For the Baouendi-Grushin operator Lγ=Δx+∣x∣2γΔy in Rm+k, with γ>0, we prove that the time integral of the heat kernel with pole at the origin equals Cγ,QNγ2−Q, where Nγ is the gauge and Q the homogeneous dimension. When γ=1 no closed form of the heat kernel is known. After a partial Fourier transform in y, the time integral of the heat kernel becomes the Green function of an anharmonic oscillator, which solves a generalized modified Bessel equation, and the gauge appears when the inverse Fourier transform is computed as a Hankel transform. In particular, the heat flow provides a new proof that Cγ,QNγ2−Q is a fundamental solution of −Lγ with pole at the origin.
Introduction
Consider the heat kernel p(x,t)=(4πt)−2ne−4t∣x∣2 in Rn, with n≥3, and denote by σn−1=Γ(n/2)2πn/2 the (n−1)-dimensional measure of the unit sphere. A simple computation shows that for every x=0
∫0∞p(x,t)dt=(n−2)σn−1∣x∣n−21,
the fundamental solution of −Δ with pole at the origin. That the time integral of the heat kernel is a fundamental solution is a general principle, but here the explicit knowledge of the heat kernel also reveals the explicit form of the Newtonian potential. The same happens in the Heisenberg group, where the time integral of the heat kernel found by Gaveau [19] and Hulanicki [22] gives Folland’s fundamental solution [12], and more generally in groups of Heisenberg type, where one obtains Kaplan’s fundamental solution [23], see [17]. This note is about a similar conclusion for a class of degenerate differential operators whose heat kernels are, with one exception, not known in closed form.
Given γ>0 and m,k∈N, we consider in Rxm×Ryk the partial differential operator
Lγ=Δx+∣x∣2γΔy,(1)
introduced by Baouendi [1] and Grushin [21]. For its role in analysis and geometry, and for some relevant literature, we refer to [14, 10, 2]. The operator (1) is translation invariant in y, and homogeneous of degree two with respect to the dilations δρ(x,y)=(ρx,ργ+1y), for which d(δρ(x,y))=ρQdxdy, with
Q=m+(γ+1)k.(2)
Let pγ((x,y),t) denote the heat kernel for (1) with pole at (0,0). When γ=1 no closed form of pγ is known, see [4 pp. 189-190]. The only exception is when γ=1. In [18 Theorem 3.4] the following heat kernel was found for the operator Δx+4∣x∣2Δy, see also the references therein:
and one has P1((x,y),(x′,y′),t)=2−kq((x,2y),(x′,2y′),t), with P1 as in (18) below. Notwithstanding the lack of a closed form of pγ when γ=1, our main result in this note is the following.
Theorem 1.1. Let m,k∈N and γ>0, and let ν=2(γ+1)m−2. For every (x,y)∈Rm+k with x=0, one has
The gauge (5) and the Baouendi-Grushin Newtonian potential (7) were instrumental in the discovery in [13] of a far-reaching monotonicity formula of Almgren type for the degenerate operators (1).
Since in Section 5 we show that Cγ,Q∗=Cγ,Q, we note explicitly that Theorem 1.1 says that the heat flow of Lγ discovers the gauge (5). To provide the reader with an explanation of why this is possible, let Lγ also denote the Friedrichs extension of (1) from C∞(Rm+k), and let $p_\gamma be the heat kernel of ∂t−Lγ with pole at the origin, defined in (19) below through the partial Fourier transform in y and the heat kernels hλ(x,x′,t) of the anharmonic oscillators
Hλ=−Δx+4π2∣λ∣2∣x∣2γ,λ∈Rk.
When γ=1 the function hλ is given by Mehler’s formula, see [18 Remark 3.3]. When γ=1 no closed form of hλ is known, and, besides the general facts collected in § 2, the only information on pγ that we will use is the equation satisfied by its partial Fourier transform.
After such partial Fourier transform in y, the function pγ becomes the heat kernel hλ(x,0,t) of the anharmonic oscillator Hλ, and in the variable s=γ+1∣x∣γ+1 the operator Hλ acting on functions which are radial in x becomes, up to the factor ∣x∣2γ, a modified Bessel operator in the fractal dimension γ+1m+2γ. Such factor cannot be removed from the evolution equation, in which its reciprocal multiplies ∂t, so that the evolution problem is not reduced to a Bessel heat equation. But it disappears from the stationary equation satisfied by ∫0∞hλ(x,0,t)dt, the Green function of Hλ with pole at the origin, which is therefore s−ν times a Macdonald function of order ν in the variable 2π∣λ∣s, see § 3. The inverse Fourier transform in λ is then a Hankel transform which can be computed in closed form, and it is at this stage that the gauge (5) appears, see § 4. The identity Cγ,Q∗=Cγ,Q, which also follows from [15 Lemma 3.4], is obtained in § 5 by a direct evaluation of the integral in (8). Finally, by Lemma 3.1 and Fubini’s theorem, ∫0∞pγdt is a fundamental solution of −Lγ, and as we have mentioned above, the argument thus also gives an independent proof of [13 Prop. 2.1].
When γ=1, Theorem 1.1 is consistent with [17 Corollary 1.3] and [16 Theor. 1.3], see Remark 5.1. For the heat kernel of (1) when γ=1 we refer to [3, 7, 8, 18, 27]. When γ∈N, the operator (1) is a sum of squares of polynomial vector fields satisfying Hörmander’s condition, to which the lifting theorem in [26] applies, and Bauer, Furutani and Iwasaki found in [4 Cor. 7.4] a fundamental solution of Lγ with pole at an arbitrary point, which for the pole at the origin reduces to (7). Their approach integrates in time the explicit heat kernel of an auxiliary operator obtained after a partial Fourier transform in y and polar coordinates in x, and uses γ∈N to sum a series of spherical harmonics; the heat kernel pγ does not appear in [4]. See also [5] for other special values of γ.
Notation. Throughout the paper m,k∈N and γ>0 are fixed, Q is as in (2), and we let
ν=2(γ+1)m−2,θ=2k+ν=2(γ+1)Q−2.(9)
We note that ν>−21, that ν=0 if and only if m=2, and that θ>0. We denote by ωm−1=Γ(m/2)2πm/2 the surface measure of the unit sphere Sm−1⊂Rm, with the understanding that ω0=2. We will use the function
The partial Fourier transform with respect to y∈Rk is
u((x,λ),t)=∫Rke−2πi⟨λ,y⟩u((x,y),t)dy.
Finally, we say that a function f on Rk is spherically symmetric if f(λ)=f∗(∣λ∣) for some f∗; when k=1 we simply mean that f is even. We will use the following classical formula of Bochner, see [6 Theor. 40 on p. 69], which holds for k≥1 and for every spherically symmetric f∈L1(Rk),
Since the inverse Fourier transform of a spherically symmetric function coincides with its Fourier transform, (12) also computes f.
The heat kernel with pole at the origin
Since (1) is translation invariant in y, the Cauchy problem
∂tu−Lγu=0,u((x,y),0)=φ(x,y),(13)
is converted by the partial Fourier transform into the following one
∂tu+Hλu=0,u((x,λ),0)=φ(x,λ),(14)
where for λ∈Rk we have let
Hλ=−Δx+4π2∣λ∣2∣x∣2γ.(15)
We collect the facts about (15) that will be needed. Let λ=0. Since the potential V(x):=4π2∣λ∣2∣x∣2γ is continuous, nonnegative, and tends to ∞ as ∣x∣→∞, the operator Hλ is self-adjoint and nonnegative on L2(Rm), with compact resolvent, see [25 Theor. XIII.67]. Its spectrum is thus discrete, and its first eigenvalue μ1(λ) is strictly positive, since
⟨Hλψ,ψ⟩=∫Rm∣∇ψ∣2+4π2∣λ∣2∫Rm∣x∣2γψ2=0
forces ψ≡0. The change of variable x→∣λ∣−γ+11x shows that Hλ is unitarily equivalent to ∣λ∣γ+12Hλ0, with ∣λ0∣=1, and therefore
μ1(λ)=μ1∣λ∣γ+12,μ1=μ1(λ0)>0.(16)
The semigroup e−tHλ admits a kernel hλ(x,x′,t), continuous on Rm×Rm×(0,∞), symmetric in (x,x′), and such that
0≤hλ(x,x′,t)≤(4πt)−2me−4t∣x−x′∣2,(17)
see [9 Theor. 1.8.1 and Example 2.1.9]. For λ=0 the kernel h0 is the Gauss-Weierstrass kernel. The upper bound in (17) implies in particular that e−tHλ is a contraction in L∞(Rm). Since Hλ commutes with the rotations of Rm, one has for every R∈O(m),
hλ(Rx,Rx′,t)=hλ(x,x′,t),
and therefore the function x→hλ(x,0,t) is spherically symmetric.
Lemma 2.1. Let λ∈Rk∖{0}. For every x,x′∈Rm and t>0 one has
hλ(x,x′,t)≤(2πt)−2me−2tμ1∣λ∣γ+12.
Proof. By the semigroup property and the symmetry of the kernel, for 0<τ<t we have hλ(x,⋅,t)=e−(t−τ)Hλhλ(x,⋅,τ). Since ∥e−sHλ∥L2→L2=e−sμ1(λ), we infer
Replacing t with t/2, and keeping (16) in mind, we reach the desired conclusion.
Since C∞(Rm) is a form core for each Hλ, the closure of the form of −Lγ on C∞(Rm+k) is, after the partial Fourier transform, the direct integral in λ of the forms of Hλ, and therefore etLγφ(⋅,λ)=e−tHλφ(⋅,λ) for a.e. λ. Measurability in λ follows from
which shows that the integral in (20): (a) converges for x=0, (b) that w(⋅,λ)∈Lloc1(Rm) (the first integral in the right-hand side of (21) is bounded by C∣x∣2−m when m≥3, by C(1+∣log∣x∣∣) when m=2, and by a constant when m=1), (c) and that, by dominated convergence (for each t>0 one has hλ(x,0,t)→0 as ∣x∣→∞ by (17), and for ∣x∣≥1 the integrand is dominated by the minimum of the two bounds in (17) and Lemma 2.1, which is integrable on (0,∞)),
w(x,λ)→0as ∣x∣→∞.(22)
Moreover, w(⋅,λ) is spherically symmetric, since so is hλ(⋅,0,t).
Lemma 3.1. Let λ∈Rk∖{0}. For every ψ∈C0∞(Rm) one has
∫Rmw(x,λ)Hλψ(x)dx=ψ(0).(23)
Proof. Since ψ belongs to the domain of Hλ, we have ∂te−tHλψ=−e−tHλHλψ. Using the symmetry of the kernel hλ, for 0<ε<T<∞ we thus find
and we can let ε→0+ and T→∞ in the above identity by dominated convergence. This proves (23).
We now solve (23). Lemma 3.1 says that w(⋅,λ) is a distributional solution of Hλw=δ in Rm, where δ is the Dirac delta at the origin. In particular, since the potential in (15) is C∞ in Rm∖{0}, we have Hλw=0 there, and by hypoellipticity w(⋅,λ)∈C∞(Rm∖{0}). By the spherical symmetry of w(⋅,λ), we can write w(x,λ)=W(∣x∣), where W∈C∞(0,∞) solves the ordinary differential equation
with ν as in (9). Therefore, (24) is equivalent to the modified Bessel equation of order ν for Φ, whose general solution is Φ(ζ)=AKν(ζ)+BIν(ζ), see [24 Sec. 5.7]. Here, Iν and Kν respectively denote the modified Bessel functions of the first and third kind, and we recall that K−ν=Kν. Since as ζ→∞ one has Iν(ζ)∼(2πζ)−21eζ, whereas Kν(ζ)∼(2ζπ)21e−ζ, (22) forces B=0. We conclude that
w(x,λ)=A(λ)∣x∣1−2mKν(2π∣λ∣s),(26)
for some constant A(λ) which we now determine using (23). Fix ψ∈C∞(Rm) with ψ(0)=1. Since Hλw=0 in Rm∖{0}, integrating by parts in {∣x∣>ε} we find
provided that the two limits exist. We now use the behavior of Kν near ζ=0. We treat separately three cases.
Case m≥3. In this case ν>0, and we have Kν(ζ)=21Γ(ν)(ζ/2)−ν(1+o(1)) and Kν′(ζ)=−21Γ(ν)(ζ/2)−νζ−1(1+o(1)) as ζ→0+, see [24 Sec. 5.7]. Since by (9) we have (γ+1)ν=2m−2, from (25) we find
W(r)=2A(λ)Γ(ν)(γ+1π∣λ∣)−νr2−m(1+o(1)),(28)
W′(r)=(2−m)2A(λ)Γ(ν)(γ+1π∣λ∣)−νr1−m(1+o(1)),
as r→0+. The first limit in (27) vanishes, and we obtain
A(λ)=(m−2)ωm−1Γ(ν)2(γ+1π∣λ∣)ν.(29)
Case m=2. In this case ν=0, and K0(ζ)=−logζ+O(1), K0′(ζ)=−K1(ζ)=−ζ−1(1+o(1)) as ζ→0+, see [24 Sec. 5.7]. Since ζ=γ+12π∣λ∣rγ+1, from (25) we obtain W(r)=−(γ+1)A(λ)logr+O(1), and W′(r)=−(γ+1)A(λ)r−1(1+o(1)) as r→0+. Again, the first limit in (27) vanishes, and we find
A(λ)=(γ+1)ω11=2π(γ+1)1.(30)
Case m=1. In this case −21<ν=−2(γ+1)1<0, and Kν=K∣ν∣, with
as ζ→0+, which follows from the series expansion of I±∣ν∣, from K∣ν∣=2πsinπ∣ν∣I−∣ν∣−I∣ν∣, and from the reflection formula for the gamma function, see [24 Sec. 5.7]. Since now (γ+1)∣ν∣=21, from (25) we find
which shows that W is continuous up to r=0, and that W′(0+)=2A(λ)Γ(−∣ν∣)(γ+1π∣λ∣)∣ν∣. Since ∂rψ(ε)+∂rψ(−ε)=ψ′(ε)−ψ′(−ε)→0, the first limit in (27) vanishes also in this case, and we obtain A(λ)Γ(−∣ν∣)(γ+1π∣λ∣)∣ν∣=−1. Recalling that ν=−∣ν∣, we have thus found
A(λ)=−Γ(ν)1(γ+1π∣λ∣)ν.(31)
Since ω0=2, we see that (31) is (29) with m=1. Furthermore, using Γ(ν+1)=νΓ(ν), and ν2m−1=γ+11, we can rewrite (29) in the following form, which for m=2 returns (30),
A(λ)=2(γ+1)π2mΓ(ν+1)Γ(2m)(γ+1π)ν∣λ∣ν.(32)
Substituting (32) in (26), we conclude that for every m∈N one has
We now fix x∈Rm∖{0} and compute the inverse Fourier transform of (33) with respect to λ. We first observe that w(x,⋅)∈L1(Rk). The exponential decay of Kν takes care of the integrability at infinity. Near λ=0, from (33) and the expansions of Kν recalled above, one has that w(x,λ) is bounded when m≥3, that ∣w(x,λ)∣≤C(1+∣log∣λ∣∣) when m=2, and that ∣w(x,λ)∣≤C∣λ∣2ν=C∣λ∣kγ+1 when m=1. In all cases, w(x,⋅) is integrable near λ=0 since k≥1>γ+11.
Since hλ≥0, we have from (19), (20) and Tonelli’s theorem
In particular, Eγ(x,⋅) is continuous in Rk. Since Γγ is also continuous in y when x=0, it suffices to consider y=0. Since w(x,⋅) is spherically symmetric in Rk, the inverse Fourier transform in (34) is computed by (12). Writing w(x,λ)=A0∣λ∣ν−2mKν(2π∣λ∣s), with s as in (10) and
Now, by (10) and (γ+1)ν=2m−2, we have ∣x∣1−2msν=(γ+1)−ν, and by (11) and 2(γ+1)θ=Q−2, we have (s2+∣y∣2)−θ=(γ+1)2θNγ(x,y)2−Q. Substituting these identities and (35) in (39), and using 2θ−2ν=k, we finally obtain
Since θ=2(γ+1)Q−2, the constant in the right-hand side of (40) is Cγ,Q in (6), and this proves (4). In the next section we show that Cγ,Q=Cγ,Q∗.
Computing the constant
In this section we show that Cγ,Q∗=Cγ,Q, where Cγ,Q∗ is defined by (8). This also follows from [15 Lemma 3.4] with p=2 and Euclidean norms, after the change of variable y→y/2; for completeness we give the direct evaluation of the integral in (8). By (9) we have
1+2(γ+1)Q+2γ=θ+2,θ+2−2k=ν+2.
Using the elementary formula ∫Rk(a+∣ξ∣2)−edξ=π2kΓ(e)Γ(e−2k)a2k−e, valid for a>0 and e>2k, with a=1+∣x∣2(γ+1) and e=θ+2, we first integrate in y in (8), obtaining
which is the reciprocal of Cγ,Q in (6). This proves Cγ,Q⋆=Cγ,Q. Finally, by Lemma 3.1 applied to ψ=φ^(⋅,λ) and Fubini’s theorem, Eγ is a fundamental solution of −Lγ with pole at the origin, and together with (40) this gives an independent proof of [13 Prop. 2.1].
Remark 5.1. When γ=1, Mehler’s formula for hλ(x,0,t), see [18 Remark 3.3], and the change of variable λ↦4πtλ in (19) give 2kp1((x,2y),t)=G2m+k((x,y),t), where Gα,β is the generalized Mehler kernel in [16 Prop. 1.2]. With m=2α one has N1(x,2y)=(∣x∣4+16∣y∣2)1/4, Q=2α+2k, ν=2α−1 and θ=2α+k−1, and by Legendre’s duplication formula 2k times the constant in (6) equals the constant in [16 Theor. 1.3], and in [17 Corollary 1.3] when m is the dimension of the horizontal layer of a group of Heisenberg type.
Declarations
Competing interests. The author has no competing interests to declare that are relevant to the content of this article.
Use of AI: The author acknowledges the assistance of AI in organizing and revising the manuscript, and in reviewing the proofs and the language. The research ideas and the mathematical arguments are exclusively the author’s, and he takes full responsibility for the content and the final text.
Declarations
Competing interests. The author has no competing interests to declare that are relevant to the content of this article.
Use of AI: The author acknowledges the assistance of AI in organizing and revising the manuscript, and in reviewing the proofs and the language. The research ideas and the mathematical arguments are exclusively the author’s, and he takes full responsibility for the content and the final text.
School of Mathematical and Statistical Sciences, Arizona State University
[1]M. S. Baouendi, Sur une classe d’opérateurs elliptiques dégénérés. Bull. Soc. Math. France 95 (1967), 45-87.DOI
[2]A. Banerjee & N. Garofalo, An improved Rellich type estimate for the eigenfunctions of the Baouendi-Grushin operator, to appear in J. Anal. Math.
[3]W. Bauer, K. Furutani & C. Iwasaki, Spectral analysis and geometry of sub-Laplacian and related Grushin-type operators. Partial differential equations and spectral theory, 183-290, Oper. Theory Adv. Appl., 211, Birkhäuser/Springer Basel AG, Basel, 2011.DOI
[4]W. Bauer, K. Furutani & C. Iwasaki, Fundamental solution of a higher step Grushin type operator. Adv. Math. 271 (2015), 188-234. 2, 3DOI
[5]R. Beals, B. Gaveau & P. Greiner, Green’s functions for some highly degenerate elliptic operators. J. Funct. Anal. 165 (1999), no. 2, 407-429. 3DOI
[6]S. Bochner & K. Chandrasekharan, Fourier Transforms, Annals of Mathematics Studies, no. 19, Princeton University Press, Princeton, N. J.; Oxford University Press, London, 1949. ix+219 pp. 4
[7]O. Calin, D.-C. Chang, K. Furutani & C. Iwasaki, Heat kernels for elliptic and sub-elliptic operators. Methods and techniques. Applied and Numerical Harmonic Analysis. Birkhäuser/Springer, New York, 2011. xviii+433 pp. 3DOI
[8]C.-H. Chang, D.-C. Chang, B. Gaveau, P. Greiner & H.-P. Lee, Geometric analysis on a step 2 Grusin operator. Bull. Inst. Math. Acad. Sin. (N.S.) 4 (2009), no. 2, 119-188. 3
[9]E. B. Davies, Heat kernels and spectral theory. Cambridge Tracts in Mathematics, 92. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1989. x+197 pp. 5
[10]F. Dragoni, N. Garofalo, G. Giovannardi & P. Salani, A fundamental solution for a subelliptic operator in Finsler geometry. Indiana Univ. Math. J. 75 (2026), no. 1, 201-226. 1
[11]A. Erdélyi, W. Magnus, F. Oberhettinger & F. G. Tricomi, Higher transcendental functions. Vol. I. Based on notes left by Harry Bateman. With a preface by Mina Rees. With a foreword by E. C. Watson. Reprint of the 1953 original. Robert E. Krieger Publishing Co., Inc., Melbourne, Fla., 1981. xiii+302 pp. 10
[12]G. B. Folland, A fundamental solution for a subelliptic operator. Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. 79 (1973), 373-376. 1DOI
[13]N. Garofalo, Unique continuation for a class of elliptic operators which degenerate on a manifold of arbitrary codimension. J. Differential Equations 104 (1993), no. 1, 117-146. 2, 3, 11DOI
[15]N. Garofalo, On an evolution equation in sub-Finsler geometry. Anal. Geom. Metr. Spaces 12 (2024), Paper No. 20240012. 3, 10arxiv.org/abs/2402.16745
[17]N. Garofalo & G. Tralli, Feeling the heat in a group of Heisenberg type. Adv. Math. 381 (2021), Paper No. 107635, 42 pp. 1, 3, 11DOI
[18]N. Garofalo & G. Tralli, Heat kernels for a class of hybrid evolution equations. Potential Anal. 59 (2023), no. 2, 823-856. 2, 3, 11arxiv.org/abs/2007.10862
[19]B. Gaveau, Principe de moindre action, propagation de la chaleur et estimées sous elliptiques sur certains groupes nilpotents. Acta Math. 139 (1977), no. 1-2, 95-153. 1DOI
[20]I. S. Gradshteyn & I. M. Ryzhik, Table of integrals, series, and products. Seventh edition. Elsevier/Academic Press, Amsterdam, 2007. xiii+1117 pp. 9
[21]V. V. Grushin, A certain class of hypoelliptic operators. (Russian) Mat. Sb. (N.S.) 83 (125) (1970), 456-473. 1
[22]A. Hulanicki, The distribution of energy in the Brownian motion in the Gaussian field and analytic-hypoellipticity of certain subelliptic operators on the Heisenberg group. Studia Math. 56 (1976), no. 2, 165-173. 1
[23]A. Kaplan, Fundamental solutions for a class of hypoelliptic PDE generated by composition of quadratic forms. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 258 (1980), no. 1, 147-153. 1DOI
[24]N. N. Lebedev, Special functions and their applications. Revised edition, translated from the Russian and edited by R. A. Silverman. Unabridged and corrected republication. Dover Publications, Inc., New York, 1972. xii+308 pp. 7, 8
[25]M. Reed & B. Simon, Methods of modern mathematical physics. IV. Analysis of operators. Academic Press, New York-London, 1978. xv+396 pp. 4
[26]L. P. Rothschild & E. M. Stein, Hypoelliptic differential operators and nilpotent groups. Acta Math. 137 (1976), no. 3-4, 247-320. 3DOI
[27]K. Stempak, A transform for the Grushin operator with applications. J. Differential Equations 481 (2026), Paper No. 114630, 23 pp. 3
[28]G. N. Watson, A treatise on the theory of Bessel functions. Reprint of the second (1944) edition. Cambridge Mathematical Library. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1995. viii+804 pp. 9