WorksMathematics
On a finite group in which every maximal subgroup of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is nilpotent
Abstract
Let be a finite group and any fixed prime divisor of . We prove that if every maximal subgroup of of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is nilpotent then is a solvable group having a Sylow tower and is -nilpotent or -closed for each prime divisor of .
Introduction
In this paper all groups are assumed to be finite. In [4] Rédei provided a complete characterization of Schmidt groups in which every maximal subgroup is nilpotent. Deng, Meng and Lu [1 Theorem 3.1] generalized [4] and they gave a description of a group in which every maximal subgroup of even order is nilpotent. Let be any fixed prime divisor of the order of a group . Shi, Li and Shen [7 Theorem 1.1] indicated that a non-solvable group always has a non-nilpotent maximal subgroup of order divisible by . Moreover, Shi and Tian [9 Theorem 1.1] obtained a complete characterization of a group in which every maximal subgroup of order divisible by is nilpotent.
Considering the coprime action of groups, let and be groups such that acts coprimely on by automorphisms. [3] and [8] independently characterized the structure of a group in which every maximal -invariant subgroup of order divisible by is nilpotent from different perspectives using different proof methods. In particular, Shi and Xu [10 Theorem 1.3] provided a complete characterization of a group in which every maximal -invariant subgroup containing the normalizer of some -invariant Sylow subgroup is nilpotent.
In this paper, as a further generalization of above research, we have the following result, the proof of which is given in § 3.
Theorem 1.1 Let be a group and any fixed prime divisor of . If every maximal subgroup of of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is nilpotent. Then
is solvable;
has a Sylow tower;
is -nilpotent or -closed for each prime divisor of .
As a generalization of [7 Theorem 1.1], the following corollary emerges by Theorem 1.1.
Corollary 1.2 Any non-solvable has a non-nilpotent maximal subgroup of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup for any fixed prime divisor of .
Note that when is an odd prime divisor of , arguing as in proof of Theorem 1.1, we can trivially generalize Theorem 1.1 to the case of the coprime action of groups. We omit its proof here.
Theorem 1.3 Let and be groups such that acts coprimely on by automorphisms. Assume that is any fixed odd prime divisor of . If every maximal -invariant subgroup of of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some -invariant Sylow subgroup is nilpotent. Then
is solvable;
has a Sylow tower;
is -nilpotent or -closed for each prime divisor of .
Let and be groups such that acts coprimely on by automorphisms. Then is said to be an -simple group if has no non-trivial -invariant normal subgroups. According to Theorems 1.1 and 1.3, we pose the following question.
Question 1.4 Let and be groups such that acts coprimely on by automorphisms. If is an -simple group in which a nilpotent maximal -invariant subgroup is its Sylow -subgroup and every maximal -invariant subgroup of even order containing the normalizer of some -invariant Sylow subgroup is nilpotent, can we ensure that is solvable?
Necessary Lemmas
Lemma 2.1 [5 Theorem 10.4.2] If has a nilpotent maximal subgroup of odd order, then is solvable.
Lemma 2.2 [6] If a non-abelian simple group has a nilpotent maximal subgroup of even order, then , where is a Fermat prime or Mersenne prime with .
Lemma 2.3 [11 Lemma 9] Let be a nilpotent Hall-subgroup of a group that is not a Sylow subgroup of . If for each prime divisor of , assume we always have , then there exists a normal subgroup of such that and .
Proof of Theorem 1.1
Proof. Part I. We first prove that is solvable.
Let be a counterexample of the smallest order. Assume that is any non-trivial normal subgroup of . It is easy to see that the hypothesis holds for the quotient group . If is solvable. Then is solvable since is also solvable by the minimality of , a contradiction. Therefore, is non-solvable and has no non-trivial solvable normal subgroups.
Let be a minimal normal subgroup of . Since is non-solvable, has at least three distinct prime divisors by -theorem. Let be an odd prime divisor of . Assume . Then . Note that , which implies that . It is obvious that . It follows that has a maximal subgroup such that . By Frattini’s argument, .
For , we divide it into two cases.
Case (i): Suppose that is nilpotent. Since has no non-trivial solvable normal subgroups, is a Hall-subgroup of and the normalizer of every Sylow subgroup of equals . Moreover, since is non-solvable and is odd, is not a Sylow subgroup of by Lemma 2.1. It follows that has a normal subgroup such that . By the maximality of , is a minimal normal subgroup of . Since , one has . Then and are two distinct minimal normal subgroups of . It follows that and then , which implies that is solvable since both and are solvable by the minimality of , a contradiction.
Case (ii): Suppose that is non-nilpotent. By the hypothesis, . Since , one has . Let . Then . Since , one has . Then has a maximal subgroup such that . Moreover, one has . By Frattini’s argument, . Note that . By the hypothesis, is nilpotent. When is odd or but , arguing as is Case we can obtain a contradiction.
Next assume and . Since , one has . Then . Note that . It follows that . Then . Furthermore, one has . It implies that is a non-abelian simple group in which the Sylow 2-subgroup is its maximal subgroup. By Lemma 2.3, , where is a Fermat prime or a Mersenne prime. If . By [2], has a maximal subgroup . Note that and is a Sylow -subgroup of . By the hypothesis, is nilpotent, a contradiction. If . By [2], has a maximal subgroup . Note that when . Let be a prime divisor of and a Sylow -subgroup of . Then is also a Sylow -subgroup of and . By the hypothesis, is nilpotent, also a contradiction.
All above arguments imply that the counterexample of the smallest order does not exist and so is solvable.
Part II. We show that has normal Sylow subgroups.
Let be a counterexample of the smallest order and a minimal normal subgroup of . Since is solvable, is an elementary abelian subgroup of of prime-power order. Assume , . By the minimality of , has a normal Sylow subgroup , where is a Sylow -subgroup of . Then . By the assumption, . One has . Then has a maximal subgroup such that . By Frattini’s argument, .
If . Then is nilpotent by the hypothesis. Assume is a normal Sylow -subgroup of . It follows that is a Sylow -subgroup of , a contradiction.
If . Then and is a normal Sylow -subgroup of , also a contradiction.
Therefore, the counterexample does not exist and then has normal Sylow subgroups.
Part III. We show that has a Sylow tower.
Assume , where are distinct prime divisors of and for . Let be a normal Sylow -subgroup of . For the quotient group , has a normal Sylow subgroup , where is a Sylow -subgroup of . Then we obtain a normal subgroups series: . It follows that has a Sylow tower.
Part IV. We prove that is -nilpotent or -closed for each prime divisor of .
Let . For , we divide it into two cases.
Case (1): . Let . Assume that are all normal Sylow subgroups of . Let . Then is a normal Hall-subgroup of . Since is solvable, has a complement in by Schur-Zassenhaus’s theorem. Then .
Next we show that is nilpotent.
Otherwise, if is non-nilpotent. Then has a Sylow subgroup such that . It implies that . Then has a maximal subgroup such that . Note that and , one has , where is a maximal subgroup of . Since , is nilpotent by the hypothesis. Then is nilpotent and . For every , one has . Let be the normal closure of in . Then . Since and is a non-normal maximal subgroup of , one has . It follows that . Arguing as above , we have that every maximal subgroup of containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is nilpotent. Then has normal Sylow subgroups by Part II. Let be a normal Sylow subgroup of . Since , one has . It follows that . Then , this contradicts by our assumption.
Therefore, is nilpotent.
It follows that is -closed when and is -nilpotent when .
Case (2): . Let be all normal Sylow subgroups of . Assume . Then is a normal Hall-subgroup of . Let be a complement of in . Then . Note that . Let be any maximal subgroup of of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup. Then is a maximal subgroup of of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup. By the hypothesis, is nilpotent. Then is nilpotent. That is, also satisfies the hypothesis of theorem. By Part II, has a normal Sylow subgroup . However, . Then . Let be a maximal subgroup of such that . Since , is nilpotent by the hypothesis. It follows that is nilpotent.
Therefore, is -closed when and is -nilpotent when .
References
- [1]Y. Deng, W. Meng and J. Lu, Finite groups with nilpotent subgroups of even order, Bulletin of the Iranian Mathematical Society 48(3) (2022) 1143-1152.DOI
- [2]L.E. Dickson, Linear Groups with an Exposition of the Galois Field Theory, Leipzig, Teubner, 1901.
- [3]Q. Jiang and C. Shao, Finite groups in which every certain maximal A-invariant subgroup is nilpotent, Communications in Algebra 53(3) (2025) 1291–1295.DOI
- [4]L. Rédei, Die endlichen einstufig nichtnilpotenten Gruppen, Publicationes Mathematicae Debrecen 4 (1956) 303–324.
- [5]D.J.S. Robinson, A Course in the Theory of Groups (Second Edition), Springer-Verlag, New York, 1996.
- [6]J.S. Rose, On finite insoluble groups with nilpotent maximal subgroups, Journal of Algebra 48 (1) (1977) 182-196.DOI
- [7]J. Shi, N. Li and R. Shen, Finite groups in which every maximal subgroup is nilpotent or normal or has p′-order, International Journal of Algebra and Computation 35(5) (2023) 1055-1063 (arXiv: 2202.02322 [math.GR]).arxiv.org/abs/2202.02322
- [8]J. Shi, M. Shan and F. Xu, Finite groups in which every maximal invariant subgroup of order divisible by p is nilpotent, Georgian Mathematical Journal 33(2) (2026) 319-322.arxiv.org/abs/2502.06408
- [9]J. Shi and Y. Tian, On finite groups in which every maximal subgroup of order divisible by p is nilpotent (or abelian), Rendiconti del Seminario Matematico della Università di Padova 154 (2025) 143-149.DOI
- [10]J. Shi and F. Xu, Finite groups with some particular maximal invariant subgroups being nilpotent or all non-nilpotent maximal invariant subgroups being normal, arXiv: 2408.01249 [math.GR].arxiv.org/abs/2408.01249
- [11]H. Wielandt, Über produkte von nilpotenten gruppen, Illinois Journal of Mathematics 2 (1958) 611-618.DOI