WorksPhysics and Astronomy
On stimulated scattering including harmonic generation in an unmagnetized pair plasma for arbitrary pump strengths
Abstract
A fully nonlinear analysis for the growth rate of the stimulated backscatter instability of an intense electromagnetic (EM) wave with arbitrary polarization in an unmagnetized pair plasma is presented. The connection of this instability to the FEL process is discussed and utilized. An intense EM wave causes an initially stationary pair plasma to drift forward with a speed near the speed of light. The resulting distribution function for both cold and warm pair plasmas is presented. It is shown that the frequency of the reflected light is thus Doppler downshifted from that of the incident wave. For a linearly polarized EM wave there is also an additional contribution to the forward drift at its second harmonic which leads to backscattered light at all odd harmonics of the Doppler downshifted frequency for sufficiently cold pair plasmas. Fully nonlinear particle-in-cell simulations confirm the theoretical growth rates and show how the instability depends on the pair plasma temperature. The effect of the intensity profile of the incoming EM wave as well as implications for astrophysical pair plasmas is discussed.
Introduction
There is much recent interest in the physics of laser plasma interactions (LPI) in pair plasmas due to how it might effect the propagation of fast radio bursts (FRB) in the magnetosphere of magnetars and thus alter terrestrial observations [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]. Recently, it has been suggested that intense EM waves can be reflected in a pair plasma [8, 9] from a process that is related to the well known stimulated Brillouin scattering (SBS) instability in electron-ion plasmas [10]. Based on the results from this article, it can also be argued that it is also the limit of SRS in a pair plasma. We thus refer to it as simply induced backscatter rather than SBS or SRS. Several authors have provided theoretical predictions for the growth rates of backscatter in a pair plasma for small amplitude pump strengths, where , , , and are the vector potential of the pump, electron charge, electron mass, and speed of light respectively. The quantity, , is referred to as the normalized vector potential where and are the radiation intensity and wavelength respectively. Very recently, several groups have presented theoretical results for backscatter from arbitrary pump strengths. Supporting particle-in-cell simulations were also described in some cases[8, 11].
It has also been recently recognized that the growth rate of induced backscatter in a pair plasma is scales as the Pierce parameter [6] that arises in the free electron laser instability (FEL)[12]. The precise reason for this was not discussed. The physical reason for this connection was alluded to in Ref. [13] where it was shown that the gain of stimulated Raman scattering (SRS) in the strongly coupled regime for a short laser pulse and the FEL instability for XFEL facilities are identical when viewed from their respective Lorentz frames .
In SRS, a laser (EM pump) is scattered into a backscattered EM wave and a forward propagating electron plasma wave (EPW). In the FEL instability, a relativistic electron beam propagates through an undulator, which is typically a static magnetic field structure oriented perpendicular to the propagation direction of the electron beam, and with a well-defined wavenumber in the propagation direction. If one views the FEL process in the frame of the electron beam, the undulator transforms to a quasi-EM wave that propagates towards the stationary beam electrons. In the strongly coupled regime of SRS (or SBS) the ponderomotive force of the laser dominates the bunching of the plasma and thus space charge forces are negligible.
With this insight, it can be seen that the differences between backscatter in a pair plasma, SRS of a short-pulse laser in a strongly coupled regime, and the XFEL instability lie in what Lorentz frame one views the process and in the regime of the instability. Specifically, in Ref. [13] it was shown that the exponentiation of SRS of a short pulse laser in the strongly coupled limit is identical to the Pierce parameter times the appropriate length of the undulator.
In this paper, we use this insight to develop the theory of “laser” plasma interactions in pair plasmas for arbitrary using the formalism from previous work in the free electron laser (FEL) literature [14] and previous work on SRS in an electron-ion plasma[15]. Specifically, in Ref. [14] SRS backscatter of a linearly polarized (LP) laser from a stationary plasma or counterpropagating relativistic electron beam was analyzed. They studied the strongly coupled regimes of the instability where the space charge forces in the EPW or the modulated electron beam are negligible compared to the ponderomotive force from the forward and backward scattered EM waves. However, for a pair plasma the ponderomotive force is identical on electrons and positrons so there are no space charge forces when the pair plasma is modulated. Thus, the physics of backscatter in a pair plasma in the presence of electromagnetic radiation is identical to the strongly coupled limit for electron beams propagating toward an EM wave (undulator) when viewed in the beam frame, with the only difference being a factor of in the plasma frequency [13, 14].
In this article, we connect the formalism of Esarey and Sprangle for backscatter of an electron beam drifting backwards to backscatter in a frame of an initially stationary pair plasma. The stationary pair plasma drifts forward in response to the radiation pressure of the incoming EM wave. The results are confirmed in particle-in-cell simulations using OSIRIS. We also extend the treatment of Ref. [14] to include circularly polarized (CP) and elliptically polarized (EP) electromagnetic waves. The possible implications for the results to a pair plasma surrounding a magnetar will also be discussed.
Derivation of the growth rate
As discussed above, to analyze the growth rate of stimulated backscatter of an intense EM wave impinging on an unmagnetized plasma, we utilize the formalism of the work of Esarey and Sprangle [14] who considered backscatter of an arbitrarily large LP EM wave with either a stationary plasma (with immobile ions) or a drifting electron beam with . Here, we are interested in backscatter from a pair plasma that is initially stationary. We note that their results can be extended to an initially stationary e-beam by setting , but in order to extend the analysis to general polarizations, we start by assuming the pair plasma is at rest and provide details of the derivation in this article.
Their formalism requires assuming that the forward and backward propagating EM waves move at the speed of light and finding an appropriate nonlinear equilibrium to perturb about. When an EM wave impinges on a pair plasma with an arbitrary initial drift, the motion of the electrons and positrons are known analytically for plane waves (one-dimensional limit) moving at the speed of light (valid for a sufficiently low density plasma). General expressions for an equilibrium for EM waves with phase velocities that depend on the plasma density can also be obtained but this is challenging for linearly polarized EM waves. We consider this for a circularly polarized EM wave in the Appendix.
When the pair plasma is initially at rest, in the presence of the EM wave, both the electrons and positrons move forward, as well as oscillate transversely. For a circularly polarized wave the pair plasma moves forward with a constant drift, while for a linearly polarized wave it moves forward with an average drift, as well as with an oscillation at twice the frequency of the laser with respect to the variable . As we show below, this leads to reflected light at a Doppler downshifted frequency due the forward drift as well as at odd harmonics of the Doppler downshifted frequency for linearly polarized light due to the additional axial motion at the second harmonic.
To determine if the forward going pump and reflected light feed back on each other to drive an instability, we use the equilibrium of an incident EM wave and the associated self-consistent motion of a pair plasma that started at rest as the nonlinear equilibrium. A discussion for how to include finite temperature effects is given at the end of this section and finite temperature effects are studied with the PIC simulations.
The fully relativistic two-fluid and maxwell equations for the pair plasma in the presence of a linearly or circularly polarized pump wave propagating in the direction are given as follows:
where refers to directions orthogonal to the propagation direction of the EM waves, denotes either an electron or positron fluid variable with , and , while , , , and denote the proper densities, proper velocities, and vector potential respectively. Electrostatic effects have been neglected since as discussed above there is no mechanism for the radiation pressure to generate charge separation in an unmagnetized pair plasma . Note that this is not true in the magnetized case [16, 17].
Several important relationships can be obtained by taking the linear combination of these equations. We define , which is the total time derivative following a particle, and then pull the right hand side of Eqn. (2) to the left side and take the sum and difference of Eqns. (3) and (4) to obtain,
Equation (6) gives the conservation of transverse canonical momentum which is rigorously true for the one-dimensional scenario under consideration. On the other hand, eqns. (7) and (8) show that or are other useful quantities, as they are also conserved when the fields are only functions of , in which case is conserved, or of , in which case is conserved. From the conservation of transverse canonical momentum it is clearly seen that for the electrons and positrons are out of phase and are both proportional to . Thus, and are equal for electrons and positrons. Consider an incident EM wave moving in the direction which is either linearly polarized (LP), or circularly polarized (CP) where and - (+) corresponds to right (left) handed CP polarized respectively. Let the electron or positron start at rest in front of the incoming EM wave (it is straightforward to modify these expressions for particles that are not at rest in front of the EM wave such as for a moving electron beam). For these initial conditions, the conserved quantities can be combined to give
for a LP EM wave and
for a CP EM wave. If the laser power is kept fixed then is smaller for the CP case such that the average is the same for both LP and CP. We take this difference in amplitude for fixed power into account when comparing growth rates below.
For either a LP or CP EM wave and are the same for electrons and positrons and both quantities oscillate at the second harmonic for a LP wave. Thus, an initially stationary pair plasma will oscillate transversely and drift forward when an EM wave is incident upon it and for a LP wave the forward drift () will also include oscillations at even harmonics. The consequence of the conserved quantities will also be shown to be useful for defining a nonlinear equilibrium to perturb about.
Recognizing that because electrons and positrons move together along , it can be seen that there is no charge separation, and thus single fluid quantities for the density and can be utilized. Henceforth, we use the normalized quantities, , , , and where which is the initial unperturbed density for the electrons and for the positrons. In what follows, we also utilize the relationships , , and , to reduce Eqns. (1)–(5) to:
where is the plasma frequency and is the unperturbed proper density of the electrons or positrons. We now define the variables and use the relationships and to transform Eqns. (18)–(21) to:
where is a smallness parameter that is . Following [14], we define and rewrite Eqns. (22)–(24) in terms of these new fluid variables,
From here on, we implicitly assume that so that all EM waves relevant to the problem travel at the speed of light. We follow the notation in [14] where perturbation theory for the above equations proceeds by expanding each fluid variable as and . The zeroth order stationary solutions, are obtained by setting to obtain,
from which it is easily found that for a pair plasma starting at rest, (the proper density is an invariant), and . This gives and . Furthermore, can be eliminated from eqns. (26) and (27) by making use of the relations and . Note that these zeroth order solutions are the same as obtained earlier from single particle dynamics. Utilizing these relationships the following three coupled equations are obtained
The perturbed solutions are assumed to be of the form . Perturbing the above equations around the equilibrium solutions gives:
The solutions to these equations are given by:
where and . We assume that the pump is elliptically polarized as and the backscattered light wave amplitude has a similar form where . The fact that the backscattered wave has a different sense of rotation in space (but not time) follows from the analysis that follows. Using these definitions leads to:
where . Using these relationships in Eqn. (39) and defining , leads to:
and . The Bessel expansion has been used in the first line, and in the second line, the indices were labeled for the second and first terms in the cosine. Furthermore, can be evaluated similarly by inserting Eqn. (39) into Eqn. (40):
The second term in the parenthesis in the final line contains only contributes nonresonant terms to the final expression for , so it can be safely dropped. The initial term can also be dropped because the denominator, which is small near resonances, is to the first power, not the second. The dispersion relation can be found by inserting the above expressions for into Eqn. (38):
where the right hand side reduces to,
On physical grounds, we can assume the dominant contributions come from the resonant terms where . Under this assumption and the use of the Bessel identity , this reduces to,
This leads to a final form for the dispersion relation:
We define , and if we assume , then exponential growth occurs near resonances of the denominator where is achieved at and .
The dispersion relation for the th mode is therefore:
where where is the harmonic number. We have adopted the notation in [14] of using so that it will be easier to compare results. We note that as shown in Ref. [18] a general expression is where recall that .
In addition, the argument of the Bessel functions are . Therefore, for circularly polarized pumps, where , it follows that and for such that only the fundamental mode is able to be resonant. For linearly polarized pumps, and all harmonics are able to become resonant and contribute to the instability.
Since , it follows that the growth rate is so that
where recall that for LP and for CP from which it follows,
for each value, and
At small , and the growth rate of the fundamental for LP (and the growth rate for CP) behaves as
and this is the growth rate that has been derived numerous times in the astrophysics literature at small [6, 19] and is the expression for the growth of SRS of a short-laser pulse in the strongly coupled regime and XFEL in the frame of e-beam [13].
However, for large , , therefore if the weak dependence on in the Bessel function terms is neglected, then scales as . For CP where the Bessel functions are absent the growth rate is maximum for while for LP the growth rate is maximum at . Thus, our expression predicts that the growth rate decreases when the motion of the pair plasma becomes relativistic, i.e., when . To understand the physical reasons behind the saturation of the growth rate it is useful to compare the growth rate to the formula for the growth rate in Ref. [14] for an ion-electron plasma that does not drift due to the massive ions,
where . For a stationary plasma the only relativistic motion is in the direction. Therefore, for large the growth rate scales (recall that in this case) which is a less rapid fall off compared to the scaling for the pair plasma. The physics behind the scaling with in the stationary plasma is easy to understand [15]. There is a correction to the rest mass, fluid velocity, and the ponderomotive force leading to a factor in addition to the term inside the parenthesis. On the other hand the pair plasma drifts forward as well as oscillates so the factor is now . Furthermore, the proper density is an invariant, so there is only a single factor. However, there is a Doppler downshift to the backscattered frequency (the factor) which leads to an additional factor. Although there are a smaller number of relativistic factors, the dependence of on is stronger for the pair plasma.
To illustrate the dependence on the growth rate on for both LP and CP, in Figure 1 we plot the solutions to the above dispersion relation for the LP case for (left) and the CP case (right).

Figure 1. Plots of growth rate as a function of pump strength from [50] for linearly polarized (left) and circularly polarized pumps (right). The left plot depicts the growth of each harmonic along with the fundamental mode for . Note that the harmonics only become significant for near unity.
For the limit, there is a single parameter that determines , namely . However, as increases then the dispersion properties of the pair plasma cannot be neglected and no longer is exactly . In this situation the incoming EM wave is no longer purely a function of and the above theory no longer holds. It is difficult to undertake a general theory for LP lasers for arbitrary pump phase velocity, however, it can be done for CP and this is in the Appendix.
Furthermore, as increases beyond unity, then the relevant parameter that determines the normalized growth rate is now which is always much less than unity. However, the parameter, , is still very important for large for a different reason, local pump depletion or etching [15]. As the EM wave enters the pair plasma it accelerates the pairs forward. Each pair has an energy . In addition, the proper density is an invariant, so the density is compressed to (recall that is the proper density). There is thus a large local kinetic energy density for the pair plasma. This energy must come from the incident EM wave. Each laser cycle thus shoots pairs forward, so when the energy density of the pairs exceeds the energy density of the incoming EM wave then the wave gradually etches backwards it cannot propagate into the plasma. Equating the two quantities gives,
Noting that and defining complete etching to occur when the energy density of the pairs exceeds that of the EM wave leads to the condition, , for full etching under the assumption that . Under these conditions, there is no reflection of the EM wave. It is fully absorbed by the pair plasma.
Last, we point out a related issue. For low density, where the group velocity of the EM wave is very close to the speed of light, then it moves faster than the pair plasma that is accelerated forward. In this situation the EM pulse will interact with a pair plasma of an ever increasing thickness given by where is the propagation distance of the EM pulse into the pair plasma and is the average axial velocity of the pair plasma. It thus follows that which is the Lorentz contraction of the propagation distance.
At higher density the EM pulse does not move at c rather at near the group velocity of the EM pulse, . In this case which for large becomes negative (the EM pulse can never catch up with the drifting pair plasma and be reflected) when . Thus, for large the EM pulse cannot undergo stimulated scattering and it is instead, suddenly or gradually absorbed.
Simulation Results
We verify aspects of the above theory and arguments using the fully relativistic particle-in-cell code OSIRIS. We perform two types of numerical experiments. The first utilize periodic boundary conditions with the pump initialized inside the plasma with the a density and fluid velocity determined from the equilibrium of Eqns. (10)-(12) for a pair plasma that started at rest in front of the pump. These simulations permit numerical validation of the temporal growth of the instability predicted by the theory. We call this the temporal problem. The second class of numerical experiments represent a more realistic initial condition, where the pump is launched from the left boundary into a stationary pair plasma. We call this the spatial problem.
Temporal Problem
The simulation lengths for the temporal problem are 60-180 laser wavelengths with 6k-18k cells and the number of particles per cell ranging from 64-128. The ratio of the plasma density to the frequency of the incident EM wave is plasma density is . Simulations were done for both linearly and circularly polarized laser pumps for ranging from . As seen in Fig. [Figure 2], which plots the growth of in -space, each mode grows for a duration of before it saturates. Note that at early times, the growth rate is noticeably lower for the higher harmonic numbers, . The amplitudes saturate near .

Figure 2. Exponential growth of the Fourier amplitude () of the backscattered harmonics for as a function of time for different pump strengths: (a) and (b) ; in both cases. The corresponding k-spectrum of the backscattered energy at late times, after the instability has saturated, is presented in panels (c) and (d), revealing the harmonic structure of the backscattered light. Dashed lines in (c) and (d) are drawn at .
In the bottom row of Fig. [Figure 2], we plot the wave number spectrum of the backward-propagating component of the EM field at a time after saturation, for the corresponding EM wave amplitudes.
For each wave amplitude, the most prominent mode is the fundamental harmonic that is downshifted in frequency by a factor of due to the nonlinear relativistic drift of the plasma particles.
We can extract this frequency from the PIC data as well as the frequency at all the harmonics by measuring the corresponding spectral peaks near each shifted frequency. We plot the PIC backscattered frequencies vs theory for the and modes in the linearly polarized case in 3a.
The leftmost plot shows the measured location of each harmonic in -space vs . We measure the location of each harmonic by fitting a gaussian to each peak in the power spectrum obtained from a lineout at the line in the dispersion. There is good agreement at small , for each harmonic, however there is noticeable deviation of the fundamental at large .
We can extract the numerical growth rate at each harmonic from the temporal evolution of the electron density at . At various we observe distinct regions of exponential growth in the , , plots and apply a linear regression to the semilog of the data, with the growth rate being half of the slope of the best fit line. The exponential growth of each harmonic is shown in Figure 2a and (2b). We have carried out this procedure to extract the growth rates for a range of wave amplitudes, , and plotted the growth rate for linearly and circularly polarized cases in Figure 3b and (3c). The fully nonlinear growth rate as predicted by Eqn. (50) for linearly and circularly polarized modes are shown as the blue and red curves. Note the characteristic bending of the growth rate at large observed in the data that is not accounted for by the linear theory. For further numerical validation, we also plot the growth rates of the harmonics along with the fundamental for the LP case.

Figure 3. a) Plot of the frequency mode vs pump strength . Frequencies were measured by extracting the maximum spectral signal of the backscattered light wave . Plots of the growth rate as a function of for b) linearly and c) circularly polarized pumps. The blue and orange solid curves denote the predicted growth rates as predicted by the FEL dispersion curve and the linear theory.
Nonlinear effects
For these periodic simulations it is illustrative to examine the nonlinear behavior of the instability. This process is illustrated in Figure 4.

Figure 4. Plots of the Poynting fluxes of the backscattered harmonics (top row), the incident EM wave (middle row), and of the electron energy flux (bottom row). The left (right) column corresponds to (0.05). The colors correspond to different values of which vary from 1 to 8 in powers of 2.
The top plot shows the total backscattered Poynting flux summed over all modes, the middle shows the Poynting flux filtered near the pump at and the bottom plot shows the spatial averaged electron energy flux vs time. The complex Poynting fluxes were extracted using the method described in [19]. The linear regime of the instability is readily seen to occur in the time range , which is associated with a rapid increase in the backscatter energy flux. From onwards, we have entered the nonlinear regime. In this region, there is pump depletion of a few percent for and a few tens of percent for for the durations considered. This energy does not go into the reflected modes, but instead goes into heating the particles, which is readily scene by the steady rise in the bottom plot which occurs at the same time as the pump depletion and the saturation of the reflection. One possibility for the mechanism for the onset of pair plasma heating is a form of stochastic acceleration in which the particles orbit chaotically due to the counterpropagating light waves[20]. This process has been observed in simulations of SRS backscatter of electron-ion plasmas [21].
Spatial Problem
While our temporal simulations provide numerical consistency with our theory, a simulation investigating the behavior of the pump when launched from a boundary is more physical in the context of the propagation of fast radio bursts. For these simulations, we use a box size of 600 laser wavelengths, with 60k-180k cells and 64-128 particles per cell.
Maintaining the same resolution as the temporal simulations is important here, as the odd-harmonics require at least 20 cells per wavelength in order to be fully resolved. The antenna module of Osiris is used to launch an electromagnetic wave of from the left boundary. The rise time was set to in order for the density to achieve the equilibrium form. Evidence of the backscatter can be readily seen in the leftward going EM field component . Plots of along with the electron density at various are shown[5].
In each case, the density at the front of the EM wave follows the equilibrium form at the head of the laser pulse before becoming unstable. There is strong evidence of backscatter past this point. A spectral analysis of the reflected signal is presented in Figure 5 in the bottom plot which reveals the locations of the fundamental and odd-harmonic generation in close agreement with theory. It is evident that the backscattered fundamental mode has increasing wavelength with increasing , which is a feature of the relativistic Doppler shift. For the case, visual inspection reveals that there around 10 backscattered wavelengths for every 100 laser wavelengths, so that the backscattered frequency is . The predicted frequency of the fundamental is . Similarly there are 3 backscattered wavelengths for every 100 laser wavelengths for , yielding a backscattered frequency of and for comparison the predicted frequency is at . Another important feature is that as the pulse propagates, the instability region gets progressively longer as plasma piles up at the compression front. This results in the region of spatial gain scaling as such the amount of gain increases as the propagation length increases. This is illustrated in the middle row of Figure 5 which shows the amplification of the backscatter for when the pump has reached and (near the end of the box). For it appears that backscatter has almost saturated at while for the backscatted signal has continued to grow and it has increased by an factor of 10 by end of the simulation. Although the amplitude of the reflected energy is low, it is worth noting that the reflected normalized vector potential is actually large. The backscattered electric field is that of the pump. However, the signal frequency is of the pump so the normalized vector potential of the reflected wave is slightly larger than that of the pump.

Figure 5. Spatial plots of the electron density and leftward going field at for and for linearly polarized pump on top. The flat part of the density at the front of the laser is precisely the equilibrium profile which then goes unstable further into the pulse. Spectral analysis of reflected light on bottom. The signal between and was fourier transformed in time from to to avoid interference from the primary pulse.
One might wonder if a greater reflected signal is observed at higher densities where the plasma response becomes important. It turns out that for higher , much of the incident laser energy is absorbed by the plasma rather than reflected, with the reflected signal accounting for very little of the incident energy flux. This is shown in Figure 6 which depicts the spatial problem for and . In these plots the electron heat flux in blue is shown alongside the total Poynting flux in green and the backward Poynting flux in red. For illustrative purposed the rise time was increased to for the top two plots, and decreased back to for the bottom plot. Note that the cause of the dip at the head of the pulse is due to a spike in the heat flux, rather than to a spike in the reflected signal, which is at most a few percent of the pump energy. Furthermore, for near unity as in the bottom plot, the dip in the laser envelope extends all the way to 0, in which case the laser is completely absorbed by the plasma and no more energy can penetrate it. The absorption does not happen when the laser attains its peak energy, but rather when the light Poynting flux equals the energy flux of the leptons when they are accelerated to the drift velocity, which occurs near for .

Figure 6. Smoothed energy fluxes for particles and fields at and .
Finite Temperature effects
For the temporal and spatial results presented above the plasma was initialized under the conditions that the pair plasma was cold in front of the EM wave. This was done chiefly to permit comparison to theory, but it also simplifies the interpretation of the results. However, pair plasmas near a magnetar are expected to have non zero temperatures. A natural question would be to determine how this effects the growth rate and the harmonic content. In this section, we provide simulation results for both the temporal and spatial problems for non-zero but equal temperatures for the pair plasma.
Initialization
For the temporal problem, we must determine how to map the distribution function for the pair plasma in equilibrium with a finite initial temperature and no net drifts to the distribution function after the EM wave has propagated through it. To determine the appropriate distribution function we rely on Jean’s theorem [22] which states that any distribution function, F, constructed from constants of the motion satisfies the Vlasov equation. When the EM wave has a phase velocity equal to c then there are three constants of motion, , and two more from the components of . To determine the correct functional dependence for F in terms of these constants we map an initial where to the values at some later time after the laser has passed through the plasma. For linear polarization it can be shown that the form of the distribution function is:
where + and − refer to positrons and electrons. To determine the proportionality constant, we integrate over the proper velocities,
and the constant is chosen such that the density in front of the laser is . It can be shown that integrating over the distribution function within the EM field gives
where , is an envelope that also moves at c, and and are modified Bessel functions of the second kind. Note that the ratio of the Bessel functions is unity for large , i.e., small temperatures, and asymptotes to zero for small . Thus, the compression provided by the EM wave decreases as the temperature increases.
Simulation
It is straight forward to include kinetic effects for weak (linear) pump strengths and this has appeared in the literature [19]. In this limit, the EM wave’s modification to the density is a lower order effect. On the other hand the above fully theory for induced scattering is not easily extended to include kinetic effects. Instead, we relay in PIC simulation experiments to understand the effect of temperature on scattering and harmonic generation for LP EM waves. We begin with results for the temporal problems where the observed growth rates can be compared to the cold plasma results and then move on to the spatial problem.
Temporal Problem In this section, we perform simulations for plasmas with different temperatures using a periodic box with the same size as for the cold case. The plasma was initialized with a distribution of the form give by Eq. (58). We used three temperatures which correspond to , and 5 keV. The evolution of the harmonics for for the each temperature is shown in Figure 7. Each plot depicts the growth of the Poynting flux component at a specific harmonic for temperatures ranging from to . In can be seen that the fundamental appears for each of the temperatures simulated. Interestingly, although the initial growth rate of the fundamental decreases with increasing temperature at early times, the growth rate actually appears to increase later in time and the fundamental mode saturates near the same value.

Figure 7. Poynting flux for finite temperature temporal problem for and .
On the other hand, the saturated levels of the modes are decrease as the temperature increases. still become less prominent at higher temperatures, with the higher harmonics saturating at two orders of magnitude less than the cold case for . Figure 8 depicts a line out of the Poynting flux after saturation at three different temperatures.

Figure 8. Lineout for poynting flux for for
In this figure, there are noticeable spikes for the colder case at while the hot case has only the fundamental harmonic as a noticeable feature.
We observe significant heating even in the cold case as the incident EM energy at these amplitudes is much greater than the initial plasma energy. This is illustrated in Figure 9 which shows the particle distribution both initially and at a later time for note that the distribution function at higher initial temperatures has a lower maximum energy than the colder case. This is consistent with the ponderomotive force being smaller.

Figure 9. Initial and final Positron distribution function for temperatures . Significant heating is observed in both cases with a much greater fraction of particles being resonantly coupled to the pump in the cold case.
Spatial Problem We also carried out simulations for finite pair plasma temperatures for the spatial problem. Results are shown in Figure 10. We observe a similar phenomenon as for the temporal problem in which the higher harmonics are less visible while the fundamental is still present. In the spatial problem there is significantly less energy in both the fundamental and corresponding higher harmonics for increasing temperature. This is potentially due to the slower there being less gain due to the Lorentz contraction to the width of the compressed plasma region.

Figure 10. Backscattered spectra for .
Application to FRBs
The above analysis and simulations describe the nonlinear interaction of EM waves with large normalized amplitudes in unmagnetized pair plasmas with small normalized densities. Here, we discuss how these results might be of relevance to Fast radio bursts (FRBs). FRBs detected from extragalactic sources are thought to originate in or near magnetar magnetospheres [1, 23, 2, 4, 5], where violent cataclysmic events launch coherent gigahertz-frequency electromagnetic pulses through a surrounding pair-dominated wind. Deep in the closed-field-line region the strong cyclotron frequency makes the unmagnetized model inapplicable, but beyond the light cylinder, the field weakens and the wind transitions toward an approximately unmagnetized pair plasma [2, 8]. In the striped wind [24] the alternating-polarity magnetic field has a time-averaged value near zero on scales larger than the stripe width, further reducing the effective magnetization. It is in this region that the intense FRB pulse interacts with the pair plasma on the timescale of interest, motivating the present analysis and simulations.
The key dimensionless parameter governing this interaction is the normalized pump amplitude . For an FRB of isotropic luminosity at distance from the source, the local intensity is , so
Even for modest burst luminosities – at distances – where the unmagnetized approximation is better justified, we find –, well above unity. Meanwhile, the single-species plasma frequency in the wind satisfies – for typical pair multiplicities – and surface fields [2, 25], placing FRBs in the underdense regime. FRBs therefore realize the strongly nonlinear parameter space , that is the focus of this work. Several physically important consequences follow from the large analysis presented here. First, the growth rate of the stimulated backscatter instability, shown in Eqns. (51) and (52) for LP and CP peak near of 2. At larger the growth rate decreases as (Eq. (50)) owing to the increasing relativistic mass of the drifting pairs and the Doppler shift due to the drift. Nevertheless, even at – the implied e-folding timescale () remains orders of magnitude shorter than a typical FRB pulse duration of , so the instability has ample time to grow to nonlinear amplitudes within a single burst. Second, it is shown that the parameter is indeed important for large values of . When the incoming wave will etch away by transferring nearly 100% of its energy to accelerating the pair plasma forward. Thus, in this case there is no reflection. Third, as discussed in the Appendix, the pump wave significantly depletes the ambient pair proper density. This occurs for both LP and CP but it is easier to analyze for CP. It was shown that when the effective plasma frequency of the depleted equilibrium can be far below . Equivalently, the relativistic critical density can exceed the ambient density by orders of magnitude, allowing the FRB and its backscattered companion to propagate freely through regions that are classically overdense. Last, for linearly polarized FRBs, as opposed to circularly polarized, the parametric coupling excites all odd harmonics of the fundamental Doppler-shifted frequency. These produce a spectral comb whose spacing contracts as with increasing pump amplitude, potentially observable as sub-pulse frequency structure at high time resolution. These estimates indicate that FEL-type stimulated backscatter is a physically plausible and potentially significant process during FRB propagation through magnetar winds, extending the earlier weak-pump analyses of Refs [19, 11] into the strongly nonlinear regime directly relevant to observed FRB intensities. A fully quantitative prediction requires coupling the present theory to a realistic wind model accounting for finite pair temperature, magnetization, and the three-dimensional geometry of the propagation path, which we leave to future work.
Summary
A relativistic theory of intense EM propagation in underdense pair plasma was derived and compared to PIC simulation results. Utilizing the formalism from [14] and insight from [13, 15], we derived the dispersion for a general elliptically polarized EM pulse impinging on a pair plasma. It was shown that a linearly polarized EM pulse is susceptible to stimulated backscatter at the odd harmonics of the Doppler shifted laser frequency. This theory requires deriving the equilibrium for the pair plasma under the influence of an arbitrarily large field. The assumptions of the analysis were carefully dilineated and the theory was validated against OSIRIS PIC simulations. The simulations confirmed the instability growth rate and showed that multiple odd harmonics can be generated. The effects of finite temperature was studied via PIC simulations, from which it was found that the growth of backscatter gradually decreases as the temperature approaches keV and that harmonics gradually disappear.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported under the U.S. Department of Energy through LLE subcontracts SUB000001031 and SUB00000211. The work of T.G. was supported FCT (Portugal) through Grant No. CEECIND/04050/2021. The work of J.P.P. was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy National Nuclear Security Administration under Award No. DE-NA0004144.
Appendix
Finite density effects
Although a complete perturbative analysis for any and polarization is beyond the scope of this work, we can still extract useful information on the behavior of the instability in the finite density case where the pump and/or the reflected light do not have phase velocities equal to if we assume that the pump wave is circularly polarized. We expect this physics to become important at large enough such that the frequency of the backscattered light becomes smaller than so that it is not obvious that it can propagate in the plasma. In the circularly-polarized case the harmonic generation is absent, and the equilibrium solutions are constant, which simplifies the analysis considerably. The zeroth-order solutions are got by assuming the fluid variables are functions of where . In terms of this variable, the fluid equations 21 are modified to take the form
The corresponding solutions for , , are:
These equations combined with the light wave equation yields the following dispersion relation for the (circularly-polarized) pump:
A plot of the vs is shown in 11

Figure 11. Pump dispersion relation vs
Even at various , it is evident that the dispersion relation only depends on the parameter . A fact that is not obvious from the equilibrium solutions. Furthermore, that the effective plasma frequency decreases dramatically with increasing means that the backscattered light wave can still propagate through the plasma even after the frequency shifts below critical. The stability analysis proceeds by perturbing about the fluid variables as , , , . Extracting the first-order variation of the above fluid equations yields:
where is the electron/positron drift velocity, . At this stage, it is convenient to assume that the backscattered light wave , has the plane wave form of and is polarized in the same direction as the pump so that where . The first three equations can be readily inverted in Fourier space:
Inserting the expression for into the light wave equation yields the lab-frame dispersion relation for the stimulated backscatter:
The extra factor of 1/2 on the RHS comes from the normalization . Note that has an additional dependence on . In the underdense limit, the imaginary part of is maximal when is equal to minus the incident wavenumber in the drift frame. This is not true in the general case, however, and the maximum growth rate must be computed by numerically solving 75 for . Plots of the full growth rate as functions of and are shown in Figure 12. The dashed lines in the left plot show where the backscattered frequency dips below . This provides a rough measure of where the underdense limit no longer holds.

Figure 12. Maximal growth rate vs (left) and vs (right) for circularly polarized pump at various . The vertical dashed lines on the left are drawn at the where the lab frame frequency of the backscattered light wave in the underdense approximation becomes less than .
References
- [1]M. Lyutikov. Induced Raman scattering in pulsar magnetospheres. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 298:1198, 1998.
- [2]E. Sobacchi, Y. Lyubarsky, A. M. Beloborodov, and L. Sironi. Filamentation of fast radio bursts in magnetar winds. Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 2022.DOI
- [3]E. Sobacchi, Y. Lyubarsky, A. M. Beloborodov, L. Sironi, and M. Iwamoto. Saturation of the filamentation instability and dispersion measure of fast radio bursts. Astrophys. J. Lett., 943:L21, 2023.DOI
- [4]E. Sobacchi, M. Iwamoto, L. Sironi, and T. Piran. Escape of fast radio bursts from magnetars. Astron. Astrophys., 690:A332, 2024.DOI
- [5]E. Sobacchi, M. Iwamoto, L. Sironi, and T. Piran. Propagation of strong electromagnetic waves in tenuous plasmas. Phys. Rev. Research, 6:043213, 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2409.04127
- [6]Maxim Lyutikov and Victor Gurarie. Anderson self-localization of light in pair plasmas. arXiv:2509.20594 [physics.plasm-ph], 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2509.20594
- [7]M. Lyutikov. Nonlinear optics in strongly magnetized pair plasma, with applications to fast radio bursts. Phys. Rev. E, 102:013211, 2020.
- [8]Navin Sridhar, Emanuele Sobacchi, Lorenzo Sironi, Masanori Iwamoto, Daniel Grošelj, and Brandon K. Russell. Interaction of strong electromagnetic waves with unmagnetized pair plasmas. Phys. Rev. Lett., 137:045102, Jul 2026.DOI
- [9]Kavin Tangtartharakul, Alexey Arefiev, and Maxim Lyutikov. Complete reflection of nonlinear electromagnetic waves in underdense pair plasmas enabled by dynamically formed bragg-like structures. Phys. Rev. Lett., 137:145201, Sep 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2509.06230
- [10]DW Forslund, JM Kindel, and EL Lindman. Theory of stimulated scattering processes in laser-irradiated plasmas. The Physics of Fluids, 18(8):1002–1016, 1975; and references therein.DOI
- [11]Masanori Iwamoto and Kunihito Ioka. Induced scattering of strong waves in pair plasmas. Phys. Rev. D, 114:063022, Sep 2026.DOI
- [12]C. Pellegrini, A. Marinelli, and S. Reiche. The physics of x-ray free-electron lasers. Rev. Mod. Phys., 88:015006, Mar 2016.DOI
- [13]X. Xu and W. B. Mori. On the relationship between the gain of stimulated Raman backscatter of a short-pulse laser in a plasma and the Pierce parameter for XFELs. arXiv:2608.04517, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2608.04517
- [14]Eric Esarey and Phillip Sprangle. Generation of stimulated backscattered harmonic radiation from intense-laser interactions with beams and plasmas. Phys. Rev. A, 45:5872–5882, Apr 1992.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9907689
- [15]CD Decker, WB Mori, K-C Tzeng, and T Katsouleas. The evolution of ultra-intense, short-pulse lasers in underdense plasmas. Physics of Plasmas, 3(5):2047–2056, 1996.DOI
- [16]Rei Nishiura, Shoma F. Kamijima, and Kunihito Ioka. Unified kinetic theory of induced scattering: Compton, brillouin, and raman processes in magnetized electron and positron pair plasma. Phys. Rev. D, 113:123070, Jun 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2510.12869
- [17]Shoma F. Kamijima, Rei Nishiura, Masanori Iwamoto, and Kunihito Ioka. One-dimensional particle-in-cell simulation of induced compton scattering in a magnetized electron-positron pair plasma. Phys. Rev. D, 114:063054, Sep 2026.
- [18]Phillip Sprangle and Eric Esarey. Stimulated backscattered harmonic generation from intense laser interactions with beams and plasmas. Phys. Rev. Lett., 67:2021–2024, Oct 1991.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10044315
- [19]A. Ghosh, D. Kagan, U. Keshet, and Y. Lyubarsky. Nonlinear electromagnetic-wave interactions in pair plasma. I. Nonrelativistic regime. Astrophys. J., 930:106, 2022.DOI
- [20]Z.-M. Sheng, K. Mima, Y. Sentoku, M. S. Jovanović, T. Taguchi, J. Zhang, and J. Meyer-ter Vehn. Stochastic heating and acceleration of electrons in colliding laser fields in plasma. Phys. Rev. Lett., 88:055004, Jan 2002.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11863737
- [21]D. W. Forslund, J. M. Kindel, W. B. Mori, C. Joshi, and J. M. Dawson. Two-dimensional simulations of single-frequency and beat-wave laser-plasma heating. Phys. Rev. Lett., 54:558–561, Feb 1985.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10031551
- [22]J. H. Jeans. On the theory of star-streaming and the structure of the universe. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 76(2):70–84, 1915.DOI
- [23]Y. Lyubarsky. Induced scattering of short radio pulses. Astrophys. J., 682:1443–1449, 2008.DOI
- [24]A. M. Beloborodov. Compression fronts from fast radio bursts. Astrophys. J., 2026. arXiv:2503.16054.arxiv.org/abs/2503.16054
- [25]A. M. Beloborodov. Can a strong radio burst escape the magnetosphere of a magnetar? Astrophys. J. Lett., 922:L7, 2021.DOI