betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Wannier Topology and Quadrupole Moments for a generalized Benalcazar-Bernevig-Hughes Model

Abstract

We analyze a special separable and chiral-symmetric model with a quantized quadrupole moment, extending the Benalcazar-Bernevig-Hughes model [Science 357, 61 (2017)]. Using nested-Wilson loop formalism, we give an exact expression for Wannier centers, sector polarizations, and quadrupole moments. These are connected to the winding numbers of the constitutive one-dimensional chains. We prove that these winding numbers can characterize the model's Wannier topology as a Z×Z\mathbb{Z}\times\mathbb{Z} set. These results clearly show that the quantization of the quadrupole moment can arise without additional spatial symmetry (except for translation symmetry) for the bulk. By switching from the Wannier representation to the Bloch representation, we derive an alternative expression for the bulk quadrupole moment and obtain its exact value. Combining the bulk quadrupole and edge polarizations, we analytically calculate the corner charge in a large square system and make the bulk-boundary correspondence explicit in an edge-consistent gauge. Our work reveals the relationship between zero-energy states at the boundary, charge localization, and the bulk quadrupole of the extended model.

Introduction

The use of the mathematical concept of topology has proven very powerful to describe edge states in systems where the topological invariant inside the material differs from that of the outside [2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9] [1, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18]. This concept has since been generalized to higher-order topological states following the work by Benalcazar, Bernevig, and Hughes (BBH) [19]. These include corner and hinge states, where a system in dd dimension can generate topological edge states in (d−n)(d-n) dimensions (n>1n > 1) [19–31]. In two dimensions, a prototypical example of a system with higher-order topological states is the BBH model, described by a simple Hamiltonian with only nearest-neighbor hopping terms and double mirror symmetry. This has been realized in various experimental setups, such as photonic [32, 33], phononic [34], acoustic [35], and microwave- and electrical-circuit systems [36–38]. The fractional corner charge in a finite system of the BBH model can be characterized by an off-diagonal quadrupole moment calculated through the nested-Wilson loop formalism [20, 39], where the quadrupole moment is defined as the multiplication of the Wannier-sector polarizations.

In the papers that started this field [19, 20], the general role of the symmetries in quantizing the quadrupole moment was discussed. It was shown that additional spatial symmetry is needed to quantize the Wannier-sector polarizations and hence for the quadrupole fractionalization. However, by calculating the quadrupole using many-body operators in real space, it has been shown that chiral symmetry can also protect the quantized quadrupole moment in a disordered BBH model [40]. Even though the definitions of the quadrupole moment in Refs. [19, 20] and Ref. [40] have not been proven equivalent mathematically, the latter study about a model without additional spatial symmetries leads us to ask the following question: Can we quantize the quadrupole moment and characterize the Wannier band topology through the Wilson formalism in some cases beyond the BBH model without additional spatial symmetry? This is the first question we attempt to answer in this paper.

Recently, a systematic framework to calculate the quadrupole moment and the corner charge using the Wannier functions has been introduced in Ref. [41]. The researchers have applied it to the BBH model and numerically obtained the same corner charge as was found in the original papers, while the quadrupole moment is gauge dependent. As there is no analytical proof of the connection between the quadrupole moment in the Wannier representation [41–48] and the Wilson-loop formalism, it leads to the question about the relationship between the two and especially when they are equal. Therefore, the second question we will try to address is the following: Can we build an analytic connection between these two definitions of the bulk quadrupole moment and thus give the correct correspondence between the bulk quadrupole moment and the corner charge (bulk-boundary correspondence)?

The BBH model is built from one-dimensional (1D) Su-Schrieffer-Heeger (SSH) chains, with a suitable chosen cross-chain coupling. Here, to answer the two questions we have proposed, we study a generalized two-dimensional (2D) model by extending all 1D SSH chains of the BBH model to general two-band chiral-symmetric chains. We call this model the “generalized BBH model”, which was first proposed in Refs. [49, 50].

We calculate the Wannier centers and polarizations by finding the exact expression for the Wilson loops along two orthogonal axes in the first Brillouin Zone (FBZ). Applying these results to the analysis of the Wannier bands, we show that their topology is indeed characterized by two winding numbers and analyze the discontinuous displacement of the Wannier centers by continuously changing the parameters. Furthermore, we evaluate a simple expression for the quantized quadrupole moment through the Wilson formalism. We find that the Wannier sector polarizations and quadrupole moment are determined by the fractional parts of the winding numbers of the constitutive chains in the corresponding direction. Thus, we conclude that the quantization of the quadrupole moment of the generalized BBH model does not require additional spatial symmetry, such as mirror or C4C_4 rotation symmetries.

Applying the Fourier transformation to the quadrupole evaluated as the expectation value of the position operator in the Wannier functions of the central unit cell[41–48], we can define a quadrupole invariant in the Bloch representation. We calculate this invariant for the bulk of the generalized BBH model in a specific gauge and prove that its fractional part is equal to the quadrupole moment defined in the Wilson formalism [19, 20]. However, as discussed in Refs [41, 47], the quadrupole invariant is gauge-dependent, and thus cannot be used to define a gauge-invariant corner charge. We then combine it with the edge polarizations with an edge-consistent gauge mimicking the idea from Ref. [41]. We find that the corner charge is equal to the fractional value given by the quadrupole moment in the Wilson formalism and obtain the correct bulk-boundary correspondence. These results provide an answer to our second question within the generalized BBH model.

1D TWO-BAND INSULATOR WITH CHIRAL SYMMETRY

We first review the model of a 1D two-band insulator with chiral symmetry in order to gain insight into the interplay between this symmetry and topology. The Bloch Hamiltonian of the 1D model can be written as

h(k)=b(k)⋅σ=b1(k)σ1+b2(k)σ2,(1)h(k)=\mathbf{b}(k)\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}=b^1(k)\sigma_1+b^2(k)\sigma_2, \tag*{(1)}

where the vector b(k)\mathbf{b}(k) will be called the “characteristic vector” and k∈[0,2π]k\in[0,2\pi] is a 1D wavevector. The vanishing of the third component b3(k)b^3(k) is a consequence of chiral symmetry: {h(k),σ3}=0\{h(k),\sigma_3\}=0. The eigen-energies of h(k)h(k) are ±∣b(k)∣\pm|\mathbf{b}(k)|.

To define the electric polarization, one should solve for the eigenvalues of the position operator projected onto the occupied bands. This reduces to the calculation of the Wilson loop [19, 20], as reviewed in the Supplementary Material (SM) [51]. It can be proven that the electric polarization is determined by the Zak-Berry phase as an integral of the Berry connection of the occupied band A(b)=iψ−†∂bψ−\mathcal{A}(\mathbf{b})=i\psi_-^\dagger\partial_{\mathbf{b}}\psi_- in the characteristic vector space along a closed loop C:k∈[0,2π]→b(k)\mathcal{C}:k\in[0,2\pi]\to\mathbf{b}(k) as

p=12π∮Cdb⋅A(b) mod 1=N2 mod 1.(2)p=\frac{1}{2\pi}\oint_{\mathcal{C}}d\mathbf{b}\cdot\mathcal{A}(\mathbf{b})\bmod1=\frac{\mathcal{N}}{2}\bmod1. \tag*{(2)}

Note that we set the electron charge e=1e=1 throughout this paper. The integer N\mathcal{N} is the winding number of C\mathcal{C} around the origin. Thus, the energy gap 2∣b(k)∣2|\mathbf{b}(k)| must close when N\mathcal{N} changes. The topological phases of this 1D model correspond to the AIII topological class [17, 52]. We choose the eigenstates of Eq. (1) to be

ψ±=(b1−ib2,±∣b∣)T/2∣b∣2.(3)\psi_\pm=(b^1-ib^2,\pm|\mathbf{b}|)^T/\sqrt{2|\mathbf{b}|^2}. \tag*{(3)}

In this gauge choice, the Zak phase in Eq. (2) gives the exact fractional winding number. The exact number of zero modes at each endpoint of a finite chain is also equal to this winding number N\mathcal{N} [3] [16, 53]. This is called the bulk-boundary correspondence [14, 16, 17], and hints that the chosen gauge is physically sufficient in characterizing the topological zero modes.

THE GENERALIZED BBH MODEL

In Refs. [19, 20], the authors propose a 2D crystal with vanishing bulk dipole moments and a non-zero quantized off-diagonal quadrupole moment. That model can be regarded as a network composed of perpendicular SSH chains arranged in a square lattice with a π\pi flux threading each square plaquette. The resulting spectrum consists of four bands, and the system is insulating at half-filling whenever the hopping parameters in the xx and yy directions are different. In this paper, we generalize this model by replacing the SSH chains with 1D two-band insulators described in Sec. II above. The corresponding Bloch Hamiltonian is

H(kx,ky)=hx(kx)⊗τ3+σ0⊗hy(ky),(4)\mathcal{H}(k_x,k_y)=h_x(k_x)\otimes\tau_3+\sigma_0\otimes h_y(k_y), \tag*{(4)}

where hx(kx)=bx(kx)⋅σh_x(k_x)=\mathbf{b}_x(k_x)\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}, hy(ky)=by(ky)⋅τh_y(k_y)=\mathbf{b}_y(k_y)\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}. The four sub-lattice sites in one unit cell are denoted as ∣αx,βy⟩\lvert\alpha_x,\beta_y\rangle (α,β=A\alpha,\beta=A or BB) and shown in Figure 1(a). The Pauli matrix τ3\tau_3 in the Hamiltonian H(k)\mathcal{H}(\mathbf{k}) reflects the presence of a π\pi flux. The characteristic vectors for each of the hμh_\mu Hamiltonians (μ=x,y\mu=x,y) can be written as

Generalized BBH model and coupling of BBH lattice layers

Figure 1. (a) A generalized BBH model with an additional long-range hopping in the xx-direction. The dashed lines correspond to the negative hopping terms with minus signs. (b) Coupling two BBH lattice layers with a stacking fault or AB stacking pattern.

bμ(kμ)=∣bμ(kμ)∣(cos⁡ϕμ(kμ),sin⁡ϕμ(kμ),0),(5)\mathbf{b}_\mu(k_\mu)=\lvert\mathbf{b}_\mu(k_\mu)\rvert\left(\cos\phi_\mu(k_\mu),\sin\phi_\mu(k_\mu),0\right), \tag*{(5)}

and the eigen-energies of H(k)\mathcal{H}(\mathbf{k}) are

E±(k)=±∣bx(kx)∣2+∣by(ky)∣2.(6)E_\pm(\mathbf{k})=\pm\sqrt{\lvert\mathbf{b}_x(k_x)\rvert^2+\lvert\mathbf{b}_y(k_y)\rvert^2}. \tag*{(6)}

The existence of the two bands at opposite energies is caused by an anticommuting chiral symmetry operation, i.e. the symmetry {H(k),σ3⊗τ3}=0\{\mathcal{H}(\mathbf{k}),\sigma_3\otimes\tau_3\}=0. The special separable form of the model of Eq. (4) also has a symmetry as {H(k),σ1⊗τ2K}=0\{\mathcal{H}(\mathbf{k}),\sigma_1\otimes\tau_2K\}=0 (where KK denotes complex conjugation). Applying these two symmetries, we can prove that both bands are twofold degenerate due to a sub-lattice symmetry, i.e. [H(k),σ2⊗τ1K]=0[\mathcal{H}(\mathbf{k}),\sigma_2\otimes\tau_1K]=0. Note that all these (anti-)symmetries do not connect the Hamiltonian at different values of k\mathbf{k} points and cannot be represented as a spatial symmetry. The eigenstates of the two degenerate negative-energy bands can be expressed as tensor products of the form

Ψ1(k)=ψx+(kx)⊗φ−(kx,ky),\Psi_1(\mathbf{k})=\psi_x^+(k_x)\otimes\varphi_-(k_x,k_y),
Ψ2(k)=ψx−(kx)⊗φ−(kx,ky).(7)\Psi_2(\mathbf{k})=\psi_x^-(k_x)\otimes\varphi_-(k_x,k_y). \tag*{(7)}

Here, ψx±(kx)\psi_x^\pm(k_x) are the eigenstates of hx(kx)h_x(k_x) with energies ±∣bx(k)∣\pm\lvert\mathbf{b}_x(k)\rvert, respectively. Furthermore, φ−n(k)\varphi_-^n(\mathbf{k}) (n=1,2n=1,2) is the eigenstate with the negative energy of the 2×22\times2 Hamiltonian

hxyn(k)=bxyn(k)⋅τ(8)h_{xy}^n(\mathbf{k})=\mathbf{b}_{xy}^n(\mathbf{k})\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau} \tag*{(8)}

whose characteristic vector is

bxyn(k)=(by1(ky),by2(ky),(−1)n−1∣bx(kx)∣).(9)\mathbf{b}_{xy}^n(\mathbf{k})=\left(b_y^1(k_y),b_y^2(k_y),(-1)^{n-1}\lvert\mathbf{b}_x(k_x)\rvert\right). \tag*{(9)}

For later discussion, we also define the polar angle of the characteristic vectors above as

θxy(k)=arccos⁡(∣bx∣/bx2+by2).(10)\theta_{xy}(\mathbf{k})=\arccos\left(\lvert b_x\rvert/\sqrt{b_x^2+b_y^2}\right). \tag*{(10)}

In passing, we note that the generalized BBH model described by Eq. (4) is a special case of the “separability-preserved” Hamiltonians proposed in Ref. [50].

For a 2D crystal, the bulk dipole moments in the directions μ=x,y\mu=x,y are determined by the 2D Zak phases [19, 20, 54, 55] as

pμ=12π∫BZTr⁡[Aμ(k)] d2kmod  1,(11)p_\mu=\frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{\mathrm{BZ}}\operatorname{Tr}[\mathcal{A}_\mu(\mathbf{k})]\,d^2\mathbf{k}\mod1, \tag*{(11)}

In the SM [51], we show that, for the generalized BBH model, the dipole moments are equal to

pμ=Nμmod  1,(12)p_\mu=\mathcal{N}_\mu\mod1, \tag*{(12)}

which are always trivial. The integrals (11) of the Berry connections Aμ\mathcal{A}_\mu over the occupied bands are the 2D Zak Berry phases, and Nμ\mathcal{N}_\mu are the winding numbers of the loops kμ→bμ(kμ)∈[0,2π]k_\mu\to\mathbf{b}_\mu(k_\mu)\in[0,2\pi].

An important part of our work is answering how to characterize the quadrupole moment of the generalized BBH model. To do that, one first has to obtain the Wilson loops [19, 20]. Using the definitions given above, we obtain an exact result for the Wilson loops along the xx and yy directions starting from the base point k=(kx,ky)\mathbf{k}=(k_x,k_y),

Wx,k(ky)=exp⁡[i∫02πdϕx(kx′)s0+sin⁡θxy(kx′,ky)s12],(13)\mathcal{W}_{x,\mathbf{k}(k_y)}=\exp\left[i\int_0^{2\pi}d\phi_x(k'_x)\frac{s_0+\sin\theta_{xy}(k'_x,k_y)s_1}{2}\right], \tag*{(13)}
Wy,k(kx)=exp⁡[i∫02πdϕy(ky′)s0−cos⁡θxy(kx,ky′)s32].(14)\mathcal{W}_{y,\mathbf{k}(k_x)}=\exp\left[i\int_0^{2\pi}d\phi_y(k'_y)\frac{s_0-\cos\theta_{xy}(k_x,k'_y)s_3}{2}\right]. \tag*{(14)}

References

  1. [2]W. A. Benalcazar, B. A. Bernevig, and T. L. Hughes, Quantized electric multipole insulators, Science 357, 61–66 (2017).
  2. [3]R. Resta, Macroscopic polarization in crystalline dielectrics: the geometric phase approach, Rev. Mod. Phys. 66, 899 (1994).
  3. [4]F. Liu and K. Wakabayashi, Novel topological phase with a zero berry curvature, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 076803 (2017).
  4. [5]C. Li and A. E. Miroshnichenko, Extended ssh model: Non-local couplings and non-monotonous edge states, Physics 1, 2 (2019).DOI
  5. [6]C.-A. Li and S.-S. Wu, Topological states in generalized electric quadrupole insulators, Phys. Rev. B 101, 195309 (2020).DOI
  6. [7]R. Resta, The insulating state of matter: a geometrical theory, The European Physical Journal B 79, 121 (2011).DOI
  7. [8]I. Souza, T. Wilkens, and R. M. Martin, Polarization and localization in insulators: Generating function approach, Phys. Rev. B 62, 1666 (2000).DOI
  8. [9]S. Ono, L. Trifunovic, and H. Watanabe, Difficulties in operator-based formulation of the bulk quadrupole moment, Phys. Rev. B 100, 245133 (2019).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_86ztw852
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents