betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

From Sheared Annular Centrifugal Rayleigh-Bénard Convection to Radially Heated Taylor-Couette Flow: Exploring the Impact of Buoyancy and Shear on Heat Transfer and Flow Structure

Abstract

We investigate the coupling effect of buoyancy and shear based on an annular centrifugal Rayleigh-Bénard convection (ACRBC) system in which two cylinders rotate with an angular velocity difference. Direct numerical simulations are performed in a Rayleigh number range 10^6 \le Ra \le 10^8, at fixed Prandtl number Pr=4.3, inversed Rossby number Ro^{-1}=20 and radius ratio η=0.5. The shear, represented by the non-dimensional rotational speed difference Ω, varies from 0 to 10, corresponding to an ACRBC without shear and a radially heated Taylor-Couette flow with only the inner cylinder rotating, respectively. A stable regime is found in the middle part of the interval of Ω, and divides the whole parameter space into three regimes: buoyancy-dominated regime, stable regime, and shear-dominated regime. Clear boundaries between the regimes are given by linear stability analysis. In the buoyancy-dominated regime, the flow is a quasi-two-dimensional flow on the rφplane; as shear increases, both the growth rate of instability and the heat transfer is depressed. In the shear-dominated regime, the flow is mainly on the rz plane, and the heat transfer in this regime is greatly enhanced. The study shows shear can stabilize buoyancy-driven convection and reveals the complex coupling mechanism of shear and buoyancy, which may have implications for fundamental studies and industrial designs.

Introduction

Turbulent convection, one of the most complicated fluid motions, is ubiquitous in nature and industrial processes. As two essential elements of fluid dynamics, buoyancy, and shear play important roles in many kinds of turbulent flows. Under gravity or other body force fields, buoyancy is generated by the inhomogeneous density distribution of fluid. When the buoyancy force is large, it can induce instability and drive the convection. Rayleigh-Bénard (RB) convection is one typical paradigm of buoyancy-driven convection and has been studied extensively in scientific research [2, 11] (Lohse & Xia 2010; Xia 2013). In the RB cell, the fluid is heated from below and cooled from above under gravity. Due to the thermal expansion of the fluid, buoyancy appears and drives the convection. Some manifold and involute flow structures are formed in the cell (Niemela et al. 2001; Xi et al. 2004; Sun et al. 2005; Wang et al. 2021). Moreover, apart from the classical RB model with rectangular cells, annular (Pitz et al. 2017; Kang et al. 2019; Jiang et al. 2020; Rouhi et al. 2021; Wang et al. 2023) and spherical [17] RB cells also attract a lot of interest. The uniform gravity is substituted by the centrifugal force or gravity which varies in the direction of the temperature gradient. Different from buoyancy, shear contributes to the flow mainly by the motion of the system boundary. Taylor-Couette (TC) flow, the flow impelled by two concentric cylinders rotating independently, is a widely used canonical model to study the effect of shear. Secondary flows are caused by the centrifugal instability, and then many complicated flow structures including turbulent Taylor vortex flow and wavelets are generated at high Reynolds numbers [4, 15, 8, 21] (Ostilla-Mónico et al. 2014a).

Transport efficiency is an important quantity in both RB convection and TC flow, as the physical quantities being transferred are temperature and angular velocity, respectively [14]. In non-dimensional forms, there exist scaling laws in RB convection, between the dimensionless heat flux (measured by the Nusselt number NuhNu_h) and the dimensionless buoyancy-driven strength (measured by the Rayleigh number RaRa) [10, 20] (Shraiman & Siggia 1990); similar scaling laws occur in TC flow as well, between the dimensionless angular velocity current (measured by NuωNu_\omega) and the dimensionless shear (measured by the Taylor number TaTa) [18] (Merbold et al. 2013). Bradshaw observed the high similarity between the RB convection and TC flow [7]; further, an exact analogy between the two flows is raised, extending the Grossmann & Lohse’s scaling theory on RB convection well to TC flow [14, 9]. This analogy reveals that the transport phenomena in the two systems have similar inner physics.

The coupling of buoyancy and shear is widespread in atmospheric motion and oceanic flow (Deardorff 1972; Khanna & Brasseur 1998). For example, the surface mesoscale eddies in the ocean are mainly generated by baroclinic instabilities, which are relevant to the pole-equator temperature gradient and a vertical shear [16] (Hopfinger & van Heijst 1993; Pierr ehumbert & Swanson 1995; Vincze et al. 2014). By far, there are many attempts to combine shear and buoyancy in one system and study their coupling effect. When a radial temperature difference is applied to a TC system, it contributes to the instability (Yoshikawa et al. 2013; Meyer et al. 2015; Kang et al. 2015) and the momentum and heat transfer (Kang et al. 2017; Leng & Zhong 2022). When the gravity or centrifugal force is considered as the body force inducing buoyancy, the results are different. Leng et al. (Leng et al. 2021; Leng & Zhong 2022) apply radial or axial temperature difference on TC flow with only the inner cylinder rotating, and find that with fixed temperature difference and increasing rotational speed, the heat transfer is first depressed by shear and then enhanced due to the development of turbulent TC flow. Interestingly, similar phenomena occur when shear is applied on a rectangular RB cell [19, 6, 5]. With increasing plane Couette shearing, the flow is first dominated by buoyancy and then dominated by shear. The heat transport shows a similar trend in the two systems, that heat transport is depressed under weak shearing until the shear is strong enough to mix the system better than thermal plumes. The transition of dominated regimes depends on the Richardson number RiRi, defined as the ratio between buoyancy and shear driving.

To explore the effect of shear on heat transfer in a wide parameter regime, we adopt the annular centrifugal Rayleigh-Bénard convection (ACRBC). The centrifugal force generated by rotating inner and outer cylinders offers buoyancy and the Earth’s gravity is neglected, similar to the rotating machines with high rotational speed. As the buoyancy is perpendicular to the cylinder surface, the aspect ratio (here, the aspect ratio is defined as the ratio of circumference to the gap length) in ACRBC is larger than that in RB convection. Recent studies show that the ACRBC owns similar scaling laws with classical RB convection, and is an efficient way to reach the ultimate regime (Jiang et al. 2020, 2022). The angular velocity difference between the inner and outer cylinders offers shear for the system, therefore the system can also be regarded as a Taylor-Couette system with radial temperature difference. With no shear, the inner and outer cylinders co-rotating at the same angular speed; with strong shear, one of the cylinders can stop rotating or become counter-rotating with another. Meyer et al. (2015) discusses the instability of a similar system with a non-rotating outer cylinder but mainly focuses on the instability at a low Taylor number. In our system, we work on a wide range of the Rayleigh number and the Taylor number, concentrating on the instability and scalar transport, aiming to bring a complete understanding of the coupling effect of buoyancy and shear in an annular centrifugal system.

The rest of the paper is organized as follows: the establishment of the numerical model and the numerical methods including linear stability analysis (LSA) and direct numerical simulation (DNS) are introduced in § 2, and the main results are discussed in § 3. Finally, conclusions are presented in § 4.

Numerical model

A three-dimensional annular centrifugal RB cell bounded by two independent-rotating concentric cylinders is considered, as shown in Figure 1. The inner cylinder with radius RiR_i rotates about zz axis at angular velocity Ωi\Omega_i and the outer cylinder with radius RoR_o rotates at the angular velocity Ωo\Omega_o. L=Ro−RiL=R_o-R_i is the gap width between the two cylinders. The temperature difference between the hot outer cylinder and the cold inner cylinder is Δ=θhot−θcold\Delta=\theta_{hot}-\theta_{cold}. For the boundary, no-slip and isothermal conditions are applied at two cylinder surfaces; periodic boundary conditions are imposed on the velocity and temperature in the axial direction, and we take a section of height HH as the computational domain in DNS.

Schematic diagram of the flow configuration in the stationary reference frame

Figure 1. Schematic diagram of the flow configuration in the stationary reference frame. RoR_o, RiR_i, and LL are the inner radius of the outer cylinder, the outer radius of the inner cylinder, and the gap width between the two cylinders, respectively. HH is the height of the cylindrical annulus in the computational domain of DNS. The outer cylinder rotates at the angular velocity Ωo\Omega_o and the inner cylinder rotates at the angular velocity Ωi\Omega_i. θhot\theta_{hot} and θcold\theta_{cold} are the temperature of the outer and inner walls.

Governing equations of the flow

The system is at a rotating frame with angular velocity Ωc\Omega_c, and the buoyancy is induced by the centrifugal force (Ωcr+uφ)2/r(\Omega_c r+u_\varphi)^2/r. The motion of the flow is governed by the non-dimensional Oberbeck–Boussinesq equations under cylindrical coordinate system (r,φ,z)(r,\varphi,z) (Jiang et al. 2020; Wang et al. 2022a):

∇⋅u=0,\nabla\cdot\boldsymbol{u} = 0,
∂u∂t+u⋅∇u=−∇p−Ro−1ez×u+PrRa∇2u−θ2(1−η)1+η(1+2uφRo−1r)2r,(1)\frac{\partial\boldsymbol{u}}{\partial t} + \boldsymbol{u} \cdot\nabla\boldsymbol{u} = -\nabla p - Ro^{-1}\boldsymbol{e}_z \times\boldsymbol{u} + \sqrt{\frac{Pr}{Ra}}\nabla^2\boldsymbol{u} - \theta\frac{2(1-\eta)}{1+\eta}\left(1+\frac{2u_\varphi}{Ro^{-1}r}\right)^2 r, \tag*{(1)}
∂θ∂t+u⋅∇θ=1Ra⋅Pr∇2θ,\frac{\partial\theta}{\partial t} + \boldsymbol{u} \cdot\nabla\theta= \sqrt{\frac{1}{Ra\cdot Pr}}\nabla^2\theta,

where u=(ur,uφ,uz)\boldsymbol{u}=(u_r,u_\varphi,u_z) is the velocity vector, θ∈[0,1]\theta\in[0,1] is the temperature, pp is the pressure, ez\boldsymbol{e}_z is the unit vector along the axial direction and η=Ri/Ro\eta=R_i/R_o is the radius ratio. Scaled quantities, including L=Ro−RiL=R_o-R_i for length, Δ\Delta for temperature, U=αΔΩc2(Ri+Ro)2LU=\sqrt{\alpha\Delta\Omega_c^2\frac{(R_i+R_o)}{2}L} for velocity, and L/UL/U for time are used to non-dimensionalize the governing equation, where α\alpha is the coefficient of thermal expansion of the fluid. Ωc\Omega_c is the rotational speed of the rotating reference frame, and we suppose it to represent the strength of centrifugal buoyancy, as reflected in the expression of free-fall velocity UU. In our system, considering both physical meaning and simplicity, we set Ωc=(Ωi+Ωo)/2\Omega_c=(\Omega_i+\Omega_o)/2. It is a good estimate for free-fall velocity when shearing is relatively small, which means Ωi−Ωo≪Ωc\Omega_i-\Omega_o\ll\Omega_c; when shearing is strong enough and dominates the flow, buoyancy contributes little and can be neglected, which will be discussed later in § 3. Therefore, the selected Ωc\Omega_c is reasonable in most of the parameter space. Under that rotating frame, the inner cylinder rotates at non-dimensional angular velocity Ω=(Ωi−Ωc)L/U\Omega=(\Omega_i-\Omega_c)L/U and the outer cylinder rotates at −Ω-\Omega.

Three non-dimensional parameters are generated through non-dimensionalization, they are the Rayleigh number (measuring the buoyancy-driving strength) RaRa, the inverse Rossby number (measuring Coriolis effects) Ro−1Ro^{-1} and the Prandtl number (fluid property) PrPr, expressed as:

Ra=(UL)2νκ=αΔΩc2(Ri+Ro)2L3νκ,Ra=\frac{(UL)^2}{\nu\kappa}=\frac{\alpha\Delta\Omega_c^2\frac{(R_i+R_o)}{2}L^3}{\nu\kappa},
Ro−1=2ΩcLU=2(αΔ(Ri+Ro)2L)−1/2,Ro^{-1}=\frac{2\Omega_cL}{U}=2\left(\frac{\alpha\Delta(R_i+R_o)}{2L}\right)^{-1/2},
Pr=νκ,(2)Pr=\frac{\nu}{\kappa}, \tag*{(2)}

where ν\nu is the kinematic viscosity and κ\kappa is the thermal diffusivity of the fluid. Therefore, there are five independent control parameters in the system: the Rayleigh number RaRa, the inverse Rossby number Ro−1Ro^{-1}, the Prandtl number PrPr, the rotational speed difference of two cylinders Ω=(Ωi−Ωc)L/U\Omega=(\Omega_i-\Omega_c)L/U and the radius ratio η\eta. Moreover, since the system can also be regarded as a TC system with radial buoyancy, the Taylor number TaTa can be defined as:

Ta=(1+η)4(Ro−Ri)2(Ri+Ro)2(Ωi−Ωo)264η2ν2=(1+η)616η2(1−η)2Ω2RaPr.(3)Ta=\frac{(1+\eta)^4(R_o-R_i)^2(R_i+R_o)^2(\Omega_i-\Omega_o)^2}{64\eta^2\nu^2}=\frac{(1+\eta)^6}{16\eta^2(1-\eta)^2}\frac{\Omega^2Ra}{Pr}. \tag*{(3)}

Therefore, TaTa is not an independent control parameter in our system, proportional to the RaRa and Ω2\Omega^2. The Richardson number RiRi, measuring the ratio between buoyancy and shear driving, can also be calculated by the ratio of characteristic buoyancy-velocity and the characteristic shearing-velocity:

Ri=U2(Ωi−Ωc)2ri2=(1−ηη)2Ω−2.(4)Ri=\frac{U^2}{(\Omega_i-\Omega_c)^2r_i^2}=\left(\frac{1-\eta}{\eta}\right)^2\Omega^{-2}. \tag*{(4)}

As we can see, the non-dimensional rotational speed difference Ω\Omega can represent the strength of shear relative to buoyancy.

In addition, two key response parameters are the Nusselt numbers measuring the efficiency of heat transport and momentum transport, given by the ratio of radius-independent currents to the currents in laminar and nonvortical cases, respectively (Eckhardt et al. 2007; Wang et al. 2022a), as Nuh=Jθ/JlamθNu_h=J^\theta/J^\theta_{\mathrm{lam}}, Nuω=Jω/JlamωNu_\omega=J^\omega/J^\omega_{\mathrm{lam}}. More about the Nusselt numbers and how they respond to RaRa and Ω\Omega will be discussed in § 3.

Linear stability analysis

LSA is a good approach to studying the instability of the flow. At the stable state, the flow is laminar and nonvortical TC flow and the heat is transferred by pure conduction. The azimuthal velocity VV and temperature Θ\Theta depend only on rr, and the radial and axial velocities are zero. The functions of VV and Θ\Theta are given by [3]

V(r)=Ar+Br,A=−1+η21−η2Ω,B=2ri21−η2Ω,V(r)=Ar+\frac{B}{r},\quad A=-\frac{1+\eta^2}{1-\eta^2}\Omega,\quad B=\frac{2r_i^2}{1-\eta^2}\Omega,
Θ(r)=ln⁡(r/ri)ln⁡(ro/ri),(5)\Theta(r)=\frac{\ln(r/r_i)}{\ln(r_o/r_i)}, \tag*{(5)}

where ri=η/(1−η)r_i=\eta/(1-\eta) and ro=1/(1−η)r_o=1/(1-\eta) are the non-dimensional radii of the inner and outer cylinders, respectively.

To perform LSA on this problem, we superimpose infinitesimal perturbations (ur′,uφ′,uz′,p′,θ′)(u'_r,u'_\varphi,u'_z,p',\theta') on the base flow state. After substituting the perturbation fields into equations (1), doing linearization, and expanding the perturbations into normal modes (Meyer et al. 2015; Kang et al. 2017),

(ur′,uφ′,uz′,p′,θ′)=(u^r(r),u^φ(r),u^z(r),p^(r),θ^(r))exp⁡(st+i(nφ+kz)),(6)(u'_r,u'_\varphi,u'_z,p',\theta')=(\hat{u}_r(r),\hat{u}_\varphi(r),\hat{u}_z(r),\hat{p}(r),\hat{\theta}(r))\exp(st+i(n\varphi+kz)), \tag*{(6)}

we obtain the resulting ordinary differential equations for rr-dependent normal mode quantities:

(D+r−1)u^r+inr−1u^φ+iku^z=0,(s+inVr)u^r−2Vru^φ=−Dp^+Ro−1u^φ+PrRa(∇2u^r−u^rr2−2inu^φr2)−2(1−η)(1+η)r[(1+2VRo−1r)2θ^+4ΘRo−1r(1+2VRo−1r)u^φ],(s+inVr)u^φ+(DV+Vr)u^r=−inrp^−Ro−1u^r+PrRa(∇2u^φ−u^φr2+2inu^rr2),(s+inVr)u^z=−ikp^+PrRa∇2u^z,(s+inVr)θ^+(DΘ)u^r=1RaPr∇2θ^.(7)\begin{aligned} (D+r^{-1})\hat{u}_r+inr^{-1}\hat{u}_\varphi+ik\hat{u}_z&=0,\\ \left(s+\frac{inV}{r}\right)\hat{u}_r-\frac{2V}{r}\hat{u}_\varphi&=-D\hat{p}+Ro^{-1}\hat{u}_\varphi+\sqrt{\frac{Pr}{Ra}}\left(\nabla^2\hat{u}_r-\frac{\hat{u}_r}{r^2}-\frac{2in\hat{u}_\varphi}{r^2}\right)\\ &\quad-\frac{2(1-\eta)}{(1+\eta)}r\left[\left(1+\frac{2V}{Ro^{-1}r}\right)^2\hat{\theta}+\frac{4\Theta}{Ro^{-1}r}\left(1+\frac{2V}{Ro^{-1}r}\right)\hat{u}_\varphi\right],\\ \left(s+\frac{inV}{r}\right)\hat{u}_\varphi+\left(DV+\frac{V}{r}\right)\hat{u}_r&=-\frac{in}{r}\hat{p}-Ro^{-1}\hat{u}_r+\sqrt{\frac{Pr}{Ra}}\left(\nabla^2\hat{u}_\varphi-\frac{\hat{u}_\varphi}{r^2}+\frac{2in\hat{u}_r}{r^2}\right),\\ \left(s+\frac{inV}{r}\right)\hat{u}_z&=-ik\hat{p}+\sqrt{\frac{Pr}{Ra}}\nabla^2\hat{u}_z,\\ \left(s+\frac{inV}{r}\right)\hat{\theta}+(D\Theta)\hat{u}_r&=\frac{1}{\sqrt{RaPr}}\nabla^2\hat{\theta}. \tag*{(7)} \end{aligned}

where operators D=d/drD=d/dr and ∇2=D2+D/r−n2/r2−k2\nabla^2=D^2+D/r-n^2/r^2-k^2 are introduced for simplification. ss is the temporal growth rate of perturbation, nn is the azimuthal mode number and kk is the axial wavenumber. Due to the infinite axial length and 2π2\pi period in the azimuthal direction, kk must be real and nn must be an integer. The boundary conditions of the perturbations are homogeneous:

r=ri: u^r=u^φ=u^z=p^=θ^=0,r=ro: u^r=u^φ=u^z=p^=θ^=0.(8)\begin{aligned} r=r_i:\ \hat{u}_r=\hat{u}_\varphi=\hat{u}_z=\hat{p}=\hat{\theta}&=0,\\ r=r_o:\ \hat{u}_r=\hat{u}_\varphi=\hat{u}_z=\hat{p}=\hat{\theta}&=0. \tag*{(8)} \end{aligned}

Then, the instability problem has been transformed into an eigenvalue problem, described by equations (7)–(8). This eigenvalue problem is solved by Chebyshev spectral collocation method. The equations (7) are discretized on Chebyshev–Gauss–Lobatto collocation points with Chebyshev differentiation matrices. In our work, the number of collocation points range from 200 to 400 for good convergence. Then the growth rate of perturbations ss becomes the eigenvalue of the generalized eigenvalue problems in the matrix form, and the corresponding perturbation normal modes are the eigenvectors. For certain parameters (Ra,Pr,Ro−1,Ω,η)(Ra, Pr, Ro^{-1}, \Omega, \eta), the flow is stable if for all (n,k)(n,k), the growth rate σ=real(s)\sigma=real(s) is always negative, which means all perturbation modes decay with time.

Direct numerical simulation

Direct numerical simulations (DNS) are performed using an energy-conserving second-order finite-difference code based on a Chebyshev-clustered staggered grid. The time-stepping of the explicit terms is based on a fractional-step third-order Runge–Kutta scheme, and the implicit terms are based on a Crank–Nicolson scheme with a pressure correction step set following. For more details on the numerical schemes of the governing equations, we refer the reader to this literature (Verzicco & Orlandi 1996; van der Poel et al. 2015; Zhu et al. 2018).

Adequate resolutions are ensured for all simulations and we have performed posterior checks of spatial and temporal resolutions to guarantee the resolution of all relevant scales. The ratios of maximum grid spacing Δg\Delta_g to the Kolmogorov scale estimated by the global criterion ηK=(ν3/ε)1/4\eta_K=(\nu^3/\varepsilon)^{1/4}, where ε\varepsilon is the mean viscous dissipation rate via exact relation, and the Batchelor scale ηB=ηKPr−1/2\eta_B=\eta_K Pr^{-1/2} (Silano et al. 2010) are checked, as shown in Appendix A. Furthermore, the clipped Chebyshev-type clustering grids adopted in the radial direction ensure the spatial resolution within boundary layers (BLs), as at least 10 grid points inside the thermal boundary layers. As for temporal resolution, we use the Courant–Friedrichs–Lewy (CFL) conditions and set CFL≤0.7CFL \le0.7 to guarantee the computational stability (Ostilla et al. 2013; van der Poel et al. 2015; Zhang et al. 2017). The simulations are run over enough time after the system has reached the statistically stationary state to obtain good statistical convergence. The relative difference of NuhNu_h based on the first and second halves of the simulations is generally less than 1%. And for NuωNu_\omega, as its absolute value is small and close to 1 in many weak shear cases, the relative difference is controlled generally less than 4% under weak shear, and less than 2% under strong shear. All those details are provided in Appendix A.

Other numerical details

In the present study, we aim at the coupling effect of shear and buoyancy on the flow structure and heat and momentum transfer, that is (Nuh,Nuω)=f(Ra,Ω)(Nu_h, Nu_\omega) = f(Ra, \Omega). Therefore, referring to the results of our previous experiments and simulations of ACRBC (Jiang et al. 2020, 2022; Wang et al. 2022b), Pr=4.3Pr = 4.3 is taken for water at 40∘C40^\circ\mathrm{C}, and η\eta is set to be 0.5. Considering the Boussinesq approximation, αΔ≪1\alpha\Delta\ll1 is required. According to equations (2), we choose αΔ=6.67×10−3\alpha\Delta= 6.67 \times10^{-3} and then Ro−1=20Ro^{-1} = 20, which is also in the parameter range of our previous experiments, corresponding to a temperature difference Δ≈17.3K\Delta\approx17.3\mathrm{K} for water (Jiang et al. 2020, 2022). The Non-Oberbeck-Boussinesq effect is not obvious at this temperature difference [1] and the Oberbeck-Boussinesq conditions are well satisfied. Meanwhile, considering the definition of Ro−1Ro^{-1}, in the non-dimensional system, the rotational speed of the rotating reference frame is (ΩcL/U)=Ro−1/2=10(\Omega_c L/U) = Ro^{-1}/2 = 10.

As for instability, we focus on Ra∈[103,109]Ra \in[10^3, 10^9] and Ω∈[10−2,10]\Omega\in[10^{-2}, 10], where positive Ω\Omega means the inner cylinder rotates at a faster angular velocity than the outer cylinder in the stationary reference frame. For example, Ω=10\Omega= 10 corresponds to the state that the inner cylinder is rotating with the non-dimensional angular velocity ω=20\omega= 20 and the outer cylinder is static in the stationary reference frame. The DNS for heat tranfer analysis covers a RaRa range [106,108][10^6, 10^8] and a rotational speed difference Ω\Omega range [10−2,10][10^{-2}, 10].

Results and discussion

Previous studies have discussed or implied how the flow and heat transfer are at both ends of our parameter range. When Ω=0\Omega= 0, Jiang et al. (Jiang et al. 2020) shows that the flow will be quasi-two-dimensional at high Ro−1Ro^{-1} number (Ro−1≥10Ro^{-1} \ge10), due to the constraint of Taylor-Proudman theorem. The scaling law of heat transfer in this region follows the Grossman-Lohse (GL) theory, with a power-law relationship of Nu∼Ra0.27Nu \sim Ra^{0.27} in the classical regime. At the other end, Ω=10\Omega= 10, only the inner cylinder rotating, previous work (Leng et al. 2021; Leng & Zhong 2022) implies that the shear is so strong that the flow is dominated by the TC vortex and the temperature behaves like a passive scalar. In this section, we will reveal how the flow undergoes such a large transformation, from the RB flow in the rφr\varphi plane to the TC flow developed in the rzrz plane.

Flow regimes

When increasing shear converts the flow from the RB flow to the TC flow, a stable regime is found on the way. To determine the boundaries of the stable regime, the approach of linear stability analysis is applied and the results are checked by the direct numerical simulation. As shown in Figure 2(a), two unstable regimes are distributed on the two sides of the parameter domain and a stable regime locates in the middle. The results of DNS agree well with the boundaries given by LSA, guaranteeing the validity of the stable regime. We denote the three regimes as RB-dominated regime (Regime I), stable regime (Regime II), and TC-dominated regime (Regime III), with the shear strength increasing.

Figure 2. (a) Instability regimes divided by LSA (the bottle green lines) and checked by DNS (the red circles and the blue triangles) in the (Ra,Ω)(Ra,\Omega) parameter domain. (b) Instantaneous temperature fields from DNS at Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, Ω=10−2\Omega=10^{-2} (Regime I). (c) Instantaneous temperature fields from DNS at Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, Ω=1\Omega=1 (Regime II). (d) Instantaneous temperature fields from DNS at Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, Ω=7\Omega=7 (Regime III).

In the stable regime (Regime II), the typical instantaneous temperature field is illustrated in Figure 2(c). The system is governed by steady laminar and nonvortical TC flow, as described by equations (5). In the other two regimes, the typical instantaneous temperature fields exhibit significant differences, depicted in Figure 2(b,Figure 2d). In Regime I, the flow is quasi-two-dimensional on the rφr\varphi plane. Plumes are detached from the boundary layers, move across the bulk region, and transfer heat to the other side. Several convection roll pairs are generated, the number depending on the radius ratio η\eta when there is no shear (Pitz et al. 2017; Wang et al. 2022a). In Regime III, the flow is three-dimensional, and the roll pairs, or called Taylor vortexes, are mainly on the rzrz plane, which can be seen clearly on the vertical φ\varphi slice in Figure 2(c). There are large differences among the flow structures in these three regimes. For a fixed RaRa, as the shear increases from zero, the flow first stabilizes from a quasi-two-dimensional RB flow into a laminar flow and then destabilizes into a three-dimensional flow similar to the TC flow. It’s worth noting that as η=0.5\eta=0.5 in our system, the Richardson number Ri=Ω−2Ri=\Omega^{-2}, based on the equation (4). Therefore, at high RaRa, the stable regime locates at Ri∼O(1)Ri\sim O(1), which means the buoyancy is in the same order with shear; this is consistent with the transition region from buoyancy-dominated to shear-dominated obtained from previous work [6] (Leng et al. 2021).

The curves meaning the marginal state between regimes contain important information. The boundary between Regimes I and II has a horizontal asymptote on the left side for Ω→0\Omega\to0, that is the onset RaRa of the ACRBC at η=0.5\eta= 0.5. As Ω\Omega increases, the instability of the flow is suppressed and a stronger buoyancy force is required to drive the convection. The critical Rayleigh number RacRa_c of the marginal state grows faster and faster with increasing Ω\Omega, and finally, when Ω\Omega exceeds a certain value (about 0.6 with our parameter settings), the flow is always stable no matter how much the Rayleigh number increases in our parameter range. According to the marginal-state curve in Figure 2(a), there may also exist a vertical asymptote for Ra→∞Ra \to\infty. With the participation of the shear, the flow instability problem is different from the onset of the RB convection. For the onset RaRa of the ACRBC without shear, there exists a perturbation energy balance between the work performed by the buoyancy and the energy dissipation by the fluid viscosity; when the shear is imposed, the movement of the boundaries changes the balance. In addition, we notice that for the sheared classical rectangular RB system, the flow does not become stable with increasing shear [6]. This indicates that the effect of curvature and the rotation in sheared ACRBC may also contribute to the stabilization of the flow. We will discuss the physics of the instability between Regime I and II in depth in § 3.2.

