WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Heavy-Quark Dynamics from -Meson Anisotropy-Response Scaling Violations
Abstract
A species-resolved anisotropy-response scaling framework is used to investigate heavy-quark dynamics through the elliptic () and triangular () azimuthal anisotropies of mesons. The independently constrained light-flavor response provides a direct null test: the transformed harmonics exhibit approximate inter-harmonic closure but remain systematically displaced from the kaon-anchored scaling function, revealing a charm scaling violation. The common response is recovered through a charm-specific attenuation rescaling, , together with a small low- hadronic-rescattering correction, , while retaining the established light-flavor prescription. In Pb+Pb collisions at ~TeV, decreases from approximately in central and mid-central collisions to in the 30–50% interval. For , ultra-central p+Pb collisions at ~TeV require , whereas Au+Au collisions at ~GeV are consistent with . The transition momentum exhibits a distinct system dependence: and light mesons show comparable –~GeV/ in Pb+Pb, consistent with the common large-system prescription also used in Au+Au, whereas p+Pb measurements are consistent with the lower light-meson scale of approximately ~GeV/. These complementary constraints on attenuation strength and transition momentum provide a differential benchmark for heavy-quark transport and medium evolution.
Heavy quarks provide distinctive probes of the strongly interacting matter produced in relativistic nuclear collisions because they are produced predominantly in initial hard-scattering processes and subsequently propagate through the evolving medium. Their momentum distributions are modified by diffusion and drag, collisional and radiative energy loss, collective expansion, and hadronization [1, 2]. A central objective of heavy-flavor measurements is therefore to determine how much of the observed response reflects the evolving bulk medium and how much carries additional information specific to heavy-quark transport [3].
A key observable is the azimuthal anisotropy of produced particles, conventionally expressed as
where denotes the th-order anisotropy coefficient and the corresponding symmetry-plane angle. In particular, and characterize elliptic and triangular anisotropies, respectively. Substantial anisotropies have been measured at both RHIC and the LHC [4, 5, 6, 7], including simultaneous measurements of prompt and in Pb+Pb collisions [7]. These measurements establish a significant charm anisotropy but do not, by themselves, distinguish the response shared with the light-flavor sector from that associated specifically with charm transport.
This separation is essential because many of the mechanisms that generate anisotropy also influence light-flavor hadrons. Initial-state geometry, collective expansion, viscous attenuation, path-length-dependent energy loss, and hadronization contribute to both sectors [8]. The central question is therefore whether charm follows the same anisotropy response as light flavor, rather than simply whether it develops substantial .
Species-resolved anisotropy-response scaling provides an experimentally constrained basis for this comparison [9, 10, 11]. Measurements of and for identified light-flavor mesons and baryons map onto common response functions after the contributions from initial eccentricities, system size, medium attenuation, radial expansion, and late-stage hadronic interactions are scaled out. This scaling extends from the low- collective-flow regime to the high- region increasingly sensitive to path-length-dependent partonic energy loss, and across collision systems, centralities, and beam energies. At fixed beam energy, the light-flavor attenuation coefficient exhibits comparatively weak centrality dependence after accounting for geometry and system size, while species-dependent contributions are scaled out separately. The resulting common response provides a medium reference established independently of the heavy-flavor measurements.
This independently established reference enables a direct null test: applying the unmodified light-meson scaling to anisotropies reveals whether an additional charm-specific response is required. Any systematic residual then identifies the scaling violation to be quantified without retuning the common medium response.
Several features provide complementary constraints. The centrality dependence probes changes in the relative charm–light response where the light-flavor attenuation coefficient varies comparatively weakly, while the beam-energy dependence tests this difference against changes in the common medium response. Simultaneous and scaling provides additional constraints through intra-harmonic and inter-harmonic mappings. The residual low- response further tests whether the scaling violation is predominantly associated with attenuation or requires additional collective or late-stage contributions.
The momentum scale connecting the collective-flow and quenching regimes provides a further constraint. In the scaling framework, the viscous correction is held fixed above a data-constrained transition momentum [9, 10, 11]. Comparison with the light-flavor reference therefore tests whether charm differs in the transition momentum, the strength of its anisotropic response, or both.
Small collision systems provide a complementary test. Significant elliptic anisotropy has been observed in high-multiplicity p+Pb collisions at TeV [12]. Light-flavor scaling in p+Pb exhibits a substantially lower transition momentum than in Pb+Pb [11]. Because the available measurements predominantly lie above this scale, they test whether an additional charm–light response difference persists in the smaller collision environment, where the balance between collective-flow and path-length-dependent energy-loss contributions may differ.
In this work, the established light-flavor anisotropy-response scaling provides an independently constrained reference for testing anisotropies across collision systems, centralities, and beam energies. In Pb+Pb collisions at TeV, identified light-flavor measurements from ALICE are combined with CMS measurements of prompt and [7, 13]. In ultra-central p+Pb collisions at TeV, the , , and prompt measurements are provided by CMS [12], while the Au+Au comparison at GeV combines STAR light-flavor and measurements [4, 14]. The comparisons test the relative charm-response strength and flow-to-quenching transition momentum against the independently established light-flavor response.
The common light-flavor reference is anchored to the kaon scaling function in ultra-central (uc, 0–1%) Pb+Pb collisions at TeV, which provides an experimentally constrained baseline for the medium response [9, 10]. Kaons provide a useful baseline because of their intermediate mass, relatively small hadronic cross section, and precise measurements. The framework has been developed and tested across identified light-flavor mesons and baryons, collision systems, centralities, and beam energies [9, 10, 11, 15]. Only the elements required for the present analysis are summarized here.
The measured anisotropies enter through the reduced response , where denotes the corresponding initial-state eccentricity. The scaled responses are compared as functions of , where is the transverse kinetic energy and is the hadron rest mass. This common kinetic-energy coordinate facilitates comparisons across hadron species without introducing additional scaling parameters. The transverse size scale is represented by , while attenuation is parameterized by . The coefficient sets the reference attenuation scale and accounts for its beam-energy dependence. Species-dependent contributions are treated separately within the established light-flavor scaling; for mesons, the residual hadronic response is parameterized by , with .
The geometric and system-size quantities entering the scaling are constrained independently of the anisotropy-response transformation. The eccentricities and are obtained from
Monte Carlo Glauber calculations of the initial collision geometry for the corresponding collision system and event selection [9, 10, 16, 17]. The charged-particle multiplicities are taken from measurements appropriate to each collision system and event class. For Pb+Pb collisions at TeV, the corresponding values are obtained from the ALICE charged-particle multiplicity measurements [18]; the p+Pb and Au+Au analyses likewise use the measured multiplicities appropriate to their respective event selections, expressed within the common pseudorapidity interval used for the scaling. The dimensionless transverse-size variable is then constructed from using the same prescription as in the established light-flavor scaling analyses [9, 10, 15]. Consequently, the eccentricities and measured charged-particle multiplicities determine the geometric and transverse-size inputs to the scaling, without adjustment to obtain data collapse. When measurements with different experimental centrality or multiplicity selections are compared, each is transformed using the geometric and multiplicity inputs appropriate to its respective event class. The momentum-dependent viscous correction entering the scaling relations is parameterized as . Consistent with this transition prescription, the species-dependent corrections and are applied below their respective and set to zero above it. For comparisons across collision environments, the fixed Pb+Pb reference uses , while the comparison system uses , with their respective transition momenta and the same independently constrained coefficient .
The meson scaling relation is
where primes denote the comparison system or centrality and . The geometry-only offset is fixed by the eccentricity ratios, with for all Pb+Pb centralities. For p+Pb, its sign is reversed to account for the inverted centrality evolution of relative to the large-A+A reference. This offset enters only through the normalization exponents and is not independently adjusted for charm.
In applying this scaling relation, the left-hand side remains the fixed ultra-central reference, with all centrality-dependent modifications implemented on the right-hand side. The normalization factor is controlled by , 0.5, and 1 for non-ultra-central, near-ultra-central, and ultra-central selections, respectively. Thus, the normalization exponential is unity for non-ultra-central collisions and retains its prescribed dependence for ultra-central selections, with near-ultra-central selections providing an intermediate response. The comparison-system attenuation exponential retains its prescribed dependence for all selections.
An independent constraint is provided by the interharmonic mapping ,
where . The complementary and relations therefore provide independent constraints on the mapping to the same reference response.
The piecewise definition of ensures continuous matching of the scaling correction at , which characterizes the effective transition between collective-flow-dominated and quenching-sensitive anisotropic responses. In each collision environment, the correction grows as below its respective and remains fixed at above it, without constraining the intrinsic momentum dependence of the high- quenching response. The variation of this transition scale across collision environments provides an additional constraint on parton–medium dynamics, distinct from the attenuation strength. A lower corresponds to an earlier crossover and a smaller matching correction for fixed . For the light-flavor Pb+Pb reference at TeV, – GeV/ [9, 15].
The scaling test begins by treating the as a meson within this established framework. The geometric, system-size, and medium-response inputs are constrained by the light-flavor scaling and applied without charm-specific modification, using the appropriate centrality-dependent inputs for each event class. The attenuation structure and normalization are likewise retained unchanged. The meson response follows the established prescription , with retaining its definition and role in the light-flavor scaling framework. The same prescription is applied to the and, where available, mappings, providing a direct null test of whether the measured anisotropies follow the independently established light-flavor response.
A systematic departure of the transformed measurements from the common reference defines the scaling violation. No charm-specific response coefficient is introduced in establishing this violation, nor are the underlying medium-response parameters independently retuned for charm. Any additional response is introduced only after the violation is identified, using a minimal extension of the established meson transformation to recover simultaneous scaling of the available harmonics. The fidelity of the transformed responses against the independently established common scaling function therefore provides a differential constraint on the additional charm response.
The null test is illustrated in Figure 1 for Pb+Pb collisions at TeV. For this comparison, the light-meson measurements are provided by ALICE and data in the 10–20% centrality interval [13], while the higher-statistics CMS and measurements correspond to 10–30% [7]. Both datasets employ the scalar-product method, minimizing differences associated with the anisotropy estimator. The light-meson and measurements need not have identical centrality selections, as each dataset is transformed using the eccentricities and the multiplicity-derived transverse-size scale appropriate to its respective event selection. The scaling therefore compares the responses after these geometric and system-size contributions have been scaled out, rather than treating the two centrality intervals as equivalent.

Figure 1. (Color online) Anisotropy-response scaling for , , and mesons in Pb+Pb collisions at TeV using the established light-meson prescription without charm-specific modification. The and measurements correspond to the ALICE 10–20% centrality interval [13] and the measurements to the CMS 10–30% interval [7]; each is scaled using the inputs appropriate to its respective centrality selection. Panels (a)–(c) show the measured anisotropies, the eccentricity-scaled responses, and the fully scaled responses, respectively. The transformed harmonics exhibit approximate inter-harmonic closure but remain displaced from the light-meson reference.
For context, the light-flavor scaling coefficients are independently constrained by the identified-hadron measurements [9, 10, 11]. In Pb+Pb collisions at TeV, the common attenuation response is characterized by , with for light mesons. The light-meson transition momentum is likewise constrained independently of the measurements. The baryon sector maps onto the same common scaling function after its stronger radial-flow response is scaled out, with increasing approximately logarithmically with and reaching approximately 0.46 in central collisions. Thus, substantial species- and centrality-dependent effects, including the stronger mass-dependent collective response of baryons, are already accommodated within the light-flavor framework. The comparison therefore tests for an additional charm–light response difference relative to this independently constrained medium-response reference.
Figure 1(a) shows the measured and before the scaling transformation. The species and harmonic dependences are clearly visible in the measured anisotropies. After scaling by the corresponding initial eccentricities, Figure 1(b), the pion and kaon and responses exhibit closely related trends, while the responses remain systematically separated from the light-meson sector. The fully transformed responses, denoted in Figure 1(c), bring both harmonics for pions and kaons onto the common light-meson scaling function, demonstrating simultaneous and closure in the light sector. Notably, the transformed and measurements also approximately collapse onto a common response, but this response is systematically displaced below the light-meson scaling function. Thus, the scaling violation is not primarily a breakdown of the inter-harmonic mapping. Instead, the two harmonics exhibit a coherent displacement from the independently constrained light-meson reference, identifying a distinct charm–light response difference after the established common contributions are scaled out.
The result in Figure 1 therefore establishes the null-test failure before any charm-specific modification is introduced. The coherence of the transformed and responses further indicates that the required modification need not independently alter the two harmonics. The next step is therefore to identify the minimal extension of the established meson transformation needed to map the displaced response onto the common light-meson scaling function. The attenuation response is tested by rescaling the reference attenuation strength as , where corresponds to the unchanged light-meson attenuation response. Importantly, enters only through the attenuation terms; and the associated normalization exponents are retained unchanged from the light-flavor reference. The meson-response factor is retained with its established definition and role in the light-flavor scaling framework.
Figure 2 shows the result of applying this minimal extension to the same measurements. The pion and kaon and measurements remain on the common light-meson scaling function because their prescription is unchanged. The established scaling fidelity across harmonics, centralities, particle species, collision systems, and beam energies provides multiple complementary constraints on this common response. For the , the scaling violation is resolved by rescaling the reference attenuation strength, , with , together with a small hadronic-rescattering response coefficient, . The transformed and responses thereby preserve their inter-harmonic consistency while recovering the common scaling function.

Figure 2. (Color online) Same measurements and centrality selections as Figure 1, with the additional response implemented through , with , and . The light-meson scaling prescription remains unchanged. Panels (a)–(c) show the measured anisotropies, the eccentricity-scaled responses, and the fully scaled responses, respectively. The modified response recovers the common light-meson scaling function.
The modest low- contribution from is distinguishable from the dominant modification: varying degrades simultaneous and scaling below the transition, even after readjusting .
The scaling provides distinct sensitivity to and . The coefficient rescales the reference attenuation strength entering the transformation over the full momentum range and therefore controls the overall mapping onto the light-meson scaling function. Its value is identified through the simultaneous alignment of the available harmonics with the independently established light-meson reference, rather than by fitting the reference response to the charm data. Below , simultaneous and scaling provides complementary sensitivity to and , while above the transition the additional charm response is governed by the attenuation rescaling . In contrast, controls the momentum dependence of the matching prescription, with inconsistent transition scales producing systematic deviations at intermediate and high . Thus, and constrain distinct features of the response rather than providing interchangeable rescalings.
The comparison of Figure 1 and Figure 2 highlights the physical significance of the charm–light response difference. The kaon-anchored scaling function provides an independently constrained mesonic reference within the same collision environment. The coefficient indicates substantially weaker development of the anisotropic response relative to the light-meson reference, while the smaller retains its established role in the hadronic-rescattering response channel.
At low and intermediate , this is consistent with weaker development of the anisotropic collective-flow response, while at high it is consistent with a reduced quenching-sensitive anisotropic response relative to the light-meson reference. Thus, provides a differential constraint on the charm response to the same evolving medium.
The momentum dependence provides an additional constraint. The measurements are consistent with a transition momentum of approximately 4.5–5.0 GeV/, comparable within the present resolution to the light-flavor value despite the additional charm attenuation characterized by . The charm–light difference is therefore expressed primarily through the strength of the anisotropic response rather than through an appreciable shift in the transition momentum. This distinction motivates a further test of the centrality dependence of the relative charm response.
The centrality dependence of the relative charm–light response is examined in Figure 3, where the same scaling procedure is applied to the more peripheral Pb+Pb measurements. For this comparison, the light-meson measurements are provided by and data in the 30–40% interval, while the measurements correspond to 30–50%. As in the preceding comparison, each dataset is transformed using the geometric and system-size inputs appropriate to its respective centrality selection. Figure 3(a) and Figure 3(b) show that the measured and eccentricity-scaled responses remain distinct from the light-meson sector. After the full scaling transformation, Figure 3(c), the and responses collapse onto the kaon-anchored light-meson scaling function. In contrast to the required for the more central collisions, the 30–50% measurements recover the common response with .

Figure 3. (Color online) Anisotropy-response scaling for , , and mesons in more peripheral Pb+Pb collisions at TeV. The and measurements correspond to the 30–40% centrality interval and the measurements to 30–50%; each is scaled using the inputs appropriate to its respective centrality selection. The response is transformed with and , while the light-meson prescription remains unchanged. Panels (a)–(c) show the measured anisotropies, the eccentricity-scaled responses, and the fully scaled responses, respectively.
The decrease in establishes a centrality dependence of the relative charm–light response. A separate scaling check of the 0–10% interval also yields , indicating that the larger charm–light response difference persists from central through mid-central Pb+Pb collisions before decreasing to in the 30–50% interval. This evolution contrasts with the comparatively weak centrality dependence of for light-flavor hadrons at the same beam energy. Thus, the narrowing charm–light response difference toward peripheral collisions provides a constraint on the evolution of heavy-quark dynamics with the changing medium, after the established geometry, system-size, and light-flavor response dependencies have been scaled out.
A complementary test of the charm response is provided by ultra-central p+Pb collisions at TeV. The 0.33–0.01% event class, corresponding to the reported multiplicity selection , provides a compact collision system with a substantially different medium extent from that of Pb+Pb collisions. For consistency with the system-size definition used throughout the scaling analysis, the reported multiplicity is converted to the corresponding within before constructing . The eccentricity and multiplicity inputs appropriate to this p+Pb event class are therefore incorporated independently of the anisotropy-response transformation.
Figure 4 applies the same anisotropy-response scaling framework to , , and measurements in these ultra-central p+Pb collisions. The inclusion of the provides a baryon reference and tests whether the behavior can be accounted for by the mass- and species-dependent response already incorporated in the light-flavor scaling framework. The measured values in Figure 4(a) exhibit substantial species dependence, which remains evident after eccentricity scaling in Figure 4(b). After the full scaling transformation, Figure 4(c), the low- and intermediate- and responses map onto the common Pb+Pb-anchored light-flavor scaling function when the lower p+Pb transition momenta appropriate to the meson and baryon sectors are used. At higher , residual light-flavor scaling deviations may reflect weaker quenching-sensitive anisotropy, with jet-driven nonflow correlations becoming relatively more prominent in the smaller p+Pb system. The measurements recover the common response with . Since these measurements lie above the transition momentum, they do not independently constrain .

Figure 4. (Color online) Anisotropy-response scaling for , , and hadrons in ultra-central (0.33–0.01%) p+Pb collisions at TeV. Panels (a)–(c) show the measured , the eccentricity-scaled responses, and the fully scaled responses, respectively. The scaling uses ; the Pb+Pb reference response at TeV is shown in panel (c).
The common low- and intermediate- scaling of the and , together with the transformed response, is particularly informative for interpreting the charm modification. The light meson and baryon reach the same reference response after their established species-dependent contributions are scaled out, including the stronger radial-flow response of the baryon sector and the lower transition momenta appropriate to the p+Pb system. The additional modification required for the therefore cannot be attributed simply to its large mass or to the meson–baryon response difference. Instead, demonstrates that a measurable charm–light response difference persists even in the compact medium produced in ultra-central p+Pb collisions.
The momentum dependence of the p+Pb scaling provides an additional constraint. For light mesons, recovery of the common response at low and intermediate requires a transition momentum near GeV/, substantially below the approximately 4.5–5.0 GeV/ scale in Pb+Pb collisions; the corresponding baryon transition occurs at a higher momentum, near 3 GeV/. Within the matching prescription, these lower transition momenta identify an earlier crossover from the viscously attenuated collective-flow response to the regime increasingly sensitive to path-length-dependent partonic energy loss. Above the transition, the scaling correction remains fixed at . Since the available measurements begin above approximately 2 GeV/, they test consistency with the lower transition scale independently established by light mesons, rather than directly locating a distinct charm crossover. Thus, as in Pb+Pb collisions, the charm–light difference is expressed primarily through the strength of the anisotropic response rather than through an observable displacement of the transition scale.
The value provides an important counterpoint to the Pb+Pb centrality dependence established earlier. In Pb+Pb collisions at TeV, decreases from approximately 2.0 in central and mid-central events to approximately 1.27 in the 30–50% interval, indicating that the charm–light response difference narrows as the properties and space-time evolution of the Pb+Pb medium change. The ultra-central p+Pb result does not simply continue this evolution toward the light-flavor limit, , despite the substantially smaller collision system. Geometric extent alone therefore does not determine the relative charm response. The p+Pb measurement is obtained at the higher beam energy of TeV and in a collision environment with different geometry, density, lifetime, and relative contributions from collective flow and path-length-dependent par-
caption: (Color online) Anisotropy-response scaling for , K, , and D hadrons in Au+Au collisions at GeV. The light-flavor measurements correspond to 0–30% centrality and the D measurements to 10–40%; each is scaled using the inputs appropriate to its respective centrality selection. Panels (a)–(c) show the measured , the eccentricity-scaled response, and the fully scaled response, respectively. The transformed D response is consistent with the common light-flavor scaling function without additional charm attenuation rescaling ().
:::
tonic energy loss. The observed therefore indicates that the charm–light anisotropic-response difference depends more broadly on the properties and space-time evolution of the produced medium, rather than on system size alone.
The large beam-energy lever arm between RHIC and the LHC provides an additional test of the relative charm–light response. Figure Figure 5 compares , K, , and D measurements in Au+Au collisions at GeV. The light-flavor measurements correspond to the 0–30% centrality interval, while the D measurements correspond to 10–40%. The STAR light-flavor and D measurements employ comparable -subevent event-plane methods, minimizing differences associated with the anisotropy estimator. As in the preceding comparisons, each dataset is transformed using the geometric and system-size inputs appropriate to its respective event selection.
The measured values in Fig. 5(a) exhibit a pronounced species dependence, which remains evident after eccentricity scaling in Fig. 5(b). Application of the full scaling transformation, Fig. 5(c), maps the light mesons and the onto the common light-flavor response after their established species-dependent contributions are scaled out. Within the precision of the available measurements, the D is also consistent with this common response without an additional charm attenuation rescaling, corresponding to .
The simultaneous comparison with the is particularly useful for interpreting this result. Despite its substantially larger mass and the strong species dependence visible before the full transformation, the maps onto the same light-flavor scaling function after its established baryon response is scaled out. The consistency of the D with this response at therefore cannot be attributed simply to its large mass. Rather, it indicates that at GeV the measured charm anisotropy requires little additional attenuation rescaling relative to the independently constrained light-flavor medium response.
This result is qualitatively different from that obtained for central and mid-central Pb+Pb collisions at the LHC. The light-flavor attenuation response at GeV is independently characterized by , compared with for the 5.02-TeV Pb+Pb reference. Thus, at RHIC does not imply that the underlying attenuation response or medium conditions are the same at the two beam energies. Rather, it indicates that little additional charm attenuation rescaling is required relative to the light-flavor response appropriate to the RHIC medium. At the LHC, by contrast, the Pb+Pb measurements require , reaching approximately 2 in central and mid-central collisions. The RHIC–LHC comparison therefore reveals differences in both the common light-flavor attenuation response, characterized by , and the additional charm–light response, characterized by . Together, these differences provide a differential constraint on heavy-quark dynamics across collision environments with distinct temperatures, densities, geometries, and space-time evolution.
The RHIC constraint is less stringent than its LHC counterpart because the available D measurements provide without the simultaneous information needed for the inter-harmonic 3 → 2 closure test. Nevertheless, the consistency of the D with the independently established 200-GeV light-flavor response provides an important constraint on the beam-energy dependence of the relative charm response. Together, the Pb+Pb, p+Pb, and Au+Au measurements demonstrate that is not a fixed property of the D, but quantifies an additional charm–light response difference that evolves with the collision environment.
The central result is that the independently constrained light-flavor scaling provides a direct null test of the charm anisotropic response. In Pb+Pb collisions at TeV, the transformed D and exhibit approximate inter-harmonic closure but remain systematically displaced from the common light-meson scaling function. This violation is resolved primarily through the charm-specific attenuation rescaling , together with a small low- contribution through the established hadronic-rescattering response channel, , without modifying the independently constrained light-flavor reference. The pronounced centrality, collision-system, and beam-energy dependence of demonstrates that the relative charm response evolves with the collision environment.
The physical interpretation of follows from its role in the scaling transformation. It rescales the reference attenuation strength only in the attenuation terms, , without modifying the independently constrained geometry, system size, light-flavor coefficient , or normalization structure. Values indicate weaker development of the anisotropic response relative to the light-meson reference. At low and intermediate , this difference is reflected in the collective-flow response, while at high it is reflected in the quenching-sensitive anisotropic response. Thus, provides a differential constraint on heavy-quark transport across the collective-flow and quenching-sensitive momentum regimes, relative to the independently established light-flavor response.
The kaon-anchored reference provides an important control on this interpretation. The established light-flavor scaling demonstrates that mesons and baryons, despite their different masses and species-dependent responses, map onto the same common function once the corresponding contributions are scaled out. This behavior is established in Pb+Pb collisions and further illustrated by the comparisons in p+Pb and Au+Au. The additional modification therefore cannot be attributed simply to conventional mass ordering or meson–baryon response differences. Moreover, the modest correction associated with reinforces the conclusion that the principal charm–light difference is captured by the attenuation rescaling .
The momentum dependence provides a complementary constraint. In Pb+Pb collisions at TeV, the and light-meson responses are consistent with comparable transition momenta, – GeV/c, despite the substantial charm–light attenuation difference characterized by . The transition connects collective-flow-dominated and quenching-sensitive anisotropic responses, whose underlying momentum-transport dynamics are theoretically related [19]. The comparable transition scales suggest that the effective crossover is strongly influenced by the common collision environment, whereas the attenuation response retains a pronounced flavor dependence. Thus, and provide complementary constraints on heavy-quark transport and its coupling to the evolving medium.
The ultra-central p+Pb results further demonstrate that the relative charm response is not governed by system size alone: does not follow a simple monotonic extrapolation of the Pb+Pb centrality trend. The light-meson transition scale, GeV/c, is substantially lower than in Pb+Pb, and the available measurements remain consistent with this scale. At higher , residual light-flavor scaling deviations may reflect weaker path-length-dependent partonic quenching, accompanied by a greater relative contribution from surviving jet-driven nonflow correlations. Inclusive neutral-meson measurements at TeV show compatible with unity above approximately 10 GeV/c [20], providing complementary context, although these measurements do not isolate the ultra-central event class. Together, these observations constrain the collision-environment dependence of the relative charm response and effective transition momentum.
Taken together, the Pb+Pb, p+Pb, and Au+Au results establish a stringent benchmark for microscopic heavy-quark transport descriptions. A successful description must reproduce the approximate – closure in Pb+Pb collisions at TeV, the systematic charm–light response difference revealed by the null test, and its evolution across centrality, collision system, and beam energy. It must also account for the comparable charm and light-meson transition scales in Pb+Pb, the consistency of the p+Pb measurements with the substantially lower light-meson transition scale, and the near-unity charm attenuation rescaling observed in Au+Au at GeV. These simultaneous constraints help distinguish the common medium response from the additional charm response, reducing ambiguities in the interpretation of heavy-quark transport.
In summary, the independently constrained light-flavor response provides a direct null test of anisotropy scaling. The transformed and exhibit approximate inter-harmonic closure but remain systematically displaced from the kaon-anchored scaling function, establishing a distinct charm scaling violation. The common response is recovered primarily through the charm-specific attenuation rescaling , together with a small low- contribution through the established hadronic-rescattering response channel, . The coefficient decreases from approximately 2.0 in central and mid-central Pb+Pb collisions to 1.27 in the 30–50% interval, while the measurements in p+Pb and Au+Au give and , respectively. The light-flavor attenuation coefficient also differs between RHIC and the LHC, distinguishing the common medium response from the additional charm response. Despite these differences, the charm and light-meson responses are consistent with a common transition scale of 4.5–5.0 GeV/c in Pb+Pb, while the p+Pb measurements remain consistent with the substantially lower transition scale independently established for light mesons. The combined harmonic, momentum, centrality, collision-system, and beam-energy constraints establish a differential experimental benchmark for heavy-quark transport and medium evolution.
Acknowledgement
This work is supported in part by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics, Grant Number DE-SC0024602.
References
References
- [1]F. Prino and R. Rapp, J. Phys. G 43, 093002 (2016), arXiv:1603.00529 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [2]R. Rapp et al., Nucl. Phys. A 979, 21 (2018), arXiv:1803.03824 [nucl-th].DOI
- [3]S. Cao et al., Phys. Rev. C 99, 054907 (2019), arXiv:1809.07894 [nucl-th].DOI
- [4]L. Adamczyk et al. (STAR), Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 212301 (2017), arXiv:1701.06060 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [5]S. Acharya et al. (ALICE), Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 102301 (2018), arXiv:1707.01005 [nucl-ex].
- [6]A. M. Sirunyan et al. (CMS), Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 202301 (2018), arXiv:1708.03497 [nucl-ex].
- [7]A. M. Sirunyan et al. (CMS), Phys. Lett. B 816, 136253 (2021), arXiv:2009.12628 [hep-ex].
- [8]M. He, H. van Hees, and R. Rapp, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 130, 104020 (2023), arXiv:2204.09299 [hep-ph].DOI
- [9]R. A. Lacey, Progress in High Energy Physics 2026 (2026), 10.31526/PHEP.2026.47, arXiv:2410.04329 [nucl-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2410.04329
- [10]R. A. Lacey, Phys. Lett. B 876, 140357 (2026), arXiv:2410.22688 [nucl-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2410.22688
- [11]R. A. Lacey, (2025), arXiv:2504.21183 [hep-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2504.21183
- [12]A. M. Sirunyan et al. (CMS), Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 082301 (2018), arXiv:1804.09767 [hep-ex].
- [13]S. Acharya et al. (ALICE), JHEP 09, 006 (2018), arXiv:1805.04390 [nucl-ex].
- [14]L. Adamczyk et al. (STAR), Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 062301 (2016), arXiv:1507.05247 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [15]R. A. Lacey, Phys. Rev. C 110, L031901 (2024), arXiv:2402.09389 [nucl-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2402.09389
- [16]B. Alver et al. (PHOBOS), Phys. Rev. C77, 014906 (2008), arXiv:0711.3724 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [17]R. A. Lacey, D. Reynolds, A. Taranenko, N. N. Ajitanand, J. M. Alexander, F.-H. Liu, Y. Gu, and A. Mwai, J. Phys. G43, 10LT01 (2016), arXiv:1311.1728 [nucl-ex].
- [18]J. Adam et al. (ALICE), Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 222302 (2016), arXiv:1512.06104 [nucl-ex].
- [19]A. Majumder, B. Muller, and X.-N. Wang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 192301 (2007), arXiv:hep-ph/0703082.DOI
- [20]S. Acharya et al. (ALICE), Phys. Lett. B 827, 136943 (2022), arXiv:2104.03116 [nucl-ex].