betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

(I,JP)=(1,1/2+)(I,J^P)=(1,1/2^+) ΣNNΣNN quasibound state

Abstract

JLab has recently found indications of the possible existence of a ΣNNΣNN resonance at (3.14±0.84)−i(2.28±1.2)(3.14 \pm 0.84) - i (2.28 \pm 1.2) MeV. In the past, using models that exploit symmetries between the two-baryon sector with and without strangeness, hyperon-nucleon interactions have been derived that reproduce the experimental data of the strangeness −1-1 sector. We make use of these interactions to review existing Faddeev studies of the ΛNNΛNN-ΣNNΣNN system that show theoretical evidences about a (I,JP)=(1,1/2+)(I,J^P)=(1,1/2^+) ΣNNΣNN quasibound state near threshold. The calculated position of the pole is at 2.92 −i \,-i\,2.17 MeV, in reasonable agreement with the experimental findings.

Hall A Collaboration at Jefferson Lab has made use of the (e,e′K+)(e,e'K^+) reaction to study the possible existence of neutral three-body Λ\Lambda and Σ\Sigma hypernuclei [1]. They reported an excess of events around the Σ\Sigma thresholds. The most significant enhancement appears 3.14 ±\pm 0.84 MeV below the Σ0nn\Sigma^0nn threshold and has a width of σ≈2.28±1.2\sigma\approx2.28 \pm1.2 MeV. It possibly hints at a bound Σ0nn\Sigma^0nn (I = 1) state.

The existing experimental data and the expected forthcoming optimized data call for theoretical studies that could help with their interpretation. In this letter it is our purpose to emphasize the relevant findings of existing Faddeev studies of the ΛNN−ΣNN\Lambda NN-\Sigma NN system. The theoretical results obtained are a valuable tool to analyze the Hall A Collaboration data.

We have carried out a detailed study of the ΛNN−ΣNN\Lambda NN-\Sigma NN three-body system at threshold looking for bound states or resonances [2]. The strangeness −1-1 two-body interactions have been derived from the chiral quark cluster model (CQCM) [3], by exploiting the symmetries with the two-nucleon sector. In the CQCM hadrons are clusters of massive (constituent) quarks. As color carriers, massive quarks are confined through a confining potential. They interact through a one-gluon exchange potential arising from Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) perturbative effects. The non-perturbative effects generate one-boson exchange potentials between quarks [3, 4].

The nucleon-nucleon (NNNN) and hyperon-nucleon (YNYN) interactions describe reasonably well the NNNN and YNYN two-body observables [4]. In particular, the two-nucleon system low-energy parameters, the NNNN SS-wave phase shifts, and the triton binding energy are described correctly [3]. Besides, there is a reasonable agreement with the hyperon-nucleon elastic and inelastic scattering cross sections and the hypertriton binding energy. Finally, the isospin one Λnn\Lambda nn system is unbound [2, 4, 5].

At the two-body level, the NΛ−NΣN\Lambda-N\Sigma coupling as well as the tensor force, responsible for the coupling between SS and DD waves, have been considered. The Λ↔Σ\Lambda\leftrightarrow\Sigma conversion is crucial to have a correct description of the ΛNN\Lambda NN system [2]. The NNNN and YNYN interactions contain sizable non-central terms which are responsible, among others, for the deuteron binding energy. The relevance of the YNYN tensor force becomes apparent when studying the Σ−p→Λn\Sigma^-p \to\Lambda n reaction. Such process is controlled by the ΣN(ℓ=0)→ΛN(ℓ=2)\Sigma N(\ell= 0) \to\Lambda N(\ell= 2) transition so that if only the central interaction ΣN(ℓ=0)→ΛN(ℓ=0)\Sigma N(\ell= 0) \to\Lambda N(\ell= 0) is considered, the cross section cannot be described correctly [6]. The non-central NΛ−NΣN\Lambda-N\Sigma interaction induces a three-body force through the coupling between YNNYNN channels with (ℓ,λ)=(0,0)(\ell,\lambda)=(0,0) and (ℓ,λ)=(2,2)(\ell,\lambda)=(2,2), where the YNYN relative orbital angular momentum is denoted by ℓ\ell and λ\lambda stands for that of the spectator nucleon respect to the YNYN system.

For this study different models have been designed by choosing sets of spin-singlet and spin-triplet ΛN\Lambda N scattering lengths describing correctly the available experimental data. In particular, besides a reasonable description of the YNYN cross sections, the hypertriton binding energy corresponds to its experimental value within the error bars B0,1/2=0.130±0.050B_{0,1/2}=0.130\pm0.050 MeV [7]. The upper limit of the ΛN\Lambda N spin-triplet scattering length, a1/2,1ΛNa^{\Lambda N}_{1/2,1}, has been established by requiring that the (I,JP)=(0,3/2+)(I,J^{P})=(0,3/2^{+}) ΛNN\Lambda NN state does not become bound [2]. The lower limit was set by requiring a correct description of the YNYN cross sections, which deteriorates markedly as the ΛN\Lambda N spin-triplet scattering length decreases. Thus, it was found that 1.41≤a1/2,1ΛN≤1.581.41\leq a^{\Lambda N}_{1/2,1}\leq1.58 fm. Once the ΛN\Lambda N spin-triplet scattering length has been defined, the ΛN\Lambda N spin-singlet scattering length, a1/2,0ΛNa^{\Lambda N}_{1/2,0}, was constrained by demanding that the hypertriton binding energy is in the experimental interval B=0.130±0.050B=0.130\pm0.050 MeV, leading to 2.33≤a1/2,0ΛN≤2.482.33\leq a^{\Lambda N}_{1/2,0}\leq2.48 fm. Without loss of generality we take the model with a1/2,1ΛN=1.41a^{\Lambda N}_{1/2,1}=1.41 and a1/2,0ΛN=2.48a^{\Lambda N}_{1/2,0}=2.48 as the reference model. All calculations have been performed for several models within the scattering lengths intervals and the conclusions remain unchanged. For the reference model the hypertriton binding energy obtained is 129 keV. Just to illustrate the relevant role played by the DD waves of the three-body system, it is worth to note that considering only SS wave three-body channels the hypertriton binding energy is 89 keV, out of the experimental range.

The solution of the three-body problem have been described elsewhere [2] and are out of the scope of this letter. We focus on the results concerning the possible existence of a ΣNN\Sigma NN (I,JP)=(1,1/2+)(I,J^{P})=(1,1/2^{+}) resonance [1].

Let us first discuss the attractive or repulsive character of the different JP=1/2+J^{P}=1/2^{+} ΣNN\Sigma NN channels. Figure 1 shows the Fredholm determinant of the JP=1/2+J^{P}=1/2^{+} ΣNN\Sigma NN channels below the Σd\Sigma d threshold, where the continuum starts. The Fredholm determinant of the I=0I=0 and 11 channels is complex because the ΛNN\Lambda NN channels are open. The imaginary part is small and uninteresting. It can be seen that the channel showing the most attractive character is the (I,JP)=(1,1/2+)(I,J^{P})=(1,1/2^{+}). For an attractive channel the Fredholm determinant, DFD_{F}, is smaller than 1 and it becomes negative if a bound state exists [5]. Thus, as the Fredholm determinant is very close to zero at the Σd\Sigma d threshold is a clear indication of a quasibound state. The (I,JP)=(0,1/2+)(I,J^{P})=(0,1/2^{+}) channel is also attractive, but far less than the I=1I=1 one.

Figure 1. Fredholm determinant, DFD_{\mathrm{F}}, for the JP=1/2+J^P=1/2^+ ΣNN\Sigma NN channels utilizing the reference model, in which the deuteron binding energy is E=−2.225E=-2.225 MeV [2].

This can be easily understood as follows. We show in Table I the two-body channels that contribute to a given JP=1/2+J^P=1/2^+ ΛNN−ΣNN\Lambda NN-\Sigma NN state with isospin II. The most attractive two-body channels, in particular the ΣN\Sigma N 3S1(I=1/2){}^{3}S_{1}(I=1/2) and 1S0(I=3/2){}^{1}S_{0}(I=3/2) and the NNNN 3S1(I=0){}^{3}S_{1}(I=0), contribute to the (I,JP)=(1,1/2+)(I,J^P)=(1,1/2^+) ΣNN\Sigma NN state, however, the last two are forbidden for the (I,JP)=(0,1/2+)(I,J^P)=(0,1/2^+) ΣNN\Sigma NN state, one of them being the deuteron channel.

The most interesting result in connection with the results reported in [1] is the prediction of a ΣNN\Sigma NN (I,JP)=(1,1/2+)(I,J^P)=(1,1/2^+) quasibound state in the region near threshold. We show in Figure 2 the real, Re⁡(A1,1/2)\operatorname{Re}(A_{1,1/2}), and imaginary, Im⁡(A1,1/2)\operatorname{Im}(A_{1,1/2}), parts of the Σd\Sigma d scattering length as a function of the attraction in the three-body channel. The real part becomes negative while

Figure 2. Real and imaginary parts of the Σd\Sigma d scattering length, A1,1/2A_{1,1/2}.

II(iΣ,sΣ)(i_{\Sigma},s_{\Sigma})(iΛ,sΛ)(i_{\Lambda},s_{\Lambda})(iN(Σ),sN(Σ))(i_{N(\Sigma)},s_{N(\Sigma)})(iN(Λ),sN(Λ))(i_{N(\Lambda)},s_{N(\Lambda)})
0(1/2,0),(1/2,1)(1/2,0),(1/2,1)(1/2,0),(1/2,1)(1/2,0),(1/2,1)(1,0)(1,0)(0,1)(0,1)
1(1/2,0),(3/2,0),(1/2,1),(3/2,1)(1/2,0),(3/2,0),(1/2,1),(3/2,1)(1/2,0),(1/2,1)(1/2,0),(1/2,1)(0,1),(1,0)(0,1),(1,0)(1,0)(1,0)
2(3/2,0),(3/2,1)(3/2,0),(3/2,1)(1,0)(1,0)

Table 1. Two-body ΣN\Sigma N channels (iΣ,sΣ)(i_{\Sigma},s_{\Sigma}), ΛN\Lambda N channels (iΛ,sΛ)(i_{\Lambda},s_{\Lambda}), NNNN channels with Σ\Sigma spectator (iN(Σ),sN(Σ))(i_{N(\Sigma)},s_{N(\Sigma)}), and NNNN channels with Λ\Lambda spectator (iN(Λ),sN(Λ))(i_{N(\Lambda)},s_{N(\Lambda)}) that contribute to a given JP=1/2+J^P=1/2^+ ΛNN−ΣNN\Lambda NN-\Sigma NN state with total isospin II.

the imaginary part has a maximum, which are the typical signals of a quasibound state [8].

The position of the pole almost does not change for the different models, being at 2.92−i2.172.92-i2.17 MeV for the reference model. The width of this state comes mainly from the coupling to a DD wave ΛNN\Lambda NN channel. It is worth to emphasize that the enhancement suggested as a possible ΣNN\Sigma NN resonance by the Hall A Collaboration at Jefferson Lab appears at about (3.14±0.84)−i(2.28±1.2)(3.14 \pm0.84)-i(2.28 \pm1.2) MeV [1], in very good agreement with the theoretical results reported in this study.

The existence of a (I,JP)=(1,1/2+)(I,J^P)=(1,1/2^+) ΣNN\Sigma NN quasibound state was suggested in a variational calculation investigating the structure of the A=3A=3 Σ\Sigma-hypernuclei [9]. Similar results were obtained by Harada and Hirabayashi [10] using a distorted-wave impulse approximation within a coupled (2N−Λ)+(2N−Σ)(2N-\Lambda)+(2N-\Sigma) model with a spreading potential. Afnan and Gibson found a near threshold I=0I=0 resonance while exploring Λd\Lambda d elastic scattering by a continuum Faddeev calculation [11]. Recent preliminary calculations [12] have suggested that the pole for the I=1I=1 resonance is also located near the ΣNN\Sigma NN threshold, but the two resonances are unlikely to be distinguished experimentally.

To conclude, Hall A Collaboration at Jefferson Lab [1] has found indications of the possible existence of a ΣNN\Sigma NN resonance at (3.14±0.84)−i(2.28±1.2)(3.14 \pm0.84)-i(2.28 \pm1.2) MeV. The state is likely a Σ0nn\Sigma^0nn state, although this has to be confirmed by future experiments. We have presented a detailed study of ΛNN−ΣNN\Lambda NN-\Sigma NN system using the hyperon-nucleon and nucleonnucleon interactions derived from a chiral constituent quark model with full inclusion of the Λ↔Σ\Lambda\leftrightarrow\Sigma conversion and taking into account all three-body configurations with SS and DD wave components. In the case of the ΣNN\Sigma NN system there exists a narrow quasibound state near threshold in the (I,JP)=(1,1/2+)(I, J^{P}) = (1, 1/2^{+}) channel. The position of the pole is at 2.92−i 2.172.92 - i\,2.17 MeV. There is a reasonable agreement with the enhancement suggested as a possible ΣNN\Sigma NN resonance by the Hall A Collaboration at Jefferson Lab, appearing at about (3.14±0.84)−i(2.28±1.2)(3.14 \pm0.84) - i(2.28 \pm1.2) MeV, being our result inside the error bar of the experimental data.

Acknowledgments

This work has been partially funded by COFAA-IPN (México) and by Ministerio de Ciencia e Innovación and EU FEDER under Contracts No. PID2019-105439GB-C22 and RED2018-102572-T.

References

References

  1. [1]Pandey, B.; et al. (Hall A Collaboration), Spectroscopic study of a possible Λnn resonance and a pair of ΣNN states using the (e,e′K⁺) reaction with a tritium target. Phys. Rev. C 2022, 105, L051001 (1–6).DOI
  2. [2]Garcilazo, H.; Valcarce, A.; Fernández-Caramés, T. ΛNN and ΣNN systems at threshold. II. The effect of D waves. Phys. Rev. C 2007, 76, 034001 (1–7).
  3. [3]Valcarce, A.; Garcilazo, H.; Fernández, F.; González, P. Quark-model study of few-baryon systems. Rep. Prog. Phys. 2005, 68, 965–1042.DOI
  4. [4]Garcilazo, H.; Fernández-Caramés, T.; Valcarce, A. ΛNN and ΣNN systems at threshold. Phys. Rev. C 2007, 75, 034002 (1–10).DOI
  5. [5]Garcilazo, H. Non-existence of Λnn or Σ−nn bound states. J. Phys. G 1987, 13, L63–L67.DOI
  6. [6]Straub, U.; Zhang, Z.; Bräuer, K.; Faessler, A.; Khadkikar, S.B. Hyperon-nucleon interaction in the quark cluster model. Nucl. Phys. A 1988, 483, 686–710.DOI
  7. [7]Jurić, M.; et al. A new determination of the binding-energy values of the light hypernuclei (A ≤ 15). Nucl. Phys. B 1973, 52, 1–30.DOI
  8. [8]Deloff, A. η − d and K⁻ − d zero-energy scattering: A Faddeev approach. Phys. Rev. C 2000, 61, 024004 (1–6).DOI
  9. [9]Koike, Y.H.; Harada, T. Structure of the A = 3 Σ-hypernuclei. Nucl. Phys. A 1996, 611, 461-483.DOI
  10. [10]Harada, T.; Hirabayashi, Y. ΣNN quasibound states in 3He(K−,π−) reactions at 600 MeV/c. Phys. Rev. C 2014, 89, 054603 (1–16).DOI
  11. [11]Afnan, I.R.; Gibson, B.F. Hypertriton: Λ ↔ Σ conversion and tensor forces. Phys. Rev. C 1990, 41, 2787–2799.DOI
  12. [12]Gibson, B.F. Possible ΣNN resonant states 14th International Conference on Hypernuclear and Strange Particle Physics-HYP2022; Prague, Czech Republic, 27 june - 1 july 2022.

Paper details

vlnc:W_9hp7x83h
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents