WorksPhysics and Astronomy
corrections to spherical EDF calculations for root-mean-square charge radii
Abstract
Root-mean-square charge radii are discussed in terms of spherical Energy Density Functional (EDF) models corrected for quadrupole deformations. Comparisons between experiment and theory are made for the absolute radii of all even-even nuclei, for the isotonic shift between cadmium and tin isotopes, the isotopic shifts of the calcium isotopes and the isotonic shift for nuclei with . We conclude that the data are well described in this approach, except for the sharp rise just after the neutron magic numbers.
Introduction
Root-mean-square (rms) charge radii of nuclei provide one of the most precise insights into nuclear structure. New experiments are being carried out on long chains of isotopes, and theoretical models are being improved, see [1], [2], [3] and references therein. Figure 1 shows the measured rms charge radii for even-even nuclei from calcium to tellurium. One observes kinks in the isotopic trends at neutron numbers and , as well as kinks in the isotonic trends at the proton numbers and . In particular, the isotonic kink at results in a close spacing between the rms charge radii of cadmium and tin isotopes which is one of the topics of this paper.

Figure 1. Measured rms charge radii for even-even nuclei from (calcium) to (tellurium). The data are taken from compilations [9] and [10] with updated results for Ca [11], Fe [12], Ni [13], Cd [14], and Sn [15].
We start with a comparison of the data to spherical energy-density functional (EDF) calculations using the 12 Skyrme functionals from Table I of [4]. As shown in Figure 4 of [5], the main difference in the results for the rms charge radii for these 12 functionals is correlated with the effective mass. One group has . The results for s8 parameter set which is representative of this group are shown in Figure 2. The other group has . The results for s17 parameter set which is representative of this group are shown in Figure 3. These are carried out in a spherical basis with proton and neutron occupation numbers obtained from a self-consistent exact-pairing calculation [6] based on the two-body matrix elements from configuration-interaction Hamiltonians used for the various mass regions. The calculations include the proton and neutron finite sizes and the relativistic spin-orbit corrections as described in [7].
Figure 2. (a) Difference between the experimental rms charge radii and those obtained in a spherical EDF calculation with the Skyrme functional. (b) The increase in the rms charge radii calculated with Eq. (1) using experimental values. (c) The difference between (a) and (b).
Figure 3. (a) Difference between the experimental rms charge radii and those obtained in a spherical EDF calculation with the Skyrme functional. (b) The increase in the rms charge radii calculated with Eq. (1) using experimental values. (c) The difference between (a) and (b).
Figure 4. Increase in the rms charge radii calculated with Eq. (1) using experimental [29].
The difference between experiment and the spherical calculations shows the well-known effect of nuclear deformation in between the magic numbers of 28, 50, 82 and 126. To account for deformation one can carry out deformed EDF calculations. Many such calculations give results at the energy minimum for a given deformation. More advanced calculations include fluctuations around the minimum [8].
A different approach is to use the information contained in the reduced transition probability for the excitation of low-lying states to deduce an effective deformation parameter (this includes the fluctuations) and then use the Bohr collective model to evaluate the change in the rms radius taking into account volume conservation as a function of deformation [16]. To order the mean-square radius is
where
is the mean-square radius with no deformation, and
The proton is related to the for to transitions (in units of ) by
The operator for is
where is the effective charge for protons () or neutrons (). Fluctuations of the nuclear surface give corrections to the rms charge radii that have the same form as those of the Bohr deformed model [17].
We will assume equal (isoscalar) proton and neutron deformations. A more general expression for Eq. (1) with unequal proton and neutron deformations is given in [18]. Results for higher-order terms in Eq. (1) are given [19], [20], [21]. For , the next most important term is proportional to . For this term gives about a 10% change to Eq. (1). This term depends on the sign of which is often not measured, and it will not be included here.
The strength functions for are dominated by the low-lying excited state and the high-lying giant quadrupole state. Low-lying excited states fall into three groups, (a) states in well deformed nuclei, (b) states in semi-magic nuclei formed from valence configurations below 2-3 MeV, and (c) states in doubly-magic nuclei formed by particle-hole excitations.
In this paper we compare experimental rms charge radii for nuclei on or near the semi-magic numbers with the results from three types of EDF calculations. The first is for the spherical EDF with parameters determined from bulk properties of doubly-magic nuclei [22], [23], [4], or from a large sample of nuclear bulk properties together with other observables resulting in the SV-min set of EDF parameters [24]. The second is the same spherical calculations but supplemented with determined from experimental and/or calculated values of type (a) and (b) above. The third is the Fayans-type EDF [25], [26] with pairing terms added to provide an improved description of rms charge radii resulting in the Fy() set of parameters [3].
In the following we first consider the global comparison for even-even nuclei using experimental data for the values. We will call this the correction. We also look at the relative size of contributions to the rms radii coming from , 3, and 4. Next we look at the specific application to the isotonic shift between cadmium and tin to compare various approaches. Then we consider the isotopic shifts for (calcium) and the isotonic shifts for using experimental values. We also use configuration-mixing calculations for and to calculate for both even-even and odd-even isotopes in order to explore the odd-even oscillations in the rms charge radii. At the end we discuss the problem for the increase in charge radii after the magic numbers and suggest possible solutions.
Global Comparisons
Using the compiled experimental values [27] the correction to the rms radii implied by Eq. (1) are shown in Figure 2 and Figure 3. The bottom panel of these figures show difference . is the calculated correction based on . The increase away from the magic numbers accounts for part of the kinks in the experimental radii at the magic numbers. There are some remaining deviations just after the magic numbers. For the region of the mass number , the for higher states are typically less than about 5% of those for the first state, see for example [28]. The contribution for the higher states for the calcium isotopes and the isotones will be discussed below.
The next most important multiple is . The increase in the rms charge radii obtained from the experimental values [29] are shown in Figure 4. In contrast to the dramatic shell effects observed for the in Figure 2 and Figure 3, the radius increase from the are rather flat. For the doubly-magic nuclei the are particle-hole excitation of the type (c) above. To the extent that the EDF parameters are determined to reproduce the rms radii of these doubly-magic nuclei, the effects of the contributions are contained in the EDF calculations. For nuclei in between the magic numbers, the is typically split over many low-lying states and their total contribution to the rms radii may be larger than that shown in Figure 4. The largest are observed for Ca and Zr. The implications of the increase in for Zr and nuclei just after the magic numbers will be discussed at the end. Results for the radii using the and obtained from the BSk27 EDF calculations [30] are shown in Figure 5. accounts for about a third of the difference just after shown in the bottom panels of Figure 2 and Figure 3.
Figure 5. (a) Increase in the rms charge radii calculated with Eq. (1) using the values obtained in a deformed EDF calculation with the HFB27 Skyrme functional. (b) Increase in the rms charge radii calculated with Eq. (1) using the values obtained in a deformed EDF calculations with the HFB27 Skyrme functional.
Isotonic Shifts for the Cadmium and Tin Isotopes
Modifications have been made to the Skyrme functionals to account for odd-even oscillators in the rms charge radii and the increase in radii after the magic numbers. The Fayans functionals add a pairing-type term to spherical EDF [25], [26]. The M3Y-P6a functional adds density-dependent spin-orbit and pairing terms to the M3Y-type functional [31].
As an example for isotonic shift in the rms charge radii, we consider the results for the cadmium and tin isotopes. These are shown in Figure 6 using the experimental data and calculations given in [14] for cadmium and [15] for tin. The experimental data are compared to the spherical calculations with the Sv-min [24] EDF calculations given in the experimental papers [14], [15]. All 12 Skyrme functionals given in [4] give isotonic shifts similar to those shown for Sv-min. The experimental isotonic shift is closer to zero than to the standard Skyrme results.
Figure 6. Cd-Sn isotonic shifts. The experimental results from [14], and [15] are compared to the Sv-min and Fy() EDF calculations given in [14] and [15].
In Figure 6 The isotonic shifts are also compared to the results from the Fy(,HFB) functional given in [14], [15], and to the results obtained by adding the corrections using the experimental values from [32] to the Sv-min values. The error bars shown in Figure 6 are from those given in [32] for the and from those given in [14] and [15] for the rms radii. The Sv-min plus corrections provide a reasonably good description of the data. The remaining differences between theory and experiment may be due to: (a) systematic uncertainties in the charge radii, (b) systematic uncertainties in the extracted from Coulex and/or lifetime measurements, (c) deficiencies in the Sv-min EDF, or (d) corrections.
Isotopic Shifts for the Calcium Isotopes
One of the most famous and challenging data for rms charge radii is that for the calcium isotopes where there is a strong odd-even oscillation in the rms charge radii with Ca being relatively large compared to those for the ”closed-shell” nuclei Ca and Ca. It is notable that the experimental rms charge radii of Ca and Ca are nearly the same [11]. This data has led to many theoretical ideas [33], [34], [35], [36], [37], [38], [39], [25], [26]. It was noted by Talmi [33] that a two-body effective operator for a correction to rms radii contains odd-even oscillations. The increase in the rms charge radii is correlated with an increase in the matter rms radii [40]. The increase in the rms radii for relative to and are in relatively good agreement with corrections obtained from the experimental values as shown in panels (a) and (b) of Figure 7. The data are for [41], [42], and [43]. For we include the the for the state for which [41]. The theoretical results from the Fy(,HFB) calculations given in [44] are shown in panel (c) of Figure 7.
Figure 7. for the calcium isotopes. The black circles are the experimental results from [11] with error bars about the size of the circles. The calculations shown in panel (c) are the results from the Fay(,HFB) calculation shown in [44]. The lines shown in panels (a) and (b) are based on the calculations discussed in the text. The red crosses in panels (a) and (b) are based on experimental values in the text.
These large cannot be described by calculations in the model space [45]. They are a result of admixtures from configurations with proton excitations from the shell to the shell. The configuration interaction (CI) calculations that include these cross shell excitation are challenging. In [37] the ZBM2 Hamiltonian for the model space was used to calculate the rms charge radii of the calcium isotopes using harmonic-oscllator radial wavefunctions. The number of protons excited from to showed an odd-even effect. When these orbital occupations were used with harmonic-oscllator radial wavefunctions one obtained an increase in the rms charge radii with odd-even oscillations that were in qualitative agreement with experiment. However, in [5] when the orbital occupation numbers from these calculations were used to constrain the spherical EDF calculations, the increase in the rms charge radii was small compared to experiment.
To explore the contributions to the charge radii we will use the ZBM2-modified Hamiltonian for the model space as described in [46]. The corrections for the rms charge radii using the values from these calculations are shown by the blue line in panel (b) of Figure 7. We use effective charges of and from [18]. There is a disagreement with the calculated and experimental for . This can be traced to the location of the – proton intruder state that comes at 1.8 MeV in the calculations. Experimentally it is observed at 2.4 MeV [47]. The ZBM2-modified Hamiltonian was designed for the region of . When it is used for the region of the proton shell gap is too small. This can be fixed by adding a monopole term to the Hamiltonian that moves the proton – state in up to 2.4 MeV. The proton – state in is suggested to be at 4.28 MeV [48] compared to the calculated excitation energy of 4.45 MeV. The results for the correction are shown by the green line in panel (a) of Figure 7. EDF results for are discussed on the end of this paper.
In addition to the results for even-even nuclei obtained with , we include results for the odd-even nuclei obtained from
where is the operator. For even-even nuclei this is . The sum for odd-even nuclei is typically over many excited states. For example, in Ca, there are 11 excited states below 3.5 MeV that contribute.
The odd-even effects in the orbital occupations and values are implicitly connected to the pairing interaction. But the specific connections between the pairing oscillations in the nuclear binding energies and the rms charge radii depends upon details of the local nuclear structure. There are many contributions to consider for rms radii: the properties of the EDF functional, orbital occupations, corrections, and possible pairing-type additions to the EDF. Our results suggest that the spherical EDF together with the corrections are the most important. But at a quantitative level of detail, all must be considered.
Isotonic Shifts for the N=28 Isotones
The results for the isotones obtained with the GXPF1A Hamiltonian for are shown by the green line in Figure 8. We use effective charges of and from [18] and the model of [18] that includes the isovector term. One observes odd-even oscillations in the calculated results. The contribution only includes the state. These are the calculations that were used to make the corrections for the connecting the mirror charge radii of Ni and Fe to the slope parameter of neutron equation of state in [18]. As noted in [18], for Fe there is additional strength at 2.8 MeV in the calculation. This is not included because it comes from coupling of two-proton holes in Ni to the particle-hole excited state in Ni at 2.7 MeV.
Figure 8. obtained from corrections for the isotones with isotopes. The red crosses are based on experimental values. The calculations shown by the green lines are discussed in the text. The experimental data differences between the given isotope and a linear extrapolation between [11] and [13]. The data for , 23, 24 and 26 are from [10] using combined analyses of the muonic-X ray and electron scattering measurements, where they are available. Otherwise only the electron scattering data is used. The charge radius for is from [9]. Charge radii for and 27 are not experimentally known yet.
Charge radii calculated by the spherical EDF for are linear as a function . Thus, to obtain the correction from experiment we can take the difference between the rms charge radius for each isotope and that obtained from a linear extrapolation between the experimental values for Ca [11] and Ni [13]. These results are shown by the black points in Figure 8. More complete and improved experimental results are needed for the odd-even isotopes.
The correlation between the difference in mirror charge radii and the symmetry energy parameter is obtained with spherical EDF [49] and CODF [50] calculations that are linear in between Ca and Ni. In addition, as discussed in [18], one has to add the corrections for Fe as shown in Figure 8 and for Ni. The oscillations in the rms charge radii are treated in a different way in the Fayans-type functional by adding pairing-type functional with new global parameters [14], [15], [3]. In the Fayans method some of the correlation between the mirror charge radii and is lost [51].
Increase in Charge Radii After the Magic Numbers
Spherical EDF with corrections do not account for the increase in the rms charge radii just after the magic numbers shown in the bottom of Figure 2, Figure 3 and Figure 7. All of these increases are associated with the sudden occupation of the orbitals with an addition node given in tbl:I. The experimental difference in the rms charge radii between Ca and Ca is given in tbl:II and compared with results of some calculations. The result for the covariant density functional (CODF) model are taken as one quarter of the increase between and shown in Fig. 24 of [2]. Nuclear matter densities for , and obtained with the s17 EDF parameter set are shown in Figure 9. The interior densities show a large variation. In particular, the matter density for has a larger interior density due to the node in the radial wavefunctions. The ”size” of the nucleus is determined by the interior saturation conditions imposed by the EDF functional. Perhaps the present generation of EDF functionals are not complex enough to correctly take into account these variations in the interior shape.
Figure 9. Nuclear matter densities obtained with the s17 EDF parameters.
It is noted in [52] that the orbitals given in Table I are all associated with a sudden change in the octupole instabilities via their large values with higher orbitals that differ by , , , , and , respectively (see Figure 2 in [52]). This results in a sudden increase in the just after the magic numbers. This may contribute to the increase in the observed in the bottom of Figure 2 and Figure 3. The contribution from the configurations for would increase linearly with . The contribution from the configurations for would be maximized in where a peak in the contribution to is observed in Figure 4. The octupole contributions to the rms radii in an EDF model that includes octupole degrees of freedom [52], [53] needs to be explored.
| orbital | Nuclei | ||
| 28 | 0.015(3) | ||
| 50 | 0.015(2) | ||
| 82 | |||
| 132 | 0.009(2) |
Table 1. Experimental increase in the rms charge radii after the magic numbers.
Conclusions
In this paper we considered the corrections to rms radii provided by the Bohr model. We showed results for , 3 and 4. The most important contribution can be obtained from experimental value. When these corrections are added to spherical EDF calculations, the rms charge radii for even-even nuclei are in
Table 2. Charge rms difference between and in units of (fm)
reasonable agreement with experiment. The major deviations between theory and experiment appear just after the magic numbers. We also used the experimental to calculate the isotonic shift between the cadmium and tin isotopes, the isotopic shifts of the calcium isotopes and the isotonic shifts of the isotones. The results are all in reasonable agreement with the data.
For the calcium isotopes and the isotones, we used configuration-mixing calculations to obtain the corrections for both even-even and odd-even nuclei. The calculated for even-even nuclei are in reasonable agreement with experiment. The evaluation of for the odd-even nuclei leads to odd-even oscillations in the rms charge radii that are also in reasonably good agreement with the data.
For the correction model, the primary remaining deviation between experimental and theoretical rms charge radii is for the rapid increase just after the magic numbers. We suggest that this may come form octupole deformations and/or a limitation in the standard form of the Skyrme-type EDF functionals.
This work was supported by NSF grant PHY-2110365 and NSF PHY 2111185. We thank H. Nakada and W. Nazarwicz for discussions and suggestions.
References
References
- [1]M. Kortelainen, Z. Sun, G. Hagen, W. Nazarewicz, T. Papenbrock, and P.-G. Reinhard, Phys. Rev. C 105, L021303 (2022).
- [2]U. C. Perera, A. V. Afanasjev, and P. Ring, Phys. Rev. C 104, 064313 (2021).
- [3]P.-G. Reinhard and W. Nazarewicz, Phys. Rev. C 95, 064328 (2017).
- [4]B. A. Brown and A. Schwenk, Phys. Rev. C 89, 011307(R) (2014).
- [5]D. M. Rossi et al., Phys. Rev. C 92, 014305 (2015).
- [6]A. Volya, B. A. Brown and V. Zelevinsky, Phys. Lett. B 509, 37 (2001).
- [7]B. A. Brown, C. Bronk and P. E. Hodgson, Jour. Phys. G 10, 1683 (1984).
- [8]J.-P. Delaroche, M. Girod, J. Libert, H. Goutt, e, S. Hilaire, S. Peru, N. Pillet, and G. F. Bertsch, Phys. Rev. C 81, 014303 (2010).
- [9]I. Angeli and K. P. Marinova, Atomic Data and Nucl. Data Tables 99, 69 (2013).
- [10]G. Fricke and K. Heilig, Nuclear Charge Radii (Springer, Berlin Heidelberg, 2004).
- [11]R. F. Garcia Ruiz, Nature Physics 12, 594 (2016).
- [12]K. Minamisono et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 252501 (2016).
- [13]F. Sommer et al., to be published.
- [14]M. Hammen et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 102501 (2018).
- [15]C. Gorges et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 192502 (2019).
- [16]A. Bohr and B. R. Mottelson, Nuclear Structure vol. I, (New York: Benjamin, 1969).
- [17]H. Esbensen and G. F. Bertsch, Phys. Rev. C 28, 355 (1983).
- [18]S. V. Pineda et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 182503 (2021).
- [19]J. Dobaczewski, P. Vogel and A. Winter, Phys. Rev. C 29, 1540 (1984).
- [20]S. A. Ahmad, W. Klempt, R. Neugart, E. W. Otten, P.-G. Reinhard, G. Ulm, and K. Wendt, Nucl. Phys. A 483, 244 (1988).
- [21]G. F. Bertsch, Eur. Phys. J. A 55, 248 (2019).
- [22]B. A. Brown, Phys. Rev. C 58, 220 (1998).
- [23]B. A. Brown, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 232502 (2013).
- [24]P. Kluepfel, P.-G. Reinhard, T. J. Buervenich, and J. A. Maruhn Phys. Rev. C 79, 034310 (2009).
- [25]S. Fayans, S. Tolokonnikov, E. Trykov, and D. Zawischa, Nucl. Phys. A 676, 49 (2000).
- [26]E. E. Saperstein and S. V. Tolokonnikov, Phys. At. Nucl. 74, 1277 (2011).
- [27]B. Pritychenko, M. Birch, B. Singh, and M. Horoi, Atomic Data and Nucl. Data Sheets 107, 1 (2016).
- [28]J. W. Lightbody, S. Penner, and S. P. Fivozinsky, P. L. Hallowell and H. Cranne, Phys. Rev. C 14, 952 (1976).
- [29]R. H. Spear and W. N. Catford, Phys. Rev. C 41, R1351 (1990).
- [30]S. Goriely, N. Chamel and J. M. Pearson, Phys. Rev. C 88, 061302(R) (2013).
- [31]H. Nakada, Phys. Rev. C 92, 044307 (2015), and private communication.
- [32]B. Pritychenko, M. Birch, and B.Singh, Nucl. Phys. A 962, 73 (2017).
- [33]I. Talmi, Nucl. Phys. A 423, 189 (1984).
- [34]L. Zamick, Phys. Rev. C 82, 057304 (2010).
- [35]M. Horoi, Phys. Rev. C 50, 2384 (1994).
- [36]L. Zamick, Zeit. fur Phys. A 327, 409 (1987).
- [37]E. Caurier, K. Langanke, G. Martinez-Pinedo, F. Nowacki and P. Vogel, Phys. Lett. B 522, 240 (2001).
- [38]D. Zawischa, Phys. Legg. B 155, 309 (1985).
- [39]F. Barranco and R. A. Broglia, Phye. Lett. B 15 1, 90 (1985).
- [40]W. R. Gibbs and J. P. Dedonder, Phys. Rev. C 46, 1825 (1992). pion scattering and matter radii for Ca
- [41]K. Hadynska-Klek, Phys. Rev. C 97, 024326 (2018).
- [42]C. E. Towsley, D. Cline and R. N. Horoshko, Nucl. Phys. A 204, 574 (1973).
- [43]J. J. Valiente-Dobon et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 242502 (2009).
- [44]A. J. Miller et al., Nat. Phys. 15, 432 (2019).
- [45]B. Longfellow, D. Weisshaar, A. Gade, B. A. Brown, D. Bazin, K. W. Brown, B. Elman, J. Pereira, D. Rhodes, and M. Spieker, Phys. Rev. C 103, 054309 (2021).
- [46]M. L. Bissell et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 052502 (2014).
- [47]W. Kutschera, B. A. Brown, H. Ikezoe, G. D. Sprouse, Y. Yamazaki, Y. Yoshida, T. Nomura and H. Ohnuma, Phys. Rev. C 12, 813 (1975).
- [48]B. A. Brown and W. A. Richter, Phys. Rev. C 58, 2099 (1998).
- [49]B. A. Brown, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 122502 (2017).
- [50]J. Yang and J. Piekarewicz, Phys. Rev. C 97, 014314 (2018).
- [51]P.-G. Reinhard and W. Nazarewicz, Phys. Rev. C 105, L021301 (2022).
- [52]W. Nazarewicz, P. Ol eadners, I. Ragnarsson, J. Dudek, G. A. Leander, P. Moeller, R. Ruchowska, Nucl. Phys. A 429, 269 (1984).
- [53]Y. Cao, S. E. Agbemava, A. V. Afanasev, W. Nazarewicz, and E. Olsen, Phys. Rev. C 102, 024311 (2020).







