betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The Cosmology of Hawking Axions

Abstract

Since primordial black holes (PBH) are always non-relativistic, their cosmological energy fraction grows relative to that of radiation. Thus, for even a tiny initial PBH abundance, the universe generically enters an epoch of early matter domination, which ends when the PBH evaporate to restore the hot big bang. We consider the possibility that a PBH dominated era yields a population of boosted axion-like particles (ALPs) produced from Hawking evaporation. Eventually these ``Hawking axions" become non-relativistic and decay to photons, which can affect various cosmological and astrophysical observables. Here we place new constraints on these particles through their impact on big bang nucleosynthesis, cosmic microwave background, large-scale structure, and X-ray observables. Furthermore, if Hawking axions remain relativistic through recombination, then depending on the progenitor PBH mass, they contribute ΔNeff≃0.05ΔN_{\rm eff}\simeq0.05-0.110.11, which may be observable with future CMB probes.

Primordial black hole (PBH) domination is a compelling and highly-predictive cosmological scenario. Since PBHs always redshift like non-relativistic matter, their energy fraction grows during radiation domination, so the early universe generically becomes PBH dominated unless their initial abundance is extremely fine-tuned. This epoch ends when the PBH evaporate and their Hawking radiation thermalizes to restore radiation domination; nearly all predictions that result from this scenario depend only on the initial PBH mass. For initial masses M≲109M \lesssim10^9 g, evaporation occurs before big bang nucleosynthesis (BBN), so this cosmology is largely unconstrained.

By the equivalence principle, Hawking evaporation produces all known and unknown particle species. Since Standard Model (SM) particles have appreciable interactions, they promptly thermalize after PBH evaporation, so information about their origins is erased. However, if a new feebly-coupled species were to be produced, it might avoid thermalization with the SM plasma, and thereby retain information from PBH domination as a “Hawking relic” [1, 2, 3]. Depending on their mass, Hawking relics can be dark matter candidates [1, 4], increase the effective number of relativistic species [1], or suppress the growth of structure, in analogy with SM neutrinos [3]. If Hawking relics couple to photons, light ones can convert into X-rays in cosmic magnetic fields, contributing to the cosmic X-ray background (CXB), while heavier ones decay into photon pairs and can alter ionization [5].

In this paper, we systematically analyze the electromagnetic decays of Hawking relic that decay to SM particles and thereby affect cosmological and astrophysical observables (see Figure 1). Following Ref. [5], without loss of generality, we focus on so-called “Hawking axions”: axion-like particles (ALPs), which are produced via Hawking radiation during PBH domination and eventually decay into photon pairs through the interaction

Schematic illustration of the cosmology studied here

Figure 1. Schematic illustration of the cosmology studied here. An early epoch of PBH domination ends when Hawking evaporation reheats the universe and SM particles thermalize. If a feebly coupled ALP (aa) is produced in the evaporation, it can avoid thermalization and decay through its photon coupling at late times, yielding cosmological and astrophysical signatures.

L⊃−gaγγ4aFμνF~μν,Γa=gaγγ2ma364π(1)\mathcal{L} \supset-\frac{g_{a\gamma\gamma}}{4}aF_{\mu\nu}\widetilde{F}^{\mu\nu}, \qquad\Gamma_a = \frac{g_{a\gamma\gamma}^2m_a^3}{64\pi} \tag*{(1)}

where aa is the ALP field of mass mam_a, gaγγg_{a\gamma\gamma} is its photon coupling, and FμνF_{\mu\nu} is the electromagnetic field strength and F~μν\widetilde{F}^{\mu\nu} its dual, and Γa\Gamma_a is the a→γγa \to\gamma\gamma decay width in the ALP rest frame. Here we calculate the cosmological ALP abundance produced via Hawking radiation and track its impact on BBN, CMB, structure formation, and X-ray observables. Our analysis significantly extends the results of Ref. [5] to include a range of cosmological bounds.

Background Cosmology. We consider a monochromatic population of Schwarzschild PBHs with initial mass MiM_i, which dominate the energy density and evaporate before BBN. This limits the PBH mass range to 1 g≲Mi≲5×108 g1\,\mathrm{g}\lesssim M_i\lesssim5\times10^8\,\mathrm{g}, where the lower limit follows from requiring the PBHs to form after inflation [6] and the upper limit ensures that they have evaporated before BBN [7]. If we sum over SM species, the Hawking mass-loss rate scales as

dMdt=−Gg⋆,H(TBH)30720πG2M2,TBH=18πGM,(2)\frac{dM}{dt}=-\frac{\mathcal{G}g_{\star,H}(T_{\mathrm{BH}})}{30720\pi G^2M^2},\qquad T_{\mathrm{BH}}=\frac{1}{8\pi GM}, \tag*{(2)}

where TBHT_{\mathrm{BH}} is the Hawking temperature, GG is the Newton constant, G≃3.8\mathcal{G}\simeq3.8 is the graybody factor, and g⋆,Hg_{\star,H} is the spin-weighted number of relativistic degrees of freedom, with g⋆,H≃108g_{\star,H}\simeq108 for the SM [1].

The background evolves according to

ρ˙BH+3HρBH=M˙MρBH,ρ˙R+4HρR=−M˙MρBH,(3)\dot{\rho}_{\mathrm{BH}}+3H\rho_{\mathrm{BH}}=\frac{\dot M}{M}\rho_{\mathrm{BH}},\qquad\dot{\rho}_{R}+4H\rho_R=-\frac{\dot M}{M}\rho_{\mathrm{BH}}, \tag*{(3)}

where ρR=π2g⋆T4/30\rho_R=\pi^2g_\star T^4/30 is the SM radiation density, g⋆g_\star is the effective number of relativistic species, ρBH\rho_{\mathrm{BH}} is the PBH density, and H2∝(ρBH+ρR)H^2\propto(\rho_{\mathrm{BH}}+\rho_R) is the Hubble rate. Since PBH domination is an attractor solution for even a tiny initial abundance [1], we assume the initial conditions: ρR,i=0\rho_{R,i}=0 and ρBH,i=3Hi2/(8πG)\rho_{\mathrm{BH},i}=3H_i^2/(8\pi G), noting that the system is insensitive to the latter condition for sufficiently large values of HiH_i. When the PBH evaporate, the universe is reheated to a temperature [1]

TRH≃50 MeV(108 gMi)3/2(14g⋆)1/4(g⋆,H108)1/2,(4)T_{\mathrm{RH}}\simeq50\,\mathrm{MeV}\left(\frac{10^8\,\mathrm{g}}{M_i}\right)^{3/2}\left(\frac{14}{g_\star}\right)^{1/4}\left(\frac{g_{\star,H}}{108}\right)^{1/2}, \tag*{(4)}

where g⋆,Hg_{\star,H} and g⋆g_\star are evaluated at TBH,i=(8πGMi)−1T_{\mathrm{BH},i}=(8\pi GM_i)^{-1} and TRHT_{\mathrm{RH}}, respectively, and we have used the instantaneous evaporation approximation, though in our main results we solve Eq. (3) numerically.

Hawking Axion Population

For ALP production, the instantaneous Hawking spectrum is

d2NadEa dt=12πΓ0(Ea,M)exp⁡[Ea/TBH]−1,(5)\frac{d^2N_a}{dE_a\,dt}=\frac{1}{2\pi}\frac{\Gamma_0(E_a,M)}{\exp[E_a/T_{\mathrm{BH}}]-1}, \tag*{(5)}

where TBHT_{\mathrm{BH}} is the Hawking temperature of a black hole with instantaneous mass MM, Γ0\Gamma_0 is the dimensionless spin-zero graybody factor, and Ea=p2+ma2E_a=\sqrt{p^2+m_a^2}. We integrate Eq. (5) from PBH formation1 at tft_f until complete evaporation at tevt_{\mathrm{ev}}, while evolving Eq. (3) through reheating.

Since the Hawking temperature increases as the PBH loses its mass, the resulting spectrum produces a hard power-law tail that is absent in a fixed mass approximation. The result is the comoving ALP distribution fa(q)=dn~a/dqf_a(q)=d\tilde n_a/dq, with q=apq=ap, where aa is the scale factor normalized according to a0=1a_0=1:

fa(q)≃n~BH∫0tevdta(t)pEad2NadEa dt∣p=q/a(t),(6)f_a(q)\simeq\tilde n_{\mathrm{BH}}\int_0^{t_{\mathrm{ev}}}\frac{dt}{a(t)}\frac{p}{E_a}\left.\frac{d^2N_a}{dE_a\,dt}\right|_{p=q/a(t)}, \tag*{(6)}

where 1/a1/a and p/Eap/E_a are the comoving momentum and massive particle Jacobians and we have taken tf≪tevt_f\ll t_{\mathrm{ev}}. limit. The comoving PBH density n~BH=a3nBH\tilde{n}_{\mathrm{BH}} = a^3 n_{\mathrm{BH}} is fixed by the same background and reheating solution, so faf_a already contains both the PBH abundance and the ALP yield per PBH, so no additional normalization is needed in the photon flux. We then use numerical scalar graybody factors throughout and keep the geometric optics approximation Γ0→27G2M2Ea2\Gamma_0 \to27G^2M^2E_a^2 only as an analytic cross-check [8, 9]. Details of the PBH background, the attractor solution, and the phase space calculation are given in the Supplemental Material.

Propagation and photon signal. After evaporation ends at the reheating redshift zRHz_{\mathrm{RH}}, the ALPs free stream with fixed comoving momentum qq, so that p(q,z)=q(1+z)p(q,z) = q(1+z) and Ea(q,z)=p(q,z)2+ma2E_a(q,z) = \sqrt{p(q,z)^2 + m_a^2}. In the frame of a comoving observer, the decay rate is Γa/γa(q,z)\Gamma_a/\gamma_a(q,z), with γa=Ea/ma\gamma_a = E_a/m_a, and the probability that an ALP survives from zRHz_{\mathrm{RH}} to zz is

Sa(q,z)=exp⁡[−∫zzRHdz′(1+z′)H(z′)Γaγa(q,z′)].(7)S_a(q,z) = \exp\left[-\int_z^{z_{\mathrm{RH}}} \frac{dz'}{(1+z')H(z')} \frac{\Gamma_a}{\gamma_a(q,z')}\right]. \tag*{(7)}

As the momentum redshifts, the Lorentz factor decreases and the decay rate in this frame grows. Since the decay in the ALP rest frame is isotropic, a single decay produces a box spectrum in the comoving frame,

Kγ(Eγ;q,z)=2pΘ(Eγ−E−)Θ(E+−Eγ),(8)K_\gamma(E_\gamma;q,z) = \frac{2}{p}\Theta(E_\gamma-E_-)\Theta(E_+-E_\gamma), \tag*{(8)}

where E±=12(Ea±p)E_\pm= \frac{1}{2}(E_a \pm p) and Kγ→2δ(Eγ−12ma)K_\gamma\to2\delta(E_\gamma-\frac{1}{2}m_a) in the nonrelativistic limit. Combining Eqs. (7) and (8) with the distribution of Eq. (6) gives the comoving photon emissivity, the number of photons produced per unit time, energy, and comoving volume,

Q^γ(Eγ,z)=Γa∫0∞dq fa(q)γa(q,z)Sa(q,z)Kγ(Eγ;q,z).(9)\hat{Q}_\gamma(E_\gamma,z) = \Gamma_a \int_0^\infty\frac{dq\,f_a(q)}{\gamma_a(q,z)} S_a(q,z)K_\gamma(E_\gamma;q,z). \tag*{(9)}

We describe photon attenuation between emission at redshift zz and observation today by e−τγ(E0,z)e^{-\tau_\gamma(E_0,z)}, with the optical depth evaluated for a photon observed at energy E0E_0. The present-day differential photon flux is then

dΦγdE0=14π∫0zRHdzH(z)e−τγ(E0,z)Q^γ[E0(1+z),z],(10)\frac{d\Phi_\gamma}{dE_0} = \frac{1}{4\pi}\int_0^{z_{\mathrm{RH}}}\frac{dz}{H(z)}e^{-\tau_\gamma(E_0,z)}\hat{Q}_\gamma[E_0(1+z),z], \tag*{(10)}

with no additional factor of (1+z)(1+z), since the factor (1+z)−1(1+z)^{-1} in ∣dt/dz∣|dt/dz| cancels the Jacobian dEγ/dE0=1+zdE_\gamma/dE_0 = 1+z. The opacity model and the numerical checks are given in the Supplemental Material.

We show in Figure 2 the ALP momentum distributions for the two cases discussed below (left) and the resulting photon spectra (right). If most ALPs decay while still relativistic, the observed spectrum retains the Hawking momentum scale and is much broader than a delta function. If instead the population becomes nonrelativistic before decaying, the emitted spectrum narrows around ma/2m_a/2, and the observed photon energies are set by the decay redshift. Describing the transition between these regimes requires the full momentum distribution and its momentum-dependent decay history.

Figure 2. Left: Comoving momentum distribution qfa(q)q f_a(q) for Mi=102M_i=10^2 and 108 g10^8\,\mathrm{g}, evaluated after evaporation with a0=1a_0=1, so that qq is the physical momentum today. Because the PBH heats up as it evaporates, the produced spectra are nonthermal and harder than any single blackbody, with mean momenta ⟨q⟩≃1.4 eV\langle q\rangle\simeq1.4\,\mathrm{eV} and 1.7 keV1.7\,\mathrm{keV} (dashed lines). The dotted curve is a Bose–Einstein spectrum with the same number density and mean momentum as the light case. The mean lies above the peak of qfaqf_a because the final stage of evaporation populates a hard fa∝q−3f_a\propto q^{-3} tail. The light case is ∼6×102\sim6\times10^2 times more abundant and correspondingly softer, n~a∝Mi−1/2\tilde n_a\propto M_i^{-1/2} and ⟨q⟩∝Mi1/2\langle q\rangle\propto M_i^{1/2}, which accounts for the difference between the constraints in Figure 3 and Figure 4. Right: Present-day photon spectra for ma=102 eVm_a=10^2\,\mathrm{eV} and gaγγ=10−10 GeV−1g_{a\gamma\gamma}=10^{-10}\,\mathrm{GeV}^{-1}. The cold light population gives a line ending at ma/2m_a/2, while the relativistic heavy population gives a broad spectrum.

Observational constraints. Laboratory and astrophysical limits on gaγγg_{a\gamma\gamma} apply directly to our scenario and do not depend on the cosmological Hawking population [12, 13, 14, 15, 16]. For all other bounds, we use fa(q)f_a(q) from Eq. (6) and Sa(q,z)S_a(q,z) from Eq. (7) to compute the surviving ALP energy density,

ρa(z)=(1+z)3∫0∞dq faSaEa,(11)\rho_a(z) = (1+z)^3 \int_0^\infty dq\,f_a S_a E_a, \tag*{(11)}

and the energy injected per unit time and volume, obtained by summing the photon energies,

ρ˙inj(z)=(1+z)3∫0∞dEγ Eγ Q^γ(Eγ,z).(12)\dot{\rho}_{\mathrm{inj}}(z) = (1+z)^3 \int_0^\infty dE_\gamma\,E_\gamma\,\hat{Q}_\gamma(E_\gamma,z). \tag*{(12)}

BBN and the CXB depend on the full photon spectrum, the CMB constrains mainly on the injected energy, and ALP domination on ρa\rho_a:

  • ALP Domination: Heavy and long-lived ALPs redshift like matter and can come to dominate the energy density. If they survive until today they exceed the observed matter density, and if they decay after BBN they inject more energy into photons than the entire radiation background, so we exclude every point where ρa\rho_a exceeds the background density at any redshift.

  • BBN: Decay photons injected after BBN (z≲2×107z \lesssim2 \times10^7) can break up light nuclei and change their abundances. We pass Q^γ\hat{Q}_\gamma to the electromagnetic cascade code ACROPOLIS [19, 20, 21], which follows the photon cascade and the resulting abundances, and exclude points where D/H or 7Li{}^7\mathrm{Li} is outside of 95% allowed range or 3He{}^3\mathrm{He}/D exceeds its upper bound.

  • CMB Spectral Distortions: Energy injected between z≃2×106z \simeq2 \times10^6 and recombination distorts the CMB blackbody spectrum. This effect is quantified with spectral distortion parameters

μ≃1.4∫dt Jμρ˙injργ,y≃14∫dt Jyρ˙injργ,(13)\mu\simeq1.4\int dt\,\mathcal{J}_\mu\frac{\dot{\rho}_{\mathrm{inj}}}{\rho_\gamma}, \qquad y \simeq\frac{1}{4}\int dt\,\mathcal{J}_y\frac{\dot{\rho}_{\mathrm{inj}}}{\rho_\gamma}, \tag*{(13)}

with visibility functions taken from Refs. Jμ,y\mathcal{J}_{\mu,y} [11, 22]. We exclude ALP parameter space in which these distortions exceed the FIRAS 95% exclusion limits, corresponding to ∣μ∣>9×10−5|\mu| > 9 \times10^{-5} or ∣y∣>1.5×10−5|y| > 1.5 \times10^{-5} [10].

  • CMB Temperature Anisotropies: Energy injected near recombination alters the ionization history. Planck constrains dark matter decaying into

two photons through the product of its abundance and decay rate [23, 24, 25]. We apply this limit with the ALP mass density in place of the dark matter density, average it over the box spectrum weighted by photon energy, and use it only where the ALPs are nearly cold and long-lived. Following Ref. [26], we evaluate the box average and the ALP survival at a single redshift, z∗=300z_* = 300, and assume that the effect on the CMB scales linearly with the injected energy, so the published limit can be rescaled without a new recombination and likelihood calculation for each point (see Supplemental Material).

  • CXB: Photons produced from Hawking axion decays can contribute to the cosmic X-ray background (CXB). We compare their energy-weighted intensity I(E0)=E02 dΦγ/dE0I(E_0) = E_0^2 \,\mathrm{d}\Phi_\gamma/\mathrm{d}E_0 from Eq. (10), which includes attenuation, with a reference CXB spectrum BCXB(E0)B_{\rm CXB}(E_0) built from the total CXB fits of Refs. [27, 28], and exclude any point where

I(E0)>BCXB(E0),(14)I(E_0) > B_{\rm CXB}(E_0), \tag*{(14)}

for 0.5 keV≤E0≤200 keV0.5\,\mathrm{keV} \le E_0 \le200\,\mathrm{keV}, that is, where the ALP photons alone would exceed the measured X-ray background. Since this lets the ALPs account for the entire background without subtracting any astrophysical sources, the bound is conservative, although it is not a limit at a fixed confidence level. Two further choices make the bound conservative: the reference spectrum lies at or above most of the CXB measurements from Ref. [29], so the ALPs must exceed a larger background, and we include only the extragalactic signal, neglecting photons from ALPs decaying in the Galactic halo. In the absence of attenuation, integrating Eq. (10) over all observed energies gives

∫dE0dΦγdE0=12π∫dq fa(q)[1−Sa(q,0)],(15)\int\mathrm{d}E_0 \frac{\mathrm{d}\Phi_\gamma}{\mathrm{d}E_0} = \frac{1}{2\pi}\int\mathrm{d}q\,f_a(q)\left[1-S_a(q,0)\right], \tag*{(15)}

two photons for each ALP that has decayed by today, which we use to check the numerical flux.

  • Structure formation: Long-lived Hawking relics can suppress structure formation in the late universe, in analogy with the familiar effect of massive neutrinos in standard cosmology. In Figure 3 and Figure 4 we apply the constraints on this scenario calculated in Ref. [3].

Constraints on decaying Hawking ALPs for $M_i = 10^8\,\mathrm{g}$

Figure 3. Constraints on decaying Hawking ALPs for Mi=108 gM_i = 10^8\,\mathrm{g}. All filled regions are derived from the same comoving ALP distribution: the direct CXB overshoot bound (red), defined by Eq. (14), Planck CMB anisotropies (dark blue), BBN photodisintegration (yellow), FIRAS μ\mu and yy spectral distortions (light blue) [10, 11], and the recast structure formation bound on stable relics (green), applied only where decays are negligible [3]. In the hatched purple region, the ALPs come to dominate the energy density and the fixed background calculation is no longer consistent and this region is excluded. Gray shading shows existing laboratory and astrophysical limits, which do not depend on faf_a [12, 13, 14, 15, 16]. Lines show projected sensitivities. The dashed and dotted red curves give the direct photon reach if the astrophysical CXB can be modeled and subtracted to 10% and 1% accuracy, respectively. The solid blue curve is the Simons Observatory projection for the CMB anisotropy recast [17], and the dashed blue line is a PIXIE-like spectral distortion forecast [18].

Same as Fig. 3, for $M_i = 10^2\,\mathrm{g}$

Figure 4. Same as Figure 3, for Mi=102 gM_i = 10^2\,\mathrm{g}. The lighter PBHs evaporate earlier, and leave a softer relic population with a number density ∼6×102\sim6 \times10^2 times larger. Secondary ALP domination (hatched purple) begins at ma≳2.5 MeVm_a \gtrsim2.5\,\mathrm{MeV} and covers the long-lived region, including the CXB band at these masses. The structure formation exclusion (green) begins at the stable relic limit ma≃10 keVm_a \simeq10\,\mathrm{keV} [3]. The direct CXB exclusion shrinks to a narrow red sliver near ma∼1 keVm_a \sim1\,\mathrm{keV}, where late decays of the abundant cold population overshoot the soft X-ray background. The BBN and spectral distortion constraints remain important at high masses. Line styles are as in Figure 3. The PIXIE and Simons Observatory projections extend the reach beyond the current spectral distortion and CMB anisotropy bounds, respectively.

Alongside the current bounds shown in Figure 3, we also include the projected reach of a PIXIE-like spectral distortion mission [18] and the Simons Observatory sensitivity to CMB anisotropies [17]. For the direct photon channel, we show the sensitivity that could be achieved if the astrophysical X-ray background were modeled and subtracted. Each procedure, its domain of validity, and its statistics are specified in the Supplemental Material.

We show in Figure 3 the heavy PBH case, Mi=108 gM_i = 10^8\,\mathrm{g}, for which the direct photon channel is strongest. The CXB exclusion is a narrow band whose lower boundary is set by the lifetime, since at smaller couplings too few ALPs have decayed by today. At larger couplings, the decays occur too early for the photons to reach us, so cosmic opacity sets the upper boundary. As increasing gaγγg_{a\gamma\gamma} shifts the decays to higher redshift, the dominant constraint changes from CMB anisotropies to yy and μ\mu distortions and finally to BBN photodisintegration. At MeV masses, the combined exclusion spans roughly seven decades in coupling.

Ref. [5] focused on ultralight ALPs converting in cosmic magnetic fields and treated decays of ALPs with 10 eV≲ma≲1 MeV10\,\mathrm{eV} \lesssim m_a \lesssim1\,\mathrm{MeV} more briefly, including the Lorentz-dilated decay rate and boosted two-photon kinematics, with constraints from reionization. Here we compute the ALP distribution with numerical spin-zero graybody factors and the full PBH-dominated background, derive a dedicated CXB bound on decaying Hawking axions, and combine it in Figure 3 and Figure 4 with BBN, CMB, structure formation, and ALP-domination constraints that extend to ma∼10 TeVm_a \sim10\,\mathrm{TeV}.

For this case, typical relic momenta today are of order keV, so boosted decays can therefore populate the X-ray band even when ma/2m_a/2 lies below its lower edge, which extends the CXB exclusion down to ma∼102 eVm_a \sim10^2\,\mathrm{eV}. In the same way, photodisintegration likewise depends on the boosted photon energy rather than on ma/2m_a/2, and the BBN constraint extends the threshold for decays at rest, ma=2EthD≃4.4 MeVm_a = 2E_{\rm th}^D \simeq4.4\,\mathrm{MeV}. At large masses, the spectral distortion wedge extends to ma∼10 TeVm_a \sim10\,\mathrm{TeV}, where ma/TBHi≃0.1m_a/T_{\rm BH}^i \simeq0.1 and ALP emission is only mildly suppressed.

In Figure 4 we show the same results for the light PBH case, Mi=102 gM_i = 10^2\,\mathrm{g}. Since the comoving abundance scales approximately as Mi−1/2M_i^{-1/2}, and the characteristic momentum scales as Mi1/2M_i^{1/2}, at fixed ALP mass, lighter PBHs yield a colder and more abundant relic population. For a stable ALP, Ωah2≃0.20 (ma/MeV)\Omega_a h^2 \simeq0.20\,(m_a/\mathrm{MeV}) at this benchmark, and even a decayed fraction of ∼10−7\sim10^{-7} is enough to saturate the CXB. As a result, the exclusion is dominated by self-consistency rather than by the photon flux. Over most of the long-lived parameter space the ALPs would dominate the energy density before decaying, and the would-be direct band lies inside this region. Comparing Figure 3 and Figure 4, the PBH mass determines which probe dominates in each part of the plane and sets the overall normalization.

Discussion. The results in Figure 3 and Figure 4 contain no free abundance parameter. For fixed PBH and ALP masses, the PBH-dominated history determines the initial relic phase space, and gaγγg_{a\gamma\gamma} enters only through the decay. Direct photons, energy deposition before and after recombination, structure formation, and consistency of the assumed cosmological history constrain complementary regions of the mass–coupling plane, with a relative importance that depends on MiM_i.

Future measurements can extend these limits. A PIXIE-like mission could push the spectral distortion bounds to smaller couplings for ALP masses up to ma∼10 TeVm_a \sim10\,\mathrm{TeV} and Simons Observatory is projected to improve on the Planck recast. Better modeling and subtraction of the astrophysical CXB would also strengthen the direct photon bound. For long-lived ALPs, the 10% background uncertainty assumed here would probe couplings about 2.5 times smaller. In the limit gaγγ→0g_{a\gamma\gamma} \to0, a population that remains relativistic through recombination contributes ΔNeff≃0.05\Delta N_{\mathrm{eff}} \simeq0.05–0.110.11 across the PBH mass window, which is an additional target for future CMB measurements [17].

Our calculation assumes a monochromatic population of Schwarzschild PBHs, semiclassical evaporation, and PBH domination before evaporation. We use massless ALP graybody tables for ma/TBHi≲0.1m_a/T_{\mathrm{BH}}^i \lesssim0.1, require ALP decays during evaporation to be negligible, and neglect plasma-induced reabsorption. The validity conditions and possible extensions are discussed in the Supplemental Material. A joint likelihood using the measured CXB spectrum could improve the direct photon limit, and a full electromagnetic transfer calculation would treat photon propagation, absorption, and energy deposition consistently across the CMB and BBN observables. With the appropriate Hawking spectrum, decay width, and treatment of the daughter particles, the same method applies to other unstable particles produced by Hawking evaporation.

Because the ALP population is produced gravitationally, its abundance does not vanish as gaγγg_{a\gamma\gamma} decreases. Diffuse photon measurements can then probe couplings at which production through the ALP interaction itself would be negligible. More generally, these observations provide a way to test unstable Hawking relics and the particle content of the Universe before BBN.

Acknowledgments

We thank Mainak Mukhopadhyay, whose comments improved this manuscript by an amount we are unable to bound from above. This work made use of the AxionLimits repository [12] by C. O’Hare. This manuscript has been authored by Fermi Forward Discovery Group, LLC under Contract No. 89243024CSC000002 with the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of High Energy Physics. A.H. acknowledges that this material is based upon work supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Workforce Development for Teachers and Scientists, Office of Science Graduate Student Research (SCGSR) program. The SCGSR program is administered by the Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education (ORISE) for the DOE. ORISE is managed by ORAU under contract number DESC0014664. All opinions expressed in this paper are the author’s and do not necessarily reflect the policies and views of DOE, ORAU, or ORISE. Fermilab is operated by Fermi Research Alliance, LLC, under Contract No. DE-AC02-07CH11359 with the US Department of Energy. The work of S.V. was supported by the Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics at the University of Chicago.

“Hawking Axions”

Abdelaziz Hussein; Gordan Krnjaic; Sarunas Verner

In this Supplemental Material we collect the technical details behind the results of the paper. § 3.1 describes the PBH background and the resulting ALP distribution, § 3.2 the treatment of ALP decays, § 3.3 how each constraint is implemented, and § 3.4 the X-ray bound.

PBH background and the ALP distribution

Assumptions

Throughout we work in natural units with G=MPl−2G = M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^{-2} and normalize the scale factor so that a0=1a_0 = 1. For the late-time cosmology we adopt the Planck 2018 parameters [30]. We take all PBHs to have the same initial mass MiM_i and to be nonrotating, and we ignore accretion and mergers. This is a reasonable starting point, since PBHs that form from rare peaks during radiation domination are expected to be born with small spins [31, 32]. A nonzero spin, or a spread in the initial masses, would modify both the evaporation rate and the spectrum of the emitted particles [33, 34, 35], and we do not consider these cases here. The SM particles produced by evaporation thermalize by the time the PBHs disappear [3], whereas the ALPs interact only through their decay into photons. Our results therefore apply only where plasma effects can neither thermalize nor reabsorb the ALPs.

We also treat the production and the decay of the ALPs as two separate stages. For this to be valid, decays during evaporation have to be negligible, which requires ΓaτBH≪1\Gamma_a\tau_{\mathrm{BH}} \ll1. In practice this condition is conservative, because the ALPs are relativistic when they are emitted and time dilation only slows down their decay. For the graybody factors we use the tabulated massless spin-zero results, which limits us to ma/TBHi≲0.1m_a/T_{\mathrm{BH}}^i \lesssim0.1 with TBHi≡TBH(Mi)T_{\mathrm{BH}}^i \equiv T_{\mathrm{BH}}(M_i). This is easily satisfied over most of our parameter space. For instance, for ma≤100 MeVm_a \le100\ \mathrm{MeV} the ratio never exceeds 5×10−65 \times10^{-6} in our mass window, while for Mi=108 gM_i = 10^8\ \mathrm{g} and ma=10 TeVm_a = 10\ \mathrm{TeV} it reaches 0.094, close to the edge of the allowed range. Apart from the graybody factors, the ALP mass is kept everywhere in the calculation, including the dispersion relation, the production threshold, and the decay kinematics. We note that ALPs heavier than TBHiT_{\mathrm{BH}}^i are not forbidden, since they are emitted at late times once the PBH has heated up. Describing this regime would however require massive graybody factors, and we leave it for future work.

Mass window and lifetime

It is convenient to write the mass-loss rate of Eq. (2) as dM/dt=−κ/M2dM/dt = -\kappa/M^2. For the SM we have κ=g∗,HMPl4/(30720π)≃8×1026 g3 s−1\kappa= g_{*,H} M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^4/(30720\pi) \simeq8 \times10^{26}\ \mathrm{g^3\,s^{-1}}. Since all SM species are already emitted at the beginning of evaporation (even for Mi=5×108 gM_i = 5 \times10^8\ \mathrm{g} the initial temperature is TBHi≃2×106 GeVT_{\mathrm{BH}}^i \simeq2 \times10^6\ \mathrm{GeV}), κ\kappa is to a good approximation constant. The PBH mass then decreases as M(t)=Mi(1−t/τBH)1/3M(t) = M_i(1 - t/\tau_{\mathrm{BH}})^{1/3}, with a lifetime

τBH=Mi33κ≃0.42 s(Mi109 g)3.(16)\tau_{\mathrm{BH}} = \frac{M_i^3}{3\kappa} \simeq0.42\ \mathrm{s}\left(\frac{M_i}{10^9\ \mathrm{g}}\right)^3 . \tag*{(16)}

A light real scalar takes away about 1.7% of the Hawking power [3, 36, 37], so its effect on κ\kappa can be safely neglected. To determine the allowed range of MiM_i, we assume that the PBHs form during radiation domination with a mass equal to a fraction γ≃0.2\gamma\simeq0.2 of the horizon mass [7, 38],

Mi=γ2GHf≃2.7×104 g(γ0.2)(109 GeVHf).(17)M_i = \frac{\gamma}{2 G H_f} \simeq2.7 \times10^4\ \mathrm{g}\left(\frac{\gamma}{0.2}\right)\left(\frac{10^9\ \mathrm{GeV}}{H_f}\right). \tag*{(17)}

Since formation has to happen after inflation, the Planck and BICEP/Keck bound Hf≲5×1013 GeVH_f \lesssim5 \times10^{13}\ \mathrm{GeV} [6, 39] gives Mi≳0.5 gM_i \gtrsim0.5\ \mathrm{g}, and we take Mi=1 gM_i = 1\ \mathrm{g} as the lower end of the window. The upper end comes from BBN, which needs a reheating temperature of at least a few MeV [40, 41, 42]. Using Eq. (19) below, this translates into Mi≲5×108 gM_i \lesssim5 \times10^8\ \mathrm{g} [3].

Attractor and reheating

If the PBHs form with an initial energy fraction β\beta, they come to dominate the energy density before they evaporate provided that β≳βc≃(tf/τBH)1/2≃5×10−6 (g/Mi)\beta\gtrsim\beta_c \simeq(t_f/\tau_{\rm BH})^{1/2} \simeq5 \times10^{-6}\,(\mathrm{g}/M_i), where we used tf≃GMi/γt_f \simeq GM_i/\gamma. When β≫βc\beta\gg\beta_c, the evolution near evaporation no longer depends on β\beta, and neither do the reheating temperature and the normalized ALP distribution [1, 3, 43]. Gravitational wave constraints on fluctuations in the PBH number density still allow this regime throughout our mass window [44, 45, 46]. In practice, we therefore solve Eq. (3) starting from ρR=0\rho_R=0, as described in the paper. Right after evaporation the solution gives

ρR(tev)≃0.886πGτBH2,n^BH≃1.09aRH36πGτBH2Mi.(18)\rho_R(t_{\rm ev}) \simeq\frac{0.88}{6\pi G\tau_{\rm BH}^{2}}, \qquad\hat{n}_{\rm BH} \simeq\frac{1.09a_{\rm RH}^{3}}{6\pi G\tau_{\rm BH}^{2}M_i}. \tag*{(18)}

where aRH≡a(tev)a_{\rm RH}\equiv a(t_{\rm ev}) and n^BH=a3nBH\hat{n}_{\rm BH}=a^3n_{\rm BH} is constant until the PBHs evaporate. We have checked that adding primordial radiation with 10% of the PBH density to the initial conditions changes these coefficients by less than 0.02%.

Not all of the radiation at tevt_{\rm ev} is thermal. A fraction ϵdec≃ϵa\epsilon_{\rm dec}\simeq\epsilon_a of it is carried by the decoupled ALPs, and a much smaller amount by gravitons. We therefore define the reheating temperature using only the SM part, (1−ϵdec)ρR(tev)=π2g∗(TRH)TRH4/30(1-\epsilon_{\rm dec})\rho_R(t_{\rm ev})=\pi^2g_*(T_{\rm RH})T_{\rm RH}^4/30, which leads to

TRH≃2.7×1010 GeV[106.75g∗(TRH)]1/4(1 gMi)3/2.(19)T_{\rm RH}\simeq2.7\times10^{10}\,\mathrm{GeV}\left[\frac{106.75}{g_*(T_{\rm RH})}\right]^{1/4}\left(\frac{1\,\mathrm{g}}{M_i}\right)^{3/2}. \tag*{(19)}

The factor (1−ϵdec)1/4(1-\epsilon_{\rm dec})^{1/4} changes TRHT_{\rm RH} by only 0.4%. Because g∗g_* depends on TRHT_{\rm RH}, we solve Eq. (19) iteratively, using the SM equation of state of Ref. [47]. If the ALP decays do not produce a significant amount of entropy, entropy conservation after reheating gives

aRH=Tγ0TRH[g∗s,0g∗s(TRH)]1/3≃2.9×10−24η(Mi1 g)3/2,η≡[106.75g∗s(TRH)]1/3[g∗(TRH)106.75]1/4.(20)a_{\rm RH}=\frac{T_{\gamma0}}{T_{\rm RH}}\left[\frac{g_{*s,0}}{g_{*s}(T_{\rm RH})}\right]^{1/3}\simeq2.9\times10^{-24}\eta\left(\frac{M_i}{1\,\mathrm{g}}\right)^{3/2}, \qquad\eta\equiv\left[\frac{106.75}{g_{*s}(T_{\rm RH})}\right]^{1/3}\left[\frac{g_*(T_{\rm RH})}{106.75}\right]^{1/4}. \tag*{(20)}

where Tγ0=2.7255 KT_{\gamma0}=2.7255\,\mathrm{K} and g∗s,0≃3.91g_{*s,0}\simeq3.91 does not include the Hawking relics. For Mi≲105 gM_i\lesssim10^5\,\mathrm{g} we find η≃1\eta\simeq1. For heavier PBHs η\eta grows slowly and reaches about 1.2 at 5×108 g5\times10^8\,\mathrm{g}, since fewer SM species are left to transfer their entropy to the photons. Together, Eqs. (18) and (20) fix the overall normalization of faf_a in Eq. (6).

The ALP distribution

To compute faf_a from Eq. (6), we use the primary spin-zero spectrum of BlackHawk v2.3 [8, 9], evaluate the graybody factor at the instantaneous mass M(t)M(t), and take a(t)a(t) from the numerical background solution. In this way each ALP is redshifted from the moment it is emitted, which would not be the case if we first integrated the spectrum over the PBH lifetime.

The shape of faf_a can be understood from a simple estimate. If we ignore the expansion and use the geometric-optics graybody factor, a change of variables to x=p/TBH(M)x=p/T_{\rm BH}(M) gives

dnadp≃27n^BH2π(8π)5κG3p3∫0p/TBHidx x4ex−1.(21)\frac{dn_a}{dp}\simeq\frac{27\hat{n}_{\rm BH}}{2\pi(8\pi)^5\kappa G^3p^3}\int_0^{p/T_{\rm BH}^i}dx\,\frac{x^4}{e^x-1}. \tag*{(21)}

For p≪TBHip\ll T_{\rm BH}^i the integral grows as (p/TBHi)4(p/T_{\rm BH}^i)^4 and dna/dp∝pdn_a/dp\propto p, while for p≫TBHip\gg T_{\rm BH}^i it approaches a constant and dna/dp∝p−3dn_a/dp\propto p^{-3}. The high-momentum tail is produced at the very end of evaporation, when the temperature of the PBH rises quickly (half of the PBH mass is lost during the last eighth of its lifetime). With the full graybody factor both power laws survive, and only their coefficients change. The expansion of the universe moves the ALPs emitted early to smaller comoving momenta, but it barely affects the tail, because those ALPs are emitted shortly before the PBHs disappear.

In the PBH-dominated attractor and for ma≪TBHim_a\ll T_{\rm BH}^i, the distributions for different PBH masses are related by a simple rescaling [3]. In particular, the comoving number density and the mean momentum today scale as

n^a∝η3Mi−1/2,⟨q⟩≃0.14 eV η(Mi1 g)1/2.(22)\hat{n}_a\propto\eta^3M_i^{-1/2}, \qquad\langle q\rangle\simeq0.14\,\mathrm{eV}\,\eta\left(\frac{M_i}{1\,\mathrm{g}}\right)^{1/2}. \tag*{(22)}

The mean momentum corresponds to ⟨p⟩≃4.6TBHi\langle p\rangle\simeq4.6T_{\rm BH}^{i} at reheating. For comparison, a scalar that decoupled from the SM plasma above the electroweak scale would have ⟨q⟩∼10−4 eV\langle q\rangle\sim10^{-4}\,\mathrm{eV} today, so the Hawking population is much hotter, and also much less abundant. If the ALP is stable and nonrelativistic today, its abundance is

Ωah2≃2.0×10−6η3(maeV)(1 gMi)1/2,(23)\Omega_a h^2 \simeq2.0 \times10^{-6}\eta^3\left(\frac{m_a}{\mathrm{eV}}\right)\left(\frac{1\,\mathrm{g}}{M_i}\right)^{1/2}, \tag*{(23)}

while if it is still relativistic after electron–positron annihilation, it contributes

ΔNeff=87(114)4/3ρaργ≃0.051η4(24)\Delta N_{\rm eff} = \frac{8}{7}\left(\frac{11}{4}\right)^{4/3}\frac{\rho_a}{\rho_\gamma} \simeq0.051\eta^4 \tag*{(24)}

to the effective number of neutrinos [1, 3, 34, 48, 49]. They can be compared with the Planck bound ΔNeff≲0.3\Delta N_{\rm eff} \lesssim0.3 at 95% C.L. [30] and with the Simons Observatory forecast σ(Neff)≃0.05\sigma(N_{\rm eff}) \simeq0.05–0.070.07 [17]. For a decaying ALP, however, NeffN_{\rm eff} depends on both the surviving ALPs and the heating of the photons.

We tested the numerical spectra in several ways. At high energies we compared them with the geometric optics result, and we checked that the spectra for different PBH masses follow Eq. (22). We also verified energy conservation, ∫dq qfa=aRH4ρRHa(tev)\int dq\,q f_a = a_{\rm RH}^4\rho_{\rm RH}a(t_{\rm ev}), which has to reproduce the ALP fraction ϵa\epsilon_a, and that doubling the time and momentum resolution leaves the moments of faf_a unchanged.

Decays and the photon spectrum

For the survival probability in Eq. (7) we write the exponent in terms of x=ln⁡(1+z)x=\ln(1+z),

Da(q,z)=Γama∫ln⁡(1+z)ln⁡(1+zRH)dx′H(x′)ma2+q2e2x′,Sa=e−Da,(25)\mathcal{D}_a(q,z)=\Gamma_a m_a\int_{\ln(1+z)}^{\ln(1+z_{\rm RH})}\frac{dx'}{H(x')\sqrt{m_a^2+q^2e^{2x'}}},\qquad S_a=e^{-\mathcal{D}_a}, \tag*{(25)}

and evaluate the integral for each momentum mode, starting from reheating. The expansion rate includes radiation, with the temperature dependence of g⋆g_\star and g⋆sg_{\star s} in the SM, as well as matter and dark energy. As a check, we compared the result with the analytic expression that can be derived for a universe that contains only radiation.

The box kernel in Eq. (8) is normalized to two photons per decay, ∫dEγ Kγ=2\int dE_\gamma\,K_\gamma=2, and its first moment gives back the ALP energy, ∫dEγ EγKγ=Ea\int dE_\gamma\,E_\gamma K_\gamma=E_a. Since Ea/γa=maE_a/\gamma_a=m_a, the larger energy of the photons from a boosted decay exactly compensates the time dilation of the decay rate, and the injection rate in Eq. (12) simplifies to

ρ˙inj(z)=maΓa(1+z)3∫dq fa(q)Sa(q,z).(26)\dot{\rho}_{\rm inj}(z)=m_a\Gamma_a(1+z)^3\int dq\,f_a(q)S_a(q,z). \tag*{(26)}

The ALP momentum therefore enters only through SaS_a. Numerically, we compute the lower edge of the box as E−=ma2/[2(Ea+p)]E_-=m_a^2/[2(E_a+p)] to avoid a cancellation when Ea≃pE_a\simeq p.

Constraints

Existing bounds

We take the existing limits on gaγγg_{a\gamma\gamma} from the AxionLimits repository [12], but keep only those that do not depend on the cosmological ALP abundance. These are the helioscope, stellar evolution, solar, and supernova bounds, including the limits from the conversion of ALPs produced in these sources [13, 14, 15, 16]. We do not include cosmological bounds that assume thermal production, freeze-in, or a fixed relic abundance, and neither helioscope nor dark matter decay limits, which would have to be recast for the Hawking population. The gray regions in Figure 3 and Figure 4 show the union of the remaining limits. Note that these are not all derived at the same confidence level.

ALP domination

We exclude every point where the ALP density ρa\rho_a of Eq. (11) exceeds the standard background density, ρbg=ρrad+Ωmρc(1+z)3+ΩΛρc\rho_{\rm bg}=\rho_{\rm rad}+\Omega_m\rho_c(1+z)^3+\Omega_\Lambda\rho_c, at some redshift between reheating and today. Relativistic ALPs never dominate, since they make up only about 1% of the radiation density. Once they become nonrelativistic, however, their density grows relative to radiation. Stable ALPs therefore dominate if man~a≳Ωmρcm_a\widetilde{n}_a \gtrsim\Omega_m\rho_c, that is, if their density today would exceed the observed matter density. For shorter lifetimes the ALPs have to dominate before they decay. During radiation domination the ratio ρa/ρrad\rho_a/\rho_{\rm rad} grows as man~at1/2m_a\widetilde{n}_a t^{1/2}, so the minimum lifetime for domination scales as (man~a)−2(m_a\widetilde{n}_a)^{-2}. With τa=64π/(gaγγ2ma3)\tau_a = 64\pi/(g_{a\gamma\gamma}^2m_a^3), the boundary then scales as gaγγ∝n~ama−1/2g_{a\gamma\gamma} \propto\widetilde{n}_a m_a^{-1/2}.

BBN

For the BBN constraint we tabulate the physical photon source (1+z)3Q^γ(Eγ,z)(1+z)^3\widehat{Q}_\gamma(E_\gamma,z) on logarithmic grids in redshift and photon energy, convert redshift to time with the same H(z)H(z) as above, and use it as input for ACROPOLIS [19, 20, 21]. The code solves the electromagnetic cascade without assuming a universal spectrum, and then evolves the light-element abundances after standard BBN. Pair production on the thermal photons suppresses the cascade spectrum above EC≃me2/(22T)E_C \simeq m_e^2/(22T) [50], so deuterium, with a binding energy of 2.22 MeV, can only be destroyed once the universe has cooled enough for ECE_C to exceed this value. For boosted ALPs the photons can lie above threshold even when ma/2m_a/2 is below it. We start from the standard BBN abundances of the reference ACROPOLIS analysis and exclude a point if D/H or YpY_p falls outside its 95% range, or if 3He{}^3\mathrm{He}/D is above its upper limit [20, 21]. Because of the unresolved lithium problem, we do not use 7Li{}^7\mathrm{Li}. To test the input, we checked that each tabulated source reproduces the photon number and energy moments, 2∫dq faSaΓa/γa2\int dq\,f_aS_a\Gamma_a/\gamma_a and ρ˙inj/(1+z)3\dot{\rho}_{\rm inj}/(1+z)^3, and that the standard abundances are recovered when the source is switched off. We also refined the grids until the contour stopped changing. Since we use standard initial abundances and a fixed background, the calculation is valid only if the ALPs neither dominate nor release a significant amount of entropy before photodisintegration becomes efficient.

Spectral distortions

For the spectral distortions we assume that the injected energy is converted into heat right away. The fractional energy release per unit redshift is then E(z)=ρ˙inj/[ργ(1+z)H]\mathcal{E}(z)=\dot{\rho}_{\rm inj}/[\rho_\gamma(1+z)H], and the distortion parameters are

μ=1.401∫zreczRHdz JμE,y=14∫zreczRHdz JyE,(27)\mu= 1.401\int_{z_{\rm rec}}^{z_{\rm RH}} dz\,J_\mu\mathcal{E}, \qquad y = \frac{1}{4}\int_{z_{\rm rec}}^{z_{\rm RH}} dz\,J_y\mathcal{E}, \tag*{(27)}

with zrec=1100z_{\rm rec}=1100. For the visibility functions we use [11, 22]

Jbb=e−[(1+z)/(1+zdc)]5/2,Jy=Jbb1+[(1+z)/(1+zμy)]2.58,Jμ=Jbb{1−e−[(1+z)/(5.8×104)]1.88},(28)J_{\rm bb}=e^{-[(1+z)/(1+z_{\rm dc})]^{5/2}}, \qquad J_y=\frac{J_{\rm bb}}{1+[(1+z)/(1+z_{\mu y})]^{2.58}}, \qquad J_\mu=J_{\rm bb}\left\{1-e^{-[(1+z)/(5.8\times10^4)]^{1.88}}\right\}, \tag*{(28)}

where zdc=1.98×106z_{\rm dc}=1.98\times10^6 and zμy=6.0×104z_{\mu y}=6.0\times10^4. In the numerical integration we count the decays through the change in SaS_a between neighboring redshifts, so that SaS_a never has to be differentiated. The FIRAS contour corresponds to ∣μ∣<9.0×10−5|\mu|<9.0\times10^{-5} and ∣y∣<1.5×10−5|y|<1.5\times10^{-5} [10], applied separately and not through a fit to the FIRAS spectrum. For the PIXIE-like projection we use instead the 5σ5\sigma values μ=5×10−8\mu=5\times10^{-8} and y=10−8y=10^{-8} of Ref. [18]. At a fixed ALP mass this constraint excludes a band in coupling. For small couplings too few ALPs decay during the distortion era, whereas for large couplings most of them decay above zdcz_{\rm dc}, where any distortion is erased. Our estimate neglects delayed energy deposition, as well as distortions beyond μ\mu and yy [22, 51]. Spectral distortion constraints on decaying ALPs were also discussed in Ref. [52].

CMB anisotropies

We denote by τ95(m)\tau_{95}(m) the Planck 95% lower limit on the lifetime of cold dark matter with mass mm that decays into two photons [23, 24, 25]. A cold and long-lived ALP population that would make up a fraction Fa=man~a/(ΩDMρc)F_a=m_a\widetilde{n}_a/(\Omega_{\rm DM}\rho_c) of the dark matter if it were stable is then excluded for FaΓaτ95(ma)>1F_a\Gamma_a\tau_{95}(m_a)>1. Since the photons from a boosted decay are spread over the box, we average the lifetime response over the photon energy at z∗=300z_* = 300, where the CMB is most sensitive to long-lived decays [23, 24],

W95(q)=1Ea∫dEγ EγKγτ95(2Eγ)=∫01du τ95(2Eγ2+uEap),(29)\mathcal{W}_{95}(q)=\frac{1}{E_a}\int dE_\gamma\,E_\gamma K_\gamma\tau_{95}(2E_\gamma)=\int_0^1 du\,\tau_{95}\left(2\sqrt{E_\gamma^2+uE_a p}\right), \tag*{(29)}

with p=q(1+z∗)p=q(1+z_\ast), and exclude a point if

ΓamaΩDMρc∫dq fa(q) Sa(q,z∗) W95(q)>1.(30)\frac{\Gamma_a m_a}{\Omega_{\rm DM}\rho_c}\int dq\,f_a(q)\,S_a(q,z_\ast)\,\mathcal{W}_{95}(q)>1. \tag*{(30)}

For a cold population W95→τ95(ma)\mathcal{W}_{95}\to\tau_{95}(m_a), and if depletion can be neglected, this condition reduces to FaΓaτ95(ma)>1F_a\Gamma_a\tau_{95}(m_a)>1. We interpolate log⁡τ95\log\tau_{95} linearly in log⁡m\log m and use only photon energies within the range of the published limit. The solid contour is shown only where the box average changes the response by less than 1%,

δbox≡∣∫dq faW95τ95(ma)∫dq fa−1∣<0.01,(31)\delta_{\rm box}\equiv\left\lvert\frac{\int dq\,f_a\mathcal{W}_{95}}{\tau_{95}(m_a)\int dq\,f_a}-1\right\rvert<0.01, \tag*{(31)}

where the population is long-lived at z∗z_\ast, and where the ALPs never dominate. For shorter lifetimes the decays happen earlier, and this cannot be described by the survival probability at a single redshift. Finding where the bound weakens would require a full calculation of the energy deposition and of the recombination history, so we leave this region out. For the Simons Observatory projection we multiply τ95\tau_{95} by a constant factor ASOA_{\rm SO} [17, 25] and keep everything else the same.

Structure formation

For structure formation we use the scalar mass bound maSF(Mi)m_a^{\rm SF}(M_i) shown in Fig. 10 of Ref. [3]. In that work the Hawking relics were mapped onto equivalent thermal relics and constrained with CMB, galaxy clustering, and weak lensing data. We interpolate the boundary in log⁡Mi\log M_i and log⁡ma\log m_a, and exclude ma>maSF(Mi)m_a>m_a^{\rm SF}(M_i) only when the decays have a small effect,

Δstab≡max⁡[1−n^asurvn^a,∣⟨v⟩surv⟨v⟩0−1∣]<10−2.(32)\Delta_{\rm stab}\equiv\max\left[1-\frac{\hat{n}_a^{\rm surv}}{\hat{n}_a},\left\lvert\frac{\langle v\rangle_{\rm surv}}{\langle v\rangle_0}-1\right\rvert\right]<10^{-2}. \tag*{(32)}

Here n^asurv=∫dq faSa(q,0)\hat{n}_a^{\rm surv}=\int dq\,f_aS_a(q,0), and ⟨v⟩\langle v\rangle is the mean speed today, computed with and without the survival probability. The second condition is needed because fast modes live longer due to time dilation, so the decays change not only the number of ALPs but also the shape of their distribution. Points that do not satisfy Eq. (32) would have to be treated with a Boltzmann code that follows both the ALPs and their decay products.

X-ray background bound

Inserting the box kernel into Eq. (9), the emissivity at a fixed emitted energy Eγ=E0(1+z)E_\gamma=E_0(1+z) becomes an integral over the tail of the momentum distribution,

Q^γ(Eγ,z)=2maΓa1+z∫qmin⁡∞dq fa(q)Sa(q,z)q Ea(q,z),qmin⁡=11+z∣Eγ−ma24Eγ∣,(33)\widehat{Q}_\gamma(E_\gamma,z)=\frac{2m_a\Gamma_a}{1+z}\int_{q_{\min}}^\infty dq\,\frac{f_a(q)S_a(q,z)}{q\,E_a(q,z)},\qquad q_{\min}=\frac{1}{1+z}\left\lvert E_\gamma-\frac{m_a^2}{4E_\gamma}\right\rvert, \tag*{(33)}

so we do not need to sample the decay angles. For nonrelativistic ALPs, a given observed energy E0E_0 receives contributions only from a narrow redshift interval around 1+zd=ma/(2E0)1+z_d=m_a/(2E_0), of width Δln⁡(1+z)≃q/E0\Delta\ln(1+z)\simeq q/E_0, and we refine the redshift grid in this region. In the absence of attenuation, integrating Eq. (10) over all energies gives

∫dE0 dΦγdE0=12π∫dq fa(q)[1−Sa(q,0)],(34)\int dE_0\,\frac{d\Phi_\gamma}{dE_0}=\frac{1}{2\pi}\int dq\,f_a(q)\left[1-S_a(q,0)\right], \tag*{(34)}

that is, two photons for every ALP that has decayed by today. We use this relation to check the normalization of the flux.

For the photon transmission e−τγe^{-\tau_\gamma} at z≤1000z\leq1000 we use the file OpticalDepth.m from PPPC4DMID with the minUV background [53]. At higher redshifts we continue it as

e−τγ(E0,z)=e−τγ(E0,1000)exp⁡{−7.8×10−5[(1+z)3/2−10013/2]},(35)e^{-\tau_\gamma(E_0,z)}=e^{-\tau_\gamma(E_0,1000)}\exp\left\{-7.8\times10^{-5}\left[(1+z)^{3/2}-1001^{3/2}\right]\right\}, \tag*{(35)}

and set it to zero once the exponent exceeds 200. The upper edge of the CXB band depends on this choice. Photons produced in electromagnetic cascades are not included in the direct signal.

Below 1.5 keV we take the reference background from the extragalactic power law of Cappelluti et al. [27], BC=10.91(E0/keV)−0.55 keV cm−2 s−1 sr−1\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{C}} = 10.91 (E_0/\mathrm{keV})^{-0.55}\ \mathrm{keV\ cm^{-2}\ s^{-1}\ sr^{-1}}, which is corrected for Galactic absorption and does not include the Galactic foregrounds. Between 1.5 and 200 keV we use the fit of Moretti et al. [28],

BM=0.109 (E0/keV)2(E0/29 keV)1.40+(E0/29 keV)2.88 keV cm−2 s−1 sr−1.(36)\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{M}} = \frac{0.109\,(E_0/\mathrm{keV})^2}{(E_0/29\ \mathrm{keV})^{1.40} + (E_0/29\ \mathrm{keV})^{2.88}}\ \mathrm{keV\ cm^{-2}\ s^{-1}\ sr^{-1}}. \tag*{(36)}

The reference background BCXB\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{CXB}} is BC\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{C}} below 1.5 keV and BM\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{M}} above. At 1.5 keV the two fits differ by 12%. We use their central values, and in Figure S1 we compare them with the data compiled by Ajello et al. [29].

Reference cosmic X-ray background used in this work

Figure S1. Reference cosmic X-ray background used in this work. The dashed line shows the extragalactic power law of Cappelluti et al. [27] and the solid line the fit of Moretti et al. [28], which we join at 1.5 keV (vertical line). The open symbols are the measurements compiled in Fig. 14 of Ref. [29] (ASCA, RXTE, HEAO-1 and its A4 detector, the Nagoya balloon experiment, and Swift/BAT). The bands correspond to a ±15%\pm15\% change in the normalization of each fit and are shown only for illustration. The shaded region is the 0.5–200 keV window used in the analysis.

Following Eq. (14), a point is excluded if I(E0)>BCXB(E0)I(E_0) > \mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{CXB}}(E_0) at any energy in the window 0.5≤E0/keV≤2000.5 \le E_0/\mathrm{keV} \le200. The largest ratio I/BCXBI/\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{CXB}} can occur at the edges of the window, so the energy grid includes both endpoints, as well as both sides of the 1.5 keV join. Figure S2 shows a few examples for Mi=102 gM_i = 10^2\ \mathrm{g}. For ma=1 MeVm_a = 1\ \mathrm{MeV} the excluded band extends from gaγγ≃1.5×10−19g_{a\gamma\gamma} \simeq1.5 \times10^{-19} to 3.7×10−13 GeV−13.7 \times10^{-13}\ \mathrm{GeV}^{-1}. At the lower edge only a fraction 7×10−87 \times10^{-8} of the ALPs has decayed by today and the signal grows as gaγγ2g_{a\gamma\gamma}^2, while at the upper edge the decays take place when the universe is still opaque to the photons. Note that in this case Eq. (23) gives Ωah2≃0.20 (ma/MeV)\Omega_a h^2 \simeq0.20\,(m_a/\mathrm{MeV}), so a long-lived population would exceed the dark matter density for ma≳0.6 MeVm_a \gtrsim0.6\ \mathrm{MeV}.

Figure S2. Direct photon signal for Mi=102 gM_i = 10^2\,\mathrm{g}. Left: Attenuated spectra for ma=1 MeVm_a = 1\,\mathrm{MeV} and five values of the coupling (in GeV−1\mathrm{GeV}^{-1}), compared with the reference CXB (black). The shaded region is the analysis window. The three rising spectra correspond to long-lived ALPs. In the transparent matter-dominated era they approach I∝E05/2\mathcal{I} \propto E_0^{5/2}, with an amplitude proportional to gaγγ2g_{a\gamma\gamma}^2 and an endpoint close to ma/2m_a/2. For the two largest couplings most of the ALPs decay before their photons can reach us, and what remains is a narrow feature whose position depends on the decay history and the opacity. Right: Largest ratio of the signal to the reference background in the analysis window, max⁡E0I/BCXB\max_{E_0}\mathcal{I}/\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{CXB}}, as a function of the coupling for ma=0.3m_a = 0.3, 1, and 3 MeV. Points above one are excluded. The open circles correspond to the spectra in the left panel, and the shaded interval shows the CXB band for ma=1 MeVm_a = 1\,\mathrm{MeV} before the other constraints are applied.

To illustrate what could be gained with a better model of the astrophysical background, we also show the reach obtained by replacing BCXB\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{CXB}} with 1.64 δ BCXB1.64\,\delta\,\mathcal{B}_{\mathrm{CXB}}, for δ=0.1\delta= 0.1 and 0.010.01. The factor 1.64 corresponds to a one-sided 95% threshold for a Gaussian residual at a fixed energy. On the long-lived branch, where I∝gaγγ2I \propto g_{a\gamma\gamma}^2, this improves the reach in coupling by factors of 2.5 and 7.8, respectively. These curves do not include correlations between energy bins, the instrumental response, or the uncertainty in modeling the astrophysical sources. Finally, we include only the isotropic extragalactic signal. A Galactic contribution would depend on the local density and velocity distribution of the surviving ALPs, which we have not computed.

References

  1. [1]D. Hooper, G. Krnjaic, and S. D. McDermott, JHEP 08, 001, arXiv:1905.01301 [hep-ph].
  2. [2]I. Baldes, Q. Decant, D. C. Hooper, and L. Lopez-Honorez, JCAP 08, 045, arXiv:2001.14773 [astro-ph.CO].
  3. [3]C. J. Shull, J. B. Muñoz, and G. Z. Krnjaic, JCAP 02, 026, arXiv:2406.08535 [astro-ph.CO].
  4. [4]O. Lennon, J. March-Russell, R. Petrossian-Byrne, and H. Tillim, JCAP 04, 009, arXiv:1712.07664 [hep-ph].
  5. [5]F. Schiavone, D. Montanino, A. Mirizzi, and F. Capozzi, JCAP 08, 063, arXiv:2107.03420 [hep-ph].
  6. [6]Y. Akrami et al. (Planck), Astron. Astrophys. 641, A10 (2020), arXiv:1807.06211 [astro-ph.CO].
  7. [7]B. Carr, K. Kohri, Y. Sendouda, and J. Yokoyama, Rept. Prog. Phys. 84, 116902 (2021), arXiv:2002.12778 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  8. [8]A. Arbey and J. Auffinger, Eur. Phys. J. C 79, 693 (2019), arXiv:1905.04268 [gr-qc].DOI
  9. [9]A. Arbey and J. Auffinger, Eur. Phys. J. C 81, 910 (2021), arXiv:2108.02737 [gr-qc].DOI
  10. [10]D. J. Fixsen, E. S. Cheng, J. M. Gales, J. C. Mather, R. A. Shafer, and E. L. Wright, Astrophys. J. 473, 576 (1996), arXiv:astro-ph/9605054.DOI
  11. [11]J. Chluba and R. A. Sunyaev, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 419, 1294 (2012), arXiv:1109.6552 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  12. [12]C. O’Hare, cajohare/axionlimits: Axionlimits, https://cajohare.github.io/AxionLimits/ (2020).DOI
  13. [13]A. Ayala, I. Domínguez, M. Giannotti, A. Mirizzi, and O. Straniero, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 191302 (2014), arXiv:1406.6053 [astro-ph.SR].DOI
  14. [14]M. J. Dolan, F. J. Hiskens, and R. R. Volkas, JCAP 10, 096, arXiv:2207.03102 [hep-ph].
  15. [15]A. Payez, C. Evoli, T. Fischer, M. Giannotti, A. Mirizzi, and A. Ringwald, JCAP 02, 006, arXiv:1410.3747 [astro-ph.HE].DOI
  16. [16]V. Anastasopoulos et al. (CAST), Nature Phys. 13, 584 (2017), arXiv:1705.02290 [hep-ex].
  17. [17]P. Ade et al. (Simons Observatory), JCAP 02, 056, arXiv:1808.07445 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  18. [18]A. Kogut et al., JCAP 07, 025, arXiv:1105.2044 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  19. [19]M. Hufnagel, K. Schmidt-Hoberg, and S. Wild, JCAP 11, 032, arXiv:1808.09324 [hep-ph].DOI
  20. [20]P. F. Depta, M. Hufnagel, and K. Schmidt-Hoberg, JCAP 04, 011, arXiv:2011.06519 [hep-ph].
  21. [21]P. F. Depta, M. Hufnagel, and K. Schmidt-Hoberg, JCAP 03, 061, arXiv:2011.06518 [hep-ph].DOI
  22. [22]J. Chluba, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 436, 2232 (2013), arXiv:1304.6121 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  23. [23]T. R. Slatyer and C.-L. Wu, Phys. Rev. D 95, 023010 (2017), arXiv:1610.06933 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  24. [24]V. Poulin, J. Lesgourgues, and P. D. Serpico, JCAP 03, 043, arXiv:1610.10051 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  25. [25]J. Cang, Y. Gao, and Y.-Z. Ma, Phys. Rev. D 102, 103005 (2020), arXiv:2002.03380 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  26. [26]K. Langhoff, N. J. Outmezguine, and N. L. Rodd, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 241101 (2022), arXiv:2209.06216 [hep-ph].DOI
  27. [27]N. Cappelluti, Y. Li, A. Ricarte, B. Agarwal, V. Allegri, T. T. Ananna, M. Ajello, F. Civano, A. Comastri, M. Elvis, A. Finoguenov, R. Gilli, G. Hasinger, S. Marchesi, P. Natarajan, F. Paucci, E. Treister, and C. M. Urry, The Astrophysical Journal 837, 19 (2017).
  28. [28]A. Moretti et al., AIP Conf. Proc. 1126, 223 (2009), arXiv:0811.1444 [astro-ph].DOI
  29. [29]M. Ajello et al., Astrophys. J. 689, 666 (2008), arXiv:0808.3377 [astro-ph].DOI
  30. [30]N. Aghanim et al. (Planck), Astron. Astrophys. 641, A6 (2020), [Erratum: Astron. Astrophys. 652, C4 (2021)], arXiv:1807.06209 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  31. [31]V. De Luca, V. Desjacques, G. Franciolini, A. Malhotra, and A. Riotto, JCAP 05, 018, arXiv:1903.01179 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  32. [32]M. Mirbabayi, A. Gruzinov, and J. Noreña, JCAP 03, 017, arXiv:1901.05963 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  33. [33]D. N. Page, Phys. Rev. D 14, 3260 (1976).
  34. [34]A. Arbey, J. Auffinger, P. Sandick, B. Shams Es Haghi, and K. Sinha, Phys. Rev. D 103, 123549 (2021), arXiv:2104.04051 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  35. [35]A. Cheek, L. Heurtier, Y. F. Perez-Gonzalez, and J. Turner, Phys. Rev. D 108, 015005 (2023), arXiv:2212.03878 [hep-ph].DOI
  36. [36]D. N. Page, Phys. Rev. D 13, 198 (1976).
  37. [37]J. H. MacGibbon and B. R. Webber, Phys. Rev. D 41, 3052 (1990).
  38. [38]B. J. Carr, Astrophys. J. 201, 1 (1975).
  39. [39]P. A. R. Ade et al. (BICEP, Keck), Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 151301 (2021), arXiv:2110.00483 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  40. [40]K. Kohri and J. Yokoyama, Phys. Rev. D 61, 023501 (2000), arXiv:astro-ph/9908160.DOI
  41. [41]P. F. de Salas, M. Lattanzi, G. Mangano, G. Miele, S. Pastor, and O. Pisanti, Phys. Rev. D 92, 123534 (2015), arXiv:1511.00672 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  42. [42]T. Hasegawa, N. Hiroshima, K. Kohri, R. S. L. Hansen, T. Tram, and S. Hannestad, JCAP 12, 012, arXiv:1908.10189 [hep-ph].DOI
  43. [43]J. D. Barrow, E. J. Copeland, E. W. Kolb, and A. R. Liddle, Phys. Rev. D 43, 984 (1991).
  44. [44]K. Inomata, M. Kawasaki, K. Mukaida, T. Terada, and T. Yanagida, Phys. Rev. D 101, 123533 (2020), arXiv:2003.10455 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  45. [45]T. Papanikolaou, V. Vennin, and D. Langlois, JCAP 03, 053, arXiv:2010.11573 [astro-ph-CO].DOI
  46. [46]G. Domènech, C. Lin, and M. Sasaki, JCAP 04, 062, [Erratum: JCAP 11, E01 (2021)], arXiv:2012.08151 [gr-qc].DOI
  47. [47]K. Saikawa and S. Shirai, JCAP 05, 035, arXiv:1803.01038 [hep-ph].DOI
  48. [48]J. Auffinger, I. Masina, and G. Orlando, Eur. Phys. J. Plus 136, 261 (2021), arXiv:2012.09867 [hep-ph].DOI
  49. [49]I. Masina, Eur. Phys. J. Plus 135, 552 (2020), arXiv:2004.04740 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2004.04740
  50. [50]M. Kawasaki, K. Kohri, T. Moroi, and Y. Takeasu, Phys. Rev. D 97, 023502 (2018), arXiv:1709.01211 [hep-ph].DOI
  51. [51]B. Bolliet, J. Chluba, and R. Battye, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 507, 3148 (2021), arXiv:2012.07292 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  52. [52]C. Balázs et al., JCAP 12, 027, arXiv:2205.13549 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  53. [53]M. Cirelli, G. Corcella, A. Hektor, G. Hutsi, M. Kadastik, P. Panci, M. Raidal, F. Sala, and A. Strumia, JCAP 03, 051, [Erratum: JCAP 10, E01 (2012)], arXiv:1012.4515 [hep-ph].DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_zxcbse78
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents