WorksMathematics
-modules on affine algebraic groups
Abstract
We study -modules on an affine algebraic group , that is, modules that admit compatible actions of the algebra of regular functions on and the Lie algebra of vector fields. A central role in this theory is played by the Lie algebra of jets of vector fields. Our main result is the Decomposition Theorem for the Lie algebra of jets of vector fields. We apply the Decomposition Theorem to describe differentiable -modules on .
Introduction
The theory of -modules on algebraic groups has been instrumental in the proof of the Kazhdan-Lusztig conjecture by Brylinski-Kashiwara and Beilinson-Bernstein [11, 3, 15]. In this paper, we discuss -modules on algebraic groups, which are natural generalizations of -modules. Geometric objects like tensor fields do not form a -module under the Lie derivative action, but belong to the category of -modules. The theory of -modules was successfully used in establishing classifications of simple Harish-Chandra modules for Lie algebras of vector fields on a torus [4], and on the affine space [13, 18].
An -module on a connected affine algebraic group is a module that admits an action of the algebra of regular functions on , and an action of the Lie algebra of vector fields, with the Leibniz rule as a compatibility condition (see Definition 1 in the next Section). The pair of algebras forms a Rinehart pair [16], and the category of -modules is governed by the weak enveloping algebra , which is the smash product of the Hopf algebra with its module : . This algebra was first introduced by Jacobson in [14]. This associative algebra has a Lie subalgebra , the smash product of the Lie algebra with a commutative algebra , on which acts by derivations. The Lie algebra has a geometric interpretation as the Lie algebra of algebraic jets of vector fields, and its completion, , is the Lie algebra of -jets of vector fields.
The Lie algebra has an interesting structure, and is important for understanding the theory of -modules. The central result of the paper is the Decomposition Theorem (Theorem 10 in § 4), which states that on an affine algebraic
2020 Mathematics Subject Classification. Primary 17B66; Secondary 13N15. group , there exists a semidirect product decomposition
where is the Lie algebra of vector fields on , vanishing at the identity element . We point out that this is a non-trivial isomorphism – in the semidirect product, neither is mapped to the Lie algebra of vector fields , nor is identified with a subalgebra in . Previously, such a Decomposition Theorem was known for affine space [18, 8], the torus, and only locally for an affine variety [7].
In order to prove the Decomposition Theorem, we generalize the classical Taylor formula
to the setting of functions on algebraic groups (Theorem 7 in § 3). We replace the family with a basis of the universal enveloping algebra of the Lie algebra of left-invariant vector fields, and view as a basis for the algebra of -invariants in .
The most important class of -modules is the category of differentiable -modules. An -module is called -differentiable if it is annihilated by the elements
for all .
-modules are precisely -differentiable -modules, and all tensor modules are -differentiable. Using the Decomposition Theorem, we prove that -differentiable -modules on are modules for the associative algebra , where is the Lie algebra of , and is the ideal of functions on vanishing at .
Our description is more detailed for -differentiable -modules on . Such a module is given by a -module structure on , together with an action of , , which commutes with the action of . In Theorem 17, we give an explicit formula for this correspondence.
In the final section of this paper, we point out that the Lax equation emerges in the context of -differentiable -modules, connecting them to the theory of integrable dynamical systems.
The paper is organized as follows. In § 2, we outline the basic definitions related to -modules, Rinehart pairs, and jets of vector fields. We generalize the Taylor formula to the context of affine algebraic groups in § 3. In § 4, we establish the Decomposition Theorem, the main result of the paper. In § 5, we present examples of -modules, focusing on -differentiable modules.
Acknowledgements. Both authors gratefully acknowledge support from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada through Discovery Grants. We benefited from helpful discussions with ChatGPT.
-modules and jets of vector fields
Let be a commutative associative algebra over a field of characteristic zero. Assume that the Lie algebra acts on by derivations.
Definition 1. An -module is a module for and also a module for the Lie algebra , with two actions compatible via the Leibniz rule:
Just as the universal enveloping algebra controls the category of modules for Lie algebra , there is an associative algebra that controls the category of -modules. The weak enveloping algebra is the smash product of the Hopf algebra with its module [14]. As a vector space, it is the tensor product with multiplication
where is the coproduct written in Sweedler notations. An -module is the same as a module over the associative algebra .
It turns out that the subspace is a Lie subalgebra of .
Definition 2. Let be a commutative associative algebra on which the Lie algebra acts by derivations. The smash product is a Lie algebra whose underlying space is and the Lie bracket is given by
We are particularly interested in the case where is the algebra of regular functions on a smooth irreducible affine algebraic variety and . In this setting, is the Lie algebra of vector fields on . Such a pair is an example of a Rinehart pair [16]:
Definition 3. Let be a commutative associative algebra, and let be a Lie algebra. The pair is a Rinehart pair if acts on by derivations, and is an -module, satisfying:
There are two natural categories of modules for a Rinehart pair: -modules, also known as weak modules, and -modules, also known as strong modules, satisfying (1) as well as the following axiom:
The algebra itself is a -module for a Rinehart pair , while is an -module, but not a -module in general.
The category of -modules is controlled by the strong enveloping algebra [16], which is the quotient
When is the algebra of regular functions on a smooth irreducible affine variety , and , the strong enveloping algebra is the algebra of differential operators on [2]. As we shall see below, in this context, the Lie algebra may be interpreted as the Lie algebra of algebraic jets of vector fields on .
If acts on by derivations, then the pair is a Rinehart pair. Moreover,
Let be the kernel of the multiplication map . The quotient is the algebra of -jets of functions on , and the completion
is the algebra of -jets of functions (see Chapter 10 in [1] for the basics on the completions of algebras).
The space is an ideal in the Lie algebra , and the quotient is the Lie algebra of -jets of vector fields on . The completion
is the Lie algebra of jets of vector fields on [7]. Since , the Lie algebra injects into the Lie algebra of -jets of vector fields. Thus, may be interpreted as the Lie algebra of algebraic jets of vector fields.
We now turn to the principal setting of this paper, the case when the underlying variety is a connected affine algebraic group, .
There are three natural actions of on itself: left translation: , right translation: , and the action by conjugation: , with . Note that the left and right actions of commute. These induce three actions of on the algebra of regular functions on : , , for . Likewise, there are three actions of on : , etc. A vector field is called left-invariant if for all .
Let be the tangent space to at the identity , which may be identified with the space of derivations at the identity: , for , . We construct a left-invariant vector field which restricts to at the identity: . Likewise, we construct a right-invariant vector field , which restricts to at the identity: . The negative sign is needed in order for the two constructions to induce the same Lie bracket on . We get two isomorphic subalgebras and of left- and right-invariant vector fields in . Alternatively, and may be expressed using the coproduct , . Then , .
Note that the elements of are the differentials of the right action of on , and are the differentials of the left action.
There is also a homomorphism induced by the conjugation action, . The kernel of this homomorphism is . Since evaluates to zero at the identity, it preserves the maximal ideal .
The Lie algebra of vector fields on an affine algebraic group is a free -module generated by either or [5]:
In fact, these tensor products are smash products of with and . For the Lie algebra of algebraic jets of vector fields, we have the double smash product construction:
In this setting, Lie bracket takes the following form:
Taylor formula for functions on algebraic groups
In this section, we will establish the Taylor formula for functions on algebraic groups.
The algebra of functions on is a -module under the diagonal left action of . Denote by the subalgebra of -invariants under this action. Since the differential of the left action of on yields the action of the Lie algebra of right-invariant vector fields , we conclude that is the kernel of the action of on the tensor product .
Lemma 4. as algebras.
Proof. The isomorphism maps and are given by
It is easy to see that the image of is consists of left-invariant functions, and that these maps are the inverses of each other:
where in the last equality follows from left-invariance.
Since the left and right actions of commute, is a -module under the actions , , and . It is straightforward to check the following claims:
Lemma 5. Under the isomorphism , the action corresponds to the left -action on , corresponds to the right -action , and corresponds to the conjugation action of on .
Corollary 6. Under the isomorphism , (i) , (ii) , (iii) , for .
Proof. This follows from the fact that left-invariant vector fields are the differentials of the -action, and right-invariant vector fields are the differentials of the -action of .
Consider the pairing , given by applying the differential operator to function and evaluating the result at the identity element of . Let be the standard augmentation filtration on . Here , , etc. Consider also the decreasing filtration on by powers of the maximal ideal : . Since acts on by differential operators of order less or equal to , it trivially pairs to , and we get a pairing of finite-dimensional spaces:
By Cartier’s Theorem ([12] II.6.1), this pairing is non-degenerate, and we can choose dual bases with respect to this pairing. By increasing the value of , inductively, we construct dual bases in and in .
Recall the classical Taylor formula:
We view both sides as functions on , where the first copy is parametrized by and the second copy by . Note that the expression is translation invariant (under the diagonal action of the additive group on ). Thus, . The Taylor formula yields the statement . The following theorem generalizes this to an arbitrary affine algebraic group.
Theorem 7 (Taylor formula). Let be the algebra of regular functions on an affine algebraic group over a field of characteristic zero. Then
given by the Taylor formula
The completion in the left hand side is
and the completion in the right hand side is
Applying the isomorphism , we obtain a non-trivial isomorphism
The above maps are isomorphisms of -modules with respect to the action of on the left tensor factors.
Proof. First, let us establish the formula
Cartier’s pairing yields a generalization of the Maclaurin formula:
in the completion of with respect to the -adic topology. Applying the Maclaurin formula to , we get
Since are left-invariant, this yields
Setting , we obtain (6). Next, we apply (6) to the second argument of :
Note that the change of variables transforms -adic topology into -adic topology, . The claims of the theorem follow. □
Decomposition theorem for the jets of vector fields
In this section, we apply the Taylor formula to establish a decomposition theorem for the jets of vector fields on . Since , we get that
Next, applying (5), we obtain
Taking into account the decomposition , we get
We claim that the first summand on the right-hand side forms a Lie subalgebra, while the second summand is an ideal. Let us compute the Lie brackets.
Lemma 8. The subspace in forms a subalgebra, which is isomorphic to .
Proof. By comparing formula (2) for the Lie brackets in the smash product with the formula for the Lie bracket in , we see that the map , , for , , is an isomorphism of Lie algebras. □
We point out that the subalgebra is distinct from the natural subalgebra of vector fields of the Lie algebra of algebraic jets of vector fields .
Denote by the subalgebra of vector fields vanishing at : . Since is an ideal in , we can take the completion:
We will also need the completion
We point out that tensor products do not commute with inverse limits in general. Let and with . Let and , where is the ideal of functions vanishing at and is the unique maximal ideal of . By [6] (Lemma 6), . Also, for every ,
Lemma 9. The subspace in is a Lie subalgebra isomorphic to with Lie bracket
extended to the completion by continuity.
Proof. We need to compute the Lie bracket in . Since , the terms with in (4) vanish, and we get
Applying Corollary 6, we get
This matches the Lie bracket in . □
Note that is a -module under the conjugation action . This follows from the fact that the identity element is fixed by conjugation. This -action induces a -module structure on , where acts as vector field . The fact that and evaluate to opposite vectors at , gives us an alternative proof of invariance of under this action of .
Now we are ready to prove the main result of the paper:
Theorem 10 (Decomposition Theorem). Let be a connected affine algebraic group. Then decomposes into a semidirect product:
with the following action of on the ideal :
extended to the completion by continuity. In this isomorphism, the embedding maps and are given by
extended to completions by continuity.
Remark 11. The semidirect product has a subalgebra with the Lie bracket
The Lie algebra is a completed smash product of with , where acts on via , and acts on trivially.
Proof. We have already seen in Lemmas 8 and 9 that the maps and are embeddings of Lie algebras. We need to compute the Lie bracket of the images of and in . For this, we use (4):
Since for , we get that . By Corollary 6, . The above expression simplifies to
This matches the Lie bracket in the semidirect product . We point out that the embedding respects the filtrations: the image of is in . This means that this embedding extends by continuity to a homomorphism of completed Lie algebras, which becomes an isomorphism by the Taylor formula. □
The most important class of -modules is the category of differentiable -modules. Let us recall the definition.
Definition 12. An -module is called -differentiable if it is annihilated by operators
for all , .
Equivalently, an -module is -differentiable if it is annihilated by . -modules are precisely 1-differentiable -modules.
Corollary 13. -differentiable -modules on an affine algebraic group are precisely modules for the associative algebra , which is the smash product of a Hopf algebra with its module . Here acts on by left-invariant derivations, whereas the action of on is trivial.
Proof. -differentiable -modules are strong modules for the Rinehart pair . Since we are considering here a truncation of a filtration, we have an isomorphism . Applying the Decomposition Theorem, we get . Again, since we truncate the filtration, we have . We conclude that is isomorphic to the smash product . However,
which establishes the claim.
Free -modules of finite rank and the Lax equation
In this final section, we will discuss a few examples of -modules on affine algebraic groups. We say that an -module has finite rank (resp. free) if it is finitely generated (resp. free) as an -module.
The first natural class of -modules has a geometric origin. These are tensor modules. The space of vector fields on is a free -module of finite rank, . Its dual is the space of 1-forms, , which is also a free -module, . By taking the tensor product over of copies of and copies of , we obtain the -module of -tensor fields, which will again be a free module of finite rank. All tensor modules are 2-differentiable.
Let us generalize the construction of -tensor modules. By Corollary 13, every 2-differentiable -module is a module for . Note that .
Proposition 14. In the semidirect product , the action of on is the tensor product of the adjoint and coadjoint representations.
Proof. In the semidirect product, acts on via the tensor product of the conjugation action and the adjoint action. Consider the pairing
given by . Let us check that this is an invariant pairing of -modules, where acts on via and on via . Indeed for ,
Since and commute, we have
However, the vector field vanishes at , which means that . The space is identified with via the above pairing, and the invariance property means that it is isomorphic to the coadjoint -module. Hence, is isomorphic to as a -module. □
Proposition 15. Consider the action of on via the tensor product of the adjoint and coadjoint actions. The corresponding semidirect product splits, as Lie algebras.
Proof. The action of on gives a homomorphism . It is easy to see that the derived subalgebra and the center of a Lie algebra are invariant under every derivation of that Lie algebra. This means that the subspaces and are invariant under for every . We claim that . Since is an invariant subspace, it is sufficient to show that . Choose dual bases of and of . Then , and
We conclude that . However, every derivation of is inner, . Composing these maps, we get a homomorphism that realizes the action by inner derivations. It is easy to see that elements span a subalgebra of which is isomorphic to and commutes with . This proves that the semidirect product splits. □
Corollary 16. A -differentiable -module on an affine algebraic group is precisely a -module on equipped with an additional action of , , where the action of commutes with the action of .
Let us present explicit formulas for the -module action in the setting of the above corollary.
Given , , we view as an element of . In the Lie algebra , acts on trivially.
For , the differential belongs to , with . Then .
Theorem 17 (ChatGPT). Let be an affine algebraic group. Let be a -module on , and simultaneously a -module, with commuting actions. Then admits a structure of an -module with -action defined by the -module structure and the following action of :
The right-hand side is viewed as an operator on , where the first term comes from the -module action, and the other two terms correspond to the action of .
Proof. We point out that the action of on is -linear, since the action of commutes with the action of , and hence the action of . We need to show that the formula defines a representation of on . For this, we record the Lie brackets involving the operators appearing on the right-hand side.
These relations are straightforward to verify, and the fact that is a representation of easily follows. □
In particular, if is a -module on and is a -module, then admits the structure of a -differentiable -module on .
Let us now discuss free -modules of finite rank. By the theorem of Bouaziz-Rocha [10], every finitely generated -module is differentiable, and hence by Corollary 13, admits the action of for some . This algebra contains a subalgebra , which is the algebra of differential operators on . Hence -differentiable -modules are -modules with an additional action of the Lie algebra , compatible with the -module structure.
Let be a free -module of finite rank, , . The -module structure is determined by the action of on : . Such a map is encoded by a 1-form on with values in . Then the action of on is given by
In order for this to yield a Lie algebra action, the form must satisfy the condition
or equivalently,
Let . A change of basis in is described by the group . Under a change of basis given by , the 1-form transforms as [9]:
Let us consider the simplest case, . The condition on in this case is just , i.e., the form must be closed. In particular, we may take an exact form, , , and the action of on this -module will be given by
Note that . If the units of are scalars, two such -modules are non-isomorphic unless is a constant function [5].
Now let us see how a free rank-one -module can be turned into an -module. For this, we need to define a compatible action of . Since is abelian, the derived subalgebra must act trivially. The quotient by the derived subalgebra is 1-dimensional and is spanned by the identity operator in . Assume that acts as multiplication by . Since the action of must commute with the action of , we see that for all , so must be a scalar in . The action of on the corresponding -module is
Let us generalize the above construction of an -module to higher rank. Let satisfy the condition
Fix . Then satisfies (7) and yields a -module structure on :
Theorem 18. Let be an affine algebraic group. Let satisfy (8) and
Let . Then we have an -module structure on , where the action of is given by
Proof. To construct a differentiable -module on , we need to take a -module on and define on it a compatible -linear action of . For the construction presented in this theorem, we take a -module given by (9), and we define the action of , where the derived subalgebra is acting trivially and the identity element acts by . Let us verify that these actions are compatible. The compatibility condition for this setting is that the action of must commute with the -module action (see the proof of Proposition 15). Indeed, using (10), we get
Applying Theorem 10 to combine the two actions, we recover (11). □
We point out that when , condition (8) holds trivially, while (10) becomes
This is known as the Lax equation in the theory of integrable systems. Many integrable systems may be expressed through the Lax equation. Finite-dimensional integrable systems of classical mechanics are written in Lax form in the context of algebraic groups. The Kovalevskaya top provides one such example [17]. System (10) is a generalized Lax equation with commuting flows. Thus, the construction reveals a connection between the Lax equation and the theory of -modules.
Conjecture 19. Let be the algebra of regular functions on a connected simplyconnected affine algebraic group. Every finitely generated projective -module is free.
School of Mathematics and Statistics, Carleton University, Ottawa, Canada
Email address: [email protected]
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]M.F. Atiyah, I.G. MacDonald, Introduction to Commutative Algebra, Vol. 2, Addison-Wesley, 1969.
- [2]V. V. Bavula, Generators and defining relations for the ring of differential operators on a smooth affine algebraic variety, Algebras and Representation Theory, 13 (2010), 159-187.arxiv.org/abs/math/0504475
- [3]A. Beilinson, J. Bernstein, Localisation de g-modules, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris Sér. I Math., 292 (1981), 15-18.
- [4]Y. Billig, V. Futorny, Classification of irreducible representations of Lie algebra of vector fields on a torus, J. für die reine und angewandte Mathematik (Crelles Journal), 2016.720 (2016), 199-216.
- [5]Y. Billig, V. Futorny, Lie algebras of vector fields on smooth affine varieties, Comm. Algebra, 46 (2018), 3413-3429.
- [6]Y. Billig, V. Futorny, J. Nilsson, Representations of Lie algebras of vector fields on affine varieties, Israel J. Math., 233 (2019), 379-399.arxiv.org/abs/1709.08863
- [7]Y. Billig, C. Ingalls, A universal sheaf of algebras governing representations of vector fields on quasi-projective varieties, Proc. of the Amer. Math. Soc. 154 (2026), 1385-1399.
- [8]Y. Billig, C. Ingalls, A. Nasr, AV-modules of finite type on affine space, J. Algebra, 623 (2023), 481-495.DOI
- [9]A. Borel et al., Algebraic D-modules, Perspectives in Mathematics, 2, Academic Press, 1987.
- [10]E. Bouaziz, H. Rocha, Annihilators of AV-modules and differential operators, J. Algebra, 636 (2023), 869-887.DOI
- [11]J.-L. Brylinski, M. Kashiwara, Kazhdan-Lusztig conjecture and holonomic systems, Invent. Math. 64 (1981), 387-410.DOI
- [12]M. Demazure, P. Gabriel, Introduction to algebraic geometry and algebraic groups, North-Holland Mathematics Studies, 39, Elsevier, 1980.
- [13]D. Grantcharov, V. Serganova, Simple weight modules with finite weight multiplicities over the Lie algebra of polynomial vector fields, J. Reine Angew. Math., 792 (2022), 93-114.arxiv.org/abs/2102.09064
- [14]N. Jacobson, Lie Algebras, Interscience Publishers, 1962.
- [15]R. Hotta, K. Takeuchi, T. Tanisaki, D-modules, perverse sheaves, and representation theory. Progress in Math., 236, Springer, 2007.
- [16]G. S. Rinehart, Differential forms on general commutative algebras, Transactions AMS, 108 (1963), 195-222.DOI
- [17]A. V. Tsiganov, The Kowalewski top: A new Lax representation, J. Math. Phys., 38 (1997), 196-211.DOI
- [18]Y. Xue, R. Lü, Classification of simple bounded weight modules of the Lie algebra of vector fields on C^n, Israel J. Math., 253 (2023), 445-468.