betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Closing the identification step in the GFF limit: Uniqueness of the zero-slope six-vertex phase for −1 ≤ Δ < 1/2

Abstract

For the six-vertex model with a=b=1a=b=1 and c∈(1,2]c\in(1,2], that is −1≤Δ<12-1\le\Delta<\frac{1}{2}, we prove that the plane measure, the limit of balanced torus measures, is the only translation-ergodic gradient Gibbs measure of slope zero, and hence the unique translation-invariant minimiser of the specific free energy. Both statements had been asserted by reference to Sheffield's uniqueness theory, which is proved for nearest-neighbour potentials; we show that for c≠1c\ne1 the six-vertex weights, which couple faces across the diagonals of each vertex, are not a nearest-neighbour potential in height coordinates. The proof extends Sheffield's cluster swapping to these diagonal interactions by means of residual energies on the diagonals, shows with the Lanford–Ruelle theorem for subshifts of finite type and a Burton–Keane argument that two distinct ergodic zero-slope phases are gradients of Gibbs measures on heights, and shows from the spin representation in the form given by Duminil-Copin, Kozlowski, Lammers and Manolescu that the plane measure is not. This supplies a step that we found missing in the chain of recent results on the Gaussian free field limit of the six-vertex height function. An unrefereed manuscript of OpenAI states the full-plane limit for every c∈(0,2]c\in(0,2]; for 2≤c<2\sqrt{2}\le c<2 it identifies a state built from nearly balanced sectors with the plane measure through the characterisation above. Our result gives that identification, given two properties of the state stated in the manuscript. We also check that the manuscript and the work of Averous, Duminil-Copin, He, Lammers and Manolescu concern the same measure, so that their convergence in domains holds, for c∈[1,2]c\in[1,2] and with constants depending on Δ\Delta, wherever the manuscript's full-plane theorem holds.

Introduction

Where things stand

The six-vertex model on Z2\mathbb{Z}^{2} assigns an arrow to every edge so that each vertex has two incoming and two outgoing arrows. We take the weights a=b=1a=b=1 and c>0c>0: a vertex has weight cc if its two horizontal arrows both point into it or both point out of it, and weight 1 otherwise. We write Δ:=1−c2/2\Delta:= 1-c^{2}/2, so that c∈[1,2]c\in[1,2] corresponds to Δ∈[−1,12]\Delta\in[-1,\frac{1}{2}]. An arrow configuration has a height function hh on the faces of Z2\mathbb{Z}^{2}, defined up to an additive constant: adjacent faces differ by 1, and the face to the left of an arrow is the higher one.

For these weights, three recent works together come close to proving that the height function converges to a Gaussian free field throughout −1≤Δ≤12-1\leq\Delta\leq\frac{1}{2}:

  • Duminil-Copin, Kozlowski, Lammers and Manolescu [5] construct the plane measure Pc\mathbb{P}_{c}, the limit of the model on a torus conditioned to have no net horizontal flux (Definition 1.1), work with a spin representation of it that goes back to Lis [13, 14], and prove the Gaussian free field limit of its height function for −1≤Δ≤−12-1\leq\Delta\leq-\frac{1}{2}.

  • Averous, Duminil-Copin, He, Lammers and Manolescu [1] prove that the height function in discrete approximations of simply connected domains converges to a Gaussian free field at every Δ\Delta for which the full-plane correlations of Pc\mathbb{P}_{c} converge to those of a Gaussian free field.

  • A manuscript of OpenAI [15], which is not refereed, states that full-plane input for every c∈(0,2]c\in(0,2], computing correlations by Bethe ansatz.

Figure 1 shows how these pieces fit. Checking them against each other, we found one step that is not proved in the literature. For 2≤c<2\sqrt{2}\leq c<2 the Bethe ansatz of [15] is carried out in sectors that are only nearly balanced, and the state ρc\rho_{c} it produces is identified with Pc\mathbb{P}_{c} by citing a characterisation of Pc\mathbb{P}_{c} as the unique minimiser of the specific free energy. That characterisation, and uniqueness of the zero-slope phase more generally, is stated in [5] as a remark without proof, and by Ryan [16] with a sketch that applies Sheffield’s uniqueness theory for simply attractive potentials [17]. Sheffield’s theory is proved for potentials that couple nearest neighbours, and the six-vertex model is not of that form in height coordinates when c≠1c\ne1 (Proposition 2.3 and Figure 2): its weight is an interaction along the diagonals of every vertex.

Dependency diagram showing how the pieces fit

Figure 1. Gaussian free field in domains for −1≤Δ≤12-1 \le\Delta\le\frac{1}{2}, conditional. Corollary 1.7. Same measure, membership, discrete harmonicity. Section 7. Gaussian free field for −1≤Δ≤−12-1 \le\Delta\le-\frac{1}{2}. [5]. Full-plane Gaussian free field limit for every c∈(0,2]c \in(0,2]. [15 Theorem 1.1(3)], unrefereed. Domains, given the full-plane input (ICI). [1 Theorems 1.3, 1.4]. ρc\rho_c exists and minimises the free energy: (O1), (O2). [15 Sections 3–4]. The identification ρc=Pc\rho_c = \mathbb{P}_c for 2≤c<2\sqrt{2} \le c < 2: the missing step. Corollary 1.6. Pc\mathbb{P}_c is the unique minimiser of the specific free energy, 1<c≤21 < c \le2. Corollary 1.3. Strict convexity of the surface tension. [12 Theorem 13.16]. Theorem 1.2 uniqueness of the zero-slope phase, 1<c≤21 < c \le2. Variational principle. [17 Theorems 2.5.2, 6.3.1]. Two distinct zero-slope phases are smooth, c>1c > 1. Theorem 1.4; Sections 3–4. Pc\mathbb{P}_c is ergodic and rough, 1≤c≤21 \le c \le2. Theorem 1.5; Section 5. Cluster swapping for nearest-neighbour potentials. [17 Chapter 8]. Lanford–Ruelle for subshifts; Burton–Keane. [2, 3]. Spin representation, circuits, Markov property. [5 Sections 14–18]. Ergodicity of the spin measure. [10 Proposition 4.11]. Stated as a remark in [5]; sketched in [16] by applying Sheffield’s nearest-neighbour theory, which does not cover the six-vertex model for c≠1c \ne1 (Proposition 2.3). supplies the identification step. main theorem. new here. missing step, supplied here. existing result. existing argument, extended. unrefereed input (OpenAI). used in the proof. alternative source or context. Figure 1: How the pieces fit. Read from the bottom up: an arrow means that its source is used to prove its target; only the main dependencies are drawn. Box styles give provenance, and grey labels give sources and where each item is proved. Here c∈[1,2]c \in[1,2] and Δ=1−c2/2\Delta= 1-c^2/2, so that c=1,2,3,2c = 1, \sqrt{2}, \sqrt{3}, 2 correspond to Δ=12,0,−12,−1\Delta= \frac{1}{2}, 0, -\frac{1}{2}, -1; ρc\rho_c is the state constructed in [15] from nearly balanced sectors, (O1) and (O2) are the two properties of it that we use (Section 1.3), and a phase is a translation-ergodic gradient Gibbs measure. The one step of the chain from the plane measure to the Gaussian free field that we found not to be proved in the literature is the identification in the dashed rounded box; it matters for −12<Δ≤0-\frac{1}{2} < \Delta\le0, and we supply it given (O1) and (O2). For −1≤Δ≤−12-1 \le\Delta\le-\frac{1}{2} the full-plane input is the main theorem of [5]. Everything above the identification is as strong as its inputs, some of which come from an unrefereed manuscript.

Six vertex configurations with surrounding face heights

Figure 2. The six vertex configurations with a=b=1a=b=1, and the heights of the four surrounding faces, normalised to 0 on the lower left face (the face to the left of an arrow is one unit higher). A vertex has weight cc exactly when the heights are equal across both diagonals of its block, and weight 1 when they are equal across one diagonal only (Lemma 2.1). In height coordinates the weight is therefore an interaction along the diagonals, not between neighbouring faces.

The main result of this paper proves the uniqueness for 1<c≤21<c\leq2 (Theorem 1.2), and with it the characterisation (Corollary 1.3). This supplies the missing identification, given two properties of the near-balanced state stated in [15] (Corollary 1.6). The remaining checks, that the three works concern the same measure and that one step of [1] at positive mesh follows from their hypotheses, are in § 7.

Main results

A probability measure on arrow configurations is a gradient Gibbs measure of the six-vertex model if, for every finite set Λ\Lambda of faces, the conditional law of the heights on Λ\Lambda given the heights off Λ\Lambda is the six-vertex weight restricted to the admissible fillings (§ 2; this is Sheffield’s notion [17] for the six-vertex potential). Such a measure is smooth if it is the gradient of a Gibbs measure on heights and rough otherwise [17 p. 10]. For a measure invariant under the translations of Z2\mathbb{Z}^{2},

slope is the vector of mean height increments (E[h(e1)−h(0)]\mathbb{E}[h(e_1)-h(0)], E[h(e2)−h(0)]\mathbb{E}[h(e_2)-h(0)]). We call a gradient Gibbs measure that is invariant and ergodic under the translations of Z2\mathbb{Z}^2 a phase.

For integers N≥1N \ge1 and LL even, let PN,Lbal\mathbb{P}_{N,L}^{\mathrm{bal}} be the six-vertex measure on the torus with NN columns and LL rows conditioned on every vertical column of horizontal edges having equally many left and right arrows.

Definition 1.1 (The plane measure). For c∈[1,2]c \in[1,2],

Pc:=lim⁡L→∞, L evenN→∞PN,Lbal\mathbb{P}_c := \lim_{\substack{L\to\infty,\ L\ \mathrm{even}\\N\to\infty}} \mathbb{P}_{N,L}^{\mathrm{bal}}

in the local weak topology. The limit exists and is invariant under the automorphisms of Z2\mathbb{Z}^2 by [5 Theorem 2.2], where it is denoted PZ2\mathbb{P}_{\mathbb{Z}^2}.

Theorem 1.2 (Uniqueness of the zero-slope phase). Let a=b=1a=b=1 and 1<c≤21<c\le2. Every gradient Gibbs measure of the six-vertex model that is invariant and ergodic under the translations of Z2\mathbb{Z}^2 and has slope 00 is equal to Pc\mathbb{P}_c.

The specific free energy of a translation-invariant measure μ\mu on arrow configurations is SFE⁡(μ)=−h(μ)−Eμ[log⁡w0]+const\operatorname{SFE}(\mu)=-h(\mu)-\mathbb{E}_{\mu}[\log w_0]+\mathrm{const}, with hh the entropy per face and w0w_0 the weight of the vertex at the origin (§ 2.3).

Corollary 1.3 (Variational characterisation). Let a=b=1a=b=1 and 1<c≤21<c\le2. The plane measure Pc\mathbb{P}_c is the only probability measure on arrow configurations that is invariant under the translations of Z2\mathbb{Z}^2 and minimises the specific free energy.

Corollary 1.3 follows from Theorem 1.2 in three steps (§ 6): almost every ergodic component of a minimiser is a minimiser; it has slope 00 because the surface tension is strictly convex [12 Theorem 13.16]; and it is a Gibbs measure by Sheffield’s variational principle [17 Theorem 2.5.2]. A translation-invariant measure that is flip-symmetric, that is, invariant under h↦−hh\mapsto-h, has slope 00, so Theorem 1.2 also gives, in the gradient formulation, the form of the remark in [5] that concerns flip-symmetric ergodic Gibbs measures. At c=1c=1 the conclusion of Theorem 1.2 follows from Sheffield’s theorem for nearest-neighbour potentials (Remark 6.1).

Theorem 1.2 has two ingredients.

Theorem 1.4 (Two distinct zero-slope phases are smooth). Let a=b=1a=b=1 and c>1c>1. Let μ1≠μ2\mu_1\ne\mu_2 be gradient Gibbs measures of the six-vertex model that are invariant and ergodic under the translations of Z2\mathbb{Z}^2 and have slope 00. Then μ1\mu_1 and μ2\mu_2 are both smooth.

Theorem 1.5 (The plane measure is ergodic and rough). Let a=b=1a=b=1 and 1≤c≤21\le c\le2. The plane measure Pc\mathbb{P}_c is a gradient Gibbs measure of the six-vertex model, it is trivial on the tail σ\sigma-field and hence ergodic under the translations of Z2\mathbb{Z}^2, it has slope 00, and it is rough: no Gibbs measure on heights, translation-invariant or not, has gradient law Pc\mathbb{P}_c.

Theorem 1.2 follows at once: if μ≠Pc\mu\ne\mathbb{P}_c, both would be smooth by Theorem 1.4, but Pc\mathbb{P}_c is rough. Theorem 1.4 is the six-vertex form of the part of Sheffield’s Chapter 8 that makes two distinct ergodic phases of the same slope smooth [17 Sections 8.4–8.6]. It holds for every c>1c>1; the hypothesis c≤2c\le2 enters only through Theorem 1.5, which rests on the spin representation of [5 Section 14].

The identification step and the limit in domains

The manuscript [15] computes correlations by Bethe ansatz, which works in one sector of the transfer matrix at a time. For 1≤c<21 \le c < \sqrt{2} its construction uses the balanced sector, so it concerns Pc\mathbb{P}_c directly (see Remark 7.4 for the endpoint c=1c = 1). For 2≤c<2\sqrt{2} \le c < 2 it uses the sectors with nL:=L/2−⌊Lε⌋n_L := L/2 - \lfloor L^\varepsilon\rfloor right arrows per column, for a fixed small ε>0\varepsilon> 0 [15 Section 3], and studies

ρc:=lim⁡L→∞L evenlim⁡N→∞PN,L(nL),(1)\rho_c := \lim_{\substack{L \to\infty\\ L\ \mathrm{even}}} \lim_{N \to\infty} \mathbb{P}_{N,L}^{(n_L)}, \tag*{(1)}

where PN,L(n)\mathbb{P}_{N,L}^{(n)} is the torus measure conditioned on nn right arrows per column. The theorem about Pc\mathbb{P}_c then requires the identification

ρc=Pc.(2)\rho_c = \mathbb{P}_c. \tag*{(2)}

In [15 Section 4, “Identification when $c \ge 1$”] this is derived from the characterisation of Pc\mathbb{P}_c as the unique minimiser of the free energy, with a reference to the remark of [5]. Corollary 1.3 proves that characterisation. We use two statements of [15], which we do not reprove:

(O1) the limit (1) exists [15 Sections 3 and 4];

(O2) ρc\rho_c minimises the specific free energy among translation-invariant measures [15 Section 4, the rectangle bound and the tiling argument].

References

  1. [1]E. Averous, H. Duminil-Copin, T. He, P. Lammers, and I. Manolescu. Conformal invariance of the six-vertex model’s height function. Preprint, arXiv:2610.07454, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2610.07454
  2. [2]S. Barbieri, R. Gómez, B. Marcus, and S. Taati. Equivalence of relative Gibbs and relative equilibrium measures for actions of countable amenable groups. Nonlinearity, 33, 2020. arXiv:1809.00078.DOI
  3. [3]R. M. Burton and M. Keane. Density and uniqueness in percolation. Comm. Math. Phys., 121(3):501–505, 1989.DOI
  4. [4]N. Chandgotia, R. Peled, S. Sheffield, and M. Tassy. Delocalization of uniform graph homomorphisms from ℤ² to ℤ. Comm. Math. Phys., 387(2):621–647, 2021. arXiv:1810.10124.arxiv.org/abs/1810.10124
  5. [5]H. Duminil-Copin, K. K. Kozlowski, P. Lammers, and I. Manolescu. Gaussian free field convergence of the six-vertex model with −1 ≤ Δ ≤ −½. Preprint, arXiv:2603.06268, 2026.
  6. [6]H. Duminil-Copin, A. Karrila, I. Manolescu, and M. Oulamara. Delocalization of the height function of the six-vertex model. J. Eur. Math. Soc., 26(11):4131–4190, 2024. arXiv:2012.13750.
  7. [7]R. G. Edwards and A. D. Sokal. Generalization of the Fortuin–Kasteleyn–Swendsen–Wang representation and Monte Carlo algorithm. Phys. Rev. D, 38:2009–2012, 1988.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9959355
  8. [8]P. Erdős. On a lemma of Littlewood and Offord. Bull. Amer. Math. Soc., 51:898–902, 1945.DOI
  9. [9]C. M. Fortuin and P. W. Kasteleyn. On the random-cluster model. I. Introduction and relation to other models. Physica, 57:536–564, 1972.
  10. [10]A. Glazman and P. Lammers. Delocalisation and continuity in 2D: loop O(2), six-vertex, and random-cluster models. Comm. Math. Phys., 406(5):108, 2025. arXiv:2306.01527.arxiv.org/abs/2306.01527
  11. [11]A. Glazman and R. Peled. On the transition between the disordered and antiferroelectric phases of the 6-vertex model. Electron. J. Probab., 28:1–53, 2023. arXiv:1909.03436.
  12. [12]P. Lammers and M. Tassy. Macroscopic behavior of Lipschitz random surfaces. Probab. Math. Phys., 5(1):177–267, 2024. arXiv:2004.15025; theorem numbers refer to arXiv version 1.
  13. [13]M. Lis. On delocalization in the six-vertex model. Comm. Math. Phys., 383(2):1181–1205, 2021. arXiv:2004.05337.DOI
  14. [14]M. Lis. Spins, percolation and height functions. Electron. J. Probab., 2022. arXiv:1909.07351.arxiv.org/abs/1909.07351
  15. [15]OpenAI. The Gaussian free field limit of the balanced six-vertex model with variance multiplier 1/arcsin(c/2). OpenAI Math Release preprint, September 23, 2026. github.com/openai/math, commit 4e aee87.
  16. [16]K. Ryan. The spin-1/2 Heisenberg XXZ chain and the Lorentz mirror model with loop weight 2. Preprint, arXiv:2608.21306, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2608.21306
  17. [17]S. Sheffield. Random surfaces. Astérisque, 304, 2005. arXiv:math/0304049; page and theorem numbers refer to arXiv version 3.DOI
  18. [18]D. van Engelenburg, J. Heeney, and M. Lis. Double cluster swapping for spin models: Pfaffian relations and sharpness. Preprint, arXiv:2609.01362, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2609.01362

Paper details

vlnc:W_cefkrmtv
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Anthropic Claude Fable 5.2, Anthropic Claude Opus 5.5

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents