In this paper
AbstractHeinzer's question and its status in the literatureA derivation with prescribed valuesDivisoriality of all idealsAn upper to zeroAcknowledgmentReferencesWorksMathematics
A divisorial domain with non-Prüfer normalization
Abstract
We answer a 1968 question of Heinzer by constructing a two-dimensional local divisorial domain whose normalization is not Prüfer.
Heinzer's question and its status in the literature
Let be a domain with fraction field . For -submodules , of , write . The divisorial closure of a nonzero fractional ideal is . The domain is divisorial if for every such . Its normalization is its integral closure in . In 1968 Heinzer [2] asked whether must be a Prüfer domain whenever is divisorial. A Prüfer domain is one in which each nonzero finitely generated ideal is invertible.
Two classical cases give an affirmative answer. An integrally closed divisorial domain is Prüfer [2 Theorem 5.1]. A Noetherian divisorial domain that is not a field has dimension one [2 Corollary 4.3], so its normalization is Dedekind by the Krull–Akizuki theorem. Gabelli, Houston and Picozza [1 Questions 3.7 and 3.8] restated Heinzer’s question and proved it equivalent to asking whether every -divisorial domain is a -domain. A domain is -divisorial if each of its -ideals is divisorial. In particular, every divisorial domain is -divisorial.
In 2026 Tran, Vo and Nguyen [6] answered a question of Vasconcelos by constructing a one-dimensional coherent local domain with non-Prüfer normalization. Kim [3 Theorem A] proved that the same domain is Gorenstein Prüfer. In particular, each of its nonzero finitely generated ideals is divisorial. Heinzer’s question requires the identity also for infinitely generated ideals.
Theorem 1.1. For each prime , put , where the are algebraically independent. There exists a two-dimensional local divisorial domain of characteristic with normalization . In particular, is not Prüfer, and fails the condition.
The construction uses a derivation to obtain a subring of a prescribed normal domain, an approach also used by Olberding [4]. Here the derivation takes values in the injective hull of the residue field of . This choice controls annihilators in every quotient by a nonzero nonunit.
A derivation with prescribed values
Write and let be the injective hull of . For an ideal and a module over the same ring, put , and write .
Lemma 2.1. There is an -derivation which is surjective as a map of additive groups.
Proof. The equality holds over the Noetherian local ring [5 Lemma 47.7.3]. Each has finite length. Indeed is exact and sends the simple module to , the socle of . As is countable, so is . Enumerate its elements as .
In the ordinary module of Kähler differentials , the are -linearly independent. For each , the derivation of extends coefficientwise to : the product rule holds since each coefficient of a product is a finite sum. The corresponding -linear functional on takes to the Kronecker delta . On the free submodule , send to . Injectivity of extends this map to all of . Its composite with the universal derivation has , so its image contains every element of .
Fix such a and put . This is a local domain with maximal ideal , since an element invertible in satisfies . In characteristic we have , so is integral over . For each , a power of kills . Choose with . Then and both belong to , so . Since is integrally closed, . Integrality gives . In a local Prüfer domain every nonzero finitely generated ideal is principal, whereas . Thus is not Prüfer.
Divisoriality of all ideals
Lemma 3.1. Let be a square-zero ideal of a commutative ring . Suppose is complete Noetherian local with residue field and as an -module. Then as -modules. Every ideal of satisfies .
Proof. Since is nilpotent, is local with residue field . Set . Its submodule is injective over by adjunction and contains essentially. Hence it is . Fix an isomorphism and extend it by injectivity to a -linear map .
Matlis duality identifies scalar multiplication with the completion map [5 Lemma 47.7.5], hence with an isomorphism. In particular is faithful over . If , then for every . Faithfulness gives , where is injective. To see surjectivity, take . The map has image in because . Composing with gives an endomorphism of , hence multiplication by some . Lift it to . Then for every , so .
Finally, if , the nonzero cyclic submodule generated by in has a quotient in which its generator survives. Embed in and extend the resulting homomorphism to . Under , the image of annihilates and has nonzero product with . This proves the double-annihilator identity.
Proposition 3.2. For , the map is onto. Its kernel is square-zero and is isomorphic to as an -module.
Proof. Multiplication by on is onto. For any , the -linear map sending to extends to , as is regular and is injective. Lemma 2.1 therefore gives, for any , some with . Then , proving surjectivity.
The kernel is . If , then , whence and . Thus . The assignment
is well-defined and injective because and is regular. It is onto because , and whenever . It is -linear since is onto and for . Finally is injective over and contains essentially, so it is .
Let be any nonzero proper ideal of , and choose . The ring is complete Noetherian local, so Lemma 3.1 applies to by Proposition 3.2. For the fractional colon lies in , because , and contains . Consequently
Applying the double-annihilator identity to yields
The identity is immediate for . Clearing a denominator extends it to every nonzero fractional ideal because for . This proves the divisoriality assertion of Theorem 1.1.
An upper to zero
A nonzero prime of contracting to zero in is called an upper to zero. A domain is a UMT-domain if each upper to zero is a maximal -ideal of . Here is the union of over the nonzero finitely generated subideals . In particular every nonzero divisorial ideal is a -ideal, since .
Corollary 4.1. In , the kernel of evaluation at is an upper to zero strictly contained in the proper -ideal .
Proof. Evaluation is injective on and its target is a field. Its kernel is nonzero since . If , then in . The monomials give a -basis of , so the residue of every in is zero. Thus , and witnesses strict inclusion.
Since , it is an intersection of principal fractional ideals of . Extending each to preserves this intersection, as membership is determined coefficientwise. Hence is divisorial in , and therefore a proper -ideal. This proves the remaining assertion of Theorem 1.1. □
Acknowledgment
The counterexample and its proof were generated through discussions with ChatGPT 6 Astra, which also assisted in drafting the manuscript.
Department of Mathematics, National University of Singapore, Singapore 119076
Email address: [email protected]
URL: https://vh-tran.github.io/
References
- [1]Stefania Gabelli, Evan Houston, and Giampaolo Picozza, w-divisoriality in polynomial rings, Comm. Algebra 37 (2009), no. 3, 1117–1127, doi:10.1080/00927870802278982.DOI
- [2]William Heinzer, Integral domains in which each non-zero ideal is divisorial, Mathematika 15 (1968), no. 2, 164–170, doi:10.1112/S0025579300002527.DOI
- [3]Hwankoo Kim, Gorenstein Prüfer domains with non-Prüfer integral closure, Preprint, arXiv:2610.15444, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2610.15444
- [4]Bruce Oberding, A counterpart to Nagata idealization, J. Algebra 365 (2012), 199–221, doi:10.1016/j.jalgebra.2012.05.002.
- [5]The Stacks Project Authors, Injective hull of the residue field, The Stacks Project, Section 47.7 (Tag 0821).
- [6]Viet-Hoang Tran, Thieu N. Vo, and Tan M. Nguyen, A one-dimensional coherent domain with non-Prüfer integral closure, Preprint, arXiv:2609.21013, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2609.21013