We prove the intersection product formulas of Gaffney and Gassler for polar multiplicities and Segre numbers over arbitrary Noetherian local rings. For equidimensional and universally catenary rings, we give a geometric refinement of the Principle of Specialization of Integral Dependence, in which the maximal dimension of the images of exceptional components mapping into the hypersurface determines a precise Segre number that strictly increases.
Introduction
The study of integral dependence through numerical invariants goes back to Rees’ multiplicity theorem [18]. In an equidimensional and universally catenary Noetherian local ring (R,m), this theorem states that two m-primary ideals I⊆J have the same integral closure if and only if e(I,R)=e(J,R). For ideals of arbitrary height, the corresponding criterion is expressed in terms of Segre numbers. In the complex analytic setting, Gaffney and Gassler [11] proved this extension of Rees’ theorem by establishing a Principle of Specialization of Integral Dependence. Their work also establishes the lexicographic upper semicontinuity of Segre numbers and gives cycle descriptions and intersection product formulas for Segre numbers and polar multiplicities.
Several of Gaffney–Gassler’s results have since been extended to the algebraic setting. Achilles and Rams [2] identified the Segre numbers of Gaffney and Gassler with the multiplicity sequence introduced by Achilles and Manaresi [1]. Polini, Trung, Ulrich, and Validashti [17] proved that equality of these sequences characterizes integral dependence of arbitrary ideals in an equidimensional and universally catenary Noetherian local ring. Algebraic cycle descriptions and semicontinuity results were obtained by Cid-Ruiz, Polini, and Ulrich [6]. One of the main goals of this paper is to establish the intersection product formulas of Gaffney and Gassler over arbitrary Noetherian local rings. We also use the geometry of the blow-up to give a different proof of the specialization criterion in [17 Theorem 3.3] and obtain a more precise statement that identifies a precise Segre number that must increase.
We now describe our results more precisely. Let (R,m,κ) be a Noetherian local ring of dimension d and I⊂R be a proper ideal. Let X=Spec(R) and consider the punctured spectrum U=X∖{m}. The polar multiplicitiesmi(I,R) and the Segre numbersci(I,R) are defined by the bigraded Hilbert polynomials associated to the standard bigraded κ-algebras
grm(K(I))andgrm(grI(R)),
Equation not extracted
respectively (see Definition 2.2). We also consider the polar-Segre multiplicitiesνi(I,R)=mi(I,R)+ci(I,R).
To express these numbers as intersection products, we work on the joint blow-up
b:B=BmI(X)⟶X.
On B, both IOB and mOB are invertible ideals, and so they determine effective Cartier divisors EI and Em given by IOB=OB(−EI) and mOB=OB(−Em). We write [EI]=[EI]b−1(U)+[EI]b−1({m}), where the two summands consist of the components meeting b−1(U) and those mapping to the closed point, respectively, with their multiplicities. The following theorem expresses the multiplicities in terms of these divisors and cycles.
Theorem A (Gaffney-Gassler intersection formulas; Theorem 3.5). With the notation above, for all 1≤i≤d−1, the following formulas hold:
mi(I,R)=−∫B(−EI)i(−Em)d−i⋅[B],
ci(I,R)=−∫B(−EI)i−1(−Em)d−i⋅[EI]b−1(U),
νi(I,R)=∫B(−EI)i−1(−Em)d−i⋅[EI]b−1({m}).
Moreover, when κ is infinite, for all 1≤i≤d−2, we have the following cutting formulas:
(i) If dim(R/I)<d and f∈I is a general element, then
Here the integrals denote local intersection degrees with support over the closed point (see § 2.2). The proof of Theorem A uses Thorup’s rational equivalence theory [24], which allows us to work over an arbitrary Noetherian local ring.
We next turn to specialization, the main step in the integral-dependence criteria established in [11] and [17]. Geometrically, the issue is whether a component of the exceptional divisor Proj(grI(R)) maps into a given hypersurface V(t)⊂X. Our next result shows that such components force a strict increase in a precise Segre number: the index of this number is determined by the largest dimension of their images in X.
Theorem B (Theorem 4.3). Assume that R is equidimensional and universally catenary and that ht(I)≥1. Let t∈m be an element such that ht(t)=1 and ht(I,t)≥2. Assume there is a minimal prime of grI(R) that contains t. Let s be the maximal dimension
s:=max{dim(R/Q∩R)∣Q minimal prime of grI(R) with t∈Q}
of the contractions to R of the minimal primes of grI(R) containing t. Let j:=d−1−s. Then we have the strict inequality
cj(I,R/tR)>cj(I,R).
In an analytic setting, Teissier’s Principle of Specialization of Integral Dependence (PSID) (see [22] and [23 Appendice I]) states that for a family of zero-dimensional ideals with constant Hilbert-Samuel multiplicity, a section is integrally dependent on the total family if and only if it is integrally dependent on the fibers corresponding to a Zariski-open dense subset of the base. Using Segre numbers, Gaffney and Gassler [11] (also in the analytic setting) extended the PSID to families of ideals that are not necessarily zero-dimensional. As a direct consequence of Theorem B, we obtain in Corollary 4.4 an algebraic version of the PSID, showing that, under certain hypotheses, it suffices to check integral dependence on the open set D(t)⊂Spec(R).
The basic outline of this paper is as follows.
Outline. In § 2, we recall the definitions and preliminary results used throughout the paper. The proof of Theorem A, together with the cutting formulas and cycle descriptions, is given in § 3. We conclude that section by studying integral dependence under general hypersurface sections (see § 3.1). Finally, in § 4, we prove Theorem B.
Basic tools
In this section, we recall the definitions and results used throughout the paper. We also prove some basic tools that will be necessary. The following data is used throughout.
Setup 2.1. Let (R,m,κ) be a d-dimensional Noetherian local ring and I⊂R be a proper ideal. Let X:=Spec(R).
We denote by Zi(X) the free Abelian group of cycles on X of Krull dimension i (in § 2.2 below, we also consider the notion of rational equivalence developed by Thorup [24]). For r≥0, set Z≤r(X):=⨁i=0rZi(X). We define the multiplicity homomorphism er:Z≤r(X)→Z by
er(p∑np[V(p)]):=dim(R/p)=r∑npe(R/p),
where e(R/p) denotes Hilbert–Samuel multiplicity.
Polar multiplicities and Segre numbers
First, we recall the notions of polar multiplicities and Segre numbers.
Definition 2.2. Consider the standard bigraded κ-algebras A:=grm(R(I)) and G:=grm(grI(R)). Their bigraded components are
Av,n=mn+1IvmnIvandGv,n=mn+1Iv+Iv+1mnIv+Iv+1.
For v,n≫0, the Hilbert function of A is a polynomial with homogeneous part of degree d−1 given by
i=0∑d−1mi(I,R)i!(d−1−i)!vind−1−i.
The second sum transform of the Hilbert function
HG(v,n):=a=0∑vb=0∑ndimκ(Ga,b)
is eventually a polynomial with homogeneous part of degree d given by
i=0∑dci(I,R)i!(d−i)!νinnd−i.
We call mi(I,R) the polar multiplicities and ci(I,R) the Segre numbers of I. We put md(I,R)=0 and νi(I,R)=mi(I,R)+ci(I,R) for 1≤i≤d.
When d≥2, the coefficients ci(I,R) with 1≤i≤d−1 can be read from the ordinary bigraded Hilbert polynomial of G. The two end coefficients are given by
We have that: if ht(I)≥1, then c0(I,R)=0; if I is m-primary, then ci(I,R)=0 for i<d and cd(I,R)=e(I,R).
Thorup's rational equivalence theory
We recall the basics of the rational equivalence theory developed by Thorup [24] over Noetherian schemes, which will be used in this paper (a slightly less general treatment is made in [21 Tag 02QK] over a universally catenary scheme). See also the recent developments [4, 5, 7].
A grading on a Noetherian base scheme assigns integers to its integral closed subschemes and induces a grading on schemes essentially of finite type over the base. In Thorup's theory [24] one can always use the canonical grading given by
δcan(V):=−dimOX,ηV.
where ηV is the generic point of an integral closed subscheme V⊂X. Since X=Spec(R) has finite Krull dimension, we use instead the topological grading
δtop(V):=dim(V)
for an integral closed subscheme V⊂X.
Let π:Y→X be a morphism essentially of finite type. The grading on Yinduced by the topological grading on X is given by
δX,top(W):=trdegκ(V)(κ(W))+dim(V),
where W⊂Y is an integral closed subscheme and V=π(W)⊂X. The dimension formula gives
dim(W)≤δX,top(W)
(see, e.g., [15 Theorem 15.5]). Moreover, Thorup [24 Proposition 4.3] showed that if π is proper, then
δX,top(W)=dim(W).
Given a grading on X and a scheme Y essentially of finite type over X, by utilizing the induced grading on $Y, Thorup builds a rational equivalence theory for Y. This leads to the following very convenient convention.
Convention 2.3. Let Y be a proper scheme over X=Spec(R). Throughout this paper, we consider Thorup's rational equivalence theory on Y with the induced grading δX,top. Most importantly, the topological grading of Y coincides with the induced grading δX,top on $Y.
Therefore, for every proper X-scheme Y, we may use the ordinary dimensional cycle group Zr(Y). We write Ar(Y/X) for the quotient by Thorup rational equivalence and [α]r for the r-dimensional part of a cycle α. If f:Z→Y is a proper morphism of proper X-schemes, we get a functorial homomorphism
f∗:Ar(Z/X)⟶Ar(Y/X)
by [24 Proposition 6.5]. Moreover, Cartier-divisor intersections and the projection formula are available for all the proper schemes used throughout this paper.
We use the following convention for local intersection degrees. Let π:Y→X be a proper morphism and set Y0:=Y×XSpec(κ). Since Y0 is proper over Spec(κ), its structure morphism π0:Y0→Spec(κ) induces the usual degree homomorphism
degκ:A0(Y0)(π0)∗A0(Spec(κ))≅Z
(see [10 Definition 1.4]). For a class β∈A0(Y0) represented by a zero-dimensional cycle ∑VnV[V], we write
∫Yβ:=degκ(β)=V∑nV[R(V):κ].
This integer is independent of the chosen representative, since proper pushforward respects rational equivalence on Y0.
Passage to an infinite residue field
Let S:=R[z]mR[z], where z is a new indeterminate. The extension R→S is faithfully flat and local, dim(S)=d, its maximal ideal is mS, and its residue field is κ(z). For every ideal I⊂R, flat base change gives
The bigraded components in Definition 2.2 are extended from κ to κ(z), so their dimensions and the resulting multiplicities are unchanged. For a proper scheme Y over X=Spec(R), on the closed fiber Y0=Y×XSpec(κ), the base change is the field extension κ⊂κ(z), and so it preserves degrees and commutes with proper pushforward and Cartier intersections. Therefore, passing to an infinite residue field is a mild operation that keeps the intersection-theoretic data.
General sections
We first give the avoidance argument used to choose general sections.
Lemma 2.4.Assume that the residue field κ is infinite. Let π:Y→X=Spec(R) be a proper morphism and L be a globally generated line bundle on Y. Choose points η1,…,ηs∈Y. Then, for a general section σ∈H0(Y,L), the zero scheme Z(σ)⊂Y does not contain any of the points η1,…,ηs.
Proof. Since π is proper and R is Noetherian, M:=H0(Y,L) is a finitely generated R-module. For 1≤i≤s, let
Mi:=Ker(M⟶Lηi⊗OY,ηiκ(ηi)).
The global generation of L implies that each Mi is a proper submodule of M. Let
V:=M/mMandVi:=(Mi+mM)/mM⊂V.
If Vi=V, then Nakayama’s lemma applied to M/Mi would give M=Mi, a contradiction. Thus each Vi is a proper κ-linear subspace of V. Since κ is infinite, V∖⋃iVi is a nonempty Zariski-open subset. Every section σ∈M whose image lies in this open subset has nonzero value in the fiber of L at each ηi, and so ηi∈/Z(σ) for all i.
Corollary 2.5. Assume that the residue field κ is infinite. Let π:Y→X=Spec(R) be a proper morphism with Y integral and L be a globally generated line bundle on Y. Let T⊂X be a closed subset such that π(Y)⊂T. Then, for a general section σ∈H0(Y,L), no irreducible component of π(Z(σ)) is contained in T.
Proof. Let W:=π−1(T)⊊Y. By Lemma 2.4, the zero scheme Z(σ) of a general section σ∈H0(Y,L) avoids the generic point of Y and the generic points of all irreducible components of W. Since Y is integral, every irreducible component of Z(σ) has codimension one in Y by the principal ideal theorem. If such a component were contained in W, it would therefore be an irreducible component of W, a contradiction. So the proof of the corollary is complete.
The following lemma describes specialization of a biprojective Rees algebra by a general element.
Lemma 2.6. Assume that the residue field κ is infinite. Let I,J⊆R be ideals, and consider the multi-Rees algebra RR(I,J)=R[IT1,JT2]. For a general element x∈I, put R=R/(x), I=IR, and J=JR. The natural surjection RR(I,J)/(xT1)⟶RR(I,J) induces a natural isomorphism
BiProj(RR(I,J)/(xT1))≅BiProj(RR(I,J)).
Proof. This follows from Rees’ lemma [19 Lemma 1.2]; see also Trung–Verma [TV07].
Intersection product formulas
In this section, by building on the work of Thorup [24] (see § 2.2), we prove the intersection product formulas stated in Theorem A. Throughout this section, we use the following setup.
Setup 3.1. Let (R,m,κ) be a d-dimensional Noetherian local ring and I⊂R be a proper ideal. Let X:=Spec(R) and consider the punctured spectrum U:=X∖{m}. Let bI:BI:=BlI(X)→X be the blow-up of X=Spec(R) along I. Likewise, the blow-up of X at the origin is bm:Bm:=Blm(X)→X. Finally, we consider the joint blow-up b:B:=BlmI(X)→X. Algebraically, we have the descriptions
Here R(I):=R[IT]⊂R[T], R(m):=R[mT]⊂R[T] and R(mI):=R[mIT]⊂R[T] are Rees algebras, and R(I,m):=R[IT1,mT2]⊂R[T1,T2] is a multi-Rees algebra. We have the following commutative diagram
BbI↓⏐BmbmbmBI↓⏐bIX
with b=bI∘bm=bm∘bI. Let DI⊂BI and Dm⊂Bm be the exceptional divisors of bI and bm, respectively. On the joint blow-up B, consider the effective Cartier divisors
EI:=V(IOB),Em:=V(mOB)andE:=V(mIOB).
Then E is the exceptional divisor of B, and EI=bI∗(DI) and Em=bm∗(Dm). Let
Lemma 3.2. On B=BℓmI(X), the following statements hold:
(i) OB(1,0)=OB(−EI), OB(0,1)=OB(−Em) and OB(1,1)=OB(−E).
(ii) E=EI+Em.
(iii) h=hI+hm.
Proof. Since B=BiProj(R(I,m)), the invertible sheaves OB(1,0), OB(0,1), and OB(1,1) correspond to the invertible ideals IOB, mOB, and (mI)OB, respectively. This gives
Since (mI)OB=mOB⋅IOB, we get E=EI+Em. Taking first Chern classes gives h=hI+hm. □
Remark 3.3. We recall some useful notation from [12, 13]. Let Y be a scheme, W a subscheme of Y, and S∈Z∗(Y) a cycle on Y. We define the W-part SW as follows: if S is the fundamental cycle of an integral closed subscheme S⊂Y, then SW=S if W contains the generic point of S, and SW=0 otherwise; then extend this definition by linearity.
The next proposition will play an important role in our approach.
Proposition 3.4. On B=BℓmI(X), the following equalities of cycles hold:
For any prime p∈U on the punctured spectrum, we have that the map s⊗RRp is an isomorphism. Hence we obtain
ml⋅Ker(s)=0for some l≥1.
This yields the following set-theoretical decomposition
SuppEI(S/m⋅S)∪SuppEI(S/Ker(s))=EI.
Since the biprojective scheme BiProj(R(m⋅grI(R)))⊂B is isomorphic to the blow-up BℓZ(Y) of Y:=Proj(grI(R)) along Z:=V(m⋅OY), its generic points are contained in b−1(U). On the other hand, by the decomposition (1), the generic points of EI that are contained in b−1(U) should also be contained in V(Ker(s))≅BiProj(R(m⋅grI(R))). Therefore, the asserted equality of cycles
[EI]b−1(U)=[BiProj(R(m⋅grI(R)))]
follows. □
We can now express polar multiplicities and Segre numbers as intersection products of divisors on the joint blow-up B=BmI(X). The following theorem extends several results of Gaffney and Gassler [11] to arbitrary Noetherian local rings.
Theorem 3.5 (Gaffney-Gassler intersection formulas). Assume Setup 3.1. Then we have the following intersection product formulas and cutting results.
(iv) Let R:=R/fR, which has dimension d−1. We have that OB(1,0)≅OB(−EI)≅OB is globally generated by sections induced from elements of I. Let σf∈H0(B,OB(1,0)) be the section induced by f∈I. Let H:=Z(σf)⊂B be the zero scheme determined by σf. By Lemma 2.6, we have the isomorphism
H≅BiProj(T)
with T:=RR(I,m).
The avoidance arguments of Lemma 2.4 and Corollary 2.5 imply that H is an effective Cartier divisor on B, that restricts to an effective Cartier divisor on EI, and that it commutes with the decomposition of [EI] into its closed-fiber and punctured-spectrum parts:
Since νi(I,R)=mi(I,R)+ci(I,R), the proof of this part is now complete.
(v) The proof of this part follows similarly to the one of part (iv). □
We recall the polar schemes and Segre cycles (see [11, 6]). Assume that κ is infinite, and let K1,…,Kd be general hyperplanes on BI corresponding to general elements g1,…,gd∈I. Let
Proof. Let r:=d−i>0 and Hj:=(bm)∗(Kj). By Lemma 2.4, we can assume that the following successive cuttings are all Cartier and yield the following effective cycles
Successively applying the avoidance result of Corollary 2.5 implies that no component of Γi is contained in b−1(V(I)) and that no component of Σi is contained in b−1({m}).
The projection formula (at the level of cycles; see [10 Proposition 1.4], [21 Tag 02RT]) yields the equalities
where the last equality follows because r=d−i>0 and so bI pushes to zero a component of [DI] that is contained in bI−1({m}). The natural isomorphisms b−1(X∖V(I))∼bI−1(X∖V(I))∼X∖V(I) yield the isomorphism
The following technical lemma justifies the multiplicity computation used above.
Lemma 3.7. Let r>0 and γ∈Zr(B) be a cycle with no component contained in b−1({m}). Then
er(b∗(γ))=−∫B(−Em)r⋅γ.
Proof. By linearity, we may assume γ=[W], where W⊂B is an integral closed subscheme of dimension r such that W⊂b−1({m}). Let V:=b(W) and consider the blow-up
π:V:=BlmOV(V)⟶V
with exceptional divisor F determined by mOV=OV(−F). Since mOW=OW(−Em∣W) is invertible, the universal property of the blow-up gives a proper factorization b∣W:WfVπV such that f∗(F)=Em∣W.
Integral dependence under general hypersurface sections
By [17 Theorem 4.2], Segre numbers characterize integral dependence in equidimensional and universally catenary Noetherian local rings. By Theorem 3.5(v), when the residue field is infinite, a general element x∈m preserves the Segre numbers ci(I,R) for 1≤i≤d−2. Together, these facts motivate the study of integral dependence under general hypersurface sections.
For ideals I⊆J in R, we consider the non-integral locus
N(I,J):={p∈Spec(R)∣Ip=Jp}⊂X.
The following theorem, valid over an arbitrary Noetherian local ring with infinite residue field, shows that if J(R/xR) is integral over I(R/xR) for a general x∈m, then dim(N(I,J))≤1.
Theorem 3.8.Assume Setup 3.1 with κ infinite and I⊆J two ideals in R. Suppose there exists a prime p∈X=Spec(R) such that dim(R/p)≥2 and Jp is not integral over Ip. Then, for a general element x∈m, the ideal J=JR is not integral over I=IR in the quotient ring R=R/xR.
Proof. Let q:Y=Proj(⨁n≥0Jn)⟶Spec(R) be the blow-up along the ideal J and E denote the exceptional divisor of Y. Let E1,…,Ek be the irreducible components of E. Let pi∈X=Spec(R) denote the prime ideal corresponding to the generic point of the image q(Ei).
Since IOY⊆JOY and JOY is an invertible sheaf, we can globally twist by its inverse to find a uniquely determined ideal sheaf b⊆OY such that
IOY=b⋅JOY.
The ideal sheaf b describes the exact obstruction to the integrality of J over I (see, e.g., [20 Corollary 1.2.5, §8.2]).
Let W=V(b)⊂Y be the closed subscheme determined by b. Since q(W)⊂X is closed and p∈q(W), we obtain the inequality
dim(q(W))≥dim(V(p))=dim(R/p)≥2.
Let S:={pi∣1≤i≤k and pi⊊m} be the set of primes strictly contained in m given as the image of the generic points of the irreducible components Ei. By prime avoidance, we obtain that
dim(V(x)∩q(W))=dim(q(W))−1≥1
and that
x∈/pifor any pi∈S.
Thus we can fix a prime ideal q⊊m such that q∈V(x)∩q(W). Since q∈q(W), we can choose a point w∈W in the blow-up Y such that q(w)=q. Let A:=OY,w be the local ring at w and mw⊂OY,w be its maximal ideal. Since x∈q=q(w), the pullback of x into A satisfies x∈mw.
By contradiction, assume that J=JR is integral over I=IR in the quotient ring R=R/xR. Considering the natural map R/xR⟶A/xA implies that J(A/xA) is integral over I(A/xA). Since JOY is an invertible sheaf, locally at A it is generated by a single regular element f∈A, so JA=(f). The global equality IOY=b⋅JOY at the point w turns into IA=bwf. Moreover, since w was chosen to lie in W=V(b), we obtain bw⊆mw. Since J(A/xA) is assumed to be integral over I(A/xA), we have
fnA⊆(bwf)fn−1A+xA=bwfn+xA.
for some n≥1. This implies fn=bfn+ax for some b∈bw and a∈A. Since b∈mw, we obtain
fn=(1−b)−1ax∈xA.
We now divide the proof into two cases.
CASE 1: Assume that w∈/E. Then JA=A and so A=(fn)=xA. This leads to the contradiction that x is a unit in A and x∈mw.
CASE 2: Assume that w∈E. Let Q∈Spec(A) be a minimal prime ideal lying over xA. The containment fnA⊂xA implies that Q represents the generic point of some irreducible component Ej. Moving back to the base ring R, this means x belongs to the prime ideal pj. However, since w belongs to Ej, we should have pj⊆q(w)=q. Finally, this leads to the contradiction
x∈pj⊆q(w)=q⊊m;
indeed, we would that x belongs to the prime pj that lies in the set S.
This concludes the proof of the theorem since we got a contradiction in both cases. □
Example 3.9. The assumption dim(R/p)≥2 in Theorem 3.8 is necessary. Let k be an infinite field, R:=k[x,y](x,y), m:=(x,y), I=(x2,xy)⊂J:=(x,y)2 and p:=(x). Then
dim(R/p)=1,Ip=xRpandJp=Rp.
Thus Jp is not integral over Ip. On the other hand, for a general element ℓ∈m, we have the equality
IR=x2R=JR
in R=R/ℓR.
Integral dependence and Specialization
In this section, we give a different proof of the following result that was proved in [17 Theorem 3.3]. The statement of this result is a Principle of Specialization of Integral Dependence (PSID) type of argument [11]. A direct corollary of this result is a proof of the fact that Segre numbers detect integral dependence (see [17 Theorem 4.2]).
Throughout this section, we fix the following data.
Setup 4.1. Let (R,m) be an equidimensional and universally catenary Noetherian local ring of dimension d≥2. Let I⊂R be an ideal with height ht(I)≥1. Let t∈m be an element such that ht(t)=1 and ht(I,t)≥2.
Theorem 4.2 ([17 Theorem 3.3]). Assume Setup 4.1 and that
ci(I,R/tR)≤ci(I,R)for all 1≤i≤d−1.
Then t, viewed in degree zero in grI(R)0=R/I, belongs to no minimal prime of grI(R).
In fact, we show the following more explicit extension of the above theorem. It shows that Segre numbers are sensitive to the dimension of the projections of the bad components (i.e., those lying over V(t)) of the exceptional divisor.
Theorem 4.3. Assume Setup 4.1 and that there is a minimal prime of grI(R) that contains t. Let s be the maximal dimension
s:=max{dim(R/Q∩R)∣Q minimal prime of grI(R) with t∈Q}
of the contractions to R of the minimal primes of grI(R) containing t. Let j:=d−1−s. Then we have the strict inequality
cj(I,R/tR)>cj(I,R).
A direct consequence of the above theorem is the following algebraic version of the Principle of Specialization of Integral Dependence (PSID).
Corollary 4.4. Assume Setup 4.1. If ci(I,R)=ci(I,R/tR) for all 1≤i≤k, then
for all p∈AssR(R/I)∩V(t),we have ht(p)≥k+2.
In particular, if ci(I,R)=ci(I,R/tR) for all 1≤i≤d−1, then
f∈IRtif and only iff∈I
for all f∈R.
Proof. By [16 3.9 and 4.1], the associated primes of R/I come from contractions of minimal primes of grI(R) (see also [14 §9.6]). So the claims follow from Theorem 4.3. □
be the blow-up of X=Spec(R) along Z, and E:=EZX=Proj(grI(R)) be the exceptional divisor. Throughout this section we shall use the fact that grI(R) is also equidimensional of dimension d. By utilizing the faithfully flat extension R→R[z]mR[z], we may assume that the residue field of R is not an algebraic extension of a finite field (see § 2.3). Let H=H1,…,Hd be a sequence of general hyperplanes on the blow-up B=BlZ(X), and denote by g=g1,…,gd the associated sequence of elements in I.
By [6 Theorem C], the i-th polar scheme is given by
One of our main technical tools is the following explicit excess type of argument in the two dimensional case. After cutting with suitably general hyperplanes on the blow-up, the general case will be deduced locally to this one.
Proposition 4.6 (Surface excess). With notation as above, we assume that dim(R)=2, (0:RI∞)=0, ht(t)=1 and (I,t) is m-primary. Then
e(I,R/tR)≥q∈V(I)ht(q)=1∑e(I,Rq)e(t,R/q).
If E=EZX has an irreducible component mapping to the closed point m, then the inequality is strict.
Proof. We may assume that ht(I)=1 because the statement of the proposition holds trivially when I is m-primary.
Choose a general element g∈I, and let H⊂B be the corresponding hyperplane on the blow-up. We choose g so that: g is a nonzerodivisor on R, (g,t) is m-primary, g is a reduction of I(R/tR), and H⊂B contains no irreducible component of E.
The first Segre cycle is given explicitly by
Λ1(I,X)=π∗([E])=q∈V(I)ht(q)=1∑e(I,Rq)[V(q)]
(see [6 Theorem C(ii)], [17 Proposition 2.4(a)] and [1 Proposition 2.3(iii)]). Let D=V(g) be the effective Cartier divisor on X corresponding to g. We have the equality of Cartier divisors
π∗(D)=E+H
on B (see [6 Proposition 5.8], [10 Lemma 2.4]). Then the projection formula yields the equality of cycles
[D]=π∗([π∗(D)])=π∗([E])+π∗([H])∈Z1(X)
on $X (see [10 Proposition 1.4], [21 Tag 02RT]). Since (g,t) is m-primary, no component of D is contained in T. By [9 Corollary 1.2.14], we get
e((g,t),R)=e(t,R/gR)=e(t,[D])
and
e(g,R/tR)≥e((g,t),R).
Thus, since g is a reduction of I(R/tR), we obtain
Now assume that E has an irreducible component F over the closed point m. We show that this assumption implies the nonvanishing H=∅. Since OF(1)=OB(1)⊗OBOF is ample over Spec(R/m), it has positive degree. By assumption H restricts to a general section of OF(1), and so we get F∩H=∅. In particular, we obtain H=∅.
Let C⊂H be an irreducible component of H. It necessarily follows that C is not contained E=B×XSpec(R/I) because by assumption H contains no irreducible component of E. This implies that C is not contained in the special fiber
B×XSpec(R/m)⊆B×XSpec(R/I)=E.
Therefore, π∗([C])=0, and so π∗([H])=0. Since no component of π∗([H]) is contained in T, we get e(t,π∗([H]))>0. Finally, by (1), the strict inequality follows.
The above proposition already yields the result of Theorem 4.3 in the following case.
Corollary 4.7.With notation as above, we assume (0:RI∞)=0, ht(t)=1 and ht(I,t)≥2. Suppose that E has an irreducible component F such that
π(F)⊂T,p0∈Spec(R) with V(p0)=π(F),ht(p0)=2.
Then c1(I,R/tR)>c1(I,R).
Proof. We consider the following Segre cycles
Λ1(I,X)=q∈V(I),ht(q)=1∑e(I,Rq)[V(q)]
and
Λ1(I,T)=p∈V(I,t),ht(p)=2∑e(I,Rp/tRp)[V(p)].
Recall that c1(I,R)=e(Λ1(I,X)) and c1(I,R/tR)=e(Λ1(I,T)). Since ht(I,t)≥2, no component of Λ1(I,X) is contained in T. Hence we can consider the cycle
By assumption, the exceptional divisor Ep0=Proj(grI(Rp0)) has an irreducible component lying over the closed point of Spec(Rp0), and so Proposition 4.6 yields the strict inequality
Finally, we are ready for the proof of Theorem 4.3.
Proof of Theorem 4.3. Let Q be a minimal prime of grI(R) containing t such that the contraction p0:=Q∩R∈Spec(R) has the maximal possible dimension dim(R/p0)=s. Note that Q corresponds to an irreducible component F of E=Proj(grI(R)) because dim(grI(R)/grI(R)+)=dim(R/I)<dim(grI(R))=d. Let j:=d−1−s. Since ht(I,t)≥2, we have 0≤s≤d−2 and so 1≤j≤d−1.
We analyze the j-th Segre cycle
Λj(I,X)=Λ1(I,Y),
where Y:=Pj−1(I,X)=π(H1∩⋯∩Hj−1)=Spec(S) and S:=R/(g1,…,gj−1):RI∞.
We now check the necessary conditions to apply Corollary 4.7 to S:
(a) Let κ(p0):=Rp0/p0Rp0. The fact that grI(R) has a minimal prime contracting to p0 is equivalent to saying that Ip0 has maximal analytic spread ℓ(Ip0):=dim(grI(R)⊗Rκ(p0))=dim(Rp0)=d−s. Since we may assume that g1,…,gd are general elements in Ip0 (see [17 Lemma 2.6]), it follows that
(see [20 §8.5] and [6 Remark 5.11]). This implies that p0⊃(g1,…,gj−1):RI∞, that ht(p0S)=2 and that there is a minimal prime of grI(S) lying over p0S. We have that S is equidimensional of dimension dim(S)=d−j+1=s+2 (see [6 Remark 5.11]). Recall also that t∈p0. (b) By applying Corollary 2.5 successively to the irreducible components of the blow-up B, we obtain that no component of Y=π(H1∩⋯∩Hj−1) is contained in T, and so ht(tS)≥1.
(c) The components of Λj(I,X)=π∗([E∩H1∩⋯∩Hj−1]d−j) have dimension d−j=s+1. Let C⊂E be an irreducible component of E. If π(C) is not contained in T, then by applying Corollary 2.5 successively to C, we obtain that no component of π(C∩H1∩⋯∩Hj−1) is contained in T. If π(C) is contained in T, then dim(π(C∩H1∩⋯∩Hj−1))≤dim(π(C))≤s. By definition of pushforward, this implies that no component of Λ1(I,Y)=Λj(I,X) is contained in T. Since
Λ1(I,Y)=q∈V(IS)ht(q)=1∑e(I,Sq)[V(q)],
it follows that ht(IS,tS)≥2.
From Corollary 4.7, we obtain
c1(I,S/tS)>c1(I,S).
Finally, the equalities of cycles Λ1(I,Spec(S/tS))=Λj(I,T) (see Lemma 4.5) and Λ1(I,Y)=Λj(I,X) yield the strict inequality
cj(I,R/tR)=c1(I,S/tS)>c1(I,S)=cj(I,R).
So the proof of the theorem is complete. □
Acknowledgments
YCR received support from NSF grant DMS-2502321 and Simons Foundation Travel Support for Mathematicians Award MPS-TSM-00013551. SDC received support from NSF grant DMS-2348849.
References
(Cid-Ruiz) DEPARTMENT OF MATHEMATICS, NORTH CAROLINA STATE UNIVERSITY, RALEIGH, NC 27695, USA
[1]Rüdiger Achilles and Mirella Manaresi, Multiplicities of a bigraded ring and intersection theory, Math. Ann. 309 (1997), no. 4, 573–591.DOI
[2]Rüdiger Achilles and Sławomir Rams, Intersection numbers, Segre numbers and generalized Samuel multiplicities, Arch. Math. (Basel) 77 (2001), no. 5, 391–398.DOI
[4]Steven Dale Cutkosky and Jonathan Montaño, Multiplicities and degree functions in local rings via intersection products, J. Lond. Math. Soc. 112 (2025), no. 5, e70338.
[5]———, Degree functions of graded families of ideals, Collect. Math. (2026), published online.arxiv.org/abs/2506.05248
[6]Yairon Cid-Ruiz, Claudia Polini, and Bernd Ulrich, Multidegrees, families, and integral dependence, preprint, 2025.
[7]Steven Dale Cutkosky, Multiplicities of graded families of ideals on Noetherian local rings, arXiv:2603.06844, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2603.06844
[9]Hubert Flenner, Liam O’Carroll, and Wolfgang Vogel, Joins and intersections, Springer Monographs in Mathematics, Springer, Berlin, 1999.
[10]William Fulton, Intersection Theory, second ed., Ergebnisse der Mathematik und ihrer Grenzgebiete (3), vol. 2, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1998.
[11]Terence Gaffney and Robert Gassler, Segre numbers and hypersurface singularities, J. Algebraic Geom. 8 (1999), no. 4, 695–736.
[12]Steven L. Kleiman and Anders Thorup, A geometric theory of the Buchsbaum–Rim multiplicity, J. Algebra 167 (1994), no. 1, 168–231.
[14]Robert Lazarsfeld, Positivity in algebraic geometry II: Positivity for vector bundles, and multiplier ideals, Ergebnisse der Mathematik und ihrer Grenzgebiete (3), vol. 49, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 2004.
[15]Hideyuki Matsumura, Commutative ring theory, Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics, vol. 8, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1986, translated from the Japanese by M. Reid.DOI
[16]Stephen McAdam, Asymptotic prime divisors, Lecture Notes in Math., vol. 1023, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1983.DOI
[17]Claudia Polini, Ngô Viêt Trung, Bernd Ulrich, and Javid Validashti, Multiplicity sequence and integral dependence, Math. Ann. 378 (2020), 951–969.DOI
[18]David Rees, a-transforms of local rings and a theorem on multiplicities of ideals, Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc. 57 (1961), no. 1, 8–17.DOI
[19]David Rees, Generalizations of reductions and mixed multiplicities, J. London Math. Soc. (2) 29 (1984), no. 3, 397–414.DOI
[20]Irena Swanson and Craig Huneke, Integral closure of ideals, rings, and modules, London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series, vol. 336, Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, 2006.
[21]The Stacks project authors, The Stacks project, https://stacks.math.columbia.edu.
[22]Bernard Teissier, Cycles évanescents, sections planes et conditions de Whitney, Singularités à Cargèse, Astérisque, nos. 7–8, Soc. Math. France, Paris, 1973, pp. 285–362.
[23]———, Résolution simultanée II: Résolution simultanée et cycles évanescents, Séminaire sur les singularités des surfaces (M. Demazure, H. C. Pinkham, and B. Teissier, eds.), Lecture Notes in Math., vol. 777, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1980, pp. 82–146.DOI
[24]Anders Thorup, Rational equivalence theory on arbitrary Noetherian schemes, Enumerative Geometry (Sitges, 1987), Lecture Notes in Math., vol. 1436, Springer, Berlin, 1990, pp. 256–297.DOI