betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Counterexamples to the buckling eigenvalue-ratio conjecture in every dimension

Abstract

In 1999, Ashbaugh formulated the conjecture that the ball maximizes the ratio of the first two clamped buckling eigenvalues among bounded domains in Euclidean space. We disprove this conjecture in every dimension d≥2d\ge2 by constructing smooth connected domains with finitely many interior holes. The key observation is that a zero-value constraint on a concentric sphere close to the boundary of a ball increases the first two eigenvalues by the same relative amount to first order, whereas their ratio increases strictly at second order. A quantitative surface penalty and logarithmic cutoffs transfer this strict inequality to smooth perforated domains. The construction gives explicit geometric parameters depending only on the dimension dd.

Introduction

The ratio of eigenvalues characterizes the separation of the low part of the spectrum and is independent of the size of the domain. For a vibrating membrane, the sharp inequality of Payne–Pólya–Weinberger shows that the ball maximizes the ratio of the first two eigenvalues [7]. The fourth order buckling problem admits a parallel conclusion.

It connects geometric eigenvalue inequalities with elastic stability and spectral shape optimization, and reveals how the extremal geometry depends on the differential operator and on the clamped boundary conditions. The present paper investigates this question after interior constraints, smooth perforation, and a change of topology.

Let Ω⊂Rd\Omega\subset\mathbb{R}^{d} be a bounded connected open set with smooth boundary, where Rd\mathbb{R}^{d} is dd-dimensional Euclidean space. Write Δ=∑i=1d∂xi2\Delta= \sum_{i=1}^{d} \partial_{x_i}^{2} for the Euclidean Laplacian, and let λkD(Ω)\lambda_k^{D}(\Omega) be the eigenvalues of the Dirichlet problem

−Δv=λvin Ω,v=0on ∂Ω,-\Delta v = \lambda v \quad\text{in } \Omega, \qquad v = 0 \quad\text{on } \partial\Omega,

arranged in nondecreasing order and counted with multiplicity. In the planar case, the Payne–Pólya–Weinberger conjecture [19] asserts that the disk maximizes the ratio of the first two eigenvalues. Its higher dimensional analogue is

λ2D(Ω)λ1D(Ω)≤λ2D(B)λ1D(B)=jd/2,12jd/2−1,12.\frac{\lambda_2^{D}(\Omega)}{\lambda_1^{D}(\Omega)} \leq\frac{\lambda_2^{D}(B)}{\lambda_1^{D}(B)} = \frac{j_{d/2,1}^{2}}{j_{d/2-1,1}^{2}}.

Here B=B1(0)B = B_1(0) is the open unit ball, JαJ_{\alpha} is the Bessel function of the first kind of order α\alpha, and jα,kj_{\alpha,k} is its kk-th positive zero. This planar conjecture was also included by Yau in his problem collection [24] as Problem 77. Ashbaugh and Benguria [7] proved this sharp inequality in every dimension, with equality only for the ball. This Euclidean Dirichlet theorem provides the prototype for the buckling ratio conjecture.

For a membrane with fixed boundary, the vibrational frequencies are proportional to the square roots of the Dirichlet eigenvalues, so the ratio of eigenvalues is the square of the ratio of the first two frequencies. Kac’s question “Can one hear the shape of a drum?” [16] concerns the geometric information contained in the entire Dirichlet spectrum, whereas the PPW problem gives a sharp constraint on two quantities in the spectrum.

For a clamped elastic plate, the corresponding stability problem is

Δ2u=−ΛΔuin Ω,u=∂νu=0on ∂Ω,\Delta^{2}u = -\Lambda\Delta u \quad\text{in } \Omega, \qquad u = \partial_{\nu}u = 0 \quad\text{on } \partial\Omega,

where Δ2=Δ∘Δ\Delta^{2} = \Delta\circ\Delta is the biharmonic operator, ν\nu is the outward unit normal, and ∂νu\partial_{\nu}u is the normal derivative. Denote its positive eigenvalues by Λ1(Ω)≤Λ2(Ω)≤⋯\Lambda_1(\Omega) \leq\Lambda_2(\Omega) \leq\cdots, counted with multiplicity. In the planar thin plate model, uu is the transverse displacement and Λ1\Lambda_1 is proportional to the critical uniform compressive load at which the plate loses stability, see [11, 20]. Higher eigenvalues correspond to higher buckling modes of the linearized problem, and the separation of these modal thresholds is measured by their ratios, which are independent of the size of the plate. This ratio is not the same as the ratio of vibrational frequencies. The vibrations of a clamped plate satisfy Δ2u=Γu\Delta^{2}u = \Gamma u, where Γ\Gamma is the vibrational eigenvalue, with the same boundary conditions.

In the original planar problem the domain used for comparison is the disk. Rayleigh’s conjecture [21 p. 382] states that among planar domains of given area the disk minimizes the first clamped vibrational eigenvalue. The citation refers to the second edition of Volume I, see also [5 Section 2.4]. Pólya and Szegő [20 Note F, p. 231] proposed the corresponding fixed-area minimization problem for the first buckling load. Both original statements concern only d=2d=2. Comparison with the ball in higher dimensions is an extension rather than the original formulation, see [11 p. 383]. Talenti’s rearrangement method [22], together with the subsequent work of Nadirashvili [18] and of Ashbaugh and Benguria [8], eventually settled Rayleigh’s conjecture and its three-dimensional extension. For the buckling problem, Ashbaugh and Laugesen [11] obtained dimension-dependent lower bounds, in which the comparison factor tends to 1 as the dimension tends to infinity. However, the comparison of the first eigenvalue and the ratio problem require different arguments, see also the survey [9].

The buckling problem on the ball can be solved by separation of variables, which yields

Λ1(B)=jd/2,12andΛ2(B)=jd/2+1,12,\Lambda_1(B)=j_{d/2,1}^{2}\quad\text{and}\quad\Lambda_2(B)=j_{d/2+1,1}^{2},

see [10 Section 11.3]. Since Λk(tΩ)=t−2Λk(Ω)\Lambda_k(t\Omega)=t^{-2}\Lambda_k(\Omega) holds for t>0t>0, this ratio is invariant under scaling. In 1999, Ashbaugh [5 Section 4, equation (4.8)] formulated the following buckling analogue of the PPW conjecture:

Λ2(Ω)Λ1(Ω)≤Cd,Cd:=jd/2+1,12jd/2,12.(1)\frac{\Lambda_2(\Omega)}{\Lambda_1(\Omega)}\leq C_d,\qquad C_d:=\frac{j_{d/2+1,1}^{2}}{j_{d/2,1}^{2}}. \tag*{(1)}

This also appears in [10 Remark 8.10]. Payne, Pólya and Weinberger earlier established the planar bound Λ2/Λ1<3\Lambda_2/\Lambda_1<3 [19]. Hile and Yeh [14] improved and extended this bound to

Λ2(Ω)Λ1(Ω)≤d2+8d+20(d+2)2.\frac{\Lambda_2(\Omega)}{\Lambda_1(\Omega)}\leq\frac{d^2+8d+20}{(d+2)^2}.

Later work has focused on stronger conclusions for several buckling eigenvalues. Ashbaugh [5, 6] proved that

∑i=1dΛi+1≤(d+4)Λ1,\sum_{i=1}^{d}\Lambda_{i+1}\leq(d+4)\Lambda_1,

and Jost et al. [15 Theorem 4.2] strengthened this to

∑i=1dΛi+1+4(Λ2−Λ1)d+4≤(d+4)Λ1.\sum_{i=1}^{d}\Lambda_{i+1}+\frac{4(\Lambda_2-\Lambda_1)}{d+4}\leq(d+4)\Lambda_1.

Looking only at the first ratio, the preceding inequality gives

dΛ2+4(Λ2−Λ1)d+4≤∑i=1dΛi+1+4(Λ2−Λ1)d+4≤(d+4)Λ1,d\Lambda_2+\frac{4(\Lambda_2-\Lambda_1)}{d+4}\leq\sum_{i=1}^{d}\Lambda_{i+1}+\frac{4(\Lambda_2-\Lambda_1)}{d+4}\leq(d+4)\Lambda_1,
Λ2Λ1≤(d+4)2+4d(d+4)+4=d2+8d+20(d+2)2.\frac{\Lambda_2}{\Lambda_1}\leq\frac{(d+4)^2+4}{d(d+4)+4}=\frac{d^2+8d+20}{(d+2)^2}.

Thus the improved inequality recovers the constant of Hile and Yeh and controls several further low eigenvalues without weakening the upper bound for Λ2/Λ1\Lambda_2/\Lambda_1.

