betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Inverse molecular design from first principles: tailoring organic chromophore spectra for optoelectronic applications

Abstract

The discovery of molecules with tailored optoelectronic properties such as specific frequency and intensity of absorption or emission is a major challenge in creating next-generation organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) and photovoltaics. This raises the question: how can we predict a potential chemical structure from these properties? Approaches that attempt to tackle this inverse design problem include virtual screening, active machine learning and genetic algorithms. However, these approaches rely on a molecular database or many electronic structure calculations, and significant computational savings could be achieved if there was prior knowledge of (i) whether the optoelectronic properties of a parent molecule could easily be improved and (ii) what morphing operations on a parent molecule could improve these properties. In this perspective we address both of these challenges from first principles. We firstly adapt the Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn sum rule to organic chromophores and show how this indicates how easily the absorption and emission of a molecule can be improved. We then show how by combining electronic structure theory and intensity borrowing perturbation theory we can predict whether or not the proposed morphing operations will achieve the desired spectral alteration, and thereby derive widely-applicable design rules. We go on to provide proof-of-concept illustrations of this approach to optimizing the visible absorption of acenes and the emission of radical OLEDs. We believe this approach can be integrated into genetic algorithms by biasing morphing operations in favour of those which are likely to be successful, leading to faster molecular discovery and greener chemistry.

This article has been accepted by The Journal of Chemical Physics. After it is published, it will be found at https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/5.0082311.

INTRODUCTION

Designer molecules

Conventional electronic structure theory[1, 2] has become highly successful at taking a molecular structure as an input and producing molecular properties as outputs [Fig. 1(a)]. However, to our knowledge there is no widely-applicable general theory or algorithm for the reverse process, namely starting with a list of desired molecular properties and producing a molecule which satisfies them as an output — the inverse design problem [Fig. 1(b)]. This is a shame, since there is huge demand for molecules meeting a given set of criteria, especially in fields such as optoelectronics where there are many (often competing) requirements for the chromophore. These requirements can include a specific absorption/emission wavelength, high oscillator strength, slow internal conversion to the ground state, fast internal conversion to a triplet-triplet state (for singlet fission[3, 4, 5, 6, 7]), large singlet-triplet energy gap (for singlet fission), small singlet-triplet gap (for thermally-activated delayed fluorescence, TADF[8, 9, 10]) and so on. For light-emitting diodes (LEDs), further development of molecular materials will enable realisation of efficient and stable blue LEDs that meet the performance of established red and green pixels for displays,[11, 12] as well as in infrared devices for optical communications and bio-imaging[13]. Strong light absorption of molecules in the visible range is useful for indoor photovoltaics, where device efficiency can be optimised for lighting conditions by chemical design[14]. This emerging technology presents opportunities for the design of new molecules tailored for these applications and hence motivates a general theory for solving the inverse design problem.

This article considers a more specific version of the inverse design problem in Fig. 1(b), namely starting with (i) a parent molecule which has reasonable, but not ideal, properties, and (ii) knowledge of which of these properties require modification, and from these inputs producing (iii) an improved molecule which better satisfies the desired properties in (ii), as shown schematically in Fig. 1(c). In this article we show how by combining electronic structure theory and quantum mechanical perturbation theory, we can provide a general theoretical and computational framework from first principles for achieving this without extensive computation or chemical synthesis. Furthermore, by applying pre-existing theory to the inverse design problem we obtain three major principles of chromophore design, summarized in the box on page 6.

This article has been accepted by The Journal of Chemical Physics. After it is published, it will be found at https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/5.0082311.

Flow diagrams illustrating conventional electronic structure theory, inverse design, virtual screening, machine learning, and genetic algorithm methods

Figure 1. Flow diagrams illustrating the motivation of this article. (a) Standard electronic structure theory: computing properties from a known molecular structure. (b) The overall challenge: computing a molecular structure from a given set of properties. (c) The case of (b) considered in this article: taking a candidate (parent) molecule and properties to optimize, and finding an improved molecule. (d) A virtual screening approach using a known database, but which is constrained by the number of known and documented molecules. (e) A machine learning approach: training an algorithm to rapidly compute the properties of unseen molecules from known chemical data. (f) A genetic algorithm approach: morphing operations to a first generation molecule, computing the properties of the mutated molecules, screening and repeating for multiple generations.

This article has been accepted by The Journal of Chemical Physics. After it is published, it will be found at https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/5.0082311.

Three Major Principles of Chromophore Design

  1. When considering different isomers of a chromophore, oscillator strength can neither be created nor destroyed but only moved from one region of the spectrum to another.

  1. For substitution, excitations mix if and only if they differ by (at maximum) one orbital and the orbitals by which they differ both have amplitude on the substituted atom.

  1. For addition and dimerization, using a zeroth-order Hamiltonian of separated monomers: (a) Leads to zeroth-order states which have exclusively Local Excitation (LE) or Charge Transfer (CT) character, are strictly orthogonal and form a complete singly-excited basis, (b) Leads to CT states which at zeroth-order are always dark and whose energies are given by Koopman’s theorem, but at first order (and above) can borrow intensity from bright LE states, and whose first-order energy correction is dominated by Coulombic stabilisation. (c) LE states mix with CT states through one-electron terms (transfer integrals) which can be determined from examining monomer molecular orbitals, and from the relative geometry of monomer units in the dimer, (d) LE states mix with other LE states, and CT states with other CT states, via electrostatic terms which can be estimated from the monomers’ multipoles and their relative geometry. The LE/LE mixing can be approximated by the Kasha dipole-dipole interaction.

In this article we derive these rules and provide examples of their applicability.

This perspective is far from the first article to address the inverse design of chromophores[15, 16, 17] and current methods fall into three broad groups. The first is the virtual screening (VS) approach Fig. 1(d) which comprises screening known molecules in a database against design criteria, using molecules’ properties contained within the database or computed on the fly, as shown in Fig. 1(d)[18]. This approach is limited by the size of the database and the quality and quantity of data therein, and any database stored on a modern computer is likely to include only a tiny fraction of chemical space. VS alone is limited in its scope as a prediction tool as it does not offer any new information about potential new molecules, even those which are similar to, or derivatives of, those which are in the database.

The second approach is active machine learning (AML) [Fig. 1(e)] where trends in chemical or physical properties are inferred by comparing the properties of a large set of molecules, called a training set, using statistical algorithms such as regression [e.g. Gaussian Processes Regression (GPR)], deep learning (DL), and artificial neural networks (ANN) among others.[19] The training set is taken from a database[20] or generated by successively applying morphing operations to a parent molecule.[15, 21] AML offers more predictive power than VS in the sense that it can ‘learn’ from the data being given to it in order to make predictions about unseen data.[22] However its predictive power is limited by the size and variation of data in the user-defined training set, as predictions about data outside the space of the training set (i.e. extrapolation) can be unreliable. Despite these limitations, AML algorithms have had much success in rapidly predicting chemical and physical properties of atoms and molecules, saving computational effort.[20, 23, 24]

Finally there is the genetic algorithm (GA) approach[25, 26] [Fig. 1(f)] in which a parent molecule is altered using morphing operations, producing ‘second generation’ molecules which have chemical properties computed for them. These second generation molecules are then screened against a design criteria and those which pass the screening process are then kept and the remainder discarded. The process is then repeated for many generations with many possible morphing operations until a suitable molecule is found. The screening is based on a fitness function, calculated from one or more properties of the molecule, which aims to quantitatively describe how well suited a molecule is for the applications. Those molecules which pass the screening process must exceed a threshold value of the fitness function. The success of the GA approach is crucially dependent on: i) whether the properties of the parent molecule can be improved and ii) whether the chosen morphing operations can improve these properties. Hence there have been efforts in combining GA and AML for molecular design (see SI Fig. 1), where AML is used to predict which are the most productive morphing operations to be applied to each successive generation.[15, 21, 27, 28]

Molecular design challenges

Machine learning, genetic algorithms and combinations of the two are perhaps the best current approaches in the field of molecular design, but still have various challenges, namely that:

  1. It is not usually known at the outset whether or not, and to what extent, the properties of the first generation molecule can be improved before many calculations are run.

  1. It is not usually known whether the proposed morphing operations will, or can, lead to any improvement, and if they can, where on the molecule they should be made, or how many are required, without running many electronic structure calculations.

Taken together these challenges mean that, until a full AML/GA calculation is run, it is difficult to know whether, and to what extent, it will be successful. Due to the large size of chemical space and the need for accurate property computation, the calculations can therefore be extremely expensive. It would therefore be very helpful to have an indication, in advance of a full calculation, of whether any improvement is possible and if so what morphing operations should be made. In this article we address both of the challenges given above for the case of electronic absorption and emission intensity (and energy) in specific regions of the spectrum, an area of huge interest for optoelectronic applications.

We stress that the above challenges are not reasons to avoid machine learning and genetic algorithms — quite the converse. We hope that the theoretical toolkit proposed in this article can be used to inform these algorithms and accelerate the discovery of new useful molecules for optoelectronic applications.

To address the first challenge, we show how the Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn sum rule can be used to provide much lower bounds on the total oscillator strengths of molecules than are usually quoted[2, 29], giving a more realistic maximum of the total low-energy absorption that can be expected. To address the second challenge, we combine electronic structure theory[1] with intensity borrowing perturbation theory[30] to construct a theoretical framework for describing how morphing operations to a parent molecule are likely to change the electronic structure of its offspring. Crucially, this requires only the knowledge of the electronic structure of the parent molecule and very basic knowledge of the alteration (for substitution, which atoms will be changed and for addition and dimerization, the relative geometry of monomers). This does not require a separate full electronic structure calculation for each possible morphing operation. Using this theoretical framework we show how it is possible to predict whether and which morphing operations are likely to increase the absorption or emission in a particular region of the spectrum (usually the visible), addressing the second challenge. It is also possible to determine where on the molecule the alterations should be made, and to give an approximate idea of the extent to which any given alteration will improve the molecule’s properties. Combining these results can then lead to general rules for increasing chromophore absorption and emission. The general methodology is illustrated in Fig. 2.

Flowchart illustrating the molecular design approach proposed in this article

Figure 2. Flowchart illustrating the general methodology proposed in this article. Starting with a candidate (parent) molecule, properties to be improved and possible morphing operations, we show how by combining intensity borrowing perturbation theory and electronic structure theory, we can predict which morphing operations are likely to be successful, and thereby formulate design rules.

What to optimize?

For light-emitting optoelectronics, such as organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs), emission is usually from the lowest bright excited state, usually S1S_1 for ground-state closed shell molecules and D1D_1 for radicals. The rate of emission is given by the Einstein transition coefficients[2] which in turn depend on the transition dipole moment of the S1→S0S_1 \to S_0 transition (or D1→D0D_1 \to D_0 for monoradicals). A key requirement for high-efficiency OLEDs is for the rate of radiative decay, krk_r, to exceed the rate of non-radiative decay, knrk_{nr}, such as reaching the ground state via an avoided crossing or conical intersection. Consequently, a goal for OLED design is to maximise the dipole moment associated with the S1→S0S_1 \to S_0 transition. An added complication for ground-state closed-shell species is the dark triplet state T1T_1, which is usually a loss pathway, though can be brightened by phosphorescence, or can emit indirectly through reverse intersystem crossing (RISC) in thermally-activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) devices[8, 9].

Conversely, for light-absorbing optoelectronics such as photovoltaic cells, the priority is usually absorbing as much light as possible within the solar spectrum, which is principally concentrated in the visible (roughly 400–700 nm in wavelength). The can be achieved by having a lowest-lying excited state with very broad absorption, or by having multiple absorptions in the visible. In the latter case, a molecule absorbing above the S1S_1 state usually undergoes rapid internal conversion to S1S_1, such that most photophysics of interest, such as charge generation, occurs from the S1S_1 state. Exceptions to this include intramolecular singlet fission[3, 4, 5, 31, 32, 33, 34], where the lowest bright state undergoes internal conversion to a (usually dark) triplet-triplet state. Many common organic molecules such as acenes have intense absorption in the UV (where there is less solar irradiance) but weak absorption in the visible, making them ideal candidate molecules for the spectral optimization discussed in this article.

Consequently, for OLEDs it is of particular interest to increase the transition dipole moment between the ground state and the lowest bright excited state, and for photovoltaics to increase absorption in the visible. These are therefore the main motivations of the theoretical framework in this article. Although we apply our methodology to the low-lying excited states of conjugated organic molecules (for which there is large interest for optoelectronics) the general theoretical principles can be applied to optimizing any property of a molecule which can be related to a quantum mechanical operator, such as spin-orbit coupling, permanent dipole, non-adiabatic coupling etc.

The general idea

Clearly there are an enormous range of chromophore alterations, and in this article we consider heteroatom substitution, addition and dimerization, where dimerization can be considered a form of addition where the adduct is identical to the parent chromophore.

The general idea, as illustrated in Fig. 2, is to start with a molecule that has reasonable, but not ideal properties (such as pentacene for visible absorption), properties to improve (visible absorption) and morphing operations (substitution, addition, and dimerization). The electronic Hamiltonian of the parent molecule can be solved at an approximate level of theory, leading to the spectrum of the parent chromophore. In the language of perturbation theory, this defines our zeroth-order Hamiltonian and zeroth-order states. From this spectrum and the TRK sum rule we can deduce whether or not a molecule has significant potential for improvement (for pentacene, having large absorption in the UV which could be moved to the visible). For substitution, we then define the morphing operations as perturbations to the zeroth order states (for addition and dimerization the algebra is similar but more involved) and use intensity borrowing perturbation theory[30] to determine how morphing alterations will alter the spectrum. In the event that the morphing operation does not improve the spectrum, a different one can be tried, and if the spectrum is improved a design rule can usually be derived.

By construction, a perturbative approach will not give an exact solution for the chromophore’s electronic structure (even within an approximate Hamiltonian), but the qualitative results can then be used to guide which morphing operations are more likely to improve the desired property. Much research on organic chromophores has focused on low-energy HOMO→LUMO\mathrm{HOMO}\to\mathrm{LUMO} transitions in organic molecules (whether local excitation or charge-transfer in nature)[3, 4, 35] and the theoretical results in this article are applicable to single excitations between any occupied and unoccupied orbitals. This can therefore include excitations in the visible which are higher-lying than the HOMO→LUMO\mathrm{HOMO}\to\mathrm{LUMO} transition, and whose optimization is unlikely to substantially affect the pre-existing photophysics (such as ability to undergo singlet fission) since Kasha’s rule[36] implies rapid internal conversion to the lowest excited singlet state.

In this article we restrict our attention to electronic intensity borrowing, with application to the (generally weaker) effects of vibronic (Herzberg-Teller) coupling[2, 37, 38] and spin-orbit interactions[2, 39, 40] left for future research. Although not the main focus of the article, a by-product of intensity borrowing perturbation theory are expressions for perturbed energies, and these can be used to guide how a given alteration can lead to spectral blue- or red-shifting. In addition, the spectra of organic molecules commonly contain vibrational stretching progressions which are of experimental and theoretical interest[41, 42]. These progressions spread the oscillator strength associated with a single transition over a number of vibronic peaks, but since the sum over Franck-Condon factors is equal to unity[2], do not increase the total absorption associated with a single electronic transition, and are consequently not the focus of this article. We seek to provide general rules for suggesting which molecules are likely to have improved absorption/emission, rather than high-level calculation on a single molecule for which many methods already exist. Similarly, we do not consider zero-point-energy adjustments[43] which may be required to replicate accurately experimental spectra.

For construction of a suitable Hamiltonian, there are a wide range of electronic structure methods available of varying computational cost and accuracy, and here we consider the simplest model which describes the necessary physics of organic chromophores. While Hückel theory is arguably the simplest model for simulating arbitrary π\pi systems, it neglects two electron terms so (for example) does not account for the exchange energy of forming a singlet excitation or its Coulomb stabilization, leading to an inaccurate description of excited states[44]. We therefore use Pariser-Parr-Pople theory[44, 45, 46, 47, 48], which is similar to Hückel theory but also includes two-electron terms within the neglect of differential overlap (NDO) approximation. Early applications of PPP theory include simulating the spectra of acenes[45] and their substituted derivatives[49, 50, 51] and it continues to be widely used[52, 53, 54, 55, 56] [57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63] for the simulation of large conjugated systems. In this article we use configuration interaction singles (CIS) to describe excited states, since the ground state of many organic chromophores can be reasonably well described by a single restricted-Hartree Fock (RHF) determinant as the dipole moment is a one-electron operator, meaning that most double and higher excitations are dark64. There are of course situations where double and higher excitations play an important role, for example in modelling the triplet-triplet state singlet fission, or the dark doubly-excited 2Ag2A_g state in β\beta-carotene. However, in this article we concern ourselves with describing linear absorption spectra in which single excitations dominate.[1, 6] Nevertheless, PPP can be extended to double and higher excitations65–67, as could intensity borrowing theory. As we shall see, PPP can accurately describe the spectral phenomena we consider in this article, though for weak interactions (such as Dexter) which rely on orbital overlap, different methods may be required.

There are, of course, many other electronic structure methods which could be used such as density functional theory (DFT) based approaches. Time-dependent DFT (TD-DFT) can sometimes predict inaccurate energies for CT states due to the incorrect long-range behaviour of local exchange-correlation functionals such as B3LYP, and therefore one has to employ a modified functional which is corrected for long-range behavior.68–72 This difficulty in predicting the energies of CT states is particularly problematic for acenes.73 Alternatively, complete active space methods such as CASSCF could in theory be used, but their high computational expense, the difficulty in selecting an active space,[6] and the need to incorporate perturbation theory in order to obtain accurate energies74 makes them unsuited to simulating large numbers of excited states in many candidate molecules.

Although the underlying theories in this article (TRK sum rule, intensity borrowing perturbation theory (IBPT), configuration interaction singles and PPP theory) have been around for decades, we believe this is the first time the TRK sum rule has been applied to the inverse molecular design problem, for which it could be used to formulate a fitness function. Combining PPP theory and IBPT to predict molecular spectra was, to our knowledge, first proposed in 201974 for the specific case of acene dimer absorption, after which it has been applied to the design of radical OLEDs75. However, to the best of our knowledge this is the first time this algebraic framework has been published generally and in full (i.e. not for a single specific application) and the first time it presented in the context of the inverse design problem or artifical intelligence approaches.

Background chromophore theories

There are clearly a large range of pre-existing chromophore theories which we briefly review here. Since the proposition of the chromophore theory of colour in 187676 there have been continued efforts to describe the effects of molecular structure upon optical absorption. tion. Early developments, mainly concerned with excitations in crystals, include the eponymous research on excitons by Frenkel77, Wannier78, Mott79 and Davydov80. For molecular absorption, Kasha’s exciton model81 describes chromophore interaction by a point-dipole approximation, and more theoretical approaches include the Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn (TRK) sum rule[2] [82, 83, 84] and intensity borrowing perturbation theory[30] [85] which are used in this article. Textbook[2] approaches to chromophore properties include the particle-in-a-box model (predicting an intense HOMO→LUMO\mathrm{HOMO}\to\mathrm{LUMO} transition which redshifts with increasing molecular size) and satisfying spin and point group symmetry.

Since then, there has been substantial interest in chromophore alteration and interaction in biological systems such as porphyrins86,87, DNA88 and green fluorescent protein89,90, in photovoltaic applications[35] [91, 92] such as singlet fission[4] [93, 94, 95], and in organic light-emitting diodes96,97 such as thermally activated delayed fluorescence[8, 9], radical emitters75,98,99 and carbene-metal-amides100,101. Examination of intermolecular interaction in crystals has led to explanation of crystallochromy102, and investigation of single molecule junctions to the effects of conformation on intramolecular interaction103,104. In addition, tuning the absorption frequency (colour) of a chromophore has been achieved by altering the HOMO-LUMO gap with various substitutents[35] [105, 106, 107], and design principles formulated by examining large groups of previously-synthesised or computed chromophores[35] [92].

Despite this progress challenges remain. The absorption of organic molecules in the visible is often a small fraction of the maximum allowed by the TRK sum rule[29] and it can be unclear how to optimize chromophore structure to increase absorption intensity (extinction coefficient)108,109. Rational design principles would arguably have wider and clearer applicability than those obtained empirically92, and the large size of chemical space can render a trial-and-error approach inefficient. Nevertheless, the design of highly absorbent chromophores would be of considerable practical benefit such as enabling the construction of thinner solar cells without attenuating the absorption of light[29], thereby requiring smaller exciton diffusion and leading to greater photovoltaic efficiency110. Similarly, designing OLED emitters with greater intensity of emission (transition dipole moment) would lead to faster radiative decay[2] and a greater likelihood of this outcompeting undesirable non-radiative processes such as internal conversion.99.

Article structure

In section II we address the challenge of determining the extent to which a given molecule’s spectrum can easily be improved. To do this we examine the Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn sum rule in section II A and see how this leads to lower limits on UV-vis transitions than is sometimes quoted. We illustrate this by application to a variety of organic chromophores in section II B. We then address the second challenge of predicting where and how a molecule should be substituted, added to or dimerized in section III. To do this we firstly recap pre-existing intensity borrowing theory (section III A). We then apply this theory, using the framework of configuration interaction singles and Pariser-Parr-Pople theory (see SI section III A 1 and 3), to substitution in section III B, addition in section III C and dimerization in section III D. Having addressed these challenges from a theoretical perspective, we then apply the methodology to real chromophores in section IV. We consider improving the visible absorption of acenes in section IV A followed by improving the emission of organic radicals in section IV B. We conclude in section V.

Challenge 1: How improvable is a molecule?

Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn sum rule

Here we consider the Thomas-Reiche-Kuhn sum rule82–84 (TRK) theoretically to determine approximate upper bounds to the absorbance of organic chromophores. For a system with NeN_e electrons TRK is commonly quoted as[2, 29]

∑u>0fu=Ne(1)\sum_{u>0} f_u = N_e \tag*{(1)}

where the oscillator strength fuf_u of excitation to eigenstate ∣Ψu⟩\lvert\Psi_u\rangle is

fu=2me3ℏ2∣⟨Ψ0∣r^∣Ψu⟩∣2(Eu−E0)(2)f_u = \frac{2m_e}{3\hbar^2}\lvert\langle\Psi_0|\hat{\mathbf{r}}|\Psi_u\rangle\rvert^2(E_u-E_0) \tag*{(2)}

where mem_e is the mass of an electron and r^\hat{\mathbf{r}} is a generalized co-ordinate vector. As presented in Eq. (1), the TRK refers to excitations from the ground state, though it also holds for any excited state. Qualitatively, Eq. (1) means that oscillator strength is conserved, and that while oscillator strength can be moved from one area of the spectrum to another (as Eq. (1) and Eq. (2) give no limits on the energy of a transition), it can neither be created nor destroyed, i.e. structural isomers will have the same total oscillator strength for all transitions from the ground state.

Computationally, it is found that low-energy (such as visible) excitations often constitute a tiny fraction of the total allowed oscillator strength[29], and since only the NvN_{\mathrm{v}} valence electrons are expected to contribute to low-energy transitions (81) is sometimes approximated as NvN_{\mathrm{v}}.[2] This would suggest that for an organic chromophore with NπN_{\pi} electrons in the π\pi system, the upper limit on oscillator strength would be NπN_{\pi}. However, the derivation of TRK holds in each dimension {x,y,z}\{x,y,z\} separately[2] such that

∑u>0fu(x)=Ne3(3)\sum_{u>0} f_{u}^{(x)} = \frac{N_{\mathrm{e}}}{3} \tag*{(3)}

where

fu(x)=2me3ℏ2∑u>0∣⟨Ψ0∣x^∣Ψu⟩∣2(Eu−E0)(4)f_{u}^{(x)} = \frac{2m_{\mathrm{e}}}{3\hbar^{2}} \sum_{u>0} \left|\langle\Psi_{0}|\hat{x}|\Psi_{u}\rangle\right|^{2}(E_{u}-E_{0}) \tag*{(4)}

and likewise for yy and zz. Clearly equations (3) and (4) are consistent with, but more restrictive than the TRK in (81), though in themselves do not suggest a new upper limit for chromophore absorption.

Let us then consider a linear π\pi-system, with atoms aligned along the xx axis. Using a basis of pp orbitals on each atom (as in Hückel and PPP theory), π→π∗\pi\to\pi^{*} transitions must be xx-polarized. This means that the maximum oscillator strength for any linear organic chromophore, which carotenoids (polyenes) can be approximated to be[29], is Nπ/3N_{\pi}/3 where fu(x,π)f_{u}^{(x,\pi)} refers to xx-polarized transitions involving π\pi electrons.

Let us now consider a planar π\pi-system such as pentacene or tetracene, with atoms in the (x,y)(x,y)-plane. Using similar arguments to the above, transitions can only be xx or yy-polarized, meaning that the maximum allowed oscillator strength is 2Nπ/32N_{\pi}/3. We see that both the linear and planar limits are smaller upper limits on absorption than NπN_{\pi} for a general 3-dimensional chromophore, and are summarized in Table 1, allowing us to appraise more accurately the extent to which the absorption of a chromophore in the visible (or any other region of the spectrum) is close to the maximum possible, or whether there may be scope to increase absorption further.

TABLE I. Vertical excitation energies and oscillator strengths for a series of π\pi-systems, calculated by various ab initio quantum chemistry methods at varying levels of theory in comparison to the results of PPP calculations and experimental values. a^{a}

ChromophoreStateλ\lambdafoscf_{\mathrm{osc}}TRK Max.% of TRK Max.Method
Etheneb^{b}1B3u+^{1}B_{3u}^{+}1630.340.67 (x)(x)51Exp.[5]
1B3u^{1}B_{3u}1670.2436TD-DFT[6]
1B3u+^{1}B_{3u}^{+}1600.5177CIS[7]
1B3u+^{1}B_{3u}^{+}1560.1624CASPT2[8]
1B3u+^{1}B_{3u}^{+}1880.5177PPP
Naphthalenec^{c}1B3u−^{1}B_{3u}^{-}3130.0026.67 (x,y)(x,y)∼0\sim0Exp.[9]
1B2u+^{1}B_{2u}^{+}2890.182.7
1B3u+^{1}B_{3u}^{+}2201.725
1B2u+^{1}B_{2u}^{+}2850.060.9TD-DFT[10]
1B3u−^{1}B_{3u}^{-}27900
1B3u+^{1}B_{3u}^{+}2121.2519
1B3u−^{1}B_{3u}^{-}30800CASPT2[11]
1B2u+^{1}B_{2u}^{+}2720.050.7
1B3u+^{1}B_{3u}^{+}2241.3420
1B3u−^{1}B_{3u}^{-}30200PPP
2B2u+^{2}B_{2u}^{+}3020.284.2
1B3u+^{1}B_{3u}^{+}2341.9629
Anthracenec^{c}1B2u+^{1}B_{2u}^{+}3790.19.33 (x,y)(x,y)1.1Exp.[9]
1B3u+^{1}B_{3u}^{+}2562.2824
1B2u+^{1}B_{2u}^{+}3860.060.6TD-DFT[10]
1B3u^{1}B_{3u}32300
1B3u+^{1}B_{3u}^{+}2411.9921
1B2u+^{1}B_{2u}^{+}3990.323.4PPP
1B3u−^{1}B_{3u}^{-}33800
1B3u+^{1}B_{3u}^{+}2672.6829

Table 1. TABLE I continued on next page ...

References

  1. [1]V. Venkatasubramanian, A. Sundaram, K. Chan and J. Caruthers, Genetic algorithms in molecular modeling, Elsevier, 271–302 (1996).
  2. [2]C. Kunkel, J. T. Margraf, K. Chen, H. Oberhofer and K. Reuter, Nat. Commun. 12 (2021), 2422.
  3. [3]R. Pollice, P. Friederich, C. Lavigne, G. dos Passos Gomes and A. Aspuru-Guzik, Matter 4 (2021), 1654.
  4. [4]Y. Kwon, S. Kang, Y.-S. Choi and I. Kim, Sci. Rep. 11 (2021), 1.
  5. [5]J. R. Platt, H. B. Klevens and W. C. Price, J. Chem. Phys. 17 (1949), 466.
  6. [6]N. N. Matsuzawa, A. Ishitani, D. A. Dixon and T. Uda, J. Phys. Chem. A 105 (2001), 4953.
  7. [7]K. B. Wiberg, C. M. Hadad, J. B. Foresman and W. A. Chupka, J. Phys. Chem. 96 (1992), 10756.
  8. [8]L. Serrano-Andrés, M. Merchán, I. Nebot-Gil, R. Lindh and B. O. Roos, J. Chem. Phys. 98 (1993), 3151.
  9. [9]H. B. Klevens and J. R. Platt, J. Chem. Phys. 17 (1949), 470.
  10. [10]E. S. Kadantsev, M. J. Stott and A. Rubio, J. Chem. Phys. 124 (2006), 134901.
  11. [11]M. Rubio, M. Merchán, E. Ortí and B. O. Roos, Chemical Physics 179 (1994), 395.
  12. [12]T. Zeng, R. Hoffmann and N. Ananth, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 136 (2014), 5755, pMID: 24697685.
  13. [13]K. Onaka, R. Fujii, H. Nagae, M. Kuki, K. Yasushi and Y. Watanabe, Chem. Phys. Lett. 315 (1999), 75.
  14. [14]H. Kandori, H. Sasabe and M. Mimuro, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 116 (1994), 2671.
  15. [15]M. Kleinschmidt, C. M. Marian, M. Waletzke and S. Grimme, J. Chem. Phys. 130 (2009), 044708.
  16. [16]H. Kleinert, Path integrals in quantum mechanics, statistics, polymer physics, and financial markets, World Scientific (2009).
  17. [17]L. Lin, Z. Wang, J. Fan and C. Wang, Org. Electron. 41 (2017), 17.
  18. [18]A. S. Romanov, S. T. E. Jones, Q. Gu, P. J. Conaghan, B. H. Drummond, J. Feng, F. Chotard, L. Buizza, M. Foley, M. Lonnolahlti, D. Credgington and M. Bochmann, Chem. Sci. 11 (2020), 435.
  19. [19]T. J. H. Hele and D. Credgington, arxiv preprint 1802.00804 (2018), (under review).
  20. [20]A. Szabo and N. Ostlund, Modern Quantum Chemistry: Introduction to Advanced Electronic Structure Theory, Dover Books on Chemistry, Dover Publications (1989).
  21. [21]R. Pariser, J. Chem. Phys. 24 (1956), 250.
  22. [22]T. J. H. Hele, E. G. Fuemmeler, S. N. Sanders, E. Kumarasamy, M. Y. Sfeir, L. M. Campos and N. Ananth, J. Phys. Chem. A 123 (2019), 2527, pMID: 30802051.
  23. [23]T. J. H. Hele, A. J. Musser and D. Baran, eds., Physical Chemistry of Semiconductor Materials and Interfaces XX, International Society for Optics and Photonics, SPIE (2021), volume 11799, 57 – 73.
  24. [24]For a monoradical we define the SOMO to be orbital 0.
  25. [25]A. Abdurahman, T. J. H. Hele, Q. Gu, J. Zhang, Q. Peng, M. Zhang, R. H. Friend, F. Li and E. W. Evans, Nat. Mater. 19 (2020), 1224.
  26. [26]C. C. J. Roothaan, Rev. Mod. Phys. 23 (1951), 69.
  27. [27]P. Sony and A. Shukla, Phys. Rev. B 75 (2007), 155208.
  28. [28]P. W. Atkins and R. S. Friedman, Molecular quantum mechanics, Oxford university press (2011).
  29. [29]G. W. Robinson, J. Chem. Phys. 46 (1967), 572.
  30. [30]We note that Wilse Robinson does not appear to include the first term of the second-order perturbation theory expression, though this term, which can be considered a form of normalization, does not significantly affect the eventual results.
  31. [31]L. D. Landau and E. M. Lifshitz, Quantum Mechanics (Third Edition, Revised and Enlarged), Pergamon, 133 – 163, third edition, revised and enlarged edition (1977).
  32. [32]H. R. R. M. Kasha and M. A. El-Bayoumi, Pure Appl. Chem. 11 (1965), 371.
  33. [33]M. Gouterman, J. Chem. Phys. 30 (1959), 1139.
  34. [34]P.-O. Löwdin, J. Chem. Phys. 19 (1951), 1396.
  35. [35]M. Kasha, Faraday Discuss. 9 (1950), 14.
  36. [36]J. A. Pople, Trans. Faraday Soc. 49 (1953), 1375.
  37. [37]K. Aryanpour, D. Psiachos and S. Mazumdar, Phys. Rev. B 81 (2010), 085407.
  38. [38]C. A. Coulson and G. S. Rushbrooke, Math. Proc. Cambridge 36 (1940), 193.
  39. [39]K. Aryanpour, J. A. Muñoz and S. Mazumdar, J. Phys. Chem. C 117 (2013), 4971.
  40. [40]A. M. Alvertis, S. Lukman, T. J. H. Hele, E. G. Fuemmeler, J. Feng, J. Wu, N. C. Greenham, A. W. Chin and A. J. Musser, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 141 (2019), 17558.
  41. [41]A. D. Buckingham, Permanent and Induced Molecular Moments and Long-Range Intermolecular Forces, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., volume 12, 107–142 (1967).
  42. [42]A. J. Stone, The Theory of Intermolecular Forces, Oxford University Press (2013), chapter 3.
  43. [43]A. Volkov and P. Coppens, J. Comput. Chem. 25 (2004), 921.
  44. [44]N. Mataga and K. Nishimoto, Zeitschrift für Physikalische Chemie 13 (1957), 140.
  45. [45]R. S. Mulliken, J. Chem. Phys. 7 (1939), 20.
  46. [46]R. S. Mulliken, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 72 (1950), 600.
  47. [47]C. A. Coulson, P. Phys. Soc. Lond. 60 (1948), 257.
  48. [48]L. Zheng, N. F. Polizzi, A. R. Dave, A. Migliore and D. N. Beratan, J. Phys. Chem. A 120 (2016), 1933.
  49. [49]S. R. Forrest, MRS Bulletin 30 (2005), 28.
  50. [50]N. F. Mott, Proc. Roy. Soc. A 167 (1938), 384.
  51. [51]T. C. Berkelbach, M. S. Hybertsen and D. R. Reichman, J. Chem. Phys. 138 (2013), 114102.
  52. [52]E. G. Fuemmeler, S. N. Sanders, A. B. Pun, E. Kumarasamy, T. Zeng, K. Miyata, M. L. Steigerwald, X.-Y. Zhu, M. Y. Sfeir, L. M. Campos and N. Ananth, ACS Cent. Sci. 2 (2016), 316, pMID: 27280166.
  53. [53]F. Neese, F. Wennmohs, U. Becker and C. Riplinger, J. Chem. Phys. 152 (2020), 224108.
  54. [54]L. Venkataraman, J. E. Klare, C. Nuckolls, M. S. Hybertsen and M. L. Steigerwald, Nature 442 (2006), 904.
  55. [55]F. A. Van-Catledge, J. Org. Chem. 45 (1980), 4801.
  56. [56]J. Hinze and D. L. Beveridge, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 93 (1971), 3107.

Paper details

vlnc:W_5t8qeupd
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents