betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

A note on an extension of Shidov's theorem and Shlyk's theorem

Abstract

Let GG be a non-solvable group and pp any fixed prime divisor of ∣G∣|G|. We prove that the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of GG of order divisible by pp containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is pp-closed, which provides a further generalization of Shidov's theorem and Shlyk's theorem.

Introduction

In this paper all groups are assumed to be finite. Recall that the intersection of all maximal subgroups of a group is called a Frattini subgroup. As generalizations, Shidov [4] showed that the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of a non-solvable group is nilpotent, which follows easily that the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of a non-solvable group is equal to its Frattini subgroup. In [5], Shlyk proved that the intersection of all non-normal non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of a non-solvable group is nilpotent. Recently, Shi, Xu and Li [3 Theorem 1.2] gave the following result.

Theorem 1.1 [3 Theorem 1.2] The intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of a non-solvable GG containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is nilpotent.

Let GG be a group and pp any fixed prime divisor of ∣G∣|G|. In [1 Theorem 1.1] Li and Shi provided a complete characterization of a group GG in which every maximal subgroup of order divisible by pp containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is nilpotent. In particular, [1 Corollary 1.2] indicated that any non-solvable GG has a non-nilpotent maximal subgroup of order divisible by pp containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup for any fixed prime divisor pp of ∣G∣|G|.

E-mail addresses: [email protected] (J. Shi), [email protected] (F. Li).

Recall that a group is said to be pp-closed if its Sylow pp-subgroup is normal. In this paper, as a further generalization of Shidov’s theorem, Shlyk’s theorem and [3 Theorem 1.2], only considering the non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of a non-solvable group of order divisible by pp containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup, we have the following result, the proof of which is given in Section 3.

Theorem 1.2 Let GG be a non-solvable group and pp any fixed prime divisor of ∣G∣|G|. Then the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of GG of order divisible by pp containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is pp-closed.

Note that [3 Theorem 1.2] is a direct consequence of Theorem 1.2. The following two corollaries emerge by Theorem 1.2.

Corollary 1.3 Let GG be a non-solvable group and pp any fixed prime divisor of ∣G∣|G|. Then the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of GG of order divisible by pp is pp-closed.

Corollary 1.4 Let GG be a non-solvable group and pp any fixed prime divisor of ∣G∣|G|. Then the intersection of all non-normal non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of GG of order divisible by pp is pp-closed.

For Corollary 1.3, when p=2p=2, we have the following result, the proof of which is given in Section 4.

Corollary 1.5 The intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of GG of even order is equal to the Frattini subgroup of GG.

Note that Corollary 1.5 provides an extension of Shidov’s theorem.

Two Necessary Lemmas

Lemma 2.1 [2 Theorem 10.4.2] If GG has a nilpotent maximal subgroup of odd order, then GG is solvable.

Lemma 2.2 [6 Lemma 9] Let HH be a nilpotent Hall-subgroup of a group GG that is not a Sylow subgroup of GG. If for each prime divisor pp of ∣H∣|H|, assume P∈Syl⁡p(H)P \in\operatorname{Syl}_p(H) we always have NG(P)=HN_G(P)=H, then there exists a normal subgroup KK of GG such that G=KHG=KH and K∩H=1K \cap H=1.

Proof of Theorem 1.2

Proof. Since GG is non-solvable, GG has non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of order divisible by pp containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroups by [1 Corollary 1.2]. Let NN be the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of GG of order divisible by pp containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup. Then N⊴GN \trianglelefteq G and N<GN < G.

In the following we prove that NN is pp-closed.

Let GG be a counterexample of the smallest order. If p∤∣N∣p \nmid|N|. Then NN is naturally pp-closed, a contradiction. Thus p∣∣N∣p \mid|N|.

Let P∈Syl⁡p(G)P \in\operatorname{Syl}_{p}(G). Then P∩N∈Syl⁡p(N)P \cap N \in\operatorname{Syl}_{p}(N). Assume P0=P∩NP_{0}=P \cap N. By the assumption, P0⋬NP_{0} \ntrianglelefteq N, which implies that P0⋬GP_{0} \ntrianglelefteq G. One has NG(P)≤NG(P0)<GN_{G}(P) \leq N_{G}(P_{0}) < G. Then GG has a maximal subgroup TT such that NG(P)≤NG(P0)≤TN_{G}(P) \leq N_{G}(P_{0}) \leq T. By Frattini’s argument, G=NG(P0)N=TNG=N_{G}(P_{0})N=TN.

Note that p∣∣T∣p \mid|T|. If TT is non-nilpotent. Then N≤TN \leq T. It follows that G=TN=TG=TN=T, a contradiction. Thus TT is nilpotent.

Claim that all nilpotent maximal subgroups of GG are conjugate. Let DD be any nilpotent maximal subgroup of GG. Since GG is non-solvable, DD has even order by Lemma 2.1. Let D2∈Syl⁡2(D)D_{2} \in\operatorname{Syl}_{2}(D). One has D≤NG(D2)D \leq N_{G}(D_{2}). If D2D_{2} is not a Sylow 22-subgroup of GG. Then D<NG(D2)D<N_{G}(D_{2}). It follows that NG(D2)=GN_{G}(D_{2})=G by the maximality of DD. One has that D/D2D/D_{2} is a nilpotent maximal subgroup of G/D2G/D_{2} of odd order, which implies that G/D2G/D_{2} is solvable by Lemma 2.1. Then GG is solvable, a contradiction. So D2D_{2} is also a Sylow 22-subgroup of GG.

Let EE and FF be any two nilpotent maximal subgroups of GG. Assume that E2E_{2} and F2F_{2} are Sylow 22-subgroups of EE and FF respectively. Then E2E_{2} and F2F_{2} are also Sylow 22-subgroups of GG. One has E2g=F2E_{2}^{g}=F_{2} for some g∈Gg \in G. Note that NG(E2)=EN_{G}(E_{2})=E and NG(F2)=FN_{G}(F_{2})=F. It follows that Eg=(NG(E2))g=NG(E2g)=NG(F2)=FE^{g}=(N_{G}(E_{2}))^{g}=N_{G}(E_{2}^{g})=N_{G}(F_{2})=F.

Therefore, any nilpotent maximal subgroup of GG is a conjugation of TT.

Claim that TT is a nilpotent Hall-subgroup of GG. Otherwise, if TT is not a Hall-subgroup of GG. Then there exists a prime divisor qq of ∣T∣|T| such that the Sylow qq-subgroup QQ of TT is not a Sylow qq-subgroup of GG. Then Q⊴GQ \trianglelefteq G. Note that q≠pq \ne p and G/QG/Q is non-solvable. Let M/QM/Q be the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of GG of order divisible by pp containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup. It is obvious that NQ/Q≤M/QNQ/Q \leq M/Q. By the minimality of GG, one has that M/QM/Q is pp-closed. It follows that NQ/QNQ/Q is also pp-closed. Then PQ/Q⊴M/QPQ/Q \trianglelefteq M/Q. Note that PQ/Qchar⁡NQ/Q⊴G/QPQ/Q \operatorname{char} NQ/Q \trianglelefteq G/Q. One has PQ/Q⊴G/QPQ/Q \trianglelefteq G/Q. Then PQ⊴GPQ \trianglelefteq G. By Frattini’s argument, one has G=NG(P)PQ=NG(P)Q=TQ=TG=N_{G}(P)PQ=N_{G}(P)Q=TQ=T, a contradiction.

Therefore, TT is a nilpotent Hall-subgroup of GG. Moreover, let UU be any Sylow subgroup of TT. Arguing as above QQ, one has NG(U)=TN_{G}(U)=T.

In the following we discuss TT in three cases.

Case (1): When p>2p>2. Since both 22 and pp divide ∣T∣|T|, TT is not a Sylow subgroup of GG. By Lemma 2.2, GG has a normal subgroup HH such that G=H×TG=H \times T. Since 2∣∣T∣2 \mid|T|, HH is a Hall-subgroup of GG of odd order. Then HH is solvable by Feit-Thompson theorem. It follows that GG is solvable since G/H≅TG/H \cong T is nilpotent, a contradiction.

Case (2): When p=2p=2 but TT is not a Sylow 2-subgroup of GG. Arguing as Case (1), we can get a contradiction.

Case (3): When p=2p=2 and TT is a Sylow 2-subgroup of GG, that is T=PT=P. Note that NN is not 2-closed by the assumption. Let rr be any odd prime divisor of ∣N∣|N|. Let R0∈Syl⁡r(N)R_0 \in\operatorname{Syl}_r(N) and R∈Syl⁡r(G)R \in\operatorname{Syl}_r(G) such that R0=R∩NR_0=R\cap N.

Claim that R0⊴GR_0 \trianglelefteq G. Otherwise, if R0⋬GR_0 \ntrianglelefteq G. Then NG(R)≤NG(R0)<GN_G(R) \leq N_G(R_0)<G. Let LL be a maximal subgroup of GG such that NG(R)≤NG(R0)≤LN_G(R)\leq N_G(R_0)\leq L. By Frattini’s argument, G=NG(R0)N=LNG=N_G(R_0)N=LN.

We discuss LL in two cases.

Case (i): Assume 2∣∣L∣2\mid|L|. If LL is non-nilpotent. Then N≤LN\leq L by the hypothesis. It follows that G=LN=LG=LN=L, a contradiction. If LL is nilpotent. By above argument, LL is a conjugation of TT, which implies that LL is also a Sylow 2-subgroup of GG, this contradicts r∣∣L∣r\mid|L| and r>2r>2.

Case (ii): Assume 2∤∣L∣2\nmid|L|. Since G=TN=PNG=TN=PN and G=LNG=LN, one has ∣P∣∣N∣∣P∩N∣=∣L∣∣N∣∣L∩N∣\frac{|P||N|}{|P\cap N|}=\frac{|L||N|}{|L\cap N|}. Note that (∣P∣∣P∩N∣=∣L∣∣L∩N∣)=1\left(\frac{|P|}{|P\cap N|}=\frac{|L|}{|L\cap N|}\right)=1. It follows that ∣P∣∣P∩N∣=1\frac{|P|}{|P\cap N|}=1. Then P=P∩N≤NP=P\cap N\leq N. One has G=PN=NG=PN=N, also a contradiction.

Therefore, R0⊴GR_0\trianglelefteq G. In particular, R0⊴NR_0\trianglelefteq N. By the arbitrariness of rr, NN has a normal 2-complement, that is NN is 2-nilpotent. Then NN is solvable by Feit-Thompson theorem. It follows that GG is solvable since G=TNG=TN and TT is nilpotent, a contradiction.

All above arguments show that the counterexample of the smallest order does not exist and then NN is pp-closed. □

Proof of Corollary 1.5

Proof. Let KK be the intersection of all non-nilpotent maximal subgroups of GG of even order. Then KK is 2-closed by Corollary 1.3. It is obvious that Φ(G)≤K\Phi(G)\leq K.

If K≰Φ(G)K\nleq\Phi(G). Then there exists a maximal subgroup MM of GG such that K≰MK\nleq M. One has G=KMG=KM. By the hypothesis, MM only might be either a non-nilpotent maximal subgroup of odd order or a nilpotent maximal subgroup which are both solvable. It follows that G=KMG=KM is solvable, a contradiction.

Therefore, K≤Φ(G)K\leq\Phi(G) and so K=Φ(G)K=\Phi(G). □

References

  1. [1]F. Li and J. Shi, On a finite group in which every maximal subgroup of order divisible by p containing the normalizer of some Sylow subgroup is nilpotent, preprint.
  2. [2]D.J.S. Robinson, A Course in the Theory of Groups (Second Edition), Springer-Verlag, New York, 1996.
  3. [3]J. Shi, F. Xu and N. Li, On an extension of Shidov’s theorem and Shlyk’s theorem, Journal of Algebra and Its Applications, https://doi.org/10.1142/S0219498828500296.
  4. [4]L.I. Shidov, On maximal subgroups of finite groups, Siberian Mathematical Journal 12 (1971) 488–489.DOI
  5. [5]V.V. Shlyk, On the intersection of maximal subgroups in finite groups, Mathematical Notes 14 (1973) 804–809.DOI
  6. [6]H. Wielandt, Über produkte von nilpotenten gruppen, Illinois Journal of Mathematics 2 (1958) 611-618.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_agzkjs35
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents