betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Isospin effects and symmetry energy in nuclear reactions

Abstract

Isospin and the symmetry energy are linked within the symmetry term of the liquid-drop mass formula and within the corresponding term of the equation of state of asymmetric nuclear matter. The Pauli exclusion principle leads to a leading quadratic dependence of the kinetic part of the symmetry term of the nuclear binding-energy formula on the neutron-proton asymmetry (N-Z)/A. Charge symmetry ensures the same leading quadratic dependence for the potential part. Charge invariance further generalizes this dependence, to lowest order, from T32_3^2 to T(T+1). The strength of the symmetry term, in contrast, is determined by the symmetry energy. At sub-saturation densities the symmetry energy can be constrained by nuclear-structure observables, such as neutron skin thicknesses, isovector collective modes and the related electric dipole polarizability, and excitation energies of isobaric analog states. It can also be constrained by reaction observables, such as charge exchange and elastic scattering cross sections, isoscaling and isospin diffusion. At supra-saturation densities, by contrast, the only means of studying asymmetric nuclear matter under laboratory conditions are relativistic heavy-ion collisions. These studies use differential observables such as neutron/proton flows and light isobar or π−/π+π^{-}/π^{+} ratios. Complementary information can be obtained from neutron star observations including gravitational waves. The latest measurements and analyses of the stiffness of the symmetry energy will be presented, together with the recent NA61/SHINE observation of an unexpectedly large isospin-symmetry violation in kaon production. Attention will also be paid to the challenges of measuring charged and neutral products of relativistic heavy-ion collisions in the context of the recent ASY-EOS II experiment at GSI and to the new detectors used in the setup.

Introduction, basic concepts, symmetries and their breaking

In 1932, based on observing nearly equal masses and the same spins of the proton, p, and the neutron, n, Heisenberg [1] proposed to treat these particles as two states of the “nucleon” and to adopt spin formalism to describe them. A nucleon has been assigned an isospin quantum number, T=1/2T=1/2, with two possible projections T3=±1/2T_3=\pm1/2 on the third axis in the isospin space, see e.g. [2]. The observation of certain symmetries in the subatomic world led to the formulation of specific hypotheses regarding nuclear interactions.

For example, explanation of the mass differences between “mirror nuclei” (3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H}-3He^{3}\mathrm{He}, 7Li{}^{7}\mathrm{Li}-7Be{}^{7}\mathrm{Be}, etc.) largely by electrostatic effects and the n-p mass difference led to the hypothesis of charge symmetry of nuclear forces. It states that, apart from the Coulomb interaction, the interactions between like nucleons are the same: (n-n)=(p-p), i.e. they do not change under the n↔p interchange.

Observation of an approximate equality of nuclear interactions in p-p and n-p scattering (in the 1S{}^{1}S channel), similarities of some level schemes in neighboring isobars (isobaric analog states, IAS, with the same spin, parity and isospin), selection and transition rules driven by isospin conservation, etc., led to the hypothesis of charge invariance of nuclear forces. It states that the strong interactions between n-n, p-p and n-p pairs in the same T=1T=1 state, (i.e. with the same spin and angular momentum), are the same: (n-n)=(p-p)=(n-p), thus they are invariant under arbitrary rotations in isospin space.

Observation of isospin multiplets of mesons and baryons, isospin driven predictions for relative strengths of certain reaction channels, led to the extension of isospin to all hadrons and to the hypothesis of isospin symmetry of strong interactions. It assumes that the up, u, and down, d, quarks interact identically provided their mass and charge difference can be ignored i.e. u=d.

Finally, flavor symmetry extends isospin to the strange quark and states that strong interactions are independent of the quark type, i.e. u=d=s.

These symmetries are approximate. Isospin symmetry is broken by the u-d quark mass difference and by electromagnetic interactions, and the flavor symmetry breaking is dominated by the larger mass of the s quark. Recently, however, the NA61/SHINE collaboration reported evidence of isospin-symmetry violation beyond these known effects with the 4.7σ4.7\sigma significance [3]. The observation was drawn from the measured charged-to-neutral kaon ratio RK≡(⟨K+⟩+⟨K−⟩)/(2⟨K0⟩)R_K \equiv(\langle K^+\rangle+ \langle K^-\rangle)/(2\langle K^0\rangle) in nearly symmetric collisions of 40Ar+45Sc{}^{40}\mathrm{Ar}+{}^{45}\mathrm{Sc} at sNN=11.9\sqrt{s_{NN}}=11.9 GeV. RKR_K was found to exceed unity by (18.4±6.1)%(18.4 \pm6.1)\%. Similar observations were made in many other experiments, but with smaller precision. To date, there is no generally accepted explanation of this unexpectedly large effect.

Since no comparably large violation has been found in observables involving only the u and d quarks (e.g. in π−/π+\pi^-/\pi^+ ratios), the effect may be specific to strangeness. If so, it should not affect observables and symmetries discussed in this contribution. Rather than providing another comprehensive overview of symmetry energy studies and constraints (see e.g [4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12] and references therein), this paper aims to identify direct links between isospin and symmetry energy, outline key (subjective) milestones and highlight most recent results and future advances.

Isospin in nuclear structure and dynamics and its relation to Esym

In 1935 Weizsäcker [13] proposed a semi-empirical “liquid drop” formula for binding energy per nucleon in a nucleus of mass, atomic and neutron numbers AA, ZZ and NN, respectively. It was later supplemented with the pairing and shell corrections (see e.g. [2]).

−EBA=−aV+aSZ2A1/3+aCZ2A4/3+aA(N−ZA)2±aP1A3/2+ΔES(1)-\frac{E_B}{A}=-a_V+a_S\frac{Z^2}{A^{1/3}}+a_C\frac{Z^2}{A^{4/3}}+a_A\left(\frac{N-Z}{A}\right)^2\pm a_P\frac{1}{A^{3/2}}+\Delta E_S \tag*{(1)}

The quadratic neutron-proton-asymmetry dependence of the symmetry term, ST, in (1) can be derived from the Fermi Gas, FG, model and complies with the charge symmetry of nuclear forces. It results from the fermionic nature of the nucleons (Pauli exclusion) and specifically from the Fermi energy dependence on neutron and proton content. Up to the quadratic term in the n-p asymmetry expansion:

EtotFGA≈35ℏ22m(32π2ρo)2/3(ρρo)2/3+59ℏ22m(32π2ρo)2/3(ρρo)2/3(N−ZA)2(2)\frac{E_{\mathrm{tot}}^{FG}}{A} \approx\frac{3}{5}\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left(\frac{3}{2}\pi^2\rho_o\right)^{2/3}\left(\frac{\rho}{\rho_o}\right)^{2/3}+\frac{5}{9}\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\left(\frac{3}{2}\pi^2\rho_o\right)^{2/3}\left(\frac{\rho}{\rho_o}\right)^{2/3}\left(\frac{N-Z}{A}\right)^2 \tag*{(2)}

where, EtotFG/AE_{\mathrm{tot}}^{FG}/A is the total “Fermi motion” energy per nucleon in uniform nuclear matter, i.e. the “Equation of State”, EoS, of an asymmetric FG at zero temperature.

The non-interacting FG EoS (2) is, however, too simple. In particular, it does not predict neutron stars, NS, heavier than 0.7 M⊙M_{\odot} (see e.g. [14, 15]) while a 2.35 ±\pm 0.11 M⊙M_{\odot} pulsar (PSR J0952-0607) has been observed recently [16]. Nevertheless, the form of the FG EoS can be used as a starting point in the search for the true EoS of asymmetric nuclear matter and in particular for the Symmetry Energy, Esym, a density dependent function multiplying the square of the n-p asymmetry in the ST of (2). In many applications (e.g. transport codes) the Esym is parametrized by adding to the FG kinetic term a potential part with a power law dependence on density with the exponent γ\gamma (3):

Esym(ρ)=(12 MeV)(ρρo)2/3+(aAV−12)MeV(ρρo)γ(3)E_{\mathrm{sym}}(\rho)=(12\ \mathrm{MeV})\left(\frac{\rho}{\rho_o}\right)^{2/3}+(a_A^V-12)\mathrm{MeV}\left(\frac{\rho}{\rho_o}\right)^{\gamma} \tag*{(3)}

It may be viewed as a simplified version of the Skyrme interactions [17], with aAV≡Esym(ρo)a_A^V \equiv E_{\mathrm{sym}}(\rho_o) being the volume contribution to the symmetry parameter aAa_A in eq. (1).

Precise density dependence of Esym is currently a subject of intensive experimental (e.g. [5, 9, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23]) and theoretical (e.g. [24, 25, 26]) studies. However, some theoretical and empirical arguments suggest that the exponent γ\gamma should follow the kinetic part and be close to 2/3 [27]. Indeed, the result of [22] yielded γ=0.72±0.19\gamma=0.72\pm0.19, and more examples can be found in [27].

A general form of the EoS of asymmetric nuclear matter can be obtained by taking a thermodynamic limit of eq. (1), i.e. requiring that the mass and volume tend to infinity while keeping the density finite, switching off the Coulomb interaction and allowing the matter to be compressible. In the parabolic approximation, this EoS takes the form:

E(ρ,δ)=E(ρ,0)+Esym(ρ)δ2(4)E(\rho,\delta)=E(\rho,0)+E_{\mathrm{sym}}(\rho)\delta^2 \tag*{(4)}

with the n-p (or isospin) asymmetry δ=ρn−ρpρ\delta=\frac{\rho_n-\rho_p}{\rho} and ρn\rho_n, ρp\rho_p, ρ\rho being the neutron, proton and total densities, respectively. The E(ρ,0)E(\rho,0) and Esym(ρ)δ2E_{\mathrm{sym}}(\rho)\delta^2 are the symmetric matter term and ST, and Esym(ρ)=E(ρ,1)−E(ρ,0)E_{\mathrm{sym}}(\rho)=E(\rho,1)-E(\rho,0). The latter relation implies that Esym can be viewed as an energy cost of converting all protons in symmetric matter into neutrons.

To facilitate experimental extraction of the density dependence of the EoS, both the symmetric matter term and Esym are usually expanded in Taylor series around the saturation density ρo\rho_o. Setting x=ρ−ρo3ρox=\frac{\rho-\rho_o}{3\rho_o}, the expansions up to the cubic term yield:

E(ρ,0)≈−aV+K2x2+Q6x3,Esym(ρ)≈Esym(ρo)+Lx+Ksym2x2+Qsym6x3(5)E(\rho,0)\approx-a_V+\frac{K}{2}x^2+\frac{Q}{6}x^3,\qquad E_{\rm sym}(\rho)\approx E_{\rm sym}(\rho_o)+Lx+\frac{K_{\rm sym}}{2}x^2+\frac{Q_{\rm sym}}{6}x^3 \tag*{(5)}

While the parameters aVa_V (volume term in eq. (1)), KK (incompressibility of symmetric matter) and ρo\rho_o are relatively well known (aV=16a_V=16 MeV, K=230±30K=230\pm30 MeV, ρo=0.17±0.03\rho_o=0.17\pm0.03 fm−3^{-3}[17]), the parameters characterizing the density dependence of EsymE_{\rm sym} (Esym(ρo)E_{\rm sym}(\rho_o), LL, KsymK_{\rm sym}, QsymQ_{\rm sym}) and correlations among them are still a subject of intensive experimental research. It is worthwhile to mention that using the EsymE_{\rm sym} expansion of (5), assuming (3) and the Siemens’ ρ2/3\rho^{2/3} scaling [27], one can expect the following correlations: L=2Esym(ρo)L=2E_{\rm sym}(\rho_o), Ksym=−2Esym(ρo)K_{\rm sym}=-2E_{\rm sym}(\rho_o), Qsym=8Esym(ρo)Q_{\rm sym}=8E_{\rm sym}(\rho_o).

The interplay of isospin, TT, and EsymE_{\rm sym} becomes apparent on a closer look at the ST of eq. (1). Charge invariance, i.e. invariance under rotations in isospin space is a more general property of nuclear interactions than charge symmetry. It requires the symmetry term to depend on T2T^2, with eigenvalue T(T+1)T(T+1), rather than on its T3T_3 component alone:

ST≡aA(N−ZA)2=4aA(T3A)2=4aA(TA)2⟶4aAT(T+1)A2(6)S_T\equiv a_A\left(\frac{N-Z}{A}\right)^2=4a_A\left(\frac{T_3}{A}\right)^2=4a_A\left(\frac{T}{A}\right)^2\longrightarrow4a_A\frac{T(T+1)}{A^2} \tag*{(6)}

The last step expresses the ST through the total isospin, and its part linear in T contributes to the Wigner energy [28]. This form is supported by excitation energies of the IAS [29, 30, 31]. It also justifies the interchangeable use of the terms neutron-proton asymmetry and isospin asymmetry for most of the ground states.

The isospin formalism allows one to assign T to measured ground and excited states of nuclei and to identify analog levels within isobaric chains. As an example, Figure 1 shows the mass excesses, taken from the compilation [32], for the ground states (small open circles) and IAS (stars) of A=20 isobars with T=0, 1 and 2 as a function of T3_3.

Figure 1. Mass excess vs T3_3 for isospin singlet (T=0), triplet (T=1) and quintet (T=2) of A=20 isobars. Small open circles and stars show experimental ground state and IAS values, respectively. Filled circles show “bare strong” mass excesses after subtracting the Coulomb energy and the contribution of the n–hydrogen mass difference, relative to the N=Z member. The vertical arrow marks the excitation energy of the T=2 IAS in 20^{20}Na. Up to pairing and shell corrections, this energy is approximately proportional to the symmetry coefficient aAa_A in eqs. (1) and (7). Note the much larger gap between the T=0 and T=1 states (see text).

The measured values for T=1 and 2 (symbols connected by lines) are split and depend almost linearly on T3_3, as described by the isobaric multiplet mass equation (IMME [32]). This is because the Coulomb interaction and the neutron–hydrogen mass difference break isospin symmetry. Once these contributions are subtracted (filled circles, with corrections calculated relative to the T3=0T_3=0 isobar following [33]), the members of each multiplet become nearly degenerate, as expected from charge invariance of nuclear forces. The energy gap between the T=2T=2 and T=1T=1 multiplets, about 6.5 MeV, is then the same for all T3T_3, and reflects the isospin dependence of the nuclear energy, i.e. the symmetry energy. The gap between the T=1T=1 and T=0T=0 states, about 10.3 MeV, is much larger. The difference reflects the additional binding of the even–even N=ZN=Z ground state due to the Wigner energy and pairing. These isobaric multiplets are the nuclear analogs to the isospin multiplets in the baryon and meson spectra.

The simplest relation between the symmetry coefficient aAa_A of eq. (1) and isospin follows from the excitation energy of an IAS with isospin T+ΔTT+\Delta T above the ground state of the same nucleus (see Figure 1):

aA≈AEIAS∗4ΔT(2T+ΔT+1)=AE(A,T+ΔT)−E(A,T)4ΔT(2T+ΔT+1)(7)a_A \approx A \frac{E_{\mathrm{IAS}}^*}{4\Delta T(2T+\Delta T+1)} = A \frac{E(A,T+\Delta T)-E(A,T)}{4\Delta T(2T+\Delta T+1)} \tag*{(7)}

where E(A,T)E(A,T) is the energy of the lowest state with isospin TT in the nucleus (eq. (7) corresponds to eq. (2-18) of [2] for ΔT=1\Delta T=1, T2T^2 form of ST and bsym=2aAb_{\mathrm{sym}}=2a_A). Since both states have the same ZZ, the Coulomb energy and the neutron–hydrogen mass difference largely cancel. The approximation neglects pairing and shell effects. The resulting aAa_A is an effective coefficient for a given nucleus, including surface effects. Transitions from T=0T=0 ground states of even–even N=ZN=Z nuclei must take into account Wigner energy, pairing and shell corrections.

Different neutron-proton content of a nucleus, through T3T_3, and its isospin TT, which can differ from ∣T3∣|T_3| for excited states such as the IAS, lead, through EsymE_{\mathrm{sym}}, to observable differences between nuclei. In nuclear structure, EsymE_{\mathrm{sym}} affects the excitation energies of IAS [31], neutron-proton distributions and skins [34], masses [35], electric dipole polarizability [36], giant [37] and pygmy [38] dipole resonances. In nuclear reactions, the density and momentum dependence of the symmetry potential governs isospin dynamics. This “isospin transport” can be related to such phenomena and observables as isospin drift and diffusion [39, 40], transparency [41], fractionation/distillation [42], isoscaling [43, 44, 45], flows [22, 46], π−/π+\pi^-/\pi^+ ratios [23].

While the structure related, “static”, isospin effects impact the EsymE_{\mathrm{sym}} mostly below ρo\rho_o (roughly between 0.40.4–0.8 ρo0.8\,\rho_o for 10≤A≤24010\leq A\leq240), the “dynamic” isospin effects can be studied in heavy ion collisions at up to 22–3ρo3\rho_o at relativistic energies.

In nuclear collisions, the isospin-sensitive observables are primarily shaped by “static” (initial state) isospin effects related to the structure of the projectile and target (N/ZN/Z, neutron-proton density distributions, skins) and by dynamically induced gradients of the isovector part of the mean field. Additional contributions arise from in-medium isospin-dependent nucleon-nucleon cross sections, Coulomb interactions, clustering, and secondary decays.

For example, in peripheral collisions of heavy nuclei at intermediate energies, the “neck” formed during the collision is neutron rich not only because of the static neutron skins of the projectile and the target, but also due to the dynamically induced gradients of the symmetry potential which exert forces of opposite sign on neutrons and protons. The resulting isospin currents are governed by the symmetry energy, its density slope, and the local density and isospin asymmetry gradients (see eq. (8) based on [47, 48]). Density gradients lead to isospin migration (drift) of neutrons towards the dilute neck, at a rate set by ∂Esym/∂ρ\partial E_{\mathrm{sym}}/\partial\rho. Asymmetry gradients lead to isospin diffusion, at a rate set by EsymE_{\mathrm{sym}}. Both drive the system towards chemical equilibrium, with uniform difference of chemical potentials: μn−μp=4Esym(ρ) δ\mu_n-\mu_p=4E_{\mathrm{sym}}(\rho)\,\delta. Because EsymE_{\mathrm{sym}} is smaller at low density, this equilibration leads to a neutron-rich neck.

jn−jp∝−ρδ∂Esym∂ρ∇ρ−ρEsym∇δ(8)\mathbf{j}_n-\mathbf{j}_p \propto-\rho\delta\frac{\partial E_{\mathrm{sym}}}{\partial\rho}\nabla\rho-\rho E_{\mathrm{sym}}\nabla\delta \tag*{(8)}

Some recent results and milestones

Systematic studies of symmetry energy coefficients for different nuclei based on IAS were done e.g. in [29, 30, 31]. The analysis of [31] is more advanced than suggested by eq. (7) as it takes into account shell corrections. It confirmed that STST is ∝T(T+1)\propto T(T+1) and thus that the charge invariance is a good approximation. It also provided values of volume and surface symmetry energy parameters aAVa_A^V and aASa_A^S and arrived at the following constraints: aAV=30.2−33.7a_A^V=30.2-33.7 MeV and L=35−70L=35-70 MeV. The extracted symmetry energy coefficients aAa_A for nuclei up to A=240 are presented in Figure 2. The superposed

Mass dependence of the symmetry energy coefficient

Figure 2. Mass dependence of the symmetry energy coefficient aA(A)a_A(A) extracted from IAS after applying shell corrections. The solid line represents a fit at A ≥\geq 30 assuming a non-linear combination of volume and surface symmetry terms. Base Figure taken from [31]. The superposed dashed line represents a result of [30] assuming a linear combination of the volume and surface symmetry coefficients.

dashed line represents the result of [30] assuming a linear combination of the volume and surface symmetry coefficients. It was obtained from the fits to the double-beta decay Q values. Description of the IAS data is also remarkable in this case.

Charge invariance of nuclear forces requires the nucleon–nucleus interaction to depend on an isospin scalar. Together with the symmetry term of the nuclear binding energy, this implies the existence of a symmetry (Lane) potential [49]:

U(r)=U0(r)+4t⋅TAU1(r)(9)U(\mathbf{r})=U_0(\mathbf{r})+4\frac{\mathbf{t}\cdot\mathbf{T}}{A}U_1(\mathbf{r}) \tag*{(9)}

where t⋅T\mathbf{t}\cdot\mathbf{T} is the scalar product of the isospins of the nucleon (t=12t=\frac{1}{2}) and of the target nucleus with mass number A, and U0U_0 and U1U_1 are the isoscalar and isovector (symmetry) optical potentials, respectively.

The influence of isospin on nuclear dynamics through the Lane potential can be studied in nucleon-nucleus scattering with and without charge exchange. In case of charge exchange, the target nucleus is excited to its IAS. Analysis of such scattering data was performed in [18]. After improving the parameters of the isoscalar and isovector potentials by fitting the model angular distributions of (p,p), (n,n) and (p,n) reactions to the experimental data, new sharp constraints were obtained: aAV=33.5−36.4a_A^V=33.5-36.4 MeV and L=70−101L=70-101 MeV.

The isospin effects in dynamics can be observed during the collision of projectile and target with different neutron content at intermediate energies. The EsymE_{\mathrm{sym}} and its density slope together with isospin and density gradients in the interaction region will lead to isospin drift and diffusion of nucleons towards chemical equilibrium in the “spectators” (see eq. (8)). The rate of the diffusion will depend on the collision energy (interaction time, attained densities), centrality of the collision, difference in the neutron content of the colliding isotopes and on the density dependence of the symmetry energy.

The idea of measuring the isospin imbalance ratio [50], (see eq. (10)), has been used in a recent analysis of the INDRA-FAZIA data on mean N/ZN/Z content of projectile like fragments from 58,64Ni+58,64Ni{}^{58,64}\mathrm{Ni}+{}^{58,64}\mathrm{Ni} combinations at 32 AMeV for different centralities [40, 51].

R(⟨NZ⟩↓↑)=2⟨NZ⟩64+58−⟨NZ⟩64+64−⟨NZ⟩58+58⟨NZ⟩64+64−⟨NZ⟩58+58(10)R\left(\left\langle\frac{N}{Z}\right\rangle_{\downarrow}^{\uparrow}\right)=\frac{2\left\langle\frac{N}{Z}\right\rangle^{64+58}-\left\langle\frac{N}{Z}\right\rangle^{64+64}-\left\langle\frac{N}{Z}\right\rangle^{58+58}}{\left\langle\frac{N}{Z}\right\rangle^{64+64}-\left\langle\frac{N}{Z}\right\rangle^{58+58}} \tag*{(10)}

The up(down)-arrows in (10) refer to the upper (lower) combinations of projectiles and targets specified in the numerator and denominator components. Figure 3 shows the evolution of the measured imbalance ratios with the centrality of the collision. The best model description of the data has been obtained for the EoS with Esym=28.53E_{\mathrm{sym}}=28.53 MeV and L=48.10L=48.10 MeV (blue line in Figure 3 for Ab initio 7 parameters).

Impact parameter dependence of the isospin transport ratio

Figure 3. Impact parameter dependence of the isospin transport ratio RR obtained from the ⟨N/Z⟩\langle N/Z\rangle of quasi-projectile for 64Ni+58Ni{}^{64}\mathrm{Ni}+{}^{58}\mathrm{Ni} and 58Ni+64Ni{}^{58}\mathrm{Ni}+{}^{64}\mathrm{Ni} reactions at 32 MeV/nucleon. The experimental results shown as open rectangles delimiting the uncertainties, are compared with BUU@VECC-McGill model calculations with equations of state specified in the legend. Figure taken from Ref. [40].

Another milestone result in the combined, static isospin effects via the neutron density distributions, and dynamic isospin migration, on the n/p content of heavy ion reaction products can be found in [39]. The analysis of peripheral 80Kr+40,48Ca{}^{80}\mathrm{Kr}+{}^{40,48}\mathrm{Ca} reactions at 35 MeV/nucleon showed that the isospin effects are small and difficult to measure, and that special, EsymE_{\mathrm{sym}} sensitive, observables are needed to observe them. Such an observable is presented in Figure 4. The analysis of fragments emitted in the projectile

Difference between the mean neutron number of backward and forward emitted fragments

Figure 4. Difference between ⟨N⟩\langle N\rangle of fragments emitted backward and forward w.r.t. quasi-projectile as a function of their ZZ for the system 80Kr+48Ca{}^{80}\mathrm{Kr}+{}^{48}\mathrm{Ca} at 35 AMeV. Figure taken from Ref. [39].

region showed that the secondary emissions wash out the sensitivity of ⟨N⟩/Z\langle N\rangle/Z or σN(Z)\sigma_N(Z) to the stiffness of EsymE_{\mathrm{sym}}. Some sensitivity has been found for the difference between ⟨N⟩\langle N\rangle of fragments emitted backward - forward w.r.t. quasi-projectile (Figure 4). Comparison with the AMD model predictions showed a preference for a rather stiff symmetry energy: L ≃\simeq 108 MeV. Nevertheless, as shown in [52], the main experimental results of [39] can also be reproduced within a statistical multifragmentation model, SMM, after careful adjustment of the size and composition of the projectile and mid-velocity sources and the charge dependence of the liquid drop symmetry energy parameter.

Isotopic transparency effects in central 124,129Xe+112,124Sn{}^{124,129}\mathrm{Xe}+{}^{112,124}\mathrm{Sn} collisions at 100 AMeV (INDRA@GSI) have been studied recently in [41]. The analysis allowed to extract the chemical potentials of n and p (see also [53]). An incomplete isospin equilibration between the projectile and target for the reaction products at forward angles has been observed, the heavier the fragment, the stronger the effect. The analysis also allowed to deduce a moderate transparency for hydrogen isotopes, whereas for heavier fragmentation products, with atomic number Z≥3Z \ge3, a high transparency exceeding 50% was observed. An anomalously large transparency was found for alpha particles.

Symmetry energy effects have also been recently studied at RIKEN through the near threshold pion production in 108,132Sn+112,124Sn{}^{108,132}\mathrm{Sn}+{}^{112,124}\mathrm{Sn} collisions at 270 AMeV by the Sπ\piRIT collaboration [23]. Interpretation of the measured spectral pion ratios within the dcQMD model allowed to derive constraints on the EsymE_{\mathrm{sym}} parameters: 32.5 < Esym(ρo)E_{\mathrm{sym}}(\rho_o) < 38.1 MeV and 42 < L < 117 MeV and on the scaled difference between neutron and proton effective masses: Δmnp∗=0.004δ\Delta m^{*}_{np}=0.004\delta.

The same data were also analyzed in the context of a coalescence invariant flow of light charged particles and of their stopping [46]. Experimental observables have been interpreted in terms of the ImQMD-Sky model within Bayesian framework yielding the constraints: Esym(ρo)=35±3E_{\mathrm{sym}}(\rho_o)=35\pm3 MeV and L=83±18L=83\pm18 MeV and Δmnp∗=(−0.07±0.07)δ\Delta m^{*}_{np}=(-0.07\pm0.07)\delta, in a very good agreement with the above pion analysis.

The Sπ\piRIT data (neutron-rich 132Sn+124Sn{}^{132}\mathrm{Sn}+{}^{124}\mathrm{Sn} and neutron-deficient 108Sn+112Sn{}^{108}\mathrm{Sn}+{}^{112}\mathrm{Sn} systems at 270 AMeV) were also analyzed in terms of directed, v1v_1, and elliptic, v2v_2, flow of hydrogen and helium isotopes, with the main focus on the momentum dependence of the nuclear mean field [54]. The data were interpreted within the AMD model with dynamical cluster production and momentum dependent mean-field. The analysis of the two systems indicated a slightly larger v2v_2 strength in 132Sn+124Sn{}^{132}\mathrm{Sn}+{}^{124}\mathrm{Sn}, suggesting a stronger repulsive potential in the neutron-rich system. Additionally, a comparison of AMD calculations at L=46L=46 MeV and L=108L=108 MeV revealed that the density dependence of the symmetry energy has a relatively modest impact (approximately 10%) on v1v_1, while the particle mass dependence of v2v_2 in 108Sn+112Sn{}^{108}\mathrm{Sn}+{}^{112}\mathrm{Sn} showed a more pronounced effect (about 20%). The effect of the momentum dependence of mean field on flow was found to dominate over the symmetry energy effect.

Measurements of the total neutron removal cross sections in relativistic collisions of neutron rich heavy projectiles with hydrogen or carbon targets has been proposed as a new method to derive precise (±\pm10 MeV) constraints on LL [55]. First measurements of this type, 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} and 120Sn+12C{}^{120}\mathrm{Sn}+{}^{12}\mathrm{C} [56] and 124−134Sn+C{}^{124-134}\mathrm{Sn}+\mathrm{C}, CH2\mathrm{CH}_2 and Pb [57], were performed within the R3B setup at GSI. Preliminary analyses suggest promising results on neutron removal, charge changing and total reaction cross sections and their impact on EsymE_{\mathrm{sym}}.

A similar measurement of the total and charge changing cross sections for neutron-rich 63−80Cu{}^{63-80}\mathrm{Cu} isotopes was performed at RIKEN [58]. The impressive data set over 18 isotopes of Cu are expected to provide precise constraints for models aiming at extracting their neutron skin thicknesses and the LL parameter.

New high energy experiments, new detectors

The symmetry energy quest continues. New experiments are planned, e.g. SπRIT III @ RIKEN in 2027-28 for measuring the 208,186Pb+208Pb{}^{208,186}\mathrm{Pb}+{}^{208}\mathrm{Pb} collisions at 250 AMeV and ASY-EOS III in the new R3B High-Energy Cave at FAIR in 2029-31 with completed and possibly split NeuLAND. Radioactive beams (e.g. 100−132Sn{}^{100-132}\mathrm{Sn}) between 200 and 1000 AMeV with higher intensity (×2\times2 compared to ASY-EOS II) are planned to be used for measuring pions with NeuLAND and measuring projectile and target combinations to extract isospin imbalance ratios. New detectors (and facilities) are being built and new data are being analyzed.

In particular, analysis of a new set of data from 2025 ASY-EOS II campaign measuring the Au+Au collisions @ 280, 400, 600 and 1000 AMeV is ongoing (see the contributions of F. Risitano and E. Gambera to these Proceedings). The experiment is expected to provide improved resolutions and tighter constraints on LL, Esym(ρo)E_{\mathrm{sym}}(\rho_o) and possibly KsymK_{\mathrm{sym}}. The setup consisted of the NeuLAND, KRAB and CHIMERA multi-detectors, along with the two TOFD time of flight walls. The acceptance of the setup for protons is depicted in Figure 5. The white contours indicate the lower and upper energy thresholds of

Acceptance of the ASY-EOS II detectors for protons

Figure 5. Acceptance of the ASY-EOS II detectors for protons. Background: UrQMD3.4 prediction of proton invariant cross sections from the 800 AMeV Au+Au collisions, including clustering and Coulomb afterburner calculations. Realistic KRAB thresholds for more than 17k photons produced in the scintillating fibers were applied (see the 5 regions corresponding to KRAB rings 0-4.

the detectors and their angular range. The dashed areas for NeuLAND and CHIMERA mark regions of possible mass identification for stopped particles. The NeuLAND and CHIMERA detectors focus on detection of the mid-rapidity emissions, while the TOFD is focused on detection of projectile fragmentation products. The KRAB detector is triggering mostly on target emissions. The new KRAB detector, depicted in Figure 6, was succesfully used in the ASY-EOS II experiment to provide fast multiplicity trigger and the data necessary for centrality and reaction plane estimates. This 736-channel

KRAB detector with its four forward rings visible

Figure 6. KRAB detector with its four forward rings visible. The backward ring is hidden beneath the green CITIROC boards. A vertical aluminum bracket supports an aluminum flange that houses a remotely controlled four-slot target wheel. The copper shielded flat cables connect the SiPMs with CITIROC ASICs. A base with rails allows for precise adjustment of the ring position.

plastic, passing-through detector enabled also a relatively undisturbed measurement of neutrons and protons in the NeuLAND neutron detector. The precise neutron and proton detection was a key requirement of the experiment aimed at providing symmetry energy constraints from the n/pn/p flow excitation function. KRAB also allowed to face two major challenges of experiments performed “in air”: δ\delta-electrons and contamination by the off-target reactions (mainly on air and on up-stream material). Triggering by δ\delta-electrons was eliminated by optimally setting the discriminator thresholds. Off-line elimination of off-target events was achieved by inspection of the forward/backward multiplicities in KRAB rings, identification of tracks passing through the backward and forward rings and anti-correlations of reaction planes in KRAB and CHIMERA detectors.

KRAB uses the 4×4 mm24 \times4\ \mathrm{mm}^{2} plastic scintillation fiber segments (BCF-10) within an innovative thin mechanical structure 3D-printed from the ABS. This resulted in a relatively transparent transmission detector. The photons generated in the scintillators were counted by multi-pixel silicon photomultipliers (SiPM, SensL MicroFJ-30035) of an area of 3×3 mm23 \times3\ \mathrm{mm}^{2}. Four larger-diameter forward rings and a smaller backward ring (hidden behind the electronic boards in the photo) cover polar angles from about 30∘30^\circ to 165∘165^\circ with a geometric efficiency of approx. 85% within its angular range. Pulses from the SiPMs were processed by 23 32-channel CITIROC 1A ASICS, providing logic signals for pulses meeting the required amplitude criteria. The detection system also included the TriggerBox and ControlBox electronic devices as well as a control software. The TriggerBox, based on 30 FPGA matrices, generated a bit pattern containing information about fired segments and a trigger signal when a pre-defined multiplicity threshold was exceeded. The decision to generate the trigger was made very fast, in about 50-100 ns. Together with the serialization and transmission times, this resulted in about 0.9 μ\mus intrinsic dead time introduced by this triggering detector. The bit patterns of the fired segments were sent to the V2495 logic module, which was the core component of the associated VME data acquisition system. The ControlBox, built on the basis of compact SiPM A7585D power supplies, enabled remote setting of individual voltages on sensors and of gains and discriminator thresholds on the CITIROC chips, as well as viewing the selected channels. An additional component of the system was also a "helium sleeve" with a remotely controlled "target wheel" for changing the targets placed in between the backward and the first forward ring. The detector performed very well during the experiment.

In summary, Figure 7 shows a condensed view of the progress in constraining the LL parameter. Recent comparisons of isospin-sensitive observables with model predictions have yielded new constraints, which are highlighted in bold in the text and presented as open symbols in Figure 7, alongside results from other sources. The most direct link between isospin and EsymE_{\mathrm{sym}} can be established through the IAS and the Lane potential. Currently, analyses of recent experiments, such as ASY-EOS II and SPiRIT II, are ongoing, while new data and interpretations are awaited from neutron and proton removal cross-section measurements. However, care should be taken when using kaon ratios due to possible enhanced isospin symmetry-breaking effects, which may require corrections beyond the electromagnetic ones. Notably, the KRAB detector played an important role in the ASY-EOS II experiment. Together with future experiments and neutron-star observations, these ongoing efforts are expected to tighten the constraints further, particularly on the curvature KsymK_{\mathrm{sym}} and on EsymE_{\mathrm{sym}} above twice the saturation density.

Constraints on the Esym slope parameter from various sources

Figure 7. Constraints on the Esym slope parameter from various sources.

The author is grateful to W. Trautmann and B. Zwięgliński for their critical and careful reading of the manuscript and valuable comments and remarks.

The author used the AI assistant Claude (Opus 5.5, Anthropic) for language editing and checking of selected passages. All content was reviewed and verified by the author, who takes full responsibility for the manuscript.

The KRAB system was funded by National Science Centre Poland, NCN, within project No. 2017/25/B/ST2/02550. We gratefully acknowledge Polish high-performance computing infrastructure PLGrid (HPC Center: CI TASK) for providing computer facilities and support within computational grants PLG/2024/017660 and PLG/2025/018828.

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation programme under grant agreement No. 824093 and from the European Union’s Horizon Europe Research and Innovation programme under Grant Agreement No. 101057511.

References

  1. [1]W. Heisenberg, Z. Phys., 77 (1932) 1
  2. [2]A. Bohr, B.R. Mottelson, Nuclear Structure, Vol. 1, 1969, W.A. Benjamin Inc.
  3. [3]H. Adhikari et al., Nature Commun., 16 (2025) 2849
  4. [4]B.-A. Li et al., Phys. Rep., 464 (2008) 113
  5. [5]B.-A. Li and X. Han, Phys. Lett. B, 727 (2013) 276
  6. [6]J.M. Lattimer and A.W. Steiner, Eur. Phys. J. A, 50 (2014) 40
  7. [7]J.M. Lattimer and M. Prakash, Phys. Rep., 621 (2016) 127
  8. [8]M. Baldo and G.F. Burgio, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys., 91 (2016) 203
  9. [9]M. Oertel et al., Rev. Mod. Phys., 89 (2017) 015007
  10. [10]A. Sorensen et al., Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys., 134 (2024) 104080
  11. [11]M.D. Cozma and W. Trautmann, Int. J. Mod. Phys. E, 34 (2025) 2530001
  12. [12]J. Vesic, Symmetry, 18 (2026) 441
  13. [13]C.F. von Weizsäcker, Z. Phys., 96 (1935) 431
  14. [14]J.R. Oppenheimer and G.M. Volkoff, Phys. Rev., 55 (1939) 374
  15. [15]J. Piekarewicz, arXiv:1805.04780v2 [nucl-th]
  16. [16]R.W. Romani et al., Astrophys. J., 996 (2026) 101
  17. [17]M. Dutra et al., Phys. Rev. C, 85 (2012) 035201
  18. [18]P. Danielewicz et al., Nucl. Phys. A, 958 (2017) 147
  19. [19]T.E. Riley et al., Astrophys. J. Lett., 887 (2019) L21
  20. [20]B.P. Abbott et al., Phys. Rev. Lett., 121 (2018) 161101
  21. [21]D. Adhikari et al., Phys. Rev. Lett., 126 (2021) 172502
  22. [22]P. Russotto et al., Phys. Rev. C, 94 (2016) 034608
  23. [23]J. Estee ET AL., Phys. Rev. Lett., 126 (2021) 162701
  24. [24]C. Fuchs and H.H. Wolter, Eur. Phys. J. A, 30 (2006) 5
  25. [25]S. Gandolfi and A.W. Steiner, J. Phys. Conf. Ser., 665 (2016) 012063
  26. [26]C. Drischler ET AL., Annu. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci., 71 (2021) 403
  27. [27]Bao-An Li, Eur. Phys. J. Spec. Top., (2026) https://doi.org/10.1140/epjs/s11734-026-02124-1
  28. [28]E.P. Wigner, Phys. Rev., 51 (1937) 106 and 947
  29. [29]J. Jänecke ET AL., Nucl. Phys. A, 728 (2003) 23
  30. [30]M.W. Kirson, Phys. Lett. B, 661 (2008) 246
  31. [31]P. Danielewicz and J. Lee, Nucl. Phys. A, 922 (2014) 1
  32. [32]J. Britz ET AL., Atom. Data and Nucl. Data Tab., 69 (1998) 125
  33. [33]E.P. Wigner and E. Feenberg, Rep. Prog. Phys., 8 (1941) 274
  34. [34]L.-W. Chen ET AL., Phys. Rev. C, 82 (2010) 024321
  35. [35]M. Kortelainen ET AL., Phys. Rev. C, 82 (2010) 024313
  36. [36]X. Roca-Maza ET AL., Phys. Rev. C, 88 (2013) 024316
  37. [37]L. Trippa ET AL., Phys. Rev. C, 77 (2008) 061304
  38. [38]A. Carbone ET AL., Phys. Rev. C, 81 (2010) 041301
  39. [39]S. Piantelli ET AL., Phys. Rev. C, 103 (2021) 014603
  40. [40]C. Ciampi ET AL., Phys. Lett. B, 868 (2025) 139815
  41. [41]A. Le Fèvre ET AL., Phys. Lett. B, 868 (2025) 139749
  42. [42]H.S. Xu ET AL., Phys. Rev. Lett., 85 (2000) 716
  43. [43]A.S. Botvina ET AL., Phys. Rev. C, 65 (2002) 044610
  44. [44]M.B. Tsang ET AL., Phys. Rev. Lett., 86 (2001) 5023
  45. [45]R. Ogul ET AL., Phys. Rev. C, 83 (2011) 024608
  46. [46]C.Y. Tsang ET AL., Phys. Lett. B, 853 (2024) 138661
  47. [47]V. Baran ET AL., Phys. Rev. C, 72 (2005) 064620
  48. [48]J. Rizzo ET AL., Nucl. Phys. A, 806 (2008) 79
  49. [49]A.M. Lane, Nucl. Phys., 35 (1962) 676
  50. [50]F. Rami ET AL., Phys. Rev. Lett., 84 (2000) 1120
  51. [51]S. Mallik ET AL., Universe, 12 (2026) 202
  52. [52]R. Ogul ET AL., Phys. Rev. C, 107 (2023) 054606
  53. [53]E. Bonnet ET AL., Phys. Rev. C, 111 (2025) 064616
  54. [54]M. Kurata-Nishimura ET AL., Phys. Lett. B, 871 (2025) 139970
  55. [55]T. Aumann ET AL., Phys. Rev. Lett., 119 (2017) 262501
  56. [56]L. Ponnath ET AL., Nucl. Phys. A, 1056 (2025) 123022
  57. [57]E. Kudaibergenova ET AL., Acta Phys. Pol. B Proc. Suppl., 17 (2024) 3-A18
  58. [58]G. Takayama ET AL., Nucl. Phys. A, 1065 (2026) 123261

Paper details

vlnc:W_9r3heqdf
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents