betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Direct determination of the atomic mass difference of the pairs 76^{76}As-76^{76}Se and 155^{155}Tb-155^{155}Gd rules out 76^{76}As and 155^{155}Tb as possible candidates for electron (anti)neutrino mass measurements

Abstract

The first direct determination of the ground-state-to-ground-state QQ values of the β−β^- decay 76^{76}As →\rightarrow 76^{76}Se and the electron-capture decay 155^{155}Tb →\rightarrow 155^{155}Gd was performed utilizing the double Penning trap mass spectrometer JYFLTRAP. By measuring the atomic mass difference of the decay pairs via the phase-imaging ion-cyclotron-resonance (PI-ICR) technique, the QQ values of 76^{76}As →\rightarrow 76^{76}Se and 155^{155}Tb →\rightarrow 155^{155}Gd were determined to be 2959.265(74) keV and 814.94(18) keV, respectively. The precision was increased relative to earlier measurements by factors of 12 and 57, respectively. The new QQ values are 1.33 keV and 5 keV lower compared to the values adopted in the most recent Atomic Mass Evaluation 2020. With the newly determined ground-state-to-ground-state QQ values combined with the excitation energy from γγ-ray spectroscopy, the QQ values for ground-state-to-excited-state transitions 76^{76}As (ground state) →\rightarrow 76^{76}Se∗^* (2968.4(7) keV) and 155^{155}Tb (ground state) →\rightarrow 155^{155}Gd∗^* (815.731(3) keV) were derived to be -9.13(70) keV and -0.79(18) keV. Thus we have confirmed that both of the β−β^{-}-decay and EC-decay candidate transitions are energetically forbidden at a level of at least 4σσ, thus definitely excluding these two cases from the list of potential candidates for the search of low-QQ-value β−β^- or EC decays to determine the electron-(anti)neutrino mass.

Introduction

The knowledge of the absolute neutrino-mass scale is extremely important both for cosmological models and for the fundamental understanding of the nature of particle masses. The information on neutrino masses from oscillation experiments is limited by the fact that these experiments are only able to measure the differences of squared neutrino masses and not their absolute mass scale. The only model-independent information on the neutrino masses, beyond just the mass differences, can be extracted from energy-momentum conservation relations in weak reactions like β−\beta^{-} or electron-capture (EC) decay in which an antineutrino or a neutrino is involved [1, 2, 3]. Enrico Fermi proposed in 1933 such a kinematic search for the antineutrino mass mνˉem_{\bar{\nu}_{e}} in the endpoint region of the β−\beta^{-} spectra in 3^{3}H β\beta decay, 3^{3}H(1/2+)→(1/2^{+}) \to 3^{3}He(1/2+)+e−+νˉe(1/2^{+}) + e^{-} + \bar{\nu}_{e}, with a QQ value of 18.59201(7) keV [4]. The KATRIN experiment [5] sets an upper limit of mνˉe<0.8m_{\bar{\nu}_{e}} < 0.8 eV, at 90% Confidence Level (CL), via this decay thus improving the previous bound from the Mainz [6] and Troitsk [7] experiments which managed to constrain mνˉe<2.2m_{\bar{\nu}_{e}} < 2.2 eV at 95% CL. KATRIN will continue running to reach a design sensitivity limit of mνˉe∼0.2m_{\bar{\nu}_{e}} \sim0.2 eV after 5 calendar years of data taking. Project 8 is exploring a new technique for β\beta spectrometry based on cyclotron radiation utilizing molecular tritium as a source [8]. In a similar manner as the β−\beta^{-}-decay end-point experiments, the sensitivity of EC experiments to the neutrino mass depends on the fraction of events near the end-point. This fraction increases with decreasing QQ value and the (anti)neutrino-mass sensitivity increases accordingly. An alternative isotope to tritium is 163^{163}Ho which has the advantage of a small QQ value of 2.833(30)stat(15)sys_{\mathrm{stat}}(15)_{\mathrm{sys}} keV [9], decaying via EC to 163^{163}Dy. Currently, there are several next generation experiments, ECHo [10], HOLMES [11], and NuMECS [12], exploring this decay to probe the electron-neutrino mass. These experiments are complementary to tritium-based searches from the perspective of technology. In addition, the decay of 163^{163}Ho determines the electron-neutrino mass as opposed to the electron-antineutrino mass in tritium. A low, especially ultra-low (<1< 1 keV), QQ-value β\beta or EC decay is of great interest for possible future (anti)neutrino-mass determination experiments [13, 14, 15, 16, 17]. If an excited state in the daughter nucleus can be found with an excitation energy close to the mass difference of the parent and decay-daughter atoms, which is equal to the ground-state-to-ground-state QQ value, the decay energy of the corresponding transition can be very low. The ultra-low QQ-value decay branch of 115^{115}In (9/2+)(9/2^{+}) to the first excited state of 115Sn∗(9/2+)^{115}\mathrm{Sn}^{*}(9/2^{+}) was first revealed by Cattadori et al. [18]. Two independent measurements of the QQ value of this branch, via Penning trap mass spectrometry (PTMS) at Florida State University [19] and at the University of Jyväskylä [20], confirmed it to be ultra-low. The QQ value of this branch was further refined to be 0.147(10) keV using the accurately measured excitation energy of the first excited state of 115Sn^{115}\mathrm{Sn} from [21].

The ground-state-to-ground-state decay QQ value (Q0Q_{0}) for β−\beta^{-} decay (Qβ−Q_{\beta^{-}}) and EC decay (QECQ_{\mathrm{EC}}) is the difference of atomic masses of the decay parent (MpM_{\mathrm{p}}) and the decay daughter (MdM_{\mathrm{d}}):

Q0=Qβ−/EC=(Mp−Md)c2.(1)Q_{0}=Q_{\beta^{-}/\mathrm{EC}}=(M_{\mathrm{p}}-M_{\mathrm{d}})c^{2}. \tag*{(1)}

where cc is the speed of light in vacuum. Combining the Q0Q_{0} value with the excitation energy E∗E^{*} of the decay-daughter state, yields the ground-state-to-excited-state QQ value of Q0∗Q_{0}^{*}:

Q0∗=Q0−E∗.(2)Q_{0}^{*}=Q_{0}-E^{*}. \tag*{(2)}

For EC decay, the atomic binding energy BjB_{j}, where jj denotes the atomic shell of the captured electron, needs to be taken into account to derive the released energy in the decay:

QEC,j∗=QEC−E∗−Bj.(3)Q_{\mathrm{EC},j}^{*}=Q_{\mathrm{EC}}-E^{*}-B_{j}. \tag*{(3)}

Two potential ultra-low QQ value candidate transitions, β−\beta^{-} decay 76As^{76}\mathrm{As} (ground-state) →\rightarrow 76Se∗(680.1035(17) keV^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{*}(680.1035(17)\ \mathrm{keV} [22]) and EC 155Tb^{155}\mathrm{Tb} (ground-state) →\rightarrow 155Gd∗(2968.4(7) keV^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{*}(2968.4(7)\ \mathrm{keV} [22]), are of particular interest. Both of the transitions are possibly of the allowed type as shown in Table I. Emphasis should be given to the transitions of allowed type for the direct (anti)neutrino mass determination [15, 23]. They are promising candidates due to two main reasons: first, they have larger branching ratios, enabling the accumulation of more data in a shorter time period and potentially making the case more lucrative for direct (anti)neutrino mass determination; second, the decay transition is driven by decay matrix element(s) such that the beta spectral shape is universal, which makes the analysis of the β\beta-decay spectrum nuclear-structure independent. The evaluated QQ values in the Atomic Mass Evaluation 2020 [24] (AME2020) and derived Q0∗Q_{0}^{*} value of the candidate transitions are tabulated in Table I. The excitation energies E∗E^{*} in the daughter nuclei are well-known with sub-keV precision [22] while the Q0Q_{0} values are poorly known and lack a value from a direct measurement. This results in the derived Qβ−/EC∗Q_{\beta^{-}/\mathrm{EC}}^{*} values of both decays a precision worse than 1 keV [23, 24]. Currently, PTMS is the most precise and accurate method for determining atomic masses and Q0Q_{0} values, and it is capable of reaching a sub-keV precision in a direct manner. Hence, to confirm whether these two decays are energetically possible, direct PTMS determination of the Q0Q_{0} values is called for. In order to solve this puzzle, we have performed in this work a direct Q0Q_{0}-value determination for the two promising candidate nuclei, 76As^{76}\mathrm{As} and 155Tb^{155}\mathrm{Tb}, using the JYFLTRAP Penning-trap setup.

Experimental method

The experiments for the direct Q0Q_{0} value determination were carried out at the Ion Guide Isotope Separator On-Line facility (IGISOL) using the JYFLTRAP double Penning trap mass spectrometer [25], located at the University of Jyväskylä [26, 27]. A schematic layout of the facility is shown in Figure 1. For β−\beta^{-} decay 76As→76Se^{76}\mathrm{As}\rightarrow{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}, the Qβ−Q_{\beta^{-}} value was deduced by measuring the cyclotron frequency ratio of singly charged 76As+^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+} and 76Se+^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+} ions. Similarly, for EC decay 155Tb→155Gd^{155}\mathrm{Tb}\rightarrow{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}, the QECQ_{\mathrm{EC}} value was derived from the cyclotron frequency ratio measurements of 155Tb+^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+} and 155Gd+^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+} ions.

Schematic overview of the IGISOL facility

Figure 1. (Color online) Schematic overview of the IGISOL facility. The ions were produced at the IGISOL target chamber (1). 76As+^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+} and 76Se+^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+} were produced with deuteron-induced fusion reactions, while 155Tb+^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+} and 155Gd+^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+} were produced with proton-induced fusion reactions. After production and extraction from the gas cell, the ions were guided through an electrostatic bender (2), mass number selected with a dipole magnet (3), cooled and bunched in the RFQ cooler-buncher (4) and finally injected to the JYFLTRAP double Penning trap setup (5) for the mass-difference measurement.

To produce the 76As+^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+} and 76Se+^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+} ions simultaneously at IGISOL, a thin germanium target with a thickness of about 2 mg/cm2^{2} was bombarded with a 9-MeV deuteron beam from the K-130 cyclotron. The 155Tb+^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+} and 155Gd+^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+} ions were simultaneously produced with a 60-MeV proton beam bombarding a gadolinium target of about 2 mg/cm2^{2} in thickness.

After production, the ions were stopped and thermalized inside the gas cell of the IGISOL light-ion guide [28]. Therein, they were transported by means of helium gas flow (typical gas pressure of ∼100\sim100 mbar) through an extraction nozzle to the sextupole ion guide (SPIG) [29] as a continuous ion beam. After extraction from the SPIG to a high-vacuum region, the ions were accelerated with a 30 kV potential. The ion beam was subsequently steered with an electrostatic kicker and guided through a magnetic dipole mass separator. The separator was sufficient to reject all non-isobaric contaminants but ions which were singly charged with a mass number of interest (A=76A=76 or 155). The separated and selected ions were then transported through an electrostatic switchyard, which also houses a fast kicker electrode that was used to chop the beam to have an optimum number of ions. After the switchyard, a radiofrequency quadrupole (RFQ) coolerbuncher [30] was used to cool and bunch the injected ions. Finally, the bunched and cooled ions were transported to the downstream JYFLTRAP double Penning trap for the frequency ratio measurement to determine the QQ values.

Initial stateT1/2T_{1/2}Final stateDecay typeQ0Q_0 (keV)Q0∗Q_0^{*} (keV)E∗E^{*} (keV)
76As (2−){}^{76}\mathrm{As}\ (2^{-})26.24(9) h76Se ({2−, 3−, 4−}){}^{76}\mathrm{Se}\ (\{2^{-},\ 3^{-},\ 4^{-}\})β−\beta^{-}: Allowed{?}2960.6(9)-7.8(11)2968.4(7)
155Tb (3/2+){}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}\ (3/2^{+})5.32(6) dy155Gd ({3/2}+){}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}\ (\{3/2\}^{+})EC: Allowed{?}820(10)4(10)815.731(3)

Table 1. Potential ultra-low QQ-value candidate transitions for electron-(anti)neutrino mass measurements: β−\beta^{-} decay of the ground state of 76As{}^{76}\mathrm{As} to an excited state in 76Se{}^{76}\mathrm{Se} and EC decay of the ground state of 155Tb{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb} to an excited state in 155Gd{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}. The first column gives the initial ground state of the parent nucleus and the second column gives the half-life of the parent nucleus. The third column gives the excited final state of interest for the low-QQ-value transition. The fourth column gives the decay type and the fifth column gives the β−\beta^{-}/EC-decay Q0Q_0 value in units of keV, taken from literature (AME2020) [24]. The sixth column gives the derived Q0∗Q_0^{*} value. The last column gives the experimental excitation energy E∗E^{*} (keV) with the experimental error [22]. Spin-parity assignments enclosed by the braces indicate that these are uncertain, which results in an uncertainty in the decay type, indicated by a {?}.

The JYFLTRAP double Penning trap consists of two cylindrical traps located in a 7-T superconducting magnet. Inside the traps, the homogeneous magnetic field and a quadrupolar electrostatic potential are used to confine the cooled and bunched ions from the RFQ. The first trap is the purification trap, which is used for purification and separation of ions of interest. While the second trap, the so-called precision trap, is utilized for a high-precision mass determination or a direct QQ value measurement. Two techniques are typically used, of which one is the conventional time-of-flight ion-cyclotron-resonance (TOF-ICR) method [31, 32], and another the phase-imaging ion-cyclotron-resonance (PI-ICR) technique [33, 34, 35].

The ions with A=76A=76 from the deuteron-induced secondary beam, which consisted of 76As+{}^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+}, 76Ga+{}^{76}\mathrm{Ga}^{+} and 76Se+{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+}, were purified via the mass-selective buffer gas cooling method [36] in the first trap. A typical resolving power M/ΔM≈105M/\Delta M \approx10^{5} was enough to remove all neighbouring isobaric ions and any other ion species present in the beam, resulting in a clean sample of 76As+{}^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+} or 76Se+{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+}. Ions of A=155A=155 from the proton-induced secondary beam were injected to JYFLTRAP, consisting of 155Tb+{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+}, 155Gd+{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+}, 155Sm+{}^{155}\mathrm{Sm}^{+} and 155Eu+{}^{155}\mathrm{Eu}^{+}. These were firstly purified via the mass-selective buffer gas cooling method. An additional higher resolving power Ramsey cleaning method [37] was utilized to selectively prepare a clean sample of 155Tb+{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+} or 155Gd+{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+}.

After the well-prepared clean ion sample of either the decay parent or decay daughter entered the second trap, the measurement of cyclotron frequency

νc=12πqmB(4)\nu_c = \frac{1}{2\pi}\frac{q}{m}B \tag*{(4)}

was performed. Here q/mq/m is the charge-to-mass ratio of the stored ion and BB the magnetic field strength.

In this work, the PI-ICR technique was used to measure the cyclotron frequencies [33, 34, 35], a method which is about 25 times faster reaching a certain precision compared to the TOF-ICR method. In particular, the measurement scheme number 2 described in [34] was utilized to directly measure the cyclotron frequency. Two timing patterns, one called “magnetron” and the other “cyclotron” pattern were used, see

[33]. These patterns are otherwise identical except for the switching-on instant of the π\pi-pulse that converts ions’ cyclotron motion to magnetron. In the “magnetron” pattern the ions revolve in the trap for an accumulation time tt with magnetron motion while in the “cyclotron” pattern the ions revolve with cyclotron motion. The exact knowledge of the switch-on time difference tt is essential. The used patterns produce so-called magnetron and cyclotron spots or phases on the position-sensitive micro-channel plate (MCP) detector [38]. Additionally, it is necessary to measure the motional center spot. With these data, it is then possible to get the angle between the magnetron and cyclotron motion phases with respect to the center spot

αc=α+−α−,(5)\alpha_c = \alpha_+ - \alpha_-, \tag*{(5)}

where α+\alpha_+ and α−\alpha_- are the polar angles of cyclotron and magnetron phases, respectively. Finally, the cyclotron frequency νc\nu_c is deduced from

νc=αc+2πnc2πt,(6)\nu_c = \frac{\alpha_c + 2\pi n_c}{2\pi t}, \tag*{(6)}

where ncn_c is the number of complete revolutions during the phase accumulation time tt. The measurement is set up so that αc\alpha_c will be small in order to minimize systematic shifts due to image distortion by choosing tt to be as close to integer-multiples of the νc\nu_c period as possible.

The accumulation time tt for both 76Ga+{}^{76}\mathrm{Ga}^{+} and 76As+{}^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+} ions during the interleaved measurement was chosen to be 310 ms in order to ensure that the cyclotron spot was not overlapping with any possible isobaric, excited or molecular contamination. For both 155Tb+{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+} and 155Gd+{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+} ions, the accumulation time tt was tuned to be 620 ms. The accumulation time tt was also tuned to the nearest integer-multiples of period of νc\nu_c to minimize the angle αc\alpha_c. This ensured minimal influence from the interconversion of magnetron and cyclotron motions and also minimized the image distortion shift [34, 39]. In these measurements αc\alpha_c did not exceed a few degrees.

The collected “magnetron” and “cyclotron” phase spots of 155Tb+{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+} ions are plotted in the left and right panels of Figure 2. The delay of the cyclotron motion excitation was repeatedly scanned over one magnetron period and the final extraction delay was varied over one cyclotron period to account for any residual magnetron and cyclotron motions that could shift the different spots. These constituted in total 5×5=255 \times5 = 25 scan points for both magnetron and cyclotron phase spots.

Figure 2. (Color online). Center, cyclotron phase and magnetron phase spots of 155Tb+^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+} on the position-sensitive MCP detector after the PI-ICR excitation pattern with an accumulation time of 620 ms composed of one set of data recorded in the experiment. The cyclotron phase spot is displayed on the left panel (a) and the magnetron phase spot with a center spot on the right (b). The color bar illustrates the number of ions in each pixel.

The decay Q0Q_0 value is determined from the cyclotron frequency measurements in form of the ratio RR:

Q0=(R−1)(Md−me)c2+ΔBp,d.(7)Q_0=(R-1)(M_d-m_e)c^2+\Delta B_{p,d}. \tag*{(7)}

where mem_e is the electron mass and ΔBp,d\Delta B_{p,d} the electron binding energy difference of the parent-daughter atoms, which is typically on the order of few eV. The cyclotron frequency ratio is

R=νc,dνc,p,(8)R=\frac{\nu_{c,d}}{\nu_{c,p}}, \tag*{(8)}

where νc,p\nu_{c,p} is the cyclotron frequency for parent 76As+^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+} and νc,d\nu_{c,d} for daughter 76Se+^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+} measured in the deuteron-induced experiment, while νc,p\nu_{c,p} is the cyclotron frequency for 155Tb+^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+} and νc,d\nu_{c,d} for 155Gd+^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+} measured in the proton-induced experiment. The ionization energies from the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) [40] are used for the calculation of ΔBm,d\Delta B_{m,d} in this work. For the case of parent 76As+^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+} and daughter 76Se+^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+}, ΔBm,d=−2.607(10)\Delta B_{m,d}=-2.607(10) eV. While for the case of parent 155Tb+^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+} and daughter 155Gd+^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+}, ΔBm,d=−0.563(28)\Delta B_{m,d}=-0.563(28) eV. By measuring mass doublets (76As^{76}\mathrm{As}-76Se^{76}\mathrm{Se} or 155Tb^{155}\mathrm{Tb}-155Gd^{155}\mathrm{Gd}), contributions to the measurement uncertainty arising from mass-dependent systematic effects due to frequency shifts, for example caused by field imperfections, become negligible compared to the typical statistical uncertainty achieved in the measurement. Additionally, as the mass differences ΔM/M\Delta M/M of parent-daughter for both 76As^{76}\mathrm{As}-76Se^{76}\mathrm{Se} and 155Tb^{155}\mathrm{Tb}-155Gd^{155}\mathrm{Gd} are smaller than 10−410^{-4}, the contribution to the Q0Q_0 values from the mass uncertainties of the reference 76Se^{76}\mathrm{Se} (0.08 keV/c2c^2) and 155Gd^{155}\mathrm{Gd} (1.1 keV/c2c^2) are negligible. Due to the fact that the magnetic field changes with time, an accurate calibration of the field is required for a frequency ratio determination. Thus, a linear interpolation of the neighbouring measurements of the cyclotron frequency of the daughter nuclide was

performed to obtain the magnetic field at the moment of the parent cyclotron frequency measurement. During these two experiments, we alternated between parent ion and daughter ion cyclotron frequency measurements every few minutes to minimize the contribution of the magnetic field fluctuation to the measured cyclotron frequency ratio. Therefore, nonlinear changes of the magnetic field between two neighbouring frequency measurements are negligible on the level of frequency determination uncertainties.

Results and discussion

The data were collected by a sequential measurement of the magnetron and cyclotron phase spots of ions of the parent nucleus and the daughter nucleus, followed by the center spot recording with daughter-nucleus ions. Each of the steps lasted about six minutes. For the case of 76As+^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+}-76Se+^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+}, two separate runs were recorded, one lasting for 2.1 hours and the other for 5.3 hours and in total 7.4 hours. For the case of 155Tb+^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+}-155Gd+^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+}, four runs were recorded. These lasted for 3.5 hours, 2.1 hours, 2.2 hours, and 1.7 hours for a total of 9.5 hours.

Before the determination of the positions of each spot, every four or eight rounds of data were grouped for analysis. For each group, positions of each spot—magnetron, cyclotron and center—were determined using the maximum likelihood method and were used to calculate the phase angles. The calculated phase angles were finally used to deduce the cyclotron frequencies via Eq. (6). The closest measured cyclotron frequencies of the daughter ions were linearly interpolated to the time of the measurement of parent ions in between. This interpolated frequency was used to deduce the cyclotron resonance frequency ratio RR via Eq. (8). The final ratio value is then calculated as the weighted mean of all individual ratios.

During the measurement, the incident ion rate was intentionally limited to a maximum 5 ions/bunch with a median value of around 2 ions/bunch. In order to reduce a possible cyclotron frequency shift due to ion-ion interactions [41, 42], only bunches with upto 5 ions or less were considered in the analysis. A countrate-class analysis [41], an evaluation of the data with respect to the number of ions for given measurement cycles, was performed to confirm that the frequency was indeed not shifting with respect to the number of ions.

As the αc\alpha_c of Eq. (5) was kept as small as possible (typically below a few degrees) in the measurement, the frequency shifts due to ion image distortions were well below the statistical uncertainty. All individual ratios for the corresponding runs were calculated along with the inner and outer errors in the analysis of both 76As+^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+}-76Se+^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+} and 155Tb+^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+}-155Gd+^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+} measurements. The Birge ratio [43], the ratio of inner and outer errors, was calculated for each data set. The larger of the errors was taken as the final uncertainty. The final ratio Rˉ\bar{R} was calculated as the weighted mean of all ratios of the data sets for the PI-ICR data. Table II lists the obtained frequency ratios RR of all runs and the final weighted mean ratio Rˉ\bar{R} of both measurements. The final frequency ratio Rˉ\bar{R} and the resulting Qβ−Q_{\beta^-} value are 1.0000418462(10) and 2959.265(74) keV for 76As+^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+}-76Se+^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+}, respectively. Rˉ\bar{R} and the QECQ_{EC} value are 1.0000056472(12)1.0000056472(12) and 814.94(18)814.94(18) keV for 155Tb+{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+}–155Gd+{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+}, respectively. The final results of the analysis compared to literature values are also demonstrated in Fig. 3.

Isobaric pairNNRRR‾\overline{R}
76As+{}^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+}/76Se+{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+}11.000 041 847 5(22)1.000 041 846 2(10)
21.000 041 845 8(12)
155Tb+{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+}/155Gd+{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+}11.000 005 645 1(25)1.000 005 647 2(12)
21.000 005 648 7(23)
31.000 005 646 0(22)
41.000 005 649 8(28)

Table II. Cyclotron frequency ratios RR for each run and average values R‾\overline{R} for each isobaric ion pair. NN is the number of the run.

The reliability of the above interpolation method has been cross checked by a polynomial fitting method [33] to deduce the frequency ratio. The frequency ratio obtained from the polynomial fit agrees well with the value from the linear interpolation analysis within a combined 1σ1\sigma uncertainty for both 76As+{}^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+}–76Se+{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+} and 155Tb+{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+}–155Gd+{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+} measurements.

The final Q0Q_{0} values and the mass-excess values of 76As{}^{76}\mathrm{As} and 155Tb{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb} obtained from the mean cyclotron frequency ratio measurements are listed in Table III. In AME2020, the Q0Q_{0} value of 76As(β−)76Se{}^{76}\mathrm{As}(\beta^{-}){}^{76}\mathrm{Se} is deduced from the mass difference of 76As{}^{76}\mathrm{As} and 76Se{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}. 76Se{}^{76}\mathrm{Se} was measured directly with high precision via PTMS [24]. 76As{}^{76}\mathrm{As} mass is linked to the 75As(n,γ)76As{}^{75}\mathrm{As}(n,\gamma){}^{76}\mathrm{As} reaction measurement with an influence of 100%. 75As{}^{75}\mathrm{As} mass was tied to 75As(p,n)75Se{}^{75}\mathrm{As}(p,n){}^{75}\mathrm{Se} and 75Se(p,α)75Se{}^{75}\mathrm{Se}(p,\alpha){}^{75}\mathrm{Se} measurements with influences of 85.3% and 14.7%, respectively. These two reaction measurements give an evaluated uncertainty of 0.9 keV/c2c^{2} for the 75As{}^{75}\mathrm{As} mass, which is the main contribution to the uncertainty of the Q0Q_{0} value of 76As(β−)76Se{}^{76}\mathrm{As}(\beta^{-}){}^{76}\mathrm{Se}. In AME2020, the Q0Q_{0} value of 155Tb(EC)155Gd{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}(\mathrm{EC}){}^{155}\mathrm{Gd} is evaluated from the mass difference of 155Tb{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb} and 155Gd{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}. The atomic mass of 155Gd{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd} is deduced from three independent measurements 155Gd(n,γ)156Gd{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}(n,\gamma){}^{156}\mathrm{Gd} (70.1% influence), 154Gd(n,γ)155Gd{}^{154}\mathrm{Gd}(n,\gamma){}^{155}\mathrm{Gd} (19.7% influence) and 155GdO{}^{155}\mathrm{GdO}-C15_{15} (7.3% influence). An uncertainty of 1.2 keV for mass of 155Gd{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd} is given in AME2020. The atomic mass of 155Tb{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb} is primarily linked to 155Dy(β+)155Tb{}^{155}\mathrm{Dy}(\beta^{+}){}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}. The 155Dy{}^{155}\mathrm{Dy} mass is related to 156Dy(d,t)155Dy{}^{156}\mathrm{Dy}(d,t){}^{155}\mathrm{Dy} (92.1% influence) and 155Ho(β+)155Dy{}^{155}\mathrm{Ho}(\beta^{+}){}^{155}\mathrm{Dy} (7.9% influence). 156Dy{}^{156}\mathrm{Dy} mass is primarily determined by PTMS (99.3% influence) and 155Ho{}^{155}\mathrm{Ho} mass is linked to 155Ho(β+)155Dy{}^{155}\mathrm{Ho}(\beta^{+}){}^{155}\mathrm{Dy} (60.9% influence) and partially (39.1% influence) evaluated from the directly determined mass with a large uncertainty of 30 keV [45] via the storage ring using the time-resolved Schottky technique at

Q0Q_{0} (keV)ME (keV/c2c^{2})
76As{}^{76}\mathrm{As} (This Work)2959.265(74)−72292.683(75)
76As{}^{76}\mathrm{As} (AME2020)2960.6(9)−72291.4(9)
155Tb{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb} (This Work)814.94(18)−71254.9(12)
155Tb{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb} (AME2020)820(10)−71250(10)

Table III. Q0Q_{0} value and the mass-excess (ME) determined in this work in comparison to the AME2020 values [44].

Comparison of results for 76As+-76Se+ measurements

Figure 3a. (a) 76As+{}^{76}\mathrm{As}^{+}–76Se+{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}^{+} and (b) 155Tb+{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+}–155Gd+{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+} measurements. The left axis shows the frequency ratio deviation from the measured value and the right axis the corresponding QQ value. The red points are the data points and the solid horizontal red line with the shaded area (1σ1\sigma uncertainty band) the final value. The dashed blue line is the value derived from AME2020 (shaded area is the 1σ1\sigma uncertainty band).

Comparison of results for 155Tb+-155Gd+ measurements

Figure 3b. (b) 155Tb+{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}^{+}–155Gd+{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}^{+} measurements.

GSI. Previous measurements show that the QQ values determined with an indirect method may possibly be incorrect, and even deviate by more than 10 keV from high-precision PTMS measurements [46, 47, 48].

As the Q0Q_{0} values of both decay pairs are linked to indirect measurements, direct measurements of the Q0Q_{0} values are strongly encouraged to confirm the accuracy with high precision. For the decay pair 76As{}^{76}\mathrm{As}–76Se{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}, the Q0Q_{0} value from this work is a factor of 12 more precise and 1.33(90) keV smaller than the value in AME2020 [44]. For the decay pair 155Tb{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb}–155Gd{}^{155}\mathrm{Gd}, the Q0Q_{0} value from this work is a factor of 57 more precise and 5(10) keV smaller than the value in AME2020 [44]. The mass-excess values of 76As{}^{76}\mathrm{As} and 155Tb{}^{155}\mathrm{Tb} are improved by a factor of 12 and 8, respectively. The main contribution to the uncertainty in 76^{76}As is from the mass uncertainty (1.1 keV/c2^2) of the reference daughter 76^{76}Se. For 155^{155}Tb, an additional 0.08 keV/c2^2 uncertainty contribution to the mass-excess is added from the mass uncertainty of the reference daughter 155^{155}Gd.

DaughtE∗E^{*}Q0∗Q_{0}^{*} (keV) (AME2020)Q0∗Q_{0}^{*} (keV) (This work)Q/δQQ/\delta Q (This work)
76^{76}Se2968.4(7)-7.8(11)-9.13(70)13
155^{155}Gd815.731(3)4(10)-0.79(18)4

Table 4. QQ values for the studied decays to the excited states of the daughter nuclei 76^{76}Se and 155^{155}Gd. The first column lists the daughter nucleus. The second column gives the experimental excitation energy E∗E^{*} [22] of the daughter state. The third and fourth columns give the Q0∗Q_{0}^{*} using the Q0Q_0 from AME2020 [24, 44] and from this work, respectively. The last column shows the confidence (σ\sigma) of the Q0∗Q_{0}^{*} being negative.

With the direct measurements of the Q0Q_0 values combined with the excitation energies from [22], the Q0∗Q_{0}^{*} values of the potential ultra-low QQ-value decays from ground states to the excited states are derived and tabulated in Table IV. A comparison of QQ values derived from AME2020 with the newly determined QQ values of this work is depicted in Figure 4 as well. Our results confirm that the β−\beta^{-} decay of the ground-state of 76^{76}As to the excited-state of 76^{76}Se (2968.4(7) keV) is an energetically-forbidden decay branch with a Q0∗Q_{0}^{*} value below 0 at a 13σ\sigma level. In addition, the EC decay of the ground-state of 155^{155}Tb to the excited-state of 155^{155}Gd (815.731(3) keV) is verified to be energetically forbidden at a level of 4σ\sigma.

Figure 4. (color online) Partial decay scheme of (a) β−\beta^{-} decay of the 76^{76}As ground state to excited states in 76^{76}Se and (b) EC decay of the 155^{155}Tb ground state to excited states in 155^{155}Gd. Qβ−/QECQ_{\beta^{-}}/Q_{\mathrm{EC}} for both decays is the ground-state-to-ground-state QQ value. The energies of the excited states are taken from [22]. The uncertain spin-parities are denoted with parentheses. The shaded bands in blue show the 1σ1\sigma uncertainty in the QQ value as derived from the AME2020. The shaded bands in red show the 1σ1\sigma uncertainty in the QQ value deduced from the newly determined Q0Q_0 from this work. The decay QQ values and excitation energies are in units of keV. See also Table I, Table III and Table IV.

While the small negative QQ values exclude these nuclei as potential candidates for neutrino-mass measurements, they

make studies of an interesting rare process, a radiative detour transition, possible. This second-order process, involving an additional photon, can have a non-negligible branching ratio when angular-momentum selection rules hinder the direct transition [49]. In Ref. [50] the contribution of the virtual transition was estimated to be about 4% of the β−\beta^{-} decay in 59^{59}Ni. However, the negative QQ-value there was 26 keV, and the probability of the virtual transition is proportional to the inverse of the square of this energy difference [49]. Thus, the smaller the energy difference, the better the candidate. Recently, another possible candidate, 72^{72}As, was discovered with a QQ-value of -3.42(8) keV for a transition to an excited state [48].

Conclusion and Outlook

At the JYFLTRAP Penning-trap mass spectrometer, direct high-precision ground-state-to-ground-state β−\beta^{-}/EC-decay QQ-value measurements of 76^{76}As(β−\beta^{-})76^{76}Se and 155^{155}Tb(EC)155^{155}Gd were performed using the PI-ICR technique. The QQ values of the two decay pairs were determined to be 2959.265(74) keV and 814.94(18) keV, respectively. The precision of the 76^{76}As(β−\beta^{-})76^{76}Se-decay QQ value was improved by a factor of more than 50. A factor of 12 more precise QQ value was obtained for the 155^{155}Tb(EC)155^{155}Gd decay. Combining with the high-precision energy-level data from γ\gamma-ray spectroscopy, we deduced with sub-keV precision the QQ values for the potential ultra-low QQ-value β−\beta^{-} transition 76^{76}As (ground state) →\rightarrow 76^{76}Se∗^{*} (2968.4(7) keV) and EC transition 155^{155}Tb (ground state) →\rightarrow 155^{155}Gd∗^{*} (815.731(3) keV) to be -9.13(70) keV and -0.79(18) keV, respectively. Both of the β−\beta^{-} decay and EC decay candidate transitions were confirmed to be energetically forbidden at least at the level of 4σ4\sigma, thus definitely ruling out these two decay transitions as possible ultra-low QQ-value candidates for the electron (anti)neutrino mass determination. On the other hand, the discovery of such small negative QQ values makes these nuclei excellent candidates for the study of virtual β\beta-γ\gamma transitions.

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge the staff of the accelerator laboratory of University of Jyväskylä (JYFL-ACCLAB) for providing stable online beam and J. Jaatinen and R. Seppälä for preparing the production targets. We thank the support by the Academy of Finland under the Finnish Centre of Excellence Programme 2012-2017 (Nuclear and Accelerator Based Physics Research at JYFL) and projects No. 306980, 312544, 275389, 284516, 295207, 314733, 318043, 327629 and 320062. The support by the EU Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under grant No. 771036 (ERC CoG MAIDEN) is acknowledged.

References

References

  1. [1]J. Suhonen and O. Civitarese, Physics Reports 300, 123 (1998).
  2. [2]F. T. Avignone, S. R. Elliott, and J. Engel, Reviews of Modern Physics 80, 481 (2008), arXiv:0708.1033.
  3. [3]H. Ejiri, J. Suhonen, and K. Zuber, Physics Reports 797, 1 (2019).
  4. [4]E. G. Myers, A. Wagner, H. Kracke, and B. A. Wesson, Physical Review Letters 114 (2015), 10.1103/PhysRevLett.114.013003.
  5. [5]M. Aker, A. Beglarian, J. Behrens, A. Berlev, U. Besserer, B. Bieringer, F. Block, B. Bornschein, L. Bornschein, M. Böttcher, T. Brunst, T. S. Caldwell, R. M. D. Carney, L. L. Cascio, S. Chilingaryan, W. Choi, K. Debowski, M. Deffert, M. Descher, D. D. Barrero, P. J. Doe, O. Dragoun, G. Drexlin, K. Eitel, E. Ellinger, R. Engel, S. Enomoto, A. Felden, J. A. Formaggio, F. M. Fränkle, G. B. Franklin, F. Friedel, A. Fulst, K. Gauda, W. Gil, F. Glück, R. Grössle, R. Gumbsheimer, V. Gupta, T. Höhn, V. Hannen, N. Haußmann, K. Helbing, S. Hickford, R. Hiller, D. Hillesheimer, D. Hinz, T. Houdy, A. Huber, A. Jansen, C. Karl, F. Kellerer, J. Kellerer, M. Klein, C. Köhler, L. Köllenberger, A. Kopmann, M. Korzeczek, A. Kovalik, B. Krasch, H. Krause, N. Kunka, T. Lasserre, T. L. Le, O. Lebeda, B. Lehnert, A. Lokhov, M. Machatschek, E. Malcherek, M. Mark, A. Marsteller, E. L. Martin, C. Melzer, A. Menshikov, S. Mertens, J. Mostafa, K. Müller, S. Niemes, P. Oelpmann, D. S. Parno, A. W. P. Poon, J. M. L. Poyato, F. Priester, M. Röllig, C. Röttele, R. G. H. Robertson, W. Rodejohann, C. Rodenbeck, M. Ryšavý, R. Sack, A. Saenz, P. Schäfer, A. Schaller, L. Schimpf, K. Schlösser, M. Schlösser, L. Schlüter, S. Schneidewind, M. Schrank, B. Schulz, A. Schwemmer, M. Šefčík, V. Sibille, D. Siegmann, M. Slezák, M. Steidl, M. Sturm, M. Sun, D. Tcherniachovski, H. H. Telle, L. A. Thorne, T. Thümmler, N. Titov, I. Tkachev, K. Urban, K. Valerius, D. Vénos, A. P. V. Hernández, C. Weinheimer, S. Welte, J. Wendel, J. F. Wilkerson, J. Wolf, S. Wüstling, W. Xu, Y. R. Yen, S. Zadoroghny, and G. Zeller, “First direct neutrino-mass measurement with sub-eV sensitivity,” (2021), arXiv:2105.08533 [hep-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2105.08533
  6. [6]C. Kraus, B. Bornschein, L. Bornschein, J. Bonn, B. Flatt, A. Kovalik, B. Ostrick, E. W. Otten, J. P. Schall, T. Thümmler, and C. Weinheimer, European Physical Journal C 40, 447 (2005), arXiv:0412056 [hep-ex].
  7. [7]V. N. Aseev, A. I. Belesev, A. I. Berlev, E. V. Geraskin, A. A. Golubev, N. A. Likhovid, V. M. Lobashev, A. A. Nozik, V. S. Pantuev, V. I. Parfenov, A. K. Skasyrskaya, F. V. Tkachov, and S. V. Zadorozhny, Physical Review D - Particles, Fields, Gravitation and Cosmology 84, 112003 (2011).
  8. [8]B. Monreal and J. A. Formaggio, Physical Review D 80, 051301 (2009).
  9. [9]S. Eliseev, K. Blaum, M. Block, S. Chenmarev, H. Dorrer, C. E. Düllmann, C. Enss, P. E. Filianin, L. Gastaldo, M. Goncharov, U. Köster, F. Leuten schläger, Y. N. Novikov, A. Rischka, R. X. Schüssler, L. Schweikhard, and A. Türler, Physical Review Letters 115, 62501 (2015), arXiv:1604.04210.DOI
  10. [10]L. Gastaldo, K. Blaum, K. Chrysalidis, T. Day Goodacre, A. Domula, M. Door, H. Dorrer, C. E. Düllmann, K. Eberhardt, S. Eliseev, C. Enss, A. Faessler, P. Filianin, A. Fleischmann, D. Fonnesu, L. Gamer, R. Haas, C. Hassel, D. Hengstler, J. Jochum, K. Johnston, U. Kebschull, S. Kempf, T. Kieck, U. Köster, S. Lahiri, M. Maiti, F. Mantegazzini, B. Marsh, P. Neroutsos, Y. N. Novikov, P. C. Ranitzsch, S. Rothe, A. Rischka, A. Saenz, O. Sander, F. Schneider, S. Scholl, R. X. Schüssler, C. Schweiger, F. Simkovic, T. Stora, Z. Szűcs, A. Türler, M. Veinhard, M. Weber, M. Wegner, K. Wendt, and K. Zuber, European Physical Journal: Special Topics 226, 1623 (2017).
  11. [11]M. Faverzani, B. Alpert, D. Backer, D. Bennet, M. Biasotti, C. Brofferio, V. Ceriale, G. Ceruti, D. Corsini, P. K. Day, M. De Gerone, R. Dressler, E. Ferri, J. Fowler, E. Fumagalli, J. Gard, F. Gatti, A. Giacherо, J. Hays-Wehle, S. Heinitz, G. Hilton, U. Köster, M. Lusignoli, M. Maino, J. Mates, S. Nisi, R. Nizzolo, A. Nucciotti, A. Orlando, L. Parodi, G. Pessina, P. Pizzigoni, A. Puiu, S. Ragazzi, C. Reintsema, M. Ribeiro-Gomez, D. Schmidt, D. Schuman, F. Siccardi, M. Sisti, D. Swetz, F. Terranova, J. Ullom, and L. Vale, Journal of Low Temperature Physics 184, 922 (2016).
  12. [12]M. P. Croce, M. W. Rabin, V. G. Mocko, G. J. Kunde, E. R. Birnbaum, E. M. Bond, J. W. Engle, A. S. Hoover, F. M. Nortier, A. D. Pollington, W. A. Taylor, N. R. Weisse-Bernstein, L. E. Wolfsberg, J. P. Hays-Wehle, D. R. Schmidt, D. S. Swetz, J. N. Ullom, T. E. Barnhart, and R. J. Nickles, Journal of Low Temperature Physics 184, 958 (2016).
  13. [13]M. T. Mustonen and J. Suhonen, Journal of Physics G: Nuclear and Particle Physics 37, 64008 (2010).
  14. [14]M. Mustonen and J. Suhonen, Physics Letters B 703, 370 (2011).
  15. [15]J. Suhonen, Physica Scripta 89, 54032 (2014).
  16. [16]A. De Roubin, J. Kostensalo, T. Eronen, L. Canete, R. P. De Groote, A. Jokinen, A. Kankainen, D. A. Nesterenko, I. D. Moore, S. Rinta-Antila, J. Suhonen, and M. Vilén, Physical Review Letters 124, 1 (2020), arXiv:2002.08282.
  17. [17]Z. Ge, T. Eronen, K. S. Tyrin, J. Kotila, J. Kostensalo, D. A. Nesterenko, O. Beliuskina, R. de Groote, A. De Roubin, S. Geldhof, W. Gins, M. Hukkanen, A. Jokinen, A. Kankainen, A. Koszorús, M. I. Krivoruchko, S. Kujanpää, I. D. Moore, A. Raggio, S. Rinta-Antila, J. Suhonen, V. Virtanen, A. P. Weaver, and A. Zadvornaya, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 272301 (2021).
  18. [18]C. M. Cattadori, M. De Deo, M. Laubenstein, L. Pandola, and V. I. Tretyak, Nuclear Physics A 748, 333 (2005).
  19. [19]B. J. Mount, M. Redshaw, and E. G. Myers, Physical Review Letters 103, 122502 (2009).
  20. [20]J. S. Wieslander, J. Suhonen, T. Eronen, M. Hult, V. V. Elomaa, A. Jokinen, G. Marissens, M. Misiaszek, M. T. Mustonen, S. Rahaman, C. Weber, and J. Äystö, Physical Review Letters 103, 122501 (2009).
  21. [21]V. A. Zheltonozhsky, A. M. Savrasov, N. V. Strilchuk, and V. I. Tretyak, EPL (Europhysics Letters) 121, 12001 (2018).
  22. [22]“National nuclear data center,” Available at https://www.nndc.bnl.gov/ (2020/4/7) (2021).
  23. [23]N. D. Ngamage, R. Bhandari, M. Horana Gamage, R. Sandler, and M. Redshaw, Hyperfine Interactions 240 (2019), 10.1007/s10751-019-1588-5.
  24. [24]M. Wang, W. Huang, F. Kondev, G. Audi, and S. Naimi, Chinese Physics C 45, 030003 (2021).
  25. [25]T. Eronen and J. C. Hardy, European Physical Journal A 48, 1 (2012).
  26. [26]I. D. Moore, T. Eronen, D. Gorelov, J. Hakala, A. Jokinen, A. Kankainen, V. S. Kolhinen, J. Koponen, H. Penttilä, I. Pohjalainen, M. Reponen, J. Rissanen, A. Saastamoinen, S. Rinta-Antila, V. Sonnenschein, and J. Äystö, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms 317, 208 (2013).
  27. [27]V. S. Kolhinen, T. Eronen, D. Gorelov, J. Hakala, A. Jokinen, K. Jokiranta, A. Kankainen, M. Koikkalainen, J. Koponen, H. Kulmala, M. Lantz, A. Mattera, I. D. Moore, H. Penttilä, T. Pikkarainen, I. Pohjalainen, M. Reponen, S. Rinta-Antila, J. Rissanen, C. Rodríguez Triguero, K. Rytkönen, A. Saastamoinen, A. Solders, V. Sonnenschein, and J. Äystö, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms 317, 506 (2013).
  28. [28]J. Huikari, P. Dendooven, A. Jokinen, A. Nieminen, H. Penttilä, K. Peräjärvi, A. Popov, S. Rinta-Antila, and J. Äystö, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms 222, 632 (2004).
  29. [29]P. Karvonen, I. D. Moore, T. Sonoda, T. Kessler, H. Penttilä, K. Peräjärvi, P. Ronkanen, and J. Äystö, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms 266, 4794 (2008).
  30. [30]A. Nieminen, J. Huikari, A. Jokinen, J. Äystö, P. Campbell, and E. C. Cochrane, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 469, 244 (2001).
  31. [31]M. König, G. Bollen, H. J. Kluge, T. Otto, and J. Szerpyo, International Journal of Mass Spectrometry and Ion Processes 142, 95 (1995).
  32. [32]G. Gräff, H. Kalinowsky, and J. Traut, Zeitschrift für Physik A: Atoms and Nuclei 297, 35 (1980).
  33. [33]D. A. Nesterenko, T. Eronen, A. Kankainen, L. Canete, A. Jokinen, I. D. Moore, H. Penttilä, S. Rinta-Antila, A. de Roubin, and M. Vilen, European Physical Journal A 54, 0 (2018).
  34. [34]S. Eliseev, K. Blaum, M. Block, A. Dörr, C. Droese, T. Eronen, M. Goncharov, M. Höcker, J. Ketter, E. M. Ramirez, D. A. Nesterenko, Y. N. Novikov, and L. Schweikhard, Applied Physics B: Lasers and Optics 114, 107 (2014).
  35. [35]S. Eliseev, K. Blaum, M. Block, C. Droese, M. Goncharov, E. Minaya Ramirez, D. A. Nesterenko, Y. N. Novikov, and L. Schweikhard, Physical Review Letters 110, 82501 (2013).
  36. [36]G. Savard, S. Becker, G. Bollen, H. J. Kluge, R. B. Moore, T. Otto, L. Schweikhard, H. Stolzenberg, and U. Wiess, Physics Letters A 158, 247 (1991).
  37. [37]T. Eronen, V. V. Elomaa, U. Hager, J. Hakala, A. Jokinen, A. Kankainen, S. Rahaman, J. Rissanen, C. Weber, and J. Äystö, Acta Physica Polonica B 39, 445 (2008).
  38. [38]“Micro-channel plate detector with delay line anode, roentdek handels gmbh,” Available at http://www.roentdek.de (2020/11/30) (2021).
  39. [39]M. Kretzschmar, AIP Conf. Proc. 457, 242 (1999).
  40. [40]A. Kramida, Yu. Ralchenko, J. Reader, and and NIST ASD Team, NIST Atomic Spectra Database (ver. 5.8), [Online]. Available: https://physics.nist.gov/asd [2021, January 19]. National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD. (2020).
  41. [41]A. Kellerbauer, K. Blaum, G. Bollen, F. Herfurth, H. J. Kluge, M. Kuckein, E. Sauvan, C. Scheidenberger, and L. Schweikhard, European Physical Journal D 22, 53 (2003).
  42. [42]C. Roux, K. Blaum, M. Block, C. Droese, S. Eliseev, M. Goncharov, F. Herfurth, E. M. Ramirez, D. A. Nesterenko, Y. N. Novikov, and L. Schweikhard, The European Physical Journal D 67, 1 (2013).
  43. [43]R. T. Birge, Physical Review 40, 207 (1932).
  44. [44]W. Huang, M. Wang, F. Kondev, G. Audi, and S. Naimi, Chinese Physics C 45, 030002 (2021).
  45. [45]Y. Litvinov, H. Geissel, T. Radon, F. Attallah, G. Audi, K. Beckert, F. Bosch, M. Falch, B. Franzke, M. Hausmann, M. Hellström, T. Kerscher, O. Klepper, H.-J. Kluge, C. Kozhuharov, K. Löbner, G. Münzenberg, F. Nolden, Y. Novikov, W. Quint, Z. Patyk, H. Reich, C. Scheidenberger, B. Schlitt, M. Steck, K. Sümmerer, L. Vermeeren, M. Winkler, T. Winkler, and H. Wollnik, Nuclear Physics A 756, 3 (2005).
  46. [46]D. Fink, J. Barea, D. Beck, K. Blaum, C. Böhm, C. Borgmann, M. Breitenfeldt, F. Herfurth, A. Herlert, J. Kotila, M. Kowalska, S. Kreim, D. Lunney, S. Naimi, M. Rosenbusch, S. Schwarz, L. Schweikhard, F. Šimkovic, J. Stanja, and K. Zuber, Physical Review Letters 108, 1 (2012).
  47. [47]D. A. Nesterenko, L. Canete, T. Eronen, A. Jokinen, A. Kankainen, Y. N. Novikov, S. Rinta-Antila, A. de Roubin, and M. Vilen, International Journal of Mass Spectrometry 435, 204 (2019).
  48. [48]Z. Ge, T. Eronen, A. de Roubin, D. A. Nesterenko, M. Hukkanen, O. Beliuskina, R. de Groote, S. Geldhof, W. Gins, A. Kankainen, A. Koszorús, J. Kotila, J. Kostensalo, I. D. Moore, A. Raggio, S. Rinta-Antila, J. Suhonen, V. Virtanen, A. P. Weaver, A. Zadvornaya, and A. Jokinen, Physical Review C 103, 065502 (2021).
  49. [49]C. L. Longmire, Phys. Rev. 75, 15 (1949).
  50. [50]M. Pfützner, K. Pachucki, and J. Żylicz, Physical Review C 92, 044305 (2015).

Paper details

vlnc:W_zxpe3wte
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents