WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Charge Density Wave transient states induced by ultrashort hard X-ray pulses
Abstract
The interaction of quantum systems with ultrashort laser pulses may lead to transient states far from equilibrium. Among these, Charge Density Wave (CDW) systems offer very rich non-equilibrium physics when submitted to ultrashort optical excitations in the infrared regime. In this Letter, we show that CDW systems pumped by ultrashort x-ray pulses excite the system in very different way. The x-ray pump, 6000 times more energetic than a laser pulse, pumping and probing the whole bulk system simultaneously, drives CDW systems in a novel reversible out of equilibrium state. The successive CDW states observed in the NbSe system with respect to the arrival of x-ray pulses follow a non-thermal kinetic path. It is characterized by a change in 2k wavevector, correlation lengths and electronic gap, as well as a change of dimensionality, all of this takes place within a very long recovery time ranging from 450 to 0.01. Several scenarios are proposed, including transient nucleation and recombination of charged topological objects.
Introduction
X-ray based pump-probe experiments using ultrafast laser pumps have been extensively developed in recent years, providing a better understanding of the coupling between different degrees of freedom (charge, lattice, spin and orbitals) and leading to emergent phenomena far from thermodynamic equilibrium. CDW systems have been widely studied using this experimental approach because strong optical excitation triggers a wide range of responses, such as coherent collective excitations[1, 2], decorrelated CDW phase and amplitude fluctuations[3, 4], non-thermal melting of the CDW phase[5, 6, 7], driven phase transition between two CDW phases[8, 9, 10], transient CDW state[11, 12] or ultrafast melting of electronic order[13]. In all cases, the intensity of the satellite reflection abruptly drops in the femtosecond time scale after the laser excitation and the time needed to recover the CDW ground state is much longer, from picoseconds to s. The ultrafast optical pump induces disorder that appears in the form of domain walls, vortices, or dislocations, which reduce long-range order and slow the dynamics of recovery or may change the nature of the phase transition[4, 12, 14, 15, 16, 17]. The pulses intensity used in this study are much smaller than the threshold damaged, but still sufficient to induce a drastic change in the CDW ground state.
The excitation of condensed matter by an ultrafast hard x-ray beam is an emerging field. Nonthermal melting events have been reported in x-ray pumping experiments in three semiconductors, silicon[18, 19], diamond[20] and AlO[21]. In these three studies, the x-ray dose used was much higher than the damage threshold, leading to a nonthermal, irreversible loss of crystal structure that occurs within a few tens of femtoseconds after the first x-ray pulse.
To illustrate the effect of x-ray pump in CDW systems, the archetype niobium triselenide inorganic compound NbSe has been studied. It belongs to the class of transition metal trichalcogenides that crystallize in the monoclinic P2/m space group. The experiment was carried out below the first CDW transition, at T=80K, i.e. 64K below the transition temperature T=144K. It should be noted that the actual sample temperature was determined by continuously measuring its resistance throughout the experiment. The Q(0 2 0) Bragg reflection and the Q(0 1+q 0) satellite associated to the periodic lattice distortion, with the incommensurate wave vector q = 0.241, have been observed. Rocking curves have been performed around the two reflections using x-ray pulses delivered by the XFEL source.
The physical properties of CDW systems are obviously quite different as the band gap is 10 times smaller than that of the semiconductors. The diffraction experiment was performed at the Materials Imaging and Dynamics (MID) instrument of the European X-ray Free Electron Laser (Eu-XFEL). The Eu-XFEL accelerator delivers x-ray pulses in bursts (named trains) with a repetition rate of 10Hz. For this study, up to 20 pulses per train with a repetition rate of 2.25 MHz were delivered, which corresponds to 444 ns delay times between pulses. Each pulse has a duration of less than 50fs in the self-seeded mode with an energy bandwidth of approximately 1eV at 90.05keV incident photon energy[22, 23].
The high penetration of hard x-ray beams allows one to work in transmission geometry. The diffraction experiment has been performed across the 1m sample thickness, corresponding to a small absorption by the sample (4%). Taking into account the low sample absorption, the beam size which was vertically larger than the sample size () and attenuators used to reduce the intensity well below the damaged threshold, the deposited dose in the sample can be estimated at .
A previous experiment using the LCLS XFEL source was performed to probe the same NbSe system[24]. The source delivered pulses shorter than at 120 Hz repetition rate—that is, one pulse every 8ms. In this frequency range, the satellite peaks remained stable from pulse to pulse. No transient effect induced by the ultrashort x-ray beam was measured.
The present experiment performed at the Eu-XFEL, which generates pulses at a much higher frequency, leads to a radically different conclusion. Although the satellite peak is stable from train to train, the satellite reflection changes dramatically within trains (see Figure 1). A large shift of the wavevector is observed along the longitudinal direction versus the pulse number, as well as a continuous decrease in intensity and an increase in width. Although no change in the transverse direction is measured, the longitudinal component, on the other hand, is highly sensitive from pulse to pulse. Before disappearance after the 10th pulse, the longitudinal shift is , corresponding to a large decrease of the CDW period from 14.44 Å to 14.26 Å.

Figure 1. Q(0 1.24 0) satellite reflection associated to the CDW in NbSe versus pulse number within a train of pulses. The process is reproducible from one train to the next. Each image corresponds of the sum over the rocking curve and have been averaged over 6000 trains. The intensity range has been rescaled for each pulse for better visibility (indicated in white on each image). The image size is 128*128 pixels of size (AGIPD detector) with per pixel in horizontal and in vertical. The intensity is multiply by either 2 or 4 for a better visibility as indicated on each diffraction pattern.
The satellite peak completely disappears after the 10th pulse but the CDW melting is only transient. The satellite’s peak returns to its initial state before the arrival
of the first pulse of the next train, i.e. 0.1s later. Most likely, the same effect occurred after each pulse during our previous experiment at LCLS. The repetition rate of the source was probably too small to allow us to observe reversible CDW melting.
The transient melting of the CDW is not due a temperature increase induced by the X-ray beam itself. The first evidence of this non-thermal phenomenon can be inferred from the behavior of the Bragg peak. The behavior of the Q(020) peak as a function of 20 pulses per train shows only a limited deviation. A slight change in profile is indeed observed as a function of pulse number, but the maximum of the rocking curve remains constant, given our resolution (see the Supplementary material). The heating effect induced by the x-ray beam on the host atomic lattice can be estimated to be less than 12K, well below the 64K required to undergo the transition temperature ().
The previous observation regarding the host lattice is corroborated by the behavior of the satellite peak. Each CDW system is characterized by three key parameters, the correlations lengths , the gap and the CDW wavevector . These three parameters depend on the topology of the Fermi surface, the electron-phonon coupling, and pinning by bulk impurities[25] and are closely linked to one another[26, 27]. These three parameters can be obtained from diffraction experiments through the value, the peak intensity () and the Half width Half Maximum of the satellite reflection ().
The behavior of the satellite as a function of temperature was partially performed in NbSe from a synchrotron source in [28]. We completed the measurement at the BM02 beamline at the ESRF synchrotron source. In agreement with [28], the gap follows the usual BCS-like behavior (), the divergence of the inverse of the correlation length and the increase of the value when approaching (see Figure 2f, Figure 2d, Figure 2a respectively). A comparison of the behavior of the three parameters versus temperature and pulse number is shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2. (a, c, e) XFEL Pulse-number dependence of the CDW satellite shift along the longitudinal direction (), the HWHM, and the square root of the CDW amplitude . (b, d, f) Temperature dependence (Synchrotron) of the same three quantities on two regions of the same sample. The dashed vertical line marks the assumed critical temperature K; in (f), the solid curves are fits of to the BCS-like mean-field form
In order to compare the two measurements —one taken at thermodynamic equilibrium versus temperature and the other versus pulse number at fixed temperature—we plot the gap as a function of , the gap versus correlation length and versus HWHM (see Figure 3). The huge difference between the two types of measurement highlights the non-thermal process induced by the ultrashort x-ray beam.
Figure 3. a-c): Correlations between the three CDW order parameters shown in Figure 2. a) versus the HWHM. b) The shift versus the HWHM. c) versus . Error bars are propagated from each quantity’s fit uncertainty. As in Figure 2, blue and orange dots are the synchrotron measurements as a function of temperature (on the two sample regions), and green dots are the XFEL data as a function of pump-pulse number.
Another major difference between the behavior with temperature and the behavior observed here with pulses number is the loss of inhomogeneity. At equilibrium, the fluctuations in NbSe above display a large anisotropy, leading to diffuse scattering elongated along the transverse directions, with the following ratio: and [29]. In the transverse direction , this corresponds to , far from the observation. In the present case, the anisotropy ratio measured at the pulse () is strongly reduced pulse after pulse until at the pulse (see Figure 1). The hard ultrashort x-ray beam reduces the inhomogeneity of CDW domains, moving the system away from a quasi-one-dimensional system.
X-ray pumping deeply changes the nature of the excited state by large shift, very slow relaxation, and loss of inhomogeneity. This non-thermal behavior could be explained first by a decrease of electron-phonon coupling induced by the ultrashort x-ray pulse. The decreasing coupling would lead to a decreasing band gap and thus a decreasing coherence lengths and loss of intensity because all three depend on the band gap ( and ) [25, 30]. However, a purely electronic phenomenon, very fast in principle, is hard to reconcile with the very slow relaxation times observed here and with the loss of inhomogeneity. The change in , as well as the increase in homogeneity as a function of pulse number, both associated with a slow recovery time, are more consistent with doped CDW systems. Studies performed on NbSe that substitute the transition-metal niobium element with tantalum[30] or titanium impurities[31] show a large decrease of the anisotropy ratio . In the case of NbSe doped with Ti-1%[31], the anisotropy ratio is 4:2:1 far from the large anisotropy present in the pure sample (27:8:1.7). Up to 40K above the transition temperature, the diffuse scattering becomes more and more asymmetric (see Figure 3 in [28]). NbSe doped with impurities also strongly alters the value with with Ti-1%[31]. The negative shift with doping results in decreasing band filling due to the substitution of Nb by Ti.
Following similar thought, the behavior of NbSe submitted to ultrashort x-ray pulses could nucleate local CDW distortions in the bulk. Since the shift with pulse number is positive, these distortions must carry an excess of charges. The x-ray beam would therefore dope the system through nucleation of topological objects such as solitons. In that case, this corresponds to a delocalized phase shift along the chain axis, leading to an additional CDW periods, each of them carrying 2 electrons[32]. The doping concentration can be estimated through the shift. In NbSe indeed, two electrons partially fill four bands out of six, giving an average .[33] The presence of additional solitons leads to electrons spread over the 4 bands where is the soliton concentration. The excess of charges would lead to a positive shift , that is to a maximum density of solitons .
In conclusion, the successive CDW states observed in NbSe with respect to pulse number are characterized by a change in wavevector, correlation lengths and electronic gap, as well as a change of dimensionality, within a very long recovery time. The proposed scenario, which involves the creation of charged topological defects, appears to be consistent with observations. The exact origin of their formation under ultrashort x-ray pulses remains to be explained, although it should be based on a profound modification of the Se-Se covalent bonds present in NbSe.
The authors would like to thanks S. Ravy for very interesting discussions. We acknowledge European XFEL in Schenefeld, Germany, for provision of X-ray free-electron laser beamtime at MID SASE2 instrument under proposal number xxx and would like to thank the staff for their assistance. Data recorded for the experiment at the European XFEL are available at doi:10.2203/XFEL.EU-DATA-xxxx-00. This research was supported in part through the Maxwell computational resources operated at Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron DESY.
References
- [1]T. Huber, S. O. Mariager, A. Ferrer, H. Schäfer, J. A. Johnson, S. Grübel, A. Lübcke, L. Huber, T. Kubacka, C. Dornes, C. Laulhé, S. Ravy, G. Ingold, P. Beaud, J. Demsar, and S. L. Johnson, Coherent structural dynamics of a prototypical charge-density-wave-to-metal transition, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 10.1103/Phys-RevLett.113.026401 (2014).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25062214
- [2]R. G. Moore, W. S. Lee, P. S. Kirchman, Y. D. Chuang, A. F. Kemper, M. Trigo, L. Patthey, D. H. Lu, O. Krupin, M. Yi, D. A. Reis, D. Doering, P. Denes, W. F. Schlotter, J. J. Turner, G. Hays, P. Hering, T. Benson, J. H. Chu, T. P. Devereaux, I. R. Fisher, Z. Hussain, and Z. X. Shen, Ultrafast resonant soft x-ray diffraction dynamics of the charge density wave in TbTe3, Phys. Rev. B 93, 1 (2016).DOI
- [3]W. S. Lee, Y. D. Chuang, R. G. Moore, Y. Zhu, L. Patthey, M. Trigo, D. H. Lu, P. S. Kirchmann, O. Krupin, M. Yi, M. Langner, N. Huse, J. S. Robinson, Y. Chen, S. Y. Zhou, G. Coslovich, B. Huber, D. A. Reis, R. A. Kaindl, R. W. Schoenlein, D. Doering, P. Denes, W. F. Schlotter, J. J. Turner, S. L. Johnson, M. Först, T. Sasagawa, Y. F. Kung, A. P. Sorini, A. F. Kemper, B. Moritz, T. P. Devereaux, D. H. Lee, Z. X. Shen, and Z. Hussain, Phase fluctuations and the absence of topological defects in a photo-excited charge-ordered nickelate, Nat. Commun. 3, 10.1038/ncomms1837 (2012).
- [4]T.-r. T. Han, Z. Tao, S. D. Mahanti, K. Chang, C.-y. Ruan, C. D. Malliakas, and M. G. Kanatzidis, Structural dynamics of two-dimensional charge-density waves in CeTe3 investigated by ultrafast, Physical Review B 86, 075145 (2012).DOI
- [5]E. Möhr-Vorobeva, S. L. Johnson, P. Beaud, U. Staub, R. De Souza, C. Milne, G. Ingold, J. Demsar, H. Schaefer, and A. Titov, Nonthermal melting of a charge density wave in tise2, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 036403 (2011).
- [6]N. Erasmus, M. Eichberger, K. Haupt, I. Boshoff, G. Kassier, R. Birmurske, H. Berger, J. Demsar, and H. Schwoerer, Ultrafast Dynamics of Charge Density Waves in 4Hb-TaSe2 Probed by Femtosecond Electron Diffraction, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 167402 (2012).DOI
- [7]D. Wickramaratne, S. Subedi, D. H. Torchinsky, G. Karapetrov, and I. I. Mazin, Photoinduced chiral charge density wave in tise2, Phys. Rev. B 105, 054102 (2022).DOI
- [8]K. Haupt, M. Eichberger, N. Erasmus, A. Rohwer, J. Demsar, K. Rossnagel, and H. Schwoerer, Ultrafast Metamorphosis of a Complex Charge-Density Wave, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 016402 (2016).DOI
- [9]C. Laulhé, T. Huber, G. Lantz, A. Ferrer, S. O. Mariager, S. Grübel, J. Rittmann, J. A. Johnson, V. Esposito, A. Lübcke, L. Huber, M. Kubli, M. Savoini, V. L. R. Jacques, L. Cario, B. Corraze, E. Janod, G. Ingold, P. Beaud, S. L. Johnson, and S. Ravy, Ultrafast Formation of a Charge Density Wave State in 1T-TaS2 : Observation at Nanometer Scales Using Time-Resolved X-Ray Diffraction, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 24701 (2017).
- [10]G. Lantz, C. Laulhé, S. Ravy, M. Kubli, M. Savoini, K. Tasca, E. Abreu, V. Esposito, M. Porer, A. Ciavardini, L. Cario, J. Rittmann, P. Beaud, and S. L. Johnson, Domain-size effects on the dynamics of a charge density wave in 1T−tas2, Phys. Rev. B 96, 224101 (2017).DOI
- [11]A. Kogar, A. Zong, P. E. Dolgirev, X. Shen, J. Straqua- dine, Y. Q. Bie, X. Wang, T. Rohwer, I. C. Tung, Y. Yang, R. Li, J. Yang, S. Weathersby, S. Park, M. E. Kozina, E. J. Sie, H. Wen, P. Jarillo-Herrero, I. R. Fisher, X. Wang, and N. Gedik, Light-induced charge density wave in LaTe3, Nat. Phys. 16, 159 (2020), 1904.07472.
- [12]F. Zhou, J. Williams, C. D. Malliakas, M. G. Kanatzidis, and A. F. Kemper, Nonequilibrium dynamics of spontaneous symmetry breaking into a hidden state of charge-density wave, arXiv:1904.07120 (2019).arxiv.org/abs/1904.07120
- [13]L. X. Yang, G. Rohde, K. Hanff, A. Stange, R. Xiong, J. Shi, M. Bauer, and K. Rossnagel, Bypassing the structural bottleneck in the ultrafast melting of electronic order, Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 266402 (2020).
- [14]R. Yusupov, T. Mertelj, V. V. Kabanov, S. Brazovskii, P. Kusar, J. H. Chu, I. R. Fisher, and D. Mihailovic, Coherent dynamics of macroscopic electronic order through a symmetry breaking transition, Nat. Phys. 6, 681 (2010).
- [15]T. Mertelj, P. Kusar, V. V. Kabanov, P. Giraldo-Gallo, I. R. Fisher, and D. Mihailovic, Incoherent topological defect recombination dynamics in TbTe3, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 1 (2013).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25167288
- [16]S. Vogelgesang, G. Storeck, J. G. Horstmann, T. Diekmann, M. Sivis, S. Schramm, K. Rossnagel, S. Schäfer, and C. Ropers, Phase ordering of charge density waves traced by ultrafast low-energy electron diffraction, Nat. Phys. 14, 184 (2017).DOI
- [17]A. Zong, A. Kogar, Y. Q. Bie, T. Rohwer, C. Lee, E. Baldini, E. Ergeçen, M. B. Yilmaz, B. Freelon, E. J. Sie, H. Zhou, J. Straquadine, P. Walmsley, P. E. Dolgirev, A. V. Rozhkov, I. R. Fisher, P. Jarillo-Herrero, B. V. Fine, and N. Gedik, Evidence for topological defects in a photoinduced phase transition, Nat. Phys. 15, 27 (2019).DOI
- [18]N. J. Hartley, J. Grenzer, L. Huang, Y. Inubushi, N. Kamimura, K. Katagiri, R. Kodama, A. Kon, W. Lu, M. Makita, T. Matsuoka, S. Nakajima, N. Ozaki, T. Pikuz, A. V. Rode, D. Sagae, A. K. Schuster, K. Tono, K. Voigt, J. Vorberger, T. Yabuuchi, E. E. McBride, and D. Kraus, Using diffuse scattering to observe x-ray-driven nonthermal melting, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 015703 (2021).
- [19]T. Pardini, J. Alameda, A. Aquila, S. Boutet, T. Decker, A. E. Gleason, S. Guillet, P. Hamilton, M. Hayes, R. Hill, J. Koglin, B. Koziolziemski, J. Robinson, K. Sokolowski-Tinten, R. Soufli, and S. P. Hau-Riege, Delayed onset of nonthermal melting in single-crystal silicon pumped with hard x rays, Physical Review Letters 120, 265701 (2018).DOI
- [20]I. Inoue, Y. Deguchi, B. Ziaja, T. Osaka, M. M. Abdullah, Z. Jurek, N. Medvedev, V. Tkachenko, Y. Inubushi, H. Kasai, K. Tamasaku, T. Hara, E. Nishibori, and M. Yabashi, Atomic-scale visualization of ultrafast bond breaking in x-ray-excited diamond, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 117403 (2021).DOI
- [21]I. Inoue, V. Tkachenko, K. J. Kapcia, V. Lipp, B. Ziaja, Y. Inubushi, T. Hara, M. Yabashi, and E. Nishibori, Delayed onset and directionality of x-ray-induced atomic displacements observed on subatomic length scales, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 223203 (2022).
- [22]A. Madsen, J. Hallmann, G. Ansaldi, T. Roth, W. Lu, C. Kim, U. Boesenberg, A. Zozulya, J. Möller, R. Shayd ulk, M. Scholz, A. Bartmann, A. Schmidt, I. Lobato, K. Sukharnikov, M. Reiser, K. Kazarian, and I. Petrov, Materials imaging and dynamics (mid) instrument at the european x-ray free-electron laser facility, J. Synchrotron Rad 28, 637 (2021).DOI
- [23]S. Liu et al., Cascaded hard x-ray self-seeded free-electron laser at megahertz repetition rate, Nature Photonics 17, 984 (2023).DOI
- [24]D. L. Bolloch’h, E. Bellec, D. Ghoneim, A. Gallo-Frantz, P. Wzietek, L. Ortega, A. Madsen, P. Monceau, M. Chollet, I. Gonzales-Vallejo, V. L. R. Jacques, and A. Sinchenko, The importance of shear on the collective charge transport in cdws revealed by an xfel source, Science Advances 11, eard6034 (2025), https://www.science.org/doi/pdf/10.1126/sciadv.adr6034.
- [25]H. Fukuyama and P. A. Lee, Dynamics of the charge-density wave. i. impurity pinning in a single chain, Phys. Rev. B 17, 535 (1978).DOI
- [26]G. Gruner, Density Waves In Solids (CRC Press, 2018).DOI
- [27]P. Monceau, Electronic crystals: an experimental overview, Advances in Physics, Advances in Physics 61, 325 (2012).DOI
- [28]A. H. Moudden, J. D. Axe, P. Monceau, and F. Levy, q1 charge-density wave in nbse3, Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 223 (1990).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10042584
- [29]A. H. Moudden, L. Vasiliu-Doloc, P. Monceau, and F. Levy, Structural studies of the q1 charge-density-wave in nbse3, Journal de Physique IV France 3, C2 (1993).DOI
- [30]D. DiCarlo, R. E. Thorne, E. Sweetland, M. Sutton, and J. D. Brock, Charge-density-wave structure in nbse3, Phys. Rev. B 50, 8288 (1994).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9974846
- [31]S. Rouzière, S. Ravy, J.-P. Pouget, and R. E. Thorne, X-ray investigation of the q1 charge-density-wave modulation in substituted ti- and Ta—nbse3, Phys. Rev. B 59, 15121 (1999).DOI
- [32]J. V. L. R. Rojo-Bravo A. and L. B. D., Collective transport of charges in charge density wave systems based on traveling soliton lattices, Phys. Rev. B 94, 201120 (2016).
- [33]E. Canadell, I. E. I. Rachidi, J. P. Pouget, P. Gressier, A. Meerschaut, J. Rouxel, D. Jung, M. Evain, and M. H. Whangbo, Comparison of the electronic structures of layered transition-metal trichalcogenides thallium triselenide, thallium trisulfide and niobium triselenide, Inorganic Chemistry 29, 1401 (1990).DOI

