betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The drainage of glacier and ice sheet surface lakes

Abstract

Supraglacial lakes play a central role in storing melt water, enhancing surface melt, and ultimately in driving ice flow and ice shelf melt through injecting water into the subglacial environment and facilitating fracturing. Here, we develop a model for the drainage of supraglacial lakes through the dissipation-driven incision of a surface channel. The model consists of the St Venant equations for flow in the channel, fed by an upstream lake reservoir, coupled with an equation for the evolution of channel elevation due to advection, uplift, and downward melting. After reduction to a `stream power'-type hyperbolic model, we show that lake drainage occurs above a critical rate of water supply to the lake due to the backward migration of a shock that incises the lake seal. The critical water supply rate depends on advection velocity and uplift (or more precisely, drawdown downstream of the lake) as well as model parameters such as channel wall roughness and the parameters defining the relationship between channel cross-section and wetted perimeter. Once lake drainage does occur, it can either continue until the lake is empty, or terminate early, leading to oscillatory cycles of lake filling and draining, with the latter favoured by large lake volumes and relatively small water supply rates.

Introduction

Large areas of the Greenland ice sheet experience surface melt water drainage [1], while surface drainage is confined to lower elevations in Antarctica [2] [3, 4]. Surface melt drives the evolution of subglacial drainage system in Greenland [5, 6, 7], which in turn controls sliding speed [8, 9, 10, 11]. Accumulation of surface water can also enhance surface melting by reducing albedo [12, 13] and cause the break-up of floating ice shelves [14, 15, 16, 17], while the injection of surface melt under a floating ice tongue can drive convection in fjords [18, 19], and enhance as well as localize melting at the base of the ice tongue [20, 21].1

Lakes situated in local depressions on the ice surface are common features of drainage systems in both, Greenland and Antarctica. These lakes store water, enhance surface melt and, in the case of Greenland, can cause short-lived acceleration of ice flow through abrupt drainage to the bed by hydrofracturing [8, 22, 23, 24]. Much research has focused on the latter effect, even though a significant fraction of surface lakes in Greenland either drain slowly or not at all [1] [25, 26, 27, 28, 29], while there are no known surface lakes on the grounded part of the Antarctic ice sheet that drain to the bed [30].

Motivated by field observations made in Antarctica [31], we consider the case of lakes draining purely through channels incised into the surface of a grounded ice sheet (as opposed to a floating ice shelf). The observations in question specifically suggest that a surface lake on a grounded portion of the ice sheet may be capable of draining through a near-surface channel incised into the ice in the absence of any significance forcing (that is, at the end of winter) after a lengthy period of apparently steady lake filling levels. While similar overland drainage may also be relevant to higher elevations in Greenland [28], where few lakes drain through hydrofracture [1], we neglect seepage into a firn aquifer in our work [32, 33], which may be relevant for some of these Greenlandic lakes.

There have only been a handful of attempts to model lake drainage along glacier and ice sheet surfaces through thermal erosion of a channel through an ice dam [34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39]. Most of these consider drainage along more steeply-angled glacier surfaces, where flow is likely to be Froude supercritical. In all of these previous studies except Kingslake et al. [38], surface lakes are considered as natural hazards, with the ultimate aim of computing hydrographs for rapid surface drainage. In addition, and by contrast with models for drainage along the glacier bed [40, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46] none of the surface drainage models listed resolve channel incision (and therefore channel slope) as a function of position along the flow path, but instead take the form of ‘lumped’ models intended to describe conditions near the channel intake only.

Although the model we develop is in principle applicable to the outburst floods studied previously, our main goal differs substantially from these prior studies. We are interested primarily in whether water input to a lake, causing the lake to overflow, necessarily leads to lake drainage by channel incision, and whether drainage can be partial or must continue until the lake basin is completely empty. As a result, we focus on systems in which incision of the channel is quite slow, and competes with horizontal advection and vertical uplift of the ice surface due to the flow of the ice sheet over bed topography. These latter two processes are responsible for shaping the surface depression occupied by the lake to begin with [47], but have rarely been considered in the context of surface lake dynamics [48] and are not incorporated in the existing models for rapid lake drainage. Among other consequences, the incorporation of advection forces us to employ a partial differential equation-based model, resolving position along the channel as well as time.

Our model bears close resemblance to so-called stream power models for fluvial landscape evolution in non-glacial contexts [49]. The latter typically incorporate uplift [e.g. 50, 51, 52], but the additional effect of horizontal advection is not commonly considered as part of fluvial landscape evolution. It is however key to studying supraglacial lake evolution: while incision due to erosion (or in our case, melting) leads to a backward-propagating steepening of the channel bed, advection simultaneously moves the steepening bed in a forward direction. In the absence of that forward advection, a lake at the upstream end of the channel will invariably be breached by channel incision if there is a non-zero water supply, but this is not the case in the presence of advection.

The paper is organized as follows: In §2.1 we define a basic model consisting of the St Venant equations for a surface stream coupled with an evolution equation for channel depth, based on local dissipation driving channel incision. In §2.2–2.4, the model is reduced based on a small ratio of water depth in the channel to lake depth, and water velocities being much larger than ice velocities, while local Froude number is assumed to remain subcritical. This results in a nonlinear hyperbolic evolution equation for channel evolution [49], coupled to an evolution equation for lake volume (§ 15.1). The formation of shocks in the model and how they control discharge from the lake is studied in §3.2–§ 3.4, with boundary layer solutions of the full model around the shocks relegated to appendices A–B. Numerical solutions by the method of characteristics (appendix D) are given in §4, where we show that lake drainage occurs above a critical value of water supply to the lake (§4.2), which can result in either in complete lake drainage or oscillatory cycles of lake drainage and refilling (§ 4.3).

Geometry of the problem: water surface in blue, channel / lake bottom in black, ice surface as dashed black line

Figure 1. Geometry of the problem: water surface in blue, channel / lake bottom in black, ice surface as dashed black line. Some of the symbols used here (bmb_m, xmx_m, xsx_s and xpx_p) are defined in the context of a leading-order model in sections 2.2–3)

Model

Model Formulation

We consider a surface melt water stream with cross-sectional area SS, with the base of the stream channel at an elevation bb, and the velocity in the stream being uu. Let xx be distance along the stream and tt time, and let SS, uu and bb depend on xx and $t ({xref}figure 1). Assuming a Darcy-Weisbach law governing shear stress at the walls of the channel, we express conservation of mass and momentum using a St Venant model as {citep}[e.g. 53, chapter 4]`

ρw[St+(uS)x]=ρm,(1)\rho_w \left[S_t + (uS)_x\right] = \rho m, \tag*{(1)}
ρwS(ut+uux)=−ρwfu2P(S)8−ρwgS[bx+h(S)x](2)\rho_w S(u_t + uu_x) = -\frac{\rho_w f u^2 P(S)}{8} - \rho_w g S \left[b_x + h(S)_x\right] \tag*{(2)}

where subscripts xx and tt denote partial derivatives, mm is melt rate at the channel wall, expressed as an area of ice melted per unit time and unit length of channel, P(S)P(S) is the wetted perimeter of the channel and h(S)h(S) is the elevation of the water surface above the bottom of the channel. ρw\rho_w is the density of water and ff is a friction coefficient depending on wall roughness in the channel. Note that by equating the source term mm with melt rate, we ignore seepage into or out of a firn aquifer, or substantial water input from tributary streams.

To simplify matters, we assume that the cross-sectional area can grow or shrink but retains a shape determined by its size alone. Our main interest is in downward incision of the channel, which we assume to be a slow process compared with the adjustment of channel shape, since we will assume below that water depth is much less than the typical amplitude of channel elevation bb. Consequently, we treat PP and hh as non-decreasing functions of SS, whose form depends on the geometry of the cross-section. At a minimum, we know that water depth must vanish when cross-sectional area does, so h(0)=0h(0) = 0.

Cross-section shapes

Figure 2. Cross-section shapes: a) semi-circle (α=β=1/2\alpha= \beta= 1/2), b) triangular (α=β=1/2\alpha= \beta= 1/2) and c) fixed-width slot (α=0\alpha= 0, β=1\beta= 1). Water with cross-sectional area SS is shown in blue, wetted perimeter in heavy black. The qualitative nature of solution computed in section 4 depends on whether α=0\alpha= 0.

The simplest way to parameterize the cross-sectional shape of the channel is to treat it as a semi-circle (figure 2). In that case, the radius rr of the cross-section is r=(2π−1S)1/2r = (2\pi^{-1}S)^{1/2} and

P(S)=πr=(2πS)1/2,h(S)=r=(2π−1S)1/2(3)P(S) = \pi r = (2\pi S)^{1/2}, \qquad h(S) = r = (2\pi^{-1}S)^{1/2} \tag*{(3)}

Alternatives would be to assume the channel is triangular with a fixed angle θ\theta between the channel sides and the vertical

P(S)=2S1/2sin⁡(2θ)1/2,h(S)=S1/2cos⁡(θ)sin⁡(2θ)1/2(4)P(S) = \frac{2S^{1/2}}{\sin(2\theta)^{1/2}}, \qquad h(S) = \frac{S^{1/2}\cos(\theta)}{\sin(2\theta)^{1/2}} \tag*{(4)}

or to fix a width WW that is much greater than water depth, and to put [as is done in 53]

P(S)=W,h(S)=SW.(5)P(S) = W, \qquad h(S) = \frac{S}{W}. \tag*{(5)}

Generically, this suggests we consider

P(S)=c1Sα,h(S)=c2Sβ(6)P(S) = c_1S^\alpha, \qquad h(S) = c_2S^\beta \tag*{(6)}

with c1c_1, c2>0c_2 > 0, α≥0\alpha\ge0, β>0\beta> 0 (we admit that width and therefore wetted perimeter may not depend on SS, but water depth must, so β\beta cannot vanish while α\alpha can): (1c)–(1d) have α=β=1/2\alpha= \beta= 1/2 while (1e) puts α=0\alpha= 0, β=1\beta= 1. In fact, the examples above suggest that the product of wetted perimeter and water depth scale as the cross-sectional area, in which case α+β=1\alpha+ \beta= 1, and that the exponents are not only positive but also satisfy 0≤α<10 \le\alpha< 1, 0<β≤10 < \beta\le1.

We assume that energy dissipated by the flow is instantly transferred to the wall of the channel and turned into latent heat, and that this is the dominant mechanism of channel incision. A more sophisticated model could track the temperature of the water and use a heat transfer model [see also the discussion in 54]; here we assume that heat transfer is highly efficient at the length scales under consideration. Letting L\mathcal{L} be the latent heat of fusion per unit mass of water, we put

ρLm=−ρwfu3P(S)8,(7)\rho\mathcal{L}m = -\frac{\rho_w f u^3 P(S)}{8}, \tag*{(7)}

the right-hand side being the rate at which work is done per unit length of channel by water moving at velocity uu against the friction force ρfu2P(S)/8\rho f u^2 P(S)/8 on the channel wall. In order to model how fast the channel cuts into the ice, we assume that downward incision can be estimated by distributing melt equally over the wetted perimeter, leading to an incision rate of m/Pm/P. Future work will need to address both the channel shape parameterizations and the distribution of melt over the channel wall: related work on englacial channels [55] may serve as a template.

In addition, we assume that the ice surface is moving horizontally at a velocity UU and is subject to localized uplift or drawdown at a prescribed rate w(x)w(x) due to flow of the glacier or ice sheet over bed topography [e.g. 47], where we will later assume for simplicity that UU is constant in space as well as time, as is appropriate for instance for rapidly sliding ice. Then

bt+Ubx=w−mP(S).(8)b_t + U b_x = w - \frac{m}{P(S)}. \tag*{(8)}

We assume that the base of the channel is incised into an ice surface at elevation ss, with b≤sb \le s. In assuming that ww is constant in time, we are assuming not only that we can ignore localized, enhanced ‘creep closure’ around a deeply incised channel [56] as well as snow accumulation at the base of the channel during winter, but also that ss is in steady state [47], and itself satisfies

Usx=w.(9)U s_x = w. \tag*{(9)}

We will generally use b(x,0)=s(x)b(x,0) = s(x) as an initial condition, representing a channel that is only just beginning to incise into the ice surface. A modification of the present model to a dynamically evolving ice surface ss will be presented elsewhere.

We envisage the channel draining a reservoir at its upstream end. For simplicity, we assume that the seal point of the lake (the maximum in bb) is some distance downstream of x=0x = 0, and that we can relate lake volume directly to water level hh at x=0x = 0, and put

V˙=q0(t)−(uS)∣x=0,V(t)=VL(h(S(0,t))).(10)\dot{V} = q_0(t) - (uS)|_{x=0}, \qquad V(t) = V_L(h(S(0,t))). \tag*{(10)}

with the dot on V˙\dot{V} denoting an ordinary time derivative, q0q_0 being a prescribed rate of inflow to the lake due to surface melting in some larger upstream catchment. VLV_L is an increasing function of hh, dictated by the bathymetry of the lake. The bathymetry in turn is presumably determined by UU and ww, but we do not consider that in detail here, nor do we consider the possibility that surface loading due to the lake could affect the motion of the ice. As with an evolving ice surface ss, the latter complication will be studied in a separate paper.

Before we continue, we note some important limitations of the model. First, by assuming a fixed flow path and not modelling tortuosity, we are not considering the effect of meanders on flow and channel incision, even though meandering is known to be a common feature of glacier surface streams [e.g. 57, 58]. Second, the one-dimensional nature of the model implies not only that there is a single outflow from the lake, which is ultimately likely as two competing outflow channels are presumably prone to instability, with the larger channel persisting while the smaller is abandoned. It also implies that, if flow in the channel were to cease temporarily due for instance to seasonal variations in water supply q0q_0, the same channel will be re-occupied when flow recommences. We return to this in section 5.

In addition, we also neglect surface lowering due to melt driven by insolation or a warm atmosphere, or freezing due to heat fluxes into the ice. This may be reasonable for the incision of the channel relative to the rest of the ice surface ss, is more questionable for the lake itself. Here, enhanced absorption of incoming radiation in the lake water is likely to lead to preferential melting of the deeper portions of the lake [see also 59]. By the same token, we also neglect the possibility that the lake water could be warmed relative to the melting point by incoming solar radiation [see also 35]. That said, by omitting externally-driven melting, our model allows us to focus purely on the coupled effects of ice and water flow in the erosion of the channel and its effect on lake drainage.

Non-dimensionalization and a reduced model

We assume that a length scale [x][x] can be determined from the uplift field w(x)w(x), and that scales for vertical and horizontal ice velocities [w][w] and [U][U] are also known. In terms of these, we define scales [t][t], [S][S], [u][u], [b][b] and [V][V] through

ρwg[b][S][x]=ρwf[u]2P([S])8,ρw[u]38ρL=[W]=[U][b][x],[U][t]=[x].\frac{\rho_w g[b][S]}{[x]} = \frac{\rho_w f[u]^2P([S])}{8}, \qquad\frac{\rho_w[u]^3}{8\rho\mathcal{L}} = [W] = \frac{[U][b]}{[x]}, \qquad[U][t] = [x].

Our choice of scales here reflects the following: we are interested in significant channel incision over a single advective time scale [t]=[x]/[U][t] = [x]/[U] for the ice surface, so that uplift, advection and incision of the channel naturally compete with each other. Given a natural surface topography [b]=[w][x]/[U][b] = [w][x]/[U], that sets a dissipation rate and therefore a water flux scale [u][S][u][S]. It is possible to construct the same problem as below for a much shorter channel incision time scale, corresponding to greater dissipation and therefore water fluxes; that however precludes the generation of a lake, which requires the lake seal to be generated through uplift of the ice surface.

From these scales we obtain the dimensionless groups

ν=h([S])[b],Fr2=[u]2gh([S]),ε=g[b]L,δ=[U][u].(11)\nu= \frac{h([S])}{[b]}, \qquad Fr^2 = \frac{[u]^2}{gh([S])}, \qquad\varepsilon= \frac{g[b]}{\mathcal{L}}, \qquad\delta= \frac{[U]}{[u]}. \tag*{(11)}

These have straightforward interpretations: ν\nu is the ratio of water depth to ice surface topography, the Froude number FrFr is the usual square root of the ratio of kinetic to gravitational energy, ε\varepsilon is the ratio of gravitational potential energy to latent heat, and δ\delta is the ratio of ice to water velocity. With the possible exception of FrFr, we expect all of these parameters to be small: if water moved at speeds comparable to the ice, then surface drainage would presumably be of no interest, while the surface topography scale would have to be around 30 km with a terrestrial gravitational field g≈10 m s−1g \approx10\ \mathrm{m\ s^{-1}} in order for gravitational potential energy and latent heat L≈3.35×105 J kg−1\mathcal{L} \approx3.35 \times10^5\ \mathrm{J\ kg^{-1}} to be comparable. We also expect the water depth in a glacially-dammed lake to be larger than the flow depth in the stream draining it, except possibly during a very rapid outburst flood or for shallow lakes.

In fact, for realistic values of [U]=100 m a−1[U] = 100\ \mathrm{m\ a^{-1}}, [b]=10 m[b] = 10\ \mathrm{m}, [x]=1 km[x] = 1\ \mathrm{km}, g=9.8 m s−2g = 9.8\ \mathrm{m\ s^{-2}}, f=0.05f = 0.05, we obtain, with h(S)h(S) and P(S)P(S) given by (1c)

[u]=1.2 m s−1,[S]=0.47 m2,[u] = 1.2\ \mathrm{m\ s^{-1}}, \qquad[S] = 0.47\ \mathrm{m^2},

values that are realistic for surface streams with gentle [b]/[x]≈0.01[b]/[x] \approx0.01 slopes. With the choice of scales defined through (2), we define dimensionless variables through

x=[x]x∗,t=[t]t∗,u=[u]u∗,S=[S]S∗,b=[b]b∗,(12)x = [x]x^*, \qquad t = [t]t^*, \qquad u = [u]u^*, \qquad S = [S]S^*, \qquad b = [b]b^*, \tag*{(12)}

and define

P∗(S∗)=P(S)P([S]),h∗(S∗)=h(S)h([S]).(13)P^*(S^*) = \frac{P(S)}{P([S])}, \qquad h^*(S^*) = \frac{h(S)}{h([S])}. \tag*{(13)}

and also put U=[U]U∗U = [U]U^*, w=[w]w∗w = [w]w^*. Then, in dimensionless form, dropping the asterisks on the dimensionless variables immediately, the model becomes

δSt+(uS)x=εu3P(S),(14)\delta S_t + (uS)_x = \varepsilon u^3 P(S), \tag*{(14)}
νFr2S(δut+uux)=−u2P(S)−Sbx−νSh(S)x,(15)\nu Fr^2 S(\delta u_t + uu_x) = -u^2P(S) - Sb_x - \nu S h(S)_x, \tag*{(15)}

References

  1. [1]M.H. Holmes. Introduction to Perturbation Methods, volume 20 of Texts in Applied Mathematics. Springer-Verlag, New York, 1995.
  2. [2]A.C. Fowler. Mathematical geoscience, volume 36 of Interdisciplinary Applied Mathematics. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 2011.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_575pd3ab
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents