betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Ultra-complex conductivity diagrams in the nearly free electron approximation

Abstract

We investigate the possibility of the emergence of ultra-complex conductivity diagrams in the nearly free electron approximation for metals with cubic symmetry. Estimates show that the emergence of such diagrams requires the Fermi level to fall into very narrow energy intervals within the conduction band. In our view, this circumstance is mostly due to the high symmetry and the simplest analytical form of the dispersion relations ε(p)ε({\bf p}) under consideration.

Introduction

In this paper, we consider the angular diagrams that determine the conductivity of normal metals in strong magnetic fields. We note that we are interested only in metals with sufficiently complex Fermi surfaces extending in all directions in p\mathbf{p}-space (Figure 1).

Figure 1. Complex Fermi surface in p\mathbf{p}-space.

As is well known (see e.g. [1, 2, 3, 4]), the electron quasi-momentum is defined modulo the vectors of the reciprocal lattice L∗L^*:

p≡p+n1a1+n2a2+n3a3,\mathbf{p} \equiv\mathbf{p} + n_1\mathbf{a}_1 + n_2\mathbf{a}_2 + n_3\mathbf{a}_3,
n1,n2,n3∈Z,n_1,n_2,n_3 \in\mathbb{Z},

where the basis of the lattice L∗L^* is given by the vectors

a1=2πℏl2×l3(l1,l2,l3),a2=2πℏl3×l1(l1,l2,l3),\mathbf{a}_1 = 2\pi\hbar\frac{\mathbf{l}_2 \times\mathbf{l}_3}{(\mathbf{l}_1,\mathbf{l}_2,\mathbf{l}_3)}, \qquad\mathbf{a}_2 = 2\pi\hbar\frac{\mathbf{l}_3 \times\mathbf{l}_1}{(\mathbf{l}_1,\mathbf{l}_2,\mathbf{l}_3)},
a3=2πℏl1×l2(l1,l2,l3),\mathbf{a}_3 = 2\pi\hbar\frac{\mathbf{l}_1 \times\mathbf{l}_2}{(\mathbf{l}_1,\mathbf{l}_2,\mathbf{l}_3)},

and (l1,l2,l3)(\mathbf{l}_1,\mathbf{l}_2,\mathbf{l}_3) define the basis of the crystallographic lattice LL.

As a consequence, the dispersion relation (the dependence of energy on quasi-momentum) ε(p)\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) in a crystal can be considered either as a 3-periodic function in the space R3\mathbb{R}^3 or simply as a smooth function on the three-dimensional torus

T3=R3/L∗\mathbb{T}^3 = \mathbb{R}^3/L^*

determined by the factorization of p\mathbf{p}-space by the reciprocal lattice vectors.

The Fermi surface of a metal

SF: ε(p)=εFS_F:\ \varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) = \varepsilon_F

can also be viewed either as a 3-periodic surface in the p\mathbf{p}-space (Figure 1) or as a smooth compact surface embedded in T3\mathbb{T}^3. We note here that both of these representations play very important role when considering electronic phenomena in strong magnetic fields.

Each compact (orientable) surface SFS_F has a topological genus gg, which can take values g=0,1,2,3,4,…g = 0,1,2,3,4,\ldots (Figure 2, a).

Figure 2. (a) Abstract orientable surfaces of genus g=0,1,2,3,4g = 0, 1, 2, 3, 4. (b) Examples of Fermi surfaces of rank 0, 1, 2 and 3.

The embedding SF⊂R3S_F \subset\mathbb{R}^3 (and also SF⊂T3S_F \subset\mathbb{T}^3) also has a topological rank Rank⁡SF\operatorname{Rank} S_F. By definition, the topological rank of SFS_F determines the number of independent directions of extension of the surface SFS_F in R3\mathbb{R}^3 (Figure 2, b). It is easy to see that the rank of the Fermi surface can take the values 0, 1, 2, and 3.

For topological reasons, the rank of a Fermi surface cannot exceed its genus. Thus, Fermi surfaces that are sufficiently complex from our point of view have Rank⁡SF=3\operatorname{Rank} S_F = 3 and g≥3g \ge3.

The application of an external magnetic field causes an adiabatic evolution of the electron states in a crystal, which is described by the quasi-momentum evolution determined by the system

p˙=ec[vgr(p)×B]≡ec[∇ε(p)×B](1)\dot{\mathbf{p}} = \frac{e}{c}\left[\mathbf{v}_{\mathrm{gr}}(\mathbf{p}) \times\mathbf{B}\right] \equiv\frac{e}{c}\left[\nabla\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) \times\mathbf{B}\right] \tag*{(1)}

Geometrically, the trajectories of system ((I.1)) are defined by the intersections of constant-energy surfaces

ε(p)=const\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) = \mathrm{const}

and planes orthogonal to B\mathbf{B}. Electronic phenomena in metals are determined by trajectories of (I.1) lying on the Fermi surface ε(p)=εF\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) = \varepsilon_F. As can be seen, for complex Fermi surfaces, the shape of the trajectories of (I.1) can strongly depend on the direction of B\mathbf{B} (Figure 3, a).

Figure 3. (a) Trajectories of the system (I.1) on the Fermi surface of a rather complex shape. (b) Closed trajectories of the system (I.1). (c) Open periodic trajectories of the system (I.1).

In the limit of large mean free paths and strong magnetic fields, electron transport phenomena in a crystal are largely determined by the geometry of the trajectories of system (I.1) in the p - space. In particular, the behavior of the conductivity tensor σkl(B)\sigma^{kl}(\mathbf{B}) depends significantly on the presence or absence of open (unclosed) trajectories of system (I.1) on the Fermi surface ([5–8]). The corresponding limit can be formally written as the condition ωBτ≫1\omega_B\tau\gg1, where ωB\omega_B is the cyclotron frequency, and τ\tau is the electron mean free time in the crystal.

More precisely, it is necessary in fact to require that the electron travels a sufficiently large part of its trajectory (compared to pFp_F) between scattering events. It should be noted immediately that this limit applies to sufficiently pure single-crystal samples at low temperatures (T≤1KT \le1\mathrm{K}) and strong magnetic fields (B≥1TlB \ge1\mathrm{Tl}).

A striking example of the manifestation of the geometry of trajectories of (I.1) in transport phenomena is the difference in the contributions of closed and open periodic trajectories (Figure 3, b, c) to the conductivity tensor in the limit ωBτ→∞\omega_B\tau\to\infty ([5]).

Δσclosedkl≃ne2τm∗((ωBτ)−2(ωBτ)−1(ωBτ)−1(ωBτ)−1(ωBτ)−2(ωBτ)−1(ωBτ)−1(ωBτ)−1∗)(2)\Delta\sigma^{kl}_{\mathrm{closed}} \simeq\frac{ne^2\tau}{m^*} \begin{pmatrix} (\omega_B\tau)^{-2} & (\omega_B\tau)^{-1} & (\omega_B\tau)^{-1} \\ (\omega_B\tau)^{-1} & (\omega_B\tau)^{-2} & (\omega_B\tau)^{-1} \\ (\omega_B\tau)^{-1} & (\omega_B\tau)^{-1} & * \end{pmatrix} \tag*{(2)}
Δσperiodickl≃ne2τm∗((ωBτ)−2(ωBτ)−1(ωBτ)−1(ωBτ)−1∗∗(ωBτ)−1∗∗)(3)\Delta\sigma^{kl}_{\mathrm{periodic}} \simeq\frac{ne^2\tau}{m^*} \begin{pmatrix} (\omega_B\tau)^{-2} & (\omega_B\tau)^{-1} & (\omega_B\tau)^{-1} \\ (\omega_B\tau)^{-1} & * & * \\ (\omega_B\tau)^{-1} & * & * \end{pmatrix} \tag*{(3)}

It can be seen that the contribution of closed trajectories to the tensor σkl(B)\sigma^{kl}(\mathbf{B}) is similar to the contribution of the free electron gas, while the contribution (I.3) has a sharp anisotropy in the plane orthogonal to B\mathbf{B}.

In formulas (I.2) - (I.3), the quantity nn plays the role of the charge carrier concentration, and m∗m^* is the effective electron mass in the crystal. The sign * here denotes dimensionless constants of order 1.

Formulas (I.2) - (I.3) describe the asymptotic behavior of the tensor σkl(B)\sigma^{kl}(\mathbf{B}) in the limit ωBτ→∞\omega_B\tau\to\infty, in particular, each matrix element above is defined up to a constant factor of order 1. However, one important remark can be made.

Namely, if we are talking about the contribution of all closed trajectories covering the Fermi surface of the form Figure 3b, then a more precise expression can be given for the Hall conductivity. Thus, in the leading order in 1/B1/B, the quantity σxy(B)\sigma^{xy}(B) has the form ([1–4, 8])

σxy=−σyx=±ecB2V(2πℏ)3(4)\sigma^{xy} = -\sigma^{yx} = \pm\frac{ec}{B}\frac{2V}{(2\pi\hbar)^3} \tag*{(4)}

where VV is the volume bounded by the surface SFS_F in the p\mathbf{p}-space.

As can be seen, the value (I.4) does not depend on the direction of the magnetic field for a given value of BB. The signs + and − in formula (I.4) correspond to the electron- and hole-type Fermi surfaces, respectively. Recall that for a dispersion relation ε(p)\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}), such that

εmin⁡≤ε(p)≤εmax⁡\varepsilon_{\min} \leq\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) \leq\varepsilon_{\max}

the electron-type Fermi surfaces Figure 3b arise at values εF\varepsilon_F close to εmin⁡\varepsilon_{\min}, and the hole-type Fermi surfaces arise at εF\varepsilon_F close to εmax⁡\varepsilon_{\max}.

Note also that for Fermi surfaces containing open trajectories of system (I.1), the relation (I.4) is not satisfied.

The problem of describing all possible trajectories of system (I.1) was posed by S.P. Novikov in his work [9] and was then intensively studied in his topological school ([10–17]). As a result of the research, a complete classification of all trajectories of systems (I.1) with arbitrary laws ε(p)\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}), as well as a detailed description of their geometric properties, was carried out. In addition, a description of all possible modes of conductivity behavior in the limit ωBτ→∞\omega_B\tau\to\infty, corresponding to open trajectories of various types, has also been obtained by now (see, for example, [18, 19, 20]).

For a metal with a given Fermi surface SFS_F, it is natural to introduce the “angular diagram” defined by the system (I.1). Namely, for each direction of B\mathbf{B}:

n=B/B∈S2,\mathbf{n} = \mathbf{B}/B \in S^2,

the angular diagram indicates the type of open trajectories (or their absence) on the surface SFS_F. Since each type of open trajectories on SFS_F is associated with a certain type of behavior of the tensor σkl(B)\sigma^{kl}(B) as ωBτ→∞\omega_B\tau\to\infty, we will call such diagrams diagrams of conductivity in strong magnetic fields.

As is easy to see, for values εF\varepsilon_F close to εmin⁡\varepsilon_{\min} or εmax⁡\varepsilon_{\max}, the conductivity diagrams are very simple. Namely, all directions n∈S2\mathbf{n} \in S^2 correspond here to the presence of only closed trajectories on the Fermi surface (Figure 3, b). The Hall conductivity here is given by the formula (I.4) and is of the electron type at εF→εmin⁡\varepsilon_F \to\varepsilon_{\min} and of the hole type at εF→εmax⁡\varepsilon_F \to\varepsilon_{\max}.

We will also classify as simple diagrams those that allow only periodic open trajectories of (I.1) on the Fermi surface. As a rule, such diagrams also arise for values of εF\varepsilon_F that are “not too” distant from εmin⁡\varepsilon_{\min} or εmax⁡\varepsilon_{\max}.

The main type of open trajectories of (I.1) are stable open trajectories, i.e. trajectories that are stable with respect to all small rotations of B\mathbf{B}, as well as small variations in the value of εF\varepsilon_F.

The stable open trajectories of system (I.1) have remarkable geometric properties ([10, 11, 13]). Namely:

  1. Each stable open trajectory of system (I.1) lies (in a plane orthogonal to B\mathbf{B}) in a straight strip of finite width, passing through it (Figure 4, a).

Stable open trajectory and stability zones

Figure 4. (a) Stable open trajectory of system (I.1) in a plane orthogonal to B\mathbf{B}. (b) Stability Zones corresponding to different integer planes Γα\Gamma_\alpha on the conductivity diagram (schematically).

  1. The mean direction of stable open trajectories (in all planes orthogonal to B\mathbf{B}) for a given direction of B\mathbf{B} is given by the intersection of the plane orthogonal to B\mathbf{B} and some (“integer”) plane Γ\Gamma generated by two reciprocal lattice vectors.

  1. The plane Γ\Gamma is unchanged for small rotations of B\mathbf{B} and variations in the value of εF\varepsilon_F.

Note that, in general, stable open trajectories are not periodic.

The emergence of stable open trajectories on the Fermi surface corresponds to domains Ωα\Omega_\alpha (Stability Zones) on the angular diagram, each of which corresponds to its own integer plane Γα\Gamma_\alpha (Figure 4, b). The Zones Ωα\Omega_\alpha, as well as the integer planes Γα\Gamma_\alpha, are experimentally observable, which formed the basis for the introduction of topological numbers in the conductivity of normal metals in [21].

Stable open trajectories can only appear on sufficiently complex Fermi surfaces (rank 2 or 3). We will classify an angular diagram as sufficiently complex if it contains Stability Zones Ωα\Omega_\alpha.

For a fixed dispersion relation ε(p)\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}), complex angular diagrams arise in some fixed energy range

εF∈(ε1A,ε2A),εmin⁡≤ε1A<ε2A≤εmax⁡,\varepsilon_F \in\left(\varepsilon_1^A,\varepsilon_2^A\right), \qquad\varepsilon_{\min} \leq\varepsilon_1^A < \varepsilon_2^A \leq\varepsilon_{\max},

where the Fermi surfaces are sufficiently complex.

The interval (ε1A,ε2A)\left(\varepsilon_1^A,\varepsilon_2^A\right) can be divided into 3 intervals

(ε1A,ε2A)=(ε1A,ε1B]∪[ε1B,ε2B]∪(ε2B,ε2A)\left(\varepsilon_1^A,\varepsilon_2^A\right) = \left(\varepsilon_1^A,\varepsilon_1^B\right] \cup\left[\varepsilon_1^B,\varepsilon_2^B\right] \cup\left(\varepsilon_2^B,\varepsilon_2^A\right)

(for generic dispersion relations), corresponding to different structures of the angular diagrams (see [22, 23]). This circumstance is connected, among other things, with different behavior of the Hall conductivity for different values of εF\varepsilon_F.

Namely, in the evolution of the angular diagrams for εF∈(ε1A,ε2A)\varepsilon_F \in\left(\varepsilon_1^A,\varepsilon_2^A\right), from the emergence of the first Stability Zones Ωα\Omega_\alpha to their disappearance (Figure 5), one can see that all the diagrams contain large regions corresponding to the presence of only closed trajectories on the Fermi surface. These regions occupy nearly the entire unit sphere for εF→ε1A\varepsilon_F \to\varepsilon_1^A or εF→ε2A\varepsilon_F \to\varepsilon_2^A (Figure 5, a, f) and correspond to electron Hall conductivity in the first case, and to hole Hall conductivity in the second case.

Evolution of Stability Zones on the conductivity diagram

Figure 5. Evolution of Stability Zones on the conductivity diagram in the interval ϵF∈(ϵ1A,ϵ2A)\epsilon_F \in(\epsilon_1^A,\epsilon_2^A) (schematically). The signs e and h mark the regions of electron and hole Hall conductivity, respectively.

In fact, formulas (I.4) can also be applied to complex Fermi surfaces, provided that they contain only closed trajectories of the system (I.1) and this property is preserved for (any) small rotations of B\mathbf{B}. In this case, the formulas (I.4) take the form

σxy=−σyx=±ecB2V∓(2πℏ)3(5)\sigma^{xy} = -\sigma^{yx} = \pm\frac{e c}{B}\frac{2V_{\mp}}{(2\pi\hbar)^3} \tag*{(5)}

where V−V_- is the volume of the region

ε(p)<εF,\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) < \varepsilon_F,

and V+V_+ is the volume of the region

ε(p)>εF\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) > \varepsilon_F

in the torus

T3=R3/L∗\mathbb{T}^{3} = \mathbb{R}^{3}/L^{*}

where

ε1A<ε1B≤ε2B<ε2A\varepsilon_{1}^{A} < \varepsilon_{1}^{B} \le\varepsilon_{2}^{B} < \varepsilon_{2}^{A}

To select the value of V−V_{-} or V+V_{+} in the formula (I.5), it is necessary to consider the picture of closed trajectories of (I.1) in planes orthogonal to B\mathbf{B}. Namely, in the described situation, two cases are possible:

  1. Situation A(−)A(-):

A plane orthogonal to B\mathbf{B} contains a unique unbounded component of the set

ε(p)>εF,\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) > \varepsilon_F ,

and all other components of the sets ε(p)<εF\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) < \varepsilon_F and ε(p)>εF\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) > \varepsilon_F are bounded (Figure 6, a).

Situations A(−) and A(+) in planes orthogonal to B

Figure 6. Situations A(−)A(-) and A(+)A(+) in planes orthogonal to B\mathbf{B}.

  1. Situation A(+)A(+):

A plane orthogonal to B\mathbf{B} contains a unique unbounded component of the set

ε(p)<εF,\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) < \varepsilon_F ,

and all other components of the sets ε(p)<εF\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) < \varepsilon_F and ε(p)>εF\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) > \varepsilon_F are bounded (Figure 6, b).

If the Fermi surface contains only closed trajectories of system (I.1), and this property is stable with respect to small rotations of B\mathbf{B}, all planes orthogonal to B\mathbf{B} have the same type (A(−)A(-) or A(+)A(+). In formula (I.5), the factor V−V_{-} corresponds to the situation A(−)A(-), and the factor V+V_{+} corresponds to the situation A(+)A(+).

Near the edges of the interval (ε1A,ε2A)(\varepsilon_{1}^{A},\varepsilon_{2}^{A}) the region

S2∖⋃αΩαS^{2}\setminus\bigcup_{\alpha}\Omega_{\alpha}

on the angular diagram is connected, and the number of Zones Ωα⊂S2\Omega_{\alpha}\subset S^{2} is finite (Figure 5, a, b, e, f). This type of angular diagrams persists in some intervals

εF∈(ε1A,ε1B)andεF∈(ε2B,ε2A),\varepsilon_F\in(\varepsilon_{1}^{A},\varepsilon_{1}^{B}) \qquad\text{and}\qquad\varepsilon_F\in(\varepsilon_{2}^{B},\varepsilon_{2}^{A}) ,

Regions where only closed trajectories are present on the Fermi surface obviously correspond to electron Hall conductivity

σxy=−σyx=ecB2V−(2πℏ)3\sigma^{xy}=-\sigma^{yx}=\frac{ec}{B}\frac{2V_{-}}{(2\pi\hbar)^{3}}

in the interval εF∈(ε1A,ε1B)\varepsilon_F\in(\varepsilon_{1}^{A},\varepsilon_{1}^{B}) and to hole Hall conductivity

σxy=−σyx=−ecB2V+(2πℏ)3\sigma^{xy}=-\sigma^{yx}=-\frac{ec}{B}\frac{2V_{+}}{(2\pi\hbar)^{3}}

in the interval εF∈(ε2B,ε2A)\varepsilon_F\in(\varepsilon_{2}^{B},\varepsilon_{2}^{A}).

We will call the conductivity diagrams diagrams of the type A−A_{-} for εF∈(ε1A,ε1B)\varepsilon_F\in(\varepsilon_{1}^{A},\varepsilon_{1}^{B}) and diagrams of the type A+A_{+} for εF∈(ε2B,ε2A)\varepsilon_F\in(\varepsilon_{2}^{B},\varepsilon_{2}^{A}).

The interval [ε1B,ε2B][\varepsilon_{1}^{B},\varepsilon_{2}^{B}] separates the two types of diagrams described above (A−A_{-} and A+A_{+}). For generic dispersion relations ε(p)\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}), the interval [ε1B,ε2B][\varepsilon_{1}^{B},\varepsilon_{2}^{B}] has finite width (ε2B>ε1B\varepsilon_{2}^{B}>\varepsilon_{1}^{B}).

In this paper, we will be interested in the position of the interval [ε1B,ε2B][\varepsilon_{1}^{B},\varepsilon_{2}^{B}] for the relations ε(p)\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}) arising in the nearly free electron approximation.

For εF∈(ε1B,ε2B)\varepsilon_F\in(\varepsilon_{1}^{B},\varepsilon_{2}^{B}) the set

S2∖⋃αΩαS^{2}\setminus\bigcup_{\alpha}\Omega_{\alpha}

contains regions of both electron and hole Hall conductivity (Figure 5, c, d). Regions of different Hall conductivity are separated by “chains” of Zones Ωα\Omega_{\alpha}, which in generic case contain an infinite number of Zones. We will call angular diagrams of this type ultra-complex conductivity diagrams, or type B diagrams.

Generic diagrams of type B contain an infinite number of Zones Ωα\Omega_\alpha. Small Zones Ωα\Omega_\alpha correspond to increasingly complex geometry of the open trajectories of system (I.1) (Figure 7, a), which, in turn, corresponds to increasingly complex behavior of the tensor σkl(B)\sigma^{kl}(B) in the limit ωBτ→∞\omega_B\tau\to\infty.

Figure 7. (a) Complication of the shape of stable open trajectories for small Stability Zones Ωα\Omega_\alpha. (b) Dynnikov’s “Chaotic” trajectory in a plane orthogonal to B\mathbf{B} (schematically).

The accumulation points of small Zones Ωα\Omega_\alpha represent special directions n∈S2\mathbf{n} \in S^2, corresponding to the emergence of trajectories called “chaotic”. The most common “chaotic” trajectories, or Dynnikov’s trajectories ([15, 16]), have a very complex shape, wandering “everywhere” in planes orthogonal to B\mathbf{B} (Figure 7, b). Trajectories of this type give the most complex contribution to the tensor σkl(B)\sigma^{kl}(B), leading to the suppression of conductivity along the direction of B\mathbf{B}, as well as the emergence of fractional powers of ωBτ\omega_B\tau in the components σkl(B)\sigma^{kl}(\mathbf{B}) [24, 25]. It should be noted that the study of chaotic trajectories of system (I.1) is actively continuing at the present time (see [26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43]).

As it turns out, the interval [ε1B,ε2B][\varepsilon_1^B,\varepsilon_2^B] is usually quite narrow, and the probability of εF\varepsilon_F falling within it is quite low. This explains the difficulty of detecting of type B diagrams in real experiments. The paper [44] presents estimates for the position of the interval [ε1B,ε2B][\varepsilon_1^B,\varepsilon_2^B] and its width in the tight-binding approximation. In this paper, we present estimates of the position of this interval in the nearly free electron approximation (see [1, 2, 3, 4, 8, 45]) for crystals of cubic symmetry. The presented results can be useful both for searching for ultra-complex conductivity diagrams and, possibly, for obtaining them by external action on the sample.

Ultra-Complex Angular Diagrams and the Case of the Simple Cubic Lattice

To determine the location of ultra-complex angular diagrams, it is convenient to relate them to the angular diagrams of the entire dispersion relation ε(p)\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}). The angular diagram of a dispersion relation ([17]) specifies the interval [ε1(n),ε2(n)][\varepsilon_1(\mathbf{n}),\varepsilon_2(\mathbf{n})] of occurrence of open trajectories of system (I.1), as well as their type, for each direction B\mathbf{B} for a given ε(p)\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}). According to [17]:

  1. For each direction n=B/B\mathbf{n}=\mathbf{B}/B, open trajectories of system (I.1) arise in a closed interval

εF∈[ε1(n),ε2(n)],\varepsilon_F \in[\varepsilon_1(\mathbf{n}),\varepsilon_2(\mathbf{n})],

which can contract to a point

ε1(n)=ε2(n)=ε0(n)\varepsilon_1(\mathbf{n})=\varepsilon_2(\mathbf{n})=\varepsilon_0(\mathbf{n})
  1. The case ε2(n)>ε1(n)\varepsilon_2(\mathbf{n})>\varepsilon_1(\mathbf{n}) corresponds to the emergence of stable or periodic open trajectories of system (I.1).

For directions n\mathbf{n} of maximal irrationality, case (2) corresponds to the emergence of stable open trajectories of system (I.1) that have the same mean direction for all εF∈[ε1(n),ε2(n)]\varepsilon_F\in[\varepsilon_1(\mathbf{n}),\varepsilon_2(\mathbf{n})]. The functions ε1(n)\varepsilon_1(\mathbf{n}) and ε2(n)\varepsilon_2(\mathbf{n}) are continuous on the set of directions n\mathbf{n} of maximal irrationality and can be extended to continuous functions ε~1(n)\widetilde{\varepsilon}_1(\mathbf{n}) and ε~2(n)\widetilde{\varepsilon}_2(\mathbf{n}) on the unit sphere. The connected components of the set

ε~2(n)>ε~1(n)\widetilde{\varepsilon}_2(\mathbf{n})>\widetilde{\varepsilon}_1(\mathbf{n})

define Stability Zones WαW_\alpha on S2S^2, corresponding to stable open trajectories associated with different integer planes Γα\Gamma_\alpha. Stability Zones WαW_\alpha represent domains with piecewise smooth boundaries on the unit sphere ([17]). The Zones WαW_\alpha form a dense set on the unit sphere (Figure 8); moreover, for dispersion laws satisfying the condition

Stability Zones $W_\alpha$ on the angular diagram for a dispersion relation $\epsilon(\mathbf{p})$ (schematically) and “symmetric” points $P$ and $Q$ on the boundary of Zone $W_1$

Figure 8. Stability Zones WαW_\alpha on the angular diagram for a dispersion relation ϵ(p)\epsilon(\mathbf{p}) (schematically) and “symmetric” points PP and QQ on the boundary of Zone W1W_1.

ε(p)=ε(−p),\varepsilon(\mathbf{p})=\varepsilon(-\mathbf{p}),

their union is a set of full measure on S2S^2 (I.A. Dynnikov, P. Hubert, P. Mercat, A.S. Skripchenko, in preparation). The picture of Zones WαW_\alpha and behavior of the functions ε~1(n)\widetilde{\varepsilon}_1(\mathbf{n}), ε~2(n)\widetilde{\varepsilon}_2(\mathbf{n}) (as well as ε1(n)\varepsilon_1(\mathbf{n}) and ε2(n)\varepsilon_2(\mathbf{n})) provide important general information about a relation ε(p)\varepsilon(\mathbf{p}).

Zones Ωα\Omega_\alpha (on the conductivity angular diagram) represent subdomains of Zones WαW_\alpha, such that

n∈Wα,εF∈[ε~1(n),ε~2(n)]\mathbf{n}\in W_\alpha,\quad\varepsilon_F\in[\widetilde{\varepsilon}_1(\mathbf{n}),\widetilde{\varepsilon}_2(\mathbf{n})]

(if this set is not empty).

As can be seen, for the values of ε1A\varepsilon_1^A and ε2A\varepsilon_2^A we have the relations

ε1A=min⁡S2ε~1(n),ε2A=max⁡S2ε~2(n)\varepsilon_1^A=\min_{S^2}\widetilde{\varepsilon}_1(\mathbf{n}),\qquad\varepsilon_2^A=\max_{S^2}\widetilde{\varepsilon}_2(\mathbf{n})

For directions of B\mathbf{B} of maximal irrationality, the condition εF<ε~1(n)\varepsilon_F<\widetilde{\varepsilon}_1(\mathbf{n}) means falling into the region of the presence of only closed trajectories on the Fermi surface (on the conductivity diagram) with the Hall conductivity of the electron type. Similarly, the condition εF>ε~2(n)\varepsilon_F>\widetilde{\varepsilon}_2(\mathbf{n}) for such directions of B\mathbf{B} means falling into the region of the presence of only closed trajectories on the Fermi surface with the Hall conductivity of the hole type.

The presence of regions of both types on the conductivity angular diagram means the condition

min⁡S2ϵ~2(n)<ϵF<max⁡S2ϵ~1(n),\min_{\mathbb{S}^2} \widetilde{\epsilon}_2(\mathbf{n}) < \epsilon_F < \max_{\mathbb{S}^2} \widetilde{\epsilon}_1(\mathbf{n}),

that entails the relations

ϵ1B=min⁡S2ϵ~2(n),ϵ2B=max⁡S2ϵ~1(n),(6)\epsilon_1^B = \min_{\mathbb{S}^2} \widetilde{\epsilon}_2(\mathbf{n}), \qquad\epsilon_2^B = \max_{\mathbb{S}^2} \widetilde{\epsilon}_1(\mathbf{n}), \tag*{(6)}

which determine the interval of emergence of type B conductivity diagrams [22, 23].

Let us immediately note that for “physically realistic” dispersion relations we will assume that all Zones Ωα\Omega_\alpha and WαW_\alpha are simply connected [23]. This, in particular, implies the relations

max⁡Wαϵ~1(n)=max⁡∂Wαϵ~1(n),min⁡Wαϵ~2(n)=min⁡∂Wαϵ~2(n),\max_{W_\alpha} \widetilde{\epsilon}_1(\mathbf{n}) = \max_{\partial W_\alpha} \widetilde{\epsilon}_1(\mathbf{n}), \qquad\min_{W_\alpha} \widetilde{\epsilon}_2(\mathbf{n}) = \min_{\partial W_\alpha} \widetilde{\epsilon}_2(\mathbf{n}),

for all Zones WαW_\alpha (and their boundaries ∂Wα\partial W_\alpha). The relations (II.1) can then be replaced by the relations

ϵ1B=min⁡∪∂Wαϵ~2(n),ϵ2B=max⁡∪∂Wαϵ~1(n),(7)\epsilon_1^B = \min_{\cup\partial W_\alpha} \widetilde{\epsilon}_2(\mathbf{n}), \qquad\epsilon_2^B = \max_{\cup\partial W_\alpha} \widetilde{\epsilon}_1(\mathbf{n}), \tag*{(7)}

where the minimum and maximum are taken only over the set of boundaries of WαW_\alpha (and not over the entire unit sphere S2\mathbb{S}^2).

On the boundaries of WαW_\alpha we have

ϵ~1(n)=ϵ~2(n)≡ϵ~0(n),\widetilde{\epsilon}_1(\mathbf{n}) = \widetilde{\epsilon}_2(\mathbf{n}) \equiv\widetilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}),

and thus the position of the interval [ϵ1B,ϵ2B][\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B] is determined by the minimum and maximum of the function ϵ~0(n)\widetilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}) over all boundaries of WαW_\alpha:

ϵ1B=min⁡∪∂Wαϵ~0(n),ϵ2B=max⁡∪∂Wαϵ~0(n)\epsilon_1^B = \min_{\cup\partial W_\alpha} \widetilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}), \qquad\epsilon_2^B = \max_{\cup\partial W_\alpha} \widetilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n})

For “physically realistic” relations ϵ(p)\epsilon(\mathbf{p}), the location of ϵF\epsilon_F in the interval [ϵ1B,ϵ2B][\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B] entails a significant complication of conductivity diagrams compared to the case ϵF∉[ϵ1B,ϵ2B]\epsilon_F \notin[\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B]. In particular, the regions of electron and hole Hall conductivity (and the presence of only closed trajectories on the Fermi surface) are divided on S2\mathbb{S}^2 by “quasi-one-dimensional” chains consisting of Zones Ωα\Omega_\alpha (Figure 5, c, d). The number of Zones Ωα⊂S2\Omega_\alpha\subset\mathbb{S}^2 for generic values ϵF∈[ϵ1B,ϵ2B]\epsilon_F \in[\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B] is infinite, which entails the emergence of stable open trajectories of arbitrarily complex shape (Figure 7, a) for certain directions of B\mathbf{B}. The accumulation points of Zones Ωα\Omega_\alpha correspond here, as a rule, to the emergence of chaotic trajectories (of the Tsarev or Dynnikov type) on the Fermi surface.

Finding the functions ϵ~0(n)\widetilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}) is a complex problem requiring rather nontrivial calculations. Since we use here only some general approximation for the relations ϵ(p)\epsilon(\mathbf{p}), our goal here will be to determine the interval [ϵ1B,ϵ2B][\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B] with some (good) accuracy. For this purpose, we use here a technique proposed in the paper [44], which gives good (and in some cases accurate) estimates for the quantities ϵ1B\epsilon_1^B and ϵ2B\epsilon_2^B.

As we have already said, the interval [ϵ1B,ϵ2B][\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B] is determined in our case by the values of ϵ~0(n)\widetilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}) on the boundaries of the Zones WαW_\alpha, i.e. on the set

⋃α∂Wα\bigcup_\alpha\partial W_\alpha

For approximate evaluation of the interval [ϵ1B,ϵ2B][\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B], we can consider the values ϵ~0(n)\widetilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}) on the boundary of one of the largest Zones WαW_\alpha, where the interval of values of ϵ~0(n)\widetilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}) is sufficiently wide. For symmetric relations ϵ(p)\epsilon(\mathbf{p}) such Zones are, as a rule, symmetric Zones WαW_\alpha (the existence of which was proved in [17]). To calculate the minimum and maximum of ϵ~0(n)\tilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}) on the boundary of such Zones, it is usually sufficient to calculate ϵ~0(n)\tilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}) at the most “symmetric” points ∂Wα\partial W_\alpha (Figure 8).

To determine the boundaries of the Zones WαW_\alpha (as well as the values ϵ~0(n)\tilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n})), it is necessary to consider the topological structure of system (I.1) on the surfaces

ϵ(p)=const,\epsilon(\mathbf{p}) = \mathrm{const},

corresponding to the emergence of stable open trajectories ([10, 13, 17]). Namely, for any

n∈Wα,ϵF∈[ϵ~1(n),ϵ~2(n)]\mathbf{n} \in W_\alpha,\qquad\epsilon_F \in[\tilde{\epsilon}_1(\mathbf{n}),\tilde{\epsilon}_2(\mathbf{n})]

the surface ϵ(p)=ϵF\epsilon(\mathbf{p})=\epsilon_F represents a set of “carriers of open trajectories” separated by cylinders of closed trajectories of (I.1) (Figure 9, a).

Fermi surface cut by cylinders of closed trajectories and a carrier of stable open trajectories

Figure 9. (a) The Fermi surface cut by the cylinders of closed trajectories of (I.1) (schematically). (b) A carrier of stable open trajectories of system (I.1) in the full p - space.

The carriers of stable open trajectories are periodically deformed integer planes (with holes) parallel to each other in R3\mathbb{R}^3 (Figure 9, b) ([10, 13, 17]). A change in the topological structure of (I.1) on the surface SFS_F for directions n∈∂Ωα\mathbf{n} \in\partial\Omega_\alpha corresponds to the vanishing of the height of one of the cylinders of closed trajectories separating the carriers of open trajectories (Figure 10).

The vanishing of the height of a cylinder of closed trajectories at the boundary of a Zone

Figure 10. The vanishing of the height of a cylinder of closed trajectories at the boundary of a Zone Ωα\Omega_\alpha and the destruction of a “stable” topological structure of system (I.1) on the Fermi surface (the occurrence of “jumps” between the carriers of open trajectories).

The boundaries of Zones WαW_\alpha correspond to the disappearance of at least two cylinders of closed trajectories of (I.1), which have different (electron and hole) types ([17]). The condition of the simultaneous disappearance of two cylinders of closed trajectories for

n∈∂Wα,ϵF=ϵ~0(n)\mathbf{n} \in\partial W_\alpha,\qquad\epsilon_F=\tilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n})

determines both the boundary of a Zone WαW_\alpha and the values ϵ~0(n)\tilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}).

In general, studying the structure of system (I.1) on a Fermi surface is quite non-trivial and requires extensive computations (see, e.g., [15, 41, 43]). This study is significantly simplified for symmetric Zones WαW_\alpha, where such a structure becomes more obvious. The use of “symmetric” points on the boundaries of such Zones makes it most convenient to find both their positions on S2S^2 and the corresponding values ϵ~0(P,Q)\tilde{\epsilon}_0(P,Q).

Below we illustrate our scheme using the example of the simple cubic lattice, which represents the simplest of the cases considered here.

The case of the simple cubic lattice is the simplest from the geometric point of view. The reciprocal lattice here is also simple cubic; we will assume its edge length to be equal to 2. As we have already said, we will consider the dispersion relations ϵ(p)\epsilon(\mathbf{p}), obtained in the nearly free electron approximation.

Our goal is to determine the position of the interval [ϵ1B,ϵ2B][\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B] within the interval [ϵmin⁡,ϵmax⁡][\epsilon_{\min},\epsilon_{\max}] and to estimate its width in comparison with the conduction band width. Based on this, we can normalize the values of ϵ\epsilon and pp such that

ϵ=p2\epsilon=p^2

near the value p=(0,0,0)\mathbf{p}=(0,0,0).

The evolution of the Fermi surface for ϵF>0\epsilon_F>0 begins with the emergence of growing spheres with centers at even integer points (Figure 11, a) in R3\mathbb{R}^3 with their subsequent surgery upon the formation of intersections (Figure 11, b).

Figure 11. (a) Emergence of the components of the Fermi surface of the first conduction band at εF>0\varepsilon_F > 0. (b) Growth and surgery of the Fermi surface of the first conduction band at εF>0\varepsilon_F > 0. (c) Disappearance of the components of the Fermi surface of the first conduction band at ε→3\varepsilon\to3 (simple cubic lattice).

The Fermi surface first becomes extended in the entire p\mathbf{p}-space at ϵF=1\epsilon_F=1, this is also the value after which stable open trajectories of system (I.1) (ϵ1A=1\epsilon_1^A=1) first appear on it.

For values ϵF∈(1,2)\epsilon_F\in(1,2) (pF∈(1,2)p_F\in(1,\sqrt{2})), the Fermi surface contains a connected component extending in all directions in p\mathbf{p}-space, as well as a periodic set of compact components (Figure 11, b). It is easy to see that among the compact components there are only 3 nonequivalent ones, and the total number of connected components of the Fermi surface in T3=R3/L∗\mathbb{T}^3=\mathbb{R}^3/L^* is equal to 4.

In fact, the emergence of new components of the Fermi surface corresponds to the creation of the second conduction band with ϵmin⁡(2)=1\epsilon_{\min}^{(2)}=1. In the interval ϵ∈(1,2)\epsilon\in(1,2) we must therefore consider the unbounded component to be the Fermi surface of the first conduction band (with ϵmin⁡(1)=0\epsilon_{\min}^{(1)}=0), and the 3 compact components to be the Fermi surface of the second band (with ϵmin⁡(2)=1\epsilon_{\min}^{(2)}=1).

At ϵF=2\epsilon_F=2, the Fermi surface of the first band decomposes into compact components of rank 0 (equivalent to each other), which disappear (contract into points) at ϵF=3\epsilon_F=3 (Figure 11, c). Thus, for the first conduction band we have

ϵmin⁡(1)=0,ϵmax⁡(1)=3\epsilon_{\min}^{(1)}=0,\qquad\epsilon_{\max}^{(1)}=3

The Fermi surface of the second band acquires rank 3 in the interval ϵ∈(2,3)\epsilon\in(2,3) (p∈(2,3)p\in(\sqrt{2},\sqrt{3})), extending in all directions in p\mathbf{p}-space. For ϵ=3\epsilon=3 the Fermi surface of the second band decomposes into components of rank zero, which vanish at the value ϵ=4\epsilon=4 (p=2p=2). We thus have for the second conduction band

ϵmin⁡(2)=1,ϵmax⁡(2)=4\epsilon_{\min}^{(2)}=1,\qquad\epsilon_{\max}^{(2)}=4

At the same time, for ϵ=2\epsilon=2 (p=2p=\sqrt{2}), new components of rank 0 are split off from the Fermi surface of the second conduction band, forming the Fermi surfaces of the following conduction bands, etc. (according to [45], each point in p\mathbf{p}-space that falls inside nn different spheres for a given ϵF\epsilon_F represents filled states for the nn first conduction bands). Continuing the procedure, we thus obtain an infinite set of (overlapping) energy bands (conduction bands).

At all points of p\mathbf{p}-space we have the relations

ϵ(s+1)(p)≥ϵ(s)(p),\epsilon^{(s+1)}(\mathbf{p})\geq\epsilon^{(s)}(\mathbf{p}),

at the same time

ϵ(s+1)(p)=ϵ(s)(p)\epsilon^{(s+1)}(\mathbf{p})=\epsilon^{(s)}(\mathbf{p})

at the intersections of the Fermi surfaces.

As is well known, in real nearly free electron approximation, the last equality is removed due to the (small) splitting of energy levels at the intersection of spectra. The Fermi surfaces are then smoothed out at the intersections, leading to the relations

ϵ~(s+1)(p)>ϵ~(s)(p)\widetilde{\epsilon}^{(s+1)}(\mathbf{p}) > \widetilde{\epsilon}^{(s)}(\mathbf{p})

Our results here, however, are approximate (and, in particular, do not take into account deviations from the nearly free-electron approximation in real metals). Therefore, we will also consider here the shape of the Fermi surfaces as described above.

Here we will estimate the position of the interval [ϵ1B,ϵ2B][\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B] for the first conduction band described above. As we have already said, we use here the values ϵ~0(n)\widetilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}) at those points of ∂Wα\partial W_\alpha where we can expect them to differ from each other the most. As such values, we can use the values ϵ~1(n)=ϵ~2(n)=ϵ~0(n)\widetilde{\epsilon}_1(\mathbf{n})=\widetilde{\epsilon}_2(\mathbf{n})=\widetilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}) on the boundaries of the largest (symmetric) Stability Zones Wα⊂S2W_\alpha\subset S^2. Here (and further) we will use the symmetric Zone W1W_1, containing the direction n=(0,0,1)\mathbf{n}=(0,0,1) (Figure 8).

The boundary points of the Zone W1W_1 are determined by the disappearance of two cylinders of closed trajectories of (I.1), dividing the Fermi surface into carriers of open trajectories for n∈W1\mathbf{n}\in W_1. For the first conduction band, we obviously have

ϵ1A=1,ϵ2A=2,\epsilon_1^A=1,\qquad\epsilon_2^A=2,

so that it suffices to consider the Fermi surfaces only for ϵF∈(1,2)\epsilon_F\in(1,2). For n∈W1\mathbf{n}\in W_1, the corresponding cylinders of closed trajectories are shown in Figure 12. To estimate the values ϵ1B\epsilon_1^B and ϵ2B\epsilon_2^B we use here the values of ϵ~0(n)\widetilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}) at “symmetric” points PP and QQ on the boundary of W1W_1 shown in Figure 8.

Fermi surface of the first conduction band and cylinders of closed trajectories

Figure 12. The Fermi surface of the first conduction band for εF∈(1,2)\varepsilon_F \in(1, 2) and the cylinders of closed trajectories of the electron (C1C_1) and hole (C2C_2) types for n∈W1\mathbf{n} \in W_1 (simple cubic lattice).

Let the radius of the circle arising at the intersection of the spheres for 1<ϵF<21<\epsilon_F<2 be rr. The disappearance of the cylinder C1C_1 at the point PP corresponds to the picture in the plane Π⊥B\Pi\perp\mathbf{B} (passing through the point (0,0,1)∈R3(0,0,1)\in\mathbb{R}^3) shown in Figure 13, a. The projection of the plane Π\Pi onto the plane yzyz is a straight line with an inclination angle α\alpha such that

Cylinder $C_1$ and projection of the plane $\Pi$

Figure 13. (a) Cylinder C1C_1 of zero height in the plane Π⊥B\Pi\perp\mathbf{B} passing through the point (0,0,1)(0,0,1) (n=P\mathbf{n}=\mathbf{P}); (b) Projection of the plane Π\Pi onto the plane yzyz (simple cubic lattice).

tan⁡α=1−r\tan\alpha=1-r

(Figure 13, b).

The disappearance of the cylinder C2C_2 at the point PP corresponds to the picture in the plane Π⊥B\Pi\perp\mathbf{B} (passing through the point (1,1,0)∈R3(1,1,0)\in\mathbb{R}^3), shown in Figure 14, a. The projection of the plane Π\Pi onto the plane yzyz is a straight line with an inclination angle α\alpha such that

Cylinder $C_2$ and projection of the plane $\Pi$

Figure 14. (a) Cylinder C2C_2 of zero height in the plane Π⊥B\Pi\perp\mathbf{B} passing through the point (1,1,0)(1,1,0) (n=P\mathbf{n}=\mathbf{P}); (b) Projection of the plane Π\Pi onto the plane yzyz (simple cubic lattice).

sin⁡α=r\sin\alpha=r

(Figure 14, b).

From the condition of the simultaneous disappearance of the cylinders C1C_1 and C2C_2

1−r=r1−r21-r=\frac{r}{\sqrt{1-r^2}}

we then obtain r≃0.469r\simeq0.469 and, accordingly,

ϵ~0(P)=1+r2≃1.22\widetilde{\epsilon}_0(P)=1+r^2\simeq1.22
endsmid=1{ends_mid=1}

The disappearance of the cylinder C1C_1 at n=Q\mathbf{n} = Q corresponds to the position of the plane Π⊥B\Pi\perp\mathbf{B} (passing through the point (0,0,1)∈R3(0,0,1) \in\mathbb{R}^3), shown in Figure 15, a. As is easy to see, the angle between the directions n\mathbf{n} and z\mathbf{z} is determined by the relation

Position of the plane $\Pi$ through $(0,0,1)$

Figure 15. (a) The position of the plane Π⊥B\Pi\perp\mathbf{B} passing through the point (0,0,1)(0,0,1) at n=Qn=Q (cube interior shown); (b) The intersection of the plane x=−1x=-1 by the plane Π\Pi and angle α′\alpha' (tan⁡α=2tan⁡α′\tan\alpha=\sqrt{2}\tan\alpha', simple cubic lattice).

tan⁡α=2tan⁡α′,\tan\alpha= \sqrt{2}\tan\alpha',

where α′\alpha' is the angle shown in Figure 15, b. As is easy to show,

tan⁡α′=2−r2−r2−r2+r.\tan\alpha' = \frac{\sqrt{2-r^2}-r}{\sqrt{2-r^2}+r}.

The disappearance of the cylinder C2C_2 at n=Q\mathbf{n} = Q corresponds to the position of the plane Π⊥B\Pi\perp\mathbf{B} (passing through the point (1,1,0)∈R3(1,1,0) \in\mathbb{R}^3), shown in Figure 16, a. The angle between the directions n\mathbf{n} and z\mathbf{z} is determined by the relation

Position of the plane $\Pi$ through $(1,1,0)$

Figure 16. (a) The position of the plane Π⊥B\Pi\perp\mathbf{B} passing through the point (1,1,0)(1,1,0) at n=Qn=Q (the exterior of the cube is shown); (b) The intersection of the plane x=1x=1 by the plane Π\Pi and the angle α′\alpha' (tan⁡α=2tan⁡α′\tan\alpha=\sqrt{2}\tan\alpha', simple cubic lattice).

tan⁡α=2tan⁡α′=2r1−r2.\tan\alpha= \sqrt{2}\tan\alpha' = \sqrt{2}\frac{r}{\sqrt{1-r^2}}.

The condition

2−r2−r2−r2+r=r1−r2\frac{\sqrt{2-r^2}-r}{\sqrt{2-r^2}+r} = \frac{r}{\sqrt{1-r^2}}

gives the value r=1/5r = 1/\sqrt{5} and, accordingly,

ε~0(Q)=1+r2=1.2\widetilde{\varepsilon}_0(Q) = 1 + r^2 = 1.2

Thus, using our estimate, we obtain

[ε1B,ε2B]≃[1.2,1.22][\varepsilon_1^B, \varepsilon_2^B] \simeq[1.2, 1.22]

for the first conduction band.

Abstracting from the normalization we use, we can also say that the interval of emergence of ultra-complex angular diagrams occurs near the value 0.4 εmax⁡0.4\,\varepsilon_{\max} from the bottom of the conduction band, and its length is ≃0.7%\simeq0.7\% of the width of the conduction band.

Note also that the tight-binding approximation gives the zero width of the interval [ε1B,ε2B][\varepsilon_1^B,\varepsilon_2^B] in the leading order for the simple cubic lattice (see e.g. [44]), and a nonzero width of [ε1B,ε2B][\varepsilon_1^B,\varepsilon_2^B] appears there only in higher corrections. The nearly free electron approximation, as can be seen, differs from the tight-binding model at this point.

The face-centered cubic lattice

Let’s consider the case of the face-centered cubic lattice. The reciprocal lattice in this case is body-centered cubic. As in the previous case, we will assume its edge length to be equal to 2.

The first Fermi surfaces are born near integer points p=(n,m,l)\mathbf{p}=(n,m,l), all of whose coordinates are either even or odd. Near these points, as in the previous section, we will assume

ϵ(p)=(Δp)2\epsilon(\mathbf{p})=(\Delta p)^2

As in the previous case, we will carry out here an estimate of the position of the interval [ϵ1B,ϵ2B][\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B] for the first conduction band.

As is well known, the Brillouin zone in this case is a truncated octahedron and has the shape shown in Figure 17, a. The bottom of the first conduction band in our normalization obviously corresponds to the value ϵmin⁡=0\epsilon_{\min}=0. The upper edge of the first conduction band corresponds to the values

Brillouin zone and Fermi-surface surgery

Figure 17. (a) Brillouin zone for the face-centered cubic lattice (reciprocal lattice - body-centered cubic). (b) Surgery of the Fermi surface upon passing through ϵF=3/4\epsilon_F = 3/4.

ϵmax⁡=139,pmax⁡=1+(23)2\epsilon_{\max}=\frac{13}{9}, \qquad p_{\max}=\sqrt{1+\left(\frac{2}{3}\right)^2}

(Figure 17, a).

Up to the value

ϵF=ϵ1A=34\epsilon_F=\epsilon_1^A=\frac{3}{4}

the Fermi surface is a sphere. At ϵF=ϵ1A=3/4\epsilon_F=\epsilon_1^A=3/4 the spheres first touch each other (p1A=3/2p_1^A=\sqrt{3}/2, Figure 17, b), the Fermi surface acquires genus 4, and open trajectories first appear on it.

After the value

ϵF=ϵg=1\epsilon_F=\epsilon^g=1

(pg=1p^g=1) the genus of the Fermi surface increases to 7.

After the value

ϵF=ϵ2A=119,p2A=1+(23)2\epsilon_F=\epsilon_2^A=\frac{11}{9}, \qquad p_2^A=\sqrt{1+\left(\frac{\sqrt{2}}{3}\right)^2}

the Fermi surface breaks down into 6 compact components that look like “dumbbells”.

After the value

ϵF=ϵ′=2518,p′=562\epsilon_F=\epsilon'=\frac{25}{18}, \qquad p'=\frac{5}{6}\sqrt{2}

the “dumbbells” disintegrate into “balls” of the hole type, which then disappear at ϵF=ϵmax⁡\epsilon_F=\epsilon_{\max}.

Let us now consider the projection of our Fermi surface onto the yzyz plane. The circles arising at the intersection of the spheres are now projected onto ellipses with semi-axes rr and r/3r/\sqrt{3} (Figure 18). It is also easy to construct projections of the cylinders C1C_1, C2C_2 and C3C_3 onto the yzyz plane for B∥z\mathbf{B}\parallel z (Figure 18). As in the previous section, the cylinders C1C_1, C2C_2, and C3C_3 cut the Fermi surface into carriers of open trajectories T12T_1^2, T22T_2^2 for n∈W1\mathbf{n}\in W_1. Note here that the cylinder C1C_1 has a circular shape, while the cylinders C2C_2 and C3C_3 have “corners”, like the cylinder C2C_2 in the previous section.

Projection of the Fermi surface onto the $yz$ plane

Figure 18. Projection of the Fermi surface onto the yzyz plane for B∥z\mathbf{B} \parallel z and disappearance of the cylinders C1C_1, C2C_2 and C3C_3 for n=P\mathbf{n} = P (face-centered lattice).

As can be seen, the disappearance of the cylinders C1C_1, C2C_2 and C3C_3 for the direction n=P\mathbf{n}=P (Figure 8) corresponds to the situation when the straight line passing through the point (0,0)(0,0) (the projection of the plane orthogonal to B\mathbf{B}) is tangent to both ellipses S1S_1 and S2S_2 shown in Figure 18. This condition, as is easy to see, uniquely determines the quantity rr, and also the value ϵ~0(P)=3/4+r2\tilde{\epsilon}_0(P)=3/4+r^2.

It is easy to verify that the equations of the ellipses S1S_1 and S2S_2 shown in Figure 18 have the form

(y−z)2+3(y+z−1)2=2r2(y-z)^2+3(y+z-1)^2=2r^2

and

3(y−z−1)2+(y+z−2)2=2r23(y-z-1)^2+(y+z-2)^2=2r^2

respectively.

The condition of tangency of the ellipse S1S_1 is

2(1−tan⁡α)2r2+6(1+tan⁡α)2r2=3(1−tan⁡α)2,2(1-\tan\alpha)^2r^2+6(1+\tan\alpha)^2r^2=3(1-\tan\alpha)^2,

and of the ellipse S2S_2 is

6(1−tan⁡α)2r2+2(1+tan⁡α)2r2=3(3tan⁡α−1)2,6(1-\tan\alpha)^2r^2+2(1+\tan\alpha)^2r^2=3(3\tan\alpha-1)^2,

which gives

r2(P)≃0.066885r^2(P)\simeq0.066885

and

ϵ~0(P)≃0.816885\tilde{\epsilon}_0(P)\simeq0.816885

For the angle of inclination of B\mathbf{B} to the axis zz, corresponding to the point PP on the angular diagram, we have

tan⁡αP≃0.45541\tan\alpha_P\simeq0.45541

Let us now consider the direction n=Q\mathbf{n}=Q (Figure 8). When projected onto the plane x+y=0x+y=0, half of the circles SiS_i are transformed into segments of length 2r2r, and the other half into ellipses with semi-axes rr and r2/3r\sqrt{2/3} (Figure 19). The disappearance of the cylinders C1C_1, C2C_2 and C3C_3 is now determined by the condition that the line l1l_1 passing through the points DD and EE and the line l2l_2 tangent to the ellipses S1S_1 and S2S_2 (the projections of the planes Π1,2⊥B\Pi_{1,2}\perp\mathbf{B} onto the plane x+y=0x+y=0) have the same inclination angle α\alpha (Figure 19). The angle α\alpha shown in Figure 19 is the angle of inclination of B\mathbf{B} to the axis zz and determines the position of the point QQ.

Projection of the Fermi surface onto the plane $x+y=0$ for $\mathbf{B}\parallel z$ and disappearance of the cylinders $C_1$, $C_2$ and $C_3$ for $\mathbf{n}=Q$

Figure 19. Projection of the Fermi surface onto the plane x+y=0x+y=0 for B∥z\mathbf{B}\parallel z and disappearance of the cylinders C1C_1, C2C_2 and C3C_3 for n=Q\mathbf{n}=Q (face-centered lattice).

As is easy to see, the equations of the ellipses S1S_1 and S2S_2 shown in Figure 19 have the form

3(z−1/2)2+2w2=2r23(z-1/2)^2+2w^2=2r^2

and

3(z−1/2)2+2(w−2)2=2r23(z-1/2)^2+2(w-\sqrt{2})^2=2r^2

(w=(y−x)/2w=(y-x)/\sqrt{2}), respectively.

It can be seen that, on the one hand,

tan⁡α=1/2−r2/31/2+r/3=3−22r6+2r\tan\alpha=\frac{1/2-r\sqrt{2/3}}{1/\sqrt{2}+r/\sqrt{3}}=\frac{\sqrt{3}-2\sqrt{2}r}{\sqrt{6}+2r}

(disappearance of the cylinder C1C_1).

On the other hand, the tangency condition of the line

(z−1/2)=tan⁡α(w−1/2)(z - 1/2) = \tan\alpha\left(w - 1/\sqrt{2}\right)

and the ellipses S1S_1 and S2S_2 leads to the relation

tan⁡α=2r3−6r2\tan\alpha= \frac{2r}{\sqrt{3 - 6r^2}}

The given relations result in

r(Q)≃0.264889r(Q) \simeq0.264889
tan⁡αQ≃0.329890\tan\alpha_Q \simeq0.329890
ϵ~0(Q)=34+r2≃0.820166\widetilde{\epsilon}_0(Q) = \frac{3}{4} + r^2 \simeq0.820166

Thus, for the case of the face-centered lattice, we can write

[ϵ1B,ϵ2B]≃[0.817,0.820][\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B] \simeq[0.817, 0.820]

It can be seen that, according to our estimate, the interval [ϵ1B,ϵ2B][\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B] lies in the energy region where the genus of the Fermi surface is 4, and the increase in the genus of SFS_F to 7 at ϵF=1\epsilon_F = 1 does not affect the emergence of ultra-complex angular diagrams.

Again abstracting from our normalization, we can say that, in the nearly free electron approximation for the face-centered cubic lattice, the interval of emergence of ultra-complex angular diagrams in the first conduction band lies at a distance of ≃0.57ϵmax⁡\simeq0.57 \epsilon_{\max} from its bottom and occupies ≃0.2%\simeq0.2\% of the band width.

The body-centered cubic lattice

In this section, we will consider the case of the body-centered cubic lattice. The reciprocal lattice in this case is face-centered cubic, and we will assume its edge length to be equal to 2. As in the previous case, we will be interested in the first conduction band in the nearly free electron approximation.

The emergence of the first (compact) components of the Fermi surface now occurs near integer points (m,n,l)(m,n,l) of the p\mathbf{p}-space, such that

m+n+l=2s,s∈Zm+n+l=2s,\quad s\in\mathbb{Z}

As above, we will set

Δϵ(p)=(Δp)2\Delta\epsilon(\mathbf{p})=(\Delta p)^2

near these points.

The Brillouin zone now has the form shown in Figure 20, a.

Brillouin zone for the body-centered cubic lattice and surgery of the Fermi surface

Figure 20. (a) Brillouin zone for the body-centered cubic lattice (reciprocal lattice - face-centered cubic). (b) Surgery of the Fermi surface upon passing through ϵF=1/2\epsilon_F = 1/2.

The Fermi surface remains spherical (in the torus T3\mathbb{T}^3) in the interval ϵF∈(0,1/2)\epsilon_F\in(0,1/2).

The value

ϵF=ϵ1A=1/2,(p1A=1/2),\epsilon_F=\epsilon_1^A=1/2,\qquad(p_1^A=1/\sqrt{2}),

corresponds to the first touch of the spheres in p\mathbf{p}-space (at the points p1Ap_1^A), after which the Fermi surface acquires genus 6 (Figure 20, b).

At the value

ϵF=ϵ2A=2/3,(p2A=2/3),\epsilon_F=\epsilon_2^A=2/3,\qquad(p_2^A=\sqrt{2/3}),

the spheres reach the edges of the Brillouin zone (at the points p2Ap_2^A), and the Fermi surface again decomposes into components of genus 0, which vanish at the values

ϵF=ϵ′=3/4,(p′=3/2)\epsilon_F=\epsilon'=3/4,\qquad(p'=\sqrt{3}/2)

and

ϵF=ϵmax⁡=1,(pmax⁡=1)\epsilon_F=\epsilon_{\max}=1,\qquad(p_{\max}=1)

We will, certainly, consider here the Fermi surfaces at ϵF∈[ϵ1A,ϵ2A]\epsilon_F\in[\epsilon_1^A,\epsilon_2^A] (Figure 20, b).

As in the previous sections, we will be interested here in the values of ϵ~0(n)\tilde{\epsilon}_0(\mathbf{n}) at the “symmetric” points of the boundary of W1W_1 (points PP and QQ, Figure 8).

To determine the structure of system (I.1), as in the previous sections, we need to describe the cylinders of closed trajectories arising on the Fermi surface for n∈W1\mathbf{n}\in W_1. Near the direction n∥z\mathbf{n}\parallel z, the number of such cylinders is 5, and they cut the Fermi surface into 4 tori with holes (carriers of open trajectories) T1,2,3,42\mathbb{T}_{1,2,3,4}^2, embedded in the three-dimensional torus

T1,2,3,42⊂T2=R3/L∗\mathbb{T}_{1,2,3,4}^2\subset\mathbb{T}^2=\mathbb{R}^3/L^*

In the full p\mathbf{p}-space, we then have 4 nonequivalent carriers of open trajectories, which are periodically deformed planes (with holes) parallel to the plane xyxy (Figure 21).

Figure 21. “Scheme” of the connection of carriers of open trajectories and cylinders of closed trajectories near the direction B∥z\mathbf{B} \parallel z (body-centered cubic lattice).

The height of the cylinders of closed trajectories is maximal at B∥z\mathbf{B}\parallel z, and their structure is in many ways analogous to the structure for the face-centered lattice. In particular, here also arise (hole-type) cylinders C2C_2 and C3C_3, completely analogous to the cylinders C2,3C_{2,3} for the simple and face-centered lattices (see, e.g., Figure 12, Figure 18). As for the cylinder C1C_1 (Figure 12, Figure 18), now, due to the presence of additional “handles” (and a larger genus of the Fermi surface), it splits into two electron type cylinders C1′C'_1 and C1′′C''_1 and a hole type cylinder C0C_0 (similar to cylinders C2C_2 and C3C_3).

Figure 22 shows the arrangement of cylinders CjC_j on the Fermi surface in p\mathbf{p}-space for B∥z\mathbf{B}\parallel z. Figure 21 also shows the connection of cylinders CjC_j with the carriers of open trajectories Ti2\mathbb{T}_i^2 for directions of B\mathbf{B} close to the direction zz.

Projections of cylinders of closed trajectories onto the plane $yz$ for $\mathbf{B} \parallel z$ and the disappearance of cylinders

Figure 22. Projections of cylinders of closed trajectories onto the plane yzyz for B∥z\mathbf{B} \parallel z and the disappearance of cylinders C1′C'_1, C0C_0 and C1′′C''_1 for n=Pn=P (body-centered lattice).

It is easy to see that, when B\mathbf{B} is deflected toward the point PP, the cylinders C2C_2 and C3C_3 (they have a smaller height) disappear before the cylinder C0C_0. Thus, the point PP on the boundary of Zone W1W_1 is determined by the disappearance of the cylinders C1′C'_1 and C1′′C''_1 (of the electron type) and the cylinder C0C_0 (of the hole type).

The disappearance of the cylinders C1′C'_1, C0C_0 and C1′′C''_1 at n=P\mathbf{n} = P is shown in Figure 22. The projections of the circles SiS_i onto the plane yzyz are now either segments of length 2r2r or ellipses with semi-axes rr and r/2r/\sqrt{2}. As is easy to see (Figure 22), the equations of the projections of S1S_1 and S2S_2 have the form

2(y+12)2+z2=r22\left(y+\frac{1}{2}\right)^2+z^2=r^2

and

2(y−12)2+z2=r22\left(y-\frac{1}{2}\right)^2+z^2=r^2

respectively.

The position of the point PP and the value r(P)r(P) are determined by the equality of the inclination angles of the tangents (the projections of the planes Π⊥B\Pi\perp\mathbf{B} onto the plane yzyz) to the projections of the circles SiS_i onto the plane yzyz, as shown in Figure 22. As can be verified, the condition of tangency of the line l2l_2 with the ellipses S1S_1 and S2S_2 has the form

tan⁡α=2r1−2r2\tan\alpha=\frac{2r}{\sqrt{1-2r^2}}

The line l1l_1 is given by the equation

z=2r1−2r2(y+1)z=\frac{2r}{\sqrt{1-2r^2}}(y+1)

According to Figure 22, it must contain the point

(12+r2,12−r2),\left(\frac{1}{2}+\frac{r}{\sqrt{2}},\frac{1}{2}-\frac{r}{\sqrt{2}}\right),

which implies

(1−r2)1−2r2=2r(3+r2)\left(1-r\sqrt{2}\right)\sqrt{1-2r^2}=2r\left(3+r\sqrt{2}\right)

From the above relations we directly obtain

r(P)≃0.126932r(P)\simeq0.126932
tan⁡αP≃0.258056\tan\alpha_P\simeq0.258056
ϵ~0(P)≃0.516112\tilde{\epsilon}_0(P)\simeq0.516112

Let us now consider the direction n=Q\mathbf{n}=Q. Figure 23 shows the projection of the Fermi surface onto the plane x+y=0x+y=0. The projections of the circles SiS_i represent here either segments of length 2r2r, or circles of radius rr, or ellipses with semi-axes rr and r/2r/2. As is easy to see, the centers of the ellipses S1S_1 and S2S_2 lie at the points with coordinates

Projections of cylinders of closed trajectories onto the plane $x+y=0$ for $\mathbf{B} \parallel z$ and the disappearance of cylinders

Figure 23. Projections of cylinders of closed trajectories onto the plane x+y=0x+y=0 for B∥z\mathbf{B} \parallel z and the disappearance of cylinders C1′C'_1, C1′′C''_1, C2C_2 and C3C_3 for n=Qn=Q (body-centered lattice).

w=−122,z=12w=-\frac{1}{2\sqrt{2}},\qquad z=\frac{1}{2}
w=122,z=12w=\frac{1}{2\sqrt{2}},\qquad z=\frac{1}{2}

(w=(y−x)/2)(w=(y-x)/\sqrt{2}).

As is not also difficult to show, the major semi-axes of the ellipses S1S_1 and S2S_2 are orthogonal to the segments connecting their centers with the origin.

Now it can be seen that, when B\mathbf{B} is deflected towards the point QQ, the cylinders C0C_0 (their projections onto the plane x+y=0x+y=0 have a much greater length) disappear before the cylinders C2C_2 and C3C_3. Thus, the point QQ on the boundary of Zone W1W_1 is determined by the disappearance of the cylinders C1′C'_1 and C1′′C''_1 (of the electron type) and the cylinders C2C_2 and C3C_3 (of the hole type).

As before, the projections of planes orthogonal to B\mathbf{B} onto the plane x+y=0x+y=0 here represent lines with an inclination angle α\alpha with respect to the axis ww. The condition for the simultaneous disappearance of the cylinders C1′C'_1, C1′′C''_1, C2C_2 and C3C_3 is determined by the simultaneous tangency of the projections SiS_i by such lines, as shown in Figure 23.

Ellipses S1S_1 and S2S_2 are given by the equations

4(2z−w−322)2+(z+2w)2=3r2(8)4\left(\sqrt{2}z-w-\frac{3}{2\sqrt{2}}\right)^2+(z+\sqrt{2}w)^2=3r^2 \tag*{(8)}

and

4(2z+w−322)2+(z−2w)2=3r24\left(\sqrt{2}z+w-\frac{3}{2\sqrt{2}}\right)^2+\left(z-\sqrt{2}w\right)^2=3r^2

respectively.

The equations of the lines l1l_1 and l2l_2, as is not difficult to show, have the form

z=wtan⁡α+1−2tan⁡α−rz=w\tan\alpha+1-\sqrt{2}\tan\alpha-r

and

z−r=(w+12)tan⁡αz-r=\left(w+\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\right)\tan\alpha

As can be shown, the conditions for the correct tangency of the lines l1l_1, l2l_2 and the ellipses S1S_1, S2S_2 are given by the relations

2r(2+tan⁡α)2+4(1−2tan⁡α)2=53tan⁡α+26r−6\sqrt{2}r\sqrt{\left(\sqrt{2}+\tan\alpha\right)^2+4\left(1-\sqrt{2}\tan\alpha\right)^2}=5\sqrt{3}\tan\alpha+2\sqrt{6}r-\sqrt{6}

and

2r(2−tan⁡α)2+4(1+2tan⁡α)2=6−33tan⁡α−26r,\sqrt{2}r\sqrt{\left(\sqrt{2}-\tan\alpha\right)^2+4\left(1+\sqrt{2}\tan\alpha\right)^2}=\sqrt{6}-3\sqrt{3}\tan\alpha-2\sqrt{6}r,

which implies

r(Q)≃0.123591r(Q)\simeq0.123591
tan⁡αQ=0.255360\tan\alpha_Q=0.255360

and

ϵ~0(Q)≃0.515275\widetilde{\epsilon}_0(Q)\simeq0.515275

Thus, for the case of the body-centered lattice, we can write

[ϵ1B,ϵ2B]≃[0.5153,0.5161][\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B]\simeq[0.5153,0.5161]

Abstracting from our normalization, we can say that, in the nearly free electron approximation for the body-centered cubic lattice, the interval of emergence of ultra-complex angular diagrams in the first conduction band lies at a distance of ≃0.515 ϵmax⁡\simeq0.515\,\epsilon_{\max} from its bottom and occupies ≃0.1%\simeq0.1\% of the band width.

Conclusion

We estimate the ranges of occurrence of ultra-complex conductivity diagrams in the nearly free electron approximation for metals with cubic symmetry. The results of the study show that the occurrence of such diagrams corresponds to extremely narrow energy intervals ϵF∈[ϵ1B,ϵ2B]\epsilon_F\in[\epsilon_1^B,\epsilon_2^B] inside the conduction band, which coincides with similar estimates in the tight binding approximation [44]. In our opinion, the obtained results are largely explained by the high symmetry of the crystal lattices, as well as the simplest analytical properties of the relations ϵ(p)\epsilon(\mathbf{p}) considered in these studies. In particular, we expect wider ranges of occurrence of ultra-complex angular conductivity diagrams for conductors with more complex relations ϵ(p)\epsilon(\mathbf{p}). In general, to observe ultra-complex angular conductivity diagrams, external influences on the crystal, shifting the position of ϵF\epsilon_F within the conductivity band, are probably necessary.

References

  1. [1]C. Kittel, Quantum Theory of Solids, Wiley, New York (1963)
  2. [2]J.M. Ziman, Principles of the Theory of Solids, Cambridge University Press 1972.
  3. [3]N.W. Ashcroft y N. D. Mermin, Solid State Physics, Saunders Collage Publishing, 1976.
  4. [4]A.A. Abrikosov, Fundamentals of the Theory of Metals., Elsevier Science & Technology, Oxford, United Kingdom, 1988
  5. [8]I.M. Lifshitz, M.Ya. Azbel, M.I. Kaganov., Electron Theory of Metals. New York: Consultants Bureau, 1973.
  6. [9]S.P. Novikov., The Hamiltonian formalism and a many-valued analogue of Morse theory., Russian Math. Surveys 37 (5), 1-56 (1982).DOI
  7. [10]A.V. Zorich., A problem of Novikov on the semiclassical motion of an electron in a uniform almost rational magnetic field., Russian Math. Surveys 39 (5), 287-288 (1984).DOI
  8. [13]I.A. Dynnikov., Proof of S.P. Novikov’s conjecture on the semiclassical motion of an electron., Math. Notes 53:5, 495-501 (1993).DOI
  9. [15]I.A. Dynnikov., Surfaces in 3-torus: geometry of plane sections., Proc. of ECM2, BuDA, 1996.
  10. [16]I.A. Dynnikov., Semiclassical motion of the electron. A proof of the Novikov conjecture in general position and counterexamples., Solitons, geometry, and topology: on the crossroad, Amer. Math. Soc. Transl. Ser. 2, 179, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 1997, 45-73.
  11. [17]I.A. Dynnikov., The geometry of stability zones in Novikov’s problem on the semiclassical motion of an electron., Russian Math. Surveys 54:1, 21-59 (1999).DOI
  12. [18]A. Ya. Maltsev and S. P. Novikov, Quasiperiodic functions and dynamical systems in quantum solid state physics, Bulletin of Braz. Math. Society, New Series 34, 171 (2003).DOI
  13. [19]A. Ya. Maltsev and S. P. Novikov, Dynamical Systems, Topology, and Conductivity in Normal Metals, J. Stat. Phys. 115, 31 (2004).DOI
  14. [20]A.Ya. Maltsev, S.P. Novikov, Topological integrability, classical and quantum chaos, and the theory of dynamical systems in the physics of condensed matter, Russ. Math. Surv., 74(1), 141-173 (2019)DOI
  15. [21]S.P. Novikov, A.Y. Maltsev., Topological quantum characteristics observed in the investigation of the conductivity in normal metals., JETP Letters 63 (10), 855-860 (1996).DOI
  16. [22]A.Ya. Maltsev, The second boundaries of stability zones and the angular diagrams of conductivity for metals having complicated Fermi surfaces, Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics 127 (6), 1087-1111 (2018)DOI
  17. [23]A.Ya. Maltsev, The Complexity Classes of Angular Diagrams of the Metal Conductivity in Strong Magnetic Fields, Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics 129(1), 116-138 (2019)DOI
  18. [24]A.Ya. Maltsev., Anomalous behavior of the electrical conductivity tensor in strong magnetic fields., Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics 85 (5), 934-942 (1997)DOI
  19. [25]A. Ya. Maltsev, S.P. Novikov., The Theory of Closed 1-Forms, Levels of Quasiperiodic Functions and Transport Phenomena in Electron Systems., Proceedings of the Steklov Institute of Mathematics 302, 279-297 (2018).arxiv.org/abs/1805.05210
  20. [26]Anton Zorich., How do the leaves of closed 1-form wind around a surface., “Pseudoperiodic Topology”, V.I.Arnold, M.Kontsevich, A.Zorich (eds.), Translations of the AMS, Ser. 2, vol. 197, AMS, Providence, RI, 1999, 135-178.DOI
  21. [27]R. De Leo., Existence and measure of ergodic leaves in Novikov’s problem on the semiclassical motion of an electron., Russian Math. Surveys 55:1 (2000), 166-168.DOI
  22. [28]R. De Leo., Characterization of the set of “ergodic directions” in Novikov’s problem of quasi-electron orbits in normal metals., Russian Math. Surveys 58:5 (2003), 1042-1043.DOI
  23. [29]R. De Leo., Topological effects in the magnetoresistance of Au and Ag., Phys. Lett. A 332, 469-474 (2004)DOI
  24. [30]R. De Leo., First-principles generation of stereographic maps for high-field magnetoresistance in normal metals: An application to Au and Ag., Physica B: Condensed Matter 362 (1–4) (2005), 62–75.DOI
  25. [31]R. De Leo., Topology of plane sections of periodic polyhedra with an application to the Truncated Octahedron,, Experimental Mathematics 15:1 (2006), 109-124.arxiv.org/abs/math/0502219
  26. [32]R. De Leo, I.A. Dynnikov., An example of a fractal set of plane directions having chaotic intersections with a fixed 3-periodic surface., Russian Math. Surveys 62:5 (2007), 990-992.
  27. [33]I.A. Dynnikov, Interval identification systems and plane sections of 3-periodic surfaces, Proceedings of the Steklov Institute of Mathematics 263, 65-77 (2008).DOI
  28. [34]R. De Leo, I.A. Dynnikov., Geometry of plane sections of the infinite regular skew polyhedron {4, 6 | 4}., Geom. Dedicata 138:1 (2009), 51-67.DOI
  29. [35]A. Skripchenko., Symmetric interval identification systems of order three., Discrete Contin. Dyn. Sys. 32:2 (2012), 643-656.
  30. [36]A. Skripchenko., On connectedness of chaotic sections of some 3-periodic surfaces., Ann. Glob. Anal. Geom. 43 (2013), 253-271.arxiv.org/abs/1112.5870
  31. [37]I. Dynnikov, A. Skripchenko., On typical leaves of a measured foliated 2-complex of thin type., Topology, Geometry, Integrable Systems, and Mathematical Physics: Novikov’s Seminar 2012-2014, Advances in the Mathematical Sciences., Amer. Math. Soc. Transl. Ser. 2, 234, eds. V.M. Buchstaber, B.A. Dubrovin, I.M. Krichever, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2014, 173-200, arXiv:1309.4884arxiv.org/abs/1309.4884
  32. [38]I. Dynnikov, A. Skripchenko., Symmetric band complexes of thin type and chaotic sections which are not actually chaotic., Trans. Moscow Math. Soc., Vol. 76, no. 2, 2015, 287-308.arxiv.org/abs/1501.06866
  33. [39]A. Avila, P. Hubert, A. Skripchenko., Diffusion for chaotic plane sections of 3-periodic surfaces., Inventiones mathematicae, October 2016, Volume 206, Issue 1, pp 109–146.DOI
  34. [40]A. Avila, P. Hubert, A. Skripchenko., On the Hausdorff dimension of the Rauzy gasket., Bulletin de la societe mathematique de France, 2016, 144 (3), pp. 539 - 568.
  35. [41]Roberto De Leo., A survey on quasiperiodic topology., Advanced Mathematical Methods in Biosciences & Applications, Springer, Eds. F. Berezovskaya and B. Toni, (2018)., arXiv:1711.01716arxiv.org/abs/1711.01716
  36. [42]Ivan Dynnikov, Pascal Hubert, Alexandra Skripchenko, Dynamical Systems Around the Rauzy Gasket and Their Ergodic Properties, International Mathematics Research Notices IMRN 2022, 1-30 (Published online), arXiv 2011.15043arxiv.org/abs/2011.15043
  37. [43]I.A. Dynnikov, A.Ya. Maltsev, S.P. Novikov, Geometry of quasi-periodic functions on the plane, Russian Math. Surveys 77 : 6, 1061–1085 (2022), arXiv:2306.11257arxiv.org/abs/2306.11257
  38. [44]A.Ya. Maltsev, On chaotic regimes of conductivity behavior in the tight-binding approximation, arXiv:2510.17589
  39. [45]Walter A. Harrison, Electronic Structure of Polyvalent Metals, Phys. Rev. 118, 1190 (1960).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_6gz8nm7d
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents