WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Recent progress in high-temperature superconducting undulators
Abstract
Considerable effort has been devoted to the development of superconducting undulators (SCUs) intended for particle accelerator-based light sources, including synchrotrons and free electron laser (FEL) facilities. Recently, a high-temperature superconducting (HTS) undulator prototype, consisting of staggered-array Re-Ba-Cu-O bulks, achieved an on-axis sinusoidal magnetic field profile with a peak amplitude B of 2.1 T and a period length of 10 mm, resulting in a deflection parameter K = 1.96. Such a short period HTS undulator not only enables the generation of higher-energy photons, but also supports the construction of economically feasible and compact FELs with shorter linear accelerators (LINACs). This article provides a comprehensive review of recent advances in the staggered-array bulk HTS undulator as well as other types of HTS undulators. Furthermore, it offers insights into the development of engineering HTS undulator prototypes designed for deployment in synchrotron and free electron laser (FEL) facilities. We conclude by discussing opportunities for and the challenges facing the use of HTS undulators in practical applications.
Review Article
Introduction
Over recent decades, there has been a rising demand in synchrotrons and free electron lasers (FELs) for insertion devices with enhanced performance. One approach to meeting this demand involves the realisation of undulator technologies capable of generating high on-axis magnetic fields over short periods. Significant evolution in undulator designs has occurred, encompassing permanent magnet undulators (PMUs) [1], in-vacuum undulators (IVUs) [2], cryogenic permanent magnet undulators (CPMUs) [3], superconducting undulators (SCUs) [4, 5], and most recently, high-temperature superconducting undulators (HTSUs) [6, 7]. Undulators with shorter periods promise substantial improvements in photon energy output and could facilitate the development of next-generation compact FELs that require shorter linear accelerators (LINACs). A notable example is the International Linear Collider (ILC) project, which necessitates the deployment of 11.5 mm-period superconducting helical undulators. These undulators are crucial for generating circularly polarized -ray sources aimed at producing polarized positrons [8, 9, 10].
Superconducting undulators offer significant advantages over PMUs because they achieve higher on-axis magnetic field () generation for a given period () [5], thereby enhancing photon flux in the high-energy region of the x-ray spectrum. The Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT) and Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) have actively developed and implemented SCU technologies using Nb-Ti/Cu superconducting coils within their respective storage rings for beamline applications [11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16]. Currently, SCU installations at these facilities utilize exceeding 14 mm to achieve satisfactory deflection parameters, . This is primarily due to the requirement of accommodating electron bunches within a large-bore vacuum pipe while they circulate in a closed orbit (e.g., 7 mm for
KIT synchrotron and 7.2 mm for APS). In recent years, the Shanghai HIgh repetitioN rate XFEL and Extreme light facility (SHINE) as well as the European XFEL (EuXFEL) in collaboration with Bilfinger Noel have been developing SCUs with reduced beam gap and increased undulator field [17, 18, 19, 20]. These developments aim to support the construction of the 3rd hard x-ray beamline at SHINE and to serve as SCU afterburners at EuXFEL’s SASE2 hard x-ray beamline [21, 22].
Superconducting undulators utilizing NbSn/Cu wires are expected to achieve elevated undulator fields due to their superior critical current density () compared to Nb-Ti/Cu wires. Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) and Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL) have developed expertise in essential technologies necessary for the construction of NbSn undulators. These include the wind-and-react technique and stress management strategies aimed at minimizing degradation in heat-treated NbSn coils [23, 24, 25, 26, 27]. In 2023, ANL in collaboration with LBNL and Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (FNAL) achieved a significant milestone by fabricating a 1.1 m-long NbSn planar undulator, achieving an undulator field of T with a period of 18 mm and a magnetic gap of 9.5 mm. Subsequently, this device was successfully integrated into the storage ring of Advanced Photon Source (APS) at ANL and delivered effective operational performance for users before the shutdown of APS for upgrade [28].
Since 2018, Paul Scherrer Institute (PSI) has been dedicated to advancing high-temperature superconducting (HTS) undulators with period lengths as short as 10 mm [7, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37]. Their short planar prototype, utilizing staggered-array Re-Ba-Cu-O (ReBCO) bulks, achieved a record undulator field of T at a period of mm, corresponding to a value of 1.96. Additionally, a short helical prototype employing double staggered-array ReBCO bulks achieved an on-axis field of T at a period of mm [38]. These
achievements represent significant strides in undulator technology. Both the Swiss Light Source 2.0 (SLS2.0) and the Shanghai Soft X-ray Free-Electron Laser (SXFEL) have outlined plans to develop practical prototypes of bulk HTS undulators for integration into the storage ring or downstream the LINACs [21, 39, 40].
Figure 1(a) presents an aerial perspective of the Shanghai Synchrotron Radiation Facility (SSRF) and Shanghai Soft X-ray Free-Electron Laser (SXFEL) located within Zhangjiang Science City, Shanghai [41, 42]. Undulators are positioned either within straight sections of the storage ring or downstream of the LINACs to produce highly collimated photon beams with a high degree of transverse and temporal coherence, as depicted in Figure 1(b-Figure 1c). Simultaneously, construction progresses on SHINE, a superconducting high-repetition-rate hard X-ray Free-Electron Laser (FEL) facility spanning approximately 3.1 km in length and capable of accelerating electron bunches up to 8 GeV [43, 44].

Figure 1. (a) Aerial photograph of SSRF and SXFEL constructed in Zhangjiang Science City, Shanghai. (b) Undulator unit in the storage ring of SSRF. (c) Undulator system downstream the LINACs of SXFEL.
This paper first presents an overview of the working principles of and recent advancements in various configurations of HTS undulators utilizing ReBCO bulk or coated conductors. It subsequently details the developmental progress of engineering prototypes of HTS undulators designated for the Swiss Light Source upgrade (SLS2.0) and the SXFEL facility [39, 42]. Finally, the paper discusses opportunities and challenges of HTS undulators for practical applications.
Working principles
There are two primary configurations of HTS undulators: planar and helical. In planar undulators, high-energy electron bunches oscillate within either the - plane under the influence of an alternating magnetic field as shown in Figure 2(a), or within the - plane under the influence of an alternating magnetic field , oriented along the beam axis. This process results in the generation of linearly polarized photons either horizontally or vertically. In contrast, helical undulators use alternating magnetic fields in the - and - planes, with a 90-degree phase shift between them, causing electron bunches to follow a spiral trajectory along the beam axis, thereby emitting photons either left handed or right handed polarised. The difference between the two undulator configurations lies in the emitted on-axis photon beams, where the helical undulator is limited to the fundamental harmonic, while a planar undulator can generate higher harmonics which is attractive to synchrotrons [45]. Helical undulators are attractive to FELs because their emitted fundamental harmonic is more intense on the axis compared to planar undulators, which is crucial for the self-amplified spontaneous emission (SASE) process where only on-axis radiation counts. For beamline users across various research disciplines, there are frequent demands for polarization mode-adjustable undulators to enable improved observation of their samples [46, 47, 48, 49]. As of the present review, no literature documenting the development of HTS undulators with adjustable polarization modes has been identified.

Figure 2. HTS planar undulator comprising of two sets of (a) horizontal racetrack coils, (b) vertical racetrack coils, and (c) laser-structured, laminated ReBCO tapes. (d) HTS helical undulator comprising of one pair of helically wound superconducting coils. (e) HTS planar undulator comprising of two sets of horizontally arranged, magnetized ReBCO bulks. (f) HTS planar undulator comprising of staggered-array ReBCO bulks. (g) HTS helical undulator comprising of double staggered-array ReBCO bulks. Each type of HTS undulator model is created with ten periods. The green lines refer to the on-axis sinusoidal magnetic field or . (For interpretation of the references to colour in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article.)
HTS undulators typically utilize superconducting coils wound with high-performance HTS wires. Common materials used include the silver-sheathed (Bi-2223) tapes [50], (Bi-2212) wires [51], (ReBCO, Re = rare earth) tapes (also called coated conductors) [52], wires [53] and iron-based superconductors [54]. Among these, ReBCO tapes stand out as particularly promising for practical applications due to their high critical temperature () and critical current density (), as illustrated in the summary plot presented in reference [38]. It is important to note that the of these tapes is significantly influenced by the angle between the magnetic field and the surface of the tape. Figure 2(a-Figure 2b) depicts magnetic models of HTS planar undulators featuring configurations with two sets of horizontal racetrack (HR) coils and two sets of vertical racetrack (VR) coils, respectively. Both configurations were widely employed in advanced Nb-Ti or NbSn undulators. Figure 2(c) illustrates a schematic of an HTS planar undulator utilizing two sets of laser-structured, laminated ReBCO tape stacks [55]. This design ensures controlled paths for the transport current within each tape stack, generating an alternating magnetic field along the beam axis. Figure 2(d) presents the magnetic model of an HTS helical undulator comprising one pair of helically wound superconducting coils. By applying currents in opposite directions to these pairs, alternating magnetic fields are generated in the - and - planes, with a 90-degree phase shift between them. Magnetized bulk superconductors can be used as pseudo-permanent magnets in HTS undulators. ReBCO bulk superconductors can trap magnetic fields over 17.6 Tesla, making them ideal for compact undulator designs [56, 57]. Figure 2(e) illustrates the magnetic layout of an HTS planar undulator comprising two sets of horizontally arranged ReBCO bulks. This design integrates racetrack coils to generate a uniform dipole field for magnetizing the ReBCO bulks [58, 59]. An alternative approach involves constructing an HTS planar undulator using ReBCO bulks with a superconducting solenoid to produce a uniform magnetic field . This field magnetizes a series of staggered-array, half-moon-shaped bulk superconductors, as depicted in Figure 2(f) [60, 61]. By rotating each ReBCO bulk continuously by 90 degrees relative to its predecessor and magnetizing the long HTS insert with a uniform magnetic field , one obtains a novel type of HTS helical undulator, as depicted in Figure 2(g) [38].
Recent progresses
Over the past decade, advances have been made in the development of racetrack HTS coils tailored for undulator applications [62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69]. An example includes the development of a ReBCO coil prototype by Boffo et al, as illustrated in Figure 3. This prototype was charged with an engineering current density up to 700 kA · mm, however, magnetic measurements were not conducted. In 2014, Nguyen et al. achieved a milestone with a three-period HTSU utilizing VR ReBCO coils, achieving an undulator field of T, featuring a period of 14 mm and a 3 mm pole gap, operated within a subcooled liquid nitrogen environment at 65 K [66]. Subsequently, Kesgin et al. investigated HTSU prototypes employing non-insulation (NI) or partial-insulation (PI) ReBCO coils, achieving an operational current density up to 2.1 kA · m [68]. Their findings highlighted that the PI technique not only reduced charging delays but also maintained the intrinsic self-protection features of NI coils during a quench. In 2024, Garg et al. reported on the fabrication and characterization of an HTS planar undulator utilizing MgB coils designed with three periods, featuring a period length of 14.4 mm and a magnetic gap of 6.35 mm, as depicted in Figure 4 [70]. The inherent asymmetry in the coil configuration resulted in an observed field offset in the undulator, characterized by peaks at + 1.19 T and − 0.25 T. Numerical simulations indicated that a meter-long MgB undulator could achieve an undulator field of T, consistent with theoretical expectations.

Figure 3. A racetrack ReBCO coil prototype by Boffo et al. Reproduced with permissions from [64].

Figure 4. An MgB undulator prototype by Garg et al.. Reproduced from [70]. CC BY 4.0.
In 2009, Prestemon et al. introduced a meander-type HTSU concept utilizing laser-structured ReBCO tapes with predefined current paths, as illustrated in Figure 2(c) [71, 72]. Subsequent experimental validation demonstrated that a single laser-structured tape could generate an
alternating magnetic field exceeding 10 mT along the central axis, positioned 2 mm above the tape surface [73]. Further R&D efforts aimed at enhancing the applicability of the meander-type undulator included innovative fabrication techniques such as the JUST winding scheme proposed by Holubek et al. [74] and the soldering method for adjacent ReBCO tapes proposed by Krasch et al. [75]. Numerical simulations indicate that this emerging technique shows potential for achieving substantial undulator field with short period length, though significant prototyping efforts are necessary for practical deployment.
High-temperature superconducting wires or tapes can be configured in a spiral arrangement to create a helical undulator, depicted in Figure 2(d). In 2008, Majoros et al. documented the fabrication and testing of a MgB helical undulator with a period length of 14 mm and a total length of 250 mm [76]. The prototype, constrained by the filling factor and low of MgB round wires, achieved an undulator field of 0.25 T within a 7 mm beam aperture. In 2024, Richter et al. introduced the design and construction of a demonstrator HTS helical undulator comprised of five periods wound using ReBCO tapes [77]. To ensure smooth winding and preserve the tape’s , the authors developed a specialized mechanical support structure with a generous bending radius to ease the tape’s return path. This helical prototype demonstrated stable operation under a charging current of 150 A at 77 K, though detailed characterization of its on-axis magnetic field distribution was not included in the publication.
High-temperature superconducting undulators constructed from bulk superconductors have become increasingly prominent in both the applied superconductivity and accelerator-based photon source communities in recent years. One promising approach involves using a superconducting solenoid to magnetize a series of ReBCO bulk superconductors, thereby generating planar or helical undulator fields, as depicted in Figure 2(f) and Figure 2(g) respectively. In 2013, Kinjo et al. demonstrated a short bulk HTSU prototype could produce an undulator field of T for mm, within a 4 mm magnetic gap [78]. Subsequently, motivated by the EU-funded CompactLight project initiated in 2018 for designing a compact hard x-ray FEL [79], PSI in collaboration with University of Cambridge undertook research and development efforts focused on short-period bulk HTS undulators. They fabricated a series of 10 mm-period undulator samples using various ReBCO bulk materials and assembly techniques, as illustrated in Figure 5. Below is a concise summary of their comprehensive fabrication and testing campaign conducted on the undulator samples:

Figure 5. Timeline of the development of HTS planar undulator models comprising of staggered-array ReBCO bulk superconductors at the Paul Scherrer Institute.
The first bulk sample comprised 5 periods with a 6 mm magnetic gap, fabricated using GdBCO/Ag bulks grown by the University of Cambridge, as illustrated in Figure 5(a). Following field cooling (FC) magnetization from 6 T, the sample produced an undulator field of 0.85 T at 10 K [30]. Notably, during a subsequent test, a higher undulator field was achieved due to delayed quenching, suggesting a potential training effect possibly linked to the movement of half-moon shaped GdBCO disks within copper disks or the relative movement between neighbouring GdBCO-Copper disks under Lorentz forces.
The second bulk sample employed GdBCO/Ag bulks obtained from Cambridge, comprising 10 periods with a 4 mm magnetic gap, illustrated in Figure 5(b). Upon FC magnetization starting from T, the undulator field showed a gradual increment until a quench occurred at T. Subsequently, as continued to decrease, the undulator field exhibited another rise until a second quench observed at T. This bulk sample achieved an undulator field of 1.29 T at 15 K and 1.54 T at 10 K, respectively.
Based on lessons learned from the initial two bulk samples, a novel shrink-fit assembly technique was developed for industrial bulk samples. This method aimed to apply sufficient prestress to half-moon-shaped HTS bulks to suppress potential displacements and withstand significant Lorentz forces during magnetizations. In this technique, each HTS bulk was precisely fitted into a heated copper disk (~200 °C), followed by assembly into a lengthened aluminum shell also heated to ~200 °C, as illustrated in Figure 5(c). It was observed that this novel technique could eliminated premature quenches but not the inhomogeneity of the undulator field observed in previous bulk samples. To reduce the peak-to-peak field error of , all bulk pieces were sorted and reassembled into a modified aluminum shell support, depicted in Figure 5(d). Details about the analysis and optimization of the undulator field were described in [80].
The observed inhomogeneity in the undulator field across the samples was attributed to variations in critical current density () among individual bulk superconductors. To address this
issue, Calvi et al. proposed a strategy to pre-screen bulk pieces based on their superconducting performance prior to assembly into an undulator [7]. This method was implemented in the fabrication of a new industrial bulk sample utilizing GdBCO bulk superconductors from Nippon Steel (NS) company. The bulk superconductors were housed within newly designed two-piece copper support shells aimed at enhancing thermal conduction, as depicted in Figure 5(e). Figure 6(a) illustrates magnetic field scans at 77 K conducted on thirty magnetized, half-moon-shaped NS/GdBCO-Cu pieces. From these scans, twenty pieces demonstrating intermediate trapped field performances were selected, as highlighted in Figure 6(b). Figure 6(c-Figure 6d) present magnetic field measurement results for the selected sample of Figure 5(e). This optimized bulk sample was magnetized at 10 K and achieved a notable undulator field of T with a 10 mm period and exhibited a low peak-to-peak field error, , comparable to that of permanent magnet undulators prior to magnetic shimming [7]. Figure 7 provides a comparative analysis of achievable values across different undulator technologies.

Figure 6. (a) Scanning magnetic field maps of 30 NS-GdBCO/Ag disks magnetized at 77 K. (b) Selection of 20 disks with intermediate trapped field capabilities. (c) Measured magnetic field of a “good” sample comprising of pre-sorted NS-GdBCO/Ag disks. (d) Relation between undulator field , the field error and . Reproduced from [7]. CC BY 4.0.

Figure 7. Comparison of the achievable undulator field between using HTS and the other technologies [7, 81]. The magnetic gap is fixed at 4 mm.
These - curves, corresponding to a fixed magnetic gap of 4 mm, were derived through extrapolation from the scaling laws outlined in reference [81].
In 2023, Calvi et al. introduced a novel GdBCO bulk superconducting helical undulator prototype tailored for compact X-ray Free Electron Lasers (FELs), as depicted in Figure 8(a) [38]. Utilizing GdBCO bulk pieces selected from the previously identified sample shown in Figure 5(e), the authors arranged each piece at a 90-degree rotation relative to its predecessor, thereby creating a new helical undulator configuration featuring a double staggered-array of bulk superconductors. This 104 mm-long undulator prototype was designed with a period length of 16 mm and a magnetic gap of 4 mm. Upon magnetization with a solenoidal field of 10 Tesla, the prototype produced an on-axis magnetic field exceeding 2.5 T in - and - planes, as illustrated in Figure 8(b-Figure 8c). It is noteworthy that a helical undulator configuration has the potential to enhance the interaction between electrons and photons [82], leading to earlier saturation of the FEL process and increased power, which in turn reduces the required undulator length.

Figure 8. (a) A short helical undulator prototype fabricated based on a novel double staggered-array configuration proposed by Calvi et al. (b) Measured magnetic field profile during FC magnetization. (c) Relation between the amplitude of undulator field, and the reduction in the background magnetic field, . Reproduced from [38]. CC BY 4.0.
Towards practical applications
Paul Scherrer Institute (PSI) has initiated the development of a meter-long bulk HTS undulator for the upcoming I-TOMCAT tomographic imaging beamline at the upgraded Swiss Light Source (SLS 2.0) by late 2026. The envisioned HTS undulator aims to significantly enhance photon brightness by more than an order of magnitude, enabling experiments at photon energies up to 60 keV and expanding the photon spectrum twofold compared to conventional undulator technologies. Figure 9 provides the flux comparison at 30 m from the source to illuminate a sample of about at I-TOMCAT beamline between installing a 10 mm-period HTSU with and a state-of-the-art 14 mm-period CPMU with of the same undulator length of 1 m into SLS 2.0 which has an electron beam energy of 2.7 GeV and emittance of 150 pm·rad. Following deliberations, the HTS undulator is designed to be 2.0 m long, with an active length of 1.0 m, a period length of 10.5 mm, a magnetic gap of 4.5 mm, and a peak undulator field of 1.8 T. Figure 10(a) depicts the appearance of the HTS planar undulator scheduled for installation at the I-TOMCAT beamline at SLS 2.0 [39]. Figure 10(b) provides a cross-

Figure 9. Comparison of the calculated flux at 30 m from the source to illuminate a sample of about 1.0 × 1.0 mm² at I-TOMCAT beamline between installing HTSU10 with T and CPMU14 with T of the same undulator length of 1 m into SLS 2.0 which has an electron beam energy of 2.7 GeV and emittance of 150 pm·rad.

Figure 10. (a) A 1 m-long, 10.5 mm-period HTS planar undulator designed for the I-TOMCAT beam line at SLS2.0. (b) Half section view of the cryostat which houses the 12 T superconducting solenoid and the variable temperature HTS insert.
sectional view of the undulator cryostat which houses a 12 T superconducting solenoid wound with NbSn/Cu wires and a variable temperature HTS insert composed of staggered-array ReBCO bulk superconductors. The HTS insert, integrated within the cold solenoid magnet, facilitates temperature control ranging from 4 K to above 100 K using GM cryocoolers and heaters. Fabrication and assembly of hundreds of half-moon-shaped bulk superconductors and ferromagnetic pole pieces have been completed, preparing for the construction of the meter-long HTS insert. The 12 T superconducting solenoid magnet is currently being constructed at Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory (FNAL) and will soon be transported to PSI for integration with the HTS insert [83].
Recently, research and development on a 0.6 m-long, 12 mm-period bulk HTS undulator prototype has been initiated in Shanghai, with the objective of supporting future enhancements to SSRF or SXFEL. This prototype is intended for testing at the Shanghai Soft X-ray Free Electron Laser (SXFEL) facility during its scheduled maintenance in 2025 [42, 84]. Figure 11 illustrates the design of the 12 mm-period bulk HTS undulator prototype, providing a sectional view featuring its two separate vacuum chambers. One chamber is dedicated to housing a 7 T superconducting solenoid, while the other accommodates a variable temperature HTS insert composed of staggered-array ReBCO bulks. Both designs, although slightly reducing magnetic field utilization efficiency, offer the advantage of enabling straightforward assembly and disassembly of the HTS insert without requiring the warm-up of the superconducting solenoid magnet. Such capability streamlines the iterative process necessary for optimizing local magnetic fields and minimizing RMS phase errors. The fabrication, assembly, and testing of the conduction-cooled 7 T superconducting solenoid magnet have been completed. Concurrently, collaborative efforts between the HTSU teams and Shanghai University are progressing towards the development of one-step-grown, half-moon-shaped YBCO bulk superconductors. These advancements hold promise for achieving improved performance characteristics tailored specifically for undulator applications [85].

Figure 11. (a) A 0.6 m-long, 12 mm-period HTS planar undulator under construction in Shanghai. (b) Half section view of the cryostat with two independent vacuum chambers, one for housing the 7 T superconducting solenoid and the other for housing the variable temperature HTS insert.
Discussion
High-temperature superconducting coils wound with ReBCO tapes have demonstrated the capability to generate static magnetic fields exceeding 20 Tesla in solenoids [86, 87, 88, 89]. However, they have not yet surpassed Nb-Ti or NbSn coils in generating high undulator fields.
This limitation stems from challenges such as detecting and protecting against quenches, managing the screening current induced field (SCIF) effects and even developing suitable winding techniques [90, 91, 92, 93, 94]. The non-insulation (NI) winding technique shows potential for quench protection but introduces delays in charging or discharging, necessitating extended stabilization times for the central magnetic field [95, 96, 97, 98]. Furthermore, current sharing between turns restricts ReBCO coils from achieving their critical current. Recent efforts have focused on addressing these issues through the partial-insulation (PI) winding technique and reducing AC losses or SCIF effects using striated ReBCO tapes [99, 100, 101, 102]. These advancements could minimize charging delays and hysteresis between the undulator field and charging current, as discussed in [5, 103]. Moreover, significant advancements have been made in developing high- ReBCO coated conductors, which exhibit superior performance compared to conventional ReBCO tapes [104, 105]. The potential commercialization of these enhanced ReBCO tapes holds promise for advancing ReBCO coil-based undulators.
Recent progress in short-period HTS undulators utilizing ReBCO bulk superconductors has garnered attention within the undulator community and broader applications of bulk superconductors. Both planar and helical undulator prototypes have shown markedly higher on-axis magnetic fields compared to Nb-Ti counterparts of equivalent period lengths [7, 38]. However, significant challenges remain from the fabrication of short undulator samples to the development of practical bulk HTS undulators suitable for synchrotron and Free Electron Laser (FEL) applications.
First, achieving uniform undulator fields requires maintaining consistent temperatures across the lengthy HTS insert, which comprises staggered-array or double-staggered-array ReBCO bulk superconductors. To achieve this thermal stability, cryostat designs for engineering HTSU devices, as developed by PSI and ZJLAB, incorporate dual GM cryocoolers to cool both ends of the HTS insert.
Second, accurate measurement systems for horizontal magnetic fields within vacuum environments are essential for characterizing both local and overall undulator fields in narrow gaps. Techniques such as hall probe scanning and moving wire methods are demanded for high-precision measurements.
Third, to correct local undulator fields and reduce peak-to-peak field errors or RMS phase errors, initial steps involve sorting ReBCO bulks based on their trapped field capabilities. Fine-tuning of local magnetic fields then requires adjusting the local gap of ferromagnetic poles, which involves iterative processes and thermal cycling to achieve the desired undulator field uniformity.
Last but not least, synchrotrons and FELs require undulator devices capable of maintaining stable undulator fields over a period of time for beamline users. To achieve this, preventing flux creep in all magnetized ReBCO bulks is crucial to avoid rapid decay of the induced undulator field. One effective approach involves subcooling the HTS insert to freeze the trapped magnetic flux [7]. Nevertheless, further detailed investigations are essential to address this concern comprehensively.
Undulators capable of switchable polarizations, exemplified by Advanced Planar Polarized Light Emitting (APPLE) undulators, are highly valued by beamline users in advancing scientific discoveries [106]. However, conventional APPLE undulators often feature a long period length constrained by the performance limitations of permanent magnets. To enhance the production of high-energy radiation photons and simplify motor control systems, researchers are exploring the development of superconducting undulators with switchable polar-
izations utilizing Nb-Ti coil technology. This includes hybrid planar-tilted configurations and the superconducting arbitrarily polarizing emitter (SCAPE) [107, 108, 109, 110, 111]. A promising strategy to advance high-performance superconducting undulators with switchable polarizations involves integrating the SCAPE design with high- ReBCO tapes-based superconducting coils.
Conclusions
In this work, we have reviewed the working principles of and recent advancements in various types of HTS undulators utilizing ReBCO tapes and bulks. Significant efforts have been focused on developing ReBCO coil-based HTS undulators, however, progress has been impeded by inherent challenges such as quench protections and screening current induced field effects. Nonetheless, progress in enhancing engineering critical current density and employing striated ReBCO tapes alongside partial-insulation winding techniques holds potential for the evolution of HTS coil-based undulators. Concurrently, breakthroughs have been achieved in research on both planar and helical HTS undulators utilizing ReBCO bulk superconductors, demonstrating undulator fields with at least doubled performance compared to Nb-Ti superconducting undulators of equivalent period lengths and magnetic gaps. Despite challenges such as precise on-axis magnetic field measurement, local field corrections, and managing flux creep-induced field decay, global undulator teams are advancing towards developing engineering bulk HTSU devices for practical applications.
CRediT authorship contribution statement
Zhuangwei Chen: Writing – original draft. Marco Calvi: Writing – review & editing. John Durrell: Writing – review & editing. Cristian Boffo: Writing – review & editing. Dabin Wei: Writing – review & editing. Kai Zhang: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Supervision. Zhentang Zhao: Writing – review & editing, Supervision.
Data availability
Data will be made available on request.
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Acknowledgement
This work is supported by the Chinese National Overseas Yang Talent program, the Swiss Accelerator Research and Technology (CHART) program and the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under grant agreement no. 101004728 (LEAPS-INNOV). This work has been partially funded by Swiss LOS Lottery Fund of Kanton Aargau. This work has been authored by Fermi Research Alliance, LLC under Contract No. DE-AC02-07CH11359 with the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of High Energy Physics.
References
References
- [1]Halbach K. Permanent magnet undulators. J Phys Colloques 1983;44: C1–211-C1-216.
- [2]Yamamoto S, Shioya T, Hara M, et al. Construction of an in-vacuum type undulator for production of undulator x rays in the 5–25 keV region. Rev Sci Instrum 1992;63:400–3.DOI
- [3]Hara T, Tanaka T, Kitamura et al. Cryogenic permanent magnet undulators. Phys Rev ST Accel Beams 2004;7:050702.
- [4]Elias LR, Madey JM. Superconducting helically wound magnet for the free-electron laser. Rev Sci Instrum 1979;50:1335–40.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18699386
- [5]Zhang K, Calvi M. Review and prospects of world-wide superconducting undulator development for synchrotrons and FELs. Supercond Sci Technol 2022;35:093001.DOI
- [6]Kesgin I, Kasa M, Ivanyushenkov Y et al. High-temperature superconducting undulator magnets. Supercond Sci Technol 2017;30:04LT01.DOI
- [7]Zhang K, Pirotta A, Liang X et al. Record field in a 10 mm-period bulk high-temperature superconducting undulator. Supercond Sci Technol 2023;36:05LT01.DOI
- [8]Ivanyushenkov Y, Baynham E, Bradshaw T et al. Development of a superconducting helical undulator for the ILC positron source. Proceedings of EPAC2006:MOPLSO69, Edinburgh, Scotland.
- [9]Ivanyushenkov Y, Baynham E, Bradshaw T et al. Status of R&D on a superconducting helical undulator for the ILC positron source. Proceedings of PAC07:THPMN071. New Mexico, USA.DOI
- [10]Scott DJ, Clarke JA, Baynham DE, et al. Demonstration of a high-field short-period superconducting helical undulator suitable for future TeV-scale linear collider positron sources. Phys Rev Lett 2011;107:174803.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22107527
- [11]Casalbuoni S, Hagelstein M, Kostka B, et al. Generation of x-ray radiation in a storage ring by a superconductive cold-bore in-vacuum undulator. Phys Rev ST Accel Beams 2009;6:0901072.
- [12]Casalbuoni S, Baumbach T, Gerstl S, et al. Training and magnetic field measurements of the ANKA superconducting undulator. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2021;21:1760–3.
- [13]Casalbuoni S, Glamann N, Grau A, et al. Superconducting undulators: from development towards a commercial product. Synchrotron Radiat News 2018;31:24–8.DOI
- [14]Ivanyushenkov Y, Harkay K, Abliz M, et al. Development and operating experience of a short-period superconducting undulator at the Advanced Photon Source. Phys Rev ST Accel Beams 2015;18:040703.DOI
- [15]Ivanyushenkov Y, Fuerst J, Hasse Q, et al. Status of the development of superconducting undulators at the Advanced Photon Source. Synchrotron Radiat News 2018;31:29–34.
- [16]Kasa M, Borland M, Emery M. Development and operating experience of a 1.2-m long helical superconducting undulator at the Argonne Advanced Photon Source. Phys Rev Accel Beams 2020;23:050701.DOI
- [17]Tang Q, Zhou Q, Zhang J, et al. Cooling Design for the magnetic structure of SHINE superconducting undulator. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2020;30:4100104.DOI
- [18]Wu Z, Zhang Q, Qian M, et al. High-precision positioning of Hall probes for SCU magnetic field measurement. Nucl Instrum Methods A 2019;1059:169004.
- [19]Casalbuoni S, Baader J E, Geloni G et al. Towards a superconducting undulator afterburner for the European XFEL. Proceedings of IPAC2021:WEPAB132. Campinas, SP, Brazil.
- [20]Baader J, Casalbuoni S, Grattoni V, et al. Magnetic performance assessment of the SPRESSO superconducting undulator Mock-Up. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2024;34:9002009.DOI
- [21]Huang N S, Deng H X, Liu B et al. Physical design and FEL performance study for FEL-HI beamline of SHINE. Proceedings of FEL2019:TUP063. Hamburg, Germany.
- [22]Weise H. Commissioning and first lasing of the European XFEL. Proceedings of FEL2017:MOC03. Santa Fe, NM, USA.
- [23]Dietrich DR, Godeke A, Prestemon SO, et al. Fabrication of a short-period Nb3Sn superconducting undulator. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2007;17:1243–6.
- [24]Arbelaez D, Lee D, Pan H, et al. An magnetic field correction concepts for superconducting undulators. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2013;23:4100104.DOI
- [25]Arbelaez D, Leitner M, Marks S, et al. Magnetic field correction methods for hybrid permanent magnet and superconducting undulators. Synchrotron Radiat News 2018;31:9–13.DOI
- [26]Kesgin I, Kasa M, Hasse Q, et al. Development of short-period Nb3Sn superconducting planar undulators. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2019;29:4100504.DOI
- [27]Kesgin I, MacDonald S et al. Fabrication and testing of 18-mm-period, 0.5-m-long Nb3Sn superconducting undulator. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2021;31:4002005.DOI
- [28]Kesgin I, MacDonald S, Kasa M et al. Quench behavior of 18-mm-period, 1.1-m-long Nb3Sn undulator magnets. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2024;34:4100905.DOI
- [29]D’Raulja G, Mitri S D, Rochow R et al. Status of the CompactLight design study. Proceedings of FEL2019:THP078. Hamburg, Germany.
- [30]Calvi M, Ainslie MD, Dennis A, et al. A GdBCO bulk staggered array undulator. Supercond Sci Technol 2020;33:014004.DOI
- [31]Zhang K, Hellmann S, Calvi M, et al. Magnetization simulation of ReBCO tape stack with a large number of layers using the Ansys A-V-A formulation. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2020;30:4700805.DOI
- [32]Hellmann S, Calvi M, Schmidt T, et al. Numerical design optimization of short-period HTS staggered array undulators. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2020;30:4100705.DOI
- [33]Zhang K, Ainslie M, Calvi M, et al. Fast and efficient critical state modelling of field-cooled bulk high-temperature superconductors using a backward computation method. Supercond Sci Technol 2020;33:114007.DOI
- [34]Zhang K, Hellmann S, Calvi M, et al. Magnetization current simulation of high-temperature bulk superconductors using the ANSYS iterative algorithm method. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2021;31:1–6.DOI
- [35]Zhang K, Ainslie M, Calvi M, et al. A fully-staggered-array bulk Re-Ba-Cu-O short-period undulator: large-scale 3D electromagnetic modelling and design optimization using A-V and H-formulation methods. Supercond Sci Technol 2021;34:094002.DOI
- [36]Kinjo R, Calvi M, Zhang K, et al. Inverse analysis of critical current density in a bulk high-temperature superconducting undulator. Phys Rev Acc Beams 2022;25:043502.DOI
- [37]Clarke J, Calvi C, Bernhard A. XLS-WP5: Task Superconducting Undulators. First XLS—CompactLight Annual Meeting: 2018. Barcelona, Spain.
- [38]Calvi M, Hellmann S, Prat E, et al. GdBCO bulk superconducting helical undulator for x-ray free-electron lasers. Phys Rev Research 2023;5:L032020.DOI
- [39]Streun A, Garvey T, Rivkin L, et al. SLS-2—the upgrade of the Swiss Light Source. J Synchrotron Rad 2018;25:631–41.DOI
- [40]Wei D, Calvi M, Zhang K, et al. Electromagnetic design study of a 12-mm-period bulk high-temperature superconducting undulator. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2024;34:4100705.DOI
- [41]Jiang M, Yang X, Xu H, et al. Shanghai Synchrotron Radiation Facility. Chin Sci Bull 2009;54:4171–81.
- [42]Zhao ZT, Wang D, Gu Q, et al. SXFEL: a Soft X-ray Free Electron Laser in China. Synchrotron Radiat News 2017;30:29–33.DOI
- [43]Zhao Z T. XFEL projects in China. Proceedings of 29th Linear Accelerator Conference 2018. Beijing, China.
- [44]Huang N, Deng H, Liu B, et al. Features and futures of X-ray free-electron lasers. The innovation 2021;2:100079.
- [45]Willmott P. An Introduction to Synchrotron Radiation. New York: Wiley; 2011. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/book/10.1002/9781119280453.
- [46]Bahrdt J, Frentrup W, Grimmer S et al. In-vacuum APPLE III undulator. Proceedings of IPAC2018:THPMF031. Vancouver, BC, Canada.
- [47]Tischer M, Bienert H, Götze K, et al. Development of an APPLE-III undulator for FLASH-2. J Phys Conf Ser 2022;2380:012017.
- [48]Ji F, Chang R, Zhou Q, et al. Design and performance of the APPLE-Knot undulator. J Synchrotron Rad 2015;22:901–7.DOI
- [49]Schmidt T, Calvi M, et al. APPLE X undulator for the SwissFEL soft x-ray beamline Athos. Synchrotron Radiat News 2018;31:35–40.DOI
- [50]Flükiger R, Hensel B, Jeremie A, et al. High critical current densities in Bi(2223)/Ag tapes. Supercond Sci Technol 1992;5:S61.DOI
- [51]Jiang J, Bradford G, Hossain SI, et al. High-performance Bi-2212 round wires made with recent powders. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2019;29:6400405.
- [52]MacManus-Driscoll JL, Wimbush SC. Processing and application of high-temperature superconducting coated conductors. Nat Rev Mater 2021;6:587–604.
- [53]Tuz W, Rindfleisch M, Yue J, et al. Development of magnesium diboride (MgB2) wires and magnets using in situ strand fabrication method. Physica C 2007;456:203–8.DOI
- [54]Hosono H, Yamamoto A, Hiramatsu H, et al. Recent advances in iron-based superconductors toward applications. Mater Today 2018;21:278–302.DOI
- [55]Prestemon S, Diederich D, Madur A et al. High performance short-period undulators using high temperature superconducting tapes. Proceedings of PAC09: WESRFP075. Vancouver, BC, Canada.
- [56]Durrell JH, Dennis AR, Jaroszynski J, et al. A trapped field of 17.6 T in melt-processed, bulk Gd-Ba-Cu-O reinforced with shrink-fit steel. Supercond Sci Technol 2014;27:082001.
- [57]Tomita M, Murakami M. High-temperature superconductor bulk magnets that can trap magnetic fields of over 17 tesla at 29 K. Nature 2003;421:517–20.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12556888
- [58]Tanaka T, Tsuru R, Kitamura H, et al. Pure-type superconducting permanent-magnet undulator. J Synchrotron Rad 2005;12:442–7.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15968120
- [59]Weerakonda D, Dennis A, Calvi M, et al. Pulse magnetized superconducting bulk array undulator concept. Phys Rev Res 2024;6:L022060.DOI
- [60]Kii T, Zen H, Okawachi N et al. Design study of high-Tc superconducting micro-undulator. Proceedings of FEL 2006:THPPH035. Berlin, Germany.
- [61]Kinjo R, Kii T, Zen H et al. A bulk high-Tc superconductor staggered array undulator. Proceedings of FEL 2008:THAAU03. Gyeongju, Korea.
- [62]Hahn G. Recent progress of 5 T HTS wavelength shifter development. The 22nd PAL-IAC Meeting 2023.
- [63]Liu S, Ding Y, Xu J, et al. Development of a short REBCO undulator magnet with resistive joints. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2019;29:4100204.DOI
- [64]Boffo C. Design and test of an HTS planar undulator prototype. Proceedings of ASCI2010:4LZ-02. Washington D.C., USA.
- [65]Richter SC, Ballarino A, Bernhard A, et al. High-temperature superconducting undulator prototype coils for compact free-electron lasers. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2023;33:4100207.DOI
- [66]Nguyen DN, Ashworth SP. High-temperature superconducting undulators for future x-ray free electron laser systems. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2014;24:4602805.DOI
- [67]Kesgin I, Doose CL, Kasa MT, et al. Design of a REBCO thin film superconducting undulator. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng 2015;101:012053.DOI
- [68]Kesgin I, Kasa M, Ivanyushenkov Y, et al. High-temperature superconducting undulator magnets. Supercond Sci Technol 2017;30:04LT01.DOI
- [69]Kesgin I, Hasse Q, Ivanyushenkov Y, et al. Degradation free vacuum epoxy impregnated short REBCO undulator magnets. IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng 2017;279:012009.DOI
- [70]Garg T, Rochester J, Majoros M, et al. Development and testing of a three-period, subsize 2G AIM MgB2 planar undulator. Supercond Sci Technol 2024;37:015011.DOI
- [71]Prestemon S, Diederich D, Madur A et al. High performance short-period undulators using high temperature superconductor tapes. Proceedings of PAC2019:WESRFP075. Vancouver, BC, Canada.
- [72]Prestemon S, Arbelaez D, Savies S, et al. Development and analysis of HTS-undulator components for FEL applications. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2011;21:1880–3.DOI
- [73]Holubek T, Casalbuoni S, Gerstl S, et al. Magnetic performance of a laser structured YBCO tape suitable for insertion devices technology. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2013;23:4602204.DOI
- [74]Holubek T, Casalbuoni S, Gerstl S, et al. A novel concept of high temperature superconducting undulator. Supercond Sci Technol 2017;30:115002.DOI
- [75]Krasch B, Abusaif F, Arndt T, et al. Measurement setup and magnetic field studies of a compact superconducting undulator with laser-structured HTS tapes. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2014;34:4101404.
- [76]Majoros M, Sumption MD, Susner MA, et al. A model superconducting helical undulator wound using a wind and react MgB2 multifilamentary wire. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2009;19:1376–9.DOI
- [77]Richter SC, Ballarino A, Bernhard A, et al. Design and manufacturing of an HTS helical undulator demonstrator for compact FELs. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2024;34:4101507.DOI
- [78]Kinjo R, Shibata M, Kii T, et al. Demonstration of a high-field short-period undulator using bulk high-temperature superconductor. Appl Phys Express 2013;6:042701.DOI
- [79]D’Auria G, Adli E, Aicheler M, et al. The CompactLight design study. Eur Phys J Spec Top 2024;233:1–208.
- [80]Calvi M, Anseruchi A, Liang X, et al. Experimental results of a YBCO bulk superconducting undulator magnetic optimisation. Phys Rev ST Accel Beams 2024;27:100702.
- [81]Moog E, Dejus R, Sasaki S. Comparison of achievable magnetic fields with superconducting and cryogenic permanent magnet undulators - a comprehensive study of computed and measured values. Light Source Note: ANL/APS/LS-348 2017. https://www.aps.anl.gov/sites/www.aps.anl.gov/files/APS_191004.pdf.DOI
- [82]Kittel C, Calvi M, Reiche S, et al. Enhanced X-ray free-electron laser performance with optical klystron and helical undulators. J Synchrotron Rad 2024;31:948–54.DOI
- [83]Calvi M. A GdBCO undulator for tomographic microscopy at the new Swiss Light Source, SLS2.0. TE-MSC Seminar 2024. VERN via Zoom. https://indico.cern.ch/event/1325657/.
- [84]Wei D, Calvi M, Zhang K, et al. Electromagnetic design study of a 12-mm-period bulk high-temperature superconducting undulator. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2024;34:4100705.DOI
- [85]Wang X, Liu X, Wei D, et al. High performance one-step grown half-moon shaped YBCO bulk superconductors. Supercond Sci Technol 2024. https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6668/ad5f58. Accepted.
- [86]Weijers HW, Markiewicz WD, Gavrilin AV, et al. Progress in the development and construction of a 32-T superconducting magnet. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2016;26:4300807.DOI
- [87]Hahn S, Kim K, Kim K, et al. 45.5-tesla direct-current magnetic field generated with a high-temperature superconducting magnet. Nature 2019;570:496–9.DOI
- [88]Liu J, Wang Q, Qin L, et al. World record 32.35 tesla direct-current magnetic field generated with an all-superconducting magnet. Supercond Sci Technol 2020;33:031001.DOI
- [89]Zhang X, Hu S, Guo L, et al. 26.86-tesla direct-current magnetic field generated with an all-REBCO superconducting magnet. Supercond Sci Technol 2024;37:085003.DOI
- [90]Breschi M, Cavallucci L, Ribani PL, et al. Analysis of quench in the NHMFL REBCO prototype coils for the 32 T magnet project. Supercond Sci Technol 2016;29:055002.DOI
- [91]Noyes PD, Markiewicz WD, Voran AJ, et al. Protection heater development for REBCO coils. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2012;22:4702404.DOI
- [92]Marchevsky M. Quench detection and protection for high-temperature superconductor accelerator magnets. Instruments 2021;5:27.DOI
- [93]Yan Y, Li Y, Qu T. Screening current induced magnetic field and stress in ultra-high-field magnets using REBCO coated conductors. Supercond Sci Technol 2022;35:014003.DOI
- [94]Yanagisawa Y, Xu X, Jin X, et al. Reduction of screening current-induced magnetic field of REBCO coils by the use of multi-filamentary tapes. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2014;25:6603705.DOI
- [95]Hahn S, Park DK, Bascunan J, et al. HTS Pancake Coils Without Turn-to-Turn Insulation. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2011;21:1592–5.DOI
- [96]Wang T, Noguchi S, Wang X, et al. Analyses of transient behaviors of No-Insulation REBCO pancake coils during sudden discharging and overcurrent. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2015;25:4603409.DOI
- [97]Wang X, Hahn S, Kim Y, et al. Turn-to-turn contact characteristics for an equivalent circuit model of no-insulation REBCO pancake coil. Supercond Sci Technol 2013;26:035012.DOI
- [98]Suetomi Y, Takahashi S, Takao T, et al. A novel winding method for a no-insulation layer-wound REBCO coil to provide a short magnetic field delay and self-protect characteristics. Supercond Sci Technol 2019;32:045003.DOI
- [99]Bonura M, Barth C, Joudrier A, et al. Systematic study of the contact resistance between REBCO tapes: pressure dependence in the case of no-insulation, metal co-winding and metal-insulation. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2019;29:6600305.DOI
- [100]Lécrivisse T, Chaud X, Fazilleau P, et al. Metal-as-insulation HTS coils. Supercond Sci Technol 2022;35:074004.DOI
- [101]Amemiya N, Kasai S, Yoda K, et al. AC loss reduction of YBCO coated conductors by multifilamentary structure. Supercond Sci Technol 2004;17:1464.DOI
- [102]Li Y, Park D, Lee W, et al. Screening-current-induced strain gradient on REBCO conductor: an experimental and analytical study with small coils wound with monofilament and striated multifilament REBCO tapes. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2020;30:4702305.DOI
- [103]Park J, Kim E, Hahn G, et al. Estimation of screening current induced field on short period planar HTS undulator. IEEE Trans Appl Supercond 2023;33:4100505.DOI
- [104]Majick G, Patrap R, Xu A et al. Engineering current density over 5 kA mm−2 at 4.2 K, 14 T in thick film REBCO tapes. Supercond Sci Technol 2018;31:10LT01.DOI
- [105]Paidipilli M, Sandra SJ, Sarangi B, et al. High-current, double-sided REBCO tapes by advanced MOCVD. Supercond Sci Technol 2023;36:095016.DOI
- [106]Wang H, Bençok P, Steadman P, et al. Complete polarization analysis of an APPLE II undulator using a soft X-ray polarimeter. J Synchrotron Rad 2012;19:944–8.DOI
- [107]Hwang CS, Lin PH. Comparison of two superconducting elliptical undulators for generating circularly polarized light. Phys Rev ST Accel Beams 2004;7:090701.DOI
- [108]Chen SD, Jan JC, Hwang CS, et al. Development of a superconducting elliptically polarized undulator. J phys Conf Ser 2010;234:032006.DOI
- [109]Kanonik P, Shrushchev S, Mezentsev N, et al. Superconducting elliptical undulator. AIP Conf Proc 2020;2299:020013.DOI
- [110]Ivanyushchenkov Y, Fuerst J, Hasse Q et al. Conceptual design of a novel SCAPE undulator. Proceedings of IPAC2017:TUPAB117. Copenhagen, Denmark.DOI
- [111]Kasa M, Anliker E, Fuerst J et al. Superconducting undulators for the Advanced Photon Source upgrade. Proceedings of IPAC2019:TUPB095. Melbourne, Australia.DOI