betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Observation of Non-Equilibrium Phonon Loss Across a Solid-Superfluid Interface

Abstract

We measure the performance of an athermal phonon calorimeter in vacuum and in thermal contact with superfluid 4^4He. Using a cryogenic photon calibration system, we show that the superfluid suppresses the collection of the phonon signal by over 99%. We conclude that submerged sensors will not benefit TESSERACT's superfluid helium dark matter target, but that superfluid helium may be useful to superconducting qubits as a sink for athermal phonons generated by radiation and other spontaneous sources. Our measurement is the first probe of solid-to-superfluid phonon transmission at energies higher than those stably supportable by the superfluid. We discuss thermal flow inside the calorimeter, as well as systematics from an alternative calibration scheme.

Introduction

The search for low-mass dark matter induced nuclear recoils in terrestrial experiments requires the development of new technologies to overcome poor kinematic matching and low recoil energies when compared with more massive dark matter models such as the WIMP [1]. Recently, superfluid 4He^{4}\mathrm{He} has gained interest as a potential dark matter recoil target due to its low nuclear mass, interesting signal channels, ease of chemical purification, and intrinsic scalability [2, 3, 4, 5]. We have operated a detector that uses un-wetted athermal phonon calorimeters to detect recoils in a superfluid 4He^{4}\mathrm{He} bath sitting below [4].

An additional array of submerged sensors would improve signal reconstruction by enhancing collection of prompt scintillation photons or triplet excimer decays [6].

We have developed calorimeters with energy resolutions as low as 253 meV [7, 8]. The extreme sensitivity of these low-threshold athermal phonon detectors has provided a window into non-equilibrium energy transport in solids, which is also an important consideration for superconducting quantum circuits [9, 10]. In superconducting qubits, the same non-equilibrium processes contribute to excess quasiparticle densities in superconducting films, leading to premature decoherence of the qubit state. Band-gap engineering [11, 12, 13] and large-area normal metal films [14] have been successfully deployed to reduce the impact of non-equilibrium energy in superconducting qubit circuits; however, further improvements are still required. The unique properties of superfluid helium motivate exploring its potential as an additional channel for removing non-equilibrium energy from superconducting circuits. Understanding energy transport across the solid–helium interface is therefore essential.

Key to evaluating this possibility, and to the performance of submerged calorimeters, is the behavior of athermal phonons at the solid–helium interface. Phonon transmission at solid–superfluid interfaces has long been of interest to the condensed matter community due to anomalously high transmission probabilities despite severe acoustic mismatch [15]. Historically, interest has gone towards the study of conduction via the stable quasiparticles present in the superfluid below 1.49 meV (phonons and rotons) [16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22]. Notably, solid materials can support phonons with energies of O(100)O(100) meV. Until now, no observation of the transmission of athermal phonons with energies greater than 1.49 meV has been made.

In this Letter, we describe the operation and performance of a TESSERACT athermal phonon sensor, hereafter referred to as a pixel phonon detector (PPD), when in contact with superfluid 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He}. We investigate both the flow of thermal and athermal phonons in and out of the PPD. We demonstrate an efficient transmission of athermal phonons across the solid–superfluid interface, with the sensor losing almost all of the energy it absorbs. We discuss our measurements’ relationships to both theory and previous measurements, their impact on the development of future low-mass dark matter experiments, and superfluid 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He}’s utility as a phonon sink for superconducting qubits.

Experimental Setup

The PPD is composed of voltage-biased tungsten Transition Edge Sensors (TESs) [23] coupled to aluminum phonon collection fins in the Quasiparticle-trap-assisted Electrothermal-feedback Transition-edge-sensor (QET) [24] architecture, fabricated on a 1 cm2^{2} by 1 mm thick intrinsic silicon substrate. We wire 172 QETs into a single readout channel, giving a total sensitive surface area coverage of 1.5%. On the same surface are two separate tungsten TESs of 200 μ\mum by 800 μ\mum by 60 nm, one of which is used as a heater for the thermal studies discussed in Appendix B, and will be referred to as a heater. A diagram of the PPD can be seen in Figure 1. Both the QET and heater channels are read out by two-stage DC SQUID amplifiers.

Layout of the PPD

Figure 1. Layout of the PPD. Green areas denote aluminum, cyan denotes tungsten, and black areas denote aluminum and aluminum overlap. White space is bare silicon, and the dashed line denotes the borders of the cm2\mathrm{cm}^{2} silicon chip. The two U-shaped QET chains were connected with aluminum wirebonds (not shown) and read out as a single channel. The TES in the bottom left corner was also read out and biased to heat the PPD when needed (see Appendix B). The TES in the bottom right was not instrumented.

The PPD is attached to a gold-plated copper mounting structure via rubber cement at three corners, with aluminum wirebonds providing electrical connection to a readout PCB. A 25.4 μ\mum diameter gold wirebond links an aluminum pad on the PPD to its mounting structure, providing a thermal link to the bath. The mounting structure is housed in a superfluid 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He}-tight experimental detector cell. A calibrated ruthenium oxide thermometer is bolted to the cell adjacent to the mounting structure. A single-mode optical fiber is coupled to the cell via a superfluid-tight feedthrough, providing an in-situ method of calibrating the detector with 3.06 eV photons generated by a laser diode at room temperature. The detector platform is mounted below the mixing chamber plate of a dilution refrigerator, with a base temperature of ∼7\sim7 mK. 99.999% pure helium of natural isotopic abundance [25] was introduced into the cell through a 0.89 mm inner diameter stainless steel capillary thermalized to the cryostat’s various temperature stages. Fill heights were calculated from the pressure drop in storage cylinders and the geometry of the cell.

The PPD was first characterized while dry, after which a small amount of 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He} was introduced so that only a film of superfluid coated the PPD. The sensor was then re-characterized in this film state. Finally, sufficient 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He} was introduced to fully submerge the PPD, and the process was repeated for this bulk state.

PPD Characterization

TES Electrothermal Preliminaries

In each of the three fill states, we performed I-V scans, sweeping downward in bias voltage. From the measured I-V curves, we extract the circuit parasitic resistance (RpR_p) and the TES resistance (R0R_0) and bias power (P0P_0) at each point along the curve. At a bias voltage in transition fixed across the fill states, we injected a square wave over the DC bias and calculated the circuit’s complex admittance (dIdV(ω)\frac{dI}{dV}(\omega)) based from the response. Both Re⁡(dIdV(ω))\operatorname{Re}(\frac{dI}{dV}(\omega)) and Im⁡(dIdV(ω))\operatorname{Im}(\frac{dI}{dV}(\omega)) were then simultaneously fit to an analytical model of the TES’s complex admittance [26]. The sensor’s current-to-power transfer function (dPdI(ω)\frac{dP}{dI}(\omega)) was then calculated [23, 26]. The PPD’s bias power as a function of bias voltage can be seen in Figure 2. The device’s bias power in transition has a measured increase of 12 fW in the film state, with an additional 4 fW gained in the bulk state. These measurements were carried out multiple times at each fill state. In Figure 3 we plot a larger set of bias power measurements throughout the run vs. time.

TES bias power versus bias voltage

Figure 2. TES bias power vs. bias voltage. Dry data are represented by orange circles, film data by blue squares, and bulk data by green triangles. The bias point for transition operation described in Sec. III B bears a thicker boundary line. Bias powers PbP_b at this operation point are recorded in the inset.

Measured bias power in transition throughout the run

Figure 3. Measured bias power in transition with constant voltage bias throughout the run. Periods of helium filling are shaded in blue. Error bars represent statistical uncertainties.

Characterization of Athermal Phonon Collection

The PPD was biased in its transition at a fixed bias voltage across the three fill states. To calibrate the PPD response to athermal phonons in the dry state we injected 1 μ\mus-wide pulses of 3.06 eV photons into the experimental cell and onto the PPD’s reverse (bare) face. The laser power was tuned so that O(1)O(1) photon was absorbed by the silicon in each pulse. The PPD’s response to injected photons was measured offline using an optimal (matched) filter (OF) [27], with timing determined by a synchronization signal from the function generator driving the laser.

The detector, when dry, exhibits a sub-photon energy resolution of 0.622 eV, enabling a direct calibration to the photon energy absorbed into the silicon. The distribution of measured PPD responses is seen in the inset of Figure 4. The measurement of dPdI(ω)\frac{dP}{dI}(\omega) allows for the measurement of the PPD’s energy collection efficiency (ECE), the fraction of the energy deposited in the silicon that is ultimately collected by the TES. In the dry state, the measured ECE is 19.2%, in line with previous measurements of similar PPDs given additional losses into the mounting glue and additional inert metal [7].

Calorimeter response in three physical states

Figure 4. Calorimeter response in three physical states: dry, coated with superfluid film, and immersed in bulk superfluid. Responses to pulses of 3.06 eV photons with a mean of 61.0 eV, applied in each state, are shown in orange. The single photon calibration distribution is also shown for the dry calorimeter in green. Finally, the distribution of random events with the laser off is plotted in blue for the two wet datasets, with Gaussian fits superimposed, along with a Gaussian fit to the dry 0-photon peak. The corresponding distribution is not shown for the dry state; however, it is equivalent to the 0-photon peak seen in the inset.

Photon calibration data when dry were also taken at a higher laser intensity, at which the mean number of photons absorbed by the detector per laser pulse was much higher. By virtue of linearity of the PPD in this energy range, the average number of absorbed photons in this higher intensity dataset could be determined using the aforementioned calibration. Sensor linearity was confirmed by stability of OF’s χ2\chi^2 goodness-of-fit metric over the range of amplitudes. The distribution of responses is shown in the top panel of Figure 4, corresponding to a mean absorbed energy of 61.0 eV (∼20\sim20 photons).

In both of the wet states, we reproduced this higher intensity dataset with identical laser settings. Under the assumption that the helium does not significantly perturb the average number of absorbed photons, the mean response is assumed to correspond to 61.0 eV of absorbed energy. The response distributions are shown in the two lower panels of Figure 4. From this calibration and the measurements of dPdI(ω)\frac{dP}{dI}(\omega), we compute ECEs of 0.164% and 0.158% for the film and bulk states respectively.

In each of the two wet states, data with the laser off were collected. At randomly triggered times, the best-fit pulse amplitude was calculated with the same OF as with the 61.0 eV calibration data, with the distributions shown for the two wet states in Figure 4. Defining the resolution as the standard deviation of this distribution, we measured resolutions of (69.8 ± 0.5) and (75.5 ± 0.6) eV for the film and bulk cases, considerably poorer than the dry analog of (0.622 ± 0.005) eV.

For all three fill states, the mean PPD pulse shape from incident 3.06 eV photons was measured. These observed pulse shapes were then convolved with dPdI(ω)\frac{dP}{dI}(\omega) to yield the time distribution of energy arrivals into the tungsten TES. Finally, the theoretical impulse-response function for the TES was calculated from dPdI(ω)\frac{dP}{dI}(\omega). These three characteristic pulse shapes are summarized in Figure 5. When dry, the PPD responds to photon absorptions with best-fit fall times τ1=(43.5±0.2)\tau_1 = (43.5 \pm0.2) and τ2=(364±2)\tau_2 = (364 \pm2) µs. In the film state, the fall times are τ1=(30.7±0.1)\tau_1 = (30.7 \pm0.1) and τ2=(302±1)\tau_2 = (302 \pm1) µs. In the bulk state, the fall times are τ1=(28.0±0.1)\tau_1 = (28.0 \pm0.1) and τ2=(264±2)\tau_2 = (264 \pm2) µs. Notably, the TES impulse response pulse shape is a weak function of the fill state, while energy arrives to the tungsten TES much faster on average when wet.

Characteristic pulse shapes

Figure 5. Characteristic pulse shapes. (Top) Average measured response to photon absorptions (solid) and TES impulse responses predicted from dPdI(ω)\frac{dP}{dI}(\omega) (dashed). (Bottom) Energy arrival times in the tungsten TES, generated by convolving the average measured pulse shape templates with dPdI(ω)\frac{dP}{dI}(\omega).

Discussion

Helium’s Impact on TES Bias Power

Section III A demonstrates that the PPD’s bias power increases substantially in response to a thin superfluid film, with further modest improvements seen when fully submerged. Figure 3 also demonstrates that the change is due to the helium, and not a gradual trend in bias power over the course of the run. There are two possibilities that explain this observation. In the first, the superfluid cools the tungsten TES via conduction. In the second, the cooling stems from a reduction in parasitic power. Collection of athermal phonons generated by the “low energy excess” (LEE) [28] has been demonstrated as a source of parasitic power [29, 30]. Since we have shown that the superfluid significantly hinders phonon collection, a corresponding reduction in this parasitic power is expected and may explain all of the measured change in bias power. For further discussion on this topic, and discussion of the thermal conductance between the helium, PPD metal films, and PPD substrate, see Appendix A.

Helium’s Impact on Phonon Collection

Section III B demonstrates that our PPD’s ECE degrades by over two orders of magnitude when coated or immersed in superfluid helium. Since superfluid has been demonstrated not to perturb quasiparticle diffusion in aluminum films [31], and since the TES’s impulse response is largely unperturbed by the helium, efficient transmission of athermal phonons into the superfluid is the only credible loss mechanism. This interpretation is further supported by the change in pulse shape demonstrated in Figure 5: the faster energy arrival to the tungsten TES when wet are consistent with preferential collection of phonons that take a near straight-line path to an aluminum film, with those that are not initially incident upon aluminum films escaping.

We note that the observed signal losses are too large to be explained by standard phonon-roton transmission as described in [32]. First, consider as a toy model a dry PPD without loss mechanisms (e.g. sub-gap down-conversion, phonon escape, pair breaking in other metals, quasiparticle recombination, etc.). In this unrealistic limit, the ECE is 100%. When the same toy PPD is submerged into a superfluid bath we have added a potential loss mechanism. Assume a probability of 1% for athermal phonon transmission from solid surfaces into the helium [32]. Athermal phonons will be assumed to have a probability of 40% of transmission at silicon/aluminum interfaces [33], and probability 70% of breaking a Cooper pair on a two-way trip through the aluminum [34]. Based on the above probabilities, an athermal phonon incident on an aluminum film has a 34% chance of breaking a Cooper pair. Likewise, it has a probability of 0.3% of escaping into the helium after traversing the aluminum, and 66% of returning to the silicon. (We calculate these using the above assumptions and an arbitrary number of bounces at the Si/Al and Al/He interfaces). A given bounce (not necessarily upon the aluminum) therefore has a probability 0.5% of breaking Cooper pairs and 1.0% of escaping, accounting for both transmission probabilities and aluminum coverage fraction. We therefore expect an ECE of order 30%, degraded by only a factor of ∼3\sim3 from the dry toy model.

While crude, this toy model is conservative: the complex loss mechanisms it ignores either scale with phonon lifetime/number of bounces and preferentially degrade the collection of the dry case or affect the two cases roughly identically. Our estimate of a 3×3\times reduction in collection efficiency due to helium is therefore a worst-case scenario, and in substantial tension with our observations.

In the above toy model we assumed that the loss occurs through ballistic phonons that have consecutive bounces at random positions on the PPD’s surface. For a silicon PPD of our size, this corresponds to energies of 5 meV and below [35]. The baseline estimate of O(1)%O(1)\% transmission into the helium derived in [32] is calculated only up to 1.49 meV, above which the superfluid does not support stable excitations. If the loss indeed occurs from ballistic phonons, our results suggest that phonons with energies below 5 meV, including a substantial population greater than 1.49 meV [36], have transmission probabilities significantly greater than 1%. If instead the loss occurs from diffusive phonons, our results instead suggest a non-negligible probability of transmission for phonons with energy greater than 5 meV, although the probability in this case is more difficult to bound. In either case, we expect the loss to manifest primarily through phonons with energies greater than 1.49 meV. While anomalously high transmission at superfluid–solid interfaces has been observed at both phonon [21, 22] and roton [20] scales, to our knowledge, no experimental or theoretical studies have probed energies greater than 1.49 meV.

Ramifications

Helium-Target Dark Matter Searches

The conclusions drawn regarding the resolution of wet PPDs have large implications for future dark matter searches using superfluid helium targets [2, 3, 4, 5]. Experiments that use a submerged array of detectors to sense downward-traveling ∼16\sim16 eV photons must either develop sensors less prone to phonon leakage, or pivot to relying on a non-wetted top array only [3]. In the latter case, the resulting loss of sensor coverage will lower the collection efficiency of quanta produced in the helium, resulting in increased detector threshold and weakened sensitivity to low-mass dark matter.

low-mass dark matter. TESSERACT will develop a low-background superfluid helium detector that will operate without submerged PPDs, while exploring paths to overcome phonon leakage into the helium for next-generation experiments.

Superconducting Qubits

The realization of quantum computers based on superconducting quantum circuits is currently dependent on the ability to correct errors impacting individual qubits [37]. Such “fault tolerant” systems have been deployed to various levels of success [38, 39]. Recently, the development of “gap-engineered” qubits has drastically lowered the logical error rate in these systems by mitigating the impact of phonon bursts in the device substrate caused by high energy ionizing particles [11, 12, 13]. However, while these gap-engineered systems have drastically reduced correlated relaxation errors, they do not remove them entirely. Also, correlated phase errors induced by radiation impacts remain a challenge, making it critical to have the ability to remove phonons in the substrate before they break Cooper pairs [40]. We propose that coating a superconducting qubit chip with a layer of superfluid helium may drastically lower the excess quasiparticle density following radiation impacts by removing phonons before they generate quasiparticles. While superfluid-immersed qubits have been studied previously [41] and show potential improvements to qubit stability, the impact of ionizing radiation in this configuration has yet to be studied. Based on our results, we believe that superconducting qubit chips may see as much as a 99% reduction of excess phonons caused by the impacts of ionizing radiation [42, 43, 44].

Conclusion

We have demonstrated the performance of a TES-based athermal phonon calorimeter both when dry and when in contact with a superfluid 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He} bath. We find that the energy collection efficiency of the detector is degraded by two orders of magnitude due to efficient transport of athermal phonons into the superfluid. We also find that the bias power of the detector changes noticeably when wet, implying that the superfluid either increases thermal conduction or removes a source of parasitic power. These measurements not only influence the design of future low-mass dark matter search experiments, but also inform knowledge of solid-state physics at superfluid/solid boundaries and introduce a mechanism with which to reduce phonon-induced quasiparticle poisoning in superconducting qubits.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported in part by DOE Grant DE-SC0025523 and DOE Quantum Information Science Enabled Discovery (QuantISED) for High Energy Physics (KA2401032). This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship under Grant No. DGE 1106400, the Department of Energy National Nuclear Security Administration through the Nuclear Science and Security Consortium under Award Number(s) DE-NA0003180 and/or DE-NA0000979, and by an appointment to the Intelligence Community Postdoctoral Research Fellowship Program at the National Institute of Standards and Technology administered by Oak Ridge Institute for Science and Education (ORISE) through an interagency agreement between the U.S. Department of Energy and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI). This material is based upon work supported by the Department of Energy, National Nuclear Security Administration under Award Number DE-NA0004277 conducted by the Nuclear Science and Security Consortium. Work at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory was supported by the U.S. DOE, Office of High Energy Physics, under Contract No. DEAC02-05CH11231. Work at Argonne is supported by the U.S. DOE, Office of High Energy Physics, under Contract No. DE-AC02-06CH11357. W.G. and Y.Q. acknowledge the support by the National High Magnetic Field Laboratory at Florida State University, which is supported by the National Science Foundation Cooperative Agreement No. DMR-2128556 and the state of Florida. This work benefited from state support managed by the French National Research Agency under the France 2030 program, reference ANR-24-RRII-0001. This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United States Government. Neither the United States Government nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights. Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise does not necessarily constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the United States Government or any agency thereof. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the United States Government or any agency thereof.

Bias power versus silicon temperature data at fixed TES temperature for the three fill states

Figure 6. Bias power vs. silicon temperature data at fixed TES temperature for the three fill states. Fits to Eq. A1 are superimposed as dashed lines. Fits are described in Table I.

Heat flow out of the Tungsten TES

Sections III A and IV A demonstrate that superfluid helium aids in cooling the tungsten TES, but fail to differentiate cooling via direct conduction or by a reduction in parasitic power from LEE. In this appendix, we investigate the precise nature of this cooling.

We follow the measurement prescription defined in [26], calculating TES bias powers at which the TES is at fixed resistance/temperature for various silicon temperatures. In the dry case, we expect the bias power PP (at fixed tungsten TES temperature TcT_{\mathrm{c}}) and silicon temperature TSiT_{\mathrm{Si}} to obey:

P(TSi)=P0(1−(TSiTc)β)(1)P(T_{\mathrm{Si}}) = P_0 \left(1 - \left(\frac{T_{\mathrm{Si}}}{T_{\mathrm{c}}}\right)^\beta\right) \tag*{(1)}

with exponent β=5\beta= 5, assuming that the electron-phonon impedance in the tungsten dominates.

In the wet case, additional conductive cooling is predicted to have a small impact, as it does not circumvent the dominant electron-phonon impedance. If conductive cooling is indeed causing the increase in bias power, only the parameter P0P_0 should see a very slight change. The helium might also reduce a parasitic power caused by LEE through phonon sinking. If this is causing the increase in bias power, we would expect a change to both P0P_0 and TcT_{\mathrm{c}}.

Figure 6 shows the data and fits, while Table I summarizes these fits. As expected, the dry case is consistent with β=5\beta= 5. No trend in fits of TcT_{\mathrm{c}} is observed, implying that the cooling is conductive. However, the magnitude of increase in P0P_0 is larger than would be expected from excess conductive cooling alone. In other words, these observations are in tension with each other, and we are unable to make a definitive statement regarding whether

the additional bias power is due to conductive cooling or a reduction in parasitic power.

Heat flow out of the Silicon Substrate

In this appendix, we describe an attempt to measure the impact of superfluid helium on thermalizing the PPD’s silicon substrate.

We follow the measurement prescription defined in [26]. We make use of the heater described in Sec. II. In the dry case, we expect the silicon heating power PP (at fixed silicon temperature TcT_{\mathrm{c}}) and the bath temperature TbathT_{\mathrm{bath}} to obey:

P(Tbath)=P0(1−(TbathTc)β)(2)P(T_{\mathrm{bath}}) = P_0 \left(1 - \left(\frac{T_{\mathrm{bath}}}{T_{\mathrm{c}}}\right)^\beta\right) \tag*{(2)}

with β=5\beta= 5, assuming that the electron-phonon impedance in the gold wirebond dominates.

In the wet cases, heat generated in the heater can flow directly into the bath through the helium, making any measurement of the power put into the silicon an upper bound. We therefore do not interpret these data, but report the raw values for the interested reader.

Figure 7 shows the data and dry fit. The dry PPD is well-fit to (2) and consistent with β=5\beta= 5.

Heater power versus bath/silicon temperature at fixed TES temperature

Figure 7. Heater power vs. bath/silicon temperature at fixed TES temperature. Fit to Eq. B1 for the dry state is superimposed.

Poisson Calibration and Detector δ\delta Parameter

Section III B demonstrates a calibration to 3.06 eV photon absorptions in the PPD’s silicon substrate. In this appendix, we attempt to calibrate using a more standard method, relying on assumptions regarding the Poisson statistics of absorbed photons.

ConditionP0P_0 (fW)β\betaTcT_c (mK)−2ln⁡L-2\ln\mathcal{L}
Dry154.4±1.4±30.9154.4 \pm1.4 \pm30.95.1±0.1±0.25.1 \pm0.1 \pm0.253.7±0.1±4.253.7 \pm0.1 \pm4.20.42
Film165.1±1.5±33.0165.1 \pm1.5 \pm33.05.3±0.1±0.25.3 \pm0.1 \pm0.253.8±0.1±4.553.8 \pm0.1 \pm4.58.21
Bulk170.4±1.6±34.1170.4 \pm1.6 \pm34.15.1±0.1±0.25.1 \pm0.1 \pm0.253.5±0.1±4.453.5 \pm0.1 \pm4.40.61

Table 1. Best-fit TES parameters for the three helium conditions. The first uncertainty is statistical and the second is systematic. −2ln⁡L-2\ln\mathcal{L} is the maximum likelihood estimation goodness-of-fit. Systematic uncertainties on TcT_c and β\beta originate from uncertainties in the temperature calibration, while those on P0P_0 are dominated by the uncertainty in the shunt resistor used to bias the PPD. They should therefore be interpreted as correlated across the three fill states.

In each of the two wet states, photon calibration data were taken in an identical manner as described in Sec. III B (with pulse width 1 µs and frequency 80 Hz), at a variety of laser intensities. For each of these datasets, the PPD’s response to injected photons was measured offline using an OF, with trigger times set by a synchronization signal from the function generator driving the laser. The mean and variance in pulse amplitudes for each dataset were calculated and plotted in Figure 8.

Mean vs. variance plots for the film and bulk states

Figure 8. Mean vs. variance plots for the film (top) and bulk (bottom) states with superimposed linear fits. The implied resolutions and ECEs are reported in the inset text. These values are incorrect; see Figure 4 for the true calibration.

According to naive assumptions [45], the slope of this relation defines the PPD’s calibration constant/responsivity, while the intercept defines the noise due to current fluctuations. The linear fits shown in Figure 8 imply a resolution of (5.75±0.09)(5.75 \pm0.09) eV in the film state and (2.80±0.05)(2.80 \pm0.05) eV in the bulk state, in substantial tension with the results of Sec. III B. Energy collection efficiencies are correspondingly optimistic relative to those shown in Sec. III B.

We interpret this tension as resulting from the wet PPD’s unusually high position dependence and low phonon collection, which have been argued to bias Poisson-based calibration schemes by inflating the variance of amplitude spectra beyond that expected from Poisson fluctuations alone [45].

The authors of [45] define a metric δ\delta to parameterize the systematic error on such calibrations, with derived energy resolutions being too small by a factor (1+δ)−1(1+\delta)^{-1}. By comparing the ECEs described in Sec. III B to those here, we measure δ=9.2±0.1\delta= 9.2 \pm0.1 for the film state and δ=20.3±0.2\delta= 20.3 \pm0.2 for the bulk state.

While the wet PPD is unique in its poor collection and extreme position dependence, it serves as an unambiguous demonstration of the limits of Poisson-based calibration. We hope that this encourages other researchers to attempt to quantify the systematics intrinsic to this calibration method, either by means of simulation [46, 47] or means of steerable calibration sources that can directly measure position dependence [48, 49]. We also note that this result also has implications for superconducting qubits, where the spatial correlation of errors is of great importance [50]. This demonstration of increased position dependence is thus another potential advantage of immersing superconducting qubits in superfluid helium.

References

References

  1. [1]G. Bertone, D. Hooper, and J. Silk, Particle dark matter: Evidence, candidates and constraints, Physics Reports 405, 279 (2005).DOI
  2. [2]S. A. Hertel, A. Biekert, J. Lin, V. Velan, and D. N. McKinsey, Direct detection of sub-GeV dark matter using a superfluid ⁴He target, Phys. Rev. D 100, 092007 (2019).DOI
  3. [3]M. Solmaz, The direct search experiment for light dark matter (DELight): Overview and perspectives (2025), arXiv:2512.15278 [hep-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2512.15278
  4. [4]R. Anthony-Petersen, A. Biekert, C. L. Chang, et al. (SPICE/HeRALD Collaboration), Demonstration of the herald superfluid helium detector concept, Phys. Rev. D 110, 072006 (2024).
  5. [5]K. Schutz and K. M. Zurek, Detectability of light dark matter with superfluid helium, Physical Review Letters 117, 121302 (2016).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27689261
  6. [6]F. W. Carter, S. A. Hertel, M. J. Rooks, P. V. E. McClintock, D. N. McKinsey, and D. E. Prober, Calorimetric observation of single He₂* excimers in a 100-mK He bath, Journal of Low Temperature Physics 186, 183 (2017).DOI
  7. [7]A. Armatol, C. Augier, L. Bergé, et al. (TESSERACT Collaboration), Low energy phonon bursts created by fast neutron damage (2026), arXiv:2603.17964 [physics.ins-det].arxiv.org/abs/2603.17964
  8. [8]T. Bui, C. Chang, Y.-Y. Chang, et al. (TESSERACT Collaboration), First limits on light dark matter interactions in a low threshold two-channel athermal phonon detector from the TESSERACT collaboration, Physical Review Letters 135, 161002 (2025).DOI
  9. [9]R. Anthony-Petersen, A. Biekert, R. Bunker, et al., A stress-induced source of phonon bursts and quasiparticle poisoning, Nature Communications 15, 6444 (2024).
  10. [10]A. R. Castelli, K. M. Beck, L. D. H. Alegria, L. A. Martinez, K. R. Chaves, S. R. O’Kelley, N. Materise, J. L. Dubois, and Y. J. Rosen, Superconducting-qubit decoherence correlated with detected radiation events, Phys. Rev. Appl. 26, 044052 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2512.18171
  11. [11]L. Sun, L. DiCarlo, M. D. Reed, et al., Measurements of quasiparticle tunneling dynamics in a band-gap-engineered transmon qubit, Physical Review Letters 108, 230509 (2012).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23003936
  12. [12]M. McEwen, K. C. Miao, J. Atalaya, et al., Resisting high-energy impact events through gap engineering in superconducting qubit arrays, Physical Review Letters 133, 10.1103/physrevlett.133.240601 (2024).DOI
  13. [13]G. Marchegiani, L. Amico, and G. Catelani, Quasiparticles in superconducting qubits with asymmetric junctions, PRX Quantum 3, 040338 (2022).DOI
  14. [14]V. Laia et al., Phonon downconversion to suppress correlated errors in superconducting qubits, Nature Communications 13, 6425 (2022).
  15. [15]E. T. Swartz and R. O. Pohl, Thermal boundary resistance, Rev. Mod. Phys. 61, 605 (1989).
  16. [16]A. Ramiere, S. Volz, and J. Amrit, Thermal resistance at a solid/superfluid helium interface, Nature Materials 15, 512 (2016).DOI
  17. [17]P. L. Kapitza, The study of heat transfer in helium II, Journal of Physics (USSR) 4, 181 (1941), also published as Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 11, 1 (1941).
  18. [18]L. J. Challis, K. Dransfeld, and J. W. Wilks, Heat transfer between solids and liquid helium ii, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. A Mathematical and Physical Sciences 260, 31 (1961).DOI
  19. [19]I. N. Adamenko and I. M. Fuks, Roughness and thermal resistance of the boundary between a solid and liquid helium, Soviet Physics JETP 32, 1123 (1971), translated from Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 59, 2071–2082 (1970).
  20. [20]S. R. Bandler, Detection of Charged Particles in Superfluid Helium, Ph.D. thesis, Brown University (1994).
  21. [21]A. F. G. Wyatt and G. J. Page, The transmission of phonons from liquid He to crystalline NaF, Journal of Physics C: Solid State Physics 11, 4927 (1978).DOI
  22. [22]T. Bradshaw and A. F. G. Wyatt, The frequency dependence of the phonon transmission from NaF into liquid ⁴He, Journal of Physics C: Solid State Physics 16, 651 (1983).DOI
  23. [23]K. Irwin and G. Hilton, Transition-Edge Sensors, in Cryogenic Particle Detection, Topics in Applied Physics, edited by C. Enss (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2005) pp. 63–150.DOI
  24. [24]K. D. Irwin, S. W. Nam, B. Cabrera, et al., A quasiparticle-trap-assisted transition-edge sensor for phonon-mediated particle detection, Review of Scientific Instruments 66, 5322 (1995).DOI
  25. [25]J. Meija, T. B. Coplen, M. Berglund, W. A. Brand, P. D. Bièvre, M. Groning, N. E. Holden, J. Irrgeher, R. D. Loss, T. Walczyk, and T. Prohaska, Isotopic compositions of the elements 2013 (IUPAC technical report), Pure and Applied Chemistry 88, 293 (2016).DOI
  26. [26]S. L. Watkins, Athermal Phonon Sensors in Searches for Light Dark Matter, Ph.D. thesis, University of California, Berkeley (2022).arxiv.org/abs/2301.08699
  27. [27]G. Turin, An introduction to matched filters, IRE Transactions on Information Theory 6, 311 (1960).DOI
  28. [28]D. Baxter, R. Essig, Y. Hochberg, M. Kaznacheeva, B. von Krosigk, F. Reindl, R. K. Romani, and F. Wagner, Low-energy backgrounds in solid-state phonon and charge detectors, Annual Review of Nuclear and Particle Science 75, 301–326 (2025).
  29. [29]R. Anthony-Petersen, C. L. Chang, Y.-Y. Chang, et al. (TESSERACT Collaboration), Low energy backgrounds and excess noise in a two-channel low-threshold calorimeter, Applied Physics Letters 126, 102601 (2025).
  30. [30]C. L. Chang, Y.-Y. Chang, M. Garcia-Sciveres, et al., Spontaneous generation of athermal phonon bursts within bulk silicon causing excess noise, low energy background events, and quasiparticle poisoning in superconducting sensors, Applied Physics Letters 127, 10.1063/5.0281876 (2025).
  31. [31]D. Osterman, Aluminum Quasiparticle Diffusion Measurements in Vacuum and Superfluid ⁴He, Ph.D. thesis, University of Massachusetts Amherst (2023).DOI
  32. [32]I. V. Tanatarov, I. N. Adamenko, K. E. Nemchenko, and A. F. G. Wyatt, Interaction of phonons and rotons with interfaces in superfluid helium, Journal of Low Temperature Physics 159, 549–575 (2010).DOI
  33. [33]M. Martinez, L. Cardani, N. Casali, A. Cruciani, G. Pettinari, and M. Vignati, Measurements and simulations of athermal phonon transmission from silicon absorbers to aluminum sensors, Phys. Rev. Appl. 11, 064025 (2019).DOI
  34. [34]D. C. Moore, A Search for Low-Mass Dark Matter with the Cryogenic Dark Matter Search and the Development of Highly Multiplexed Phonon-Mediated Particle Detectors, Ph.D. thesis, California Institute of Technology (2012).
  35. [35]M. E. Msall and J. P. Wolfe, Phonon production in weakly photoexcited semiconductors: Quasidiffusion in Ge, GaAs, and Si, Phys. Rev. B 56, 9557 (1997).DOI
  36. [36]D. S. Kim, H. L. Smith, J. L. Niedziela, C. W. Li, D. L. Abernathy, and B. Fultz, Phonon anharmonicity in silicon from 100 to 1500 k, Physical Review B 91, 014307 (2015).
  37. [37]A. G. Fowler, M. Mariantoni, J. M. Martinis, and A. N. Cleland, Surface codes: Towards practical large-scale quantum computation, Physical Review A 86, 032324 (2012).DOI
  38. [38]R. Acharya, I. Aleiner, R. Allen, et al., Suppressing quantum errors by scaling a surface code logical qubit, Nature 614, 676–681 (2023).DOI
  39. [39]Z. Chen, K. J. Satzinger, J. Atalaya, et al., Exponential suppression of bit or phase errors with cyclic error correction, Nature 595, 383–387 (2021).DOI
  40. [40]V. D. Kurilovich, G. Roberts, L. S. Martin, et al., Correlated error bursts in a gap-engineered superconducting qubit array (2025), arXiv:2506.18228 [quant-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2506.18228
  41. [41]C. Li, Y. Wu, M. C. C. Pace, M. D. LaHaye, M. Senatore, and H. X. Tang, Superfluid-cooled transmon qubits under optical excitation, PRX Quantum 6, 030303 (2025).DOI
  42. [42]V. Iaia, J. Ku, A. Ballard, C. P. Larson, E. Yelton, C. H. Liu, S. Patel, R. McDermott, and B. L. T. Plourde, Phonon downconversion to suppress correlated errors in superconducting qubits, Nature Communications 13, 6425 (2022).DOI
  43. [43]E. Yelton, C. P. Larson, V. Iaia, K. Dodge, G. La Magna, P. G. Baty, I. V. Pechenizhsky, R. McDermott, N. A. Kurinsky, G. Catelani, and B. L. T. Plourde, Modeling phonon-mediated quasiparticle poisoning in superconducting qubit arrays, Physical Review B 110, 024519 (2024).
  44. [44]C. P. Larson, E. Yelton, K. Dodge, K. Okubo, J. Batarekh, V. Iaia, N. A. Kurinsky, and B. L. T. Plourde, Phonon downconversion to suppress correlated errors in superconducting qubits with active gamma irradiation, PRX Quantum 6, 030339 (2025).
  45. [45]W. Matava and M. R. Williams, Photon calibration techniques for high resolution cryogenic detectors, Phys. Rev. D 114, 032007 (2026).
  46. [46]M. Kelsey, R. Agnese, Y. Alam, et al., G4CMP: Condensed matter physics simulation using the Geant4 toolkit, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 1055, 168473 (2023).DOI
  47. [47]I. Hernandez, R. Linehan, R. Khatiwada, et al., Modeling athermal phonons in novel materials using the G4CMP simulation toolkit, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 1073, 170172 (2025).DOI
  48. [48]K. Stifter, H. Magoon, A. J. Anderson, et al., Cryogenic optical beam steering for superconducting device calibration, Journal of Optical Microsystems 5, 024503 (2025).DOI
  49. [49]N. Tabassum, T. Aralis, J. Anczarski, et al., Broadband optical modulation and control at millikelvin temperatures, Review of Scientific Instruments 96, 103101 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2504.06995
  50. [50]S. J. S. Tan, C. A. Pattison, M. McEwen, and J. Preskill, Resilience of the surface code to error bursts, Physical Review A 113, 022450 (2026), arXiv:2406.18897 [quant-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2406.18897

Paper details

Contents