betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The generalized entropy in holographic semiclassical de Sitter spacetime

Abstract

We consider generalized de Sitter entropy which includes both entanglement entropy of the strongly coupled quantum field and the gravitational Wald entropy in the framework of holographic semiclassical gravity. The quantum corrected de Sitter spacetime is constructed perturbatively by considering static deformations of the classical solution. By applying the Noether charge formula to our semiclassical model, we show that both the renormalized entropies remain finite without introducing a cutoff, even when the bulk AdS gravitational field does not satisfy the Dirichlet boundary condition. We show that the first order variation of the generalized entropy with respect to the de Sitter horizon always vanishes when the conformal boundary metric is promoted to a dynamical variable.

NU-QG-29

Introduction

The generalized entropy, which consists of the gravitational entropy associated with a horizon and the entanglement entropy between the inside and outside of the horizon, has attracted considerable attention in a variety of research areas. The generalized second law (GSL) of black holes states that the generalized entropy never decreases toward the future, even though the gravitational entropy itself can decrease during black hole evaporation. The non-decreasing property of the generalized entropy has recently become a key framework for quantum substitutes for classical energy conditions, giving rise to concepts such as the quantum null energy condition (QNEC) and the quantum focusing conjecture (QFC) [1]. The latter states that the quantum expansion, defined as the rate of change of the generalized entropy per unit area, is non-increasing along null directions. More recently, the classical Penrose singularity theorem [2] has been generalized by replacing the classical null energy condition with the GSL [3, 4, 5], so that it applies even to spacetimes in which the NEC is violated. In this context, the quantum extremal surface [6], defined as the surface that extremizes the generalized entropy along both the future and past null directions, is the quantum counterpart of a classical marginally trapped surface and is a key ingredient of the island formula [7] for reproducing the Page curve [8] of evaporating black holes (see, e.g., a recent review [9] for comprehensive discussions on concepts bridging classical gravity and quantum theory through the use of generalized entropy).

Although the calculation of entanglement entropy is generally a difficult task in curved spacetimes, it becomes tractable for strongly coupled quantum field theories with gravitational duals through the Ryu-Takayanagi formula [10] in the framework of the AdS/CFT duality [11]. In a static spacetime, the holographic entanglement entropy of a boundary region R\mathcal{R} is given by the area of the bulk minimal surface homologous to R\mathcal{R}. In particular, when the boundary of R\mathcal{R} coincides with a horizon on the AdS boundary, the corresponding minimal surface is the bulk horizon. In general, the area of the minimal surface diverges near the AdS boundary, reflecting the UV-divergence of the boundary field theory, and a cutoff is therefore required to obtain a finite entropy. However, when the conformal boundary metric is treated as non-dynamical, i.e., the boundary metric is fixed as in the standard AdS/CFT framework, the variation of the entanglement entropy is finite and satisfies the first law of entanglement entropy [13] (see also [14] for the curved boundary case). From the bulk perspective, this follows from the Dirichlet boundary condition imposed on the metric perturbation, under which the variation of the bulk horizon area remains finite and can be derived using the Noether charge formalism [15].

It is therefore natural to ask what happens when the boundary metric is promoted to a dynamical variable. As first proposed in Ref. [16], the dd-dimensional semiclassical Einstein equations (SCE) can be holographically encoded in mixed boundary conditions imposed at the conformal boundary of the (d+1)(d+1)-dimensional AdS spacetime [17]. At first sight, one might expect that the variation of the entanglement entropy also becomes divergent because the bulk metric perturbations exhibit UV-divergences near the AdS boundary. To address this question, in this paper we investigate the entanglement entropy of de Sitter spacetime coupled to a strongly interacting CFT through the holographic SCE. Entanglement entropy in de Sitter spacetime has attracted considerable attention in both quantum field theory and holographic approaches [18, 19]. In particular, understanding quantum entanglement across the cosmological horizon is expected to shed light on the microscopic interpretation of the Gibbons–Hawking entropy [20] and quantum aspects of de Sitter spacetime. Furthermore, recent developments have highlighted the generalized entropy as the natural quantity for incorporating quantum corrections to horizon entropy in semiclassical gravity [21]. These developments provide strong motivation for investigating the generalized entropy in semiclassical de Sitter spacetimes.

In this paper, we show that the renormalized entanglement entropy is finite without introducing a cutoff scale by applying the Noether charge formula [15] to the static perturbations of the bulk and the dynamical boundary metric. Furthermore, we prove that the first-order variation of the generalized de Sitter entropy vanishes for solutions of the semiclassical Einstein equations with higher-curvature corrections for d=3,4,5d = 3, 4, 5. The physical picture behind this result can be understood as follows. When the boundary spacetime is dynamical, the de Sitter horizon evolves, and hence the energy ECFTE_{\mathrm{CFT}} of the CFT enclosed by the de Sitter horizon can decrease through energy transfer across the horizon. Consequently, the gravitational (Wald) entropy SWaldS_{\mathrm{Wald}} [12] of the de Sitter horizon increases. For the temperature TT, the first law takes the form

TdSWald=−dECFT.(1)T dS_{\mathrm{Wald}} = -dE_{\mathrm{CFT}}. \tag*{(1)}

On the other hand, there exists a bulk horizon that terminates at the de Sitter horizon on the AdS boundary. Although the variation of the horizon area itself is divergent, the Noether charge combined with the counterterm action remains finite without introducing a cutoff scale. According to the Ryu–Takayanagi formula [10], this finite quantity gives the entanglement entropy SEES_{\mathrm{EE}} of the region enclosed by the de Sitter horizon. Applying the Noether charge formula [15], as in the case of a non-dynamical boundary metric [13], we obtain the first law of entanglement entropy,

TdSEE=dECFT.(2)T dS_{\mathrm{EE}} = dE_{\mathrm{CFT}}. \tag*{(2)}

Combining Eqs. (1) and (2), we find

d(SEE+SWald)=0.(3)d(S_{\mathrm{EE}} + S_{\mathrm{Wald}}) = 0. \tag*{(3)}

Although our derivation is based on static perturbations, we expect that the same relation holds for dynamical processes. Therefore, Eq. (3) can be regarded as a saturated form of the generalized second law, where the total generalized entropy remains unchanged.

The paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, we briefly review the holographic semiclassical model of de Sitter spacetime [22]. In Section 3, we show that the sum of the variations of the bulk charge associated with the entanglement entropy and the boundary gravitational charge associated with the Wald entropy vanishes, confirming Eq. (3). In Section 4, we calculate the static perturbations of de Sitter spacetime and show that each renormalized charge is finite and that Eq. (3) is indeed satisfied. Section 5 is devoted to a summary and discussion. In the appendix, we collect some relevant formulas.

The holographic semiclassical model of de Sitter spacetime

We begin with a brief review of a holographic model of dd-dimensional de Sitter spacetimes dynamically interacting with a strongly coupled quantum field via the the semiclassical Einstein equations with higher curvature corrections [22]. We write the d+1d+1-dimensional bulk metric as

dsd+12=GMNdXMdXN=dz2Ω2(z)+Gμν(x,z)dxμdxν=dz2+g~μν(x,z)dxμdxνΩ2(z),Ω(z)=ℓLsinh⁡(zℓ),(4)\begin{aligned} ds_{d+1}^{2}=G_{MN}dX^{M}dX^{N} \\ &=\frac{dz^{2}}{\Omega^{2}(z)}+\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}(x,z)dx^{\mu}dx^{\nu} \\ &=\frac{dz^{2}+\widetilde{g}_{\mu\nu}(x,z)dx^{\mu}dx^{\nu}}{\Omega^{2}(z)},\qquad\Omega(z)=\frac{\ell}{L}\sinh\left(\frac{z}{\ell}\right), \tag*{(4)} \end{aligned}

where LL and ℓ\ell are the bulk AdS and the boundary curvature radius, respectively. We define the conformal AdS boundary metric Gμν(x)\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}(x) by

Gμν(x)=lim⁡z→0g~μν(x,z).(5)\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}(x)=\lim_{z\to0}\widetilde{g}_{\mu\nu}(x,z). \tag*{(5)}

The conformal metric satisfies the semiclassical Einstein (SCE) equations with higher curvature corrections,

Eμν=8πGd⟨Tμν⟩,(6)\mathcal{E}_{\mu\nu}=8\pi G_{d}\langle T_{\mu\nu}\rangle, \tag*{(6)}
Eμν:=Rμν−R2Gμν+ΛdGμν+α1(μ)Hμν(1)+α2(μ)Hμν(2)+α3(μ)Hμν(3),(7)\mathcal{E}_{\mu\nu}:=\mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu}-\frac{\mathcal{R}}{2}\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}+\Lambda_{d}\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}+\alpha_{1}(\mu)\mathcal{H}_{\mu\nu}^{(1)}+\alpha_{2}(\mu)\mathcal{H}_{\mu\nu}^{(2)}+\alpha_{3}(\mu)\mathcal{H}_{\mu\nu}^{(3)}, \tag*{(7)}

where GdG_{d} is the dd-dimensional gravitational constant at the AdS boundary, z=0z=0, Rμν\mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu} and Hμν(i)\mathcal{H}_{\mu\nu}^{(i)} (i=1,2,3i=1,2,3) are the Ricci tensor and the higher curvature tensors respectively, constructed from the metric Gμν\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu} as defined below (2.5). In general, the coefficients αi(μ)\alpha_{i}(\mu) (i=1,2,3i=1,2,3) are parameters that depend on an arbitrary mass scale associated with the renormalization of the field theory. In what follows, we suppress the explicit μ\mu-dependence of these coefficients for notational simplicity. Finally, ⟨Tμν⟩\langle T_{\mu\nu}\rangle represents the vacuum expectation value of the stress-energy tensor of the strongly interacting quantum field with a gravitational dual.

As the boundary gravity action, we adopt the quadratic gravity model with the action

Sbdy=∫−GLbdy ddx=116πGd∫−G(R−2Λd+α1R2+α2RμνRμν+α3RμναβRμναβ)ddx,(8)\begin{aligned} S_{\mathrm{bdy}}=\int\sqrt{-\mathcal{G}}L_{\mathrm{bdy}}\,d^{d}x \\ &=\frac{1}{16\pi G_{d}}\int\sqrt{-\mathcal{G}}\left(\mathcal{R}-2\Lambda_{d}+\alpha_{1}\mathcal{R}^{2}+\alpha_{2}\mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu}\mathcal{R}^{\mu\nu}+\alpha_{3}\mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\mathcal{R}^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\right)d^{d}x, \tag*{(8)} \end{aligned}

where Rμναβ\mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta} is the Riemann tensor of the metric Gμν\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}, and Λd\Lambda_{d} is the (renormalized) cosmological constant. Hereafter, we suppress the volume element in integrals of scalar quantities, writing, for example, Sbdy=∫Σ0LbdyS_{\mathrm{bdy}}=\int_{\Sigma_{0}}L_{\mathrm{bdy}} in Eq. (8), where Σ0\Sigma_{0} is the dd-dimensional timelike hypersurface at z=0z=0. By varying the action (8) with respect to Gμν\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}, we have Hμν(i)\mathcal{H}_{\mu\nu}^{(i)} (i=1,2,3i=1,2,3) as

Hμν(1)=2(Rμν−DμDν)R−Gμν(12R2−2D2R),(9)\mathcal{H}_{\mu\nu}^{(1)}=2(\mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu}-\mathcal{D}_{\mu}\mathcal{D}_{\nu})\mathcal{R}-\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}\left(\frac{1}{2}\mathcal{R}^{2}-2\mathcal{D}^{2}\mathcal{R}\right), \tag*{(9)}
Hμν(2)=2RμρνσRρσ+D2Rμν−DμDνR−12Gμν(RσρRσρ−D2R),(10)\mathcal{H}_{\mu\nu}^{(2)}=2\mathcal{R}_{\mu\rho\nu\sigma}\mathcal{R}^{\rho\sigma}+\mathcal{D}^{2}\mathcal{R}_{\mu\nu}-\mathcal{D}_{\mu}\mathcal{D}_{\nu}\mathcal{R}-\frac{1}{2}\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}\left(\mathcal{R}_{\sigma\rho}\mathcal{R}^{\sigma\rho}-\mathcal{D}^{2}\mathcal{R}\right), \tag*{(10)}
Hμν(3)=2RμρστRν ρστ−Gμν2RρσαβRαβρσ+4RμρνσRρσ−4RμρRν ρ−2DμDνR+4D2Rμν,(11)\mathcal{H}^{(3)}_{\mu\nu}=2R_{\mu\rho\sigma\tau}R_{\nu}^{\ \rho\sigma\tau}-\frac{G_{\mu\nu}}{2}R_{\rho\sigma}^{\alpha\beta}R_{\alpha\beta}^{\rho\sigma}+4R_{\mu\rho\nu\sigma}R^{\rho\sigma}-4R_{\mu\rho}R_{\nu}^{\ \rho}-2D_{\mu}D_{\nu}R+4D^{2}R_{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(11)}

where DμD_{\mu} is the covariant derivative with respect to GμνG_{\mu\nu}.

According to the AdS/CFT duality [11], the vacuum expectation value of the stress-energy tensor ⟨Tμν⟩\langle T_{\mu\nu}\rangle is obtained by varying the renormalized on-shell bulk action given by

Γ=∫ML+∫ΣεK8πGd+1+∫ΣεLct,L=116πGd+1(R+d(d−1)L2),Lct:=−L16πGd+1(d−2)(2(d−1)(d−2)L2+R(g)+cdL2d−2{Rμν(g)Rμν(g)−dR2(g)4(d−1)}).(12)\begin{aligned} \Gamma&= \int_M L+\int_{\Sigma_\varepsilon}\frac{K}{8\pi G_{d+1}}+\int_{\Sigma_\varepsilon}L_{\mathrm{ct}},\\ L &= \frac{1}{16\pi G_{d+1}}\left(R+\frac{d(d-1)}{L^2}\right),\\ L_{\mathrm{ct}}&:=-\frac{L}{16\pi G_{d+1}(d-2)}\left(\frac{2(d-1)(d-2)}{L^2}+R(g)+\frac{c_dL^2}{d-2}\left\{R_{\mu\nu}(g)R^{\mu\nu}(g)-\frac{dR^2(g)}{4(d-1)}\right\}\right). \tag*{(12)} \end{aligned}

Here Σε\Sigma_\varepsilon denotes the timelike hypersurface at z=εz=\varepsilon, and the associated extrinsic curvature KμνK_{\mu\nu} is defined by

Kμν:=−12Ω∂zgμν,(13)K_{\mu\nu}:=-\frac{1}{2}\Omega\partial_zg_{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(13)}

and cdc_d is given by

cd={0d=3−ln⁡(μz)d=41d=5,(14)c_d=\begin{cases} 0 & d=3\\ -\ln(\mu z) & d=4\\ 1 & d=5 \end{cases}, \tag*{(14)}

where μ\mu is an arbitrary mass scale related to renormalization in the field theory.

As shown in Refs. [16, 17], by varying the total action Stotal=Γ+SbdyS_{\mathrm{total}}=\Gamma+S_{\mathrm{bdy}} with respect to the metric GMNG_{MN} and GμνG_{\mu\nu} simultaneously, we derive the semiclassical equations (2.3) and the vacuum Einstein equations, whose solutions are realized by allowing a mixed boundary condition on the AdS boundary, instead of the Dirichlet boundary condition. As shown in Ref. [22], the SCE Eqs. (2.3) are satisfied for the bulk spacetime (4) with the dd-dimensional de Sitter metric

Gˉμνdxμdxν(=Ω2gˉμνdxμdxν)=−f(u)udt2+ℓ24u2f(u)du2+ℓ2udΩd−22,(15)\bar{G}_{\mu\nu}dx^\mu dx^\nu\left(=\Omega^2\bar{g}_{\mu\nu}dx^\mu dx^\nu\right)=-\frac{f(u)}{u}dt^2+\frac{\ell^2}{4u^2f(u)}du^2+\frac{\ell^2}{u}d\Omega^2_{d-2}, \tag*{(15)}

where f(u)=u−1f(u)=u-1 for a suitable choice of the cosmological conatant, Λd\Lambda_d, and where dΩd−22d\Omega^2_{d-2} denotes the metric of the unit d−2d-2-dimensional sphere. This de Sitter metric in the static chart has the cosmological Killing horizon at u=1u=1 with (d−2)(d-2)-dimensional sphere as the bifurcate surface, which divides each de Sitter slice (Σε,Gˉμν)(\Sigma_\varepsilon,\bar{G}_{\mu\nu}) into two static wedges just like the Schwarzschild spacetime.

The AdS-bulk metric is now concretely written in terms of the above de Sitter metric as

ds(d+1)2=1Ω2(dz2+Gˉμνdxμdxν)=L2ℓ2sinh⁡2(z/ℓ)[dz2−f(u)udt2+ℓ24u2f(u)du2+ℓ2udΩd−22],(16)\begin{aligned} ds^2_{(d+1)}&=\frac{1}{\Omega^2}\left(dz^2+\bar{G}_{\mu\nu}dx^\mu dx^\nu\right)\\ &=\frac{L^2}{\ell^2\sinh^2(z/\ell)}\left[dz^2-\frac{f(u)}{u}dt^2+\frac{\ell^2}{4u^2f(u)}du^2+\frac{\ell^2}{u}d\Omega^2_{d-2}\right], \tag*{(16)} \end{aligned}

whose geometry is illustrated in Figure 1, with the bulk spherical Rindler horizon located at z=∞z = \infty and the SCE satisfied for the conformal metric Gμν\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu} at AdS boundary (at z=0z = 0). In terms of this coordinate system, we introduce several geometric quantities (see Figure 2). First, let Sε(d−1)S_{\varepsilon}^{(d-1)} be the (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional spacelike surface on Σε\Sigma_{\varepsilon}, specified by t=0t = 0 and 1<u<∞1 < u < \infty in one of the static wedges (say, the left wedge) of de Sitter slice (Σε,Gμν)(\Sigma_{\varepsilon},\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}), so that it is topologically Sε(d−1)≃Sd−2×RS_{\varepsilon}^{(d-1)} \simeq S^{d-2} \times\mathbb{R} and its boundary ∂Sε(d−1)\partial S_{\varepsilon}^{(d-1)} corresponds to the bifurcate surface of the de Sitter horizon on Σε\Sigma_{\varepsilon}. Next, let σ(d−1)\sigma^{(d-1)} be the (d−1)(d-1)-dimensional spacelike surface in the bulk, specified by t=0t = 0, u=1u = 1, and ε<z<∞\varepsilon< z < \infty so that its boundary at z=εz = \varepsilon coincides with the bifurcate surface of the de Sitter horizon on Σε\Sigma_{\varepsilon}, hence expressing the “bifurcate surface string” with topology σ(d−1)≃Sd−2×R\sigma^{(d-1)} \simeq S^{d-2} \times\mathbb{R}. Finally, let S(d)S^{(d)} be the dd-dimensional spacelike submanifold in the bulk, specified by t=0t = 0, 1<u<∞1 < u < \infty, and ε<z<∞\varepsilon< z < \infty, so that it is bounded by Sε(d−1)S_{\varepsilon}^{(d-1)} and σ(d−1)\sigma^{(d-1)} (with taking the limit ε↦0\varepsilon\mapsto0) and the vertex (t=0t = 0 and z→∞z \to\infty) of the bulk spherical Rindler horizon.

Figure 1. AdS bulk spacetime foliated by de Sitter slices. z=∞z = \infty corresponds to the spherical Rindler horizon, whose inside is expressed as the hyperbolic FLRW chart of AdS spacetime.

Figure 2. The surface S(d)S^{(d)} defined as a part of t=0t=0 hypersurface and its boundaries Sε(d−1)S_{\varepsilon}^{(d-1)}, σ(d−1)\sigma^{(d-1)} and Σε\Sigma_{\varepsilon}. The vectors nMn^M and mMm^M are introduced later.

The first law of generalized entropy

Let us consider static perturbations of the AdS bulk spacetime (4) with the background de Sitter spacetime (15) on the conformal AdS boundary. We assume that the perturbed metric takes the form

gμν(x,z)=G‾μν(x)+ϵhμν(x,z)Ω2(z)(17)g_{\mu\nu}(x,z)=\frac{\overline{G}_{\mu\nu}(x)+\epsilon h_{\mu\nu}(x,z)}{\Omega^2(z)} \tag*{(17)}

and impose the transverse-traceless conditions

hμμ=D‾νhμν=0,(18)h^\mu{}_\mu=\overline{D}^{\nu}h_{\mu\nu}=0, \tag*{(18)}

where D‾ν\overline{D}^{\nu} is the covariant derivative with respect to the background conformal boundary metric G‾μν(x)\overline{G}_{\mu\nu}(x). As shown below, we derive Eq. (3) with respect to the generalized entropy by applying the Noether charge formula [15] to both the bulk and the dynamical boundary spacetimes. In what follows, boldface letters denote differential forms with their indices indicating the corresponding components. Accordingly, the Lagrangian LL in an nn-dimensional spacetime can be expressed as an nn-form, L=Lϵa1a2⋯anL=L\epsilon_{a_1a_2\cdots a_n}, where ϵa1a2⋯an\epsilon_{a_1a_2\cdots a_n} denotes the Levi-Civita volume form. As we already used in the previous section, throughout this paper, we use the indices MM, NN, ⋯\cdots to denote bulk spacetime coordinates, while the indices μ\mu, ν\nu, …\ldots to denote coordinates on the (conformal) boundary spacetime or on a constant-zz hypersurface, as appropriate. When there is no risk of confusion, we often omit the indices. In such cases, however, we explicitly indicate the degree of the differential form. For instance, the dd-dimensional Levi-Civita volume form ϵμ1μ2⋯μd\epsilon_{\mu_1\mu_2\cdots\mu_d} is simply written as ϵ(d)\epsilon^{(d)}. Also in the following, the tilde indicates that the corresponding quantity is defined with respect to the conformal metric Gμν\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu} (5). In particular, ϵ(d)\epsilon^{(d)} and ϵ~(d)\widetilde{\epsilon}^{(d)} denote the dd-dimensional Levi-Civita volume forms associated with gμνg_{\mu\nu} and Gμν=lim⁡z→0Ω2gμν\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}=\lim_{z\to0}\Omega^2g_{\mu\nu}, respectively.

The variation of the Lagrangian LL, LctL_{\mathrm{ct}} in (12), and L~bdy\widetilde{L}_{\mathrm{bdy}} in (8) can be expressed in the form

δL=(E)MNδGMN+dΘ(d),δLct=(Ect)μνδgμν+dΘct(d−1),δL~bdy=(E~bdy)μνδGμν+dΘ~bdy(d−1),(19)\begin{aligned} \delta L &= (E)^{MN}\delta G_{MN}+d\Theta^{(d)},\\ \delta L_{\mathrm{ct}} &= (E_{\mathrm{ct}})^{\mu\nu}\delta g_{\mu\nu}+d\Theta_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)},\\ \delta\widetilde{L}_{\mathrm{bdy}} &= (\widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{bdy}})^{\mu\nu}\delta\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}+d\widetilde{\Theta}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)}, \tag*{(19)} \end{aligned}

where (E)MN:=ϵ(d+1)EMN(E)^{MN}:=\epsilon^{(d+1)}E^{MN}, (Ect)μν:=ϵ(d)Ectμν(E_{\mathrm{ct}})^{\mu\nu}:=\epsilon^{(d)}E_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu}, and (E~bdy)μν:=ϵ~(d)E~bdyμν(\widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{bdy}})^{\mu\nu}:=\widetilde{\epsilon}^{(d)}\widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu}, with the tensors EMNE^{MN}, EctμνE_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu}, and E~bdyμν\widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu} given by

EMN=116πGd+1(−RMN+12RGMN+d(d−1)2L2GMN),(20)E^{MN}=\frac{1}{16\pi G_{d+1}}\left(-R^{MN}+\frac{1}{2}RG^{MN}+\frac{d(d-1)}{2L^2}G^{MN}\right), \tag*{(20)}
Ectμν=−116πGd+1[d−1Lgμν−Ld−2(Rμν−12Rgμν)−cdL3(d−2)2(H(2)μν−d4(d−1)H(1)μν)],(21)E_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu}=-\frac{1}{16\pi G_{d+1}}\left[\frac{d-1}{L}g^{\mu\nu}-\frac{L}{d-2}\left(R^{\mu\nu}-\frac{1}{2}Rg^{\mu\nu}\right)-\frac{c_dL^3}{(d-2)^2}\left(H_{(2)}^{\mu\nu}-\frac{d}{4(d-1)}H_{(1)}^{\mu\nu}\right)\right], \tag*{(21)}
E~bdyμν=−116πGdEμν,(22)\widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu}=-\frac{1}{16\pi G_d}\mathcal{E}^{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(22)}

while Θ(d)\Theta^{(d)}, Θct(d−1)\Theta_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}, and Θ~bdy(d−1)\widetilde{\Theta}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)} denote the corresponding symplectic potential forms introduced in Eqs. (A.1) in Appendix § 7. Here, H(1)μνH_{(1)}^{\mu\nu} and H(2)μνH_{(2)}^{\mu\nu} are defined by the same expressions as H(1)μνH_{(1)}^{\mu\nu} and H(2)μνH_{(2)}^{\mu\nu}, respectively, with the boundary metric Gμν\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu} replaced by gμνg_{\mu\nu}. Note that the indices of EctμνE_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu} and E~bdyμν\widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu} are raised and lowered using gμνg_{\mu\nu} and Gμν\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}, respectively.

In terms of an arbitrary vector ξM\xi^M tangent to z=const.z=\mathrm{const.} hypersurface, let us define the bulk and the boundary Noether currents, J(d)J^{(d)} and J(d−1):=Jct(d−1)+J~bdy(d−1)J^{(d-1)}:=J_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}+\widetilde{J}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)}, by

J(d)=Θ(d)(G,LξG)−Lξϵ(d+1),Jct(d−1)=Θct(d−1)(g,Lξg)−(Lct+K8πGd+1)iξϵ(d),J~bdy(d−1)=Θ~bdy(d−1)(G,LξG)−L~bdyiξϵ~(d),(23)\begin{aligned} J^{(d)} &= \Theta^{(d)}(G,\mathcal{L}_{\xi}G)-\mathcal{L}_{\xi}\epsilon^{(d+1)},\\ J_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)} &= \Theta_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}(g,\mathcal{L}_{\xi}g)-\left(L_{\mathrm{ct}}+\frac{K}{8\pi G_{d+1}}\right)i_{\xi}\epsilon^{(d)},\\ \widetilde{J}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)} &= \widetilde{\Theta}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)}(\mathcal{G},\mathcal{L}_{\xi}\mathcal{G})-\widetilde{L}_{\mathrm{bdy}}i_{\xi}\widetilde{\epsilon}^{(d)}, \tag*{(23)} \end{aligned}

where K=K μμK=K^\mu_{\ \mu} and here and in the following iξi_{\xi} denotes the interior product with ξ\xi.

Let us introduce the bulk Noether charge (d−1)(d-1)-form as,

Q(d−1)=12ϵMNK3K4⋯Kd+1QMN,QMN:=18πGd+1∇[NξM].(24)Q^{(d-1)}=\frac{1}{2}\epsilon_{MNK_{3}K_{4}\cdots K_{d+1}}Q^{MN},\qquad Q^{MN}:=\frac{1}{8\pi G_{d+1}}\nabla^{[N}\xi^{M]}. \tag*{(24)}

Using the relation J(d)=dQ(d−1)(ξ)−2ϵMK1⋯Kd+1E NMξNJ^{(d)}=dQ^{(d-1)}(\xi)-2\epsilon_{MK_{1}\cdots K_{d+1}}E^{M}_{\ N}\xi^{N}, we can express the integral of J(d)J^{(d)} over the dd-dimensional spacelike hypersurface S(d)S^{(d)} in terms of the bulk Noether charges Qσ(ξ)Q_{\sigma}(\xi) on σ(d−1)\sigma^{(d-1)} and QE(ξ)Q_{E}(\xi) on Sε(d−1)S_{\varepsilon}^{(d-1)} as

∫SJ(d)=−2∫SnMEMNξN+∫SdQ(d−1)(ξ)=∫σQ(d−1)+∫SεQ(d−1)−2∫SnMEMNξN=Qσ(ξ)+QE(ξ).(25)\begin{aligned} \int_{S}J^{(d)}&=-2\int_{S}n_{M}E^{MN}\xi_{N}+\int_{S}dQ^{(d-1)}(\xi)\\ &=\int_{\sigma}Q^{(d-1)}+\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}Q^{(d-1)}-2\int_{S}n_{M}E^{MN}\xi_{N}\\ &=Q_{\sigma}(\xi)+Q_{E}(\xi). \tag*{(25)} \end{aligned}

Here and in the following, nMn^{M} denotes the future-directed unit timelike vector normal to S(d)S^{(d)}. In the last equality, we used the bulk equations of motion, EMN=0E^{MN}=0, and defined QσQ_{\sigma} and QEQ_{E} accordingly. Here and hereafter, we omit the volume element in integral formulas, for notational simplicity.

Similarly, the integration of the boundary current J(d−1)J^{(d-1)} over (d−1)(d-1)-surface Sε(d−1)S_{\varepsilon}^{(d-1)} yields

QSε:=∫SεJ(d−1)=∫Sε{Θct(d−1)−(Lct+K8πGd+1)iξϵ(d)+Θ~bdy(d−1)−Lbdyiξ~ϵ~(d)}=∫SεdQct(d−2)(ξ)−2∫SεnμEctμνξν−∫SεKiξϵ(d)8πGd+1+∫SεdQ~bdy(d−2)(ξ)−2∫Sεn~μEbdyμνξ~ν=∫∂SεQct(d−2)(ξ)+∫∂SεQ~bdy(d−2)(ξ)−2∫SεnμEctμνξν−∫SεKiξϵ(d)8πGd+1−2∫Sεn~μEbdyμνξ~ν.(26)\begin{aligned} Q_{S_{\varepsilon}}&:=\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}J^{(d-1)}\\ &=\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\left\{\Theta_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}-\left(L_{\mathrm{ct}}+\frac{K}{8\pi G_{d+1}}\right)i_{\xi}\epsilon^{(d)}+\widetilde{\Theta}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)}-L_{\mathrm{bdy}}i_{\widetilde{\xi}}\widetilde{\epsilon}^{(d)}\right\}\\ &=\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}dQ_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-2)}(\xi)-2\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}n_{\mu}E_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu}\xi_{\nu}-\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\frac{K i_{\xi}\epsilon^{(d)}}{8\pi G_{d+1}}+\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}d\widetilde{Q}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-2)}(\xi)-2\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\widetilde{n}_{\mu}E_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu}\widetilde{\xi}_{\nu}\\ &=\int_{\partial S_{\varepsilon}}Q_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-2)}(\xi)+\int_{\partial S_{\varepsilon}}\widetilde{Q}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-2)}(\xi)-2\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}n_{\mu}E_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu}\xi_{\nu}\\ &\qquad-\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\frac{K i_{\xi}\epsilon^{(d)}}{8\pi G_{d+1}}-2\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\widetilde{n}_{\mu}E_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu}\widetilde{\xi}_{\nu}. \tag*{(26)} \end{aligned}

with the help of Eqs. Eqs. (A.5) and (A.7), where here and hereafter nμn^{\mu} denotes the future-directed unit timelike vector normal to SεS_{\varepsilon}, which coincides with the pull-back to Σε\Sigma_{\varepsilon} of nMn^{M} introduced above1. The vector n~μ\widetilde{n}^{\mu} is the future-directed unit timelike vector normal to SεS_{\varepsilon} with respect to the conformal metric Gμν\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu} on the AdS boundary. It is related to nμn^{\mu} by n~μ=nμ/Ω\widetilde{n}^{\mu}=n^{\mu}/\Omega and n~μ=Gμνn~ν=Ωnμ\widetilde{n}_{\mu}=\mathcal{G}_{\mu\nu}\widetilde{n}^{\nu}=\Omega n_{\mu}. Here, ∂Sε\partial S_{\varepsilon} denotes the bifurcation surface of the de Sitter horizon embedded in the AdS boundary (see Figure 2). In contrast to the bulk case, the boundary current cannot be entirely rewritten in terms of boundary charges, since both EctμνE_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu} and EbdyμνE_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu} are non-vanishing. However, as shown below, the sum of the bulk current (25) and the boundary current (26) can be reorganized into the Noether charge on the bulk horizon and the Wald entropy on the de Sitter horizon of the boundary spacetime, respectively, by virtue of the SCE Eqs. (2.3).

Let us define the renormalized bulk charges Qσ(ren)Q^{(\mathrm{ren})}_{\sigma} on σ(d−1)\sigma^{(d-1)} and QE(ren)Q^{(\mathrm{ren})}_{E} on Σε\Sigma_{\varepsilon} as follows:

Qσ(ren)(ξ):=lim⁡ε→0[∫σQ(d−1)(ξ)+∫∂SεQct(d−2)(ξ)],(27)Q^{(\mathrm{ren})}_{\sigma}(\xi) := \lim_{\varepsilon\to0} \left[\int_{\sigma} Q^{(d-1)}(\xi) + \int_{\partial S_{\varepsilon}} Q_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-2)}(\xi)\right], \tag*{(27)}
QE(ren)(ξ):=lim⁡ε→0[∫Sε(Q(d−1)(ξ)−Kiξϵ(d)8πGd+1)−∫Sε2nμEctμνξν]=−∫Sεn~μ⟨Tνμ⟩ξν,(28)Q^{(\mathrm{ren})}_{E}(\xi) := \lim_{\varepsilon\to0} \left[\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\left(Q^{(d-1)}(\xi)-\frac{K i_{\xi}\epsilon^{(d)}}{8\pi G_{d+1}}\right)-\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}2n_{\mu}E_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu}\xi^{\nu}\right] = -\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\widetilde{n}_{\mu}\langle T^{\mu}_{\nu}\rangle\xi^{\nu}, \tag*{(28)}

where we used Eq. (B.4) in Appendix § 8, and where the volume element of Sε(d−1)S_{\varepsilon}^{(d-1)} is understood. This Qσ(ren)Q^{(\mathrm{ren})}_{\sigma} corresponds to the SEES_{\mathrm{EE}} in eq. (2). In the next section, we show that Qσ(ren)(ξ)Q^{(\mathrm{ren})}_{\sigma}(\xi) remains finite in the limit z=ε→0z=\varepsilon\to0. Thus, combining Eqs. (25), (26), (27), and (28), we obtain

lim⁡ε→0(Qσ+QE+QSε)=lim⁡ε→0[∫σQ(d−1)(ξ)+∫∂SεQct(d−2)(ξ)+∫SεQ(d−1)(ξ)−∫SεKiξϵ(d)8πGd+1−2∫SεnμEctμξν−2∫Sεn~μEbdyμξν+∫∂SεQ~bdy(d−2)(ξ)]=Qσ(ren)(ξ)−∫Sεn~μ⟨Tνμ⟩ξν−2∫Sεn~μEbdyμξν+∫∂SεQ~bdy(d−2)(ξ)=Qσ(ren)(ξ)+∫∂SεQ~bdy(d−2)(ξ),(29)\begin{aligned} \lim_{\varepsilon\to0}(Q_{\sigma}+Q_{E}+Q_{S_{\varepsilon}}) = \lim_{\varepsilon\to0}\bigg[&\int_{\sigma}Q^{(d-1)}(\xi)+\int_{\partial S_{\varepsilon}}Q_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-2)}(\xi)+\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}Q^{(d-1)}(\xi)-\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\frac{K i_{\xi}\epsilon^{(d)}}{8\pi G_{d+1}}\\ &-2\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}n_{\mu}E_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu}\xi^{\nu}-2\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\widetilde{n}_{\mu}E_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu}\xi^{\nu}+\int_{\partial S_{\varepsilon}}\widetilde{Q}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-2)}(\xi)\bigg]\\ &=Q^{(\mathrm{ren})}_{\sigma}(\xi)-\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\widetilde{n}_{\mu}\langle T^{\mu}_{\nu}\rangle\xi^{\nu}-2\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\widetilde{n}_{\mu}E_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu}\xi^{\nu}+\int_{\partial S_{\varepsilon}}\widetilde{Q}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-2)}(\xi)\\ &=Q^{(\mathrm{ren})}_{\sigma}(\xi)+\int_{\partial S_{\varepsilon}}\widetilde{Q}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-2)}(\xi), \tag*{(29)} \end{aligned}

where we used the SCE Eqs. (2.3) in the last equality. This is the generalized entropy as the sum of entanglement entropy and gravitational one appeared in (3). This result shows that the sum of the bulk and boundary currents can be expressed entirely in terms of Noether charges, although the boundary current itself cannot be entirely rewritten in terms of boundary charges. This feature is a direct consequence of imposing the semiclassical Einstein equations on the boundary metric.

Now, let us take the first-order variation of Eq. (29) under the static perturbations (17) satisfying Eq. (18). Substituting Eqs. (19) into the variations of J(d)J^{(d)} and J(d−1)J^{(d-1)} in Eqs. (23) and applying the formula for an arbitrary form uu,

Lξu=ξ⋅du+d(ξ⋅u),(30)\mathcal{L}_{\xi}u=\xi\cdot du+d(\xi\cdot u), \tag*{(30)}

one obtains

δ(Qσ+QE+QSε)=∫S(δΘ(d)(G‾,LξG)−LξΘ(d)(G‾,δG))+∫σiξΘ(d)(G‾,δG)−18πGd+1∫Sεδ(K(g‾,δg)iξϵ(d))+∫Sεiξ{Θ(d)(G‾,δG)−(Ect)μν(g‾)δgμν−(E~bdy)μν(G‾)δGμν}+∫∂Sεiξ{Θct(d−1)(g‾,δg)+Θ~bdy(d−1)(G‾,δG)}+∫Sε{δΘct(d−1)(g‾,Lξg)−LξΘct(d−1)(g‾,δg)+δΘ~bdy(d−1)(G‾,LξG)−LξΘ~bdy(d−1)(G‾,δG)},(31)\begin{aligned} \delta(Q_{\sigma}+Q_{E}+Q_{S_{\varepsilon}})={}&\int_{S}\left(\delta\Theta^{(d)}(\overline{G},\mathcal{L}_{\xi}G)-\mathcal{L}_{\xi}\Theta^{(d)}(\overline{G},\delta G)\right)+\int_{\sigma}i_{\xi}\Theta^{(d)}(\overline{G},\delta G)\\ &-\frac{1}{8\pi G_{d+1}}\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\delta\left(K(\overline{g},\delta g)i_{\xi}\epsilon^{(d)}\right)\\ &+\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}i_{\xi}\left\{\Theta^{(d)}(\overline{G},\delta G)-(E_{\mathrm{ct}})^{\mu\nu}(\overline{g})\delta g_{\mu\nu}-(\widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{bdy}})^{\mu\nu}(\overline{G})\delta G_{\mu\nu}\right\}\\ &+\int_{\partial S_{\varepsilon}}i_{\xi}\left\{\Theta_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}(\overline{g},\delta g)+\widetilde{\Theta}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)}(\overline{G},\delta G)\right\}\\ &+\int_{S_{\varepsilon}}\left\{\delta\Theta_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}(\overline{g},\mathcal{L}_{\xi}g)-\mathcal{L}_{\xi}\Theta_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}(\overline{g},\delta g)+\delta\widetilde{\Theta}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)}(\overline{G},\mathcal{L}_{\xi}G)-\mathcal{L}_{\xi}\widetilde{\Theta}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)}(\overline{G},\delta G)\right\}, \tag*{(31)} \end{aligned}

where we used the bulk equations of motion, EMN=0E^{MN}=0.

Eq. (31) can be further simplified. First, we note that Θ(d)(G‾,δG)\Theta^{(d)}(\overline{G},\delta G) and δK(g‾,δg)\delta K(\overline{g},\delta g) vanish by definitions of these quantities (see Appendix § 7), together with Eq. (18) for the timelike Killing field ξM=(∂t)M\xi^{M}=(\partial_t)^M, and also by the fact that ξM\xi^{M} is vanishing at the bifurcate surface ∂Sε\partial S_{\varepsilon}. Second, since the background spacetime is maximally symmetric,

Ectμν(g‾)∝g‾μν,E~bdyμν(G‾)∝G‾μν(32)E_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu}(\overline{g})\propto\overline{g}^{\mu\nu}, \qquad\widetilde{E}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu}(\overline{G})\propto\overline{G}^{\mu\nu} \tag*{(32)}

as follows from Eqs. (21) and (22). Therefore, their contractions with the traceless perturbations (18) vanish. According to the procedure in Ref. [15], let us define the symplectic currents ω(d)\omega^{(d)}, ωct(d−1)\omega_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}, and ωbdy(d−1)\omega_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)} as

ω(d)(G‾,δG,LξG)=δΘ(d)(G‾,LξG)−LξΘ(d)(G‾,δG),\omega^{(d)}(\overline{G},\delta G,\mathcal{L}_{\xi}G)=\delta\Theta^{(d)}(\overline{G},\mathcal{L}_{\xi}G)-\mathcal{L}_{\xi}\Theta^{(d)}(\overline{G},\delta G),
ωct(d−1)(g‾,δg,Lξg)=δΘct(d−1)(g‾,Lξg)−LξΘct(d−1)(g‾,δg),\omega_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}(\overline{g},\delta g,\mathcal{L}_{\xi}g)=\delta\Theta_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}(\overline{g},\mathcal{L}_{\xi}g)-\mathcal{L}_{\xi}\Theta_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}(\overline{g},\delta g),
ωbdy(d−1)(G‾,δG,LξG)=δΘ~bdy(d−1)(G‾,LξG)−LξΘ~bdy(d−1)(G‾,δG).(33)\omega_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)}(\overline{G},\delta G,\mathcal{L}_{\xi}G)=\delta\widetilde{\Theta}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)}(\overline{G},\mathcal{L}_{\xi}G)-\mathcal{L}_{\xi}\widetilde{\Theta}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)}(\overline{G},\delta G). \tag*{(33)}

Since LξGMN=Lξgμν=LξGμν=0\mathcal{L}_{\xi}G_{MN}=\mathcal{L}_{\xi}g_{\mu\nu}=\mathcal{L}_{\xi}G_{\mu\nu}=0, ω(d)\omega^{(d)}, ωct(d−1)\omega_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}, and ωbdy(d−1)\omega_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)} vanish. In addition, σ(d−1)\sigma^{(d-1)} and ∂Sε(d−1)\partial S_{\varepsilon}^{(d-1)} are the bifurcate Killing horizon with ξM=0\xi^{M}=0. Therefore, by combining Eqs. (29) and (31), we obtain

δQO(ren)(ξ)+δ(∫∂SεQ~bdy(d−2)(ξ~))=0.(34)\delta Q^{(\mathrm{ren})}_{\mathcal{O}}(\xi)+\delta\left(\int_{\partial S_{\varepsilon}}\widetilde{Q}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-2)}(\widetilde{\xi})\right)=0. \tag*{(34)}

The first term of the l.h.s. of eq. (34) corresponds to the variation of the holographic entanglement entropy. This follows from the Ryu-Takayanagi prescription [10], since the bifurcation surface of the bulk Killing horizon is the corresponding extremal surface. The second term of the l.h.s. of eq. (34) corresponds to the variation of the gravitational (Wald) entropy of the horizon.

Static perturbations of de Sitter spacetimes

We consider static perturbations satisfying the gauge condition as (18). Following the procedure of Ref. [22], we separate the perturbation hμν(x,z)h_{\mu\nu}(x,z) in Eq. (17) as hμν(x,z)=ξ(z)Hμν(x)h_{\mu\nu}(x,z)=\xi(z)H_{\mu\nu}(x). Then, from the bulk Einstein equations, EbulkMN=0E_{\mathrm{bulk}}^{MN}=0, derived from Eqs. (19) reduce to two decoupled equations:

ξ′′−(d−1)Ω′Ωξ′+m2ξ=0,(35)\xi^{\prime\prime}-\frac{(d-1)\Omega^{\prime}}{\Omega}\xi^{\prime}+m^{2}\xi=0, \tag*{(35)}
(D‾2−2ℓ2)Hμν(x)=m2Hμν,(36)\left(\overline{D}^{2}-\frac{2}{\ell^{2}}\right)H_{\mu\nu}(x)=m^{2}H_{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(36)}

where the mass-squared term m2m^{2} appears as a separation constant. Hereafter, we focus on the case m2<0m^{2}<0, since, as shown below, only negative values of m2m^{2} admit non-trivial static solutions.

Imposing the regularity condition at z=∞z=\infty for ξ\xi in (35), the solutions are expressed in terms of the hypergeometric function FF as

ξ=c(−y)d−12−pF(p−d−12,p+12,2p+1;1y),y=1−cosh⁡(zℓ)2,(37)\xi=c(-y)^{\frac{d-1}{2}-p}F\left(p-\frac{d-1}{2},p+\frac{1}{2},2p+1;\frac{1}{y}\right),\qquad y=\frac{1-\cosh\left(\frac{z}{\ell}\right)}{2}, \tag*{(37)}
p:=(d−1)24−m^2,m^2:=m2ℓ2,(38)p:=\sqrt{\frac{(d-1)^2}{4}-\hat{m}^2},\qquad\hat{m}^2:=m^2\ell^2, \tag*{(38)}

where cc is an arbitrary constant. Under the above regularity condition at y=−∞y=-\infty (equivalently, z=∞z=\infty), a nontrivial bounded solution satisfying ∣ξ∣<∞|\xi|<\infty exists only for m2≤0m^2\leq0, whereas for m2>0m^2>0 the only regular solution is the trivial one, ξ=0\xi=0.

We adopt the following metric ansatz for HμνH_{\mu\nu}:

dsd2=Gμν(u)dxμdxν=−f(u)u(1+ϵT(u))dt2+ℓ24u2f(u)(1+ϵU(u))du2+ℓ2u(1+ϵR(u))dΩd−22,(39)ds_d^2=G_{\mu\nu}(u)dx^\mu dx^\nu =-\frac{f(u)}{u}(1+\epsilon T(u))dt^2+\frac{\ell^2}{4u^2f(u)}(1+\epsilon U(u))du^2+\frac{\ell^2}{u}(1+\epsilon R(u))d\Omega_{d-2}^2, \tag*{(39)}

where 1≤u<∞1\leq u<\infty and u=∞u=\infty corresponds to the center of spherical symmetry.

Under our gauge condition (18), i.e., H μμ=0=D‾νHμνH^\mu_{\ \mu}=0=\overline{D}^{\nu}H_{\mu\nu}, Eqs. (36) reduce to the following set of equations:

R=−T+Ud−2,(40)R=-\frac{T+U}{d-2}, \tag*{(40)}
T=(du−(d−1))U+2(u−1)U′,(41)T=\left(\frac{d}{u}-(d-1)\right)U+2(u-1)U', \tag*{(41)}
U′′−(d+12u+21−u)U′+2d+2+m^24u2(1−u)U=0.(42)U''-\left(\frac{d+1}{2u}+\frac{2}{1-u}\right)U'+\frac{2d+2+\hat{m}^2}{4u^2(1-u)}U=0. \tag*{(42)}

Imposing the regularity at u=∞u=\infty, the solution of Eq. (4.5c) is given by the hypergeometric function

U=F(d+34+p2,d+34−p2,d+12,1u).(43)U=F\left(\frac{d+3}{4}+\frac{p}{2},\frac{d+3}{4}-\frac{p}{2},\frac{d+1}{2},\frac{1}{u}\right). \tag*{(43)}

Making use of the hypergeometric identity

F(α,β,γ;z)=Γ(α+β−γ)Γ(γ)Γ(α)Γ(β)(1−z)γ−α−βF(γ−α,γ−β,γ−α−β+1;1−z)+Γ(γ−α−β)Γ(γ)Γ(γ−α)Γ(γ−β)F(α,β,α+β−γ+1;1−z),(44)F(\alpha,\beta,\gamma;z)=\frac{\Gamma(\alpha+\beta-\gamma)\Gamma(\gamma)}{\Gamma(\alpha)\Gamma(\beta)}(1-z)^{\gamma-\alpha-\beta}F(\gamma-\alpha,\gamma-\beta,\gamma-\alpha-\beta+1;1-z) +\frac{\Gamma(\gamma-\alpha-\beta)\Gamma(\gamma)}{\Gamma(\gamma-\alpha)\Gamma(\gamma-\beta)}F(\alpha,\beta,\alpha+\beta-\gamma+1;1-z), \tag*{(44)}

the regularity at the de Sitter horizon (u=1u=1) requires

d+34−p2=−n,n=0,1,2,….(45)\frac{d+3}{4}-\frac{p}{2}=-n,\qquad n=0,1,2,\ldots. \tag*{(45)}

Eq. (4.3b) implies that the largest value of m^2\hat{m}^{2} admitting a regular static solution is attained for n=0n=0, namely

m^2=−2(d+1),(46)\hat{m}^{2}=-2(d+1), \tag*{(46)}

which agrees with the threshold mass for the instability of de Sitter spacetime obtained in Ref. [22].

Substituting n=0n=0 into Eqs. (43), (40), (4.5b) yields

U=1,T=du+1−d,R=1−d(d−2)u,(47)U=1,\qquad T=\frac{d}{u}+1-d,\qquad R=1-\frac{d}{(d-2)u}, \tag*{(47)}

where the overall normalization has been fixed so that U=1U=1.

For later convenience, it is useful to express the bulk Noether charge ∫Q(d−1)\int Q^{(d-1)} with the (d−1)(d-1)-form, (24), in terms of the functions UU, TT, and RR. For each surface σ(d−1)\sigma^{(d-1)} and Sϵ(d−1)\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}^{(d-1)}, they are written as

Qσ:=∫σQ(d−1)=ℓd−38πGd+1∫1−ϵξ(z)Ωd−1(z) dz dΩd−2=ℓd−34Gd+1πd−32Γ(d−12)∫ϵ∞1−ϵξ(z)Ωd−1(z) dz,(48)Q_{\sigma}:=\int_{\sigma}Q^{(d-1)}=\frac{\ell^{d-3}}{8\pi G_{d+1}}\int\frac{1-\epsilon\xi(z)}{\Omega^{d-1}(z)}\,dz\,d\Omega_{d-2} =\frac{\ell^{d-3}}{4G_{d+1}}\frac{\pi^{\frac{d-3}{2}}}{\Gamma\left(\frac{d-1}{2}\right)}\int_{\epsilon}^{\infty}\frac{1-\epsilon\xi(z)}{\Omega^{d-1}(z)}\,dz, \tag*{(48)}
QE:=∫SϵQ(d−1)=∫SϵmNnMQMN=ℓd−116Gd+1πd−32Γ(d−12)∫1∞Ω−dud+12(−2∂zΩ+ϵΩ(∂zξ)T) du∣z=ϵ,(49)Q_{E}:=\int_{\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}}Q^{(d-1)}=\int_{\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}}m^{N}n^{M}Q_{MN} =\left.\frac{\ell^{d-1}}{16G_{d+1}}\frac{\pi^{\frac{d-3}{2}}}{\Gamma\left(\frac{d-1}{2}\right)}\int_{1}^{\infty}\frac{\Omega^{-d}}{u^{\frac{d+1}{2}}}\left(-2\partial_{z}\Omega+\epsilon\Omega(\partial_{z}\xi)T\right)\,du\right|_{z=\epsilon}, \tag*{(49)}

where Γ(z)\Gamma(z) denotes the Gamma function and where in the second integral of (49), the volume element of Sϵ(d−1)\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}^{(d-1)} is understood. Here nMn^{M} and mMm^{M} are, respectively, the unit (future directed) timelike and spacelike (outward) vectors orthogonal to Sϵ(d−1)\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}^{(d-1)}. It is also useful to evaluate the second term in Eq. (27) under the metric ansatz (39). Let us define a unit spacelike vector sμs^{\mu} orthogonal to ∂Sϵ\partial\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon} as

sM=−2ufΩℓ(1+ϵξU)−12(∂u)M.(50)s^{M}=-\frac{2u\sqrt{f}\Omega}{\ell}(1+\epsilon\xi U)^{-\frac{1}{2}}(\partial_{u})^{M}. \tag*{(50)}

With this definition, we find ∫∂SϵQct(d−2)\int_{\partial\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}}Q_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-2)} to be written as

Qct:=∫∂SϵsνnμQctμν=−Lℓd−38π(d−2)Gd+1Ωd−2(ϵ)∫(1−ϵξ(ϵ)) dΩd−2−cdL3ℓd−38π(d−2)2Gd+1Ωd−2(ϵ)∫(1−ϵξ(ϵ))(2R uu−d2(d−1)R)dΩd−2∣u=1,(51)Q_{\mathrm{ct}}:=\int_{\partial\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}}s_{\nu}n_{\mu}Q_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu} =-\frac{L\ell^{d-3}}{8\pi(d-2)G_{d+1}\Omega^{d-2}(\epsilon)}\int(1-\epsilon\xi(\epsilon))\,d\Omega_{d-2} -\left.\frac{c_{d}L^{3}\ell^{d-3}}{8\pi(d-2)^{2}G_{d+1}\Omega^{d-2}(\epsilon)}\int(1-\epsilon\xi(\epsilon))\left(2R^{u}_{\ u}-\frac{d}{2(d-1)}R\right)d\Omega_{d-2}\right|_{u=1}, \tag*{(51)}

where in the last equality, we used f(1)=0f(1)=0, U(1)=T(1)=1U(1)=T(1)=1, and H μμ=0H^{\mu}_{\ \mu}=0 as follows from Eqs. (47). In the remainder of this paper, we take the limit ϵ→0\epsilon\to0 for the renormalized charges (27) and (28).

d=3d=3 de Sitter spacetime

Let us first consider the simplest case, d=3d=3, in which the higher curvature corrections are absent. In this case, substituting Eq. (46) into Eq. (4.3a), we obtain

ξ=2e−2zℓ−e−4zℓ.(52)\xi=2e^{-\frac{2z}{\ell}}-e^{-\frac{4z}{\ell}}. \tag*{(52)}

By Eqs. (47), (C.1a), and (4.15), the variations of the charges in Eqs. (48), (49), and (51) are

δQσ=3ϵL24G4ℓ−ϵL24G4ϵ+O(ϵ),δQct=ϵL24G4ϵ+O(ϵ),δQE=ϵℓ216G4∫1∞Ω−2(ϵ)u2(∂zξ)T(u) du=−3ϵL24G4ℓ+ϵL24G4ϵ+O(ϵ).(53)\begin{aligned} \delta Q_{\sigma}&=\frac{3\epsilon L^2}{4G_4\ell}-\frac{\epsilon L^2}{4G_4\epsilon}+O(\epsilon),\\ \delta Q_{\mathrm{ct}}&=\frac{\epsilon L^2}{4G_4\epsilon}+O(\epsilon),\\ \delta Q_E&=\frac{\epsilon\ell^2}{16G_4}\int_1^\infty\frac{\Omega^{-2}(\epsilon)}{u^2}(\partial_z\xi)T(u)\,du=-\frac{3\epsilon L^2}{4G_4\ell}+\frac{\epsilon L^2}{4G_4\epsilon}+O(\epsilon). \tag*{(53)} \end{aligned}

By Eq. (18), the variation of the second term in Eq. (28) vanishes and the variation of the third term in Eq. (28) yields

−2δ∫SϵnμEctμνξν=−L8πG4∫SϵϵμαβδRμνξν=−ϵL24G4ϵ+O(ϵ),(54)-2\delta\int_{\mathcal{S}_\epsilon}n_\mu E_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu}\xi^\nu=-\frac{L}{8\pi G_4}\int_{\mathcal{S}_\epsilon}\epsilon_{\mu\alpha\beta}\delta R^{\mu\nu}\xi^\nu=-\frac{\epsilon L^2}{4G_4\epsilon}+O(\epsilon), \tag*{(54)}

where we used Eqs. (46), (47), and (C.1a). Thus, the renormalized charges in Eqs. (27) and (28) are finite, and we obtain

δQσ(ren)=−δQE(ren)=3ϵL24G4ℓ.(55)\delta Q_{\sigma}^{(\mathrm{ren})}=-\delta Q_E^{(\mathrm{ren})}=\frac{3\epsilon L^2}{4G_4\ell}. \tag*{(55)}

The variation of the gravitational charge on the boundary horizon u=1u=1 is evaluated by Eqs. (A.6) and (4.10), with α1=α2=α3=0\alpha_1=\alpha_2=\alpha_3=0, as

δ∫∂SϵQ~bdy(d−2)=δ∫∂Sϵs~νn~μQbdyμν=−ϵ4G32,(56)\delta\int_{\partial\mathcal{S}_\epsilon}\widetilde{Q}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-2)}=\delta\int_{\partial\mathcal{S}_\epsilon}\widetilde{s}_\nu\widetilde{n}_\mu Q_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu}=-\frac{\epsilon}{4G_3^2}, \tag*{(56)}

where s~μ\widetilde{s}^{\mu} and n~μ\widetilde{n}^{\mu} are unit spacelike and timelike vectors orthogonal to ∂Sϵ\partial\mathcal{S}_\epsilon associated with the conformal metric (39),

s~μ=−2ufℓ(1+ϵU)−1/2(∂u)μ,n~μ=uf(1+ϵT)−1/2(∂t)μ.(57)\widetilde{s}^{\mu}=-\frac{2u\sqrt{f}}{\ell}(1+\epsilon U)^{-1/2}(\partial_u)^\mu,\qquad\widetilde{n}^{\mu}=\sqrt{\frac{u}{f}}(1+\epsilon T)^{-1/2}(\partial_t)^\mu. \tag*{(57)}

The previous work [22] showed that the SCE Eqs. (2.3) are satisfied if the following algebraic relation holds for m^2=−8\hat{m}^2=-8 (46):

γ3:=L2G3πG4ℓ=1π1−m^2=13π.(58)\gamma_3:=\frac{L^2G_3}{\pi G_4\ell}=\frac{1}{\pi\sqrt{1-\hat{m}^2}}=\frac{1}{3\pi}. \tag*{(58)}

Thus, the variation of the gravitational charge (56) is given by

δ∫∂SϵQ~bdy(d−2)=−ϵ4G3=−δQσ(ren)(59)\delta\int_{\partial\mathcal{S}_\epsilon}\widetilde{Q}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-2)}=-\frac{\epsilon}{4G_3}=-\delta Q_{\sigma}^{(\mathrm{ren})} \tag*{(59)}

together with Eq. (55), confirming (34) for the d=3d=3 case.

d=5d=5 de Sitter spacetime

Next, we consider the d=5d=5 de Sitter case. Substituting p=4p=4, which follows from Eq. (46), into Eq. (4.3a), we obtain

ξ(z)=532(−y(z))−2F(2,92,9,1y(z))=12e−6zℓ(1−4e2zℓ+5e4zℓ).(60)\xi(z)=\frac{5}{32}\left(-y(z)\right)^{-2}F\left(2,\frac{9}{2},9,\frac{1}{y(z)}\right)=\frac{1}{2}e^{-\frac{6z}{\ell}}\left(1-4e^{\frac{2z}{\ell}}+5e^{\frac{4z}{\ell}}\right). \tag*{(60)}

where ξ\xi is normalized so that ξ(0)=1\xi(0)=1. By Eqs. (47), (C.1a), and (60), the variations of the charges defined in Eqs. (48), (49), and (51) are

δQσ=−ϵπℓ24G6∫ϵ∞ξ(z)Ω4(z) dz=−πL4ℓϵ12G6ϵ3+2πL4ϵ3G6ϵ−5πL4ϵ3G6ℓ+O(ϵ),δQct=πϵL4ξ(ϵ)12G6ℓsinh⁡3(ϵ/ℓ)−11πϵL4ξ(ϵ)24G6ℓsinh⁡(ϵ/ℓ)=πL4ℓ2ϵ12G6ϵ3−2πL4ϵ3G6ϵ+O(ϵ),δQE=ϵπℓ416G6∫1∞Ω−4(ϵ)u3∂zξ(ϵ)T(u) du=πL4ℓ2ϵ12G6ϵ3−2πL4ϵ3G6ϵ+5πL4ϵ3G6ℓ+O(ϵ).(61)\begin{aligned} \delta Q_{\sigma}&=-\frac{\epsilon\pi\ell^{2}}{4G_{6}}\int_{\epsilon}^{\infty}\frac{\xi(z)}{\Omega^{4}(z)}\,\mathrm{d}z=-\frac{\pi L^{4}\ell\epsilon}{12G_{6}\epsilon^{3}}+\frac{2\pi L^{4}\epsilon}{3G_{6}\epsilon}-\frac{5\pi L^{4}\epsilon}{3G_{6}\ell}+O(\epsilon),\\ \delta Q_{\mathrm{ct}}&=\frac{\pi\epsilon L^{4}\xi(\epsilon)}{12G_{6}\ell\sinh^{3}(\epsilon/\ell)}-\frac{11\pi\epsilon L^{4}\xi(\epsilon)}{24G_{6}\ell\sinh(\epsilon/\ell)}=\frac{\pi L^{4}\ell^{2}\epsilon}{12G_{6}\epsilon^{3}}-\frac{2\pi L^{4}\epsilon}{3G_{6}\epsilon}+O(\epsilon),\\ \delta Q_{E}&=\frac{\epsilon\pi\ell^{4}}{16G_{6}}\int_{1}^{\infty}\frac{\Omega^{-4}(\epsilon)}{u^{3}}\partial_{z}\xi(\epsilon)T(u)\,\mathrm{d}u=\frac{\pi L^{4}\ell^{2}\epsilon}{12G_{6}\epsilon^{3}}-\frac{2\pi L^{4}\epsilon}{3G_{6}\epsilon}+\frac{5\pi L^{4}\epsilon}{3G_{6}\ell}+O(\epsilon). \tag*{(61)} \end{aligned}

By Eq. (18), the variation of the second term in Eq. (28) vanishes, while the variation of the third term in Eq. (28) yields

−2δ∫∂SϵnμEctμνξν=−πϵL4m^224G6ℓsinh⁡3(ϵ/ℓ)∫1∞[12+(m^26−34)sinh⁡2(ϵ/ℓ)]ξ(ϵ)T(u)u3 du=−πL4ℓ2ϵ12G6ϵ3+2πL4ϵ3G6ϵ+O(ϵ).(62)-2\delta\int_{\partial S_{\epsilon}}n_{\mu}E_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu}\xi^{\nu}=-\frac{\pi\epsilon L^{4}\hat{m}^{2}}{24G_{6}\ell\sinh^{3}(\epsilon/\ell)}\int_{1}^{\infty}\left[\frac{1}{2}+\left(\frac{\hat{m}^{2}}{6}-\frac{3}{4}\right)\sinh^{2}(\epsilon/\ell)\right]\frac{\xi(\epsilon)T(u)}{u^{3}}\,\mathrm{d}u =-\frac{\pi L^{4}\ell^{2}\epsilon}{12G_{6}\epsilon^{3}}+\frac{2\pi L^{4}\epsilon}{3G_{6}\epsilon}+O(\epsilon). \tag*{(62)}

where we used Eqs. (46), (47), (C.1a), (C.1b), and (C.1c). Thus, the renormalized charges in Eqs. (27) and (28) are finite, and we obtain

δQσ(ren)=−δQE(ren)=−5πL4ϵ3G6ℓ.(63)\delta Q_{\sigma}^{(\mathrm{ren})}=-\delta Q_{E}^{(\mathrm{ren})}=-\frac{5\pi L^{4}\epsilon}{3G_{6}\ell}. \tag*{(63)}

The variation of the gravitational charge on the boundary horizon u=1u=1 is evaluated using Eqs. (A.6) and (47) as

δ∫∂SϵQ~bdy(d−2)=δ∫∂Sϵs~νn~μQbdyμν=−πϵℓ24G5(1+40α^1−4α^2−52α^3).(64)\delta\int_{\partial S_{\epsilon}}\widetilde{Q}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-2)}=\delta\int_{\partial S_{\epsilon}}\widetilde{s}_{\nu}\widetilde{n}_{\mu}Q_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu}=-\frac{\pi\epsilon\ell^{2}}{4G_{5}}\left(1+40\hat{\alpha}_{1}-4\hat{\alpha}_{2}-52\hat{\alpha}_{3}\right). \tag*{(64)}

where s~μ\widetilde{s}^{\mu} and n~μ\widetilde{n}^{\mu} are defined in Eq. (57). As shown in [22], the following algebraic relation follows from the SCE Eqs. (2.3):

γ5:=G5L4πℓ3G6=−3(1+40α^1−4α^2−52α^3)20π.(65)\gamma_{5}:=\frac{G_{5}L^{4}}{\pi\ell^{3}G_{6}}=-\frac{3\left(1+40\hat{\alpha}_{1}-4\hat{\alpha}_{2}-52\hat{\alpha}_{3}\right)}{20\pi}. \tag*{(65)}

where we have used m^2=−12\hat{m}^{2}=-12 (46) in the last equality.2 Combining Eqs. (63), (64), and (65), we confirm Eq. (34) for the d=5d=5 case.

d=4 de Sitter spacetime

In the d=4d=4 case, the calculations of the renormalized charges in Eqs. (27) and (28) are somewhat more involved due to the presence of the Weyl anomaly.

Substituting p=7/2p=7/2, which follows from Eq. (46), into Eq. (4.3a), we obtain

ξ(y)=1−10y(y−1){1+12y(y−1)}−60y2(y−1)2(2y−1)ln⁡(1−1y),(66)\xi(y)=1-10y(y-1)\{1+12y(y-1)\}-60y^{2}(y-1)^{2}(2y-1)\ln\left(1-\frac{1}{y}\right), \tag*{(66)}

where yy is a function of zz, as defined by Eq. (4.3a), and ξ\xi is normalized so that ξ(0)=1\xi(0)=1. Substituting (66) into the expression for the variation of the charge (48), we obtain

δQσ=−ϵL32G5∫ϵ∞ξℓ2sinh⁡3(z/ℓ) dz=−ϵL316ℓG5∫−∞−δϵξ(y)y2(y−1)2 dy=−ϵL316ℓG5[30+1δϵ+60δϵ+11+δϵ−12(1+5δϵ+5δϵ2)ln⁡(1+1δϵ)]=−ϵL32G5ℓ[236+ℓ22ϵ2+3ln⁡(ϵ2ℓ)]+O(ϵ),(67)\begin{aligned} \delta Q_{\sigma}&=-\frac{\epsilon L^{3}}{2G_{5}}\int_{\epsilon}^{\infty}\frac{\xi}{\ell^{2}\sinh^{3}(z/\ell)}\,\mathrm{d}z=-\frac{\epsilon L^{3}}{16\ell G_{5}}\int_{-\infty}^{-\delta_{\epsilon}}\frac{\xi(y)}{y^{2}(y-1)^{2}}\,\mathrm{d}y\\ &=-\frac{\epsilon L^{3}}{16\ell G_{5}}\left[30+\frac{1}{\delta_{\epsilon}}+60\delta_{\epsilon}+\frac{1}{1+\delta_{\epsilon}}-12(1+5\delta_{\epsilon}+5\delta_{\epsilon}^{2})\ln\left(1+\frac{1}{\delta_{\epsilon}}\right)\right]\\ &=-\frac{\epsilon L^{3}}{2G_{5}\ell}\left[\frac{23}{6}+\frac{\ell^{2}}{2\epsilon^{2}}+3\ln\left(\frac{\epsilon}{2\ell}\right)\right]+O(\epsilon), \tag*{(67)} \end{aligned}

where δϵ=−y(ϵ)>0\delta_{\epsilon}=-y(\epsilon)>0, and we have used δϵ≃ϵ2/(4ℓ2)+ϵ4/(48ℓ4)\delta_{\epsilon}\simeq\epsilon^{2}/(4\ell^{2})+\epsilon^{4}/(48\ell^{4}) in the last equality. Using Eq. (C.1a), the variation of the charge in Eq. (51) is given by

δQct=ϵL3ξ(ϵ)4G5ℓ(1sinh⁡2(ϵ/ℓ)+6ln⁡(μϵ)).(68)\delta Q_{\mathrm{ct}}=\frac{\epsilon L^{3}\xi(\epsilon)}{4G_{5}\ell}\left(\frac{1}{\sinh^{2}(\epsilon/\ell)}+6\ln(\mu\epsilon)\right). \tag*{(68)}

Adding Eqs. (67) and (68), the divergences cancel, yielding the finite variation of the renormalized charge QσQ_{\sigma} (27):

δQσ(ren)=lim⁡ϵ→0ϵL34G5ℓ[−{233+ℓ2ϵ2+6ln⁡(ϵ2ℓ)}+{1sinh⁡2(ϵ/ℓ)+6ln⁡(μϵ)}]=3ϵL32G5ℓ(ln⁡(2μℓ)−74).(69)\begin{aligned} \delta Q_{\sigma}^{(\mathrm{ren})}&=\lim_{\epsilon\to0}\frac{\epsilon L^{3}}{4G_{5}\ell}\left[-\left\{\frac{23}{3}+\frac{\ell^{2}}{\epsilon^{2}}+6\ln\left(\frac{\epsilon}{2\ell}\right)\right\}+\left\{\frac{1}{\sinh^{2}(\epsilon/\ell)}+6\ln(\mu\epsilon)\right\}\right]\\ &=\frac{3\epsilon L^{3}}{2G_{5}\ell}\left(\ln(2\mu\ell)-\frac{7}{4}\right). \tag*{(69)} \end{aligned}

As before, by Eq. (18), the variation of the second term in Eq. (28) vanishes. The remaining terms can be evaluated using Eqs. (46), (47), (66), and (C.1), giving

δQE(ren)=lim⁡ϵ→0∫1∞Tu5/2 du χ=ϵℓ38G5[Ω−3(ϵ)ξ,z(ϵ)−2ξ(ϵ)(Lm24Ω2(ϵ)−L3ln⁡(μϵ){m28(m2+6ℓ2)−m2ℓ2})]=3ϵL38G5ℓ(7−4ln⁡(2μℓ)).(70)\begin{aligned} \delta Q_{E}^{(\mathrm{ren})}&=\lim_{\epsilon\to0}\int_{1}^{\infty}\frac{T}{u^{5/2}}\,\mathrm{d}u\,\chi\\ &=\frac{\epsilon\ell^{3}}{8G_{5}}\left[\Omega^{-3}(\epsilon)\xi_{,z}(\epsilon)-2\xi(\epsilon)\left(\frac{Lm^{2}}{4\Omega^{2}(\epsilon)}-L^{3}\ln(\mu\epsilon)\left\{\frac{m^{2}}{8}\left(m^{2}+\frac{6}{\ell^{2}}\right)-\frac{m^{2}}{\ell^{2}}\right\}\right)\right]\\ &=\frac{3\epsilon L^{3}}{8G_{5}\ell}(7-4\ln(2\mu\ell)). \tag*{(70)} \end{aligned}

Thus, we have confirmed that the variations of both renormalized charges, δQσ(ren)\delta Q_{\sigma}^{(\mathrm{ren})} and δQE(ren)\delta Q_{E}^{(\mathrm{ren})}, are finite.

The variation of the gravitational charge on the boundary horizon u=1u = 1 is evaluated using Eqs. (A.6) and (47), yielding

δ∫∂SEQ~bdy(d−2)=−ℓ2G4(1+24α^1−4α^2−40α^3),(71)\delta\int_{\partial\mathcal{S}_{\mathcal{E}}} \widetilde{Q}_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-2)}=-\frac{\ell}{2G_{4}}\left(1+24\hat{\alpha}_{1}-4\hat{\alpha}_{2}-40\hat{\alpha}_{3}\right), \tag*{(71)}

where s~μ\tilde{s}^{\mu} and n~μ\tilde{n}^{\mu} are defined in Eq. (57). As shown in Ref. [22], the first-order variations of ⟨Tμ ν⟩\langle T_{\mu}^{\ \nu}\rangle and Eμ ν\mathcal{E}_{\mu}^{\ \nu} in the SCE Eqs. (2.3) are

δ⟨Tμ ν⟩=−ϵL3m^264πG5ℓ4[1+(m^2−2){ψ(p+12)+γE−ln⁡(2μℓ)}]Hμ ν=5ϵL332πG5ℓ4(−21+12ln⁡(2μℓ))Hμ ν,(72)\begin{aligned} \delta\langle T_{\mu}^{\ \nu}\rangle=-\frac{\epsilon L^{3}\hat{m}^{2}}{64\pi G_{5}\ell^{4}}\left[1+(\hat{m}^{2}-2)\left\{\psi\left(p+\frac{1}{2}\right)+\gamma_{E}-\ln(2\mu\ell)\right\}\right]H_{\mu}^{\ \nu} \\ &=\frac{5\epsilon L^{3}}{32\pi G_{5}\ell^{4}}\left(-21+12\ln(2\mu\ell)\right)H_{\mu}^{\ \nu}, \tag*{(72)} \end{aligned}
δ(EμρGρν)=5ϵℓ2(1+24α^1−4α^2−40α^3)Hμ ν,(73)\delta(\mathcal{E}_{\mu\rho}G^{\rho\nu})=\frac{5\epsilon}{\ell^{2}}\left(1+24\hat{\alpha}_{1}-4\hat{\alpha}_{2}-40\hat{\alpha}_{3}\right)H_{\mu}^{\ \nu}, \tag*{(73)}

where ψ(x)\psi(x) and γE\gamma_{E} are the digamma function and Euler constant, and we used

ψ(4)+γE=116(74)\psi(4)+\gamma_{E}=\frac{11}{6} \tag*{(74)}

corresponding to p=7/2p=7/2. Substituting Eqs. (72) and (73) into Eqs. (2.3), we obtain the following algebraic equation

4(1+24α^1−4α^2−40α^3)=G4L3G5ℓ2(−21+12ln⁡(2μℓ)).(75)4\left(1+24\hat{\alpha}_{1}-4\hat{\alpha}_{2}-40\hat{\alpha}_{3}\right)=\frac{G_{4}L^{3}}{G_{5}\ell^{2}}\left(-21+12\ln(2\mu\ell)\right). \tag*{(75)}

Using Eq. (75) to eliminate G4G_{4} from Eq. (71), we find that the variation of the gravitational charge coincides with the variation of the renormalized charge δQE(ren)\delta Q_{\mathcal{E}}^{(\mathrm{ren})}. Together with Eqs. (69) and (70), this confirms Eq. (34) for the d=4d=4 case.

Summary and discussions

We have studied the generalized de Sitter entropy, which consists of the entanglement entropy of the strongly coupled quantum field theory and the gravitational Wald entropy, in the framework of holographic semiclassical gravity [16, 17]. For static perturbations, we have shown that the first order variation of the entanglement entropy is finite without introducing a cutoff, by applying the Noether charge formula to the semiclassical model, in which the perturbation does not decay as rapidly as required by the Dirichlet boundary condition. This finiteness arises from the cancellation between the divergent contributions to the area of the bulk horizon and the Noether charges associated with the boundary counterterm action. Using the semiclassical Einstein equations (2.3), we have further shown that the sum of the first-order variations of the entanglement entropy and the gravitational Wald entropy vanishes. This result is naturally understood in terms of the first laws for the gravitational entropy of the boundary de Sitter horizon and the entanglement entropy of the bulk region associated with that horizon, as explained in the Introduction.

It would be interesting to extend our analysis to other semiclassical spacetimes, including those containing black holes. For example, in the case of an AdS black hole, which provides an example of a boundary semiclassical spacetime, one can identify three quantities associated with Noether charges: the canonical energy evaluated at the asymptotic boundary of the boundary spacetime, the bulk entanglement entropy, and the gravitational entropy of the black hole horizon. Although the boundary field decays more slowly than in the Dirichlet case due to the presence of a negative mass term, we expect that the canonical energy can still be rendered finite by introducing an appropriate counterterm [23]. In this case, we expect to obtain a first law in which the variation of the total energy of the boundary spacetime is related to the variation of the generalized entropy. We leave a detailed investigation of this possibility to future work.

We expect the first laws associated with the gravitational entropy of the boundary de Sitter horizon and the entanglement entropy of the corresponding bulk region to hold even for dynamical perturbations. This suggests that the first-order variation of the generalized entropy vanishes, corresponding to a saturation of the generalized second law at first order. From the bulk perspective, the entanglement entropy is related to the area of the bulk horizon. By introducing a timelike cutoff hypersurface near the AdS boundary [24], the change in the bulk horizon area along the horizon null generators can be understood in terms of the flux of the null generators across this cutoff hypersurface. In this picture, the area variation can be decomposed into a flux contribution and a nonnegative contribution associated with the classical area increase of the bulk horizon. The former arises from the flux of the horizon generators across the cutoff hypersurface, while the latter reflects the area increase governed by the classical area theorem for black holes [25]. For perturbations about a stationary horizon, the terms quadratic in the expansion and shear in the Raychaudhuri equation contribute at second order in perturbation theory. These terms govern the nonlinear contribution to the horizon area change and underlie the classical area increase theorem, subject to the appropriate assumptions.

In our semiclassical model, the bulk entanglement entropy is expected to remain finite without introducing a cutoff hypersurface. It would be interesting to investigate whether the renormalized generalized entropy obeys a second law in our semiclassical model, despite the possible increase or decrease of the bulk horizon area due to the flux of the horizon generators across the cutoff hypersurface.

Acknowledgments

We wish to thank Gary T. Horowitz and Donald Marolf for useful discussions. This work is supported in part by JSPS KAKENHI Grant No. 25K07306 (K.M.) and also in part supported by MEXT KAKENHI Grant-in-Aid for Transformative Research Areas A Extreme Universe No.21H05186 (A.I. and K.M.) and 21H05182 and JSPS KAKENHI Grant No. JP26K07105.

Symplectic potential and the Noether current

Here we collect several formulas. The variations are taken for the lower-index quantities. However, for simplicity of notation, we often use mixed indices. For instance, δGNM\delta G^{M}_{N} implies gMLδGLNg^{ML}\delta G_{LN} rather than δ(gMLGLN)\delta(g^{ML}G_{LN}). Θ(d)\Theta^{(d)}, Θct(d−1)\Theta_{\mathrm{ct}}^{(d-1)}, and Θbdy(d−1)\Theta_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{(d-1)} are derived from the action (12) and (8) as

ΘK2⋯Kd+1=ϵMK2⋯Kd+116πGd+1(∇NδGNM−∇MδGNN),(76)\Theta_{K_{2}\cdots K_{d+1}}=\frac{\epsilon_{M K_{2}\cdots K_{d+1}}}{16\pi G_{d+1}}\left(\nabla_{N}\delta G^{M}_{N}-\nabla^{M}\delta G^{N}_{N}\right), \tag*{(76)}
Θ~ν2⋯νdbdy=ϵ~μν2⋯νd(Θ(0)μ+∑i=13αiΘ(i)μ).(77)\widetilde{\Theta}^{\mathrm{bdy}}_{\nu_{2}\cdots\nu_{d}}=\widetilde{\epsilon}_{\mu\nu_{2}\cdots\nu_{d}}\left(\Theta^{\mu}_{(0)}+\sum_{i=1}^{3}\alpha_{i}\Theta^{\mu}_{(i)}\right). \tag*{(77)}

where Θ(0)μ\Theta^{\mu}_{(0)} and Θ(i)μ\Theta^{\mu}_{(i)} are defined by

Θ(0)μ=116πGd(DνδGνμ−DμδG),(78)\Theta^{\mu}_{(0)}=\frac{1}{16\pi G_{d}}\left(D^{\nu}\delta G^{\mu}_{\nu}-D^{\mu}\delta G\right), \tag*{(78)}
Θ(1)μ=116πGd[−2(DνR)δGνμ+2(DμR)δG+2RDνδGνμ−2RDμδG],(79)\Theta^{\mu}_{(1)}=\frac{1}{16\pi G_{d}}\left[-2(D^{\nu}R)\delta G^{\mu}_{\nu}+2(D^{\mu}R)\delta G+2RD^{\nu}\delta G^{\mu}_{\nu}-2RD^{\mu}\delta G\right], \tag*{(79)}
Θ(2)μ=116πGd[−RρνDμδGρν+δGρνDμRρν−RμρDρδG+(DρRρμ)δG+2RρνDρδGνμ−2δGνμDρRμν],(80)\Theta^{\mu}_{(2)}=\frac{1}{16\pi G_{d}}\left[-R^{\rho\nu}D^{\mu}\delta G_{\rho\nu}+\delta G_{\rho\nu}D^{\mu}R^{\rho\nu}-R^{\mu\rho}D_{\rho}\delta G+(D_{\rho}R^{\rho\mu})\delta G+2R^{\rho\nu}D_{\rho}\delta G^{\mu}_{\nu}-2\delta G^{\mu}_{\nu}D_{\rho}R^{\mu\nu}\right], \tag*{(80)}
Θ(3)μ=14πGd(RμναβDαδGνβ−δGανDρRρναμ).(81)\Theta^{\mu}_{(3)}=\frac{1}{4\pi G_{d}}\left(R^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}D_{\alpha}\delta G_{\nu\beta}-\delta G^{\alpha\nu}D^{\rho}R_{\rho\nu\alpha}{}^{\mu}\right). \tag*{(81)}

For an arbitrary vector field ξμ\xi^{\mu}, substituting

δGμν=Dμξν+Dνξμ(82)\delta G_{\mu\nu}=D_{\mu}\xi_{\nu}+D_{\nu}\xi_{\mu} \tag*{(82)}

into (A.2), one obtains

Θ(0)μ=Dν(Dνξμ−Dμξν)16πGd+R ξμξα8πGd,(83)\Theta^{\mu}_{(0)}=\frac{D_{\nu}(D^{\nu}\xi^{\mu}-D^{\mu}\xi^{\nu})}{16\pi G_{d}}+\frac{R^{\mu}_{\ \xi}\xi^{\alpha}}{8\pi G_{d}}, \tag*{(83)}
Θ(1)μ=14πGd[D2Rδνμ−DμDνR+RRνμ]ξν+14πGdDν(RD[νξμ]−2D[νR ξμ]),(84)\Theta^{\mu}_{(1)}=\frac{1}{4\pi G_{d}}\left[D^{2}R\delta^{\mu}_{\nu}-D^{\mu}D_{\nu}R+RR^{\mu}_{\nu}\right]\xi^{\nu}+\frac{1}{4\pi G_{d}}D_{\nu}\left(RD^{[\nu}\xi^{\mu]}-2D^{[\nu}R\,\xi^{\mu]}\right), \tag*{(84)}
Θ(2)μ=116πGd[2D2Rνμ−2DμDνR+D2Rδνμ+4R ρνβμRρβ]ξν+18πGdDν(D[ρξμ]R ρν−D[ρξν]R ρμ−ξ[μDν]R+2ξρD[μR ρν]).(85)\Theta^{\mu}_{(2)}=\frac{1}{16\pi G_{d}}\left[2D^{2}R^{\mu}_{\nu}-2D^{\mu}D_{\nu}R+D^{2}R\delta^{\mu}_{\nu}+4R^{\mu}_{\ \rho\nu\beta}R^{\rho\beta}\right]\xi^{\nu}+\frac{1}{8\pi G_{d}}D_{\nu}\left(D^{[\rho}\xi^{\mu]}R^{\nu}_{\ \rho}-D^{[\rho}\xi^{\nu]}R^{\mu}_{\ \rho}-\xi^{[\mu}D^{\nu]}R+2\xi^{\rho}D^{[\mu}R^{\nu]}_{\ \rho}\right). \tag*{(85)}
Θ(3)μ=18πGd[−2DμDνR+4RμρνβRρβ−4RνρRμρ+4D2Rμν+2RμγβρRνγβρ]ξν+14πGdDν(Rρβ[νμ]Dβξρ+4ξρD[μRν]ρ).(86)\Theta_{(3)}^{\mu} = \frac{1}{8\pi G_d}\left[-2D^\mu D_\nu\mathcal{R} + 4\mathcal{R}^{\mu}{}_{\rho\nu\beta}\mathcal{R}^{\rho\beta} - 4\mathcal{R}_{\nu}{}^{\rho}\mathcal{R}^{\mu}{}_{\rho} + 4D^2\mathcal{R}^{\mu}{}_{\nu} + 2\mathcal{R}^{\mu}{}_{\gamma\beta\rho}\mathcal{R}_{\nu}{}^{\gamma\beta\rho}\right]\xi^\nu+ \frac{1}{4\pi G_d}D_\nu\left(\mathcal{R}_{\rho\beta}{}^{[\nu\mu]}D^\beta\xi^\rho+ 4\xi^\rho D^{[\mu}\mathcal{R}^{\nu]}{}_\rho\right). \tag*{(86)}

This yields

Θ~ν2⋯νdbdy=ϵ~μν2⋯νd(DνQbdyμν+Eμνξν8πGd+Lbdyξμ).(87)\widetilde{\Theta}^{\mathrm{bdy}}_{\nu_2\cdots\nu_d} = \widetilde{\epsilon}_{\mu\nu_2\cdots\nu_d}\left(D_\nu Q_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu} + \frac{\mathcal{E}^{\mu\nu}\xi^\nu}{8\pi G_d} + L_{\mathrm{bdy}}\xi^\mu\right). \tag*{(87)}

where QbdyμνQ_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu} is defined by

Qbdyμν≔−18πGd[D[μξν]−2α1(RD[νξμ]−2D[νRξμ])−α2(D[ρξμ]Rρν−D[ρξν]Rρμ−ξ[μDν]R+2ξρD[μRν]ρ)+2α3(Rρβ[μν]Dβξρ−4ξρD[μRν]ρ)].(88)Q_{\mathrm{bdy}}^{\mu\nu} \coloneqq-\frac{1}{8\pi G_d}\left[\mathcal{D}^{[\mu}\xi^{\nu]} - 2\alpha_1\left(\mathcal{R}D^{[\nu}\xi^{\mu]} - 2D^{[\nu}\mathcal{R}\xi^{\mu]}\right) - \alpha_2\left(D^{[\rho}\xi^{\mu]}\mathcal{R}_{\rho}{}^\nu- D^{[\rho}\xi^{\nu]}\mathcal{R}_{\rho}{}^\mu- \xi^{[\mu}D^{\nu]}\mathcal{R} + 2\xi^\rho D^{[\mu}\mathcal{R}^{\nu]}{}_\rho\right) + 2\alpha_3\left(\mathcal{R}_{\rho\beta}{}^{[\mu\nu]}D^\beta\xi^\rho- 4\xi^\rho D^{[\mu}\mathcal{R}^{\nu]}{}_\rho\right)\right]. \tag*{(88)}

Similarly, we first have

Θν2⋯νdct=ϵμν2⋯νd{DνQctμν−2Ectνξμ+Lctξμ}.(89)\Theta^{\mathrm{ct}}_{\nu_2\cdots\nu_d} = \epsilon_{\mu\nu_2\cdots\nu_d}\left\{D_\nu Q_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu} - 2E_{\mathrm{ct}}^\nu\xi^\mu+ L_{\mathrm{ct}}\xi^\mu\right\}. \tag*{(89)}

Then, QctμνQ_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu} and the rest of the corresponding formulas for the counter-term can be obtained from the above quantities by the following replacements,

1Gd→−LGd+1(d−2),α1→−d4cdL2(d−1)(d−2),α2→cdL2d−2,α3→0,Gμν→gμν,Dμ→Dμ.\frac{1}{G_d}\to\frac{-L}{G_{d+1}(d-2)},\qquad\alpha_1\to-\frac{d}{4}\frac{c_dL^2}{(d-1)(d-2)},\qquad\alpha_2\to\frac{c_dL^2}{d-2},\qquad\alpha_3\to0,\qquad G_{\mu\nu}\to g_{\mu\nu},\qquad D_\mu\to D_\mu.

The derivation of Eq. (3.10)

According to the AdS/CFT dictionary [11], the vacuum expectation value of the stress-energy tensor ⟨Tμν⟩\langle T^{\mu\nu}\rangle is derived from the variation of the bulk on-shell action (12) as

⟨Tμν⟩=lim⁡ϵ→02−gδIδGμν∣On−shell=lim⁡ϵ→01Ωd+2[−Kμν+Kgμν8πGd+1+2Ectμν].(90)\langle T^{\mu\nu}\rangle= \lim_{\epsilon\to0}\left.\frac{2}{\sqrt{-g}}\frac{\delta I}{\delta G_{\mu\nu}}\right|_{\mathrm{On-shell}} = \lim_{\epsilon\to0}\frac{1}{\Omega^{d+2}}\left[\frac{-K^{\mu\nu}+Kg^{\mu\nu}}{8\pi G_{d+1}} + 2E_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu\nu}\right]. \tag*{(90)}

Let nMn^M be the future-directed timelike unit normal vector to SϵS_\epsilon and mMm^M be the outward spacelike unit normal vector to SϵS_\epsilon. Under the metric ansatz (39), these two unit normal vectors can be explicitly written as

nM=Ωuf(1+ϵξT)−12(∂t)M,mM=−Ω(∂z)M.(91)n^M = \Omega\sqrt{\frac{u}{f}}(1+\epsilon\xi T)^{-\frac{1}{2}}(\partial_t)^M,\qquad m^M=-\Omega(\partial_z)^M. \tag*{(91)}

Then, the bulk Noether charge (24) can be expressed by the extrinsic curvature KμνK_{\mu\nu} (13) as

QE=∫SϵQ(d−1)(ξ)=∫SϵmNnMQMN=18πGd+1∫SϵnμKμνξν.(92)Q_E=\int_{S_\epsilon}Q^{(d-1)}(\xi)=\int_{S_\epsilon}m^Nn^MQ_{MN}=\frac{1}{8\pi G_{d+1}}\int_{S_\epsilon}n_\mu K^{\mu}{}_\nu\xi^\nu. \tag*{(92)}

where in the second and third integrals, the volume element of Sϵ(d−1)\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}^{(d-1)} is understood. Substituting Eq. (B.3) into Eq. (28), we finally obtain

QE(ren)(ξ)=lim⁡ϵ→0[18πGd+1∫SϵnμKμνξν−∫SϵKξ(d)8πGd+1−2∫Sϵϵμν2ν3⋯νdEctμξν]=lim⁡ϵ→0∫Sϵϵμν2ν3⋯νd(Kνμ−δνμK8πGd+1−2Ectνμ)ξν=−∫Sϵϵ~μν2ν3⋯νd⟨Tνμ⟩ξν=−∫Sϵn~μ⟨Tνμ⟩ξν,(93)\begin{aligned} Q_{\mathrm{E}}^{(\mathrm{ren})}(\xi)=\lim_{\epsilon\to0}\left[\frac{1}{8\pi G_{d+1}}\int_{\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}}n_{\mu}K^{\mu\nu}\xi_{\nu}-\int_{\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}}\frac{K\xi^{(d)}}{8\pi G_{d+1}}-2\int_{\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}}\epsilon^{\mu\nu_{2}\nu_{3}\cdots\nu_{d}}E_{\mathrm{ct}}^{\mu}\xi^{\nu}\right] \\ &=\lim_{\epsilon\to0}\int_{\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}}\epsilon^{\mu\nu_{2}\nu_{3}\cdots\nu_{d}}\left(\frac{K^{\mu}_{\nu}-\delta^{\mu}_{\nu}K}{8\pi G_{d+1}}-2E_{\mathrm{ct}}{}^{\mu}_{\nu}\right)\xi^{\nu} \\ &=-\int_{\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}}\widetilde{\epsilon}^{\mu\nu_{2}\nu_{3}\cdots\nu_{d}}\langle T^{\mu}_{\nu}\rangle\xi^{\nu}=-\int_{\mathcal{S}_{\epsilon}}\widetilde{n}_{\mu}\langle T^{\mu}_{\nu}\rangle\xi^{\nu}, \tag*{(93)} \end{aligned}

where ϵ~(d)=lim⁡ϵ→0Ωdϵ(d)\widetilde{\epsilon}^{(d)}=\lim_{\epsilon\to0}\Omega^{d}\epsilon^{(d)} is the Levi-Civita volume form associated with the conformal metric GμνG_{\mu\nu}, and in the last equality, we have used Eq. (B.1).

Curvature tensors

Following Ref. [22], the perturbations of the Ricci tensor RμνR^{\nu}_{\mu}, higher curvature tensors Hμ(i)νH_{\mu}^{(i)\nu} in Eqs. (3.4b) are derived as

δ(Rμσgνσ)=−ϵΩ2m22ξHμν,(94)\delta(R_{\mu\sigma}g^{\nu\sigma})=-\frac{\epsilon\Omega^{2}m^{2}}{2}\xi H_{\mu}^{\nu}, \tag*{(94)}
δ(Hμσ(1)gνσ)=−ϵd(d−1)ℓ2Ω4m2ξHμν,(95)\delta(H_{\mu\sigma}^{(1)}g^{\nu\sigma})=-\epsilon\frac{d(d-1)}{\ell^{2}}\Omega^{4}m^{2}\xi H_{\mu}^{\nu}, \tag*{(95)}
δ(Hμσ(2)gνσ)=−ϵΩ4m22(m2+2(d−1)ℓ2)ξHμν.(96)\delta(H_{\mu\sigma}^{(2)}g^{\nu\sigma})=-\epsilon\Omega^{4}\frac{m^{2}}{2}\left(m^{2}+\frac{2(d-1)}{\ell^{2}}\right)\xi H_{\mu}^{\nu}. \tag*{(96)}

References

  1. [1]R. Bousso, Z. Fisher, S. Leichenauer and A. C. Wall, “Quantum focusing conjecture,” Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) no.6, 064044 doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.93.064044 [arXiv:1506.02669 [hep-th]].
  2. [2]R. Penrose, Gravitational collapse and space-time singularities, Phys. Rev. Lett. 14, 57 (1967).
  3. [3]A. C. Wall, “The Generalized Second Law implies a Quantum Singularity Theorem,” Class. Quant. Grav. 30 (2013), 165003 [erratum: Class. Quant. Grav. 30 (2013), 199501] doi:10.1088/0264-9381/30/19/199501 [arXiv:1010.5513 [gr-qc]].
  4. [4]R. Bousso, “Robust Singularity Theorem,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 135 (2025) no.1, 011501 doi:10.1103/69b-3jmx [arXiv:2501.17910 [hep-th]].arxiv.org/abs/2501.17910
  5. [5]N. Engelhardt and I. Nagar, “A Quantum Singularity Theorem for the Evaporating Black Hole,” [arXiv:2605.05326 [hep-th]].arxiv.org/abs/2605.05326
  6. [6]N. Engelhardt and A. C. Wall, “Quantum Extremal Surfaces: Holographic Entanglement Entropy beyond the Classical Regime,” JHEP 01 (2015), 073 doi:10.1007/JHEP01(2015)073 [arXiv:1408.3203 [hep-th]].DOI
  7. [7]G. Penington, “Entanglement Wedge Reconstruction and the Information Paradox,” JHEP 09 (2020), 002 doi:10.1007/JHEP09(2020)002 [arXiv:1905.08255 [hep-th]].DOI
  8. [8]D. N. Page, “Information in black hole radiation,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 71 (1993), 3743-3746 doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.71.3743 [arXiv:hep-th/9306083 [hep-th]].DOI
  9. [9]N. Iizuka, A. Ishibashi, K. Maeda, H. Nakayama and T. Nishioka, Can. J. Phys. 104, 1-33 (2026) doi:10.1139/cjp-2025-0271 [arXiv:2509.01286 [hep-th]].
  10. [10]S. Ryu and T. Takayanagi, “Holographic derivation of entanglement entropy from AdS/CFT,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 96 (2006), 181602 doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.96.181602 [arXiv:hep-th/0603001 [hep-th]].DOI
  11. [11]J. M. Maldacena, “The Large N limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity,” Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 2 (1998), 231-252 doi:10.4310/ATMP.1998.v2.n2.a1 [arXiv:hep-th/9711200 [hep-th]].DOI
  12. [12]R. M. Wald, Phys. Rev. D 48 (1993) no.8, R3427-R3431 doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.48.R3427 [arXiv:gr-qc/9307038 [gr-qc]].DOI
  13. [13]T. Faulkner, M. Guica, T. Hartman, R. C. Myers and M. Van Raamsdonk, “Gravitation from Entanglement in Holographic CFTs,” JHEP 03 (2014), 051 doi:10.1007/JHEP03(2014)051 [arXiv:1312.7856 [hep-th]].DOI
  14. [14]A. Ishibashi and K. Maeda, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021) no.2, 026004 doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.104.026004 [arXiv:2104.01862 [hep-th]].DOI
  15. [15]V. Iyer and R. M. Wald, “Some properties of Noether charge and a proposal for dynamical black hole entropy,” Phys. Rev. D 50 (1994), 846-864 doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.50.846 [arXiv:gr-qc/9403028 [gr-qc]].
  16. [16]G. Compere and D. Marolf, “Setting the boundary free in AdS/CFT,” Class. Quant. Grav. 25, 195014 (2008) doi:10.1088/0264-9381/25/19/195014 [arXiv:0805.1902 [hep-th]].DOI
  17. [17]A. Ishibashi, K. Maeda and T. Okamura, “Semiclassical Einstein equations from holography and boundary dynamics,” JHEP 05 (2023), 212 doi:10.1007/JHEP05(2023)212 [arXiv:2301.12170 [hep-th]].DOI
  18. [18]J. Maldacena and G. L. Pimentel, JHEP 02 (2013), 038 doi:10.1007/JHEP02(2013)038 [arXiv:1210.7244 [hep-th]].DOI
  19. [19]K. Narayan, Phys. Rev. D 91 (2015) no.12, 126011 doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.91.126011 [arXiv:1501.03019 [hep-th]].DOI
  20. [20]G. W. Gibbons and S. W. Hawking, Phys. Rev. D 15 (1977), 2738-2751 doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.15.2738DOI
  21. [21]V. Chandrasekaran, R. Longo, G. Penington and E. Witten, JHEP 02 (2023), 082 doi:10.1007/JHEP02(2023)082 [arXiv:2206.10780 [hep-th]].DOI
  22. [22]A. Ishibashi, K. Maeda and T. Okamura, JHEP 05 (2026), 308 doi:10.1007/JHEP05(2026)308 [arXiv:2512.00503 [hep-th]].DOI
  23. [23]A. Ishibashi, K. Maeda and T. Okamura, JHEP 04 (2025), 167 doi:10.1007/JHEP04(2025)167 [arXiv:2412.18764 [hep-th]].DOI
  24. [24]W. Bunting, Z. Fu and D. Marolf, Class. Quant. Grav. 33 (2016) no.5, 055008 doi:10.1088/0264-9381/33/5/055008 [arXiv:1509.00074 [hep-th]].DOI
  25. [25]S. W. Hawking and G. F. R. Ellis, The Large Scale Structure of Space-Time (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1973).

Paper details

vlnc:W_7rpecp2g
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents