WorksMathematics
A note on an extension of Shidov's theorem and Shlyk's theorem
Abstract
Let be a non-solvable group and any fixed prime divisor of . We prove that the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is -closed, which provides a further generalization of Shidov's theorem and Shlyk's theorem.
Introduction
In this paper all groups are assumed to be finite. Recall that the intersection of all maximal subgroups of a group is called a Frattini subgroup. As generalizations, Shidov [4] showed that the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of a non-solvable group is nilpotent, which follows easily that the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of a non-solvable group is equal to its Frattini subgroup. In [5], Shlyk proved that the intersection of all non-normal non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of a non-solvable group is nilpotent. Recently, Shi, Xu and Li [3 Theorem 1.2] gave the following result.
Theorem 1.1 [3 Theorem 1.2] The intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of a non-solvable containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is nilpotent.
Let be a group and any fixed prime divisor of . In [1 Theorem 1.1] Li and Shi provided a complete characterization of a group in which every maximal subgroup of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is nilpotent. In particular, [1 Corollary 1.2] indicated that any non-solvable has a non-nilpotent maximal subgroup of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup for any fixed prime divisor of .
E-mail addresses: [email protected] (J. Shi), [email protected] (F. Li).
Recall that a group is said to be -closed if its Sylow -subgroup is normal. In this paper, as a further generalization of Shidov’s theorem, Shlyk’s theorem and [3 Theorem 1.2], only considering the non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of a non-solvable group of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup, we have the following result, the proof of which is given in Section 3.
Theorem 1.2 Let be a non-solvable group and any fixed prime divisor of . Then the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is -closed.
Note that [3 Theorem 1.2] is a direct consequence of Theorem 1.2. The following two corollaries emerge by Theorem 1.2.
Corollary 1.3 Let be a non-solvable group and any fixed prime divisor of . Then the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of of order divisible by is -closed.
Corollary 1.4 Let be a non-solvable group and any fixed prime divisor of . Then the intersection of all non-normal non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of of order divisible by is -closed.
For Corollary 1.3, when , we have the following result, the proof of which is given in Section 4.
Corollary 1.5 The intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of of even order is equal to the Frattini subgroup of .
Note that Corollary 1.5 provides an extension of Shidov’s theorem.
Two Necessary Lemmas
Lemma 2.1 [2 Theorem 10.4.2] If has a nilpotent maximal subgroup of odd order, then is solvable.
Lemma 2.2 [6 Lemma 9] Let be a nilpotent Hall-subgroup of a group that is not a Sylow subgroup of . If for each prime divisor of , assume we always have , then there exists a normal subgroup of such that and .
Proof of Theorem 1.2
Proof. Since is non-solvable, has non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroups by [1 Corollary 1.2]. Let be the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup. Then and .
In the following we prove that is -closed.
Let be a counterexample of the smallest order. If . Then is naturally -closed, a contradiction. Thus .
Let . Then . Assume . By the assumption, , which implies that . One has . Then has a maximal subgroup such that . By Frattini’s argument, .
Note that . If is non-nilpotent. Then . It follows that , a contradiction. Thus is nilpotent.
Claim that all nilpotent maximal subgroups of are conjugate. Let be any nilpotent maximal subgroup of . Since is non-solvable, has even order by Lemma 2.1. Let . One has . If is not a Sylow -subgroup of . Then . It follows that by the maximality of . One has that is a nilpotent maximal subgroup of of odd order, which implies that is solvable by Lemma 2.1. Then is solvable, a contradiction. So is also a Sylow -subgroup of .
Let and be any two nilpotent maximal subgroups of . Assume that and are Sylow -subgroups of and respectively. Then and are also Sylow -subgroups of . One has for some . Note that and . It follows that .
Therefore, any nilpotent maximal subgroup of is a conjugation of .
Claim that is a nilpotent Hall-subgroup of . Otherwise, if is not a Hall-subgroup of . Then there exists a prime divisor of such that the Sylow -subgroup of is not a Sylow -subgroup of . Then . Note that and is non-solvable. Let be the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of of order divisible by containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup. It is obvious that . By the minimality of , one has that is -closed. It follows that is also -closed. Then . Note that . One has . Then . By Frattini’s argument, one has , a contradiction.
Therefore, is a nilpotent Hall-subgroup of . Moreover, let be any Sylow subgroup of . Arguing as above , one has .
In the following we discuss in three cases.
Case (1): When . Since both and divide , is not a Sylow subgroup of . By Lemma 2.2, has a normal subgroup such that . Since , is a Hall-subgroup of of odd order. Then is solvable by Feit-Thompson theorem. It follows that is solvable since is nilpotent, a contradiction.
Case (2): When but is not a Sylow 2-subgroup of . Arguing as Case (1), we can get a contradiction.
Case (3): When and is a Sylow 2-subgroup of , that is . Note that is not 2-closed by the assumption. Let be any odd prime divisor of . Let and such that .
Claim that . Otherwise, if . Then . Let be a maximal subgroup of such that . By Frattini’s argument, .
We discuss in two cases.
Case (i): Assume . If is non-nilpotent. Then by the hypothesis. It follows that , a contradiction. If is nilpotent. By above argument, is a conjugation of , which implies that is also a Sylow 2-subgroup of , this contradicts and .
Case (ii): Assume . Since and , one has . Note that . It follows that . Then . One has , also a contradiction.
Therefore, . In particular, . By the arbitrariness of , has a normal 2-complement, that is is 2-nilpotent. Then is solvable by Feit-Thompson theorem. It follows that is solvable since and is nilpotent, a contradiction.
All above arguments show that the counterexample of the smallest order does not exist and then is -closed. □
Proof of Corollary 1.5
Proof. Let be the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of of even order. Then is 2-closed by Corollary 1.3. It is obvious that .
If . Then there exists a maximal subgroup of such that . One has . By the hypothesis, only might be either a non-nilpotent maximal subgroup of odd order or a nilpotent maximal subgroup which are both solvable. It follows that is solvable, a contradiction.
Therefore, and so . □
References
- [1]F. Li and J. Shi, On a finite group in which every maximal subgroup of order divisible by p containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is nilpotent, preprint.
- [2]D.J.S. Robinson, A Course in the Theory of Groups (Second Edition), Springer-Verlag, New York, 1996.
- [3]J. Shi, F. Xu and N. Li, On an extension of Shidov’s theorem and Shlyk’s theorem, Journal of Algebra and Its Applications, https://doi.org/10.1142/S0219498828500296.
- [4]L.I. Shidov, On maximal subgroups of finite groups, Siberian Mathematical Journal 12 (1971) 488–489.DOI
- [5]V.V. Shlyk, On the intersection of maximal subgroups in finite groups, Mathematical Notes 14 (1973) 804–809.DOI
- [6]H. Wielandt, Über produkte von nilpotenten gruppen, Illinois Journal of Mathematics 2 (1958) 611-618.DOI