For any k≥1k \ge1, Cheng and Yang [12] established a general quadratic inequality with coefficient 4(d+2)/d24(d+2)/d^2, and later improved it in [13 Theorem 1.1] to

∑i=1k(Λk+1−Λi)2≤4(d+4/3)d2∑i=1k(Λk+1−Λi)Λi.\sum_{i=1}^{k}(\Lambda_{k+1}-\Lambda_i)^2 \le\frac{4(d+4/3)}{d^2}\sum_{i=1}^{k}(\Lambda_{k+1}-\Lambda_i)\Lambda_i.

Taking k=1k=1 and Λ2>Λ1\Lambda_2>\Lambda_1 gives

(Λ2−Λ1)2≤4(d+4/3)d2(Λ2−Λ1)Λ1⟹Λ2Λ1≤1+4(d+4/3)d2.(\Lambda_2-\Lambda_1)^2 \le\frac{4(d+4/3)}{d^2}(\Lambda_2-\Lambda_1)\Lambda_1 \quad\Longrightarrow\quad\frac{\Lambda_2}{\Lambda_1}\le1+\frac{4(d+4/3)}{d^2}.

The ratio bound also holds when Λ2=Λ1\Lambda_2=\Lambda_1. However, it is weaker than the Hile and Yeh bound:

1+4(d+4/3)d2−d2+8d+20(d+2)2=16(d2+7d+4)3d2(d+2)2>0.1+\frac{4(d+4/3)}{d^2}-\frac{d^2+8d+20}{(d+2)^2}=\frac{16(d^2+7d+4)}{3d^2(d+2)^2}>0.

Thus these later general inequalities are meaningful progress for the whole spectrum, but the conclusions about the first ratio derived from them cannot replace the Hile–Yeh estimate used here.

The theorem for the membrane problem, together with a few simple symmetric examples, makes this conjecture appear quite plausible. For the square (0,1)2(0,1)^2, separation of variables for the membrane problem gives

λ2D((0,1)2)λ1D((0,1)2)=5π22π2=52<j1,12j0,12≈2.5387.\frac{\lambda^{D}_2((0,1)^2)}{\lambda^{D}_1((0,1)^2)}=\frac{5\pi^2}{2\pi^2}=\frac{5}{2}<\frac{j_{1,1}^2}{j_{0,1}^2}\approx2.5387.

Numerical computations in the buckling case likewise place the square below the disk, the ratio being about 1.76, while C2≈1.7964C_2\approx1.7964, see [4 Section 3.2.2 and Figure 7]. We note here that these buckling values are only numerical evidence, since the spectrum of the clamped square has no explicit formula. Antunes computed triangular, quadrilateral and octagonal domains and found that within each class the regular polygon maximizes the ratio, with the disk as the limiting case. Thus the membrane theorem and the computations on polygons both point toward the ball, whereas the later general inequalities do not address this specific comparison.

A direct transfer of the membrane proof encounters structural difficulties. The argument of Ashbaugh and Benguria uses product-type trial functions together with Chiti’s comparison theorem. The latter compares the rearranged positive first eigenfunction with the first eigenfunction on a ball having the same first eigenvalue, see [5 Section 2.3, equations (2.20)–(2.28)]. Let v>0v>0 be the first Dirichlet eigenfunction and g∈C∞(Ω‾)g\in C^\infty(\overline{\Omega}) a real-valued function, here dxdx denotes the Lebesgue volume measure. Taking g2vg^2v as a test function in the equation for vv yields

∫Ω∣∇(gv)∣2 dx−λ1D∫Ωg2v2 dx=∫Ωv2∣∇g∣2 dx.(2)\int_{\Omega}|\nabla(gv)|^2\,dx-\lambda^D_1\int_{\Omega}g^2v^2\,dx=\int_{\Omega}v^2|\nabla g|^2\,dx. \tag*{(2)}

If gv≢0gv \not\equiv0 and ∫Ωgv2 dx=0\int_{\Omega} gv^{2}\,\mathrm{d}x=0, then

References

  1. [1]R. A. Adams and J. J. F. Fournier, Sobolev Spaces, second ed., Pure and Applied Mathematics 140, Academic Press, Amsterdam, 2003. D. R. Adams and L. I. Hedberg, Function Spaces and Potential Theory, Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften 314, Springer, Berlin, 1996.
  2. [3]L. V. Ahlfors, Complex Analysis, third ed., McGraw–Hill, New York, 1979.
  3. [4]P. R. S. Antunes, On the buckling eigenvalue problem, J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 44 (2011), no. 21, 215205, 13 pp.DOI
  4. [5]M. S. Ashbaugh, Isoperimetric and universal inequalities for eigenvalues, in Spectral Theory and Geometry, E. B. Davies and Yu. Safarov (eds.), London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series 273, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1999, 95–139.DOI
  5. [6]M. S. Ashbaugh, On universal inequalities for the low eigenvalues of the buckling problem, in Partial Differential Equations and Inverse Problems, Contemporary Mathematics 362, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2004, 13–31.DOI
  6. [7]M. S. Ashbaugh and R. D. Benguria, A sharp bound for the ratio of the first two eigenvalues of Dirichlet Laplacians and extensions, Ann. of Math. (2) 135 (1992), 601–628.DOI
  7. [8]M. S. Ashbaugh and R. D. Benguria, On Rayleigh’s conjecture for the clamped plate and its generalization to three dimensions, Duke Math. J. 78 (1995), 1–17.DOI
  8. [9]M. S. Ashbaugh, R. D. Benguria, and R. S. Laugesen, Inequalities for the first eigenvalues of the clamped plate and buckling problems, in General Inequalities 7, C. Bandle, W. N. Everitt, L. Losonczi, and W. Walter (eds.), International Series of Numerical Mathematics 123, Birkhäuser, Basel, 1997, 95–110.DOI
  9. [10]M. S. Ashbaugh, F. Gesztesy, M. Mitrea, R. Shterenberg, and G. Teschl, A survey on the Krein–von Neumann extension, the corresponding abstract buckling problem, and Weyl-type spectral asymptotics for perturbed Krein Laplacians in nonsmooth domains, in Mathematical Physics, Spectral Theory and Stochastic Analysis, M. Demuth and W. Kirsch (eds.), Operator Theory: Advances and Applications 232, Birkhäuser, Basel, 2013, 1–106.DOI
  10. [11]M. S. Ashbaugh and R. S. Laugesen, Fundamental tones and buckling loads of clamped plates, Ann. Scuola Norm. Sup. Pisa Cl. Sci. (4) 23 (1996), 383–402.
  11. [12]Q.-M. Cheng and H. C. Yang, Universal bounds for eigenvalues of a buckling problem, Comm. Math. Phys. 262 (2006), no. 3, 663–675.DOI
  12. [13]Q.-M. Cheng and H. C. Yang, Universal bounds for eigenvalues of a buckling problem II, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 364 (2012), no. 11, 6139–6158.arxiv.org/abs/0908.3745
  13. [14]G. N. Hile and R. Z. Yeh, Inequalities for eigenvalues of the biharmonic operator, Pacific J. Math. 112 (1984), 115–133.DOI
  14. [15]J. Jost, X. Li-Jost, Q. Wang, and C. Xia, Universal bounds for eigenvalues of the polyharmonic operators, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 363 (2011), no. 4, 1821–1854.arxiv.org/abs/0910.2067
  15. [16]M. Kac, Can one hear the shape of a drum?, Amer. Math. Monthly 73 (1966), no. 4, part II, 1–23.DOI
  16. [17]W. McLean, Strongly Elliptic Systems and Boundary Integral Equations, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2000.
  17. [18]N. S. Nadirashvili, Rayleigh’s conjecture on the principal frequency of the clamped plate, Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. 129 (1995), 1–10.DOI
  18. [19]L. E. Payne, G. Pólya, and H. F. Weinberger, On the ratio of consecutive eigenvalues, J. Math. Phys. 35 (1956), 289–298.DOI
  19. [20]G. Pólya and G. Szegő, Isoperimetric Inequalities in Mathematical Physics, Annals of Mathematics Studies 27, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 1951.
  20. [21]Lord Rayleigh (J. W. Strutt), The Theory of Sound, vol. I, second ed., Macmillan, London, 1894 (first edition, 1877).
  21. [22]G. Talenti, On the first eigenvalue of the clamped plate, Ann. Mat. Pura Appl. (4) 129 (1981), 265–280.DOI
  22. [23]G. N. Watson, A Treatise on the Theory of Bessel Functions, second ed., Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1944.
  23. [24]S.-T. Yau, Problem section, in Seminar on Differential Geometry, S.-T. Yau (ed.), Annals of Mathematics Studies 102, Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ, 1982, 669–706.

Paper details

vlnc:W_6sxfmju8
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 11

downloads · 1

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents