In this paper
AbstractIntroductionDistance representation of the Escobar constantCAT() spaces and majorizationProofs of the comparison theoremsHigher order Escobar constantsReferencesWorksMathematics
The Escobar Constant for Two-dimensional Disks
Abstract
Let be a smooth compact Riemannian surface homeomorphic to a closed disk, with boundary length . We establish sharp upper bounds for its Escobar constant under upper bounds on the Gaussian curvature. If , then , with equality if and only if is isometric to a Euclidean disk. If for some , , and , then , with equality if and only if is isometric to the geodesic disk of the same perimeter contained in an open hemisphere of the sphere of constant curvature . We also discuss the higher order Escobar constant for planar domains. In particular, we construct counterexamples to Hassannezhad and Siffert's conjecture.
Introduction
Let , be a compact connected Riemannian manifold with nonempty smooth boundary. Motivated by the search for geometric lower bounds for the first nonzero Steklov eigenvalue, Escobar [4] introduced the isoperimetric constant
where , , and denotes -dimensional Riemannian measure. An admissible set is a relatively open subset with finitely many connected components and piecewise smooth boundary. The above infimum is taken over all admissible sets such that both terms in the denominator are positive. This constant provides a boundary analogue of the classical Cheeger constant. In particular, Escobar proved a Cheeger-type inequality yielding a lower bound for the first Steklov eigenvalue of in terms of and the first Robin eigenvalue of .
In this note, we are concerned with the Escobar constant for two-dimensional Riemannian disks with Gauss curvature bounded from above. For a Riemannian disk , this constant admits a particularly simple representation (see Lemma 2.1)
where is the intrinsic distance on and is the length of the shorter boundary arc joining and . Thus, in this setting, the Escobar constant is determined entirely by the comparison between distances measured within the disk and along its boundary. In the Euclidean setting, Escobar [5 Theorem 2] proved the sharp inequality
for bounded planar domains with rectifiable boundary, with equality if and only if is a round disk. For convex planar domains, the same sharp comparison also follows from the distortion inequality for closed curves; see Kusner–Sullivan [8 Proposition 2.1] for a proof and its attribution to Gromov.
The corresponding Euclidean maximization problem has also been resolved in higher dimensions. Cianchi, Ferone, Nitsch and Trombetti [3 Theorem 1.1] proved that balls minimize the optimal median-normalized boundary trace constant in among admissible domains in , for every . For a bounded connected smooth domain , this constant, denoted by , is the smallest constant such that
where denotes the boundary trace and the total variation of . Its geometric characterization gives . Consequently, their theorem yields the sharp inequality
Within the class of smooth domains, equality holds if and only if is a Euclidean ball. Here is the unit ball in and denotes the volume of the unit ball in .
We establish two sharp comparison theorems of Escobar constants of two-dimensional disks with Gauss curvature bounded from above.
Theorem 1.1. Let be a smooth compact Riemannian surface homeomorphic to a closed disk. If , then
Equality holds if and only if is isometric to a Euclidean disk.
A corresponding sharp comparison holds when the Gaussian curvature has a positive upper bound, under suitable restrictions on the boundary length and the area.
Theorem 1.2. Let be a smooth compact Riemannian surface homeomorphic to a closed disk, and set . Suppose that, for some ,
Then
The equality holds if and only if is isometric to the closed geodesic disk of radius
in the round sphere of constant Gaussian curvature .
It is convenient to introduce a boundary partition isoperimetric profile. Let . For an admissible set , write for the interior and exterior parts of its boundary, respectively. For , define
Taking complements gives , and it follows from the definition that
Theorem 1.3. Let be a smooth compact Riemannian surface homeomorphic to a closed disk with . Then
where . Moreover, the equality at holds if and only if is isometric to the Euclidean disk of perimeter .
The boundary partition profiles of Euclidean and hyperbolic disks can be computed explicitly. Let denote the Euclidean disk of perimeter , and let denote the geodesic disk of perimeter in the hyperbolic plane of constant curvature . A direct computation gives
and
Since is nonincreasing on , we obtain
For every fixed , however,
Consequently, even under the stronger curvature assumption , no upper bound strictly smaller than can hold independently of the perimeter. Thus the constant remains optimal in this class, with optimality witnessed by shrinking hyperbolic disks.
We also consider higher order Escobar constants, introduced by Hassannezhad and Miclo [6]. For an integer , these are defined by
where consists of -tuples of pairwise disjoint nonempty admissible sets, which are not required to cover . The case recovers the Escobar constant . Hassannezhad and Siffert [7] conjectured that the Euclidean disk maximizes among bounded planar domains with rectifiable boundary for every .
We disprove this conjecture by constructing counterexamples among smooth strictly convex planar domains. More precisely, let be the Euclidean unit disk and set . For every fixed integer , we show that
for all sufficiently small nonzero ; see Proposition 5.2. Thus arbitrarily small elliptic deformations of the disk increase each fixed higher order Escobar constant, in contrast to the maximizing property of the disk for .
The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 gives a detailed proof of the distance representation of the Escobar constant. Section 3 recalls the necessary background on CAT() spaces and Reshetnyak’s majorization theorem. Section 4 proves the main comparison theorems. Finally, Section 5 discusses higher-order Escobar constants, gives a short proof of the formula of Hassannezhad and Siffert for Euclidean disks, and constructs counterexamples to their conjecture.
Distance representation of the Escobar constant
Throughout this section, is a smooth compact Riemannian disk, and . We denote by the intrinsic length distance on and by the length of the shorter boundary arc joining .
The following observation reduces the Escobar constant of a disk to a comparison of interior and boundary distances. It was already stated by Escobar for planar domains [5 p. 102, Eq. (3)]. For completeness, we give a detailed proof in the setting of smooth Riemannian disks, allowing admissible sets and their boundary traces to be disconnected. We also record the corresponding estimate for the boundary partition profile, which will be used in the comparison arguments.
Lemma 2.1. For every smooth compact Riemannian disk ,
Moreover, if a boundary arc of length has endpoints , then
Proof. Fix distinct points . For every , there exists a properly embedded piecewise smooth arc joining to , with , such that
Indeed, start with a curve of length less than , push its boundary portions slightly into a smooth collar, and then remove loops and smooth corners. The endpoints remain fixed, and the additional length can be made smaller than .
The arc separates into two components. The component adjacent to the prescribed boundary arc has boundary trace of length . Letting proves (2.2). Using the component adjacent to a shorter boundary arc also gives
For the reverse inequality, set
First consider an admissible set for which is a finite disjoint union of piecewise smooth embedded arcs meeting transversely and simple closed curves in . Let be the arc components, with endpoint pairs . Choose a shorter boundary arc joining to , and put
The characteristic functions of and of the symmetric difference have the same jumps modulo two around the boundary circle. Consequently, this symmetric difference agrees, up to endpoints, with either or its complement. Since the length of a symmetric difference is at most the sum of the lengths, we obtain
Closed components of only add to its length. Therefore,
For a general piecewise smooth admissible set, local smoothing and transverse perturbations in a boundary collar give regular sets such that
The preceding inequality therefore passes to the limit. Taking the infimum over proves (2.1). □
CAT() spaces and majorization
In this section, we collect the metric-geometric facts used in the comparison proofs, beginning with a brief review of CAT() spaces.
For , let denote the complete simply connected surface of constant curvature , and set
Thus , while for ,
A geodesic metric space is called CAT() if every geodesic triangle of perimeter less than satisfies the following comparison: the distance between any two points on its sides is at most the distance between the corresponding points on the comparison triangle in . The corresponding points are determined by their distances along the sides. For , the perimeter restriction is vacuous. A space is locally CAT() if every point has a neighborhood satisfying this comparison.
Under the hypotheses of Theorem 1.1 and Theorem 1.2, the Riemannian disk is a CAT() space.
Lemma 3.1. Let be a smooth compact Riemannian disk.
If , then is CAT(0).
If , , , and , then is CAT().
Proof. For the first statement, equip with its intrinsic length metric. The characterization theorem of Alexander–Berg–Bishop [1] implies that is locally CAT(0), including at boundary points. In dimension two, the additional conditions on sectional curvatures of the boundary are vacuous, since the boundary is one-dimensional. By the Cartan–Hadamard theorem [1 Corollary 1], is CAT(0).
For the second statement, Bowditch [2 Lemma 4.1.3] proved that if a disk is locally CAT(1) and , then is globally CAT(1) if and only if . The general case follows by rescaling. □
A key tool we use in the proof is the following form of Reshetnyak’s majorization theorem [11]; see also [10 Section 3.2 and Section 17].
Theorem 3.2. Let be a complete CAT() space, and let be an arclength parametrization of a rectifiable Jordan curve. Assume that . Then there exist a compact geodesically convex domain , an arclength parametrization , and a 1-Lipschitz map such that . In particular, is an arclength-preserving homeomorphism onto the image of , and . When , the domain lies in an open hemisphere of .
Here the metric on is the restriction of the model distance, which agrees with its intrinsic length metric by convexity.
Lemma 3.3. Let be a smooth compact Riemannian disk, and set . Assume either
or
Then there exist a compact geodesically convex domain and a surjective 1-Lipschitz map whose boundary restriction is an arclength-preserving homeomorphism
In particular, .
Proof. By Lemma 3.1, is CAT(). Apply Theorem 3.2 to an arclength parametrization of . The length condition is automatic when .
It remains to prove that is surjective. Every boundary point lies in its image. If an interior point were omitted, then the boundary homeomorphism would extend to a continuous map . This would make the boundary circle null-homotopic in a punctured disk, which is impossible. Therefore is surjective. □
Proofs of the comparison theorems
We first establish two auxiliary facts used in both curvature regimes: a mean-chord inequality in Euclidean space and a rigidity statement for maps preserving the lengths of diameters. The following inequality can be found in [9].
Lemma 4.1. Let , and let be a closed Lipschitz curve parametrized by arclength. For every ,
Equality at holds if and only if parametrizes a round circle in an affine two-dimensional plane once at unit speed.
Proof. Rescale the curve and its parameter so that . Write its vector-valued Fourier expansion as
Since almost everywhere, Parseval’s identity gives
For , we therefore obtain
Here we used
Rescaling proves (4.1).
Suppose equality holds at . For every ,
so for all . Since is real-valued,
for vectors . The unit-speed condition implies
Thus parametrizes a unit circle in an affine two-dimensional plane. The converse follows by direct calculation. □
Lemma 4.2. Let , let be a CAT space, and let , where and, when , . For , denote by the point on the opposite radial segment with
Let be -Lipschitz. If
then is an isometric embedding.
Proof. Write for the distance in . The -Lipschitz property and (4.2) imply that preserves all distances along each diameter: the distance between its endpoints equals the length of the diameter, so no subsegment can be shortened. Consequently,
and is the midpoint of the geodesic joining to .
First suppose , and identify with the origin. For with , the CAT midpoint inequality gives
Every inequality is an equality. In particular, . The case follows from (4.3).
Now suppose , and set . Fix with , and write
The spherical midpoint identity gives
Since , this implies . Also, . Thus the triangle with vertices has perimeter
The corresponding triangle in has no larger perimeter, so the CAT midpoint comparison applies. Using (4.3), (4.4), and , we obtain
The first inequality follows from the 1-Lipschitz property and the monotonicity of cosine on . The second is the CAT() midpoint inequality, obtained by applying the spherical midpoint identity to the comparison triangle.
All inequalities are therefore equalities. Each of the two terms in the numerator can only have increased in the first inequality, so equality forces
Again, the case follows from (4.3). Thus preserves all distances. □
Proof of Theorems 1.1 and 1.3. Assume . Let and be supplied by Lemma 3.3. Choose an arclength parametrization
and set . Then is an arclength parametrization of , and
Fix . Lemma 4.1 implies that some satisfies
The boundary arc has length . By Lemma 2.1 and (4.5),
Symmetry gives the same estimate for . Taking yields
Suppose . For every , Lemma 2.1 gives
On the other hand,
by Lemma 4.1. Hence equality holds in the mean-chord inequality. Its equality statement shows that is a Euclidean disk of radius . The preceding pointwise inequalities now give
Lemma 4.2 shows that is an isometric embedding. It is surjective by Lemma 3.3, so is isometric to that Euclidean disk.
If , then (9) forces . The preceding argument therefore applies. Conversely, (1) shows that a Euclidean disk attains equality in both comparisons.
Proof of Theorem 1.2. Assume that and
Set
Let and be supplied by Lemma 3.3. Choose an arclength parametrization
and set .
The comparison estimate. Viewed as a curve in , is still parametrized by arclength. For every , Lemma 4.1 gives some such that
For , the spherical distance is related to the Euclidean chord length by
Using Lemma 2.1 and the 1-Lipschitz property of , we obtain
By symmetry, this estimate holds for every . Thus
In particular,
Suppose equality holds in the Escobar comparison. Then (10) implies . For every , Lemma 2.1 gives
Since spherical distance lies in , the chord-length formula implies
Meanwhile, Lemma 4.1 gives
Thus equality holds in the mean-chord inequality, and parametrizes a Euclidean round circle in an affine plane in .
This circle lies on and has Euclidean radius . Since lies in an open hemisphere, it is the smaller spherical disk bounded by this circle. Consequently, for some .
Points whose boundary parameters differ by are now the opposite endpoints of a diameter of this spherical disk. Their spherical distance is , so the preceding inequalities give
Lemma 4.2 shows that is an isometric embedding. Surjectivity then proves that is isometric to the spherical disk of radius .
Conversely, let
Its perimeter is , so . Because is geodesically convex, two boundary points separated by a shorter boundary arc of length have intrinsic distance
To determine the minimum of , put
Then and
Hence is nonincreasing for , and therefore is nonincreasing on . Lemma 2.1 now gives
Thus the spherical disk attains equality. □
Higher order Escobar constants
We conclude by considering higher order Escobar constants. These constants were introduced by Hassannezhad–Miclo [6] in connection with lower bounds for higher Steklov eigenvalues, and were subsequently studied for planar domains by Hassannezhad and Siffert [7].
Let be a compact Riemannian surface with boundary. For a nonempty admissible set , retain the notation and define
A quotient with vanishing denominator is interpreted as .
For an integer , let be the family of -tuples of nonempty mutually disjoint admissible sets. The sets are not required to cover , and their closures may meet. Each may have several connected components; thus counts the number of sets in the tuple, rather than the total number of their connected components. Both boundary lengths in include all components of .
The -th Escobar constant is
In particular, and . Indeed, an admissible set and its complementary region give . Conversely, in any admissible pair, at least one boundary trace has length at most , and the corresponding ratio is at least .
Let denote the Euclidean unit disk. Hassannezhad and Siffert [7 Conjecture 1] conjectured that
for every bounded planar domain with rectifiable boundary and every integer .
In this section, we use the boundary partition profile to give a short proof of the computation of by Hassannezhad–Siffert [7 Theorem 1.3]. Then we show that (12) fails even for smooth strictly convex planar domains.
Proposition 5.1 (Hassannezhad–Siffert). For every Euclidean disk and every integer ,
Proof. By scale invariance, it suffices to consider the unit disk . Its boundary partition profile is
Let . If one of the exterior boundary lengths vanishes, the required lower bound is immediate. Otherwise, disjointness gives
Hence there exists an index such that . Since is decreasing on ,
Taking the infimum proves the lower bound.
For the upper bound, divide into equal arcs and take the circular segments bounded by these arcs and their chords, with common boundaries omitted. These sets are pairwise disjoint, and each satisfies
This proves the matching upper bound. □
Next, we construct counterexamples to (12). For , set
Thus is an ellipse of area .
Proposition 5.2. For every integer , there exists such that
To prove the proposition, we first reduce the problem to regions bounded by one boundary arc and its chord. We call such a region a cap; after straightening its interior boundary, it is a type-1 region in the terminology of [7].
Lemma 5.3. Fix . There exist and such that, whenever , any admissible -tuple in satisfying
can be replaced by a -tuple of caps without increasing its maximal ratio, up to an arbitrarily small error.
Proof. Choose a number such that , and choose sufficiently small that . Since the singular values of are and , every admissible set satisfies
We first perform the usual planar reductions. From each set, retain a connected component whose ratio does not exceed that of the whole set. Fill interior holes and replace interior boundary arcs by their chords. These operations do not increase the ratios. Convexity and the noninterlacing of the boundary traces allow the resulting regions to remain disjoint. Coincident endpoints or interfaces can be separated by arbitrarily small perturbations. This is the chord-straightening reduction used in [7, proof of Theorem 1.3].

Figure 1. Absorbing leaf
The resulting noncrossing chords partition the ellipse into regions. The graph having these regions as vertices and the chords as edges is a tree. If a leaf region does not belong to the chosen -tuple, absorb it into its adjacent chosen region (see the figure above). This removes an interior chord and adds an exterior boundary arc, so the corresponding ratio decreases. Repeating this procedure, we may assume that every leaf region belongs to the tuple.
Pull the resulting configuration back to . By (13), all its ratios are strictly smaller than . Let be determined by
The monotonicity of gives
A leaf region in the disk is a circular segment. If its boundary arc has length , its ratio is . Consequently, every leaf region has boundary arc length greater than .
Removing any edge of a finite tree leaves a leaf of the original tree on each side. Therefore, each side of every chord contains the boundary trace of a chosen leaf region. Both boundary arcs cut off by that chord have length greater than . Its Euclidean length is thus at least .
For the -th chosen region in the disk, let be the number of its interior chords, and let be the length of its exterior boundary. Then
Since the exterior traces are disjoint, , and hence
Each is a positive integer. It follows that for every , so every chosen region is a cap (see the figure below). The same is true after applying .

Figure 2. The grey region cannot occur in such a configuration.
Proof of Proposition 5.2. Fix and put
Thus .
Parametrize the boundary of the ellipse by
and write
A cap corresponding to the parameter interval has ratio
Here is a parameter interval length, rather than the arclength of the corresponding elliptic arc.
We first explain the reduction to equal-ratio cap configurations. Applying to an optimal disk configuration gives
Lemma 5.3 therefore applies to minimizing sequences when is sufficiently small. For such a cap configuration, let be the lengths of its boundary parameter intervals. Pulling back to the disk and using (13) gives
Together with and the strict monotonicity of , this implies
for every , with an additional error tending to zero along the minimizing sequence.
At , extending either endpoint of a cap strictly decreases its ratio near , since . This remains true for small . We may therefore extend the boundary intervals to fill the gaps without increasing the maximal ratio. The configuration is then described by
where . The resulting minimization takes place in a compact neighborhood, modulo rotation, of the regular partitions. At a minimizing partition all ratios are equal. Indeed, at their linearizations with respect to the endpoints are
Any proper subset of these rows is linearly independent, and this remains true for sufficiently small . If only a proper subset of the ratios attained the maximum, an endpoint variation could strictly decrease all those ratios while keeping the others below the previous maximum, a contradiction.
We now parametrize the equal-ratio configurations. For , consider
with . At , the solution is
The linearization in is invertible: summing the first linearized equations determines the variation of , the cyclic differences then determine the endpoint variations up to a common constant, and the last equation fixes that constant.
The implicit function theorem thus gives smooth functions and , uniformly in . By the preceding reduction and uniqueness near the regular partitions,
We compute the second-order expansion of . Uniformly in ,
Set
Substitution into (14) gives
Write a dot for differentiation in at , and set . Differentiating (5.5) yields
Since
we obtain . Define
Solving the cyclic difference equations, with the normalization in (5.5), gives
Suppose first that or . Then
Expanding (5.5) to second order, using (5.7) and (5.8), and averaging over , we find
where the remainder is uniform in and
Both factors in the numerator are positive for . Indeed, they vanish at , and
while
Consequently, .
For , the fourth Fourier mode survives the averaging. Writing
the same expansion gives
Here
and therefore the quadratic coefficient is bounded below by
Thus, for every fixed , there is a constant such that, uniformly in ,
Taking the minimum in (5.6) proves for all sufficiently small nonzero .
Declaration of AI use We use ChatGPT 6 Astra for proof exploration and editing. We take responsibility for verification and exposition.
School of Mathematics, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210093, Jiangsu, China
Email address: [email protected]
School of Mathematical Sciences, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, China
Email address: [email protected]
School of Mathematical Sciences, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, Shanghai 200240, China
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]S. B. Alexander, J. D. Berg, and R. L. Bishop, Geometric curvature bounds in Riemannian manifolds with boundary, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 339 (1993), no. 2, 703–716.DOI
- [2]B. H. Bowditch, Notes on locally CAT(1) spaces, in Geometric Group Theory, Ohio State Univ. Math. Res. Inst. Publ. 3, de Gruyter, Berlin, 1995, 1–48.
- [3]A. Cianchi, V. Ferone, C. Nitsch, and C. Trombetti, Balls minimize trace constants in BV, J. Reine Angew. Math. 725 (2017), 41–61.
- [4]J. F. Escobar, The geometry of the first non-zero Stekloff eigenvalue, J. Funct. Anal. 150 (1997), no. 2, 544–556.DOI
- [5]J. F. Escobar, An isoperimetric inequality and the first Steklov eigenvalue, J. Funct. Anal. 165 (1999), no. 1, 101–116.DOI
- [6]A. Hassannezhad and L. Miclo, Higher order Cheeger inequalities for Steklov eigenvalues, Ann. Sci. Éc. Norm. Supér. (4) 53 (2020), no. 1, 43–88.arxiv.org/abs/1705.08643
- [7]A. Hassannezhad and A. Siffert, Escobar constants of planar domains, Ann. Global Anal. Geom. 61 (2022), 215–233.arxiv.org/abs/1905.07634
- [8]R. B. Kusner and J. M. Sullivan, On distortion and thickness of knots, in Topology and Geometry in Polymer Science (Minneapolis, MN, 1996), IMA Vol. Math. Appl., vol. 103, Springer, New York, 1998, pp. 67–78.arxiv.org/abs/dg-ga/9702001
- [9]G. Lukó, On the mean length of the chords of a closed curve, Israel J. Math. 4 (1966), 23–32.DOI
- [10]A. Lytchak and S. Wenger, Isoperimetric characterization of upper curvature bounds, Acta Math. 221 (2018), no. 1, 159–202.arxiv.org/abs/1611.05261
- [11]Yu. G. Reshetnyak, Inextensible mappings in a space of curvature no greater than K, Siberian Math. J. 9 (1968), no. 4, 683–689.DOI