Moreover, the straight boundary between Regimes II and III seems to behave differently. On this boundary, TaTa is much larger than RaRa: according to the equation (3), when Ra=103Ra = 10^3, Ta≈1×105Ta \approx1 \times10^5. Therefore, the marginal-state curve between Regime II and III is similar to the line given by Rayleigh’s inviscid criterion [3, 13] (Yoshikawa et al. 2013), with the thermal effect enhancing the instability slightly. As the instability of TC flow with radial temperature difference has been widely discussed [3] (Yoshikawa et al. 2013; Kang et al. 2015; Meyer et al. 2015; Yoshikawa et al. 2015), we mainly focus on the instability in Regime I and II in the following discussion.

Instability

Mode analysis

To investigate the effect of shear on the flow and how the stable regime arises, we begin with linear instability. In Regime I, the flow is unstable, and each pair of azimuthal and axial wavenumber (n,k)(n, k) is associated with a perturbation mode of a growth rate σ\sigma. We notice that for every nn, σ\sigma reaches a maximum all at k=0k = 0, corresponding to the quasi-2D flow characteristic in Regime I, that the flow is limited on the rφr\varphi plane. Therefore, only k=0k = 0 is considered in subsequent analysis on Regime I.

Wondering how shear influences the flow instability, we analyze the growth rate σ\sigma as a function of the azimuthal wavenumber nn for increasing Ω\Omega at Ra=107Ra = 10^7, and the results are plotted in Figure 3(a). In the no shear case Ω=0\Omega= 0, σ\sigma grows with nn quickly at first and then reaches a plateau. Modes of high azimuthal frequency n≳5n \gtrsim5 are preferred, having a higher growth rate than the low azimuthal wavenumber modes. With the shear imposed, the growth rates of all modes decrease synchronously, while the high-frequency modes are suppressed more. This means that shear suppresses the growth of linear instability and further influences the generation of the convection flow. Meanwhile, perturbations with higher azimuthal frequency modes are suppressed more, and the dominated mode becomes the low-frequency mode gradually, as an increasing shear is imposed. Figure 3(b) demonstrates this trend. The azimuthal wavenumber of the main mode (the mode owning maximum growth rate σ\sigma) nmainn_{main} decreases from 15 to 1 with the increasing shear. When the flow approaches the marginal state, nmainn_{main} drops to 1 and holds on. Figure 3(c) shows at the marginal state, how the critical azimuthal number ncn_c changes with the critical Rayleigh number RacRa_c. At no shear state, which is the left asymptote in Figure 2(a), nc=5n_c = 5, giving the mode of five roll pairs. As the Rayleigh number and the shear increase, ncn_c drops from 5 to 1, and holds on at high Rayleigh number (Rac≥106Ra_c \geq10^6). It’s worth noting that in Figure 2(a), the critical rotating difference Ωcr\Omega_{\mathrm{cr}} reaches a maximum near Ra=106Ra = 10^{6} as well, and then the Ωcr\Omega_{\mathrm{cr}} required to stabilize the flow decreases slightly with increasing RaRa. The slight decrease of Ωcr\Omega_{\mathrm{cr}} may be related to the fact that the critical azimuthal wavenumber reaches the minimum.

Figure 3. (a) Growth rate σ\sigma as a function of the azimuthal wavenumber nn for Ω=0,0.1,0.3,0.5\Omega= 0, 0.1, 0.3, 0.5 and 0.57.0.57., at Ra=107Ra = 10^{7}. The black dashed line denotes σ=0\sigma= 0. (b) The azimuthal wavenumber of the main mode nmainn_{\mathrm{main}} as a function of Ω\Omega, at Ra=107Ra = 10^{7}. (c) The critical azimuthal wavenumber ncn_{\mathrm{c}} as a function of the critical Rayleigh number RacRa_{\mathrm{c}} at the marginal state.

The temperature and the velocity eigenfunctions of certain modes normalized by the maximum temperature perturbations are illustrated in Figure 4. For n=1n = 1, there is only one hot-cold perturbation pair, while for n=5n = 5 there are five pairs. In all perturbation modes, the colder flow goes outward from the inner side with a clockwise azimuthal velocity, in the opposite direction of the basic flow. When the system is under low shear, as shown in Figure 4(a), the azimuthal motion of the flow is strong at the junction of the cold and hot flow, while relatively weak at the center of cold and hot perturbations. Near the inner wall, two flows with opposing azimuthal velocity converge at the center region of cold temperature perturbations. As a result of the mass conservation, the flow undergoes an outward deflection, thereby transporting the strong cold temperature perturbations toward the outer wall. Similar structures exist extensively in the modes under various conditions, as illustrated in Figure 4(b-Figure 4d). Comparing Figure 4(b) to (a), as the shear becomes stronger, we notice that the cold and hot perturbations are more stretched azimuthally and are narrower radially, which is similar to the plumes in sheared RB convection (Goluskin et al. 2014; Blass et al. 2020). In Figure 4(b), a strong azimuthal velocity exists everywhere in the cold and hot flow, even in the center region of the cold flow, different from the low-shear case. The main motion of the flow is in the azimuthal direction, which has a negative effect on heat transfer and the work done by buoyancy. Under stronger shear, it seems more difficult to transport heat from one side to the other side. Both larger dissipation and less work done by buoyancy depress the growth of the instability.

Figure 4. Eigenfunctions (u′,θ′)(\boldsymbol{u}',\theta') of the unstable modes at corresponding conditions: (a) Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, Ω=0.1\Omega=0.1, n=1n=1, (b) Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, Ω=0.5\Omega=0.5, n=1n=1, (c) Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, Ω=0.5\Omega=0.5, n=5n=5, (d) Ra=108Ra=10^{8}, Ω=0.5\Omega=0.5, n=1n=1. The maximum temperature perturbation is set to be the same in all conditions, ∣θ′∣max=10−2|\theta'|_{max}=10^{-2}. The velocity perturbation vectors are scaled by the maximum velocity magnitude of each, as ∣u′∣max|\boldsymbol{u}'|_{max} equals to (a) 7.3×10−37.3\times10^{-3}, (b) 4.0×10−34.0\times10^{-3}, (c) 4.2×10−34.2\times10^{-3}, (d) 4.0×10−34.0\times10^{-3}.

Moreover, for the modes of high azimuthal frequency under strong shear, more pairs occupy the azimuthal length of 2π2\pi, an example of which is shown in Figure 4(c). The temperature perturbation pairs and flow roll pairs are denser, presenting a pattern that extends counterclockwise from the inside out. As can be expected, this mode has higher dissipation and more significant buoyancy work than the low azimuthal frequency mode n=1n = 1 in figure 4(b). In addition, we are interested in the instability case when moving to high Rayleigh numbers. A mode near the marginal state at Ra=108Ra=10^{8} is presented in Figure 4(d). Interestingly, the perturbations exhibit a pronounced concentration within an exceedingly narrow annulus, approximately located at the intermediate radius of the system. Inside and outside of this annulus, both temperature and velocity perturbations are weak. As RaRa escalates, the annulus progressively diminishes in width, tending to converge to a certain radius, which may be associated with the limit of Ωcr\Omega_{cr} for an infinitely-great Rayleigh number.

Energy analysis

In order to get a comprehensive explanation of the instability in Regime I, we perform the energy analysis on perturbations. Multiply the velocity perturbations ur′u'_r, uφ′u'_\varphi, uz′u'_z by the linearized momentum equations in their respective directions and take their summation, then the kinetic energy equation of perturbations is obtained (Yoshikawa et al. 2013, 2015; Meyer et al. 2015):

dKdt=WTa+WcB−Dν,(9)\frac{dK}{dt}=W_{Ta}+W_{cB}-D_{\nu}, \tag*{(9)}

where the kinetic energy KK, the power of inertial forces WTaW_{Ta}, the power of centrifugal buoyancy WcBW_{cB} and the dissipation Dν=⟨Φ⟩D_{\nu}=\langle\Phi\rangle are expressed as:

K=12⟨∣u′∣2⟩,WTa=⟨−ur′uφ′(dVdr−Vr)⟩,K=\frac{1}{2}\langle|\boldsymbol{u}'|^{2}\rangle,\quad W_{Ta}=\langle-u'_r u'_\varphi\left(\frac{dV}{dr}-\frac{V}{r}\right)\rangle,
WcB=⟨−2(1−η)rur′1+η[θ′(1+2VRo−1r)2+4Ωuφ′Ro−1r(1+2VRo−1r)]⟩,W_{cB}=\left\langle-\frac{2(1-\eta)r u'_r}{1+\eta}\left[\theta'\left(1+\frac{2V}{Ro^{-1}r}\right)^{2}+\frac{4\Omega u'_\varphi}{Ro^{-1}r}\left(1+\frac{2V}{Ro^{-1}r}\right)\right]\right\rangle,
Dν=PrRa{2[(∂ur′∂r)2+(1r∂ur′∂φ+uφ′r)2+(∂ur′∂z)2]+[r∂∂r(uφ′r)+1r∂ur′∂φ]2+[1r∂uz′∂φ+∂uφ′∂z]2+[∂ur′∂z+∂uz′∂r]2}.(10)D_{\nu}=\sqrt{\frac{Pr}{Ra}}\left\{2\left[\left(\frac{\partial u'_r}{\partial r}\right)^{2}+\left(\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial u'_r}{\partial\varphi}+\frac{u'_\varphi}{r}\right)^{2}+\left(\frac{\partial u'_r}{\partial z}\right)^{2}\right]+\left[r\frac{\partial}{\partial r}\left(\frac{u'_\varphi}{r}\right)+\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial u'_r}{\partial\varphi}\right]^{2}+\left[\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial u'_z}{\partial\varphi}+\frac{\partial u'_\varphi}{\partial z}\right]^{2}+\left[\frac{\partial u'_r}{\partial z}+\frac{\partial u'_z}{\partial r}\right]^{2}\right\}. \tag*{(10)}

The angle brackets ⟨⋅⟩\langle\cdot\rangle denote the average over the whole space rr, φ\varphi, and zz. A mode is stable if the right-hand side of the equation (9) is negative. The kinetic energy generation terms WTaW_{Ta}, WcBW_{cB}, DνD_{\nu} normalized by the kinetic energy KK are illustrated in Figure 5 as functions of Ω\Omega at Ra=106Ra=10^{6} and 10810^{8}. As all terms are normalized by the averaged kinetic energy KK, the left side of the equation (9) dK/dtdK/dt is twice the growth rate, derived from equation (6).

Figure 5. Variation of energy generation terms −WTa-W_{Ta}, DνD_{\nu}, WcBW_{cB} and the growth rate of kinetic energy dKdt\frac{dK}{dt} with Ω\Omega, at conditions (a) Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, n=1n=1, (b) Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, n=5n=5, (c) Ra=108Ra=10^{8}, n=1n=1. All terms are normalized by KK. The modes in the light orange region (left side) are unstable, while in the nattier blue region (right side) are stable.

As shown in Figure 5(a), Ra=106Ra=10^{6} and n=1n=1, with Ω\Omega increasing, the power of centrifugal buoyancy WcBW_{cB} decreases and the dissipation term DνD_{\nu} increases slightly, in line with our analysis of the modes in Figure 4. The largest change is in the inertial force action term, WTaW_{Ta}, which is zero under no shear but its magnitude increases rapidly as Ω\Omega increases. According to the formula of WTaW_{Ta} in equations (10), this term is closely related to the shear action. When the system reaches the marginal state, three energy generation terms exhibit equilibrium. The presence of WTaW_{Ta} constitutes the primary differentiating factor between the flow instability with shear and the flow instability without shear.

The energy analysis method can also explain the reasons behind the greater suppression of high azimuthal frequency modes in comparison to low-frequency modes to a certain degree. Figure 5(b) shows the variation of energy generation terms under Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, n=5n=5. At Ω=0\Omega=0, the centrifugal buoyancy term WcBW_{cB} is much larger than dissipation, injecting a lot of energy into the development of the instability. However, with shear imposed, both −WTa-W_{Ta} and DνD_{\nu} rise quickly, while the buoyancy term WcBW_{cB} drops faster than in the low-frequency mode n=1n=1. This reflects the strong suppression of the high-frequency modes by shear. Unlike the low-frequency mode in Figure 5(a), the dissipation term DνD_{\nu} plays a more important role, increasing significantly with shear, which is closely related to the tight distribution of velocity perturbations rolls. Therefore, although the high-frequency mode offers a high growth rate at no shear, it reaches the marginal state earlier as the shear increases.

At high RaRa, the dissipation term decreases at first with increasing shear, as illustrated in Figure 5(c). The buoyancy terms drop more than the mode at Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, as the perturbations are concentrated in a narrow annulus and the azimuthal motion occupies more kinetic energy. Meanwhile, we notice that at the marginal state, it is still a balance of three items WTaW_{Ta}, WcBW_{cB}, DνD_{\nu}, which can be further observed at higher Ra=1013Ra=10^{13}. Therefore, the limit of instability as the Rayleigh number tends to infinity can not be explained by an inviscid solution, since the dissipation term DνD_{\nu} is not negligible.

Moreover, at Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, the distribution of energy generation terms, wTaw_{Ta}, wcBw_{cB}, Φ\Phi are compared under different shear strengths with the azimuthal wavenumber n=1n=1, as shown in Figure 6. The densities of energy generation terms are also normalized by KK. By comparing Figure 6(b) and Figure 6(f), one can find that the power of inertial term wTaw_{Ta} increases substantially with the enhancement of shear. (Note: the scales of the color bars in these two figures are different.) Negative wTaw_{Ta} is derived from the rightward deflection of outward or inward flow (ur′uφ′<0u'_r u'_{\varphi}<0); while the positive part mainly comes from the limit of mass conservation near the boundary and occurs at the junction of cold and hot currents. As for the buoyancy power wcBw_{cB}, the increase of shear amplifies its maximum intensity while making it more concentrated in distribution, as the cold and hot perturbations are more stretched azimuthally. Dissipation term Φ\Phi mainly occurs near the boundary and the regions with opposing flows of cold and hot currents, where a strong velocity gradient exists. As shear increases, Φ\Phi increases significantly at the region where two flows meet, contributing to a final increase of DνD_{\nu}. These qualitative interpretations are in relatively good agreement with the curves in Figure 5(a).

Figure 6. Distribution of perturbations (a,e)(a,e) (u′,θ′\mathbf{u}',\theta') and the densities of energy generation terms (b,f)(b,f) wTaw_{T a}, (c,g)(c,g) wcBw_{c B} and (d,h)(d,h) Φ\Phi under different shear (a−d)(a-d) Ω=0.1\Omega=0.1, (e−f)(e-f) Ω=0.5\Omega=0.5 when Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, n=1n=1. All the densities of energy generation terms are normalized by the averaged kinetic energy KK. Note that the scales of wTaw_{T a} in (b) and (f) are different.

Heat and momentum transfer

In this subsection, we focus on both heat and momentum transport efficiency and discuss their behaviors in different regimes. Under the dimensionless formulation, the heat transfer efficiency and the momentum transfer efficiency are measured by two Nusselt numbers: NuhNu_h and NuωNu_{\omega}, defined as the ratios of the corresponding currents of the system to the currents in the laminar and nonvortical flow case [14] (Wang et al. 2022a):

Nuh=RaPr⟨urθ⟩t,φ,z−∂r⟨θ⟩t,φ,z(rln⁡(η))−1,Nu_h=\frac{\sqrt{RaPr}\langle u_r\theta\rangle_{t,\varphi,z}-\partial_r\langle\theta\rangle_{t,\varphi,z}}{(r\ln(\eta))^{-1}},
Nuω=r3[Ra/Pr⟨urω⟩t,φ,z−Ra/Pr∂r⟨ω⟩t,φ,z]2B(11)Nu_{\omega}=\frac{r^3\left[\sqrt{Ra/Pr}\langle u_r\omega\rangle_{t,\varphi,z}-\sqrt{Ra/Pr}\partial_r\langle\omega\rangle_{t,\varphi,z}\right]}{2B} \tag*{(11)}

where ω=uφ/r\omega=u_{\varphi}/r is the angular velocity of the fluid, and BB is the parameter of the base flow defined in equations (5). The variation of the two Nusselt numbers with the shear strength Ω\Omega under different Rayleigh numbers are illustrated in Figure 7. The different regimes in the figure are distinguished using different background colors. As the Taylor number is much larger than RaRa in Regime III (Ta=2.65×109Ta=2.65\times10^{9} at Ra=107Ra=10^{7}, Ω=10\Omega=10, calculated from the equation (3)), the flow is too drastic and computationally expensive, so we only calculate the cases of Ra=106Ra=10^{6} in the TC-dominated regime.

Figure 7. Variation of (a) NuhNu_h and (b) NuωNu_\omega with Ω\Omega, at Ra=106Ra=10^6, 10710^7 and 10810^8.

In Regime I, as the imposed shear increases, NuhNu_h decreases slowly at first and then rapidly when Ω>0.3\Omega> 0.3. The curves of different RaRa behave in a similar trend. The heat transfer efficiency NuhNu_h increases with RaRa in Regime I, but as the shear increases and flow turn stable, NuhNu_h under different RaRa all drop to 1. These results are similar to the results in the sheared rectangular RB cell [6], where the heat transfer is also first depressed by shear. However, in sheared rectangular RB cell, shear can not turn the flow laminar. While for momentum transfer, we notice that the system gives a negative NuωNu_\omega under a weak shear, which means the large-scale circulation (LSC) in the RB convection pushes the two cylinders to rotate relative to each other. According to the definition of NuωNu_\omega, when there is no relative rotation between two cylinders, LSC also imposes shear stress to the wall, and NuωNu_\omega is negative infinity. NuωNu_\omega increases quickly as Ω\Omega increases, and the growth trend slows down when its value is close to 1. Similar to the heat transfer, a larger RaRa gives a stronger torque.

In Regime II, the flow field is laminar, described by equations (5). Both NuhNu_h and NuωNu_\omega equal to 1. As Ω\Omega increases, the system reaches the marginal state between Regime II and III. If the buoyancy is not considered, at high TaTa, the marginal-state curve of Taylor instability is close to the solution given by Rayleigh inviscid theory [13], which gives Ω=6\Omega= 6. Considering the buoyancy, the instability is strengthened and the flow at Ω=6\Omega= 6 gives a heat transfer efficiency close to NuhNu_h under weak shear. Meanwhile, NuωNu_\omega remains almost unchanged, which means the flow driven by buoyancy is hard to mix the angular velocity profile. As the shear strength continues to increase, the heat transfer is enhanced more, and the momentum transfer increases gradually as well. It is suggested that this regime appears in a similar system with gravity-driven buoyancy, where the system is mainly controlled by the Taylor vortex and temperature acts as a passive scalar (Leng et al. 2021). To check if this idea is also valid in our system, we perform another set of simulations under the same conditions, where the velocity is decoupled from temperature (buoyancy not considered) and the temperature really acts as a passive scalar. The comparison of the two is displayed in Figure 8(a). As there is no buoyancy, the system is still stable at Ω=6\Omega= 6, but then it behaves almost the same as the velocity-temperature-coupled system, at Ω=6.5\Omega= 6.5 in the figure. Therefore, in most of Regime III, the temperature can be regarded as a passive scalar in our system; it is the shear that dominates the flow.

Figure 8. (a) Variation of NuhNu_h with Ω\Omega in Regime III, for the cases that the temperature and velocity are coupled (the purple line) and uncoupled (the red line). Ra=106Ra = 10^6. (b) Variation of ∣γ∣|\gamma| with Ω\Omega at Ra=106Ra = 10^6, 10710^7, 10810^8. γ<0\gamma< 0 in Regime I and γ>0\gamma> 0 in Regime III.

The exact relation gives us an interesting perspective to understand the relation between NuhNu_h and NuωNu_\omega. Derived by the kinetic energy balance equation, the exact relation represents the energy balance between buoyant energy injection, shear energy injection, and mechanical dissipation. In the dimensional form, referring to derivation from Eckhardt, Grossmann, and Lohse [14] and Wang et al. (Wang et al. 2022b), if we assume

⟨αθ(Ωc+uφ/r)2rur⟩V,t=CαΩc2⟨rurθ⟩V,t\langle\alpha\theta(\Omega_c+u_\varphi/r)^2ru_r\rangle_{V,t}=C\alpha\Omega_c^2\langle ru_r\theta\rangle_{V,t}, the exact relation of our system is:

ε−εlam=ν3L−4[σr−2Ta(Nuω−1)+Cf(η)Pr−2Ra(Nuh−1)],(12)\varepsilon-\varepsilon_{\mathrm{lam}}=\nu^3L^{-4}\left[\sigma_r^{-2}Ta(Nu_\omega-1)+Cf(\eta)Pr^{-2}Ra(Nu_h-1)\right], \tag*{(12)}

where ε=ν⟨(∂iuj+∂jui)2⟩V,t\varepsilon=\nu\langle(\partial_i u_j+\partial_j u_i)^2\rangle_{V,t} is the mean energy dissipation rate, εlam\varepsilon_{\mathrm{lam}} is the mean energy dissipation rate of the laminar and nonvortical flow, σr=(1+η)4/16η2\sigma_r=(1+\eta)^4/16\eta^2 is the quasi-Prandtl number, and f(η)=2(η−1)/((1+η)ln⁡(η))f(\eta)=2(\eta-1)/((1+\eta)\ln(\eta)) is a correction factor. In Regime I, uφ/r≪Ωcu_\varphi/r\ll\Omega_c, then C≈1C\approx1. In Regime III, the flow is dominated by shear; therefore, referring to the angular velocity profile of the TC flow (Grossmann et al. [21]), CC is still at the order O(1)O(1).

The terms on the right of the equation (12) represent the energy injection by the wall shear and the buoyancy, respectively. The TC flow considers the first term while the RB convection concentrates on the second. In Regime I, as the Nuh>1Nu_h>1 and Nuω<1Nu_\omega<1, only buoyancy provides energy for turbulent dissipation, while the wall motion consumes energy instead. In Regime III, buoyancy and shear provide energy to the fluid together. Moreover, considering the ratio of the two terms, we can verify the dominant regimes of the flow. The ratio γ\gamma can be simplified by take η=0.5\eta=0.5, Pr=4.3Pr=4.3 and C≈1C\approx1:

γ=σr−2Ta(Nuω−1)Cf(η)Pr−2Ra(Nuh−1)≈31.79Ω2Nuω−1Nuh−1,(13)\gamma=\frac{\sigma_r^{-2}Ta(Nu_\omega-1)}{Cf(\eta)Pr^{-2}Ra(Nu_h-1)}\approx31.79\Omega^2\frac{Nu_\omega-1}{Nu_h-1}, \tag*{(13)}

where Ta/RaTa/Ra is simplified using the equation (3). How γ\gamma varies with Ω\Omega is shown in Figure 8(b). In Regime I, γ<0\gamma<0; in Regime II, γ\gamma is not calculated as both terms are zero; in Regime III, γ>0\gamma>0. When the system is under weak shear, such as Ω=10−2\Omega=10^{-2}, a very small fraction of the energy is consumed by shearing. As Ω\Omega increases, more energy is transferred out of the system by the wall motion, as ∣γ∣|\gamma| grows approximately linearly with Ω\Omega in logarithmic coordinates. At the point near Regime II, Ω=0.5\Omega=0.5, about half of the energy injected by buoyancy is consumed by the wall shear. Such a large percentage of energy consumption may be responsible for bringing the system to a stable state. Crossing Regime II into Regime III, γ≫1\gamma\gg1, the energy input by the wall shear is much more than the energy injection of the buoyancy. As Ω\Omega increases, the dominance of shear is reinforced. Additionally, the data of the buoyancy-dominated part in Regime III (Ω=6\Omega=6) is not given in Figure 8(b), because the accuracy of γ\gamma is difficult to guarantee as NuωNu_\omega is very close to 1. The factor in front of the ratio of the Nusselt numbers, 31.79Ω231.79\Omega^2, is large, therefore the buoyancy-driven flow (∣γ∣<1|\gamma|<1) is hard to influence NuωNu_\omega. From an alternative perspective, this can be attributed to the fact that the energy difference induced by angular velocity difference is much larger than the energy difference induced by density difference since the density variation is limited as αΔ≪1\alpha\Delta\ll1.

Flow structures

To further investigate the dynamics behind the behaviors of heat and momentum transfer, we focus on the evolution of the flow structures. As the flow is stable in Regime II, the typical two-dimensional slice of temperature and angular velocity fields for Regimes I and III are visualized in Figure 9 and Figure 11, respectively. Next, we will explore and analyze the flow structures of the systems in Regimes I and III sequentially, to figure out how heat transfer is inhibited and facilitated, and how the system is stabilized.

Figure 9. Typical snapshots of the instantaneous temperature θ\theta (the first row) and angular velocity ω=uφ/r\omega=u_{\varphi}/r (the second row), at Ω=0\Omega=0, 0.10.1, 0.30.3, 0.50.5 in Regime I. Ra=106Ra=10^{6}.

Figure 11. Typical snapshots of the instantaneous temperature θ\theta (the first row) and angular velocity ω=uφ/r\omega= u_\varphi/r (the second row), at Ω=6,7,8.5,10\Omega= 6, 7, 8.5, 10 in Regime III. Ra=106Ra = 10^{6}. The corresponding Taylor numbers are Ta=9.54×107,1.30×108,1.91×108,2.65×108Ta = 9.54 \times10^{7}, 1.30 \times10^{8}, 1.91 \times10^{8}, 2.65 \times10^{8}, respectively.

Regime I

In Regime I, the flow is quasi-two-dimensional under a large inversed Rossby number, Ro−1=20Ro^{-1}=20. Therefore, two-dimensional slices on the rφr\varphi plane are taken for the temperature and angular velocity fields under different Ω\Omega at Ra=106Ra=10^{6}, and the visualizations are displayed in Figure 9. Without shear, four pairs of convection rolls are formed, which can be clearly observed in the temperature and angular velocity snapshots. Due to the effect of Coriolis force, hot plumes detached from the outer cylinder turn right when rising, therefore one roll pair consists of a bigger roll on the right of the hot plume and a smaller roll on the left. This effect also results in the zonal flow in annular centrifugal RB convection, which is explained well by Jiang et al. (Jiang et al. 2020) and Wang et al. (Wang et al. 2022a). The flow structure of the system is stable and the heat is continuously transferred through the plume with the LSC. Meanwhile, due to the asymmetry of the two rolls, the bigger roll takes more area and has a larger impact on the boundaries than the other roll, which pushes the inner cylinder to rotate anticlockwise and the outer cylinder to rotate clockwise. Hence, once the boundary is rotating slowly, a negative NuωNu_{\omega} is generated.

It is conceivable that the flow structure shifts continuously with shear enhancement. As Ω\Omega increases to 0.1, there is a notable alteration in the flow structure, whereby the quantity of convection roll pairs exhibits a decline. Only two pairs can be observed, and each pair consists of a large roll covering nearly half of the annulus and a quite small roll. These can be seen especially clearly in the angular velocity field. It can be speculated that the shear of two boundaries stretches the plumes and promotes the azimuthal motion of the plume in the shear direction. The stretched plumes under shear are also observed in sheared RB convection [19, 6]. The flow motion induced by shear is in the same direction as the motion induced by the Coriolis force, including that hot plumes turn anticlockwise near the inner cylinder and the cold plumes turn clockwise near the outer cylinder; hence, the imposed shear increases the size of the large roll further. Meanwhile, the other roll becomes smaller. The number of roll pairs decreases as the system is not large enough to accommodate four roll pairs. Moreover, at this stage, the angular velocity of the fluid is still larger than the rotational speed of the boundary, and stronger than the angular velocity of the fluid without shear as well. This means, on the one hand, the azimuthal motion of the fluid is strengthened by shear; on the other hand, the shear is not strong enough and the azimuthal movement of the fluid driven by heat is still maintained. In the small rolls, the flow against the direction of boundary motion remains strong. Due to that the basic convection structures, the LSC and plumes, are maintained, and the heat transfer is reduced by only a small fraction, about 6% compared to the heat transfer at Ω=0\Omega=0.

As Ω\Omega continues to increase to 0.3, one big roll covering near 3π/23\pi/2 is generated. In this case, the number of convection roll pairs is hard to define, as the roll against the direction of boundary motion nearly disappears. Actually, though we can see two strong cold plumes in the temperature field, there is no fluid rotating anticlockwise near the outer cylinder; while near the inner cylinder, only two small pieces of fluid rotate clockwise, against the direction of boundary motion. For all the fluid in the system, ∣ω∣≤Ω|\omega|\leq\Omega, fluid can not rotate faster than the boundary wall and the NuωNu_{\omega} turns positive but is still smaller than 1. The rotating velocity of the boundaries exceeds the azimuthal velocity of the fluid induced by LSC. At this stage, the convection roll pairs are not maintained, while plumes remain working, transporting heat from one side to the other. Therefore, the heat transfer drops not too much but noticeably, reducing about 28% compared to the heat transfer at Ω=0\Omega=0.

As Ω\Omega continues to increase to 0.5, near the marginal state, the flow is close to the laminar and nonvortical flow, and the plumes disappear in the end. Some temperature fluctuations are observed in the temperature field, while the angular velocity fluctuations are hard to recognize. At this stage, the convection and heat transfer are highly suppressed. Plumes, as important carriers of heat transfer, are hard to exist. The Nusselt number NuhNu_h drops significantly, about 83% compared to the NuhNu_h at Ω=0\Omega=0.

The averaged temperature and angular velocity profiles under different Ω\Omega are shown in Figure 10. A uniform bulk temperature θc\theta_c is observed for Ω≤0.3\Omega\leq0.3, which deviates from the arithmetic mean temperature of two boundaries θm=0.5\theta_m=0.5. The asymmetry temperature profiles without shear can be explained by the radially dependent gravity effects and the bulk temperature θc\theta_c depends on the radius ratio η\eta, which are discussed by Wang et al. (Wang et al. 2022a). The bulk temperature remains unchanged until Ω\Omega exceeds 0.3. As the shear increases, the uniform bulk temperature vanishes and the temperature profile gradually evolves toward a laminar and nonvortical flow profile (the dashed line). For the angular velocity profile, a stage similar to the bulk temperature is not found. At Ω=0\Omega=0, the averaged angular velocity is small as the asymmetry of the flow structure is not strong; as the shear is imposed, the averaged angular velocity varies from Ω\Omega at the inner cylinder to −Ω-\Omega at the outer cylinder. It should be noted that when the shear is not strong (such as Ω=0.1\Omega=0.1), the two extremums of the profile occur inside the cell rather than on the boundaries. While for Ω≥0.3\Omega\geq0.3, the extremums of the profile move to boundaries. As Ω\Omega increases, the angular velocity profile gradually evolves towards a laminar flow profile as well. At Ω=0.5\Omega=0.5, it coincides almost exactly with the laminar and nonvortical flow profile, while the temperature profile still differs. Thus, we can see that as shear is enhanced, the changes in the angular velocity profile are not synchronized with the changes in the temperature profile; the former tends to occur earlier, either for the transition at Ω=0.3\Omega= 0.3 or at Ω=0.5\Omega= 0.5.

Figure 10. Radial distribution of azimuthally, axially and time-averaged (a) temperature ⟨θ⟩t,φ,z\langle\theta\rangle_{t,\varphi,z} and (b) angular velocity ⟨ω⟩t,φ,z\langle\omega\rangle_{t,\varphi,z} profiles for different Ω\Omega in Regime I. Ra=106Ra = 10^{6}. The dashed lines mean the profiles of the laminar and nonvortical flow.

Regime III

In Regime III, though the flow is three-dimensional, the main structure is on the rzr z plane (Grossmann et al. [21]). Therefore, two-dimensional slices are taken for the temperature and angular velocity fields, illustrated in Figure 11. At Ω=6\Omega= 6, of which the inviscid TC system without buoyancy is at the marginal state, the flow shows a classical RB temperature field with a typical LSC. However, the angular velocity distribution is still almost laminar and nonvortical though convection occurs. As explained in subsection 3.3, the convection driven by heat is hard to transfer angular momentum at large Ω\Omega. With Ω\Omega increasing, the flow becomes more turbulent, with the angular velocity field better mixed and the plumes get thinner, meaning the transport efficiency is enhanced. At this stage, because the temperature acts as a passive scalar, the temperature fields and the angular velocity fields are highly relevant, which can be roughly seen by the highly similar plume morphology.

The averaged temperature and angular velocity profiles of Regime III are shown in Figure 12. A uniform bulk temperature is observed for all the cases, both the buoyancy-dominant case (Ω=6\Omega= 6) and the shear-dominated cases. Interestingly, this temperature does not change with Ω\Omega, but is different from the arithmetic mean temperature θm=0.5\theta_m = 0.5 and the bulk temperature in Regime I. As Ω\Omega increases, the profile becomes sharper at two boundaries, which also implies an improved efficiency of heat transfer. The angular velocity profile is in line with the laminar and nonvortical profile at Ω=6\Omega= 6, and then transits to a turbulent profile as the Taylor number is increasing. At Ω=10\Omega= 10, the outer cylinder is at rest, and the Taylor number Ta=2.65×108Ta = 2.65 \times10^{8}, therefore the system is still in the classical regime of the TC flow ([21] (Ostilla-Mónico et al. 2014b)); the shear-dominated flow in the Regime III behaves similar to the TC flow.

Figure 12. Radial distribution of azimuthally, axially and time-averaged (a) temperature ⟨θ⟩t,φ,z\langle\theta\rangle_{t,\varphi,z} and (b) normalized angular velocity ⟨ω⟩t,φ,z/Ω\langle\omega\rangle_{t,\varphi,z}/\Omega profiles for different Ω\Omega in Regime III. Ra=106Ra = 10^{6}. The dashed lines mean the profiles of the laminar and nonvortical flow.

Conclusion

In the present study, we investigate the evolution of the flow regimes in an annular centrifugal Rayleigh-Bénard system with increasing imposed shear, which is represented by the angular velocity difference between the inner and outer cylinders, Ω\Omega. At first, Ri≪1Ri \ll1 under weak shear, the flow is buoyancy-dominated and manifests itself as quasi-two-dimensional convection on the rφr\varphi plane. As Ω\Omega increases, the convection and heat transfer are depressed, and the flow finally turns to stable laminar and nonvortical flow. Through linear instability analysis, we notice that the marginal state depends on both RaRa and Ω\Omega, formed by the energy balance among viscous dissipation, the work of buoyancy, and the work of inertial terms. At low Ra∼103Ra \sim10^{3}, the marginal state mainly depends on RaRa and only a weak shear is required to stabilize the flow. At high Ra≥106Ra \ge10^{6}, the marginal state seems insensitive to RaRa, locating at Ri=Ω−2∼O(1)Ri = \Omega^{-2} \sim O(1). In the parameter region Ra∈[106,108]Ra \in[10^{6}, 10^{8}], as shear increases, the growth rate of the instability is suppressed and the low azimuthal frequency modes become the main mode. Similarly, the heat transfer efficiency NuhNu_h is also depressed gradually, and the number of roll pairs decreases as the shear enhances the asymmetry between the two opposing rolls and enlarges the bigger one. The plumes are stretched by the shear, and the temperature perturbations are also stretched in LSA as well. The LSA and DNS give many comparable findings.

With the continued enhancement of shear, the flow becomes unstable again, but this time the flow is completely different from before. Initially, when the system has not crossed the marginal state derivated by Rayleigh’s inviscid theory for pure TC flow, the instability of the flow is driven by buoyancy, and the thermal convection occurs on the rzrz plane, similar to the classical RB convection. As Ω\Omega increases and the centrifugal instability takes over, the flow quickly becomes shear-dominated, with the temperature acting as a passive scalar. At this moment, the flow is similar to the TC flow, and still in the classical regime for our parameter sets.

On the whole, as the flow transits from an annular centrifugal RB convection to a radially heated TC flow of only the inner cylinder rotating, it passes through three regimes. Regime I is mainly buoyancy dominated, Regime II is the stable regime while Regime III is mainly shear dominated. There is an obvious dividing line between the three regimes, that is the marginal state of the instability. Furthermore, the energy analysis through the exact relation implies more information. In Regime I, the energy injected by buoyancy is consumed by both turbulent dissipation and wall shear. As the shear increases, more percentages of injected energy are taken by the wall motion, and near the marginal state, it takes about 50%. Therefore, shear plays an important role in Regime I as well, diverting buoyant injections of energy and inhibiting the convection. Meanwhile, on the other end of the stable regime, buoyancy drives the flow at first. Convection is observed in the temperature profile while the angular velocity profile is still close to the profile in the laminar and nonvortical case. When near the marginal state, both shear and buoyancy are important, and the exact relation (the equation (12)) is a good approach to analyzing the flow characteristics.

The traditional Rayleigh-Bénard system sheared by wall motion in a plane Couette flow is remarkably close to our system. Blass and Yerragolam have conducted a series of meaningful studies on this topic recently [6, 5 b] (Yerragolam et al. 2022a). As shear increases from 0, the flow regime moves from the buoyancy-dominated regime, through the transitional regime, and finally into the shear-dominated regime. A non-monotonic progression of NuNu is observed as well, with a minimum in the transitional regime, where Ri∼1Ri \sim1. These observations are consistent with ours, suggesting that the dominance of buoyancy or shear is a key factor in determining the flow state. Moreover, the coupling effects of buoyancy and shear on the heat transfer are also close between the two systems. However, due to the effect of curvature and rotation, the evolution of flow structures in the sheared ACRBC exhibits a lot of differences. The appearance of the stable regime is a very special finding. Meanwhile, because of the differences between the Taylor-Couette flow and the plane Couette flow, the flow in the shear-dominated regime is quite dissimilar. The similarities and differences between the sheared ACRBC and sheared RB are interesting points that deserve our future research.

The current system properly couples the TC flow with the RB convection through a couple of differential rotation centrifugal cylinders and is a feasible approach to analyze the coupling effect of shear and buoyancy. Limited by the parameters space, there are plenty of questions to be further explored. In the region of high Rayleigh number, how does shear affect the Nu∼RaγNu \sim Ra^\gamma scaling? Meanwhile, the effect of other parameters on the stable region, including Ro−1Ro^{-1} and PrPr, is also an interesting project. Moreover, some studies show that as the radius ratio η\eta increases and approaches 1, the convection in the annulus system behaves more and more similar to the convection between two planes (Pitz et al. 2017; Wang et al. 2022a). As we know, there is no stable regime for a sheared RB convection between two horizontal planes [6]. The disappearance of the stable regime is an attractive phenomenon that is deserved to be explored in the future.

Acknowledgements. We thank Detlef Lohse and Hechuan Jiang for the helpful discussions.

Funding. This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under grant no. 11988102, and the New Cornerstone Science Foundation through the XPLORER PRIZE

Declaration of interests. The authors report no conflict of interest.

Appendix A

Simulation parameters

No.RaRaΩ\OmegaTaTaNφ×Nz×NrN_{\varphi} \times N_z \times N_rΔg/ηK\Delta_g/\eta_KNuhNu_hϵNuh\epsilon_{Nu_h}NuωNu_\omegaϵNuω\epsilon_{Nu_\omega}Γ\Gammaϕ0\phi_0
11.0×1061.0 \times10^6001024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.297.300.30%——0.251
21.0×1061.0 \times10^60.012.65×1022.65 \times10^21024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.296.960.86%−7.222.83%0.251
31.0×1061.0 \times10^60.12.65×1042.65 \times10^41024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.286.850.99%−0.392.29%0.251
41.0×1061.0 \times10^60.21.06×1051.06 \times10^51024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.276.350.49%0.183.84%0.251
51.0×1061.0 \times10^60.32.38×1052.38 \times10^51024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.245.270.22%0.542.73%0.251
61.0×1061.0 \times10^60.353.25×1053.25 \times10^51024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.203.082.79%0.783.44%0.251
71.0×1061.0 \times10^60.44.24×1054.24 \times10^51024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.172.093.24%0.913.77%0.251
81.0×1061.0 \times10^60.56.62×1056.62 \times10^51024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.121.282.02%0.988.62%0.251
91.0×1071.0 \times10^7001024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.6213.290.36%——0.251
101.0×1071.0 \times10^7001536×32×1921536 \times32 \times1920.4113.280.54%——0.251
111.0×1071.0 \times10^70.012.65×1032.65 \times10^31024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.6212.810.10%−18.491.87%0.251
121.0×1071.0 \times10^70.012.65×1032.65 \times10^31536×32×1921536 \times32 \times1920.4112.730.30%−18.420.38%0.251
131.0×1071.0 \times10^70.12.65×1052.65 \times10^51024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.5912.420.57%−1.550.03%0.251
141.0×1071.0 \times10^70.21.06×1061.06 \times10^61024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.5812.201.55%−0.472.42%0.251
151.0×1071.0 \times10^70.32.38×1062.38 \times10^61024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.5410.331.01%0.351.37%0.251
161.0×1071.0 \times10^70.44.24×1064.24 \times10^61024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.477.511.09%0.503.15%0.251
171.0×1071.0 \times10^70.455.36×1065.36 \times10^61024×32×1281024 \times32 \times1280.343.120.74%0.840.86%0.251
181.0×1081.0 \times10^8002048×32×2562048 \times32 \times2560.6626.060.04%——0.1251
191.0×1081.0 \times10^8002560×32×2702560 \times32 \times2700.5826.121.02%——0.1251
201.0×1081.0 \times10^80.012.65×1042.65 \times10^42048×32×2562048 \times32 \times2560.6524.700.73%−25.074.40%0.1251
211.0×1081.0 \times10^80.12.65×1062.65 \times10^62048×32×2562048 \times32 \times2560.6425.110.04%−1.335.18%0.1251
221.0×1081.0 \times10^80.21.06×1071.06 \times10^72048×32×2562048 \times32 \times2560.6021.241.69%−0.634.03%0.1251
231.0×1081.0 \times10^80.32.38×1072.38 \times10^72048×32×2562048 \times32 \times2560.5717.750.63%0.145.09%0.1251
241.0×1081.0 \times10^80.44.24×1074.24 \times10^72048×32×2562048 \times32 \times2560.5717.351.69%0.566.19%0.1251
251.0×1081.0 \times10^80.56.62×1076.62 \times10^72048×32×2562048 \times32 \times2560.4210.110.71%0.404.47%0.1251
261.0×1061.0 \times10^669.54×1079.54 \times10^7384×256×256384 \times256 \times2560.196.502.10%1.0002/3π2/3\pi1/41/4
271.0×1061.0 \times10^66.51.12×1081.12 \times10^8384×256×256384 \times256 \times2560.8219.970.67%2.421.41%2/3π2/3\pi1/41/4
281.0×1061.0 \times10^671.30×1081.30 \times10^8384×256×256384 \times256 \times2561.0123.580.81%3.900.79%2/3π2/3\pi1/41/4
291.0×1061.0 \times10^671.30×1081.30 \times10^8768×256×256768 \times256 \times2561.0123.381.00%3.881.35%2/3π2/3\pi1/21/2
301.0×1061.0 \times10^68.51.91×1081.91 \times10^8432×324×324432 \times324 \times3241.3528.610.74%7.270.77%2/3π2/3\pi1/41/4
311.0×1061.0 \times10^6102.65×1082.65 \times10^8432×324×324432 \times324 \times3241.6131.631.75%9.981.25%2/3π2/3\pi1/41/4
321.0×1061.0 \times10^6102.65×1082.65 \times10^8432×324×432432 \times324 \times4321.2630.830.71%9.830.36%2/3π2/3\pi1/61/6

Table 1. Simulation parameters. The columns display the Rayleigh number RaRa, the non-dimensional rotational speed difference Ω\Omega, the Taylor number TaTa, the resolution employed, the maximum grid spacing Δg\Delta_g compared with the Kolmogorov scale estimated by the global criterion ηK=(ν3/ε)1/4\eta_K = (\nu^3/\varepsilon)^{1/4}, the calculated Nusselt numbers NuhNu_h, NuωNu_\omega and their relative difference of two halves ϵNu=∣(⟨Nu⟩T/2−⟨Nu⟩T/2−T)/(Nu−1)∣\epsilon_{Nu} = |(\langle Nu\rangle_{T/2} - \langle Nu\rangle_{T/2-T})/(Nu - 1)|, the aspect ratio Γ=H/L\Gamma= H/L, and the reduced azimuthal domain ϕ0\phi_0. ε\varepsilon is the mean energy dissipation rate calculated by the equation (12) of C≈1C \approx1. Note that the azimuthal resolution corresponds to the resolution of the sector segment. For example, Nφ=768N_\varphi= 768 for ϕ0=1/2\phi_0 = 1/2 means 768 points for one half of the annulus.

References

  1. [1]Ahlers, G., Brown, E., Araujo, F. F., Funfschilling, D., Grossmann, S. & Lohse, D. 2006 Non-oberbeck–Boussinesq effects in strongly turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection. J. Fluid Mech. 569, 409–445.
  2. [2]Ahlers, G., Grossmann, S. & Lohse, D. 2009 Heat transfer and large scale dynamics in turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection. Rev. Mod. Phys. 81 (2), 503–537.DOI
  3. [3]Ali, M. & Weidman, P. D. 1990 On the stability of circular Couette flow with radial heating. J. Fluid Mech. 220, 53–84.DOI
  4. [4]Bayly, B. J. 1988 Three-dimensional centrifugal-type instabilities in inviscid two-dimensional flows. Phys. Fluids 31 (1), 56–64.DOI
  5. [5]Blass, A., Tabak, P., Verzicco, R., Stevens, R. J. A. M. & Lohse, D. 2021 The effect of Prandtl number on turbulent sheared thermal convection. J. Fluid Mech. 910, A37.DOI
  6. [6]Blass, A., Zhu, X., Verzicco, R., Lohse, D. & Stevens, R. J. A. M. 2020 Flow organization and heat transfer in turbulent wall sheared thermal convection. J. Fluid Mech. 897, A22.DOI
  7. [7]Bradshaw, P. 1969 The analogy between streamline curvature and buoyancy in turbulent shear flow. J. Fluid Mech. 36 (1), 177–191.DOI
  8. [8]Brauckmann, H. J. & Eckhardt, B. 2013 Intermittent boundary layers and torque maxima in Taylor-Couette flow. Phys. Rev. E 87 (3), 033004.DOI
  9. [9]Busse, F. 2012 The Twins of Turbulence Research. Physics 5, 4.DOI
  10. [10]Castaing, B., Gunaratne, G., Heslot, F., Kadanoff, L., Libchaber, A., Thomae, S., Wu, X.-Z., Zaleski, S. & Zanetti, G. 1989 Scaling of hard thermal turbulence in Rayleigh-Bénard convection. J. Fluid Mech. 204 (-1), 1.DOI
  11. [11]Chillà, F. & Schumacher, J. 2012 New perspectives in turbulent Rayleigh-Bénard convection. Eur. Phys. J. E Soft Matter 35 (7), 58.DOI
  12. [13]Drazin, P. G. & Reid, W. H. 2004 Hydrodynamic Stability, 2nd edn. Cambridge University Press.
  13. [14]Eckhardt, B., Grossmann, S. & Lohse, D. 2007 Torque scaling in turbulent Taylor–Couette flow between independently rotating cylinders. J. Fluid Mech. 581, 221–250.DOI
  14. [15]Esser, A. & Grossmann, S. 1996 Analytic expression for Taylor–Couette stability boundary. Phys. Fluids 8 (7), 1814–1819.DOI
  15. [16]Feng, L., Liu, C., Köhl, A. & Wang, F. 2022 Seasonality of four types of baroclinic instability in the global oceans. J. Geophys. Res. Oceans 127 (5), e2022JC018572.DOI
  16. [17]Gastine, T., Wicht, J. & Aurnou, J. M. 2015 Turbulent Rayleigh–Bénard convection in spherical shells. J. Fluid Mech. 778, 721–764.DOI
  17. [18]van Gils, D. P. M., Huisman, S. G., Bruggert, G.-W., Sun, C. & Lohse, D. 2011 Torque Scaling in Turbulent Taylor-Couette Flow with Co- and Counterrotating Cylinders. Phys. Rev. Lett. 106 (2), 024502.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21405232
  18. [19]Goluskin, D., Johnston, H., Flierl, G. R. & Spiegel, E. A. 2014 Convectively driven shear and decreased heat flux. J. Fluid Mech. 759, 360–385.DOI
  19. [20]Grossmann, S. & Lohse, D. 2000 Scaling in thermal convection: a unifying theory. J. Fluid Mech. 407, 27–56.
  20. [21]Grossmann, S., Lohse, D. & Sun, C. 2016 High–Reynolds Number Taylor-Couette Turbulence. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 48 (1), 53–80.

Paper details

vlnc:W_7pvkr867
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents