WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Non-evolutionary effects on period change in Magellanic Cepheids. III. Empirical connection with additional low-amplitude variability
Abstract
The O-C method in classical Cepheids traces both evolutionary and shorter-timescale (non-evolutionary) period changes. In our previous works, we found irregular period changes in 33% of Magellanic classical Cepheids, but excluded Cepheids showing additional low-amplitude variability. Here, we establish whether first-overtone Cepheids hosting such variability differ in their period-change behaviour from the general first-overtone population. We analyse 544 Magellanic Cepheids with period ratios or , using OGLE photometry, and classify and characterise their O-C diagrams following our previous studies. We find irregular period changes in 339 first-overtone Cepheids (195 in the LMC and 144 in the SMC), an incidence rate of 75.5%, a statistically significant increase over the 68.1% of our previous single-mode first-overtone sample. The combined first-overtone incidence becomes 69.7%. This provides the first empirical connection between additional low-amplitude variability and irregular period changes in first-overtone Cepheids. At a fixed pulsation period, the irregularity strength anticorrelates with the dominant pulsation amplitude but not with the additional-signal amplitude, suggesting that the additional periodicity marks a weakly saturated pulsation state rather than driving the irregularity. We further detect cycle-to-cycle (C2C) period variation in 37% of the class 3 sample, with jitter roughly seven times larger than in non-Blazhko RRc stars and a shallower scaling with pulsation period.
Introduction
Classical Cepheids, or Type-I Cepheids (hereafter Cepheids), are a cornerstone of stellar evolution and pulsation studies. This class of stars is particularly notable for its role as a distance indicator [17, 58] owing to its tight Period–Luminosity (–) relation [28, 29], also known as the Leavitt Law. Cepheids are – stars that are predominantly in the core-helium-burning phase and are characterised by their distinctive light curves, which exhibit high-amplitude variability.
Classically, Cepheids were known to pulsate in single radial modes such as fundamental (F) mode, first overtone (1O) mode or second overtone (2O) mode. Eventually, with more observations, multi-mode Cepheids were discovered ranging from double-mode Cepheids in combinations (F+1O, 1O+2O, 1O+3O) to even triple-mode detections (F+1O+2O, 1O+2O+3O) [e.g. 67, 68, 71, 73, 69]. Even though the physics of excitation of multi-mode radial mode pulsation is a bone of contention [e.g. 25, 62], the presence of multiple modes in Cepheids has aided in constraining physical parameters and in turn evolution/pulsation theory [e.g. 32, 5]. In the past two decades, Cepheids have been recognised as exhibiting greater complexity than previously assumed, mainly the presence of secondary low-amplitude (mmag) periodicities that cannot be attributed to radial modes. One important group of such variability in Cepheids manifests an additional periodicity () alongside the radial first-overtone period (), with a period ratio - [67, 68], also referred to as the 0.62-mode in other studies [78 a]. We refer to them in this work as the Cep variability group. These additional periodicities arrange themselves in three distinct sequences on the Petersen diagram [45]. Many studies across Galactic and Magellanic fields have been dedicated to detecting these additional signatures using Optical Gravitational Lensing Experiment (OGLE) photometry [33, 34, 68, 48, 65, 55, 66] and, more recently, TESS data [51, 50]. The model attempting to explain the origin of these sequences, introduced by Dziembowski [13], states that these signals are harmonics of non-radial modes of degree (top sequence), 8 (middle sequence), and 9 (bottom sequence). According to this model, geometric cancellation reduces the observed amplitude of the non-radial mode itself, thereby obscuring its direct detection. Analogues of such periodicities are also present in RR Lyrae pulsators, RRc stars in particular [42, 35, 63, 23, 41, 39].
In addition to Cep stars, first-overtone classical Cepheids also display another distinct type of additional variability, with a period longer than that of the dominant first overtone, and a period ratio (hereafter referred to as the Cep group). Several studies have reported their occurrences (Süveges & Anderson 2018b,a; Smolec et al. 2023). The signal typically has an amplitude at the millimagnitude level and often appears coherent, with no apparent variation in phase or amplitude. Similar to the Cep group, RR Lyrae stars also manifest the presence of Cep-group variability [40, 39]. Interestingly, a Kepler RR Lyrae star (KIC 9453114) exhibits the simultaneous presence of signals belonging to both 0.61 and 0.68-type variability [35]. The incidence rate of the Cep group is estimated to be 1.3% in the LMC and 0.3% in the SMC [66]. Despite these observational constraints, the physical origin of the additional periodicities remains unclear.
Apart from secondary periodicities, Cepheids also undergo long-term changes in their pulsation periods. This occurs as a result of secular evolution during their passage through the instability strip, leading to gradual period increases (during the first and third crossings) or decreases (during the second crossing). Such a phenomenon is recorded by measuring the period-change rate of Cepheids, as done by several studies (e.g. [9, 82, 46, 47, 52, 59] (Csörnyei et al. 2022). The measured rates have been only broadly consistent with theoretical predictions [82, 38, 2, 3, 30, 15], with scope for improvement through the inclusion of additional physics (e.g., core overshooting, rotation, or mass loss). However, even secular period changes have at times been found to exhibit deviations from this expected behaviour (e.g. S Vul, Y Oph; Csörnyei et al. 2022), including sudden period shifts, cyclic modulations, and stochastic variations (e.g. [43, 10, 52, 54] (Csörnyei et al. 2022)). These irregularities suggest additional physical processes influencing Cepheid pulsations beyond standard evolutionary effects.
Departures from the above-mentioned secular period changes usually occur on shorter timescales ( days) and are referred to as non-linear period changes. A fraction of these non-secular period variations (and consequently the diagram) are cyclic in nature and are attributed to binarity. Such phenomena manifest due to the light-travel time effect (LTTE; [21, 22], which has been explored for Cepheids [53] and RR Lyrae stars (e.g., [18, 19] to identify binary candidates. The remaining fraction of non-linear period changes is substantially more complex and is most often manifested as irregular behaviour in the diagram. Despite decades of observational signatures, the physical mechanism responsible for this puzzling behaviour has not yet been established. A number of possible explanations have been put forward, including binary interactions [80], discrete mixing events in the core [79], magnetic fields [76], and episodic mass loss [27, 26]. However, none of these explanations can account for the observed timescales.
In our previous works, we investigated period changes in the context of the LTTE, indicative of binarity [53 hereafter Paper I], and the irregular behaviour of period changes of yet unknown origin [54 hereafter Paper II]. However, in these studies, in order to ensure a clean sample of purely single radial-mode Cepheids, we intentionally excluded stars that showed additional low-amplitude signals. This sample cut was motivated by the concern that additional low-amplitude periodicities could influence the stability of the radial mode. This resulted in hundreds of Cepheids being rejected from the analysis, which may have biased the calculation of the incidence rate of irregular period changes across the metallicity environment and pulsation mode. In this study, our goal is to investigate whether the presence of additional low-amplitude periodicities affects or correlates with irregular period changes in Magellanic Cloud Cepheids. Therefore, we focus explicitly on such candidates, using OGLE photometry to examine two groups of additional periodicity: Cep and Cep. The motivation for focusing on these specific types of low-amplitude periodicities is because a considerable sample of Cepheids exhibiting these periodicities has been identified in the OGLE survey [66].
Sect. 2 introduces our OGLE [87] sample and the methodology used for both frequency analysis and diagram construction. Thereafter, in Sect. 3, we compile our findings, probing the connection between the additional low-amplitude periodicities of Cepheids and their curve shapes, followed by a discussion in Sect. 4 and our concluding remarks in Sect. 5.
Methodology
Photometry data
Our data are similar to those presented in Paper I and Paper II, extended by the most recent observations from the ongoing OGLE-IV survey phase. The photometry consists of homogeneous OGLE2 survey photometry spanning several phases: (i) OGLE-III (2001–2009; [86] Soszyński et al. [67, 68], which also contains OGLE-II (1997–2000; Udalski et al. [83, 84]); and (ii) OGLE-IV (2010–February 2025; Udalski et al. [87]; Soszyński et al. [71, 72, 69]), which also contains high-cadence, nonpublic post-2022 data from the extended OGLE-IV survey; and (iii) the ongoing OGLE-V phase, which began in February 2025 and continues the high-cadence monitoring of the Magellanic Clouds. During the OGLE-IV extended and OGLE-V observations, the survey’s primary focus was on detecting short-duration microlensing events, which resulted in an unprecedented observational cadence over approximately three years (see high-cadence survey details in Mróz et al. 2024). The extended OGLE-IV and ongoing OGLE-V survey covers only the central fields of the Magellanic Clouds, comprising five fields in the LMC and four in the SMC. Overall, this provides more than two decades of photometric coverage of the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) and Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) Cepheids. Our analysis was restricted to the -band data, which provide substantially denser temporal coverage than the -band observations.
We note that blending by nearby sources is not expected to significantly affect our analysis, as a constant or slowly varying blend alters the light-curve amplitude but introduces no significant time-variable phase shift, while a variable blend of nearly matching period is highly improbable and would likely have been flagged in our frequency analysis.
Sample and data preparation
As mentioned earlier, in this study we investigate period changes in Cepheids with two types of low-amplitude periodicity, the Cep and Cep groups. The largest reported sample of Magellanic first-overtone Cepheids exhibiting these periodicities was compiled by Smolec et al. [66]. We note that fundamental-mode Cepheids do not show this form of variability but instead exhibit another kind of low-amplitude modulation (e.g., Smolec [61]; Smolec et al. [66]). We start with the sample of Smolec et al. [66] for the Cep group, consisting of 291 LMC and 225 SMC Cepheids, for an overall sample of 516 candidates. For the Cep group, we start with a sample of 28 Cepheids, comprising 23 from the LMC and 5 from the SMC. Overall, this constitutes a starting total sample of 544 Cepheids.
After obtaining the data, the initial step is merging the photometry from all OGLE survey phases. Following an instrument upgrade between the OGLE-III and OGLE-IV phases (Udalski et al. [87]), combining the data required caution (see Sect. 2.1 of Hajdu et al. [18]). We refer to Sect. 3.1 of Paper I or Sect. 2.3 of Paper II, where we describe in detail the procedure to combine the data, which involves transforming each individual OGLE-phase dataset to an arbitrary intensity scale, followed by an appropriate Fourier-order fit to correct for the shift in the mean intensity, and ending with recovering the dataset on a magnitude scale. Such a method is also employed in similar work on RR Lyrae stars using OGLE photometry (Hajdu et al. [19]).
Similar to our previous works, we have also imposed sample cuts on the Cepheids under investigation (see Table 1). To place all candidates on the same footing, we rejected candidates that were missing either of the OGLE survey phases (Step 1 in Table 1). From the Cep LMC sample, 59 Cepheids lacked OGLE-III data and 1 lacked OGLE-IV data. In the SMC sample, 7 lacked OGLE-III data and 1 lacked OGLE-IV data. This resulted in the rejection of 68 candidates overall, consisting of 60 from the LMC and 8 from the SMC. Similarly, in the Cep sample, we rejected 6 in the LMC and 1 in the SMC, leading to a total of 7 rejected candidates, all of which were missing OGLE-III survey-phase photometry. Additionally, 20 Cepheids in total were rejected during the subsequent filtering procedure (Step 2 in Table 1) for various reasons: (i) consecutive seasons with sparse sampling, leading to a gap in the diagram (fewer data points in a season yield an measurement with a high error, so these points were omitted); (ii) pulsation periods close to integer values, leading to a sampling bias that in certain cases affects the resulting Fourier template; and (iii) a systematic magnitude shift across individual OGLE seasons.
| Type | Initial OGLE sample | Sample Cleaning Steps | Final Sample | |||
| from Smolec et al. [66] | Step 1 | Step 2 | Class 1 | Class 2 | Class 3 | |
| Cep LMC 1O | 291 | 60 | 9 | 27 | 7 | 188 |
| Cep SMC 1O | 225 | 8 | 9 | 52 | 14 | 142 |
| Cep LMC 1O | 23 | 6 | 2 | 3 | 5 | 7 |
| Cep SMC 1O | 5 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 2 |
| Total | 544 | 75 | 20 | 83 | 27 | 339 |
Table 1. Cepheid sample distribution.
Analysis
In this study, we deal with the detection and characterisation of irregular period changes in Cepheids with low-amplitude periodicities; hence, the two backbone procedures of our work are frequency and analysis. We briefly describe both. The frequency analysis was conducted on our Cepheid sample in a similar way to previous studies on comparable targets and databases (e.g., Netzel et al. [41]; Smolec & Śniegowska [65]; Smolec [61]; Rathour et al. [55]; Smolec et al. [66]).
As an initial step, we compute the Discrete Fourier Transform of the time series to identify the dominant frequency. The subsequent stage of the analysis involves applying the standard consecutive pre-whitening method (e.g., Moskalik & Kołaczkowski [34]). For Cepheids with comparable cadences in both the standard OGLE-IV and extended datasets, the data are merged and analysed collectively. When the extended OGLE-IV data differ significantly in cadence or coverage, we conduct manual frequency analyses on the OGLE-IV and extended datasets separately, following the same methodology as above. This distinction is necessary due to their differing observational characteristics, particularly variations in sampling cadence, which influence detection limits (see Fig. 5 in Smolec [61]) and affect frequency identification. Additionally, the signals under investigation may not be strictly coherent (especially Cep-group candidates); small intrinsic variations over long timescales can affect their stability. Analysing separate datasets allows for more effective pre-whitening.
To detect non-evolutionary period changes in Cepheids with low-amplitude periodicities, we compute their diagrams. The diagram is a powerful tool for studying timing variations in both eclipsing binaries and pulsating stars (for the canonical methodology, see Zhou [88]; Sterken [74]). An alternative approach to analysing period variations is the Hertzsprung method (Hertzsprung [20]), which focuses on phase shifts rather than the precise timing of extrema. Instead of measuring individual maxima or minima, this technique tracks how the observed light curve shifts in phase relative to a constructed template. The phase shift over time provides a direct measure of period variations. A modified version is adopted, as described in Sect. 3.2 of Paper I or Sect. 2.5 of Paper II, and used in other similar studies (Hajdu et al. [18, 19]; Rodríguez-Segovia et al. [59]).
Results
Justification: Effect of low-amplitude variability
Before computing the diagrams and investigating their connection with the low-amplitude periodicities, it is important to quantify the contribution of these periodicities to the overall behaviour of the period changes depicted in the shapes. We note that in Paper I, for only a few targets, we performed a similar investigation of Cepheids that not only showed a binary sigNotes. Step 1: Candidates missing either of the OGLE survey phase data; Step 2: Rejected during final filtering. Classes are defined by morphology: class 1 for constant period (flat ); class 2 for linear period change (parabolic ); class 3 for irregular period change (see Sect. 3.2).
nature in the diagram but also contained low-amplitude signals in the frequency spectrum. We analysed such Cepheids within the binary sample and checked whether there was any significant effect on the binary parameters extracted from the diagram when the low-amplitude signals were cleaned, compared with when they were not. The results indicated a negligible effect, as already demonstrated for several Cepheids (see Paper I, Sect. 4.4). In Paper II, we rejected from the outset all Cepheids reported to show any kind of low-amplitude variability, in order to investigate only purely single-radial-mode Cepheids. However, in this study, as we work specifically with the low-amplitude-periodicity sample showing non-linear period changes, it is all the more important to test whether these periodicities have an effect on the diagram.
To demonstrate this, we selected a total of 8 Cepheids (4 from each MC sample), comprising both variability types (Cep and Cep), with the highest amplitude ratio () among their respective samples. This test case is designed to select only those Cepheids for which the low-amplitude signal is strongest in the sample. In the first case, we computed the diagram in the regular way, as in Paper I and Paper II. In the second case, we analysed the frequency spectrum of each Cepheid and specifically subtracted the low-amplitude signal before computing the diagram.
In Figure 1 we present the differences in the diagrams resulting from the two cases mentioned above. The top panels correspond to the Cep sample, and the bottom panels to the Cep sample. The blue and red points illustrate the difference between the individual points in the two cases. The marginal differences in both the overall shape and the individual values are clearly depicted. To quantify the differences, we calculate the individual point differences across the time baseline and investigate the residuals. For the Cep test candidates, we measure the error-weighted mean of the residuals. This quantity does not exceed d, indicating that the effect does not introduce a significant systematic shift. For the Cep sample, the same quantity is at most d. These values correspond to less than 10% of the typical measurement uncertainty for any individual star in the sample. This confirms that the presence of the additional periodicities does not introduce a statistically significant systematic shift in the period changes.
Figure 1. Top panel shows examples of diagrams with Cep variability present (blue square) over-plotted with the case with the associated variability subtracted (red circle). Bottom panel shows the same for Cep sample.
Hence, we conclude that the removal of the low-amplitude signature from the frequency spectrum has a negligible effect on the resulting diagram. For the remainder of the study, we directly compute diagrams for the Cepheids without individually isolating the low-amplitude signature.
Classification
We classify the working sample of 449 Cepheids, based on their diagrams, into three main classes, following the methodology described in Sect. 3 of Paper II. Example diagrams representative of each class are shown in Fig. A.1 (class 1), Fig. B.1 (class 2) and Figure 2 (class 3) for both Cep and Cep samples.
Figure 2. Representative diagrams of Cep (top panel) and Cep (bottom panel) candidates belonging to class 3. The OGLE identifier and pulsation period are shown at the top of each panel.
Class 1 candidates
The first are the class 1 candidates, which show a flat variation indicative of negligible period change within the observational baseline, consistent with a constant pulsation period across the OGLE observations. We find 83 class 1 candidates in total, comprising 79 from the Cep and 4 from the Cep sample, constituting 18.5% of the working sample. Broken down by variability type, this fraction is 18.4% among the Cep group and 21.1% among the Cep group. Additionally, across both galaxies, the LMC shows a notably lower class 1 fraction of 12.7% compared to 25.0% in the SMC. The complete list of class 1 candidates from this study is presented in Table A.1.
Class 2 candidates
The second are the class 2 candidates, which exhibit a parabolic shape indicative of a linear period change. However, we caution against a direct evolutionary period-change interpretation. On the 20 yr OGLE baseline, a parabolic is consistent with secular evolution only for first-crossing candidates, which are characterised by high period-change rates (high enough to be captured within the OGLE time span). Alternatively, a parabolic shape may represent only half a cycle of LTTE signature, pointing to a binary interpretation with an orbital period exceeding 20 yr. Additionally, a third plausible scenario is of irregular period change with a fluctuation timescale longer than the observational baseline, which can mimic a smooth parabolic shape on a 20 yr window. In that case, the diagram should gradually reveal its irregular nature in possible future observing seasons. Distinguishing between above-mentioned scenarios requires either a longer observational baseline or radial-velocity follow-up. We recover 27 class 2 candidates in total, comprising 21 from the Cep and 6 from the Cep sample, yielding an overall fraction of 6.0%. Within the Cep group this fraction is 4.9%, while for the Cep group it rises to 31.6%. The latter is, however, driven by the low-number statistics of the Cep sample (19 stars) compared to the Cep sample (430 stars). Again, comparing the two galaxies, the SMC shows a marginally higher class 2 fraction of 7.1% compared to 5.1% in the LMC, though, given the small numbers involved, this difference is not significant. Among the class 2 additional-variability Cepheids, we find 17 stars (63%) with positive period-change rates consistent with redward evolution across the instability strip (tentative first-crossing candidates). These comprise 14 Cep stars (5 in the LMC and 9 in the SMC) and 3 Cep stars (all in the LMC). Ten stars (37%) show negative period change rates, indicating blueward evolution. These comprise 7 Cep stars (2 in the LMC and 5 in the SMC) and 3 Cep stars (2 in the LMC and 1 in the SMC).
Across the combined sample of 17 stars, our first-crossing candidates, the period-change rates () span the range 1.4–26.4 d/Myr, with a median value of 5.75 d/Myr. These values are considerably smaller than those reported by Rodríguez-Segovia et al. [59] for their two LMC first-crossing candidates (OGLE-LMC-CEP-2840: d/Myr and OGLE-LMC-CEP-2132: d/Myr). This difference is expected, since these two Cepheids have pulsation periods longer than all of our tentative candidates. Since the theoreti-
cal period-change-rate predictions of Turner et al. [82] show that increases with pulsation period, shorter-period Cepheids are naturally expected to exhibit smaller period-change rates for a given crossing. The list of class 2 candidates, along with their estimated period-change rates, is compiled in Table B.1.
We note that part of the class 2 variations could be of non-evolutionary origin as well (see the scenarios at the beginning of this subsection), hence the derived rates and fractions given here need caution.
Class 3 candidates
The final are the class 3 candidates (see Table C.1), which are the main focus of this study within our overall low-amplitude-periodicity sample. This class refers to Cepheids showing irregular period changes. There is no known explanation for the origin of this period-change behaviour, as depicted by their diagrams. We find a total of 339 Cepheids in our sample exhibiting irregular period changes (see Table 1). This sample comprises 330 Cep and 9 Cep candidates. The overall fraction of class 3 candidates is , whereas within each variability subgroup the fractions are and for the Cep and Cep groups, respectively. Once again, the latter is affected by low-number statistics. The class 3 fraction is markedly higher in the LMC () than in the SMC ().
In Figure 3 we compare the pulsation-period distribution of our class 3 candidates with that of the first-overtone class 3 sample from Paper II. In the LMC (top panel), the Paper II class 3 distribution extends from the 0–0.5 d bin to beyond 5.5 d and peaks in the broad 1.5–2.5 d bin (). Our Cep class 3 candidates first appear in the 1–1.5 d bin () and peak one bin later in the 2–2.5 d bin (), extending out to the 4.5–5 d bin. The Cep class 3 candidates in the LMC number only 7 stars across the 1.5–3 d bins and are too few to describe any distribution. We note that the difference between the Cep and Paper II distributions is the absence of Cep stars in the 0–1 d bins, where the Paper II sample contributes 57 stars, and their near-absence in the 1–1.5 d bin (). Beyond 2.5 d, both distributions follow a similar declining trend. In the SMC (Figure 3, bottom panel), the Paper II class 3 distribution is strongly concentrated at shorter periods, spanning the 0–4.5 d range and peaking sharply in the 0.5–1 d bin () before declining gradually. The Cep candidates are present but sparse in that dominant bin () and instead peak in the following 1–1.5 d bin (), extending later to the 3.5–4 d bin. The Cep class 3 sample in the SMC contains only 2 stars across the 1.5–3 d bins, and no meaningful distribution can be described. In both galaxies, the class 3 candidates follow the period distribution of the overall Cep working sample (classes 1–3), as shown in Figure 3. The differences with respect to the Paper II distributions simply reflect the period range in which the additional periodicities occur.
Figure 3. Pulsation period distribution of class 3 candidates in the LMC (top) and SMC (bottom). Black, green, and red dashed histograms correspond to the first-overtone class 3 sample from Paper II and to the Cep and Cep class 3 samples of this work, respectively. The blue dotted histogram shows all Cep stars of the working sample, irrespective of the period change classification. The y-axis is in logarithmic scale.
Characterisation
Following the classification described in Sect. 3.2, we obtain a total of 339 class 3 candidates (LMC: 195 and SMC: 144). These Cepheids simultaneously exhibit additional low-amplitude periodicities and irregular period changes. Subsequently, we characterise their period changes using several statistical tests on the resulting diagrams. Different analyses probe separate features of the period changes. For a detailed methodology, we refer the reader to Paper II (Sect. 4). Here, we provide only a brief summary of each method and then focus on comparing the results for our Cep and Cep samples against the larger class 3 sample from Paper II.
The first method is the Eddington-Plakidis test ([14]), which exploits all pairwise differences among the measurements rather than their individual values. It quantifies the pulsation-period irregularity by examining how the squared differences between all observation pairs, , grow with their cycle separation . For a star with a stochastically wandering period, this growth is linear,
where is the measurement noise and is the mean period fluctuation over a pulsation cycle. A significant positive slope in Eq. (1) constitutes a detection of period irregularity, which is encapsulated in the parameter.
Figure 4 (upper panel) places our results in the context of the full F- and 1O-mode Cepheid populations from Paper II (shown as brown and blue contours, respectively). Since our sample consists only of first-overtone candidates, we split the larger class 3 sample from Paper II by pulsation mode, merging the LMC and SMC stars within each mode, for comparison. The Cep and Cep stars from both galaxies lie fully within the 1O-mode contours across the period range they occupy (-- d). The estimated values span the ranges for the detected Cep and for the detected Cep candidates. The median for Cep and for Cep is in excellent agreement with the median of the general 1O class 3 Cepheid population from Paper II (). No systematic offset in is apparent between the additional-variability stars and the bulk 1O population at corresponding periods. For comparison, we also include the Galactic, predominantly fundamental-mode, Cepheid sample of Csörnyei et al. (2022); these occupy longer periods and substantially higher values. The previously established period dependence of the irregularity amplitude is again supported by our sample. Consequently, we note that the presence of Cep- or Cep-type additional low-amplitude periodicity is not associated with any systematic change (enhancement or suppression) in the parameter.
Figure 4. Eddington-Plakidis test based fluctuation parameter (upper) and Stetson variability index (lower) as a function of pulsation period for the class 3 sample of this study. Background density contours show the distributions of fundamental-mode (brown) and first-overtone (blue) Cepheids from Paper II. Circles mark Cep and stars mark Cep candidates from this study, for the LMC (red, orange) and SMC (blue, green). Black plus symbols in the upper panel show the Galactic Cepheid sample of Csörnyei et al. (2022): encircled for fundamental-mode, boxed for first-overtone, and bare for uncertain mode classification.
The second method estimates the Stetson index (Stetson [75]), which measures the temporal correlation of the points. When the pulsation period wanders irregularly, the diagram drifts steadily and consecutive points cluster on the same side of the mean, which is captured by large -index values. In the ideal scenario, for a strictly periodic star, the points should scatter randomly around zero, and hence the index would remain low. Conversely, a higher index indicates stronger period irregularity.
Similar to the previous result, here we compare the Stetson-test estimates (log ) with the overall sample from Paper II. Both Cep and Cep stars lie well within the 1O-mode contours across their occupied period range (see Figure 4, lower panel), and the combined median agrees well with the Paper II 1O class 3 median of . Consequently, the current sample distribution also lies systematically above the F-mode contours, reinforcing the empirical finding that first-overtone stars show a higher degree of irregularity than fundamental-mode Cepheids.
In the third method, to characterise the timescales and amplitudes of the variations, we apply a wavelet-based time-frequency analysis, as in Paper II (see Sect. 4.2 therein). In brief, the diagram of each star is first fitted with a Gaussian Process Regression (GPR) model, and the resulting profile is analysed with a Continuous Wavelet Transform (CWT; Farge [16]; Torrence & Compo [81]) using a Morlet wavelet (Morlet et al. [31]; Torrence & Compo [81]). The dominant variability timescale and its associated amplitude are identified from the wavelet power spectrum. In essence, the GPR turns the scattered points into a continuous curve, and the wavelet transform measures how strongly, and on which timescales, that curve fluctuates at each moment of the observing baseline. We caution that the dominant periodicity estimates should be interpreted as characteristic timescales of irregular variability rather than strict periodicities.
In Fig. 5 we show the estimated dominant variability amplitude as a function of timescale (upper left panel) and pulsation period (lower left panel). Both Cep and Cep stars follow the same amplitude--timescale relation as the larger Paper II class 3 sample, populating its shorter-timescale, lower-amplitude end. The dominant variability timescales of our sample span -- d, with a median of d, well below the Paper II 1O-mode median of d. The dominant variability amplitudes span -amplitude , with a median of dex. This lies dex below the Paper II 1O-mode median () and close to the F-mode median (), reflecting the systematically shorter dominant timescales of our sample rather than a departure from the class 3 sequence. Overall, the wavelet analysis places our stars on the general class 3 amplitude--timescale relation, at the short-timescale end of the 1O-mode population.
The fourth and final method estimates the instantaneous period directly from the diagram using two parallel approaches, following Paper II (see their Sects. 4.3 and 5.6). In the first, the is fitted with a polynomial of order , selected by minimising the Akaike information criterion (AIC; Akaike [1]) and the Bayesian information criterion (BIC; Schwarz [60]) values (with a minimum degree of 3, since degrees 1 and 2 correspond to class 1 and class 2 behaviour by construction), and the instantaneous period is derived analytically from its derivative:
where denotes the period used to construct the diagram. In the second approach, a GPR model is fitted to the diagram, and is obtained from its numerical derivative. Two summary statistics are recorded: , the normalised peak-to-peak range of the instantaneous-period deviations , and , the standard deviation of those deviations. Both estimates quantify the amplitude of pulsation-period fluctuations over the observed baseline. Following Paper II, the GPR-based instantaneous period is the preferred estimator owing to its flexibility in handling the irregular class 3 diagrams, while the best-fit polynomial serves as a consistency cross-check.
We present the above quantities in Fig. 5, showing (upper right panel) and (lower right panel) as functions of pulsation period. In both panels, our combined class 3 sample lies well within the Paper II class 3 1O-mode contours across the occupied period range, relative to the larger class 3 sample. Our sample has median values of and . Both quantities show a statistically significant positive correlation with pulsation period (Spearman and , respectively; ), confirming that larger period fluctuations occur at longer pulsation periods, consistent with the trend reported in Paper II.
Figure 5. Distribution of log dominant variability amplitude as a function of the dominant variability timescale (upper-left) and pulsation period (lower-left), derived from the wavelet analysis. The right panels show the instantaneous period method derived (upper right) and period scatter (lower right) as a function of pulsation period. Background density contours and symbol conventions follow from Figure 4.
Discussion
Incidence rate
We now discuss the incidence rates of period-change classes among the low-amplitude variability Cepheid population and place them in the context of the broader Magellanic Cloud Cepheid sample studied by Paper II. The incidence rates of irregular period changes (class 3) for the first-overtone samples of this work, of Paper II and of the two combined are summarised in Table 2.
| Galaxy | Class 3 candidates | Incidence Rate (%) | |||||
| Cep | Cep | Paper II | This work | Paper II | Combined | ||
| LMC 1O | 188 | 7 | 405 | ||||
| SMC 1O | 142 | 2 | 659 | ||||
| Total | 330 | 9 | 1064 |
Table 2. Class 3 incidence rates for the first-overtone samples of this work, of Paper II, and of the two combined.
The class 1 candidates, exhibiting negligible period change with flat diagrams, constitute 83 stars in our working sample, corresponding to an overall incidence rate of 18.51.8%. The incidence rates within the Cep and Cep samples are 18.41.9% and 21.19.4%, respectively. The difference between the two subtypes is small and not statistically significant (within 0.3), the larger Cep uncertainty reflecting its small sample. Compared to Paper II, which reported a class 1 fraction of 56.30.7% across all pulsation modes and both galaxies, the considerably lower fraction in the present study is expected, as our sample consists exclusively of first-overtone Cepheids with additional low-amplitude variability. Restricting the Paper II comparison to its first-overtone sample yields a class 1 fraction of 17.11.0%, in excellent agreement with the overall incidence rate in this work, confirming a consistent class 1 incidence rate among first-overtone Cepheids regardless of the type of additional variability. Split by galaxy, the class 1 incidence rate in this work is 12.72.2% for the LMC and 25.03.0% for the SMC, a difference significant at the 3.4 level. This trend is opposite to that in the Paper II first-overtone results, where the LMC incidence rate (19.81.6%) exceeds that of the SMC (15.21.1%). Combining the class 1 candidates from both studies across the first-overtone population yields an updated incidence rate of 17.40.8% (350 candidates in total), consistent with the Paper II first-overtone value of 17.11.0% and confirming a stable class 1 incidence rate among first-overtone Cepheids in the Magellanic Clouds.
The class 2 candidates amount to 27 stars in our sample, yielding an overall incidence rate of 6.01.1$%, with sub-type incidence rates of 4.91.0$% for Cep and 31.610.7$% for Cep, the latter affected by low-number statistics, as before. Paper II reported a class 2 overall incidence of 10.20.5$% across all pulsation modes, higher than that found here. However, the more meaningful comparison is with the Paper II first-overtone sample, which yields 14.90.9$%, substantially higher than the 6.01.1$% found in the present work. Unlike the class 1 comparison, where the two first-overtone rates were in excellent agreement, the class 2 rate in our sample is notably suppressed. Split by galaxy, the LMC and SMC class 2 rates are 5.11.4$% and 7.11.8$%, respectively, a small difference, in contrast to the pronounced galaxy-wise asymmetry seen in class 1. Combining the class 2 candidates from both studies across the first-overtone population yields an updated incidence rate of 12.90.7$% (260 candidates in total), lower than the Paper II first-overtone rate of 14.90.9$%.
An important empirical constraint on the nature of the irregular period-change phenomenon is its incidence rate. In Paper II we reported a class 3 incidence rate of 33.50.7$% across both pulsation modes and both galaxies, based on a total of 1585 class 3 Cepheids. Restricted to its first-overtone sample, the appropriate reference for this work, the rate is considerably higher, 68.11.2$%, as fundamental-mode Cepheids are far less prone to irregular period changes. As highlighted earlier, however, those rates were likely underestimated due to the omis- @page 8/15 starts_mid=0 ends_mid=1
Figure 5 (PDF p. 8). Distribution of log dominant variability amplitude as a function of the dominant variability timescale (upper-left) and pulsation period (lower-left), derived from the wavelet analysis. The right panels show the instantaneous period method derived (upper right) and period scatter (lower right) as a function of pulsation period. Background density contours and symbol conventions follow from Figure 4.
Discussion
Incidence rate
We now discuss the incidence rates of period-change classes among the low-amplitude variability Cepheid population and place them in the context of the broader Magellanic Cloud Cepheid sample studied by Paper II. The incidence rates of irregular period changes (class 3) for the first-overtone samples of this work, of Paper II and of the two combined are summarised in Table 2.
The class 1 candidates, exhibiting negligible period change with flat diagrams, constitute 83 stars in our working sample, corresponding to an overall incidence rate of 18.51.8%. The incidence rates within the Cep and Cep samples are 18.41.9% and 21.19.4%, respectively. The difference between the two subtypes is small and not statistically significant (within 0.3), the larger Cep uncertainty reflecting its small sample. Compared to Paper II, which reported a class 1 fraction of 56.30.7% across all pulsation modes and both galaxies, the considerably lower fraction in the present study is expected, as our sample consists exclusively of first-overtone Cepheids with additional low-amplitude variability. Restricting the Paper II comparison to its first-overtone sample yields a class 1 fraction of 17.11.0%, in excellent agreement with the overall incidence rate in this work, confirming a consistent class 1 incidence rate among first-overtone Cepheids regardless of the type of additional variability. Split by galaxy, the class 1 incidence rate in this work is 12.72.2% for the LMC and 25.03.0% for the SMC, a difference significant at the 3.4 level. This trend is opposite to that in the Paper II first-overtone results, where the LMC incidence rate (19.81.6%) exceeds that of the SMC (15.21.1%). Combining the class 1 candidates from both studies across the first-overtone population yields an updated incidence rate of 17.40.8% (350 candidates in total), consistent with the Paper II first-overtone value of 17.11.0% and confirming a stable class 1 incidence rate among first-overtone Cepheids in the Magellanic Clouds.
The class 2 candidates amount to 27 stars in our sample, yielding an overall incidence rate of 6.01.1$%, with sub-type incidence rates of 4.91.0$% for Cep and 31.610.7$% for Cep, the latter affected by low-number statistics, as before. Paper II reported a class 2 overall incidence of 10.20.5$% across all pulsation modes, higher than that found here. However, the more meaningful comparison is with the Paper II first-overtone sample, which yields 14.90.9$%, substantially higher than the 6.01.1$% found in the present work. Unlike the class 1 comparison, where the two first-overtone rates were in excellent agreement, the class 2 rate in our sample is notably suppressed. Split by galaxy, the LMC and SMC class 2 rates are 5.11.4$% and 7.11.8$%, respectively, a small difference, in contrast to the pronounced galaxy-wise asymmetry seen in class 1. Combining the class 2 candidates from both studies across the first-overtone population yields an updated incidence rate of 12.90.7$% (260 candidates in total), lower than the Paper II first-overtone rate of 14.90.9$%.
An important empirical constraint on the nature of the irregular period-change phenomenon is its incidence rate. In Paper II we reported a class 3 incidence rate of 33.50.7$% across both pulsation modes and both galaxies, based on a total of 1585 class 3 Cepheids. Restricted to its first-overtone sample, the appropriate reference for this work, the rate is considerably higher, 68.11.2$%, as fundamental-mode Cepheids are far less prone to irregular period changes. As highlighted earlier, however, those rates were likely underestimated due to the omisNotes. All rows refer to first-overtone Cepheids only. Combining both pulsation modes and both galaxies, the overall Paper II incidence rate of rises to after adding the new Cep and Cep candidates from this work.
sion of Cepheids exhibiting additional low-amplitude variability. The present study recovers 339 new class 3 candidates (195 in the LMC and 144 in the SMC), increasing the total Magellanic class 3 sample to 1924 stars. Within our sample alone, the class 3 incidence rate is ; separately within the Cep and Cep subsamples, the rates are (330 of 430) and (9 of 19), respectively, the latter sub-sample subject to large uncertainty from low-number statistics. Compared with the Paper II first-overtone rate, our incidence is higher at the level, suggesting that first-overtone Cepheids with low-amplitude variability are moderately more prone to irregular period changes than the general first-overtone population. Split by galaxy, the class 3 incidence rates in this work are for the LMC and for the SMC, a difference significant at the level. This is opposite in sense to the Paper II first-overtone trend, where the SMC () exceeds the LMC (), mirroring the galaxy-wise reversal seen in the class 1 rates. Considering the whole sample of 1O Cepheids, both with and without additional periodicities, the combined incidence rate of class 3 candidates becomes and seems not to depend on environment, with the corresponding rates for the LMC and SMC being and , respectively.
If, on the other hand, we consider the incidence rates of Cepheids with additional periodicities (both Cep and Cep) among class 3 candidates, again combining results from the present analysis and Paper II, we find a significantly higher rate for the LMC, , compared to for the SMC. Notably, Smolec et al. [66] demonstrated that additional signals remain more frequent in the LMC, a real empirical effect that they attributed to more efficient mode excitation at higher metallicity. The conditions favouring the excitation of these modes may thus also raise the incidence of irregular period changes among their hosts.
Cycle-to-cycle variation
A pulsating star does not always behave like a perfect metronome. Each pulsation cycle may be slightly shorter or longer than the average, and these small, seemingly random deviations accumulate over time to produce apparent period changes in the diagram even when the underlying mean period is perfectly stable. This intrinsic stochasticity is referred to as cycle-to-cycle (C2C) variation and has long been suspected (Eddington & Plakidis [14]), but remained largely unquantified until modern space telescopes delivered the combination of photometric precision, temporal continuity, and high cadence needed to resolve it directly (see, e.g., Derekas et al. [12]; Plachy et al. [49]; Benkő et al. [8]; Plachy et al. [51]).
Recent studies (Benkő et al. [8, 7]; Benkő [6]) have placed C2C variation on a quantitative footing by applying the statistical framework of Koen [24] to Kepler and TESS diagrams of RR Lyrae stars (including Blazhko and non-Blazhko
stars). In this approach, the observed scatter is decomposed into three components: measurement noise (), a smooth secular drift (), and pure C2C jitter (). These combine into four models: M1 includes the measurement noise only (); M2 adds the C2C jitter (); M3 instead adds the secular drift (); and M4 includes all three components () (see Appendix § 11 for a detailed description). The models are ranked by their AIC/BIC probabilities to identify which best describes each star. We applied the same Koen [24] framework to the Hertzsprung-pinned diagrams of our Cep and Cep samples in the LMC and SMC, the first application of this framework to Cepheids with additional low-amplitude variability. Because each of our data points represents the mean epoch of –100 pulsation cycles, within-bin C2C fluctuations are absorbed into rather than , so the values we recover are conservative lower bounds on the true C2C jitter amplitude.
Across the full sample of 339 class 3 candidates analysed (Cep: 330 and Cep: 9), a total of 126 (37%) Cepheids are best described by models incorporating C2C variation (M2 or M4 models; see Appendix § 11). For the Cep sub-sample, 125 out of 330 stars (38%) show significant C2C jitter, with 52 of 188 in the LMC (28%) and 73 of 142 in the SMC (51%). The Cep sub-sample shows a mean value of d. For the Cep sub-sample, only a single detection is found among the nine stars in the combined LMC and SMC sample (OGLE-LMC-CEP-2432, d); the remaining eight stars prefer model M3, and the sample is too small to draw any statistical conclusions about C2C behaviour in this sub-type. The overall mean C2C amplitude across the full Cepheid sample is d, roughly seven times larger than the value measured for non-Blazhko RRc stars by Benkó et al. [7], indicating a substantially higher degree of intrinsic period instability in longer-period classical pulsators. As shown in Figure 6, this contrast is not a uniform offset but reflects a fundamentally different dependence of on pulsation period between the two stellar classes. For the 24 non-Blazhko RRc stars reported by Benkó et al. [7], a linear fit in log–log space yields
Figure 6. Comparison of cycle-to-cycle (C2C) period variation strength for non-Blazhko RRC stars (Benkő et al. [7]) with OGLE first-overtone Cepheids (class 3 with preferred M2 or M4 model) from this study.
whereas the same fit for our combined Cep and Cep sample of 126 M2/M4 Cepheids gives
where is in units of d and is the pulsation period in days. Both relations are statistically significant, with the Cepheid fit yielding a tighter correlation () over a broader pulsation-period baseline than the RRc sample (). Their slopes also differ substantially: the RRc relation is nearly three times steeper (slope 4.90) than our Cepheid fit (slope 1.64), showing that rises far more rapidly with period in RR Lyrae stars than in classical Cepheids. The substantially higher amplitudes found for the Cepheids are qualitatively consistent with the expectation that more luminous pulsators with deeper convective envelopes produce stronger stochastic jitter, while the shallower period dependence suggests that stellar structure, rather than pulsation timescale alone, governs the magnitude of the C2C variation. We also note a contrast in the preferred models as in non-Blazhko RR Lyrae sample of Benkó et al. [7], the C2C model M2 is optimal for majority of stars, whereas most of our class 3 Cepheids prefer the M3 model. At least part of this difference likely reflects the different time baselines and the samplings of the two photometry datasets, to which the jitter and the drift terms may not be equally sensitive.
Finally, across our class 3 sample no star prefers model M1 (the noise-only model), which further confirms that the variations in our sample cannot be attributed to measurement noise alone and are therefore physical in origin.
Amplitude dependence of the irregular period changes
In Paper II, working on a large sample of Magellanic Cepheids, we previously established two important empirical properties of the irregular period changes. The first is that the irregularity grows with pulsation period, a trend also seen in Galactic Cepheids (Csörnyei et al. 2022). This is further confirmed by our smaller class 3 sample in this work, where all characterisation measures show significant positive correlations with pulsation period (see Sect. 3.3). The second empirical property is that at a given pulsation period the phenomenon is systematically stronger in first-overtone Cepheids than in fundamental-mode Cepheids. The physical origin of these two dependences remains unclear. One suspect for the stochastic perturbations is the convective envelope, which can disturb the pulsation directly or distort the observed light curve through hot spots (see, e.g., [37]). A useful framework was developed by Avelino et al. [4] and Cunha et al. [11], who modelled pulsating stars as coherently driven oscillators subject to random perturbations. In their model, each perturbation shifts the pulsation phase by an amount inversely proportional to the oscillation amplitude, and the accumulated phase wander in the diagram grows as a random walk with an rms proportional to the ratio of the perturbation strength to the oscillation amplitude. Our sample is well suited to test this prediction, since Smolec et al. [66] provide, for every star, not only the amplitude of the dominant first-overtone mode, , but also the amplitude of the additional low-amplitude periodicity, .
In Figure 7 we show the comparison of the parameter and the C2C jitter (available only for the 126 M2/M4 candidates) with the amplitude of the first-overtone mode () and the amplitude of the additional periodicity (), for the overall class 3 sample presented in this work. All four panels show significant anticorrelations, with Spearman rank coefficients of and for against and , respectively, and for . However, both the amplitudes and the irregularity measures depend on the pulsation period, so these correlations may simply be inherited from their common period trends. To separate the two effects, we compute a period-controlled coefficient, , obtained by removing the period trend from both quantities and correlating the residuals. A significant indicates a genuine amplitude dependence at fixed pulsation period. The anticorrelations with the pulsation amplitude persist at fixed period ( for and for , both ), with an observed scaling , and the remaining characterisation measures behave similarly ( to ). In contrast, the correlations with the additional-signal amplitude vanish ( for and for , both not significant), and the relative strength shows no robust independent correlation with any of the measures (see Figure 7 right panels).
Figure 7. Strength of the irregular period changes as a function of the pulsation amplitude (left) and the additional-signal amplitude (middle), and their ratio (right), for the parameter of the class 3 sample (top) and the C2C jitter (bottom). Dashed lines show linear fits in the log–log plane.
The strength of the irregularity therefore tracks the amplitude of the dominant pulsation mode, and not that of the additional periodicity. This is exactly what the results outlined above predict. The measured scaling, , matches the inverse-amplitude phase wander expected for a coherently driven pulsator perturbed by random kicks of fixed strength ([4, 11]), and extends this picture to classical Cepheids. In this interpretation, the pulsation amplitude measures the robustness of the limit cycle. High-amplitude pulsators resist the stochastic perturbations, while low-amplitude ones accumulate phase wander more rapidly. The same reasoning explains the second empirical property noted above, because fundamental-mode Cepheids pulsate with systematically larger amplitudes than the overtones. A lower stability of first-overtone pulsation was also noted by Süveges & Anderson [78]. The absence of an independent correlation argues against the additional periodicity being a driver of the irregularity, in line with the lack of relations between the primary and secondary-mode amplitudes reported by Süveges & Anderson [77]. We instead interpret its presence as a marker of the underlying pulsation state. Dziembowski [13] regards the coexistence of the non-radial modes with the radial overtone as a form of double-mode pulsation, arising in circumstances similar to those of radial double-mode pulsators. In such a state, the dominant mode does not fully saturate the driving. A weakly saturated first-overtone limit cycle would then do two things at once: admit the additional modes, and respond more strongly to the stochastic perturbations. This explains why the presence of the additional periodicity accompanies an elevated incidence of irregular period changes (75.52.0% in our current sample versus 68.11.2% for the general first-overtone population; Sect. 4.1), while its strength leaves no imprint. The frequently non-stationary behaviour of both the additional signals and the radial overtone in these stars ([66]) fits the same picture.
Conclusions
In this study we analysed a sample of 544 Cepheids manifesting low-amplitude variability (516 Cep and 28 Cep) for their associated period-change behaviour. All of these are first-overtone stars in both the LMC and SMC. This sample is complementary to that of Paper II, where we analysed a large sample of single-mode Magellanic Cepheids and deliberately excluded stars with additional low-amplitude variability. The present work targets precisely those excluded Cepheids. After sample cuts, overall in the working sample, we find that 449 Cepheids belong to three different period-change classes. Our main findings are summarised as follows:
We identify 83 class 1 Cepheids with flat diagrams indicative of negligible period change, yielding an incidence rate of . This is in excellent agreement with the Paper II first-overtone rate of .
A total of 27 class 2 Cepheids exhibit parabolic shapes, with an incidence rate of . Combining these with the previous Paper II detections, the updated combined first-overtone class 2 incidence rate is . Several of these may be candidates for secular period change, their upward-parabolic diagrams tentatively marking first-crossing candidates.
The majority of our sample, 339 Cepheids, are class 3 candidates, simultaneously exhibiting low-amplitude variability and irregular period changes, at an incidence rate of . These candidates increase the total Magellanic class 3 sample to 1924 stars, and the updated combined first-overtone class 3 incidence rate is .
Various characterisation tests on the class 3 candidates all indicate a coherent picture of increasing irregular period-change fluctuations with pulsation period, a trend in excellent agreement with the behaviour of the Paper II first-overtone sample and consistently elevated above the Paper II fundamental-mode Cepheids. This indicates that period instability is an intrinsic property that intensifies towards longer periods, irrespective of the presence of Cep- or Cep-type low-amplitude variability.
We detect significant C2C period variation in 37% (126 Cepheids) of our class 3 sample, with a mean jitter amplitude d, times larger than that measured in non-Blazhko RRc stars [7]. We also find that scales empirically with pulsation period, with a shallower slope than in RRc stars.
At fixed pulsation period, the strength of the irregular period changes anticorrelates with the pulsation amplitude across all our characterisation measures, most strongly for the C2C jitter, which scales as . The amplitude of the additional periodicity shows no independent correlation. This behaviour matches the inverse-amplitude response expected for a coherently driven pulsator perturbed by stochastic kicks [4, 11], and suggests that the additional periodicity marks a weakly saturated pulsation state rather than driving the irregularity.
The empirical picture of irregular period changes in classical Cepheids is now substantially richer following our previous work in Paper II and this study. For class 3 candidates we have provided comprehensive incidence rates, their pulsation-period distribution, and a multi-method characterisation of the irregular period-change amplitude, probing both a large sample of purely radial-mode Cepheids (F-mode and 1O-mode) and the niche sub-sample of 1O Cepheids hosting low-amplitude signals associated with non-radial modes (Cep) or additional variability (Cep). The physical origin of these irregular period changes, however, remains unresolved. With a statistically significant sample, we have established a positive correlation between irregular period-change strength and pulsation period, a strong empirical constraint that Cepheid pulsation models should reproduce.
We plan to extend our investigation to longer-period regimes by analysing irregular period changes in Type-II Cepheids using OGLE Magellanic photometry. Such targets have long been known to undergo abrupt and erratic period changes (see, e.g., Parenago [43]; Percy et al. [44]; Smolec et al. [64]), and their inclusion will provide a more complete view of the phenomenon across the instability strip. Finally, the high-cadence, continuous photometry from TESS (Ricker et al. [57]) and the forthcoming PLATO mission (Rauer et al. [56]) offer promising prospects for resolving C2C period jitter directly in individual pulsation cycles, extending this analysis to a broader census of Cepheids.
Data availability
The full versions of Tables A.1, B.1, and C.1 are available in electronic form at the CDS via http://cdsweb.u-strasbg.fr/cgi-bin/qcat?J/A+A/, and at Zenodo: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22644776.
Acknowledgements. We thank all the OGLE observers for their contribution to the collection of the photometric data over the decades. RSR, RS, and OZ acknowledge support from the National Science Centre, Poland, OPUS project 2024/53/B/ST9/02630. RSR, VH, and NN acknowledge the support of the French Agence Nationale de la Recherche (ANR) under grant ANR-23-CE31-0009-01 (Unlock-pfactor). IS acknowledges support from the National Science Centre, Poland, grant no. 2022/45/B/ST9/00243. The OGLE project has received funding from the Polish National Science Centre grant OPUS-28 2024/55/B/ST9/00447 awarded to AU. This research made use of the SIMBAD and VIZIER databases at CDS, Strasbourg (France) and the electronic bibliography maintained by the NASA/ADS system.
Class 1 candidates
Table A.1 lists the class 1 candidates along with their pulsation periods. Representative diagrams are shown in Fig A.1.
Table A.1. Class 1 Cepheid candidates.
| OGLE ID | Pulsation period (d) |
| LMC Cep sample | |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0071 | 1.38588763 |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0221 | 2.21645283 |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0265 | 2.25444192 |
| SMC Cep sample | |
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-0348 | 2.06688185 |
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-0447 | 1.26514836 |
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-0466 | 1.13176248 |
| LMC Cep sample | |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0184 | 1.79356023 |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0193 | 1.69166756 |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-2137 | 4.21029710 |
| SMC Cep sample | |
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-3158 | 1.52899648 |
Table A.1.
Notes. The two columns list the star’s ID and its pulsation period in days. Only first few entries are shown and the full table is available at Zenodo (see Sect. 6)
Class 2 candidates
Table B.1 lists the class 2 candidates along with their pulsation periods and estimated period change rates. Representative diagrams are shown in Fig B.1.
Table B.1. Class 2 Cepheid candidates.
| OGLE ID | Pulsation period (d) | (d/Myr) | err (d/Myr) |
| LMC Cep sample | |||
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0133 | 1.384010 | 19.675 | 0.196 |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0368 | 2.319331 | -43.108 | 0.192 |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0421 | 2.215381 | 7.721 | 0.212 |
| SMC Cep sample | |||
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-2455 | 2.524637 | -6.465 | 0.675 |
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-2550 | 1.966623 | -1.120 | 0.085 |
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-2668 | 1.940816 | 1.816 | 0.082 |
| LMC Cep sample | |||
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0113 | 1.838345 | 2.549 | 0.153 |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-1801 | 1.178179 | -0.963 | 0.064 |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-2789 | 2.537726 | 4.792 | 0.228 |
| SMC Cep sample | |||
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-1634 | 1.288080 | -2.580 | 0.057 |
Table B.1.
Notes. The four columns give star’s ID, pulsation period, period change rate and its error. Only first few entries are shown and the full table is available at Zenodo (see Sect. 6)
Class 3 candidates
Table C.1 lists the class 3 candidates together with their corresponding characterisation parameters. Representative diagrams are shown in Figure 2.
Koen model distribution
To characterise the C2C period variability of the class 3 candidates, we apply the statistical framework of Koen [24], as implemented for RR Lyrae stars by Benkő et al. [7]. Following Koen [24], the instantaneous period of the -th pulsation cycle is modelled as
where is the constant mean period, is a zero-mean, uncorrelated cycle-to-cycle (C2C) perturbation of the cycle length, and the cumulative term , with , represents a smooth, persistent variation of the mean period. The measured epochs additionally carry an independent timing error . Propagating these contributions into the observed-minus-calculated residual after cycles gives
so that the timing noise enters per point, the C2C jitter accumulates as a random walk, and the period drift accumulates as an integrated random walk. The model therefore depends on three parameters, , , and . Since the timing noise is unavoidable (), four nested models are obtained by switching the C2C and drift terms on or off:
M1 : ,
M2 : ,
M3 : ,
M4 : ,
corresponding to pure timing noise (M1), timing noise plus C2C jitter (M2), timing noise plus a smooth period drift (M3), and all three components (M4). Following Benkő et al. [7], each series is first linearly transformed so that its first and last points are zero. The parameters of each model are then estimated by maximising the Gaussian likelihood computed from the full covariance matrices of the three components, evaluated at the cumulative cycle numbers of the points (see Appendix § 8 of Koen [24]). The preferred model for each star is selected by minimising the AIC value.
Figure D.1 summarises the best-model distribution across the four subsamples. M1 is never preferred for any star. Pure timing noise therefore cannot reproduce the observed scatter, and a genuine signal in the form of C2C jitter, a period drift, or both is always required. This is expected, since these are robustly classified class 3 candidates whose irregularity clearly exceeds the measurement noise. Model M3, consisting of timing noise plus a smooth period drift with no C2C term, is the most common, preferred by 72% of LMC Cep, 49% of SMC Cep, 86% of LMC Cep, and all SMC Cep stars. For the majority of stars, therefore, the variations are well described by measurement noise together with a smooth period drift, without invoking a dedicated C2C jitter term (). Only 37% of stars assigned to M2 or M4 require .
Figure A.1. Representative diagrams of Cep (top panel) and Cep (bottom panel) candidates belonging to class 1. The OGLE identifier and pulsation period are shown at the top of each panel.
Figure B.1. Representative diagrams of Cep (top panel) and Cep (bottom panel) candidates belonging to class 2. The OGLE identifier and pulsation period are shown at the top of each panel.
Figure D.1. Distribution of the preferred Koen models (M1–M4) across the four Cepheid subsamples.
| OGLE ID | Pulsation period (d) | Dominant Periodicity | Dominant Amplitude | index | ( d) | ( d) | Best Model | |||
| LMC Cep sample | ||||||||||
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0031 | 4.33983633 | −2.56 | 4318.9 | 0.4943 | 0.398 | −3.44 | −3.52 | 259.819 | − | M2 |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0077 | 2.96606336 | −3.00 | 4323.3 | 0.1844 | 0.390 | −3.90 | −3.99 | − | 0.820 | M3 |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0080 | 3.42006805 | −2.35 | 2143.6 | 1.1041 | 1.420 | −3.44 | −3.58 | − | 2.982 | M3 |
| SMC Cep sample | ||||||||||
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-0088 | 1.53847476 | −3.11 | 2873.4 | 0.0731 | 0.671 | −3.93 | −4.37 | − | 0.288 | M3 |
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-0212 | 1.74103505 | −3.08 | 3430.4 | 0.1389 | 0.609 | −3.93 | −4.26 | − | 0.318 | M3 |
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-0251 | 1.79680357 | −3.34 | 3186.9 | 0.0139 | 0.203 | −3.75 | −4.22 | 68.950 | − | M2 |
| LMC Cep sample | ||||||||||
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0676 | 2.54452114 | −2.64 | 4354.2 | 0.5027 | 1.827 | −3.79 | −4.08 | − | 0.752 | M3 |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0817 | 1.87363459 | −2.91 | 3645.2 | 0.9685 | 1.082 | −3.97 | −4.32 | − | 0.709 | M3 |
| OGLE-LMC-CEP-0925 | 2.04551965 | −2.93 | 2750.9 | 0.0619 | 0.949 | −4.11 | −4.29 | − | 0.201 | M3 |
| SMC Cep sample | ||||||||||
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-0151 | 1.5329022 | −2.99 | 10362.2 | 0.0038 | 1.010 | −4.11 | −4.41 | − | 0.152 | M3 |
| OGLE-SMC-CEP-1598 | 2.9940860 | −2.92 | 3346.3 | 0.0599 | 0.516 | −3.78 | −3.91 | − | 0.545 | M3 |
Table C.1. Sample of class 3 Cepheid candidates.
Notes. The columns give star’s ID, pulsation period, Eddington-Plakidis fluctuation parameter (); dominant variability period and amplitude from the wavelet analysis; Stetson index; and from the instantaneous period method; C2C jitter amplitude and drift term from the Koen C2C analysis and the corresponding best-fitting model. Only first few entries are shown and the full table is available at Zenodo ( see Sect. 6)
References
- [1]Akaike, H. 1974, IEEE Trans. Autom. Control, 19, 716
- [2]Anderson, R. I., Ekström, S., Georgy, C., et al. 2014, A&A, 564, A100
- [3]Anderson, R. I., Saio, H., Ekström, S., Georgy, C., & Meynet, G. 2016, A&A, 591, A8
- [4]Avelino, P. P., Cunha, M. S., & Chaplin, W. J. 2020, MNRAS, 492, 4477
- [5]Beaulieu, J.-P., Buchler, J. R., Marquette, J.-B., Hartman, J. D., & Schwarzenberg-Czerny, A. 2006, ApJ, 653, L101
- [6]Benkő, J. M. 2026, A&A, 705, L8
- [7]Benkő, J. M., Bódi, A., Plachy, E., & Molnár, L. 2025, A&A, 697, A154
- [8]Benkő, J. M., Jurcsik, J., & Derekas, A. 2019, MNRAS, 485, 5897
- [9]Berdnikov, L. N. & Ignatova, V. V. 2000, in ASP Conf. Ser. Vol. 203, IAU Colloquium 176: The Impact of Large-Scale Surveys on Pulsating Star Research, ed. L. Szabados & D. Kurtz, 244–245
- [10]Berdnikov, L. N., Ignatova, V. V., Caldwell, J. A. R., & Koen, C. 2000, New A, 4, 625
- [11]Cunha, M. S., Avelino, P. P., & Chaplin, W. J. 2020, MNRAS, 499, 4687
- [12]Derekas, A., Szabó, G. M., Berdnikov, L., et al. 2012, MNRAS, 425, 1312
- [13]Dziembowski, W. A. 2016, Commun. Konkoly Obs., 105, 23
- [14]Eddington, A. S. & Plakidis, S. 1929, MNRAS, 90, 65
- [15]Espinoza-Arancibia, F., Catelan, M., Hajdu, G., et al. 2022, MNRAS
- [16]Farge, M. 1992, Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech., 24, 395
- [17]Freedman, W. L., Madore, B. F., Gibson, B. K., et al. 2001, ApJ, 553, 47
- [18]Hajdu, G., Catelan, M., Jurcsik, J., et al. 2015, MNRAS, 449, L113
- [19]Hajdu, G., Pietrzyński, G., Jurcsik, J., et al. 2021, ApJ, 915, 50
- [20]Hertzsprung, E. 1919, Astron. Nachr., 210, 17
- [21]Irwin, J. B. 1952, ApJ, 116, 211
- [22]Irwin, J. B. 1959, AJ, 64, 149
- [23]Jurcsik, J., Smitola, P., Hajdu, G., et al. 2015, ApJS, 219, 25
- [24]Koen, C. 2006, MNRAS, 365, 489
- [25]Kolláth, Z., Buchler, J. R., Szabó, R., & Csubry, Z. 2002, A&A, 385, 932
- [26]Koopmann, R. A., Lee, Y.-W., Demarque, P., & Howard, J. M. 1994, ApJ, 423, 380
- [27]Laskarides, P. G. 1974, Ap&SS, 27, 485
- [28]Leavitt, H. S. 1908, Ann. Harvard Coll. Obs., 60, 87
- [29]Leavitt, H. S. & Pickering, E. C. 1912, Harvard Coll. Obs. Circ., 173, 1
- [30]Miller, C. L., Neilson, H. R., Evans, N. R., Engle, S. G., & Guinan, E. 2020, ApJ, 896, 128
- [31]Morlet, J., Arens, G., Forgeau, I., & Giard, D. 1982, Geophysics, 47, 203
- [32]Moskalik, P. & Dziembowski, W. A. 2005, A&A, 434, 1077
- [33]Moskalik, P. & Kołaczkowski, Z. 2008, Commun. Asteroseismol., 157, 343
- [34]Moskalik, P. & Kołaczkowski, Z. 2009, MNRAS, 394, 1649
- [35]Moskalik, P., Smolec, R., Kolenberg, K., et al. 2015, MNRAS, 447, 2348
- [37]Neilson, H. R. & Ignace, R. 2014, A&A, 563, L4
- [38]Neilson, H. R., Langer, N., Engle, S. G., Guinan, E., & Izzard, R. 2012, ApJ, 760, L18
- [39]Netzel, H. & Smolec, R. 2019, MNRAS, 487, 5584
- [40]Netzel, H., Smolec, R., & Dziembowski, W. 2015a, MNRAS, 451, L25
- [41]Netzel, H., Smolec, R., & Moskalik, P. 2015b, MNRAS, 447, 1173
- [42]Olech, A. & Moskalik, P. 2009, A&A, 494, L17
- [43]Parenago, P. P. 1956, Peremennye Zvezdy, 11, 236
- [44]Percy, J. R., Bezulhy, M., Milanowski, M., & Zsoldos, E. 1997, PASP, 109, 264
- [45]Petersen, J. 1973, A&A, 27, 89
- [46]Pietrukowicz, P. 2001, Acta Astron., 51, 247
- [47]Pietrukowicz, P. 2002, Acta Astron., 52, 177
- [48]Pietrukowicz, P., Dziembowski, W. A., Mróz, P., et al. 2013, Acta Astron., 63, 379
- [49]Plachy, E., Molnár, L., Jurkovic, M. I., et al. 2017, MNRAS, 465, 173
- [50]Plachy, E., Netzel, H., & Bódi, A. 2025, A&A, 703, A155
- [51]Plachy, E., Pál, A., Bódi, A., et al. 2021, ApJS, 253, 11
- [52]Poleski, R. 2008, Acta Astron., 58, 313
- [53]Rathour, R. S., Hajdu, G., Smolec, R., et al. 2024, A&A, 686, A268
- [54]Rathour, R. S., Smolec, R., Hajdu, G., et al. 2025, A&A, 695, A114
- [55]Rathour, R. S., Smolec, R., & Netzel, H. 2021, MNRAS, 505, 5412
- [56]Rauer, H., Aerts, C., Cabrera, J., et al. 2025, Exp. Astron., 59, 26
- [57]Ricker, G. R., Winn, J. N., Vanderspek, R., et al. 2015, J. Astron. Telesc. Instrum. Syst., 1, 014003
- [58]Riess, A. G., Casertano, S., Yuan, W., et al. 2021, ApJ, 908, L6
- [59]Rodriguez-Segovia, N., Hajdu, G., Catelan, M., et al. 2022, MNRAS, 509, 2885
- [60]Schwarz, G. 1978, Ann. Stat., 6, 461
- [61]Smolec, R. 2017, MNRAS, 468, 4299
- [62]Smolec, R. & Moskalik, P. 2008, Acta Astron., 58, 233
- [63]Smolec, R., Moskalik, P., Kałużny, J., et al. 2017, MNRAS, 467, 2349
- [64]Smolec, R., Moskalik, P., Plachy, E., Soszyński, I., & Udalski, A. 2018, MNRAS, 481, 3724
- [65]Smolec, R. & Śniegowska, M. 2016, MNRAS, 458, 3561
- [66]Smolec, R., Ziółkowska, O., Ochalik, M., & Śniegowska, M. 2023, MNRAS, 519, 4010
- [67]Soszyński, I., Poleski, R., Udalski, A., et al. 2008, Acta Astron., 58, 163
- [68]Soszyński, I., Poleski, R., Udalski, A., et al. 2010, Acta Astron., 60, 17
- [69]Soszyński, I., Udalski, A., Szymański, M. K., et al. 2019, Acta Astron., 69, 87
- [71]Soszyński, I., Udalski, A., Szymański, M. K., et al. 2015b, Acta Astron., 65, 297
- [72]Soszyński, I., Udalski, A., Szymański, M. K., et al. 2017a, Acta Astron., 67, 103
- [73]Soszyński, I., Udalski, A., Szymański, M. K., et al. 2017b, Acta Astron., 67, 297
- [74]Sterken, C. 2005, in ASP Conf. Ser., Vol. 335, The Light-Time Effect in Astrophysics: Causes and Cures of the O-C diagram, ed. C. Sterken, 3
- [75]Stetson, P. B. 1996, PASP, 108, 851
- [76]Stothers, R. 1980, PASP, 92, 475
- [77]Süveges, M. & Anderson, R. I. 2018a, MNRAS, 478, 1425
- [78]Süveges, M. & Anderson, R. I. 2018b, A&A, 610, A86
- [79]Sweigart, A. V. & Renzini, A. 1979, A&A, 71, 66
- [80]Szabados, L. 1992, in ASP Conf. Ser., Vol. 32, IAU Colloq. 135: Complementary Approaches to Double and Multiple Star Research, ed. H. A. McAlister & W. I. Hartkopf, 255
- [81]Torrence, C. & Compo, G. P. 1998, Bull. Am. Meteorol. Soc., 79, 61
- [82]Turner, N. G., Abdel-Sabour Abdel-Latif, M., & Berdnikov, L. N. 2006, PASP, 118, 410
- [83]Udalski, A., Kubiak, M., & Szymanski, M. 1997, Acta Astron., 47, 319
- [84]Udalski, A., Soszyński, I., Szymanski, M., et al. 1999a, Acta Astron., 49, 223
- [86]Udalski, A., Soszyński, I., M. K., Soszyński, I., & Poleski, R. 2008, Acta Astron., 58, 69
- [87]Udalski, A., Szymański, M. K., & Szymański, G. 2015, Acta Astron., 65, 1
- [88]Zhou, A. 1999, Publ. Beijing Astron. Obs., 33, 17









