WorksPhysics and Astronomy
On the association of secondary hairpin growth and surface pressure gradient for oscillating foils
Abstract
The correspondence of secondary spanwise structures and pressure gradient is numerically evaluated for a foil, performing heaving and pitching motion, at a range of phase offsets (90 270) and reduced frequency (0.32 0.56). The Reynolds number is 8000. The wake is shown to be dominated by secondary hairpin-like structures that are formed due to an elliptic instability prompted by the paired primary and secondary leading edge vortex (). The weaker secondary undergoes a core deformation, resulting in streamwise vorticity outflux across the span of the foil, and hence, the growth of hairpin-like structures. Evaluating pressure gradients on the surface of the foil reveals a unique fundamental measure to quantitatively characterize the growth of these coherent structures. Their dominant presence can be directly linked to the growth of the secondary formed due to the large-scale interactions under localized adverse pressure gradients. These promote a streamwise flow compression in neighboring regions of the primary . This association also presents a vivid consistency across a range of kinematics. Therefore, this correspondence provides a novel procedure to investigate the mechanisms involved in the formation of secondary structures in the wake of an oscillating foil.
Banner appropriate to article type will appear here in typeset article
Introduction
Formation of vortices and evolution of complex wakes behind an oscillating foil has been the focus of many researchers in the fluid dynamics community. Their studies have enriched our understanding of efficient propulsive locomotion and flow control mechanisms employed by biological swimmers and flyers [2, 19, 17]. The influence of complex kinematics, such as coupled heaving and pitching oscillation, on the vortex enhancement and diffusion in the wake requires more detailed investigation [23]. These foils are largely considered as propulsors, bio-mimicking the motion of underwater swimmers and aerial flyers [20]. The mechanisms of evolution in the wake of marine swimmers (e.g. batoid fish) and micro flyers are critical in developing propulsive techniques that relate to the reduction of noise propagation [13]. The associated instabilities of s are further exploited to promote turbulence and early diffusion of large scale coherent structures [8]. Such mechanisms play a critical role in the advancement of technologies that particularly reduce wake hazards behind aircraft [8] (Moriche et al. 2016).
Recent studies have also established an association between the growth of secondary hairpin-like vortex structures and kinematics of foils, undergoing combined heaving and pitching motion [23, 21]. The transition from heave to pitch dominated kinematics coincides with changes in the flow mechanism that contributes towards the growth of hairpin-like secondary structures, or their absence [21]. At increased chord- and amplitude-based Strouhal numbers ( and ), the stronger deformation of primary s were also discussed previously [3, 23, 18], although an association with secondary structures is not entirely clear. In this study, we advance the fundamental knowledge about the formation of secondary hairpin-like structures at a range of kinematic parameters by evaluating the distribution of streamwise surface pressure gradients on an oscillating foil.
Verma & Hemmati [23] provided a comprehensive three-dimensional wake evolution process for an infinitely span foil oscillating with a coupled heaving and pitching motion. The distribution of the coefficient of pressure () at low and high reveal the onset of elliptic instability mechanism for pairs of counter-rotating vortices of unequal strength [9, 14]. At high , dominant secondary hairpin-like structures are observed, whose origins are considered to be associated with core vorticity outflux [10] of dipole rollers shed in the wake. Recently, Verma & Hemmati (2023b) reported novel findings related to the growth mechanisms and presence of secondary hairpin-like vortex arrangement at a constant . The phase offset () between heaving and pitching motion varied in the range of to . The profiles of reveal the presence of a paired primary and secondary roller arrangement, leading to an elliptic instability mechanism [8], and thereby promote an outflux of core vorticity from the weaker secondary [21]. This subsequently leads to thin streamwise vorticity filaments, which ultimately extend to form an arrangement of hairpin-like secondary structure in the wake [10]. Similar assessments that employed pressure measurements on wings with finite aspect ratios [6] are largely focused on the dominant spanwise instability characteristics, e.g., wavelength of undulating s prior to their separation from wings. The association of pressure distribution and the growth of secondary hairpin-like structures, however, remains unknown in the current literature.
In this study, we explain a fundamental association and quantified links between streamwise gradients of pressure, calculated on the boundary of the foil, and the formation of secondary hairpin-like vortical structures, which were recently discussed by Verma & Hemmati [21]. The findings are extended to a range of kinematics in order to ensure a wider applicability of the association between evolution of secondary wake structures and pressure gradients on an oscillating foil.
Problem Description
The flow around an infinitely span (2D) foil with a maximum thickness () to chord length () ratio of is examined numerically for a range of chord-based () and amplitude-based Strouhal numbers (). Andersen et al. [1] indicated that significant transitions in the wake of flapping foils were observable at . It also coincides with the range corresponding to the optimal propulsive efficiency in swimming mammals [19, 17]. The cross section of the foil shown in Figure 1 resembles a teardrop hydrofoil shape, which was used in recent experimental investigations [5, 20]. The Reynolds number is , which is consistent with previous studies in this area [23, 21], and agrees closely with the biological characteristics of swimming fish [2, 17]. Here, and represent the freestream velocity and kinematic viscosity of the fluid, respectively.
Figure 1. Schematic of the foil geometry and motion.
The kinematics of the foil is prescribed by a coupled heaving and pitching motion, where the pitch axis is located at approximately from the leading edge. Figure 1 marks the heave and pitch amplitudes as and , respectively. The resultant trailing edge amplitude is also shown as . The motion profiles of heave () and pitch (), where pitching has a phase advancement (or offset) of relative to heaving, are represented as and , respectively.
In order to present a broader association of secondary wake structures (hairpin-like), surface pressure gradient, and kinematics of the foil, we also vary the phase offset () between heaving and pitching motion in the range of and . This leads to changes in relative to a fixed () and (Verma & Hemmati 2022). It is important to note that the most propulsively efficient phase offset corresponds to in our study, following the reference coordinate system employed by Van Buren et al. [20].
Computational Method
The continuity and Navier-Stokes equations are solved directly using OpenFOAM, which is a numerical package based on the finite-volume method. This platform is extensively used for simulating wake dynamics behind oscillating foils and panels [16, 23]. Kinematics of the oscillatory foil is modeled using Overset Grid Assembly (OGA) method, based on a stationary background grid and a moving overset grid that are merged for the simulation [15]. More details of the method can be found in Verma & Hemmati [22, 23] (2022).
The computational domain is also presented in Figure 1, which highlights the C-type overset boundary containing the foil. The boundary conditions at the inlet are prescribed a uniform fixed velocity (Dirichlet) and a zero normal gradient (Neumann) for pressure. At the outlet, a zero-gradient outflow boundary condition is implied [4]. The top and bottom walls are further prescribed a slip boundary condition that effectively model open-channel or free-surface flows, and closely resemble the experimental and computational conditions of Van Buren et al. [20] and Hemmati et al. [7], respectively. At the boundary of the foil, a no-slip condition for velocity and a zero-gradient condition for pressure is ensured. The periodic boundary condition is further implemented on the side boundaries, coinciding with the spanwise extent of the foil. It provides an effective way to model flows over bodies with infinite spans without the end or tip effects.
A spatial convergence analysis is completed at , , , and . This enables comparative evaluation of the numerical results with respect to experiments of Van Buren et al. [20]. Table 1 summarizes the grid convergence results involving three grids, Grid1, Grid2 and Grid3. The ratio () of minimum grid size element () to Kolmogorov scale () is kept approximately below 10 within the critical region near the foil (), specifically for Grid2 and Grid3 (see Table 1). This region corresponds to the origin of spanwise instability and secondary structures that emerge and grow with the wake evolution (Verma & Hemmati [23, 21]). The relative error in prediction of (), calculated with respect to the experimental results of Van Buren et al. [20], is below 5% for Grid2. Similarly, , calculated with respect to the finest grid (Grid3), is below 0.1%. The corresponding experimental results for are not yet available. This agreement in results provide sufficient confidence in Grid2 for our analysis. For more details on grid convergence, readers are referred to Verma & Hemmati [21]. Details for verification and validation of the numerical solver, with respect to the domain size, spatial and temporal grid, OGA solver, and boundary conditions, can be found in Hemmati et al. [7], Verma & Hemmati [22], Verma & Hemmati [23] and Verma & Hemmati [21].
| Study | |||||||||
| Grid1 | 0.64 | 2.86 | 0.084 | 0.010 | 7.3 | 16.9 | 55.2 | ||
| Grid2 | 0.60 | 2.84 | 0.017 | 0.003 | 3.7 | 8.5 | 15.8 | ||
| Grid3 | 0.59 | 2.83 | 0.001 | - | 1.8 | 4.2 | 7.9 | ||
| Exp. | - | 0.59 | - | - | - | - | - | - |
Table 1. Grid refinement details for the current study. represents the sum of hexahedral elements in background grid and overset grid.
The simulations are completed using Cedar and Narval high performance clusters, operated by Digital Research Alliance of Canada. The parallel decomposition and assignment of computational domain utilizes 96 CPUs with a total of 190 GB memory and 1440 simulation hours per case.
Results & Discussion
We begin with a brief discussion of the growth of secondary hairpin-like structures over the span of the foil for a range of kinematic conditions of the oscillating foil. It is followed by a detailed discussion of streamwise pressure gradients on the boundary of the foil and its association with the primary and secondary structures. The implications of varying and on this novel finding is further highlighted, which provides sufficient confidence in employing streamwise pressure gradient as a unique quantitative measure to explain the evolution of secondary hairpin-like formations in the wake of an oscillating foil.
Formation of secondary hairpin-like structures
Verma & Hemmati [21] recently discussed the mechanisms that contribute to the growth of secondary hairpin-like structures. Here, we provide only a brief description of the wake dynamics explored by Verma & Hemmati [21] to set the stage for our main analysis. At a range of increasing (), a paired primary and secondary with unequal strengths are formed at , which lead to an elliptic instability of vortex cores [9, 8]. This subsequently promote the outflux of vorticity from the weaker secondary . The shear straining on account of the primary further leads to the streamwise extension of thin hairpin-like filaments that subsequently form the dominant hairpin-like arrangement in the wake. As increases to , however, the dominant hairpin-like arrangement fails to originate from an instability of the pair of primary and secondary . Rather, the primary paired with the promotes the elliptic instability of the vortex cores. Hairpin-like structures are subsequently formed through a deformed core, in contrast to the observations noted at . The wake at and lacks any secondary structure formation, which is associated with the decreased strength of corresponding primary [21].
We further evaluate the formation of secondary hairpin-like structures at a similar range of , while increasing from 0.32 to 0.56. The results (refer to the supplementary online material) confirm that at , and the entire range of examined here, the wake is characterized by the formation of secondary hairpin-like structures. These follow the mechanism of elliptic core instability triggered by a pair of primary and secondary . However, for and at the onset of pitch-dominated kinematics (i.e. –), the wake either depicts a dominant hairpin-like formation, through the deformed core, or a complete absence of them.
We expand on these wake dynamics by evaluating a unique quantitative measure, in terms of streamwise pressure gradient that enable us to understand and relate the mechanism of secondary hairpin-like growth with transitioning kinematics of an oscillating foil.
Secondary structures and streamwise pressure gradients
We employ a span-averaged estimation of the coefficient of pressure () over the boundary of the foil during a half oscillation cycle. The selected kinematic setting corresponds to and , although the discussion and mechanisms remain consistent for the entire parameter space presented in § 1.1. In order to provide a qualitative outlook on the formation of the vortices, Figure 2(a-Figure 2c) provides an instantaneous snapshot of s formed over the surface of the foil at first three quarters of the oscillation cycle (i.e. , 0.25 and 0.5). The dominant vortical structures are identified using criterion () following the study of Verma & Hemmati [21]. The arrangement of and at reflects a pair of unequal strength (Figure 2(a)), which subsequently triggers an elliptic instability of the vortex core (Leweke et al. [8]). The undulations on are enhanced at t^+ = 0.5 (Figure 2(c)), the growth of secondary hairpin-like structures is evident as a result of core vorticity outflux from the secondary (Mittal & Balachandar [10]). The instantaneous pressure signatures, corresponding to the s identified in Figure 2, are averaged across the span and subsequently employed for calculating the streamwise pressure gradient ().
Figure 2. Vortex formation (primary and secondary ) and secondary hairpin-like evolution over the foil boundary at and . The time instants correspond to (a) , (b) and (c) . The structures correspond to and are colored using spanwise vorticity ().
In order to evaluate an association between and the evolution of secondary hairpin-like structures through the secondary (Verma & Hemmati [21]), we initially evaluate the observations relevant to the case exhibited in Figure 2. Figure 3(a-Figure 3c) depicts the profiles of at first three quarter instants (, 0.25 and 0.5) of the oscillation cycle, where the paired primary and secondary are dominant. The pressure minima that coincide with the presence of the primary is highlighted in Figure 3(a). The onset of the secondary is also marked, which is characterized by a sharp change in the profile of . Obabko & Cassel [12] provided a quantitative interpretation with regards to the formation of the secondary re-circulation zone in the neighborhood of a thick vortex core. Particularly, the discussion highlights the contribution of large-scale interactions in the formation of re-circulation zones. These are associated with the streamwise compression of the flow due to the existence of localized adverse pressure gradients (Obabko & Cassel [12]).

Figure 3. Span averaged profiles for and . The time instants correspond to (a) , (b) and (c) .
To follow along the discussion of Obabko & Cassel [12], it is evident that a sudden rise from the minima of (coincident with ) occurs towards a positive . Hence, this region featuring a localized adverse pressure gradient is associated with the formation of , similar to the observations highlighted by Obabko & Cassel [12] with regards to the secondary re-circulation zone. The presence of can also be observed at $t^+ = 0.25 in Figure 3(b). Further ahead in the oscillation cycle at , a faded signature with regards to becomes evident, which also coincides with the formation of secondary hairpin-like structures through the outflux of core vorticity from the secondary (see Figure 2(c)). This is in contrast to the observations of Obabko & Cassel [12], which indicates an increase in the magnitude of drop in , corresponding to the secondary re-circulation zone. Hence, based on the above observations, it is reasonable to discuss a plausible association between the variations of and the coincident transformation of the secondary to hairpin-like vortices.
To address this association for a wider kinematic setting, evaluations are now discussed for different values of and , within the range specified in § 1.1. Figure 4 exhibits the profiles of span-averaged along the chord of the foil for and increasing from 0.32 to 0.56. The presented time instants correspond to and 0.25, respectively. The cases that feature the growth of secondary hairpin-like structures from the secondary demonstrate a sharp change in , as it increases from the local minima corresponding to the primary . Further ahead in the cycle (), the changes diminish as secondary hairpin-like structures grow out of the secondary . For kinematics characterized by heave-domination at , this characteristic association between secondary hairpin-like evolution and is consistent in the range of increasing .

Figure 4. Span averaged profiles for and increasing . The straight — and dashed – – lines corresponds to and , respectively.
Figure 5(a-Figure 5c) shows the variations of span-averaged for , and , respectively. The observations for demonstrates sharp changes in only at . This also coincides with the qualitative results similar to those presented in Figure 2, which highlight the evolution of secondary hairpin-like structures from the secondary at similar kinematics. For and , observations at suggest that the dominant secondary hairpin-like structures are associated with the instability triggered by the pair of , rather than a pair of primary and secondary . In order to further illustrate this mechanism, we look at the wake visualization in Figure 6(a-Figure 6c). These plots qualitatively depicts the formation of dominant secondary hairpin-like structures through a pair at and [21]. The secondary (marked as ) at in Figure 6(b) appears much weaker and diffused, which only results in the growth of thin hairpin-like flow structures at (see Figure 6(c)). These structures soon lose their coherence due to diffusion in the near wake (Figure 6(d)). However, the dominant secondary hairpin-like arrangement emerged from the core vorticity outflux of , as seen in Figure 6(d). The dominant hairpin-like arrangement in the wake in Figure 6(a), are formed on account of the instability. We observe that the trends of increasing for such cases also appear flatter and closer to zero, which reflects a low streamwise flow compression, and thus the absence of a strong secondary .
Figure 5. Span averaged profiles for (a) , (b) and (c) . The straight and dashed lines corresponds to and , respectively.

Figure 6. Vortex formation (primary and secondary ) and secondary hairpin-like evolution over the foil boundary at and . The time instants correspond to (a) , (b) , (c) and (d) . The structures correspond to and are colored using spanwise vorticity ().
To further understand the role of in quantitative characterization of the evolution of secondary hairpin-like structures, we calculate the slope of with respect to the streamwise distance along the foil. These estimates are further focused on a localized region
that features the rise from a pressure minima (marked by blue dotted square in Figure 4 and Figure 5), coinciding with the primary structures. It provides an indicative measure for the increasing streamwise flow compression as increases, and hence expands on the association of and the growth of secondary hairpin-like structures. Figure 7 demonstrates the variation in the slope of for every kinematic setting considered in this study. Here, the slope is computed as the ratio of and , where represents the magnitude of increasing (marked in Figure 4), and denotes the relative streamwise distance between the minima and local maxima following the rise of . With increasing , the slope of increases in Figure 7. It suggests an environment of larger adverse pressure gradient and a stronger streamwise flow compression, which further coincides with a consistent secondary hairpin-like evolution from the secondary , as becomes greater than 0.48.

Figure 7. Variation of slope () with and .
The novel association described above presents a very useful quantitative tool in characterization of the changes in mechanisms that govern the growth of secondary spanwise structures. These particularly coincide with changes in kinematics of an oscillating foil from heave- to onset of pitch-domination. For example, [21] recently investigated and discussed such transitions, namely, Series and Series . The trends for explained in this study accurately quantifies the identification of these transitions. Particularly, the increasing slope of with increasing coincides with the growth of secondary hairpin-like structures through a primary and secondary pair (i.e. Mechanism “1” in [21]), which also coincides with the Series transition at different [21].
Conclusion
A fundamental association between the evolution of secondary structures, in the form of a spanwise hairpin-like arrangement, and the pressure gradient along the streamwise flow is computationally investigated for the case of infinitely span oscillating foils. Under large adverse gradients, a stronger streamwise flow compression promotes the formation of a dominant secondary in the neighborhood of the paired primary . The growth of the secondary leads to an elliptic instability mechanism [8], resulting in a core vorticity outflux from the secondary , and a subsequent growth of secondary hairpin-like structures. The highlighted association is consistent across the range of increasing and , and thus reflects a unique quantitative measure of the growth of secondary wake structures behind oscillating foils.
Funding. This research has received support from the Canada First Research Excellence Grant. The computational analysis was completed using Compute Canada clusters.
Declaration of Interests. The authors report no conflict of interest.
References
- [1]Andersen, A., Bohr, T., Schnipper, T. & Walther, J. H. 2017 Wake structure and thrust generation of a flapping foil in two-dimensional flow. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 812, R4.DOI
- [2]Anderson, J. M., Streitlien, K., Barrett, D. S. & Triantafyllou, M. S. 1998 Oscillating foils of high propulsive efficiency. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 360, 41–72.DOI
- [3]Chiereghin, N., Bull, S., Cleaver, D. J. & Gursul, I. 2020 Three-dimensionality of leading-edge vortices on high aspect ratio plunging wings. Phys. Rev. Fluids 5, 064701.DOI
- [4]Deng, Jian & Caulfield, C. P. 2015 Three-dimensional transition after wake deflection behind a flapping foil. Physical Review E - Statistical, Nonlinear, and Soft Matter Physics .pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25974590
- [5]Floryan, Daniel, Van Buren, Tyler, Rowley, Clarence W. & Smits, Alexander J. 2017 Scaling the propulsive performance of heaving and pitching foils. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 822, 386–397, arXiv: 1704.07478.DOI
- [6]Hammer, Patrick R., Garmann, Daniel J. & Visbal, Miguel R. 2022 Effect of aspect ratio on finite-wing dynamic stall. AIAA Journal 0 (0), 1–13.DOI
- [7]Hemmati, Arman, Van Buren, Tyler & Smits, Alexander J. 2019 Effects of trailing edge shape on vortex formation by pitching panels of small aspect ratio. Physical Review Fluids 4, 033101.DOI
- [8]Leweke, Thomas, Le Dizès, Stéphane & Williamson, Charles H.K. 2016 Dynamics and Instabilities of Vortex Pairs.DOI
- [9]Leweke, T. & Williamson, C. H.K. 1998 Cooperative elliptic instability of a vortex pair. Journal of Fluid Mechanics .DOI
- [10]Mittal, R. & Balachandar, S. 1995 Generation of streamwise vortical structures in bluff body wakes. Physical Review Letters .pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10060258
- [13]Ortega, J. M., Bristol, R. L. & Savas, Ö. 2003 Experimental study of the instability of unequal-strength counter-rotating vortex pairs. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 474 (474), 35–84.DOI
- [14]Ortega, Jason M. & Savas, Ömer 2001 Rapidly growing instability mode in trailing multiple-vortex wakes. AIAA Journal 39 (4), 750–754, arXiv: https://doi.org/10.2514/2.1375.
- [15]Petra, T. 2019 In Description of the overset mesh approach in ESI version of OpenFOAM. Proceedings of the CFD with OpenSource Software, Nilsson, H., Ed.; Chalmers University of Technology: Gothenburg, Sweden.
- [16]Senturk, Utku & Smits, Alexander J. 2019 Reynolds number scaling of the propulsive performance of a pitching airfoil. AIAA Journal 57, 2663–2669.DOI
- [17]Smits, Alexander J. 2019 Undulatory and oscillatory swimming. J. of Fluid Mechanics 874, P1.DOI
- [18]Son, O., Gao, A.-K., Gursul, I., Cantwell, C.D., Wang, Z. & Sherwin, S.J. 2022 Leading-edge vortex dynamics on plunging airfoils and wings. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 940, A28.DOI
- [19]Triantafyllou, M. S., Hover, F. S., Techet, A. H. & Yue, D. K.P. 2005 Review of hydrodynamic scaling laws in aquatic locomotion and fishlike swimming. In Applied Mechanics Reviews, , vol. 58, pp. 226–237.DOI
- [20]Van Buren, Tyler, Floryan, Daniel & Smits, Alexander J. 2018 Scaling and Performance of Simultaneously Heaving and Pitching Foils. https://doi.org/10.2514/1.J056635 57 (9), 3666–3677, arXiv: 1801.07625.
- [21]Verma, Suyash, M.S.U Khalid & Hemmati, Arman 2023a On the association of kinematics, spanwise instability and growth of secondary vortex structures in the wake of oscillating foils. arxiv (submitted) .arxiv.org/abs/2307.05788
- [22]Verma, Suyash & Hemmati, Arman 2020 Performance of overset mesh in modeling the wake of sharp-edge bodies. Computations 8, 66.DOI
- [23]Verma, Suyash & Hemmati, Arman 2021 Evolution of wake structures behind oscillating hydrofoils with combined heaving and pitching motion. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 927, A23.DOI
