betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

C5 as simplest ultrahard allotrope with mixed sp2/sp3 carbon hybridizations from first principles

Abstract

From crystal chemistry rationale and density functional DFT calculations, novel tetragonal carbon C5 is proposed as simplest ultrahard allotrope with mixed hybrid carbon hybridizations (sp2 - sp3). Novel pentacarbon is identified as cohesive and stable both dynamically and mechanically. Whereas charge density is localized about tetrahedral C-sp3, it is found delocalized around trigonal C-sp2 resulting in metallic behavior. The anisotropic structure characteristics caused by the aligned trigonal carbon along the tetragonal c-axis provide high Vickers hardness with a magnitude close to diamond

Introduction and context

Diamond, as natural gem and man-made for applications, is recognized as the hardest material [1]. In last decades large research efforts were devoted to identifying novel allotropes of carbon close to diamond using modern materials research software as USPEX (Universal Structure Predictor: Evolutionary Xtallography) [2]. Regarding carbon, in view of the large number of claimed stoichiometries and structures, a database: SACADA was built regrouping all known carbon allotropes thus helping researchers in their endeavor and letting avoid claiming existing systems as novel allotropes [3].

Another initial pathway that could be used complementarily to modern materials research software lies in crystal chemistry rationale calling for structural ‘engineering’. Recently, body-centered tetragonal C4_4 (Figure 1a) was proposed by us in space group Iˉ4m2\bar{I}4m2 as one of the simplest three-dimensional (3D) carbon networks with the purpose of serving as seed-template for other original chemical compounds [6]. Using TopCryst crystallography package [7] C4_4 was found with “dia” topology -for diamond- as categorized for several chemical compounds in Reticular Chemistry Structure Resource (RCSR) Database [8].

Figure 1. Sketches of the crystal structures. a) C4C_{4} [6], b) model C3C_{3}, c) novel pentacarbon C5C_{5} shown with white spheres depicting trigonal carbon C=CC=C pair.

In this work, starting from C4_4, we build novel tetragonal pentacarbon C5_5 through crystal chemistry followed by full geometry relaxations using calculations based on the quantum mechanics density functional theory DFT [9]. Analyzed through TopCryst, the fully geometry relaxed structure of C5_5 was found to be in an original topology within RCSR Database. The novel allotrope characterized with both sp2^2 and sp3^3 carbon hybridizations was found cohesive, and stable both mechanically and dynamically accompanied with large hardness magnitude slightly below diamond. It needs to be mentioned at this point that a mixed carbon hybridization (sp2^2 and sp3^3), cubic ‘pentadiamond’ was reported in 2020 as a novel allotrope with high mechanical properties close to diamond, but the paper was later retracted due to calculational errors on the mechanical properties admitted by the authors [10]. The relevance of mixed carbon hybridization is in the change of the electronic structure of insulating diamond, bringing metallic-like behaviors leading to applications.

After this contextual introduction (§ 1) and next § 2 reporting the computational framework, the crystal chemistry rationale leading to novel tetragonal C5_5 is discussed in § 3. § 4 is devoted to illustrating qualitatively the charge density projections on the atoms and between them. The mechanical and dynamic stabilities and properties are detailed in sections 5 and 6 respectively. The electronic band structures and density of states are discussed in § 7 with a concluding statement.

Computational framework

For the search for the ground state structures of the devised structures, geometry optimizations calculations onto the ground state with minimal energies were performed using DFT-based plane-wave Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP) [11, 12]. For the carbon atomic potential including valence states, the projector augmented wave (PAW) method was applied [12, 13]. Treating at the same level the exchange X and the correlation C, the exchange-correlation (XC) effects were considered using a generalized gradient approximation (GGA) [14]. The relaxation of the atoms onto ground state geometry was done applying a conjugate-gradient algorithm [14]. A tetrahedron method [15] with corrections made with Methfessel-Paxton scheme [16] was applied for geometry optimization and energy calculations. A special kk-point sampling [17] was applied for approximating the reciprocal space Brillouin-zone (BZ) integrals. For good reliability, the optimization of the structural parameters was carried out along with successive self-consistent cycles while increasing k-mesh until the forces on atoms were less than 0.02 eV/Å and the stress components below 0.003 eV/Å3^{3}.

Besides the elastic constants calculated to infer the mechanical stabilities and hardness, calculations of phonon dispersion curves were also carried out to verify the dynamic stability of the new carbon allotropes (template C3_3 and novel C5_5). For the purpose, the phonon modes were computed considering the harmonic approximation via finite displacements of the atoms around their equilibrium positions to obtain the forces from the summation over the different configurations. The phonon dispersion curves along the direction of the Brillouin zone are subsequently obtained using "Phonopy" interface code based on Python language [18]. Finally, the electronic band structures and density of states were obtained with the full-potential augmented spherical wave ASW method based on DFT using the same GGA scheme [19].

Crystal chemistry and characteristics of C5_5

Body center tetragonal C4_4 structure (Figure 1a) consists of two distinct carbon sites with 2-atoms occupancy: C1 at the corner and body center positions developing C4 tetrahedra with C2 positioned at the faces (Table 1a). We highlight that all lattice parameters of the structures in Table 1 result from unconstrained geometry optimizations to the energy ground states. The removal of the body center carbon breaks the body-center symmetry and leads to C3_3 where tetrahedra are at the 8 corners of the structure forming a two-dimensional like stacking along c-tetragonal direction (Figure 1b). Such modification leads to symmetry lowering and the space group changes from I4‾m2I\overline{4}m2, N°119 down to P4‾m2P\overline{4}m2, N°115. The second column of Table 1 shows C3C_3 crystal parameters with the Wyckoff positions. Both types of carbon atoms are labeled C1(tet)C1(\mathrm{tet}) and C2(tet)C2(\mathrm{tet}) in so far that they produce tetrahedral carbon. Expectedly, the volume and the interatomic distance decrease with the removal of one carbon.

C4_4 [6]C3_3C5_5
I‾4m2\overline{I}4m2, N°119P‾4m2\overline{P}4m2, N°115P‾4m2\overline{P}4m2, N°115
aa2.5272.5212.4786
cc3.5743.4025.0279
C1(tet.).(2a) 0, 0, 0(1a) 0, 0, 0(1a) 0, 0, 0
C2(tet.)(2d) ½, 0, ¼(2g) ½, 0, zz<br>zz = 0.237(2g) ½, 0, zz<br>zz = 0.187
C(trig.)--(2f) ½, ½, zz<br>zz = 0.646
Volume22.8221.6330.89
dC1(tet.)−C2(tet.)d_{\mathrm{C1(tet.)-C2(tet.)}}1.5471.501.55
dC2(tet.)−C2(trig.)d_{\mathrm{C2(tet.)-C2(trig.)}}-1.50
dC(trig)−C(trig.)d_{\mathrm{C(trig)-C(trig.)}}--1.46
Etotal.E_{\mathrm{total.}}-36.36-21.58-43.26
Ecoh./at.E_{\mathrm{coh./at.}}-2.49-0.59-2.05

Table 1. Tetragonal carbon crystal structure parameters: C4_4, C3_3, and C5_5. Lattice constants and distances are in units of Š(Volume in ų). Energies are in eV. Atomic energy of C: -6.6 eV

The last lines present the total energy and the atom averaged cohesive energies obtained from deducting the atomic contribution of a single C. From the atom-averaged cohesive energy there is a large destabilization of the diamond-like structure upon removal of central carbon to create hypothetical C3C_3 meant to be used as template to devise novel allotropes. Despite the small magnitude cohesive energy (Table 1) -versus the other allotropes in Table 1-, C3C_3 was found, nevertheless, as mechanically and dynamically stable from the sets of elastic constants and phonons band structures respectively, as detailed in the development of the paper.

Consequently, the following scheme is presented:

C3C_3 “receives”

  • one extra carbon to make C4C_4, already investigated [6],

    • C-C pair to make novel C5C_5 (shown in Figure 1c),

      • one additional carbon atom at cell center, based on C5C_5, to make C6C_6 introducing C-C-C, published as a structure in CCDC [21] for future developments.

The major difference between C4C_4 and C5C_5 is that whereas the central carbon is tetrahedral C(tet) completing the diamond-like edifice as discussed above, the two additional carbon atoms are labeled C(trig), “trig” standing for trigonal carbon shown with white spheres in Figure 1c. Alike C3C_3, the new allotrope C5C_5 belongs to P4‾m2P\overline{4}m2, N°115 space group (no body-center symmetry). The C(tet)-C(tet) interatomic distances are within range of C4C_4 (diamond-like) and smaller magnitudes are observed for d(Ctrig−Ctrig)=1.47 A˚\mathrm{d}(\mathrm{C}_{\mathrm{trig}}-\mathrm{C}_{\mathrm{trig}})=1.47\,\text{\AA}. Beside C-C single bonds for C(tet)-C(tet), we are in presence of additional double C=C bond-like, thus characterizing pentacarbon C5C_5 with sp2/sp3\mathrm{sp}^{2}/\mathrm{sp}^{3} hybridizations. The atom averaged cohesive energy is significantly larger than in C3C_3 with a magnitude closer to C4C_4.

Charge density projections

Further qualitative illustration of the different types of hybridizations is obtained from the projections of the charge densities around and between atoms. Figure 2 presents the projections. shown with yellow volumes. Upon crossing a crystal plane, charge density slices with red color are shown indicating strong charge localizations.

Figure 2. Charge density projections (yellow volumes) in a) C4_4, b) C3_3, and c) C5_5 White spheres represent trigonal C=C carbon pair.

In C4C_{4} (Figure 2a) the sp3\mathrm{sp}^{3}-type hybridization expected for C(tet)C(\mathrm{tet}) is clearly observed especially on central carbon with the yellow volumes taking the shape of a tetrahedron, and C4C_{4}, alike diamond, is a perfectly covalent chemical system. Upon removal of central carbon producing C3C_{3} with only C(tet)C(\mathrm{tet}) -cf. Table 1-, the charge density is modified especially for the carbon atoms pointing towards the empty space as it is exhibited by the larger red area versus C4C_{4}. Such behavior resembling dangling bonds is in line with the low cohesive C3C_{3}.

Larger changes are observed in C5C_{5} (Figure 2c) where the charge density (dangling bonds in C3C_{3}) is skewed towards the pair of C(trig)C(\mathrm{trig}) white spheres. The charge density in no more homogeneously distributed as in covalent C4C_{4}, and less pronounced red color is observed letting suggest a polar-covalent behavior normally usually found in compounds with different constituents’ electronegativities such as boron nitride BN. Therefore, we are presented with a decrease of the covalence from C4C_{4} to C5C_{5} brought by the introduction of trigonal carbon.

Mechanical properties from elastic constants

The investigation of mechanical properties was based on the calculations of the elastic properties determined by performing finite distortions of the lattice and deriving the elastic constants from the strain-stress relationship. Most compounds are polycrystalline, and generally considered as randomly oriented single crystalline grains. Consequently, on a large scale, such materials can be considered as statistically isotropic. They are then fully described by bulk (BB) and shear (GG) moduli obtained by averaging the single-crystal elastic constants. The method used here is Voigt's [22], based on a uniform strain. The calculated sets of elastic constants are given in Table 2; the elastic constants of C4C_{4} [6] are reported for the sake of comparison. While most elastic constants of C4C_{4} are larger than in C5C_{5}, it can be noted that C33C_{33} magnitude is slightly larger in C5C_{5}, concomitantly with aligned trigonal C-C along the c-tetragonal axis (cf. Figure 1c).

C11C_{11}C12C_{12}C13C_{13}C33C_{33}C44C_{44}C66C_{66}BVoigtB_{\mathrm{Voigt}}GVoigtG_{\mathrm{Voigt}}HVickersH_{\mathrm{Vickers}}
C4_4 [6]114728126105046155943457497
C5_591810122116919736139041481*
C5_589**
C3_3696203315510519111515

Table 2. Calculated elastic constants and bulk BVB_V and shear GVG_V moduli. Values are in units of GPa

The elastic constants of C3C_{3} exhibit a relatively large magnitude for in-plane C11C_{11} and much smaller magnitude for C33C_{33} relevant to inter-planes, i.e., along tetragonal c-direction. Both largest CiiC_{ii} (C11C_{11} and C33C_{33}) are smaller than the corresponding values in C5C_{5}. Indeed, the chemical system describing C3C_{3} is more relevant to two-dimensional 2D letting it receive interstitials as schematized in § 3, and hence leading to 3D C4C_{4}, C5C_{5}, C6C_{6} etc. All magnitudes of the other CijC_{ij}’s are very small letting expect a soft material. However, it will be shown that C3C_{3} is dynamically valid from the calculations of positive phonon frequencies in next section.

All CijC_{ij} (i=ji=j and i≠ji\ne j) values are positive and their combinations obey rules pertaining to the mechanical stability of the chemical system.

CiiC_{ii} (i=1,3,4,6i=1, 3, 4, 6) >0>0; C11>C12C_{11}>C_{12}, C11+C33−2C13>0C_{11}+C_{33}-2C_{13}>0; and 2C11+C33+2C12+4C13>02C_{11}+C_{33}+2C_{12}+4C_{13}>0.

The equations providing the bulk BVB_{\mathrm{V}} and shear GVG_{\mathrm{V}} moduli are as follows for the tetragonal system [23]:

BVoigttetr.=19(2C11+C33+2C12+4C13);B_{\mathrm{Voigt}}^{\mathrm{tetr.}} = \frac{1}{9}(2C_{11}+C_{33}+2C_{12}+4C_{13});

and

GVoigttetr.=115(2C11+C12+2C33−2C13+6C44+3C66).G_{\mathrm{Voigt}}^{\mathrm{tetr.}} = \frac{1}{15}(2C_{11}+C_{12}+2C_{33}-2C_{13}+6C_{44}+3C_{66}).

C4C_{4} has the largest BVB_{\mathrm{V}} and GVG_{\mathrm{V}}, close to the accepted values for diamond BV=445B_{\mathrm{V}}=445 GPa and GV=550G_{\mathrm{V}}=550 GPa [1]. The corresponding BVB_{\mathrm{V}} and GVG_{\mathrm{V}} magnitudes in C5C_{5} are slightly smaller but they remain high, oppositely to C3C_{3} which shows much smaller BVB_{\mathrm{V}} and GVG_{\mathrm{V}} magnitudes versus C5C_{5}.

From the calculated BVB_{\mathrm{V}} and GVG_{\mathrm{V}} we can predict the Vickers hardness HVH_{\mathrm{V}}, evaluated with the model of Chen et al. based on the bulk and shear moduli obtained from the elastic constants [24]. HVH_{\mathrm{V}} is formulated as follows:

HV=0.92(GV)1.137G0.708.H_{\mathrm{V}}=0.92\left(\frac{G}{V}\right)^{1.137}G^{0.708}.

The numerical values are given in the last column of Table 1. HV(C4)=97H_{\mathrm{V}}(C_{4})=97 GPa is a magnitude in agreement with the admitted values of diamond [1]. HV(C5)=81H_{\mathrm{V}}(C_{5})=81 GPa is found smaller than in C4C_{4}, but the large magnitude leads to announce C5C_{5} as ultra-hard carbon allotrope characterized with mixed carbon hybridizations. Lastly, HV(C3)=15H_{\mathrm{V}}(C_{3})=15 GPa letting describe it as a soft material.

It should be noted here that Chen et al. model is not the only one to calculate Vickers hardness. Using the thermodynamic model relying on the structure topology [25], HV(C5)=89H_{\mathrm{V}}(C_{5})=89 GPa, a magnitude close to the one obtained above and closer to diamond.

Dynamic properties from the phonons

Another criterion of stability is obtained from the phonons defined as quanta of vibrations; their energy is quantized through the Planck constant ‘hh’ used in its reduced form ℏ\hbar (ℏ=h/2π\hbar=h/2\pi) giving with the wave number ω\omega the phonons energy: E=ℏωE = \hbar\omega. Besides the novel allotropes C3\mathrm{C}_{3} and C5\mathrm{C}_{5} the phonon band structures of C4\mathrm{C}_{4} [6] are shown for the sake of comparison. Figure 3 shows the phonon bands. Along the horizontal direction, the bands run along the main lines of the tetragonal Brillouin zone (reciprocal kk- space). The vertical direction shows the frequencies given in units of terahertz (THz). Since no negative frequency magnitudes are observed, expectedly for formerly studied C4\mathrm{C}_{4}, but also for present C3\mathrm{C}_{3} and C5\mathrm{C}_{5}, all structures are considered as dynamically stable. There are 3N−33N-3 optical modes at higher energy than three acoustic modes which start from zero energy (ω=0\omega= 0) at the Γ\Gamma point, center of the Brillouin Zone, up to a few Terahertz. The acoustic modes correspond to the lattice rigid translation modes of the crystal (two transverse and one longitudinal). The remaining bands correspond to the acoustic modes and culminating at ω∼40\omega\sim40 THz in C4\mathrm{C}_{4} and C5\mathrm{C}_{5}, a magnitude observed for diamond by Raman spectroscopy [26], and only up to 34 in less stable C3\mathrm{C}_{3} (cf. Table 1). The phonons show the closeness of C5\mathrm{C}_{5} to C4\mathrm{C}_{4} regarding dynamic stability.

Figure 3. Phonons band structures of a) C₄ [6], b) C₃, and c) C₅

Electronic band structures and density of states

Using the crystal parameters in Table 1, the electronic bands structures shown in Figure 4 were obtained using the all-electrons DFT-based augmented spherical method (ASW) [20]. The bands develop along the main directions of the primitive tetragonal Brillouin zones. For diamond-like insulating C4\mathrm{C}_{4} (Figure 4a), the energy level along the vertical line is with respect to the top of the valence band (VB), EVE_{\mathrm{V}}. As a specific character of diamond, the band gap of C4\mathrm{C}_{4} is indirect along kzk_{z} between ΓVB\Gamma_{\mathrm{VB}} and ZCBZ_{\mathrm{CB}} with a magnitude close to 5 eV. Oppositely, C3\mathrm{C}_{3} (Figure 4b) and C5\mathrm{C}_{5} (Figure 4c) behave as metals with bands crossing the Fermi level EFE_{\mathrm{F}}. The delocalized π\pi electrons are likely responsible of the electronic conductivity.

Electronic band structures

Figure 4. Electronic band structures: a) C4C_4[6], b) C3C_3, c) C5C_5.

Concluding, with novel C5\mathrm{C}_{5} we are presented material with metallic-like mixed sp2\mathrm{sp}^{2}-sp3\mathrm{sp}^{3}-like carbon hybridizations with ultra-hard properties slightly below diamond.

Acknowledgments: I am grateful to Dr Vladimir Solozhenko Directeur de Recherche at CNRS-Paris for exchanges on the topic regarding ‘pentadiamond’, and the hardness properties of the C5_5 allotrope.

Author statement: I declare that conceptual, calculations and analyses are all mine and I have no conflict of interest with any other work or colleagues.

*Using Chen et al. model [24]

**Using Mukhanov et al. thermodynamic model [25].

Figures

References

  1. [1]V.V. Brazhkin, V.L. Solozhenko, Myths about new ultrahard phases: Why materials that are significantly superior to diamond in elastic moduli and hardness are impossible. J. Appl. Phys. 125, 130901 (2019).DOI
  2. [2]A.R. Oganov. Crystal structure prediction: reflections on present status and challenges. Faraday Discuss. 211, 643 (2018 ).DOI
  3. [3]R. Hoffmann, A. A. Kabanov, A. A. Golov, D. M. Proserpio. Homo Citans and Carbon Allotropes: For an Ethics of Citation. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 55, 10962–10976 (2016). & SACADA database (Samara Carbon Allotrope Database). www.sacada.infoDOI
  4. [6]S.F. Matar, V.L. Solozhenko. The simplest dense carbon allotrope: Ultra-hard body centered tetragonal C₄. J. Solid State Chem. 314, 123424 (2022) & Corrigendum to “The simplest dense carbon allotrope: Ultra-hard body-centered tetragonal C₄” https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jssc.2022.123587
  5. [7]A.P. Shevchenko, A.A. Shabalin, I.Yu. Karpukhin, and V.A. Blatov Topological representations of crystal structures: generation, analysis and implementation in the TopCryst system, Science and Technology of Advanced Materials: Methods, 2:1, 250-265 (2022).
  6. [8]O'Keeffe M., Peskov M. A., Ramsden S. J., Yaghi O. M. The reticular chemistry structure resource (RCSR) database of, and symbols for, crystal nets. Acc. Chem. Res. 41, 1782-1789 (2008).DOI
  7. [9]P. Hohenberg, W. Kohn, Inhomogeneous electron gas. Phys. Rev. B 136, 864-871 (1964); & W. Kohn, L.J. Sham, Self-consistent equations including exchange and correlation effects. Phys. Rev. A 140, 1133-1138 (1965).
  8. [10]Y. Fujii, M. Maruyama, N. Thanh Cuong, S. Okada. Pentadiamond: A Hard Carbon Allotrope of a Pentagonal Network of sp2 and sp3 C Atoms. Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 016001 (2020) & Retraction: Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 079901 (2020).DOI
  9. [11]G. Kresse, J. Furthmüller, Efficient iterative schemes for ab initio total-energy calculations using a plane-wave basis set. Phys. Rev. B 54 11169, (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9984901
  10. [12]G. Kresse, J. Joubert, From ultrasoft pseudopotentials to the projector augmented wave. Phys. Rev. B 59 1758-1775 (1999).DOI
  11. [13]P.E. Blöchl, Projector augmented wave method. Phys. Rev. B 50 (1994) 17953-17979.DOI
  12. [14]J. Perdew, K. Burke, M. Ernzerhof, The Generalized Gradient Approximation made simple. Phys. Rev. Lett. 77 3865-3868 (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10062328
  13. [15]W.H. Press, B.P. Flannery, S.A. Teukolsky, W.T. Vetterling, Numerical Recipes, 2nd ed. Cambridge University Press: New York, USA, 1986.
  14. [16]P.E. Blöchl, O. Jepsen, O.K. Anderson, Improved tetrahedron method for Brillouin-zone integrations. Phys. Rev. B 49 16223-16233 (1994)pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10010769
  15. [17]H.J. Monkhorst, J.D. Pack, Special k-points for Brillouin Zone integration. Phys. Rev. B 13 (1976) 5188-5192.DOI
  16. [18]A. Togo, I. Tanaka. First principles phonon calculations in materials science”, Scr. Mater., 108, 1-5 (2015).arxiv.org/abs/1506.08498
  17. [20]V. Eyert, Basic notions and applications of the augmented spherical wave method. Int. J. Quantum Chem. 77, 1007-1031 (2000).doi.org/10.1002/(sici)1097-461x(2000)77:6<1007::aid-qua8>3.0.co;2-u
  18. [21]S.F. Matar, CCDC 2208344: (Refcode NEQHUQ; name C6POLr), 2022. DOI:10.5517/ccdс.csd.cc2d3yxd
  19. [22]W. Voigt, Über die Beziehung zwischen den beiden Elasticitätsconstanten isotroper Körper. Annal. Phys. 274, 573-587 (1889).DOI
  20. [23]D.C. Wallace, Thermodynamics of crystals. New York, USA: John Wiley and Sons; 1972.DOI
  21. [24]Xing-Qiu Chen, Haiyang Niu, Dianzhong Li, Yiyi Li, Modeling hardness of polycrystalline materials and bulk metallic glasses, Intermetallics 19 1275–1281 (2011).DOI
  22. [25]Mukhanov, V.A., Kurakevych, O.O. & Solozhenko, V.L. The interrelation between hardness and compressibility of substances and their structure and thermodynamic properties. J. Superhard Mater. 30, 368–378 (2008). https://doi.org/10.3103/S1063457608060026
  23. [26]R.S. Krishnan, Raman spectrum of diamond, Nature 155 171 (1945).

Paper details

vlnc:W_zsktxuup
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents