betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Frequency-comb-linearized, widely tunable lasers for coherent ranging

Abstract

Tunable lasers, with the ability to continuously adjust their emission wavelengths, have found widespread applications across various fields such as biomedical imaging, coherent ranging, optical communications and spectroscopy. In these applications, a wide chirp range is advantageous for large spectral coverage and high frequency resolution. Besides, the frequency accuracy and precision also depend critically on the chirp linearity of the laser. While extensive efforts have been made on the development of many kinds of frequency-agile, widely tunable, narrow-linewidth lasers, wideband yet precise methods to characterize and to linearize laser chirp dynamics are also demanded. Here we present an approach to characterize laser chirp dynamics using an optical frequency comb. The instantaneous laser frequency is tracked over terahertz bandwidth with 1 MHz interval. Using this approach we calibrate the chirp performance of twelve tunable lasers from Toptica, Santec, New Focus, EXFO and NKT that are commonly used in fiber optics and integrated photonics. In addition, with acquired knowledge on laser chirp dynamics, we demonstrate a simple frequency-linearization scheme that enables coherent ranging without any optical or electronic linearization units. Our approach not only presents a novel wideband, high-resolution laser spectroscopy, but is also critical for sensing applications with ever-increasing requirements on performance.

Introduction. Tunable lasers, which have the ability to dynamically adjust their emission wavelength, have found widespread applications in a variety of industries and scientific fields. For example, as shown in Figure 1a, in bio-medical imaging, optical coherence tomography (OCT)[1, 2] employs a widely tunable laser that provides a non-invasive and non-contact imaging modality for high-resolution two-dimensional cross-sectional and three-dimensional volumetric imaging of tissue structures. In optical communication systems, optical frequency-domain reflectometry (OFDR)[3, 4] uses tunable lasers for broadband loss and dispersion characterization. In laser spectroscopy, tunable diode laser spectrometers (TDLAS)[5, 6] allow compound analysis of gases, as well as their conditions such as concentration, pressure, temperature and velocity. For light detection and ranging (LiDAR), frequency-modulated continuous-wave (FMCW) LiDAR[7, 8, 9] uses a tunable laser to measure the distance (based on the time of flight) and speed (based on the Doppler effect) of a moving object.

Principle and applications of widely tunable lasers

Figure 1. Principle and applications of widely tunable lasers. a. Applications that require linearly chirping lasers. OCT, optical coherence tomography. OFDR, optical frequency-domain reflectometry. LiDAR, light detection and ranging. b. Principle of laser chirp linearization. An ideal laser chirps at a constant rate. However, in reality the actual chirp rate varies. By beating the laser with its delayed part, the chirp nonlinearity in the optical domain is revealed in the RF domain.

In all these applications, as well as others, the laser chirp range determines the measurement resolution and spectral bandwidth. However, due to the nonlinearity of laser gain and dynamics, tunable lasers typically exhibit chirping nonlinearity that is particularly deteriorated for a wide chirp range, as illustrated in Figure 1b. As a result, the laser chirp rate deviates from the set value, which compromises the frequency resolution, precision and accuracy in applications. Therefore, widely tunable lasers require careful characterization and linearization for demanding applications.

To trace the laser chirp rate α(t)\alpha(t), a fiber Mach-Zehnder interferometer (MZI) is commonly used to calibrate the instantaneous frequency, e.g. in data processing[10, 11], active linearization[7], and laser drive signal optimization[12]. However, for a wide chirp range, the fiber dispersion seriously compromises the calibration precision of fiber MZIs and cause phase-instability issues, leading to insufficient accuracy for linearization. In comparison, optical frequency combs (OFC) with equidistant grids of frequency lines can essentially resolve these issues[8, 13, 14, 15]. Here we demonstrated an approach to characterize the chirp dynamics of widely tunable lasers. We apply this method on twelve lasers from Toptica, Santec, New Focus, EXFO and NKT that are commonly used in fiber optics and integrated photonics. Using an OFC and digital band-pass filters, the instantaneous laser frequency is tracked with every 1 MHz interval over terahertz bandwidth. This allows the linearization of the pre-calibrated chirp rate α(t)\alpha(t), particularly useful for coherent LiDAR.

Principle and setup

To trace the laser chirp rate α(t)\alpha(t), we use a commercial, fully stabilized, fiber-based OFC (Quantum CTeK) as a frequency “ruler”[16, 17, 18] to trace the instantaneous laser frequency during chirping. In our case, the comb repetition rate frep=200f_{\mathrm{rep}}=200 MHz and its carrier envelope offset frequency fceof_{\mathrm{ceo}} are actively locked to a rubidium atomic clock, thus the OFC is fully stabilized. Consequently, in the frequency domain, the nn-th comb line’s frequency is unambiguously determined as fn=fceo+n⋅frepf_n=f_{\mathrm{ceo}}+n\cdot f_{\mathrm{rep}} (n∈Nn\in\mathbb{N}).

When the laser chirps, it beats against tens of thousands of comb lines with precisely known frequency values, as shown in Figure 2a. Beat signals of frequencies ∣fn−fl(t)∣|f_n-f_l(t)| are generated, where fl(t)f_l(t) is the instantaneous frequency of the chirping laser at time tt. As the frequency comb is fully stabilized, for a mode-hop-free chirping laser, the dynamics and linearity of fl(t)f_l(t) are projected onto the beat signals. The simplest beat signals to analyze are the two generated by the chirping laser with its two neighbouring comb lines, i.e. ∣fn−fl(t)∣≤frep=200|f_n-f_l(t)| \leq f_{\mathrm{rep}} = 200 MHz. Experimentally, the two beat signals are recorded by an oscilloscope after passing through a low-pass filter (LPF, Mini-Circuits, BLP-150+), whose 3-dB cutoff frequency is 155 MHz in our case. We denote the frequencies of the two beat signals as β1\beta_1 and β2\beta_2 (β1+β2=frep=200\beta_1+\beta_2=f_{\mathrm{rep}}=200 MHz and β1<β2\beta_1<\beta_2). As shown in Figure 2b, for continuous linear chirp, when the laser frequency passes through the comb lines sequentially, β1\beta_1 and β2\beta_2 vary in a sawtooth waveform. The time-domain waveform near β1=0\beta_1=0 is shown in the leftmost panel of Figure 2d, corresponding to the situation when the laser chirps across a comb line.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Schematic and experimental setup of laser chirp characterization. a. Experimental setup. BPF, band-pass filter. PC, polarization controller. BPD, balanced photodetector. LPF, low-pass filter. OSC, oscilloscope. b. Illustration of the laser frequency beating with the OFC during laser chirping at a rate of α\alpha. The time trace of the two beat frequencies β1\beta_1 and β2\beta_2 (β2>β1\beta_2 > \beta_1) are shown. c. Upper panel shows the instantaneous frequency of the chirping laser in the ideal (red) and actual (blue) cases. Lower panel shows the corresponding instantaneous chirp rate α\alpha. d. Flowcharts of the algorithm based on finite impulse response (FIR) band-pass filters, to extract the instantaneous laser frequency as well as the chirp rate. The dashed lines mark the region where the laser frequency scans across a comb line. e. The FIR filter’s center frequency fFIRf_{\mathrm{FIR}} is digitally set, and the instantaneous laser frequency is calculated over 1 MHz interval.

Here, we only concentrate on the analysis of β1\beta_1, since β1+β2=200\beta_1+\beta_2=200 MHz. The dynamics and linearity of β1(t)\beta_1(t) as a function of time are identical to those of the laser frequency fl(t)f_l(t). We process the β1(t)\beta_1(t) signal and extract the instantaneous frequency value as illustrated in Figure 2d. A finite impulse response (FIR) band-pass filter with a specific pass-band center frequency fFIRf_{\mathrm{FIR}} is applied to the recorded β1(t)\beta_1(t) signal. The FIR filter only transmits the temporal segments when β1(t)\beta_1(t) is around fFIRf_{\mathrm{FIR}}, as illustrated in the left middle panel of Figure 2d. Then Hilbert transform[19] is applied to obtain the pulse’s envelope. Via peak searching, the exact time of the pulses’ centers is extracted and recorded, when β1(t)=fFIR\beta_1(t)=f_{\mathrm{FIR}}. Experimentally, we repeatedly apply FIR filters whose fFIRf_{\mathrm{FIR}} values are digitally set from 3 MHz to 97 MHz with an interval of ΔfFIR=1\Delta f_{\mathrm{FIR}}=1 MHz, as shown in Figure 2e. In this way, during continuous laser chirp over a wide bandwidth, the β1(t)\beta_1(t) time trace is frequency-calibrated and recorded with 1 MHz interval.

Next we unwrap the sawtooth-like β1(t)\beta_1(t) trace. We select pulses corresponding to fFIR=3f_{\mathrm{FIR}}=3 MHz as markers. As shown in the bottom panel of Figure 2e, when the laser chirps over a pair of comb lines (dashed lines), i.e. frepf_{\mathrm{rep}} distance, two markers are created by the fFIR=3f_{\mathrm{FIR}}=3 MHz filters. With the known comb spacing frep=200f_{\mathrm{rep}}=200 MHz, β1(t)\beta_1(t) can then be unwrapped to an increasing function of time tt, which is Δf(t)=fl(t)−fl(t0)\Delta f(t)=f_l(t)-f_l(t_0), where fl(t0)f_l(t_0) is the starting laser frequency at time t0t_0. As shown in Figure 2c, the instantaneous chirp rate - estimated as the average rate within ΔfFIR=1\Delta f_{\mathrm{FIR}}=1 MHz calibration interval - is calculated as α(t)=dΔf(t)/dt\alpha(t)=\mathrm{d}\Delta f(t)/\mathrm{d}t, and is later used for chirp linearization.

Results

Now we use this frequency-comb-calibrated method to characterize totally ten widely tunable, mode-hop-free, external-cavity diode lasers (ECDL), including three Toptica CTL lasers, four Santec lasers, two New Focus lasers, and one EXFO laser. These lasers are all operated in the telecommunication band around 1550 nm, and are extensively used in fiber optics and integrated photonics. For example, Toptica CTL and New Focus lasers are widely used in the generation of microresonator-based dissipative Kerr soliton frequency combs[20, 21, 22]. Santec and EXFO lasers are widely used in wideband characterization of waveguide dispersion[6, 15, 23]. In addition, two NKT fiber lasers are characterized,

although their frequency tuning ranges are significantly narrower.

An ECDL typically has two tuning modes, i.e. the wide and fine tuning modes. In the wide tuning mode, the external cavity length that determines the laser frequency is controlled by a stepper motor, enabling a frequency tuning range exceeding ten terahertz. In the fine tuning mode, the external cavity length is controlled by a piezo under an external voltage that determines the laser frequency. In this mode, the laser can only be tuned by tens of gigahertz. Triangular and sinusoidal voltage signals are often used to drive the piezo, and to determine the laser chirp range BB and modulation frequency fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}}. The average chirp rate is αset=2Bfmod\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 2Bf_{\mathrm{mod}}.

First, we characterize these lasers in the wide tuning mode. We take one Toptica CTL laser as the first example. Experimentally, the laser is configured to a single run that chirps from 1550 to 1560 nm. On the laser panel, we manually set the chirp rate αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} to 1, 2, 5, and 10 nm/s. The oscilloscope’s sample resolution is set to 155 Hz for different αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}. The instantaneous chirp rate α(t)\alpha(t) within 1 MHz interval is tracked, allowing retrieval of the instantaneous laser frequency fl(t)f_l(t) as well as the wavelength λ(t)\lambda(t). In this manner, α(t)\alpha(t) can be convert to α(λ)\alpha(\lambda) for a better comparison of cases of different αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}.

Laser brandModelTuning modeOptimal αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}}Chirp rangeRMSEδL\delta_L
TopticaCTL 1550Wide, single2 nm/s (0.24 THz/s)-10 nm (1.2 THz)7.5% (1.1%)0.2% (0.0%)
SantecTSL-570-AWide, single100 nm/s (12 THz/s)-10 nm (1.2 THz)6.8% (1.6%)0.4% (0.2%)
New FocusTLB-6700Wide, single2 nm/s (0.24 THz/s)-10 nm (1.2 THz)12.9% (1.9%)0.3% (0.2%)
EXFOT500SWide, single100 nm/s (12 THz/s)-10 nm (1.2 THz)4.8%0.2%
TopticaCTL 1550Fine, triangular0.4 nm/s (50 GHz/s)10 Hz80 pm (10 GHz)15.8% (3.8%)0.8% (0.0%)
SantecTSL-570-AFine, triangular2 nm/s (250 GHz/s)50 Hz80 pm (10 GHz)21.3% (0.7%)2.8% (0.1%)
New FocusTLB-6700Fine, triangular2 nm/s (250 GHz/s)50 Hz80 pm (10 GHz)18.2% (11.8%)0.4% (0.1%)
NKTE15Fine, triangular64 pm/s (8 GHz/s)2 Hz64 pm (8 GHz)5.9% (1.3%)0.5% (0.3%)
TopticaCTL 1550Fine, sinusoidal2 nm/s (250 GHz/s)50 Hz80 pm (10 GHz)15.8% (3.2%)-
SantecTSL-570-AFine, sinusoidal2 nm/s (250 GHz/s)50 Hz80 pm (10 GHz)26.1% (1.4%)-
New FocusTLB-6700Fine, sinusoidal4 nm/s (500 GHz/s)100 Hz80 pm (10 GHz)8.7% (3.8%)-
NKTE15Fine, sinusoidal64 pm/s (8 GHz/s)2 Hz64 pm (8 GHz)7.1% (0.5%)-

Table 1. Comparison of laser chirp dynamics of different lasers with with different conditions.

Figure 3 shows representative α(λ)\alpha(\lambda) traces with different αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} within 0.2 nm wavelength range (1555 to 1555.2 nm) during chirping. To facilitate comparison, we normalize the measured α(λ)\alpha(\lambda) to the set value αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} on the laser panel, i.e. the normalized chirp rate is α(λ)/αset\alpha(\lambda)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}. Here α(λ)/αset=1\alpha(\lambda)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 1 corresponds to perfectly linear chirp at a constant rate. Figure 3a shows that, the experimentally measured α(λ)/αset\alpha(\lambda)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} fluctuates and exhibits nonlinearity. Particularly, when αset=1\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 1 and 5 nm/s, prominent frequency oscillation is observed. Whereas for αset=2\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 2 and 10 nm/s, this oscillation is inhibited. The oscillation pattern of α(λ)/αset\alpha(\lambda)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} is repeated every 1.6 pm, probably due to the laser’s intrinsic configuration or regulation. Besides, mechanical modes of the external laser cavity might also cause chirp rate jitter. Figure 3b shows α(t)/αset\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} spectra in the frequency domain. A component at 3.86 kHz Fourier offset frequency - independent of αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} - is revealed, likely linking to the eigen-frequency of the cavity’s fundamental mechanical mode. Higher-order mechanical modes can also be observed in Figure 3b at 28.22 and 56.43 kHz frequencies when the laser chirps more slowly.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Characterization of Toptica CTL laser’s chirp dynamics. a. Normalized chirp rate α(λ)/αset\alpha(\lambda)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} with different set values αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} over 0.2 nm wavelength range. b. Frequency spectrum of the normalized chirp rate α(t)/αset\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}. The frequency values of prominent peaks are marked. c. Normalized chirp rate α(λ)/αset\alpha(\lambda)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} with different set values αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} over 10 nm wavelength range.

Since Figure 3a shows the optimal laser chirping performance at αset=2\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 2 and 10 nm/s, we further investigate α(λ)/αset\alpha(\lambda)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} over the entire 10 nm bandwidth. Figure 3c shows the laser’s chirp rate drift with αset=2\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 2 and 10 nm/s. Limited by the oscilloscope’s memory depth (400 Mpts) and sampling rate (400 MSa/s), we can only acquire data in 1 second. We set the laser to repeatedly chirp from 1550 to 1560 nm, and characterize one segment of the chirp trace each time. Multiple segments displayed with different colors are stitched to form a complete trace covering the full 10 nm range. It becomes apparent that, although Figure 3b bottom shows weak chirp rate jitter with αset=10\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 10 nm/s, the overall chirp rate drifts considerably. With αset=2\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 2 nm/s, the laser completes its acceleration at 1550.5 nm and reaches stability at 1552.0 nm, until it begins to decelerate at 1559.5 nm. The laser maintains a good linearity in the center 7.5 nm range. We therefore conclude that, in the wide tuning mode, the optimal chirp rate for Toptica CTL is αset=2\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 2 nm/s.

We further characterized another two Toptica CTL lasers, four Santec lasers, two New Focus lasers and one EXFO laser in their wide tuning modes. The laser chirping performance is investigated within 1550 to 1560 nm bandwidth, and αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} is set from 1 to 200 nm/s. Table I presents a summary of different lasers’ chirp dynamics with their respective optimal αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}. We refer the readers to Supplementary Materials for detailed characterization results of each laser, which can be useful for readers currently using these lasers. Overall, in the wide tuning mode, the Santec and EXFO lasers work best with αset=100\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 100 nm/s, and the Toptica CTL and New Focus lasers work best with αset=2\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 2 nm/s.

To show the deviation of laser chirp rate from α(t)/αset=1\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 1, we calculate the root mean square error (RMSE) as

RMSE=∑i=1T(αi/αset−1)2T,(1)\mathrm{RMSE} = \sqrt{\frac{\sum_{i=1}^{T}(\alpha_i/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}-1)^2}{T}}, \tag*{(1)}

where αi\alpha_i is the sample of chirp rate and TT is sample number. Besides, the wavelength linearity can be estimated by nonlinearity error[24] δL=Δλmax⁡/λf.s.\delta_L = \Delta\lambda_{\max}/\lambda_{\mathrm{f.s.}}, where Δλmax⁡\Delta\lambda_{\max} is the maximum deviation of the measured wavelength from its linearly fitted value, and λf.s.\lambda_{\mathrm{f.s.}} is the full-scale wavelength range. This indicator mainly considers whether the laser chirp is linear, but not whether the average chirp rate α‾set\overline{\alpha}_{\mathrm{set}} matches the set value αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}. Particularly, Table I shows that the EXFO laser features the smallest RMSE and δL\delta_L with αset=100\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 100 nm/s.

Next, we characterized eleven lasers in the fine tuning modes, including three Toptica CTL lasers, four Santec lasers, two New Focus lasers, and two NKT lasers.

We note that the EXFO laser does not feature the fine tuning mode. These lasers are frequency-modulated at 193.3193.3 THz optical frequency and with excursion range of 1010 GHz (except that 88 GHz for the NKT lasers). The drive voltage signal to the piezo is either triangular or sinusoidal. We set the modulation frequency fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} to 2, 10, 50 and 100 Hz. For normalization, the set chirp rate αset(t)\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}(t) is calculated according to the drive signal. The optimal fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} for different lasers with different drive manners are listed in Table I (see Supplementary Materials for detailed characterization results of each laser). For the cases with sinusoidal drive, αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} represents the average set chirp rate α‾set\overline{\alpha}_{\mathrm{set}}. For the Toptica CTL and New Focus lasers, different drives have different effects, as the triangular drive may cause resonance in the piezo at certain frequencies (see Supplementary Materials). Therefore, these lasers behave better with a sinusoidal drive.

Light detection and ranging

Based on our frequency-comb-calibrated laser chirping dynamics, we further demonstrate a linearization method for widely chirping laser for FMCW LiDAR. LiDAR can quickly and accurately map the environment, provide insights into the structure and composition, and allow operators to make informed decisions on the protection of natural resources[25, 26] and environment[27, 28] or manage agriculture[29]. For autonomous vehicles, LiDAR enables safe and reliable navigation by providing high-resolution, real-time 3D mapping of the environment[30, 31]. The technology has also revolutionized archaeology, allowing nondestructive imaging of hidden features and artifacts[32, 33, 34].

The principle of LiDAR is to project an optical signal onto a moving object. The reflected or scattered signal is received and processed to determine the object’s distance from the laser[35]. The light received by the photodetector experiences a time delay τ\tau from its emission time. Thus the object’s distance is calculated as d=cτ/2d=c\tau/2, where cc is the speed of light. For FMCW LiDAR, the time delay τ\tau is obtained in a coherent way[7, 8, 9]. The frequency-modulated laser is split into two paths as shown in the LiDAR panel of Figure 1a. In one path, the laser passes through a collimator, enters into free space, and is reflected by the object. The reflected laser is then combined with the other reference path, and the beat signal between the two paths is recorded by a photodetector. If the laser frequency is modulated linearly at a constant chirp rate α\alpha, the time delay τ\tau creates a beat signal of frequency Δf=ατ\Delta f=\alpha\tau. Thus, the photodetected beat signal is

V(t)∝cos⁡(2πΔft)=cos⁡(2πα2dct).(2)\begin{aligned} V(t) &\propto\cos(2\pi\Delta f t)\\ &=\cos\left(2\pi\alpha\frac{2d}{c}t\right). \tag*{(2)} \end{aligned}

Equation (2) indicates that the distance dd can be obtained with fast Fourier transformation on tt.

The ranging resolution[10] δd\delta d of FMCW LiDAR is limited by the chirp range BB, as δd=c/2B\delta d=c/2B. High resolution, i.e. small δd\delta d, requires a large BB of the chirping laser. However, chirp nonlinearity causes a varying α\alpha over time. Consequently, the beat frequency Δf\Delta f varies as shown in Figure 1b. To extract the precise value of dd from V(t)V(t), an accurate trace of α(t)\alpha(t) is mandatory, necessitating the calibration of the instantaneous laser frequency during chirping. The chirp linearization is performed by re-scaling the beat signal’s time axis by t′=α(t)tt'=\alpha(t)t to

V(t′)=cos⁡(2π2dct′).(3)V(t')=\cos\left(2\pi\frac{2d}{c}t'\right). \tag*{(3)}

Here, using our frequency-comb-calibration method, the characterized laser chirp rate α(t)\alpha(t) in return allows chirp rate pre-linearization. Again we use the Toptica CTL laser as the example. The laser has optimal performance of chirp linearity when driven by a 50 Hz sinusoidal wave. The chirp range is set to 35 GHz in the fine tuning mode, and α(t)\alpha(t) is characterized (see Supplementary Materials). The same characterization of α(t)\alpha(t) is performed three times, and the averaged result is used as the pre-linearized chirp rate αc(t)\alpha_c(t). By re-scaling the time axis in Eq. (2) by t′=αc(t)tt'=\alpha_c(t)t, the laser is pre-linearized and the range profile can be extracted from Eq. (3). The photodetected signal is re-scaled with αc(t)\alpha_c(t). Zero-padding[36] is also implemented to reduce resolution ambiguities.

Finally, we proceed a LiDAR experiment without any extra linearization unit. Experimentally, a stainless steel cylinder with an engraved text of 2.8 mm depth on its surface is imaged using our LiDAR setup. The stainless steel cylinder is placed on a 2D translation stage 4 meter away from the collimator. As the translation stage moves, the distance between the cylinder surface and the collimator is continuously measured to produce a 2D ranging map.

To highlight the effect of linearization, we measure the surface profile using two methods, i.e. with pre-linearization and without any linearization. We emphasize that, the former case only requires a characterized αc(t)\alpha_c(t) as prior knowledge for signal processing, and no OFC nor real-time frequency calibration is used in the ranging experiment. To retrieve the ranging profile, for pre-linearization, the beat signal V(t′)V(t') of Eq. (3) is rewritten as V(l′)=cos⁡(2πdl′)V(l')=\cos(2\pi d l'), where l′=ct′/2l'=ct'/2. By fast Fourier transform on l′l', the space spectrum is obtained, as shown in the top panel of Figure 4b. The peak corresponds to the distance d=4d=4 m of the surface to the laser. For the case without linearization, the beat signal V(t)V(t) of Eq. (2) is rewritten as V(l)=cos⁡(2πdl)V(l)=\cos(2\pi d l), where l=ct/2αsetl=ct/2\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} and αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} is the set chirp rate. The space spectrum obtained by fast Fourier transform on ll is shown in the bottom panel of Figure 4b. Without linearization, the peak is broadened due to ranging imprecision, leading to ambiguous determination of distance. Figure 4a shows the measured relative distance map with pre-linearization (left) and without any linearization (right). The long-term stability of pre-linearization is verified by a precision test (see Supplementary Materials).

Maps of measured relative distance and space spectra for coherent LiDAR with and without pre-linearization

Figure 4. Coherent LiDAR experiment. a. Maps of measured relative distance of an engraved surface with pre-linearization and without linearization. A tilt angle of 11.6∘11.6^\circ of the sample is measured and further subtracted. b. Space spectra of the ranging profiles obtained with pre-linearization and without linearization. Fast Fourier transform is applied on the ranging profile of each case to retrieve the spectrum. The peaks correspond to the distance d=4d = 4 m of the surface to the laser.

Conclusion

In conclusion, we have demonstrated an approach to characterize chirp dynamics of widely tunable lasers based on an OFC. Using this method we have characterized twelve lasers including three Toptica CTL lasers, four Santec lasers, two New Focus lasers, two NKT fiber lasers and one EXFO laser. By comparing the laser’s chirp linearity with different settings, the optimal operation condition of each laser is found. For example, the optimal chirp rate of Toptica CTL, New Focus, Santec, and EXFO lasers are αset=2\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}=2, 2, 100 and 100 nm/s, respectively. Operating the laser with its optimal setting and pre-linearizing laser chirp, we successfully apply the laser for coherent LiDAR without any extra linearization units. Field-programmable gate arrays (FPGA) to implement multiple FIR filters can be further added to increase data processing speed and reduce the amount of data to be stored by real-time data processing. Our method of characterizing and pre-linearizing laser chirp dynamics is proved to be a critical diagnostic method for applications such as OCT, OFDR, and TDLAS.

Funding Information: J. Liu acknowledges support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No.12261131503), Shenzhen-Hong Kong Cooperation Zone for Technology and Innovation (HZQB-KCZYB2020050), and from the Guangdong Provincial Key Laboratory (2019B121203002). Y.-H. L. acknowledges support from the China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (Grant No. 2022M721482).

Author contributions: B. S., W. S., Y.-H. L. and J. Long built the experimental setup, with the assistance from X. B. and A. W.. B. S. performed the laser characterization. B. S. and Y. H. and Y.-H. L. performed the LiDAR experiments. B. S., W. S., Y.-H. L. and J. Liu analysed the data and prepared the manuscript with input from others. J. Liu supervised the project.

Conflict of interest: B. S., Y.-H. L., W. S., X. B. and J. Liu filed a patent application for the tunable laser characterization and linearization method. Others declare no conflicts of interest.

Data Availability Statement: The code and data used to produce the plots within this work will be released on the repository Zenodo upon publication of this preprint.

Supplementary Materials for:

Laser chirp dynamics for wide tuning mode

For wide tuning mode, we have characterized totally 10 lasers. These lasers include three Toptica CTL lasers, four Santec lasers, two New Focus lasers, and one EXFO laser. The laser chirp dynamics is investigated within 1550 to 1560 nm bandwidth, and αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} is set to 1 nm/s, 2 nm/s, 5 nm/s, 10 nm/s, 50 nm/s, 100 nm/s, and 200 nm/s. A summary of different lasers’ chirp dynamics with different αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} is shown in Table S1. As well as the laser tuning dynamics performance of the Toptica lasers shown in Figure 3 in the main text, we also present the results for other brands lasers in Figure S1, Figure S2, and Figure S3.

Laser brandModelTuning modeChirp rangeαset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}RMSEδL\delta_{\mathrm{L}}
TopticaCTL 1550Wide, single10 nm1 nm/s16.9% (2.4%)0.2% (0.0%)
TopticaCTL 1550Wide, single10 nm2 nm/s7.5% (1.1%)0.2% (0.0%)
TopticaCTL 1550Wide, single10 nm5 nm/s26.2% (3.4%)0.5% (0.4%)
TopticaCTL 1550Wide, single10 nm10 nm/s14.7% (3.3%)0.3% (0.2%)
SantecTSL-570-AWide, single10 nm5 nm/s14.5% (6.0%)0.5% (0.3%)
SantecTSL-570-AWide, single10 nm10 nm/s11.3% (3.9%)0.7% (0.3%)
SantecTSL-570-AWide, single10 nm20 nm/s14.0% (6.3%)1.4% (0.8%)
SantecTSL-570-AWide, single10 nm50 nm/s6.9% (1.8%)0.4% (0.3%)
SantecTSL-570-AWide, single10 nm100 nm/s6.8% (1.6%)0.4% (0.2%)
SantecTSL-570-AWide, single10 nm200 nm/s8.9% (1.6%)0.3% (0.2%)
New FocusTLB-6700Wide, single10 nm1 nm/s13.9% (1.1%)0.4% (0.0%)
New FocusTLB-6700Wide, single10 nm2 nm/s12.9% (1.9%)0.3% (0.2%)
New FocusTLB-6700Wide, single10 nm5 nm/s13.6% (1.4%)0.8% (0.4%)
New FocusTLB-6700Wide, single10 nm10 nm/s14.8% (4.0%)0.9% (0.6%)
New FocusTLB-6700Wide, single10 nm20 nm/s17.1% (3.4%)0.6% (0.4%)
EXFOT500SWide, single10 nm20 nm/s15.1%1.6%
EXFOT500SWide, single10 nm50 nm/s6.5%0.5%
EXFOT500SWide, single10 nm100 nm/s4.8%0.2%
EXFOT500SWide, single10 nm200 nm/s48.9%0.2%

Table S1. Laser chirp dynamics of stepper based wide tuning mode

Characterization of chirp dynamics of a Santec laser in wide tuning mode

Figure S1. Characterization of chirp dynamics of a Santec laser in wide tuning mode. a. Normalized chirp rate α(λ)/αset\alpha(\lambda)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} with different set values αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} over 0.2 nm wavelength range. b. Frequency spectrum of the chirp rate α(t)/αset\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}. c. Normalized chirp rate α(λ)/αset\alpha(\lambda)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} with αset=100\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 100 nm/s over 10 nm wavelength range.

Characterization of chirp dynamics of a New Focus laser in wide tuning mode

Figure S2. Characterization of chirp dynamics of a New Focus laser in wide tuning mode. a. Normalized chirp rate α(λ)/αset\alpha(\lambda)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} with different set values αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} over 0.2 nm wavelength range. b. Frequency spectrum of the chirp rate α(t)/αset\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}. c. Normalized chirp rate α(λ)/αset\alpha(\lambda)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} with different set values αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} over 10 nm wavelength range.

Normalized chirp rate of an EXFO laser

(a)

Frequency spectrum of the chirp rate

(b)

Figure S3. Characterization of chirp dynamics of an EXFO laser in wide tuning mode. a. Normalized chirp rate α(λ)/αset\alpha(\lambda)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} with different set values αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} over 0.2 nm wavelength range. b. Frequency spectrum of the chirp rate α(t)/αset\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}.

For Santec lasers, when αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} is relatively small, the actual chirp rate has main jitter frequencies of 2.06 kHz, 16.04 kHz, 32.08 kHz, 64.10 kHz, 96.15 kHz and 128.17 kHz. These jitters become less and less pronounced as αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} increases. Taking into account that the random jitter of the chirp rate is slightly greater at 200 nm/s, RMSE is larger, the optimum αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} for the Santec laser is 100 nm/s. In Figure S1, we show the normalised chirp rate over the full 10 nm chirp range for αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 100 nm/s. The Santec laser performed well throughout the set chirp range, with no acceleration or deceleration in between.

As shown in Figure S2, the New Focus laser behaves essentially the same at different αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}. The main jitter frequencies are 0.68 kHz, 2.62 kHz, and 8.43 kHz. And the performance over the full chirp range shows that the laser is not stable at the maximum chirp rate of 20 nm/s. When the chirp rate is 10 nm/s, the laser reaches stability at 1551.5 nm and keeps at a chirp rate larger than the set value.

For the EXFO laser, the jitter frequency is enormous at 8.21 kHz, while no other obvious jitter frequencies are observed, as shown in Figure S3. When αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} = 200 nm/s, the laser did not finish the chirp rate acceleration after the first 5 nm chirp range. After changing the chirp start wavelength from 1550 nm to 1540 nm, the laser can complete its acceleration before entering the test area and shows an RMSE of 5.1% and δL\delta_{\mathrm{L}} = 0.2%. Overall, the EXFO laser has an optima αset\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} of 100 nm/s.

Laser chirp dynamics for piezo-driven fine tuning mode

In addition to stepper based wide tuning mode, we also characterised laser tuning dynamics of piezo-driven fine tuning-mode. The measurement includes three Toptica lasers, four Santec lasers, two New Focus lasers, and two NKT fiber lasers. These lasers are frequency-modulated at the central frequency of 193.3 THz and with an excursion range of 10 GHz (8 GHz for NKT lasers). The drive voltage signal to the piezo is either triangular or sinusoidal. Their modulation frequencies fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} are set to 2 Hz, 10 Hz, 50 Hz and 100 Hz. A summary of different lasers’ chirp dynamics with different fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} is shown in Table S2. The typical results for these lasers are shown in Figure S4, Figure S5, Figure S6 and Figure S7.

Laser brandModelTuning modefmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} (Hz)Chirp rangeRMSEδL\delta_L
TopticaCTL 1550Piezo, triangular210 GHz17.8% (4.5%)0.8% (0.0%)
TopticaCTL 1550Piezo, sinusoidal210 GHz17.8% (4.0%)-
TopticaCTL 1550Piezo, triangular1010 GHz15.8% (3.8%)0.8% (0.0%)
TopticaCTL 1550Piezo, sinusoidal1010 GHz16.0% (3.4%)-
TopticaCTL 1550Piezo, triangular5010 GHz16.3% (3.4%)0.9% (0.0%)
TopticaCTL 1550Piezo, sinusoidal5010 GHz15.8% (3.2%)-
TopticaCTL 1550Piezo, triangular10010 GHz21.5% (5.7%)0.9% (0.0%)
TopticaCTL 1550Piezo, sinusoidal10010 GHz17.8% (3.0%)-
SantecTSL-570-APiezo, triangular210 GHz34.9% (3.4%)1.8% (0.1%)
SantecTSL-570-APiezo, sinusoidal210 GHz35.3% (7.5%)-
SantecTSL-570-APiezo, triangular1010 GHz27.1% (1.7%)1.8% (0.1%)
SantecTSL-570-APiezo, sinusoidal1010 GHz29.3% (2.9%)-
SantecTSL-570-APiezo, triangular5010 GHz21.3% (0.7%)2.8% (0.1%)
SantecTSL-570-APiezo, sinusoidal5010 GHz26.1% (1.4%)-
SantecTSL-570-APiezo, triangular10010 GHz34.1% (1.0%)3.3% (0.3%)
SantecTSL-570-APiezo, sinusoidal10010 GHz34.4% (1.5%)-
New FocusTLB-6700Piezo, triangular5010 GHz18.2% (11.8%)0.4% (0.1%)
New FocusTLB-6700Piezo, sinusoidal5010 GHz12.6% (8.4%)-
New FocusTLB-6700Piezo, triangular10010 GHz33.2% (7.3%)1.3% (0.1%)
New FocusTLB-6700Piezo, sinusoidal10010 GHz8.7% (3.8%)-
NKTE15Piezo, triangular28 GHz5.9% (1.3%)0.5% (0.3%)
NKTE15Piezo, sinusoidal28 GHz7.1% (0.5%)-
NKTE15Piezo, triangular108 GHz5.9% (1.7%)0.6% (0.3%)
NKTE15Piezo, sinusoidal108 GHz7.8% (1.7%)-
NKTE15Piezo, triangular508 GHz11.2% (3.7%)1.2% (0.5%)
NKTE15Piezo, sinusoidal508 GHz18.1% (2.3%)-
NKTE15Piezo, triangular1008 GHz18.4% (4.2%)2.2% (0.5%)
NKTE15Piezo, sinusoidal1008 GHz34.8% (3.0%)-

Table S2. Laser chirp dynamics of piezo-driven fine tuning mode

Image not extracted

Figure S4. Characterization of chirp dynamics of an NKT laser in fine tuning mode. a. Normalized chirp rate α(f)/αset\alpha(f)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} with different set values fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} over 6 GHz frequency range. The piezo of the laser is driven by a triangular (blue) or a sinusoidal (red) signal. b. Frequency spectrum of the chirp rate α(t)/αset\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}.

Characterization of chirp dynamics of a Santec laser in fine tuning mode

Figure S5. Characterization of chirp dynamics of a Santec laser in fine tuning mode. a. Normalized chirp rate α(f)/αset\alpha(f)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} with different set values fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} over 9 GHz frequency range. The piezo of the laser is driven by a triangular (blue) or a sinusoidal (red) signal. b. Frequency spectrum of the chirp rate α(t)/αset\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}.

Characterization of chirp dynamics of a Toptica laser in fine tuning mode

Figure S6. Characterization of chirp dynamics of a Toptica laser in fine tuning mode. a. Normalized chirp rate α(f)/αset\alpha(f)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} with different set values fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} over 9 GHz frequency range. The piezo of the laser is driven by a triangular (blue) or a sinusoidal (red) signal. b. Frequency spectrum of the chirp rate α(t)/αset\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}.

Characterization of chirp dynamics of a New Focus laser in fine tuning mode

Figure S7. Characterization of chirp dynamics of a New Focus laser in fine tuning mode. a. Normalized chirp rate α(f)/αset\alpha(f)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} with different set values fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} over 9 GHz frequency range. The piezo of the laser is driven by a triangular (blue) or a sinusoidal (red) signal. b. Frequency spectrum of the chirp rate α(t)/αset\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}.

NKT lasers behave the same with both triangular and sinusoidal drive signals. The laser has significant jitter frequencies of 25.09 kHz and 73.49 kHz when fmod=10f_{\mathrm{mod}} = 10 Hz. Jitter at these frequencies disappears at higher fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}}. However, as fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} increases, so does the chirp rate drift. Another manifestation of the NKT laser is that its actual chirp range does not reach the set value when fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} is relative high. The optimum fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} for the NKT laser is 2 Hz, which actually works well at different modulation frequencies.

The behavior of Santec lasers are similar to NKT ones. The laser has significant jitter frequencies of 0.71 kHz and 1.88 kHz at fmod=2f_{\mathrm{mod}} = 2 Hz and these jitters disappear at higher fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}}. Besides, as fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} increases, the actual chirp range of Santec lasers decreases. Over all, Santec lasers work best when driven by a 50 Hz sinusoidal wave.

The results for Toptica lasers are shown in Figure S6. For the triangular drive signal of 50 Hz and 100 Hz, an obvious chirping rate oscillation can be observed. While for the situation a sinusoidal signal is input, the oscillation is not evident. From the frequency domain, as shown in Figure S6, the oscillation frequency can be directly obtained as 3.84 kHz, which is likely the resonant frequency of the fundamental mechanical mode excited by high-order components of the high fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} triangular input signal. To make this easier to understand, three different drive signals are shown in Figure S8 and their Fourier transforms are shown in Figure S8. It can be seen that triangular waves contain many high frequency components. The higher the drive frequency, the higher the amplitude around the 3.84 kHz frequency of the triangular waveform. Thus, the triangular wave drive signal tends to excite the resonance of the laser cavity. Besides, at a modulation frequency of 10 Hz, higher order mechanical modes with frequencies of 28.22 kHz and 56.43 kHz can also be observed. Similarly, as the chirp rate increases, these obvious high-frequency resonances disappear. Overall, Toptica lasers should be driven sinusoidally and their optimum modulation frequency is 50 Hz.

Image not extracted

Figure S8. Supplementary Figure S8: a. Different drive signals. b. The Fourier transform of different drive signals.

Figure S7 shows the results of New Focus lasers. New Focus lasers exist mode-hopping when fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} equals to 10 or 20 Hz, so we failed to trace the laser’s instantaneous frequency. Besides, the laser’s fundamental mechanical mode of 1.10 kHz will be excited by a triangular driven signal. The laser’s optimum fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} is 100 Hz.

Laser tuning dynamics for LiDAR demonstration {#sec:Supplementary Note 3}

In FMCW LiDAR, the fine tuning mode is commonly used because of its low duty cycle. Here we chose a Toptica laser for the LiDAR demonstration because it has the largest chirp range, 35 GHz, out of our 4 types of lasers. We make the laser chirp with the central frequency of 193.3 THz and the chirp range of 35 GHz. Some typical results are shown in Figure S9. Still, we can observe the fundamental mode of 3.8 kHz excited by 50 Hz triangular driven signal. Besides, higher-order mechanical modes can also be observed from the upper panel of the Figure S9, i.e., with a frequency of 56.4 kHz. As fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} increases, the noise floor of the frequency-domain chirp rate increases but some obvious high-frequency resonances disappear, as shown in the lower panel of Figure S9. Overall, this laser performs best when driven by a 50 Hz sinusoidal signal.

Image not extracted

Figure S9. Laser characterization for LiDAR demonstration. a. Normalized chirp rate α(f)/αset\alpha(f)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}} with different set values fmodf_{\mathrm{mod}} over 24 GHz frequency range. The piezo of the laser is driven by a triangular (blue) or a sinusoidal (red) signal. b. Frequency spectrum of the chirp rate α(t)/αset\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}. c. Upper panel shows the chirp rate curve α(t)\alpha(t) (blue) and pre-linearization curve αc(t)\alpha_{\mathrm{c}}(t) (red). Lower panel shows the linearized chirp rate curve α(t)/αc(t)\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{c}}(t). d. Frequency spectrum of the linearized chirp rate in lower panel of panel c. The dot-and-dash line shows its averaged amplitude below 100 kHz. The dashed line shows the averaged amplitude of normalized chirp rate α(t)/αset(t)\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}(t)'s frequency spectrum below 100 kHz.

Next, we characterized the effect of our pre-linearization method. We first measure the laser’s chirp rate for three times. The averaged result is used as the pre-linearization chirp rate αc(t)\alpha_c(t), as shown in the upper panel of Figure S9. The pre-obtained αc(t)\alpha_c(t) can be used to perform chirp rate linearization. To verify the effectiveness of linearization, we characterized the laser again as the real-time measurement α(t)\alpha(t). Their consistency is compared by α(t)/αc(t)\alpha(t)/\alpha_c(t) as shown in the lower panel of Figure S9. Clearly, the chirp rate drift is eliminated. Its Fourier transform spectrum is shown in Figure S9. The averaged amplitude of it below 100 kHz is shown by a dot-and-dash line. Compared with the averaged amplitude of α(t)/αset(t)\alpha(t)/\alpha_{\mathrm{set}}(t)’s frequency spectrum, shown by the dashed line, the oscillation level has been attenuated by 7.4 dB. However, oscillations of 3.8 kHz and 56.4 kHz still exist, indicating the random nature of the oscillation generated by the cavity resonances. This fact implies that the avoidance of the cavity resonance is crucial to reduce the phase noise of an offline calibrated chirping laser. Thus in our case, a 50-Hz sinusoidal drive signal is utilized for LiDAR demonstration.

Set up for LiDAR demonstration and precision test {#sec:Supplementary Note 4}

With the pre-obtained αc(t)\alpha_c(t), the LiDAR demonstration can be proceeded without any extra linearization unit. As shown in Figure S10, the frequency modulated laser is split into two paths. In one path, the laser passes through a collimator, enters into free space, is reflected by the target, and is re-collected. The reflected laser is then combined with the other reference path, and the beat signal between the two paths is recorded by a balanced photodetector.

Image not extracted

Figure S10. Setup for LiDAR demonstration and precision test a. Experimental setup. BPD, balanced photodetector. OSC, oscilloscope. b. Histogram of deviation of range measurement. The long-term stability of pre-linearization is verified by a precision test. A mirror is fixed at a distance of 53.361 mm and measured 1128 times every 3 s. The standard deviation of the measured distance is 11 μ\mum.

To test the long-term stability of pre-linearization, a fixed mirror is used as the target at a distance of 53.361 mm and measured 1128 times every 3 s. Their relative distance histogram is shown in Figure S10 with a standard deviation of 11 μ\mum.

References

  1. [1]B. Cense, N. A. Nassif, T. C. Chen, M. C. Pierce, S. Yun, B. H. Park, B. E. Bouma, G. J. Tearney, and J. F. Boer, Optics Express 12, 2435 (2004).
  2. [2]J. Grulkowski, J. J. Liu, B. Potsaid, V. Jayaraman, C. D. Lu, J. Jiang, A. E. Cable, J. S. Duker, and J. G. Fujimoto, Biomedical Optics Express 3, 2733 (2012).
  3. [3]F. Lexer, C. K. Hitzenberger, A. F. Fercher, and M. Kulhavy, Applied Optics 36, 6548 (1997).
  4. [4]B. J. Soller, D. K. Gifford, M. S. Wolfe, and M. E. Froggatt, Opt. Express 13, 666 (2005).
  5. [5]X. Liu and Y. Ma, Sensors 22 (2022), 10.3390/s22166095.
  6. [6]J. Liu, V. Brasch, M. H. P. Pfeiffer, A. Kordts, A. N. Kamel, H. Guo, M. Geiselmann, and T. J. Kippenberg, Opt. Lett. 41, 3134 (2016).
  7. [7]P. A. Roos, R. R. Reibel, T. Berg, B. Kaylor, Z. W. Barber, and W. R. Babbitt, Opt. Lett. 34, 3692 (2009).
  8. [8]E. Baumann, F. R. Giorgetta, I. Coddington, L. C. Sinclair, K. Knabe, W. C. Swann, and N. R. Newbury, Opt. Lett. 38, 2026 (2013).
  9. [9]G. Lihachev, J. Riemensberger, W. Weng, J. Liu, H. Tian, A. Siddharth, V. Snigirev, V. Shadymov, A. Voloshin, R. N. Wang, J. He, A. S. Bhave, and T. J. Kippenberg, Nature Communications 13, 3522 (2022).
  10. [10]U. Glombitza and E. Brinkmeyer, Journal of Lightwave Technology 11, 1377 (1993).
  11. [11]T. Ahn, J. Y. Lee, and D. Y. Kim, Appl. Opt. 44, 7630 (2005).
  12. [12]X. Zhang, J. Pouls, and M. C. Wu, Opt. Express 27, 9965 (2019).
  13. [13]P. Del’Haye, O. Arcizet, M. L. Gorodetsky, R. Holzwarth, and T. J. Kippenberg, Nature Photonics 3, 529 (2009).
  14. [14]F. R. Giorgetta, I. Coddington, E. Baumann, W. C. Swann, and N. R. Newbury, Nature Photonics 4, 853 (2010).
  15. [15]K. Tawana, Z. Ye, Óskar B. Helgason, K. Vivivan, M. Karlsson, and V. Torres-Company, Opt. Express 29, 24363 (2021).
  16. [16]T. Udem, R. Holzwarth, and T. W. Hänsch, Nature 416, 233 (2002).
  17. [17]S. T. Cundiff and J. Ye, Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 325 (2003).
  18. [18]S. A. Diddams, K. Vahala, and T. Udem, Science 369, eaay3676 (2020).
  19. [19]L. Marple, IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing 47, 2600 (1999).
  20. [20]T. Herr, V. Brasch, J. D. Jost, C. Y. Wang, N. M. Kondratiev, M. L. Gorodetsky, and T. J. Kippenberg, Nature Photonics 8, 145 (2013).
  21. [21]H. Guo, M. Karpov, E. Lucas, A. Kordts, M. H. P. Pfeiffer, V. Brasch, G. Lihachev, E. E. Lobanov, M. L. Gorodetsky, and T. J. Kippenberg, Nature Physics 13, 94 (2017).
  22. [22]J. Liu, E. Lucas, A. S. Raja, J. He, J. Riemensberger, R. N. Wang, M. Karpov, H. Guo, R. Bouchand, and T. J. Kippenberg, Nature Photonics 14, 486 (2020).
  23. [23]Y.-H. Luo, B. Shi, W. Sun, R. Chen, S. Huang, Z. Wang, J. Long, C. Shen, H. Jia, Z. Ye, H. Guo, and J. Liu, “A vector spectrum analyzer of 55.1 thz spectral bandwidth and 99 khz frequency resolution,” (2023), arXiv:2304.04295 [physics.optics].
  24. [24]C. L. Giusca, R. K. Leach, and F. Helery, Measurement Science and Technology 23, 065005 (2012).
  25. [25]M. A. Lefsky, W. B. Cohen, G. G. Parker, and D. J. Harding, BioScience 52, 19 (2002).
  26. [26]M. P. Simard, N. F. Pinto, B. Joshua, and A. Baccini, Journal of Geophysical Research: Biogeosciences 116 (2011), 10.1029/2011JG001708.
  27. [27]F. G. Fernald, Applied Optics 23, 652 (1984).
  28. [28]M. A. Vaughan, K. A. Powell, W. D. M, C. A. Hostetler, R. E. Kuehn, M. W. H. B, J. J. Getzewich, S. A. Young, Z. Liu, and M. J. McGill, Journal of Atmospheric and Oceanic Technology 26, 2034 (2009).
  29. [29]D. J. Mulla, Biosystems Engineering 114, 358 (2013).
  30. [30]X. Chen, H. Ma, J. Wan, B. Li, and T. Xia, in 2017 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), (2017) pp. 6526–6534.
  31. [31]X. Yue, B. Wu, W. S. A. Seshia, K. Keutzer, and A. L. Sangiovanni-Vincentelli, in Proceedings of the 2018 ACM on International Conference on Multimedia Retrieval (Association for Computing Machinery, 2018) pp. 458–464.
  32. [32]A. F. Chase, D. Z. Chase, J. F. Weishampel, J. B. Drake, R. L. Shrestha, K. C. Slatton, J. J. Awe, and W. E. Carter, Journal of Archaeological Science 38, 387 (2011).
  33. [33]A. F. Chase, D. Z. Chase, C. T. Fisher, S. J. Leisz, and J. F. Weishampel, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109, 12916 (2012).
  34. [34]D. H. Evans, R. J. Fletcher, C. Pottier, J. Chevance, D. Soutif, B. S. Tan, S. Im, D. Ea, T. Tin, S. Kim, C. Cromarty, S. D. Greef, K. Hanus, P. Bäty, R. Kusinger, I. Shimoda, and G. Boornazian, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 110, 12595 (2013).
  35. [35]M.-C. Amann, T. M. Bosch, M. Lescure, R. A. Mylylae, and M. Rioux, Optical Engineering 40, 10 (2001).
  36. [36]K. A. Shinpaugh, R. L. Simpson, A. L. Wicks, S. M. Ha, and J. L. Fleming, Experiments in Fluids 12, 319 (1992).

Paper details

vlnc:W_a5rmdwc8
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents