WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Where should we look for the deviation from quantum mechanics?
Abstract
We argue that the experimental measurement of the lifetime and decay law of metastable helium is a promising way to find a deviation from quantum mechanics. We analyze the decay of the metastable state for a quartic deformation of quantum mechanics. We find that the absolute change of the mean lifetime can be significant even if the modification is small. We show that, in the Wigner–Weisskopf approximation, the deviation from the exponential law in the modified theory can occur on time scales comparable with the lifetime.
Introduction
It is natural to verify the predictions of quantum mechanics (QM) at the level of elementary particles or atoms by analyzing their energy levels, scattering or decay. If the deviation from quantum mechanics is small, then the shift of energy levels should also be small; the modification of scattering may be even smaller because the collision time is short. This suggests studying the decay of almost stable particles or atoms. We can arrive at the same conclusion by noticing that the relative change of the width is the same as the relative change of the lifetime , to first order in . (Here stands for the decay rate (width), denotes the lifetime, and denotes a small change.) One should expect that is small, but even in this case can be large for long-lived particles. It seems that a good chance to find a violation of the rules of quantum mechanics is to analyze the lifetime and decay law of metastable helium experimentally. The choice of this atom is prompted by the fact that its lifetime is really long (about two hours) and by the fact that the lifetime can be calculated theoretically (for more complicated atoms it is very difficult to calculate the lifetime precisely). The lifetime of metastable helium was studied in [1]. The measured value, 7870(510) s, has a relative uncertainty of about 6.5% and agrees with the theoretical prediction [2] within this uncertainty. A more precise experiment can either confirm QM within experimental accuracy or show some deviation from QM.
We study the decay of the metastable state of helium in modified quantum mechanics. The modification can be constructed either in the framework of Weinberg’s nonlinear quantum mechanics [3] or in the framework of the paper [4], where quantum mechanics was interpreted as classical mechanics close to equilibrium. The use of [4] leads to simpler calculations. We will follow this paper. (Notice, however, that Weinberg’s nonlinear quantum mechanics leads qualitatively to the same results with an appropriate choice of modification of QM, see the Appendix.) It follows from our calculations in § 4 that the absolute change in the mean lifetime can be appreciable even in the case when the modification is small. Another conclusion of § 4: generically the decay law is nonexponential on the lifetime scale in the Wigner–Weisskopf approximation, whereas the decay law of ordinary quantum mechanics is usually close to an exponential law everywhere except some intervals at the beginning and the end of the process. As we emphasized, metastable helium is a long-lived atom for which the lifetime can be calculated precisely from first principles. For long-lived atoms whose lifetime cannot be calculated precisely, finding the lifetime experimentally cannot by itself provide a test of quantum mechanics. However, an unexpected deviation from the exponential law can serve as an indication of a violation of the laws of quantum mechanics.
Lifetime of metastable helium
In this section we present a well-known calculation of the lifetime of metastable helium in the form appropriate for generalization. Field conventions and technical details are given in the Appendix.
Let us consider helium as a two-level quantum system. The lower level is the nondegenerate state , of energy , and the upper level is the triplet, of energy . The total electronic angular momentum quantum number is for this triplet. We use a Cartesian basis , , transforming as the components of a vector under rotations. Let be the reduced Planck constant. Define the positive energy gap and angular frequency .
With a suitable choice of phases, rotational invariance gives , where are the Cartesian components of the atomic magnetic-moment operator, is the Kronecker symbol and is a real transition coefficient.
The transition part of the interaction at the position of the atom is
Here are the components of the quantized magnetic field. For real metastable helium, is an effective transition magnetic moment. A photon mode has wave vector , polarization and angular frequency , where is the speed of light. Every sum over runs over all such modes. Let be the photon vacuum and the corresponding one-photon state. For emission, define
We retain the terms in (2.1) that conserve the number of atomic excitations plus photons. This is the rotating-wave approximation (RWA), which defines the effective model used below.
Take an initial normalized upper-state polarization , with , and no photons. The state of one atom and the field in the one-excitation sector is
We use a normalized joint state. The initial condition is , . We write where .
We introduce the notation
In this notation, the Schrödinger equations (A5)–(A6) of the Appendix give
Eliminating yields the memory equation
Rotational invariance in the continuum limit implies . Hence , and
The expression can be interpreted as the probability that the atom is still in the metastable state at time .
For any fixed , define the spectral density
where stands for the Dirac delta function.
The function is independent of in the isotropic limit. We use a spectral density completed at high frequency by a form factor, with . Its cubic form (A7), derived in the Appendix, is used only locally.
In the Wigner–Weisskopf approximation, the amplitude changes slowly over the memory time of the field. We replace by and extend the upper limit of the memory integral to infinity. We use “reduced” for quantities obtained in this approximation. Denote the reduced amplitude by . It obeys
Here stands for the Cauchy principal value. The quantity is a radiative shift in angular-frequency units. It affects the phase. Write for the upper probability in the reduced model, distinguished from the exact probability . In the ordinary model, . For the local cubic density (A7),
The comparison with the quartic model below is made within the Wigner–Weisskopf approximation and with the same reservoir.
The mean survival time, which will also be used for a nonexponential law, is defined by
It equals for the reduced exponential solution. In the one-excitation sector it integrates the upper electronic probability.
Quantum mechanics from classical mechanics. Deformation of quantum mechanics.
It was shown in [5, 6] that deterministic theories generalizing quantum mechanics can be obtained from classical mechanics with a restricted set of observables (we assume that our devices can measure only a part of the observables). Considering classical mechanics on complex projective space and defining “observable observables” as quadratic expressions, we obtain conventional quantum mechanics. (This construction is closely related to Weinberg’s nonlinear quantum mechanics.) Another particular case was described in [4], where it was proved that quantum mechanics can be considered as classical mechanics near equilibrium. (We assume that only observables that are quadratic with respect to coordinates and momenta can be measured and that the sum of squares of coordinates and momenta is an integral of motion. We should fix some value of this integral of motion.)
It is convenient to work in complex coordinates , . Then the integral of motion can be written in the form . It is invariant with respect to the gauge transformation , with real . One can consider as coordinates in an orthonormal basis of a complex Hilbert space. Then the integral of motion is the square of the norm. To obtain quantum mechanics, we should fix and consider quadratic classical observables. We fix throughout, consistently with the normalization in § 2.
Classical observables (in particular, classical Hamiltonians) should be gauge invariant. For a classical Hamiltonian , Hamilton’s equations have the form
(The derivative is taken with and treated as independent variables.)
A gauge transformation transforms a state into the same physical state. Therefore, a solution of Hamilton’s equations of the form , with a fixed vector and real frequency , is physically stationary: its entire time dependence is a gauge transformation.
“Observable observables” are gauge-invariant quadratic expressions , where is the Hilbert-space inner product and is a Hermitian operator. For a quadratic Hamiltonian , Hamilton’s equations are precisely the Schrödinger equation , and the quadratic observables evolve according to the Heisenberg equations. This means that, with a quadratic Hamiltonian, working only with “observable observables” we are dealing with quantum mechanics.
Now it is clear what we should do to slightly modify quantum mechanics: we should add to the quadratic Hamiltonian a small gauge-invariant quartic term.
The two-level system of the preceding section is described by the quadratic Hamiltonian where , , with the amplitude of and the amplitudes of the triplet states . We deform it by adding a small quartic term invariant with respect to rotations
Here , are real constants.
To obtain stationary states of the deformed Hamiltonian, we should solve the equation (3.1) with , that is,
It is easy to solve these equations using the assumption that , are small. The stationary energies are the values of the Hamiltonian on normalized stationary states, giving corrections and .
In what follows we take , so that only the metastable level is deformed: , and the stationary atomic energies are and .
In the rotating-wave approximation, the two-level system interacting with the electromagnetic field is described by a quadratic Hamiltonian depending, in the one-excitation sector, on and photonic variables in (3). (Recall that , , are the amplitudes of the three metastable states with no photon, and is the amplitude of the ground state together with one photon in mode .)
This quadratic Hamiltonian has the form
Here , as in § 2. Hamilton’s equations of are
These are exactly the Schrödinger equations (A5)–(A6).
To obtain a Hamiltonian describing the interaction of the two-level system with photons in the modified quantum theory, we add :
This is the chosen quartic deformation. Notice that we did not deform the Hamiltonian describing photons, and did not deform the magnetic moment .
Decay in the modified quantum theory
We now repeat the calculation of § 2 for the Hamiltonian (16). Hamilton’s equations are
They coincide with (A5)–(A6), except for the diagonal term in (17), coming from .
After substituting (4) into (17)–(18), we obtain the equations for and :
To remove the additional diagonal term in (19) directly, define
and set
The photon amplitudes are unchanged. The new amplitudes have the same moduli as , so the sector norms (A4) of the Appendix and are unchanged. The amplitudes and satisfy
which are (2.5)–(2.6) with the additional phase . Since , integration of (24) gives
Substitution into (23) yields
with the kernel of (7). The nonlinear part of the phase is independent of the photon mode . Rotational invariance again makes the kernel proportional to . A fixed upper polarization is preserved. Writing , the scalar memory equation is
Here and is the same kernel as in (9). This is the central reduction of the modified decay problem: the ordinary kernel is multiplied by the population-dependent phase. This equation is exact in the specified rotating-wave model. For , and it reduces to (8).
Nonlinear Wigner–Weisskopf approximation
The phase in the coupling has derivative , where
Thus is the resonance frequency when the population is frozen over the memory time, as is done below. The initial resonance-energy shift is twice the stationary energy correction , because the equations of motion involve the derivative of . The radiative shift is treated separately.
In the short-memory regime, and change little over the memory time of the field. We freeze the population at its current value in the phase and make the same replacement of the amplitude as in § 2. The ordinary calculation then applies locally in time, at the frequency . Define the rate as a function of the population by
and let be the radiative shift of (10) with replaced by . The reduced amplitude , with upper probability , obeys
Taking the derivative of , we obtain
The short-memory conditions for this step are discussed in the Appendix.
Consider the local cubic law (A7) and put
To first order in the quartic coefficient,
On bounded intervals of the scaled time , integration of the reduced law (30) gives
The term proportional to changes the shape of the curve.
Mean lifetime and decay curve
Since the reduced decay is generally not exponential, there is no unique definition of a lifetime. A natural choice is the mean survival time. When for , substituting in (12) gives
For the cubic law, expansion of the integrand using (32) yields
This is the correction relative to the ordinary model with the same gap , matrix element and reservoir. Equivalently, the absolute change of the mean is .
For a fixed spectral density that is twice continuously differentiable near , with , Taylor expansion more generally gives
Here and below, a prime on denotes a population derivative, with . The constants in these remainders may depend on the fixed reservoir.
The reference gap matters. The stationary atomic energies of Section 3 have difference . An ordinary atom with this corrected gap and the same coupling has rate . Equation (36) implies . Thus the mean agrees with that ordinary lifetime to first order, while the cubic reduced curve (33) changes shape at first order. This comparison uses , whereas (35) uses .
Variation of the decay rate. The logarithmic decay rate of the reduced solution is
Its initial and late values are
where the displayed expression for uses the cubic law. Both rates belong to the reduced description (see the Appendix). The initial effective lifetime is consequently . The different initial and late logarithmic rates show how the curve departs from an exponential on the decay timescale.
Expanding and the mean in (4.20) gives
If , both linear terms in (4.24) vanish. This relation does not require the cubic law or an independent value of . It compares quantities from a single reduced decay curve. For observations much shorter than the lifetime, the late rate and the mean must be inferred by extrapolation. The achievable precision then depends on the observation time, photon statistics and control of ordinary losses.
Differentiating (4.21) and using (4.14) gives
For the cubic rate, is convex for and concave for . More generally, through the frequency dependence of , the population-dependent resonance frequency (4.11) makes the reduced decay nonexponential whenever is positive and nonconstant on . Nonexponentiality of a measured survival does not by itself distinguish a deformation from ordinary loss processes.
Conclusion
We calculated the change in the mean lifetime of metastable helium in the case when quantum mechanics is slightly modified. We proved that in our approximation, for the cubic law (A7) and to first order in , this change is , where is the ordinary lifetime at the same gap . Taking into account that the lifetime is about two hours, we conclude that the change can be significant even if (the relative change of the energy level with respect to the gap between the excited state and ground state) is small.
A long lifetime enlarges this absolute change, but not the fractional mean-lifetime change at first order. At the corrected gap and with the same coupling, the mean agrees with the ordinary lifetime to first order, whereas the cubic decay curve changes shape at first order.
Metastable helium, whose ordinary radiative lifetime was calculated from first principles, provides a system in which these predictions can be compared with experiment.
We also analyzed the deviation from the exponential law of decay in modified quantum mechanics on the example of metastable helium. It is important to emphasize that our calculations can be generalized to other decay models with a specified deformation [7]. They show that in the situation when the lifetime cannot be calculated theoretically, one can hope to discover a violation of the laws of QM by looking at the deviation from the exponential law.
Acknowledgements
We are indebted to L.Alvarez-Gaume, M. Luty, N.Nekrasov, J.Terning, and A. Vainshtein for useful discussions.
AI (ChatGPT) was helpful in the preparation of this paper.
Appendix
Field and coupling conventions. In a normalization volume , use two transverse real orthonormal polarization vectors , with , for each wave vector . The photon angular frequency is , where is the speed of light. We use rationalized Heaviside–Lorentz electromagnetic units, with explicit. Each sum over runs over the nonzero wave vectors allowed in the normalization volume. Let and be the photon annihilation and creation operators. These operators satisfy . The one-photon state is .
In Coulomb gauge,
With the unit vector along axis , the coupling (2) satisfies
In the strict nonrelativistic Russell–Saunders, or -coupling, limit, the transition is forbidden. Relativistic and spin-dependent corrections generate the small physical matrix element [2].
Rotating-wave model. In the ordinary weak-coupling calculation, the omitted counterrotating terms create only off-resonant virtual states at leading order. They mainly affect energy renormalization and higher-order corrections and do not modify the leading on-shell (energy-conserving) decay rate. Writing , where the first term contains annihilation operators and the second their adjoints, the retained interaction is
Define the projectors and . The free Hamiltonian is , where . Tensor identities on the atomic and photon factors are suppressed. The operator commutes with .
Define the squared sector norms and their conserved sum by
In the variables of (3), the Schrödinger equation reads
Local cubic spectral density. For the point coupling (1) with constant , is cubic. Writing , we obtain
For a realistic atom, this expression is multiplied by an atomic form factor . The cubic expression is used locally, where the effective matrix element and may be treated as constant. The value of the measured rate fixes a normalization, but does not determine the local slope of the effective matrix element [2].
Formula (11) also follows from Fermi’s golden rule. In this approximation, the natural linewidth is , the full width at half maximum of the emission line in angular-frequency units.
Validity of the reduced description. For metastable helium, and the reported lifetime is about [1]. These scales give . The upper-state amplitude changes on a scale , while the field kernel changes on microscopic optical/atomic scales in the short-memory regime. The separation is about twenty orders of magnitude. With a form factor smooth on atomic frequency scales, is extremely smooth over the resonance width , so across this narrow interval. A bound on the memory error also requires information about the completed spectral density. No quantitative memory-error bound for helium is inferred from the ratio alone.
The exact memory equation (8) is not an exponential law even in ordinary quantum mechanics. For an integrable spectral density, , and the survival initially has a quadratic rather than a linear decrease. Its behavior at very long times also depends on the continuum spectrum. The exponential approximation describes the intermediate decay regime.
The reduced law (30) assumes a regular reservoir with a sufficiently short memory and a slowly varying transition frequency over that memory time. The cubic approximation for must hold throughout the interval swept by , , whenever that approximation is used.
The rates (38)–(39) are rates of the reduced law. The exact initial derivative of the survival is zero, as in the ordinary memory equation (8). The late rate (39) is also distinct from the ultimate continuum tail.
Within the reduced description, the measurement of Ref. [1], which observes the XUV emission over windows of about s, much shorter than , probes the initial rate (38), provided that remains close to , the memory transient has passed and the calibration is unchanged. The lifetime inferred from it then corresponds to rather than directly to the mean survival time .
The first-order truncation of the reduced law (30) is . For , this is also an ordinary population-loss law with constant one- and two-body loss coefficients. Such losses satisfy relation (40) to first order in . The relation is therefore an internal consistency check, not a unique signature of a deformation.
Comparison with Weinberg’s nonlinear QM. Throughout, we used the quartic Hamiltonian (16) on the unit norm sphere to deform the two-level QM. In Weinberg’s framework [3] a classical Hamiltonian is a homogeneous function of degree one in and in . Two-level atoms in this framework were considered in [8].
One can check that our quartic deformation leads to results that are essentially equivalent to deformations constructed in [8]. This comparison concerns the specified atom–field model. It does not select prescriptions for systems of several atoms, statistical mixtures or measurements. General questions of observables and probabilities are discussed in Chapter 4 of [6].
Experimental considerations. A precise measurement of the lifetime and decay law of metastable helium is a promising way to find deviations from QM. It also could provide a complementary test of nonlinear QM alongside existing precision tests [9, 10, 11, 12], which search for population- or polarization-dependent frequency shifts. Current XUV detectors can detect individual emitted photons; hence one can hope to observe the number of decays with high precision. A difficult problem is to take into account the losses due to collisions with other atoms and with the boundary.
References
- [1]S. S. Hodgman, R. G. Dall, L. J. Byron, K. G. H. Baldwin, S. J. Buckman and A. G. Truscott, Metastable Helium: A New Determination of the Longest Atomic Excited-State Lifetime, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 053002 (2009). doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.103.053002.DOI
- [2]G. Łach and K. Pachucki, Forbidden transitions in the helium atom, Phys. Rev. A 64, 042510 (2001). arXiv:physics/0105110.DOI
- [3]S. Weinberg, Testing quantum mechanics, Ann. Phys. 194, 336–386 (1989). doi:10.1016/0003-4916(89)90276-5. See also Precision Tests of Quantum Mechanics, Phys. Rev. Lett. 62, 485–488 (1989). doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.62.485.DOI
- [4]A. Schwarz, Quantum theory from classical mechanics near equilibrium, Lett. Math. Phys. 115, 76 (2025). doi:10.1007/s11005-025-01967-4. arXiv:2504.09806.DOI
- [5]A. Schwarz, Geometric and algebraic approaches to quantum theory, Nucl. Phys. B 973, 115601 (2021). doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysb.2021.115601. arXiv:2102.09176.DOI
- [6]A. Schwarz, Quantum Mechanics and Quantum Field Theory from Algebraic and Geometric Viewpoints, SpringerBriefs in Physics, Springer, Cham (2024). doi:10.1007/978-3-031-67915-5.DOI
- [7]J. Nicolas and A. Schwarz (unpublished).
- [8]M. Czachor, Elements of Nonlinear Quantum Mechanics (I): Nonlinear Schrödinger equation and two-level atoms, arXiv:quant-ph/9501007 (1995), long preprint version. See also Phys. Rev. A 53, 1310–1315 (1996).
- [9]J. J. Bollinger, D. J. Heinzen, W. M. Itano, S. L. Gilbert and D. J. Wineland, Test of the linearity of quantum mechanics by rf spectroscopy of the ⁹Be⁺ ground state, Phys. Rev. Lett. 63, 1031–1034 (1989). doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.63.1031.DOI
- [10]T. E. Chupp and R. J. Hoare, Coherence in freely precessing ²¹Ne and a test of linearity of quantum mechanics, Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 2261–2264 (1990). doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.64.2261. Erratum, Phys. Rev. Lett. 66, 120 (1991).DOI
- [11]R. L. Walsworth, I. F. Silvera, E. M. Mattison and R. F. C. Vessot, Test of the linearity of quantum mechanics in an atomic system with a hydrogen maser, Phys. Rev. Lett. 64, 2599–2602 (1990). doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.64.2599.DOI
- [12]P. K. Majumder, B. J. Venema, S. K. Lamoreaux, B. R. Heckel and E. N. Fortson, Test of the linearity of quantum mechanics in optically pumped ²⁰¹Hg, Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 2931–2934 (1990). doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.65.2931.DOI