-0.9}3.4−3.4+2.43.4^{+2.4}_{-3.4}
HR 2562 b86.4−0.2+0.186.4^{+0.1}_{-0.2}120.0−0.1+0.1120.0^{+0.1}_{-0.1}84.7−5.3+5.384.7^{+5.3}_{-5.3}122.7−0.8+0.7122.7^{+0.7}_{-0.8}86.8−9.7+3.086.8^{+3.0}_{-9.7}1.1−1.1+4.21.1^{+4.2}_{-1.1}1.9−1.9+7.11.9^{+7.1}_{-1.9}
HD 95086 b147.2−10.9+11.8147.2^{+11.8}_{-10.9}76.8−41.5+55.176.8^{+55.1}_{-41.5}144−2+3144^{+3}_{-2}98−3+398^{+3}_{-3}–2.7−2.5+9.72.7^{+9.7}_{-2.5}–

Table S2. Summary of the orientations of the planetary orbits, debris disks, and stellar spin axes. The values reported here are MPA and 68% highest probability region

Planet-debris disk alignment

First, we quantify the planet-disk misalignment using Δip,d=∣ip−id∣\Delta i_{p,d} = \lvert i_p - i_d \rvert, where ipi_p and idi_d are orbital inclinations of planets and debris disks relative to the sky plane. This quantity reflects the difference in how the planet’s orbital plane and the debris disk are tilted along the line of sight, and thus represents a lower limit on their true mutual inclination. For each planet, we inferred the posterior distribution of the Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} by combining the posteriors on the planet’s inclination from orbital fitting with the reported disk-inclination distribution from the literature (see materials and methods). Figure 1B presents the Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} as the function of planet orbital distances. Following the significance framework adopted in recent obliquity studies [38, 39], we take the maximum a posteriori (MAP) value of Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} and define a conservative lower limit as the value 2σ2\sigma below the posterior peak (corresponding to 95% confidence). We classify a planet as aligned or misaligned by comparing this lower limit to a chosen threshold. Using a threshold of 10∘10^\circ, we find 30/32 planets are aligned with the debris disks, indicating the most planets are aligned with the debris disks within 10∘10^\circ. At the system-level, we then estimate the inclination of each system’s invariable plane, when multiple planets are present. We find 14/16 systems show alignment between the system invariable plane with debris disks assuming a threshold of 10∘10^\circ. For the stricter threshold of 1∘1^\circ, the aligned fraction decreases to 26/32 for planets and 11/16 for systems. In other words, about 5 out of 16 systems show a modest misalignment with an amplitude of a few degrees. A representative example is β\beta Pic, where the two planets are misaligned relative to the debris disk by 3.9−1.2+0.9∘3.9^{+0.9}_{-1.2}{}^\circ and 3.6−0.9+1.2∘3.6^{+1.2}_{-0.9}{}^\circ, consistent with the observed 3∘3^\circ–4∘4^\circ warp in the disk. The planet-disk mutual inclination in β\beta Pic is therefore modest (<10∘< 10^\circ), yet significantly different from zero. The Solar System provides another example: the mean plane of the Kuiper belt lies within about 0.7∘0.7^\circ of the Solar System’s invariable plane, but is nevertheless distinguishable from it at greater than 99.7% confidence [12].

We visualize the population-level distribution of Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} by pooling posterior samples of Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} from individual systems and computing a kernel density estimate (KDE, see Figure 1C). To avoid overcounting multi-planet systems, we include each system only once, using the orbital inclination difference between the system invariable plane and the debris disk. The KDE peaks at 0∘0^\circ, with a half-width of about 10∘10^\circ. We then explore two types of underlying population distribution for Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} using hierarchical Bayesian model (HBM): a Rayleigh distribution and a truncated Gaussian distribution. The resulting Rayleigh model yields a characteristic inclination scale of 6.3±1.1∘6.3 \pm1.1^\circ. The best-fit truncated Gaussian model shows a peak at 4.5±2.6∘4.5 \pm2.6^\circ and a dispersion of 9.3±2.8∘9.3 \pm2.8^\circ. Together, the KDE and model fits indicate that the Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} distribution is concentrated toward low mutual inclinations, with characteristic values below 10∘10^\circ.

Furthermore, we examine the 3-D mutual inclinations, ψp,d\psi_{p,d}, between the planets and the debris disks. In principle, ψp,d\psi_{p,d} can be derived with measured orbital inclinations and longitudes of ascending node for both the planets and the debris disks. However, because disk observations reveal only the projected ellipse on the sky, the inferred 3-D disk orientation remains degenerate (see materials and methods). For any individual system, the true solution cannot be uniquely identified without additional information, such as scattering-phase constraints or kinematic observations of gas motion in the disk, which are not always available. For the sample as a whole, however, we account for this ambiguity within the HBM by marginalizing over the degenerate solutions. Figure S1 presents the best-fit hierarchical Bayesian models of ψp,d\psi_{p,d} using a Rayleigh distribution and a truncated Gaussian distribution, respectively. The two models yield similar results: although the ψp,d\psi_{p,d} distribution is broader and shifted to larger values than Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d}, they still favor low planet-disk mutual inclination, with a typical scale of ∼15∘\sim15^\circ. The Rayleigh model implies a characteristic inclination scale of 15.1±2.5∘15.1 \pm2.5^\circ, while the truncated Gaussian model yields a peak at 15.6±4.5∘15.6 \pm4.5^\circ and a dispersion of 16.3±3.6∘16.3 \pm3.6^\circ.

Distribution of 3-D planet-disk mutual inclinations and hierarchical Bayesian constraints

Figure S1. Distribution of 3-D planet-disk mutual inclinations ψp,d\psi_{p,d} and hierarchical Bayesian constraints on the underlying population. Left: KDEs of the pooled posterior distributions for ψp,d\psi_{p,d}. The green and orange dashed lines show the pooled distributions of the two degenerate solutions, p(ψp,d1)p(\psi^1_{p,d}) and p(ψp,d2)p(\psi^2_{p,d}). The purple curve shows the equal-weight marginalized distribution, p(ψp,d)=12p(ψp,d1)+12p(ψp,d2)p(\psi_{p,d}) = \frac{1}{2}p(\psi^1_{p,d}) + \frac{1}{2}p(\psi^2_{p,d}). Right: HBM fits to ψp,d\psi_{p,d} assuming underlying Rayleigh (blue) and truncated Gaussian (red) distributions. The dashed lines show the posterior medians, and the shaded regions indicate the corresponding 68% credible intervals.

Star-planet-debris disk alignment

We further probe the alignment between star, planet and debris disks in the sample. Stellar inclination measurements are available for 12 systems, inferred from the stellar rotation period ProtP_{\mathrm{rot}}, projected rotational velocity vsin⁡i∗v \sin i_*, and stellar radius R∗R_* (see materials and methods). Similar to Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d}, we define the minimum stellar obliquity as Δip,∗=∣ip−i∗∣\Delta i_{p,*} = |i_p - i_*|, the absolute difference between the planetary and stellar inclinations. Figure 2 compares Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} and Δip,∗\Delta i_{p,*}. To assess the level of agreement, we calculated Lin’s concordance correlation coefficient (CCC), which quantifies how closely two variables match in both correlation and equality about the 1:1 line [40]. We obtain CCC = 0.867, indicating strong agreement between Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} and Δip,∗\Delta i_{p,*}. We find 11 out of 12 systems exhibit low inclinations (<10∘< 10^\circ) for both the planet-disk mutual inclination and the star-planet obliquity. Overall, these results indicate that the systems in our sample are predominantly consistent with alignment among stars, planets, and debris disks, reminiscent of the architecture of the Solar System.

Comparison of stellar obliquity and planet-disk mutual inclinations

Figure 2. Comparison of stellar obliquity and planet-disk mutual inclinations. Left: Minimum stellar obliquity, Δip,∗\Delta i_{p,*}, as a function of minimum planet-disk mutual inclination, Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d}, for the 12 systems in our sample with measured stellar inclinations (including Solar System). Right: KDEs of Δip,∗\Delta i_{p,*} and Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} across the 12 systems.

Misaligned systems

HD 10647 (q1q^1 Eri) and κ\kappa CrB (HD 142091) are the two exceptions in our sample, showing significant misalignment between their planets and debris disks. HD 10647 is F9V star with an age of 1.4−0.9+0.91.4^{+0.9}_{-0.9} Gyr [41]. κ\kappa CrB is a K0 sub-giant star with an age of 3.28−0.55+0.553.28^{+0.55}_{-0.55} Gyr [42]. Both systems host a giant planet in the inner system, at 2 AU [43] and 2.6 AU [44], respectively. They also host spatially resolved debris disks in the outer planetary system, with characteristic disk radii of R∼103R \sim103 AU for HD 10647 [45] and ∼93\sim93 AU for κ\kappa CrB [46]. The minimum planet-disk mutual inclinations are Δip,d=43.6−10.4+8.1°\Delta i_{p,d} = 43.6^{+8.1}_{-10.4}\degree for HD 10647 and 44.3−3.0+5.8°44.3^{+5.8}_{-3.0}\degree for κ\kappa CrB, ruling out alignment within 10∘10^\circ at the >3σ> 3\sigma (99.7%) level. For HD 10647, we can additionally infer the stellar inclination from the stellar rotation period and projected rotational velocity, vsin⁡i∗v \sin i_*. This allows us to compare the orientations of all three components in the system: the stellar spin axis, the planetary orbit, and the debris disk. We find that the planet is misaligned with both the star (Δip,∗=37.0−17.4+11.6°\Delta i_{p,*} = 37.0^{+11.6}_{-17.4}\degree) and the debris disk (Δip,d=43.6−10.4+8.1°\Delta i_{p,d} = 43.6^{+8.1}_{-10.4}\degree), whereas the stellar spin axis is nearly aligned with the debris disk (Δi∗,d=8.8−8.6+3.4°\Delta i_{*,d} = 8.8^{+3.4}_{-8.6}\degree). The two systems represent departures from Solar System-like coplanarity and therefore provide valuable opportunity for probing the origin of orbital misalignments.

Implication for planetary system formation

Our results reveal that most extrasolar planetary systems resemble the Solar System in exhibiting alignment between the orbital plane of planets and debris disks. This alignment is seen not only for wide-orbit planets near the debris disks, but also for planets in the inner regions, suggesting these systems preserve a common angular-momentum orientation across a wide range of orbital separations. For the subset of systems with stellar inclination constraints, we also find evidence for alignment among the debris disk, planetary orbits, and the stellar spin axis. Together, these results support the basic picture that planets and planetesimal belts form within a common, broadly coplanar protoplanetary disk. We also note that, although most planets are broadly aligned with the debris disks within 10∘10^\circ, many systems, such as β\beta Pic, exhibit modest mutual inclinations of a few degree. This is consistent with the observations of protoplanetary disk, where modest warp (0.5−2∘0.5 - 2^\circ) are common [24]. Thus, planetary systems may be broadly aligned while preserving small dynamical imprints from disk warps, planet–planet interactions, or other perturbations.

Although rare, we identify two systems, HD 10647 and κ\kappa CrB, showing significant misalignment between planets and debris disks. Previous observations, including the outer-disk inclination distribution of young dipper stars [47], and shadows observed in scattered-light images of protoplanetary disks [26], indicate that misalignments between inner and outer disks can arise during the protoplanetary-disk stage. A striking example is HD 142527, which hosts an inner and outer protoplanetary disk with a relative inclination of ∼70∘\sim70^\circ [25]. If such inner-outer disk misalignments are preserved during planet formation, they could naturally produce misaligned inner and outer planetary architectures, including misalignments between inner planets and outer debris disks. An important question, therefore, is whether the two misaligned systems in our sample reflect this primordial origin, or whether their planets were later driven onto inclined orbits through post-formation dynamical processes. HD 10647 and κ\kappa CrB are among the oldest stars in our sample, with ages of 1.5 and 3.4 Gyr (see Figure 3), whereas the rest of the sample, spanning a broad range of ages from tens of Myr to a few Gyr, is largely consistent with alignment. Although the sample remains limited, the fact that significant planet-disk misalignments are only observed in older systems may favor a post-formation origin, where the system initially formed in a roughly coplanar configuration and was later misaligned by dynamical events. If large planet-disk misalignments were generally primordial, inherited from natal disks at birth, we would expect to observe them more broadly across systems of different ages, including younger systems. In addition, ref. [48] found a south-west ansa asymmetry in the disk of HD 10647, which could be perturbed by a planet with mass from 8 M⊕8\,M_{\oplus} to 11 MJ11\,M_{\mathrm{J}} at ∼60 AU\sim60\ \mathrm{AU}. If such a planet exists, it could point to a past interaction with HD 10647 b that excited the planet into a misaligned orbit. Furthermore, the alignment between the debris disk and the stellar spin axis in HD 10647 suggests that the planet was excited onto an inclined orbit at a later stage, rather than inheriting its misalignment from the natal disk. We cannot, however, rule out a primordial origin in individual cases. Even so, the rarity of the observed planet-disk misalignments suggests that primordial misalignment is unlikely to be a dominant pathway shaping planetary-system architectures.

Planet-disk mutual inclination as a function of stellar age

Figure 3. Planet-disk mutual inclination as a function of stellar age. Minimum mutual inclination between planet and debris disk, Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d}, is shown versus stellar age for the systems in our sample. The two systems with planets in misaligned orbits relative to the debris disks are labeled.

A separate but related question is the origin of stellar obliquity. Previous studies have argued that the observed spin-orbit misalignment could be from primordial misalignment between disk and stars. Ref. [39] has shown that roughly one-third of protoplanetary disks are misaligned with respect to their host stars’ spin axes, although the majority remain aligned. In comparison, our results show a tighter alignment between the angular momentum vectors of planetary orbits and debris disks than between those of stars and protoplanetary disks. In our sample, however, stellar obliquity measurements are available for only 12 systems, and in all of them the debris disks are consistent with alignment with their host stars. As a result, our data do not strongly constrain the frequency of primordial star-disk misalignment at the debris-disk stage for direct comparison. A larger sample with measurements of stellar inclinations, planetary orbits and resolved debris disks will be required to test the connection among all three components. In the future, the release of Gaia DR4 will make the breakthrough by enabling the detection and orbital characterization of thousands more giant planets [49] and substantially expanding the sample of systems amenable to such system-wide alignment measurements.

References and Notes

Acknowledgments

J.Z. would like to acknowledge the use of computational facilities purchased with funds from the National Science Foundation (CNS-1725797) and administered by the Center for Scientific Computing (CSC). The CSC is supported by the California NanoSystems Institute and the Materials Research Science and Engineering Center (MRSEC; NSF DMR 2308708) at UC Santa Barbara. This research has made use of the NASA Exoplanet Archive, which is operated by the California Institute of Technology, under contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Administration under the Exoplanet Exploration Program. This research has made use of the Catalog of Circumstellar Disks (circumstellardisks.org), curated by Nicholas Grosso. This work benefited from the 2025 Exoplanet Summer Program in the Other Worlds Laboratory (OWL) at the University of California, Santa Cruz, a program funded by the Heising-Simons Foundation. J.Z. would like to thank Jerry Xuan for his support and helpful scientific discussion.

Funding: J.Z. and M.A.M. are supported by grant JWST-GO-06012.001-A from the Space Telescope Science Institute under NASA contract NAS 5-03127. B.P.B. acknowledges support from the National Science Foundation grant AST-1909209, NASA Exoplanet Research Program grant 20-XRP20 2-0119, and the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. T.D.P is supported by a UKRI Stephen Hawking Fellowship and a Warwick Prize Fellowship, the latter made possible by a generous philanthropic donation.

Author contributions: J.Z. conceived the project, developed the main scientific idea, performed the analysis, and wrote the manuscript – original draft. M.A.M contributed to the conceptualization of the study, interpretation of the results, and funding acquisition. B.P.B and T.D.P. contributed to the conceptualization of the study, interpretation of the results and scientific discussions. W.T. and D.B. provided the astrometric data products, developed the software of orbital fitting and advised on their use. M.M. contributed to methodology and the HBM modeling. All authors reviewed and commented on the manuscript.

Competing interests: There are no competing interests to declare.

Data, code and materials availability: All radial velocity and imaging relative astrometry data used in this analysis (listed in Table S4 and S5) are from public, archival data with full references to the original data publications. There are no restrictions on the availability of all data used in this work. The absolute astrometry data from Calibrated Gaia DR2, DR3, and Hipparcos Catalog [31] are available in https://www.canfar.net/citation/landing?doi=26.0002. All photometric data from TESS used in this analysis (plotted in Figure S30-Figure S34) are available in the Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes: https://doi.org/10.17909/T9-NMC8-F686 [50].

Measurements of stellar rotational period of HD 10647

Figure S30. Measurements of stellar rotational period of HD 10647. The first four panels show the TESS light curves, and the final panel shows the corresponding periodogram. The red dashed line marks the identified rotation period.

Measurements of stellar rotational period of HR 2562

Figure S34. Measurements of stellar rotational period of HR 2562. The first eight panels show the TESS light curves, and the final panel shows the corresponding periodogram. The red dashed line marks the identified rotation period.

NameInstrumentNumber of RVsObservation BaselineReference
HD38529HIRES pre481996-12-01 to 2002-11-24[158]
Lick Fischer1361998-10-14 to 2011-10-12[62, 159]
HRS1752004-12-02 to 2008-12-22[67]
HIRES post952006-01-15 to 2021-10-24[160]
APF3142013-09-27 to 2020-02-08[160]
HD82943Lick Fischer72001-03-11 to 2009-02-01[159]
HIRES pre222001-04-07 to 2004-06-25[161]
HIRES post1512005-01-27 to 2023-05-25[160]
HD38858HIRES pre171996-12-01 to 2003-09-15[43]
HARPS pre1002003-10-29 to 2015-02-08[71]
HARPS post332015-10-07 to 2021-09-13[162]
HIRES post712004-10-24 to 2021-08-19[160]
APF1272013-10-17 to 2020-02-08[160]
NEID692021-09-18 to 2024-01-20[163]
HD10647UCLES281998-01-17 to 2005-07-22[43]
COR98971998-11-13 to 2007-01-21[41]
COR07162007-06-27 to 2011-11-03[41]
HARPS pre1392003-11-06 to 2012-01-05[164]
HARPS post582018-10-17 to 2020-01-17[164]
HD113337SOPHIE2072007-01-23 to 2022-07-15[66]
κ\kappa CrBLick Fischer732004-04-26 to 2008-07-29[159]
HIRES post4352010-03-01 to 2022-03-18[160]
APF3322013-11-11 to 2021-12-17[160]
HD216435UCLES581998-08-08 to 2005-11-28[43]
HARPS pre142004-10-11 to 2013-11-26[165]
HARPS post402018-10-18 to 2021-09-15[165]
ϵ\epsilon EriLick Fischer1761987-09-08 to 2011-10-12[159]
HIRES post1562009-10-06 to 2020-12-06[160]
APF1772013-10-17 to 2019-11-13[160]
HD206893HARPS422016-10-05 to 2021-09-22[101]
β\beta PicHARPS902010-12-12 to 2021-01-29[88]

Table S4. Summary of RVs used in orbital fitting

This work used the open-source package Octofitter [51] for orbital fitting. Documentation for Octofitter is available at https://sefffal.github.io/Octofitter.jl/stable/. The code for statistical analysis is available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.

Supplementary materials

Materials and Methods

Supplementary Text

Figs. S1 to S34

Tables S1 to S5

References (50-172)

Supplementary Materials for Exoplanets are predominately aligned with exo-Kuiper Belts

Jingwen Zhang; Maxwell A. Millar-Blanchaer; Brendan P. Bowler; Tim D. Pearce; Marvin Morgan; William Thompson; Dori Blakely

This PDF file includes:

Materials and Methods

Supplementary Text

Figure S1 to S34

Table S1 to S5

Materials and Methods

Debris Disk Parameters

We construct this sample by cross-matching systems with confirmed planets from the NASA Exoplanet Archive (https://exoplanetarchive.ipac.caltech.edu/) with resolved debris disks from the Catalog of Circumstellar Disks (https://www.circumstellardisks.org/index.php) and the Resolved Debris Disks Catalog (https://www.physik.uni-jena.de/en/21956/catalog-of-resolved-debris-disks) and other recent compilation of debris disk surveys from ALMA [45] and SPHERE [52]. We adopted the measurements of disk orbital inclination (idi_{\mathrm{d}}) and position angle (θd\theta_{\mathrm{d}}) from literature. For disks where many independent measurements are available, we adopt the highest reported precision. For the disk parameters with asymmetric uncertainties, we adopt the mean of the upper and lower limits. All measurements used in our analysis are with uncertainties below 10∘10^\circ. The adopted stellar parameters and disk parameters are presented in Table S1 and Table S2. We provide detailed descriptions of each system in the Supplementary Text.

Planet Orbit Fit

We performed joint Bayesian orbit fits using open-source package Octofitter [51], simultaneously modeling absolute astrometric measurements from Gaia DR3, DR2 and Hipparcos together with long-baseline RVs, or relative astrometry from imaging, or both when available. We adopted a single-companion model for most systems, except for HD 113337, β\beta Pic, HD 206893, and HD 82943, for which we fit two-companion models. Each companion is described by seven parameters: orbital period PP, planet-to-star mass ratio qq, eccentricity ee, argument of periastron ω\omega, cosine of inclination cos⁡i\cos i, longitude of the ascending node Ω\Omega, and position angle at a reference epoch θ\theta. We also fit additional nuisance parameters, including RV and astrometric noise terms, instrument-specific RV zero points, and astrometric epoch selection (see ref. [31] for details). We assume Gaussian priors for host star mass M∗M_\ast based on reported values from literature. We adopted a uniform prior between 0 and 0.99 on the eccentricity, and a uniform prior in cos⁡i\cos i for orbital inclination. The priors on argument of periastron ω\omega and longitude of the ascending node Ω\Omega are uniform between 0 to 2π2\pi. For companion mass, we adopted a broad log-uniform prior spanning from 0.1 to 100 MJM_{\mathrm{J}}.

Following the framework in ref. [31, 53], the total likelihood is constructed from the product of the RV, relative astrometry from imaging, absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia, and Gaia astrometric excess noise (unbiased estimator of variance, or UEVA), so that all constraints are fit self-consistently within a single orbit model:

ln⁡L=ln⁡LRV+ln⁡Lrel. ast.+ln⁡Labs. ast.+ln⁡LUEVA(1)\ln\mathcal{L} = \ln\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{RV}} + \ln\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{rel.\ ast.}} + \ln\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{abs.\ ast.}} + \ln\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{UEVA}} \tag*{(1)}

We adopted archival RV measurements for ten stars in the sample from a variety of instruments. For directly imaged planets, we adopted archival relative astrometry from imaging observations. A detailed summary of the RV and relative astrometry data, including the number of measurements and observational baseline for each system, are provided in Table S4 and Table S5.

NameNumber of Relative AstrometryObservation BaselineReference
β\beta Pic b402003-11-10 to 2018-11-19[86, 87, 88, 166, 167]
β\beta Pic c32020-02-10 to 2020-03-08[90]
HD206893 B132019-07-17 to 2025-06-08[102, 103, 104, 168]
HD206893 c32021-09-03 to 2021-10-23[101]
HR2562 B202016-01-25 to 2024-03-19[110, 169, 170]
HD95086 b162012-01-12 to 2023-03-16[106, 171, 172]

Table S5. Summary of imaging relative astrometry used in orbital fitting

For absolute astrometry, we modeled a joint set of calibrated proper-motion observables: the Hipparcos proper motion μH\mu_{\mathrm{H}}, the Hipparcos-Gaia long-baseline scaled position difference μHG\mu_{\mathrm{HG}}, the Gaia DR2 and DR3 proper motions (μDR2\mu_{\mathrm{DR2}}, μDR3\mu_{\mathrm{DR3}}), and the Gaia DR3-DR2 scaled positiondifference term μDR32\mu_{\mathrm{DR32}}. Hipparcos quantities (μH\mu_{\mathrm{H}} and μHG\mu_{\mathrm{HG}}) were adopted from the DR3-calibrated HGCA solution, whereas Gaia DR2 quantities were separately cross-calibrated onto the DR3 frame using global magnitude-dependent rotation, local HEALPix offsets, and uncertainty inflation. We also include the DR2-DR3 cross-covariance to take into account for the shared Gaia transits by DR2 and DR3.

Finally, we included a likelihood from Gaia UEVA term, which is inferred from Gaia’s astrometric excess-noise or Renormalized Unit Weight Error (RUWE) information. For each trial orbit, we forward-model the Gaia scan sampling, fit a 5-parameter single-star solution to the perturbed path, and compute the predicted UEVA from the resulting along-scan residuals. We then compare observed and predicted UEVA (typically in a cube-root-transformed Gaussian form). This term adds sensitivity to short-timescale astrometric wobble during the Gaia baseline and helps break degeneracies left by proper-motion anomalies alone.

We sampled the posterior using the stabilized variational nonreversible parallel tempering algorithm implemented in Pigeons.jl [54] for 2142^{14} scans. We provide the details of the orbital fitting results for each individual system in Supplementary Text.

Stellar Inclination

Stellar inclination is the angle between the stellar rotation axis and line of sight, for which i∗=0∘i_\ast= 0^\circ corresponding to pole-on configuration and i∗=90∘i_\ast= 90^\circ corresponding to edge-on configuration. Typically, when the stellar radius R∗R_\ast and rotational period ProtP_{\mathrm{rot}} are known, the equatorial rotational velocities can be calculated as veq=2πR∗/Protv_{\mathrm{eq}} = 2\pi R_\ast/P_{\mathrm{rot}}. Although it is intuitive to estimate i∗=sin⁡−1(vsin⁡i∗veq)i_\ast= \sin^{-1}\left(\frac{v\sin i_\ast}{v_{\mathrm{eq}}}\right), this assumes veqv_{\mathrm{eq}} and vsin⁡iv\sin i are independent, which ref. [55] points out it is not usually valid. We therefore follow the Bayesian probabilistic framework from ref. [38, 55] to derive the stellar inclination. For stars with vsin⁡i∗>2 km s−1v\sin i_\ast> 2\ {\rm km\,s^{-1}}, the stellar inclination can be derived as

P(i∗∣Prot,R∗,vsin⁡i∗)∝sin⁡i∗×exp⁡[−12(vsin⁡i∗−2πR∗Protsin⁡i∗σvsin⁡i∗2+σveq2sin⁡2i∗)2]σvsin⁡i∗2+σveq2sin⁡2i∗,(2)P(i_\ast\mid P_{\mathrm{rot}}, R_\ast, v\sin i_\ast) \propto\sin i_\ast\times\frac{\exp\left[-\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{v\sin i_\ast-\frac{2\pi R_\ast}{P_{\mathrm{rot}}}\sin i_\ast}{\sqrt{\sigma_{v\sin i_\ast}^{2}+\sigma_{v_{\mathrm{eq}}}^{2}\sin^{2}i_\ast}}\right)^{2}\right]}{\sqrt{\sigma_{v\sin i_\ast}^{2}+\sigma_{v_{\mathrm{eq}}}^{2}\sin^{2}i_\ast}}, \tag*{(2)}

where σvsin⁡i∗\sigma_{v\sin i_\ast} and σveq\sigma_{v_{\mathrm{eq}}} are the uncertainties in the projected velocity vsin⁡i∗v\sin i_\ast and the equatorial velocity veqv_{\mathrm{eq}}. We estimate the uncertainty of equatorial velocity σveq\sigma_{v_{\mathrm{eq}}} from those of stellar rotation period and radii as

σveq=2πR∗Prot(σR∗R∗)2+(σProtProt)2(3)\sigma_{v_{\mathrm{eq}}} = \frac{2\pi R_\ast}{P_{\mathrm{rot}}}\sqrt{\left(\frac{\sigma_{R_\ast}}{R_\ast}\right)^2+\left(\frac{\sigma_{P_{\mathrm{rot}}}}{P_{\mathrm{rot}}}\right)^2} \tag*{(3)}

For slow-rotating stars with vsin⁡i∗<2 km s−1v\sin i_\ast< 2\ {\rm km\,s^{-1}}, it is challenging to distinguish macro-turbulence broadening from rotation broadening in the stellar spectra. Therefore, we only adopt a upper limit of vsin⁡i∗v\sin i_\ast and the stellar inclination can be given as

P(i∗∣Prot,R∗,l)∝sin⁡i∗×(erf⁡(l−2πR∗Protsin⁡i∗2σveqsin⁡i∗)+erf⁡(2πR∗σveqProt))(4)P(i_\ast\mid P_{\mathrm{rot}}, R_\ast, l) \propto\sin i_\ast\times\left(\operatorname{erf}\left(\frac{l-\frac{2\pi R_\ast}{P_{\mathrm{rot}}}\sin i_\ast}{\sqrt{2}\sigma_{v_{\mathrm{eq}}}\sin i_\ast}\right)+\operatorname{erf}\left(\frac{\sqrt{2}\pi R_\ast}{\sigma_{v_{\mathrm{eq}}}P_{\mathrm{rot}}}\right)\right) \tag*{(4)}

where ll is the upper limit of vsin⁡i∗v\sin i_* and erf⁡(x)\operatorname{erf}(x) is the error function, defined by erf⁡(x)=2π∫0xe−t2 dt\operatorname{erf}(x) = \frac{2}{\sqrt{\pi}}\int_{0}^{x}e^{-t^2}\,\mathrm{d}t.

Across the full sample, 10 systems have published stellar rotation periods, determined from either photometric light curves or stellar activity indices, and the measurements from different sources are broadly consistent. We also derived stellar rotation periods for five stars (see Supplementary Text), obtaining values in agreement with the literature. We adopted the weighted mean rotation period for each star and imposed a minimum uncertainty floor of 10%. We compiled vsin⁡i∗v\sin i_* measurements from multiple sources; when reported uncertainties were available, we combined values using a weighted mean and weighted standard deviation, and when uncertainties were unavailable, we estimated a mean and standard deviation from those measurements and included that as an additional constraint. Stellar radii were adopted from the TESS Input Catalog [56], with uncertainties inflated in quadrature by 7%. Table S3 provides a detailed summary of the stellar radii, projected rotational velocities, and rotation periods used in our analysis. We also provide detailed descriptions in Supplementary Text.

Stellar inclination can also be derived through asteroseismic analysis, because stellar rotation induces splitting of non-radial oscillation modes in a manner that depends on the stellar inclination [57, 58]. For β\beta Pic, we adopted the stellar inclination measurements derived with asteroseismology from ref. [59]. In total, we have 12 systems with stellar inclination measurements in our sample, including the Solar System.

Geometry for Mutual Inclination and Stellar Obliquity

We first assess the planet–disk mutual inclination using the absolute difference between the orbital inclinations of the planet and the debris disk as

Δip,d=∣ip−id∣(5)\Delta i_{p,d} = \left|i_p - i_d\right| \tag*{(5)}

This observable measures the relative tilt between the two plane along the line of sight, and provides a lower limit on the 3-D mutual inclination. For a measured disk inclination idi_d, the disk angular momentum vector has two possible orientations, idi_d or π−id\pi-i_d, if the direction of dust’s orbital motion of is unknown. The two values correspond to the same plane but opposite normal directions, producing the usual prograde–retrograde degeneracy (see Figure S2). In this work, we focus on the angle between the two planes, equivalent to the prograde solution, because distinguishing prograde from retrograde configurations requires kinematic information that is generally difficult for debris disks, which typically contain little or no gas.

Geometry of the disk orientation in three dimensions

Figure S2. Geometry of the disk orientation in three dimensions. The blue circle denotes the sky plane, with the zz-axis pointing along the line of sight. The yellow plane represents the debris disk, and the orange arrows indicate the normal vector of the disk plane. The solid and dashed vectors illustrate the prograde and retrograde degeneracy that arises because the direction of dust motion in the disk is unknown, corresponding to orbital inclinations of idi_d and π−id\pi- i_d, respectively. The left and right panels show the additional degeneracy associated with the unknown near side of the disk, which gives rise to an ambiguity in the longitude of ascending node, Ωd\Omega_d versus Ωd+π\Omega_d + \pi.

We also calculate the 3-D mutual inclination ψp,d\psi_{p,d} between the debris disk and the planetary orbit as

cos⁡ψp,d=cos⁡ipcos⁡id+sin⁡ipsin⁡idcos⁡(Ωp−Ωd)(6)\cos\psi_{p,d} = \cos i_p\cos i_d + \sin i_p\sin i_d\cos(\Omega_p-\Omega_d) \tag*{(6)}

where Ωp\Omega_p and Ωd\Omega_d are the longitudes of ascending node. However, debris disk observations only constrain the projected ellipse on the sky, which introduces degeneracies in recovering the true 3D orientation (see Figure S2). Besides the prograde–retrograde degeneracy, disk imaging usually cannot determine which side of the disk is nearer to the observer, leaving the longitude of ascending node degenerate between Ωd\Omega_d and Ωd+π\Omega_d+\pi. As a result, each system admits four possible values of the planet–disk mutual inclination: ψp,d1(id,Ωd)\psi_{p,d}^{1}(i_d,\Omega_d), ψp,d2(id,Ωd+π)\psi_{p,d}^{2}(i_d,\Omega_d+\pi), ψp,d3(π−id,Ωd+π)\psi_{p,d}^{3}(\pi-i_d,\Omega_d+\pi), and ψp,d4(π−id,Ωd)\psi_{p,d}^{4}(\pi-i_d,\Omega_d). Two (ψp,d1,ψp,d2)(\psi_{p,d}^{1},\psi_{p,d}^{2}) of these correspond to prograde configurations and two (ψp,d3,ψp,d4)(\psi_{p,d}^{3},\psi_{p,d}^{4}) to retrograde configurations. These four solutions are not independent: the retrograde solutions are simply the supplementary angles of the prograde ones, such that ψp,d3=π−ψp,d1\psi^{3}_{p,d} = \pi- \psi^{1}_{p,d} and ψp,d4=π−ψp,d2\psi^{4}_{p,d} = \pi- \psi^{2}_{p,d}, and therefore do not provide additional information. In this work, we are interested in the amplitude of the angle between the planet and disk planes, rather than whether the orbit is prograde or retrograde, which is beyond the scope of this study. We therefore retain only the two prograde solutions and exclude the retrograde solutions from further analysis.

Similarly, for systems with stellar inclination measurements, we quantify the stellar obliquity with the absolute difference between the stellar inclination and orbital inclination of planets as

Δip,∗=∣ip−i∗∣.(7)\Delta i_{p,*} = \left|i_p - i_*\right|. \tag*{(7)}

This quantity represent a minimum values for the true stellar obliquity, because the stellar inclination constrains only the angle between the stellar spin axis and the line of sight. The sky-projected stellar obliquity, λ\lambda, remains unknown. The sky-projected stellar obliquity can be measured via the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect, which is typically available for transiting hot Jupiters and not for the majority of planets in our sample. There is also a degeneracy in the stellar inclination: a given angle between the stellar spin axis and the line of sight corresponds to two possible spin-axis orientations, pointing either toward the observer (<90∘< 90^\circ) or away from the observer (>90∘> 90^\circ). In the same spirit as for the mutual inclination, we therefore focus on the prograde stellar obliquity solution as a measure of the amplitude of the spin-orbit angle, rather than attempting to distinguish between prograde and retrograde configurations.

Kernel Density Estimation of Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d}, Δip,∗\Delta i_{p,*}, and ψp,d\psi_{p,d}

For each system, we construct Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} by randomly drawing 10,000 samples of ipi_p from the posteriors of the orbital fitting and same number of samples of idi_d from a Gaussian distribution based on the literature values. For multi-planet systems, we include only a single system-level entry in the population analysis, adopting the inclinations of the invariable plane for each system. To visualize the Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} distribution of the full population, we combine individual systems into a pooled sample, and construct a boundary-corrected Gaussian kernel density estimate (KDE) of Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d}. Because Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} is restricted to non-negative values, Gaussian kernels centered close to Δip,d=0\Delta i_{p,d} = 0 place part of their weight at negative, nonphysical values and therefore underestimate the density near the boundary. We therefore apply a reflection correction at Δip,d=0\Delta i_{p,d} = 0 to reduce boundary bias, and re-normalize the resulting KDE over the allowed domain. The KDEs of Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} are presented in Figure 1C.

Similarly, for systems with stellar inclination measurements, we obtain Δip,∗\Delta i_{p,*} by randomly drawing 10,000 samples of ipi_p from orbital-fitting posteriors and same number of i∗i_* from the probability density function of the stellar inclination. We then follow the same procedure to construct a boundary-corrected Gaussian KDE of Δip,∗\Delta i_{p,*}. The KDEs of Δip,∗\Delta i_{p,*} are presented in Figure 2.

We apply the same approach to the pooled KDEs of ψp,d1\psi^{1}_{p,d} and ψp,d2\psi^{2}_{p,d} by randomly drawing 10,000 samples from the distributions of ipi_p, Ωp\Omega_p, idi_d and Ωd\Omega_d. We then treat the two degenerate solutions as equally plausible and compute the marginalized population-level distribution as p(ψp,d)=12p(ψp,d1)+12p(ψp,d2)p(\psi_{p,d}) = \frac{1}{2}p(\psi^{1}_{p,d}) + \frac{1}{2}p(\psi^{2}_{p,d}). The KDEs of ψp,d\psi_{p,d} are presented in Figure S1.

Hierarchal Bayesian Modeling of Δip,d\Delta_{i p,d}

We infer the underlying population distribution of Δip,d\Delta_{i p,d} using a hierarchical Bayesian model based on posterior recycling [60]. For simplicity, we denote θ≡Δip,d\theta\equiv\Delta_{i p,d} in the following equations. We consider two choices for the latent distribution, which we denote generically as p(θ∣Λ)p(\theta\mid\Lambda), where Λ\Lambda denotes a set of hyperparameters.

First, we consider a Rayleigh distribution with Λ={ν}\Lambda= \{\nu\}, given by

p(θ∣ν)=θν2exp⁡(−θ22ν2),θ≥0(8)p(\theta\mid\nu) = \frac{\theta}{\nu^2} \exp\left(-\frac{\theta^2}{2\nu^2}\right), \qquad\theta\ge0 \tag*{(8)}

where ν\nu sets the width of the distribution and characterizes the typical mutual inclination in the population.

The second model we use is a truncated Gaussian distribution with Λ={μ,σ}\Lambda= \{\mu, \sigma\}, given by

p(θ∣μ,σ)=exp⁡[−(θ−μ)22σ2]σ2π[Φ(b−μσ)−Φ(a−μσ)],a≤θ≤b.(9)p(\theta\mid\mu,\sigma) = \frac{\exp\left[-\frac{(\theta-\mu)^2}{2\sigma^2}\right]}{\sigma\sqrt{2\pi}\left[\Phi\left(\frac{b-\mu}{\sigma}\right)-\Phi\left(\frac{a-\mu}{\sigma}\right)\right]}, \qquad a \le\theta\le b. \tag*{(9)}

where μ\mu and σ\sigma characterize the location of peak and dispersion of the truncated Gaussian distribution. Φ\Phi is the cumulative density function of the standard Gaussian distribution, and we adopt a=0∘a = 0^\circ and b=180∘b = 180^\circ.

For a given model, the goal of the hierarchical inference is to estimate the posterior distribution of the hyperparameters, p(Λ∣{dk})p(\Lambda\mid\{d_k\}), where dkd_k denotes the observational data for system kk and {dk}\{d_k\} denotes the full data set for all systems in the sample. For system kk, we marginalize over the latent parameter θ\theta to obtain the marginal likelihood under the population model,

p(dk∣Λ)=∫p(dk∣θ) p(θ∣Λ) dθ.(10)p(d_k \mid\Lambda) = \int p(d_k \mid\theta)\,p(\theta\mid\Lambda)\,d\theta. \tag*{(10)}

Based on Bayes’ theorem, this can be rewritten as

p(dk∣Λ)∝∫p(θ∣dk)p(θ∣Λ)π(θ) dθ,(11)p(d_k \mid\Lambda) \propto\int p(\theta\mid d_k)\frac{p(\theta\mid\Lambda)}{\pi(\theta)}\,d\theta, \tag*{(11)}

where p(θ∣dk)p(\theta\mid d_k) is the posterior distribution obtained from the orbital fitting of each system, and π(θ)\pi(\theta) is the corresponding interim prior, which we assume to be uniform in cos⁡θ\cos\theta. We evaluate this integral using posterior recycling by replacing the continuous posterior with a finite set of posterior samples. Specifically, for system kk, we denote by {θk,j}j=1Nk\{\theta_{k,j}\}_{j=1}^{N_k} the NkN_k samples drawn from p(θ∣dk)p(\theta\mid d_k), where jj indexes the samples and kk indexes the systems. The integral can then be approximated as a Monte Carlo average over these samples,

p(dk∣Λ)∝1Nk∑j=1Nkp(θk,j∣Λ)π(θk,j).(12)p(d_k \mid\Lambda) \propto\frac{1}{N_k}\sum_{j=1}^{N_k}\frac{p(\theta_{k,j} \mid\Lambda)}{\pi(\theta_{k,j})}. \tag*{(12)}

The total likelihood for the population model is given by the product of the marginal likelihoods of all systems,

ptot({dk}∣Λ)=∏k=1Nsysp(dk∣Λ),(13)p_{\mathrm{tot}}(\{d_k\} \mid\Lambda) = \prod_{k=1}^{N_{\mathrm{sys}}}p(d_k \mid\Lambda), \tag*{(13)}

where NsysN_{\mathrm{sys}} is the total number of systems. The posterior distribution of the population hyperparameter would be

p(Λ∣{dk})∝ptot({dk}∣Λ) p(Λ),(14)p(\boldsymbol{\Lambda}\mid\{d_k\}) \propto p_{\mathrm{tot}}(\{d_k\}\mid\boldsymbol{\Lambda})\,p(\boldsymbol{\Lambda}), \tag*{(14)}

where p(Λ)p(\boldsymbol{\Lambda}) is the hyperprior on Λ\boldsymbol{\Lambda}. In our analysis, we adopt a log-uniform hyperprior p(Λ)∝1Λp(\boldsymbol{\Lambda}) \propto\frac{1}{\Lambda}. Substituting Eq. (12) for each system gives

p(Λ∣{dk})∝p(Λ)∏k=1Nsys[1Nk∑j=1Nkp(θk,j∣Λ)π(θk,j)].(15)p(\boldsymbol{\Lambda}\mid\{d_k\}) \propto p(\boldsymbol{\Lambda})\prod_{k=1}^{N_{\mathrm{sys}}}\left[\frac{1}{N_k}\sum_{j=1}^{N_k}\frac{p(\theta_{k,j}\mid\boldsymbol{\Lambda})}{\pi(\theta_{k,j})}\right]. \tag*{(15)}

We sample the hyperposterior p(Λ∣{dk})p(\boldsymbol{\Lambda}\mid\{d_k\}) using the Markov chain Monte Carlo sampler emcee with 32 walkers, running each walker for 50000 steps. We discarded the first 10000 steps as burn-in and thinned the chains by a factor of 10 before constructing the final posterior sample. For each trial value of Λ\boldsymbol{\Lambda}, the posterior samples from the individual-system analysis are reweighted by the importance factor p(θk,j∣Λ)π(θk,j)\frac{p(\theta_{k,j}\mid\boldsymbol{\Lambda})}{\pi(\theta_{k,j})}, which measures how strongly a given sample is favored by the population model relative to the interim prior. Figure S3 shows the trace plots and posterior distributions of the hyperparameters for the two models.

MCMC diagnostics for the HBM fits to $i_{p,d}$

Figure S3. MCMC diagnostics for the HBM fits to ip,di_{p,d}. The top row shows the results for the Rayleigh population model, and the middle and bottom rows show the results for the truncated Gaussian population models. The left panels show the walker trace plots. The right panels show the corresponding marginalized posterior distributions, where dashed lines mark the posterior means.

Hierarchal Bayesian Modeling of ψp,d\psi_{p,d}

We use a hierarchical Bayesian framework similar to that described in above section to infer the underlying population distribution of ψp,d\psi_{p,d}. For simplicity, we omit the subscripts below and denote the mutual inclination simply as ψ\psi. We assume two choices for the underlying population distributions p(ψ∣Λ)p(\psi\mid\boldsymbol{\Lambda}): a Rayleigh distribution and a truncated Gaussian distribution, with the same forms as in Eqn. 7 and 8.

In this case, each posterior sample is associated with two degenerate values of the mutual inclination. Rather than selecting a single value for each system, we treat the degeneracy as a nuisance parameter and marginalize over the two possibilities with the equal weight. If ψkjs\psi_{k j}^{s} denotes the s-th degenerate state associated with the j-th posterior sample for system kk, then the marginal likelihood for system kk is

p(dk∣Λ)∝1Nk∑j=1Nk[12∑s=1,2p(ψkjs∣Λ)π(ψkjs)],(16)p(d_k\mid\boldsymbol{\Lambda}) \propto\frac{1}{N_k}\sum_{j=1}^{N_k}\left[\frac{1}{2}\sum_{s=1,2}\frac{p(\psi_{k j}^{s}\mid\boldsymbol{\Lambda})}{\pi(\psi_{k j}^{s})}\right], \tag*{(16)}

where NkN_k is the number of posterior samples for system kk. π(ψkjs)\pi(\psi_{k j}^{s}) is the interim prior and we adot it as uniform in cos⁡ψ\cos\psi. The full likelihood for the population is the product of all systems

ptot({dk}∣Λ)=∏k=1Nsysp(dk∣Λ),(17)p_{\mathrm{tot}}(\{d_k\}\mid\boldsymbol{\Lambda})=\prod_{k=1}^{N_{\mathrm{sys}}}p(d_k\mid\boldsymbol{\Lambda}), \tag*{(17)}

where {dk}\{d_k\} denotes the full set of data for all systems. Combining this likelihood with the hyperprior p(Λ)p(\boldsymbol{\Lambda}), the posterior distribution of Λ\boldsymbol{\Lambda} is

p(Λ∣{dk})∝p(Λ)∏k=1Nsys[1Nk∑j=1Nk(12∑s=1,2p(ψkjs∣Λ)π(ψkjs))].(18)p(\boldsymbol{\Lambda}\mid\{d_k\}) \propto p(\boldsymbol{\Lambda})\prod_{k=1}^{N_{\mathrm{sys}}}\left[\frac{1}{N_k}\sum_{j=1}^{N_k}\left(\frac{1}{2}\sum_{s=1,2}\frac{p(\psi_{k j}^{s}\mid\boldsymbol{\Lambda})}{\pi(\psi_{k j}^{s})}\right)\right]. \tag*{(18)}

We sample the posterior distribution of Λ\mathbf{\Lambda} using the emcee Markov chain Monte Carlo sampler with 32 walkers for 50000 steps. We discarded the first 10000 steps as burn-in and thinned the chains by a factor of 10 before constructing the final posterior sample. Figure S1 shows the resulting HBM results for ψp,d\psi_{p,d}. Figure S4 shows the trace plots and posterior distributions of the hyperparameters for the two models.

MCMC diagnostics for the HBM fits to $\psi_{p,d}$

Figure S4. MCMC diagnostics for the HBM fits to ψp,d\psi_{p,d}. The top row shows the results for the Rayleigh population model, and the middle and bottom rows show the results for the truncated Gaussian population models. The left panels show the walker trace plots. The right panels show the corresponding marginalized posterior distributions, where dashed lines mark the posterior means.

Observation Bias Test

In an ideal scenario without observation bias, we would observe the inclination distribution for planets and disk as isotropic, corresponding to be uniform in cos⁡i\cos i. In practice, however, our sample is not inclination-unbiased. On the planet side, our sample includes two transiting planets, which by construction must have nearly edge-on orbits, and RV detections are also biased toward high inclinations because the RV semi-amplitude scales as msin⁡im \sin i. On the disk side, the ability to detect and characterize disk geometry also depend on inclination. For example, edge-on disks are often easier to spatially resolve in scattered-light imaging, although this dependence is generally weaker in thermal emission. In our sample, four systems (AU mic, HD 114082, β\beta Pic, HR 2562) have planet inclinations within 10∘10^\circ of an edge-on configuration at 90∘90^\circ (80∘<i<100∘80^\circ< i < 100^\circ). For an isotropic distribution, the probability of falling in this interval is

P(80∘<i<100∘)=∫80∘100∘12sin⁡i di=0.174,P(80^\circ< i < 100^\circ) = \int_{80^\circ}^{100^\circ} \frac{1}{2}\sin i\,\mathrm{d}i = 0.174,

which corresponds to an expected number of 15×0.174≈2.615 \times0.174 \approx2.6 systems in a sample of 15 (excluding the Solar System). The observed count of four systems therefore suggests a mild excess of nearly edge-on orbits from the observational selection effects.

We therefore test the null hypothesis that the observed disk-planet alignment solely results from the observed inclination distributions and sample-selection effects using a Monte Carlo permutation test. Specifically, for each Monte Carlo trial, we randomly draw the planet and disk inclinations from their posterior distributions and construct two samples. In the first, the disk and planet inclinations are paired within the same observed system, allowing us to compute the observed Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d}. In the second, the disk and planet inclinations are randomly reassigned between different systems, thereby generating a null sample in which the observation selection effect are preserved but any physical disk-planet connection is removed. We then compare the mean Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} of the two samples. Figure S5 shows the distribution of the mean Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} over 20,000 Monte Carlo trials for both the observed and randomly pairing samples.

Results of observation bias test

Figure S5. Results of observation bias test. The histograms are from 20,000 Monte Carlo trials, with planet and disk inclinations were drawn from their posterior distributions in each trial. The blue distribution represents the observed sample, in which each planet is paired with the disk of the same system. The red distribution represents the randomly paring sample, in which planet and disk inclinations are randomly reassigned among systems.

We first define that the randomly pairing sample is similar to or more align than observed sample if it has a mean Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} smaller than or equal to that of the observed-pair sample. The probability that the randomly pairing has a mean Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} meets this criteria is p=0.003p = 0.003, indicating that only 0.3% of randomized trials are at least as well aligned as the observed sample. As a second statistic, we calculate the fraction of systems with Δip,d<10∘\Delta i_{p,d} < 10^\circ in each sample for each Monte Carlo trial. The probability that randomly pairing sample has a same or higher fraction than that of observed sample is p=0.006p = 0.006. Both probability strongly reject the null hypothesis that the observed alignment between disk and planets are from observation bias and sample selection effect.

Supplementary Text

Results for individual system

HD 38529

HD 38529 (HIP 27253) is a bright G4 sub-giant star (M∗=1.41−0.03+0.03 M⊙M_* = 1.41^{+0.03}_{-0.03}\,M_\odot, R∗=2.84−0.14+0.14 R⊙R_* = 2.84^{+0.14}_{-0.14}\,R_\odot, mv∼5.9m_{\mathrm{v}} \sim5.9) with a age of 3.09−0.17+0.173.09^{+0.17}_{-0.17} Gyr [56, 61]. The star hosts two confirmed planets, both detected with RV observations. HD 38529 b is a close-in, sub-Jupiter mass planet, with an orbital period of ∼14\sim14 days and minimum mass of 0.65−0.06+0.05 MJ0.65^{+0.05}_{-0.06}\,M_{\mathrm{J}} [62]. HD 38529 c is a cold Jupiter, orbiting at ∼3.7\sim3.7 AU and with a minimum mass of 13.2−0.1+0.1MJ13.2^{+0.1}_{-0.1}M_{\mathrm{J}} [63]. In the orbital fitting, we ignore the inner planet b because its 14-day orbital period is much shorter than the observing windows of Hipparcos (Δt∼1278\Delta t \sim1278 days), Gaia DR2 (Δt∼668\Delta t \sim668 days), and Gaia DR3 (Δt∼1038\Delta t \sim1038 days). The astrometric signal of HD 38529 b is effectively averaged out as Gaia DR2/DR3 only report mean astrometric quantities across multiple measurements over the observing window. We used the archival RVs from multiple instruments, with a RV baseline over 26 years (see Table S4). HD 38529 has a wide stellar companion at a separation of 283″, corresponding to ∼12300\sim12300 AU [64]. Because this companion is so widely separated, we do not consider it in the orbital fitting. Figure S6 presents the data and best-fit model for the HD 38529 c. We obtained an orbital inclination of 107.8^{+9.6}_{-5.6}^\circ and a longitude of ascending node of 63.2^{+12.8}_{-10.0}^\circ deg. Our inclination constraint is consistent with that from ref. [65], which obtained an orbital inclination of 104.5^{+6.4}_{-8.7}^\circ. The joint posterior distributions for additional orbital parameters in our fitting are presented in Figure S7.

3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 38529 c

Figure S6. 3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 38529 c. Left: astrometric orbits of HD 38529 c projected on the sky plane from our model (top) and observed and fitted absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia DR2 and DR3 in right ascension and declination (middle and bottom). The blue lines are randomly drawn from the posterior distribution. Right: observed and fitted RVs used in the fitting.

Joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 385529 c

Figure S7. The joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 385529 c. The plotted parameters are orbital inclination iorbi_{\rm orb}, longitude of ascending node Ω\Omega, orbital period PorbP_{\rm orb}, eccentricity, and semi-major axis aa and planet mass MpM_{\rm p}.

The debris disk around HD 38529 was spatially resolved at 70 μ\mum with Herschel/PACS. By modeling the disk geometry, ref. [66] derived a disk inclination of 71^{+10}_{-7}^\circ and a position angle of 48^{+5}_{-5}^\circ. As discussed in Method, the imaging data constrain only the projected disk morphology but not the moving direction of the disk material. The disk inclination is therefore subject to a prograde-retrograde degeneracy, id→180∘−idi_d \to180^\circ- i_d. The alternative disk inclination is therefore i_d = 109.0^{+10.0}_{-7.0}^\circ. Considering the prograde configuration between planet and disk, in which the disk angular-momentum vector lies in the same hemisphere as the planetary orbital angular-momentum vector, we find Δip,d=2.98−2.6+8.6∘\Delta i_{p,d} = 2.98^{+8.6}_{-2.6}{}^\circ.

Several independent measurements of the stellar rotation period of HD 38529 were obtained with different instruments and are in good agreement. From photometric modulation observed with Automated Photoelectric Telescope at Fairborn Observatory, ref. [63] identified a rotation period of Prot=35.7P_{\mathrm{rot}} = 35.7 d. From HST/FGS photometry, ref. [67] measured Prot=37.0±0.4P_{\mathrm{rot}} = 37.0 \pm0.4 d. Ref. [68] used 12 years of precision photometry and found a consistent rotation period of Prot=37.1±0.2P_{\mathrm{rot}} = 37.1 \pm0.2 d. We adopt the average value of the three measurements and derive a stellar inclination of 112.2−14.2+9.7∘112.2^{+9.7}_{-14.2}{}^\circ. The stellar obliquity for HD 38529 c projected in line of sight direction is therefore Δip,∗=3.9−3.9+9.6∘\Delta i_{p,*} = 3.9^{+9.6}_{-3.9}{}^\circ.

HD 38588

HD 38858 (HIP 27435) is a sun-like star (M∗=0.94−0.04+0.04 M⊙M_* = 0.94^{+0.04}_{-0.04}\,M_\odot, mv∼6.0m_{\mathrm{v}} \sim6.0) with a distance of ∼15\sim15 pc and an age of 5.4−1.9+2.75.4^{+2.7}_{-1.9} Gyr [56, 69]. The star hosts a confirmed giant planet at ∼1\sim1 AU with a minimum mass of 0.10−0.01+0.01 MJ0.10^{+0.01}_{-0.01}\,M_{\mathrm{J}} [70]. We used archival RVs from several instruments, with a RV baseline over 25 years (see Table S4). Figure S8 presents the data and best-fit model for the HD 38588 b. We obtained a bimodal distribution in the orbital inclination, symmetric along 90∘90^\circ, for which the sum of values at two peaks equals to 180∘180^\circ. These two peaks result from the prograde-retrograde degeneracy, corresponding to that the planet orbits in the same plane but can move in two opposite directions. The two possible orbital inclinations are 46.5−23.2+20.646.5^{+20.6}_{-23.2} and 129.8−18.9+24.0129.8^{+24.0}_{-18.9}. The joint posterior distributions for additional orbital parameters are presented in Figure S9.

3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 38558 b

Figure S8. 3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 38558 b. Left: astrometric orbits of HD 38558 b projected on the sky plane from our model (top) and observed and fitted absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia DR2 and DR3 in right ascension and declination (middle and bottom). The blue lines are randomly drawn from the posterior distribution. Right: observed and fitted RVs used in the fitting.

Joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 38858 b

Figure S9. The joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 38858 b. The plotted parameters are orbital inclination iorbi_{\mathrm{orb}}, longitude of ascending node Ω\Omega, orbital period PorbP_{\mathrm{orb}}, eccentricity, and semi-major axis aa and planet mass MpM_{\mathrm{p}}.

The debris disk around HD 38858 was spatially resolved at 70μm70\mu\mathrm{m} with Herschel/PACS. By modeling the disk orientation, ref. [71] derived a disk inclination of 44∘44^\circ and a position angle of 67∘67^\circ, each with an uncertainty of 5∘5^\circ. Adopting a prograde configuration between planet and debris disk, we find Δip,d=4.9−4.9+17.8∘\Delta i_{p,d} = 4.9^{+17.8}_{-4.9}{}^\circ.

Ref. [72] and ref. [73] independently inferred the stellar rotation period of HD 38858 from chromospheric activity indicators, obtaining consistent values of 24.0 and 24.7 d, respectively. We adopt the average stellar rotation period from their measurements and derive a stellar inclination of 33.0−12.1+10.9∘33.0^{+10.9}_{-12.1}{}^\circ. The stellar obliquity for HD 38858 b projected in line of sight direction would be Δip,∗=8.5−8.4+18.3∘\Delta i_{p,*} = 8.5^{+18.3}_{-8.4}{}^\circ.

HD 82943

HD 82943 (HIP 47007) is a G2V star (M∗=1.04−0.02+0.02M⊙M_* = 1.04^{+0.02}_{-0.02} M_\odot, mV∼7.4m_{\mathrm{V}} \sim7.4) at a distance of ∼36\sim36 pc and with an age of 2.4−0.3+0.32.4^{+0.3}_{-0.3} Gyr [56, 74]. The star hosts two giant planets at 1 : 2 orbital resonance, with semi-major axis of ∼0.74\sim0.74 AU and ∼1.2\sim1.2 AU [75]. We used archival RVs spanning from Mar. 2001 to May 2023 (see Table S4). We consider a two-planet model in the orbital fitting. Figure S10 presents the data and best-fit model for the HD 82943 b&c. We obtained the orbital inclination and longitude of ascending node of the HD 82943 b as 19.1−4.9+6.519.1^{+6.5}_{-4.9} and 39.9−25.3+19.939.9^{+19.9}_{-25.3}. The orbital inclination and longitude of ascending node of HD 82943 c are 23.3−5.6+7.223.3^{+7.2}_{-5.6} and 27.9−21.7+27.127.9^{+27.1}_{-21.7}. Our result is consistent with that of ref. [76], which inferred an orbital inclination of ∼20∘\sim20^\circ for the HD 82943 b&c by modeling the RV curvature with a dynamical fit that accounts for planet-planet interactions in the mean-motion resonant configuration. Using the measured inclinations and longitudes of ascending node, we find a mutual inclination between HD 82943 b&c of 6.0−6.0+9.8∘6.0^{+9.8}_{-6.0}{}^\circ, indicating that the two giant planets are nearly coplanar. The joint posterior distributions for additional orbital parameters are presented in Figure S11.

3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 82943 b&c

Figure S10. 3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 82943 b&c. Left: astrometric orbits of HD 82943 b&c projected on the sky plane from our model (top) and observed and fitted absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia DR2 and DR3 in right ascension and declination (middle and bottom). The blue and yellow lines are randomly drawn from the posterior distribution. Right: observed and fitted RVs used in the fitting.

Joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 82943 b&c

Figure S11. The joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 82943 b&c. The plotted parameters are orbital inclination iorbi_{\mathrm{orb}}, longitude of ascending node Ω\Omega, orbital period PorbP_{\mathrm{orb}}, eccentricity, and semi-major axis aa and planet mass MpM_p.

The debris disk around HD 82943 was resolved at 70μm70\mu\mathrm{m} with Herschel/PACS. Ref. [77] modeled the disk geometry and obtained a disk inclination of 27±4∘27 \pm4^\circ and a position angle of 152±8∘152 \pm8^\circ. The minimum planet-disk mutual inclinations for HD 82943 b and c are 6.8−5.4+4.5∘6.8^{+4.5}_{-5.4}{}^\circ and 1.8−1.8+5.6∘1.8^{+5.6}_{-1.8}{}^\circ, respectively.

Using the chromospheric activity index, ref. [75] and ref. [72] reported stellar rotation periods of HD 82943 as 18 and 17 d, respectively. We also independently identify a stellar rotation period of 18±1218 \pm12 d from the TESS light curves. From these constraints, we derive a stellar inclination of 19.9−2.0+3.7∘19.9^{+3.7}_{-2.0}{}^\circ. The stellar obliquity for HD 82943 b and c projected in line of sight direction would be 1.9−1.8+4.9∘1.9^{+4.9}_{-1.8}{}^\circ and 2.3−2.3+6.4∘2.3^{+6.4}_{-2.3}{}^\circ.

HD 113337

HD 113337 (HIP 63584) is a bright F6V star (M∗=1.40−0.14+0.14M⊙M_* = 1.40^{+0.14}_{-0.14}M_\odot, mV∼6.0m_{\mathrm{V}} \sim6.0, d∼37d \sim37 pc), with an age of 150−50+100150^{+100}_{-50} Myr [56, 78]. There are two giant planets orbiting around the star, at semi-major axis of ∼1\sim1 AU and ∼5.3\sim5.3 AU, respectively [66, 79]. We consider a two-planet model for the orbital fitting. In addition, HD 113337 has a wide M star companion around 120 arcsec, corresponding to ∼4400\sim4400 AU [64]. Because this companion is so widely separated, we ignore the wide stellar companion in the orbital fitting. We used SOPHIE RVs spanning January 2007 to July 2022, corresponding to a baseline of more than 15 years (see Table S4). Figure S12 presents the data and best-fit model for the HD 113337 bb&cc. We find that the orbital inclination of the inner planet is poorly constrained because its short orbital period (∼317\sim317 d) is shorter than the Hipparcos and Gaia observing windows, causing its astrometric signal to be diluted by time averaging. But we obtain a well-constrained three-dimensional orbit for planet c, for which the orbital inclination is 24.4−0.7+2.024.4^{+2.0}_{-0.7}°. Our orbital inclination is consistent with that (ic=31.0−4.0+5.0i_c = 31.0^{+5.0}_{-4.0}°) from ref. [66] within 1σ1\sigma. The joint posterior distributions for additional orbital parameters are presented in Figure S13.

3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 113337 b&c

Figure S12. 3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 113337 b&c. Left: astrometric orbits of HD 113337 b&c projected on the sky plane from our model (top) and observed and fitted absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia DR2 and DR3 in right ascension and declination (middle and bottom). The blue lines are randomly drawn from the posterior distribution. Right: observed and fitted RVs used in the fitting.

Joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 113337 c

Figure S13. The joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 113337 c. The plotted parameters are orbital inclination iorbi_{\mathrm{orb}}, longitude of ascending node Ω\Omega, orbital period PorbP_{\mathrm{orb}}, eccentricity, and semi-major axis aa and planet mass MpM_p.

The debris disk around HD 113337 was resolved at 70μ70\mum with Herschel/PACS. Ref. [66] modeled the disk geometry and derived a disk inclination of 13−9+1013^{+10}_{-9}° and a position angle of 160−38+63160^{+63}_{-38}°. Ref. [80] analyzed the same dataset and also reported a consistent disk inclination of 19.0−6.2+5.319.0^{+5.3}_{-6.2}° and position angle of 119.8−12.6+11.5119.8^{+11.5}_{-12.6}°. Therefore, we find Δip,d=9.8−9.8+6.4\Delta i_{p,d} = 9.8^{+6.4}_{-9.8}°.

Ref. [79] identified a stellar rotation period of 3±13 \pm1 d for HD 113337 from the residual radial velocities and the bisector velocity span. Using the TESS light curves, we independently identify a period of 5±15 \pm1 d (see Figure S32), which is consistent with their measurement at the 1σ1\sigma level. Adopting a stellar rotation period of 5±15 \pm1 d, we derive a stellar inclination of 25.5−3.6+4.825.5^{+4.8}_{-3.6}° and the line-of-sight stellar obliquity for HD 113337 c as Δip,∗=1.1−1.1+3.5\Delta i_{p,*} = 1.1^{+3.5}_{-1.1}°.

Measurements of stellar rotational period of HD 113337

Figure S32. Measurements of stellar rotational period of HD 113337. The first five panels show the TESS light curves, and the final panel shows the corresponding periodogram. The red dashed line marks the identified rotation period.

HD 10647

HD 10647 (q1q^1 Eri, HIP 7978) is a nearby F9V star (M∗=1.11−0.02+0.02M_* = 1.11^{+0.02}_{-0.02} M⊙_\odot, mV∼5.5m_V \sim5.5) with a distance of ∼17.3\sim17.3 pc and an age of 1.4−0.9+0.91.4^{+0.9}_{-0.9} Gyr [41, 56]. It hosts a cold Jupiter at ∼2\sim2 AU with a minimum mass of ∼0.94\sim0.94 MJ_J [43]. We used archival RVs from several instruments, with a RV baseline over 21 years (see Table S4). Figure S14 presents the data and best-fit model for the HD 10647 b. We obtained an orbital inclination of 34.0−8.3+10.634.0^{+10.6}_{-8.3}° and longitude of ascending node of 281.2−20.6+19.2281.2^{+19.2}_{-20.6}°. The joint posterior distributions for additional orbital parameters are presented in Figure S15.

3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 10647 b

Figure S14. 3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 10647 b. Left: astrometric orbits of HD 10647 b projected on the sky plane from our model (top) and observed and fitted absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia DR2 and DR3 in right ascension and declination (middle and bottom). The blue lines are randomly drawn from the posterior distribution. Right: observed and fitted RVs used in the fitting.

Joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 10647 b

Figure S15. The joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 10647 b. The plotted parameters are orbital inclination iorbi_{\mathrm{orb}}, longitude of ascending node Ω\Omega, orbital period PorbP_{\mathrm{orb}}, eccentricity, and semi-major axis aa and planet mass MpM_{\mathrm{p}}.

HD 10647 hosts a spatially resolved debris disk that has been imaged in scattered light with HST/ACS [46], in thermal emission at 70, 100, and 160 μ\mum with Herschel/PACS [81], and at submillimeter wavelengths with ALMA [45, 48]. The most recent ALMA analysis from ref. [45] derived a disk inclination of 77.8−0.1+0.177.8^{+0.1}_{-0.1}° and a position angle of 57.3−0.1+0.157.3^{+0.1}_{-0.1}°. Therefore, we obtained a minimum mutual inclination between planet and debris disk Δip,d\Delta i_{p,d} as 43.6−10.4+8.243.6^{+8.2}_{-10.4}°.

Ref. [41] reported a stellar rotation period of 10 d for HD 10647, derived from the chromospheric activity index. Ref. [82] found a consistent stellar rotation period of 9.2 d. Using TESS light curves, we independently identify a stellar rotation period of 9.4±19.4 \pm1 d, in agreement with these previous measurements (see Figure S30). Multiple spectroscopic measurements of the projected rotational velocity are also available in the literature (see Table S2). Adopting their weighted mean, we obtain vsin⁡i=5.4±0.2v \sin i = 5.4 \pm0.2 km, s−1^{-1}. From these constraints, we derive a stellar inclination of 68.1−8.8+13.568.1^{+13.5}_{-8.8}°. Ref. [82] obtained a stellar inclination of 40.6−5.6+6.440.6^{+6.4}_{-5.6}°, but their estimate was based on a lower value of vsin⁡i∗=3.8±0.4v \sin i_* = 3.8 \pm0.4 km s−1^{-1}, which deviates from most other measurements by about 2σ2\sigma. Our stellar inclination is consistent with the disk inclination, indicating the debris disk is aligned with the stellar spin axis. The minimum stellar obliquity for HD 10647 b is 37.0−17.4+11.637.0^{+11.6}_{-17.4}°.

κ\kappa CrB

κ\kappa CrB (HD 142091, HIP 77655) is a K0 sub-giant star (M∗=1.45−0.03+0.03 M⊙M_\ast= 1.45^{+0.03}_{-0.03}\,M_\odot, R∗=4.68−0.71+0.84 R⊙R_\ast= 4.68^{+0.84}_{-0.71}\,R_\odot, mv∼4.8m_{\mathrm{v}} \sim4.8) with a age of 3.28−0.55+0.553.28^{+0.55}_{-0.55} Gyr [42, 56]. It hosts a giant planet at ∼2.6\sim2.6 AU with a minimum mass of ∼1.8 MJ\sim1.8\,M_{\mathrm{J}} [44]. We used archival RVs with a baseline over 18 years (see Table S4). Figure S16 presents the data and best-fit model for the κ\kappa CrB b. We obtain a nearly phase-on orbit for the planet. The orbital inclination posterior shows bimodal distribution, which are symmetric around 90∘90^\circ, and sum of values at two peaks equals to 180∘180^\circ. These two peaks result from the prograde-retrograde degeneracy, indicating that the planet orbits in the same plane but can move in two opposite directions. The two possible orbital inclinations are 16.2^{+1.7}_{-2.9}^\circ and 163.7^{+1.7}_{-2.4}^\circ. The joint posterior distributions for additional orbital parameters are presented in Figure S17.

3-D Keplerian orbital model of $\kappa$ CrB (HD 142091) b

Figure S16. 3-D Keplerian orbital model of κ\kappa CrB (HD 142091) b. Left: astrometric orbits of κ\kappa CrB (HD 142091) b projected on the sky plane from our model (top) and observed and fitted absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia DR2 and DR3 in right ascension and declination (middle and bottom). The blue lines are randomly drawn from the posterior distribution. Right: observed and fitted RVs used in the fitting.

Joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of $\kappa$ CrB b

Figure S17. The joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of κ\kappa CrB b. The plotted parameters are orbital inclination iorbi_{\mathrm{orb}}, longitude of ascending node Ω\Omega, orbital period PorbP_{\mathrm{orb}}, eccentricity, and semi-major axis aa and planet mass MpM_p.

κ\kappa CrB hosts a debris disk that has been spatially resolved at 100 and 160, μ\mum with Herschel/PACS [83] and at submillimeter wavelengths with ALMA [46]. Ref. [83] reported a disk inclination of 59±10∘59 \pm10^\circ and a position angle of 142±10∘142 \pm10^\circ using Herschel observations. Based on ALMA dataset, ref. [46] found consistent values of disk inclination 62.3±3.4∘62.3 \pm3.4^\circ and position angle 148±5∘148 \pm5^\circ. Adopting the disk parameters with higher precision from ALMA observations [46], we find a minimum disk-planet mutual inclination of 45.6^{+3.5}_{-5.5}^\circ. For κ\kappa CrB, we could not identify a reliable stellar rotation period measurement in the literature, nor did we detect one from the TESS light curve; therefore, the stellar inclination is unavailable.

HD 216435

HD 216435 (τ1\tau^1 Gruis, HIP 113044) is a sunlike star (G0V, M∗=1.30−0.10+0.10 M⊙M_\ast= 1.30^{+0.10}_{-0.10}\,M_\odot, mv∼6.0m_{\mathrm{v}} \sim6.0) at the distance of ∼33\sim33 pc and an age of 3.5−0.5+1.53.5^{+1.5}_{-0.5} Gyr [56, 84]. The star hosts a giant planet at ∼2.56\sim2.56 AU with a minimum mass of ∼1.26 MJ\sim1.26\,M_{\mathrm{J}} [43, 85]. We used archival RVs with a baseline over 23 years in the orbital fitting (see Table S4). Figure S18 presents the data and best-fit model for the HD 216435 b. We obtained a bimodal distribution for the orbital inclination, which corresponds to 72.0^{+7.6}_{-13.5}^\circ and 107.3^{+12.0}_{-9.2}^\circ. These two peaks are symmetric around 90∘90^\circ, which results from the prograde-retrograde degeneracy. The joint posterior distributions for additional orbital parameters are presented in Figure S19.

3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 216435 b

Figure S18. 3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 216435 b. Left: astrometric orbits of HD 216435 b projected on the sky plane from our model (top) and observed and fitted absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia DR2 and DR3 in right ascension and declination (middle and bottom). The blue lines are randomly drawn from the posterior distribution. Right: observed and fitted RVs used in the fitting.

Joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 216435 b

Figure S19. The joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 216435 b. The plotted parameters are orbital inclination iorbi_{\mathrm{orb}}, longitude of ascending node Ω\Omega, orbital period PorbP_{\mathrm{orb}}, eccentricity, and semi-major axis aa and planet mass MpM_p.

The debris disk around HD 216435 was spatially resolved by at 70μ\mum with Herschel/PACS [80], yielding a disk inclination of 68.5^{+3.6}_{-5.5}^\circ and position angle of 66.1^{+6.1}_{-5.1}^\circ. Therefore, we obtained a minimum planet-disk mutual inclination of \Delta i_{p,d} = 3.1^{+8.4}_{-3.1}^\circ. Because we could not identify a reliable stellar rotation period measurement in the literature, nor did we detect one from the TESS light curve for HD 216435, the stellar inclination is not available.

β\beta Pic

β\beta Pic (HD 39060, HIP 27321) is a bright A5V star (M∗=1.76−0.17+0.18 M⊙M_\ast= 1.76^{+0.18}_{-0.17}\,M_\odot, mv∼3.9m_{\mathrm{v}} \sim3.9) with a distance of ∼50\sim50 pc [56, 86]. It is an young star with an age of ∼15.5−4.5+4.5\sim15.5^{+4.5}_{-4.5} Myr. The star hosts two giant planets from direct imaging observations, at a semi-major axis of ∼9\sim9 AU and ∼2.7\sim2.7 AU [87, 88]. In the orbital fitting, we used the archival RVs for the host star from HARPS spanning from Dec. 2010 and Jan. 2021 and the relative astrometry for the two planets from the direct imaging observations (see Table S4 & Table S5). Figure S20 presents the data and best-fit model for the β\beta Pic b&c. We obtained very similar orbital inclination and longitude of ascending nodes for the two planets, indicating they are nearly coplanar. The orbital inclination for β\beta Pic b and c are 89.1−0.1+0.1 ∘89.1^{+0.1}_{-0.1}\,^\circ and 89.2−0.4+0.2 ∘89.2^{+0.2}_{-0.4}\,^\circ, respectively. The longitude of ascending nodes for β\beta Pic b and c are 32.1−0.1+0.1 ∘32.1^{+0.1}_{-0.1}\,^\circ and 31.3−0.1+0.1 ∘31.3^{+0.1}_{-0.1}\,^\circ. Our results are consistent with previous results from ref. [89, 90]. The joint posterior distributions for additional orbital parameters are presented in Figure S21.

3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 216435 b

Figure S20. 3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 216435 b. Left: astrometric orbits of β\beta Pic b&c projected on the sky plane from our model with observed relative astrometries of the two planets (top) and observed and fitted absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia DR2 and DR3 in right ascension and declination (middle and bottom). The blue and yellow lines are randomly drawn from the posterior distribution. Right: observed and fitted RVs used in the fitting.

Joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of β Pic b&c

Figure S21. The joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of β\beta Pic b&c. The plotted parameters are orbital inclination iorbi_{\mathrm{orb}}, longitude of ascending node Ω\Omega, orbital period PorbP_{\mathrm{orb}}, eccentricity, and semi-major axis aa and planet mass MpM_p.

β\beta Pic hosts a nearly edge-on debris disk that was first resolved in the infrared by the Infrared Astronomy Satellite [91]. From scattered-light images obtained with HST/ACS, ref. [92] identified a ∼4∘\sim4^\circ warp in the disk, which was later attributed to dynamical perturbations from the planets. Using the polarimetric mode of the Gemini Planet Imager, ref. [89] resolved the disk from 0.3′′0.3^{\prime\prime} (∼6\sim6 au) to 1.7′′1.7^{\prime\prime} (∼33\sim33 au), and measured a disk inclination of 85.3−0.2+0.2 ∘85.3^{+0.2}_{-0.2}\,^\circ and a position angle of 30.4−0.1+0.1 ∘30.4^{+0.1}_{-0.1}\,^\circ. Our results show that the disk-planet mutual inclination for β\beta Pic b&c to be 3.9−1.2+0.9 ∘3.9^{+0.9}_{-1.2}\,^\circ and 3.6−0.9+1.2 ∘3.6^{+1.2}_{-0.9}\,^\circ, respectively. They are consistent with the observed warp amplitude and support the interpretation that the planet perturbs the disk and drives the warp. Ref. [59] measured the stellar inclination of β\beta Pic to be 87.8−1.6+1.6 ∘87.8^{+1.6}_{-1.6}\,^\circ from the rotational splittings of non-radial stellar oscillation modes, indicating that both planets are consistent with alignment with the stellar spin axis.

ϵ\epsilon Eri

ϵ\epsilon Eri (HD 22049, HIP 16537) is a nearby K2V star (M∗=0.82−0.02+0.02 M⊙M_* = 0.82^{+0.02}_{-0.02}\,M_\odot, mv∼3.7m_v \sim3.7) with a distance of ∼3.9\sim3.9 pc. The star has a age of 600−200+200600^{+200}_{-200} Myr [56, 93]. It hosts a giant planet at ∼3.5\sim3.5 AU with a minimus mass of 0.66 MJ0.66\,M_{\rm J} [94]. We used archival RVs with a baseline over 32 years (see Table S4). Figure S22 presents the data and best-fit model for the ϵ\epsilon Eri b. We obtained an orbital inclination of 38.9−4.5+6.5 ∘38.9^{+6.5}_{-4.5}\,^\circ and longitude of ascending node of 185.5−7.3+9.9 ∘185.5^{+9.9}_{-7.3}\,^\circ. Our results agree with those from ref. [53]. The joint posterior distributions for additional orbital parameters are presented in Figure S23.

3-D Keplerian orbital model of $\epsilon$ Eri b

Figure S22. 3-D Keplerian orbital model of ϵ\epsilon Eri b. Left: astrometric orbits of ϵ\epsilon Eri b projected on the sky plane from our model (top) and observed and fitted absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia DR2 and DR3 in right ascension and declination (middle and bottom). The blue lines are randomly drawn from the posterior distribution. Right: observed and fitted RVs used in the fitting.

Joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of $\epsilon$ Eri b

Figure S23. The joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of ϵ\epsilon Eri b. The plotted parameters are orbital inclination iorbi_{\mathrm{orb}}, longitude of ascending node Ω\Omega, orbital period PorbP_{\mathrm{orb}}, eccentricity, and semi-major axis aa and planet mass MpM_p.

The debris disk around ϵ\epsilon Eri was first resolved at submillimeter wavelengths with the James Clerk Maxwell Telescope [95], and was later resolved in the far-infrared with Herschel/PACS [96] and at submillimeter wavelengths with ALMA [97]. We adopt the disk inclination and position angle from high-resolution ALMA observations of ref. [97], namely 33.7−0.5+0.5 ∘33.7^{+0.5}_{-0.5}\,^\circ and 178.9−1.0+1.0 ∘178.9^{+1.0}_{-1.0}\,^\circ. The minimum disk-planet mutual inclination is 3.7−3.7+6.6 ∘3.7^{+6.6}_{-3.7}\,^\circ.

Multiple previous studies have found a stellar rotation period of approximately 12 d for ϵ\epsilon Eri [73, 98, 99, 100]. From the TESS light curves, we independently identify a consistent stellar rotation period of 11.5±111.5 \pm1 d (see Figure S33). We derive a stellar inclination of 41.4−5.7+6.2 ∘41.4^{+6.2}_{-5.7}\,^\circ, consistent with the result of ref. [82] within 1σ1\sigma. Based on this value, we derive Δip,∗=2.5−2.5+6.5 ∘\Delta i_{\rm p,*} = 2.5^{+6.5}_{-2.5}\,^\circ.

Measurements of stellar rotational period of $\epsilon$ Eri

Figure S33. Measurements of stellar rotational period of ϵ\epsilon Eri. The first two panels show the TESS light curves, and the final panel shows the corresponding periodogram. The red dashed line marks the identified rotation period.

HD 206893

HD 206893 (HIP 107412) is a F5V star (M∗=1.32−0.05+0.07 M⊙M_* = 1.32^{+0.07}_{-0.05}\,M_\odot, mv∼6.7m_v \sim6.7, d∼40.8d \sim40.8 pc) with an age of 155−15+15155^{+15}_{-15} Myr [56, 101]. The star hosts a giant planet (HD 206893 c) at ∼3.5\sim3.5 AU [101] and a brown dwarf companion (HD 206893 B) at ∼9.6\sim9.6 AU [102, 103, 104]. The giant planet HD 206893 c was discovered using RV observations, while the brown dwarf companion (HD 206893 B) was detected from direct imaging observations. We used both archival RVs of the host stars and relative astrometry of the brown dwarf companion in the orbital fitting (see Table S4 & Table S5). We consider a two-companion model in the fitting. Figure S24 presents the data and best-fit model for the system. We obtained the orbital inclination and longitude of ascending node of the giant planet HD 206893 c as 149.9−2.7+2.2^{+2.2}_{-2.7}° and 79.0−2.4+6.3^{+6.3}_{-2.4}°. The orbital inclination and longitude of ascending node of the brown dwarf HD 206893 B are 146.0−1.7+2.2^{+2.2}_{-1.7}° and 73.1−4.6+1.7^{+1.7}_{-4.6}°. Our results shows the inner planets are nearly coplanar with the outer brown dwarf companion, with a mutual inclination of iB,c=5.0−2.9+3.4i_{B,c}=5.0^{+3.4}_{-2.9}° between the two companions. The minimum mutual inclination between debris disk and HD 206893 c&B are 5.8−3.7+3.4^{+3.4}_{-3.7}° and 9.8−4.2+3.6^{+3.6}_{-4.2}°, respectively.

3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 206893 b&c

Figure S24. 3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 206893 b&c. Left: astrometric orbits of HD 206893 b&c projected on the sky plane from our model with observed relative astrometries of the two planets (top) and observed and fitted absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia DR2 and DR3 in right ascension and declination (middle and bottom). The blue and yellow lines are randomly drawn from the posterior distribution. Right: observed and fitted RVs used in the fitting.

HD 206893 hosts a debris disk that was spatially resolved at far-infrared wavelengths with Herschel/PACS [102] and at submillimeter wavelengths with ALMA [105]. We adopt the disk inclination of 40 ± 3° and position angle of 61 ± 4° from the ALMA observations from ref. [105]. Owing to the disk-orientation degeneracy, which arises because the direction of motion of the disk material is not measured, the degenerate disk inclination solution is 140 ± 3°. Considering the prograde configuration between planet and disk, we find the minimum mutual inclination between disk and 206893 c&B are 5.8−3.7+3.4^{+3.4}_{-3.7}° and 9.8−4.2+3.6^{+3.6}_{-4.2}°, respectively. We adopt the stellar rotation period of 0.996 ± 0.003 d from [103] and derive a stellar inclination of 151.6−3.2+1.7^{+1.7}_{-3.2}°. The stellar obliquities of HD 206893 c and the brown dwarf HD 206893 B are 5.2−3.3+2.8^{+2.8}_{-3.3}° and 0.9−0.9+2.9^{+2.9}_{-0.9}°.

HD 95086

HD 95086 (HIP 53524) is a young A2V star (M∗=1.77−0.21+0.36M_* = 1.77^{+0.36}_{-0.21} M⊙_\odot, mv∼7.4m_v \sim7.4) with an age of 17−4+4^{+4}_{-4} Myr [56, 106]. The star hosts a young giant planet at ∼55\sim55 AU from direct imaging observations [106, 107]. In our fitting, we used the archival relative astrometry spanning from Jan. 2012 to Mar. 2023, with a baseline over 11 years (see Table S5). Figure S26 presents the data and best-fit model for HD 95086 b. We obtained the orbital inclination of HD 95086 b as 147.2−10.9+11.8^{+11.8}_{-10.9}°. We have also obtained two peaks in longitude of ascending node to be 76.8−41.5+55.1^{+55.1}_{-41.5}° and 290.2−55.0+29.7^{+29.7}_{-55.0}°.

3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 95086 b

Figure S26. 3-D Keplerian orbital model of HD 95086 b. Left: astrometric orbits of HD 95086 b projected on the sky plane from our model (top) and observed and fitted absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia DR2 and DR3 in right ascension and declination (middle and bottom). The blue lines are randomly drawn from the posterior distribution. Right: observed and fitted RVs used in the fitting.

The debris disk around HD 95086 was resolved at far-infrared wavelengths with Herschel/PACS [108] and at submillimeter wavelengths with ALMA [109]. We adopted the disk inclination of 36−2+3^{+3}_{-2}° and longitude of ascending node of 98−3+3^{+3}_{-3}° deg from ALMA observations [109]. Due to the disk-orientation degeneracy from two possible moving direction of the disk material, an degenerate disk inclination is 144−2+3^{+3}_{-2}°. For the pro-grade configuration, we find Δip,d=2.7−2.5+9.7\Delta i_{p,d}=2.7^{+9.7}_{-2.5}°. Because we could not identify a reliable stellar rotation period measurement in the literature, nor did we detect one from the TESS light curve for HD 95086, the stellar inclination is not available.

HR 2562

HR 2562 (HD 50571, HIP 32775) is a F5V star (M∗=1.30−0.05+0.05M_* = 1.30^{+0.05}_{-0.05} M⊙_\odot, mv∼6.1m_v \sim6.1) with an age of 600−300+300^{+300}_{-300} Myr [56, 110]. It hosts a low-mass brown dwarf companion HR 2562 B at a separation of ∼20\sim20 AU from direct imaging observations [110]. We used the archival relative astrometry spanning from Jan. 2016 to Mar. 2024 in the orbital fitting (see Table S5). Our results show that HR 2562 B orbits the host star in an edge-on orbit with an orbital inclination of 86.4−0.2+0.1^{+0.1}_{-0.2}° and longitude of ascending node of 120.0−0.1+0.1^{+0.1}_{-0.1}°.

HR 2562 hosts a nearly edge-on debris disk that has been spatially resolved at 70, 100, and 160 μ\mum with Herschel/PACS [108], and at submillimeter wavelengths with ALMA [111]. We adopt the disk geometry from the ALMA observations, which yield an inclination of 84.7−5.3+5.3^{+5.3}_{-5.3}° and a position angle of 32.7−0.8+0.7^{+0.7}_{-0.8}°. The minimum mutual inclination between HR 2652 B and disk is 1.1−1.1+4.2^{+4.2}_{-1.1}°.

From the TESS light curves, we identify a stellar rotation period of 2 ±\pm 0.5 d (see Figure S34), obtaining a stellar inclination of 86.8−9.7+3.086.8^{+3.0}_{-9.7}°. Therefore, the light-of-sight stellar obliquity of HR 2562 B is 1.9−1.9+7.11.9^{+7.1}_{-1.9}°.

AU Mic

AU Mic (HD 197481, HIP 102409) is a nearby young M1V star (M∗=0.64−0.07+0.04 M⊙M_\ast= 0.64^{+0.04}_{-0.07}\,M_\odot, mv∼8.8m_v \sim8.8) with an age of 19−6+1019^{+10}_{-6} Myr [56, 112]. It hosts three small transiting planets at orbital periods of 8.64 d, 12.74 d and 18.86 d, respectively [32, 113, 114]. We adopted their orbital inclinations constrained from transiting observations as ib=89.6−0.4+0.4i_b = 89.6^{+0.4}_{-0.4}, ic=89.3−1.1+1.1i_c = 89.3^{+1.1}_{-1.1}, id=89.2−0.2+0.2i_d = 89.2^{+0.2}_{-0.2} from ref. [114]. Their longitude of ascending node is not available from transiting observations.

AU Mic hosts a nearly edge-on debris disk that has been spatially resolved in scattered light with coronagraphic imaging at the UH 2.2 m telescope [115], with HST/ACS [116], and with SPHERE [52], as well as in thermal emission with ALMA [117]. We adopt the disk inclination and position angle from the ALMA observations [117], which give 89.5−0.5+0.589.5^{+0.5}_{-0.5}° and 128.4−0.1+0.1128.4^{+0.1}_{-0.1}°, respectively. The minimum mutual inclination between disk and AU Mic b, c, d are 0.2−0.2+0.50.2^{+0.5}_{-0.2}°, 0.3−0.3+1.00.3^{+1.0}_{-0.3}° and 0.1−0.1+0.50.1^{+0.5}_{-0.1}°.

Multiple previous studies have reported a stellar rotation period of approximately 4.8 d for AU Mic, consistent with our measurement of 4.86 ±\pm 0.5 d using TESS light curves (see Figure S31). From this, we derive a stellar inclination of 88.1−7.7+1.688.1^{+1.6}_{-7.7}°. the light-of-sight stellar obliquity of the three planets are 1.4−1.4+7.61.4^{+7.6}_{-1.4}°, 1.5−1.4+7.31.5^{+7.3}_{-1.4}° and 1.1−1.1+7.61.1^{+7.6}_{-1.1}°, respectively.

Measurements of stellar rotational period of AU Mic

Figure S31. Measurements of stellar rotational period of AU Mic. The three four panels show the TESS light curves, and the final panel shows the corresponding periodogram. The red dashed line marks the identified rotation period.

HD 114082

HD 114082 (HIP 64184) is young F3V star (M∗=1.47−0.07+0.07 M⊙M_\ast= 1.47^{+0.07}_{-0.07}\,M_\odot) with an age of 15−6+615^{+6}_{-6} Myr [56, 118]. It hosts two transiting giant planets at ∼0.5\sim0.5 AU and ∼1\sim1 AU [52, 118]. We adopted their orbital inclinations constrained from transiting observations as ib=89.8−0.3+0.3i_b = 89.8^{+0.3}_{-0.3}, ic=89.7−0.2+0.2i_c = 89.7^{+0.2}_{-0.2} [52]. Their longitude of ascending node is not available from transiting observations.

The debris disk around HD 114082 has been spatially resolved in scattered light with SPHERE [52, 119], revealing a nearly edge-on disk with an inclination of 83.2−1.1+1.183.2^{+1.1}_{-1.1}° and a position angle of 105.7−1.4+1.4105.7^{+1.4}_{-1.4}°. Relative to the planetary orbits, this implies a line-of-sight mutual inclination between planets and the debris disk of Δip,d=6.6−1.2+1.0\Delta i_{p,d} = 6.6^{+1.0}_{-1.2}°. Because we could not identify a reliable stellar rotation period measurement in the literature, nor did we detect one from the TESS light curve for HD 114082, the stellar inclination is not available.

HR 8799

HR 8799 (HD 218396, HIP 114189) is a young A5V star with a mass of M∗=1.50−0.05+0.05 M⊙M_\ast= 1.50^{+0.05}_{-0.05}\,M_\odot and an age of 60−30+10060^{+100}_{-30} Myr [120]. It hosts four giant planets at projected separations of approximately 68, 38, 24, and 16 AU, discovered through direct imaging observations [120].

Multiple studies have examined the dynamical interactions among the four planets, and most conclude that their orbits are nearly coplanar and likely locked in a 1:2:4:8 resonant chain [110, 121, 122, 123, 124, 125]. At the same time, previous attempts to constrain the planetary orbits using relative astrometry have shown that the current observational time baseline is still too short to uniquely determine long-term stable orbital solutions for HR 8799 without using additional dynamical constraints [122, 124, 125]. A full orbital analysis of all four planets subject to dynamical stability constraints would require extensive computational resources and is beyond the scope of this work. We therefore adopt the orbital solution from ref. [125], which is based on 23 years of relative astrometry for the four planets.

HR 8799 hosts a nearly face-on debris disk that has been resolved at far-infrared wavelengths with Herschel/PACS [126] and at submillimeter wavelengths with ALMA [127, 128]. We adopt the disk geometry from the ALMA observations of ref. [128], which give an inclination of 30.8^{+2.8}_{-3.2}^\circ and a position angle of 52.4^{+5.4}_{-5.7}^\circ. We therefore obtained a minimum mutual inclination between planet and disk as 0.9^{+2.7}_{-0.9}^\circ. Adopting the stellar rotation period of 0.7 d from ref. [129], we derive a stellar inclination of 26.8^{+2.0}_{-1.9}^\circ, and the line-of-sight stellar obliquity to be 3.4^{+2.4}_{-3.4}^\circ.

Solar System

For the Solar System planets, we adopted the orbital inclinations and longitudes of ascending node from the JPL Planetary and Lunar Ephemerides DE440/DE441 [130], which were constructed by fitting numerically integrated orbital solutions to ground-based and space-based observations. All quoted orbital elements are referenced to the ecliptic plane. For the Kuiper Belt, we adopted the inclination and longitude of ascending node of the mean plane of the main belt from ref. [10], measured relative to the ecliptic plane, as 1.86^{+0.37}_{-0.37}^\circ and 86.7^{+0.20}_{-0.20}^\circ, respectively. To get the stellar obliquities of the Solar System planets, we compare the Sun’s J2000 pole orientation from ref. [131] with each planet’s orbital plane.

Joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 206893 b&c

Figure S25. The joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 206893 b&c. The plotted parameters are orbital inclination iorbi_{\mathrm{orb}}, longitude of ascending node Ω\Omega, orbital period PorbP_{\mathrm{orb}}, eccentricity, and semi-major axis aa and planet mass MpM_p.

Joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 95086 b

Figure S27. The joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HD 95086 b. The plotted parameters are orbital inclination iorbi_{\mathrm{orb}}, longitude of ascending node Ω\Omega, orbital period PorbP_{\mathrm{orb}}, eccentricity, and semi-major axis aa and planet mass MpM_p.

3-D Keplerian orbital model of HR 2562 B

Figure S28. 3-D Keplerian orbital model of HR 2562 B. Left: astrometric orbits of HR 2562 B projected on the sky plane from our model with observed relative astrometries of the two planets (top) and observed and fitted absolute astrometry from Hipparcos and Gaia DR2 and DR3 in right ascension and declination (middle and bottom). The blue lines are randomly drawn from the posterior distribution.

Joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HR 2562 B

Figure S29. The joint posterior distributions from the orbital fit of HR 2562 B. The plotted parameters are orbital inclination iorbi_{\mathrm{orb}}, longitude of ascending node Ω\Omega, orbital period PorbP_{\mathrm{orb}}, eccentricity, and semi-major axis aa and planet mass MpM_p.

NameR⋆R_{\star} (R⊙R_{\odot})R⋆R_{\star} ref.vsin⁡i⋆v\sin i_{\star} (km s−1^{-1})vsin⁡i⋆v\sin i_{\star} ref.ProtP_{\mathrm{rot}} (d)ProtP_{\mathrm{rot}} ref.
HD106471.10±0.071.10 \pm0.07(56)5.6±0.55.6 \pm0.5(134)9.2±0.19.2 \pm0.1(82)
5.8±1.95.8 \pm1.9(135)10±310 \pm3(41)
4.94.9(41)9.4±19.4 \pm1This work
5.15.1(136)
5.35.3(137)
66(138)
Adopted1.10±0.071.10 \pm0.075.4±0.35.4 \pm0.39.4±19.4 \pm1
HD388580.92±0.040.92 \pm0.04(56)0.5±10.5 \pm1(139)24.024.0(72)
0.3±0.50.3 \pm0.5(134)24.724.7(73)
1.41.4(136)
2.62.6(140)
33(138)
Adopted0.92±0.040.92 \pm0.040.94±0.40.94 \pm0.424.4±2.424.4 \pm2.4
HD385292.83±0.142.83 \pm0.14(56)3.5±0.53.5 \pm0.5(63)35.735.7(63)
3.2±0.53.2 \pm0.5(68)37.0±0.437.0 \pm0.4(68)
3.9±0.53.9 \pm0.5(134)37.1±0.237.1 \pm0.2(67)
Adopted2.83±0.142.83 \pm0.143.5±0.33.5 \pm0.337±437 \pm4
HD1133371.52±0.071.52 \pm0.07(56)6.3±1.06.3 \pm1.0(78)3±13 \pm1(78)
88(138)5±15 \pm1This work
Adopted1.52±0.071.52 \pm0.076.3±1.06.3 \pm1.05±15 \pm1
AU Mic0.82±0.020.82 \pm0.02(56)8.5±0.28.5 \pm0.2(141)4.86±0.024.86 \pm0.02(142)
9.5±0.29.5 \pm0.2(143)4.86±0.54.86 \pm0.5This work
9.2±0.89.2 \pm0.8(144)4.854.85(145)
8.7±0.28.7 \pm0.2(32)4.834.83(146)
7.5±1.57.5 \pm1.5(147)4.864.86(100)
7.8±0.37.8 \pm0.3(148)4.894.89(149)
Adopted0.82±0.020.82 \pm0.028.7±0.28.7 \pm0.24.86±0.54.86 \pm0.5
ϵ\epsilon Eri0.76±0.050.76 \pm0.05(56)2.4±0.52.4 \pm0.5(134)1212(98)
2.4±0.42.4 \pm0.4(150)11.6811.68(99)
1.3±0.61.3 \pm0.6(151)11.6811.68(100)
2.2±0.42.2 \pm0.4(152)11.6311.63(73)
2.2±0.32.2 \pm0.3(143)11.55±111.55 \pm1This work
4.14.1(140)
4.74.7(153)
0.30.3(135)
1.51.5(136)
2.42.4(154)
Adopted0.76±0.050.76 \pm0.052.2±0.22.2 \pm0.211.55±111.55 \pm1

Table S3. Stellar radii, projected rotational velocities, and rotation periods.

NameR∗R_\ast (R⊙R_\odot)R∗R_\ast ref.vsin⁡i∗v\sin i_\ast (km s−1^{-1})vsin⁡i∗v\sin i_\ast ref.ProtP_{\rm rot} (d)ProtP_{\rm rot} ref.
HD829431.18 ±\pm 0.05[56]1.3 ±\pm 0.5[134]18[75]
0.7 ±\pm 0.4[151]17[72]
1.7[75]
3[138]
1.4[136]
2.8[137]
Adopted1.18 ±\pm 0.051.1 ±\pm 0.318 ±\pm 2
HR 87991.49 ±\pm 0.05[56]49.2 ±\pm 5.4[152]0.7[129]
50.5 ±\pm 1[155]
35[156]
49[157]
Adopted1.49 ±\pm 0.0548 ±\pm 30.7 ±\pm 0.1
HR 25621.40 ±\pm 0.07[56]57.5 ±\pm 6.4[152]2 ±\pm 0.5This work
43[118]
60[138]
Adopted1.40 ±\pm 0.0755 ±\pm 52 ±\pm 0.5
HD2068931.31 ±\pm 0.06[56]32 ±\pm 2[103]0.996 ±\pm 0.003[103]
29[152]
32.7[118]
Adopted1.31 ±\pm 0.0632 ±\pm 20.996 ±\pm 0.003

Table S3 (PDF p. 74). Stellar radii, projected rotational velocities, and rotation periods (continued).

References

  1. [1]K. E. Edgeworth, The origin and evolution of the Solar System. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 109, 600–609 (1949), doi:10.1093/mnras/109.5.600.DOI
  2. [2]G. P. Kuiper, On the Origin of the Solar System. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 37 (1), 1–14 (1951), doi:10.1073/pnas.37.1.1.DOI
  3. [3]J. A. Fernandez, On the existence of a comet belt beyond Neptune. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 192, 481–491 (1980), doi:10.1093/mnras/192.3.481.DOI
  4. [4]D. Jewitt, J. Luu, Discovery of the candidate Kuiper belt object 1992 QB₁. Nature 362 (6422), 730–732 (1993), doi:10.1038/362730a0.
  5. [5]B. Gladman, K. Volk, Transneptunian Space. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 59, 203–246 (2021), doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-120920-010005.DOI
  6. [6]J. M. Hahn, R. Malhotra, Neptune’s Migration into a Stirred-Up Kuiper Belt: A Detailed Comparison of Simulations to Observations. Astron. J. 130 (5), 2392–2414 (2005), doi:10.1086/452638.DOI
  7. [7]D. Nesvorný, Jumping Neptune Can Explain the Kuiper Belt Kernel. Astron. J. 150 (3), 68 (2015), doi:10.1088/0004-6256/150/3/68.DOI
  8. [8]R. Malhotra, Resonant Kuiper belt objects: a review. Geoscience Letters 6 (1), 12 (2019), doi:10.1186/s40562-019-0142-2.DOI
  9. [9]K. Volk, R. Malhotra, The Curiously Warped Mean Plane of the Kuiper Belt. Astron. J. 154 (2), 62 (2017), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/aa79ff.DOI
  10. [10]M. E. Brown, M. Pan, The Plane of the Kuiper Belt. Astron. J. 127 (4), 2418–2423 (2004), doi:10.1086/382515.DOI
  11. [11]C. Van Laerhoven, et al., OSSOS. XIV. The Plane of the Kuiper Belt. Astron. J. 158 (1), 49 (2019), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/ab24e1.DOI
  12. [12]I. Matheson, R. Malhotra, A Measurement of the Kuiper Belt’s Mean Plane From Objects Classified By Machine Learning. Astron. J. 165 (6), 241 (2023), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/accfd.DOI
  13. [13]D. Souami, J. Souchay, The solar system’s invariable plane. Astron. Astrophys. 543, A133 (2012), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201219011.DOI
  14. [14]I. Kant, Allgemeine Naturgeschichte und Theorie des Himmels (1755).
  15. [15]P. S. de Laplace, Exposition du système du monde (1796), doi:10.3931/e-rara-497.DOI
  16. [16]J. P. Williams, L. A. Cieza, Protoplanetary Disks and Their Evolution. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 49 (1), 67–117 (2011), doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-081710-102548.DOI
  17. [17]M. C. Wyatt, Evolution of debris disks. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 46, 339–383 (2008), doi:10.1146/annurev.astro.45.051806.110525.DOI
  18. [18]K. C. Schlaufman, Evidence of Possible Spin-orbit Misalignment Along the Line of Sight in Transiting Exoplanet Systems. Astrophys. J. 719 (1), 602–611 (2010), doi:10.1088/0004-637X/719/1/602.DOI
  19. [19]S. Albrecht, et al., Obliquities of Hot Jupiter Host Stars: Evidence for Tidal Interactions and Primordial Misalignments. Astrophys. J. 757 (1), 18 (2012), doi:10.1088/0004-637X/757/1/18.DOI
  20. [20]D. Huber, et al., Stellar Spin-Orbit Misalignment in a Multiplanet System. Science 342 (6156), 331–334 (2013), doi:10.1126/science.1242066.DOI
  21. [21]J. Zhang, et al., Long-period Jovian Tilts the Orbits of Two sub-Neptunes Relative to Stellar Spin Axis in Kepler-129. Astron. J. 162 (3), 89 (2021), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/ac0634.DOI
  22. [22]J. W. Xuan, M. C. Wyatt, Evidence for a high mutual inclination between the cold Jupiter and transiting super Earth orbiting π Men. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 497 (2), 2096–2118 (2020), doi:10.1093/mnras/staa2033.DOI
  23. [23]J. Zhang, et al., Discovery of a Jupiter Analog Misaligned to the Inner Planetary System in HD 73344. Astron. J. 169 (4), 200 (2025), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/ada60a.DOI
  24. [24]A. J. Winter, et al., exoALMA. XVIII. Interpreting Large-scale Kinematic Structures as Moderate Warping. Astrophys. J. Lett. 990 (1), L10 (2025), doi:10.3847/2041-8213/adf113.DOI
  25. [25]S. Marino, S. Perez, S. Casassus, Shadows Cast by a Warp in the HD 142527 Protoplanetary Disk. Astrophys. J. Lett. 798 (2), L44 (2015), doi:10.1088/2041-8205/798/2/L44.DOI
  26. [26]A. J. Bohn, et al., Probing inner and outer disk misalignments in transition disks. Constraints from VLTI/GRAVITY and ALMA observations. Astron. Astrophys. 658, A183 (2022), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202142070.DOI
  27. [27]M. Jurić, S. Tremaine, Dynamical Origin of Extrasolar Planet Eccentricity Distribution. Astrophys. J. 686 (1), 603–620 (2008), doi:10.1086/590047.DOI
  28. [28]D. Fabrycky, S. Tremaine, Shrinking Binary and Planetary Orbits by Kozai Cycles with Tidal Friction. Astrophys. J. 669 (2), 1298–1315 (2007), doi:10.1086/521702.DOI
  29. [29]G. Picogna, F. Marzari, Effects of stellar flybys on planetary systems: 3D modeling of the circumstellar disk’s damping effects. Astron. Astrophys. 564, A28 (2014), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201322816.DOI
  30. [30]K. Batygin, A primordial origin for misalignments between stellar spin axes and planetary orbits. Nature 491 (7424), 418–420 (2012), doi:10.1038/nature11560.DOI
  31. [31]W. Thompson, et al., Detecting and Characterizing Companions with a Calibrated Gaia DR2, DR3, and Hipparcos Catalog (G23H). arXiv e-prints arXiv:2602.00235 (2026), doi:10.48550/arXiv.2602.00235.DOI
  32. [32]P. Plavchan, et al., A planet within the debris disk around the pre-main-sequence star AU Microscopii. Nature 582 (7813), 497–500 (2020), doi:10.1038/s41586-020-2400-z.DOI
  33. [33]B. E. Woodgate, et al., The Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph Design. Publ. Astron. Soc. Pac. 110 (752), 1183–1204 (1998), doi:10.1086/316238.
  34. [34]B. Macintosh, et al., First light of the Gemini Planet Imager. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science 111 (35), 12661–12666 (2014), doi:10.1073/pnas.1304215111.DOI
  35. [35]J.-L. Beuzit, et al., SPHERE: the exoplanet imager for the Very Large Telescope. Astron. Astrophys. 631, A155 (2019), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201935251.DOI
  36. [36]G. L. Pilbratt, et al., Herschel Space Observatory. An ESA facility for far-infrared and submillimetre astronomy. Astron. Astrophys. 518, L1 (2010), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201014759.DOI
  37. [37]A. Wootten, A. R. Thompson, The Atacama Large Millimeter/Submillimeter Array. IEEE Proceedings 97 (8), 1463–1471 (2009), doi:10.1109/JPROC.2009.2020572.DOI
  38. [38]B. P. Bowler, et al., Rotation Periods, Inclinations, and Obliquities of Cool Stars Hosting Directly Imaged Substellar Companions: Spin-Orbit Misalignments Are Common. Astron. J. 165 (4), 164 (2023), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/acbd34.DOI
  39. [39]L. I. Biddle, B. P. Bowler, M. Morgan, Q. H. Tran, Y.-L. Wu, One-third of Sun-like stars are born with misaligned planet-forming disks. Nature 644 (8076), 356–361 (2025), doi:10.1038/s41586-025-09324-0.DOI
  40. [40]L. I.-K. Lin, A Concordance Correlation Coefficient to Evaluate Reproducibility. Biometrics 45 (1), 255–268 (1989).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2720055
  41. [41]M. Marmier, et al., The CORALIE survey for southern extrasolar planets. XVII. New and updated long period and massive planets. Astron. Astrophys. 551, A90 (2013), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201219639.DOI
  42. [42]S. G. Sousa, et al., Homogeneous spectroscopic parameters for bright planet host stars from the northern hemisphere . The impact on stellar and planetary mass. Astron. Astrophys. 576, A94 (2015), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201425227.DOI
  43. [43]R. P. Butler, et al., Catalog of Nearby Exoplanets. Astrophys. J. 646 (1), 505–522 (2006), doi:10.1086/504701.DOI
  44. [44]J. A. Johnson, et al., Retired A Stars and Their Companions. II. Jovian Planets Orbiting κ CrB and HD 167042. Astrophys. J. 675 (1), 784–789 (2008), doi:10.1086/526453.DOI
  45. [45]S. Marino, et al., The ALMA survey to Resolve exoKuiper belt Substructures (ARKS): I. Motivation, sample, data reduction, and results overview. Astron. Astrophys. 705, A195 (2026), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202556489.DOI
  46. [46]J. B. Lovell, et al., High-resolution ALMA and HST imaging of κCrB: a broad debris disc around a post-main-sequence star with low-mass companions. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 517 (2), 2546–2566 (2022), doi:10.1093/mnras/stac2782.DOI
  47. [47]M. Ansdell, et al., Are inner disc misalignments common? ALMA reveals an isotropic outer disc inclination distribution for young dipper stars. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 492 (1), 572–588 (2020), doi:10.1093/mnras/stz3361.DOI
  48. [48]J. B. Lovell, et al., High-resolution ALMA and HST images of q¹ Eri: an asymmetric debris disc with an eccentric Jupiter. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 506 (2), 1978–2001 (2021), doi:10.1093/mnras/stab1678.DOI
  49. [49]M. Perryman, J. Hartman, G. A. Bakos, L. Lindegren, Astrometric Exoplanet Detection with Gaia. Astrophys. J. 797 (1), 14 (2014), doi:10.1088/0004-637X/797/1/14.DOI
  50. [50]C. X. Huang, et al., Photometry of 10 Million Stars from the First Two Years of TESS Full Frame Images: Part I. Research Notes of the American Astronomical Society 4 (11), 204 (2020), doi:10.3847/2515-5172/abca2e.DOI
  51. [51]W. Thompson, et al., Octofitter: Fast, Flexible, and Accurate Orbit Modeling to Detect Exoplanets. Astron. J. 166 (4), 164 (2023), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/acf5cc.DOI
  52. [52]N. Engler, et al., Characterization of debris disks observed with SPHERE. Astron. Astrophys. 704, A21 (2025), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202554953.DOI
  53. [53]W. Thompson, E. L. Nielsen, J.-B. Ruffio, S. Blunt, C. Marois, Revised Mass and Orbit of ε Eridani b: A 1 MJup Planet on a Near-circular Orbit. Astron. J. 170 (6), 301 (2025), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/ae0cbd.DOI
  54. [54]N. Surjanovic, et al., Pigeons.jl: Distributed sampling from intractable distributions. arXiv:2308.09769 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2308.09769
  55. [55]K. Masuda, J. N. Winn, On the Inference of a Star’s Inclination Angle from its Rotation Velocity and Projected Rotation Velocity. Astron. J. 159 (3), 81 (2020), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/ab65be.DOI
  56. [56]K. G. Stassun, et al., The Revised TESS Input Catalog and Candidate Target List. Astron. J. 158 (4), 138 (2019), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/ab3467.DOI
  57. [57]L. Gizon, S. K. Solanki, Determining the Inclination of the Rotation Axis of a Sun-like Star. Astrophys. J. 589 (2), 1009–1019 (2003), doi:10.1086/374715.DOI
  58. [58]W. J. Chaplin, A. Miglio, Asteroseismology of Solar-Type and Red-Giant Stars. Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 51 (1), 353–392 (2013), doi:10.1146/annurev-astro-082812-140938.DOI
  59. [59]K. Zwintz, et al., Revisiting the pulsational characteristics of the exoplanet host star β Pictoris. Astron. Astrophys. 627, A28 (2019), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201834744.DOI
  60. [60]E. Thrane, C. Talbot, An introduction to Bayesian inference in gravitational-wave astronomy: Parameter estimation, model selection, and hierarchical models. Publ. Astron. Soc. Aust. 36, e010 (2019), doi:10.1017/pasa.2019.2.DOI
  61. [61]E. Jofré, et al., Stellar parameters and chemical abundances of 223 evolved stars with and without planets. Astron. Astrophys. 574, A50 (2015), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201424474.DOI
  62. [62]D. A. Fischer, et al., Planetary Companions to HD 12661, HD 92788, and HD 38529 and Variations in Keplerian Residuals of Extrasolar Planets. Astrophys. J. 551 (2), 1107–1118 (2001), doi:10.1086/320224.DOI
  63. [63]D. A. Fischer, et al., A Planetary Companion to HD 40979 and Additional Planets Orbiting HD 12661 and HD 38529. Astrophys. J. 586 (2), 1394–1408 (2003), doi:10.1086/367889.DOI
  64. [64]B. D. Mason, G. L. Wycoff, W. I. Hartkopf, G. G. Douglass, C. E. Worley, The 2001 US Naval Observatory Double Star CD-ROM. I. The Washington Double Star Catalog. Astron. J. 122 (6), 3466–3471 (2001), doi:10.1086/323920.DOI
  65. [65]F. Feng, et al., 3D Selection of 167 Substellar Companions to Nearby Stars. Astrophys. J. Suppl. Ser. 262 (1), 21 (2022), doi:10.3847/1538-4365/ac7e57.DOI
  66. [66]J. W. Xuan, G. M. Kennedy, M. C. Wyatt, B. Yelverton, Mutual inclinations between giant planets and their debris discs in HD 113337 and HD 38529. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 499 (4), 5059–5074 (2020), doi:10.1093/mnras/staa3155.DOI
  67. [67]G. F. Benedict, et al., The Mass of HD 38529c from Hubble Space Telescope Astrometry and High-precision Radial Velocities. Astron. J. 139 (5), 1844–1856 (2010), doi:10.1088/0004-6256/139/5/1844.DOI
  68. [68]G. W. Henry, et al., Host Star Properties and Transit Exclusion for the HD 38529 Planetary System. Astrophys. J. 768 (2), 155 (2013), doi:10.1088/0004-637X/768/2/155.DOI
  69. [69]G. Takeda, et al., Structure and Evolution of Nearby Stars with Planets. II. Physical Properties of ~1000 Cool Stars from the SPOCS Catalog. Astrophys. J. Suppl. Ser. 168 (2), 297–318 (2007), doi:10.1086/509763.DOI
  70. [70]M. Mayor, et al., The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets XXXIV. Occurrence, mass distribution and orbital properties of super-Earths and Neptune-mass planets. arXiv e-prints arXiv:1109.2497 (2011), doi:10.48550/arXiv.1109.2497.DOI
  71. [71]G. M. Kennedy, et al., Kuiper belt structure around nearby super-Earth host stars. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 449 (3), 3121–3136 (2015), doi:10.1093/mnras/stv511.DOI
  72. [72]H. Isaacson, D. Fischer, Chromospheric Activity and Jitter Measurements for 2630 Stars on the California Planet Search. Astrophys. J. 725 (1), 875–885 (2010), doi:10.1088/0004-637X/725/1/875.DOI
  73. [73]B. Fuhrmeister, et al., The corona - chromosphere connection studied with simultaneous eROSITA and TIGRE observations. Astron. Astrophys. 661, A24 (2022), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202141020.DOI
  74. [74]K. Liu, et al., Precise determination of fundamental parameters of six exoplanet host stars and their planets. Research in Astronomy and Astrophysics 14 (11), 1447-1457 (2014), doi:10.1088/1674-4527/14/11/008.DOI
  75. [75]M. Mayor, et al., The CORALIE survey for southern extra-solar planets. XII. Orbital solutions for 16 extra-solar planets discovered with CORALIE. Astron. Astrophys. 415, 391–402 (2004), doi:10.1051/0004-6361:20034250.DOI
  76. [76]X. Tan, et al., Characterizing the Orbital and Dynamical State of the HD 82943 Planetary System with Keck Radial Velocity Data. The Astrophysical Journal 777 (2), 101 (2013), doi:10.1088/0004-637X/777/2/101.DOI
  77. [77]G. M. Kennedy, M. C. Wyatt, G. Bryden, R. Wittenmyer, B. Sibthorpe, Star-planet-debris disc alignment in the HD 82943 system: is planetary system coplanarity actually the norm? Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 436 (1), 898–903 (2013), doi:10.1093/mnras/stt1657.DOI
  78. [78]S. Borgniet, et al., Constraints on HD 113337 fundamental parameters and planetary system. Combining long-base visible interferometry, disc imaging, and high-contrast imaging. Astron. Astrophys. 627, A44 (2019), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201935494.DOI
  79. [79]S. Borgniet, et al., Extrasolar planets and brown dwarfs around A-F type stars. VIII. A giant planet orbiting the young star HD 113337. Astron. Astrophys. 561, A65 (2014), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201321783.DOI
  80. [80]J. P. Marshall, L. Wang, G. M. Kennedy, S. T. Zeegers, P. Scicluna, A search for trends in spatially resolved debris discs at far-infrared wavelengths. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 501 (4), 6168–6180 (2021), doi:10.1093/mnras/staa3917.DOI
  81. [81]R. Liseau, et al., Resolving the cold debris disc around a planet-hosting star. PACS photometric imaging observations of q¹ Eridani (HD 10647, HR 506). Astron. Astrophys. 518, L132 (2010), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201014601.DOI
  82. [82]S. A. Hurt, M. A. MacGregor, Evidence for Misalignment between Debris Disks and Their Host Stars. Astrophys. J. 954 (1), 10 (2023), doi:10.3847/1538-4357/accf9d.DOI
  83. [83]A. Bonsor, et al., Spatially resolved images of dust belt(s) around the planet-hosting subgiant κ CrB. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 431 (4), 3025–3035 (2013), doi:10.1093/mnras/stt367.DOI
  84. [84]L. Ghezzi, et al., Stellar Parameters and Metallicities of Stars Hosting Jovian and Neptunian Mass Planets: A Possible Dependence of Planetary Mass on Metallicity. Astrophys. J. 720 (2), 1290–1302 (2010), doi:10.1088/0004-637X/720/2/1290.DOI
  85. [85]H. R. A. Jones, et al., An exoplanet in orbit around τ¹ Gruis. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 341 (3), 948–952 (2003), doi:10.1046/j.1365-8711.2003.06481.x.DOI
  86. [86]E. L. Nielsen, et al., The Gemini NICI Planet-Finding Campaign: The Orbit of the Young Exoplanet β Pictoris b. Astrophys. J. 794 (2), 158 (2014), doi:10.1088/0004-637X/794/2/158.DOI
  87. [87]A.-M. Lagrange, et al., A probable giant planet imaged in the β Pictoris disk. VLT/NaCo deep L’-band imaging. Astron. Astrophys. 493 (2), L21–L25 (2009), doi:10.1051/0004-6361:200811325.DOI
  88. [88]A.-M. Lagrange, et al., Evidence for an additional planet in the β Pictoris system. Nature Astronomy 3, 1135–1142 (2019), doi:10.1038/s41550-019-0857-1.DOI
  89. [89]M. A. Millar-Blanchaer, et al., Beta Pictoris’ Inner Disk in Polarized Light and New Orbital Parameters for Beta Pictoris b. Astrophys. J. 811 (1), 18 (2015), doi:10.1088/0004-637X/811/1/18.
  90. [90]M. Nowak, et al., Direct confirmation of the radial-velocity planet β Pictoris c. Astron. Astrophys. 642, L2 (2020), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202039039.DOI
  91. [91]B. A. Smith, R. J. Terrile, A Circumstellar Disk around β Pictoris. Science 226 (4681), 1421–1424 (1984), doi:10.1126/science.226.4681.1421.DOI
  92. [92]S. R. Heap, et al., Space Telescope Imaging Spectrograph Coronagraphic Observations of β Pictoris. Astrophys. J. 539 (1), 435–444 (2000), doi:10.1086/309188.DOI
  93. [93]J. Llop-Sayson, et al., Constraining the Orbit and Mass of epsilon Eridani b with Radial Velocities, Hipparcos IAD-Gaia DR2 Astrometry, and Multiepoch Vortex Coronagraphy Upper Limits. Astron. J. 162 (5), 181 (2021), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/ac134a.
  94. [94]A. P. Hatzes, et al., Evidence for a Long-Period Planet Orbiting ε Eridani. The Astrophysical Journal 544 (2), L145–L148 (2000), doi:10.1086/317319.DOI
  95. [95]J. S. Greaves, et al., A Dust Ring around ε Eridani: Analog to the Young Solar System. The Astrophysical Journal 506 (2), L133–L137 (1998), doi:10.1086/311652.DOI
  96. [96]J. S. Greaves, et al., Extreme Conditions in a Close Analog to the Young Solar System: Herschel Observations of ε Eridani. The Astrophysical Journal Letters 791 (1), L11 (2014), doi:10.1088/2041-8205/791/1/L11.DOI
  97. [97]M. Booth, et al., The Northern Arc of ε Eridani’s Debris Ring as Seen by ALMA. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 469 (3), 3200–3212 (2017), doi:10.1093/mnras/stx1072.DOI
  98. [98]S. Baliunas, D. Sokoloff, W. Soon, Magnetic Field and Rotation in Lower Main-Sequence Stars: an Empirical Time-dependent Magnetic Bode’s Relation? Astrophys. J. Lett. 457, L99 (1996), doi:10.1086/309891.DOI
  99. [99]C. Cincunegui, R. F. Díaz, P. J. D. Mauas, Hα and the Ca II H and K lines as activity proxies for late-type stars. Astron. Astrophys. 469 (1), 309–317 (2007), doi:10.1051/0004-6361:20066503.DOI
  100. [100]B. Seli, et al., Extending the FIP bias sample to magnetically active stars. Challenging the FIP bias paradigm. Astron. Astrophys. 659, A3 (2022), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202141493.DOI
  101. [101]S. Hinkley, et al., Direct discovery of the inner exoplanet in the HD 206893 system. Evidence for deuterium burning in a planetary-mass companion. Astron. Astrophys. 671, L5 (2023), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202244727.DOI
  102. [102]J. Milli, et al., Discovery of a low-mass companion inside the debris ring surrounding the F5V star HD 206893. Astronomy & Astrophysics 597, L2 (2017), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201629908.DOI
  103. [103]P. Delorme, et al., In-depth study of moderately young but extremely red, very dusty substellar companion HD 206893B. Astron. Astrophys. 608, A79 (2017), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201731145.DOI
  104. [104]K. Ward-Duong, et al., Gemini Planet Imager Spectroscopy of the Dusty Substellar Companion HD 206893 B. The Astronomical Journal 161 (1), 5 (2021), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/abc263.
  105. [105]S. Marino, et al., Insights into the planetary dynamics of HD 206893 with ALMA. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 498 (1), 1319–1334 (2020), doi:10.1093/mnras/staa2386.DOI
  106. [106]J. Rameau, et al., Confirmation of the Planet around HD 95086 by Direct Imaging. Astrophys. J. Lett. 779 (2), L26 (2013), doi:10.1088/2041-8205/779/2/L26.DOI
  107. [107]T. Meshkat, et al., Further Evidence of the Planetary Nature of HD 95086 b from Gemini/NICI H-band Data. The Astrophysical Journal Letters 775 (2), L40 (2013), doi:10.1088/2041-8205/775/2/L40.DOI
  108. [108]A. Moór, et al., Stirring in massive, young debris discs from spatially resolved Herschel images. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 447 (1), 577–597 (2015), doi:10.1093/mnras/stu2442.DOI
  109. [109]K. Y. L. Su, et al., ALMA 1.3 mm Map of the HD 95086 System. Astron. J. 154 (6), 225 (2017), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/aa906b.DOI
  110. [110]Q. M. Konopacky, et al., Discovery of a Substellar Companion to the Nearby Debris Disk Host HR 2562. Astrophys. J. Lett. 829 (1), L4 (2016), doi:10.3847/2041-8205/829/1/L4.DOI
  111. [111]S. Y. Zhang, et al., Testing the Interaction between a Substellar Companion and a Debris Disk in the HR 2562 System. Astron. J. 165 (5), 219 (2023), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/acbfab.arxiv.org/abs/2302.04893
  112. [112]M. Mallorquín, et al., Revisiting the dynamical masses of the transiting planets in the young AU Mic system: Potential AU Mic b inflation at ~20 Myr. Astron. Astrophys. 689, A132 (2024), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202450047.DOI
  113. [113]E. Martioli, G. Hébrard, A. C. M. Correia, J. Laskar, A. Lecavelier des Etangs, New constraints on the planetary system around the young active star AU Mic. Two transiting warm Neptunes near mean-motion resonance. Astron. Astrophys. 649, A177 (2021), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202040235.DOI
  114. [114]J. M. Wittrock, et al., Validating AU Microscopii d with Transit Timing Variations. Astron. J. 166 (6), 232 (2023), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/acfda8.DOI
  115. [115]P. Kalas, M. C. Liu, B. C. Matthews, Discovery of a Large Dust Disk Around the Nearby Star AU Microscopii. Science 303 (5666), 1990–1992 (2004), doi:10.1126/science.1093420.DOI
  116. [116]J. E. Krist, et al., Hubble Space Telescope Advanced Camera for Surveys Coronagraphic Imaging of the AU Microscopii Debris Disk. Astron. J. 129 (2), 1008–1017 (2005), doi: 10.1086/426755.DOI
  117. [117]M. A. MacGregor, et al., Millimeter Emission Structure in the First ALMA Image of the AU Mic Debris Disk. Astrophys. J. Lett. 762 (2), L21 (2013), doi:10.1088/2041-8205/762/2/L21.DOI
  118. [118]O. V. Zakhozhay, et al., Radial Velocity Survey for Planets around Young stars (RVSPY). Target characterisation and high-cadence survey. Astron. Astrophys. 667, A63 (2022), doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/202244213.DOI
  119. [119]Z. Wahhaj, et al., The SHARDDS survey: First resolved image of the HD 114082 debris disk in the Lower Centaurus Crux with SPHERE. Astron. Astrophys. 596, L4 (2016), doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201629769.DOI
  120. [120]C. Marois, et al., Direct Imaging of Multiple Planets Orbiting the Star HR 8799. Science 322 (5906), 1348 (2008), doi:10.1126/science.1166585.DOI
  121. [121]D. C. Fabrycky, R. A. Murray-Clay, Stability of the Directly Imaged Multiplanet System HR 8799: Resonance and Masses. Astrophys. J. 710 (2), 1408–1421 (2010), doi:10.1088/0004-637X/710/2/1408.DOI
  122. [122]J. J. Wang, et al., Dynamical Constraints on the HR 8799 Planets with GPI. Astron. J. 156 (5), 192 (2018), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/aae150.DOI
  123. [123]GRAVITY Collaboration, et al., First direct detection of an exoplanet by optical interferometry. Astrometry and K-band spectroscopy of HR 8799 e. Astron. Astrophys. 623, L11 (2019), doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201935253.
  124. [124]K. Goździewski, C. Migaszewski, An Exact, Generalized Laplace Resonance in the HR 8799 Planetary System. Astrophys. J. Lett. 902 (2), L40 (2020), doi:10.3847/2041-8213/abb881.DOI
  125. [125]A. Zurlo, et al., Orbital and dynamical analysis of the system around HR 8799. New astrometric epochs from VLT/SPHERE and LBT/LUCI. Astron. Astrophys. 666, A133 (2022), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202243862.DOI
  126. [126]B. Matthews, et al., Resolved Imaging of the HR 8799 Debris Disk with Herschel. Astrophys. J 780 (1), 97 (2014), doi:10.1088/0004-637X/780/1/97.DOI
  127. [127]M. Booth, et al., Resolving the planetesimal belt of HR 8799 with ALMA. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 460 (1), L10–L14 (2016), doi:10.1093/mnrasl/slw040.DOI
  128. [128]V. Faramaz, et al., A Detailed Characterization of HR 8799’s Debris Disk with ALMA in Band 7. Astron. J. 161 (6), 271 (2021), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/abf4e0.DOI
  129. [129]A. G. Sepulveda, et al., 20 s Cadence TESS Photometry of HR 8799. Research Notes of the American Astronomical Society 7 (1), 2 (2023), doi:10.3847/2515-5172/acafea.DOI
  130. [130]R. S. Park, W. M. Folkner, J. G. Williams, D. H. Boggs, The JPL Planetary and Lunar Ephemerides DE440 and DE441. Astron. J. 161 (3), 105 (2021), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/abd414.DOI
  131. [131]B. A. Archinal, et al., Report of the IAU Working Group on Cartographic Coordinates and Rotational Elements: 2015. Celestial Mechanics and Dynamical Astronomy 130 (3), 22 (2018), doi:10.1007/s10569-017-9805-5.DOI
  132. [134]J. A. Valenti, D. A. Fischer, Spectroscopic Properties of Cool Stars (SPOCS). I. 1040 F, G, and K Dwarfs from Keck, Lick, and AAT Planet Search Programs. Astrophys. J. Suppl. Ser. 159 (1), 141–166 (2005), doi:10.1086/430500.DOI
  133. [136]A. R. Costa Silva, E. Delgado Mena, M. Tsantaki, Chemical abundances of 1111 FGK stars from the HARPS-GTO planet search sample. III. Sulfur. Astron. Astrophys. 634, A136 (2020), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201936523.DOI
  134. [137]E. Delgado Mena, et al., Li abundances in F stars: planets, rotation, and Galactic evolution. Astron. Astrophys. 576, A69 (2015), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201425433.DOI
  135. [138]B. Nordström, et al., The Geneva-Copenhagen survey of the Solar neighbourhood. Ages, metallicities, and kinematic properties of ∼14 000 F and G dwarfs. Astron. Astrophys. 418, 989–1019 (2004), doi:10.1051/0004-6361:20035959.DOI
  136. [151]M. G. Soto, J. S. Jenkins, Spectroscopic Parameters and atmosphEric ChemIstriEs of Stars (SPECIES). I. Code description and dwarf stars catalogue. Astron. Astrophys. 615, A76 (2018), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201731533.DOI
  137. [152]R. Glebocki, P. Gnacinski, VizieR Online Data Catalog: Catalog of Stellar Rotational Velocities (Glebocki+ 2005), VizieR On-line Data Catalog: III/244. Originally published in: 2005csss...13..571G (2005).
  138. [155]C. Swastik, et al., Host Star Metallicity of Directly Imaged Wide-orbit Planets: Implications for Planet Formation. Astron. J. 161 (3), 114 (2021), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/abd802.DOI
  139. [156]M. Gebran, W. Farah, F. Paletou, R. Monier, V. Watson, A new method for the inversion of atmospheric parameters of A/Am stars. Astron. Astrophys. 589, A83 (2016), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201528052.DOI
  140. [157]F. Royer, J. Zorec, A. E. Gómez, Rotational velocities of A-type stars. III. Velocity distributions. Astron. Astrophys. 463 (2), 671–682 (2007), doi:10.1051/0004-6361:20065224.DOI
  141. [158]J. T. Wright, et al., Ten New and Updated Multiplanet Systems and a Survey of Exoplanetary Systems. Astrophys. J. 693 (2), 1084–1099 (2009), doi:10.1088/0004-637X/693/2/1084.DOI
  142. [159]D. A. Fischer, G. W. Marcy, J. F. P. Sponck, The Twenty-five Year Lick Planet Search. Astrophys. J. Suppl. Ser 210 (1), 5 (2014), doi:10.1088/0067-0049/210/1/5.DOI
  143. [160]L. J. Rosenthal, et al., The California Legacy Survey. I. A Catalog of 178 Planets from Precision Radial Velocity Monitoring of 719 Nearby Stars over Three Decades. Astrophys. J. Suppl. Ser. 255 (1), 8 (2021), doi:10.3847/1538-4365/abe23c.DOI
  144. [161]M. H. Lee, R. P. Butler, D. A. Fischer, G. W. Marcy, S. S. Vogt, On the 2:1 Orbital Resonance in the HD 82943 Planetary System. Astrophys. J. 641 (2), 1178–1187 (2006), doi:10.1086/500566.DOI
  145. [162]M. Flores, et al., HD 38858: a solar-type star with an activity cycle of ∼10.8 yr. Searching for variations in the Balmer and metallic lines. Astron. Astrophys. 620, A34 (2018), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201833330.DOI
  146. [163]A. F. Gupta, et al., The NEID Earth Twin Survey. III. Survey Performance after Three Years on Sky. Astron. J. 170 (5), 264 (2025), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/ae0339.DOI
  147. [164]D. Bisht, H. R. A. Jones, Radial velocity analysis of stars with debris discs. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 534 (3), 2105–2118 (2024), doi:10.1093/mnras/stae2223.DOI
  148. [165]C. K. Harada, et al., SPORES-HWO. II. Companion Mass Limits and Updated Planet Properties for 120 Future Exoplanet Imaging Targets from 35 yr of Precise Doppler Monitoring. Astron. J. 170 (6), 343 (2025), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/ae0b62.DOI
  149. [166]G. Chauvin, et al., Orbital characterization of the β Pictoris b giant planet. Astron. Astrophys. 542, A41 (2012), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201118346.DOI
  150. [167]J. J. Wang, et al., The Orbit and Transit Prospects for β Pictoris b Constrained with One Milliarcsecond Astrometry. Astron. J. 152 (4), 97 (2016), doi:10.3847/0004-6256/152/4/97.DOI
  151. [168]Q. Kral, et al., Exomoon search with VLTI/GRAVITY around the substellar companion HD 206893 B. Astron. Astrophys. 705, A217 (2026), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202557127.DOI
  152. [169]A.-L. Maire, et al., VLT/SPHERE astrometric confirmation and orbital analysis of the brown dwarf companion HR 2562 B. Astron. Astrophys. 615, A177 (2018), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201732476.DOI
  153. [170]J. Roberts, et al., New Orbital Constraints for YSES 1b and HR 2562 B from High-Precision Astrometry and Planetary Radial Velocities. Astron. J. 170 (5), 273 (2025), doi:10.3847/1538-3881/ae07cb.
  154. [171]C. Desgrange, et al., In-depth direct imaging and spectroscopic characterization of the young Solar System analog HD 95086. Astron. Astrophys. 664, A139 (2022), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202243097.DOI
  155. [172]M. Målin, et al., Unveiling the HD 95086 system at mid-infrared wavelengths with JWST/MIRI. Astron. Astrophys. 690, A316 (2024), doi:10.1051/0004-6361/202450470.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_zemfmg8f
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents