betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Uniform excess charge for Coulomb molecules and the outer radius of neutral atoms

Abstract

We prove that a molecule with M fixed nuclei of real charges at least one and total nuclear charge Z strictly binds at most Z+CMZ+CM electrons, where C is universal. The result holds for the full nonrelativistic Coulomb Hamiltonian with two spin states and arbitrary distinct nuclear positions. For neutral atoms with integer nuclear charge Z ≥ 1, the first ionization energy and, for every ground state, the radius outside which one half of an electron remains are each bounded above and below by positive universal constants.

Introduction

We prove a uniform bound on the number of excess electrons that fixed Coulomb nuclei can strictly bind. If there are MM nuclei of total charge ZZ, that number is at most CMCM, with a constant independent of their charges and positions. For a neutral atom with integer nuclear charge, we also prove that the cost of removing one electron and the radius containing all but one half of an electron each stay between positive universal constants. These conclusions address the number of bound electrons, the first ionization energy, and the location of the outer electronic mass. Their proofs share the local screening estimates developed in this paper.

The model and the results

Fix M≥1M \ge1, distinct positions R1,…,RM∈R3R_1,\ldots,R_M \in\mathbb{R}^3, and real charges z1,…,zM≥1z_1,\ldots,z_M \ge1. Put

Z=∑j=1Mzj,ν=∑j=1MzjδRj,K(x)=∣x∣−1,V=K∗ν.Z = \sum_{j=1}^{M} z_j, \qquad\nu= \sum_{j=1}^{M} z_j\delta_{R_j}, \qquad K(x) = |x|^{-1}, \qquad V = K * \nu.

For n≥1n \ge1 let Hn=⋀nL2(R3;C2)\mathcal{H}_n = \bigwedge^n L^2(\mathbb{R}^3;\mathbb{C}^2), so that there are two electron spin states and antisymmetry exchanges spatial and spin variables together. The Hamiltonian is the self-adjoint operator associated with the closed, bounded-below Coulomb form on Qn=Hn∩H1((R3)n;(C2)⊗n)Q_n = \mathcal{H}_n \cap H^1((\mathbb{R}^3)^n;(\mathbb{C}^2)^{\otimes n}):

Hn=∑i=1n(−12Δi−V(xi))+∑1≤i<j≤n∣xi−xj∣−1.(1)H_n = \sum_{i=1}^{n}\left(-\frac{1}{2}\Delta_i - V(x_i)\right) + \sum_{1 \le i<j \le n}|x_i-x_j|^{-1}. \tag*{(1)}

The nuclei are fixed, their mutual repulsion is a scalar independent of nn and is omitted. Write En=inf⁡σ(Hn)E_n = \inf\sigma(H_n) and E0=0E_0 = 0. We say that sector nn binds strictly if En<En−1E_n < E_{n-1}.

Theorem 1.1 (Uniform excess charge). There is a universal finite constant CC such that every nuclear system specified above and every integer n≥1n \ge1 satisfy

En<En−1⟹n≤Z+CM.E_n < E_{n-1} \quad\Longrightarrow\quad n \le Z + CM.

Moreover, En=En−1E_n = E_{n-1} whenever n>Z+CMn > Z + CM. For one nucleus this gives n≤Z+Cn \le Z + C under strict binding, for every real Z≥1Z \ge1. The same constant is independent of all charges and nuclear positions.

The positions may be arbitrarily close or far apart. The theorem resolves positively the excess-charge form of the ionization conjecture in this strict-binding formulation [7, 19]. Equality of adjacent energies does not by itself exclude a ground state at threshold; such threshold states are not needed here.

For the radius conclusion specialize to one nucleus at the origin with integer charge Z≥1Z \ge1. Write Hn,ZH_{n,Z} and E(n,Z)E(n,Z) when the nuclear charge needs to be displayed. If ΨZ\Psi_Z is a normalized ground state of HZ,ZH_{Z,Z}, its spin-summed density is

ρΨZ(x)=Z∑σ1,…,σZ∫∣ΨZ(x,σ1;x2,σ2;…;xZ,σZ)∣2 dx2⋯dxZ,\rho_{\Psi_Z}(x) = Z \sum_{\sigma_1,\ldots,\sigma_Z} \int|\Psi_Z(x,\sigma_1;x_2,\sigma_2;\ldots;x_Z,\sigma_Z)|^2\,dx_2\cdots dx_Z,

where the integral is absent for Z=1Z = 1. Its mass is ZZ. Define

R(ΨZ)=inf⁡{r≥0:∫∣x∣>rρΨZ(x) dx≤12}.(2)R(\Psi_Z) = \inf\left\{r \ge0 : \int_{|x|>r}\rho_{\Psi_Z}(x)\,dx \le\frac{1}{2}\right\}. \tag*{(2)}

Theorem 1.2 (Uniform outer half-electron radius). There are universal constants 0<c≤C<∞0 < c \le C < \infty such that, for every integer Z≥1Z \ge1 and every normalized ground state of HZ,ZH_{Z,Z},

c≤R(ΨZ)≤C.c \le R(\Psi_Z) \le C.

The existence of these ground states is included in Lemma 2.5. No uniqueness or spherical symmetry is assumed. The exterior mass in (2) stays fixed as ZZ grows; it describes outer electrons rather than a fixed fraction of the atom.

Corollary 1.3 (Two-sided first-ionization bound). For the full nonrelativistic Coulomb atom specified above, with integer nuclear charge Z≥1Z \ge1, one-electron kinetic term −Δ/2-\Delta/2, and two electron spin states, write EZ(n)=E(n,Z)E_Z(n) = E(n,Z). There are universal constants 0<c≤C<∞0 < c \le C < \infty such that the first ionization energy of the neutral atom satisfies

c≤I1(Z):=EZ(Z−1)−EZ(Z)≤Cfor every integer Z≥1.c \le I_1(Z) := E_Z(Z-1) - E_Z(Z) \le C \qquad\text{for every integer } Z \ge1.

History and the scales of the problem

Simon’s atomic formulation asks whether N0(Z)−ZN_0(Z)-Z stays bounded, where N0(Z)N_0(Z) is the first sector at which the energy equals every later sector energy [19]. Since the sector energies are nonincreasing and ultimately constant, this is the largest strictly binding sector used here. The corresponding molecular conjecture has the form Nc≤Z+CMN_c \le Z+CM [7].

The early charge bounds already distinguished atoms from molecules. Lieb proved bounds linear in the total nuclear charge for fixed atoms and molecules, without requiring Fermi statistics [8]. For fermionic atoms, Lieb, Sigal, Simon and Thirring established asymptotic neutrality: the maximal strictly bound particle number Nc(Z)N_c(Z) satisfies Nc(Z)/Z→1N_c(Z)/Z \to1 as Z→∞Z \to\infty [12, 13]. Fefferman and Seco, and Seco, Sigal and Solovej, subsequently obtained quantitative sublinear bounds [2, 18]. Ivrii obtained further semiclassical charge bounds for atoms and heavy molecules under the hypothesis that each nuclear charge is comparable to the electron number, with improved exponents for atoms and for suitably separated nuclei [5]. For explicit finite-charge estimates, Nam proved Nc(Z)<1.22Z+3Z1/3N_c(Z) < 1.22Z+3Z^{1/3} [14]. More recently, Hundertmark, Pattakos and Schulz obtained Nc(Z)<1.1185Z+4Z1/3N_c(Z) < 1.1185Z+4Z^{1/3} for Z≥4Z \ge4 [4]. These estimates supply useful quantitative control while leaving the uniform excess-charge assertion distinct.

For the full many-electron Schrödinger atom, Seco, Sigal and Solovej also obtained, for large ZZ, an upper bound for the neutral first ionization energy and a lower bound for an exterior-mass radius, both given by powers of the nuclear charge [18]. Their radius leaves one expected electron outside, whereas (2) leaves one half. Their energy upper bound grows with ZZ, and their radius lower bound decays with ZZ. The upper bound in Corollary 1.3 establishes the usual boundedness assertion for I1(Z)I_1(Z) [22]; the uniform positive lower bound is an additional conclusion.

The statistical theories introduced by Thomas and Fermi [3, 23] predict a particularly rigid exterior screening profile. Lieb and Simon established the variational theory and its leading large-charge energy and density limits [9, 10]. Uniform ionization bounds were proved in Thomas–Fermi–von Weizsäcker theory by Benguria and Lieb [1], and in reduced and unrestricted Hartree–Fock theory by Solovej [20, 21]. Solovej’s unrestricted Hartree–Fock analysis compares screened potentials through successive spatial scales and also establishes uniform bounds and asymptotics for outer-electron radii [21], Definition 1.2, Theorem 1.5, and Sections 10–13. Those conclusions concern their stated variational models; the states in (1) may have arbitrary many-body correlations.

The bulk density limit lives on the length scale Z−1/3Z^{-1/3}, whereas the normalized mass outside the radius in (2) is 1/(2Z)1/(2Z). Its vanishing fraction makes bulk convergence insufficient to prove Theorem 1.2. The fixed exterior-mass viewpoint is also central to the generalized ionization conjecture [22].

Companion papers use the estimates developed here, with additional arguments, to obtain Thomas–Fermi asymptotics for full two-spin Coulomb atoms. The energy result sends the number of removed electrons to infinity while it remains negligible relative to the nuclear charge [15]; the neutral-radius result first takes upper and lower large-charge limits at fixed expected exterior electron mass, and then lets that mass tend to infinity [16].

The analytic ingredients have separate roles. The Lieb–Thirring kinetic inequality provides a positive coarse density bound, for which we use Rumin’s spectral-splitting argument [11, 17]. The exact Thomas–Fermi coefficient comes instead from coherent-state filling and Neumann eigenvalue counting, with explicit remainders. These constructions have classical antecedents in the semiclassical analysis of Lieb and Simon and in the coherent-state comparison of Solovej [10], Theorems III.10–III.13 [21], Lemma 8.2). Spatial square partitions are the usual IMS localization; sector-valued localization for correlated states is systematically developed by Lewin [6], Proposition 3.1 and Example 3.3. Our conditional core construction retains the removed positions and spins, so that the remaining correlated state can be compared with local trial electrons through its own screened field.

Obstacles and the common argument

Fixing the total electron number obstructs a local density comparison: a ball may contain too many or too few electrons, and its conditional core need not minimize any fixed local-particle-number problem. We therefore first work relative to the minimum E=inf⁡n≥0EnE = \inf_{n \ge0} E_n over all sectors. A coarse binding bound guarantees that it is attained at a largest strictly bound sector. A normalized state with form energy at most E+δE + \delta will be called a δ\delta-state. Keeping δ\delta visible makes local estimates available again after an event is imposed, after particles are deleted, and after a shell weight changes the probability law.

Three steps are common to the molecular and atomic conclusions. First, a spatial cut records every removed electron and leaves an antisymmetric conditional core. In the hole, arbitrary expected trial mass is allowed because each actual trial has an integer sector with energy at least EE. The coherent upper and Neumann lower comparisons have the same kinetic coefficient. Their comparison produces a local Thomas–Fermi minimizer ρ\rho and its screened field WW, related by

ρ=k(W+)3/2,k=23/23π2.\rho= k(W_+)^{3/2}, \qquad k = \frac{2^{3/2}}{3\pi^2}.

It also controls the Coulomb discrepancy from the actual fine density and the energy of that density in the negative part of WW. A bootstrap for the positive field closes a bound on the second moment of local electron counts.

Next, smoothing and noisy observations produce a conditional density μ\mu and a screened field. In the atomic case the field is H=V−K∗μH = V - K * \mu. On nucleus-free patches we transfer the local Thomas–Fermi law to these quantities, as one-sided comparisons between μ\mu and k(H+)3/2k(H_+)^{3/2} at positive, bounded rescaled heights. The molecular comparison retains the nearby nuclear potential explicitly: after splitting off its singular part, we compare the continuous conditional offset through an averaged Thomas–Fermi response.

To prove these comparisons, observe all positions with independent errors of width ℓ\ell and forget the particle labels. An observation event of probability pp has a symmetric square-root likelihood multiplier. Applied to a sector eigenstate, its energy cost is bounded by Cℓ−2log⁡5(e/p)C\ell^{-2}\log^5(e/p), without a particle-number factor. A hypothetical failure can therefore be tested by the local quantum estimates. The original observation posterior and the fresh patch posterior are different: two separate conditional-expectation identities compare their fields after averaging in the event law. The negative-field penalty controls the rare configurations needed to pass a lower field estimate to expectation.

Finally, a positive comparison field is continued outward. A local maximum chooses between a shifted nonlinear subsolution and a shifted observed field. The inverse comparisons let us replace the model reaction by the actual conditional density on one more layer. Conditional averaging then forgets one observation array, with convexity preserving the nonlinear inequality. The errors are summed through their expected integrals. At the terminal scale, comparison with a compact source potential and its spherical mean turns the positive field into a lower bound on the nuclear charge minus the enclosed electron mass, up to the accumulated error.

The geometry determines how this mechanism closes. For a molecule, the local length measures nearby nuclear charge. Empty nuclear annuli must be counted without a loss for their number of scales. A decomposition by nested nuclear representatives gives a total cost proportional to MM; it bounds the electrons outside the terminal region and closes the excess-charge estimate.

For an atom, local balls away from the nucleus use their distance from it; this distinct scale reaches inside the bulk length. The continuation produces an interior electron deficit for sector ground states with n≤3Zn \le3Z and bounded energy offset from EE. We first use it at offset zero. Deleting exterior particles then proves EZ−1≤E+CE_{Z-1} \le E + C, so both neutral and singly ionized ground states become eligible for the fixed-offset estimates. The neutral deficit gives the lower radius bound. A spatially averaged insertion into the singly ionized state gives a uniform positive gap EZ−1−EZ≥cE_{Z-1} - E_Z \ge c. Together with the offset bound this proves Corollary 1.3, after adjusting the constants at finitely many smaller charges. The gap also yields the expected tail bound C/RC/R through a shell-weighted change of law. Here the shell weight is measurable in the revealed data, which is why this change of law preserves the surviving conditional field.

Organization and normalization

Section 2 provides the sector facts, and Sections 3–5 prove the shared localization, screening, and conditioning estimates. The two local geometries are specified in Section 4. From these shared tools, Sections 6–9 prove the molecular excess-charge bound. A reader interested in the neutral atomic results may instead proceed directly to Sections 10–14; these proofs do not use the molecular excess-charge theorem. The atomic comparison and intermediate subsolutions come first, followed by deletion, insertion, and the tail argument in the order described above. Section 15 collects the precise inputs for the companion asymptotic problems, including the classical Thomas–Fermi comparisons proved in Section 7.

All density integrals include spin summation. For a real number or function vv, write v+=max⁡(v,0)v_+ = \max(v,0) and v−=max⁡(−v,0)v_- = \max(-v,0). The constants C,c>0C,c > 0 may change from line to line and are universal unless a dependence is stated. With the kinetic normalization in (1.1),

cTF=310(3π2)2/3,k=(5cTF/3)−3/2=233π2,cF=4πk.(3)c_{\mathrm{TF}} = \frac{3}{10}(3\pi^2)^{2/3}, \qquad k = (5c_{\mathrm{TF}}/3)^{-3/2} = \frac{2^3}{3\pi^2}, \qquad c_F = 4\pi k. \tag*{(3)}

The coarse kinetic lower bound does not assert that its unspecified constant equals cTFc_{\mathrm{TF}}.

A ground state at the minimum over all sectors

The local comparisons in the proof may replace electrons in a region by a different number of electrons. We therefore first reduce to a ground state whose energy is minimal among all particle-number sectors. A coarse number bound makes this reduction possible; no convexity of the sector energies is needed.

The Coulomb form and strict binding

Use the Hilbert spaces and form domains defined in the Introduction, writing nn for a variable particle number. The quadratic form associated with (1.1) is

qn[ψ]=12∑i=1n∥∇iψ∥22−∑i=1n∫V(xi)∣ψ∣2+∑1≤i<j≤n∫K(xi−xj)∣ψ∣2.(4)q_n[\psi] = \frac{1}{2}\sum_{i=1}^{n}\lVert\nabla_i\psi\rVert^2_2 - \sum_{i=1}^{n}\int V(x_i)|\psi|^2 + \sum_{1\le i<j\le n}\int K(x_i-x_j)|\psi|^2. \tag*{(4)}

We also evaluate this expression on the ambient spin-valued H1H^1 space when a localization preserves antisymmetry only within groups of variables. Sector-energy bounds will be applied only to the groups that remain antisymmetric. Hardy’s inequality in three dimensions, followed by Cauchy–Schwarz, shows that each Coulomb term is infinitesimally form bounded relative to the kinetic energy. For a pair term, apply the same argument to the relative coordinate xi−xjx_i-x_j. Thus, for each fixed system and sector, the sum of the absolute Coulomb forms is bounded by

References

  1. [1]R. Benguria and Elliott H. Lieb. The most negative ion in the Thomas–Fermi–von Weizsäcker theory of atoms and molecules. Journal of Physics B: Atomic and Molecular Physics, 18(6): 1045–1059, 1985. doi: 10.1088/0022-3700/18/6/006.DOI
  2. [2]Charles L. Fefferman and Luis A. Seco. Asymptotic neutrality of large ions. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 128(1):109–130, 1990. doi: 10.1007/BF02097048.DOI
  3. [3]Enrico Fermi. Un metodo statistico per la determinazione di alcune proprietà dell’atomo. Rendiconti dell’Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei, 6:602–607, 1927.
  4. [4]Dirk Hundertmark, Nikolaos Pattakos, and Marvin Raimund Schulz. On the excess charge problem of atoms, 2025. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.18487. Version 1, 25 April 2025.
  5. [5]Victor Ivrii. Asymptotics of the ground state energy of heavy molecules and related topics, 2012. arXiv:1210.1132v2, 28 March 2017.
  6. [6]Mathieu Lewin. Geometric methods for nonlinear many-body quantum systems. Journal of Functional Analysis, 260(12):3535–3595, 2011. doi: 10.1016/j.jfa.2010.11.017.DOI
  7. [7]Mathieu Lewin. Some open mathematical problems concerning charged quantum particles. Comptes Rendus. Physique, 26:369–380, 2025. doi: 10.5802/crphys.249.DOI
  8. [8]Elliott H. Lieb. Bound on the maximum negative ionization of atoms and molecules. Physical Review A, 29(6):3018–3028, 1984. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevA.29.3018.DOI
  9. [9]Elliott H. Lieb and Barry Simon. Thomas–Fermi theory revisited. Physical Review Letters, 31(11):681–683, 1973. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.31.681.DOI
  10. [10]Elliott H. Lieb and Barry Simon. The Thomas–Fermi theory of atoms, molecules and solids. Advances in Mathematics, 23(1):22–116, 1977. doi: 10.1016/0001-8708(77)90108-6.DOI
  11. [11]Elliott H. Lieb and Walter E. Thirring. Bound for the kinetic energy of fermions which proves the stability of matter. Physical Review Letters, 35(11):687–689, 1975. doi: 10.1103/PhysRev Lett.35.687. Erratum: Physical Review Letters 35 (1975), 1116.
  12. [12]Elliott H. Lieb, Israel M. Sigal, Barry Simon, and Walter Thirring. Asymptotic neutrality of large-Z ions. Physical Review Letters, 52(12):994–996, 1984. doi: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.52.994.DOI
  13. [13]Elliott H. Lieb, Israel M. Sigal, Barry Simon, and Walter Thirring. Approximate neutrality of large-Z ions. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 116(4):635–644, 1988. doi: 10.1007/BF01224904.DOI
  14. [14]Phan Thành Nam. New bounds on the maximum ionization of atoms. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 312(2):427–445, 2012. doi: 10.1007/s00220-012-1479-y.DOI
  15. [15]OpenAI. Generalized ionization energies for full Coulomb atoms. OpenAI Math Release preprint OAI:Generalized-ionization-energies-for-full-Coulomb-atoms-September-24-2026, 2026.
  16. [16]OpenAI. Generalized outer-electron radii of neutral Coulomb atoms. OpenAI Math Release preprint OAI:Generalized-outer-electron-radii-of-neutral-Coulomb-atoms-September-24-2026, 2026.
  17. [17]Michel Rumin. Balanced distribution-energy inequalities and related entropy bounds. Duke Mathematical Journal, 160(3):567–597, 2011. doi: 10.1215/00127094-1444305.DOI
  18. [18]Luis A. Seco, Israel M. Sigal, and Jan Philip Solovej. Bound on the ionization energy of large atoms. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 131(2):307–315, 1990. doi: 10.1007/BF02161416.DOI
  19. [19]Barry Simon. Schrödinger operators in the twenty-first century. In A. Fokas, A. Grigoryan, T. Kibble, and B. Zegarlinski, editors, Mathematical Physics 2000, pages 283–288. Imperial College Press, London, 2000. doi: 10.1142/9781848160224_0014.DOI
  20. [20]Jan Philip Solovej. Proof of the ionization conjecture in a reduced Hartree–Fock model. Inventiones mathematicae, 104:291–311, 1991. doi: 10.1007/BF01245077.DOI
  21. [21]Jan Philip Solovej. The ionization conjecture in Hartree–Fock theory. Annals of Mathematics, 158(2):509–576, 2003. doi: 10.4007/annals.2003.158.509.
  22. [22]Jan Philip Solovej. A new look at Thomas–Fermi theory. Molecular Physics, 114(7–8): 1036–1040, 2016. doi: 10.1080/00268976.2015.1130273.
  23. [23]L. H. Thomas. The calculation of atomic fields. Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, 23(5):542–548, 1927. doi: 10.1017/S0305004100011683.DOI
  24. [24]G. M. Zhislin. A study of the spectrum of the Schrödinger operator for a system of several particles. Trudy Moskovskogo Matematicheskogo Obshchestva, 9:81–120, 1960. URL https://www.mathnet.ru/eng/mmo97. Erratum: volume 10 (1961), 437.
  25. [25]G. M. Zhislin and A. G. Sigalov. The spectrum of the energy operator for atoms with fixed nuclei on subspaces corresponding to irreducible representations of the group of permutations. Izvestiya Akademii Nauk SSSR. Seriya Matematicheskaya, 29(4):835–860, 1965. URL https://www.mathnet.ru/eng/im3076.

Paper details

vlnc:W_6vk6sck8
Version
v1 · latest
Published
License
LicenseRef-OpenAI-public
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 2

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

unreleased internal OpenAI model

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents